RecordWell Data

BDS Committee agenda_2025-04-07

City of Mauldin · Greenville County · meeting of Apr 3, 2025 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Mauldin

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

BUSINESS & DEVELOPMENT SERVICES COMMITTEE MEETING MONDAY, APRIL 7, 2025 | 6:00 PM 1st committee meeting The Committee will meet in the Council Chambers at Mauldin City Hall at 5 East Butler Road Business & Development Services Committee Meeting • • • 1 Business & Development Services Committee AGENDA April 7, 2025 Committee Members: Mark Steenback (Chair), Taft Matney, and Frank Allgood 1. Call to Order Chairperson Mark Steenback 2. Public Comment Chairperson Mark Steenback 3. Reading and Approval of Minutes a. Building Codes Committee Meeting: March 3, 2025 (Pages 2-4) Chairperson Mark Steenback 4. Reports or Communications from City Officers a. BDS Department Report, David Dyrhaug i. Monthly update ii. Comprehensive plan update Chairperson Mark Steenback 5. Unfinished Business a. None Chairperson Mark Steenback 6. New Business a. An ordinance to amend Section 10:16, Religious Institution, of the Mauldin Zoning Ordinance, to allow childcare, pre-school and after-school activities as an accessory use to religious institutions with conditional standards [Pages 5-13] b. An ordinance to amend Section 10:35, Packaged Alcoholic Beverage Store, of the Mauldin Zoning Ordinance to clarify the application of the separation requirement between packaged alcoholic beverage stores and residences [Pages 14-17] c. Discussion: Regulation of micro-livestock [Pages 18-26] d. Discussion: Accessory dwelling units [Pages 27-35] Chairperson Mark Steenback 7. Public Comment Chairperson Mark Steenback 8. Committee Concerns Chairperson Mark Steenback 9. Adjourn Chairperson Mark Steenback Business & Development Services Committee Meeting • • • 2 Minutes Business & Development Services Committee March 3, 2025 3rd Committee Meeting Committee Members present: Mark Steenback (Chair), Taft Matney, and Frank Allgood. Others present: Business and Development Services Director David Dyrhaug and City Administrator Seth Duncan 1. Call to Order- Chairman Mark Steenback 2. Public Comment- None 3. Reading and Approval of Minutes a. Building Codes Committee Meeting: February 3, 2025 Motion: Councilman Matney made a motion to approve the minutes with Councilman Allgood seconding. Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0). 4. Reports or Communications from City Officers a. BDS Department Report, David Dyrhaug i. Update on condemned properties. Building Official Steven Woods has spoken to the property owner at 123 Carlton Drive and they are working on an action plan to get the property cleaned up. ii. Update on comprehensive plan process. Benchmark Planning will hold a public session for input in April and will continuously meet with the Planning Commission on the comprehensive plan. Background research and data gathering have started. iii. Monthly update. The last home is complete in Indigo Pointe. Pinnacle Financial and an expansion of MP Husky will begin soon. The number of building inspections have increased this month and business license renewals are currently coming in. 5. Unfinished Business a. None Business & Development Services Committee Meeting • • • 3 6. New Business a. Discussion of overlay districts Overlay districts have been an on-and-off discussion among City of Mauldin officials for a number of years. The purpose of this discussion is to gauge the interest of and seek direction from the current BDS committee members regarding the consideration of overlay districts. An overlay district, sometimes known as an overlay zone, provides an additional layer of development standards to address special land use needs and is imposed over existing zoning districts. Usually overlay districts consist of regulations that address unusual topics, or are used to protect a particular natural resource or cultural resource, such as historic districts and landmarks, airports, floodplains, and environmentally sensitive areas (such as habitat, steep slopes, or wetlands). Overlay districts may have other applications as well such as promoting transit-oriented development and/or pedestrian- focused design. Because an overlay district supplements the regulations in the underlying zoning district, or base zone, an overlay district is a “double zoning” approach. A landowner must follow the regulations of both the base zone and the overlay district. Councilman Matney said we need a thorough examination of the zoning we have in the City. We are now into the comprehensive plan process which talks about future land use. As we map out City Center and projects at Bridgeway, it is not a bad idea to look at this. Councilman Allgood said we have undeveloped land that may need an overlay district. City Center is more along the lines of form-based zoning. He thinks we have an opportunity to look at the overlay district. Councilman Matney asked Mr. Dyrhaug if has talked to the City of Greenville about how their programs have been received by property owners and how well their zoning changes are going. Mr. Dyrhaug said he has not, but thinks that would be a good idea. Chairman Steenback said he would like to see this as part of the zoning overhaul that has been discussed with the Strategic Plan if there is time. Councilman Matney said Council can amend the Strategic Plan as needed. Mr. Duncan said as the comprehensive plan is being developed, this tool can be looked at for future land development and redevelopment. A zoning overhaul should be done after the comprehensive plan is completed. Business & Development Services Committee Meeting • • • 4 Councilman Matney said it might be beneficial to have a Council workshop so that everyone can look at the documents and give feedback. Chairman Steenback agreed. No action was needed on this item. 7. Public Comment a. Michael Yanover, 105 Meadowood Drive. He asked that current residents’ comments regarding zoning changes that may affect their neighborhood carry a significant amount of weight. There is a current zoning issue that will affect the neighborhood he lives in. 8. Committee Concerns- None 9. Adjourn- Chairman Steenback adjourned the meeting at 6:53 p.m. Respectfully Submitted, Cindy Miller Municipal Clerk Business & Development Services Committee Meeting • • • 5 BUSINESS & DEVELOPMENT SERVICES COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: April 7, 2025 AGENDA ITEM: 6a TO: Business & Development Services Committee FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug SUBJECT: Childcare at Religious Institutions BACKGROUND Recently the Greenville Journal published an article about the shortage of child care within Greenville County. The article describes how insufficient childcare is a major workforce barrier impacting businesses and the economy in South Carolina. Recently, City staff was approached by an operator wishing to open a childcare program at a church located in the City of Mauldin. Upon examining the ordinance, it was discovered that childcare operations and pre- schools are not allowed as accessory uses at churches even though this has already been established practice in the City of Mauldin. Mauldin First Baptist Church, Mauldin Methodist Church, and Grace Covenant Presbyterian Church are examples of churches in Mauldin that currently operate pre-school programs. CURRENT REGULATION Currently, pre-schools are included in the category of child day care centers. According to the current ordinance, childcare centers are primarily allowed in the City’s non-residential districts including O-D, C- 1, C-2, CRD, and S-1. The only residential district in which a childcare center is allowed is the R-M district; the ordinance caps the enrollment of child care centers at 16 children in this district. Using the examples provided above, Mauldin First Baptist Church and Grace Covenant Presbyterian Church would not be allowed to operate a pre-school program by these current standards if they were not already in operation. DRAFT ORDINANCE The draft ordinance establishes child care, pre -school, and after -school activities as permissible as an accessory use to religious institutions, where religious institutions are conditionally allowed in residential districts. Additionally, the draft ordinance establishes conditional standards for the operation of childcare, pre-school, and after-school activities at religious institutions. These standards include: 1. The property shall have a minimum area of two (2) acres; 2. Safe and adequate provisions shall be provided onsite to accommodate all drop -off and pick -up activities ensuring a safe route from motor vehicles to the building entrance; 3. Parking facilities must be provided in accordance with the minimum standards required in Section 6:1, Off-Street Parking Requirements; and Business & Development Services Committee Meeting • • • 6 4. Childcare operations must comply with all applicable State laws, including Chapter 114, Article 5, of the South Carolina Code of Regulations. State law includes procedures for licensing, requirements for the administration and management of childcare operations, ratios for staffing, sanitation and safety requirements, program requirements, and space requirements, among several other standards. Spacing requirements include a minimum standard of 35 square feet of indoor play space per child and 75 square feet of outdoor play space per child. PUBLIC HEARING The Planning Commission held a public hearing on March 25, 2025. No public comments were offered at this hearing. TIMELINE On March 25, 2025, the Planning Commission held a public hearing and voted 6-0 to recommend approval of the ordinance. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends the adoption of this ordinance. PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION On March 25, 2025, the Planning Commission voted 6-0 to recommend approval of the ordinance. ATTACHMENTS Draft Ordinance Greenville Journal Article Business & Development Services Committee Meeting • • • 7 ORDINANCE # __________ AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND SECTION 10:16, RELIGIOUS INSTITUTION, OF THE MAULDIN ZONING ORDINANCE, TO ALLOW CHILD CARE, PRE -SCHOOL AND AFTER -SCHOOL ACTIVITIES A S AN ACCESSORY USE TO RELIGIOUS INSTITUTIONS WITH CONDITIONAL STANDARDS WHEREAS, the Mauldin City Council at various times reviews the city ordinances to make necessary improvements and/or changes; and WHEREAS, in a Greenville Journal article dated February 28, 2025, Greenville First Steps has reported that childcare slots in Greenville County are in short supply; and WHEREAS, the Greenville Area Development Corporation has identified insufficient childcare as a major workforce barrier that impacts businesses and the economy in Greenville County; and, WHEREAS, the City of Mauldin finds that childcare, pre -school, and after -school activities are an ordinary and customary accessory use at religious institutions in many communities; WHEREAS, the City of Mauldin desires to amend its zoning ordinance to allow childcare, pre-school, and after-school activities as an accessory use at religious institutions; and, WHEREAS, the City of Mauldin finds it appropriate to enact standards for the operation of childcare, pre-school, and after-school activities at religious institutions; and, WHEREAS, the City of Mauldin finds that the following amendment to the zoning ordinance promotes the health, safety, and welfare of the citizens and residents of the City of Mauldin; and WHEREAS, pursuant to properly published public notice, the Mauldin Planning Commission considered this matter at a public hearing on March 25, 2025. NOW THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED by the Mayor and City Council of the City of Mauldin, South Carolina, in council assembled and by the authority thereof that the Mauldin Municipal Code be amended as follows: Section 1 Amendment. Amend Section 10:16, Religious Institutions, as follows (language that is struck through is language proposed to be deleted, underlined language is language proposed to be added, language is not struck through or underlined is not to be changed, and *** represents sections of the Zoning Ordinance that have been skipped and remain unchanged): Sec. 10:16. Religious Institution. Business & Development Services Committee Meeting • • • 8 For the purposes of these development standards, Religious Institutions shall be placed in the following categories based upon the number of seats in the sanctuary: 1. Small place of worship—Not more than three hundred (300) seats in the sanctuary. 2. Medium place of worship—Three hundred one (301) to eight hundred (800) seats in the sanctuary. 3. Large place of worship—More than eight hundred (800) seats in the sanctuary. 