RecordWell Data

_09222026-11224

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Sep 22, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING COUNCIL CHAMBER Regular Meeting September 22, 2026 The fifteenth meeting of the City Council of Charleston was held this date convening at 5:00 p.m. at City Hall and over video conference call (Zoom). A notice of this meeting and an agenda were made available on the City’s website September 17, 2026. PRESENT (13) The Honorable William S. Cogswell, Jr., Mayor Councilmember Gregg District 1 Councilmember Waring District 7 Councilmember Shealy (virtual) District 2 Councilmember Seekings District 8 Councilmember McBride District 3 Councilmember Tinkler District 9 Councilmember Polkey District 4 Councilmember Bowden District 10 Councilmember Brady District 5 Councilmember Appel District 11 Councilmember D’Allesandro District 6 Councilmember Skardon District 12 Mayor Cogswell called the meeting to order at 5:00 p.m. The Clerk called the roll. Mayor Cogswell said, “I would now like to ask Councilmember Tinkler to give the invocation and lead everybody in the Pledge of Allegiance.” Councilmember Tinkler opened the meeting with an invocation. Councilmember Tinkler then led City Council in the Pledge of Allegiance. Mayor Cogswell said, “Tonight, we have two very important proclamations. The first one is honoring the life and memory of Martha Rivers Ingram. I would like to call up her brother John and other members that are here tonight from the arts community to join me, if you will, up on the dais, as I read this resolution.” Mayor Cogswell read the proclamation. There was a standing ovation in the Chamber. Mayor Cogswell said, “Next up, we have a proclamation recognizing Mesothelioma Awareness Day, and I would like to ask James Ledlie to join me up on the dais.” Mayor Cogswell read the proclamation. City Council minutes September 22, 2026 Page 2 There was applause in the Chamber. Mayor Cogswell said, “Next we have Public Hearings . We have nine items on the docket. I would like to have Christopher Morgan come up and make a brief presentation.” Mr. Morgan said, “Mayor, Council, the first item is 806 Magnolia Road. This is a rezoning request to go from Single-Family Residential, SR-2, to Diverse Residential, DR-9. The property is located, as stated, on Magnolia Road, and immediately adjacent to other SR-2 neighborhoods. As you can see on the map, it is almost entirely single-family development around it. We have an aerial image. There is an older house, I think about a 100-year-old house on the lot. It had been all one parcel up until now. We have some information on that, and we also have some images of the house that’s on the property and street view of the property, you can see that. There had been an area character appraisal done of this area. The history of the area had been studied when it had been laid out. It was a very unique neighborhood that was laid out with a central park that is still there today. This also showed the actual property that is the subject of the property. This little grid here shows the subject property and the subject house and what had originally been laid out. It was laid out originally as 18 lots. This shows how that was laid out with the original Ashleyville-Maryville layouts. This was all in the area character appraisal for the neighborhood. We had this image just to get a sense of the green spaces that were in the nearby area. Of course, the park that’s to the northeast, then the West Ashley Bikeway to the north, and then to the south the Magnolia Park, and then Ackerman Park there. So, it’s in the midst of a lot of green spaces over here. In our Comprehensive Plan, it is in our Suburban category that recommends four to eight units an acre, as does the surrounding area. This item did come to our Planning Commission and was recommended for disapproval by a 6-2 vote. Our staff had been in support of it because we feel it's a way to achieve missing middle housing. I know that there was a lot of consternation from the neighborhood about the fact that there would be potentially smaller lots or more houses in this amount of area than they had in their nearby area, but that is the very essence of missing middle. Sometimes it is a little bit denser than standard Single-Family. Our feeling was that DR-9 is the closest district we get to be in line with what the developer is looking to do on the site, but is also as close as possible to the Comprehensive Plan recommendation. We don't have a DR-8 in other words. So, we don't have an eight units an acre. We don't have a DR-7. We have a DR-6, or we have a DR-9. So, that's the limitation of our current Zoning. Our feeling was that the DR-9 would still be in keeping with the overall spirit of the Comprehensive Plan because once you preserve the older house on the property, you really would not end up with nine units per acre here or 18 total units. You would have less than that, and that was what the developer was interested in doing is less than 18 units, so it was not going to max out. But anyway, our staff had recommended approval, but Planning Commission recommended disapproval on this. So, we will move on to the next case, which is Jack Primus Road . This was a property that was annexed in the 1990s into the City, surveys were a little bit different then, the way we put maps into our City system was a little di fferent, and it ended up being unzoned. I’ll show you where the property is. It’s next to the Jack Primus community, and so it’s spent all this time undeveloped, unzoned. No one was seeking to develop it. It was owned by the folks that own some of the Cainhoy development next door, and now they are interested in selling it to Habitat for Humanity, or maybe a donation, I don’t know the exact particulars of that situation, but it will be used by Habitat for Humanity for affordable housing, and it needed a zoning. So, we looked at the surrounding area and determined that based on what Habitat wanted to do and the overall character in the area, that SR-1 would work on this site and recommend for SR-1 here. City Council minutes September 22, 2026 Page 3 Here you see the undeveloped site right on Jack Primus Road, and so that was recommended for approval. We have 2038 Ironstone Alley. This is a recent annexation coming in the City as SR-2, and there’s an image of that property. We have 1036 Teracotta Drive, another recent annexation in West Ashley, would come in the City as SR-2, as well. Here is an image of that property. We have 1028 Teracotta Drive, a recent annexation coming in the City as SR-2. We have 1259 Wisteria Road, a recent annexation coming in the City as SR-2. Then, we have 1704 Walpole Way on Johns Island , a recent annexation coming in the City as SR-1. It is surrounded by SR-1. It was in one of the County’s overlays, but, in general, it would have been a site that would have been appropriate for that four units an acre of the SR-1. We have 1805 Huntington Drive, and that is coming in the City as SR-1. Then, we also have 1631 Main Street on James Island . That would come in the City, as well, as SR-1. I would be happy to answer any questions you have about it.” The Clerk said, “We have six.” Mayor Cogswell said, “Alright. We have six people. Let’s give a minute and a half.” The Clerk said, “Alright.” Mayor Cogswell said, “Please call our first speaker.” The Clerk said, “The time is a minute and a half, and we’ll start with our in-person list first. Anthony Bryant.” 