RecordWell Data

_03122026-512

City of North Myrtle Beach · Horry County · meeting of Mar 12, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of North Myrtle Beach

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 CITY OF NORTH MYRTLE BEACH, SOUTH CAROLINA NORTH MYRTLE BEACH CITY HALL BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS MEETING Thursday, March 12, 2026 5:00 PM MINUTES William McGonigal, Chairman City Staff: Cynthia Lover, Vice-Chairwoman Ben Caldwell, Zoning Administrator Mendell Bell Elton Farmer, Zoning Technician Joe Reaves Chris Noury, City Attorney Andy Thomas Amber Elmadolar, Plan Reviewer Wyman Wise, Absent 1. CALL TO ORDER & ROLL CALL: Chairman McGonigal called the meeting to order at 5:00 PM. 2. APPROVAL OF MEETING MINUTES: Chairman McGonigal called for a motion to approve the minutes of the February 12, 2026, meeting. The motion was made by Mr. Bell and seconded by Mr. Thomas. The motion to approve passed 5-0. 3. COMMUNICATION: Chairman McGonigal stated he would recuse himself from agenda items A and B and let Vice-Chairwoman Lover take over. Vice-Chairwoman Lover noted that it was not a full board that evening. Vice-Chairwoman Lover explained that with only five members present, three affirmative votes were required for approval and that applicants could choose to continue their variance requests to the next meeting, where four of seven votes would be required. 4. SWEAR IN THOSE PERSONS TO SPEAK: Ms. Elmadolar swore in persons to speak at the meeting. 5. NEW BUSINESS: A. BZA-26-01: Application by Robert Guyton for a variance to increase the percentage of compact parking spaces provided and to reduce the required perimeter landscape buffer for a proposed surface parking lot at 1716 S. Ocean Blvd. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated revised parking and perimeter landscaping plans had been submitted and that an additional parcel had been incorporated into the project. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated the revisions required the variance requests to be readvertised, as the original details were no longer accurate, and that the applicant had requested the items be tabled since they could not be heard as submitted. Vice-Chairwoman Lover called for a motion. Mr. Thomas motioned to postpone BZA-26-01. The motion was seconded by Mr. Reeves. The motion to postpone passed 4-0. B. BZA-26-02: Application by Robert Guyton for a variance to reduce the required perimeter landscape buffer for a proposed surface parking lot at 1802 S. Ocean Blvd. zoned Resort Residential, R -4 District. The Board discussed this item in conjunction with BZA -26-01 and decided to postpone the item. Vice-Chairwoman Lover called for a motion. Mr. Thomas motioned to postpone BZA-26-02. The motion was seconded by Mr. Reeves. The motion to postpone passed 4-0. 2 C. BZA-26-04: Application by Kenneth Haynes for a variance of the side yard setback requirements for a proposed screen lanai to cover the existing swimming pool at 806 Merrill Place zoned Single Family, Low Density Residential, R-1 District. Ken Haynes, representing First Choice Enclosures on behalf of the applicant, stated that a survey revealed the side yard setback was 10 feet rather than 5 feet as previously believed, resulting in existing pool decking encroaching into the setback. He explained that the variance was requested to allow the enclosure to cover the existing decking and provide adequate access for maintenance, noting that without the variance the enclosure would be constructed at the water’s edge, creating functional difficulties. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated that they observed the property from over the fence and noted that there appeared to be ample space on that side. She asked for clarification as to whether the distance between the pool decking and the fence was less than five feet. Mr. Haynes stated that he had not anticipated a setback issue prior to receiving the survey and noted that the fence may be located on the neighboring property, creating the appearance of additional space. He explained that the property line extends through the existing pool decking, and that without the variance, the decking would need to be removed to install the enclosure footing at the water’s edge. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated she was not familiar with how the lanai would be constructed and asked whether it would extend over the existing pool decking. Mr. Hayes explained the enclosure must be installed on a footer in the ground and the plan was to place the footing outside or beneath the existing pavers. He stated the variance would allow for a walkway to maintain access around the pool for maintenance and safety . Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked for the proposed height of the lanai. Mr. Haynes stated the proposed lanai would be approximatel y 12 feet in height and confirmed that it would be screened and visible through. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked whether the structure would be enclosed in any way, such as with vinyl panels or windbreaks. Mr. Haynes stated that the only structural elements would be 2-inch by 6-inch posts spaced approximately every six feet. Mr. Thomas asked if the applicant installed the pool. Mr. Haynes stated that neither he nor the homeowner constructed the existing decking, noting it was present at the time of purchase, and that the enclosure was proposed to prevent debris and animals from entering the pool area. Chairman McGonigal referenced the plan and asked for confirmation of the measurements, noting approximately 10 feet with an additional two feet to the pool; Mr. Haynes confirmed this was correct. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked how mu ch of a variance was being requested. Mr. Caldwell stated there was a 10 -foot required setback and it appeared to be half. Chairman McGonigal clarified it would give them about 7 feet around the pool. Mr. Haynes stated that the enclosure would be inset within the footing, resulting in an encroachment of approximately 4.5 feet, but noted that a 5 -foot variance was requested to ensure adequate clearance. He stated the variance would give the owner roughly 3 feet to walk around the pool. Mr. Caldwell read the description of the request, the ordinance, and recommended to hear the variance. Chairman McGonigal asked for clarification of the required setback, noting the 10-foot dimension shown on the plan and inquiring whether it applied to the side yard. Mr. Caldwell confirmed that the 10-foot setback requirement applied to both the principal structure and the enclosure. Chairman McGonigal asked whether the request was for a variance or a special exception. Mr. Caldwell stated the request was a variance, as it sought to reduce the 10- foot setback requirement. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked whether the review was based on the accessory buildings and uses code and whether they applied to the request. Mr. Caldwell confirmed that the enclosure was considered an accessory structure under Section 23 -107 and noted it was addressed in the accessory use table, similar to garages, and that swimming pools were permitted. He explained within the R -1 district, a 5- foot setback was required for an unenclosed swi mming pool, but the enclosure was considered an addition to the principal 3 structure and must meet the same setbacks as the house. He noted due to the lot’s size and width, a 10-foot side yard setback applied. Mr. Reeves stated the Board’s responsibility was to determine whether a hardship existed and noted that inconvenience alone did not constitute a hardship, referencing the shape of the lot as a potential factor. Mr. Haynes noted while working around the pool could be inconvenient, inconvenience alone was not a hardship. He explained that safety concerns , such as climbing out near the water, and issues with animals or debris in the pool could constitute hardship. He added the enclosure could be built without a variance, but it would be less aesthetically pleasing than if constructed within the setback. He stated a footing would need to be installed by removing and resetting the existing pavers, which would place the enclosure within the setback. He noted that the enclosure would still sit close to the water’s edge once constructed and limit space for someone to safely exit the pool. Mr. Haynes acknowledged the request might be a stretch to qualify as a hardship and expressed appreciation to the Board for considering the case. Chairman McGonigal asked whether state regulations require a specific setback, such as five feet, around the pool for safety purposes. Mr. Caldwell stated the zoning ordinance d id not specify a setback from the pool and that he was not aware of any building code or other regulations requiring a setback from the water’s edge or screen enclosure. Mr. Haynes stated that unless the enclosure served as a fence, which it did not in this case, there was no required clearance from the water, and the structure could be placed at the edge of the water. Chairman McGonigal stated the Board was reviewing the case to identify any outstanding issues that could help. Chairman McGonigal called for a motion. Mr. Thomas motioned to deny BZA-26-04 because the applicant had not demonstrated an unnecessary hardship. There were no extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to this particular piece of property that would merit a variance from the application of the zoning code. The motion was seconded by Mr. Bell. The motion to deny passed 5-0. D. BZA-26-05: Application by Gilad Tannenbaum for a variance of the signage allowances for a building at 201 Main Street within the Resort Commercial RC District . Mr. Tannenbaum stated he was the authorized applicant for Palmetto Island at 2011 Main Street. He explained he took over the store, formerly Kings at the Beach, in October and began façade improvements in partnership with the city of North Myrtle Beach, including applying for a façade grant. Mr. Tannenbaum noted while designing new signage, he was unaware of the 100-square-foot limit for building signs. He emphasized the requested additional square footage was the minimum necessary to provide proportional identification for the corner property, which has dual frontage on Main Street and Ocean Boulevard, giving i t unique visibility compared to other corridor buildings. Mr. Tannenbaum stated he had printed seven examples to illustrate the difference between the proposed sign size and what was permitted. He explained the building ha d approximately 106 feet of frontage, and the proportion of the permitted sign would appear very small. He emphasized the proposed sign was intended to enhance the corner’s appearance and that significant investment had already been made in improving the property. Mr. Tannenbaum stated the property would operate as a retail business. Mr. Tannenbaum noted the previous owner had a stucco facade with different colors, which