4. Minimum lot size: The minimum lot size for places of worship shall be as follows: a) Small places of worship—Minimum lot size for the zoning district in which the place of worship is located. b) Medium place of worship—Two (2) acres. c) Large place of worship—Three (3) acres. 5. Places of worship shall comply with the following setbacks: a) Small and medium place of worship: • Front: Same as residential uses in the zoning district. • Side: Twenty-five (25) feet. • Rear: Twenty-five (25) feet. • No parking or other outdoor activities shall be located in any of the required setbacks. b) Large place of worship: • Front: Fifty (50) feet, except that buildings, or portions of buildings, with a width not exceeding fifty (50) feet, may be set back a distance equivalent to the front setback for residential uses in the zoning district in which the place of worship is located. • Side: Twenty-five (25) feet. • Rear: Twenty-five (25) feet. • No parking or other outdoor activities shall be located in any of the required setbacks. 6. Access points. A Place of Worship whose parcel is accessed from a local residential street shall be limited to a total of two (2) driveway access points. 7. Parking. Off-street parking shall be provided at the following ratio: a) Minimum: One (1) space per eight (8) seats in the sanctuary(ies). Business & Development Services Committee Meeting • • • 9 b) Maximum: One (1) space per three (3) seats in the sanctuary(ies). 8. Landscaping. Landscaping shall be provided as required by Section 6:2, Landscape and Design Standards, except as required by the following standards: a) Parking and outdoor activity areas shall be buffered from adjacent residential uses with a minimum of a fifteen -foot-wide landscape buffer consisting of a mix of evergreen trees and shrubs necessary to establish a year -round screen from view of adjacent pr operties. The purpose of the landscape buffer is to visually separate the parking and outdoor activity area(s) from adjacent residential uses. Where grade changes or other features of the site make it difficult for a standard buffer to visually separate the parking and outdoor activity area(s) from adjacent residential uses, the buffer shall be developed and/or located as required to create an effective visual separation. b) Parking and outdoor activity areas shall be buffered from the street with a planting strip with a minimum width of ten (10) feet which incorporates one (1) large deciduous tree for each thirty (30) feet of street frontage or one (1) small deciduous tree for each twenty (20) feet of street frontage. The planting strip shall also include one (1) evergreen shrub for each five (5) lineal feet of street frontage. 9. Lighting. Lighting shall be in accordance with Section 6:3, Lighting Standards Other Design Requirements. 10. Height. The height of all buildings shall not exceed fifty (50) feet. Steeples, spires, bell towers, minarets, and similar architectural features shall not be subject to the height limitation. 11. No commercial activities (selling of items to the general public on an on -going basis) shall be permitted. 12. Outdoor speaker systems shall be prohibited. 13. Factory fabricated transportable buildings designed to serve as expansion space for existing places of worship may be utilized subject to requirements in Article 9 Section 7:3, Temporary Uses and Structures. 14. Accessory Structures. Accessory uses and structure s shall be permitted in accordance with the Conditional Use related provisions in Section 10:2, Accessory Structures, of this ordinance. 15. Accessory childcare, pre-school, and after-school activities. Childcare, pre-school, and after -school activities and operations are permitted as an accessory use to religious institutions in accordance with the following standards: Business & Development Services Committee Meeting • • • 10 a) The property shall have a minimum area of two (2) acres; b) Safe and adequate provisions shall be provided onsite to accommodate all drop- off and pick -up activities ensuring a safe route from motor vehicles to the building entrance; c) Parking facilities must be provided in accordance with the minimum standards required in Section 6:1, Off-Street Parking Requirements; and d) Childcare operations must comply with all applicable State laws, including Chapter 114, Article 5, of the South Carolina Code of Regulations. *** Section 2. This ordinance shall become effective upon and after its final passage. Passed on First Reading: _______________________________ Passed on Second Reading: ______________________________ CITY OF MAULDIN, SOUTH CAROLINA BY: ________________________________ Terry Merritt, Mayor ATTEST: ___________________________________ Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: ___________________________________ Daniel Hughes, City Attorney GREENVILLEJOURNAL.COM • Friday, February 28, 2025 BLACK BASEBALL LEGACY EARNS LONG-OVERDUE RECOGNITION Read the fourth part of our series honoring Black History Month | Page 10 $1.00$1.00 Shortage and high price of child care options impacts Greenville County economy HIDDEN COST OF A CRISIS DRIVE CELEBRATES 20 YEARS OF HITS Minor league baseball transformed West End C hild care is essential for working parents in Greenville County. Adults with young children rely on this resource to maintain employ - ment. However, affordable, high-quality child care can be challenging to find. Without reliable child care, some par- ents may decide to quit or change jobs to stay home with their children. Approx - imately 15% of children in South Caro - lina were in families that had to change or quit their jobs due to problems with child care, according to the Annie E. Ca- sey Foundation’s “2023 Kids Count Data Book. ” The foundation focuses on the educational, economic, social and health outcomes of youth. Insufficient child care has been iden- tified as a major workforce barrier im - pacting businesses and the economy in South Carolina. The crisis has an es - timated $23 billion aggregate annual burden on businesses across the state, according to a 2023 report by Ready - Nation, an initiative of the Council for a Strong America. Businesses typically lose an average of $1,640 per working parent due to inadequate child care. “Not only does it hurt the businesses because they’re not getting the employ- ees they need, they’re losing employees so they have to spend more money re - cruiting, retaining and training, ” said Kim Russell, ReadyNation’s South Caro- lina state lead. story & photo by TIARE SOLIS CONTINUED ON PAGE 12 T he Greenville Drive is ramping up cele - brations for its 20th anniversary. The minor league baseball organi - zation, which plays at Fluor Field in the West End, held a special event to mark the mile - stone at New Realm Brewing Co. in downtown Greenville on Feb. 25. As part of the event, the Drive made a $25,000 contribution to combat homelessness in the city. “Something that we’ve been very proud of is just to see the community grow – and not only grow, but grow together, ” Drive Owner and Chairman Craig Brown said of the team’s two decades in Greenville. Joining Craig Brown at the event were team President Jeff Brown, Greenville Mayor Knox White and Jennifer Foelske, Greenville gen - eral manager of Fluor Corporation’s ATLS Americas Operations and Engineering. CONTINUED ON PAGE 11 story by MEGAN FITZGERALD The estimated annual cost of the child care crisis to businesses in South Carolina is $23 BILLION 2025 Celebrate Black History Month with Greenville Journal as we honor the trailblazers shaping the Upstate’s Black community. Join us in recognizing the voices and visionaries making a lasting impact in our community. Follow along with the series in the Greenville Journal and on GreenvilleJournal.com presented by 12 GREENVILLEJOURNAL.COM // FEBRUARY 28 FEATURED | NEED TO KNOW Child care crisis in SC, Greenville County DEPLETES WORKFORCE, COSTS COMPANIES U nderstanding the widespread economic impact of child care has led many companies and policymakers to look for solutions. EMPLOYER EFFORTS Child care slots in Greenville County are in short supply. Derek Lewis, exec- utive director of Greenville First Steps, said approximately 4,000 child care slots ar e currently needed in Greenville County. “For me, that’s thousands of families who would be able to return to work if they just had reliable and affordable child care, ” Lewis said. To eliminate the child care barrier, businesses may consider creating on-site care for their employees. For example, Prisma Health — one of the major em - ployers in Greenville County — has a child care center on the Greenville Me - morial Hospital Campus. The Gr eenville Memorial Childcare Center provides care for children ages 6 weeks to 5 years old and is run by third-party provider Bright Horizons. The center operates on extended hours from 6:30 a.m. to 8 p.m. Mondays through Fridays to accommodate the atypical schedules of health care workers. Part- and full-time team members are eligible for Prisma Health’s on-site program. Approximately 138 children from 105 Prisma Health team members are currently enrolled at the on-site center. A total of 375 team members are on the center’s waiting lists. “We know that affordable child care is a concern for many of our team members, ” said Sandy Dees, a Prisma spokeswoman. “Prisma Health strives Continued from cover infant and toddler child care slots are currently needed infant and toddler child care slots are projected to be needed by Source: Greenville First Steps CHILD CARE SHORTAGE IN GREENVILLE COUNTY 6,400 2040 4,000 FEBRUARY 28 // GREENVILLEJOURNAL.COM 13 NEED TO KNOW | FEATURED to offer benefits that help provide child care that’s right for the family and the situation, whether that’s a child care center, back-up care or another care arrangement. ” Many businesses do not have the space or finances to operate on-site child care for their employees. Another option companies can consider is negotiating with a local provider to set aside a block of child care slots for their employees. Megan Carolan, vice president of policy research for the Institute for Child Success, said companies can also help employees with some of the financial burden of child care. “(The company) can make payments directly to child care providers of a certain amount that would then discount what the family has to pay, ” Caro- lan said. “ A lot of companies offer a flexible savings account … it has some costs for the employer but then their employees can put money into it to use for child care that doesn’t get taxed, which can be a huge benefit. ” POLICY SUPPORT Policymakers in South Carolina are looking at ways to support employ - er-sponsored child care programs. A bill was introduced in the state Sen - ate in January to incentivize employers to help employees with child care. Senate Bill 47 is being assessed by the Senate Finance Committee. It has received support from local leaders and organizations including the Greenville Chamber of Commerce. Improving the accessibility and affordability of child care is one of the chamber’s top priorities for the 2025 South Carolina Legislature session. Matt Will, Greenville Chamber’s vice president of government affairs, ex - plained the state’s child care tax credit has been underutilized by busi - nesses and individuals in the past. “Senate Bill 47 kind of takes a little bit more bite at the apple if you will on the tax-credit side, ” Will said. The bill, S.47, would increase the maximum tax credit available to em - ployers who have created child care programs for their employees. Em - ployers can also receive a tax credit if they help cover employees’ child care costs at outside providers. In addition, the bill would create a new, refundable income tax credit for full-time employees at licensed child care facilities in South Carolina. Greenville City Councilmember Dorothy Dowe believes the bill is a step forward to help people who want to work in child care make ends meet. “If that can get across the finish line, that’s using a tool in the toolkit of the state purview to help incentive workers to come into the child care industry at a local level, ” Dowe said. According to the Institute for Child Success, 40% of South Carolina children under the age of 6 have parents working at these times. NON-TRADITIONAL HOURS Working parents struggle to find child care that operates during “non- traditional hours.” These hours include before 7 a.m., after 6 p.m. and on weekends. Megan Carolan, vice president of policy research for the Institute for Child Success, said that approximately 7,700 children in Greenville County likely need care during these non-traditional hours. Employees working in Greenville’s key industries typically need child care during nontraditional