RecordWell Data

Public Safety Committee Agenda

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Oct 20, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CHARLESTON CITY HALL  80 BROAD STREET  CHARLESTON, SOUTH CAROLINA 29401  (843) 724-3727 City of Charleston South Carolina Clerk of Council Department PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE MEETING AGENDA City Hall, Council Chamber 80 Broad Street https://www.youtube.com/@CityofCharlestonSCgov/streams October 20, 2026 4:00 p.m. 1. Moment of Silence 2. Minutes: September 15, 2026 3. Any person who speaks at a Public Safety Committee meeting shall conduct himself or herself in a manner appropriate to the decorum of the meeting and is asked to observe Section 2-28 (a) of the Code of the City of Charleston, Rules of Decorum. Violation of the Rules of Decorum may result in the forfeiture of audience before the Committee and/or removal from the meeting. Citizens can participate at the meeting or leave comments for the Committee by completing the form at http://innovate.charleston- sc.gov/comments/. Comments must be received by 12:00 p.m., Tuesday, October 20, 2026. 4. Police Department: Approval to submit an application for the FY27 Ernest E. Kennedy Center Alcohol Enforcement Team grant in the amount of $3,000.00. Funds will help combat underage drinking and drug use with ID software and field intelligence training. There is no match required for this grant. 5. Police Department: After -the-fact approval to accept an award for the FY26 Ernest E. Kennedy Center A lcohol Enforcement Team grant in the amount of $5,000.00. Funds will combat underage drinking with ID software and field intelligence training. There is no match required for this grant. CHARLESTON CITY HALL  80 BROAD STREET  CHARLESTON, SOUTH CAROLINA 29401  (843) 724-3727 6. Police Department: Approval to accept an award for the Q4 2026 Firehouse Subs Public Safety Foundation Grant in the amount of $21,106.54. The grant will fund an all -terrain vehicle for the Mounted Patrol Team. No match is required for this grant. 7. Police Department: Approval to accept an award for the SFY27 SCDPS Body - Worn Camera Grant in the amount of $196,634.18. The grant will help reimburse the costs of CPD’s body -worn camera replacement project. There is no match required for this grant. 8. Police Department: Approval to accept the FY26 Port Security Grant Program award in the amount of $314,453. 00. The grant will fund 1) maritime operations and safety gear and 2) portable X -ray systems for hazard detection for CPD. The grant requires a 25% cash match of $78,613.00, which CPD has budgeted for FY27. 9. Police Department: After -the-fact approval to submit an application for the FY26 BJA Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant in the amount of $51,014.00. The grant will fund traffic and marine patrol equipment. There is no match required for this grant. 10. Presentation regarding evaluation of alternative location for Fire Station 20 on the Cainhoy Peninsula. Action may be taken. 11. Consideration of amendments to ordinance re: First Amendment Demonstrations and potential action 12. Adjournment In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, people who need alternative formats, ASL (American Sign Language) Interpretation or other acc ommodation please contact Janet Schumacher at (843) 577 -1389 or email to schumacherj@charleston-sc.gov three business days prior to the meeting. C I T Y O F CHARLESTONSC FACIL ITIE S & CAPIT AL PR OJECT S FIRE STATION 20 SITE EVALUATION Clements Ferry Road Corridor Property Analysis OCTOBER 2 2, 20 26 PU BLIC SAFETY COMMI TTEE BRI EFING PURPOSE & BACKGROUND Why staff is bringing this item to committee PURPOSE The City of Charleston previously evaluated four potential properties in 2025 and is further evaluating two potential properties along the Clements Ferry Road corridor for a new Fire Station 20 facility. This briefing presents both sites and the evaluation framework staff used to compare them. REQUESTED ACTION Committee review of both sites and the evaluation criteria, in advance of a staff recommendation for property acquisition, up to and including condemnation AT A GLANCE 2 Potential properties under review 9 Evaluation criteria applied to each site 1 Corridor: Clements Ferry Road CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 2 4 Potential properties reviewed March 2025* * Reference: Fire Station 20 Site Selection presentation to Public Safety on March 11, 2025 by Malena Dinwoodie, Real Estate Management Director FIRE STATION 20 PROGRAMMING NEEDS Building and site programming needs used to provide test -fits for each site 1 12,000 to 14,500 square foot facility 2 Minimum of 25 to 28 parking spaces, including required ADA spaces per code 3 Minimum 80’ front apparatus drive 4 Preferred single -story facility 5 Drive-through bays 6 Number of apparatus bays: 2.5 to 3 apparatus bays for an E -120, high water vehicle and and Battalion Chief vehicle 7 Offices: three for Captain, Battalion Chief, and Fire Marshal 8 Number of Bunks: seven to nine semi-private bunks with two private bunks for Captain and Battalion Chief 9 Training room not required but would prove beneficial to CFD and surrounding community CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 3 SITE LOCATIONS 1 2 1 2 Property 1 Eastern Site 2637 