_01082026-489
City of North Myrtle Beach · Horry County · meeting of Jan 8, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of North Myrtle Beach
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
CITY OF NORTH MYRTLE BEACH, SOUTH CAROLINA
NORTH MYRTLE BEACH CITY HALL
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS MEETING
Thursday, January 8, 2026
5:00 PM
MINUTES
William McGonigal, Chairman City Staff:
Mendel Bell Ben Caldwell, Zoning Administrator
Cynthia Lover Elton Farmer, Zoning Technician
Joe Reaves, Chris Noury, City Attorney
Andy Thomas Dawn Snider, Planner
Wyman Wise Amber Elmadolar, Plan Reviewer, Absent
Melissa Wober
1. CALL TO ORDER & ROLL CALL: Chairman McGonigal called the meeting to order at 5:00 PM.
2. APPROVAL OF MEETING MINUTES: Chairman McGonigal called for a motion to approve the
minutes of the December 11, 2025, meeting. The motion was made by Ms. Wober and seconded by
Mr. Bell. The motion to approve passed 6-0. Chairman McGonigal abstained because he was not
present at the previous meeting.
3. COMMUNICATION: None.
4. SWEAR IN THOSE PERSONS TO SPEAK: Ms. Snider swore in persons to speak at the meeting.
5. NEW BUSINESS:
A. BZA-25-40: Application by Roger Roy for a 15’ front yard variance and a 10’ side yard variance
for a proposed residential project at 6810 Water Tower Road, zoned Medium Density Residential
(R-2). Mr. Roy stated the property consisted of two lots being combined into one and there was
a 20-foot easement given to the City for road widening and a 35’ setback off Water Tower Road.
The requested front yard setback reduction was due to the roadway easement and the existing
conditions along Water Tower Road. Mr. Roy explained that the side yard setback variance related
to an adjacent flag lot that functioned as a driveway providing access to a cellular tower. He
stated that the reduced setback would not be injurious to adjacent property owners. Mr. Roy
further explained that the property was bordered by wetlands on the north and east sides, which
required additional buffers and limited the buildable area of the site. Mr. Roy stated there was
another townhome project on the west of the flag lot. Mr. Roy explained that the proposed
development was an over-55 community with associated amenities. He noted that the developer
was requesting a reduced front -yard setback of 15 ’; however, due to the existing right -of-way
and buffer areas, approximately 45 feet would be between the roadway and the start of the
development. He further indicated that the buildings would be placed adjacent to a flag lot
extending approximately 30’ to the rear.
Mr. Roy explained the site will include a buffer area with
vegetation, shrubs, and other landscaping. He noted that additional green space would be
maintained around the wetlands, along with any required supplemental landscaping. He
concluded that, for these reasons, the proposal would not be injurious to surrounding properties
and that the lot differs from other lots within the city limits.
Mr. Bell asked whether the request was essentially for a landscaping buffer. Mr. Roy responded
that was correct. Mr. Bell asked whether any buildings would be constructed outside of the
2
setback and Mr. Roy responded no. Ms. Lover asked for clarification regarding the 35 ’ roadway
setback. Mr. Roy noted that, according to the plat in the packet, the 35 ’ setback was required
because Water Tower Road was planned for future expansion. He added that, as these lots were
developed, easements would likely be signed with the City to allow for the addition of another
lane. Ms. Lover asked how close the buildings would be to the roadway if the road were widened
in the future. Mr. Roy stated that even with the roadway expansion, the buildings would remain
approximately 30’ from the roadway and that a landscaped buffer would remain. Ms. Lover asked
how much space would remain between the pavement and the building if the road were expanded
to its maximum width. Mr. Roy responded there would be 25’ remaining. Mr. Bell clarified 25’ was
standard for the R-1 zoning district.
Mr. Caldwell read the description of the request, the ordinance, and recommended to hear the
variance. Chairman McGonigal requested clarification on the consequences that were discussed
earlier over a phone call and asked for the numbers. Mr. Caldwell stated the developer ha d not
conveyed the numbers yet. He explained that the property would remain private until the city
widened the road, at which time the developer would convey the necessary portion to the City.
Mr. Caldwell explained he gave a drawing that conveyed this. Chairman McGonigal stated he just
wanted to make sure the numbers were correct. Mr. Caldwell explained that an earlier version of
the plan showed a 35’ roadway setback and a 20-foot front-yard setback. The front-yard setback
had since been reduced to 15 feet, but a 35-foot-wide strip of land would still be conveyed to the
City.
