RecordWell Data

bds minutes may 2025

City of Mauldin · Greenville County · meeting of Jun 3, 2025 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Mauldin

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 Minutes Business & Development Services Commitee May 5, 2025 1st commitee mee�ng Commitee Members present: Mark Steenback (Chair) and Frank Allgood. Commitee member Ta� Matney was not present at the Call to Order, but arrived during public comment. Others present: David Dyrhaug, Business and Development Services Director, and City Administrator Seth Duncan 1. Call to Order- Chairman Steenback 2. Public Comment a. Pearlie Harris of 117 Meadowood Drive spoke first. Her family moved into the community over 50 years ago and were the first residents. She is concerned about the traffic on New Neely Ferry Road. She also spoke about stagnant water in reten�on ponds. Ms. Harris did not like the conceptual drawing that has been presented of the indoor swimming pool project and likened it to an old barn. She only wants residen�al zoning surrounding Meadowood. b. John Rainey- 103 Woodgreen Drive. Mr. Rainey’s concern is safety. Reten�on ponds are dangerous and could cause drownings to occur. Meadowood subdivision is one entrance/one exit. The traffic on New Neely Ferry Road has goten bad and the subdivision is overcrowded. This situa�on also creates a problem for emergency vehicles. c. Samuel Neely- He moved into the neighborhood in 1976. Meadowood is a great place to live and used to cater to families, being low-key and quiet. Mr. Neely said the traffic and this proposed development takes away the peace that the neighborhood had in the past. The current reten�on pond is not being maintained properly and there are snakes and other varmints in the neighborhood. He asked commitee to consider the ci�zens when making its decision. Changing the zoning to C2 would open this parcel up to many possibili�es not compa�ble with the neighborhood. d. Michael Yanover- 105 Meadowood Drive. He is concerned about the impact on the community. There could be a domino effect if C2 is allowed near their neighborhood. He would like the property held as OD. e. James Kennedy- 123 Meadowood Drive. He has examined the neighborhood complaints and said they are legi�mate. There will be more traffic problems with increased access to the community. 2 f. Dondra Childs- 110 Lawnfield Street. She raised concerns about construc�on noise in the early morning and being disturbed by trucks. Mauldin is growing and changing the zoning to C2 will make the community feel vulnerable. This proposed business could thrive in another loca�on. She asked the commitee to please consider Meadowood. g. Jocelyn Nix- 113 Woodgreen Drive. She does not like the aesthe�cs of the building. Traffic will be generated from mul�ple swim instructors teaching mul�ple children. The rezoning modifica�on to C2 will leave this property open to other projects. 3. Reading and Approval of Minutes a. Building Codes Commitee Mee�ng: April 7, 2025 Mo�on: Councilman Allgood made a mo�on to accept the minutes as distributed with Councilman Matney seconding. Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0). 4. Reports or Communica�ons from City Officers a. BDS Department Report, David Dyrhaug i. Monthly update Mr. Dyrhaug reported more businesses have renewed their licenses by the April 30th deadline than in years before. 494 residen�al permits were issued in April. Revised building plans for the Pickleyard have been received and a permit issued for the Cultural Center amphitheater stage cover. The last phase of Hidden Lake Estates has begun. 5. Unfinished Business a. None 6. New Business a. An ordinance to rezone a 1.45-acre por�on of a por�on located at New Neely Ferry Road and Meadowood Drive (p/o Tax Map Parcel #M006.02-01-027.01) and providing an effec�ve date The City of Mauldin has received a signed pe��on reques�ng the rezoning of a tract of land pursuant to Sec�on 4:2 of the Mauldin Zoning Ordinance. This pe��on includes rezoning a 1.45-acre por�on of a tract at New Neely Ferry Road and Meadowood Drive 3 from the O-D district to the C-2 district. The intent of the applicant is to develop this property for an indoor swim school that provides one-on-one swim instruc�ons. C-2 has been requested a�er consulta�on with City staff. The type of business being proposed falls into the category of “fitness/sports club, studio, or center” in the Mauldin Zoning Ordinance. This type of use is currently allowed in the C-1, C-2, CRD, and S-1 districts in the City. The applicant could just as well have requested this tract be rezoned to C-1, which is a light commercial district that is somewhat more restric�ve than C-2. There is no C-1 zoning in the immediately surrounding area. However, there is C-2 zoning on New Neely Ferry Road directly across the street from this tract. This is why the applicant was advised to request C-2 zoning as opposed to C-1 zoning. The proposed use, size, and opera�ons of this proposed indoor swim school providing one-on-one swim instruc�ons appears to be