January 6, 2016 (PDF, 264.18 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Jan 6, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE
9:30 a.m., Wednesday, January 6, 2016
The regular meeting of the Public Safety Committee was held at 9:30 a.m., Wednesday, January
6, 2016 in the Conference Room of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf, Bettelli and Carroll, Administrator Tucker,
Fire Chief Graham, Police Captain Usry, Administrator Tucker, Assistant Administrator Fragoso
and City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Administrator Tucker called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and
public had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Election of Chair and Vice Chair
Councilmember Bergwerf nominated Councilmember Bettelli for the position of Committee Chair;
Councilmember Carroll seconded and the nomination was unanimously approved.
Councilmember Carroll nominated Councilmember Bergwerf for the position of Vice Chair; Chair
Bettelli seconded and the nomination was unanimously approved.
3. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of
November 5, 2015 as submitted; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and th e
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
4. Citizens’ Comments
Discussion of Service Provided by Charleston County EMS as it relates to Development of
Quick Response Vehicle – Christine Durant, Deputy City Administrator
Chair Bettelli welcomed the residents who had weathered a cold morning to attend this meeting.
Administrator Tucker recalled that the City has been considering the need for a quick response
vehicle (QRV) or similar system for the past couple of years; the most attractive move for the City
would be more and better services from Charleston County or a way in whic h the County could
work with the City to provide better medical response to the island.
Present to discuss this issue were Christine Durant, Deputy County Administrator, and Chief
Medical Operations Officer Todd McGeorge . Ms. Durant stated that, as the only consolidated
public service safety system in the county, the goal is to provide comprehensive medical response
to every citizen regardless of geographical location. She noted that, for the past year, they have
been providing that service without the resources to meet the demand; over the past five (5) years,
the call volume has doubled. With that growth, County Council, through its budget process,
approved the largest public safety expa nsion in the history of the County funded by a millage
increase. Phase One expansion begins this year and addresses some of the QRV geographic
challenges; the way that Charleston County EMS provides services is to keep its resources in
constant movement based on what is happening in the County.
Public Safety Committee
January 6, 2016
Page 2 of 9
Responding to the City Administrator’s question, Ms. Durant explained that the difference
between a QRV and a transport vehicle is that the QRV does not have a bed, but does have all
of the medical provisions and equipment necessary for a paramedic on the transport vehicle,
ambulance.
One of the things she works with medical directors on is having the right service to meet the need.
With DHEC, the County is working on some initiatives to solve some of the calls that are received
that could avoid a trip to the emergency room, i.e. mental health, drug-related issues, etc.
At the Dispatch Center, EMS uses a predictive software that, based on a certain number of years’
data on call volumes and the typical call received from a general area, help dispatcher s know
where to move these service vehicles. The resources are moved all over the county to meet the
demand based on where the other resources are located.
Since Charleston is a linear county, there are different needs based on the geography variances
that makeup the county, rural to urban. The County is planning to implement the QRV hybrid so
that certain resources are stationed in strategic geographic areas, as the County did with the QRV
on the weekends on the island during the summer. Having the p aramedic in the area allowed
paramedics to arrive at the scene quickly, assess the problem and decide whether transport was
needed; this appears to be a much more effective and efficient way for the County to use its
resources. Based on national standards , the County strives to have response times less than
nine minutes (9 min.) for any medical advanced life support system , which could be a QRV or a
transport vehicle; Ms. Durant stated that she has learned that medical intervention has a greater
impact on survivability than just getting to the hospital.
Chief Graham reminded the Committee that the County’s paramedics can administer drugs which
the City’s EMT employees cannot.
The strategic geographic positioning of the QRV on the island over the summe r resulted in a
significant decrease in response times for the first paramedic on site. Ms. Durant stated that she
believes that the transport rate from the City is between forty and fifty percent (40-50%).
Ms. Durant announced that the City would see the implementation of Phase One in February
2016 and expanded again in July or August 2016 as part of Phase Two.
