_04302026-2173
Town of Mount Pleasant · Charleston County · meeting of Apr 30, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Mount Pleasant
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
TREE TASK FORCE
Thursday, April 30, 2026
8:00 a.m.
Municipal Complex, Committee Meeting Room
100 Ann Edwards Lane, Mount Pleasant, SC 29464
MI
NUTES
Cl
ick here to listen to the recording.
Discussion Topics
1. Call to Order
Chair McKee called the April meeting of the Tree Task Force to order at
8:00 a.m. Members Shanna Harris, Michelle Mansour, George Grice,
and Deidre Kennedy were all present. David Quick arrived at 8:02 a.m.
Edward Oswald was absent.
2. Approval of Agenda
Chair McKee requested a motion to approve the agenda.
Ms. Mansour moved to approve the agenda, seconded by Ms.
Kennedy. The motion carried by unanimous vote.
3. Approval of Minutes from March 19, 2026 Meeting
Chair McKee requested a motion to approve the minutes from the
previous meeting.
Ms. Mansour moved to approve the minutes from the March 19,
2026 meeting, seconded by Ms. Kennedy. The motion carried by
unanimous vote.
4. Public Comment
Chair McKee opened the public comment period, noting that comments
would be limited to two and a half minutes per speaker. (Mr. Quick
arrived at 8:02 a.m.)
Lisa Schnipke expressed gratitude to the Task Force members for their
service and acknowledged the Town's community outreach efforts
related to tree restoration and preservation. She noted that the Town
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 2 of 25
had recently hosted a program at the library conducted by two of the
Town's arborists, which included a tree giveaway. She remarked that
she had attended numerous community events at which the Town had a
presence to promote its tree programs, and she encouraged the Task
Force to build on that momentum.
Ms. Schnipke drew the Task Force's attention to two large capital
improvement projects coming up that she indicated would have a
significant impact on the Town's tree canopy, citing statistics she had
observed at a recent meeting of the GREEN Commission. She urged the
Task Force to recommend that the Town do more than the minimum
required by ordinance with respect to mitigation, and she specifically
encouraged that mitigation trees be planted in or near the areas where
trees are being removed, to the greatest extent possible. She further
called for increased public engagement to restore the canopy on
privately owned properties and to encourage businesses to do the same.
She asked the Task Force to share with the community what work was
being accomplished and how residents could participate — not only in
retaining existing trees, but in restoring the broader canopy. She
encouraged the Task Force to acknowledge the anticipated canopy loss
from upcoming large projects and to outline a proactive plan to address
that loss through more education, more engagement, and more trees
planted.
Mike Tinkey addressed the Task Force and commended the Town for
leading by example through its comprehensive plan, the community
forest master plan, the tree ordinance, and the wetlands ordinance,
noting that these were all passed unanimously and reflect strong public
support. He observed that tree-related initiatives bring the community
together and have near-unanimous public backing.
Mr. Tinkey emphasized the importance of mitigating the impact of large
capital projects, referencing a situation in which a large number of trees
would be removed while the ordinance might require a comparatively
small number of replacement trees. He described this imbalance as
sending a contradictory message to the public. Mr. Tinkey argued that to
address this, the Town must increase the net number of new trees
planted and develop a clear accounting of how many trees are lost each
year so that the net new tree figure can be meaningfully calculated. Mr.
Tinkey raised the question of funding, suggesting that if net new trees
were set at a certain goal, the actual planting effort might need to be
substantially larger to compensate for removals, and asked how that
effort would be funded. He encouraged the Task Force to get ahead of
these challenges, acknowledging that strong community programs such
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 3 of 25
as the tree giveaway and the Blessing of the Fleet event were positive
signs that momentum was building.
5. Review of March 19 Meeting Discussion
Chair McKee invited members to raise any points or questions arising
from the previous month's meeting. Hearing limited response, Chair
McKee offered one observation related to the budget discussions. Chair
McKee noted that there was an additional one hundred thousand dollars
• Fund Tree Coordinator position
• Track total number of trees planted in Mount Pleasant
through all programs
• Continue current programs
• Protect tree bank funds
• Further disussion of pay versus plant and hardship
policy
Recap from March
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 4 of 25
proposed in the budget for the tree canopy program, which had not yet
received final reading but represented a meaningful step forward. Chair
McKee expressed that this reflected the encouraging reception of the
Task Force's work to date.