Chairman McGonigal noted that the primary concern had been ensuring there was sufficient space
for the future widening of the roadway. Ms. Lover expressed concern that if the road was
eventually widened to its maximum, future residents of the townhomes might lose their expected
privacy and be exposed to traffic noise. She asked how much distance or protection would remain
between the roadway and the buildings for the residents’ benefit. Mr. Reeves asked if that would
be in the deed. Mr. Caldwell did not bel ieve it would be in the deed and explained it would be
commonly owned so there was no cross-section of what the road may look like ; so, he did not
feel confident answering the question. Mr. Caldwell assumed a 12- 13’ wide lane and additional
right of way to the property line. Ms. Lover quoted Mr. Roy saying he believed the building itself
would be 25’ from the road. Mr. Caldwell responded that even if the front -yard setback were
reduced to 15 feet and the roadway width were only 12 to 14 feet, there would still be sufficient
distance between the buildings and the road. Mr. Bell asked for clarification, noting that there
was a 15’ landscape buffer plus an additional 35’ totaling 50’ and 12 to 13’ off that 50’. Mr.
Caldwell explained that it was a guess without having a cross -section of the proposed right-of-
way. Mr. Roy clarified that the units would not be sold but would be part of a rental project. He
noted that it would be an over-55 rental community. Ms. Lover asked whether ownership would
be limited to KT or a successor. Mr. Bell asked for confirmation that, even with the roadway
expanded, approximately 35 feet of buffer would remain between the road and the buildings. She
stated her understanding that future occupants who found road noise unacceptable could relocate
without a reduction in property value.
Chairman McGonigal called for a motion. Mr. Wise motioned to approve BZA-25-40 with a 15’
front yard and 10’ side variance. The applicant had demonstrated an unnecessary hardship. There
were extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to this particular piece of property where
the shape and wetlands that constricted the utilization of the property. These conditions did not
generally apply to other properties in the vicinity. Because of these conditions, the application of
3
the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict
the utilization of the property. The authorization of the variance would not be of substantial
detriment to adjacent properties or to the public good, and the character of the district would not
be harmed by the granting of the variance. The motion was seconded by Mr. Thomas. The motion
to approve passed 7-0.
B. BZA-25-41: Application by Jerred Roberts to remove a multi trunk tree at 1603 Hillside Drive
South. Mr. Roberts stated the subject property was a 50 -foot-wide lot and that the cedar tree
was located in the center of the front yard, which made installation of a driveway infeasible. He
further stated that utility lines were required to cross the front of the lot and that the installation
of those utilities would damage the tree’s root system, likely resulting in the loss of the tree even
if it were preserved. Chairman McGonigal asked the applicant for a picture to figure out the
layout of the lot. Ms. Lover asked if it was the lot in the rear and not the lot with the foundation
laid out. Mr. Roberts explained where they saw the foundation laid out, there were two additional
lots to the right of it, and it was the one to the far right. Ms. Lover clarified the tree in question
was on Hillside Drive but not the tree in the front corner. Mr. Roberts explained it was not the
tree in the front corner and that tree was being saved and was located on a different lot.
Chairman McGonigal clarified that the lot in question was the only one with a split tree. Ms. Lover
noted that there were three lots, with no other trees on the lot except those around the fringe
and confirmed that one of the fringe trees needed to be protected. Chairman McGonigal clarified
the tree in the front was close to the street. Mr. Ro bert noted that a third smaller tree was
extending from the main tree.
Mr. Caldwell read the description of the request, the ordinance, and recommended to hear the
variance. Chairman McGonigal asked if Hillside Drive was a DOT road. Chairman McGonigal noted
the challenge that came from it being a DOT road since they dictated location.
Chairman McGonigal called for a motion. Ms. Lover motioned to approve BZA-25-41 based on
the hardship created by the location of the tree within the buildable area of the lot and the utility
requirements. The motion included a condition requiring the replacement of 14’’ of trees on the
subject lot, to be planted as hardwoods, or payment of $4,200 into the City’s Tree Bank, or a
combination thereof. The motion was seconded by Mr. Reeves. The motion to approve passed
7-0.
C. BZA-25-42: Application by William McFaul to exceed the maximum signage allowances for an
under construction 24,900 square foot family dining and entertainment facility at 3607 Highway
17 South zoned Highway Commercial, HC District. Mr. McFaul stated the proposed development
was an approximately 25,000-square-foot facility on a 2.75-acre lot. He noted his understanding
that signage was limited to 150 square ft. Mr. McFaul noted the project would include multiple
components, including dining, beverage service, bowling, arcade games, and mini golf . Mr.
McFaul stated that they submitted schedules for three sides of the building, as well as a pylon
sign. They requested a variance to exceed the 150-square-foot sign limit due to the number of
uses within the venue and the overall size of the project. Mr. McFaul further explained that a
large live oak tree located near the center of the property had been preserved, which affected
the orientation and placement of the building and reduced its visibility from Highway 17 South.
