Planning Commission Public Comment
City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Oct 21, 2026 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Charleston
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITY OF CHARLESTON
PLANNING COMMISSION
PUBLIC COMMENT
OCTOBER 21 , 2026
A meeting of the Planning Commission will be held on Wednesday, October 21, 2026 at 5:00 p.m.
in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street.
The following written comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of the
meeting. The comments will also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is
encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard.
Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/pc. Please check the website on the
meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items.
For additional information, please contact:
Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781
B. ORDINANCE AMENDMENTS
1. Request approval to amend Sections 54-208 and 54-227 to incorporate wording and
definition changes to the Short-Term Rental Ordinance intended to clarify and quantify
certain terms, limits, submittal and review criteria, and penalties
4 Comments Submitted to Innovate in Opposition
1 Comment Submitted to Staff in Opposition (see attached)
First
Name
Last
Name
Address Submitted Comment Date/Time
Submitted
Sara Shrouds 1949
Village
Crossing
Dr
I ask that all currently permitted units be treated
equally under Section 4. My ask is six words:
strike "with more than four (4) bedrooms" from
Section 4(1), so every home that holds a valid
permit today is treated the same way.
Oct 20
2026
11:02AM
David Betts 34
Radcliffe
Street
Charleston
SC 29403
Commissioners, Thank you for the time you and
staff have put into this amendment. The
September draft is a substantially better
document than the one deferred in July. We
recognize the work that went into those changes.
Two issues remain in Section 4, and both can be
addressed with minor edits before the amendment
goes to Council. 1. The grandfather clause
excludes permitted homes with four or fewer
bedrooms. Section 4(1) preserves IPMC
occupancy only for permitted units with “more
than four (4) bedrooms.” A permitted four-
bedroom home that meets the life safety
standards set by IPMC for more than eight guests
receives no protection and is reduced to eight on
the date of ratification. There is no sound basis
Oct 20
2026
11:19AM
Planning Commission
Public Comment | August 19, 2026 Page 2
for treating one lawfully permitted unit differently
from another based on bedroom count. We ask
that the phrase “more than four (4) bedrooms” be
struck so that all currently permitted units are
treated equally. 2. The under-construction
provision sets conditions few projects can meet.
Section 4(2) requires that a commercial STR
permit be issued within twelve months of
ratification. Building permit applications regularly
take multiple years to obtain if the TRC process is
required, and these projects were underwritten,
purchased and entitlement pursuit costs spent,
under the current ordinance. We ask that a
building permit issued in an eligible zone within
12-months of ratification be sufficient for the
grandfathering protection. We respectfully
request that the Commission forward the
amendment to City Council with a
recommendation to adopt these two changes.
Thank you for your consideration.
Natalie Hedden 2 Pagett
Street,
Daniel
Island SC
29492
As the owner of a spacious, legally permitted 4-
bedroom, 4-bathroom short-term rental property
that comfortably sleeps 10 guests, my request is
simple: strike "with more than four (4) bedrooms"
from Section 4(1), so every home holding a valid
permit today is treated equally. I have never had
any noise or safety violations, and I purchased
this property under the reasonable expectation
that I could continue operating it as is. I feel
capping occupancy at 2 occupants per bedroom
plus 2 additional guests per house is a much fairer
and more realistic standard for homes designed
to host family gatherings.
Oct 20
2026
11:50AM Laura Bush 107 Holly
St,
Cranford,
NJ
I appreciate that comments from the previous
hearing were reviewed and respected, and that
homes with more than 4 bedrooms have been
grandfathered in. However, every permitted
home should be treated equally and homes with
four bedrooms or less shouldn't be penalized and
allowed less occupants than they are currently
permitted for and upon which the owners relied
when making their purchases and investments.
We ask the City strikes the words "with more than
four (4) bedrooms" from Section 4(1). This would
allow every home that holds a valid permit today
to be grandfathered and treated the same.
Nothing else would change and no home would
add a guest. Occupancy would stay at the
number the City has already approved under the
IPMC, and only upon renewal of an existing
permit. New units, the 8-guest standard and
enforcement would not be changed by this
request.
Oct 20
2026
11:42AM
From: Lee Hewett <leehewett@me.com>
Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2026 3:45 PM
To: Morgan, Christopher <MORGANC@charleston-sc.gov>
Subject: Late public comment opposing STR amendment: October 21 Planning Commission, Item B.1
Mr. Morgan,
Please accept the following late written comment for the October 21 Planning Commission
meeting, agenda item B.1, concerning the proposed short-term rental amendment. I
understand that the noon October 20 deadline has passed. Please forward this comment
to the Commission for consideration if permitted, and confirm whether it can be included
in the record.
Members of the Planning Commission,
I strongly oppose the short-term rental amendment as drafted and ask you to recommend
denial or defer it for substantial revision.