Chair McKee also relayed that Task Force member Oswald had sent his
apologies for being unable to attend and had communicated that he felt
education and community engagement were important considerations
moving forward. Chair McKee observed that community engagement
efforts were already visible at the Blessing of the Fleet tree giveaway
and in Clemson Extension materials that tied tree planting to stormwater
management. Chair McKee suggested that some of the partnerships
needed for education and outreach already exist and do not need to be
created from scratch. Chair McKee indicated a desire to ensure that
education and outreach would be included as a formal topic of
discussion following the review of the ordinance.
Mr. Quick noted that he had first learned at the GREEN Commission
meeting on Tuesday that there was an existing fifty thousand dollars for
the tree canopy program that had not been spent in the current budget
year. He expressed that this was news to many commissioners present
at that meeting and asked whether those unspent funds would carry
over in addition to the new one hundred thousand dollars. He also
indicated he had initially assumed the one hundred thousand dollars was
intended to fund a coordinator position.
Assistant Town Administrator Christiane Farrell clarified that the one
hundred thousand dollars was allocated for the canopy program itself,
not for a staff position. She explained that with respect to a new position,
the Task Force's final recommendations would need to be presented to
Town Council, which would then make a determination as to whether to
move forward with a position. She noted that such a decision would
likely require a mid-year budget adjustment. Regarding the unspent fifty
thousand dollars, she indicated she would need to check with the Chief
Financial Officer, who was not present at the meeting.
Chair McKee then directed the group's attention to the draft report,
noting that a preliminary draft had been recently circulated by Ms.
Kennedy. Chair McKee described the draft as generally organized
around the report outline and encouraged all members to review it
carefully between this meeting and the next, and to submit specific
suggestions for each of the six sections to Ms. Kennedy, who had
volunteered to serve as editor. Chair McKee emphasized that Ms.
Kennedy needed input from all members for the document to reflect the
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 5 of 25
work of the full group. Ms. Farrell noted she had brought hard copies to
distribute at the end of the meeting.
6. Work Plan — TTF 2026 Work Plan
6a. Review and Discussion of Tree Protection Zoning Ordinances
and Policies
Mr. O'Neill suggested that staff be allowed to present the full slide deck
before the group engaged in detailed questions or discussion. He
recommended that members take notes during the presentation and
consolidate their questions afterward, noting that the group tended to be
diverted quickly if discussion began slide by slide. Chair McKee and the
group agreed to this approach.
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 6 of 25
Ms. Farrell introduced the presentation, explaining how the slides had
been structured. She noted that the work had been challenging to
organize given the breadth of topics that had been discussed since the
Task Force began its work the previous summer. She explained that the
slides were organized in accordance with the topics identified in the
original work plan, each addressing a particular issue or set of issues the
group had identified and then offering considerations for potential
ordinance amendments. She indicated that over the past month she had
spoken individually with several Task Force members and that staff had
also met as a group, including a session the previous day, to refine the
final slide deck. She described the summary slide at the end as
reflecting changes that staff believed would be broadly acceptable to the
Task Force and consistent with the conversations that had taken place
over the course of the Task Force’s work.
Ms. Farrell noted that she had previously emailed the full comparative
ordinance analysis, including materials compiled by Ms. Kennedy and by
an intern from the prior summer, and expressed the view that attempting
to walk through that comparison in the meeting itself would be too time-
consuming. She suggested the group could return to that comparative
material following the current discussion if members identified particular
provisions from other municipalities that they wished to highlight.
Tree Protection Zone
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 7 of 25
Ms. Farrell addressed the first topic, the tree protection zone, which she
acknowledged had been discussed repeatedly over the life of the Task
Force. She explained that the current ordinance allows some flexibility
for encroachment into the tree protection zone but does not define the
permissible extent of that encroachment with precision. She indicated
that this ambiguity was the source of recurring problems and that staff's
recommendation was to allow modifications to the tree protection zone
up to a defined percentage, accompanied by an arborist report
specifying how the tree should be protected during the construction
period.