He stated that the building was positioned farther west on the site as a result, creating additional
hardship related to signage visibility. Mr. McFaul stated he submitted signage schedules for three
building elevations and a freestanding pylon sign to promote the different uses on the property.
He noted that if the building were subdivided into multiple commercial spaces, each could be
allowed 150 square feet of signage, which on the same lot would exceed the current limit. Ms.
Lover asked what the variance amount was for. He noted that signage requirements varied by
4
jurisdiction, creating uncertainty regarding how certain artistic elements would be calculated.
Mr. McFa ul explained their signage package included a Jeep “Woody” vehicle, which was
considered artwork in some jurisdictions. Mr. McFaul noted that the sizes of each sign were
detailed in the submitted schedules. On the east elevation, the two Woody signs measure d 20
square feet each, and in combination with three additional signs, including a fork and knife, a
bowling pin, a tropical drink, and a golf green, the total signage on that elevation amounted to
approximately 250 square feet. Mr. McFaul noted that the signage package specified the size of
each sign for all three building elevat ions, as well as the pylon sign. Mr. McFaul was uncertain
whether the 40 square feet for the Woody signs would be counted toward the total.
Ms. Wober asked whether the sign would be illuminated. Mr. McFaul explained they were all
back lit. Mr. Bell asked if there would be a digital component. Mr. McFa ul stated that the pylon
sign would include a digital component and that a separate submission was provided for. He
explained that the pylon sign measure d approximately 130 square feet based on overall width
and height, noting that the actual area was reduced due to its irregular shape. The electronic
message center (EMC) portion measured approximately 5 feet 3 inches by 9 feet 3 inches, adding
roughly 50 square feet of signage.
Mr. Caldwell read the description of the request, the ordinance, and recommended to hear the
variance. Ms. Lover asked how much of a variance was being requested and noted that 150
square feet was permitted, asking if the applicant was requesting an additional 606 square feet.
Chairman McGonigal asked staff to clarify what the ordinance allow ed. Mr. Caldwell explained
the ordinance allowed one square foot of signage per linear foot, not to exceed 150 square feet,
including any freestanding sign. Mr. Reeves asked if this was a 25,000 square foot building. Mr.
McFaul noted the building was 24,900 square feet so just about 25,000 square feet. Mr. Bell
stated that if the building were divided into 2,500-square-foot tenant spaces, the property could
legally accommodate up to approximately 1,470 square feet of signage across those spaces. Mr.
Bell also noted the building was reoriented to preserve a tree in the center of the lot, which
reduced visibility and limited signage opportunities, as the building d id not directly face the
street. Mr. Bell expressed agreement that these factors created challenges for the applicant.
Ms. Lover asked what the plans were for the smaller oak trees located in the parking lot. Mr.
McFaul stated several of the trees looked to be in bad shape and they intended to trim them and
save them. Mr. McFaul noted his understanding that if the trees were removed, they would need
to be replaced. Ms. Lover noted that some of the trees looked dead and some were trimmed.
Mr. McFaul stated they had not trimmed the trees. Ms. Lover asked for the City’s position on the
pictures. Mr. Caldwell explained that all artwork was considered signage. Although artistic in
nature and without words, the company logo , the “Woody”, was included on the freestanding
sign and would be counted as building-mounted signage if it appeared on the building. Ms. Lover
asked about the artwork of the bowling pin. Mr. Caldwell noted that signage representing on-
site activities, including bowling, drinks, and golf, would be counted toward the total signage.
He also noted that artwork unrelated to the business, such as a painted beach scen e on the
building, would not be considered signage.
Mr. Bell asked if City Council was considering changes to the signage regulations for future
projects, noting that 150 square feet may be insufficient for larger buildings. Mr. Caldwell pointed
out that based on the side and front elevations, the building d id not appear to have a large
amount of signage. Mr. Caldwell noted a discussion with the Chairman regarding the potential
increase in signage size to better correspond with the scale of the building. Chairman McGonigal
discussed the possibility of reviewing signage allowances based on building size, noting that
larger buildings may warrant additional signage to be effective and support community success.
He suggested evaluating square footage to determine a reasonable signage amount. Ms. Lover
5
stated that she agreed with the discussion regarding the proportionality of the signage to the
building size. She requested that any motion to approve included a condition requiring the
preservation of all healthy existing trees in the parking lot. Mr. McFaul asked for clarity on the
replacement program. Ms. Lover inquired about the required amount of landscaping and number
of trees for the property. Mr. Caldwell stated that the property was required to have one tree
per 25 linear feet along the perimeter, one tree on each end island of a parking space bank, and
one shrub for every 10 linear feet. Mr. Caldwell noted that there were existing trees on the site,
and while some were intended to be preserved, the reorientation of certain parking areas
prevented all of them from being saved. The Board discussed the preservation of trees on the
property. Mr. McFaul pointed out the submitted plans included a landscape plan with replacement
requirements.