The City should not disrupt established, lawfully permitted operations without clearly
explaining which existing approvals will be protected and how the new rules will apply.
Section 4 limits its existing-permit occupancy exception to units with more than four
bedrooms. That leaves smaller permitted units without the same protection. Existing
lawful occupancy should be evaluated against documented approvals and fire-safety
standards, not protected or excluded simply by bedroom count.
The proposed prohibition on advertising more than one permitted unit in a single listing is a
separate concern. Two separately permitted three-bedroom units do not become one
permitted six-bedroom unit because they are marketed together. But the draft does not
clearly protect existing combined listings or provide an explicit transition for them.
Before moving forward, require clear written rules for separately permitted units, protect
documented lawful occupancy, and address existing bookings and combined listings
directly. Owners should not have to guess whether longstanding operations will remain
permitted.
Please vote against recommending this version. If the Commission is unwilling to reject it,
defer it until these issues are resolved in the ordinance itself.
Sincerely,
Lee Hewett
Planning Commission
Public Comment | August 19, 2026 Page 3
C. PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT & CONCEPT PLAN
1. 3294 & 3280 Maybank Hwy, 1730 & 1738 Fern Hill Dr
Johns Island | TMS# 2790000288, -006, -008, -009, -017 & 3130000047,
3130000237| Council District 3 | Approx. PUD acreage: 15.61 & Approx. Concept
Plan acreage: 13.47
Request to rezone from Commercial Transitional, Rural Residential, & Single-Family
Residential (CT, RR-1, & SR-1) to Planned Unit Development (PUD). Request Zoning
Planned Unit Development (PUD). Zoned Residential (R-4) & Johns Island Maybank
Highway Corridor Overlay (JO-MHC-O) in Charleston County. Request approval of
Concept Plan for 62 lot development.
Owner: The Charleston Real Estate Company LP, Sherry B. Bailey & Dennis R.
Bailey, Rosemary Lynn Knox, Fenwick Hills Corp. & Bight Oak
Properties LLC.
Applicant: Kimley-Horn
1 Comment Submitted to Innovate in Support
14 Comments Submitted to Innovate in Opposition
1 Comment Submitted to Staff in Opposition (see attached)
First
Name
Last
Name
Address Submitted Comment Date/Time
Submitted
George Gratzick 2485 royal
Oak drive
JOhns
Island sc
I strongly support this project and the addition
of a stop light at the intersection of St Johns
woods and Maybank when the project is
completed with the new road extension across
from St johns woods.
Oct 19
2026
6:14PM
First
Name
Last
Name
Address Submitted Comment Date/Time
Submitted
jCharles Tumbleston 1665
Fernhill
Drive Johns
Island SC
29455
I am asking the city to reject the current
proposal, or delay its decision until my
specific concerns are answered.
Oct 19
2026
4:11PM
Amy Tumbleston
Brown
817 Saint
Denis Drive
Charleston,
SC 29407
The proposed PUD zoning change has not
addressed the following: 1)Major traffic
issues 2)Drainage 3)Access near and to
property owners 4)Precedence
5)Adjustments and/or changes that
developers could and/or will do once
proposed land is changed to the PUD
zoning. The public has a right to know
how these inevitable changes will affect
them and their wishes to maintain low
density and rural development. Also,
current residence and property owners
have not had enough notice on this
proposed zoning change to obtain FOIA
docs from the developer.
Oct 19
2026
5:48PM
Planning Commission
Public Comment | August 19, 2026 Page 4
Charles Tumbleston 1325 Salt
Marsh Cove
Charleston,
SC 29412
What is the difference between the
approximate 15.61 acres for the PUD
and the 13.47 acres for the concept
plan? The proposal for a 62 lot
development does not explain the
difference.
Oct 19
2026
5:55PM
Joe Tumbleston 1673 Fern
Hill Drive
Johns Island
SC 29455
How would the current proposed zoning
change affect major traffic issues on
Maybank Hwy. If I leave Fernhill Drive
after 7am, M-F, it takes me no less than
45 minutes to travel less than 2 miles to
the intersection of River Road and
Maybank Hwy. Possibly putting in 1
traffic light will not solve this major
concern.
Oct 19
2026
6:08PM
Charles Stutts 1680
Fernhill
Drive Johns
Island SC
We don't need anymore housing projects
on Maybank Highway. too much traffic
and house for this Island as it is now. We
don't have the infrastructure to handle
what we have now. The city has ruined
this Island allowing all of this growth
without making sure we had the proper
infrastructure to support the growth. As it
is you have to leave this Island by 6:30 to
be at work by 8:30 downtown.
Oct 19
2026
9:03PM
Cynthia Stutts 1680
Fernhill
Drive, Johns
Island, SC
29455
I sit on Maybank Highway every morning.