1. Anthony G. Brown said he was there for a couple of reasons. He had concerns regarding the NextEra and Dominion Energy combination merger. He said that in the public’s interest Reggie Burgess, the Mayor of North Charleston, would host a forum in November to give North Charleston residents the opportunity to voice concerns or support for the merger. Councilmembers could make public comments or disdain in opposition for a potential 800,000 ratepayers added to another 12 million ratepayers, as relationships would not be the same with Dominion Energy as before. He thanked the Mayor for having led the charged conversation. He also thanked Mayor Cogswell for representing Charleston and West Ashley at the State of the City’s meeting. Mr. Bryant spoke of the $9 million generated in property taxes from the City’s project to redevelop the Housing Authority's three largest public housing projects that covered roughly 40 acres on the peninsula. He said that the peninsula itself could be worth $41 billion. The Clerk called time. The Clerk said, “Jock Stender.” City Council minutes September 22, 2026 Page 4 Jock Stender did not speak. The Clerk said, “Ezra Zankel.” 2. Ezra Zankel asked the Council to uphold the Planning Commission’s recommendations. He said if that DR-9 was approved, the parcel would be worth more with nothing built on it. The developer openly said that the SR-2 plan did not pencil. If DR-9 did not pencil either, the entitlement could be simply sold. He believed that every promise made at the podium ended at the closing table and any future buyer that owned the zoning and not the promises. SR-2 would be the only protection that survived sale. He said that the City Plan designated the area Suburban, four to eight units per acre, and DR-9 allowed nine. There was not a DR-9 anywhere near the site, and the Planning Commission reviewed the same record, heard from 27 residents, and voted six to two that the request was not consistent with the plan. The only thing that changed since that meeting was that the petition stood at 253 signatures then and now stood at 313. The Clerk called time. The Clerk said, “If everyone could please hold their applause. Thank you.” The Clerk said, “Thomas Horan.” 3. Thomas Horan said he wanted to thank the Mayor and City Council for their time. He said that it was not intelligent infill housing. It did not create housing for the people who needed it including teachers, nurses, and firefighters. It was property that would be sold at close to $1 million dollars. He said units could be bought two doors down; there was one in the subdivision. He believed it would cause more traffic, particularly on Magnolia Road where there were children who got on and off buses for multiple schools. It would cause more garbage and a higher risk of flooding. It set a terrible precedent for what might happen with other properties when they came up for sale. He said that the Planning Commission was there to protect neighborhoods. It was not there to protect someone who had $1 million to speculate in real estate and wanted to make more millions for himself, or at the expense of the safety of the children in the area, or the area’s property values, or at the expense of the whole character of the neighborhood. He asked all who opposed to stand with him in solidarity and give Council a sense of how many were concerned. He asked Council to uphold the decision that the Planning Commission previously made which voted against it and protected the neighborhood. The Clerk said, “William Hicks.” 4. William Hicks said he was there to ask Council to deny the request. He believed it was a simple economic argument and asked to consider who would win from the potential rezoning. The developer could be a winner if they had the opportunity to put the maximum number of units in the area and received a higher rate of return on the investment. City Council could be a winner if the new metric brought additional houses to the West Ashley area. He said he was just a normal taxpayer there to ask Council to deny the rezoning. He thought it was a great place to be. City Council minutes September 22, 2026 Page 5 The Clerk said, “We will go to our online list. We do have a citizen. They did not put down if they were speaking under Citizens’ Participation or Public Hearings. If you are online and need to speak to a Public Hearing, you can press star six to unmute yourself. Danielle Stetszel? If not, we will come back to you during Citizens’ Participation. We did receive some comments online, and I will summarize those for you. We had eight comments that were received expressing opposition to the rezoning of 806 Magnolia Road. One petition was received expressing opposition to the rezoning of 806 Magnolia Road, and it included 313 signatures. Those are all the comments that we received on Public Hearings.” Mayor Cogswell said, “Any further questions, comments from Councilmembers?” Councilmember McBride said, “I have one for Item 7, Mr. Mayor, but I can wait until we get to that spot.” Mayor Cogswell said, “On number 7?” Councilmember McBride said, “Yes, sir.” Mayor Cogswell recognized Councilmember Seekings. Councilmember Seekings said, “I thought we probably should take number 1 separately, if we are going to do any bulk voting tonight. Let’s take number 1 separately, please.” Mayor Cogswell said, “So, can I get a motion for Item 1?” Councilmember Tinkler said, “Well, I think the parliamentarian Brady may object to my order here, but I think my motion is to accept the recommendation of the Planning Commission on this one. I don’t know if that’s the proper order, but you get my drift.” Mayor Cogswell said, “It is to deny.” Councilmember Waring said, “I second that.” Mayor Cogswell said, “So, we