RecordWell Data

_08272026-11166

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Aug 27, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Public Safety Committee August 27 , 2026 On this date, the Public Safety Committee met in the Council Chamber, City Hall, 80 Broad Street and via video conference call beginning at 4: 3 0 p.m. Notice of this meeting was sent to all local news media. Present : Chair Kevin Shealy, Vice Chair William Tinkler (virtual), Councilmember Aaron Polkey (arrived at 4:33 p.m. ), Councilmember Karl Brady (virtual), Councilmember Keith Waring (arrived at 4:34 p.m.), and Mayor Cogswell. Staff : Elizabeth Dieck, Julia Copeland, Steve Ruemelin, Chief Walker, Jennifer Cook recording. 1. Moment of Silence The meeting was opened with a moment of silence led by Chair Shealy. 2. Approval of Minutes from the Ju ly 7 , 2026 Meeting On a motion of Mayor Cogswell , seconded by Vice Chair Tinkler , the Committee voted unanimously to approve the minutes from the July 7 , 2026 meeting. 3. Public Comment Mr. Tim Shaw said the First Amendment ordinance was enforced inconsistently. He alleged that it was based on viewpoint and race. While some groups were arrested, others could unofficially negotiate with officers to continue protesting. He said the right to protest in Charleston depended on who you knew and whether you could afford an attorney and the fine. The laws people write will outlast them. Former Councilmember Ms. Carol Jackson first read a statement that was delivered to City Council in July of 2025. It was a resolution passed by the City ’s Human Affairs and Racial Conciliation Commission (HARCC) before its dissolution. HARCC recommended the City look over the restrictive ordinance again. When the ordinance was created, there were high public health and safety concerns, which caused the maximum number of unpermitted individuals to be low. The ordinance was also reactive to a peaceful protest that escalated with a few bad actors that vandalized downtown. The protests sparked the creation of HARCC and its predecessor, the City ’s Special Commission on Equity, Inclusion, and Racial Conciliation (SCEIRC). She said the First Amendment assembly ordinance was an affront to the constitutional right to public, visible assembly. Ms. Heather Stegelin said the ordinance invited arbitrary enforcement. She said the ordinance required participants to walk in a single spot, which wasn ’t how public procession worked, and gave officers an excuse to intervene in any march. The ordinance prohibited anyone from blocking momentary access to a building, park, or memorial. She said they captured the inherent and unavoidable friction that came with peaceful public assembly. She said the crowd size limitations did not serve any safety purpose; it just made lawful protest more difficult. Any alleged violation lets police immediately revoke the permit, making the assembly unlawful. This allowed CPD to disperse everyone even if the alleged offense was minuscule. Ms. Tracy Tap was a volunteer organizer for an organization that hosted multiple protests in the County. She said the City ’s permitting process was the most onerous in the County. She said there were 3 ways the ordinance violated the First Amendment and established case law. The ordinance was quite restrictive based on place, she said CPD will often only offer two venues. The ordinance was arbitrarily enforced, with different groups being told different things by CPD. Finally, the ordinance placed unrealistic demands on citizens by moving larger protests to the special event process. When they tried to organize a protest with an estimated crowd size of 1,200 people, CPD told them they needed a special event permit with required $1,700 in fees and liability insurance. They had to file an appeal, enter negotiations with a City attorney, change the event date, and revise their crowd estimate to 1,000 to be granted a First Amendment permit. She said that was too many hoops to go through for a peaceful protest. She said these actions were inconsistent with binding 11 th circuit court precedent set in Burke v. Augusta-Richmond County, which found that requiring permit applicants to furnish insurance was a violation of the First Amendment. Ms. Bonnie Cleveland said in 2020 she organized a protest of less than 50 people, which at the time didn ’t need permitting. She posted about the protest on Facebook, and CPD called her to ask her to apply for a permit. She applied and was denied. The protest was held without a permit. In 2025, she organized a protest, and CPD modified her permit. She refused the modifications and said the protest would be held anyway. There were negotiations between her and CPD, and a compromise was made. She said negotiation was a privilege not available to every citizen. She said that, as a self- employed White woman with attorney friends who will represent her pro bono, she was operating from a point of privilege. For people who don ’t have those resources, the ordinance wasn ’t just an inconvenience. Ms. Cook summarized the online comments. 