_03122026-377
City of North Myrtle Beach · Horry County · meeting of Mar 12, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of North Myrtle Beach
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
CITY OF NORTH MYRTLE BEACH, SOUTH CAROLINA
NORTH MYRTLE BEACH CITY HALL
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS MEETING
Thursday, February 12, 2026
5:00 PM
MINUTES
William McGonigal, Chairman City Staff:
Mendel Bell Ben Caldwell, Zoning Administrator
Cynthia Lover, Vice-Chairwoman Elton Farmer, Zoning Technician, Absent
Joe Reaves, Absent Chris Noury, City Attorney
Andy Thomas Amber Elmadolar, Plan Reviewer
Wyman Wise
Melissa Wober
1. CALL TO ORDER & ROLL CALL: Chairman McGonigal called the meeting to order at 5:00 PM.
2. APPROVAL OF MEETING MINUTES: Chairman McGonigal called for a motion to approve the
minutes of the January 8, 2026, meeting. The motion was made by Mr. Bell and seconded by M s.
Wober. The motion to approve passed 6-0.
3. COMMUNICATION: Vice-Chairwoman Lover noted that it was not a full board that evening. It was
explained that a majority of the quorum was required to approve a variance request. With the current
quorum, four votes were required to approve a variance request. Therefore, the variance request
related to the trees required four affirmative votes. It was also noted that Mr. McGon igal recused
himself from the subsequent items, which reduced the voting members and required three affirmative
votes to approve those variance requests.
Robert Guyton stated that because the Board was not at full membership and the applicant felt
additional work was needed on the two parking variances, which included trees that were still being
studied, he requested those two variance requests be deferred to the next meeting. He stated the
only remaining item for consideration that evening would be the slide on the oceanfront tract. Vice-
Chairwoman Lover stated that once Mr. McGonigal left the meeting, three affirmative votes would be
required to approve that variance request.
4. SWEAR IN THOSE PERSONS TO SPEAK: Ms. Elmadolar swore in persons to speak at the meeting.
5. NEW BUSINESS:
A. BZA-25-47: Application by David Rumney for a variance to remove trees at 948 Morrall Drive.
Chairman McGonigal noted this case had already been closed and they received a letter from an
arborist. The letter stated the trees questioned were dying or dead or not worth saving since they
would not survive. Chairman McGonigal asked Mr. Caldwell to explain the tree ordinance so the
public had a better understanding. Mr. Caldwell stated if the tree was dead or dying a permit
could be issued to remove it with one tree replacement.
Mr. Bell explained the applicant came in last month requesting tree removal on a heavily wooded
lot that impacted the construction of the house and questioned the health of several trees. In the
request, the applicant asked the Board to consider the trees that he thought were unhealthy. The
Board advised him to hire an arborist to evaluate the trees and provide a letter.
2
Chairman McGonigal called for a motion. Mr. Bell motioned to close BZA-25-47. The motion was
seconded by Mr. Wise. The motion to close the item passed 6-0.
B. BZA-26-01: Application by Robert Guyton for a variance to reduce the required perimeter
landscape buffer for a proposed surface parking lot at 1716 S. Ocean Blvd. zoned Resort
Residential, R-4 District. Mr. McGonigal stated he would recuse himself from the next three items
before the Board because they pertained to him, and he stepped away from the meeting. He
stated Vice-Chairwoman Lover would take over. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked if she were
correct in understanding the applicant wished to continue the item from that evening’s agenda
and had it heard at a later date. Mr. Guyton confirmed that the applicant requested to continue
both items at 1716 and 1802, identified as item 26-01 and item 26-02, to the next meeting date.
Mr. Bell stated he believed the Board should first hear from the City. He also suggested asking
whether anyone present wished to speak on the matter, even though the item was being
postponed, in case anyone still wished to provide comments. Mr. Bell asked if that would be the
recommended approach and wanted to make sure, they were following protocol. Vice-
Chairwoman Lover asked if anyone present wished to speak regarding Variance Requests 26-01
or 26-02. Members from the public stated they wanted to be heard on the third item regarding
the slide.
