_05212026-2191
Town of Mount Pleasant · Charleston County · meeting of May 21, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Mount Pleasant
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
TREE TASK FORCE
Thursday, May 21, 2026
8:00 a.m.
Municipal Complex, Committee Meeting Room
100 Ann Edwards Lane, Mount Pleasant, SC 29464
MI
NUTES
Cl
ick here to listen to the recording.
Discussion Topics
1. Call To Order
Chair McKee called the Tree Task Force meeting to order at 8:01 AM on
Thursday, May 21, 2026. Shanna Harris, David Quick, Michelle
Mansour, George Grice, and Deidre Kennedy were all present. Edward
Oswald was absent.
2. Approval of Agenda
Motion to approve the agenda was made by Mr. Quick and by Ms.
Mansour. The motion carried, all in favor.
3. Approval of minutes from April 30 Meeting
Motion to approve the minutes from the April 30 meeting was made
by Mr. Quick and seconded by Ms. Mansour. The motion carried, all
in favor.
4. Public Comment
[None]
5. Work Plan TTF 2026 Work Plan
5a. Continued Review and Discussion of Tree Protection Zoning
Ordinances and Policies
Chair McKee opened the work plan discussion, noting that the meeting
was a continuation of the previous session and that Christiane Farrell,
Assistant Town Administrator, had prepared summary slides based on
prior discussion. Before Ms. Farrell began her presentation, Mr. Bob
O'Neill offered a time management suggestion, recommending that the
Tree Task Force
May 21, 2026
Page 2 of 19
group spend the first hour focused on the ordinance discussion and then
dedicate the remaining time to reviewing the recommendation section of
the draft final report. He emphasized that the ordinance conversation
had the potential to extend indefinitely, and that disciplined time
management would help the group identify the outstanding issues
requiring resolution before the next meeting. The group agreed to this
approach and Farrell proceeded.
Updated with notes from April meeting
• Tree Protection Zone- allow flexibility/ reduction of 20 to 25%. Protection plan from
arborist for construction period. General Agreement on 20% reduction w/ plan
• Reduce minimum caliper for mitigation trees to 1.5 inches. General Agreement
• Tree mitigation for single family nonconstruction- revise to 1 to 1 tree placement
rather than inches when required. More Discussion/ Options
• Develop minimum tree density standard for plantings on single family lots involving
construction More Discussion/ Options
• Reduce classification of laurel oaks (water oaks remain as is) Limited discussion, more
needed to determine consensus
• Allow photo evidence of dead trees (esp. laurel and water oaks) and photo as proof of
planting (policy not ordinance) Limited discussion, more needed to determine
consensus
• Clarify ordinance language and fines for pruning, construction violations in the TPZ
Limited discussion, likely supported, legal input needed
• Streamline ordinance language for capital projects Limited discussion
Summary: Staff Recommendations
Laurel and Water Oaks
Staff recommendation
• Reclassify Laurel Oaks to Class III, leave Water Oaks as
Class III
• This potentially eliminates the issue of people trying to argue
laurel oaks down to water oaks classification (ordinance
revision)
• Laurel and Water Oaks have shorter life spans resulting in
very frequent applications for removal, most are dead or
poor
• Allow photo evidence for these species (and others) to save
staff resources (nonconstruction permits only)- (policy
decision)
Tree Task Force
May 21, 2026
Page 3 of 19
• Staff recommends strengthening the language for
pruning and construction related violations. These
violations typically do not involve tree removal but can
be very harmful to the health and future growth of the
tree.
• No specific language is needed from TTF. Staff will
coordinate with Legal in drafting ordinance
amendments to develop better enforcement language
and fees.
Enforcement
Capital Projects
• The ordinance needs modification and clarification to
create uniformity, flexibility, and implementation
standards unique to public projects and utility
installations in public right-of-ways.
• No changes are proposed to the 160” per acre or tree
mitigation with new capital projects.
• No specific language is needed from TTF. This primarily
involves reorganization of the text and includes other
matters dealt with by staff to include fiber installation
and maintenance matters.