Ms. Mansour expressed support for requiring an arborist report tied to
any adjustment to the tree protection zone, calling it a good idea that
would allow more flexibility while maintaining accountability. Ms.
Kennedy agreed that a plan should accompany any such report.
Ms. Farrell asked the group whether they preferred a maximum
encroachment of twenty percent or twenty-five percent. Ms. Harris
indicated her preference for twenty percent and elaborated at length on
what a meaningful arborist report should contain. She suggested that the
report should address the condition of the tree, an approximate
percentage of canopy loss, a calculation of root loss, an encroachment
percentage, and confirmation that the arborist had physically assessed
the tree rather than simply relying on survey data. She observed that
surveys often contain inconsistencies in species identification and
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 8 of 25
measurements, and that a physical assessment corrects for those
discrepancies. She also noted that the arborist should assess all
protected trees on the lot when construction is occurring, not only the
tree most directly affected. She expressed frustration that some arborist
reports she had reviewed were insufficiently detailed, amounting to little
more than a brief statement that proposed work would be acceptable,
and she advocated for a more robust, enumerated checklist.
Ms. Mansour asked whether a formal checklist could be created to
accompany the site plan. Harris confirmed that this had been among her
earlier recommendations, though she indicated she would want to
review relevant course materials before finalizing a list.
Senior Planner Chris Lubert offered his perspective from staff's
experience. He suggested that if a twenty percent encroachment limit
were adopted, it would be beneficial to incorporate a secondary, inner
zone analogous to what Charleston County uses — a zone in which no
encroachment would be permitted because it encompasses the area
where structural roots are found. He noted that this two-tiered approach
would prevent the encroachment from reaching all the way to the trunk
flare of the tree, even within the allowable twenty percent. He
acknowledged that every arborist brings different experience to these
evaluations and that best practices are grounded in accumulated field
experience rather than a single universal standard.
Ms. Harris offered a detailed illustration of her concern, describing how,
for a large-diameter tree, twenty-five percent encroachment could
theoretically extend all the way into the trunk flare area, which she
described as unacceptable. She also raised the issue of how pool
installations can sever root systems even when the pool structure itself
falls outside the technical encroachment calculation, noting that utility
trenching for plumbing lines severs roots that are never accounted for in
a standard encroachment review. She observed that the direction of
encroachment relative to the tree also matters because root systems are
not symmetric, and that the calculus differs by species — live oaks being
generally more tolerant of encroachment than red oaks if work is done
properly.
Mr. Grice expressed support for a two-tiered protection zone, noting that
certain species, particularly red oaks, should have a no-touch inner
zone. Mr. Lubert confirmed that this kind of approach had been used in
other jurisdictions and offered to consult with county staff about their
experience. Mr. Grice suggested that rather than specifying individual
species, the inner protection zone could be applied broadly to a family of
trees, which would reduce the administrative burden. Mr. Quick
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 9 of 25
proposed applying the two-tiered approach uniformly to all oaks rather
than selecting individual species. Ms. Harris indicated she was
comfortable with that approach, though she noted that a flat rule could
be complicated in some cases, such as co-dominant trees — two trees
whose trunks have grown together — because the measurement
methodology could yield a protection zone radius that seems
disproportionate to the practical situation.
Mr. Lubert noted that while a two-tiered approach adds specificity, it can
become difficult to communicate clearly to surveyors and homeowners
and risks becoming burdensome. He indicated that applying the inner
zone uniformly across the board might be simpler in practice, and that at
the end of the day, one would not want structural roots that close to a
structure regardless.
Ms. Kennedy raised the question of whether arborist reports must come
from a certified arborist specifically or whether other qualifications would
be accepted. Lubert confirmed that other qualifications exist, though he
noted he could not enumerate them from memory.
The group discussed the scenario of existing homes that are already
inside the tree protection zone and are undertaking renovations. Ms.
Kennedy noted that in those cases, homeowners engaging in
renovations — for example, adding a porch — may be required to move
footings to avoid roots, which can result in significant engineering work.
Mr. Lubert suggested that in those situations, the operative principle
would be that the homeowner cannot encroach any further into the tree
protection zone than already exists, rather than a penalty being
assessed for the existing condition. Ms. Harris confirmed that existing
footprint situations would be treated differently from new encroachment.
