RecordWell Data

_09102026-582

City of North Myrtle Beach · Horry County · meeting of Sep 10, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of North Myrtle Beach

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 CITY OF NORTH MYRTLE BEACH, SOUTH CAROLINA NORTH MYRTLE BEACH CITY HALL BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS MEETING Thursday, September 10, 2026 4:15 PM MINUTES William McGonigal, Chairman City Staff: Cynthia Lover, Vice-Chairwoman, Absent Ben Caldwell, Zoning Administrator Mendel Bell Elton Farmer, Zoning Technician Norfleet Jones Chris Noury, City Attorney Joe Reaves, Absent Amber Elmadolar, Plan Reviewer Andy Thomas Wyman Wise 1. CALL TO ORDER & ROLL CALL: Chairman McGonigal called the meeting to order at 4:19 PM. Ms. Elmadolar called roll. 2. EXECUTIVE SESSION: Mr. Noury advised the Board to move into E xecutive Session. Mr. Thomas motioned to move into Executive Session to receive a legal briefing regarding The Alliance to Preserve the Old White Horse Road Quarter versus Greenville County Planning Commission. The motion was seconded by Mr. Bell. The motion to move into executive session passed 5-0. Mr. Noury stated the record would reflect the Board had moved out of Executive Session. He stated no decisions or actions were taken in Executive Session. The Board moved into its regular business portion of the meeting at 5:05 pm. 3. APPROVAL OF MEETING MINUTES: Chairman McGonigal called for a motion to approve the minutes of the July 9, 2026, meeting. The motion was made by Mr. Thomas and seconded by Mr. Jones. The motion to approve passed 5-0. Ms. Elmadolar noted for the record the August meeting was cancelled and there were no minutes. 4. COMMUNICATION: None. 5. SWEAR IN THOSE PERSONS TO SPEAK: Ms. Elmadolar swore in persons to speak at the meeting. 6. NEW BUSINESS: A. BZA-26-24: Application by Jerred Roberts for a Special Exception to construct a single-family dwelling in the Highway Commercial, HC District at 100 Barnwell St. Jarred Roberts, applicant, stated the intent was to build a single -family home on the parcel. Mr. Roberts explained the request represented a transition between the Highway Commercial zoning along Highway 17 and the residential townhomes across the street. He stated he felt the request would be in harmony with the area. Mr. Caldwell read the staff report into the record, noting Petitioner Jared Roberts had submitted an application for a special exception to construct a single -family home at 100 Barnwell Street in the Highway Commercial (HC) District. He explained the proposed single-family dwelling was permitted only through the special exception process. Mr. Caldwell stated the Board was tasked 2 with determining whether the property met the applicable criteria and noted that staff recommended the Board review the special exception, hear the evidence presented at the meeting, and review Section 23-26. Mr. Caldwell read the definition of a special exception under the applicable zoning district, noting that special exceptions had the potential for negative impacts on the community. He stated that single -family residential uses could be approved as special exceptions by the Board of Zoning Appeals and were subject to the following conditions. Mr. Caldwell reviewed the conditions for the special exception, stating the property could not abut Highway 17, Main Street, or Sea Mountain Highway. He noted the property did not abut any of these roadways. Mr. Caldwell reviewed the condition that the special exception would be in substantial harmony with the area in which it was to be located. He noted the multi -family residential uses across Barnwell Street and a dental office behind the property. Mr. Caldwell reviewed the condition; the special exception would not discourage or negate the use of surrounding property for uses permitted by right. He stated it would not. Mr. Caldwell reviewed the condition the Board of Zoning Appeals could impose reasonable and additional stipulations, conditions, or safeguards that, in its judgment, would enhance the siting of the special exception. He noted a swimming pool was proposed in the rear yard, and a solid six-foot screen fence would be installed around the rear and sides of the backyard, or other fencing and landscaping would be provided to achieve a suitable screen. Chairman McGonigal asked if there were any questions for the City and if there were any public comment. Chairman McGonigal called for a motion. Mr. Bell asked when the property was subdivided. Mr. Caldwell stated it may have been subdivided around three years ago. Mr. Bell clarified the property had previously come before the Board after the applicant proposed using the entire property for parking and the Board had denied the variance to maintain the parking use. Mr. Caldwell noted they provided more parking than was allowed. Mr. Bell clarified one of the stipulations of the variance required the applicant to maintain green space and noted the property had since been subdivided. Mr. Caldwell stated he had to look into the case. Mr. Bell suggested reviewing the prior variance, he noted Vice-Chairwoman Lover had emphasized