Chief McGeorge stated that Phase One should roll out February 8 th when a QRV will be placed
on the island during peak hours, 10 a.m. to 10 p.m., seven (7) days per week staffed by a
paramedic capable of full ALS response and intervention. Beginning in July or moving into
August, the QRV will convert to a full twenty -four hours (24 hrs.) a day and seven (7) days per
week. Additionally in Jul y, the County is planning to add more transport vehicles/ambulances
allowing the call volume per truck to decrease.
Administrator Tucker stated that this was great news for the City.
Since a QRV will be placed in Awendaw, the unit assigned to IOP would not be asked to respond,
and the unit would remain on the island.
Public Safety Committee
January 6, 2016
Page 3 of 9
Through this process, the County plans to add fifty-one (51) new employees.
Chair Bettelli stated that he looked forward to deliveri ng the good news to City Council and
thanked Ms. Durant and Captain McGeorge for attending the meeting.
Michael and Ann Maughon, 7 Wills Way, addressed the Committee about the coyote issue on the
island. From the November meeting minutes, he asked where the brochure was that was
discussed then and why it had not been distributed to residents of the island. He said that, if they
had seen the brochure, their cat might still be alive. He noted that there was information on the
City’s website about how to live with coyotes, but nothing was there about the seriousness of the
problem. As he and his wife walk in the evenings, they have seen many “have you seen lost
cat/dog?” signs posted in the neighborhood. He asked why residents have not been warned
about the extent of the coyote problem on the island; Mr. Maughon stated that he had been told
that only twenty percent (20%) of the i sland’s deer population remain . He thought that the
brochure should have been put in every resident’s mailbox.
Mrs. Maughon said she thought the City would have an ordinance related to overgrown vacant
lots; in her opinion, coyotes are using these vacant lots as staging areas. She referred to the
coyotes as non-native, invasive animals.
The Maughon’s goals for attending th is meeting is to see the public notified of the problem as
quickly as possible and to learn the City’s plan for controlling the coyotes and how soon it would
be implemented.
Councilmember Carroll encouraged residents to “be-friend” the City of Isle of Palms on Facebook
because the City posts a lot of information there.
Mrs. Maughon commented that there used to be a blinking light at a driver goes into the curb at
1st Avenue that warned “pedestrian walkways next 2.5 miles.” That warning is no longer t here
resulting in many drivers who do not even slow down for pedestrians trying to cross to their cars
from the beach. She asked that the white stripes be placed on Palm Boulevard at each beach
access indicating that pedestrians have the right-of-way.
Allen Bowen, 108 Summer House, reported that he had sent a letter to City Council stating his
concerns; in his opinion, there is a disconnect between the new noise placard for rental properties
and the City’s ordinances. When he returned to the island recently, he was surprised to learn that
he was already in violation because he did not have the placard posted and that he could be
sentenced to thirty (30) days in jail; as a result he began to research the situation. The placard
calls for “absolute silence” during certain hours, but the noise ordinance for the City is primarily
concerned with amplified noise. He stated that this matters to him because he rents in the
summer to be able to live on the island in the winter. He said he was pleased to see the subject
on the Agenda for discussion later in the meeting.
5. Old Business
A. Consideration of Noise Ordinance Amendment
Public Safety Committe6
January 6, 2016
Page 4 of 9
Administrator Tucker noted that this business was carried forward from 2015; it was primarily put
up for discussion because of occurrences at Morgan Creek Grill that have now been resolved. In
the ensuing legal review, the City Attorney discovered things that needed to be changed and
instances where a section was inadvertently omitted when the noise ordinance was amended one
year to the next. The advice from counsel is to consider amending the ordinance; the City also
delayed action on an amendment during the time Morgan Creek Grill was trying to rectify dis -
turbances reported by nearby residents and to eliminate confusion for police officers in enforce -
ment.
The Administrator suggested that the Committee delay any action on the amendment until after
the Executive Session.