Chairman McGonigal called for a motion. Ms. Lover motioned to approve BZA-25-42 to allow the
applicant to have 756 square feet of the requested signage based on the hardship created by
the size of the building, the size of the lot, and the limited visibility resulting from the preservation
of the large oak tree. The motion included a stipulation requiring that existing trees deemed
alive and healthy be retained and allowed to count toward the project’s landscaping
requirements. The motion was seconded by Mr. Bell. The motion to approve passed 7-0.
D. BZA-25-43:
Application by Robert Bays for a variance to place a storage building in one of the
two front yards at 2410 Douglas Street zoned Mobile / Manufactured Home Residential, R -3
District. Mr. Bays stated that their property was considered a double-frontage lot, with frontage
on Douglas Street and Bryant Street. He explained that there was an existing shed in the fenced
backyard, which was removed due to disrepair, and they were requesting a variance to place a
new portable building in the fenced backyard on the Bryant Street side. Mr. Bell clarified the
hardship being the double frontage lot.
Mr. Caldwell read the description of the request, the ordinance, and recommended to hear the
variance. Ms. Lover explained to the audience that, under the ordinance, a lot with frontage on
two streets was considered to have two front yards rather than a backyard. Certain structures,
such as sheds, garages, and swimming pools, were only permitted in the backyard. Therefore,
the applicant’s lot had two front yards, which constituted the hardship for the variance request.
Mr. Bell motioned to approve BZA-25-43 based on the unnecessary hardship created by the lot’s
double frontage and resulting in two front yards. The applicant ha d demonstrated an
unnecessary hardship. The extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to this particular
piece of property given the fact it ha d two front yards. These conditions do apply to the other
properties in the vicinity. Because of these conditions, the application effectively prohibits or
unreasonably restricts the utilization of the property. The authorization of the variance would
not be a substantial detriment to adjacent properties or to the public good given the fact there's
already a structure on that side of the street as well on the house next to them and wouldn’t be
harmed by the granting of the variance. The motion was seconded by Ms. Wober. The motion
to approve passed 7-0.
E. BZA-25-44:
Application by Derek DaPonte for a variance to place or have constructed a metal
building that exceeds the allowance for a freestanding garage at 1502 26th Avenue North zoned
Low Density Single Family Residential, R -1 District. Mr. D aponte stated that the property
consisted of a double lot and that his residence was constructed on one lot, with the second lot
was intended for a detached garage. He explained that he had originally believed a larger
accessory structure would be permitted but later learned the ordinance limited garage size to 30
percent of the home’s gross living area, resulting in a maximum allowable size of approximately
6
625 square feet. Mr. Daponte requested approval to construct a 30-foot by 30-foot (900-square-
foot) garage to accommodate boats, camper trailers, and other equipment currently stored under
and around the home. Mr. Daponte stated that he was inexperienced with the process and was
appearing before the Board for the first time. He explained that they had their property surveyed
and followed the required steps, but were informed that, based on their 1,900 -square-foot
house, the allowed garage space was limited to 625 square feet (25 by 25 feet). Mr. D aponte
stated that the proposed garage would be used solely for residential storage purposes and not
for any business or living space. He explained that the larger structure would allow equipment
to be stored out of view, improve the appearance of the property, and provide buffering from
traffic along Little River Neck Road.
Ms. Lover asked how many square feet the house was currently. Mr. Daponte stated that their
house had approximately 1,600 to 1,900 square feet of heated living area. They noted that
including decks and the full foundation, the structure measure d approximately 36’ by 40’. Ms.
Lover asked how much living space the house would have if the area underneath were enclosed
to create a two-story home. Mr. Daponte responded that the enclosed two-story configuration
would provide approximately 3,600 to 3,700 square fe et of living space. Ms. Lover asked if
approval was granted, would it interfere with the tree on the property. Mr. Daponte stated he
staked out the property and indicated that the proposed structure would be approximately 15
feet from the front corner of the house, aligned with the front of the house. He noted that this
placement met all front and rear setback requirements and described that the structure would
extend along the side of the house, stopping before the back deck and leaving approximately 25
feet before reaching the tree on the property. Ms. Lover expressed concern over aesthetics,
stating a metal building would look like an industrial building. Mr. Daponte explained the garage
would be two toned like the style of the house with a regular peaked roof. Mr. Daponte described
the proposed building’s exterior, stating it would have a black lower portion, white upper walls
with black trim around the doors, a white side door, and a black roof, generally matching the
colors of the house. He noted that the building would have two garage doors rather than three.