Tree Task Force
May 21, 2026
Page 4 of 19
• Ordinance amendments where there is general agreement should have a
significant positive impact on processes and staff resources
• allowing 20% reduction in the TPZ,
• reducing replacement trees to 1.5 inches,
• shifting Laurel Oaks to Class III
• Policy changes allowing photo evidence along with above ordinance
changes would help support staff resources
• It has been determined that ordinances and processes for commercial
development are working well. Are further changes needed to single family
beyond the above proposed amendments ?
• 1 to 1 replacement
• Tree density (160”/ acre or 20 trees/ acre)
• Replacement of Class IV, dead, dying and hazardous tree (would this apply to
commercial?)
• Increase protection levels on trees less than 24 inches (require variance approval
for 16 inch up)
Options/ Considerations
1) Keep the ordinance as is, no changes
a) Mitigation based on inches for Class 1, 2, and 3 in
good or fair condition
b) No replacement for Class 4, dead, or hazardous
2) Establish tree density of 160"/ acre or 20 trees/
acre
3) 1 to 1 tree replacement
Single Family: Construction & Nonconstruction
Tree Task Force
May 21, 2026
Page 5 of 19
Tree Protection Zone and Mitigation Tree Size
Ms. Farrell began by recapping the key points from the prior meeting
where general consensus had been reached. She stated that the group
had largely agreed on allowing a 20 percent reduction in the tree
protection zone, provided that a specific arborist management plan
accompanied any such request. She also noted consensus around
reducing the minimum size of mitigation trees from 2.5 inches to 1.5
inches for single-family residential applications. Farrell indicated she
would return to the single-family topic at the end of the presentation, as
that remained the most complex and unresolved area.
Laurel Oaks and Water Oaks Reclassification
Ms. Farrell transitioned to the question of Laurel Oaks and Water Oaks,
noting that data presented in previous meetings had identified these
species as the source of a disproportionate number of applications
coming through the planning department, particularly on the non-
construction residential side. She stated that staff had discussed moving
Water Oaks down from Class II to Class III in a prior meeting, and that
the current proposal was to move Laurel Oaks down to match Water
Oaks at Class III, rather than dropping Water Oaks further to Class IV.
Ms. Farrell explained that Senior Planner Chris Lubert had noted a
recurring pattern of applicants arguing that a Laurel Oak was a Water
Oak in order to obtain lower mitigation requirements. By equalizing their
classification, the administrative burden of those disputes could be
• Additional ordinance amendments or process
modifications?
Tree Task Force
May 21, 2026
Page 6 of 19
reduced. She noted that this change reflected both the shorter lifespan
observed in these species and input from staff arborist Eddie Bernard,
who had endorsed the reclassification.
Ms. Kennedy asked whether removing these trees would still require an
arborist report. Farrell responded that staff did not always require
arborist reports for removals, and that Mr. Lubert could speak further.
Mr. Lubert clarified that when a tree appeared to be in obvious poor
condition, no arborist report was typically needed, but when the tree
appeared healthy with no obvious defects, staff would generally request
an arborist report prior to approving removal. He also noted that the
Engineering and Development Services likewise routinely requested
arborist reports.
Ms. Harris raised the observation that protecting Laurel Oaks at the
same level as Live Oaks seemed inconsistent given the significantly
shorter lifespan of Laurel Oaks. She noted that Water Oaks were
generally permittable in construction situations due to their tendency to
fail, and that Laurel Oaks exhibited similar characteristics. She asked
whether reclassifying them to Class III would make Laurel Oaks more
permittable in construction scenarios as well.
Mr. Lubert confirmed that at Class III, a Laurel Oak removal would not
require a Board of Zoning Appeals hearing. He noted that he routinely
counseled applicants against placing structures close to large Laurel
Oaks, citing a recent incident in which a large Laurel Oak dropped half
its canopy onto adjacent private property, damaging a vehicle. He stated
that this type of failure was common with both Laurel and Water Oaks.
Ms. Kennedy followed up, asking whether a tree in fair or good condition
would still require a Board of Zoning Appeals review if it was a Laurel
Oak at Class III. Lubert confirmed it would not.
