RecordWell Data

_09212026-907

Town of Lexington · Lexington County · meeting of Sep 21, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Lexington

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

MINUTES Town of Lexington Executive Sessions and COUNCIL WORK SESSION MEETING September 21, 2026 The Town Council convened an Executive Session at 5:00 p.m., followed by a regular work session, which then took place at 6:00 p.m. on September 21, 2026, in the Council Chambers located at 111 Maiden Lane, Lexington, South Carolina. The meeting was attended by: Mayor Hazel Livingston, Mayor Pro-Tem Todd Carnes, Councilmembers Todd Lyle, Gavin Smith, Will Allen, Jeannie Michaels, and Ron Williams. A quorum was met. Staff members present were Assistant Town Administrator Kevin Richardson, Chief of Police Terrence Green, Finance Director Kathy Pharr, Planning and Building Director Jessica Lybrand, Chief Building Inspector Brent Hawkins, Transportation Director Randy Edwards, Utilities Director David Wiman, Parks and Community Services Director Jeff Metz, Public Information Officer Laurin Barnes, Digital Media Coordinator Michael Tolbert, Town Attorney David Epperson, Municipal Clerk Laura Hinson, Transportation Department Coordinator Rondie Cheathem, and Marketing Coordinator Lauren Smith. Approximately three (3) citizens were present and no (0) members of the news media. WORK SESSION OPENING & CALL TO ORDER: Mayor Livingston welcomed everyone to the meeting and introduced her fellow Councilmembers. INVOCATION AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE : Councilmember Allen delivered the invocation and Councilmember Lyle led the Pledge of Allegiance. CALL TO ORDER: Mayor Livingston called the meeting to order at 6:01 pm. EXECUTIVE SESSION REPORT: Mayor Livingston reported that Executive Session was called to order at 5:00 p.m. following a motion by Councilmember Lyle, seconded by Councilmember Williams. Council entered Executive Session pursuant to S.C. Code § 30- 4-70(a) to discuss potential proper ty acquisition and a contractual matter related to a roadway project. No action or vote was taken during Executive Session. A motion to adjourn Executive Session was made by Councilmember Lyle and seconded by Councilmember Smith, and Executive Session adjourned at 5:47 p.m. Councilmember Williams moved to ratify the report , which was seconded by Councilmember Michaels. The motion carried unanimously. 7 in favor/0 opposed. DELETIONS FROM AGENDA: None MINUTES WORK SESSION MEETING September 21, 2026 2 PRESENTATION: 1. Introduction of the 26 -27 Town of Lexington Youth Ambassador Members - Marketing Coordinator Lauren Smith introduced the 12 newest Youth Ambassadors from River Bluff High School and Lexington High School. She noted that the students had already hit the ground running and were actively working on the Vision Plan. Ms. Smith rea d the names of the students as they stood. Council welcomed the new Youth Ambassador class. BUSINESS ITEMS: (Discussion & Recommendation for the October 5, 2026, Council Meeting) 1. Proposed Amendment to Chapter 150, Building Codes Administration Planning Director Jessica Lybrand presented proposed amendments to Chapter 150 to specifically identify each building code adopted and enforced by the Town. She explained that the current ordinance generally adopts building codes recognized and mandated by the State of South Caroli na, while the proposed amendment would identify each applicable code individually. Director Lybrand stated that the amendment was recommended based on guidance from the South Carolina Building Codes Officials Association and recent litigation concerning the adoption of permissive building codes. She noted that the proposed amendment would provide greater clarity regarding the codes formally adopted by the Town and promote consistency with recommended practices for municipalities throughout the State. Director Lybrand emphasized that the amendment would not change the Town’s current enforcement or application of the building codes. Director Lybrand also presented a proposed change to remove specific building and zoning fee amounts currently contained in Chapter 150. She explained that fees are established by Town Council through the annual budget process and that the ordinance would instead reference the fees established by Council. She noted that this would eliminate the need to amend the ordinance each time fees are updated. Councilmember Williams made a motion to place the item on the October 5 agenda. Councilmember Smith seconded the motion. Mayor Pro -Tem Carnes asked Town Building Official Brent Hawkins what substantive changes would result from the proposed amendment. Director Lybrand clarified that the Town already follows the applicable State building codes and that the amendment would primarily codify and more clearly identify the specific codes followed by the Town. Mayor Pro -Tem Carnes asked whether the amendment could cause citizens to believe that the applicable codes had changed. Director Lybrand confirmed that it would not and reiterated that the amendment was intended to clarify the codes currently followed by the Town. Mayor Pro -Tem Carnes asked about arc- fault circuit interrupter (AFCI) requirements in electrical panel boxes and whether such requirements