RecordWell Data

BZA-Z Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Oct 20, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING PUBLIC COMMENT OCTOBER 20, 2026 A meeting of the Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning (BZA-Z) will be held on Tuesday, October 20, 2026, at 5:15 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street. The following comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of the meeting and also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/bza-z. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 C. PUBLIC HEARINGS – OLD BUSINESS 1. 10 Hester St. Wagener Terrace| Council District 6| TMS# 463-11-03-092 Zoned: SR-2 | BZA2026-002406 Request Variance from Sec. 54-301 to build a south side addition with a 3’ setback (9’ required), a rear addition with a 5’ south side setback (9’ required), and exterior stairs with an 8’ north side setback (9’ required). Owner: Samuel Metzger & Kendal Leonard Applicant: Charles Kane, Formvoid 1 Comment Submitted to Innovate in Support 6 Comments Submitted to Staff in Support (see attached) 1 Comment Submitted to Staff in Opposition (see attached) First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted jarett nicholson 97 St Margaret ST I am writing to you on behalf of the Wagener Terrace Neighborhood Association (WTNA) to express our support for the recent zoning request submitted by Samuel Metzger & Kendal Leonard for the property located at 10 Hester st. The plans for an addition were presented at our WTNA meeting, and the association felt the project was respectful to the neighborhood architecture and a practical use of space. A motion was made and carried to write a letter of support for the variance request and all were in favor. We kindly ask the Board of Zoning Oct 15 2026 7:50PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | October 20, 2026 Page 2 Appeals to consider this letter as a formal expression of our support for the zoning request at 10 Hester Street. We believe that granting this variance will contribute positively to the property and to our neighborhoods cohesiveness. Thank you for your time and consideration. President, Wagener Terrace Neighborhood Association June 15, 2026 I am writing to express my support for the request by Sam Metzger and Kendal Leonard, who reside at 10 Hester St, to add a mudroom over the setback line. As their neighbor, I have been informed of the proposed changes and understand the plans. I believe the proposed addition is appropriate and will not negatively affect the character or integrity of the neighborhood. I support their efforts to improve their property in a way that is thoughtful and consistent with the surrounding community. Please consider this my formal statement of support for their request to the Board of Zoning Appeals. Sincerely, Stacey and Adam Bailey 39 Alberta Ave ------------ Stacey L. Bailey (She/Her) 770-329-7709 June 16, 2026 To whom it may concern, We are writing to express our support for the request by Sam Metzger and Kendal Leonard, who reside at 10 Hester St, to add a mudroom over the setback line. As their next door neighbor, we have been informed of the proposed changes and understand the plans. We believe the proposed addition is appropriate and will not negatively affect the character or integrity of the neighborhood. We support their efforts to improve their property in a way that is thoughtful and consistent with the surrounding community. Please consider this our formal statement of support for their request to the Board of Zoning Appeals. Sincerely, Bryan & Lindsey Heffner 4 Hester Street Charleston, SC 29403 To Whom It May concern, I am writing to express my support for the request by Sam Metzger and Kendal Leonard, who reside at 10 Hester St, to add a mudroom over the setback line. As their neighbor, I have been informed of the proposed changes and understand the plans. I believe the proposed addition is appropriate and will not negatively affect the character or integrity of the neighborhood. I support their efforts to improve their property in a way that is thoughtful and consistent with the surrounding community. Please consider this my formal statement of support for their request to the Board of Zoning Appeals. Sincerely, Brooke