Mr. Quick asked staff whether Laurel Oaks and Water Oaks were
effectively equivalent in quality. Mr. Lubert responded that there were
small differences at the detailed level, but that when evaluating trees
from a failure risk perspective — which was how he primarily evaluated
them — both species exhibited high failure rates, particularly in storm
conditions. He noted that recent storms had produced primarily Laurel
Oak and Water Oak failures, not pine failures, which he attributed in part
to the lack of regular maintenance and arborist inspection by property
owners.
Ms. Harris remarked that in her professional experience managing public
tree issues, large Water Oaks and Laurel Oaks in the right-of-way could
Tree Task Force
May 21, 2026
Page 7 of 19
cause significant operational disruptions when they fell in storms,
particularly when entangled in power lines. She described the difficulty of
clearing such large trees and expressed her professional discomfort
when trees of these species grew to large diameters.
Chair McKee asked whether there was any disagreement within the
group regarding reclassification. Mr. Grice noted that when it came to
hardwood timber value, the two species were effectively equivalent. Ms.
Harris confirmed her view that quality was approximately the same,
noting she saw more Water Oak failures but a substantial volume of
Laurel Oak failures as well, with comparable lifespans.
Ms. Mansour noted that the footnote in the mitigation table already
acknowledged quality concerns for both Laurel Oaks and Water Oaks.
Chair McKee observed that both species already carried footnotes in the
table reflecting prior adjustments, and that moving Laurel Oaks to Class
III would simply align their treatment with the existing footnoted
understanding.
Ms. Farrell confirmed this, attributing the original footnoting to a
recommendation from Eddie Bernard based on his field experience,
noting that both Mr. Lubert and Mr. Bernard had agreed the move to
Class III was appropriate. Chair McKee asked for a straw poll, and the
group indicated general agreement to reclassify Laurel Oaks to Class III.
Ms. Kennedy then posed a question to Ms. Harris, asking whether she
would want to protect a 16-inch Laurel Oak. Ms. Harris responded
emphatically that she would, stating she strongly preferred protecting
trees in the 16-to-24-inch range as well as smaller trees, noting that this
size range was more viable and healthier. She stated her concern that a
24-inch-and-up threshold was where trees of these species began
presenting dangerous structural risk, citing tendencies toward heartwood
rot and included bark leading to failure. She expressed a preference for
providing flexibility on the larger specimens while offering stronger
protection to the smaller ones.
Ms. Mansour referenced the footnote again, noting it addressed quality
ratings. Chair McKee summarized the discussion by noting that both
species had already been recognized as lower quality through the
footnote system and that moving them to the same category was a
natural extension of that prior reasoning. The group expressed
consensus in favor of the reclassification.
Photo Evidence Policy for Non-Construction Residential
Tree Task Force
May 21, 2026
Page 8 of 19
Chair McKee then moved to the question of allowing photo evidence as
a tool for staff evaluation of tree removal applications, particularly in the
residential non-construction context. He noted that approximately 80
percent of trees coming through the residential non-construction process
were dead or dying Water Oaks or Laurel Oaks, and questioned the
value of spending significant staff time on applications where the
condition of the tree was obvious.
Ms. Mansour asked whether photo evidence would be submitted
alongside an arborist report. Ms. Kennedy raised a concern that
applicants sometimes claimed trees were in poor condition as a pretext,
then proceeded to construct a pool or other improvement after the tree
was removed. Ms. Harris noted that a submission from an established
tree service would carry far more credibility than a homeowner's photos,
and that professionals would not risk their reputation over a single
application. She distinguished between professional submissions and
those from homeowners acting on their own behalf.
Mr. Lubert explained how he had used photo evidence in past cases,
noting that he looked for contextual photos that showed the surrounding
property, confirmed the tree's location relative to GIS data, and that
season and species mattered — noting, for example, that a pecan with
no leaves in winter would not be mistakenly approved as dead. He
described looking for contextual framing rather than close-up shots.
Chair McKee clarified that this policy was not being proposed for
commercial properties or for construction applications, where staff were
already conducting site visits as part of the storm water and
development review process. He emphasized the context of residential
non-construction only — a homeowner seeking to remove a single tree
with no associated construction. He noted that approximately 700
applications had come through the previous year, representing about
390 trees total and generating only approximately $20,000 in total
revenue, making the administrative stakes of any decision relatively low.