were imposed by the County. Mr. Hawkins explained that the State building code MINUTES WORK SESSION MEETING September 21, 2026 3 contains certain modifications that may allow requirements to be removed and that such provisions are subject to State and jurisdictional decisions. He stated that the Town follows the State building code and does not modify the State building codes. Mr. Hawkins added that he had not received questions regarding the AFCI requirements and noted that the proposed amendment would identify the specific State codes followed by the Town. He stated that he had seen more jurisdictions move toward specifically identifying the State codes they follow, making the proposed amendment more consistent with practices in other jurisdictions. There being no further discussion, the motion carried unanimously: 7 in favor/ 0 opposed. 2. US-1 at Harmon St. / Martel Dr. Intersection Improvement (utilities) Transportation Director Randy Edwards presented an update regarding road design work at US 1 and Harmon Road. He explained that the project requires the relocation of a water line and that, following research and discussions with Utilities Director Wiman, Staff identified overlapping projects that could be coordinated. Staff are proposing to slow the roadwork schedule to incorporate the replacement of the existing cast iron water line into the project rather than completing the roadwork and returning at a later date to replace the water line. Director Edwards stated that the proposed approach would require an additional design fee of approximately $100,000. He noted that $50,000 has already been allocated in the current fiscal year and that the remaining amount could be incorporated into the next fiscal year’s budget to allow the projects to be designed and completed together. Councilmember Smith made a motion to place the item on the October 5 agenda. Councilmember Allen seconded the motion. Mayor Livingston asked whether the project would be pushed into late 2027. Director Edwards stated that, based on the time required for all necessary permitting through the Department of Environmental Services (DES), the project would extend into that timeframe. Mayor Pro-Tem Carnes asked why the water lines were being replaced . Utilities Director Wiman explained that the age of the infrastructure is a factor, noting that the existing cast iron piping includes lead goosenecks and has experienced breaks. He stated that the replacement would utilize PVC, with ductile iron used where the water line is located beneath the roadway. Director Wiman noted that the replacement would provide additional water pressure in the area, eliminate a dead- end line, and improve water quality. He explained that Staff did not want to complete the road project and then have to return approximately a year later to cut into portions of the newly constructed roadway to replace the water line. MINUTES WORK SESSION MEETING September 21, 2026 4 Director Edwards stated that Michael Baker International would handle the road and utility design for the coordinated project. Councilmember Williams asked whether the project could be expedited to avoid delayed improvements to the intersection. He suggested that the water mains could potentially be installed first, with other work completed later. Director Edwards explained that the location of the connections makes that approach difficult and that the roadway would still need to be disturbed due to the layout of the area. Councilmember Smith asked whether, since the roadwork was delayed to accommodate utility work, the Town could evaluate the cost of burying existing overhead utilities to maintain the aesthetic character of the Town. He asked Town Attorney Epperson whether language could be included in franchise agreements or whether an ordinance could be adopted to require utilities to be placed underground. Town Attorney Epperson stated that language could potentially be included in an agreement or ordinance but noted that the associated costs could be substantial and may result in pushback. He added that he had not seen such a requirement implemented previously but would research whether language could be incorporated. Director Edwards stated that the project is currently in the design phase and that he could ask the engineer and utility providers to evaluate, at a high level, the cost of undergrounding the utilities. He stated that the information would be brought back to Council at the next meeting. There being no further discussion, the motion carried unanimously. 