consistent with the level of intensity of other uses already allowed in the O-D district. Furthermore, staff finds that this business will likely be less impac�ul than other common uses currently allowed in the O-D district. Therefore, staff supports the use that is being proposed. For the angst about what other businesses could be allowed on this property if it were rezoned to the C-2 district, staff recommends an alterna�ve solu�on. Rather than rezone the property, the O-D district could be amended to allow this type of business either by right or as a condi�onal use subject to addi�onal standards. Such addi�onal standards could include a maximum size of the building, landscaping/screening standards along neighborhood streets, and possibly even restric�ons on driveway loca�on (provided such standards are not arbitrary or capricious). This alterna�ve approach would require the dra�ing of a text amendment to the zoning ordinance and a public hearing for that text amendment. Councilman Allgood asked about the design of the development since several residents have men�oned an “old barn” look. Mr. Dyrhaug replied the design previously brought forward would be against the City’s design standards, and would not be allowed. Councilman Allgood then asked about the one-in, one-out entrance and exit to Meadowood. Mr. Dyrhaug said a conversa�on needs to be had with DOT. As it stands now, the entrance to the new development would be Meadowood Drive. There is an exis�ng small driveway now off of New Neely Ferry that would have to be widened and paved, but could possibly be used if DOT would allow. Councilman Allgood asked about spot zoning. Mr. Dyrhaug answered the Supreme Court of South Carolina has invalidated “spot zoning” wherein a single small parcel of land is zoned totally different from the surrounding area. Most jurisdic�ons in South Carolina use two acres as a minimum threshold for rezoning a parcel to something different from that of the surrounding area. This tract is less than two acres. 4 Chairman Steenback asked about O-D District. Mr. Dyrhaug answered the O-D district is a limited non-residen�al district that is primarily limited to office and research facili�es. It is specifically intended to restrict retail sales and the warehousing or stocking of merchandise. Councilman Allgood asked if the applicant had made any changes based on comments they may have heard at the neighborhood mee�ng or planning commission mee�ng. Nick Myers of Seamon Whiteside was present. He said really the only aspect the applicant could be flexible on would be the buffering between the development and the subdivision. There could be some enhanced landscaping or fencing. The physical nature of the site cannot be changed. If this rezoning is rejected by Council, there cannot be another applica�on for the same zoning classifica�on on the same property for a year. Mo�on: Councilman Matney made a mo�on to table this item in commitee and direct staff to dra� a text amendment to allow for this type of business in OD to include design standards. Councilman Allgood seconded the mo�on. Councilman Allgood said we have a planning commission for a reason and there is a very strong community here to speak on this topic and submit a pe��on. He feels strongly that the community should be listened to. There is a reason why the property is zoned the way it is and the comprehensive plan needs to be considered. Councilman Matney amended his mo�on to add when the text amendment is dra�ed, it shall come straight back to this commitee for considera�on. Councilman Allgood seconded the amended mo�on. Vote: The vote on the mo�on as amended was unanimous (3-0). 7. Public Comment a. John Rainey- 103 Woodgreen Drive. The five swimming sessions should take 30 minutes apiece. Each person will do two sessions per hour . If the business is open for eight hours, that is 80 more cars filtered into Meadowood. Across the street is a property that is already zoned C2. The neighbors will not be able to get on New Neely Ferry Road. Adding 80 cars to an already busy road will be impossible. b. Samuel Neely- 127 Woodgreen Drive. The retaining pond in the lower part of the subdivision floods currently. There are snakes around the pond. Stormwater also flows from the next subdivision up New Neely Ferry Road down into Meadowood. No grass is seen in the yards on Woodgreen when it rains. This new development will add more stormwater to a problem that is already there. Meadowood is being invaded with 5 something the neighbors do not want. This proposed business has moved several �mes. What could come in if they leave? Please consider the neighbors. 8. Commitee Concerns Councilman Matney said he has heard tonight about stormwater in the Meadowood subdivision. He would like this to be added to the stormwater project list or at least looked at to see how it might fit in the current plan. 9. Adjourn- Chairman Steenback adjourned the mee�ng at 7:04 p.m. Respec�ully Submited, Cindy Miller Municipal Clerk

Source: City of Mauldin website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.