B. Discussion of Noise Ordinance Placard in Rental Unit
Speaking to Mr. Bowen , Administrator Tucker stated that h is was not the only complain t about
the new placard requirement to be displayed in rental properties demanding “absolute silence.”
The action was the result of complaints from residents to City Council about outdoor noise from
rental units; the plac ard was a mechanism to remind vacationers of the City’s noise ordinance
when they are in outdoor spaces like pools, porches, decks, etc., and that there might be people
next door who have to get up and go to work the next day. The Administrator opined that, in the
discussions, the small rental units on the island were not likely to have a pool party or game of
corn hole happening in the equally small o utdoor space. Although there was an expen se
associated with changing the language on the placard, the Administrator thought possible
changes to the placard should be considered by the Public Safety Committee and the Planning
Commission.
Councilmember Carroll acknowledge that he was the person wh o recommended a new placard
for rental units relative to the noise ordinance, but stated that he was not aware of the use of the
words “absolute silence.”
Chair Bettelli recalled that the Public Safety Committee had unanimously approved the language
of the placard to be posted in outdoor gathering places of rental units. He added that the City
was not trying to prohibit outdoor conversations or music, but Council’s responsibility was for the
entire island, particularly the full-time residents.
Chair Bettelli stated that the subject would remain on the Agenda and look forward to input from
the Planning Commission.
Administrator Tucker commented that the calls to City Hall had been from the owners of smaller
rental units who suggested that the placards should be directed toward the large rental units that
are creating the problems. So it might be that the requirement for posting the placard should be
directed to residences with a specific number of square feet.
C. Status of Beach Parking Signs Request for Bids
Public Safety Committee
January 6, 2016
Page 5 of 9
Administrator Tucker reported that the City had received only one (1) bid which exceeded the
amount in the revised budget for the beach access parking signs, so it was rejected. The RFB is
being re-bid. Staff is hopeful that the City will receive more than one (1) bid since the holiday
season is over; some vendors had indicated that the timeframe for producing the signs was too
short for the holidays when they were short-staffed. The bids will be opened January 12th at 11:00
a.m.; assuming the City gets more competitive bids, the contract award will go straight to the
Ways and Means Committee for approval.
6. New Business
A. Consideration of Purchase of 4 Portable Radios and Accessories for Parking
Management Program from Mobile Communications for $19,018.02, state
contract pricing
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to approve the radio purchase as detailed above;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded.
Councilmember Carroll asked why the radios were needed.
Captain Usry replied that, with the implementation of the parking management program, the City
will hire four (4) additional Beach Services Officers (BSOs) for a total of ten (10), and command
must be able to communicate with them.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
B. Consideration of Purchase of 2016 Chevrolet Colorado Pickup Truck from
Love Chevrolet in the amount of $27,611, state contract pricing, for the
Parking Management Program
Councilmember Carroll asked whether this purchase was “absolutely necessary.”
Chair Bettelli said that he had full faith in the Police Department; therefore, it was necessary.
Councilmember Carroll then asked if the new vehicle was a full -sized truck and was told that it
was not.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
C. Consideration of Purchase of one 2016 For d Police Interceptor Sedan
(marked) from Benson Ford in the amount of $24,415, state contract pricing
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to purchase one Ford Interceptor Sedan as noted
above; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded.
Councilmember Carroll asked whether this vehicle would replace one (1) with high mileage.
Public Safety Committee
January 6, 2016
Page 6 of 9
Captain Usry responded that the vehicle would replace a marked patrol unit with ninety -five
thousand miles (95,000 mi.).
Chair Bettelli reminded the Committee that the City has a specified vehicle replacement schedule
that it follows.
As a point of information, Councilmember Carroll explained that tourism funds are used to pay for
some public safety vehicles.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
9. MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to re-order the Agenda and to go into Executive
Session at 10:30 a.m. in accordance with S.C. Code Section 30 -4-7(a)(2) to receive
legal advice related to potential claims concerning the City’s noise ordinance;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED on a vote of 2 to 1 with
Councilmember Carroll dissenting.
