TRC Meeting Results 8-6-2026- 3rd Review Maybank PUD
City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Oct 21, 2026 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Charleston
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CHARLESTON FIRE DEPARTMENT
Fire Marshal Division
Permit Application & Plan Review Comments
2 GEORGE ST, CHARLESTON, SOUTH CAROLINA 29401 • PHONE (843) 724-3429• FAX (843) 720-5857
Version: 06/06/2018
Project Project Status
Name: Maybank PUD concept plan Status: Approved w/comments
Address: 3298 Maybank Hwy Received: July 27, 2026
Type: Site Plan Review Reviewed: August 5, 2026
Submittal: Revised submittal review Revised plans required: No
Permit #: PUD2026-000033 Written response required: No
Project Contact Fire Plans Reviewer
Name: Andrew Todd-Burke Name: Rick Fluegge
Company: Kimley-Horn and Associates Title: Deputy Fire Marshal
Phone: Phone: (843)724-5893
Applicant’s
Email:
Andrew.todd-burke@kimley-horn.com
Reviewer’s
Email: fluegger@charleston-sc.gov
Thank you for your recent submittal. We look forward to working with you throughout this project in order to ensure
the safety of our citizens and our emergency responders.
The following items will need to be addressed as part to the TRC review process.
General:
1. Provide the construction type (SCBC), total square footage, stories above and below grade.
2. Provide the available fire flow at the site, measured at 20 PSI residual pressure, available for firefighting.
3. Indicate the required fire flow in accordance with an acceptable calculation method. Basic guidance may be
found in Appendix B of the SCFC. Flow rate reductions must be submitted for review and approval.
4. The required water supply for fire protection must be made available prior to combustible construction
material arrival at the site as required by SCFC 3313.1.
5. In the event the required fire department vehicle access roads is only 20’ in width, provide “No on street
parking” signs or an equivalent.
6. All residential dwellings associated supporting building systems (e.g. electrical services, fire-pump, fire-alarm,
HVAC units and ductwork, hot water heaters, etc.), and residential ancillary spaces within mixed -use
commercial buildings are prohibited below DFE and are not permitted to be dry floodproo fed. Refer to
FEMA Technical Bulletin 3. For additional information, please contact Caroline Schnell, City of Charleston
Floodplain Management Manager. She can be reached at (843) 579-6481 or via e-mail at schnellc@charleston-
sc.gov.
7. Please coordinate with City GIS regarding the address for the property. Street address shall be posted in not
less than 4-inch letters/numbers (recommend 6 inch) in a manner that is plainly visible from the street or road
fronting the property as required by SCFC section 505.1. Address numbers shall be Arabic numbers or
alphabetical letters. Numbers shall not be spelled out. Individual suites or subdivision within the building shall
include the suite designation in a 4-inch minimum letter/number. Street marquees shall include the site
address.
Plan review by this office does not include a check of every item and does not relieve the owner, contractor, or designer
of meeting all code requirements. Issuance of a permit shall not be construed as authority to violate local, State, or Federal
rules or regulations. Work commencing prior to permitting may result in double permit fees and/or fines.
2 George Street · 3RD Floor · Charleston, South Carolina 29401 · Tel. (843) 724-3765
City of Charleston
Department of Planning and Preservation
William S. Cogswell, Jr., Mayor Robert Summerfield, Director
TECHNICAL REVIEW COMMITTEE COMMENTS
To: HLA, Inc.
From: Ana Harp, Senior Zoning Planner
harpa@charleston-sc.gov
Date: August 6, 2026
Re: Maybank PUD
Planned Unit Development – 3rd Rev
TMS#: 2790000006, 008, 009, 0017, 288, 3130000047, 237
City ID: PUD2026-000033
Comments: Yes
Title Sheet:
1. Correct City ID# to read PUD2026-000033.
Site Survey/Existing Conditions:
1. Include width, ownership and maintenance of all rights-of-way on all plan sheets.
Response indicates that it has been added to the plans but I’m not sure where it is.
2. The legend includes grades for grand tree but none of the trees on the plan have the
corresponding grades. Revise as needed. .
Land Use Plan:
1. Show grand trees with species and size. Add the trees shown on Existing Conditions to
the Land Use Plan. Not shown as indicated on response to this comment. The trees
should be shown on all sheets of the PUD.
Sec. 4 – Zoning Criteria
1.01 – Commercial District (CD)
1. On dimensional standards table, change Charleston County Stormwater Manual to City
of Charleston Stormwater Manual as the Charleston County standards do not apply.
1.02 – Residential District (RD)
1. Add a note that on-street parking will be provided as required in the Zoning
Ordinance.
2 George Street · 3RD Floor · Charleston, South Carolina 29401 · Tel. (843) 724-3765
Sec. 5 – Open Space
1.03 – Conceptual Plan for Open Space
1. Based on the Open Space exhibit, provide the acreage of Open Space and usable
Open Space required and provided to ensure the requirement is being met.
Sec. 8 – Right-of-Way
8.03 – Sidewalks
1. Include verbiage that speaks to the “Johns Island Greenway” requirement for
providing sidewalks. State that the alignment shall be discussed with City staff
(Planning, T&T, Parks) at a later time. Keep in mind that a wider sidewalk is not what
is envisioned and it must be off the rights-of-way.
Additional notes:
1. PUD must be approved by Planning Commission and City Council after receiving TRC
approval.
2. Additional comments may be provided upon review of future submittals and/or upon
review of the project by the Zoning Administrator.
Subdivision Concept Plan Submittal:
*The plans submitted under the PUD document and for Concept Plan review are
different as the CP set does not include the County parcel 006 . The plans must be
the same and parcel 006 must be included on all sheets . Revise as needed.
Layout Plan
1. Revise Title Block to include the name of this project.
2. Purpose Note: Add the purpose note shown on the cover sheet and on the Layout
Plan.
3. Land Use/Site Data Table - Provide the following information for the entire
subdivision: Land use area acreage (e.g. commercial acres, mixed -use, single-
family, multi-family, etc.), including % area per Zoning Ordinance requirements.
Total maximum number of lots , including HOA lots and if the alley will be its
own parcel. Total number of residential units for attached and detached single
family residential .
4. Label easements as existing and proposed with description and width.
5. Include the green line across the two pocket parks, plan southwest on the Open
Space plan, on the site plan legend
6. For Concept Plan, show lots only. Do not include setbacks as they may be
confused with building footprints.
7. Move cross-sections to a separate sheet. Reminder that on -street parking is
required and must be shown on the cross -sections.
Trails and Open Space
1. Include the green line across the two pocket parks, plan southwest , on the stie plan
legend
Grading and Drainage Plan
1. Refer to Engineering, Zoning and Stormwater comments.
Utility Plan
1. Refer to Engineering, Zoning and Stormwater comments.
2 George Street · 3RD Floor · Charleston, South Carolina 29401 · Tel. (843) 724-3765
Fire Protection Plan
1. Provide information as requested by the Fire Marshal.
Additional comments:
1. Planning Commission must approve the Concept Plan prior to submitting for
Preliminary Plat and Road Construction Plans. The plans presented to PC must be
reviewed and approved by TRC at least two weeks prior to the PC monthly
meeting to allow time to prov ide the approved plans to the Planning
Commissioners in a timely manner.
WILLIAM S. COGSWELL, JR. City of Charleston ROBERT SUMMERFIELD
MAYOR DIRECTOR
Department of Planning, Preservation and Sustainability
TECHNICAL REVIEW COMMITTEE
Zoning Division Comments
August 6, 2026
Prepared by: Eric Schultz, #843.724.3790 or Schultze@charleston-sc.gov
Agenda Item #11 – Maybank Hwy/Fern Hill Dr., Maybank Hwy. PUD.
TMS #279-00-00-008.
Paperwork Only.
Section 5.
1.) Please make a reference to the project providing & building a segment
of the Johns Island Greenway Plan. Note that the applicant will
consult wi th the city ’s Mobility Planner as the greenway may traverse
through the HOA lots with a public access easement during the plat
and road construction plan review process.
2.) Path should be a minimum of 8’ wide, may need to modify the
‘east/west’ street cross -section.
