RecordWell Data

PC_Minutes_2025-04-22

City of Mauldin · Greenville County · meeting of Jun 13, 2025 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Mauldin

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Page 1 of 4 MAULDIN PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES April 22, 2025 6:00 P.M. MEMBERS PRESENT: Jonathan Paulsen, Randy Eskridge, Kevin Greene, Chauncelynn Locklear, Lyon Bixler, Raj Reddy MEMBERS ABSENT: Dan Chism CITY STAFF PRESENT: David Dyrhaug, Gregory Saxton CALL TO ORDER/OPENING REMARKS Mr. Paulsen called the meeting to order at 6:00 P.M. Mr. Dyrhaug held roll call. READING OF MINUTES Mr. Eskridge moved to accept the minutes for the March 25, 2025, Planning Commission meeting. Mr. Reddy seconded the motion. The motion to accept the minutes for the March 25, 2025, Planning Commission meeting passed by unanimous vote, 6-0. OLD BUSINESS No old business was discussed. NEW BUSINESS Docket #: PC-2025-03-RZ Request: Rezoning from O-D to C-2 for ±1.5 acres at New Neely Ferry Road and Meadowood Drive Mr. Dyrhaug introduced a request to rezone a 1.45-acre tract of land at New Neely Ferry Road and Meadowood Drive from the O-D district to the C-2 district. The intent of the applicant is to develop this property for an indoor swim school that provides one-on-one swim instruction. Ms. Mary Veideman introduced herself as the applicant and talked about her business. To kick off the public hearing for this rezoning request, Mr. Dyrhaug read into the record a petition received by the City that has been signed by 65 residents of the Meadowood community. This petition states, “We, the undersigned residents and property owners of Meadowood subdivision respectfully oppose the proposed rezoning of 310 New Neely Ferry from O-D to C- 2. We also oppose any changes to the allowed uses by district to accommodate or as part of or as a modification to the proposed rezoning request.” This petition goes on to express concerns Page 2 of 4 relating to (1) preservation of neighborhood character and aesthetic, (2) traffic congestion and safety, (3) property value depreciations, (4) environmental concerns, and (5) need. Mr. Paulsen opened the floor to public comments. The following citizens provided public comment during the hearing: Opposition • Mr. John Rainey, a resident at 103 Woodgreen Drive, spoke in opposition to the proposal. He commented on deaths caused by retention ponds, the proposed location of the retention pond, threats to the water line, and problems with mosquitoes and rodents. • Mr. Michael Yanover, a resident at 105 Meadowood Drive, spoke in opposition to the proposal. He stated that his opposition is to the rezoning, not necessarily the business. He commented on the proposed location of the driveway. • Ms. Dondra Childs, a resident at 110 Lawnfield Street, spoke in opposition to the proposal. She commented on traffic levels, traffic safety, and the danger for bicyclists and pedestrians. • Mr. James Kennedy, a resident at 123 Meadowood Drive, spoke in opposition to the proposal. He commented on how the proposal would alter the aesthetic of the neighborhood and the consequences of more people coming to the neighborhood including trash. • Ms. Jocelyn Nix, a resident at 113 Woodgreen Drive, spoke in opposition to the proposal. She commented on the deficiencies of the current driveway on New Neely Ferry Road. • Ms. Denise Clark, a resident at 108 Woodgreen Drive, spoke in opposition to the proposal. She commented on increased traffic and environmental concerns from having a new detention pond. • Mr. Carl McCluney, pastor at New Harvest Ministries at 308 New Neely Ferry Road, spoke in opposition to the proposal. He commented on traffic safety at New Neely Ferry Road. Favor • Dr. Shannon Williamson, business owner at 310 New Neely Ferry Road, spoke in favor of the proposal. She commented on the need for water safety education and the gap this service would fill. No additional public comments were offered. Hearing no more comments, Mr. Paulsen closed the floor to public comments. Mr. Daniel Merritt, part of the applicant’s engineering team at Seamon Whiteside, commented about the factors driving the proposed location of the stormwater management pond and the driveway. Ms. Veideman commented about the business’s hours of operation. She also read a customer testimonial to provide insight into the type of experience and the benefit to the community her business provides. Mr. Greene asked the applicant if she had researched the zoning of the property prior to purchasing the property and if she had purchased the property knowing that the property would need to be rezoned. Page 3 of 4 Ms. Veideman replied that she did and that she proceeded with the purchase of the property recognizing the opportunity to bring a great service to the community while understanding the risk involved. Mr. Greene asked about the building that would be constructed. Ms. Veideman described the building proposed. Mr. Greene asked about the possibility of installing underground stormwater detention. Mr. Merritt commented that while they have explored underground stormwater detention, this is not the type of site where that would typically be installed. Mr. Eskridge asked the applicant if she has any conceptual drawings of the proposed building. Mr. Dyrhaug provided the staff report and recommendation. Staff finds that this business will likely be less impactful than other common uses currently allowed in the O-D district. Therefore, staff supports the use that is being proposed. For the angst about what other business could be allowed on this property if it were rezoned to the C-2 district, staff recommends an alternative solution. Rather than rezone the property, the O-D district could be amended to allow this type of business either by right or as a conditional use subject to additional standards. Mr. Eskridge commented that he would like to see more about the building that would be constructed. He commented on his concerns about changing the zoning to the C-2 district. Recognizing that this property is bound to be developed at some point time regardless of whether it is rezoned, he also remarked that it may seem more appropriate to amend the O-D district to allow this type of business. Mr. Reddy expressed concern about the long-term possibilities of what type of businesses could go on this property if the swim school were to go away. Mr. Reddy asked about the process for amending the O-D district to allow this type of business. Mr. Dyrhaug responded that this would follow the process for a text amendment. Mr. Greene commented on the lack of a conceptual rendering of the building, concerns about the location of access, and concerns about the stormwater detention pond that should be worked through before considering appropriate conditional standards for this type of use. Ms. Locklear expressed concerns about the lack of a conceptual rendering of the building and concerns about how the proposed building would fit with the neighboring community. Mr. Dyrhaug commented about the building design standards that the City requires. Mr. Greene made a motion to recommend denial of the rezoning. Mr. Greene indicated as a basis for this motion the lack of what the building will look like and concerns about the access and the design of the stormwater detention pond. Page 4 of 4 Ms. Locklear seconded the motion. Mr. Bixler requested that the motion be amended to comment on the alternative approach to allow this type of use in the O-D district. Mr. Dyrhaug explained that an amendment to the motion can only be made by the person who made the original motion and as agreed upon by the person who seconded the motion. Mr. Greene declined to amend his motion. Mr. Reddy expressed interest in the alternative solution to amend the O-D district. He asked how that amendment would be brought up. Mr. Dyrhaug replied that the best course of action for a possible amendment to the O-D district would be to wait and see if this is directed by the City Council or the standing committee of City Council. The motion to recommend denial of the rezoning passed by a vote of 5-1 with the dissenting vote by Mr. Paulsen. OTHER BUSINESS No other business was discussed. ADJOURNMENT Mr. Eskridge moved to adjourn the meeting. Ms. Locklear seconded the motion. The motion to adjourn this meeting passed by unanimous vote, 6-0. The Planning Commission meeting adjourned at 7:17 p.m.

Source: City of Mauldin website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.