Mr. Daponte explained that the original submittal was for a 960-square-foot building, which was
not approved. He stated that a revised submittal for a 30 -by 30-foot (900-square-foot) garage
was submitted for consideration. Ms. Lover asked if he was requesting 900 or 960 square feet.
Mr. Daponte noted that no materials have been purchased and they were seeking a permit before
proceeding. He explained that the original design was for a 24- foot-deep, 960 -square-foot
garage, but was informed that the maximum allowed in North Myrtle Beach was 900 square feet
for a 2,700-square-foot house. The request for the variance was for an additional 5-foot depth
to construct a 30-by-30-foot garage, which was needed to accommodate the items they planned
to store, as a 25-by-25-foot garage would be insufficient. Mr. Bell asked if there was a way to
attach the garage to the house by a breezeway. Mr. Daponte explained he did not want to attach
it to the home due to cost and the look of the property. Mr. Daponte addressed aesthetic
concerns raised by Ms. Lover, stating that the proposed structure was designed to match the
residence with coordinated colors and finishes and would resemble a residential garage rather
than an industrial or commercial building. He emphasized that the building was intended for
personal storage only and not for commercial use. Board members discussed construction
options, noting that a stick -built structure would be significantly more expensive. Mr. Daponte
confirmed that cost was a limiting factor but explained that the design included residential-style
doors and windows to reduce an industrial appearance. The Board agreed that maintaining a
residential aesthetic was important to protect neighborhood character and property values and
expressed no opposition to the structure’s size, noting that it appeared proportionate to the lot.
The applicant also mentioned potential future plans for fencing along the property.
7
The Board discussed the importance of maintaining neighborhood character and requested
conditions to ensure the building’s appearance was compatible with the surrounding residential
area. The Board discussed whether design details of the structure would require additional
approval if the variance were granted. It was noted that while separate approval would not be
required, conditions could be included in the variance regarding windows, doors, c olors, paint,
and landscaping. Mr. Caldwell explained that a nei ghboring property’s fence screened the
structure from view along Little River Neck Road, limiting visibility from one direction. He noted
that the overhead and pedestrian doors would face the opposite direction and that adding a
window with shutters could provide additional visual appeal, while visibility from other
approaches would remain minimal due to the existing fence. Mr. Noury asked for clarification as
to whether the proposed structure was accurately represented by the photograph provided by
the applicant’s wife, and the applicant confirmed that it was. Mrs. Daponte stated that a larger
structure had been preferred but was not permitted, so the smaller option was selected, noting
some difficulty evaluating its appearance due to the dark color shown in the photograph.
Chairman McGonigal stated that the structure would need to be reviewed and approved by staff
to ensure it met upgraded appearance standards. He also noted the installation of a fence could
further screen the structure from view. Mr. Daponte stated he had no issue installing a fence.
Mr. Thomas noted that the example metal building shown in the photograph was black while the
residence was white, and the applicant clarified that the proposed structure would feature black
wainscoting approximately four feet along the lower portion with white siding above to match
the house. Ms. Lover recommended design conditions for the structure, including four feet of
wainscoting with white siding above, at least two windows along the Little River Neck Roadside
with contrasting shutters to complement the residence, and additional landscaping such as
oleanders and crepe myrtles. Members noted that the shutters would enhance the building’s
appearance and reduce the visual impact of the metal structure. Mr. Bell asked what the hardship
was. Ms. Lover explained the proportionate size of the lot to the structure. Chairman McGonigal
asked whether the area beneath the structure would be considered living space, even though it
was intended as a garage, and whether such space would be counted in calculations. Mr. Caldwell
explained they wouldn’t count the outdoor areas, porches, or underneath the house. Ms. Wober
asked if the boats and vehicles would fit in the building. Mr. Daponte stated all vehicles, boats
and trailers would fit. Ms. Lover noted that a common issue throughout North Myrtle Beach was
the presence of campers and trailers and emphasized the city’s intent to encourage property
owners to provide coverage or screening for such vehicles. The Board discussed previous
situations like this one.
Chairman McGonigal called for a motion. Mr. Reeves motioned to approve BZA-25-44 based on
the applicant demonstrating unnecessary hardship. The extraordinary and exceptional conditions
pertaining to this particular piece of property was due to the irregular shape and large size of
the lot relative to the home. These conditions did not generally apply to other properties in the
vicinity. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of
property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property. The
authorization of the variance would not be substantial to the detriment to adjacent properties or
to the public good, and the character of the district would not be harmed by the granting of the
variance. The approval was granted subject to conditions including that the garage be limited to
900 square feet; that the building incorporate an upgraded residential appearance; that the color
scheme match the existing home, with no more than four feet of black wainscoting at the base;
that at least two windows with shutters be installed on the Little River Neck Road side; that
8
appropriate landscaping be provided; that the existing tree adjacent to the proposed garage
location be preserved; and that final design details be reviewed and approved by City staff. If
staff approval cannot be obtained, the applicant would be required to return to the Board for
further review. The motion was seconded by Mr. Wise. The motion to approve passed 7-0.