hours. CHILD CARE IN GREENVILLE’S KEY INDUSTRIES MANUFACTURING HOSPITALITY & TOURISM Leisure and tourism make up 9.4% of Greenville County’s employment Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics’s 2020 Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages and the Greenville Area Development Corp. Manufacturing makes up 10.8% of Greenville County’s employment Health services and education make up 12.9% of Greenville County’s employment HEALTH CARE Business & Development Services Committee Meeting • • • 14 BUSINESS & DEVELOPMENT SERVICES COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: April 7, 2025 AGENDA ITEM: 6b TO: Business & Development Services Committee FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug SUBJECT: Packaged Alcoholic Beverage Stores BACKGROUND In 2021, the City of Mauldin adopted an ordinance that established a table of allowed uses and introduced new conditional standards for certain uses. This included new conditional standards for packaged alcoholic beverage stores. This type of store is conditionally allowed in the C-2, General Commercial District. The conditional standards include that new businesses must be separated from residences by at least 300 feet and that businesses must comply with State laws. When the separation requirement fro m residences was originally drafted, it was intended that this requirement would primarily apply to stand -alone stores. However, this intent was not made clear in the conditional standards. This has recently come to light while tending to a recent inquiry about locating a wine and liquor shop in a shopping center in the City of Mauldin . In further evaluating the current ly required separat ion from residences, which is 300 feet measured from the property line of the business to the property line of a residential property, it was observed that this conditional standard would nearly preclude all opportunities of opening a new packaged alcoholic beverage store in the City of Mauldin. CURRENT REGULATION The current ordinance requires that “a packaged alcoholic beverage store shall not be closer than three (300) feet from any residential use in a residential zoning district, as measured from lot line to line.” DRAFT ORDINANCE The draft ordinance modifies this conditional standard by clarifying that this 300 feet separation between packaged alc oholic beverage stores and residences will be measured “pursuant to the me thod of measurement used for proximity to schools, churches, and playgrounds provided in Title 61, Chapter 6, of the S.C. Code of Laws and as further clarified in Chapter 7 of the S.C. Code of Regulations. Title 61, Chapter 6, of the S.C. Code of Laws currently requires that wine and liquor stores may not be located within 300 feet of any church, school, or playground within a muni cipality nor within 500 feet of any church, school, or playground in an unincorporated area outside of a municipality. This section states that “such distance shall be computed by following the shortest route of ordina ry pedestrian or ve hicular travel along the public thoroughfare from the near est point of the grounds in use as part of such church, Business & Development Services Committee Meeting • • • 15 school, or playground.” Chapter 7 of the S.C. Code of Regulations further clarifies what constitutes the “grounds in use” and that this distance is measured from the nearest entrance of the business. PUBLIC HEARING The Planning Commission held a public hearing on March 25, 2025. There were three residents who spoke at this hearing. • John Rainey, a resident at 103 Woodgreen Drive, spoke in opposition to allowing wine and liquor stores in the City and especially near any neighborhoods including Meadow Wood . He cited concerns about drunk driving. • Michael Yanover, a resident at 105 Meadowood Drive, also spoke in opposition to allowing wine and liquor stores in the City and especially near any neighborhoods. He ci ted concerns about a property at New Neely Fe rry Road and Meadowood Drive that has applied to be rezoned to C-2 and is worried that, even though that rezoning is not for the intent of developing a wine and liquor store, this ordinance could allow a wine and liqu or store to be located at the entrance of th eir neighborhood. • Denise Clark, a resident at 108 Woodgreen Drive, spoke in opposition to allowing wine and liquor stores in the City and es pecially near any neighborhoods. She also asked if this ordinance would affect the O-D district currently located on Meadowood Drive. TIMELINE On March 25, 2025, the Planning Commission held a public hearing and voted 5-0 to recommend approval of the ordinance. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends the adoption of this ordinance. PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION On March 25, 2025, the Planning Commission voted 5-0 to recommend approval of the ordinance. NOTE: The Planning Commission discussi on focused first on a different approach of amending the ordinance to exempt wine and liquor stores located in shopping centers with at least 3 other businesses from being subject to this separat ion from residences. Howe ver, it became evident that defining a shopping center was somewhat tricky and the exemption was somewhat arbitrary. Further, this exemption would not provide ideal protection for residences and neighborhoods. Therefore, the Planning Commission shifted their approach to amending the standard to use the same method of measure ment as used in State law pertaining to churches, schools, and playgrounds. This approach would still provide a level of protection for residences and neighborhoods consistent with the pro tection provided to churches, schools, and playgrounds. ATTACHMENTS Draft Ordinance Business & Development Services Committee Meeting • • • 16 ORDINANCE # __________ AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND SECTION 10:35, PACKAGED ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE STORE , OF THE MAULDIN ZONING ORDINANCE TO CLARIFY THE APPLICATION OF THE SEPARATION REQUIREMENT BETWEEN PACKAGED ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE STORES AND RESIDENCES WHEREAS, the Mauldin City Council at various times reviews the city ordinances to make necessary improvements and/or changes; and WHEREAS, the City of Mauldin desires to amend its zoning ordinance to clarify the intended application of the separation requirement between packaged alcoholic beverage stores and residences; and, WHEREAS, the City of Mauldin finds that the following amendment to the zoning ordinance promotes the health, safety, and welfare of the citizens and residents of the City of Mauldin; and WHEREAS, pursuant to properly published public notice, the Mauldin Planning Commission considered this matter at a public hearing on March 25, 2025. NOW THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED by the Mayor and City Council of the City of Mauldin, South Carolina, in council assembled and by the authority thereof that the Mauldin Municipal Code be amended as follows: Section 1 Amendment. Amend Section 10:35, Packaged Alcoholic Beverage Store , as follows (language that is struck through is language proposed to be deleted, underlined language is language proposed to be added, language is not struck through or underlined is not to be changed, and *** represents sections of the Zoning Ordinance that have been skipped and remain unchanged): Sec. 10:35. Packaged Alcoholic Beverage Store. A packaged alcoholic beverage store is subject to the following standards: 1. Separation from residences. A packaged alcoholic beverage store shall not be closer than three hundred (300) feet from any residential use in a residential zoning district, as measured from lot line to lot line pursuant to the method of measurement used for proximity to schools, churches, and playgrounds provided in Title 61, Chapter 6, of the S.C. Code of Laws and as further clarified in Chapter 7 of the S.C. Code of Regulations. 2. Compliance with state law. Any such business shall comply with all applicable State laws, including Chapter 7 of the S.C. Code of Regulations and Title 61, Chapter 6, of the S.C. Code of Laws. Business & Development Services Committee Meeting • • • 17 *** Section 2. This ordinance shall become effective upon and after its final passage. Passed on First Reading: _______________________________ Passed on Second Reading: ______________________________ CITY OF MAULDIN, SOUTH CAROLINA BY: ________________________________ Terry Merritt, Mayor ATTEST: ___________________________________ Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: ___________________________________ Daniel Hughes, City Attorney Business & Development Services Committee Meeting • • • 18 BUSINESS & DEVELOPMENT SERVICES COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: April 7, 2025 AGENDA ITEM: 6c TO: Business & Development Services Committee FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug SUBJECT: Micro-livestock OBJECTIVE For years, o ne of the most popular requests received by the Mauldin Business & Development Services Department is from residents who would like to have sma ll farm animals (i.e., m icro-livestock), mostly chickens, at their home . This is being included for discussion to gauge if Council members have any particular direction they would like to provide on this subject. NATIONAL TRENDS See the attached Zoning Practice article titled “Urban Micro-Livestock Ordinances: Regulating Backyard Animal Husbandry” for national trends that were emerging as of 2013. The author of this article suggests that most attempts within the United States to legalize micro -livestock have focused on chickens, goat s, and bees. The article also comments on other small animals including r abbits and pot-bellied pigs, but notes that some of these small animals have become more accepted as pets rather than livestock. The author reports that raising livestock is becoming an activity that many young, educated, middle-class people seek out. Many v iew a well -regulated return of micro -livestock to the cit ies and suburbs as embracing progressive values. BENEFITS AND CONCERNS The aforementioned article outlines some benefits and concerns generally associated with keeping chickens, goats, and bees. The main be nefit is to eat the food they produce: eggs, milk, and honey. Keeping bees also provides the benefit of pollination services and ensuring an extant bee population. Concerns about chickens and goats generally boil down to three things: odor, noise, and dis ease; more specifically, roosters can be too nois y and a rutty b uck may be too smelly. The major ob jection to honeybees is the fear of being stung and a fear of a swarm. CITY OF MAULDIN REGULATIONS The City of Mauldin’s Animal Control Ordinance currently prohibits keeping bees within residential areas. Cows and goats are prohibited from running at large unless properly haltered. Swine are entirely prohibited throughout the City. The Animal Control Ordinance says nothing about chickens except to say that Business & Development Services Committee Meeting • • • 19 allowing an animal to crow or cackle in an excessive , continuous, or unreasonable fashion constitutes a public nuisance. A former edition of the City’s zoning ordinance used to have a provision that allowed livestock, except pigs and sheep, to be kept in the R-20, R-15, and R-12 districts provided that the lot was at least one acre in size and any barns had to be set back at least 50 feet from any property line. Up to one head of livestock was allowed per half-acre of lot area. The nature of this provision see med to be for the purpose of allowing horses, cows, and goats, but not chickens. This provision was replaced in the current zoning ordinance with a provision that permitted horse stables in the R-20 district on properties that are at least one acre in size. OTHER UPSTATE COMMUNITIES Other local communities in the Upstate regulate the keeping of micro-livestock as follows: Community Regulations City of Greenville Chickens: Allowed in quantities that do not unreasonably disrupt or disturb the peace, cause damage to property, or cause offenses by reason of noise, odor, filth, or vermin. Coops are required to be at least 18 inches in height and shall be kept in cleanly and healthy conditions. Swine: Swine are prohibited in the City. City of Greer Livestock: Livestock (cattle, horses, mules, asses, swine, sheep, goats, roosters, turkeys, ducks, guineas, pheasants, pigeons and other domestic fowl) are not allowed to be kept as pets. Chickens: Up to six female chickens may be kept at a residence. Coops must be in the back yard and must be set back at least 50 feet from any adjacent residence. Coops must be cleaned regularly. Permit required. Town of Fountain Inn Livestock: Ponies, horses, and cows are only allowed in the R-15 and R-12 districts on properties at least 2 acres in size. Barns must be set back at least 50 feet from any property line. Pigs, goats, and sheep are prohibited. Domestic fowl are allowed provided they do not run at large. City of Spartanburg Livestock: Horses, donkeys, mules, asses, swine, sheep, goats, and cattle are prohibited. Chickens: Up to six female chickens may be kept at a residence. Coops must be in the back yard. Coops must have at least 2 square feet per hen. Permit required. Business & Development Services Committee Meeting • • • 20 Community Regulations City of Anderson Livestock: Mules, horses, cows, and goats cannot be kept within 150 feet of a residence, business, hospital, church, or school. Pigs are prohibited. Chickens: Up to four female chickens may be kept at a residence. Coops must be in the back yard must be set back at least 3 feet from the property line and at least 50 feet from any adjacent residence. Coops are required to be at least 18 inches in height and have at least 2 square feet per hen and be connected to a minimum size run. The total area for the coop and run cannot exceed 100 square feet. Coops must be entirely screened from the side and rear property lines. Permit required. Greenville County Livestock: Keeping livestock is allowed in the R-20A district. Structures for keeping and feeding farm animals may not be located within 100 feet of a property line. Chickens: Up to eight female chickens may be kept at a residence. Coops must be in the back yard and be kept in healthy and sanitary conditions. REQUEST This item has been placed on the agenda for discussion purposes only. ATTACHMENTS Zoning Practice Article ZONINGPRACTICE 4.13 AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION | page 2 Urban Micro-Livestock Ordinances: Regulating Backyard Animal Husbandry By Jaime Bouvier While small farm animals never completely disappeared from most cities, a growing number of communities are revisiting their animal control and zoning regulations in response to a renewed interest in chickens, bees, and goats among urban agriculture practitioners and backyard hobbyists. This article explores how small farm ani- mals (i.e., micro-livestock) can and already do coexist in urban environments, and it examines the regulatory tools cities use to sanction and control backyard animal hus- bandry. The following sections are intended to serve as a guide for local governments considering legalizing and regulating this budding hobby. WHAT IS MICRO-LIVESTOCK? There is no universal definition of micro- livestock. It often just means small animals—like chickens, ducks, quail, and rabbits. It can also mean breeds that are smaller than average—such as bantam chickens, Nigerian Dwarf goats, or Red Panda cows. Finally, it can mean an animal of what is normally a large breed that just happens to be small. Many international organizations have long championed rais- ing micro-livestock in cities to provide a secure and safe local food source. Because they require less food and water, are often especially hardy breeds, and their small size makes them ideal for small lots, micro- livestock are especially well suited to urban living. Right now, most attempts to legalize micro-livestock focus on chickens, goats, and bees. Although rabbits are micro-live- stock, they have caused less controversy. Perhaps because they are more accepted as pets, they were never made illegal in many cities. Very small pigs, like the pot-bellied pig, have also been accepted in many cities to be an accepted and even encouraged part of urban life. For example, during the Victory Garden campaign, when the U.S. government urged American citizens to grow more of their own food to support the war, the government encouraged people to keep and raise chickens. As it became cheaper and more con- venient to buy food from a grocery store, it became less common to see livestock in the city. While many people believe that livestock became illegal because they were a nuisance, there is little evidence that this was the case—especially when just as a pet; because they are not being raised for bacon, people don’t think of them as livestock. There has been some move to le- galize miniature horses as guide animals for the blind and disabled. Other animals, like miniature hogs, cows, or sheep, may also be suitable for city life under the right circum- stances, but fewer people are advocating for them. A SHORT HISTORY OF URBAN HENS AND OTHER MICRO-LIVESTOCK. Although micro-livestock never disap - peared from cities altogether, they used During World War II, the U.S. government framed backyard chicken keeping as a patriotic duty. U.S. Department of Agriculture ASK THE AUTHOR JOIN US ONLINE! About the Author Jaime Bouvier is a senior instructor of law and codirector of the Writing and Academic Support Program at Case Western Reserve University School of Law in Cleveland, Ohio. She has also represented state and local governments as well as landowners in zoning and land-use litigation. Go online during the month of April to participate in our “Ask the Author” forum, an interactive feature of Zoning Practice. Jaime Bouvier will be available to answer questions about this article. Go to the APA website at www.planning.org and follow the links to the Ask the Author section. From there, just submit your questions about the article using the e-mail link. The author will reply, and Zoning Practice will post the answers cumulatively on the website for the benefit of all subscribers. This feature will be available for selected issues of Zoning Practice at announced times. After each online discussion is closed, the answers will be saved in an online archive available through the APA Zoning Practice web pages. ZONINGPRACTICE 4.13 AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION | page 3 a few animals were kept. Instead, exiling livestock was partially a class-based phe- nomenon. Excluding animals that were seen as productive, that is animals kept for food purposes, was a way to exclude the poor. Animals that came to be viewed as nonpro- ductive, such as dogs and cats, required money to keep and did not have the same associations. By illegalizing behavior as- sociated with the recently rural and poor, a city could present itself as prosperous and progressive. The desire to exclude the poor is a reason why ordinances making livestock illegal are often found in suburbs and even exurbs where the lot sizes are especially conducive to raising animals. It is also a reason why changing the regulations, even in such suburbs, is often especially contentious. Now, however, raising livestock is becoming an activity that many young, educated, middle-class people seek out. The association between micro-livestock and poverty is no longer relevant. And dis- tinguishing cities and suburbs from rural occupations is no longer universally seen as a sign of progress. In fact, many view a well-regulated return of micro-livestock to the cities and suburbs as embracing progressive values. And legalizing micro- livestock can actually attract people who seek to live in a place that supports the close-knit communities that this hobby creates. MICRO-LIVESTOCK COMMUNITIES Communities are essential to the micro- livestock movement. They provide much- needed support for people to discuss common problems and share interests. Many communities began as a few people who already raised chickens, or goats, or bees—in violation of city law. They organized to legalize their animals. One of the leading examples of this is a group called Mad City Chickens in Madison, Wisconsin. Members of the group who kept chickens illegally, the self-described “Chicken Underground,” were they can, and already do, peacefully coexist in cities, they often will legalize these ani- mals. Finally, it shows that cities are better off reasonably regulating micro-livestock, rather than forcing hobbyists out of their cities or underground. CHICKENS, GOATS, AND BEES: BENEFITS The main benefits to keeping chickens, goats, and bees is not so much to eat the animal itself, though people do eat chick - ens and goats. The main benefit is to eat the food they produce: eggs, milk, and honey. There is good research to show that backyard eggs are tastier and have more nutrients than store-bought ones. Milk from backyard goats, moreover, tastes better because goat milk does not store or ship well. It is also, arguably, easier to digest for those who cannot drink cow’s milk. Goat hair is a prized material for making cash- mere and mohair fabric. Manure from these animals is an excellent, and surprisingly pricey, fertilizer. Many people also value these animals for their companionship and become as close to them as they do any other pet. Finally, backyard and hob- byist livestock keepers ensure a diverse and more robust population of animals, ensuring the propagation of breeds that are not valued commercially but may become important if commercial breeds, because of genetic uniformity, become threatened by disease. Apart from honey, keeping bees in urban areas has two main benefits: pollina- tion services and ensuring an extant bee population. Honeybees pollinate two-thirds of our food crops and in recent years have suffered devastating losses. Some experts assert that these losses are caused or exac - Many communities began as a few people who already raised chickens, or goats, or bees—in violation of city law. generally law-abiding citizens uncomfort- able with their outlaw status. They did not understand why raising chickens in a way that did not bother their neighbors should be illegal. In 2004, in response to the group’s lobbying efforts, Madison amended its zoning ordinance to allow chickens (and, subsequently, bees in 2012). Their lobby- ing efforts became the focus of a film, also titled Mad City Chickens, and have been a model for other groups seeking to legalize micro-livestock, such as the New York City Beekeepers Association and Seattle’s Goat Justice League. These groups’ stories show that many people already keep micro-livestock in cities whether or not they are legal. It also shows that once citizens and city leaders are edu- cated about these animals and shown how ZONINGPRACTICE 4.13 AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION | page 4 §451 et seq.; 21 U.S.C., §1031 et seq.; and 21 U.S.C. §601 et seq.). The FDA requires that all milk be pasteurized, including goat milk (21 C.F.R. §1240.61) and regulates nutri- tion and information labeling of honey (21 U.S.C. §§342–343). Many of these laws have exceptions for animals and animal products raised for home consumption, but someone who wants to raise eggs, milk, or meat for sale or distribution would need to comply. Most states have laws regulating the movement of livestock, including chickens, goats, and bees, into and out of the state. To track and attempt to control some diseases associated with livestock and bees, some states either require or encourage keepers of livestock and beekeepers, even backyard hobbyists, to register their premises with the state. Other states only ask to be alerted if a particular disease is found. Many states also have laws regulating the slaughter and sale of any animal used for meat, as well as laws regulating the sale of eggs, milk, and milk products. While these, also, generally have exceptions for home consumption, they will apply to sales. Often state agricultural erbated by the use of pesticides, the stress of constant travel to different farms to pol - linate crops, and the lack of plant diversity in rural environments. Thus, hobbyist bee- keepers who do not subject their hives to such stressors may prove to be a haven for the continued existence of honeybees. CHICKENS, GOATS, AND BEES: CONCERNS Concerns about chickens and goats gener- ally boil down to three things: odor, noise, and disease. None of these provide a reason to ban hens and does, but roosters can be too noisy and a rutty buck may be too smelly for dense urban environments. Contrary to popular myth, roosters do not just crow in the morning to greet the rising sun—roosters crow all day. Hens do not need roosters to lay eggs; roosters are only necessary to fertilize the eggs. Hens are generally quiet, but when they do cluck, the resulting noise is about the same decibel level as a quiet human conversation. And, as long as a chicken coop is regularly cleaned and adequately ventilated, a small flock of hens will not be smelly. Goats, too, are not generally noisy ani- mals. While a goat may bleat, the sound is generally far less than the noise of a barking dog. Some goats, just like dogs or cats, are noisier than others. And, as for odor, fe- male goats (does) and neutered male goats (wethers) do not smell. Male goats (bucks), during