January 6, 2016 (PDF, 226.95 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Jan 6, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
REAL PROPERTY COMMITTEE
5:30 p.m., Wednesday, January 6, 2016
The regular meeting of the Real Property Committee met at 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, January 6,
2016 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf and Harrington, Admini strator Tucker,
Assistant Administrator Fragoso and City Clerk Copeland; the absence of Councilmember Rice
was excused. A quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Administrator Tucker called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and
public had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Election of Chair and Vice Chair
Councilmember Harrington nominated Councilmember Bergwerf for Committee Chair;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the nomination PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Councilmember Harrington nominated Councilmember Rice for Vice Chair; Chair Bergwerf
seconded and the nomination PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Harrington moved to approve the minutes of the
regular meeting of November 5, 2015 submitted; Chair Bergwerf seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
4. Citizens’ Comments – None
5. Comments from Marina Tenants
Chase Field, representing the Marina Outpost, asked whether the meeting time could be changed
to 8:30 a.m.; Chair Bergwerf replied that a change in the meeting time would be discussed later.
6. Old Business
A. Consideration of Morgan Creek Grill Lease Amendment – Jay Clarke and
Carla Pope from Morgan Creek Grill
Mr. Clarke recalled that a Special Meeting of the Real Property Committee was scheduled for late
November but was cancelled by the City; Mr. Clarke opined that one (1) reason for the cancella-
tion was a mechanics lien filed by Baker Roofing Company against Morgan C reek Grill (MCG).
In the interim, MCG has reconciled its difference with Baker Roofing and they have completed
the job; the lien should have been lifted today, but, at least, by tomorrow.
Administrator Tucker explained that this was a lien against the City’s property, and, for it to be
cleared, the City must receive the notice that the lien has been released.
Mr. Clarke reported that all items previously recorded in the lease as the City’s responsibility have
changed the lease to reflect that they are under the purview of the restaurant, and MCG has
Real Property Committee
January 6, 2016
Page 2 of
added to the body of the lease and assumed full financial responsibility for the items listed on the
City’s long -range c apital plan, i.e. the walk -in freezer, the hood ventilation system and the
sprinkler system.
Ms. Pope noted that in previous versions of the request, MCG had tried to toggle down the addi-
tional rent; in the most recent version that was included in meeting packets, that change has been
deleted and MCG is happy “at this time” to accept the additional rent. She stated that they have
grown the business over the years to the benefit of the community, the business and the City up
until this past year when th ere were issues with the noise ordinance the resulted in negative
growth for the year. After learning of the proposed changes to the noise ordinance at the Public
Safety Committee and the positive results from the new sound stage, MCG anticipates to a
prosperous year.
Referring to the last page of the lease copies, Ms. Pope explained that the items in the left column
that do not appear in the right column are no longer in existence or have already been replaced.
MCG’s single request is to move forward with an extension of the lease, six (6) renewals of five
years (5 yrs.) each for a total of thirty years (30 yrs.).
For the benefit of Councilmember Harrington, the Administrator asked the Mr. Clarke and Ms.
Pope review their plan should the lease be extended.
Mr. Clarke said that they make a large investment in the building each year because the building
is old and the general maintenance is high, and he referenced the roof replacement at seventeen
thousand dollars ($17,000). The walk-in refrigerator will be replaced within the coming year at a
cost of about one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000). After conferring with an engineer, he
also has been advised that he will need to rebuild the Waterway Room within a very few years
and anticipates it to cost two hundred thousand dollars ($200,000).
Mr. Clarke noted that he has joined with the other marina tenants in working with ATM on the
marina redevelopment plan; he is hopeful that the City will undertake park ing lot improvements
after getting the parking recommendations from ATM.
Chair Bergwerf asked whether there were any plans in the future to install an elevator, and Mr.
Clarke responded that an elevator had been a part of his original plans for the restaurant, but it is
a very expensive investment.