maintaining certain trees on the property when the variance for additional parking was granted. Mr. Caldwell and Mr. Bell discussed the prior variance and subdivision with Mr. Caldwell noting he had to look into what was approved in the past. Chairman McGonigal asked staff where they go from there. Mr. Bell asked if they could make a special exception for the recommendation because he did meet the exceptions. Mr. Caldwell noted the applicant did meet all of the criteria. Mr. Bell stated the applicant met all applicable criteria, and the special exception could be approved provided the property was not subject to the original variance. Mr. Bell restated the question to Mr. Noury, asking whether the Board could recommend approval since the applicant met the special exception criteria, subject to verifying the timing of the subdivision in relation to the prior variance and the green space and buffering requirements imposed by Vice-Chairwoman Lover. Mr. Noury asked if the question was regarding the piece of property in question. Mr. Caldwell noted it was not the parcel under review that night, but the property the dentist’s office sits on. Mr. Bell noted he tried to remember when the property was subdivided. Mr. Bell asked whether the Board could grant the special exception if the subdivision occurred before the prior variance, provided the property had not been subdivided after the variance was granted. Mr. Noury asked, consistent with the variance, and Mr. Bell agreed. Mr. Bell asked if Chairman McGonigal was okay with that. Mr. Noury advised the Board to include the adoption of the staff report in the motion. 3 Mr. Bell motioned to approve the special exception BZA -26-24 and the Board adopt into the record all the facts that were presented and along with the previous variance that did not conflict with the granting of a special exception . He had met the special exceptions which didn’t abut Highway 17, Main Street, or Sea Mountain Highway. The special exception would be in substantial harmony with the area since there was multi-family in the area. The special exception would not discourage the use of the surrounding property . In the granting of the special exception, the Board of Zoning Appeals may impose such reasonable additional conditions which they have and the swimming pool has been proposed and the City has addressed a solid screening fence around the rear areas inside the setback yards or other fences landscape that will grow to achieve a suitable screen. The motion was seconded by Mr. Wise. The motion to approve passed 5-0. B. BZA-26-25: Application by Jerred Roberts for a Special Exception to construct a single -family dwelling in the Highway Commercial, HC District at 104 Barnwell St. Mr. Roberts stated it was a similar story, he noted he looked to build a single-family home on the parcel. He noted the parcel was adjacent to item one on the agenda. He stated there was commercial zoning in front o f it and townhomes across the street. He stated for the record he wasn’t familiar with any previous variance situation, and he would look forward to learning more about that. Chairman McGonigal asked if there were any questions for the applicant then asked to hear from Mr. Caldwell. Mr. Caldwell read the staff report into the record, he no ted Petitioner Jared Roberts had submitted an application for a special exception to construct a single-family home at 104 Barnwell Street in the Highway Commercial (HC) District. He explained the proposed single-family dwelling was permitted only through the special exception process. Mr. Caldwell stated the Board was tasked with determining whether the property met the appl icable criteria and noted staff recommended the Board review the special exception, hear the evidence presented at the meeting, and review Section 23 -26. Mr. Caldwell read the special exception provision for the Highway Commercial (HC) District and noted certain uses could be approved as special exceptions by the Board of Zoning Appeals due to their potential negative impact on the community. He stated single-family residential uses could be approved as special exceptions by the Board of Zoning Appeals and were subject to the following conditions. Mr. Caldwell reviewed the conditions for the special exception, he stated the property could not abut Highway 17, Main Street, or Sea Mountain Highway. He noted the property did not abut any of these roadways. Mr. Caldwell reviewed the condition that the special exception would be in substantial harmony with the area in which it was to be located. He noted the multi -family residential uses across Barnwell Street and a dental office behind the property. Mr. Caldwell reviewed the condition; the special exception would not discourage or negate the use of surrounding property for uses permitted by right. He stated it would not. Mr. Caldwell reviewed the condition the Board of Zoning Appeals could impose reasonable and additional stipulations, conditions, or safeguards that, in its judgment, would enhance the siting of the special exception. He noted a swimming pool was proposed in the rear yard, fencing is required around the pool, and