the mating season, do smell. The gamy odor of a rutty buck is the smell many associate with goats. While it is necessary for a doe to mate with a buck and deliver a kid to lactate and provide milk, this can be arranged with a stud-buck kept in more rural environs. Finally, there is the issue of disease. As with any animal, including dogs and cats, disease can be spread through feces. Regular cleaning and straightforward sanita- tion practices, such as hand washing, can take care of this issue. While concerns about backyard chickens spreading avian flu have surfaced in some communities, the kind of avian flu that can cross over to humans has not yet been found in North America. And neither the Centers for Disease Control nor the Department of Agriculture have asserted that the possibility of bird flu is a reason to ban backyard hen keeping. Public health scholars have concluded that backyard chickens present no greater threat to public health than other more common pets like dogs and cats. The major objection to honeybees is the fear of being stung. Here, it is impor - tant to understand the distinction between bees and wasps. Honeybees are defensive; they will not bother others unless they are threatened. A honeybee’s stinger is attached to the entrails, so it will die if it stings. Bees want pollen; they are not inter - ested in human food. Wasps, by contrast, are predatory, can sting repeatedly with little consequence, and are attracted to human food. Many people confuse fuzzy honeybees with smooth-skinned yellow jackets, a kind of wasp that forms papery hives. People do not keep wasps because they are not effective pollinators and do not produce honey. A connected objection is a fear of a swarm. A swarm is a group of bees traveling to establish a new hive. While a swarm can be intimidating, before bees swarm they gorge on honey to prepare for the trip, which makes them particularly lazy and docile. Unless attacked or bothered, they will follow a scout bee to a new location within a few hours to a day. Before drafting an ordinance, local governments should be aware that federal and state laws already regulate livestock. AGRICULTURAL BASICS FOR CITIES CONSIDERING LEGALIZING MICRO-LIVESTOCK Chickens and goats require companionship. As a consequence, cities should allow a minimum of four hens and two does. This ensures that the city is not interfering with good animal husbandry practices. And, while bees never lack for compan- ionship, it is a good idea to allow beekeep- ers to have more than one hive. This allows the beekeeper to better inspect for and maintain hive health. Cities should not be overly concerned that hives kept too close together will compete for food—honeybees fly up to a three-mile radius from the hive to find pollen. FEDERAL AND STATE LAW CONSIDERATIONS Before drafting an ordinance, local govern- ments should be aware that federal and state laws already regulate livestock. The federal government regulates the sale, processing, labeling, and transportation of chickens, eggs, and other meats (21 U.S.C. extension services will have online informa- tion pages describing the regulations and exemptions for hobbyists. For beekeeping, however, a few states have passed laws that interfere with a local government’s ability to regulate. Wyoming, for instance, controls how close together apiaries (an area with one or more beehives) may be located (Wyo. Stat. Ann. §11-7-201). In June 2011, Tennessee preempted all local government ordinances regulating honeybee hives (Tenn. Code. Ann. §44-15-124). And in July 2012, Florida also preempted all local government ordinances regulating managed honeybee colonies or determining where they can be located (Fla. Stat. §§586.055 & 586.10). C OMMON ASPECTS OF URBAN MICRO- LIVESTOCK REGULATION In the cities that have recently passed or- dinances regulating micro-livestock, the ordinances are all quite different. No stan- dard ordinance has yet been established. There are, however, many common aspects to these regulations. Most of them limit the number and type of livestock that can be kept in the city, establish setbacks for where the animals can be kept on the property, and require a certain amount of space per animal. Some also require a license. Micro-Livestock Standards Most cities have not taken a comprehensive regulatory approach to micro-livestock, but appear to allow particular livestock in response to citizen lobbying. Hundreds of cities have legalized chickens in the past few years. And the growing popularity of beekeeping means many cities have also adopted separate ordinances to allow for it. For example, South Portland, Maine (§§3-51 & 3-710; Cary, North Carolina (§5.3.4(J) & (O)); Ypsilanti, Michigan (§§14-13 & 14-171); and Littleton, Colorado (§§10-4-4 & 10-4-14) have recently passed ordinances separately allowing for both chickens and bees. Some cities make idiosyncratic choices. For example, Ponca City, Oklahoma, allows miniature horses and donkeys, but still bans all other fowl and livestock (§7-3- 10). Sebring, Florida, allows two hens and ZONINGPRACTICE 4.13 AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION | page 5 two pot-bellied pigs (§4-1). And Carson City, Nevada, allows chickens, pigs, rabbits, and bees, but no goats (§§7.02 & 7.13.190). And some only allow goats. In 2011, Loveland, Ohio, allowed two pygmy goats on residential properties of any size (§505.16). It defines pygmy as a goat no heavier than 60 pounds. The choice of such a light weight is curious, given that many micro-goat breeds weigh more than 60 pounds. Also, many breeds of dogs weigh up to three times as much, but most cities do not restrict the size of dogs. In 2010, Carl Junction, Missouri, allowed just one pygmy goat on a property of any size (§205.200(C)). Because goats are herd animals, this limit encourages poor animal husbandry practices. Meanwhile, many cities are legalizing a wider variety of livestock. For example, Denver allows up to eight ducks or chickens and up to two dwarf goats and two beehives (§8-91; §11.8.5.1). But it requires 16 square feet of permeable land available to each chicken and 130 square feet for each goat. The city also requires adequate shelter to protect the animals from the elements and from predators. This means that to keep the full complement of eight chickens and two goats, the yard would have to have approxi- mately 400 square feet of space. For chick- ens, ducks, and goats, Denver has a 15-foot setback from neighboring structures used for dwelling and requires that the animals be kept in the rear half of the lot. For bees, Denver has a five-foot setback from any property line and requires that hives be kept in the back third of the lot. Seattle allows up to eight domestic fowl, four beehives, one potbelly pig, and two pygmy goats, or no pig and three pygmy goats, on any lot (§23.42.052). It then em- ploys a step system for additional animals. For lots larger than 20,000 square feet, an additional small animal—which means a dog, cat, or goat, may be kept on the lot. Seattle also allows other farm animals, in- cluding cows, horses, or sheep, to be kept on lots that are greater than 20,000 square feet. Seattle allows one of these animals per 10,000 square feet. Also, it has a 50-foot setback from the neighboring property for all farm animals, not including potbelly pigs, fowl, or miniature goats. Finally, Seattle has a separate ordinance that restricts goats to their premises, “except for purposes of transport or when on property other than Portland, Oregon, allows up to three pygmy goats in a residential backyard without a permit (§13.05.015.E). Wikimedia Commons/beth h ZONINGPRACTICE 4.13 AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION | page 6 that of the miniature goat’s owner with the permission of a lawful occupant of that prop- erty” (§ 9.25.084(H)). Cleveland has a slightly more complex ordinance in that it has different regulations for residential and nonresidential districts (§347.02). It also employs a step system, allowing one animal per a certain number of square feet. In residential districts, it allows one hen, duck, rabbit, or similar animal per 800 square feet, and one beehive per 2,400 square feet. The ordinance spells out that a standard residential lot in Cleveland is 4,800 square feet, so most households could keep up to six hens and two beehives. Setbacks for hens are five feet from the side- yard line and 18 inches from the rear-yard line. Setbacks for bees are five feet from the lot line and 10 feet from any dwelling on another parcel. Neither animal is allowed in the front or side yard. Cleveland only allows goats, pigs, sheep, or similar farm animals on lots that have at least 24,000 square feet (i.e., a little more than a half-acre). If a lot is that size or larger, two of these animals will be allowed, with an additional one for each additional 2,400 square feet. Enclosures for these animals must be set back 40 feet from the property line and at least 100 feet from the dwelling of another. In Cleveland, the nonresidential dis- tricts are less restrictive, with one chicken, duck, or rabbit per 400 square feet, one beehive per 1,000 square feet, and one goat, pig, or sheep per 14,400 square feet. This can allow for more intensive operations in less populated areas—and also opens the area to urban farms. Hillsboro, Oregon, and El Cerrito, California, employ similar step systems. El Cerrito allows three hens as long as the property is at least 4,000 square feet (§7.08.020). Hillsboro allows three hens as long as the property is 7 ,000 square feet (§6.20.070). Both cities require at least 10,000 square feet to keep goats, but Hillsboro limits goats to two, and El Cerrito does not appear to limit them. El Cerrito, however, does require an administrative use permit to keep goats and allows for a conditional use permit to keep goats on a smaller parcel of land. El Cerrito requires a property of at least 5,000 square feet to keep one beehive. That beehive must be 20 feet from an adjacent dwelling and 10 feet from the property line. Hillsboro allows up to three beehives on any size residential property with a setback of 10 feet from the property line. the license on those grounds (§205.04). The department also notifies neighbors about the license application and waits at least 21 days to hear back from them. The director can consider any evidence that the neighbors submit concerning nuisance, unsanitary, or unsafe conditions. To de- termine whether to grant the license, and any time after the license is granted, the department can inspect the property and enforce any penalties for violating sanita- tion or nuisance regulations. Ellensburg, Washington, has an inter- esting ordinance in that it requires a license for dogs and cats, but does not require a license to keep up to two beehives and four hens (§§5.30.260 & 5.30.310). Seattle, likewise, requires a license for dogs, cats, pigs, and goats, but does not require one for chickens or bees (§9.25.050). After restricting livestock to prop- erty with three acres or more, Pittsburgh amended its ordinance to allow chickens Vancouver, Washington, is an example of a less restrictive ordinance (§20.895.050). It allows up to three goats, if they weigh less than 100 pounds, on any size property. It also allows chickens, ducks, geese, or rab- bits on any size lot with no numerical restric- tion. It does provide in the ordinance that the keeping of animals is subject to already existing nuisance requirements. Roosters and Bucks Most of these cities prohibit roosters and male goats (or bucks). Hillsboro prohib - its roosters and uncastrated male goats with no exceptions. Seattle also prohibits roosters and uncastrated males but has an exception for nursing offspring that are less than 12 weeks old. Denver does the same but only until they are six weeks old. El Cerrito prohibits roosters but does not say anything about the gender of the goats it allows. And Cleveland has a more compli- cated system, in that it will allow roosters, Some cities require a permit or license . . . [which] are relatively straightforward and do not allow for much discretion on the part of the official who issues it. but only on property that is at least one acre in size with a 100-foot setback from the property line for the coop. Cleveland, like El Cerrito, does not say anything about goat gender. Lic ensing Some cities require a permit or license. Most of these permits are relatively straightfor- ward and do not allow for much discretion on the part of the official who issues it. For instance, Denver requires a livestock or fowl permit to keep chickens or goats but requires no more than the provisions of the ordinance be met and a fee be paid to ac quire the license. The city charges $100 annually for a livestock