7 2 G E O R G E S T R E E T • C H A R L E S T O N , S O U T H C A R O L I N A • 2 9 4 0 1- 3 5 0 6
T H E S I T E P L A N M U S T R E F L E C T T H E P L A N A P P R O V E D B Y T H E B Z A - S D P H O N E : ( 8 4 3 ) 7 2 4 - 3 7 6 5 •
F A X : ( 8 4 3 ) 7 2 4 - 3 7 7 2
Department of Stormwater Management Page 1 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
Date: 8/5/26
To: Kimley-Horn
Andrew Todd-Burke Andrew.Todd-Burke@kimley-horn.com
From: Ardurra
Jason Sesler jsesler@ardurra.com
cc: City of Charleston
Bucci, Ron buccir@charleston-sc.gov
Yazgan, Yesim Yazgany@charleston-sc.gov
Lewis, Alicia lewisa@charleston-sc.gov
Project Name: Maybank PUD
Project Type: PUD and Concept Plan
Project ID #: PUD2026-000033
TMS #: 2790000017, -008, -009, -010, -288,
3130000047, -237
Submittal Review #: 3rd Review – Comments provided
*Comments provided for 1st Review Submittal (1) on 3/10/2026 for TRC meeting on 3/12/2026.
** Comments provided for 2nd Review Submittal (2) on 5/26/2026 for TRC meeting on 5/28/2026.
*** Comments provided for 3rd Review Submittal (3) on 8/5/2026 for TRC meeting on 8/6/2026.
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
1 --- (1) While some specific comments have been provided, a
complete review cannot be performed until all required
forms, documentation and design in conformance with the
City of Charleston Stormwater Design Standards Manual
(SWDSM) and TRC Procedure Manual are provided.
(1) Stormwater documentation has been revised and
resubmitted. A comprehensive Stormwater Memo has been
provided that includes updated hydrologic and hydraulic
modeling, ICPR input/output files, revised drainage areas,
updated curve number calculations, and supporting exhibits
prepared in accordance with the 2025 City of Charleston
Stormwater Design Standards Manual.
(2)Acknowledged. No further action for PUD process. Specific
comments will be added when appropriate.
2 Construction
Activity
Application
(CAA)
(1) Provide a completed, original Construction Activity
Application (CAA) using the most current version provided in
the City’s Stormwater Design Standards Manual (SWDSM). A
fillable form version is available at https://www.charleston-
sc.gov/351/Stormwater-Design-Standards-Manual.
(1) A completed Construction Activity Application (CAA) will be
submitted under separate cover using the current City of
Charleston form prior to construction plan approval.
(2) Acknowledged. No further action for PUD process.
Department of Stormwater Management Page 2 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
3 CAA (1) Provide stormwater plan review fee: $500.00 base fee plus
$200.00 per disturbed acre rounded up to the next whole
acre (up to $5,000.00 maximum fee). Please reach out to the
Stormwater Administrator to generate an invoice for this fee.
(1) The required stormwater plan review fee will be
coordinated with the City of Charleston Stormwater
Administrator based on the final disturbed acreage identified
in the revised Stormwater Memo.
(2) Provide receipt upon payment.
(3) Still outstanding. The Stormwater Review Fee is different
from the TRC review fee.
PUD Plan Set Comments
1 All Plan Sheets (1) Please update labels of Stormwater Management Devices
to tie into the 2025 Stormwater Design Manual BMPs. If
utilizing Wet Pond, change label to Wet Detention Pond. If
the design is utilizing Bioretention, change label to
Bioretention Basin. If utilizing Infiltration Basin, change label
to Infiltration Basin.
(1) Stormwater Management Device labels have been updated
throughout the plan set and stormwater memo to align with
the 2025 City of Charleston Stormwater Design Standards
Manual.
(2) Complied.
2 (1) Ensure Stormwater BMP designs adhere to City 2025
Stormwater Design Manual and Low Impact Development in
Coastal South Carolina: A Planning and Design Guide.
(1) All proposed stormwater BMPs have been designed in
accordance with the 2025 City of Charleston Stormwater
Design Standards Manual and the Low Impact Development in
Coastal South Carolina: A Planning and Design Guide.
(2) Complied.
3 Survey Sheet (1) Survey sheets need to include survey of Project Area of Lot
6 & Lot 7 of Charleston Real Estate.
(1) Survey coverage has been expanded to include the full
Project Area for Lot 6 and Lot 7 and is reflected on the
updated survey sheets.
A signed and sealed survey will be provided prior to plan
approval.
(2) Acknowledged.
(3) Comment still open.
4 C3-00 (Grading
and Drainage
Plan)
(1) Per Section 3.9.3, All designs must also account for the
discharge rates and volumes into the downstream and
adjacent properties if proper easements and permissions are
not in place. Unless the discharge rates and total volumes for
the site’s discharge locations onto downstream and adjacent
(1) Site grading and drainage have been revised to address
rear-lot and offsite drainage conditions. Runoff is routed to
proposed stormwater management BMPs where feasible, and
discharge locations have been evaluated to confirm no
Department of Stormwater Management Page 3 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
properties match the pre-development conditions, a legal
right from that property owner or a proper drainage
easement for any increase in runoff rates and volumes would
be required.
There are several locations where onsite rear of LOTS
drainage is discharging offsite to adjacent properties and not
draining to Stormwater Management Devices. Examples
include LOTS 46-49, unclear if LOTS 50-53 drain to proposed
Pond 1, LOTS 33-37, and LOTS 44-45. In addition, Pond #4
outlet pipe discharges offsite onto an adjacent property, and
the outlet pipe extends onto the adjacent offsite property.
increase in offsite discharge rates or volumes. Refer to the
revised Stormwater Memo and drainage exhibits.
(2) There are 2 design aspects related to the areas that don’t
drain to the stormwater management devices (1. Release onto
offsite properties, and 2. Providing stormwater management
for areas that don’t drain to infiltration basins.) Please
respond to specific lots mentioned in this review comment.
Lots 46-50 are discharging offsite to Alexander Nosov
property, and rates & volumes are assumed to be increasing
onto the Nosov property. Please review Lots 33-37 & Lots 44-
45. Calculations will be required to confirm post conditions
are not increasing from pre conditions. Refer to original
review comment for complete requirements. How is
stormwater management being provided for the lots/areas
not draining to the proposed infiltration basins? As an
example, how is stormwater management being provided for
Lots 46-50? Please also refer to Stormwater Memo Comment
#16 for Stormwater Management requirements.
(2) Any runoff that is going to the adjacent/neighboring
properties is undisturbed, and there are no changes being
proposed to the existing drainage patterns for these
undisturbed areas.
(3) To add additional information to the above response, per
6/9/2026 meeting with the City, applicant stated that all
houses (Impervious Areas) will drain from rear of lot to front
of lot (drain to street R/W) and therefore will discharge to the
infiltration basins. It was specifically mentioned that this
applies to Lots 33-37 and 46-50. Comment closed.
5 Wet Pond (1) Aquatic Bench: The proposed wet detention ponds must
incorporate aquatic benches in accordance with section
3.10.3 of the SWDSM. This will have an effect on the
configuration of the ponds as presented in the concept plan.
Please revise the design to account for the contours
(1) This comment is no longer applicable as wet detention
ponds are no longer proposed. Stormwater treatment is
provided via infiltration basins.
(2) Acknowledged. Stormwater management wet pond no
longer in project; therefore, comment N/A (Typical).
Department of Stormwater Management Page 4 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
associated with the aquatic benches. A minimum 10-foot-
wide aquatic bench around the perimeter of the wet
stormwater detention facility (with exception of the forebay
area) with the inside edge of the shelf 6” below the
permanent pool level and the outside edge 6” above the
permanent pool level with a resulting slope of 10H:1V.
6 Wet Pond (1) The wet stormwater detention facility must incorporate
several (minimum of three (3)) diverse native species of
shallow water emergent and shall land herbaceous vegetation
on the vegetated shelf. Landscaping meets requirements of
the Wet Detention Practice Landscaping Criteria.
(1) This comment is no longer applicable as wet detention
ponds are no longer proposed. Stormwater treatment is
provided via infiltration basins.
(2) Comment N/A.
7 Wet Pond (1) Bottom of all detention and retention ponds graded shall
have a slope of not less than 0.5% towards the outlet
structure(s) and side slopes no steeper than 3:1 unless
adequately protected.
(1) This comment is no longer applicable as wet detention
ponds are no longer proposed. Stormwater treatment is
provided via infiltration basins.
(2) Comment is still applicable. All ponds need to comply with
comment.