the Board may wish to require a solid six -foot screen fence around the rear and sides of the back yard, or other fencing and landscaping would be provided to achieve a suitable screen. Chairman McGonigal asked if there were any questions for the City and if there was any public comment. Chairman McGonigal called for a motion. Mr. Bell motioned to grant the special exception BZA- 26-25 as long as it didn’t conflict with any original variances prior to the issuance of the subdivision of the lot. Th at special exception would not abut Highway 17, Main Street, or Se a 4 Mountain Highway. The special exception would be in substantial harmony with the area since there was multi -family across the str eet and a dental office behind the property. The special exception would not discourage or negate the use of the surrounding property for uses permitted in its right. In the granting of the special exception, the Board of Zoning Appeals may impose such reasonable additional stipulations, conditions, or safeguards as in the judgement would enhance the siting of the proposed special exception . The swimming pool has been proposed, and fencing was required around the pool, and the landscaping could be in place to screen the pool to achieve suitable screening. The motion was seconded by Mr. Thomas. The motion to approve passed 5-0. C. BZA-26-26: Application by Suren Manukyan for special exception for permitting on premise consumption of alcoholic beverages, beer and/or wine at 4403 Highway 17 South zoned Highway Commercial, HC District. Mr. Manukyan explained the proposal was for a full- service family restaurant that served breakfast and dinner and requested approval to serve beer, wine, and liquor. Chairman McGonigal asked if there were any comments for the applicant. Mr. Caldwell read the staff report into the record, he noted p etitioner Suren Manukyan had submitted an application for a special exception for serving or permitting on premise consumption of alcoholic beverages, beer, and or wine at 4403 Highway 17 South zoned Highway Commercial (HC) district. Mr. Caldwell stated that, due to their potential negative effect on the community, certain businesses could not be operated prior to approval for a special exception by the Board. He stated the Board was tasked with assessing compliance with the applicable criteria, including that the special exception could not be located closer than 200 feet from an R-1, R-2, R-2A, or R-3 district line or residential neighborhood, except in unusual circumstances where mitigating conditions could be imposed to minimize adv erse effects on residential uses. He stated it was 208 feet to an R-1 zoning district. He stated the special exception would comply with all applicable development standards, including off -street parking, and dimensional requirements. He stated the special exception would be in substantial harmony with the area in which it was to be located. Mr. Caldwell noted the property was bordered on the north and east side beside a pharmacy and on the south side by an office, retail and a restaurant. He stated the special exception would not be injurious to adjoining property. The former uses of the building were office and retail. He stated having alcoholic drinks along with breakfast, lunch, and dinner menus should not be injurious to the surrounding properties. The special exception would contribute to economic vitality and promote the general welfare of the community. He noted the building was vacant for a while after the last tenant left and having a restaurant operating would contribute to the economic vitality of the community . Mr. Caldwell noted the special exception would not discourage or negate the use of the surrounding property for use(s ) permitted by right. He noted grating a special exception, the Board of Zoning Appeals may impose such reasonable and additional st ipulations, conditions or safeguards as, in its judgement, would enhance the proposed special exception. He noted the restaurant would be open from 7:00 am to 1:30 pm and again from 4:00 pm to 10:00 pm. All seating was in the front of the building and inside the building. The redevelopment of the building includes adding additional parking spaces and significant landscaping improvements. Mr. Caldwell recommended the Board review the special exception application and hear the evidence presented at the meeting. Chairman McGonigal asked if there were any questions for the City. Mr . Wise as ked which property it was. Mr. Caldwell responded that the property used to be the Amish store. Chairman McGonigal noted there didn’t appear to be anyone from the public to ma ke any comments. 