and Ryan Atwood Post Office Box 1120 ∙ Charleston, SC 29402 ∙ (843) 723-1623 ∙ Fax (843) 577-2067 ∙ www.historiccharleston.org To: Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals From: Kate Dutilly, Preservation Planner Date: October 20, 2026 Re: 10 Hester Historic Charleston Foundation (HCF) has reviewed the application for a variance from Sec. 54- 301 to construct a south side addition with a 3-foot setback (9 feet required), a rear addition with a 5-foot south side setback (9 feet required), and exterior stairs with an 8-foot north side setback (9 feet required). HCF does not believe the application meets the criteria required for a variance. The applicant has not demonstrated that extraordinary or exceptional conditions unique to 10 Hester Street warrant relief from the ordinance. The presence of a historic structure, in and of itself, does not establish unnecessary hardship. Numerous historic properties throughout the Wagener Terrace neighborhood have the same conditions and are also subject to BAR and zoning requirements. Furthermore, the applicant has not demonstrated that granting the requested variances would avoid substantial detriment to adjacent properties or the public good, or that the character of the district would be preserved. The existing one-story, 1940s-era house is representative of the Wagener Terrace neighborhood and contributes to its historic character as is. The proposed additions would overwhelm the historic structure, diminish its architectural integrity, and compromise the historic character of the surrounding neighborhood. Approval of this variance request would result in a heavily altered building that has a detrimental impact on the adjacent properties and negatively impact the character of the district, failing the hardship test. Because the applicant has not demonstrated that the request meets the required findings for unnecessary hardship, and because the proposed addition will be of detriment to the historic character of the neighborhood, Historic Charleston Foundation respectfully recommends that the Board deny the application. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | October 20, 2026 Page 4 2. 1025 Sam Rittenberg Blvd. West Ashley| Council District 9 | TMS# 415-10-00-073 Zoned LB/SR-1| BZA2026-002460 Request Use Variance to allow a personal service use (wedding photography) on the SR-1 portion of the existing split zoned parcel. Owner: 1025 Sam Rittenberg Blvd., LLC Applicant: Ashley River Hall, LLC c/o Ellis Lesemann 1 Comment Submitted to Innovate in Opposition First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Tim e Submitted Corey Frazier 14 Leichester Road, Charleston , SC In addition to my prior comments from the deferred submission regarding the prior unpermitted construction that occurred on this portion of the parcel and other related impacts this variance would create, the operator has already built a fence along the proposed SR-1 line prior to zoning approval. While I am not opposed to the fence separating the property to ensure that the SR-1 portion of the parcel is not used for commercial use, it does yet again demonstrate the operator not following proper processes and decision to move forward with use and/or construction without approvals. Allowing a variance for the use of the property in any commercial use will set a precedent that the SR- 1 can be utilized for commercial use and further the opportunity for misuse of the property, encroach on critical line setbacks, and further push the operations of this venue into neighboring properties line of sight and create additional impacts as described in my previous submission. Oct 16 2026 1:50PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | October 20, 2026 Page 5 D. PUBLIC HEARINGS – NEW BUSINESS 2. 