The Committee returned to open session at 11:12 a.m., and the Chair announced that the
Committee had taken neither action nor a vote in Executive Session, but had received legal advice
related to the noise ordinance.
Administrator Tucker summarized the changes that would allow for outdoor amplified music on
City property, which was motivated by learning that the City wad out of compliance based on
some language in its existing ordinance. The changes are as follows:
In Section 9 -2-5(a) and (b), language changes have been made to include “reasonable
person of ordinary sensibilities” in multiple paragraphs on pages 1 and 2;
In 9 -2-5(3) reference is made to “City -owned property subject to commercial lease is
exempt from the requirements of this par agraph,” meaning that businesses at the IOP
Marina would be allowed to play amplified music; and
Sections (e) and (f) on page 3 identify the exemptions that allow for amplified music for
specific City-sponsored events where the Police Chief has given permission for the event.
The Committee has discussed certain tweaks to the language, and, as the amendment goes
forward for First Reading at the January meeting, they will likely be included. One such language
change was to paragraphs (b) and (c) to better distinguish between the hours of music relative to
daytime play and nighttime play.
In Section 9 -2-5(g) – Enforcement procedures will have some language tweaks based on
conferring with the Police Department to define circumstances that should be considered when
responding to a noise complaint. A provision has also been added that would declare that
repeated violations of the noise ordinance would constitute a nuisance and that repeat offenders
could have the business license suspended or revoked.
Responding to Jay Clarke’s question regarding number 15 under Enforcement, Attorney
Halversen explained that the officer cannot consider whether the noise is music, advertising,
commercial or residential, i.e. the content is not the constitutional issue, but should consider
Public Safety Committee
January 6, 2016
Page 7 of 9
where the noise is coming from, the context under which the noise is being generated, the time
of day, etc.
MOTION: Councilmember Carroll moved to present the amendment to the noise
ordinance dated November 20, 2015 for First Reading at the January Council
meeting; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded.
Administrator Tucker suggested that the City Attorney be allowed to make the changes discussed
to the amendment and to present that version to Council for First Reading; she opined that, when
it is discussed by full Council, other changes might be made for Second Reading.
Carla Pope of Morgan Creek Grill asked for a definition of the term “plainly aud ible” in 9-2-5(b);
the Administrator replied that Attorney Halversen has been tasked with providing clarification on
the term.
Attorney Halversen commented that the phrase was used in reference to nighttime play which
has a different standard from daytime play; the daytime standard refers to “in the cir cumstances
as to disturb the quiet, comfort or repose of any reasonable person of ordinary sensibilities in any
dwelling or other residence.“
Councilmembers Carroll and Bergwerf withdrew the motion and second respectively.
MOTION: Councilmember Carroll m oved for the City Attorney make the
changes that have been discussed and to bring them forward for First Reading at
the January 2016 Council meeting; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
7. Highlights of Departmental Reports
Fire Department – Chief Graham
Chief Graham reported that a lot of work was done on the trucks after the October storm; some
of which was reimbursed by insurance – every large fire apparatus was damaged to some extent
while responding to a fire call during the peak of the storm.
On December 20 th, personnel responded to a water leak at a condominium on Palmetto Drive
emanating from a fire hose box; the property management company was contacted for a
maintenance person to shut off the water to the three (3) buildings until repairs could be made.
Personnel responded to a total of fifty -two (52) calls in the month, and twenty -four (24) of them
were EMS calls. For the calendar year 2015, the Department wrote one hundred seventy -eight
(178) incident reports and saw four hundred ninety -eight (498) patients. Two (2) large
maintenance bills for storm damage were completed in December . FEMA has indicated they
might not reimburse for some of the damages because they compensate for usage during an
emergency, and they considered the Department’s fire response during the storm to be “normal
wear and tear.” Twenty-one (21) fire inspections were performed in December where thirteen
Public Safety Committee
January 6, 2016
Page 8 of 9
(13) violations were found. Members of the Department were involved in the typical public
relations activities ranging from assisting residents to getting a cat out of a tree.
