January 7, 2016 (PDF, 327.72 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Jan 7, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PERSONNEL COMMITTEE
10:00 a.m., Thursday, January 7, 2016
The regular meeting of the Personnel Committee was held at 10:00 a.m., Thursday, January 7,
2016 in the City Hal Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bettelli, Ferencz and Harringto n, Administrator
Tucker, Assistant Administrator Fragoso and City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to
conduct business.
1. Administrator Tucker called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and
public had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Election of Chair and Vice Chair
Councilmember Ferencz nominated Councilmember Harrington to serve as Committee Chair;
Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the vote was unanimous for Councilmember Harrington.
Councilmember Ferencz nominated Councilmember Bettelli to serve as Vice Chair; Chair
Harrington seconded and the nomination was unanimously approved.
3. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION Councilmember Ferencz moved to approve the minutes of the
regular meeting of November 5, 2015 as submitted; Councilmember Bettelli
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
4. Citizens’ Comments – None
5. Old Business – None
6. New Business
A. Discussion of Temporary Employees
According to Administrator Tucker, this item is on the Agenda because some Councilmembers
were surprised to learn that, following Council’s instructions, full -time City employees in good
standing at June 30, 2015 were awarded a one-time bonus of seven hundred dollars ($700), the
temporary employees who ride on the back of the garbage trucks were not included. The
persons who do that job are employees of Staff Zone with whom the City contracts for
temporary labor; they receive no remuneration from the City.
Councilmember Ferencz said that she had initiated this discussion and has talked with Director
Pitts regarding the five (5) guys who are on the truck and do such hard work; she voiced her
understanding that one (1 ) of these men has worked for the City for about twenty years (20
yrs.). She explained that she believes there must be a mechanism whereby these men could
be rewarded for their work to the City.
Director Pitts explained that the City’s relationship wit h Staff Zone is one (1) where he gets a
contract from them every day asking for the number of laborers he will need for the next day; in
normal operations, he typically brings in five or six (5-6), but, in the summer, he might have
Personnel Committee
January 7, 2016
Page 2 of 6
eight (8) workers for certain days of the week. Director Pitts stated that he does not select the
men to come back, but, for reasons the he can only surmise, Staff Zone sends certain men back
day after day to the Isle of Palms. The Director refers to them as “repeat tickets”, and they
typically work forty hours (40 hrs.) per week; the average years of service to the City through
Staff Zone for the “repeat tickets” is ten to eleven (10 -11 yrs.) years to one year (1 yr.).
Periodically the Staff Zone representative will contact Director Pitts to check on his level of
satisfaction with their personnel; on the other hand, if the Director finds that one (1) of the men
is not working out, he can stop his pay and contact Staff Zone to br ing someone else until he is
satisfied.
Since the City only has garbage pickup two (2) days a week in the off-season, Chair Harrington
asked how the contract employees would get forty hours (40 hrs.) per week. On the days they
are not on the truck, they might be involved with debris removal or picking up miscellaneous
debris; when the drivers leave, they are moved from place t o place to do jobs like right -of-way
maintenance. The two (2) long trucks are assigned to the long routes and have two (2) Staff
Zone employees; the other trucks have one (1) Staff Zone employee.
The man who has worked on the island for Staff Zone the longest is well-known on the island,
and is referred to as “Blue.” Director Pitts informed the Committee that he has twice been
offered a full-time position in the Public Works Department and has twice declined the offer.
When asked whether Staff Zone has a merit or award system that the City could tie into, the
Director replied that he did not know.
Councilmember Bettelli said that the jobs these men have through Staff Zone is the one (1) they
have chosen, and, although referred to as temporary empl oyees, they are actually contract
employees hired by Staff Zone and selected by Staff Zone to work at the Isle of Palms.
Councilmember Ferencz acknowledged that everything Councilmember Bettelli said was true,
but she reiterated her desire for the City to find some way for the City to reward their hard work.