C. BZA-26-02: Application by Robert Guyton for a variance to reduce the required perimeter
landscape buffer for a proposed surface parking lot at 1802 S. Ocean Blvd. zoned Resort
Residential, R-4 District.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover called for a motion. Mr. Thomas motioned to postpone BZA -26-01 and
BZA-26-02 to the next scheduled meeting. The motion was seconded by Ms. Wober. The motion
to postpone passed 5-0.
D. BZA-26-03:
BZA-26-03: Application by Robert Guyton for a variance of side yard setback for a
proposed slide tower at 1717 S. Ocean Blvd. zoned Resort Residential, R-4 District. Mr. Guyton
stated, as with past oceanfront hotel projects he had been involved with, some type of variance
was typically required. He explained these were all dimensional variances due to constraints from
Ocean Boulevard, the OCRM line , which shifts over time , and the d une line. In this case, he
noted the building fit within the overall envelope, and the request was specifically for relief from
the 10-foot side setback. Mr. Guyton explained the structure in question was a slide tower, not
a building per se, but classified as a structure under the code. He noted that because it was
under 35 feet in height, a variance was still required. He described it as a metal circular staircase
providing access for patrons to the slide and pool and stated the request was to reduce the side
setback from 10 feet to 6 feet for the slide tower only. Mr. Guyton stated, unlike a typical building
wall, the slide tower did not create shadowing issues, airspace problems between adjoining
properties, or block any view corridors from the street. He noted neighboring properties had
been developed either prior to current zoning or under a previous code and were therefore
already closer to the property line than the proposed improvements. Mr. Guyton stated each
oceanfront property was unique, with topographical changes that ma de development
challenging, and the requested relief was necessary. He explained the conditions described were
unique to this property, noting that neighboring properties were already developed under prior
codes, while the current code would prohibit development of this property.
Mr. Guyton stated North Myrtle Beach was unique due to ongoing improvements to oceanfront
properties, and this project was another example aimed at maintaining a vibrant coastal market.
He explained that applicable state, federal, and local ordinances affecting only new construction
were the reason the current zoning regulations would otherwise prohibit or unreasonably restrict
use of this oceanfront property. Mr. Guyton stated the hardship would require the use of an
3
outdated concept, such as a diving board, which was no longer incorporated in new
developments, rather than allowing the current airy, safe, and simple design for enjoying the
pool on the oceanfront side of the property. Mr. Guyton stated adding the new slide to the
oceanfront parcel would extend the long-standing use of amenities on the property as a resort,
increase value for both the public and visitors to North Myrtle Beach, remain harmonious with
adjacent properties, and reduce potential for guest injury. He explained the requested variance
represented the minimum relief necessary for reasonable development of the site. Mr. Guyton
stated, due to OCRM restrictions on placing amenities on the ocean side, this was the only
feasible location for the resort amenities, and the requested 4-foot variance represented less
than 50% of the remaining setback. Mr. Guyton stated the proposed variance was a dimensional
variance applicable only to the exterior elevated slide adjacent to the oceanfront pool, which had
existed on the prior property for many years, resulting in no change in use. Mr. Guyton stated
that the proposed variance was a dimensional variance applicable only to the exterior elevated
slide adjacent to the oceanfront pool, which had existed on the prior property for many years,
resulting in no change in use. He added continui ng this use with a newer, safer, and more
attractive slide preserved the current use of the property without expanding it, as no adjacent
properties incorporated an elevated slide with an exterior oceanfront pool.