4. Presentation and discussion on First Amendment Ordinance. Action may be taken after the presentation and discussion. Ms. Copeland said they were here partially because of the recommendation made by HARCC to conduct a rigorous and comprehensive review of Article 3, Chapter 25 in the City ’s Code, which governed First Amendment demonstrations. The First Amendment stated that the government couldn ’t prohibit citizens ’ right to assemble and exercise their freedom of speech to petition the government for a redress of grievances. However, the government can regulate speech and assembly in public forums. In 1981, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a holding that the First Amendment didn ’t guarantee expression at all times and places or in any manner that may be desired. Regulations were permissible if the government could demonstrate adequate justification for the regulation. The City ’s Code described a First Amendment demonstration as a demonstration, assembly, picketing, speechmaking, marching, protest, vigil or religious service, or any form of conduct in a public place that involves the communication or expression of views that has more than 1 person and is likely to draw a crowd. There are 7 features Chief Walker had to consider when reviewing a permit, which Ms. Copeland listed. She said the ordinance was challenged in 2025 because of a permit that was requested during one of the busiest weekends in the City. Due to the other events that were being held, CPD offered a different time, place, and manner. The applicant rejected the alternative and sought an injunction in court. The court gave the ordinance a thorough analysis and provided feedback to the City. The court decided that the grounds the Chief relied on were reasonably specific and objective, and that the City offered content- neutral justifications for its decisions and left open ample alternatives. Therefore, the judge upheld the constitutional applicability of the ordinance. There were exemptions to the permit requirement , s uch as spontaneous gatherings and small gatherings under 25 people. Ms. Copeland described the process they went through to decide on a cap of 25. Chief Walker said he appreciated the citizens who commented and reiterated that the CPD upheld the constitution and their main priority was public safety. He said they tried to avoid sidewalk protests because it caused people who weren ’t a part of the protest to walk in the street. He said CPD didn ’t care about the reason behind the protest, just that all parties were safe. Councilmember Polkey said the ordinance wasn ’t likely to be repealed, but it could be carefully reviewed with everyone ’s concerns in mind. He said there were allegations of possible abuse that would be reviewed thoroughly. The City was committed to upholding citizens ’ right to peacefully assemble and petition. He said they weren ’t necessarily discussing a repeal, but the time, place, and manner restrictions in the ordinance. They should ask themselves: if sections of the ordinance were repealed, what would they be replaced with? He said he was committed to analyzing the ordinance to see what they could do to mitigate concerns about potential abuses. He said in cases of uneven enforcement provide as much specificity as possible. Councilmember Polkey asked Ms. Cleaveland to provide more details about an experience she had under the previous ordinance. Ms. Cleaveland said time, place, and manner wasn ’t her biggest concern, and under the previous ordinance it was easier to get protests approved. She was told her permit was denied because of a lack of personnel. She took issue with this because it was a peaceful protest with around 25 people walking very slowly from Washington Square Park to City Hall. Also, despite saying there was a lack of personnel, 20 officers were sent to the protest. Councilmember Waring said he supported the implementation of the ordinance, though he thought it was reactionary. He said CPD was there to protect the law and peaceful protesters. He said after the riot in 2020, something had to be done, but the ordinance could be made better. He cited protests from the women ’s suffrage and civil rights movements and asked if those parties would be arrested today under this ordinance. He said a lot of good can come from protesting. He said they shouldn ’t repeal the ordinance entirely, but it could be improved. Mayor Cogswell said the City had a competent and fair police chief in Chief Walker. His judgment was paramount in any potential modifications to the ordinance. He said it was important to note that there would have to be compromises made throughout this process. He said they should discuss recommended language and modifications at a future Public Safety Committee meeting. Councilmember Waring asked how the public could participate in the process. Mayor Cogswell said there were a few commenters at the meeting who had notes and memoranda that could be submitted through the Legal Department or Mayor ’s Office. 5. Adjournment There being no further discussion, the Committee adjourned at 3 :20 p.m. Jasmine O ’Neal Clerk of Council ’s Office

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.