have a motion to deny on Item 1. Any further questions? Properly seconded, any further questions, comments?” Councilmember Tinkler said, “I think just to support that, I realize this is a very complicated issue. I know we say it all the time about the City’s interest in developing workforce housing, missing middle housing, and in this day and age of rising costs, it is absolutely necessary. I think, Mr. Mayor, you’ve spent a lot of time working on this issue, so that’s certainly appreciated and noted. I think my concerns here are similar to the concerns that the Planning Commission had, and Mr. Morgan kind of alluded to this a little bit, the challenge that the Planning Department had in trying to find the cl osest zoning classification to achieve these goals. I know some of the residents who commented tonight really identified the issue here that we are providing zoning that exceeds what we, as a Council, have said is the proper planning, at least over the course of the next ten years. I just feel when we’re opening that door, it’s probably not good planning. I think this is a tough issue. I know Councilmember Appel who has tried to highlight this problem, and I think he probably wants to talk a little bit about it tonight as well, because it is a real problem, and we need to address our Zoning Code from the 80’s, and before that. We are having a hard time achieving these goals that we are struggling with today. So, I say all that to support my motion. I don’t know if anybody else has anything to add to that.” City Council minutes September 22, 2026 Page 6 Mayor Cogswell said, “So, you make a great point. We do appreciate the applicant coming to CD and giving a presentation. Some of the speakers tonight did highlight the relevant fact, though, that there’s no guarantee that the plan ultimately would be submitted and certainly respect that zoning. It does, I think to your point, Councilman Tinkler, speak to some of the real needs for our update to the Zoning Code which is underway, and that is not to pack more houses in, but it is trying to, and hopefully it will, try to better help give us the tools to better balance more housing, more missing middle that does remain within the character and context of these neighborhoods, not just in West Ashley, but the City at large. I certainly appreciate the speakers that have come out tonight. I appreciate your passion and at the same time respect the applicant. I think that they are looking to do something that is important to the City. But we have a motion to deny. We have a motion that has been properly seconded to deny. If there’re any further questions, if there are no further questions or comments, I call for a vote.” Mayor Cogswell recognized Councilmember Waring. Councilmember Waring said, “Mr. Morgan, can you pull up the zoning map again, and show the site again? I’m going to talk about some of the time I did on the Planning Commission. I only did seventeen years.” Councilmember Seekings said, “Seventeen years.” Councilmember Waring said, “That’s seventeen years.” Councilmember Seekings said, “It’s hard time.” Councilmember Waring said, “The hardest part about it, they sent me here, right there. SR-2 is pretty much all around this area, and my respected colleague, Councilmember Appel, and I are on the same page when it comes to infill. One of your terms, Mr. Mayor, ‘pencil.’ You really don’t cram units in until it ‘pencils.’ I mean, in this particular case, when you’ve got a surrounding area pretty much SR-2, Mr. Morgan, most of this neighborhood? Well, it's pretty much SR-2 around it. To go to DR-9 on that, as a matter of fact, put the color picture up showing the houses, the Google shot. So, if you could be in a helicopter, pretty much everything around there is SR-2, and then bang, you get DR-9 in the middle of that. Years and years ago, we would have called that spot zoning, which is against the law. The failing here is that we don't have the right zoning category. So, you go to a zoning category that will qualify the number of units until it pencils. Hypothetically, if that property was the other way instead of being perpendicular to Magnolia Road and was parallel to Magnolia Road, then you could access infrastructure that already exists. The water, the sewer, the drainage is all on Magnolia Road. In this case, you have to punch a road in and create smaller lots so you can pay for the infrastructure, road, water, sewage, curb, and guttering and all of that. So, these neighbors are right. But, hopefully, I'm looking forward to our zoning rewrite because to say only one house or two houses should be on that track probably is not right, but DR-9 is not the solution. Thank you.” Mayor Cogswell said, “Any further questions, comments on this?” Councilmember Polkey said, “Just a parliamentary inquiry, a vote ‘aye’ is to deny and accept the denial of the Planning Commission, correct?” City Council minutes September 22, 2026 Page 7 Mayor Cogswell said, “To accept the Planning Commission’s recommendation.” Councilmember D’Allesandro said, “Pardon a little bit of my ignorance here, but would or does a TIF not help in this situation to build the road and get the infrastructure in place?” Mayor Cogswell said, “It potentially could, but this does not sit in a TIF Overlay, and also TIFs are typically 6% or commercial property assessment.” Mayor Cogswell recognized Councilmember Tinkler. Councilmember Tinkler said, “Councilmember Appel, I know you can educate the public better than I can on these issues, but this is the struggle here because I do think Mr. Stribbling has, I mean, he has pushed this through the TRC under SR-2, and I have no reason to doubt his economic predicament that he’s in, and because I’ve heard from other builders across the local builders who are trying to do this. Council member D’Allesandro talks about public funding to support these projects. I think the builders are trying to do this without public funding and without public subsidy, and that’s the problem. We’re here trying to solve this problem, and we don’t have unlimited public resources to address this issue. So, we need to rely on the private community to try to achieve these goals, and I think it’s an effort. They worked hard on it. I think our rules just don’t work here and certainly something that we should be addressing going forward. But on this particular issue, I think we need to agree with the Planning Commission.” Mayor Cogswell said, “We have a motion made and properly seconded. I’m going to call for a vote. Remember ‘aye’ vote is to go with the Planning Commission and deny zoning requests.” On a motion of