February 1, 2016 (PDF, 331.49 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Feb 1, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
RECREATION COMMITTEE
9:00 a.m., Monday, February 1, 2016
The regular meeting of the Recreation Committee was called to order at 9:00 a.m., Monday,
February 1, 2016 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Kinghorn, and Rice, Chair Carroll, City
Administrator Tucker, Recreation Director Page, and City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present
to conduct business.
1. Chair Carroll called the meeting to order and acknowledge that the press and public had
been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Rice moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of January 11, 2016 as submitted; Councilmember Kinghorn seconded and
the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments
Jim Raih, 3904 Cameron Boulevard, complimented the Recreation Department for the island
history events held in January; he stated that the Exchange Club has scrapbooks in their archives
that contain volumes of materials the City could use if it were inclined to continue with the program.
He noted that the Exchange Club c ontinues to have the Meeks/Sotti le Scholarship Fund that is
up to approximately ten thousand dollars ($10,000) a year; the Exchange Club oyster roast is the
primary source of funding for the scholarships.
MOTION: Chair Carroll moved to re-order the Agenda to go to New Business at
this point in the meeting; Councilmember Rice seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
6. New Business
A. Review of FY17 Revenue Budget
As the Administrator started the review of the FY17 revenue budget, she stated that, year over
year, revenues for the City do not change significantly; the items in bold type have changed from
the FY16 budget. The basis for the increase in Property Taxes revenue is the past twelve (12)
month actual and the Consumer Price Index (CPI) . In addition to the history of collections from
the various revenue categories, increases to revenue might come as a result of an action taken
by Council, like the increase in the daily rate for parking in the municipal lots in 2016; looking at
Line 21 in the General Fund budget, revenue from parking lot fees is projected to increase by
forty thousand dollars ($40,000). Reiterating what was said at C ity Council, the City intends to
put the additional parking fees into a sinking fund for new public restrooms.
Administrator Tucker reported that the RFP for management of the parking lots is on the City
website, and she urged Councilmembers to read it. The opening date has been set for February
12th, giving interested parties a very short window; she asked that, if Committee members should
see something that is problematic, please bring it to staff’s attention so that an addendum can be
done quickly to be posted for prospects. Included in the RFP is the offer of the two (2) City lots,
Recreation Committee
February 1, 2016
Page 2 of 10
excluding the area around t he compactor, an option for seasonal use and an option for annual
use along with a request for the explanation of what that use would be.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked that someone investigate an automated payment system; the
Administrator noted that an automated system was included in the RFP.
The percentage that is transferred to the General Fund from State Accommodations Taxes has
been increased slightly based on twelve (12) months’ actual collections.
Administrator Tucker explained that, for the past several years, staff has offered City C ouncil a
menu of options for increasing revenues , and one (1) of those options has been increasing the
hourly rate at the kiosks. Since Council has already agreed to increase the fees at the parking
lots, FY17 might be the right year to increase kiosk rat es as well. Offering general information,
the Administrator commented that people with a Wild Dunes’ sticker, a hurricane re-entry sticker
and now a residential parking permit are allowed to park free during the hours of operation of the
two (2) lots.
Councilmember Rice said that she could only support increasing the kiosk rates if the hours of
their use was returned to 6:00 p.m.
In the Capital Projects budget, Grant Income represent s the re-budgeting of the money the City
plans to be reimbursed by Charleston County for the NPDES improvements to the Public Works
site. The only other source of revenue for this fund is interest income.
In the Municipal Accommodations Fee Fund, revenues, in addition to interest income, have been
increased modestly based on the past twelve (12) months’ actual. The Administrator explained
that Charleston County gives the local governments a piece of their local government accommo-
dations taxes; the amount was increased in FY15 from twenty to twenty-five percent (20-25%).
Hospitality Taxes continue to grow; she remarked that, whenever the City gets a new restaurant,
the hospitality taxes tick upward.
Responding to Councilmember Kinghorn’s question, the Administrator stated that the City has
had one (1) habitual offender who always eventually paid up along with any late fees added to
the taxes; that business has recently had a management change and the problem appears to be
handled.