Ms. Pope stated that for them to make these types of investments in the restaurant, they need to
know that they will be there long enough to get a return on the investment; she noted that the
current lease only has four years (4 yrs.) remaining.
Mr. Clarke recalled that lease negotiations were stopped last year because of the issues with the
noise ordinance; he initially came to the City with the request for a thirty-year (30 yr.) lease after
the City approved the long-term lease for the marina.
Real Property Committee
January 6, 2016
Page 3 of 6
When asked by Councilmember Harrington about dates in the future when the improvements
would be made, Ms. Pope replied that there is no replacement date because they work hard to
maintain everything so it will last as long as possible.
Chair Bergwerf suggested adding sixteen (16) years to the lease for a total of twenty (20) years
and asked if that term would be sufficient to acquir e bank funding, and Mr. Clarke answered in
the affirmative.
As he has stated in the past, the profit margins for restaurants is very small and that MCG has
experienced a serious financial setback in the past year; the long -range plan for the restaurant
revolves around thirty -year (30 yr.) financing for improvements backed by a thirty -year (30 yr.)
lease.
Mr. Clarke asked the Chair to explain the difference between the Marina Manager’s request for a
thirty-year (30 yr.) lease and MCG’s request for the same.
Chair Bergwerf stated that she had not been supportive of the thirty -year (30 yr.) lease with Mr.
Berrigan; in her opinion, a thirty-year (30 yr.) lease only gives Mr. Clarke something to sell.
On the topic of selling the business, Ms. Pope reminded the Committee that the City as landlord
has the right to terminate the lease with proper notice, approve lease renewals and approve any
sale.
Based on his past experience, Mr. Clarke stated that a restaurant is saleable with the minimum
of a seven -year (7 yr.) lease. He opined that they have a good track record with the City of
maintaining the building and growing the business.
By way of clarity, Administrator Tucker re -stated what she was hearing from the Committee in
that they would like to s ee a priority list of what would be done above and beyond regular and
routine maintenance which would demonstrate to the City that these improvements were going to
be made to its property. This list could serve as added justification for approving a long -term
lease.
Mr. Clarke concluded by inviting the Committee members to the restaurant for a guided tour and
by saying that he would prepare the improvements’ timeline to be presented at the February
meeting.
B. Consideration of Parking Lot Lease and Future Management
The City Administrator stated that she was ready to generate and advertise it for the management
of the City parking lots when she learned that there were those Councilmembers who wanted to
consider the City managing the lots , at least, for this inaugural season of the beach parking
management plan.
Councilmember Harrington asked whether the City had considered uses for the parking lots in
the off-season, and Administrator Tucker recounted that the Council had considered using the lot
for RV parking, but had decided that it was not financially feasible due to the infrastructure that
Real Property Committee
January 6, 2016
Page 4 of 6
would be required to accommodate the RVs. If the lots were to be used simply for storage of
boats and/or RVs, the City would need to provide added security and better lighting.
Chair Bergwerf agreed that the City should control the lots for this first year of the parking
management plan.
Councilmember Harrington asked what that would mean, and the Administrator recalled that,
when the City managed the lots in the past, it was staffed by off -duty fire or police personnel.
Today, she would recommend placing tw o (2) BSOs at the lots and a supervisor that would be
willing to be available seven (7) days a week.
Responding to the Chair, the Administrator said that she would have a budget drawn up for the
Ways and Means Committee to consider along with the information Mr. Schupp provided related
to revenue.
MOTION: Councilmember Harrington moved for the Ways and Means
Committee to discuss the City’s management of the municipal parking lots; Chair
Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
C. Discussion of Off-season Use of County Park
Administrator Tucker commented that, like the City’s parking lots, the County Park property is idle
during the off -season, and the question has been raised regarding better utilization of it. The
Administrator stated that there are restrictions as to what Charleston County Parks and
Recreation can do on the property, and certain agreements exist between Charleston County
PRC and the adjacent residential development. If Council is interested in pursuing this, on e
recommendation would be to invite a representative from PRC to attend the next meeting to talk
about the property and the kinds of things that would be allowed and any restrictions that might
apply.