Councilmember Tinkler, seconded by Councilmember Waring, City Council voted unanimously to accept the recommendation of the Planning Commission and to deny Item E-1. Mayor Cogswell said, “Can I get maybe a motion to take Items 2 through 6 for approval?” Councilmember Brady said, “Just as a point of order, Item 2 is a second reading. So, we would need to do —" Mayor Cogswell said, “So, we are going to take a second, and I’m going to amend my motion to take Item 2 as a second reading.” Councilmember Seekings said, “Motion made.” Councilmember Waring said, “Second,” Mayor Cogswell said, “We have a motion made and properly seconded.” On a motion of Councilmember Seekings, one (1) bill (Item E-2) received second reading. It passed second reading on motion by Councilmember Waring and third reading on motion of Councilmember Brady. On a further motion of Councilmember Seekings, the rules were suspended, and the bill was immediately ratified as: City Council minutes September 22, 2026 Page 8 2026-157 AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND THE ZONING ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CHARLESTON BY CHANGING THE ZONE MAP, WHICH IS A PART THEREOF, SO THAT JACK PRIMUS RD (CAINHOY) (APPROX. 0.73) (TMS #2680000099) (COUNCIL DISTRICT 1), ANNEXED INTO THE CITY OF CHARLESTON OCTOBER 4, 1991 (#ORDINANCE 1991-121), BE ZONED SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL (SR- 1) CLASSIFICATION. THE PROPERTY IS OWNED BY SEVEN STICKS LLC Mayor Cogswell said, “Now, I'm going to ask for Items 3 through 6. Well, do we want to keep seven out?” Councilmember Brady said, “Okay,” Mayor Cogswell said, “So, 3 through 6. I'm going to make the motion for approval.” Councilmember Brady said, “Second.” Mayor Cogswell said, “We have a motion made and properly seconded.” On a motion of Mayor Cogswell, seconded by Councilmember Brady, City Council voted unanimously to give first reading to the following bills: An ordinance to amend the Zoning Ordinance of the City of Charleston by changing the Zone Map, which is a part thereof, so that 2038 Ironstone Alley (West Ashley) (approx. 0.17 ac.) (TMS #3531200044) (Council District 2), be zoned Single Family Residential (SR-2) classification. The property is owned by David and Nancy Heronemus. An ordinance to amend the Zoning Ordinance of the City of Charleston by changing the Zone Map, which is a part thereof, so that 1036 Teracotta Drive (West Ashley) (approx. 0.17 ac.) (TMS #3531200062) (Council District 2), be zoned Single Family Residential (SR- 2) classification. The property is owned by Therese Marie Melton. An ordinance to amend the Zoning Ordinance of the City of Charleston by changing the Zone Map, which is a part thereof, so that 1028 Teracotta Drive (West Ashley) (approx. 0.18 ac.) (TMS #3531200064) (Council District 2), be zoned Single Family Residential (SR- 2) classification. The property is owned by Curtis and Jennifer Jackson. An ordinance to amend the Zoning Ordinance of the City of Charleston by changing the Zone Map, which is a part thereof, so that 1259 Wisteria Road (West Ashley) (approx. 0.21 ac.) (TMS #3511200108) (Council District 7), be zoned Single Family Residential (SR-2) classification. The property is owned by Rebecca Hopkins and Joseph Redding Mayor Cogswell said, ”I’m going to take Item 7. Can I get a motion before I get to discussion?” Councilmember Brady said, “Move for approval.” Councilmember McBride said, “Second.” Mayor Cogswell said, ”I’ll give the second to you, Councilmember McBride. I’ll let you have the floor.” City Council minutes September 22, 2026 Page 9 Councilmember McBride said, “Thanks, Mr. Mayor. I just want to take this opportunity for a lot of my constituents who have scar tissue over the decades when they hear ‘annexation on Johns Island’ or ‘James Island,’ there’s a perception that means we’re annexing from the County into the City, and that equates to some kind of upzoning, which is not necessary the case, and is usually not the case. So, I wanted to ask Mr. Morgan if he would just spend about five minutes or less to explain this for the constituents. This is a great example where there’s a pocket of County land in the middle of annexed City land that they’re asking to be annexed in. Mr. Morgan, if you can explain what that means in reality, and this is a great example of what typically happens around Johns Island and other parts of Charleston.” Mr. Morgan said, “This is a donut hole. It’s in an existing neighborhood that was built roughly around the same time, 60’s and 70’s, and for whatever reason, some parcels had already been annexed into the City, but were definite donut holes, such as this parcel. Periodically, we get requests from folks who are on those parcels who would rather be in the City. In this instance, they wanted to come in the City. It’s a Single-Family house. The Single- Family houses around them are all zoned SR-1 , so we recommended SR-1 zoning to the Planning Commission on that. It was also in line with our Comprehensive Plan, and those are things that we use when annexations are coming into the City.” Councilmember McBride said, “Just to pull the thread a little bit more, Comprehensive Plan Law was passed by the State in 1994 if I’m not mistaken. Before that, it was maybe a little bit more hap-hazard, but since then, the County and the City, and the County and the towns and cities, more or less, in the same areas that they co-exist, the Comprehensive Plan results in as- close-to-equivalent-as-possible zoning. So, the County land right there, until the annexation was, I think you said, four units per acre, which is what also the SR-1 happens to be for the City. So, there’s actually no change at all as to the units per acre on that property.” Mr. Morgan said, “These were all R-4 properties. They were added to the County’s overlay. I’m not quite clear why they took parcels that were not on Maybank Highway and put them in the middle of the neighborhood overlay, but that is what it is. So, that gave other zoning allowances there that nobody is taking advantage of over there.” Councilmember McBride said, “One last question, what are some examples of advantages for someone to annex into the City in a situation like this?” Mr. Morgan said, “It may be that they want to do business rather with the City. Sometimes we find that people feel like our building inspections, or things like that, work better than the County’s.” Mayor Cogswell said, “They also get a full rebate of the local option sales tax that comes to the City that reduces their property taxes pretty significantly.” Councilmember McBride said, “Yes, and from