In the State Accommodations Tax Fund, the FY17 budget is showing an increase based on th e
trend set over the past twelve months.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked for a clarification on the “promotion” piece of State ATAX
revenue, and Administrator Tucker related that state law for accommodations taxes states that a
percentage of the total amount collected has to go to a tourism promotion agency. The City could
only keep that piece if it were to form a 501(c)3 corporation for tourism and promotion, and staff
it. Historically the Isle of Palms has given their funds to the Charleston Visitors Bureau. For a
Recreation Committee
February 1, 2016
Page 3 of 10
brief period of time, the City did have an organization and tried to operate it on their own when
the revenue was much smaller, but it did not survive more than about eighteen (18) months.
Councilmember Kinghorn stated that he was willing to listen to both sides, but he thought there
was a “tremendous” opportunity there. In his understanding of the guidelines, they are pretty
flexible and would afford the City the ability to do a portion or all of the promotion in-house.
Administrator Tucker explained that she had recently been appointed to serve on the Tourism
Expenditure Review Committee (TERC) that regularly reviews accommodation tax reports from
the ATAX recipients across the state. In reviewing them, she has noticed that some local
governments who give their required percentage to the CVB also give them more money for
specific events, for example, the City of Charleston might give the CVB extra money to promote
Spoleto.
Councilmember Rice expressed her feeling that the City gets “an unbelievable bang” for its buck
through the CVB because of the national marketing they do, and, with the addition of direct flights
to Charleston, visitors are coming here from all over the country.
Councilmember Kinghorn commented that the challenge he sees is that the City is promoting
something that it is already at capacity in the summer; he thought the City’s money should be
spent to draw visitors in the off-season.
Chair Carroll suggested that this discussion be continued at the W ays and Means Committee
meeting.
Going forward to the Disaster Recovery Fund, interest income is the only revenue projected.
Revenue for the Victims Assistance Fund of nineteen thousand dollars ($19,000) is based on the
last twelve (12) months actual.
The Volunteer Fire 1% revenues are expenses that all citizens pay when they pay their casualty
insurance premiums; it is a fund over which the City only has fiduciary responsibility. The money
is to be spent for entertainment type of activities; for the Isle of Palms’ Fire Department the biggest
expenditure is for supplemental life insurance.
This year the Plant-a-Palm Fund has seen a significant uptick in the sale of commemorative bricks
at Front Beach; therefore, the revenue for FY17 has been increased accordingly.
Revenues for the Recreation Building Fund come from a donation to the Connector Run and
registration fees for the IOP Beach Run.
Councilmember Kinghorn opined that these funds could be marketed better; until this meeting, he
had never heard of these two (2) funds. He suggested including it on the website or marketing
them at special events.
The primary source of revenue for the marina is the lease income from the marina tenants; addi-
tionally, each of the leases has a provision for increasing slightly year over year – rent is increased
Recreation Committee
February 1, 2016
Page 4 of 10
by the rate of the CPI. If the business is doing well, the City also gets a percentage of their
revenues.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked how the City monitors cash transactions, and the Administrator
stated that the City receives financial statements from these businesses and has the right for its
auditors to go and look around.
The over-sized schedule compares revenues from FY15 and projected revenue and shows the
amount of revenue each fund contributes to the City. The Administrator explained that the
General Fund and the Capital Projects Fund are grouped together because the only source of
revenue for the Capital Projects fund is the General Fund.
B. Discussion of Budget Process
Director Page referred to the budget calendar that was distributed at the January Council meeting
and pointed out that in March Committees will be reviewing Capital Budgets and that will be
followed by Expenditure Budgets in April.
Councilmember Rice asked for the reasoning behind instructor revenue declining in FY17.
Assistant Recreation Director Ferrell reported that some instructors have cut back on the classes
they were offering, such as going from three (3) classes per week to one (1), or an unsuccessful
class may be cancelled for a while.
Chair Carroll remarked that the Recreation Center is not considered to be a revenue generator.
Director Page explained that the program income is the sponsorships for athletics and other
events, like the sand sculpting contest in the spring. Instructor income is accounted for separately
since the instructors are actually paid out of it. Since some classes have a maximum, the revenue
from them will be relatively steady.
In Councilmember Kinghorn’s opinion, the Recreation Department has not historically been a
revenue generator but that does not mean that it cannot be in the future.
Administrator Tucker recalled having heard in the past that the City should increase it s fees for
athletics and camps; the inhibition in one (1) year was the desire not to have a negative impact of
families with multiple children who might all be enrolled in athletics or programs . She did not
remember whether those discussion s ever got to a point of considering graduated fees; the
Recreation Department does not want to lose participation over monetary issues.