Chair McKee suggested that the town's arborist staff had good
professional judgment and that the group's endorsement of the photo
evidence approach would provide a backstop for staff if challenged
politically by a council member or neighbor. He suggested the policy
would allow staff to exercise their professional discretion in obvious
cases without requiring burdensome formal visits.
Ms. Kennedy expressed concern about a pattern she had observed in
which healthy trees were removed under various pretexts, only for the
Tree Task Force
May 21, 2026
Page 9 of 19
property to be subsequently redeveloped. Others acknowledged this
pattern but cautioned that attempting to address it through a moratorium
or time-based restriction would raise significant legal questions about
private property rights.
Mr. Quick urged the group to stay on schedule, noting the time
constraint. Chair McKee called for a straw poll on whether the group
supported allowing flexibility through photo evidence with deference to
town staff judgment. The group indicated unanimous general agreement.
Ms. Farrell noted that when staff received photo evidence and still had
questions, they retained the discretion to request an arborist report or
conduct a site visit. The policy was understood to be an option, not a
mandate.
Violations Language and Enforcement
Ms. Farrell indicated that the next item — refinement of language for tree
protection zone violations during construction, including incidents
involving root systems — did not require specific language from the task
force at this time. She stated that staff and legal counsel were capable of
improving that language, and that the recent incident near the Town
Center had made the need for clearer enforcement language apparent.
She asked for general concurrence that staff would work with legal to
improve that language.
The group indicated agreement, and Chair McKee confirmed this point
would be included in the recommendations.
Capital Projects
Ms. Farrell presented the capital projects ordinance section, noting that
the relevant language had been amended multiple times over the years
at the request of various utility entities, resulting in non-uniform
provisions. She stated that staff were not proposing any changes to the
substantive requirements — including the 160 inches-per-acre standard
or the 8-inch tree survey requirement for new capital projects — but was
recommending a cleanup of the language for clarity and consistency.
She stated that most anticipated town projects would likely result in a net
increase in trees rather than a decrease, citing the Jones Center
redevelopment as an example. She noted that fiber installation by
private companies had become a particular problem area, and that this
issue would likely be incorporated into the enforcement language
cleanup as well.
Tree Task Force
May 21, 2026
Page 10 of 19
Ms. Kennedy expressed support for the proposed cleanup. Farrell
confirmed that Mr. Morrison had already begun work on some of the
relevant language.
Chair McKee summarized the recommendation as supporting language
cleanup to address capital projects and enforcement, without changes to
the substantive content of the ordinance requirements. The group
agreed with that framing.
Single-Family Residential — Construction and Non-Construction
Ms. Farrell stated that all ordinance topics had now been addressed
except for single-family residential, which she described as the most
challenging area both for the task force and for staff. She noted that
commercial development was working well under the current system,
with the Design Review Board providing oversight and professional
applicants already engaged.
She introduced a large physical matrix board she had prepared to help
the group visualize the options and their combinations across
construction and non-construction scenarios. She explained the three
main options: keeping the ordinance as-is with only the previously
agreed changes, establishing a tree density standard, implementing a 1-
to-1 replacement requirement, or pursuing a combination. She
acknowledged the difficulty of resolving how these options might interact
— for example, whether meeting a density standard should exempt an
applicant from the 1-to-1 replacement requirement.
Ms. Farrell then summarized the key unresolved questions: the 1-to-1
replacement concept versus tree density, treatment of Class IV trees
(dead, dying, hazardous), and whether the protection threshold should
be lowered from 24 inches to 16 inches.
Chair McKee reflected on the purpose of the task force and the
overarching goal of canopy recovery. He expressed concern about
adding complexity and onerousness for single-family property owners,
noting that the group's prior recommendations had consistently focused
on making planting easier rather than harder. He acknowledged that
single-family was the most complex context, given the absence of
professional design teams that were standard in commercial
applications.
Ms. Mansour noted her experience on the Planning Commission and
clarified that the Planning Commission saw new single-family
construction and some additions, but not non-construction applications.