10 Percy St. Cannonborough/Elliottborough | Council District 6 | TMS# 460-08-03-159 Zoned: DR-2F | BZA2026-002483 Request Use Variance to allow a personal service use (wedding venue) on a DR-2F zoned parcel. Owner/Applicant: Brenna Lynden 5 Comments Submitted to Innovate in Opposition 1 Comment Submitted to Staff in Opposition (see attached) First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted Vince Palazzo 32 Bogard St Dear Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals, I own and live in my home at 32 Bogard Street, 150 feet / doors from 10 Percy Street. I respectfully urge the Board to deny the requested use variance to allow a wedding venue on this DR-2F parcel. DR-2F is a residential district. A commercial event venue is fundamentally incompatible with it. Weddings bring amplified music, large groups of guests arriving and leaving late at night, caterers, rental and vendor trucks, and heavy demand for parking and rideshare pickups on streets that are already narrow and congested. These impacts would recur every weekend and would substantially harm the adjacent properties and the residential character of the neighborhood. A use variance requires an unnecessary hardship arising from conditions peculiar to the property. I am not aware of anything unique about 10 Percy Street that prevents its reasonable use as a residence, as permitted in DR-2F. The desire to use the property more profitably is not a hardship. Families with young children, chose this neighborhood because it is residential. Recurring late-night events would disrupt the sleep and quiet enjoyment that DR-2F zoning is meant to protect For these reasons, I ask the Board to deny BZA2026-002483. If the Board is inclined to approve, I ask that it defer the case so neighbors can review the details of the operation. Oct 15 2026 8:21PM David Underwood 29 Bogard Street Good Morning Members of the Board, We own 29 Bogard Street, which adjoins 10 Percy Street. We respectfully oppose the request for a use variance to allow Oct 16 2026 9:16AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | October 20, 2026 Page 6 The applicants have clearly cared for their home, and we appreciate the limits they have proposed. Still, we believe a commercial event use is not appropriate for this residential block, for the following reasons. First, the variance runs with the land. The application relies on the owners living at the property full time, but a variance stays with the property after a sale. A future owner who does not live there could operate the same event use, and owner occupancy is not a condition the Board can easily guarantee over time. Second, the proposed limits are hard to define and enforce. "A limited number of Saturdays each month" has no fixed number, and the four-hour limit does not say whether it includes vendor setup and breakdown. Neighbors would be left to monitor compliance and report problems, and the City has limited ability to enforce these limits on a weekend. Third, parking and drop-off would burden the block. The application provides two driveway spaces for up to twenty guests. Events like those shown also bring a photographer, florist, officiant, and rental deliveries for draping, chairs, and arches. On-street parking on Percy Street and surrounding streets is already scarce. Repeated rideshare drop- offs and vendor vans on a narrow residential street would affect every resident nearby. Fourth, there is no hardship unique to the property. A variance requires an unusual condition of the property itself that creates a hardship. This application describes a business opportunity, not a hardship. If approved, other owners with attractive porches or gardens could make the same request, and the block would gradually take on a commercial character. Fifth, the use would disrupt residential quiet. Even without amplified music, ceremonies bring applause, guest gatherings, and photography in outdoor areas, as well as early setup and late breakdown. Neighbors on this block reasonably expect weekends at home without a recurring commercial event next door. Finally, ample venues already exist. Charleston and the surrounding area already have numerous public and private wedding venues, including many suited to small elopements. Couples have plenty of options in areas zoned and equipped for events. We Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | October 20, 2026 Page 7 do not believe it would be prudent to approve an event use within a quiet residential neighborhood when that demand is already well served elsewhere. For these reasons, we respectfully ask the Board to deny the request. Thank you for your time and your service to the neighborhood. Brian Allen 36 Bogard Street I oppose this request due to concerns