Clements Ferry Rd Property 2 Western Site Cooper Towne Rd @ Klister Ln CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 4 SITE LOCATIONS 1 2 1 2 Property 1 Eastern Site 2637 Clements Ferry Rd Property 2 Western Site Cooper Towne Rd @ Klister Ln CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 4 EVALUATION CRITERIA Factors used to compare proposed sites 1 Environmental Impact 2 Land Use 3 Impact to Individual Landowners 4 Cost 5 Visual Impact 6 Safety 7 Aesthetics 8 Reliability 9 Other Factors & Long -Range Area Planning CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 5 PROPERTY 1 2637 Clements Ferry Road ~4.0 ACRES - APPROXIMATE PENDING PLAT OVERALL SITE ~ 22.0 ACRES NEEDED ~ 3.5 to 4.0 ACRES ● ADDRESS 2637 Clements Ferry Road Charleston, SC PARCEL STATUS Platted parcel with assigned address Entire parcel not needed, partial acquisition anticipated PURCHASE PRICE To be determined Additional due diligence (environmental) is pending and will inform the final comparison. CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 6 1 2 EVALUATION CRITERIA Factors used to compare proposed sites 1 Environmental Impact 2 Land Use 3 Impact to Individual Landowners 4 Cost 5 Visual Impact 6 Safety 7 Aesthetics 8 Reliability 9 Other Factors & Long -Range Area Planning CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 10 PROPERTY 2 TBD ~3.08 ACRES - APPROXIMATE PENDING PLAT OVERALL SITE ~ 22.0 ACRES ● CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 11 1 2 PARCELS Portions of TMS 271-00-01-035, -129, -037, -123, and -038 PARCEL STATUS Not yet platted No address currently assigned Portion of property included in the Development PURCHASE PRICE To be determined Acreage, boundaries, and site data are pending plat finalization for the combined parcels. ● • Does any alternative cross a wetland, floodplain, water body or protected area? • Yes, limited wetland impacts (driveway) • Possibly under SHPO purview • Would construction on any alternative likely require federal or state permitting? • Yes, State (SCDOT standard permitting, and Federal (wetland permitting) • Yes, State (SCDOT standard permitting) • Are there known protected species or sensitive habitat along any alternative? • No • No • How does the comparative footprint of ecological disturbance differ across alternatives? • Existing site is impervious. Improvements will decrease the impervious area. No tree clearing needed, and limited fill needed. • Significant ecological disturbance due to tree removals and ubstantial amount of fill being brought to the site. EVALUATION CRITERIA - ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT Definitions and Key Evaluation Questions DEFINITION The extent to which an alternative would affect natural resources, water features, wetlands, or protected habitat, and the associated permitting exposure that follows from that effect. KEY EVALUATION QUESTIONS CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 17 PROPERTY 1 (EASTERN SITE) PROPERTY 2 (WESTERN SITE) • Does any alternative conflict with an existing structure, an approved plat, or an announced construction plan? • No, existing site is a gravel and paved parking lot • No • Is the property's highest -and-best use likely to be affected differently by each alternative? • No • No • Does the preferred alternative align with the acquiring authority's own operational or service -area needs? • Yes • No EVALUATION CRITERIA - LAND USE Definitions and Key Evaluation Questions DEFINITION KEY EVALUATION QUESTIONS CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 18 PROPERTY 1 (EASTERN SITE) PROPERTY 2 (WESTERN SITE) The compatibility of each alternative with the current and reasonably anticipated future use of the affected property and surrounding area, from both the acquiring authority's operational need and the landowner's perspective. • How many landowners are affected under each alternative, and how does that number compare across alternatives? • One property owner • Three property owners - over six properties will be affected. • What specific impact (visibility, access limitation, use restriction, improvements affected) does each landowner experience? • Decreases visibility from Clements Ferry Rd. • Improved access with right in and out from parcel to Clements Ferry Rd. • This would be a full taking of the parcel labeled “fire station”, and the majority of parcels 271-00-01-129, -123, and small portions of -037, -038 and outparcel A (271-00-01-035) • Has each landowner had a meaningful opportunity to propose or respond to alternatives? • Yes • Unknown- Inlight requested that this property be re-evaluated along with the addition of several other properties. EVALUATION CRITERIA - IMPACT TO INDIVIDUAL LAND OWNERS Definitions and Key Evaluation Questions DEFINITION The specific, individualized effect of each alternative on every landowner whose property would be crossed or burdened. This is assessed parcel by parcel, not only for the landowner most engaged in the process. KEY EVALUATION QUESTIONS CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 19 PROPERTY 1 (EASTERN SITE) PROPERTY 2 (WESTERN SITE) • What is the land acquisition cost for each alternative, based on parcel-specific valuation? • TBD • TBD • What is the total project cost (design fees + facility construction costs + right-of-way construction costs) for each