(2) Please see sheet C3-00 for revised basin grading. A 0.5%
slope towards the outlet control structure is shown where
applicable.
(3) Per coordination with the City, infiltration basins do not
need to provide the min. 0.50% slope towards the outlet
structure(s). All other types of ponds would need to meet this
min. slope requirement. Infiltration basins can be sloped 0.0%
along the bottom of the basin. Comment Closed.
8 Wet Pond (1) Total water balance and base flow conversion computed
using Equation 4.11-1 and 4.11-2 or other approved
methodology in Low Impact Development in Coastal South
Carolina manual.
(1) This comment is no longer applicable as wet detention
ponds are no longer proposed. Stormwater treatment is
provided via infiltration basins.
(2) Comment N/A.
9 Wet Pond (1) Documentation that the permanent pools will not draw
down by more than 2' after a 30-day summer drought (see
(1) This comment is no longer applicable as wet detention
ponds are no longer proposed. Stormwater treatment is
provided via infiltration basins.
(2) Comment N/A.
Department of Stormwater Management Page 5 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
equations in Wet Detention Pond Design Criteria in Low
Impact Development in Coastal South Carolina manual)
10 Wet Pond (1) Geotechnical testing and analysis as necessary (see under
table 4.11-1 in Low Impact Development in Coastal South
Carolina manual).
(1) Geotechnical evaluations have been completed, including
infiltration testing and seasonal high water table
determination, and results are summarized in the Stormwater
Memo.
(2) Complied.
11 Stormwater
Management
BMPs
(1) Geotechnical testing and analysis as required per City 2025
design manual and Low Impact Development in Coastal South
Carolina manual). Infiltration rates, seasonal high-water
table, number of tests, etc. to be determined. Refer to
Appendix B in LID in Coastal South Carolina manual and City
Design Manual Sections 3.10.4, Section 6.9, Technical
Procedure Document #9.
(1) Geotechnical evaluations have been completed, including
infiltration testing and seasonal high water table
determination, and results are summarized in the Stormwater
Memo.
(2) Number of test pits/infiltration test borings required needs
to comply with Appendix B SC LID manual. Please incorporate
all of Appendix B requirements into project design. For
example, Infiltration Basin #1 will require approx. 5 total test
pits/infiltration tests. Test locations should be equally spaced
within the Infiltration Basin footprint. Testing needs to
include Seasonal high-water table as well.
(2) Through conversations with the City of Charleston and
third-party reviewer, this will not be a requirement at this
time. Kimley-Horn is aware this will be reviewed in full TRC.
(3) Comment Closed.
12 Wet Pond (1) Permanent pool depth not to exceed 8' or be less than 3'.
The 4 wet ponds as currently shown and modeled are not
providing the required min. 3’ permanent pool depth.
(1) This comment is no longer applicable as wet detention
ponds are no longer proposed. Stormwater treatment is
provided via infiltration basins.
(2) Comment N/A.
13 Wet
Pond/Detention
Pond
(1) Per Section 3.16, An access easement with a width of 20
feet, minimum, shall be provided from the right-of-way to the
pond. In addition, the entire pond and sufficient access room
on the perimeter shall be included as part of the drainage
easement that will include a minimum width of 20 feet
outward from the top of the bank for the bench. The
(1) Drainage and access easements have been incorporated
into the conceptual layout to meet minimum width and access
requirements of the City of Charleston Stormwater Design
Standards Manual.
(2) City requires 20’ outward from the top of the bank with
max 10:1 slope. 20’ width is not provided for any of the
Department of Stormwater Management Page 6 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
perimeter easement around the top of the bank of a pond
shall have a maximum cross slope of 10H:1V.
Infiltration Basins. Please provide min. 20’ width at required
slope. In addition, for Basins adjacent to proposed street
right-of-way, applicant needs to provide min. 5' from back of
sidewalk at max 10:1 slope. If 20' is not being provided then
please detail how access will be made available.
(2) Per section 3.16.4 of the City of Charleston Stormwater
Design Standards Manual, an easement width of 10’ is
acceptable. Where basins are adjacent to proposed right-of-
way (basin 3), 5’ at max 10:1 is provided.
(3) 2026-07-08 email, Design Exception agreed to with City for
Basin #3 & #4 with 5’ width from back of sidewalk at 10:1
slope. Design Exceptions will be formally reviewed and
approved by the City during RCP submittal review process.
2026-06-09 meeting & email, Per 3.16.4, City agreed to 10’
easement for infiltration basins only. If infiltration basins are
changed to detention basins, then a 20’ easement width
would be required. Comment Closed.
14 WQv & Wet
Pond
(1) Determine the rainfall depth to be used for WQv required
based on Table 3-6 (tiered system, see equation 3-1). Note
that WQv is based on the rainfall depth applied to the entire
construction project area. Different tiers may be used for
different portions of the site if different practices are used.
Designer may manage more on one area than other to
compensate for portions where they cannot obtain water
quality volume. Wet Ponds (Detention) are Tier III = 2.8.
(1) The Water Quality Volume (WQv) has been calculated
based on the applicable Tier I and Tier II rainfall depth and
managed through infiltration basin storage in accordance with
the City of Charleston Stormwater Design Standards Manual.
(2) In Stormwater Memo please explain why Tier II are being
used with Pond #1 & Ponds #2 and why Pond #1 & #2 are
using underdrains?
(2) Only Tier 1 is being proposed now. Underdrains and Tier II
practices have been removed.
(3) Comment Closed.
15 Wet Pond (1) Ponds need to show the stage of the water quality volume
based on the rainfall depth and show that the pond will drain
longer than 24 hours and no more than 72 hours for that
volume to meet the water quality requirement. Water
(1) Infiltration basin drawdown times have been evaluated
and demonstrate drainage within the required 24- to 72-hour
timeframe following the design storm.
(2) Complied.
Department of Stormwater Management Page 7 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
Quality required volume begins at the Permanent Pool
elevation and increases in stage until reaching the required
water quality volume.
16 Wet Pond (1) The proposed stormwater practice must incorporate
forebays as applicable with the SWDSM. While not required
to be shown during the conceptual plan submittals, this will
have an effect on the configuration of the ponds as
presented. As a result, please make sure the potential loss of
storage is accounted for in the design.
The forebay shall be sized to contain 0.1 inch of runoff per
impervious acre of contributing area. The forebay shall be a
minimum of 2 feet deep with the top of the associated berm
being no more than 0.5’ below the normal water level. The
volume in the forebay counts towards the total water quality
volume requirements of the BMP if it is above the normal
water level. As an alternative, the forebay may be designed to
meet a sediment trapping efficiency of 60 percent.
(1) Pretreatment concepts have been incorporated upstream
of infiltration basins where appropriate, and impacts to
available storage volume have been accounted for.
(2) Complied. Min. Depth of forebay requirements will be
reviewed in greater detail during RCP submittal review
process.
17 MTDs/ Wet
Pond
(1) MTDs are being proposed within the R/W and for
treatment of a residential project. Manufactured treatment
devices (MTDs), often referred to as water quality devices
(WQDs), are not recommended and are typically not
approved for subdivisions due to the long-term maintenance
concerns for HOAs. If the applicant would like to propose the
use of MTDs, additional discussions with the City's
Development Services and Legal departments will be
required.
(1) Manufactured treatment devices are not proposed.
Stormwater treatment is provided through infiltration basins
and upstream pretreatment mechanisms.
(2) Acknowledged. Stormwater treatment devices are no
longer included in the project; therefore, comment N/A.
18 MTDs/ Wet
Pond
(1) If approved for the site, manufactured treatment devices
(MTDs) are not permitted in the right-of-way and are not to
be maintained by the City. Location will need to be discussed
with the City and the long-term operation and maintenance
(1) Forebay calculations and considered are provided in
resubmittal.
(2) Complied.
Department of Stormwater Management Page 8 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
will need to be addressed in the Covenants for Permanent
Maintenance of Stormwater Facilities agreement.
New Plan Comments 2nd Review (2):
19 C3-00 (Grading
and Drainage
Plan)
(2) Where are the Infiltration Basin Emergency spillways
located? Please note this will be checked in greater detail
during RCP submittal review process as more detailed
information will be presented in the construction plans.
However, applicant needs to be mindful of requirements for
discharge rates, volumes, and stages onto offsite properties,
cannot exceed existing conditions (discharge location specific)
unless property owner is in agreement.
