January 19, 2016 (PDF, 259.99 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Jan 19, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
WAYS and MEANS COMMITTEE
5:45 p.m., Tuesday, January 19, 2016
The regular meeting of the Ways and Means Committee was called to order at 5:45 p.m. in
Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina. Attending
the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf, Bettelli, Carroll, Ferencz, Harrington, Kinghorn,
Rice and Ward, Mayor Cronin, Administrator Tucker, Attorney Halversen, Assistant Administrator
Fragoso and Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Administrator Tucker called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and
public had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Election of Chair and Vice Chair
Councilmember Bergwerf nominated Mayor Cronin to serve as Committee Chair, and
Councilmember Ferencz nominated Councilmember Ward. Her nomination speech follows:
I wish to nominate Council member James M. Ward for Chairman of Ways and
Means
Mayor Cronin is already involved with the Council of Governments, the Charleston
Visitors Bureau, and a Board Member of the Municipal Association of South Carolina. In
addition he attends a plethora of meetings with our City Administrator including the
County, FEMA, SCDOT and Legislative Committees on our behalf.
Council Member Ward on the other hand is assigned to ONLY ONE Committee….Public
Works allowing him much more time to give to this most important committee
In addition Council Member Ward meets frequently with our Treasurer since they speak
the same financial language and has a grasp for details necessary to our burgeoning
budget. Our “over budgeted” items are becoming the norm rather than the exception and
need to be viewed with a more critical eye. As the only Certified Public Accountant on
Council he can give us that guidance.
The position of Chair of Ways and Means is not new to him in that he served in this
position during the tenure of Mayor Carmen Bunch. This will be an enormous asset
during the budgeting process.
For these reasons, I ask that Council Member James M. Ward be nominated for Chair of
the Isle of Palms Way and Means Committee.
In addition I ask that these statements be included in their entirety into the minutes of this
meeting, but since there seems to be a problem with my voice being audible on tape, I
have a copy of my statements for Marie. Thank you.
Mayor Cronin was elected Chair on a vote of 6 to 3 with Councilmembers Carroll, Ferencz and
Ward casting the dissenting votes.
Ways and Means Committee
January 19, 2016
Page 2 of 11
Councilmember Ferencz nominated Councilmember Ward for the position of Vice Chair, and
Councilmember Harrington nominated Councilmember Kinghorn. Councilmember Kinghorn was
elected Vice Chair on a vote of 6 to 3 with Councilmembers Carroll, Ferencz and Ward cast the
dissenting votes.
3. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Bergwerf moved to approve the minutes of the
regular meeting of November 17, 2015 as submitted; Counci lmember Harrington
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
4. Citizens’ Comments – None
5. Financial Statements – Treasurer Suggs
A. Financial Statement
Financials to be reviewed are for the first half of the fiscal year, meaning that the target i s fifty
percent (50%). In the General Fund, revenues are at twenty -six percent (26%) of the annual
budget, and expenditures are at forty -four percent (44%) of the annual FY17 budget. In the
comparison with last fiscal year, Property Taxes appear to be si gnificantly ahead of last year
because the last November payment was received in December this year and in early January
last year. The other revenue sources are similar to FY15. Total cash is one point nine million
dollars ($1,900,000) higher than last year; the increase can be attributed primarily to the Beach
Preservation Fee. In General Fund expenditures, all departments are under budget except
Mayor/Council, which was impacted by the one-time payment of salaries in November.
B. Tourism Funds
The Municipal Accommodations Taxes are running four percent (4%) ahead of FY15; the City has
not yet received the December quarter for State ATAX or the first semi-annual payment from the
Charleston County Accommodations Tax Pass-through. Hospitality Taxes appears to have had
a very good December, but in her research, Treasurer Suggs found that several late November
payments were not in the bank until December; the fund is running ten percent (10%) higher than
FY15. Collections of Beach Preservations Fee to tal nine hundred fifty -one thousand dollars
($951,000).
Mayor Cronin recognized that the City’s tourism funds continue to increase and budgeted into the
State Accommodations Tax is fifty-thousand dollars ($50,000) each year to support initiatives that
will put “heads in beds” on the island. The Mayor suggested that he invite the principals with local
property management companies and members of the hospitality and food and beverage
businesses to share with them the fact that the City has money that could be used to benefit all if
the City has programs and activities that are worthwh ile. One idea the Mayor has is to produce
a five-minute (5 min. ) video about island life and gi ve it to each business to use for their own
purposes – put on their own website, put it on their welcome screen, take pictures from it to use
for promotion etc.