The trip from Fernhill Drive along
Maybank Highway to get to the bridge
is usually about 60 minutes and is often
even longer. That short stretch of
highway can not handle the current traffic
load. Adding any more homes will be
devastating to commuters. The traffic in
all directions of the Island is overloaded.
Please do not allow these large
developments to continue to be
approved. Our hometown is no longer
the place it used to be. Please lets stop
making it worse.
Oct 19
2026
9:16PM
Katherine Tumbleston 1669 Fern
Hill Drive
Johns Island
SC 29455
I am writing this evening to request an
immediate deferral on your Agenda Item
C.1 for the Maybank-PUD-3294 & 3280
Maybank Hwy + 1730 and 1738 Fernhill
Drive scheduled for this Wednesday,
October 21, 2026, at 5pm. The
surrounding residence and property
owners were not given sufficient notice to
obtain the necessary documents to
provide an informed and meaningful
response to this zoning request and
concept plan for 62 lots.
Oct 19
2026
9:45PM
Planning Commission
Public Comment | August 19, 2026 Page 5
Traci Smith 1712
Fernhill
Drive Johns
Island, SC
29455
I am writing to express my strong
opposition to this application. Johns Island
is already facing a critical infrastructure
deficit that can not support any future
development at this time. Our main
thoroughfares are heavily congested
daily, leading to major delays and
increased safety hazards. Also, our
surrounding road networks, drainage
systems and public resources are already
overburdened and inadequate to handle
the increased demand to new building in
the area. Please deny this application
until infrastructure improvements are
actively completed to support out
growing community safely. Other major
concerns are flooding in the area.
Oct 20
2026
5:44AM
Tammy Bazzle 2459
Marina
Road
Wadmalaw
Island, SC
29487
I am opposed to this development
because of many reasons. First and
foremost, traffic and congestion are
already a major issue. The infrastructure
is not up to date and needs to be
addressed before any more dwellings
are built. Second, building this
development will take away from the
rural character of Johns Island. This
location (Southwick to Fernhill) is rural,
and building will alter the landscape of
the area. Currently we able to see
wildlife live freely and this development
will disrupt the wildlife's living habits.
Third, drainage and erosion control to our
area on Fernhill Drive has changed
dramatically since development began
more than 15 years ago. Flooding is now
an issue on Fernhill Drive when heavy
rainfall occurs. I can only imagine how
much flooding will occur with more
asphalt/concrete and nowhere for the
water to drain except to the dirt road
with ditches, the only undeveloped area
if this development happens. Any new
development on Johns Island right now
should not be considered until all of these
issues (and others) are addressed. I hate
seeing Johns Island change over the years
and would love to maintain some rural
characteristics that made the island
unique. Thank you for your time and I
hope you all consider the consequences
of this development.
Oct 20
2026
8:49AM
Planning Commission
Public Comment | August 19, 2026 Page 6
TRACI SMITH 1712
FERNHILL
DRIVE
JOHNS
ISLAND, SC
29455
To: City of Charleston Planning
Commission Re: Agenda Item C.1, PUD
and Concept Plan for 3294 and 3280
Maybank Highway and 1730 and 1738
Fern Hill Drive (Johns Island) Meeting:
Wednesday, October 21, 2026, 5:00
p.m. Dear Commissioners, My name is
Traci Tallent Smith, and I own the
property at 1712 Fern Hill Drive/TMS
#313-00-00-046, which directly adjoins
the parcels in this application along the
north boundary. I respectfully ask the
Commission to defer this item or
recommend denial until the questions
below are answered on the record. My
family has already requested a deferral
because neighboring owners have not
had adequate time to review the
application. 1. Added rights compared
with current zoning. The application asks
for custom rules to support a 62-lot
concept plan. The agenda does not show
what the property allows today or what
additional rights the PUD would grant.
Please require a side-by-side comparison
for each parcel covering maximum units,
minimum lot sizes, setbacks, heights,
permitted uses and every requested
exception. Please also confirm whether
62 is a binding maximum or only the lot
count shown on this concept plan. 2.
Drainage and flooding. My property,
1712 Fern Hill Drive, is lower than this
proposed site. On September 11, 2026,
during a heavy rainstorm, water pooled
across my property for 2 days. New
rooftops, paving and fill-dirt could push
more stormwater onto adjoining land.
Please require a drainage study showing
that runoff to neighboring properties will
not increase. 3. Buffers and
compatibility. The concept plan should
show the width and type of buffer along
my shared property line, whether trees
there will be preserved, and the setbacks
of the nearest homes. The City Plan calls
for protecting Johns Island's rural
character, trees and wetlands, and this
proposal should show how it does that. 4.