F. BZA-25-45: Application by Michelle Barney for a variance to remove protected trees at 1232
Crooked Hook Road. Scott Davis, Beverly Homes representative, explained this was the first of
two requests and that the trees were located within the footprint of a proposed future amenity
center, including a pool, pool house, sidewalks, parking lot, and mailbox kiosk. Ms. Lover
indicated she had difficulty locating the trees during site visits and initially believed the request
involved larger trees located in the center of the open space. Mr. Davis noted that the large trees
in the middle of the property w ould remain, while the trees on the waterway side of the small
island between the roads were being proposed for removal. Ms. Lover pointed out the application
noted two p oplar trees. Mr. Davis acknowledged confusion regarding tree species, noting he
misspoke earlier by referring to cedar trees and clarified that the trees included poplar for this
application. Mr. Davis clarified that the large central trees would remain and that the trees
proposed for removal were located on a small island area closer to the roadway and near a
dumpster location.
Ms. Lover expressed concern that the development had already removed a significant number
of trees and questioned why the applicant was returning for additional removals of protected
trees. Mr. Davis explained that the area in question was an open space, and the engineer later
designed the pool to comply with all requirements for stormwater management, parking lot size,
number of parking spaces, sidewalks, and related parameters.
Mr. Caldwell read the description of the request, the ordinance, and recommended to hear the
variance. Mr. Bell asked whether, realistically, the city would have required an amenity center to
be constructed before the development began. Mr. Caldwell stated there wasn’t a requirement
for an amenity center in this development, but they decided to provide one. Mr. Caldwell noted
the development was not a part of a Planned Development District (PDD) but was under standard
zoning. Mr. Caldwell stated that the applicant had previously appeared before the Board for tree
removal. While they initially thought they had identified all trees to be removed, two additional
trees had been identified due to plans for an amenity center. Mr. Caldwell noted that these trees
were protected from the beginning, and adjustments in the amenity center’s location during final
development planning have resulted in the need to remove them. Ms. Lover stated the trees
appeared healthy and were among the few remaining trees on the site. The Board discussed
that the amenity center was not originally required for the development and was added later,
raising questions about whether the site could be rede signed to preserve the remaining trees.
Mr. Bell asked city staff if they could grant a variance on the parking requirements to help
preserve the trees. Mr. Caldwell explained that doing so would require the applicant to reapply,
readvertise, and to be considered at the following month’s meeting. Mr. Caldwell noted that
amenity centers do not have a minimum parking requirement and that applicants were typically
advised to provide what they anticipated needing. He added that the Board would not need to
take any action if the applicant chose to reduce the number of parking spaces at the amenity
center, noting that the applicant could make that adjustment independently. Chairman
McGonigal suggested that the applicant return to the city and postpone the matter to develop a
reasonable solution to preserve the trees. He emphasized that while the amenity center was
important to residents, the Board also sought to preserve trees wherever possible and noted
that this appeared to be a case where tree preservation could be achievable.
Mr. Wise asked how many parking spaces there were in the proposed plan. Mr. Davis stated
there were six standard and one handicap, so a total of seven parking spaces. Mr. Bell asked
9
whether retaining the tree would interfere with access to a single parking space. Mr. Davis
responded that it would likely affect two or three spaces on one side and two or three on the
other, though an exact determination would require reviewing the plans. Chairman McGonigal
asked whether the Board was also attempting to preserve the cedar tree. Ms. Lover stated that
she had not seen a cedar on site, and Mr. Davis acknowledged that he had misspoken. Ms. Lover
explained that while a cedar appeared in the ph otograph, the site contained several large
individual trees, including a sycamore near the foundation. Mr. Davis noted that an 8-inch cedar
was located within a cluster of two trees, and Ms. Lover confirmed that the cedar could not be
removed without also removing the poplars. Ms. Lover stated that she preferred to continue the
matter and have the applicant return with an updated drawing or consider repositioning the
driveway to preserve the few remaining trees. She noted that the Board had previously reviewed
which trees were required to be saved and expressed concern that the a pplicant was now
requesting removal of the few lone trees still on the site. Mr. Caldwell stated that Mr. Farmer
was retrieving the drawings for the amenity center and would display them on the camera to
show what was proposed. He noted that the tree was located on the opposite side of the parking
spaces and suggested that the driveway could potentially be shifted slightly toward the bottom
of the site plan to preserve it. Suggestions included shifting or shortening the parking lot,
relocating the driveway entrance, creating a landscaped tree island with curbing to protect roots,
and adjusting ADA parking placement. After reviewing the proposed plans and photographs, the
Board agreed that additional coordination with City staff could likely identify an alternative layout
that would preserve the trees. Members requested a revised plan clearly showing tree locations
and parking adjustments before considering removal.