Tree Task Force
May 21, 2026
Page 11 of 19
She expressed interest in a land development waiver mechanism that
could be tied to density requirements. She also stated a preference for
1-to-1 tree replacement in the ground rather than payments into the tree
bank, citing situations in which subdivisions cleared multiple trees
without replacing them.
She noted that the current ordinance already required at least one
mitigation tree in the ground for most cases, with only the final amount
payable into the bank. She expressed a desire to lower the protection
threshold from 24 inches to 16 inches, stating her view that a 16-inch
tree represented a meaningful, viable specimen worth protecting. She
noted that Summerville and Greenville had both moved to a 16-inch
threshold and were reporting workable outcomes.
Ms. Harris acknowledged the value of protecting smaller trees but
cautioned against undue complexity, noting that in cases where a
property already had a high density of trees, flexibility to remove some
smaller ones was sometimes ecologically appropriate — allowing
surrounding specimens more space to grow. She described situations
where compelling property owners to go through Board of Zoning
Appeals for every 16-inch tree could generate lawsuits and resentment.
Chair McKee referenced a conversation he had had with a staff member
from Summerville, noting that even after implementing the 16-inch
threshold, Summerville continued to see very low volume going to their
tree board, because staff spent time filtering out obvious cases before
elevation.
Ms. Mansour suggested that combining the 16-inch threshold with a
density or acreage requirement might provide a workable framework.
The group began discussing Summerville's approach, which she
described as prohibiting lots from dropping below a required tree-per-
acre ratio of 20 trees per acre. She suggested that meeting the density
standard could provide flexibility to remove trees without 1-to-1
replacement, serving as a backstop.
Mr. Quick raised the question of whether tree density with the 160-
inches-per-acre and 20-trees-per-acre standard would give staff enough
flexibility while still protecting canopy. Mr. Lubert stated that some
properties would be over the standard and some would be under, and
that the density standard functioned as one layer within a larger system.
Ms. Farrell asked whether the practical effect would be that applicants
could remove trees freely as long as they maintained the density
standard. Ms. Kennedy noted that trees requiring Board of Zoning
Tree Task Force
May 21, 2026
Page 12 of 19
Appeals approval would still require that review. Ms. Mansour suggested
that language encouraging protection of 16-inch-and-larger trees could
be included even if not strictly enforceable, and that a tree survey could
be required to help staff evaluate compliance.
Mr. O'Neill offered a caution, noting that the group needed to be careful
about applying the density requirement to non-construction applications,
as this would effectively create nonconforming lots out of properties
whose owners were simply seeking to remove a single tree. Staff
concurred strongly, with Ms. Farrell stating explicitly that staff did not
recommend applying the density standard to non-construction.
Chair McKee suggested that for non-construction, the existing 1-to-1
replacement requirement was already in the ordinance and was working
reasonably well, and that the density standard should apply to
construction only. He proposed that the group think about this as: single-
family construction would require meeting the density standard (160
inches per acre / 20 trees per acre), and single-family non-construction
would be simplified to a straight 1-to-1 replacement, removing the Tre
Bank-based mitigation calculation.
Mr. Lubert noted that a common point of confusion and contention in the
current system was that applicants would replace a single tree and then
be surprised to learn they still owed mitigation inches. He described this
as the main implementation challenge. Chair McKee suggested that
simplifying non-construction to a flat 1-to-1 replacement standard without
Tree Bank mitigation would eliminate this confusion.
Discussion arose about including Class III trees (declining condition,
including the newly reclassified Laurel Oaks and Water Oaks) in the 1-
to-1 replacement requirement for non-construction. The group noted that
Class III trees currently did not require replacement, and that adding
them would incrementally increase tree planting. Mr. Quick expressed
support for this inclusion as a means of leveraging more planting
opportunities.
A broader discussion emerged about invasive species and whether
Class IV trees (including species such as Chinese Tallow and Bradford
Pear) should also require replacement or should be handled separately
through a removal incentive program. The group recognized the
ecological tension, noting that requiring permits for invasive removal
might inadvertently discourage homeowners from removing them. After
debate, the group agreed that invasive species should be handled
through a dedicated program rather than the permitting process, and
Tree Task Force
May 21, 2026
Page 13 of 19
that the ordinance should not be burdened with that complexity at this
stage.