permit and $50 an- nually for a fowl permit. Cleveland also requires a license. Its health department issues a two-year license to keep any type of livestock, in- cluding chickens and bees. In issuing the license the director of public health must consider evidence of “nuisance or condi- tions that are unsafe or unsanitary” and any “recorded violations” and may deny and bees in 2011 (§912.07). It allows three hens and two beehives per 2,000 square feet on occupied, residentially zoned lots. It allows one more bird and hive for each additional 1,000 square feet. However, it requires the home owner to seek a special exception to keep livestock as an acces- sory use (§922.07). The special exception requires the zoning board of adjustment to hold a public hearing, to make findings of fact, and issue a written decision within 45 days of the hearing. This allows it to reevaluate and reweigh all of the concerns with raising chickens and bees in the city, even though the city council had already made the legislative determination and established criteria for when and where it was legal to do so. This puts a substantial burden on each home owner to fully argue the case before each iteration of the board. It also uses up considerable city resources. COMMON AND LESS COMMON BEE PROVISIONS Some cities never made keeping bees il- legal, and do not regulate the practice. ZONINGPRACTICE 4.13 AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION | page 7 VOL. 30, NO. 4 Zoning Practice is a monthly p ublication of the American Planning Association. Subscriptions are available for $95 (U.S.) and $120 (foreign). W. Paul Farmer, faicp, Chief Executive Officer; William R. Klein, aicp, Director of Research Zoning Practice (ISSN 1548–0135) is produced at APA. Jim Schwab, aicp, and David Morley, aicp, Editors; Julie Von Bergen, Assistant Editor; Lisa Barton, Design and Production. Missing and damaged print issues: Contact Customer Service, American Planning Association, 205 N. Michigan Ave., Suite 1200, Chicago, IL 60601 (312-431-9100 or customerservice@planning.org) within 90 days of the publication date. Include the name of the publication, year, volume and issue number or month, and your name, mailing address, and membership number if applicable. Copyright ©2013 by the American Planning Association, 205 N. Michigan Ave., Suite 1200, Chicago, IL 60601–5927 . The American Planning Association also has offices at 1030 15th St., NW, Suite 750 West, Washington, DC 20005–1503; www.planning.org. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the American Planning Association. Printed on recycled paper, including 50-70% recycled fiber and 10% postconsumer waste. Cover image: © iStockphoto.com/Michael Gatewood; design concept by Lisa Barton flying unless it occurs naturally. The water may be ‘sweetened’ with mineral salt or chlorine to enhance its attractiveness.” Cleveland requires a freshwater source to be maintained “throughout the day.” And Carson City requires water only from April 1 to September 30. As for less common provisions, Ellensburg, Washington, requires that all hives “consist of moveable frames and combs.” Cleveland prohibits Africanized bees. Africanized bees have only been found in a few southern states; bee- keepers, moreover, do not seek to keep Africanized bees. Boise, Idaho, prohibits Africanized bees, as well as wasps and hornets (§11-09-11.03). This is peculiar; people do not keep wasps or hornets be- cause they do not provide honey or pollina- tion services. Boise and Carson City require a queen to be removed if the hive shows “unusually aggressive characteristics.” And Carson City requires the new queen to be chosen from “stock bred for gentleness and non-swarming characteristics.” Carson City only allows honey to be extracted “where there is no access by bees before, during, or after the extraction process.” Carson City also requires any hive found to be diseased to be either “treated so as to completely eradicate the disease” or destroyed at the owner’s expense. Finally, both Carson City and Ellensburg provide that abandoned hives are to be considered nuisances. RECOMMENDATIONS Of the ordinances discussed above, two stand out as potential models: Denver’s and Seattle’s. These ordinances show that the trend, over time, is to simplify regulations. Local governments seeking to regulate these practices should consider how much they are prepared to spend, in terms of resources, on licensing or monitoring these practices given the relatively small degree of actual nuisance they cause. Governments should also keep in mind that straight- forward ordinances following developing norms will be easier to follow and easier to enforce. Among cities that do regulate beekeeping, flyway barriers and a source of fresh water are common requirements. Flyway barri - ers force bees to fly up over the heads of people so that they do not establish flight paths through a neighbor’s property or populated sidewalks, streets, or parks. Bees require water; if a beekeeper does not provide it, bees will frequently use a close source, like a neighbor’s pool. Concerning flyway barriers, Cleveland requires a fence or a dense hedge of at least six feet in height within five feet of the hive and extending at least two feet on either side. However, it does not require a flyway barrier if the hive is at least 25 feet from the property line or on a porch or bal- cony at least 10 feet from the ground. South Portland, Maine, has a similar flyway bar - rier standard, but requires it to extend at least 10 feet in each direction. And Carson City, Nevada, requires the flyway barrier to “surround” the hive on any side that is within 25 feet of a property line. Neither South Portland nor Carson City has excep- tions for balcony or rooftop hives. Concerning a water source, Ellensburg, Washington, requires “a consistent source of water . . . at the apiary when bees are Michael Acas Chicago allows up to five bee colonies in a residential backyard without a permit (§17-17-0270.7). Business & Development Services Committee Meeting • • • 27 BUSINESS & DEVELOPMENT SERVICES COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: April 7, 2025 AGENDA ITEM: 6d TO: Business & Development Services Committee FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug SUBJECT: Accessory Dwelling Units OBJECTIVE For years, one of the most popular requests received by the Mauldin Business & Development Services Department is from residents who would like to add an accessory dwelling unit to the ir home. These requests have solely been for homes in the R-20, R-15, or R-12, which are the districts in which accessory dwellings are prohibited. Sometimes this request has been for the purpose of building an independent living space for an aging parent. Other times it has been for the purpose of building an independent living space for young adult children. And other times it has been for the purpose of building a rentable space that can provide a supplementary source of inc ome. This is being included for discussion to gauge if Council members have any particular direction they would like to provide on this subject. NATIONAL TRENDS See the attached Zoning Practice article titled “Accessory Housing” for national trends that were emerging as of 201 2. The author of this article suggests that accessory housing is old idea but has seen renewed interest since the 1990s. CITY OF MAULDIN REGULATIONS The City of Mauldin’s Zoning Ordinance currently allows accessory dwelling units in the R-10, R-8, R-6, R-M1, R-M, and R-O zoning districts. These represents the residential areas in the City that have primarily been developed for small-lot residential communities. Accessory dwellings in these districts are subject to the following conditional standards: 1. Accessory dwellings are only allowed at detached single-family residences. 2. Detached accessory dwellings must be located in the back yard. 3. No more than one accessory dwelling unit is allowed on a property. 4. No additional driveways are allowed (the accessory dwelling cannot have its own indepe ndent driveway). 5. The accessory dwelling cannot exceed 500 square feet or 25 percent of the gross floor area of the primary residence, whichever is greater. Note: D etached accessory dwellings can be up to 50 percent of the gross floor area of primary residence. 6. Accessory dwellings cannot be sold apart from the primary residence. 7. Accessory dwellings cannot be used as a short-term rental. Business & Development Services Committee Meeting • • • 28 OTHER UPSTATE COMMUNITIES Other local communities in the Upstate regulate accessory dwelling units as follows: Community Regulations City of Greenville Permitted in all detached single-family residential districts (House-Scale, RH- ). Maximum size of the accessory dwelling is 80 percent of the primary dwelling or 1,000 square feet, whichever is less. No street-facing entry allowed. City of Greer Permitted in all detached single-family residential districts (Rural Residential, Suburban Neighborhood, and Traditional Neighborhood). Maximum size of the accessory dwelling is 800 square feet. No more than one accessory dwelling per lot. Mobile homes are not allowed to be used as an accessory dwelling. Town of Fountain Inn Only permitted in the O-D, Office District. Town of Travelers Rest Permitted in all detached single-family residential districts (R-15, R-10, R-7.5). Maximum size of the accessory dwelling is 70 percent of the primary dwelling or 1,000 square feet. No more than one accessory dwelling per lot. The property owner must reside on-site. REQUEST This item has been placed on the agenda for discussion purposes only. ATTACHMENTS Zoning Practice Article ZONINGPRACTICE 7 .12 AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION | page 2 Zoning for Accessory Housing By Tom Daniels Compact, walkable, and well-designed development is a primary goal of smart growth, and accessory housing can provide affordable housing opportunities that promote smart growth without sacrificing appearance. Accessory housing may either be a detached dwelling unit with full services—bath, sleep- ing quarters, and kitchen—or an autono- mous apartment attached to a house. Accessory apartments are often known as “granny flats” or “in-law suites” because of the common practice of keeping an elderly parent as part of the household but in a largely independent living situation. An apartment may be inconspicuously built over an attached or detached garage or added on to the back of a house. Whether attached or detached, acces- sory housing can increase residential densi- ties and encourage walkability. However, many older zoning ordinances present major obstacles to the creation of accessory dwell- ing units (ADUs). Accessory housing is one response to major changes in demographics and the real estate market. First, the number of single- person households is growing, especially among young adults who are marrying later and don’t need large homes. Second, many people are living longer and want to age in place with family members nearby, rather than join their fellow senior citizens in an assisted-living complex. Third, many empty nesters are downsizing, and an apartment makes good sense. Fourth, the popularity of off-campus living among college students means a steady demand for apartments, especially within walking distance of school. Finally, people who work in a high-end com- munity often cannot afford to live there as well. ADUs can provide affordable workforce housing for local workers. Efforts to retrofit suburbs and encour- age infill in cities have often focused on large projects such as redeveloping dead malls and multistory mixed use commercial and residential buildings. But financing for these projects is less available since the 2007 downturn in the real estate market. While these large projects are certainly needed to promote mixed uses and walk- ability, the residential market has lately fa- vored renters over buyers. Still, proposals for multifamily rentals often spark a backlash, especially in newer suburbs. One less con- spicuous way to provide more rental units is through an accessory housing ordinance in single-family residential districts. grew more slowly or lost population com- pared to most suburbs and exurban areas, where builders could offer large houses on large lots. In the 2000s, this big-house strategy contributed to the housing melt- down in two ways. First, many people paid more than they could afford for these large houses, and second, home builders created an oversupply of houses, which exacerbated the downturn in home prices and left many recent buyers “underwater”—owing more on their mortgage than their house was worth. Although housing prices seem to be stabilizing after five years of declines, rental opportunities remain attractive. Several studies have shown that accessory apartment units rent for below- market rates, in part because the accessory apartments are less expensive to build onto existing houses or garages. Pedestrian access to commercial uses and transit are important, especially for older people who may no longer drive and for young adults who cannot afford a car or may not want to own a car. Thus, accessory units tend to be more pedestrian- and transit-friendly within cities and inner suburbs, rather than in newer suburbs where residential and com- mercial areas are typically separated and a car is needed for transportation. Two potential longer term threats to ac- cessory housing are gentrification and rising property taxes. Gentrification can lead to re- ductions in accessory housing supply when wealthier residents moving into a neighbor- hood “mothball” or remove accessory units. Also, as property values rise, the rents on the ADUs can rise beyond the affordability of low- to moderate-income residents. It is also important to keep in mind that the construc- ADVANTAGES OF ACCESSORY HOUSING 1. A way to create mixed income neighbor- hoods without reducing property values (a traditional use of zoning). 