Chairman McGonigal called for a motion. Ms. Lover motioned to postpone BZA-25-45 to allow
the applicant to work with City staff to explore redesign options aimed at saving the protected
trees. The motion was seconded by Mr. Reeves. The motion to postpone passed 7 -0. The
applicant was advised to return to the Board only if no feasible alternative could be identified.
G. BZA-25-46:
Application by Michelle Barney for a variance to remove a protected tree at 1200
Brackish Bay Road. Scott Davis, Beverly Homes representative explained a residence was located
nearby on Brackish Bay Road and that a 27-inch sycamore tree was approximately four feet from
the foundation once the house was constructed. Ms. Lover reiterated that the applicant had been
aware the tree was protected prior to beginning construction of the house. Mr. Davis explained
that the home was pre-sold and that the buyer had selected the floor plan and related features.
He noted that the tree was approximately 48 inches from the foundation and relatively close to
the property line, adding that the lot was a corner par cel with larger setback requi rement on
both sides. Ms. Lover asked whether the applicant had been aware that the tree had been
protected in a prior hearing before the foundation was installed. Ms. Lover stated that she
believed the situation was self -imposed, noting that the issue resulted from the applicant’s
actions. Mr. Bell agreed, commenting that allowing the buyer to select a house plan that
encroached on the protected tree created the con flict. Ms. Lover added that construction was
still in its early stages, with only framing in place and no footers poured at this time.
Mr. Caldwell read the description of the request, the ordinance, and recommended to hear the
variance. Chairman McGonigal called for a motion. Ms. Lover motioned to deny BZA-25-46 on
the grounds that this was a protected tree and any hardship that may exist was self-imposed.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Bell. The motion to deny passed 7-0.
H. BZA-25-47: Application by David Rumney for a variance to remove trees at 948 Morrall Drive.
Mr. Rumney appeared before the Board as the property owner and explained that the parcel
exceeded two acres in size, approximately three -quarters of the lot consis ted of wetlands and
dense woodland. He emphasized that preservation of trees was a primary reason for purchasing
10
the property and that his intent was to minimize tree removal to the greatest extent possible.
He explained that the construction submittal included a house and driveway that accounted for
less than 15 percent of the lot’s total impervious area. He noted that eight trees had been
identified during inspection, then clarified that there were seven trees to be reviewed individually.
Ms. Lover clarified that the Board was only reviewing trees measuring 24 inches in diameter or
larger. She noted that the application referenced additional smaller trees, which may have
caused some confusion, but explained that while the City considered those trees separately, the
Board’s review was limited to those meeting the 24- inch threshold. The owner and the Board
clarified that the relevant trees were numbered one through four and agreed to proceed with
reviewing those items individually. Ms. Lover noted difficulty identifying which specific trees were
proposed for removal due to multiple ribbon colors on site and the volume of trees present. Mr.
Rumney clarified that purple tape identified trees proposed for removal, pink tape identified
wetlands, and that yellow markings had later been added by staff to clarify impacted trees. The
survey included numbered tree designations to assist with identification. Ms. Lover stated that
after walking the site, she had difficulty identifying the specific trees referenced but believed she
had located the tree near the right corner of the house and the tree situated within the driveway
area. Mr. Rumney referenced photographs of Tree No. 1 and indicated its approximate location,
noting that it was roughly 150 feet from the road and positioned straight in from the roadway,
identified as Tree No. 46 on the site plan. Ms. Lover asked if it was the tree leaning hard. Mr.
Rumney explained it was and that it was three trees with three trunks. He noted that the tree
was located in the area where t he driveway was proposed to be constructed. He commented
that the tree was not particularly attractive and noted that it appeared to be a multi -trunk tree
rather than a single-stem tree. Ms. Lover stated she had questions regarding other trees and felt
Mr. Rumney was within his purview to remove Tree No. 1 (46).