septic, potentially, to Charleston Water Systems, things like that. The Mayor hit on one of the biggest points that I have had to learn over the last couple of years is that the landowner actually gets a financial benefit from annexing into the City. They don’t pay more taxes. They actually get a net decrease in what they’re paying because of the local option sales tax that the City collects and distributes to residents.” Mayor Cogswell said, “And it’s the best way for the City to grow without going out further and further into the hinterland and taking down more large tracts of trees and extending the City Council minutes September 22, 2026 Page 10 City's boundaries. Growing internally with these annexations represents a much more efficient use of government resources. So, we have the conversation, I appreciate you bringing that up.” Mayor Cogswell recognized Councilmember Waring. Councilmember Waring said, “Just one other thing, the City and the County have an urban growth boundary line that goes around, and for about 30 to 35 years almost now, have really respected that line and not let density go over the line, and that makes a difference. Some cities unfortunately don't recognize it.” Mayor Cogswell said, “We have a motion made and properly seconded for approval on Item 7. If there’s no further discussion on this, I appreciate the education, Councilmember McBride. I think it’s important for people to know these nuances.” On a motion of Councilmember Brady, se conded by Councilmember McBride, City Council voted unanimously to give first reading to the following bill: An ordinance to amend the Zoning Ordinance of the City of Charleston by changing the Zone Map, which is a part thereof, so that 1704 Walpole Way (Johns Island) (approx. 0.48 ac.) (TMS #2791400008) (Council District 3), be zoned Single Family Residential (SR-1) classification. The property is owned by Shateque Hacker. Mayor Cogswell said, “Now, maybe we could take Items 8 and 9 together for approval.” Councilmember Seekings said, “Motion made.” Councilmember Waring said, “Second.” Mayor Cogswell said, “We have a motion made and properly seconded.” On a motion of Councilmember Seekings, seconded by Councilmember Waring, City Council voted unanimously to give first reading to the following bills: An ordinance to amend the Zoning Ordinance of the City of Charleston by changing the Zone Map, which is a part thereof, so that 1805 Huntington Drive (West Ashley) (approx. 0.30 ac.) (TMS #3520900095) (Council District 9), be zoned Single Family Residential (SR- 1) classification. The property is owned by Nicholas D'Allesandro. An ordinance to amend the Zoning Ordinance of the City of Charleston by changing the Zone Map, which is a part thereof, so that 1631 Means Street (James Island) (approx. 0.22 ac.) (TMS #4240500082) (Council District 11), be zoned Single Family Residential (SR-1) classification. The property is owned by Kenneth Strange. Mayor Cogswell said, “Now, I would like to move on to approval of the September 8th Council Minutes. Can I get a motion?” Councilmember Skardon said, “Motion made.” Councilmember Seekings said, “Second.” City Council minutes September 22, 2026 Page 11 Mayor Cogswell said, “We have a motion made and properly seconded.” On a motion of Councilmember Skardon, seconded by Councilmember Seekings, City Council voted unanimously to approve the minutes of the September 8, 2026 City Council meeting. Mayor Cogswell said, “We are now on to the Citizens Participation Period. Madam Clerk, how many people do we have signed up?” The Clerk said, “We have about fourteen.” Mayor Cogswell said, “Let's give them a minute because we've got a 30-minute cap on it, sometimes they go a little bit over. I'm going to remind those that are here to speak tonight, that we ask you to follow the Rules of Decorum. This is not a question-and-answer period. We are here to hear your voice, hear your points of view. We ask that you be civil and respectful. We in turn will do the same. If you do not adhere to the Rules of Decorum, I will give you one warning. If you continue, you will be asked to leave. So, Madam Clerk, will you please call the first speaker?” The Clerk said, “We will start with the in-person list first. Anthony G. Bryant.” 1. Anthony G. Bryant was there to speak on the grief he had with his first amendment rights. He showed the Council the condition of the mail that he received at his home. The Governor of South Carolina sent him something, and It appeared to have been tampered with. He asked that it be given to the Mayor. He guessed that it happened somewhere outside of the County. He would not come to a Council meeting and be disrespectful of City Council. Regarding the first amendment ordinance, he said that young people needed to be shown the importance of decorum and how to be respectful of the process, even when it did not work, because eventually it could work. He said to put the work in the right way like Dr. King did. The Clerk said, “Samuel Schumann.” 2. Samuel Schumann said he wanted to discuss the proposed pickle ball courts at the Parkshore Park. His house abuts the park, and he was concerned about the noise pollution, which affected the livability of the residential area around the park, as well as the property values. He believed that the courts conflicted with the articles of parks and recreation to protect the tranquility of the surrounding residential area. In addition, he was concerned about who the courts would serve in the future. He asked for an independent noise commission to evaluate the noise pollution that would be created by the courts and requested additional meetings so that the public and the community would be aware of the work. The Clerk said, “For our next speaker we have, Robert Kneece.” 3. Robert Kneece said he understood the matter with the approval of the pickle ball courts had been deferred and appreciated the simple transparency regarding the decision to put the pickle ball courts at Parkshore Park. He said there had been concerns about noise pollution, and additional concerns about funds used in the park. He believed the baseball field shed in the park, and some other areas, appeared to be long underfunded, and wondered if the courts were the best use of City Council minutes September 22, 2026 Page 12 funds that addressed the needs of the park and its compatibility with the surrounding neighborhood. He appreciated the fact that the decision apparently had been deferred, and there would be some public input. The Clerk said, “Laura Stoessel.” 