Discussion then turned to whether native trees currently classified in
Class IV — specifically pines — deserved reconsideration. Several
members noted that pines were ecologically valuable and should
perhaps be moved to Class III. Mr. Grice and Ms. Harris both expressed
some support, but Mr. Lubert noted that the classification issue was
complex and that pines presented their own distinct management
considerations. The group agreed that the pine classification question
would be added to the next agenda for continued discussion.
Public Services Director Andy Weis offered a comment from a long-term
infrastructure perspective, noting that a recurring issue was the
placement of new trees in utility easements, which led to their eventual
removal when infrastructure maintenance was required. He urged the
group to consider whether tree placement requirements could reinforce
the importance of keeping new trees out of easement areas to ensure
long-term canopy survival. The group acknowledged this was an
important practical consideration and noted its relevance for staff review
of mitigation planting locations.
Chair McKee also introduced two additional recommendations for non-
construction mitigation: first, raising the mitigation fee from 2 times the
wholesale cost per inch to 3 times the wholesale cost, bringing it in line
with Summerville's $200-per-inch rate and reflecting the actual cost of
planting, which staff had estimated at approximately 3 times wholesale.
He argued that the current fee was below planting cost, incentivizing
payment over planting. Second, he suggested allowing greater flexibility
in where replacement trees could be planted — including pre-designated
public spaces and, with appropriate agreement from the relevant entity,
HOA common areas or other private common lands — rather than
restricting all mitigation planting to the subject property.
Mr. Grice asked for clarification on the common area planting proposal,
questioning whether a tree planted in a public park and then mowed
down would genuinely constitute mitigation. Chair McKee clarified that
under Summerville's framework, planting in public areas required staff
approval, and that planting on private common lands would require a
signed letter of agreement from the HOA or property manager
confirming maintenance responsibility. He noted that these were edge
cases, and that the vast majority of the 390 annual applications involved
dead or dying trees that were simply replaced on-site without issue.
Tree Task Force
May 21, 2026
Page 14 of 19
Ms. Harris noted that for lower-income property owners, a significant
increase in fees might be burdensome, even while acknowledging that
the increase was justified from a program funding standpoint. Chair
McKee acknowledged the concern.
Mr. O'Neill noted that the hour reserved for the ordinance discussion had
elapsed and recommended the group move forward, summarizing the
outstanding questions for the next meeting.
Chair McKee summarized the apparent agreements as follows: single-
family construction would be subject to a density standard of 160 inches
per acre and 20 trees per acre (Option 2 from the matrix); single-family
non-construction would be simplified to a 1-to-1 replacement without
Tree Bank-based mitigation, including Class III trees. He asked the
group to confirm these two points.
The group confirmed consensus on both points.
Discussion on 16-Inch Protection Threshold
Chair McKee raised the remaining unresolved question of whether the
protection threshold for residential trees should be lowered from 24
inches to 16 inches, which would subject 16-to-24-inch trees to a review
process rather than allowing their removal without review. Ms. Mansour
continued to advocate for this change, arguing that 16 inches
represented a tree with significant viability and canopy contribution, and
that other municipalities such as Summerville and Greenville had
successfully implemented it.
Ms. Harris expressed concern about the Board of Zoning Appeals as the
review body, noting that decision-making there could feel inconsistent or
emotionally driven rather than grounded in clear land use criteria. Ms.
Farrell explained the legal context of the Board of Zoning Appeals,
noting that under state law, its function in the variance context was to
determine whether a hardship existed — not merely whether a property
owner wanted to remove a tree. She noted that the Board had not been
approving many such applications recently.
Chair McKee proposed tabling this question for the next meeting, noting
that sufficient discussion had taken place and that the group had made
substantial progress on other items.
Mr. Grice suggested that rather than scheduling a special meeting, the
group could extend the June meeting slightly if needed to resolve this
item. Mr. O'Neill agreed, noting that if the revised draft report was
Tree Task Force
May 21, 2026
Page 15 of 19
circulated in advance of the June meeting, the group should have
enough material to close out the remaining issues.