Ms. Lover explained she had a hard time finding the trees but did find the trees in the ditch
where the corner of the house was proposed. Mr. Rumney noted that the second tree was a
fairly large poplar, also multi-trunk, with an approximate trunk diameter of 17 inches, identified
as Tree No. 99. He explained that Tree No. 2 (99), a healthy poplar, was located in the middle
of a ditch at an elevation about five feet lower than the proposed lot grade. He noted that the
tree would likely not survive construction and further observed that when the foundation strings
were laid, one string passed through the middle of the two trunks, placing roughly half of the
tree within the house footprint. He added that it was unclear whether the lot lines had been
properly marked during the survey, which could affect the scope of the tree’s impact on
construction. Chairman McGonigal asked to see the plot plan so they could see the driveway
layout. Chairman McGonigal noted that the proposed driveway minimized tree impacts, and that
Tree No. 1 (46) was located in the middle of the driveway and could not be preserved. Mr.
Rumney inquired about measuring multi -trunk trees, and Mr. Caldwell explained that the two
largest trunks were combined to determine if a tree met the protected 24-inch threshold, noting
that separate trees or smaller trunks could affect whether the tree fell under the Board’s review.
Chairman McGonigal suggested addressing Tree No. 1 (46) first, noting that if it was located in
the driveway and could not be preserved, it would be removed from consideration before
reviewing the remaining trees. Ms. Lover noted that she had walked the site within the marked
driveway and house area and observed that most trees could be removed without issue. She
stated that her only concern was confirming which trees the applicant intended to remove, asking
whether the four large trees in question were all within the house footprint and driveway area
or if any were outside the marked boundaries. Mr. Rumney noted that Tree No. 3 fell into a
separate category and was not considered a hardship, as it did not appear healthy, and indicated
that only Trees No. 1 (46) and No. 2 (99) posed hardships.
11
The Board reviewed the specific trees individually, agreeing that Tree No. 1 (46), which was
leaning and located in the driveway, could be removed. Members discussed replacement
requirements and generally agreed that no replacement was necessary due to the abundance of
existing multi-trunk trees on the property and the condition of the affected trees. Chairman
McGonigal called for a motion. Ms. Lover made a motion to approve BZA-25-47 with regards to
Tree No. 1 (46), finding it’s a hardship that was located in t he footprint of the driveway. Since
the lot had multiple large trees, she noted replacement was not necessary. Ms. Lover noted she
would require no further trees other than the ones approved in the meeting to be removed. The
motion was seconded by Mr. Bell. The motion to approve Tree No. 1 (46) passed 7-0.
The Board then considered Tree No. 2 (99), a multi-trunk poplar located in a drainage ditch near
the corner of the proposed house footprint. Mr. Rumney explained that staking indicated the
tree partially conflicted with the house foundation layout. The Board agreed that removal could
be permitted only if the tree remained within the footprint of the structure. If the foundation
were shifted such that the tree no longer conflicted, the tree would be required to remain.
Chairman McGonigal called for a motion. Ms. Lover made a motion to allow the removal of Tree
No. 2 (99) with no replacement schedule provided the foundation was not shifted. The motion
was seconded by Mr. Reeves. The motion to approve Tree No. 2 (99) passed 7 -0. Discussion
then turned to additional trees identified as items three through five, which were located farther
from the house footprint and were cited primarily due to potential health concerns, including
visible fungus and apparent decay at the base. There was confusion between members about
the identification of the trees. Board members determined that removal based solely on
suspected health issues should be evaluated by a certified arborist rather than decided at the
meeting. Ms. Lover suggested denying the variance request for Tree No. 5, noting visible signs
of fungus, and recommended that an arborist inspect the tree. Mr. Bell suggested offering a
continuance and let ting the applicant speak to an arborist. The Board agreed to continue
reviewing trees three, four, and five pending an arborist evaluation, with the City to report
findings back to the Board at a future meeting. It was noted that this continuance would not
delay permitting for the home.
Chairman McGonigal called for a motion. Mr. Bell motioned to continue BZA-25-47, approving
the first two tree removal items and directing that the remaining trees be evaluated by an
arborist, with the City reporting back at the next meeting to determine whether the variance
should be finalized or further continued. The motion was seconded by Mr. Wise. The motion to
approve passed 7-0. Mr. Rumney also clarified that two additional trees initially identified had
since been determined to remain outside construction impacts and would be preserved.
Chairman McGonigal called for a motion to adjourn. The motion to adjourn was made by Mr. Bell and
seconded by Mr. Thomas. The motion passed 7-0. The meeting adjourned at 6:41 PM.
Respectfully submitted,
Amber Elmadolar
Plan Reviewer
NOTE: BE ADVISED THAT THESE MINUTES REPRESENT A SUMMARY OF THE BOARD OF ZONING
APPEALS MEETING AND ARE NOT INTENDED TO REPRESENT A FULL TRANSCRIPT OF THE MEETING.
Source: City of North Myrtle Beach website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.