Mr. Lubert indicated that cases which push beyond the allowable
encroachment, including some renovation situations, would need to go
to the Board of Zoning Appeals. Ms. Harris noted that the Board of
Zoning Appeals process is rigorous and does not guarantee approval.
Following the discussion, Chair McKee summarized the group's
emerging consensus: a twenty percent maximum encroachment limit, a
critical root zone in which no encroachment is permitted, an
accompanying arborist plan with defined checklist items, and a
requirement for periodic arborist check-ins during the construction
period. Chair McKee noted that while the Task Force was establishing
the general direction of these recommendations, the actual drafting of
ordinance language would occur later through a separate public
process. Ms. Farrell confirmed that what was needed from the Task
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 10 of 25
Force at this stage was directional recommendations and indicated that
staff would take the ideas discussed and begin laying them out in
preparation for future review.
Single Family versus Commercial
Ms. Farrell moved to the second topic, explaining that under the current
ordinance, every type of development except single-family residential is
subject to a minimum standard of one hundred sixty inches per acre.
She noted that single-family residential properties are often the smallest
parcels being regulated, yet they face the same mitigation requirements
as other property types, which can in some cases be more than the
property can realistically accommodate and can be significantly more
expensive for the homeowner.
Ms. Farrell presented two categories of consideration. The first was for
single-family construction — situations where an addition, pool, or porch
is being added — and the suggestion was to establish a minimum tree
density standard for those properties, similar to the standard already in
place for commercial development. The second category was for single-
family non-construction, meaning a homeowner who simply wants to
remove a tree not connected to any construction project. For that
category, staff recommended a simplified one-to-one replacement
requirement rather than an inch-based mitigation calculation.
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 11 of 25
Ms. Farrell noted that the vast majority of tree removal permit
applications that the planning department processes are for trees in poor
or declining condition, and that the one-to-one replacement concept was
designed to simplify the process, making it easy for homeowners to
understand while still ensuring that removed trees are replaced.
Planning Director Michelle Reed suggested that for single-family
residential, using a tree count rather than an inch calculation would be
more accessible to the average homeowner, who is unlikely to know the
exact inch measurements of all trees on their property. She contrasted
this with commercial developers, who routinely engage surveyors for this
purpose. Ms. Farrell acknowledged the distinction between single-family
construction and non-construction scenarios and indicated that staff had
debated this question carefully, ultimately concluding that the two
situations warranted different treatment. She explained that for non-
construction permits — where the homeowner simply wants to remove a
declining tree — the one-to-one replacement concept was most
appropriate, while for construction-related permits, establishing a
minimum density standard made more sense.
Chair McKee cited the Summerville ordinance as an example of a
jurisdiction that addresses minimum density in both inch-based and tree-
count terms, specifying both a minimum of one hundred sixty inches per
acre and a minimum of twenty trees per acre, with either standard
satisfying the requirement. Chair McKee noted that this kind of baseline
serves two purposes: it makes it easier to approve a removal when the
lot already has sufficient density, and it creates a minimum threshold
below which trees must be added rather than simply removed.
Mr. Grice expressed strong support for a minimum tree density standard
for residential properties, noting his frustration with seeing house
footprints covering ninety percent of a lot with the remaining space
occupied by a pool.
Mr. Lubert noted that staff had reviewed aerial maps of several smaller
lots and evaluated them against Summerville's twenty-trees-per-acre
standard, finding it to be a reasonable baseline. He flagged that invasive
species should not count toward the minimum.
Ms. Reed reiterated that for the average homeowner, a tree count is
simply easier to understand than an inch calculation, and that making
compliance easier encourages participation. Ms. Mansour indicated she
believed using both the inch standard and the tree count, as
Summerville does, was the best approach, with the inch standard
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 12 of 25
applying primarily to new construction and the tree count being the more
accessible metric for renovation and non-construction situations.
Ms. Harris offered a practical caution, noting that some small lots — she
used the example of quarter-acre lots in the Old Village neighborhood
with several large live oaks already present — cannot realistically
accommodate additional trees, and that requiring such lots to meet a
twenty-trees-per-acre standard could be disproportionate. The group
acknowledged this tension.