Chair Bergwerf opined that the City is sufficiently occupied with the implementation of the beach
parking management plan to take on another project at this time; she suggested that the
discussion be delayed until after the coming beach season.
D. Update on Golf Cart Path between 18th and 20th Avenues
The Administrator reported that the district engineer for SCDOT has visited the site when the plan
was explained to him; he gave a favorable response when asked about the possibility for a permit.
The money for the design and survey has been approved by Cou ncil and purchase orders were
signed today for them to be done. Once they are complete, the information will be put on an
encroachment application and go to SCDOT for their consideration. P rogress is slow but is
happening.
Administrator Tucker acknowledged that the golf cart path will be an expensive endeavor, but one
that the residents want very badly.
E. Discussion of Beach Preservation
Real Property Committee
January 6, 2016
Page 5 of 6
Prior to Joaquin and the historic flooding, the City had included in the FY16 budget City and
stakeholder money for another shoal management project at this time; in tandem with that , the
City requested a permit modification to increase the volume of sand. The motivation behind the
modification request was that the stakeholders felt they had invested a lot of money for sand to
be moved and a few months later they needed sand bags or wave dissipation devices.
Since the City originally conceived shoal management projects, the City has learned ways that it
could be improved, and OCRM has taken the firm stance that no sand can be placed landward of
any sand bag or wave dissipation devices, meaning that the protective measures that have been
deployed by endangered re sidents must be removed before any sand can be placed to rebuild
the beach. These residents have spent a lot of money for sand that washed away much too soon;
they have spent money for sand bags or wave dissipation devices; and they must spend more
money to remove them and more money for sand. Unless the City is in a position to do an
extremely significant project that will have stability, the City might find it difficult to have the level
of participation from the stakeholders that would be needed to have the money to do another off-
shore dredging project.
Then Hurricane Joaquin comes making a situation that is bad worse, and it is followed very closely
by the unusually high tides.
The City has asked the engineers what would be the next, best course of action and what would
be the level of participation that could be expected from all parties; everyone agrees that ideally
the most effective choice would be off -shore dredging. Having see n the effectiveness over the
long haul of an off-shore dredging project, the stakeholders might be more willing to participate.
The City is also dialoguing with FEMA about what level of participation they might have in either
a shoal management project or in some piece of a longer term endeavor, which would mean that
expenditures anticipated for a shoal management project would be re -directed to another off -
shore project.
Administrator Tucker reported that the City has now engaged with the person at FEMA who has
the beaches as his responsibility; this person has also connected with the City’s coastal engineer
and former coastal engineer, who now has the contract to update the beach management plan,
Chris Jones. The Administrator has learned that the FEMA person and Mr. Jones have worked
together on projects in the past and know each other well. At this time, there have been federa l
officials on the beach, and, subsequently, they have sent the City a list of data it ems they need
from City staff to be able to make a decision.
Responding to Councilmember Harrington’s concern about a timeline for the beach
renourishment, the Administrator indicated that, if the best scenario develops, i.e. federal
participation on mobilization, demobilization and the restoration of sand and motivation on the
part of other funding entiti es to participate, and get the permit to do it, another off -shore project
would be the best answer to the City and the stakeholders.
When asked about the progress of the shoal attaching on the northern end of the island, the
Administrator remarked that the shoal has attached, but it is not spreading and continues to erode.
Real Property Committee
January 6, 2015
Page 6 of 6
7. New Business – None
8. Miscellaneous Business
Tenant Rents Report
Administrator Tucker stated that all tenants are current.
Next Meeting Date: 3:00 p.m., Monday, February 8, 2016 in the Conference Room
9. Executive Session – not needed
10. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Harrington moved to adjourn the meeting at 6:42
p.m.; Chair Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.