alternative? • Construction costs are estimated to be lower due to less fill, no tree removals, no retaining walls, etc. Road construction costs comparable as well as design fees. • Construction costs estimated to be higher due to the amount of fill needed, tree removals, retaining walls, etc. Road construction costs comparable as well as design fees. • What are the permitting costs for each alternative? • Permitting costs comparable for both • Permitting costs comparable for both • Was land acquisition cost presented to the decision -making body as its own line item, or only folded into a general estimate? • Estimated cost of land acquisition is held as an independent line item. • Estimated cost of land acquisition is held as an independent line item. • Does the comparison account for remainder damages, not just the value of the interest actually taken? • No • No EVALUATION CRITERIA - COST Definitions and Key Evaluation Questions DEFINITION KEY EVALUATION QUESTIONS CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 20 PROPERTY 1 (EASTERN SITE) PROPERTY 2 (WESTERN SITE) The total projected cost of each alternative (i.e. construction, engineering, and right-of-way acquisition) with land acquisition cost itemized and based on parcel-specific valuation rather than a general-area assumption. • Will the structures be visible from any residence on the remainder or an adjacent parcel under each alternative? • No • Potential visibility from planned multi -family • At what distance, and is there existing topographic or vegetative screening? • Site located along CFR frontage with 50’ buffer • Site set back off Clements Ferry Rd behind future commercial/retail parcel (outparcel A) • Does visibility (or its absence) correspond to a measurable difference in remainder value? • No • No EVALUATION CRITERIA - VISUAL IMPACT Definitions and Key Evaluation Questions DEFINITION The extent to which the completed improvement will be visible from specific vantage points , in particular, any residence or other sensitive use on the remainder or an adjacent property. KEY EVALUATION QUESTIONS CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 21 PROPERTY 1 (EASTERN SITE) PROPERTY 2 (WESTERN SITE) • Is any alternative closer to a known hazard (an airport, another utility corridor, a densely occupied structure) than the others? • Requires roadway improvements to • Cell tower • Does the geometry of any alternative introduce added construction or long-term structural risk? • No • Yes, • Does one alternative provide better or safer access to Clements Ferry Road and the general fire coverage area? • Yes, with future developments, CFD is anticipating higher call volume North on Clements Ferry = right turns • No, with future developments, CFD is anticipating higher call volume North on Clements Ferry = left turns and stacked traffic at light. EVALUATION CRITERIA - SAFETY Definitions and Key Evaluation Questions DEFINITION KEY EVALUATION QUESTIONS CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 22 PROPERTY 1 (EASTERN SITE) PROPERTY 2 (WESTERN SITE) The relative risk each alternative poses to persons and property, including proximity to identifiable hazards and any added construction or structural risk created by route geometry. • How many additional angle structures, guy wires, or anchors does each alternative require relative to the straightest feasible path? • None • Cell tower • Is the resulting infrastructure consistent with the general character of the area? • Yes • Yes; however it is preferred to have a fire station along the main corridor for visibility. EVALUATION CRITERIA - AESTHETICS Definitions and Key Evaluation Questions DEFINITION The general visual and design character of the completed improvement, independent of any single vantage point — principally, the number of turns, angle structures, guy wires, and anchors the route's geometry requires, and whether the result is consistent with the character of the area. KEY EVALUATION QUESTIONS CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 23 PROPERTY 1 (EASTERN SITE) PROPERTY 2 (WESTERN SITE) • System demand or load data supporting the underlying project need • Facility replaces not only an existing station 20 but is intended to provide coverage for future development along the Clements Ferry corridor. • Facility replaces not only an existing station 20 but is intended to provide coverage for future development along the Clements Ferry corridor. • Correspondence documenting any specific customer or growth driver for the project • Substantial development initiatives North on Clements Ferry Rd. • Substantial development initiatives North on Clements Ferry Rd. • An engineering comparison of route length and structure count across alternatives • Right turn • Approximately 300’ to Clements Ferry Rd • Left turn and stacking is of concern. • Approximately 400’ to Clements Ferry Rd • Capacity studies, if any • None • None EVALUATION CRITERIA - RELIABILITY Definitions and Key Evaluation Questions DEFINITION KEY EVALUATION QUESTIONS CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 24 SITE 1 (EASTERN SITE) SITE 2 (WESTERN SITE) Both (a) the system-wide or operational justification for the project (i.e. why it is needed to serve present or reasonably anticipated demand) and (b) the route-specific factors, chiefly length and straightness, that affect