Ways and Means Committee
January 19, 2016
Page 3 of 11
The Mayor acknowledged that the Charleston Visitors Bureau does a lot of advertising for the
island on its website and drop -down sections and other links, but the Mayor was thinking of
something more homespun. The video would not only promote tourism, but also entice people to
want to live on the island.
Councilmember Rice stated that she has been thinking of adding a fun, island-themed sculpture
for the Front Beach or the Recreation to be a spot for visitors to have their own photo -ops, like
the very large chair at the Okra Grill.
6. Old Business
A. Status of Internal Control Audit
Administrator Tucker noted that, in the original timeline for the internal control audit, a presentation
of the report was schedule for January, but the FEMA work has i nterfered with the completion.
The presentation will be at the February Council meeting.
B. Status of Annual Audit Engagement
Since the City’s commitment to Greene, Finney and Horton has been comple ted, the
Administrator placed this subject on the Agenda to learn whether the City wanted to enter into
another engagement letter with them or to go out to bid.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to go out for a Request for Proposals for a
competent auditing firm; Councilmember Carroll seconded.
The Mayor said that he has had no problem with Greene Finney and Horton, and they may be
the successful party, but he thought it might be useful to look around.
The Administrator recalled from the presentations for a firm to perform the internal control audit,
that one (1) firm stated that, as part of their regular financial audit, they also randomly select a
department for an internal control audit. In the Administrator’s opinion, such a procedure would
mean constant improvement; if Council was interested, a provision could be included in the RFP.
Mayor Cronin asked how such an internal control audit process could be priced since there would
be much less work in the Building Department than in the Fire or Police Departments.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
7. New Business
A. Recommendations from the Public Safety Committee
1. Award of a contract to Mobile Communications for 4 portable radios
and accessories for Parking Management Program in the amount of
$19,018.02, sta te contract pricing (MUNI ATAX, Police Department Capital
purchase, page 40, $20,000)
Ways and Means Committee
January 19, 206
Page 4 of 11
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to award a contract to Mobile Communications
as stated; Councilmember Bettelli seconded.
Councilmember Carroll reported that these radios were for the additional Beach Services Officers
(BSOs) who would be hired to enforce the managed beach parking program and asked why they
cost so much.
The Mayor reminded him of the thousands of dollars Council is setting aside for radio
replacements in a couple of years.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
2. Award of a contract to Love Chevrolet for one 2016 Chevrolet
Colorado Pickup Truck in the amount of $27,600, state contract pricing, for
the Parking Management Plan (MUNI ATAX, Police Capital Purchase, page 40, $30,000)
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to award the contract to Love Chevrolet as detailed
above; Councilmember Harrington seconded.
Councilmember Carroll noted that four (4) low -speed vehicles ha ve been purchased for the
parking management plan then asked whether this would be a four (4) wheel drive vehicle.
After Chief Buckhannon acknowledged that the small truck w ould have four (4) wheel drive,
Councilmember Bergwerf stated that she was of the opinion that having another vehicle that could
go on the beach was a plus for the Police Department.
Councilmember Ferencz asked whether the truck would be large enough to haul signs, and the
Mayor commented that the small truck was used every weekend to put out the crossing signs and
things along that order.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked how many vehicles were in the Police Department, and Chief
Buckhannon replied that the Department had twenty-one (21) sedans and two (2) pickups. The
Councilmember then asked what the Department would do without this truck.
Chief Buckhannon explained that the pickup trucks were used in multi-faceted areas; BSOs do a
lot of sign maintenance, carrying the signs and the poles; they also do things like trimming trees
and bushes around signs during the summer months. To do the trimming, they must carry that
equipment around the island; they deliver and pick up the crosswalk signs on the weekends; they
also assist animal control and help with calls on the beach – carrying equipment and people on
and off the beach.
Councilmember Kinghorn indicated that the City was doing all of these things now, and the Chief
noted that the difference will b e that the number of BSOs was expanding to provide and island -
wide presence. Currently their presence is concentrated in the business district.