2. A way to increase density in urban and suburban areas without multifamily development. Little burden on commu- nity services compared to property taxes generated. 3. A way to provide housing for the elderly, especially for an older family member. This enables senior citizens to “age in place.” 4. Workforce and student housing. Interest in accessory housing has existed for decades. In 1985 author Martin Gellen estimated that there were 10 to 18 million houses with sufficient space to add an accessory dwelling unit, and if just 15 percent of these units were actually built, at least 150,000 units could be added to the nation’s housing stock. In much of the 1980s and 1990s cities and inner suburbs ASK THE AUTHOR JOIN US ONLINE! About the Author Tom Daniels is a professor in the Department of City and Regional Planning at the University of Pennsylvania. He teaches Land-Use Planning, Environmental Planning, and Growth Management. Daniels is the coauthor of the Small Town Planning Handbook (APA Planners Press, 2007) and the Planners Guide to CommunityViz (APA Planners Press, 2011). tion of an ADU, whether detached or an attached apartment, will result in higher property taxes for the property owner. CREATING AN ACCESSORY HOUSING ORDINANCE Zoning is not known as a tool that local governments use to respond quickly to demographic trends or changes in the real estate market. The main purpose of zoning remains the separation of conflicting uses, which is closely tied to the protection of property values. But there is a sequence of steps that a local government can take to create a legally and politically sound acces- sory housing ordinance. First, planners and elected officials should make sure that the community generally supports ADUs. Then they can add an affordable housing goal to the comprehensive plan (if such a goal does not already exist). Next, planners and elected officials can include a policy objective to promote ADUs in the housing section of the comprehensive plan and amend the future land-use map to indicate where ADUs are al- lowed. Planners should have a sense of the maximum build-out potential for accessory dwelling units, and accessory units should only be allowed in areas with adequate central sewer and water service. This first step shows that the elected officials and planners support accessory housing. Second, make sure than the accessory housing provisions of the zoning ordinance are consistent with the local comprehensive plan. The affordable housing goal and ac- cessory dwelling objective give direction to the zoning ordinance and establish a legal basis for the accessory dwelling provisions Go online during the month of July to participate in our “Ask the Author” forum, an interactive feature of Zoning Practice. Tom Daniels will be available to answer questions about this article. Go to the APA website at www.planning.org and follow the links to the Ask the Author section. From there, just submit your questions about the article using the e-mail link. The author will reply, and Zoning Practice will post the answers cumulatively on the website for the benefit of all subscribers. This feature will be available for selected issues of Zoning Practice at announced times. After each online discussion is closed, the answers will be saved in an online archive available through the APA Zoning Practice web pages. ZONINGPRACTICE 7 .12 AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION | page 3 An important decision is whether to allow accessory dwellings by right or through a special exception. A conditional use permit makes little sense because ac- cessory housing generally does not affect the entire community but rather certain neighborhoods. The advantage of the spe- cial exception approach is that the zoning ordinance can impose certain limits on the number of occupants of the accessory hous- ing. The special exception process involves within the zoning ordinance. The location of where ADUs are allowed on the zoning map should coincide with locations identified as appropriate on the future land-use map. The overall consistency of the zoning ordinance and zoning map with the affordable housing goal, the accessory housing objective, and the future land-use map of the comprehen- sive plan will make the accessory housing ordinance more likely to withstand legal challenges. The location of where ADUs are allowed on the zoning map should coincide with loca- tions identified as appropriate on the future land-use map. Third, the addition of the accessory hous- ing provisions in the zoning ordinance helps to avoid rezoning and variance battles, which can be expensive and engender bad feelings with neighbors. In drafting the ADU ordinance, planners should meet with residential prop- erty owners and neighborhood associations and negotiate design standards, parking, and rules for ADUs, such as “no more than two people may reside in an accessory unit.” This community outreach serves to head off political opposition to the accessory housing ordinance and to incorporate as much as pos- sible the comments of the people who will live near and next to the ADUs. The ADU ordinance emphasizes revising single-family zoning dis- tricts to allow accessory dwellings. ADUs, both detached units and attached apartments, must be defined in the ordinance. a review of the ADU that the home owner is proposing, a fee, and approval from the Zoning Board of Adjustment. On the other hand, allowing an ADU by-right can speed the review process while maintaining certain performance standards, such as a required tie-in to central sewer and water, limits on size, and number of residents. A site plan review is commonly required whether the zoning to allow ac- cessory dwellings is by-right or by special exception. Fourth, land development and building design standards are key issues, especially for detached units. Setbacks from prop- erty lines are usually stated in the zoning ordinance rather than left up to the variance process. For the sake of good neighbor rela- tions and appearance, a specific setback of ZONINGPRACTICE 7 .12 AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION | page 4 10 or 15 feet is recommended. Maximum lot coverage can be the same standard as for single-family dwellings. Height limits may be no more than 20 feet. The idea is that a single floor with some storage space above is adequate, or that an apartment above a garage should not loom over a neighbor’s property. The maximum size is a common issue. A maximum square footage should be spelled out, such as 800 square feet. Design and landscaping requirements for a detached accessory unit should not be dissimilar from the rest of the neighbor- hood. Graphic illustrations of design and landscaping standards in the ordinance can be particularly helpful. Parking, however, can be a problem. An accessory dwelling unit will most likely rely upon on-street parking. Adding a parking space on the property could be difficult. In addition, the property owner must demonstrate that there is adequate central sewer and water service for the accessory dwelling unit. Typically, no more than one accessory dwelling is allowed with a primary residence, and often, the owner of the primary residence must live on the property, either in the primary residence or in the accessory unit. Also, an ADU must meet the local building code before the local government will issue an occupancy permit. Finally, it is important to demonstrate that builders are interested in constructing detached ADUs and attached accessory apartments. Local lenders should be made aware that accessory dwellings are permit- ted and that a construction loan should be forthcoming pending zoning approval. WHERE HAS ACCESSORY HOUSING WORKED? Cities appear to have had more success in constructing ADUs than suburbs. And West Coast cities, in particular, have made inno- vative efforts to encourage accessory units in part to provide affordable housing and to promote compact development. Portland, Oregon Portland is often cited as a paragon of smart growth. Portland’s zoning code provides standards for ADUs in all of its residential zones and was last updated in 2010. ADUs can be created by right in a detached single- family house, an attached row house, or a manufactured home. The ADU can result from converting existing living area, finish- ing an existing basement or attic, building a new structure, or making an addition to an existing structure. The purposes of the accessory dwelling provisions in the Portland zoning ordinance include: • inc reasing the housing stock while respecting the appearance and scale of single-dwelling neighborhoods; • pr oviding a mix of housing that responds to changing family needs and smaller households; • pr oviding a means for residents—particu - larly seniors, single parents, and families with grown children—to remain in their homes defines a household rather broadly: “One or more persons related by blood, marriage, legal adoption or guardianship, plus not more than 5 additional persons, who live together in one dwelling unit.” The emphasis in Portland’s accessory dwelling approval process is on mitigating off-site impacts, for example requiring an erosion-control plan and a stormwater plan if the ADU will add more than 500 square feet of impervious surface. In addition, there is a system development charge (think impact fee) of about $6,000 to $10,000 for and neighborhoods and obtain extra income, security, companionship, and services; and • pr oviding a broader range of accessible and more affordable housing. The ordinance defines an ADU as a sec- ond dwelling unit created on a lot with an existing house, row house, or manufactured home, where the second unit is auxiliary to and smaller than the existing unit. Portland’s ordinance allows a house- hold to inhabit an ADU. The ordinance sewer and water service, recreation, and streets. The density requirements are quite favorable for adding accessory dwellings. In the single-dwelling zones, ADUs are not in- cluded in the minimum or maximum density calculations for a site. In other words, den- sity is not an issue. In all other residential zones ADUs are included in the minimum density calculations but are not included in the maximum density calculations. This is in an incentive not to create large lots. Keep These illustrations show a range of detached ADU types. Owners looking to create an ADU rental for supplemental income may elect to construct a detached unit to maximize privacy. City of Santa Cruz, California ZONINGPRACTICE 7 .12 AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION | page 5 in mind that the general standard for new development inside the greater Portland metropolitan service boundary is 10 to 12 dwelling units per acre. The ADU ordinance is designed to help achieve that density. For an existing house the ADU can be no more than 75 percent of the total living area of the house or a maximum of 800 square feet, whichever is less. To keep detached ac- cessory dwellings inconspicuous, a unit must be at least 60 feet from the front property line, or the unit must be at least six feet be- hind the house, row house, or manufactured cannot cover more than 15 percent of the entire lot. As for design, the exterior of the accessory dwelling unit must be the same as or visually match the primary dwelling. For instance, the roof pitch of the acces- sory dwelling must be same as the pitch for the primary dwelling, and the trim and the windows should match. Unfortunately, though, the ordinance does not contain any graphics for the reader to follow