For Council to take the “overt position” that they were rewarding hard work with the one -time
employee bonus, she was searching for a way to do the same for these five (5) men.
Councilmember Bett elli noted that the Recreation Department has some long time part -
time/temporary people who are instructors and receive a paycheck like employees.
According to the Administrator, these people did not meet the criteria established by Council to
receive the employee bonus also.
Councilmember Ferencz said that she was not intending to include these men in the same
category as the employee bonus, but requested that “the City look into some way that … these
five (5) men that on a day -to-day basis do the ha rd work for this City and reward them some
way.” She continued that “if we [Council] are saying that the City is recognizing hard work in a
year that it was particularly hard to do over the summer season, then [she] would like to see
some way to do something for these men.”
Personnel Committee
January 7, 2016
Page 3 of 6
Administrator Tucker added that, if the City were to find some way to reward these Staff Zone
employees by a contribution from the City, other long -term t emporary/part-time employees
should be considered as well.
At the least, Councilmember Ferencz indicated that she would like to see these five (5) men
recognized in a Council meeting or private funds collected to reward them.
Councilmember Bettelli stated that, during the holidays, he and many others in the community
put some cash in the hands of the driver and the guy who loads the truck for doing a good job.
Recreation Director Page commented that she did not want to say any thing against Director
Pitts’ men because she agrees that they work hard. But the Recreation Department has a lot of
part-time employees that work under thirty (30) hours per week, but have been affiliated with the
Department for a long time – one (1) ins tructor’s employment pre -dates Director Page and
several have been with the City fifteen (15) or more years. According to the Director, none of
these part-time employees are included in the Christmas grocery gift -card program or any other
perks other employees receive. If a way to reward the Pubic Works’ contract employees were
to be found, she would feel badly for those employees who work nearly thirty (30) hours per
week in the Recreation Department.
“As the working supervisor of Public Works,” Direc tor Pitts stated that he wanted to protect the
Staff Zone employees, “but, as the department head looking out for the City,” anything done
“must be fair across the board,” i.e. do ne for everyone. He added his personal opinion was to
do nothing fr these five (5) men.
The Administrator explained that the reason the City opts to use Staff Zone or any other temp
agency is because of the seasonal need for additional people; if someone is an employee, the
City must keep them busy twelve (12) months a year.
Director Pitts noted that he has more flexibility when using contract workers; he reported that, if
one (1) of the guys from Staff Zone has an appointment on a Thursday or Friday, often he will
ask that no replacement be sent. When the busy time c omes in the summer and the Director
needs additional people, he has saved up a quantity of days that allows the Director to bring in
ten (10) guys without going over budget.
Chair Harrington asked whether there was a way to recognize long -term part-time temporary or
contract workers that would be meaningful but not in a monetary way.
Director Pitts suggested including these deserving people in next year’s budget for the grocery
gift cards; he added that for residents to verbally acknowledge them and t hank them when they
are working the routes would be much appreciated – they make a point to relate these instances
to the Director.
When asked if the City could include them in the gift -card, Administrator Tucker responded that
expanding the number for next year could be investigated; the only issue that could be
problematic is that the City recently learned that the value must be taxed as income.
Personnel Committee
January 7, 2016
Page 4 of 6
The Administrator informed the Committee that the amount in the FY16 budget for temporary
labor in the Public Works Department is one hundred seventy -one thousand seven hundred
eighty-five dollars ($171,785).
On the subject of the gift cards, the Administrator suggested that additional money could be
budgeted for gift cards in each Department, and the distribution of the additional cards would be
at the Department Manager’s discretion.
Councilmember Bettelli suggested that this topic should be vetted by the Ways and Means
Committee.
Administrator Tucker advised the Committee that, after the generous bonuses were paid to
employees, the City Attorney, in other research, found that there is an Attorney General’s
opinion that municipal employees should not receive bonuses.
B. Discussion of 2016 Holidays
Chair Harrington noted that minutes from March Personnel Committee meetings were included
in the meeting packets to remind the Committee of the discussions that took place when the
decision was made to give City employees two (2) additional holidays.