When Councilmember Ferencz commented that the truck would be parked in the off-season, the
Chief stated that the season for the Police Department was from the beginning of March through
Ways and Means Committee
January 19, 2016
Page 5 of 11
September, and he tries to keep as many BSOs as possible after October 1 to assist with the
maintenance that is needed.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Award of a contract to Benson Ford for one 2016 Ford Police
Interceptor Sedan (marked) in the amount of $24,415, state contract
pricing (Hospitality Tax Fund, Police Department Capital Purchase, page 40,
$32,000)
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to award a contract to Benson Ford as stated
above; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
B. Recommendation from the Personnel Committee
Consideration of designating President’s Day as a declared holiday in lieu of the
personal day of choice for 2016 and subsequent years
Administrator Tucker reported that last year City Council had granted employees two (2)
additional holidays, one of which was a personal day of choice that means any m ember of the
City staff, during the course of a calendar year, can declare a day a holiday when the City would
not be closed. The Department Managers appealed to the Personnel Committee to change the
day of choice to a declared holiday; several options were offered to the Committee who ultimately
decided upon President’s Day. In essence, an action of Council would do away with the personal
day of choice and declare President’s Day a City holiday when City offices, except Public Safety,
would be closed.
MOTION: Councilmember Harrington moved to change the personal day of
choice for City employees to a declared holiday, President’s Day, for 2016 and
future years; Councilmember Bettelli seconded.
Mayor Cronin stated that the biggest problem he sees with the day of choice is scheduling and
knowing when people are in or out to be able to run the full shift or to ensure that all necessary
tasks are covered.
Administrator Tucker noted that the personnel costs of a holiday was approximately ten thousand
three hundred dollars ($10,300).
Councilmember Bergwerf asked for the rationale from the various departments.
Director Page stated that the personal day of choice was particularly difficult for the small
departments. In her opinion, a personal day of choice was another day of annual leave contrasted
with a holiday when offices was closed. In the Recreation Department, when someone is out for
whatever reason, someone must cover for them, and the Director said she is really in a bind if
someone is taking a personal day and someone else calls in sick.
Ways and Means Committee
January 19, 2016
Page 6 of 11
The Director also spoke for the Public Works Department, recalling that Director Pitts had
explained that the majority of residents on the island believe that the City offices are closed
anytime they know that the County or the State is taking a holiday. As a result, these residents
do not put their garbage/debris out to be picked collected; what ensues is that the Public Works
Department and City Hall get numerous phone calls that the resident needs a special pickup
because he did not know the City had operated that day.
Chief Graham explained that for the Fire Department, if someone take s a personal holiday they
would get eight (8) hours of holiday pay, but the Department would have to pay twenty -four (24)
hours of overtime to cover the slot.
Mayor Cronin stated that he was assuming that the overage could be absorbed in the existing
budget since no request for a budget exception has come forward.
Chief Buckhannon remarked that personnel in the Police Department are not allowed to take
leave from March 1 through September.
VOTE: The motion PASSED on a vote of 7 to 2 with Councilmember Carroll and
Ward casting the dissenting votes.
C. Recommendation from the Public Works Committee
Award of a contract to Vic Bailey Ford for one F350 Ford 4x4 truck with 6 -yard
garbage hopper in the amount of $44,206, state contract pricing (Public Works Capital
Purchases, MUNI ATAX, page 42, $44,000)
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to award a contract to Vic Bailey Ford as stated
above; Councilmember Carroll seconded.
Administrator Tucker noted that the price was over budget by two hundred six dollars ($206).
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
D. Award of a contract to Motorola for radio/walkie maintenance in the amount
of $12,858, state contract pricing, for the Police Department ($6,228) and the Fire
Department ($6,630) (Police Department, Maintenance and Service Contracts, page 10, $6,516
and Fire Department, Maintenance and Service Contracts, page 12, $6,960; total $13,476)
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to award a contract to Motorola for radio/walkie
maintenance for the Fire and Poli ce Departments in the amount of $12,858;
Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
E. Discussion from the Real Property Committee of consideration of beach
season 2016 City management of the municipal parking lot
The Mayor commented that the existing provider of this service has decided not to continue so
Council must decide whether to go out for proposal or to manage the lots with City employees.
Ways and Means Committee
January 19, 2016
Page 7 of 11
If the City were to assume management, the employees tending to the lot would be seasonal
employees, maybe BSOs, or that type of person once meeting all of the criteria established for
BSOs.
Having initiated the discussion in the Real Property Committee, Councilmember Bergwerf stated
that, with the changes the City will have to work through with the parking management plan, she
anticipates the utilization of the lots to be quite different this year. She also expressed the opinion
that getting a new proprietor might be more compli cated than the City’s running the lots in this
initial year of the parking plan.