5 Chairman McGonigal called for a motion. Mr. Thomas asked Mr. Caldwell whether he agreed with the assessment presented under criterio n 1. Mr. Caldwell explained it represented his assessment. Mr. Caldwell noted there was an application in the packet that was filled out by the applicant, but the testimony he gave was by his hand. Mr. Bell noted the applicant was located 208 ft from the R -1 district line , which resulted in the applicant to be 8 f eet outside the requirement. Mr. Caldwell agreed and stated he had 8 feet to spare. Mr. No ury noted for the record before a motion was made that the record for BZA-26-26 would include the applicant’s testimony, staff testimony regarding the item, and the staff report, and all such items would be admitted into the record. Mr. Thomas motioned to grant special exception BZA -26-26. He noted per staff’s recommendation, the reasons were stated why the special exception complied with all applicable development standards and all street parking. The proposed restaurant had been developed in compliance with the applicable City development standards. The site provided the required off- street parking, safe vehicle access and would comply with all applicable building , fire, health, and zoning regulations. Alcohol service would be accessory to the primary restaurant use. The record stated why the special exception would be in substantial harmony with the area in which was located. Ocean and Oak was a family oriented full-service restaurant that was compatible with the surrounding commercial area. The proposed use was consistent with nearby businesses that would provide an additional dining option for residents and visitors while maintaining the characteristic of the neighborhood. The special exception would not be injurious to adjoining properties. The restaurant would be professionally operated with alcohol served only in the dining portion to dining patrons in accordance with South Carilina law. The business would comply with the applicable regulations regarding hours of operation, parking, lighting, noise, and public safety. Proposed use i s not expected to negatively impact neighboring properties. The special exception would not discourage or negate the use of surrounding properties. The proposed restaurant would support and continue commercial development in the area without interfering with neighborhood properties or permitted uses. The project was expected to enhance the area’s economic activity while remaining compatible with surrounding businesses. The motion was seconded by Mr. Bell. Chairman McGonigal called for discussion. Mr. Jones asked if the applicant would close at 10 pm. Mr. Bell responded it could give him the availability to stay open. Mr. Jones noted the applicant could stay open till 2 am and still serve alcohol. Mr. Thomas noted that was a good question . Mr. Caldwell pointed out the Board could put conditions in the approval and the Board had done that in the past with a special exception. Mr. Bell stated Mr. Thomas would need to change the motion to be the special exception as presented to the Board. Mr. Thomas added to amend the motion. Mr. Caldwell pointed out the application note d the closing hour of 10 pm but pointed out the restaurant could still seat someone at 9:49 pm and they would be there till after 10 pm. Mr. Thomas asked Mr. Manukyan if he had any comments and if they planned on closing at 10 pm, would everybody by out by 10 pm, and did he plan on selling alcohol past 10 pm. Mr. Manukyan stated they were planning to close around 9 pm so that everyone would be out by 10 pm. Chairman McGonigal pointed out to the applicant he would be restricted to the 10 pm closing. Chairman McGonigal noted if the applicant asked for 10 pm then that was what would be allowed. Mr. Bell proposed changing the closing time to 11 pm just in case. Mr. Caldwell noted that he was going to recommend the 11 pm closing to give time for people to be out of there by 11 pm. 6 Chairman McGonigal stated to amend the motion. The Board all agreed on amending the motion. Mr. Thomas state d he wanted to amend the motion for BZA -26-26 to reflect the restaurant closing at 11 pm. The motion was seconded by Mr. Bell. The motion passed 5-0. D. BZA-26-27: Application by Roger Roy for a variance to reduce the minimally required parking by one space at 5905 North Ocean Boulevard zoned Resort Residential, R4 District. Ben Caldwell, Zoning Administrator, stated the appli cation ha d the incorrect address so it had to be readvertised, and this would come before the Board at the next meeting. Mr. Thomas motioned to postpone BZA-26-27 to the next meeting. The motion was seconded by Mr. Wise. The motion to postpone passed 5-0. E. BZA-25-34: Application by David O’Connell for a Special Exception to construct a single-family dwelling in the Highway Commercial, HC District at 710 12th Avenue South. Mr. Caldwell stated the applicant forgot about the meeting and would be at next month’s meeting, and requested to postpone. Mr. Thomas motioned to postpone BZA -25-34 to the next meeting. The motion was seconded by Mr. Wise. The motion to postpone passed 5-0. Chairman McGonigal called for a motion to adjourn. The motion to adjourn was made by Mr. Bell and seconded by Mr. Thomas. The motion passed 5-0. The meeting adjourned at 5:32 PM. Respectfully submitted, Amber Elmadolar Plan Reviewer NOTE: BE ADVISED THAT THESE MINUTES REPRESENT A SUMMARY OF THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS MEETING AND ARE NOT INTENDED TO REPRESENT A FULL TRANSCRIPT OF THE MEETING.

Source: City of North Myrtle Beach website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.