RecordWell Data

_05042026-2183

Town of Mount Pleasant · Charleston County · meeting of May 4, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Mount Pleasant

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

TOWN OF MOUNT PLEASANT, SOUTH CAROLINA PLANNING COMMITTEE MAY 4, 2026 MINUTES Municipal Complex, Council Chambers PowerPoint Presentation Present: Laura Hyatt, Chair, Alex Crosby, Mike Tinkey, Kathryn Whitaker. Staff: Eric DeMoura, Michele Reed, Peter Stone, Liz Boyles, David Pagliarini 1. Call to order Ms. Hyatt called the meeting to order at 12:30 pm. 2. Approval of Minutes from the April 6, 2026 meeting Ms. Whitaker moved for approval of the minutes. Mr. Tinkey seconded the motion. All in favor. 3. Public Comments Mr. George Freeman, 2347 Hwy 17 North, and president of CAGE, spoke regarding the US17 Task Force recommendations regarding settlement communities and provided a handout for the Committee to review. He suggested that a memorandum of agreement (MOA) between the County and Town that included a recommendation to have no changes to the settlement communities and no new roads within the community. He suggested that another recommendation was to help the community construct a community center. He stated that the community is not in favor of Mount Pleasant Way and the extensive ten foot sidewalk along that roadway. He suggested another recommendation was construction of a five-foot sidewalk built within the Six Mile Community along Rifle Range Road to the traffic circle. He asked that the recommendations of the US17 Task Force and Settlement Community Task Force be upheld. He asked that the information he provided be forwarded to Town Council for review as he would not be able to attend the next Town Council meeting. There being no further comments, Ms. Hyatt continued with the agenda. Planning Committee May 4, 2026 Page 2 of 8 4. Employee years of service Ms. Reed recognized Chris Lubert for five years of outstanding service. She stated that he was hired in 2021 under the Engineering and Development Services Department as a Development Codes Inspector. He later moved to the PLAN Department. As a Senior Planner, he currently is staff liaison to our Design Review Board and GREEN Commission, is an ISA certified arborist, TRAQ certified, and is working toward his master’s degree in public administration from the College of Charleston. He has shepherded dozens of design proposals, tree planting efforts and GREEN Commission initiatives. He is experienced in the Town ordinances and is a valuable co-worker, providing his expertise and knowledge when needed. 5. Review of Planning Commission recommendations from the March 18, 2026 meeting A. R-10-26. Highway 17 Retail Village PD. Request to establish a Planned Development District for an approximately 15-acre tract of land located at the intersection of North Highway 17 and Joe Bryant Court. Proposed is a mixed-use development with 85 townhouse units Ms. Reed stated that the applicant has requested an additional deferral to the June Committee meeting. Ms. Crosby moved for approval of the deferral as requested by the applicant to the June meeting. Mr. Tinkey seconded the motion. All in favor. 6. Review of Planning Commission recommendations from the April 22, 2026 meeting a. Ten Mile Community Overlay Zoning District. Request to establish Ten Mile Community Overlay Zoning District, to coincide with Charleston County District identified by the same name, adopted 12/09/2025. Proposed standards shall apply to all development within Town limits designated as 10M-O, as indicated on the referenced map titled, “Ten Mile Community Overlay Zoning District.” Properties not presently incorporated within the Town but located within the boundaries of this map will be included in this Overlay upon Annexation by Town Council. Ms. Boyles reviewed the request with the Committee. She reviewed the timeline of events leading to the establishment of the Ten Mile Overlay District Planning Committee May 4, 2026 Page 3 of 8 and the efforts made within the past few years to protect the historic settlement communities. She reviewed the draft overlay district that includes the recommendations from the Committee and Town Council that were reviewed with the Planning Commission as well. She reviewed the differences between the County overlay district and the Town’s proposed draft overlay district with the Committee. She stated that the Planning Commission recommended approval. Ms. Whitaker asked if the area character appraisals for the historic districts have been completed. Ms. Boyles answered that her understanding is that they have not been completed. Ms. Emily Pigott, Charleston County Planning, stated that they have not received the area character appraisals from the historic communities. Ms. Whitaker asked about the formulation of historic commissions. Ms. Boyles answered that this was a discussion item later on the agenda. Mr. Tinkey asked if it is known when the area character appraisals would be completed. Ms. Boyles and Ms. Pigott answered in the negative. Mr. Tinkey asked if the recommended historic boundary is the most inclusive. Ms. Boyles answered in the affirmative. Ms. Crosby moved to recommend to Town Council approval of the overlay district as presented. Ms. Whitaker seconded the motion. All in favor. B. R-12-26. 