Mr. Caldwell read the description of the request, the ordinance, and recommended to hear the
variance. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked Mr. Caldwell to explain the OCRM line and why it
changed and how it affected the setback. Mr. Caldwell stated the OCRM setback line, which lies
between the beach and the developable portion of the property, shift ed over time and was
established by the State, not the City. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked how often the line was
reassessed. Mr. Caldwell stated it ha d been done a few times in the past twenty years and
surveyors would update this line on surveys. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked if the structure was
considered a waterslide and clarified that it was a staircase for the waterslide. Vice-Chairwoman
Lover asked if the City considered it a building, which was confirmed, explaining why a variance
was required. Mr. Caldwell explained it was referred to as a building setback or setback line, and
that only a few types of structures were allowed to encroach into a required side yard setback,
with stairs not being one of them. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated the slide itself did not extend
over the setback line, but the stairs to access the top of the slide did. Mr. Caldwell stated it
appeared the slide met the requi red 15-foot setback, and only a portion of the stair tower
extended four feet into the required side yard.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked if the staircase would be enclosed and Mr. Guyton explained he
did not see drawings for it except the one provided in packet. Ms. Wober
confirmed the structure
was made of metal and asked whether it would create any noise issues for guests on the other
side of the resort . Mr. Guyton noted it would only be foot traffic, and it would be an open-air
staircase. Ms. Wober asked if there would be a privacy issue. Mr. Guyton stated the slide tower
was much lower than any of the guest rooms in the building, and only people on the pool deck
would be using and enjoying the tower. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked if there was currently a
slide on the property, and Mr. Guyton explained the former property had a diving board and a
pool, which had since been demolished. Mr. Thomas asked if there was public access on either
side, and Mr. Caldwell explained there would be access on the southern side and the slide would
be located on the northern side.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover opened the floor for public comment. Debbie Lapierre, a full -time
resident of 1414 Hillside Drive South, stated the project began around 2021 and the City had
spent significant time working to reach an agreement between MIG and the residents of Crescent
Beach. She explained that residents had opposed the project from the beginning, but City Council
approved it in 2022, granting MIG the right to build a 165-foot oceanfront resort and a 90-foot
parking garage across the street. Ms. Lapierre stated although residents did not agree with those
4
approvals, they had accepted them and did not believe the developer should be allowed to
further encroach into the state-mandated and regulated setback area. Mr. Bell clarified that the
staircase would not encroach into any federal or state setback, noting the variance request
involved a City setback, not a state setback. Mr. Bell explained that the OCRM setback, referring
to Ocean Resource Management, was located at the rear of the property toward the dune and
oceanfront side, not along the side property l ine. Mr. Bell clarified that the variance request
involved a side setback rather than the OCRM setback. He explained, if facing the beach, the
staircase would be located on the left side of the property, and the applicant was requesting a
four-foot variance on that side. He stated he wanted to ensure everyone was referring to the
same location.
Mr. Bell asked how Ms. Lapierre felt if the parking garage was eliminated. Ms. Lapierre stated
she did not mind the elimination of the parking garage because it would bring everything down
to street level. However, she expressed disappointment because the garage had previously
included retail or restaurant -type commercial businesses that were to make up 10% of the
square footage. Mr. Bell asked whether Ms. Lapierre would prefer to eliminate the 90 -foot
structure on Ocean Boulevard or keep the retail component that had been proposed as part of
the parking garage. Ms. Lapierre stated she did not mind the parking lots but expressed concern
about the proposed reduction of the landscape buffer. She stated, based on their understanding
of the information provided, the reduction of the landscape buffer was intended to allow
additional parking spaces. Mr. Bell stated the Board would discuss those matters later and that
he was asking questions to ensure everyone was on the same page. He explained that the ability
to build up to 165 feet resulted from the need to build vertically due to the OCRM line, whi ch
was established by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), and which had
shifted. He added the previous dilapidated hotel was demolished to allow for redevelopment that
would enhance tourism and support the local economy. Mr. Bell st ated the developer was
attempting to find a way to improve the property and noted that the project did not build to the
full 165-foot height allowance, as four stories were removed from the originally permitted height.