7 in favor/ 0 opposed 3. North Church Street Parking Lot – Project Award and Dominion Energy Lighting Agreement (Combined with FYI Item No. 1) Director Edwards combined this item with FYI Item No. 1 on the agenda because the two items were related. Director Edwards stated that the first portion of the discussion was presented as an FYI regarding the award of the project. He reported that a Notice of Award had been issued to Coogler Construction following receipt of 15 bids. The awarded bid was $1,599,000, which is within the approved project budget. Director Edwards stated that Staff anticipates the project will be completed in early 2027. Director Edwards then presented the proposed parking lot lighting agreement with Dominion Energy. He explained that the parking lot project includes the installation of LED lighting and that the proposed agreement would provide 12 LED lights consistent with the existing lighting along Main Street. A copy of the MINUTES WORK SESSION MEETING September 21, 2026 5 proposed agreement was provided to Council for review. Director Edwards requested that the agreement be placed on the next agenda for consideration and approval. Councilmember Michaels made a motion to place the item on the October agenda. Councilmember Williams seconded the motion. Councilmember Williams asked why the Town was not installing and maintaining the lights directly. Director Edwards explained that the Town has followed a similar practice on other projects in the area by contracting with Dominion Energy to provide lighting consistent with the existing lights along Main Street. He stated that this approach allows the lights to operate consistently with the surrounding area and permits the energy provider to maintain the lighting infrastructure. Councilmember Williams asked Staff to evaluate the cost of the Town installing and maintaining the lights in -house. Director Edwards stated that Staff could provide an approximate cost and use the Old Mill project as a potential comparison. Councilmember Smith asked whether Staff had evaluated solar lighting as an alternative to the proposed Dominion Energy lighting. Director Edwards explained that, because the parking lot is a public facility, Staff considered the reliability of the lighting system and determined that standard lighting powered through the existing energy system appeared to provide the most reliable option and would reduce the risk of the lights being unavailable at night. Councilmember Smith stated that a private vendor provi des solar-powered lighting and requested that Staff evaluate that option and its associated costs. Director Edwards agreed to speak with the solar lighting vendor. Councilmember Lyle asked whether Dominion Energy could supplement solar - powered lighting if the Town installed solar light poles in the parking lot. Assistant Administrator Richardson stated that he would confirm the matter with Dominion Energy, noting that his understanding was that Dominion would not supplement the solar-powered system. He agreed to obtain additional information. Director Edwards clarified that, if the Town does not agree with Dominion Energy, the Town would be responsible for maintaining the parking lot lighting. He noted that the staff time required for ongoing maintenance would also be a cost consideration, in addition to the direct costs associated with installation an d maintenance. There being no further discussion, the motion carried unanimously. 7 in favor/ 0 opposed 4. Review of Street Light Ordinance: Assistant Administrator Kevin Richardson presented an overview of the Town’s existing street lighting program and three potential options for moving forward (copy of presentation attached). He noted that the current ordinance dates to 1986, with a minor amendment made in 2009, and explained that the ordinance is outdated. He stated that Staff is proposing to MINUTES WORK SESSION MEETING September 21, 2026 6 separate the development standards for street lighting from the Town’s financial obligations. Any changes to development standards would be addressed through the Planning Commission, while the financial component would be addressed through a separate ordinance. Assistant Administrator Richardson reviewed Option 1 , which would update the existing program and clarify the Town’s financial obligations, lighting design standards, and associated costs. Mayor Livingston asked whether the $71,497 figure represented the cost of adding all neighborhoods that were not currently included in the Town’s street lighting program. Assistant Administrator Richardson confirmed that it did. Councilmember Lyle asked about the Town’s current expenditure. Assistant Administrator Richardson explained that the current subdivisions included approximately $162,143, while the total program cost was approximately $429,641. He noted that adding additional neighborhoods could result in approximately $500,000, with costs continuing to increase over time. Assistant Administrator Richardson presented Option 2, a residential subsidy approach. Under this option, Council would establish either a base rate or percentage of the lighting cost that the Town would pay. The Town’s contribution would remain at the established rate or percentage even if Dominion Energy increased its rates. The option would also include an application and approval process with submission deadlines. Assistant Administrator Richardson noted that the slides illustrate the potential cost based on the Town paying 100% of the lighting rate; however, Council would determine the applicable rate or percentage if it chose to pursue this option, and the anticipated cost would vary accordingly. Councilmember Lyle questioned why the cost increased from approximately $500,000 to $683,000. Assistant Administrator Richardson explained that the higher figure reflected the potential addition of neighborhoods that were not currently receiving Town- funded lighting and assumed the Town would pay the applicable percentage for all eligible lighting in the Town. He noted that the 