(2) Please see sheet C3-00 for emergency spillway locations.
Discharge going to adjacent properties will not exceed existing
conditions, as these areas will be undisturbed.
(3) Complied.
20 C3-00 (Grading
and Drainage
Plan)
(2) Project Property Line Boundary along Fern Hill Drive,
Infiltration Basin #4, Alfred Grant, and Pollard-Grand
properties do not look correct, and do not match property
linework that was shown on existing survey sheet in Submittal
#1. IPF symbols are shown without property linework going
to/through them, and property linework extends well into
Fern Hill Drive. Correct Proposed Property Line Boundary,
update project area if incorrect, and show existing property
lines adjacent to proposed project (Alfred Grant, etc.).
(2) Property linework has been corrected.
(3) Acknowledged, comment closed.
21 C3-00 (Grading
and Drainage
Plan)
(2) Driveway culverts for proposed subdivision entrance road
appear to be required for Southwick Drive and Fern Hill Drive.
Please refer to previously provided culvert pipe sizing
requirements comment from Review #1.
(2) Please see updated plans and model for culvert
information.
(3) Culverts added. Comment Closed.
22 C3-00 (Grading
and Drainage
Plan)
(2) Is Proposed Grass Swale within 30’ City Drainage
Easement intended to flow into Infiltration Basin #3? If so,
Storm drain pipe will be needed. Grass channels will need to
adhere to Open Channel requirements of Section 3.4.6.8 and
City will need to approve easement width. 30’ easement
width provided does not seem adequate to comply with
Section 3.16.2.
(2) Please see sheet C3-00 for updated grass swale. The
proposed swale is now a 2’ depth V-shape swale with an 18”
RCP pipe connecting to infiltration basin 3.
(3) Applicant is showing a 30’ drainage easement. The City will
need detailed computations showing that the flow is
contained within the ditch and the culvert pipe meets design
Department of Stormwater Management Page 9 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
requirements as a part of the RCP submittal review process.
Comment closed.
23 C3-00 (Grading
and Drainage
Plan)
(2) Position/move and add Inlets at proposed road entrances
to pick-up as much onsite drainage as possible, and bypass
offsite less.
(2) Please see revised grading and drainage plan.
(3) Looks like an additional inlet can/should be added on
opposite side of street adjacent Basin #2 near intersection
with Southwick Drive. This can be reviewed during RCP
submittal review process. Comment closed.
New Plan Comments 3rd Review (3):
24 C3-00 (Grading
and Drainage
Plan)
(3) Infiltration Basin #5 will require pretreatment measures.
In response, please describe the pretreatment measures.
Provide calculations in Stormwater Report.
Stormwater Memo - Maybank PUD Comments
1 (1) Provide ICPR Model Files. (1) ICPR model files have been provided with the resubmittal.
(2) Complied.
2 All Sheets/
Calculations
(1) Stormwater management design to adhere to 2025
Stormwater Design Manual.
(1) Statement for stormwater management design to adhere
to 2025 Stormwater Design manual is included within the
Stormwater Memo.
(2) Complied.
3 All Sheets/
Calculations
(1) Please update Stormwater Management Device
references throughout document/calculations to tie to 2025
Stormwater Design Manual BMPs. If utilizing Wet Pond,
change to Wet Detention Pond. If utilizing Bioretention,
change to Bioretention Basin. If utilizing Infiltration Basin,
change to Infiltration Basin.
(1) This comment is no longer applicable as wet detention
ponds are no longer proposed. Stormwater treatment is
provided via infiltration basins.
(2) Complied.
4 1 (1) State the design follows the 2025 Stormwater Design
Manual.
(1) Statement for stormwater management design to adhere
to 2025 Stormwater Design manual is included within the
Stormwater Memo.
(2) Complied.
Department of Stormwater Management Page 10 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
5 1 (1) Include a description of how the conceptual design is
consistent with the City’s adopted comprehensive plan (the
Century V Plan) and the Johns Island Community Plan as
relates to stormwater management and Low Impact
Development (LID)/Green Infrastructure (GI) design elements.
(1) The conceptual stormwater design is consistent with the
City’s adopted Comprehensive Plan (Century V Plan) and the
Johns Island Community Plan through the application of Low
Impact Development (LID) and Green Infrastructure (GI)
principles. The project prioritizes infiltration-based
stormwater management, preservation of natural drainage
patterns where feasible, minimization of impervious cover,
and distributed stormwater treatment to reduce runoff
volume and improve water quality. Proposed infiltration
basins, vegetated buffers, and grassed conveyance features
manage stormwater close to its source, consistent with City
policies supporting context-sensitive development, protection
of coastal resources, and reduced downstream impacts. These
approaches align with the City’s long-term objectives for
sustainable growth, resilient infrastructure, and
environmentally responsible development on Johns Island.
(2) Complied.
6 2 (1) D soils are being used in the CN calcs. Please add
description of the dual HSG soils into the Narrative per City’s
requirement to utilize the undrained soil type condition (i.e.
for Type A/D soils, the Type D HSG classification is to be used
in the hydrologic determinations) for new development and
redevelopment projects.
(1) Soils within the project area include dual hydrologic soil
group classifications. In accordance with City of Charleston
requirements, all hydrologic analyses (including Curve Number
calculations) utilize the undrained soil condition, with dual
HSG soils modeled as Hydrologic Soil Group D for both pre‑
and post‑development conditions. The Stormwater Memo has
been updated to include this clarification within the soils and
hydrology narrative, consistent with City stormwater design
standards and Technical Procedure Documents.
(2) Complied.
Department of Stormwater Management Page 11 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
7 2 (1) Infiltration Rate: Refer to City Design Manual Technical
Procedure Document #9, max infiltration rate is 3 in/hr after
factor of safety incorporated unless design exception
requested. Update narrative and calcs with infiltration rate to
be utilized.
(1) Max infiltration rate is mentioned. Design exception will be
pursued.
(2) City will need to review and approve the requested Design
Exception. It is noted that only Infiltration Basin #3 will have
an infiltration rate greater than 3.0 in/hr when incorporating
the 2x factor of safety.
• Please provide Separate Design Exception Request
Letter per Section 4.10 and include Letter in Stormwater
Memo.
• In Narrative Soils Section where describe project
Infiltration rates and the design exception, please
include reference to the included design exception in
the Stormwater Report.
(2) An email has been sent to Yesim regarding requested
design exceptions.
(3) Per 2026-07-08 email, formal review of design exception
request will be reviewed during RCP submittal review process.
Applicant will need to submit design exception request letter
during RCP process for review by the City. Comment Closed.
8 3 2.8.3 Site Planning
The City requires the designer to consider the incorporation
of low impact development (LID) or green infrastructure (GI)
stormwater management techniques into the project to
provide runoff reduction from the site along with enhanced
water quality. Utilization of such practices may reduce the
overall footprint of any proposed detention areas.
Approaches to be considered are further detailed in section
2.8.3 of the SWDSM, and the resubmittal must specifically
account for how each of these site planning and design
elements (2.8.3.1 – 6) were addressed or considered.
(1) LID techniques have been updated with a description
included.
(2) Complied.
Department of Stormwater Management Page 12 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
Only 5 of the 6 low impact development techniques are
mentioned. Please include the category “Minimization of
Impervious Cover”. In addition, add and describe Infiltration
Basin, preservation of Wetlands and natural drainage ways to
appropriate categories. Also, update to change names of
BMPs being utilized.
9 3 (1) Special Protection Area: Update the narrative to detail the
requirements per 2025 stormwater design manual and state
project meeting or not meeting X% required reduction.
(1) Narrative detailing requirements per 2025 stormwater
design manual and meeting.
(2) Please update narrative SPA Section to replace 2020
Stormwater requirements with 2025 requirements. Narrative
currently includes 2020 version 3.6.1 requirements.
(2) Please see revised stormwater narrative for updated
language.
(3) Per original comment, in SPA and 1% analysis sections in
narrative, state if project is meeting or not meeting SPA and
1% requirements. Per included tables of results, Project is
NOT currently meeting 2-, 10-, or 25-year rate and volume
reduction requirements. In addition, check tables reduction
% numbers because many are incorrect. Results in these
submittal #03 tables are significantly lower than Submittal #02
where Submittal #02 showed 40%-70% reductions. Project is
required to meet SPA requirements.