Traffic and access. Maybank Highway is
already congested near this site. When I
leave Fern Hill Drive in the morning
during the weekday, it must be before
Oct 20
2026
11:23AM
Planning Commission
Public Comment | August 19, 2026 Page 7
6:30am, or I get stuck in the only lane
leaving the island. It takes over an hour
to go less than two miles. Please clarify
where access points will be, whether any
road connections or stubs are proposed
into adjoining properties including mine,
and what traffic improvements are
committed and when they would be built.
5. Acreage discrepancy. The agenda lists
approximately 15.61 acres for the PUD
but 13.47 acres for the concept plan.
Please explain the difference and what is
planned for the remaining acreage. The
burden should be on the applicant to
show that this PUD is better for the
community than development under the
existing rules. Based on the information
available, that case has not been made. I
request deferral, or a recommendation of
denial. I plan to attend the October 21
meeting. Respectfully, Traci Tallent Smith
1712 Fern Hill Drive Johns Island, SC
29455 Phone: 843-343-0607 Email:
smith1674@bellsouth.net
SCOTT TALLENT 1714
FERNHILL
DRIVE
JOHNS
ISLAND, SC
29455
To: City of Charleston Planning
Commission Re: Agenda Item C.1, PUD
and Concept Plan for 3294 and 3280
Maybank Highway and 1730 and 1738
Fern Hill Drive (Johns Island) Meeting:
Wednesday, October 21, 2026, 5:00
p.m. Dear Commissioners, My name is
Scott Tallent, and I own the property at
1714 Fern Hill Drive/TMS #313-00-00-
263, which directly adjoins the parcels in
this application along the north boundary.
I respectfully ask the Commission to defer
this item or recommend denial until the
questions below are answered on the
record. My family has already requested
a deferral because neighboring owners
have not had adequate time to review
the application. 1. Added rights
compared with current zoning. The
application asks for custom rules to
support a 62-lot concept plan. The
agenda does not show what the property
allows today or what additional rights
the PUD would grant. Please require a
side-by-side comparison for each parcel
covering maximum units, minimum lot
sizes, setbacks, heights, permitted uses
and every requested exception. Please
also confirm whether 62 is a binding
Oct 20
2026
11:27AM
Planning Commission
Public Comment | August 19, 2026 Page 8
maximum or only the lot count shown on
this concept plan. 2. Drainage and
flooding. My property, 1714 Fern Hill
Drive, is lower than this proposed site. On
October 10 and 11, 2026, during a
heavy rainstorm, water pooled across my
property for several days. New rooftops,
paving and fill-dirt could push more
stormwater onto adjoining land. Please
require a drainage study showing that
runoff to neighboring properties will not
increase. 3. Buffers and compatibility.
The concept plan should show the width
and type of buffer along my shared
property line, whether trees there will be
preserved, and the setbacks of the
nearest homes. The City Plan calls for
protecting Johns Island's rural character,
trees and wetlands, and this proposal
should show how it does that. 4. Traffic
and access. Maybank Highway is
already extremely congested near this
site. Currently, you must leave Fern Hill
Drive in the morning, before 6:30am, or
you get stuck in bumper-to-bumper
Maybank Hwy traffic. On a good day, it
takes an hour to go less than two miles.
Please clarify where access points will be,
whether any road connections or stubs
are proposed into adjoining properties
including mine, and what traffic
improvements are committed and when
they would be built. 5. Acreage
discrepancy. The agenda lists
approximately 15.61 acres for the PUD
but 13.47 acres for the concept plan.
Please explain the difference and what is
planned for the remaining acreage. The
burden should be on the applicant to
show that this PUD is better for the
community than development under the
existing rules. Based on the information
available, that case has not been made. I
request deferral, or a recommendation of
denial. I plan to attend the October 21
meeting. Respectfully, Scott Tallent
1714 Fern Hill Drive Johns Island, SC
29455 Phone: 843-729-8709 Email:
scott.tallent67@gmail.com
David Bazzle 2459
Marina
Road
Wadmalaw
I am opposed to the new development
because of traffic and privacy issues.
The current infrastructure/roads do not
uphold the current number of residents on
Oct 20
2026
11:41AM
Planning Commission
Public Comment | August 19, 2026 Page 9
Island, SC
29487/Co-
owner of
several
properties
on Fernhill
Drive
Johns Island now. Adding the number of
housing to our island would greatly
impact the traffic even more. Also,
Fernhill Drive is a private drive and we
want to keep it that way. How is the
developer going to guarantee that new
residents from the new housing
development does not trespass on private
property? Please deny this application
and let us keep our little area of Johns
Island private.
Thad Tallent 1718 Fer
hill Drive
Johns
Island, SC
29455
I oppose because of the overgrowth on
Johns Island already. Infrastructure does
not support the population now. Do not
add more to it.
Oct 20
2026
11:58AM
Logan Tallent 1729 Fer
hill Drive
Johns
Island, SC
29455
Johns Island is overpopulated! Traffic is a
nightmare. No more houses.
Oct 20
2026
11:59AM
Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.