Chair McKee noted that the remaining open items included the 16-inch
threshold question, the pine classification question, and the single-family
construction and non-construction framework as refined in that day's
discussion.
6. Review And Discussion Of Draft Final Report And
Recommendations
Draft Report Recommendations
• Establish a long-term canopy goal of 40% within 20 years.
• Develop a 20 year Tree Planting Plan that identifies specific planting areas ,
their priority , and the type and costs of planting that area . This would include
all land uses , not just Town owned land .
• Develop a Tree Scorecard /Dashboard /Urban Forest Tracking System to
continuously assess tree losses and gains for all the tree programs and tree
removal permitting processes (residential , commercial , and capital
improvements ).
• To achieve canopy objectives , establish a dedicated leadership role within the
Town’s organizational structure to oversee tree-related programs and
outcomes .
• To achieve canopy objectives , re-imagine existing programs to increase tree
planting volumes , engage the community at every opportunity , and seek
external sponsors and funding .
• Prioritize the majority of Tree Mitigation Funds to support tree planting and
canopy-related programs .
Tree Task Force
May 21, 2026
Page 16 of 19
Chair McKee transitioned to the draft final report, noting a brief recess
during which Chair McKee stepped out at 9:32 AM. Ms. Farrell indicated
that recording should continue during any discussion in Chair McKee’s
absence. Chair McKee returned at 9:36 AM.
Ms. Farrell and Mr. O'Neill recommended focusing exclusively on the
recommendations section of the report rather than the full narrative,
noting that consensus on the recommendations would allow the
narrative text to follow. Chair McKee agreed, and the group proceeded
through the recommendations sequentially.
First Set of Recommendations
The first recommendation — establishing a canopy goal of 40 percent
within 20 years — was presented. The group indicated agreement.
The second recommendation — establishing a scorecard and
dashboard with a tracking system to identify canopy gain or loss across
all review processes — was presented. The group indicated agreement,
noting it was essential for monitoring progress toward the stated goal.
The third recommendation — identifying a dedicated leader to drive
achievement of the canopy objective — was presented. The group
indicated agreement.
The fourth recommendation — reimagining existing tree planting
programs — was presented. The group indicated agreement.
Draft Report Recommendations
• Explore grants , sponsorships , and public private partnership opportunities to
leverage Town funding to focus on education and planting programs to
encourage private tree planting .
• Set aside a portion of the funds for tree-related financial support programs to
ensure tree benefits are available to all .
• Provide detail encroachment options for the Tree Protection Zones to enable
more flexible site use for development without tree removal
• Reduce minimum tree size for mitigation replacement from 2.5” to 1.5” for
residential non construction tree removal permits for easier planting by
residents themselves and better long term survivability of the replacement
tree. RESIDENTS MUST PROVIDE PROOF .
• Implement 160”/acre or 20 trees /acre as minimum tree cover for Residential
Non Construction (??).
• Simplify mitigation for tree removal permits for Residential Non Construction
to a simple one for one replacement in all cases and conditions with the
exception of Good Condition tree in Categories 1 and 2.
Tree Task Force
May 21, 2026
Page 17 of 19
The fifth recommendation — prioritizing tree mitigation funds to support
canopy-related programs — was presented. The group indicated
agreement.
Second Set of Recommendations
Chair McKee moved to the second slide of recommendations.
The first recommendation on this slide — exploring branch partnerships,
public-private partnerships, and town funding mechanisms to support
tree programs — was presented. The group indicated agreement.
The second recommendation — setting aside a portion of funds to
support programs and ensuring tree benefits are equitably available
through a financial hardship fund — was presented. The group indicated
enthusiastic agreement.
The third recommendation — defining specifics for tree protection zone
encroachment violations — was presented. The group agreed this was
already addressed in the ordinance discussion.
The fourth recommendation — reducing the minimum mitigation tree
size from 2.5 inches to 1.5 inches — was presented. Ms. Farrell asked
whether this reduction should apply only to non-construction or to all
residential applications. Ms. Mansour and others expressed preference
for applying it to all residential, noting that in construction scenarios, the
survivability benefit of smaller caliper trees at planting was equally
applicable. The group agreed to apply the 1.5-inch minimum to all
residential applications.