10 4-7 (1) For all Tables, list % storm events with frequency storm
events i.e. 2-year (50%)
(1) % AEP storm event now listed.
(2) Complied.
11 4 (1) Update Table 1.2, Percent Reduction Column numbers.
Discrepancy with percent reduction numbers as numbers
should be lower values.
(1) All tables have been revised
(2) Complied.
12 4-5 (1) Remove Tables 2.1-2.4 as the same 24-hour volume
information is shown in Tables 3.1-3.2.
(1) All tables have been revised
(2) Complied.
Department of Stormwater Management Page 13 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
13 4- 6 (1) Provide Table of POA-1 Pre & Post 2-yr, 10-yr, etc. storm
events with Stages.
(1) All tables have been revised
(2) Please provide a table of POA 1 Pre & Post 2-yr, 10yr, etc.
storm events with stages.
(2) Please see Table 4: 24-Hour Runoff Volume Summary.
(3) Complied.
14 6-7 (1) Tables 4.1-4.5: Update Stormwater BMP Name to tie to
City Stormwater Manual BMP name. Add Bottom elevation,
Permanent Pool elevation, Water Quality Volume elevation,
and Top berm elevation to tables.
(1) All tables have been revised
(2) Please add bottom of elevation, permanent pool elevation,
water quality volume elevation, and top berm elevation to
tables.
(2) Bottom elevation, water quality volume and top of berm
have been added to table 5. As for permanent pool elevation,
these are infiltration basins and are not designed to hold
water permanently.
(3) In table 5, the bottom elevation does not match the initial
stage in the model. Please correct the initial node stages in the
model or update the table if the table is incorrect. Please
check all ponds, and if subsequent updates are made ensure
latest design is incorporated throughout plans and models.
15 7 (1) Water Quality Volume – Report mentions several different
rainfall depths (0.5”, 1”, and 2.8”). Please remove/update
narrative based upon stormwater management devices
proposed and adherence to City requirements.
(1) Narrative has been revised to meet WQV requirements.
(2) Complied. However, please explain in Narrative why
Underdrains are being included for Pond #1 & #2 (Tier II).
(2) Underdrains are no longer needed and have been
removed.
(3) Comment N/A.
16 7 (1) Describe and account for how water quality requirements
will be addressed for rear lot drainage not routed through the
proposed collection/conveyance and detention pond systems.
The use of vegetated filter strip would be an acceptable
approach; however, those buffers will need to be accounted
(1) Rear yards are not treated due to site BMPs required
WQVs, which is allowable per City of Charleston Stormwater.
(2) Please refer to Plan Set comment #4 for additional
requirements. If the applicant’s response/justification is that
Infiltration Basins are oversized for the rear lots that bypass
Department of Stormwater Management Page 14 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
for in the concept plans relative to grading and vegetation
(preserved and/or planted) as well as locating those buffers
within common HOA parcels as opposed to individual lots.
the infiltration basins, this does not appear to be a correct
statement. For example Basin #1 WQv calcs DA = 3.74 acres
and Drainage Area map DA-2A.1 = 4.15 acres. Please review
all other project areas/basins. Once the applicant determines
their approach, this will probably require additional discussion
with the City for City’s concurrence.
(2) Please see revised post development drainage map and
calculations for basins that bypass proposed BMP’s. These
areas are treated as undisturbed and will not generate
additional runoff to neighboring properties.
(3) To add additional information to the above response, per
6/9/2026 meeting with the City, applicant stated that all
houses (Impervious Areas) will drain from rear of lot to front
of lot (drain to street R/W) and therefore will discharge to the
infiltration basins. It was specifically mentioned that this
applies to Lots 33-37 and 46-50. It is understood that all
impervious areas will be treated in the infiltration basins, and
impervious areas will not bypass the stormwater management
infiltration basins. Rear lot areas consisting of grass areas only
(or primarily grass areas, no house impervious areas) will drain
offsite following the existing drainage patterns and therefore
will bypass the infiltration basins. Comment closed.
17 8 (1) List, address and fully describe any design exceptions to be
requested in accordance with Chapter 4 of the SWDSM.
(1) Design exceptions for additional infiltrate have been listed.
(2) Complied. If other Design Exceptions are requested, then
please include them in the Design Exception Letter. See
Stormwater Memo Comment #7 for complete applicable
response and next steps.
(2) Noted.
(3) Applicant is seeking 2 Design Exceptions: 1: Infiltration rate
exceeding 3 in/hr and 2: basin access of 5’ width from back of
sidewalk at 10:1 slope. Applicant will be required to submit
Department of Stormwater Management Page 15 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
Design Exception Request Letter for City’s review during RCP
review submittal process. Comment Closed.
18 8 (1) A discussion of issues relating to other State and Federal
permits needed or regulations to be followed.
(2) Please address outstanding comment.
(2) Wetland impacts have been submitted to the Army Corps
of Engineers, and we are awaiting feedback.
(3) Acknowledged. USACE Jurisdictional Determination to be
reviewed during RCP submittal review process. During RCP
submittal review process, please include description of
wetlands, wetland impacts, associated permits, other permits
required in the narrative. Comment Closed.
19 11 (1) Soils map shows B soils within Project Area. Please
account for in Pre and Post CN calculations.
(1) Modeling a more conservative D soil to ensure flows will
adequately drain in a more conservative preliminary design
approach.
(2) Please account for soil group B (Seabrook loamy fine sand)
for pre and post curve number calculations.
(2) B soils now shown and accounted for in CN calculations.
(3) Complied
20 Pre-/Post-Dev
Drainage Maps
14-16 & 81-83
• Please provide TC flow paths on the Pre- and Post-
Development Drainage Maps.
• Provide Pre & Post Development Maps with Model Nodes
and Links shown. Ensure Map and calculations naming
conventions are consistent.
• Pre & Post Development Drainage Area Maps &
calculations need to account for Offsite DA from Fenwick
Woods Residential HOA (Exist. Wet Pond, located adjacent
Prop Pond #2) with apparent discharge to existing drainage
ditch & eventually to POA 1. Also, need to evaluate offsite
drainage along Southwick Drive to the west to determine
drainage area that reaches POA 1.
(1) Revised.
(2) Please provide the flow paths for pre- and post-
development drainage maps. Also, please add the links and
nodes to the drainage maps. Change the legend from Woods,
Poor to Woods, Good as curve number calculations use
Woods Good conditions. Update the legend for the post-
development drainage map to reflect the solid blue color.
Also, please use a curve number value of 100 for all proposed
wet ponds.
(2) Flow paths provided in pre and post development drainage
exhibits. See Appendix B – 1b and Appendix C – 1b for
drainage maps with link and node information. Legend has
Department of Stormwater Management Page 16 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
• Pre & Post Development Drainage Area Maps need to
show all drainage area boundaries while still showing the
Project Property Lines. Many of the drainage area
boundaries are not shown for the Pre and a couple are not
shown for the Post. Please add road labels and show
existing contours with some contour labels enough to
evaluate general basin boundaries.
• Change Legend from Woods, Poor to Woods, Good as CN
calcs use Woods Good Conditions of 77 for D soils.
• It appears Existing Wetlands & Prop. Wet Ponds are
calculating CN with 98 per City Design Manual Technical
Procedure Document #6. Suggest add a separate column
for Wetlands/Prop Wet Ponds CN calculations and add a
separate pattern to show in DA maps.
• For 1% AEP Analysis per Section 3.9.4 and Technical
Procedure Document #4, Offsite Undeveloped properties
use Current Zoning, Offsite Developed properties use land
use curve numbers. The Offsite Wood areas need to be
changed to the Current Zoning. Update land use for recent
project developments. Review and update CN. Review
and update TC calcs based upon current land use/recent
project developments.
been changed to Woods, Good. Drainage area boundary in
legend showing as solid line. Wet ponds are no longer
proposed; they have been converted to infiltration basins.
(3) Items addressed per original comment except for the
following: Evaluate and include Offsite DA from Fenwick
Woods Residential HOA….. into 100-year (1%) analysis (POA
analysis). This will be reviewed in greater detail during RCP
submittal review process. Comment Closed.
21 15 & 82/83 (1) Update & Review CN calcs. The “Total” Row is not adding
all the basins areas.
(1) Calcs revised
(2) Pre-development curve number calculations do not
account for all basin areas.