210 Klink Lane Rezoning. Request to Rezone 210 Klink Lane from AB-1, Areawide Business District-1 District, to R-2, Low-Density Residential District. The 0.13-acre parcel is further indicated as TMS No.532-01-00-147. Mr. Stone reviewed the request with the Committee. He stated that there have been several rezoning requests within this block to rezone from commercial to residential since the ordinance change in 2010. He reviewed the surrounding existing uses with the Committee and stated that the Planning Commission recommended approval on a 6 to 1 vote. Ms. Whitaker asked the reasoning for the recommendation from the Planning Commission. Mr. Stone answered that there were public comments from Planning Committee May 4, 2026 Page 4 of 8 surrounding residents desiring residential neighbors and the viability of being developed as a commercial property were the main considerations. Mr. Tinkey stated that he is not in favor of the request. He suggested that the residential properties on May Lane are distinctly different from the proposed property in terms of being internal to the neighborhood and decidedly residential. The subject property is external to Coleman Blvd and has mixed use. Additionally, this property and the property behind it fronting on Coleman Blvd has the same owner, so there is the possibility to aggregate the properties and develop them as one cohesive use. He stated that the property could have mixed use under the current zoning with commercial on the bottom floor and residential above. Mr. Tinkey moved to recommend to Town Council denial of the request. Ms. Crosby seconded the motion. Ms. Hyatt asked if it rezoned residential how would the commercial property behind it have access. Mr. Stone answered that there is access to the commercial property from Coleman Blvd. He noted that if rezoned residential, it would mean that the surrounding commercial property would be required to install buffers if redeveloped. The Committee discussed access for the two properties with staff. Mr. Tinkey asked if the owners of the commercial property on Coleman Blvd have indicated any development plans. Mr. Stone answered that several commercial options have been discussed. Ms. Hyatt called for a vote on the motion. All in favor. C. Future Land Use/Public-Institutional (PI) Zoning. Discussion and possible action pertaining to the Comprehensive Plan Future Land Use Map recommendation as it relates to Public Institutional Zoning Designations. Ms. Hyatt stated that the Committee requested this go to the Planning Commission for discussion. Ms. Reed reviewed this item with the Committee. She reviewed the properties recommended for PI zoning and their current zonings with the Committee. She stated that many of the properties were never rezoned to PI Planning Committee May 4, 2026 Page 5 of 8 zoning as the existing use was allowed under the current residential zoning. She stated that a school use requires a special exception and is not a use by right under the residential zoning. Ms. Reed stated that the Planning Commission reviewed possible options and questioned what problem was trying to be resolved. She stated that the Planning Commission expressed concerns with rezoning all of the properties to PI zoning. She stated that before the adoption of the new zoning code, density was established in the Comprehensive Plan, so if a property was to be developed, the recommended zoning and corresponding density in the Comprehensive Plan was utilized. If the density and recommended zoning were not consistent with the current proposal, a request to change the Comprehensive Plan would have to be submitted to establish density. If that Comprehensive Plan change request was denied, the property could not be developed as currently zoned and therefore could be considered a taking. She stated that a use waiver was also considered and discussed by the Commission, but this is not a viable option. Ms. Whitaker suggested that the current issue is that Town Council was taken out of the review process. Ms. Reed stated that moving the density to the Zoning Code and out of the Comprehensive Plan, the Comprehensive Plan does not need to be amended. Ms. Whitaker asked what the risk would be for the Town if we reverted to prior to the change in 2010. Mr. Pagliarini answered that there is a risk of denial of the Comprehensive Plan amendment could be considered arbitrary and capricious. He suggested that rules of use, which includes density, should be contained under the zoning designation. Mr. Tinkey asked if many, if not all properties listed were zoned prior to development or built prior to zoning being assigned. Ms. Reed answered that the properties with school and church uses were originally zoned residential. She stated that James B. Edwards rezoned to PI instead of going forward with a special exception when they were looking to redevelop. Mr. Tinkey suggested that moving forward with rezoning the school properties to PI “makes sense” and should be considered. He suggested that moving forward with rezoning of the church properties should be considered as a possible next step, if it is determined to be the best appropriate action. Mr. Tinkey asked if a property zoned residential and currently used as a church would need approval if they wanted to use a portion of the property for residential homes. Ms. Reed answered in the Planning Committee May 4, 2026 Page 6 of 8 affirmative and stated that they would need sketch plan approval from the Planning Commission. Ms. Whitaker suggested analyzing the properties listed and making a recommendation on whether it is appropriate to be rezoned PI. Ms. Hyatt asked if the existing uses allowed as a right under the residential zoning. Ms. Reed answered in the affirmative, with the caveat that school use requires a special exception. Ms. Hyatt asked what language in the Zoning Code was removed and suggested that the height map is