Ms. Mansour described her own experience in a community with a
dense canopy where mitigation planting is difficult simply because there
is no room to put new trees, further illustrating the need for flexibility.
The group reached general agreement that a minimum residential
density standard — one hundred sixty inches per acre or twenty trees
per acre, either standard satisfying the requirement — should apply to
single-family properties with construction, while a simplified one-to-one
replacement rule should apply for single-family non-construction permits.
The group further agreed that existing commercial processes should not
be altered, as those were functioning well.
Canopy versus Inches
Ms. Farrell addressed the next topic briefly, noting that while the Task
Force's overarching goal is to increase tree canopy, the current
ordinance measures everything in terms of trunk diameter inches, and
shifting to a canopy-based measurement system raises difficult
questions about how canopy would be quantified and measured in
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 13 of 25
practice. She suggested that this was likely too major a structural
change to pursue immediately but observed that by focusing on
replacement — getting trees back in the ground — the Task Force could
achieve canopy maintenance and growth without needing to overhaul
the measurement system at this stage. She indicated this topic might be
returned to in the future.
Increasing Preservation
Ms. Farrell introduced the question of protection thresholds, explaining
that under the current ordinance, single-family property owners can
remove trees between sixteen and twenty-four inches in diameter
through the standard permitting process with mitigation, while trees over
twenty-four inches require a variance from the Board of Zoning Appeals.
She described discussions that had occurred both within the Task Force
and more broadly about whether the threshold at which trees are
formally protected — meaning referred to the Board of Zoning Appeals
— should be reduced from twenty-four inches to sixteen inches.
Ms. Farrell expressed staff's concern that reducing the protection
threshold would significantly increase the workload of the Board of
Zoning Appeals, particularly at a time when the goal was to increase
efficiency. She suggested that through the other amendments being
discussed — particularly the tree protection zone modifications and the
minimum density standard — the Task Force could achieve meaningful
preservation outcomes without necessarily changing the inch threshold
for Board of Zoning Appeals review.
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 14 of 25
Ms. Kennedy argued in favor of reducing the threshold to sixteen inches,
noting that most comparable municipalities use sixteen inches and that
allowing trees between sixteen and twenty-four inches to be removed
easily was eliminating the next generation of canopy. Mr. Quick echoed
this concern, colorfully describing the practice as harming the
community's young adult trees.
Ms. Harris indicated she was genuinely uncertain about this
recommendation and felt her perspective was complicated by a conflict
of interest given her professional role. She expressed concern that
reducing the threshold to sixteen inches would create significant
complications across the board.
Ms. Mansour suggested a middle path, proposing that a lower threshold
of sixteen inches might apply specifically to historic trees while a higher
threshold remained in place for other protected trees. She recalled
seeing a similar tiered structure in another jurisdiction's ordinance.
Chair McKee offered a more nuanced framing of the issue, arguing that
the real question was whether trees in the sixteen to twenty-four inch
range — trees that are healthy, providing substantial canopy, and
offering meaningful shade and stormwater benefits — should be more
difficult to remove than the current ordinance allows. Chair McKee
observed that under the current system, the practical standard is that
mitigation is the only protection: as long as an applicant is willing to pay
the mitigation fee or plant replacement trees, removal is approved. Chair
McKee expressed discomfort with this dynamic, particularly for healthy
trees in the mid-size range that have grown for decades and provide
tangible benefits to the neighborhood.
Ms. Reed and Ms. Farrell noted that the Board of Zoning Appeals
applies a strict hardship standard when hearing variance requests, and
that hardships must be specific to the property and cannot be financial or
medical in nature. Ms. Reed observed that the Board has historically
denied many requests even where the average person might have
expected approval. Farrell added that because the hardship standard is
so difficult to meet, some property owners who want to remove trees in
the sixteen to twenty-four inch range simply proceed without permits,
creating enforcement challenges.
Mr. Lubert explained that under the current ordinance, there is effectively
no mechanism for staff to deny a removal request for a tree under
twenty-four inches — the process functions as a checklist, and once the
criteria are met, the permit is issued. He suggested that the minimum
density standard being discussed could serve as a partial remedy: if
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 15 of 25
removal of a tree in the sixteen to twenty-four inch range would cause
the property to fall below the minimum density, that could serve as a
basis for requiring additional planting before removal could be approved.