4. Laura Stoessel said she was there to once again speak on the food truck / food cart issues and the different things that would be allowed. She recently learned that additional items would be allowed, including tents and trailers when originally it would be push-carts, especially down by the Exchange Building. She questioned if the different items were necessary, or if they just added to the craziness. She suggested that they rethink the allowed items and stay with the hand pushcart that worked with the sites of Charleston. The Clerk said, “Helen Dovell.” Helen Dovell did not speak. The Clerk said, “Grayson Pedone.” 5. Grayson Pedone said he was happy to be there again. He believed that decisions were being made quietly against what the community had asked for, and it concerned him that those who carried the weight of the decisions were the ones with the least ability to bear them. He said changes were made in the way of amendments without a vote, yet votes were going through despite what he believed was documented community support. His said that his business platform was on the verge of being irrelevant. He had seen small businesses across the City swallowed up by people with deeper pockets. The Clerk called time. Mayor Cogswell granted the speaker additional time. Grayson Pedone (continued). He hoped that the Charleston known to many lasted long enough for future generations to benefit from. If the goal was to create a pastel, picturesque Miami, they were on the right track. If the goal was to keep Charleston the place everyone fell in love with, then was every decision in accordance with that? The Clerk said, “Nick Saltmarsh.” 6. Nick Saltmarsh was there to thank Mayor Cogswell and his team. He had been in hotel management for 25 years, changed careers, and started a paddle club at Trophy Lakes. He had received a lot of support from people on the Mayor’s team and wanted to recognize them. He named Councilmember McBride, Robert Summerfield, Liz Kimsey, Ron Bucci, Lee Batchelder, Philip Clapper, Earl Gurley, Annie Mitchell, David Grace, Kevin Sanders, and Maggie Edwards. They took the time, guided him, and allowed him to understand the process. When dealing with government, he had no clue, but they were kind every single time. The Clerk said, “Izzy Waldner.” City Council minutes September 22, 2026 Page 13 7. Izzy Waldner said he was a college student and a Charleston resident, and was there to speak on the 1A ordinance, again. He thought it was shameful that City Council kept kicking the can down the road and delayed a hearing on the ordinance. He believed that the ordinance would be heard at the Public Safety Committee meeting, and it was not on the agenda. He demanded that the ordinance had a hearing at City Council because the people wanted it repealed. He said it was unconstitutional, and protesting was not a crime. The Clerk said, “Marcus McDonald.” 8. Marcus McDonald said he was the lead organizer of Charleston Black Lives Matter. He was there to say the City of Charleston, and especially City Council, needed to take a stand on the Dominion price hikes and proposed merger/acquisition with Next Era. There was a lot of corporate greed at the AI data centers that Next Era would build and organize. He thought that City Council could lead the effort and submit a letter of protest or complaint to the Public Service Commission and/or formally intervene with a late petition and ask that the process be slowed down. The City could have public meetings so the community could provide input. He encouraged Councilmembers to contact him or his brother with either so they could put something together. The Clerk said, “Darrel Horry.” 9. Darrel Horry said he was with the Charleston Community Action Network, and he was speaking on behalf of the citizens of the City of Charleston. He said that with Dominion Energy’s recent price hikes, energy bills had gone from $400 to $700, which was difficult for many residents to pay, let alone senior citizens who must pay the higher rates but received only $800 to $900 a month in Social Security and/or Medicaid benefits. Dominion said that rising fuel costs were the main reason for the rate increases. Mr. Horry noted that the residents had to pay for rising fuel costs, plus the energy rate hikes. The Action Network called for the City to host a Town Hall meeting so the public could address the potential merger and the rate hikes with Dominion executives. Mr. Horry had an evidence packet for Council and called for immediate action. Charleston had just started paying $20 an hour for basic jobs, and to pay $800 a month plus in rent was ridiculous. The Clerk said, “Jock Stender.” Jock Stender did not speak. The Clerk said, “We’ll go to our online list. Danielle Stelzl, and if you are online you can press star six to unmute yourself. I do not see anyone online. So, I think that is it for the speakers. We did receive some comments. One letter was received from Lauren Schumann expressing opposition for the four pickle ball courts planned for Parkshore Park and included signatures from 20 other individuals. One letter was received from Joan Fry expressing opposition to the pickle ball courts and was concerned at the loss of habitat for the animal and birds that lived in the woods. Eight letters were received in favor of the revised plan to build four public pickle ball courts at Parkshore Park. One email was received from Ellie Kneece asking the City for additional time and meaningful neighborhood engagement before finalizing the four dedicated court configuration, and four comments were received from Mr. Bryant, which were sent to City Council in full.” City Council minutes September 22, 2026 Page 14 Mayor Cogswell said, “Thank you, Madam Clerk. That concludes Citizens’ Participation Period. We are now on to Petitions and Communications. There are several appointments up for consideration: Commission on Women, Redevel opment and Preservation Commission, Board of Zoning Appeals - Site Design, and Tourism Commission.” Councilmember Waring said, “Approval for all recommended appointments.” Councilmember Seekings said, “Second.” Mayor Cogswell said, “We have a motion made and properly seconded for approval on all items. If there are no further discussions, I will just say there are a lot of people on this list. I really appreciate all the citizens being willing to sign up and engage, and certainly, thanks to all Councilmembers for your volunteering to serve on these committees, as well. These are important, give us advice, perspective, etc. So, we have a motion made, properly seconded.” On a motion of Councilmember Waring, seconded by Councilmember Seekings, City Council voted unanimously to approve