RecordWell Data

_08202026-11149

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Aug 20, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

DRAFT C ommunity D evelopment C ommittee August 20, 2026 A m e e tin g o f th e C o m m u n ity D e v e lo p m e n t C o m m itte e w a s h e ld o n th is d a te b e g in n in g a t 3 :0 4 p .m . a t 8 0 B ro a d S t. a n d o v e r v id e o c o n fe re n c e c a ll. Notice of this meeting was sent out to the news media. Present: Mayor Cogswell, Chair Councilmember Ross Appel, Vice Chair Councilmember Jim McBride (Virtual), Councilmember Ben D ’Allesandro, Councilmember Aaron Polkey (Virtual), and Councilmember Mike Seekings (Virtual) Also Present: Elizabeth Dieck, Shannon Elliott, Julia Copeland, Robert Summerfield, Melissa Cruthirds, Magalie Creech, Christopher Morgan, Hampton Logan, Eric Pohlman, Katherine Dahlheim, Tiffany Pressley, Grace Riley, and Jasmine O ’Neal and Calista Bowen recording . The meeting was opened by Councilmember D ’Allesandro with a moment of silence a. Public Participation 1. Mr. Robert Anderson said his father had bought the property in 1950. His father had torn down the main building and kept the back portion. He said that a maintenance person who used to work at the club stayed and lived there. 2. Juli e O ’Connor was the president and founder of local nonprofit , Save Our Structures Charleston. She said demolition was not the answer and that there were countless ways to save the building and to prioritize history over a parking space. She said this was a textbook case of demolition by neglect , because Ash le y Hall had owned the building for 20 years and had chosen not to maintain it. She asked the committee not overturn this decision. b. Approval of Minutes i. July 9,2026 On a motion of Mayor Cogswell, seconded by Councilmember D ’Allesandro, the Committee on Community Development voted unanimously to approve the July 9, 2026, minutes . c. Old Business None d. New Business i. A Resolution certifying property located at 141 Meeting Street as an Abandoned Building Site pursuant to the South Carolina Abandoned Buildings Revitalization Act, Title 12, Chapter 67 of the CODE O N LAWS O F South Carolina, 1976 , as amended On a motion of Mayor Cogswell, seconded by Councilmember D ’Allesandro, the Committee on Community Development voted unanimously to approve D1. ii. Presentation on demolition request for 148 Smith Street (Dash Hall) and recommendation to Council regarding the proposed mediated settlement DRAFT Chair Appel said the matter went before the Board of Architectural Review (BAR) the previous year , was denied, then an appeal was filed. Under state laws , there was an opportunity for appellants to mediate the dispute, the mediation occurred, and it resulted in a settlement agreement. That settlement agreement went to City Council and when they were set to approve it , it was suggested that this be referred to the Community Development C ommittee for additional fact finding. R epresentatives from Ash le y Hall and the Preservation Society were there so that the committee could gain a better understanding and make a recommendation to Council . Councilmember Polkey asked if it was Chair Appel ’s intent to determine a recommendation at th e meeting or make a recommendation at a subsequent meeting based on the information they received t hat day . Chair Appel said that it was up to the will of the C ommittee. There needed to be additional fact finding for th e C ommittee to report a recommendation on how to proceed , and that a recommendation would be made today at their meeting. Councilmember Seekings asked to hear from the legal team . Ms. Creech said under the terms of the current proposed mediated settlement that Ash le y Hall would be permitted to demolish the structure. As part of that approval , Ashley Hall would commemora te Dash Hall by hav ing a c ollaboration with the City architect, incorporat ing Dash Hall ’s history in the 11 th grade American studies class, ha ving presentations done to the students from the architect, had students participate in the creation of a historical plaque or marker that would go through the History Commission for approval, this plaque would be put at a publicly accessible location on or along Smith Street no later than December 31, 2027. Mr. Brian Hellman said he was there to represent the Ash le y Hall Foundation, the owners of 148 Smith Street. He had Mr. Russell Rosen, an engineer, Dr. Anne Weston, head of school, and Ms. Sarah DeWolf, board chair of Ash le y Hall, with him. He showed the National Archives 1939 photo and a current photo of Dash Hall. He said they were there on a referral from C ouncil as part of a me d iated settlement agreement that arose out of a pre-litigation mediation process from the BAR. He said it was part of Charleston ’s Black or African American history and