Director Page reported having spoken with other agencies in the Charleston County area to
compare registration fees, particularly with athletics; the Isle of Palms charges the same as the
City of Charleston, St. An drews, and North Charleston in youth athletics with the resident’s fee;
Mount Pleasant is fifty dollars ($50) and the Isle of Palms is thirty dollars ($30).
Councilmember Kinghorn asked what percentage of non -residents would be from Sullivan’s
Island versus elsewhere, and the Director said the number was low. According to the Director,
Recreation Committee
February 1, 2016
Page 5 of 10
the Recreation Department does not get many Mount Pleasant residents registering; the largest
number would be found in the three and four (3-4) year old program.
To explain the Department’s registration process, Director Page stated that Isle of Palms’ and
Sullivan’s Island residents are allowed to register first, and the number of off-island registrants is
determined by how many have already registered – there must be enough participants to form
leagues. After the registration is opened for non -residents, if an island resident registers, he is
put on the team; being a small agency, the IOP Rec Department can cater to its residents. Team
fees are comparable to the surrounding area as well; these teams are typically sponsored and
the teams obtain that sponsor before they come to register.
In the past, calculations were done to determine how much additional revenue the Department
would generate if the fees were increased by five dollars ($5), and the result was twelve thousand
dollars ($12,000).
If the fees were to be raised, Councilmember Kinghorn opined that the increase should be limited
to adult programs. Dire ctor Page indicated that she had the same thought, but the Rec
Department already taps its sponsors so much, for instance, the Windjammer sponsors a softball
team, a youth baseball, a youth basketball team and helps with the sand sculpting contest and
the beach run and sponsors a light display at Christmas.
Chair Carroll asked how the new Sullivan’s Island basketball was impacting IOP registration.
Assistant Director Ferrell said that she has seen some impact, but the IOP Rec Department has
four (4) teams, possibly with fewer players on the teams.
One (1) activity that Director Page would consider an increase is in the fee for summer camp that
is currently sixty dollars ($60) per week.
Councilmember Rice noted that many families have more than one (1) child participating in
summer camp.
A copy of the FY17 Revenue Budget is attached to the historical record of the meeting.
C. Pursuit of Non-traditional Funding
Councilmember Kinghorn had asked that this item be on the Agenda, and he sent an email over
the weekend to Committee members with his ideas on this and two (2) other issues. (A copy of
the email is attached to the historical record of the meeting.) He initiated his comments noting
that he does not suggest raising fees for programs or athletics; he opined that the Recreation
Department better market contributions to support programs and facilities. He suggested adding
a line to the registration forms of other City materials that would inform residents that such
opportunities exist.
Director Page noted that the Rec Department does not use paper registration forms, and online
registration is not yet available; registrations are handled face-to-face.
Recreation Committee
February 1, 2016
Page 6 of 10
The Councilmember commented that contributions for the Building Fund could be done through
an annual giving fund; he thought that a quarterly advertising campaign might generate a positive
response.
Aggressively pursuing grants – federal and state – was another area that Councilmember
Kinghorn thought could generate funding for the City to improve programs, augment programs,
improve equipment and improve athletic fields using outside funding. He reported that a
Department of Recreation checkoff is on the state tax form that would allow a taxpayer’s taxes to
go directly to Parks, Recreation and Tourism; he charged Director Page with finding out how that
money could get back to the Isle of Palms.
Councilmember Kinghorn recalled that one (1) of the athletic fields was named, and he thought
that naming rights and/or business signs on the fences could be other sources of outside funding.
Chair Carroll noted that many gr ants come with strings attached and the City must be cautious
about what they might be, and he reiterated that the Recreation Department goal was to provide
recreation for all of the residents from toddlers to seniors and dogs.
Councilmember Rice indicated that she would need to give these ideas some thought before
voicing an opinion; she did comment that she does not want the issue of fund raising to become
too commercial.
Director Page indicated that she was not opposed to the naming idea, but the busi nesses that
would be asked to par ticipate would be the same people that are already being tapped pretty
regularly by the Rec Department.
D. Strategic Partnering Possibilities
For this idea, Councilmember Kinghorn suggested increasing activities with other allied groups to
create new programs or enhance existing ones. Specifics include joint applications for funding,
use of the Wild Dunes pool or tennis courts, the expansion of health care screening s with local
medical organization s, the development of more pr ograms with Sullivan’s Island, etc. The
Councilmember proposed establishing a Recreation Department advisory board composed of
three (3) volunteers from IOP and two (2) volunteers from Sullivan’s Island for outreach and
promotion.