the following appointments: a. Commission on Women: (i). Councilmember Leslie Skar don (New Appointment/Councilmember) (ii). Dr. Elisa Jones (New Appointment/College of Charleston) (iii). Dr. DeAnna Ellington Cheek (New Appointment/Medical University of South Carolina) (iv.) LaVanda Brown, CEO (New Appointment/YWCA) (v.) Cara Erickson, Co-President (League of Women Voters) (vi.) Janet Bates (New Appointment/Chamber of Mothers) (vii.) Dr. Amalia Luxardo, CEO (New Appointment/WREN) (viii.) Jennifer L. Brown (Reappointment) (ix.) Dr. Hilda Gadsden (Reappointment) (x.) Jennifer Strickland (New Appointment/City Staff Member – Human Resources) b. Redevelopment and Preservation Commission: (i). Michael Boylst on (New Appointment) (ii). Michele Johnson (New Appointment) c. Board of Appeals (Site Design) (i). Edward Pritchard (New Appointment) – Citizen At-Large Seat (ii). Kelvin M. Huger (Reappointment) – Attorney’s Seat d. Tourism Commission: (i). Councilmember Ben D’Allesandro (Councilmember Seat) Mayor Cogswell said, “We have Items 2 through 4, and they are being fast-tracked due to time constraints.” City Council minutes September 22, 2026 Page 15 Councilmember Brady said, “I would move that we take 2 through 4 together and move for their approval.” Councilmember Waring said, “Second.” Mayor Cogswell said, “We have a motion made and properly seconded to take two, three, and four together for approval. Any further discussion or comments on any of these items?” No one asked to speak. On a motion of Councilmember Brady, seconded by Councilmember Waring, City Council voted unanimously to approve the following items: Acceptance of a permanent drainage easement on TMS 354-01-00-103, TMS 354-01-00- 102, and TMS 306-00-00-039 in support of drai nage improvements in the Mariners Ferry area that are associated with the Lake Dotterer Drainage Improvement Project. Request for approval to amend the existing bike share agreement with Lime Bikes to reflect an annual contract in lieu of a month-to-month Contract. Authorization to notify SCDOT that the City intends to accept maintenance of approximately 58 SF of bluestone sidewalk on Meeting St.(S-107) in conjunction with the 200 Meeting St. project. Mayor Cogswell said, “We are now on to Committee Reports . I’d like to call on Councilmember Gregg for Ways and Means. Motion made for approval.” Councilmember Gregg said, “Is that amended with the deferral, or how do we have the deferral?” The Clerk said, “For Ways and Means it would be amended to defer. It would include the deferral, just as amended.” Mayor Cogswell said, “So, adoption of the Committee Report, as amended.” Councilmember Seekings said, “Motion made.” Councilmember Brady said, “Second.” Mayor Cogswell said, “We have a motion made and properly seconded.” Councilmember McBride said, “Got one comment, sir.” Mayor Cogswell recognized Councilmember McBride. Councilmember McBride said, “What I learned about the paddle ball courts that are now at Trophy Lakes, speaking of the pickle ball friction going on right now, and the pickle ball community will want to impeach me for saying this, however, paddle ball courts, and I am not even an expert at this, are much quieter. The ball is quieter, and they are built in with plexiglass City Council minutes September 22, 2026 Page 16 walls to help keep the sound in, and it's about the same size as pickle ball courts, and I think it's a lot more fun. So, that’s all I wanted to say.” Mayor Cogswell said, “We have a motion made and probably seconded.” On a motion of Councilmember Seekings , seconded by Councilmember Brady, City Council voted unanimously to adopt the Committee on Ways and Means Report, as amended: (Bids & Purchases (A resolution to approve an amendment of the Agreement for Development for Joint County Industrial Park, by and between Charleston County, South Carolina and Colleton County, South Carolina, so as to include additional property in the City of Charleston as part of the Joint County Industrial Park. (Planning, Permitting, & Engineering – Stormwater Management: Approval of a Resolution for the additional funding from SCOR ASIP for Barberry Woods and the related addendum to subrecipient agreement. (Facilities & Capital Projects – Capital Pr ojects: Approval of Lowline Revised Early Site Package Scope of Work Change Order #5 to facilitate a remobilization date of 10/19/26. The Change Order amount is $2,006,204.00. This Change Order must be approved by COB September 22, 2026 to maintain revised Early Site Package construction package. This will be funded by the Cooper River Bridge TIF. (Facilities & Capital Projects – Parks: Approval of Joseph P . Riley, Jr., Ballpark Field Improvements Construction Contract with Carolina Green Corp in the amount of $1,372,870.00 as a part of the Joe Riley Ballpark Field Improvements project. The scope of this project includes turf removal and replacement, drainage systems scoping, and field raising. With approval of the project budget, staff is authorized to award and/or amend contracts less than $100,000.00 to the extent contingency funds exist in the Council Approved Budget. This work must be completed before the beginning of the 2027 baseball season. Approval of the construction contract obligates $1,372,870.00 of the $1,893,703.00 project budget. Funding sources for this project are: Hospitality Fund ($818,903.00); General Fund Reserves ($874,800.00) and JPR Ballpark Fund balance ($200,000.00). (Facilities & Capital Projects – Parks: Approval of Parkshore Park Pickleball Courts Construction Contract in the amount of $255,956.00 with IPW as a part of the Parkshore Pickleball Courts project. The scope of the contract includes demolishing existing park amenities and replacing with four new pickleball courts, as well as the construction of walkways and landscaping to enhance the site at 1 Windsor Drive in West Ashley. With approval of the project budget, staff is authorized to award and/or amend contracts less than $100,000.00 to the extent contingency funds exist in the Council Approved Budget. Approval of this contract obligates $255,956.00 of the $400,000.00 project budget. The funding source for this project is: General Fund Reserves ($400,000.00). (DEFERRED) (Facilities & Capital Projects – Parks: Approval of Johns Island Recreation Center Guaranteed Maximum Price (GMP) Amendment #2 to the CMAR contract with Trident Construction LLC in the amount of $11,154,647.00 for an early release GMP package for the timely mobilization, delegated design, and procurement of goods and supplies for the Johns Island Recreation Center project. A final GMP amount and