100% figure shown in the presentation was for illustrative purposes and that Council could establish a different percentage, such as 15% or 20%, if it chose to pursue this option. Councilmember Lyle noted that the option would essentially result in taxpayers paying for street lighting throughout the community. Assistant Administrator Richardson confirmed that this was the effect of the option. Mayor Livingston asked for further clarification of how the cost increased from approximately $500,000 to $683,000 between options 1 and 2. MINUTES WORK SESSION MEETING September 21, 2026 7 Finance Director Kathy Pharr explained that Option 1 was based on standard lighting and would not include decorative lighting, while Option 2 would treat subdivisions all equally by allowing the Town to pay a rate or percentage toward any type of lighting costs. Councilmember Smith asked why fixed costs were included in the discussion if the Town’s existing lighting obligations would not change. Director Pharr explained that Staff included the information to present the full financial picture and be transparent about the costs. Councilmember Smith stated that, based on his preliminary calculations, approximately $260,000 appeared to be variable costs. He questioned how the $71,000 figure was calculated if there were more than 30 subdivisions that did not currently have Town- funded street lighting. He noted that his subdivision pays approximately $42,000 annually for street lighting as an example of the costs involved. Assistant Administrator Richardson explained that the ordinance would need to be updated because its current language references lighting that is no longer being used. He confirmed that, if the ordinance language were updated, the Town could consider adding neighborhoods under the existing basic lighting standard. Assistant Administrator Richardson further explained that the $71,000 figure was based on the basic lighting standard of one light per six lots and did not include additional or decorative lighting. He explained that the figure represents the Town’s pro rata share under the basic lighting standard, which is why the potential additional cost is lower than the full cost of providing lighting. Mayor Livingston asked why the Town could not simply pay the base lighting rate. Assistant Administrator Richardson stated that such an approach was similar to one of the options presented and could be considered if that was Council’s direction. Assistant Administrator Richardson presented Option 3 , which would phase out the Town’s involvement over a two- to five -year period. Under that approach, lighting contracts would remain with the applicable homeowner’s association, private owner, and energy provider. He also reviewed a side -by-side comparison of the three options. Councilmember Michaels asked whether any of the options would be phased in. Assistant Administrator Richardson stated that any option would be phased in, preferably around a fiscal year, and that current requests would be evaluated as part of the process. Mayor Livingston stated that the discussion on this matter overall would require additional consideration and was not something that needed to be resolved in one MINUTES WORK SESSION MEETING September 21, 2026 8 meeting. She requested that Staff provide additional numbers for Option 1 based on the baseline lighting cost. She also expressed concern about neighborhoods that did not have homeowners’ associations, such as Coventry, and questioned how those neighborhoods would be addressed. She asked Attorney Epperson whether the Town could continue the existing program for current neighborhoods while establishing a grandfather provision for future neighborhoods. Mr. Epperson stated that a grandfather provision could be included in the ordinance. When asked about developments already in the pipeline, Mr. Epperson advised that vested-rights considerations would need to be evaluated. Assistant Administrator Richardson noted that the City of Columbia had implemented a similar approach. Councilmember Lyle asked Director Edwards, based on his experience with street lighting in his road projects, for his thoughts. Director Edwards stated that his recommendation was multifaceted and noted that Dominion Energy had been helpful to the Town as its energy provider. He said the existing ordinance was written in 1986 and that the Town and development environment had change d significantly since then. He estimated the financial difference associated with the potential expansion of the program at approximately $500,000 annually, including neighborhoods without homeowners’ associations. Director Edwards stated that his view was that the Town should consider getting out of the street lighting business. He also recommended that, if Council wished to continue participating, the standard of one light per six lots should be reconsidered because lot sizes have changed since 1986 and are generally smaller. As a second possibility, he suggested a subsidy based on a small percentage of the lighting rate. He noted that the existing ordinance effectively favors the lowest - level standard lighting, while decorative lighting that enhances neighborhoods is not subsidized by the Town. He reiterated it was ultimately the will of Council. Councilmember Lyle