in trying to understand the design standards. Finally, Portland requires that an applicant for an ADU submit a site plan, Most of the new ADUs have been built on the east side of the city fairly close to downtown. About 40 percent of the ADUs built have been detached cottage units and 60 percent attached apartments, typically above a garage. Spokane, Washington Spokane has taken a unique approach to accessory dwellings by adopting a cottage housing ordinance in 2006. Although this ordinance may not be applied as widely as a typical accessory housing ordinance, it offers a way to increase density and affordability through the construction of small houses. The purpose of the Spokane ordinance is to “support the diversity of housing, increase the variety of housing types for smaller households and pro- vide the opportunity for small, detached single-family dwelling units within existing neighborhoods.” The cottage ordinance applies in the city’s single-family residential district and the residential agricultural district. The ordinance requires a minimum of half an acre and a minimum of six units, with a maximum of 12 units, and offers the property owner a 20 percent density bonus. Properties that meet the minimum acreage standard are most often on the edge of a city, and hence the cottage ordinance could be especially helpful as a city with annexa- tion powers adds land within the city limits. The maximum square footage is 1,000 square feet, excluding any floor area where the floor-to-ceiling height is less than six feet. But half of the cottages can have no more than 650 square feet on the main floor and half can have no more than 1,000 square feet on the main floor. Once a cot- tage is built, it cannot be expanded. Maximum lot coverage is 40 percent. The height limit is 18 feet, except if the dwell- ing has a pitched roof. Then the maximum height is 25 feet. All cottages are required to have covered porches, which are oriented toward common open space or to the street. For each cottage there must be at least 250 square feet of common open space and 250 square feet of private open space. The com- mon open space must be landscaped and maintained by a home owners association. Setbacks for all structures from the property lines must average 10 feet but cannot be less than five feet, and not less than 15 feet from a public street. This last standard is similar to the front yard setback required of any detached single-family residence. home. For fire safety, the detached ADU must be at least six feet from the primary dwelling. Portland does not require additional on-site parking for an accessory dwelling. Thus, on-street parking can be used. Design review is required if changes are proposed to the exterior of an existing house. The height limit for a detached acces- sory dwelling unit is 18 feet. The lot coverage of the detached accessory dwelling unit cannot exceed the lot coverage of the pri- mary dwelling. Together, the two dwellings architectural plans, and structural plans. From 2002 through 2011 Portland issued a total of 316 accessory dwelling per- mits. The downturn in the national economy was also reflected in ADU activity. In 2007 , 31 permits were issued; only 19 were issued in 2008 and 22 in 2009. The Portland City Council then enacted a waiver of the system development charges for three years for new accessory dwelling units. The new policy seems to be working. In 2010, the city is- sued 61 permits; in 2011, 64. City of Santa Cruz, California These illustrations show a range of attached ADU types. Attached ADUs may be preferable for housing extended family members. ZONINGPRACTICE 7 .12 AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION | page 6 Parking must be clustered in groups of five spaces and set back at least 20 feet from the street. Each cottage must have ac- cess to a sidewalk. The cottage ordinance calls for variety in design. Only one-fifth of the cottages can have the same design, and no two similar designed cottages can be placed next to each other. Each cottage must have at least four elements from a list of 14. These include, for example, varying roof shapes, dormers, bay windows, and variation in building materials and colors. Spokane has had difficulty in imple- menting the cottage ordinance. So far only three projects have been proposed. Objections from neighbors have been a major problem. But in 2009, the Washington Court of Appeals issued a ruling uphold- ing the city’s approval of a 24-unit cottage development on two acres. The court found that the cottages would have no signifi- cant adverse effect on the neighborhood. Another obstacle has been minimum lot size of 4,350 square feet with a minimum lot width of 40 feet and a minimum front lot line of 40 feet. In 2011, an Infill Housing Task Force recommended creating a new compact residential single-family zoning district (RSF-C) in addition to the existing residential single-family district (RSF) in order to promote the cottage ordinance. The RSF-C district would have a minimum lot size of 3,000 square feet, a minimum lot width of 36 feet, and a minimum front lot line of 30 feet. Santa Cruz, California Santa Cruz is located about 70 miles south of San Francisco on the Pacific Ocean. It is a college town that has experienced consid- erable growth from its proximity to Silicon Valley to the northeast. Santa Cruz created its accessory dwelling ordinance in 2003 in response to California law AB 1866 of 2002, which not only sought to promote the cre- ation of accessory dwelling units but made it so that local governments could not prohibit the development of an ADU if it meets devel- opment standards. The purpose of the Santa Cruz ADU program is to provide more rental housing, encourage infill development and thus protect green space on the edge of the city, and to promote the use of public trans- portation. Santa Cruz has one of the least affordable housing markets in the United States. The city estimates that less than seven percent of the city’s residents can af- ford to buy a local median-priced house. On the other hand, Santa Cruz has more than 18,000 single-family lots, which suggests a good opportunity to create affordable rental housing. Santa Cruz formed the Accessory Dwelling Unit Development Program, which featured changes to the zoning ordinance, a strong public education effort, and financial assistance. The city removed a requirement that a single-family home had to have a covered parking structure (garage or carport), which made space available for City of Santa Cruz, California These illustrations show how detached ADUs can be sited on corner lots and lots with access to an alley. Permitting two or more small cottages on a single lot provides an alternative to the standard accessory dwelling model. City of Spokane, Washington ZONINGPRACTICE 7 .12 AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION | page 7 VOL. 29, NO. 7 Zoning Practice is a monthly p ublication of the American Planning Association. Subscriptions are available for $95 (U.S.) and $120 (foreign). W. Paul Farmer, faicp, Chief Executive Officer; William R. Klein, aicp, Director of Research Zoning Practice (ISSN 1548–0135) is produced at APA. Jim Schwab, aicp, and David Morley, aicp, Editors; Julie Von Bergen, Assistant Editor; Lisa Barton, Design and Production. Missing and damaged print issues: Contact Customer Service, American Planning Association, 205 N. Michigan Ave., Suite 1200, Chicago, IL 60601 (312-431-9100 or customerservice@planning.org) within 90 days of the publication date. Include the name of the publication, year, volume and issue number or month, and your name, mailing address, and membership number if applicable. Copyright ©2012 by American Planning Association, 205 N. Michigan Ave., Suite 1200, Chicago, IL 60601–5927 . The American Planning Association also has offices at 1030 15th St., NW, Suite 750 West, Washington, DC 20005–1503; www.planning.org. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the American Planning Association. Printed on recycled paper, including 50-70% recycled fiber and 10% postconsumer waste. Cover image: ©iStockphoto.com/otisabi RESOURCES BOX Resources on Accessory Housing Georgia Department of Community Affairs “Accessory Housing Units.” www.dca.state.ga.us/intra_nonpub/Toolkit/Guides /AcsryHsngUnts.pdf Portland (Oregon) Bureau of Development Services, City of “Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs).” www.portlandonline.com/bds/index.cfm?c=36676 www.portlandonline.com/bds/index.cfm?&a=53301 Spokane (Washington), City of 2012. Municipal Code. Section 17C.110.350: Cottage Housing. www.spokanecity.org/services/documents/smc/?Section=17C.110.350 Santa Cruz (California), City of “Accessory Dwelling Unit Development Program” www.cityofsantacruz.com/index.aspx?page=1150 www.huduser.org/rbc/newsletter/vol6iss2more.html Washington Appeals Court, State of 2009. William Davis et al. v. City of Spokane and Konstantin Vasilenko, No. 29204-5-III. http://statecasefiles.justia.com/documents/washington/court-of-appeals-division-iii /292045.unp.doc.pdf?ts=1323968271 an ADU. ADUs are allowed on single-family lots of 5,000 or more feet, and must meet setback, height, and parking requirements. Two-story ADUs that are located within a rear yard setback or any ADU that does not meet applicable zoning standards require a public hearing and an administrative use permit. Next, the city had architects draft de- signs of accessory units that met both size (500 square feet) and style requirements that home owners could follow to speed the review and approval process. Then the city drafted an ADU manual describing how home owners could work their way through design, review, and city approval to construction. The city also held five public workshops to explain the ADU process. In 2003 a total of 35 accessory dwelling units were built in Santa Cruz, up from just eight in 2001. In 2004, the city added a progressive Fee Reduction/Waiver Program for property owners who build an ADU for a household whose income level is at or below 60 or 50 percent of the Area Median Income (AMI). Fees may vary by unit size and other design components. Typical city development fees for a new one-bedroom, 500-square-foot ADU might be about $9,000. For providing rental housing to low-income households at 60 percent of the AMI, a home owner would save about $6,000 in city development fees. For very low-income housing at 50 percent of the AMI, the full $9,000 would be saved. The Santa Cruz Community Credit Union offered loans of up to $100,000 at 4.5 % interest for Santa Cruz home owners looking to build an affordable ADU. To qualify, home owners had to sign a covenant stating that the ADU would be rented at a price afford- able to low- to moderate-income residents. In 2004 the city received the Policies and Regulations Smart Growth Achievement Award from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Since 2003, Santa Cruz has added more than 170 accessory dwelling units. CONCLUSION The accessory housing concept is an old idea, but has seen renewed interest over the past 30 years and especially since the rise in real estate prices in the late 1990s. Local govern- ments have adopted accessory dwelling ordinances to encourage housing for elderly relatives and rental opportunities for young adults, including students. A local govern- ment can identify accessory housing as an objective in the comprehensive plan and provide for it in the local zoning ordinance. Portland and Santa Cruz have created successful accessory dwelling unit programs that seek to streamline the development pro- cess yet maintain good design that fits in with the neighborhood. Both cities have offered financial incentives. Portland has temporarily waived the system development charges on new accessory dwelling units, and Santa Cruz has offered low-cost financing. Eleven cities in Washington, including Spokane, have adopted cottage ordinances. Spokane’s experience shows that site design is also important, not just zon- ing. In effect, a unified development code that combines zoning and land develop- ment regulations would help landowners understand what they have to do to create an ADU as well as streamline the approval process. Opposition from neighbors is to be expected, especially if the city does not undertake an educational effort. Even then, accessory units can make neighbors feel encroached upon as well as raise concerns about impacts on property values. With the U.S. population expected to add more than 100 million people over the next 40 years, accessory housing can play a small, but significant role in offering affordable housing and walkable, compact development that helps to revitalize cities.

Source: City of Mauldin website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.