that was not what they were there to debate. He said that the current structure was not the original building known as Dash Hall. He said Mr. Rosen would point out that Go o gle Maps and the 1939 photo were not the same , and that Mr. Rosen believed that the building was moved there because the building had the absence of 1950s materials to modify the structure, the foundation did not match the structure, the materials used in the foundation and the balloon framing which confirm ed that it was not a two-story building. He said the conclusion they came to was that it was an old building that was not part of Dash Hall. He said there was a difference in the roof slope from the 1939 building that sloped to Smith Street versus the current building whose roof slope d to Radcliffe. He said Mr. Anderson ’s family bought the property from the Dash family in 1950, proceeded to demolish and construct something new , then sold the property in 1991 to the Tiedemann ’s . Before the Tiedemann ’s purchased the property , they hired Mr. Rosen, a structural engineer, to inspect the property. He said when Mr. Rosen inspected the property in 1991, he had found that the building was in poor condition, would require substantial investment to be a home, had termites, leaks, decay, and was full of vines. He said the building that stood today had been in decay for four decades. Ash le y Hall purchased the building in 2005, and they had tried to make improvements to the building but failed , and after that the foundation failed, and the roof collapsed , which made it a liability to the students. He said they had brought Mr. Rosen back to inspect the property. Mr. Rosen said that based on the photograph from 1939 , it was a two-story building that was in the corner, but his findings showed that it was too short to be a two-story building because it was a 12-foot ceiling with a tongue and groove bead board and balloon framed. He said that the building was constructed in the DRAFT 19 th century and possibly as late as 1910 because by then they used a hybrid construction between balloon and western frames. He said that by 1910 one started to see houses with a smaller stud than one saw at 148 Smith Street and houses had diagonal sheathing which had lasted until the 1940s, which was when people started using plywood. He said that 148 Smith Street did not have structural sheathing. He said that 148 Smith Street as it stood was a single-story building, had a balloon frame, and was built in the 19 th century. He said the information conflicted with the picture which showed a two-story building. He said that his conclusion was that the structure was relocated. He said when the Tiedemann ’s bought the property in 1991 he looked at the building and that the building was covered with vines, so he was unable to get inside the building, so he observed it from the outside. The Tiedemann ’s renovated the building and put in a loft. He said the East portion away from Smith Street had contemporary concrete masonry units for foundation and contemporary studs. He said that the building that was there was not Dash Hall. He said the 1950 Sanborn Maps show that there was no structure. Chair Appel asked if anyone else wanted to speak. Mr. Hellman said that in the 1944 Sanborn Maps it showed the same building, in the 1939 Sanborn Maps but in the 1951 Sanborn Maps the building had been removed and there was instead a new concrete structure and in the 1955 Sanborn Map the structure reappeared. He said that the maps corroborated with what Mr. Rosen had said about the structure being moved. He introduce d Dr. Weston who was Ash le y Hall ’s H ead of School. Dr. Weston said that Ash le y Hall was committed to being a good partner in Charleston and recognized the historical significance of the areas and buildings in the City. She said the building was not Dash Hall. She said that while they recognize d the cultural and historical significance of the area , the safety of their students came first. Mr. Hellman said they discussed with Ms. Creech ’s overview of the settlement agreement was to bring awareness to history and had this issue not been raised the story of Dash Hall would had never been told. He said the building was not a two-story building which did not match with what was there in 1939 or 1950. He said the history should be told through stories , not a building to substitute the stories. Mr. Brian Turner, president and CEO of the Preservation Society , said he respected Mr. Hellman and Ash le y Hall and they enjoyed the partnership, and they were a valuable part of the cultural landscape in Charleston. He said that there was new information and they did try to prepare as diligently as they could. He said they had put out a new paper article that morning with the facts as well as a profile of Mr. Anderson who had a memory of the building. He said he wanted