Chair McKee pushed back on the idea that a density-based replacement
requirement provides meaningful protection, noting that an applicant
could simply plant new trees in a corner of the yard and still receive
approval to remove the valuable mid-size tree. Chair McKee expressed
the view that the community's interests in shade, stormwater
management, and canopy coverage argue for a harder look at trees in
this size range.
Ms. Reed raised the issue of pending litigation, noting that the Town is
currently engaged in legal proceedings over tree removal denials, with
mediation having failed to resolve those disputes. She cautioned that
completely prohibiting removal of trees in the sixteen to twenty-four inch
range could raise constitutional property rights concerns.
The discussion remained unresolved, with Chair McKee noting that the
group held genuinely different views on this topic. Chair McKee
suggested that Mr. Quick's request for staff to prepare a clear options
memo — laying out the various approaches with their respective
implications, particularly in light of the minimum density standard —
would be the most productive path forward. Staff agreed to prepare this
analysis in advance of the next meeting.
Mitigation
Mitigation
• Issue:
• Expense and tree size
• Mitigation compliance (single family non-construction)
• No mitigation required for dead or hazardous trees, (some
TTF members have discussed requiring replacement)
• Consideration:
• Decrease tree replacement size to less than 2.5 inches
• Require 1 to 1 tree replacement instead of inches for single
family nonconstruction
• Require mitigation payment up front for SF non-construction
• Required replacement for dead trees
• Mitigation rate currently $143/ inch
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 16 of 25
Ms. Farrell addressed the mitigation topic, identifying the key issues as
the expense of mitigation relative to tree size, the difficulty of enforcing
mitigation requirements for single-family non-construction permits, and
ongoing discussions about whether mitigation should be required at all
for dead or hazardous trees.
On the question of the size of replacement trees, Ms. Farrell proposed
reducing the required caliper size of mitigation trees from two and a half
inches to one and a half inches. She explained that smaller trees are
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 17 of 25
more affordable for homeowners, more feasible to plant without
professional assistance, and potentially more available from nurseries if
the Town communicates clearly what it is requiring. She noted that Mr.
Bernard, the Town arborist who was involved in staff discussions, had
suggested that nurseries would begin stocking smaller caliper trees if
they knew there was consistent demand.
Ms. Farrell reiterated staff's support for the one-to-one replacement
concept for single-family non-construction permits, explaining that
requiring an upfront mitigation payment in lieu of planting was not
recommended because the payment does not guarantee that a tree will
ultimately be planted on the property, and because administering
refunds adds an extra layer of administrative complexity.
On the question of whether mitigation should be required for the removal
of dead trees, Ms. Farrell noted that there was currently no mitigation
requirement for water oaks in poor condition, while live oaks in declining
condition still carry some mitigation obligation depending on their class.
She indicated this was a point requiring further discussion by the group.
Ms. Farrell stated that staff's strong preference was for trees in the
ground rather than mitigation payments, noting that the group appeared
to share this value based on all prior discussions.
The group engaged in an extended discussion about how the one-to-one
replacement concept should apply across different tree classes and
conditions. Mr. Grice expressed enthusiasm for the one-to-one
replacement concept, noting from personal experience that friends and
family members are frequently confused by the current inch-based
mitigation system.
Chair McKee laid out the core tension in the discussion: the staff's
proposal was to apply the one-to-one replacement concept to trees in
declining or poor condition while continuing to require traditional inch-
based mitigation for trees in fair or good condition. Chair McKee noted
that approximately eighty percent of residential non-construction tree
removal permits involve trees in declining or poor condition, and that
under the current ordinance, many of those trees carry no mitigation
requirement at all. Chair McKee expressed support for requiring
replacement for all removed trees, including those that are dead or
dying, even if the replacement requirement is reduced to a more
manageable one and a half inch tree.
Mr. Lubert acknowledged the enforcement difficulty of requiring
replacement for dead trees, explaining that it would be very hard to ticket
someone for removing a dead tree, that courts would be unlikely to
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 18 of 25
uphold such a citation, and that homeowners who know they face a
replacement requirement for dead trees may simply choose not to pull a
permit, removing the tree illegally without any documentation.