(2) Please see updated drainage report and ICPR model for
updated pre-development calculations. Please see updated
drainage report and ICPR model that reflects these changes.
(3) The pre-development curve numbers used in the model do
not match the calculated curve numbers presented on page
132 of the report. Please update either the model inputs or
Department of Stormwater Management Page 17 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
the report calculations so that the values are consistent
throughout the analysis.
22 16 3.4.5 Time of Concentration
Shallow concentrated flow cannot exceed 1200 ft.
(1) Shallow concentrated flow does not exceed 1200 ft
(2) Basin 1B and 1D both exceed 1200 ft for shallow
concentrated flow.
(2) Please see updated TC calculations.
(3) Complied
23 Post-Dev
Drainage Maps
81-83
(1) Post Development Drainage Area Map and CN calcs need
to show and label all onsite drainage areas that bypass the
stormwater management treatment devices. Ensure the
bypass drainage areas are properly accounted for in the
calculations and models. Some of the Rear of Lots are not
draining to the Stormwater Management Devices. Most of
the Onsite Woods shown will not be Woods, but wetlands,
stormwater management device, and grass areas.
(1) DA maps revised
(2) Please show and label all onsite drainage areas that bypass
the stormwater management treatment devices.
(2) Please see post development drainage map for added
bypass areas.
(3) Complied
24 Pre- and Post-
Dev CN Calcs
15 & 82
(1) If end up using grass areas for CN in pre-development,
please explain if using fair grass. Please explain poor grass
use for post-development CN calculations.
(1) Using good condition for all grassed areas
(2) Please explain the use of grassed (poor) for on-site
disturbed areas.
(2) Please see updated basin calculations where no grassed
(poor) area is accounted for.
(3) Complied
25 TC Post Calcs (1) If end up using values above min. TC of 6 min., please
include TC for post-development.
(1) TC calcs not needed
(2) Please provide the time of concentration calculations for
post-development.
(2) Please see updated time of concentration calculations. All
disturbed areas are modeled with a TC of 6 min, while all
undisturbed areas have calculated time of concentrations.
Department of Stormwater Management Page 18 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
26 47 & All (1) The manning’s N value used for Existing & Proposed RCP
pipe of 0.011 is not typically used. Higher values are typically
used. Justification for this value will need to be provided.
(1) Manning n values state 0.011 – 0.013. Does city require
0.013?
(2) Where is the above 0.011-0.013 information taken from?
Typical Manning’s n value commonly accepted for concrete
pipe is 0.013. If applicant intends to use 0.011 detailed
justification will need to be submitted for review and approval
during RCP submittal review process.
(2) Mannings n for concrete pipe updated to 0.013 in model.
(3) Complied
27 55 & All (1) Why are Proposed improvements shown/included in the
Existing Conditions model? Pg 55 has information on
Infiltration Pond 4, Bioretention. Existing conditions output
pages have many examples of proposed information included.
(1) No longer included
(2) Complied.
28 172 (Wet Pond) (1) Please check all Pond Outlet Control Structures updating
orifice and weir sizes, elevations, and associated notes.
Typical comment applicable to all 4 wet detention ponds:
Pond #1 low flow orifice invert of 17’ coincides with bottom
elevation of wet pond. Wet pond requires a permanent pool;
therefore, low flow orifice with bottom of pond @ 17’ would
need to be higher at approx. 20.5’ in order to provide the
min. 3’ permanent pool depth and provide the 0.5% slope
along bottom of pond. In addition, water quality volume
stage/storage begins at the Permanent Pool elevation.
(1) Outlet control structure dimensions have been reviewed
and coordinated with revised weir configurations.
(2) Complied.
29 Infiltration
Basins
(1) If utilizing Infiltration Basins, a low flow orifice would not
be installed in the Outlet Control Structure as the intent is for
the stormwater to infiltrate into the underlying soils.
However, an overflow weir for larger storm events could be
utilized. Update Calcs and models if/where utilizing an
Infiltration Basin.
(1) Infiltration basins are modeled without low-flow orifices,
with overflow structures provided for larger storm events.
(2) Complied.
Department of Stormwater Management Page 19 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
30 172 (Outlet
Control
Structure)
(1) Pond #1, with weir #2 bottom width of 25’, what is the size
(Length x Width) of the Outlet Control Structure? This
comment may be applicable to other Pond Outlet Control
Structures. Please review all Pond Outlet Control Structures.
(1) Weirs modeled separately from OCS. Widths will be top.
(2) Complied.
31 Input Report (1) Please include the simulation manager ICPR input report
into the stormwater memo for pre- and post-development
scenarios.
(1) Simulation manager included
(2) Complied.
32 Modeling
Existing
Wetlands
(1) Modeling Existing Wetlands: Refer to City Design Manual
Technical Procedure Document #6. Individual wetlands must
be modeled with a Curve Number of 98 unless documented.
(1) Existing wetlands are modeled with CN 98
(2) Please include a wetlands classification in the land use
category and apply a curve number of 98 for all related
calculations.
(2) Please see revised basin calculations for existing wetlands
land use category.
(3) Complied
33 Tailwater (1) Please state which tailwater is used in the ICPR models i.e.,
static and dynamic and describe how starting elevation was
determined.
(1) Tailwater is 6” above normal crown of Southwick Drive
(2) Please include a statement in the narrative on why you
used a value of 13.89 ft for the boundary condition.
(2) Please see narrative for statement of chosen tailwater
value.
A static tailwater of 13.89’ was used because this is the
downstream invert elevation of the existing 36” RCP pipe at
the POA. Since there is an elevation change of over 5’ across
the existing ditch that the site outfalls to, a free outfall can be
modeled.
(3) Complied
34 1. Table of
Contents
(1) Please provide a table of contents. (2) Please provide a table of contents.
(2) Table of contents is now provided at the beginning of the
stormwater memo.
(3) Complied
Department of Stormwater Management Page 20 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
35 Exhibits (1) Please provide a FEMA, USGS, Soils, and NWI exhibit and
ensure the project area is shown on each exhibit.
The FEMA FIRM reference and associated flood zone(s) must
be updated to reflect the new Charleston County flood maps
that became effective on 01/29/2021.
(1) Exhibits are provided
(2) Please identify the site location on the FEMA FIRM map.
(2) Please see updated FEMA FIRM map.
(3) Complied
36 303d (1) Please list the nearest SCDES Water Quality Monitoring
Station (WQMS) that the site’s stormwater discharges drain
to and the waterbody on which it is located (If nearest WQMS
is listed on the latest 303(d)).
(2) Please address outstanding comment.
(2) Please see the third paragraph of the Background section.
(3) Complied
37 Disturbed Area (1) Please include the total disturbed area in the stormwater
memo.
(1) Total disturbed area included
(2) Please include the total disturbed area in the stormwater
memo.
(2) Please see the third paragraph of the Background section.
(3) Complied
38 Maintenance (1) Please include a summary of the maintenance of the
stormwater system and arrangements for post-construction
maintenance responsibility.
(1) Maintenance plan added
(2) Complied.
39 3.4.6.2 Culverts
Please include a section in the Stormwater Memo describing
the proposed culvert crossing (E.0 to E.1) design and
demonstrating how it meets the requirements of the
referenced manual section. Provide sufficient design
information to confirm that the crossing will not create
adverse impacts to upstream conditions and that adequate
roadway clearance is maintained.
A full culvert analysis is not required at this stage; however,
the applicant should ensure the proposed culvert is planned
(1) Section and language added
(2) Pipe link “Dual 40 RCP” requires a 25 percent factor safety.
Please reduce the pipe size in the model or utilize a bottom
clip to obtain the necessary factor of safety. Also, please
include a statement in the narrative explain how the use of a
smaller culvert or bottom clip was utilized to satisfy 3.4.6.2.
(2) Bottom clip of 1.125’ assigned to “Dual 54” RCP” link to
account for the 25% factor of safety required in section
3.4.6.2. This methodology was applied to all culverts in the
model.
(3) 4 total culverts underneath roadways are now in project.
All of these culverts require the 25% factor of safety. The dual
Department of Stormwater Management Page 21 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
in accordance with the 2025 City of Charleston Stormwater
Design Standards Manual (SWDSM), Section 3.4.6.2.