Mr. Anderson to speak before he presented his evidence. Mr. Anderson said Mr. Rosen talked about the foundation and explained that in the 50s his father had put cinder or concrete blocks under it, jacked it up, moved it around, added a window, all to make to livable. He said he did not see the purpose of tearing down the building so they could expand the parking lot. He said they could fix it up and turn it into a storage building or anything to make use of the building. He said not to tear down the building. Mr. Turner said that this was an extraordinary request because they had a history of arguing in front of the BAR and C ouncil on settlement agreements which were related to design, stories, and merit, but never demolition. He said for them to adopt a standard for the review unless they wanted the community to be able to second guess the judgement the BAR made for erasing building from the landscape. He said that there needed to be clear and compelling evidence that the board made an error . Mr. Turner said their narrative was most plausible. He said he wanted Mr. Rosen ’s engineering report peer-reviewed by another structural engineer and the proper venue w as the Board of Architectural Review DRAFT as they had experts. He said that if an older building was moved to the site there was no record of where the building came from, the demolition of the original building or, how it was modified to fit the trapezoidal footprint. He said the Sanborn maps showed a square structure not the irregular structure that stood. He said there should be a record of the building being demolished and it did not make sense for Mr. Anderson to tear down a portion of the structure to relocate another building to the site. He said that most of the building was demolished and the remnant was made into living quarters for a former Dash Hall employee. He said that Sanborn Maps were inaccurate, from previous information submitted by Professor Christina Butler. He said there was evidence of historical aerial photos that d id not show the same image that Sanborn Maps had show n . He said that the plat map did show the same trapezoidal shape as the photo. He said the deed survey showed the trapezoidal bump on the east side of the building which lined up with the current Goggle Earth view. He said that if there was a relocated building it would be needed to fit the exact dimensions of the remnant. He said that he agreed that Dash Hall had been modified and was in poor condition. He said this building was a tangible link the City ’s African American heritage and jazz legacy that was worth preserving which was not able to be conveyed in a plaque or history class. He said that his opponent ’s position was unsupported by clear and convincing evidence. He did not believe that the committee should recommend the settlement agreement as proposed . Mayor Cogswell said he understood Mr. Turner ’s concern. He said this was unusual when they ended up in mediations since usually the BAR and BZA could use their expertise and come to a logical conclusion. He said w hether or not the structure that stood today was part of the original structure or not a lot of modification had been made to the structure. He said the goal of the settlement was to find a compromise which was demolition. Mayor Cogswell asked if there was an opportunity to move the structure. He said that relocation could be a compromise. He said Ashley Hall was willing to tell the history and continue the legacy which had been brought to light by this discussion. He said that the Preservation Society could help raise money to relocate the building and with Ash le y Hall tell the story of the building. Councilmember D ’Allesandro asked wh y relocation was not an option. Councilmember Polkey asked where and how far the building would be moved. He asked if it was possible to relocate the building and still maintain the contextual historic connection with the neighborhood. He asked if they could relocate the building to the original lot. Mr. Hellman said that on March 8, Mr. Kurt Palmer, who was on the board of Ash le y Hall, met with Mr. Tu r ner. He said Mr. Palmer said to Mr. Turner that the building was available if they could find an interested party to move or dismantle the building and Ash le y Hall agree d with that. He said that Ashley Hall was in bad shape to be relocated. He said the question was where the building would be relocated and who would do it. He said the building was available but not to be kept on Ashley Hall ’s school site. He asked how Ashley Hall would be responsible for it if it stay ed on Ash le y Hall ’s property as a museum or historic piece . He said the Preservation Society had to find and fund a place to relocate the building, and Ash le y Hall would like to save the building. He said they did not believe the building was Dash Hall Mr. Turner said this