BZA 12.11.21 Minutes – Approved
Town of McClellanville · Charleston County · meeting of Dec 11, 2021 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of McClellanville
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Minutes
McClellanville Board of Zoning Appeals
December 11, 2021, 6:00PM
The McClellanville Board of Zoning Appeals held a public hearing on the above-noted date.
Notice of the hearing had been published as required by the Freedom of Information Act
and the Town’s Zoning and Land Development Ordinance. Board members present were
Allen DuPre, Cheves Leland, Scott Youngblood, Scott Rowland, and TJ Johnston. Town staff
present included Town Planner Eddie Bernard and Executive Assistant Natalie Lewis. In
attendance virtually by Zoom, Zoning Administrator, Kathryn Basha. Public in attendance
included Bob McCarly, Claude Cross, Barbara and Keyes Aton, Marylou High, and Christine
Freeze.
Allen DuPre, Chair, called the hearing to order at 6:00 PM. She asked the members to
review the minutes from the July 20, 2023, public hearing. TJ Johnston made a motion to
approve the minutes as written. The motion was seconded by Cheves Leland and carried
unanimously with “aye” vote recorded for all members.
Next, Allen DuPre opened the public hearing on an appeal for reconsideration of the Zoning
Administrator’s determination that a violation occurred, and mitigation is required for
removal of a significant tree absent of a permit as required by Section 6.S(d) of the Town of
McClellanville Zoning and Land Development Ordinance on property located at 506
Pinckney Street, Charleston County Tax Map# 766-03-00-003. Allen DuPre asked Zoning
Administrator to present staff findings.
Kathryn Basha went over staff notes prepared for board. (Reference attachment). BZA
members, the Zoning Administrator and the public discussed the application and
information as it pertains to the staff notes and the Order on Variance. Allen DuPre then
asked the representative of the applicant, the owner’s father, Claude Cross, if he would like
to speak on behalf of the applicant. Mr. Cross stated that the family has had concerns
about pecan trees on the property since they purchased it in 1975, due to the size and age
of the large trees and the brittleness of pecan trees as they age, which makes them
especially dangerous. Mr. Cross stated that they had permission to take down other pecan
trees on the property, and this was the last remaining tree that was of concern. This tree
was dropping limbs on and around the driveway and sidewalk, and there was concern that
a limb could hit and damage the residence during hurricane season while the applicant
was out of town. Mr. Cross also noted that the applicant planted 14 live oak trees on the
property prior to taking down this pecan tree.
BZA members discussed the application and information as it pertains to the Order on
Variance. The board felt that applicant could have come back to Town sometime within the
eight months between February 2023 and October 2023 when application was denied and
when tree was removed to ask for another tree removal. Also, because the applicant at one
time worked for the Town, he should not have knowingly violated Town ordinance.
The Board asked Zoning Administrator to explain the mitigation regarding deciding the
mitigation fees to be charged. Kathryn Basha informed the board that they could alter the
dollar amount of mitigation per tree. TJ Johnston made a motion to fine the property owner
for violating the ordinance.
The board concludes that the decision of the zoning official was based on the
interpretation of sections 6.4 and 6.5 of the zoning ordinance and zoning map that it was
unlawful to remove the subject tree without a permit pursuant to the ordinance.
The board makes the following findings of fact which are supported by the evidence that
the tree was removed without an approved permit in violation of Sections 6.4 and 6.5 are
applicable in this case and shall be interpreted as sections 6.4 and 6.5 prohibit the removal
of the subject tree without a permit. The board, therefore, orders that the decision of the
zoning official is modified as follows. The applicant has the option of contributing to the
Towns’s Tree Fund of $200 per mitigation tree and all other findings remain unmodified.
Next, Allen Dupre opened the public hearing request for variance of the minimum side/rear
setback for an accessory structure as required by Section 3.4.4(c)(6)f to allow re-
establishment of a shed in the former location less than the required five (5) feet on
property located at 119 Oak Street, bearing Charleston County Map #764-14-00-105. Allen
DuPre asked Town Planner to present staff findings.
Eddie Bernard read staff notes for board. (Reference Attachment). BZA members, the
Zoning Administrator and the public discussed the application and information as it
pertains to the staff notes and the Order on Variance. After reviewing the Orders of the
Board, Cheves Leland made a motion to grant the variance.
The board concludes that the applicant has an unnecessary hardship because there are
extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property and
that these conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity based on the
following findings of fact:
The well and associated other equipment are currently within the 5’ setback, as was the
previous structure which burned. The lot to the west is largely marsh land with a limited
amount of high ground, approximately 10’ wide opposite the area where the shed was and
is currently proposed.
The shed would abut an area that is largely marsh and the configuration of the coastline to
the side of a lot is unique in this area to the Aton’s lot. The sliver of high ground opposite of
the shed location could only support a small accessory building. Combined with several
protected trees within the area, no principal structure could be built in the vicinity of the
proposed shed location without a variance. Therefore, the typical concerns of proximity
noises, smells, drainage, fire etc. which setbacks protect against would be of less concern.
The lot has several protected trees scattered around which limit potential shed locations,
but more so the well would have to be moved and redrilled.
Authorization of a variance would have no impact to the adjacent property due to the
adjacent property configuration and the fact that approximately high ground opposite the
shed is only 10’ wide. An identical shed was previous in this location prior to burning, so
the public perception and district character would not be altered.
The board concludes that because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to
the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the
utilization of the property.
The board concludes that the authorization of the variance will not be of substantial
detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will
not be harmed by the granting of the variance based on the following findings of fact: The
variance will allow the property to be returned as close as possible to its state before the
fire.
The board concludes that the effect of the variance would allow the establishment of a use
not otherwise permitted in the zoning district, would not extend physically a
nonconforming use of th eland; and would not change the zoning district boundaries
shown of the official zoning map, based on the following finding of fact: The variance will
allow the property to be returned as close as possible to its state before the fire.
Allen DuPre made a motion to accept staff recommendations and approve the requested
variance. The motion was seconded by TJ Johnston, none opposed. Motion carried
unanimously with an “aye” vote recorded for all members.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 7:28 PM.
Respectfully submitted,
Natalie Lewis
Executive Assistant
Source: Town of McClellanville website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.