In addition, Councilmember Bergwerf asked what the County Park charged for parking, and she
was told seven dollars ($7) per day during the week and ten dollars ($10) per day on the weekend.
Mayor Cronin commented that he had already been thinking of raising the daily parking rate to
match the County Park and to use the additional money to establish a sinking fund for the
construction of the public restrooms. He reiterated that the City is going to be required to have a
substantial fund to add to whatever outside money it might get; he noted that he has stated the
City’s position to both Charleston County and the State Parks Recreation and Tourism Committee
where he has gotten nodding heads but no offers of money.
Responding to Councilmember Ferencz’ statement that the City should outsource the
management of the parking lots, Councilmember Bergwerf said that the City should keep the
money since the information clearly shows that the lots are a lucrative venture.
Councilmember Carroll voiced concern over liability and insurance if the City were to assume the
management of the parking lots; he added that, often in a cash business, not all of the day’s
collections make their way into the bank.
The Mayor opined that the Police Department is already being burdened with the new parking
management plan beginning in March and adding staffing and managing the parking lots was too
much to ask of them in year one of the parking plan.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to generate an RFP for management of the
municipal parking lots and to advertise it as required as quickly as possible;
Councilmember Carroll seconded.
In the meantime, Chief Buckhannon will be advertising and interviewing for BSOs in hopes of
hiring enough to staff the parking lots if none of the bids received meet Council’s requirements.
Councilmember Kinghorn commented that the City’s management of the parking lots should be
a good source of revenue for the City, but he wanted to see the lots utilized twelve (12) months a
year.
The Mayor suggested that the City could add an option to the RFP for generating revenue from
the lots in the off-season.
Ways and Means Committee
January 19, 2016
Page 8 of 11
According to Administrator, in the 2012 RFP, the base rent amount was one hundred thousand
dollars and that the primary factor to a prospective bidder would be whether or not the investment
of time would make the job worth undertaking. On that same line, the Administrator opined that
the RFP should include the new rates, if they are approved.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY. (Councilmember Ward was out of
the room when the vote w s taken.)
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to raise the daily rates to match those of the
County Park, i.e. $7 per week day and $10 per day on the weekends and holidays;
Councilmember Rice seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
(Councilmember Ward was not present for the vote.)
F. Consideration of an award of a contract to A&H Company, Inc. in the amount
of $58,900 for the fabrication and installation of signs for t he Managed Beach
Access Parking Plan.
MOTION: The Mayor moved to award the contract for signs for the Managed
Beach Access Parking Plan to A&H Company, Inc. in the amount of $58,900;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded.
The Mayor noted that the recommendation from Director Kerr to award the sign contract to A&H
Company, Inc. was include in meeting packets.
Councilmember Carrol asked for reassurance that the low bidder was offering the same product
as the other bidders and whether the low bidder was offering a warranty.
Director Kerr reported that the City has a close relationship with a local sign manufacturer who
was very useful in assessing the bids and was instrumental in writing the bid specifications. The
large difference in the bids caused concern with the Director and other members of staff;
therefore, he compared the A&H bid to the local companies and learned that the materials they
would use are identical to the other and that the materials would be coming from the same
supplier.
In talking with A&H personnel, the Director learned that in Minnesota the ground is too hard to
penetrate and A&H needs the work; he noticed that areas in the South are very busy.
Councilmember Ferencz asked how many signs the City would get for the bid amount, and the
Administrator responded that City would receive four hundred forty -four (444) signs, but some
poles would have two (2) signs on them.
Treasurer Suggs e xplained that one hundred seventy-one (171) new poles would be added to
accommodate the number of signs.
Councilmember Ferencz noted that these signs would be in place twelve (12) months a year for
the beach season that lasts from May to September; she opined that the residents were not a
Ways and Means Committee
January 19, 2016
Page 9 of 11
consideration when the sign plan was devised. The Councilmember asked if all of these sign s
were really necessary.
The Mayor reminded the Committee that there could be no enforcement without the signs.
Councilmember Ferencz continued that no one had considered the negative impact to the quality
of life on the island; every corner on Waterway Boulevard will ha ve a sign. The only way she
could approve the bid award would be for the signs to come down at the end of the season.
Councilmember Bergwerf explained that the signs were needed to enforce no parking in the
neighborhoods.
Councilmember Ferencz warned that the City would need a large maintenance budget because
she “guaranteed that, as fast as the signs g o up, they will come down.” In her opinion, visitors
would not be parking on Hartnett to go to the beach.