Councilmember Rice asked Director Page about the status of the “Piccolo Spoleto Goes to the
Beach” event; Director Page reported that the attendance had fallen off substantially, and for an
unknown reason, they stopped recognizing that event. In its place, the Rec Department has held
Music in the Park that has been a big success, and the Rec Department continues to partner with
them for the sand sculpting event. Even further back in the past, Councilmember Rice recalled
Spoleto events being held at Wild Dunes.
Councilmember Kinghorn stated that the Exchange Club’s IOP Foundation has been in existence
for long time, and it is now a 501(c)3 corporation. It is an entity whose function is to raise money
and could be an opportunity to raise funds that the City might not tradition ally feel comfortable
with.
Recreation Committee
February 1, 2016
Page 7 of 10
E. Facility Utilization and Assessment of Future Needs
Councilmember Kinghorn asked how often an assessment was done, whether the master plan
was still viable or did it need to be updated, were users of the facilities, programs and staff
surveyed, was the data gathered analyzed, what were the ages of users etc.?
Director Page stated that the Recreation staff has a feel for its users, i.e. during the day, users
are primarily seniors and the little children who are not yet in school; most of the exercise class
participants are in their forties and fifties (40s -50s); the summer activities are for the youth with
summer and athletic camps.
The Director indicated that the st aff had not done any surveying of users since before the
Recreation Center was built; the design, needs and the building were based on that survey taken
in 2004. When people come into our offices, we accept their feedback whether it is good or bad.
Since it has been twelve (12) years since the last survey, Councilmember Kinghorn suggested
that, based on the changes on the island, another survey might be beneficial and should be taken
periodically. He stated that the feedback he has received about the C ardio Room is that it is
“pretty miserable;” if a survey were to indicate the need for the space to be larger with new lighting
and more equipment, the question is raised about how to do it, which means generating revenue.
The Director was willing to do surveying, but cautioned that the Committee might get requests it
could not fulfill and those people would not going to be happy.
Responding to Councilmember Rice’s question about what could be done about the workout
room, Director Page said that space is not available to relocate it without adding on to the building.
Councilmember Rice mentioned that possibly the Exchange Club would be available;
Councilmember Kinghorn suggested that the Exchange Club would be a good location for mat -
based activities.
Having had many of the same thoughts, the Director stated that an outdoor storage building would
not be climate-controlled; the High Tide/Low Tide Room, where yoga and exercise classes are
held, is typically in use eight (8) hours a day. If another space existed in the building, the cardio
equipment would have been moved before now.
Councilmember Kinghorn suggested partnering with Wild Dunes to use their cardio equipment
room; in so doing, the residents’ request has been answered without the City s pending any
money. He also recommended taking five thousand dollars ($5,000) from the Building Fund to
hire a design/engineer that deals with existing buildings to give her ideas on how space could be
found or to give her a report that the building was not suitable to do anything different.
F. Consideration of General Lecture Series
Councilmember Rice asked for this topic to be on the Agenda because the island history series
has been so successful and because it brought a great demographic that usually does not come
to City events. She suggested that the Recreation Department put on more cerebral programming
Recreation Committee
February 1, 2016
Page 8 of 10
periodically; she commented that many fascinating people have retired to the island who might
be honored to give a lecture on whatever had been the focus of their working life.
Director Page reported that staff was working toward anot her series in March and in May and
start again in the fall; Susannah Miles , who writes about the island has called offering to
participate. The current plan is to stay with island history for a while with one or two (1-2) nights
spent on Hurricane Hugo; the Director thought that stories from residents who had decided to ride
out the storm on the island would not only be informational but also educational to new residents.
Councilmember Rice suggested that Sullivan’s Island be included.
Councilmember Kinghorn reiterated his concept of an advisory board where the Director could
hand-pick three to five (3 -5) people to serve and to investigate ideas that are brought to her for
consideration or they could pursue surveying participants.
G. Discussion of Drainage in the Bark Park
Director Page reported that she called in experts and believes that she can engage a pump at the
bark park to drain the water for about two thousand dollars ($2,0 00); she plans to include that
expense in her expenditure budget for FY17.