the long-term operational reliability of the completed facility. • Does any documented long -range plan by the acquiring authority or another public authority bear on this decision? • Offers future expansion possibilities • Does not offer any future expansion possibilities • Are there other factors specific to this property, (i.e historical, cultural, rchaeological significance, or an opportunity for joint use with an existing corridor) not captured by the other criteria? • Allows for future connection and cross access to Beresford Run and Grande Oaks Drive • Allows access within Cooper Towne development and future Everly St to LeGrand Blvd. • Impacts to the parcel and driveway for New Mary Ann Baptist Church EVALUATION CRITERIA - OTHER FACTORS & LONG-RANGE AREA PLANNING Definitions and Key Evaluation Questions DEFINITION An open-ended category for any additional factor genuinely relevant to the specific property or route decision that does not fit neatly within the other categories, expressing including documented long-range planning for growth, capacity, or land use by the acquiring authority or another public authority. KEY EVALUATION QUESTIONS CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 25 SITE 1 (EASTERN SITE) SITE 2 (WESTERN SITE) SITE COMPARISON Evaluation status across adopted criteria CRITERIA PROPERTY 1 - Eastern Site Clements Ferry Rd @ Beresford Run PROPERTY 2 - Western Site Cooper Towne Rd @ Klister Ln Acreage ~22 ACRES OVERALL ~ 3.5 to 4.0 NEEDED ~ 3.08 ACRES Purchase Price NEUTRAL NEUTRAL Environmental Impact SUPERIOR INFERIOR Land Use SUPERIOR INFERIOR Impact to Individual Landowners SUPERIOR INFERIOR Visual Impact SUPERIOR INFERIOR Safety SUPERIOR INFERIOR Aesthetics SUPERIOR INFERIOR Reliability SUPERIOR INFERIOR Other Factors / Long-Range Planning SUPERIOR INFERIOR CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 26 SITE COMPARISON Inlight contentions for comparison of Eastern site at Clements Ferry Rd and Beresford Run v. Western site at Cooper Towne Rd and Klister Ln CRITERIA PROPERTY 1 - Eastern Site Clements Ferry @ Beresford Run PROPERTY 2 - Western Site Cooper Towne Rd @ Klister Ln Accessibility One lane of ingress and two lanes of egress. Property located on Clements Ferry Rd frontage. Four exit lanes onto Clements Ferry Rd. Property located off Clements Ferry Rd behind commercial property with vehicular stacking Water service Nearest usable water line is 10” DIP; requires a cut-in tap and a road crossing. Cost is not considered excessive for a new fire station. Water service already stubbed out to the property line Sanitary sewer No gravity option; requires a new sewer lift with new force main connecting to existing 4” force main on south side of Beresford Run Gravity-fed sewer available at site due to substantial volume of fill brought on site. Site grade / fill Minimum fill needed. No retaining walls anticipated. Grades south of development are several feet lower than adjacent parcels; all parcels require substantial volume of imported fill. Developer brought in 5’-8’ of fill. Impacts to adjacent commercial property and existing church. Flood zone Property is in zone AE (EL 10), with Zone AE (EL 11) immediately adjacent; building will not be located within flood hazard zone and will be approx.+5’ above nearby flood zones Located outside the Zone AE special flood hazard area Stormwater No comparable master-planned system nearby; stormwater must be designed and permitted from scratch. Existing site is mostly impervious and new developed site would decrease pervious area allowing more infiltration. Existing master-planned system as part of the overall Towne at Cooper River development. CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 27 STAFF RECOMMENDATION To be finalized upon completion of site analysis RECOMMENDED SITE: PROPERTY 1 (EASTERN SITE), 2637 Clements Ferry Road, Charleston, SC RECOMMEN DATION W EIG HS TH E FOL LOW ING: • Cost and long-term value to the City • Environmental and land-use impacts of each site • Impacts to individual property owners nearby • Safety, reliability, and response coverage for the corridor • Consistency with long-range area planning by public authorities CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 7CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 28 NEXT STEPS Path from committee briefing to project final completion 1 Complete Site Due Diligence Environmental, land-use, cost, and impact analysis for both properties 4 Prepare Full Design Development Plans 100% design development plans to confirm all elements will fit on recommended proposed site 3 Complete Appraisal Independent appraisal and evaluation of recommended proposed site 2 5 City Council Approval of Acquisition Execute agreement upon City Council authorization CITY OF CHARLESTON / FACILITIES & CAPITAL PROJECTS 29 5 Finalize Plat — Recommended Property Establish final boundaries and acreage for the combined parcel 6a Prepare Full Construction Documents 100% construction documents including all processes for permitting 6b Selection Committee for CMAR Advertise for Construction Manager at Risk Construction Includes site work, utility work, roadway work, all vertical construction for building and landscaping 7 8 Project Closeout Turn over facility to Charleston Fire Department

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.