Councilmember Bergwerf noted that, with all of the construction in Mount Pleasant, the crowds
on the island will grow incrementally.
Councilmember Ferencz asked for the data on how many tickets were issued and where the
vehicle was parked when the ticket was issued.
Councilmember Rice agreed with Councilmember Ferencz that the signs should come down at
the end of the season.
Councilmember Carroll suggested placing signs at the end of the streets and no signs on the
interior of the block.
Councilmember Kinghorn advocated for Council to mak e a decision on the contract award and
have the appropriate Committee assess the parking plan after it has been in place one beach
season.
MOTION: The motion PASSED on a vote of 6 to 3 with Councilmembers Ferencz,
Rice and Ward casting the dissenting votes.
G. Discussion of post-Joaquin emergency beach work to re-establish dunes on
the western end of the island.
The Mayor noted that FEMA has finally assigned a person who is knowledgeable about the beach,
and he has made several visits to the City to ev aluate beaches and offer proposals. The FEMA
person saw the problems at both the eastern and western ends of the island.
The concern voiced by the Mayor for the Breach Inlet beach is that, in certain areas, the City has
lost all of the primary dunes, mea ning that the homes in those areas have no protection in the
event of a storm. The consideration was to move forward under a Corps of Engineers emergency
permit, which appears to be open to the State of South Carolina, to hire a firm to move sand by
Ways and Means Committee
January 19, 2016
Page 10 of 11
mechanical means, bulldozer, to the areas in front of those property creating a dune. The Mayor
stated that he had been told that this work could be done for about twenty -five thousand dollars
($25,000).
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to authorize Coastal Science and Engineering,
using up $25,000 from the Beach Preservation Fee fund, to contract to move
adequate amounts of sand to protect the those properties where the primary dunes
have disappeared; Councilmember Kinghorn seconded.
Responding to Councilmember Ber gwerf’s question, the Administrator confirmed that the City
would have to get a permit from OCRM to do this work but will not need to pursue a permit from
the Corps of Engineers since they have already been issued one.
The Mayor reiterated that the work would be done under an emergency condition to protect those
properties without primary dunes.
Councilmember Carroll stated, that in Wild Dunes, each property owner is paying his share of the
cost for beach restoration. He then asked if any property at Breach Inlet was in imminent danger,
and the Mayor answered in the negative but noted that, in the event of a storm, they would be in
danger.
Administrator Tucker reported that the topography of the western end of the island makes it very
difficult for members of the Fire Department to launch a jet ski for a water rescue.
The Administrator reported that the City is still in dialogue with FEMA regarding 49 th and the
eastern end of the island.
Mayor Cronin stated that the City would not take any further actions until speaking with OCRM,
and he expected to know more by the time Council meets next week.
VOTE: The motion PASSED on a vote of 7 TO 2; Councilmembers Carroll and
Bergwerf cast the dissenting votes.
In addition, the Mayor indicated that the eastern end of the island will be under consideration by
FEMA, once all of the document ation has been submitted. Of South Carolina beaches affected
by Joaquin, only three (3) are likely to have applications for FEMA; they are Hilton Head, Edisto
and the Isle of Palms. The Mayor opined that Hilton Head will likely not qualify because they had
already initiated an off -shore dredging project when the storm came through. The Mayor has
been told that Governor Haley has included forty million dollars ($40, 000,000) in her budget for
beach renourishment for the coming year under Parks, Recreation and Tourism; of that total two
million six hundred thousand dollars ($2,600,000) is earmarked for the City of Isle of Palms.
Administrator Tucker noted that FEMA worksheets are an obligation of money; once the work is
done, the municipality get s reimbursed; later there is a “truing up” followed by an audit – the
possibility always exists that something on the worksheet will be disallowed or the reverse where
the amount is increased.
Ways and Means Committee
January 19, 2016
Page 11 of 11
8. Miscellaneous Business
FY17 Budget Calendar
Councilmember Ferencz asked that a work session by the Ways and Means Committee be held
after each section of the budget has gone through committees, i.e. revenue, capital and expense
budgets. The Mayor said that he would look for an available time.
The Mayor asked whether any Committee member(s) would entertain holding the meetings earlier
than 5:45 p.m., but no one responded.
Next Meeting Date: 5:45 p.m., Tuesday, February 16, 2016
9. Executive Session – not needed
10. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to adjourn the meeting at 7:27 p.m.;
Councilmember Ferencz seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.