Ms. Harris noted that photo submission requirements — where
homeowners submit a photograph as evidence of the planted
replacement tree — could help address this compliance issue while
reducing staff time in the field. Other members acknowledged that some
homeowners might attempt to submit false photographs, but the group
generally agreed that even partial compliance would represent a
meaningful improvement over the status quo.
After further discussion, the group reached a working consensus on the
following framework for residential non-construction permits: trees in
poor or declining condition in any class would require a one-to-one
replacement with a one and a half inch tree from Class 1 or Class 2
without an additional monetary mitigation payment; trees in fair or good
condition in Classes 1 or 2 would still be subject to the traditional
mitigation requirement in addition to the one-to-one replacement; and
the one-to-one replacement requirement would apply regardless of the
class of the removed tree, from Class 1 through Class 3.
Quick offered a clear summary formulation: Class 1 and 2 trees in fair to
good condition — plant a replacement tree and pay mitigation; Class 3
trees or any tree in poor or declining condition — one-to-one
replacement only, no additional mitigation payment; Class 4 trees — no
mitigation or replacement currently required, and the group appeared
comfortable leaving that in place.
Mr. Lubert confirmed that this formulation reflected what staff had been
thinking and that it was intended to make the process easier for people
who are genuinely trying to do the right thing — for example, a
homeowner who has a hazardous but not yet dead live oak and wants to
remove it safely. Under the current system, that homeowner may face a
mitigation obligation so large that they leave the hazardous tree in place
rather than pay it. Under the proposed system, they would simply need
to plant a replacement tree.
Ms. Harris expressed support for this framework and noted that while
she was initially hesitant about eliminating monetary mitigation for some
categories of trees, the reality that the Town collects only approximately
twenty thousand dollars per year from residential non-construction
mitigation after substantial staff effort chasing compliance made the
tradeoff more acceptable.
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 19 of 25
Chair McKee observed that the ultimate goal is trees in the ground
rather than money in the fund, and that a simplified system with more
reliable compliance achieves more of the actual canopy goal than a
more complex system with inconsistent enforcement.
Process Efficiencies
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 20 of 25
Ms. Farrell noted that the inventory data previously shared with the Task
Force illustrated that the planning department's workload is heavily
concentrated in the single-family non-construction process, involving
multiple site visits, extensive communication, disputes over tree
condition assessments, and the need to obtain structural engineer
reports in some cases. She noted that the vast majority of time-
consuming cases involve Laurel Oaks and Water Oaks, which
collectively account for approximately eighty percent of all trees
inspected as dead, declining, or hazardous.
Ms. Farrell presented the possibility of reclassifying Laurel Oaks, which
are currently Class 2, to bring them in line with Water Oaks, which are
Class 3. She explained that Mr. Lubert spends considerable time on
disputes in which applicants attempt to argue that a Laurel Oak is
actually a Water Oak, because a lower classification reduces the
mitigation requirement. She indicated that moving Laurel Oaks to Class
3 would eliminate this source of disputes, as the two species are very
similar in character and face similar longevity challenges.
Mr. Lubert confirmed this dynamic, noting that the two species are nearly
indistinguishable to many people and that the classification difference
creates an incentive for misidentification.
Ms. Farrell introduced the concept of allowing photo submittal as
evidence of compliance, both for confirming the condition of a dead tree
at the time of removal and for confirming that a replacement tree has
been planted. She noted that this was a policy matter rather than an
ordinance amendment, but that it could be formally recommended by the
Task Force and would significantly reduce the amount of staff time spent
in the field.
Enforcement
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 21 of 25
Ms. Farrell addressed enforcement, noting that while illegal removals are
less common than other types of violations, the most significant ongoing
enforcement challenge involves unpermitted pruning of roots and
canopy within tree protection zones during construction. She indicated
that the current ordinance language speaks more generally to
destruction of trees and that more specific language regarding pruning
violations during construction would be beneficial, particularly with
respect to how fines would be calculated and assessed. She indicated
that staff would need to work with the Town attorney and the court
solicitor to develop enforceable fine language.