for noise as well as parking. Noise and parking are already current issues in our neighborhood due to existing short term rentals and popular restaurants - a wedding venue would only exacerbate these existing struggles. If the city wants to maintain the long term residents we have in this neighborhood, I recommend denying this application. Oct 18 2026 5:42PM Jason Coy 31 Bogard Street I own a home down the street from 10 Percy, and I strongly oppose this use variance request because of the adverse effects the proposed use as a wedding venue would have on our neighborhood. If it is used as a wedding venue, it would create parking, noise, and trash collection issues. Despite the applicant’s assurances that the number of wedding guests would be limited, there is no way for them to prohibit guests, photographers, caterers, bartenders, musicians, officiants, wedding planners, etc., from parking on the street. This would affect neighborhood residents and local businesses that rely on already scarce street parking. It is also unclear how the applicant would enforce their supposed ban on amplified music or loudspeakers. The owner of this property bought it as a residential property, and there is no unnecessary hardship created by the BZA rejecting this variance request. Oct 19 2026 9:03AM Stephen Ramos 48 Bogard Street Dear City Staff and Members of the BZA-Z, As a resident of the Elliotborough- Cannonborough neighborhood and an architect with a strong background in urban design, I am writing in opposition to the proposed use variance at **10 Percy Street**, which would allow an existing residence to operate as a small wedding venue on a limited number of Saturdays each month. Our neighborhood has historically supported the reestablishment of commercial uses **only at corner properties with a documented history of commercial activity.** This is an important distinction. The neighborhood has not supported introducing Oct 19 2026 9:24AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | October 20, 2026 Page 8 commercial uses into traditionally residential properties with no commercial history. The commercial uses we have supported, such as neighborhood restaurants, help reactivate historic commercial corners, contribute to a vibrant streetscape, and enhance our community. Maintaining this balance between commercial and residential uses is essential to preserving the character and livability of Elliotborough-Cannonborough. **Perhaps most importantly, I see no meaningful public benefit to the proposed use variance.** Unlike restaurants or neighborhood-serving businesses, a private wedding venue serves only invited guests. It does not provide an amenity for residents, activate the streetscape, or enhance neighborhood vitality. Instead, it introduces commercial activity into a residential setting, with the potential for increased traffic, parking demands, noise, and disruption. I certainly respect the property owner's desire to explore new opportunities for their home, and my opposition is not personal. Rather, it comes from a genuine interest in protecting the residential character of our neighborhood and maintaining a consistent approach to land use. Approval could also establish an undesirable precedent for converting other residential properties into commercial event venues. **10 Percy Street is a lovely residence that contributes positively to the residential fabric of our neighborhood.** I would love to see it remain a residence. For these reasons, I respectfully ask the Board to deny the requested use variance. Thank you for your consideration. Stephen Ramos Elliotborough-Cannonborough Resident October 19, 2026 Board of Zoning Appeals Attn: Christopher Swalhah City of Charleston 2 George Street Charleston, SC 29401 Re: 10 Percy Street application Dear Chairman and Members of the Board: I am writing in my capacity as President of the Cannonborough-Elliotborough Neighborhood Association (CENA) to express the Association's concern regarding the application for a personal services wedding venue at 10 Percy Street. CENA greatly appreciates engagement with the neighborhood and its residents. The applicant here has not communicated with the neighborhood regarding this application. Our Association and our Design and Development