54” pipe culver factor of safety is correct, and acceptable. The
other 3 culverts either need the factor of safety added or
corrected. For the 36” culvert, the factor of safety is not
meeting the required 25%. It appears that there are 3 total
proposed culverts in the model. Please note the project is
showing 4 proposed culverts. This will be reviewed in greater
detail during RCP submittal review process. Comment Closed.
40 3.9.3 Project Discharge
The Drainage Memo states that “all on-site runoff for
Maybank PUD will discharge directly to a right-of-way and will
not impact any other private properties without permission
from the site owners and the City of Charleston.” However,
the plans show outfalls discharging to a private drainage
easement and to private property (TMS No. 279-00-00-002).
All designs must account for discharge rates and volumes to
downstream and adjacent properties when easements or
permissions are not in place. Unless post-development
discharge rates and total volumes match pre-development
conditions at these discharge points, a legal right of discharge
or a properly recorded drainage easement is required.
• Provide City of Charleston Drainage Easements for
the ditch outfall, and provide documentation that the
existing private drainage easement permits the
proposed outfall in the design.
• For the outfall to private property (TMS No.
279-00-00-002), ensure the design meets 2025
SWDSM requirements and does not increase total
discharge volume, or obtain written permission from
the property owner.
(1) Easements and language included
(2) Discharges onto Adjacent properties is discussed in other
comments, please refer to those comments.
For existing drainage ditch, applicant has provided Recorded
Plats as Exhibit N within Maybank PUD document.
For the existing drainage ditch, a proposed COC Drainage
Easement that meets City requirements per 3.16.2 is required
at this stage of review (with the appropriate maintenance
shelf). The existing drainage ditch is over 4’ deep for the
portion adjacent to Infiltration Basin #2 and other sections of
the ditch are at least 2’ deep.
Then City will need detailed computations showing that the
flow is contained within the ditch and the culvert meets design
requirements as a part of the RCP submittal review process.
Also make sure COC DEs for all proposed pipes where
applicable are shown. As currently shown, there are concerns
that a sufficient COC DE for the existing ditch will not be able
to be provided, especially near Lot 62 and this may affect
Infiltration Basin #1 & #2 size/layout/configuration.
(2) Please see plans for updated COC drainage easement
where the ditch reaches 4’ in depth.
Department of Stormwater Management Page 22 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
Please see stormwater calculations for post developed
conditions and staging of existing ditch.
(3) For the existing drainage ditch and proposed required City
easement, applicant is showing 15’ easement width
apparently from near the top of existing bank on each side of
existing ditch where project property occurs. Existing
drainage ditch exceeds 4’ depth from Infiltration Basin #1
through downstream end of property. Please provide an
exhibit (to include showing existing and proposed contours,
existing spot elevations in the bottom ditch, etc., depth of
existing ditch at various locations throughout site) that does
a better job of presenting the proposed easement
information with explanation and justification for proposed
drainage ditch easement width. City will review information
once provided.
41 Easements (1) Per Section 54-822(c) of the Zoning Code, easements,
when required for drainage or sewage for the area to be
subdivided, shall be of such width as necessary to permit
proper construction of drainage facilities based on the
drainage system of the area. No subdivision shall block or
obstruct the natural drainage of an adjoining area. Existing
natural drainage shall be maintained or replaced where
possible or feasible. Please address how this requirement is to
be satisfied as part of the site design. Also include the
identification of any off-site drainage easements needed for
stormwater conveyance or storage.
(1) Easements provided.
(2) Memo includes discussion on required easements for
storm drain pipes, channels, and stormwater management
ponds; however, please update based upon reviewer
comments and applicant responses. In addition, add
description of existing drainage ditch and provide a proposed
City drainage easement for the existing drainage ditch.
(2) Please see updated plans for additional easements based
on City comments.
(3) Complied.
42 USACE
(1) Provide a Unites States Army Corps of Engineers (USACE)
Jurisdictional Determination and the accompanying wetland
survey plat.
(1)A USACE Jurisdictional Determination and accompanying
wetland delineation exhibit have been provided.
(2) Army Corps of Engineers Jurisdictional Determination has
not been included. Didn’t see in submittal package if included.
Did see Wetland plot map included in Exhibits with Maybank
PUD document. Please provide USACE Jurisdictional
Department of Stormwater Management Page 23 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
Determination & indicate where the documents are located
within the submittal documents.
(2) USACE determination is still underway. Based on meeting
with City and 3rd party reviewer, this can be looked at during
full submittal.
(3) Acknowledged. USACE Jurisdictional Determination to be
reviewed during RCP submittal review process. Comment
Closed.
New Stormwater Memo Comments 2nd Review (2):
43 Calcs (2) 0.5’ Min. Freeboard above 100-year WSEL NOT provided
for most of the Infiltration Basins. Check all Infiltration Basins
and provide min. 0.5’.
(2) 0.5’ min freeboard now met for all infiltration basins.
(3) Please see comment #14 above about the node initial stage
invert not matching the bottom elevation.
44 C3-00 (Grading
and Drainage
Plan)
(2) Reviewing existing ground elevations and contours on
grading plan and from existing survey from submittal #1,
Infiltration Basin #4 SHWT elevation = approx. 20.75’ (18”
below existing ground of approx. 22.25’) is higher than
elevation of bottom of infiltration basin (20.50’). 0.5’
required separation from bottom of basin to SHWT elevation
is not provided.
(2) Please see updated plans and storm calculations,
Infiltration basin #4 has been raised to have a bottom
elevation of 21.25’, given the SHWT being at 20.75’.
(3) Please update the initial stage of node, “INFILTRATION
BASIN 4”, in the post-development model to an elevation of
21.25’ and update Table 5.
45 C3-00 (Grading
and Drainage
Plan)
(2) How is existing commercial property (Bright Oaks
Property) being accounted for in the project? Please describe
stormwater management approach for this portion of the
project. The existing pond does not appear to be an
infiltration basin. Per aerial images it appears to be a wet
pond. On grading plan, existing pond is labeled as an existing
dry pond, please verify. Update plans and stormwater memo.
(2) The Bright Oaks Property will not be receiving any
stormwater improvements. Labels updated throughout plan to
show an existing wet pond.
(3) Per 2026-06-09 meeting with the City, applicant provided
the below existing preschool information: Offsite developed
Property included within PUD. Not changing existing
preschool development, being included because need to
include Commercial property component in PUD. Comment
Closed.
Department of Stormwater Management Page 24 of 24
Stormwater/MS4 Review Comment Sheet
Maybank PUD (PUD and Concept Plan) - PUD2026-000033
# SHEET /
PAGE # COMMENT RESOLUTION/RESPONSE
46 Calcs & C3-00
(Grading and
Drainage Plan)
(2) Basin #2 100-year and less storm events WSEL will bypass
pond by discharging/overtopping proposed grass channel and
convey downstream.
(2) Please see updated stormwater model and report, the
channel is no longer overtopping.
(3) The upstream and downstream invert of the grass channel
stages higher than 22 feet for the 100-year, thus the flow will
not be contained in the grass channel. Please update the
channel dimensions so that the flow will be contained.
47 StormWise
Model
(2) Pipe link “Existing 18 RCP” has a downstream invert of
15.68 ft in the pre- and post-development model and the
survey shown on sheet C1-00 shows an invert of 15.65 ft.
Please correct the pre- and post-development model to
match the survey.
(2) Please see revised ICPR model for corrected downstream
invert elevation of 15.65’.
(3) Complied.
48 StormWise
Model
(2) For simple basin “DA-1D” please use the rainfall name,
Scsiii for post-development.
(2) Please see revised ICPR model, DA-1D Offsite is using the
Scsiii rainfall name.
(3) Complied.
49 StormWise
Model
(2) Please update the Post-Development Drainage Area Map
to match the inputs used for the post-development simple
basins.
(2) Please see updated Post Development Drainage Area Map,
all drainage areas match inputs used for simple basins.
(3) The Post Development Drainage Map does not match the
time of concentration values in the model for basins, DA-2A.1
(UNDISTURBED), DA-1D OFFSITE, DA-1E OFFSITE, and DA-1B.