a similar example. Ms. Reed clarified that the height map is a zoning map and not a future recommendation. She stated that the Comprehensive Plan and future land use is a guiding document. She stated that before the new zoning code was adopted, the density was listed in the Comprehensive Plan and not in the Zoning Code, so any density changes desired would require an amendment to the Comprehensive Plan. She stated that during the Zoning Code rewrite, the consultants noted that having the density in the Comprehensive Plan was highly unusual and should be moved back to the Zoning Code. Ms. Hyatt suggested that this change appears to remove Town Council oversight of these types of changes. Mr. Tinkey expressed concern with an existing use being eliminated in the future and there could be unintentional consequences for use of the property as residential. Mr. Tinkey moved to have staff review those properties with an existing school use to determine if rezoning to PI zoning would be appropriate. Ms. Whitaker seconded the motion. All in favor. Mr. Tinkey suggested that any detrimental unintended consequences to rezoning the properties to PI zoning should be identified and the potential impact of rezoning to PI zoning. The Committee agreed that the possibility of rezoning existing school properties to PI zoning should be sent to the Planning Commission for further discussion. Planning Committee May 4, 2026 Page 7 of 8 7. Discuss Options for Reviewing Proposed Development in the Ten Mile and other Settlement Communities that are designated as historic. Ms. Reed reviewed this item with the Committee. She stated that further discussion is needed to determine how to move forward in reviewing development of properties in the historic settlement communities. She reviewed possible options with the Commission as follows: ➢ Rely on Zoning Overlay District only ➢ Coordinate with Charleston County on a Joint Commission ➢ Expand Existing Historic District Preservation Commission (HDPC) ➢ Create Separate Historic Commission specific to Settlement Communities East of the Cooper River ➢ Deny Annexations for properties in a County Historic District Ms. Whitaker suggested that expanding HDPC would be her preference as this creates a unified commission within the Town; however, not having the area character appraisals completed and not knowing when they would be available is a concern. She suggested that without the area character appraisals, the timelier option might be to see if a joint commission with Charleston County is legally viable. Mr. Tinkey suggested that working with Charleston County on a joint commission is a logical option. He agreed that the area character appraisals are needed to have further discussion on expanding HDPC and how that could be accomplished or if a separate historic commission specific to the settlement communities needs to be established. He suggested that until these could be determined, denying annexation would be the best option. Ms. Crosby agreed that it could be problematic in expanding HDPC and suggested that a joint commission is currently the best option. Ms. Hyatt suggested that the overlay district could govern the review and preservation of the neighborhood, like how the Design Review Board operates. Ms. Boyles answered that once the area character appraisals were completed, the overlay district could be amended to incorporate those design standards / guidelines, which staff could then use for review and approvals; however, this would be a staff level approval as opposed to having public input. Planning Committee May 4, 2026 Page 8 of 8 Ms. Reed suggested that there are more issues that would come into play that would not be related to zoning. M s. Pigott explained the County’s process for historically designated settlement communities. She stated that this includes the area character appraisal and identifying contributing historic resources. She stated that they also follow the Secretary of Interior standards for treatment of historic properties. She stated that some of the issues addressed were the placement of street trees due to the height of the proposed structure, elevation of buildings beyond the required flood zone, etc. Ms. Whitaker suggested that the historic communities voiced the desire to have guidelines for those reviewing the requests, so it is less subjective. Mr. Tinkey suggested that having the guidelines included in the Zoning Code is a benefit and suggested that the area character appraisal would be a good source of those guidelines. He suggested that it would be important to have the historic commission made up of residents within the community. Ms. Crosby asked if the joint commission would be adding members to the existing historic commission or an entirely new joint commission. Mr. Pagliarini answered that as proposed it would be a joint commission made up of members from the Town and County. He suggested that he is not certain that this could be legally established and would have to confer with the County attorneys. He suggested that this was very premature as what is desired to be enforced needs to be determined before having discussion on how to establish the governing commission. The Committee agreed that the legality of having a joint commission with the county should be explored as the first option with the possibility of expanding the historic district preservation commission in the future. 8. Adjourn There being no further business, the meeting adjourned at 1:42 pm. Submitted by, L. Lynes PlanComm05042026

Source: Town of Mount Pleasant website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.