asked whether there was any reason a neighborhood could not collect dues to pay for its own street lighting. Mr. Epperson stated that there was nothing legally preventing residents from voluntarily organizing to pay for lighting. Councilmember Smith questioned how neighborhoods without homeowners’ associations would be treated if responsibility for lighting shifted. He used Mallard Lakes as an example and asked what would happen if residents decided they did not want to pay for the lighting. Assistant Administrator Richardson explained that neighborhoods currently included in the Town’s fixed costs would not immediately change, which included Mallard Lakes. He stated that situations involving future neighborhoods without MINUTES WORK SESSION MEETING September 21, 2026 9 homeowners associations would need to be addressed individually and that Staff could not provide a more specific answer without direction from Council. Councilmember Smith requested a spreadsheet identifying the lighting costs associated with each neighborhood and distinguishing between fixed and variable costs. He also questioned whether the proposed structure could create an incentive for subdivisions not to have homeowner’s associations in order to receive Town- funded lighting. Director Lybrand explained that an HOA is not currently required, although most subdivisions coming through the development process have an HOA. She noted that Council could consider amendments if it wished to establish such a requirement. Councilmember Smith referenced a list of neighborhoods previously provided to Council showing which neighborhoods are reimbursed for lighting. Director Lybrand explained that the list was GIS -generated and had not been created specifically to verify street lighting. She stated that Transportation Staff had since begun fieldwork to develop a more accurate inventory of existing streetlights. Councilmember Smith stated that he had gone through several subdivisions where the Town currently paid for lighting that did not appear to meet the standards contained in the existing ordinance. He noted that the Town had not removed those subdivisions from the program but had also not approved new neighborhoods under those same standards. He felt some people are being disadvantaged by that. Assistant Administrator Richardson explained that, in some instances, lighting had been updated directly by the energy provider and had not come through the Town if the neighborhood was existing. Director Lybrand noted that the Town did not maintain a street lighting plan or conduct an annual inspection process and that the Town currently receives the lighting bill at the base rate. Councilmember Smith cited Barr Lake and Sterling Bridge as examples of subdivisions that had not been reviewed for Town- funded lighting because they do not have lighting that meets the current 1980s-era standard, but neither do some other neighborhoods that do get funding. He questioned whether the ordinance was being applied consistently. Director Lybrand reiterated that Staff had begun field verification of existing streetlights. She explained that Pilgrim Point had historically received the base lighting rate, with the Town owning and paying its pro rata share while the neighborhood paid the difference for the additional decorative lighting. She noted MINUTES WORK SESSION MEETING September 21, 2026 10 that the current ordinance provides that Council may determine whether the Town will participate in lighting on a private road but does not specifically address lighting on public roads. Assistant Administrator Richardson confirmed that the only recent additions to the Town’s street lighting bill had generally involved existing neighborhoods when additional phases were added. He identified Golden Hills as the most recent example, when Phase II was developed. Councilmember Smith stated that his concern was that some neighborhoods were being denied participation because the existing ordinance specified an outdated lighting standard, while other neighborhoods were receiving Town -funded lighting that did not meet that same standard. He said this meant residents were not receiving the same benefit. Assistant Administrator Richardson said clarifying the ordinance was one reason Staff brought the matter forward for Council’s direction. Mayor Livingston asked about updating the current policy to reference current lighting standards while having a separate discussion regarding how much of the cost the Town should cover. Director Lybrand stated that Staff believed the financial obligation should be addressed separately from the development and design standards. She explained that changes to development standards would require Planning Commission recommendation. Mayor Livingston noted that this was where a grandfather provision could potentially address developments that had already been approved or were already in the development process while Council considered changes to the policy. Director Lybrand confirmed with Mr. Epperson that subdivisions in the development pipeline would present a vested right. She also noted that those subdivisions had been included in the numbers presented to Counci l in review of options. Mayor Pro -Tem Carnes stated that he was not interested in creating numerous distinctions