construction timeline will be brought to Council at a later date. Approval of GMP Amendment #2 will increase the CMAR contract by $11,154,647.00 (from $7,731,848.00 to $18,886,495.00). The funding source for City Council minutes September 22, 2026 Page 17 this project is: 2025 Parks and Recreation Bond ($17,000,000.00) and Anticipated Future Borrowing ($55,125,000.00). (Facilities & Capital Projects – Parks: Approval of Hazel Parker Playground Renovation Construction Contract in the amount of $177,010.00 with Truluck Construction, Inc. as a part of the Hazel Parker Playground Renovation project. The scope of this contract includes renovations to the existing concrete tennis court at Hazel Parker Playground, 70 East Bay Street. With approval of the project budget, staff is authorized to award and/or amend contracts less than $100,000.00 to the extent contingency funds exist in the Council Approved Budget. Approval of this contract obligates $177,010.00 of the $550,000.00 project budget. Funding sources for this project are: state Accommodations Tax ($300,000.00) and Hospitality Fund ($250,000.00). (Facilities & Capital Projects – Parks: Approval of WL Stephens Aquatic Center & Forest Park Playground Professional Services Contract for Special Inspections with S&ME in the amount of $100,000.00 for Construction Materials Testing and Special Inspections as a part of the WL Stephens Aquatic Center project. The scope of services includes evaluations, observations, and testings of Concrete, Piers, Masonry, and other construction materials, as well as erosion control inspections and project management pursuant to said work. Approval of this contract will obligate $100,000.00 of the project budget. The funding sources for this project are: 2025 Parks and Recreation Bond ($24,206,345.15) and Anticipated Future Borrowing ($12,793,654.85). (Planning, Permitting, & Engineering – Housing and Community Development: Authorization for acceptance of COC SNOFO auto-renewal for $130,210.00 and extension of the current agreement for $85,000.00 for a total of $215,210.00 with Star Gospel Mission, Inc. to continue providing assistance to the unsheltered with mental illness. (Planning, Permitting, & Engineering – Stormwater Management: Approval of a 1- year maintenance service agreement contract extension with Harper General Contractors, Inc. in the amount of $420,000.00 for the continued maintenance of the Lockwood Drive/ William Dudley Gregorie Pump Station. The current contract expires on October 24, 2026. Approval of the contract extension does not obligate the City to any expenditures but will continue to utilize the Lockwood Drive Pump Station line item in the Stormwater Operations Budget. The contract amount is $420,000.00 and is included in the 2027 Stormwater Budget. (Planning, Permitting, & Engineering – Stormwater Management: Approval of Central Park Drainage Improvements Construction Contract in the amount of $4,504,395.48 with Gulfstream construction Company, Inc. as a part of the Central Park Drainage Improvements project. The scope of this contract includes installation of a new storm drain pipe, culverts, valves, and temporary and permanent erosion control, and additional work pursuant to improving drainage and tidal and flood resiliency in the Central Park Road basin on James Island. With approval of the project budget, staff is authorized to award and/or amend contracts less than $100,000.00 to the extent contingency funds exist in the Council Approved Budget. Approval of this contract obligates $4,504,395.48 of the $6,500,000.00 project budget. Funding sources for this project are: Drainage Fund ($5,000,000.00) and the SC Rural Infrastructure Authority ($1,500,000.00). City Council minutes September 22, 2026 Page 18 Mayor Cogswell said, “Madam Clerk just let me know that there were two citizens who signed up for Citizens Participation that she missed.” The Clerk said, “Yes. So, we need to call them. My apologies.” Mayor Cogswell said, “So, we apologize for that. That was not intentional. I think it just slipped under the folder there. So, we are going to open that back up and allow those two citizens.” Councilmember Brady said, “Just officially, since that is altering the agenda, I would move that we suspend the rules to allow that.” Councilmember Shealy said, “Second.” Mayor Cogswell said, “We have a motion made to suspend the rules. We have a second.” On a motion of Councilmember Brady, se conded by Councilmember Bowden, City Council voted unanimously to suspend the Rules of Order and resume Citizens’ Participation. Mayor Cogswell said, “We’ll call the first speaker. The time is one minute.” The Clerk said, “One minute. Yes. Samuel Schumann.” Mayor Cogswell said, “Samuel Schumann, if you are still here.” Samuel Schumann did not speak. The Clerk said, “Matthew Colburn.” Mayor Cogswell said, “Matthew.” Matthew Colburn did not speak. The Clerk said, “Well, we can reach out to them and get their comments for everyone.” Mayor Cogswell said, “Yes. Please, let the record note that we apologize for that. That was certainly not intentional, and we look forward to hearing what they have to say. The one bill that is up for third reading has been deferred. So, we’re now on to second readings, and we have only one bill up for second reading that hasn’t been deferred. That’s item number 1. Can I get a motion?” Councilmember Waring said, “Motion made.” Councilmember Skardon said, “Second.” Mayor Cogswell said, “We have a motion made and properly seconded.” On a motion of Councilmember Waring one (1) bill (Item N-1) received second reading. It passed second reading on motion by Councilmember Skardon and third reading on motion of City Council minutes September 22, 2026 Page 19 Councilmember Seekings. On a further motion of Councilmember Brady, the rules were suspended and the bill was immediately ratified as: 2026-158 AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND CHAPTER 2 - ADMINISTRATION; ARTICLE IV – BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS; DIVISION 4 – RESILIENCY AND SUSTAINABILITY ADVISORY COMMITTEE, SECTION 2-183, OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF CHARLESTON, SOUTH CAROLINA Mayor Cogswell said, “We have no bills up for first reading which takes us to Miscellaneous Business. The last agenda item, which is the only item there, is to announce that the next City Council Meeting date will be on October 13, 2026 at 5:00 p.m. There is nothing further.” There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 6:02 p.m. Jennifer B. Cook Clerk of Council

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.