he felt was unappealing. He explained they wanted to give the building a more modern look and believed the renovation would encourage others in the area to improve their facades, making the corridor more attractive. He also noted that the City was excited about these improvements. Mr. Tannenbaum explained that the proposed signs show all three entrances of the building. He noted even if a smaller sign were placed on the Main Street or Boulevard entrance, it would still appear very small and not achieve the desired effect for the building. He emphasized the comparison between 4 the proposed and permitted sign sizes illustrated this difference. Vice-Chairwoman Lover and Mr. Tannenbaum discussed the dimensions labeled on the plans. Mr. Thomas asked staff if there was a minimum lo t size in the residential commercial zoning district. City staff researched the code to get the information requested. Mr. Caldwell stated the lot width requirement was not applicable for uses that were not specifically listed. Since the only listed uses in the RC district were residential, multi-family, and mixed-use dwellings, and this was a retail operation, there was no required lot width. Mr. Reeves asked if the building was divided into three separate businesses, the total signage area per location would still be limited to 100 square feet. Mr. Caldwell stated that altogether the signage would be limited to 100 square feet. However, if there were three businesses on separate lots within the building, then each tenant could have up to 100 square feet, totaling 300 square feet for all three tenants. Mr. Bell asked if City Council had an interest in addressing this through a special exception rather than a variance. He noted this approach was becoming more common with the signage ordinance. Mr. Caldwell stated that if the Board wanted City Council to review, they could make that recommendation. Mr. Bell asked if the entire façade ordinance had just been updated, noting that the applicant was receiving funds to upgrade the façade. Chairman McG onigal stated that the zoning rules were written for a standard 50 by 225 -foot lot, but this property consisted of six lots, making it much larger. He noted that it would make sense to have a way to consider special exceptions within the thresholds set by City Council and staff, allowing signage to be proportionate to the building. The Board noted the frontage of the building should be considered, particularly since the property faced two roads, affecting how signage would be proportioned. Mr. Tannenbaum stated the façade upgrade had already begun, and they had planned to start manufacturing the signs about three days ago, intending to complete the project over three to four weeks while avoiding interference with visitors and tourists. Mr. Caldwell and Vice- Chairwoman Lover discussed that although the sign ordinance limits window coverage to 25%, it does not regulate what can be displayed inside the windows, meaning large or flashy displays could be installed, but the applicant’s proposed signage would be more visually appropriate. Mr. Tannenbaum explained the previous owner had placed numerous stickers and signs on the windows, creating a cluttered appearance, and they were in the process of removing them to achieve a clean, modern look with unobstructed windows. Vice-Chairwoman Lover noted that decorative elements like the circular palm tree graphics were not considered signage, and that the applicant could separate the palm tree from the words ‘Palmetto Island’ to effectively enlarge the sign without violating the ordinance. She observed that this flexibility supported granting the variance, as it allowed the building to maintain an attractive appearance without being constrained by strict sign rules. Chairman McGonigal opened the floor for public comment. Jolene Puffer, 3506 Turner Avenue, North Myrtle Beach, stated confusion because of a previous similar case that Alley Oops was granted a variance. She noted the location of this business was located in an area of interest for revitalization. Ms. Puffer noted the design was attractive and a smaller design would be a hardship. She stated the building was fairly large and that a smaller sign would be aesthetically inadequate, especially given the high vis ibility on Main Street, and expressed the community supported the proposal. Mr. Bell stated while there were different approaches, this project would provide value and benefit to the community, noting that it present ed a hardship since the property didn’t have grandfathered street-side parking. The Board consulted City Attorney, Chris Noury, for input. Chairman McGonigal stated that while this was a good example where common sense would apply, the presence of a hardship made the situation more challenging. He suggested exploring a special exception. Mr. Bell noted the property had two road frontages, Main Street a nd Ocean Boulevard, and that improvements would enhance the site despite parking limitations. Mr. Noury stated the request could not be considered as a special exception 5 and must be addressed as a variance. The Board discussed with Mr. Noury how to proceed in addressing the hardship associated with this case. Mr. Bell motioned to approve BZA- 26-05 as submitted by the applicant because applicant has demonstrated an unnecessary hardship, specifically there were extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to this particular piece of property given the fact it does sit on Ocean Boulevard and Main Street having double road frontage. These conditions do not generally apply to all properties in the vicinity. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit earnings to restrict the utilization of the property. The authorization of the variance would not be a substantial detriment to adjacent properties or to the public good and the character of the district would not be harmed by granting of the variance. The motion was seconded by Mr. Reeves. The motion to approve passed 5-0. E. BZA-26-06: Application by Elizabeth Petit due to the removal of a tree greater than 24" without a permit at 500 8th Avenue North. Ms. Petit apologized to the City, stating she would not have allowed the individual to persuade them to cut down any trees had they been aware that permits were required. Ms. Petit stated the tree in question, as shown in the submitted materials, had an infestation, believed to be termites. She explained she had been informed that the infestation posed a risk to other trees on the property and stated she had no intention of losing additional trees. City Staff helped Ms. Petit set up her iPad which showed the picture of the infected tree. Ms. Petit described the tree as being completely deteriorated, “just like paper,” and explained she was told the infest ation would eventually spread to the other trees on the property. She stated, as a result, the tree had to be removed. Vice -Chairwoman Lover asked the applicant if the person who informed them about the infestation was also the one hired to remove the tree. Ms. Petit confirmed that and further admitted she did not ask whether that individual held a city license. Vice-Chairwoman Lover questioned the contractor’s credentials. Ms. Petit stated it did not seem unusual at the time and later acknowledged the individual was not licensed, accepting responsibility. Mr. Caldwell read the description of the request, the ordinance, and recommended to hear the variance. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked how this came to the City’s attention. Mr. Caldwell stated he believed it was reported through a complaint. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked whether the contractor was still cutting the tree when the City arrived or if it had already been removed and inquired whether staff had observed the condition of the tree. Mr. Caldwell stated the trees did not appear healthy; however, they did not make formal determinations on tree health and relied on a certified arborist to confirm whether a tree was dead or dying prior to issuing a permit. Mr. Caldwell explained the conditions described would not have been visible until the tree was cut into and reiterated that City staff were not arborists. He stated they relied on a certified arborist to determine whether a tree was dead, dying, or hazardous before issuing a removal permit, in order to avoid liability. Mr. Bell stated he was inclined to allow the applicant the opportunity to provide a letter from a certified arborist that confirmed the tree was dead or dying, noting it appeared hollow and deteriorated, rather than issuing a fine. Vice-Chairwoman Lover noted the tree was no longer visible. Mr. Bell noted portions of the trunk and stump remained, and photos and video documentation showed visible hollowing. Chairman McGonigal indicated that while they understood the applicant’s case, they would require a let ter from a certified arborist. Ms. Petit stated she didn’t know an arborist personally and Chairman McGonigal asked if the city could recommend one. Mr. Caldwell stated they did not make recommendations. The Board suggested to have the applicant get an arborist’s letter, table the decision , and revisit it next month once the letter was provided. Chairman McGonigal asked if she would be required to plant new trees. Mr. Caldwell stated if the arborist deemed the tree dead or dying, a one-tree replacement was 6 required, with no minimum size specified. He added the applicant would not need to return to the Board if a letter from an arborist was provided. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked about the 24-inch tree, noting the previous discussion referred to the 40-inch tree. Mr. Bell noted the 24-inch tree was hollow, he referenced the next picture that showed the hollowed-out middle. Chairman McGonigal noted there wasn’t really a penalty for the tree replacement; the goal was to provide a reasonable, common-sense path forward. Ms. Petit mentioned she had planned to plant magnolias and flowering shrubs . It was noted the applicant referenced 75%, and Mr. Caldwell clarified if a permit had been issued for a tree less than 24 inches in diameter, it would require a 50% replacement, or 75% if replacing with the same species that were removed. However, if an arborist provided a letter stating the tree was dead or dying, only a one-tree replacement would be required, and it would not have to be the same species. Mr. Caldwell stated if the Board had been inclined to issue a variance, conditions could be added requiring that the replacement tree be an oak. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated she wanted to ensure clarity before proceeding, noting one replacement tree would be an oak, but since the applicant had removed both a 40 -inch tree and a 20 -inch tree, she would be required to replace two trees. Vice-Chairwoman Lover motioned as a penalty for cutting the trees without a permit, the applicant be required to plant two oak trees between two and four inches in diameter. The motion was seconded by Mr. Bell. The motion to set the penalty passed 5-0. F. BZA-26-07: Application by John Rebry for a variance of the signage allowances for a church at 200 Highway 17 South zoned Office Commercial, OC and Highway Commercial, HC. Mr. Stap stated he was representing Mr. Rebry and that he was the general contractor for the project where the new church sign was being installed. Chairman McGonigal stated he had looked at the property and noted how far back it was from Highway 17 and then asked if they could show where the building and the addition were located. Mr. Stap explained the addition was attached to the southern side of the existing sanctuary, and the new sign would be mounted directly on the building using about four-inch standoffs, standing approximately 170 feet back from the road frontage on Highway 17. Chairman McGongigal noted the existing building appeared to be roughly 300 feet back from Highway 17, estimating this based on the presence of four lots between the road and the structure. Mr. Stap stated the front of the building was about 170 feet from Highway 17, with a parking lot in front, and explained the sign’s size was necessary to ensure it was legible from that distance. He added the entire property spanned 6.4 acres and had road frontage on three roads , Highway 17, 6 th Avenue, and 2nd Avenue, providing approximately 1,200 feet of total road frontage along the three sides of the property. Mr. Caldwell read the description of the request, the ordinance, and recommended to hear the variance. Mr. Stap stated there was a variance issued back in 2012 for additional wording over by the childcare area. The variance had approved the sign, which indicated “Family Life Center,” but that wording was now partially obscured by the new building due to its placement further back and angled more toward 6th Avenue. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked whether the existing signage from the prior variance was still visible or if the new building was covering it, and whether previous variances for other signage were being considered in the current review. Vice- Chairwoman Lover asked about removing existing signage square footage and replacing it with new signage. Mr. Caldwell explained this would be allowed because the variance runs with the property, not the specific sign design, and applie d only to the total square footage. Mr. Stap explained they could remove the other signage, noting that the buildings were separate and not connected. The new sign would identify the new sanctuary, whereas the previous signage was for the Family Life Center and was no longer visible from Highway 17. He added that without the new sign, visitors would struggle to locate the church, especially in a tourist-heavy area, and 7 that the property’s large size and positioning create a hardship justifying the request for additional sign frontage. Mr. Bell motioned to approve BZA -26-07 because the applicant ha d demonstrated an unnecessary hardship. Specifically, there are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to this particular piece of property given the fact that it ha d three road frontages, it’s on a six- acre property, and sits 175 feet back from the road. These conditions do not generally apply to the other properties in the vicinity. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or to restrict the utilization of the property. The aut horization of the variance would not be substantial detriment to adjacent properties or to the public good and the character of the district would not be harmed by the granting of the variance and approving the request as is. Mr. Reeves seconded the motion. The motion to approve passed 5-0. G. BZA-26-08: Application by James Baldwin for a variance to remove trees in excess of 24" in diameter at 1701 Springland Drive. Mr. Bell stated he was an active stockholder of the Surf Club, and he would recuse himself for the item. Mr. Roy requested, on behalf of the applicant, the Board table the item and conducted a site visit to better understand the project at Surf Club. He explained phase one of a multi-building, campus-style redevelopment had been completed and noted that while some trees would be removed, the property inc ludes extensive green space. He emphasized the project was designed to preserve the integrity of the golf course. Mr. Roy stated upon project completion, there would be more green space because the overall building footprint would be smaller than the existing structure. He noted a portion of the building had already been removed during phase one and offered to conduct a site visit for the Board, either collectively or individually, to demonstrate the project. Chairman McGonigal called for a motion. Mr. Thomas motioned to postpone BZA -26-08. The motion was seconded by Mr. Reeves. The motion to postpone passed 4-0. Chairman McGonigal called for a motion to adjourn. The motion to adjourn was made by Mr. Reeves and seconded by Mr. Thomas. Mr. Bell, having recused himself for the preceding item, did not return to the Chambers for the vote on adjournment. The motion passed 4-0. The meeting adjourned at 6:14 PM. Respectfully submitted, Amber Elmadolar Plan Reviewer NOTE: BE ADVISED THAT THESE MINUTES REPRESENT A SUMMARY OF THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS MEETING AND ARE NOT INTENDED TO REPRESENT A FULL TRANSCRIPT OF THE MEETING.

Source: City of North Myrtle Beach website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.