Ms. Farrell noted a pending case in the Town Center area involving
significant damage to trees during construction and that the ordinance's
current language made it difficult to assess a meaningful fine. She
indicated this was a priority area for language clarification.
On the topic of illegal removals, Ms. Farrell noted that the one-to-one
replacement framework discussed earlier could serve as a deterrent: if
the standard removal process results in a simple one-to-one
replacement, illegal removal would trigger the existing two hundred
percent mitigation penalty based on the number of trunk inches
removed, making the illegal path significantly more expensive.
Capital Projects and Maintenance
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 22 of 25
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 23 of 25
Ms. Farrell introduced the capital projects section, noting that the
relevant portion of the ordinance had been amended numerous times
over the years at the request of Dominion Energy, Waterworks, and
other entities, resulting in language that was cumbersome and
inconsistent. She indicated that it could be simplified while still
addressing the genuine challenges that arise with linear projects such as
road construction and waterline installation, where the typical one-
hundred-sixty-inch-per-acre standard is difficult to apply because the
work is constrained to a linear corridor.
Ms. Farrell noted that Public Services is responsible for maintaining
ditches, roadways, and sidewalks, and that tree removal is sometimes
necessary in the course of that maintenance work. She indicated that
the ordinance should more clearly provide discretion for Public Services
to proceed with those operations without being impeded by the tree
removal process in situations where maintenance of the Town's assets
requires it.
Ms. Farrell also noted that utility installations, particularly fiber optic and
Dominion Energy work, present a somewhat distinct category of issues
that should probably be addressed separately from the capital projects
language.
Ms. Farrell said Public Services Director Andy Weis and Engineering
and Development Services Director Brad Morrison were present to
address questions on this topic, though detailed discussion was deferred
given time constraints.
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 24 of 25
Staff Summary and Recommendations
Ms. Farrell presented the summary slide, which consolidated the staff's
primary recommendations into the following categories: allowing
modifications to the tree protection zone up to a defined percentage,
suggested as twenty to twenty-five percent, accompanied by an arborist
plan; introducing a critical root zone as a no-encroachment inner buffer;
reducing the required caliper size of replacement trees from two and a
half inches to one and a half inches; implementing a one-to-one
replacement framework for single-family non-construction permits;
establishing a minimum tree density standard for single-family residential
lots involving construction; reclassifying Laurel Oaks from Class 2 to
Class 3; allowing photo evidence for confirmation of dead trees and
planted replacements as a policy matter; clarifying ordinance language
regarding fines for pruning violations during construction; and
streamlining the capital projects provisions.
Ms. Farrell framed the overall goal as making preservation easy and
incentivizing people to do the right thing. She thanked the Task Force for
its engagement and turned the discussion back to the group for
questions.
The group then worked through the slide deck in order, with discussion
as noted above. The overall discussion was detailed and at times
nuanced, with members working through specific edge cases and
practical scenarios. The atmosphere was collegial and constructive,
though the question of the sixteen-to-twenty-four inch protection
threshold generated the most substantive disagreement and was left
unresolved pending further staff analysis.
7. Discuss Next Agenda
Chair McKee noted that the group had not been able to work through all
of the remaining ordinance topics and that additional slides remained
unaddressed. Mr. O'Neill proposed that the next meeting's agenda
include, as the first item, continuation of the ordinance review — working
through the remaining slides, which Ms. Farrell indicated were largely
repetitive of points already addressed and would move more quickly —
and as the second item, review and contribution to the draft report, with
the goal of bringing a more complete draft to the meeting after that for
final review and approval in June.
Ms. Farrell indicated that in the interim, staff would repackage the slides
to reflect the decisions already made by the Task Force, which should
help streamline the next discussion. Mr. Quick specifically requested that
Tree Task Force
April 30, 2026
Page 25 of 25
staff prepare an options analysis on the sixteen-to-twenty-four inch
protection threshold question, presenting the available approaches
clearly so the group could make a final determination. Ms. Farrell agreed
and noted that this analysis would incorporate the interaction between
that question and the minimum density standard that the group had
discussed.
8. Adjourn
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 10:03
a.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Christine Barrett
Clerk of Council
April 30, 2026
Source: Town of Mount Pleasant website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.