Funding Recommendation — Undergrounding Discussion
Mr. O'Neill raised a concern about the framing of the funding
recommendation, noting that as written, it appeared to set up a
competition between undergrounding utility lines and tree planting, given
that both drew from the tree mitigation fund. He cautioned that this
framing could generate opposition from residents who strongly
supported undergrounding as a form of tree protection.
Chair McKee acknowledged the concern, noting that the group's intent
had never been to oppose undergrounding, but rather to ensure
sufficient funding for tree planting programs. He proposed revising the
recommendation to emphasize the need for increased funding for tree
programs without explicitly framing it in opposition to undergrounding.
Tree Task Force
May 21, 2026
Page 18 of 19
Mr. Quick stated his position that undergrounding was properly a capital
improvement and should not draw from the tree mitigation fund, arguing
that tree mitigation money should be reserved for tree-related programs.
Mr. O'Neill suggested the group avoid prescribing a specific allocation,
and instead make a clear recommendation to town council that both
undergrounding and tree planting should be funded adequately, leaving
the specific budget decisions to council and staff. He noted that making
it appear to be a zero-sum choice between the two would likely generate
unnecessary political opposition.
Ms. Farrell noted that the town already drew undergrounding funding
from multiple sources including hospitality tax and infrastructure funds,
and that the Public Services Committee will be discussing a more
structured undergrounding funding program at an upcoming committee
meeting. She suggested that the source of undergrounding funding
would likely be addressed through that process.
Ms. Mansour supported the revision, agreeing that the recommendation
should express support for both undergrounding and tree planting and
leave budget allocation decisions to leadership.
The group agreed to revise the recommendation to support both
programs, express the need for increased funding for tree programs,
and leave the specific allocation of funds to council and staff. Chair
McKee confirmed that the subtext of the recommendation would note
support for undergrounding alongside tree planting, without framing
them as competing priorities.
Mr. Quick confirmed his support, noting the group should express that it
was happy as long as both programs were adequately funded.
Final Recommendations
Chair McKee noted that the remaining items in the recommendations —
related to single-family ordinance changes — were still in draft form
pending the earlier discussions and would be finalized at the next
meeting.
Mr. O'Neill recommended that the group focus between now and the
next meeting on: reviewing the recommendations for completeness,
identifying any missing items, and providing feedback on the issue
statements and benefit rationales supporting each recommendation, as
those narrative elements would frame the introductory sections of the
final report.
Tree Task Force
May 21, 2026
Page 19 of 19
Chair McKee proposed a timeline for revisions: staff would circulate an
updated draft of the report, incorporating the funding recommendation
revision and other agreed changes, with member feedback due by June
7. A second draft would follow during the first week of June, leaving
approximately two weeks before the June 25 meeting.
The group discussed whether a special meeting would be needed to
resolve the remaining single-family issues. Mr. Grice suggested that
rather than scheduling a standalone special meeting, the group could
simply allow the June 25 meeting to run slightly longer if needed. O'Neill
agreed, noting that with a well-prepared draft in advance, the group
should be able to complete the report without a special meeting.
Ms. Farrell reminded the group that the final report and its
recommendations, once completed, would still need to go through the
planning commission for a public hearing process before any ordinance
amendments could be adopted. She noted that staff would be
responsible for translating the task force's recommendations into formal
ordinance language, which would require additional detail not
necessarily within the scope of the task force's report.
7. Discuss Next Agenda
Chair McKee noted that the agenda for the June meeting would largely
mirror the current meeting's agenda, continuing with the work plan and
moving toward a finalized draft of the report. The group confirmed that
the outstanding single-family ordinance items — including the 16-inch
protection threshold and the pine classification question — would be
carried forward. The feedback deadline of June 7 was confirmed. The
group noted that July would be the final meeting, at which the task force
would aim to adopt the completed report and recommendations.
8. Adjourn
There being no further business, Chair McKee declared the meeting
adjourned at 10:05 AM.
Respectfully submitted,
Christine Barrett
Clerk of Council
May 21, 2026
Source: Town of Mount Pleasant website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.