based on the type of light or other individual circumstances. He said there was no single solution that would satisfy everyone and that the Town should seek a fair approach for all citizens rather than create different categories. He stated that the Town would either need to pay for street lighting broadly, which could cost approximately $700,000 annually and increase over time, or consider getting completely out of the street lighting business. He emphasized that, if the Town exited the program, the approach would need to be applied fairly and not create exceptions for particular neighborhoods, including neighborhoods without homeowners associations. MINUTES WORK SESSION MEETING September 21, 2026 11 Mr. Epperson advised Council that there was also an issue worth examining concerning the use of public tax dollars to improve private property, including private roads. He noted that public safety was a factor but recommended that the issue be carefully considered as the ordinance was revised. Councilmember Smith asked whether the term “neighborhood” was defined. Director Lybrand stated that it was not. She explained that “subdivision” was defined in the land development ordinance, but that definition related to the actual division of land and did not necessarily correspond with the traditional use of the term subdivision or neighborhood. Councilmember Smith asked how the use of public funds for street lighting had previously addressed the legal concerns referenced by Mr. Epperson, citing Pilgrim Point as an example. Mr. Epperson clarified that he was raising the issue as a legal consideration for the ordinance update and was not stating that the existing program was unlawful or had previously presented a legal problem. He explained that the issue could depend on the location of the streetlight and other circumstances as something to keep in mind. Councilmember Lyle stated that the questions raised demonstrated the complexity of the issue and supported the need to consider an approach that was either broadly inclusive or that ended the Town’s involvement. He stated that his position was to get the Town out of the street lighting business and have taxpayers avoid assuming responsibility for private lighting costs. He said the various scenarios further demonstrated the importance of ensuring that any ordinance changes were applied consistently. Mayor Livingston stated to Council that they had raised numerous questions and asked them to submit additional questions to Staff before the matter returned for further discussion. She proposed bringing the item back to the October work session. Assistant Administrator Richardson confirmed that Staff would further develop Option 1 and provide answers to Council’s questions for the October work session. Councilmember Smith said he supported continued research but asked whether the development standards portion could subsequently be updated by Director Lybrand. Councilmember Smith also noted that the Town’s lighting standards were tied to public safety. Mayor Pro-Tem Carnes responded that public safety considerations still had to be balanced with the Town’s budget and financial responsibilities. MINUTES WORK SESSION MEETING September 21, 2026 12 Mayor Livingston stated that understanding the development side assists Council in evaluating the financial component and said she was not opposed to Staff beginning that research. Councilmember Allen agreed with Mayor Pro- Tem Carnes that the Town should take its time to establish the financial policy before moving into the development standards portion of the issue. Mayor Livingston asked Councilmembers for their thoughts on the direction to provide Staff. Councilmember Smith expressed concern that pending requests from neighborhoods were being delayed while the Town worked through the policy questions. Councilmember Williams stated that he understood both sides of the issue and agreed that it was complex. He supported addressing the financial component first and taking additional time to determine development updates. Mayor Pro Tem Carnes stated that he believed it was premature to change development standards before Council had established the financial policy. Council, by majority direction, deferred consideration of changes to the Planning Commission-related development standards to determine the financial component of the street lighting policy first. Mayor Pro-Tem Carnes noted that Dominion Energy had received a 7.6 percent rate increase and stated that Council would need to consider the potential for continued rate increases if the Town assumed additional lighting costs. Councilmember Smith noted that the issue ultimately involved shifting the cost between the Town and individual citizens. Mayor Livingston acknowledged that the discussion had become controversial and noted that Councilmembers had differing opinions but should listen to and respectfully consider one another’s perspectives. She reiterated the direction for Staff to continue it s research and for Councilmembers to submit additional questions to Assistant Administrator Richardson for review at the October work session. No action taken. COMMENTS: NEWS MEDIA QUESTIONS: None PUBLIC COMMENTS: None STAFF ANNOUNCEMENTS: None

Source: Town of Lexington website. First collected Oct 22, 2026.