Ms. Lapierre stated the overlay zoning allowed for the original height, and she praised the City
for planning ahead. She explained that the City’s proposal enabled MIG to proceed with their
project while also addressing the concerns of full-time residents. Mr. Bell stated that, as part of
the process, MIG had dedicated 30 feet of their property to expand beach access to the City of
North Myrtle Beach, which would include pickleball courts, additional beach access, and more
golf cart parking. He noted this dedication, on the south side of the property, restricted the
hotel’s use and required the building to be shifted to accommodate the public improvements.
Ms. Lapierre asked how much public access existed prior to the property dedication. Mr. Bell
explained there was only one existing access that was just a walkway in that area. Mr. Bell
explained he was born and raised here and understood her concerns. Mr. Bell asked whether,
given that MIG had dedicated 30 feet of property to the City for public use on the south side,
there was any objection to granting a four -foot variance on the north side for an open -air
staircase to serve visitors on the property. Mr. Bell stated he wanted the residents to know they
had been heard and emphasized that the Board’s role was to seek common ground between
both sides. Mr. Bell clarified that Mr. McGonigal, who was affiliated with MIG, had recused himself
from the meeting that day to maintain transparency and would not be going over the OCRM
setback because that would be against federal law. Mr. Bell asked whether granting the four -
foot variance, which would slightly encroach into the setback, would be detrimental or cause
harm to neighboring properties or the community, and Ms. Lapierre responded that it would not.
Ann L emay, an investor in the Compass by Margaritaville project, thanked the Board and
attendees for their time. She explained, as a lifelong hotel professional, she prioritized guest
experience and hospitality, aiming to create a positive impression for visitors w hile respecting
5
the surrounding community. She described the careful planning behind the oceanfront outdoor
amenity, noting although they could had pushed the building closer to the ocean for more
parking, they chose a design that provided spacious, comfortable areas for guests. She
emphasized that the project was thoughtfully designed to benefit both visitors and neighbors,
including some retail spa ce, and expressed hope that the community would be proud of the
development and would visit once completed.
Cheryl Kilday, President and CEO of Destination North Myrtle Beach, stated that her organization
had followed the project and previously testified in support before City Council. She noted the
parties involved had worked to minimize any harm to the communi ty and neighbors, and that
much of that discussion had been addressed during the meeting. She emphasized the project
aligned with the community -led Destination Master Plan and the City’s C omprehensive Plan,
providing an upscale, amenity -rich development th at fits into the community. She added the
project’s walkable commercial nodes, improved beach access, and accommodations for guests
were aspects her organization strongly supported.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover called for a motion. Mr. Bell motioned to approve BZA -26-03. The
applicant had demonstrated an unnecessary hardship. There were extraordinary and exceptional
conditions pertaining to this particular piece of property including the OCRM setback line
established by NOAA and the donation of 30 feet of land to the City for public use. These
conditions do not apply to neighboring properties. Due to these conditions, strict application of
the ordinance would effectively prohibit reasonable use of the property. It was further noted that
granting the four -foot variance for the staircase would not substantially detriment adjacent
properties or the public good, and the character of the district would not be harmed. The motion
was seconded by Mr. Thomas. The motion to approve passed 5-0.
Chairman McGonigal returned to the meeting. Vice-Chairwoman Lover called for a motion to adjourn.
The motion to adjourn was made by Mr. Bell and seconded by Mr. Wise. The motion passed 6-0. The
meeting adjourned at 5:37 PM.
Respectfully submitted,
Amber Elmadolar
Plan Reviewer
NOTE: BE ADVISED THAT THESE MINUTES REPRESENT A SUMMARY OF THE BOARD OF ZONING
APPEALS MEETING AND ARE NOT INTENDED TO REPRESENT A FULL TRANSCRIPT OF THE MEETING.
Source: City of North Myrtle Beach website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.