Chair Carroll asked if it would be cheaper to being in dirt and raise the bark park, but the Director
remarked that to do that was much more expensive. In general, the area all around the Recreation
Center is low and always tends to flood.
4. Departmental Report for January 2016
The Director stated that, as requested last month, she reduced the monthly report, but she noted
that the reduction was painful because she also uses the report as a training tool. When she
hires a new person, the reports tell him what to do when, and this year she has a new Parks and
Facilities Specialist taking care of the building and a new Parks and Grounds Supervisor. Andy
Sinwald and Aaron Sweet are only in their second year, but the monthly reports give them an idea
when to start to work on the next program. IOP employees are very attractive to other agencies,
so the turnover rate is pretty high since there is little opportunity for advancement.
Councilmember Kinghorn stated that Director Page has three (3) primary constituents, i.e.
residents, staff and the policy -making body; for the policy people, he believes that the Director
can produce a report of a couple of pages.
Adult sports registrations are being completed; for youth athletics, basketball will be winding up
shortly and registration for baseball has begun. For Programs and Classes, the number of
participants and the names of the instructors has been provided. The January meeting of the
Keenagers drew forty-one (41) seniors; the next meeting will be February 3rd. A movie and dodge-
ball were held on Friday, January 13 th when children were out of school for a teacher -work day,
and twenty -four (24) children participated. Related to the Wellness Program, Director Page
reported that the City partners with East Coper Hospital who helps with the annual wellness fair
and wellness workshops. On Saturday, February 6th the 10th Annual Doggie Day at the Rec will
be held from 9:00 a.m. to 11:00 a.m.; other than the competitions, owners can purchase City dog
Recreation Committee
February 1, 2016
Page 9 of 10
licenses and dogs can get their rabies vaccinations. The next Middle School Dance is planned
for Friday, February 19th; Cupid’s Card Shoppe will be held Thursday, February 11th; the first Front
Beach Fest will be Saturday, March 5th from noon to 4:00 p.m. and will feature The Tams; and the
Easter Egg Hunt will take place on Saturday, March 26th, beginning at 10:00 a.m. SHARP. Other
matters that were done in January include the fire inspection of the building, the replacement of
two (2) outside showers, and extended the playground borders to accommodate more play area
and picnic tables.
Chair Carroll asked whether the City or the Recreation Department was partnering with the Mount
Pleasant Police Department for a polar plunge at the Windjammer later in the month. Director
Page explained that it is a City-approved event for Special Olympics.
Councilmember Kinghorn stated that sometimes people miss the i mportant things because the
report is so long; having studied the monthly report, he found that it contains five (5) categories,
i.e. athletics and youth sports, programs and classes, administration and personnel, special
events and facilities and maintenance, as well as a miscellaneous category. He suggested using
presentation flashboards indicating the important things, the six (6) categories with the important
information that is necessary to make decisions. The Councilmember thought that the format
would be a useful and effective tool for the Director.
Councilmember Rice thought a full report could be generated once or twice a year.
Director Page explained that the reports became more detailed and longer because of the
questions that were posed to her at Recreation Committee meetings.
Chair Carroll stated that he “loved the programs and the number of people who [participate] are
on island or off-island.”
Councilmember Kinghorn said that he thought the elected body would be better decision makers
with presentations in a format that is related to something.
Director Page asked if she could differentiate between the programs for which people pay and
the ones they do not. If this type of reporting is the pleasure of the Committee, staff will make it
happen.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked about reducing registration fees by a couple of dollars if the
registrants would complete a simple survey asking about satisfaction with the facilities and
suggestions.
MOTION: Councilmember Kinghorn moved for the Recreation staff to look at
the three (3) things he had included in the Agenda, the survey and the report ideas
and to report on the ones that they believe have merit and that will be considered
for implementation at the next meeting; Councilmember Rice seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Since a list of registrants and their email addresses is held in the RecTrac system, the Recreation
Department could use the e-newsletter as a vehicle for the survey.
Recreation Committee
February 1, 2016
Page 10 of 10
7. Miscellaneous Business
Status of Hand Dryer
In her research, Director Page found that replacement dryers cost about a thousand dollars
($1,000) each; therefore, the purchase will go into the FY17 budget.
Next Meeting Date: 9:00 a.m., Tuesday, March 1, 2016 in the Conference Room
8. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Rice moved to adjourn the meeting at 11:04 a.m.;
Chair Carroll seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.