Committee find that this application runs counter to CENA's longstanding record of opposing commercial uses in purely residential areas away from the commercially zoned thoroughfares or street corners. Being responsive to the feedback and concerns raised by our residents, we find that such commercial uses adversely affect residents’ quality of life. This proposal is for a parcel deep in a residential block on Percy Street. I am unable to attend the meeting of the Board due to a meeting out of town; however, on behalf of the Cannonborough-Elliotborough Neighborhood Association, please accept this letter of deep concern regarding the 10 Percy Street wedding venue application. Sincerely, George Seago, IV President, Cannonborough-Elliotborough Neighborhood Association Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | October 20, 2026 Page 9 3. 29 Henrietta St. Garden District| Council District 4 | TMS# 460-12-01-081 Zoned: DR-2F | BZA2026-002484 Request Variance from Sec. 54-301 to build a duplex with 1,592sf per unit (2,000sf required), a front setback of 0’ (25’ required), a 3’ west side setback (7’ required), and a Variance from Sec. 54-317 to provide no off-street parking spaces (4 spaces required). Owner: Christopher Finn, Eadwacer Holdings LLC Applicant: Kenny Craft, Design Studio 2 Comments Submitted to Staff in Support (see attached) Post Office Box 1120 ∙ Charleston, SC 29402 ∙ (843) 723-1623 ∙ Fax (843) 577-2067 ∙ www.historiccharleston.org To: Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals From: Kate Dutilly, Preservation Planner Date: October 20, 2026 Re: 29 Henrietta Street Historic Charleston Foundation (HCF) has reviewed the application for 29 Henrietta Street requesting variances from Sec. 54-301 to construct a duplex with 1,592 square feet per unit (2,000 square feet required), a 0-foot front setback (25 feet required), and a 3-foot west side setback (7 feet required), as well as a variance from Sec. 54-317 to provide no off-street parking spaces (4 spaces required). HCF appreciates the applicant meeting with us prior to submitting the application. The site was historically occupied by a duplex that was subsequently and unfortunately demolished. HCF supports the proposed construction as an opportunity to reestablish the historic building pattern along Henrietta Street. The requested setback variances would allow the new structure to reflect the historic urban character of the street, where buildings were traditionally situated close to or directly along the public right-of-way. HCF also supports the requested parking variance, as we do not believe providing parking beneath the structure is an appropriate solution for this site, or within the historic district. We recognize the neighbors’ concerns regarding on-street parking along Henrietta Street and encourage the applicant to explore alternative options for leased parking spaces. HCF believes the proposed development presents an opportunity to restore the historic character of this site and that the requested variances are appropriate to support this goal. Historic Charleston Foundation respectfully recommends that the Board approve the application. 9'-6"2'-11"2'-11" 2'-11"2'-11"2'-11"2'-11"2'-11"2'-11"CONTEMPLATIONBASIN SURVIVORS'GARDEN 6 X 6TRANSFORMERDUMPSTER CALHOUN STREET HENRIETTA STREET 48 PARKING SPOTS SEPTIMA'S PATH AME MOTHEREMANUEL CHURCH 104106 21'-7" 26'-8"62'-10" 26'-3"70'-8" 120'-5"MEMORIAL COURTYARD 48'-0"SURVIVORS' GARDEN6'-0"6'-0" 6'-0" 37'-0"30'-1" 6'-0"49'-0" 7'-0" 7'-0"34'-0" 6'-2" 10'-6"20'-2"58'-7"27'-11" 58'-4"VISITORS' GARDEN RELOCATEDEXISTING PALM TREE 10'-7"10'-7"10'-7"10'-7" MEMORIALCOURTYARD 10'-0"17'-2"9'-7"9'-6"9'-4"9'-8"12'-8" 7'-0"7'-0" 63'-0" 7'-0" 7'-0" 7'-0"7'-0" 48'-10" 47'-8" EQUIPMENTBUILDING 23'-0"72'-0"34'-8"10'-0" 116"=1'-0" A101SITE PLAN ARCHITECT KEY PLAN NO.DATE SEAL & SIGNATURESCALE:PROJECT NO:DRAWING TITLE: DRAWING NO: STRUCTURAL ENGINEER HANDEL ARCHITECTS LLP120 BROADWAY, 6TH FLOORNEW YORK, NY 10271WWW.HANDELARCHITECTS.COM CIVIL ENGINEER GEOTECH © 2022 Handel Architects LLP - All Rights Reserved GUY NORDENSON AND ASSOCIATES29 BROADWAY, 18TH FLOORNEW YORK, NY 10006WWW.NORDENSON.COMTHOMAS & HUTTON682 JOHNIE DODDS BLVD, STE 100MT. PLEASANT, SC 29464WWW.TANDH.COM S&ME620 WANDO PARK BLVD.MT. PLEASANT, SC 