Chair Bettelli stated that he would like the report to include usage off the medical loan closet.
Police Department
Captain Usry reported that, on December 3rd, officers responded call to a construction site where
an unknown female had gotten into a worker’s truck and gone to sleep; investigation revealed
that she had outstanding warrants with the state Department of Probation, Parole and Pardon so
she was lodged in the Charleston County Detention Center. Having received information about
a possible underage drinking party in the 900 block of Carolina, officers arrived and made contact
with several underage subjects consuming beer; twenty (20) youth were arrested and released to
their parents. On Christmas Day, there was a burglary in the 8000 block of Palmetto Drive where
two (2) televisions were stolen; the serial number off o ne (1) TV was entered into NCIC.
Telecommunication Specialists answered forty -three hundred seventy -eight (4,378) calls in
December of which thirty-seven hundred thirty-one (3,731) were for the Police Department; they
answered a total of sixty thousand forty -six (66,046) calls for the year. Three hundred eight
(308) traffic stops were made in the month with one hundred four (104) tickets issued; the island
experienced one hundred eleven (111) traffic collisions in 2015. One hundred six (106) reports
were written in December and forty-four (44) arrests were made. In 2015, officers received two
thousand nine hours (2,009 hrs.) of training. Four (4) noise complaints were made in the month,
and three (3) of them received warnings.
8. Miscellaneous Business
Councilmember Bergwerf noted that only three (3) coyote sightings were reported in December,
and she asked whether the small animal deaths, cats and dogs that are being attributed to coyotes
were being reported to the Police Department.
Administrator Tucker rela ted to the Committee a couple of things the City might do if it were
inclined to incur the expens e; they are to do mass mailings and/or put up signs like Mount
Pleasant and Sullivan’s Island have done. The Administrator has read that public education is
the most important thing because we, as humans, often do things that exacerbate the problem.
Recalling the Maughon’s complaints about overgrown lots, the Administrator acknowledged that
the City does have mechanisms in place to address them.
Captain Usry cautioned that what the Maughons believe to be overgrown may not fit the City’s
definition in the ordinances. The Captain explained that the process is to contact the property
owner by phone or mail, and, if he does not respond to the communication by m owing/clearing
the lot, the City steps in and does the job and a citation is issued.
Chair Bettelli commented that, when the property is cleared, the vermin living there disperse into
the neighborhoods.
In the Administrator’s opinion, the City should continue its current process for overgrown lots, but
do more public education on the coyotes.
Public Safety Committee
January 6, 2016
Page 9 of 9
Councilmember Carroll suggested noticing on the message boa rds that coyote literature is
available at City Hall; Chair Bettelli suggested adding a request to residents to report coyote
sightings to 843/886-6522.
Assistant Administrator Fragoso noted that all of the City’s coyote information was posted to the
City’s website and that City Hall has received few calls about coyotes in recent weeks.
Councilmember Carroll commended the actions of ACO Enourator who stayed with a dog left
alone in a truck for more than two hours (2 hrs.). Captain Usry added that the owner of the truck
was the same man whose money ACO Enourato later found and returned.
Councilmember Bergwerf asked how many officers comprise a shift for the Police Department
and was told that a shift is composed of one (1) sergeant and two (2) patrol of ficers. The
Councilmember laughed as she reported that she often hears the complaint that there are too
many police officers on the island.
Captain Usry announced that Detective Sergeant Swain has been promoted to Captain of Support
Services.
Administrator Tucker asked Captain Usry to provide on update on the traffic camera to be installed
on the Connector; Captain Usry reported that Chief Buckhannon had determined that there was
a router problem and he was working to correct it.
The Administrator also announced that the City’s new website will be launched on Monday,
January 18th; it will have a new look and be more user-friendly.
Next Meeting Date: 9:30 a.m., Monday, February 8, 2016 in the Conference Room
10. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Carroll moved to adjourn the meeting at 11:53 a.m.;
Chair Bettelli seconded, and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.