City of Charleston
Department of Parks
Technical Review Committee Comments
Submitted by:
Rodney H. Porter, PLA
porterr@charleston-sc.gov
City of Charleston, Department of Parks, 823 Meeting Street, Charleston, SC 29403
843.637.9518 (m), 843.724.7322 (o)
EREVIEW
COMMENTS
______ COMMENTS ______ NO COMMENTS
1. There are no comments.
PROJECT ID: PUD2026 -000033 AGENDA #: 4
PROJECT NAME: MAYBANK PUD AND CONCEPT PLAN DATE: 08/06 /202 6
ADDRESS: 3298 MAYBANK HWY REVIEW: 3RD REVIEW
TMS #: C2790000010 REVIEW TYPE: PUD AND CONCEPT PLAN
Department of Public Service – Engineering
Division
Engineering Review Comment Sheet
Page 1 of 4
ENGG-PUD2026-000033_3rd Review-Maybank PUD and Concept
Plan
Date:
To:
12-Mar-2026, 04-Jun-2026, 06-Aug-2026
Kimley-Horn and Associate, Inc.
Project Name:
Project Type:
Maybank PUD and Concept Plan
PUD Master Plan and Concept Plan
From: Moshtaba Vedad, Civil Engineer I
vedadm@charleston-sc.gov or 843-619-6086
Project TMS:
Project ID #:
C279-00-00-010
PUD2026-000033
Submittal Review #: 1st review – Comments Provided
2nd Review-Paperwork
3rd review-Paperwork
Documents Reviewed:
Ref# Review # Document Title: Rev Ref# Review # Document Title: Rev
SWDSM all City of Charleston Storm water Design Standards Manual,
January 2020
Please provide a response to each review comment below (match text coloring to review for clarity) to show how the comment was addressed within your submittal.
This will help provide a thorough project review and ensure proper communication between the reviewer and the applicant. With out responses to comments,
subsequent submittals may not be reviewed. Resolution column is for City use only – A blank cell in this column indicates issue is still outstanding.
Please return the completed Word document to the Engineering Division concurrently with your next TRC (re)submittal.
# Sheet/
Page # Review Comment Response (Applicant) Resolution
(City Staff)
1. All PDF
Files:
Please provide functional PDF bookmarks with sheet/page numbers
(and abbreviated sheet/chapter titles) to expedite review. Check
function of ‘action’ prior to submitting.
Functional PDF bookmarks with sheet/page numbers is
provided.
Resolved
2. Cover: Include City PUD ID # PUD2026-000033 on cover. Provide a
description of all work being done at this stage.
PUD review case # with a description of work to be
completed is included on cover sheet.
Resolved
Department of Public Service – Engineering
Division
Engineering Review Comment Sheet
Page 2 of 4
ENGG-PUD2026-000033_3rd Review-Maybank PUD and Concept
Plan
# Sheet/
Page # Review Comment Response (Applicant) Resolution
(City Staff)
3. Cover: Add the new 811 number with logo for the Palmetto Utility
Protection Service (PUPS).
Place Logo on any sheet(s) shows Excavation, Demolition, and any tree
removal.
New 811 number with logo has been included on all sheets. Resolved
4. Site Plan
– Lots:
Although individual lots do not have to be shown, the
types of lots/uses proposed should be provided (e.g.,
single-family, townhouse, multi-family, commercial,
civic)
All lots are proposed to be single-family. Additional information is
provided on the site
development summary within the land use section of sheet C2-00.
Resolved
5. Site Plan: Open space, public use areas, amenity areas and
recreational areas, identify location (Provide more detail on Open
Space).
For PUD projects, label Street Types
Requested information included within the Site Plan and Open
space Plan.
Resolved
6. Site Plan –
Streets:
Show proposed street layout within the development including
connections to existing streets and adjacent properties. Streets should
be identified as public or private. Note R/W width and provide all
right-of-way elements.
Street layout is provided. Additional information to note R/W
widths and maintenance
responsibilities is included on the Site Plan.
Resolved
Department of Public Service – Engineering
Division
Engineering Review Comment Sheet
Page 3 of 4
ENGG-PUD2026-000033_3rd Review-Maybank PUD and Concept
Plan
# Sheet/
Page # Review
Comment
Response (Applicant) Resolution
(City Staff)
7. Existing
Conditions /
Survey:
Provide a topographic survey of the existing conditions and a
boundary survey or plat, both properly certified (signed and sealed)
by a Land Surveyor registered in South Carolina responsible for the
preparation of the survey.
All Surveyed sheets must be signed and sealed by a surveyor
registered in South Carolina responsible for the preparation of the
survey.
Surveyor is obtaining additional information as it relates to
other comments within this concept
review and was not able to return prior to resubmittal. A
signed and sealed certified copy of the
survey will be provided prior to Concept Approval.
Paperwork
8. Site Plan –
Streets:
Rights-of-way/Streets: show the locations, names, and ROW widths
of all existing streets within 150 feet of the property boundary with
ownership and maintenance (state, county, city, community, private
etc.) noted. Show all proposed improvements to existing public
roadways (i.e., widening existing streets for turn lanes, etc.).
All proposed improvements are being shown within row.
Names of streets will be reserved at time
of preliminary plat. All existing streets and maintenance
responsibilities are provided.
Resolved
9. Site Plan –
Streets:
Provide ROW Cross-Section or roadway typical to show roadway
length and width, sidewalk width, Curb and gutter dimensions and
concrete PSI being used.
Show all types of HMA being used, indicate Yield (lb./sq. yd or
inches compacted).
No typical are shown in plan sheet C2-00
Multiple typical sections are being proposed as part of this
PUD. All typical sections are provided
on sheet C2-00. Additional notes for HMA, curb and gutter,
concrete sidewalk, etc. are provided
within the Road Notes.
Paperwork
10. Site Plan: Provide a concept site “Master Plan” layout with principal
dimensions. This must be prepared by a professional land.
surveyor, Civil Engineer, or professional land planning consultant.
Noted. Resolved
11. Site Plan: Pedestrian trails and bike paths: Show circulation within the
Development if it will be in proposed design include connections to
existing streets and adjacent properties. Identify whether items will
be within or outside of proposed ROW areas. Note width of trails
and bike paths.
Pedestrian trails and bike paths are provided. See open space
plan.
Resolved
Department of Public Service – Engineering
Division
Engineering Review Comment Sheet
Page 4 of 4
ENGG-PUD2026-000033_3rd Review-Maybank PUD and Concept
Plan
12.. Grading and
Drainage.:
Provide a complete grading and drainage plan, labelling all
drainage stormwater pipes and structures.
Clearly illustrate intended direction of stormwater run-off on all
surfaces.
Complete grading and drainage plan with drainage intent clearly
illustrated is provided.
Resolved
13. Grading and
Drainage:
Provide all the information for any temporary Grading (cut and Fill)
and drainage for this stage. Ensure all easements shown are
consistent with the width requirements of the City’s Stormwater
Design Standards Manual (SWDSM).
Cut and fill provided on grading plan. All easements shown are
consistent with City design
standards manual.
Resolved
14. Utility Plan: Provide a complete Utility Plan, showing all existing and proposed
connections to water, sewer, electric power, and gas, as applicable.
Provide a conceptual Utility Plan, showing any existing utility
easements, including any to be abandoned, or relocated. Show new
utility easements for new transmission lines (water, sewer, gas
and/or electricity).
Complete Utility Plan is provided. Electric power, gas, etc. shall be
coordinated by owner within
the ROW or GUE as needed during preliminary plat plan review
process.
Resolved
15. PUD: Provide letter from St. John’s Water Co., Inc indicating public water
and/or sewer capacity and availability for all the proposed new
developments.
Letter from St. Johns Water Co is provided. Resolved
Department of Public Service – Engineering
Division
Engineering Review Comment Sheet
Page 5 of 4
ENGG-PUD2026-000033_3rd Review-Maybank PUD and Concept
Plan
Approval Conditional Approval Comments Agenda Item #_04_
1
CITY OF CHARLESTON
DEPARTMENT OF TRAFFIC & TRANSPORTATION TRC REQUIREMENTS
TRANSPORTATION PROJECT MANAGEMENT DIVISION
(843) 724-7372
WallaceJ@charleston-sc.gov
SITE: Maybank PUD and Concept Plan DATE: 8/06/2026
TMS #: 279-00-00-010 PLEASE NOTE: Final approval is contingent upon implementation of comments.
3rd Review Comments: TRC-PUD2026-000033
No TRC Comments.
Other comments:
1. Request from Mayor at T&T Committee – Create an easy to understand aerial/concept plan showing the final
configuration of the signal, roadway network, and Heritage driveway.
Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.