29464WWW.SMEINC.COM ISSUANCE OWNERMOTHER EMANUEL MEMORIAL FOUNDATIONPO BOX 242CHARLESTON, SC 29402WWW.EMANUELNINE.ORG 1322 110 CALHOUN ST, CHARLESTON, SC 29401 WATER FEATUREDAN EUSER WATERARCHITECTURE INC401 QUEENS QUAY WEST, UNIT 102TORONTO, ON, CANADA M5V2Y2WWW.DEWINC.BIZ LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTDESIGNWORKS205 12 KING STREETCHARLESTON, SC 29401WWW.DESIGNWORKSLC.COM HENRIETTA ST CALHOUN ST 02.03.2022100% DESIGN DEVELOPMENT LIGHTING DESIGNERFISHER MARANTZ STONE22 WEST 19TH ST, FLOOR 6NEW YORK, NY 10011WWW.FMSP.COM MECHANICAL ENGINEERALTIERI SEBOR WIEBER LLC31 KNIGHT ST, NORWALK CT 06851111 DEVONSHIRE ST, BOSTON, MA 02109WWW.ALTIERISEBORWIEBER.COM SECURITY DESIGNINSITE RISK MANAGEMENT150W 30TH ST, SUITE 700NEW YORK, NY 10001WWW.INSITERISKMANAGEMENT.COM 03.03.202250% CONSTRUCTION DOCS06.03.2022100% CONSTRUCTION DOCS GRAPHIC DESIGNPENTAGRAM250 PARK AVENUE SOUTHNEW YORK, NY 10003WWW.PENTAGRAM.COM 06.24.2022BID SET 1SITE PLAN1/16"=1'-0" 10' EASEMENT FOR PLANTING CLEARANCE AREA FOR TRANSFORMER 29 HENRIETTA Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | October 20, 2026 Page 10 4. 51 ½ Gibbes St. Charlestowne| Council District 8 | TMS# 457-11-02-087 Zoned: STR | BZA2026-002485 Request Special Exception under Sec. 54-501 and a Variance from Sec. 54-301 to build a detached single-family home on a lot of insufficient size (6,000sf required, 4416sf existing) with a 22’ rear setback (25’ required). Owner: 51.5 Gibbes St. LLC Applicant: Julie O’Connor – American Vernacular Inc. 3 Comments Submitted to Staff in Support (see attached) From:Sebastian von Marschallsebastian@svmarchitect.com Subject:Re: 51 1/2 Gibbes Date:September 15, 2026 at 3:30 PM To:Julie O’Connorjulieoconnor@mac.com Cc:Scott Hayesscottdhayes1@gmail.com,Gildersleeve, Garygildersleeve@evercore.com,Alexandra Byrne alexandra@bowheadllc.com,CNA Boardcharlestowneneighborhood@gmail.com Hi Julie, Thank you for your call, and for updating the CNA on this particular request. We are pleased that you took the initiative with the neighbors and have their support. The CNA takes no exception with the request. Good luck with the project. Best, Sebastian Sebastian von Marschall Principal Sebastian von Marschall Architect, LLC 39 Broad Street, Suite 100 Charleston, SC 29401 843.790.4924 www.SvMArchitect.com On Tue, Sep 15, 2026 at 10:03​AM Julie O’Connor <julieoconnor@mac.com> wrote: Hi Sebastian! Thank you for taking my phone call this morning. As we discussed, we have worked out a compromise with the abutting neighbors regarding the siting of the house and have received 2 letters of support that I am attaching here. We will now be applying for a special exception to build a single family residence on a lot of insufficient size and a 2’-6” rear setback variance. Thank you! Julie On Aug 25, 2026, at 8:03 PM, Sebastian von Marschall <sebastian@svmarchitect.com> wrote: Hi Julie, Thank you for following up with the update. I am sorry to hear about the neighbor's concerns, and I am glad you arranged a meeting with the owner to address them. If neighbors disagree or voice opposition to a request, the CNA strongly advocates for the owners and neighbors to resolve their differences. As a rule, the CNA does not take a position or hear requests in this instance but defers to the relevant board (BZA or BAR) to review the circumstances. In the event a contentious application is not resolved by the neighbors, the CNA will typically recommend deferral for further study and revision as needed to address the concerns of the relevant board. I strongly encourage the applicant and the neighbors to work to find a resolution. Please let me know if you have any questions! Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | October 20, 2026 Page 12 6. 88 King St. Charlestowne| Council District 8 | TMS# 457-12-04-035 Zoned: SR-5 | BZA2026-002487 Request Special Exception under Sec. 54-110.f. to vertically extend a nonconforming 0’ east side setback (3’ required) and a Variance from Sec. 54-301 to build a two-story rear addition with a lot occupancy of 43% (35% maximum, 38% existing). Owners: Meredith and Karan Das-Grande Applicant: Glenn Keyes Architects 2 Comments Submitted to Staff in Support (see attached)

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.