Administrator Tucker stated that this discussion was the reason that all Department Managers,
except Chief Buckhannon, were attending the meeting to opine on this subject. The f inal
decision was to add two (2) new holidays, Christmas Eve an d a new floating holiday to be
declared by each individual employee annually; the decision was made because one (1)
member of Council was adamant that citizens were deprived of services when the City offices
were closed. The Administrator reported that ev ery Department Manager of the City would
rather have another declared holiday when the City is cl osed, but essential services would still
be provided. Having a floating holiday for each employee’s choice makes managing employees
and departments much harde r. At the request of Department Managers, the subject is
submitted for re -consideration. The Administrator noted that the island’s residents believe the
City offices are closed whenever Charleston County and other local governments take a
holiday, result ing in no demand for City services. Suggestions for a declared holiday are
President’s Day (February), Veterans Day (November) and Columbus Day (October).
Director Page said that anytime one (1) member of her department cannot come to work – sick,
annual leave or a day off, there is a burden on the department to cover that person’s job
responsibilities that must be done. A holiday is defined as a day when everything is shutdown
or closed; as the 2016 holidays are structured now, the floating holiday is just another day off.
On a personal note, the Director reported that she finds it difficult to take the annual leave she
earns every year because there is always a lot to do and a lot going on at the Recreation
Center. On a holiday, she indicated that she did not feel guilty and could truly relax.
Speaking for emergency services, Captain Usry noted that, technically, they have only six (6)
months, October through April, in which they can take annual leave because they should not
take annual leave durin g the busy season. This new floating holiday also makes scheduling
shifts more difficult; whereas they function as usual when the City has a holiday.
Personnel Committee
January 7, 2016
Page 5 of 6
Replying to Councilmember Ferencz’ inquiry, the Adminis trator stated that public safety
personnel are paid double time when they work a holiday and reminded the Committee that the
total estimated cost to the City for a declared holiday before June 30, 2016 was approximately
ten thousand dollars ($10,000).
From the Public Works perspective, declared holidays are better; Director Pitts explained that,
when residents see that Charleston County or the State or Mount Pleasant is taking a holiday,
they assume the City is also and do not put their garbage out for col lection. This results in
many calls for special pickups in the following days, especially when garbage collection is once
a week.
Chair Harrington stated that the Department Managers had provided sufficient justification to
recommend to Council that the new floating holiday become a declared holiday, a nd he would
recommend that day be President’s Day.
When asked whether employees preferred a designated holiday or an individual holiday of
choice, all Department Managers responded that their employees favored a designated holiday.
With this information, Councilmember Ferencz indicated that she would support a designated
holiday.
MOTION: Chair Harrington moved to recommend to Ways and Means that
Presidents Day become a designated holiday in lieu of the personal day of choice;
Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
C. City Administrator’s 2015 Performance Evaluation
The approved evaluation form f or 2015 for the City Administrator was included in the meeting
packet; one (1) of the items listed is the Administrator’s personal goal, and she is in the process
of quantifying the meeting of that goal to be sent to Councilmembers. The Administrator
recommended that the evaluation form be sent to Councilmembers who were carried over from
2015 with a deadline to be returned to the Personnel Committee Chair. In addition, at a
subsequent meeting, the Committee needs to discuss the Administrator’s personal g oal for
2016.
On the subject of the Administrator’s 2016 goal, Administrator Tucker said that she would like
for the Committee to establish a list of suggested goals upon which the balance of Council
would make the final decision.
7. Miscellaneous Business
Captain Usry announced that Detective Sergeant Swain has been promoted to the position of
Captain of Support Services.
Next Meeting Date: 10:00 a.m., Thursday, February 4, 2016 in the Conference Room
Personnel Committee
January 7, 2016
Page 6 of 6
8. Executive Session – not necessary
9. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to adjourn the meeting at 11:07 a.m.;
Councilmember seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.