was deferred from a February agenda of C ouncil. He said they saw the original settlement agreement, so they contacted Ashley Hall to find a solution. He said they submitted an advocacy alert when they saw it was on the C ouncil agenda with the same settlement agreement that would allow for the demolition of the property. He said there were concerns about the legal right to wreck a building. He said normally a relocation plan would be submitted to the Board of Architectural Review to make sure the experts understood the consequences and how it would be situated and that they did not want to bypass that process. He said they believe d the building was Dash Hall and wanted it to be owned by an entity that want ed to be a steward and tell the story of the building. He said he had talked to people about DRAFT the logistics of the building, and it could be worked out . He said he would have liked there to be no deadline for when the building would be wrecked. Mr. Hellman said this conversation had been going on since March 8. He said they would not have to have asked the BAR ’s permission to relocate the building. He said the issue then became who was going to move it and to where. He said the building was about to collapse and was a safety issue for the grade school. Councilmember Polkey said he still did not know whether or not the building was Dash Hall. He said he wanted to hear from either Mr. Hellman or Mr. Turner whether any efforts had been made to identify where the structure could have come from if it was not Dash Hall. He said that the building was important to the African American community and to the neighborhood. He said that if they could not come to a conclusion on whether or not the building was Dash Hall that they would continue to struggle. He asked to hear from Mr. Hellman about the efforts he had taken to locate where, if the building had been relocated, the building had come from. Mr. Hellman said Mr. Rosen observed that the building was not originally two stories. He said they had look ed at the plat Mr. Tu r ner had talked about and the section was eight feet deep, but the building was 30 feet deep and one story. He said the eight foot section of Dash Hall was one story but everything else was two stories. He said that buildings had been destroyed by flooding. He said that there used to be public notices that the City published for everything so they searched for the records for Radcliffe and Smith, as well as the Sanborn Maps from 1950 to 1955 to find where the building could have come from. He said they had found three buildings but there was no way for them to tell if they were the building that stood today. He said one of the buildings was on 148 Smith St r eet and one building that was owne d by a lumber mill was relocated , but they did not say where it was relocated to . He said the third building was a property the Anderson ’s had owned on Logan Street that was the same size that showed up on the 1951 Sanborn Map and was not on the 1955 Sanborn Map. He said in 1939 a large building showed up on the Sanborn Map. He said this building looked like the Dash Hall building. Mr. Turner said he wanted to introduce Ms. Laurel Fay. He said it was an implausible theory that the building was demolished and another building was relocated into its place. He said if historical inquiry was the goal that there were people that were still alive that they could go ask what they remembered. He said there should be more investigation done before the building was wrecked. Mr. Anderson said w h ether or not the committee believed it was the back of the nightclub or not was fine. He said the club was a part of the land and if it was relocated it, one would lose the feeling of the land. He said that one should not keep tearing down buildings for parking lots. He said the building could not be relocated because they would lose the heart of the land because the land told a story and one could not put a plaque in another location and get the same feeling . Councilmember Polkey said it was a fair statement that the building being on Ash le y H all ’s property was a challenge for them. He said he agreed with Mr. Anderson. He said if the building was relocated it would have to be in a location that was still appropriate in the context of the neighborhood. He said land was expensive and he struggled to see how it would work in practice. Councilmember McBride said if they could not determine whether or not the building was Dash Hall, but in the case that it was , they would spend money to move it , which would not be prudent either. He said someone should find out for sure about the history of the building. Chair Appel asked if the past destruction and alteration of a building got to a point to where it was no longer the original building. He compared the situation to the Ship of Theseus. He asked if they reh abilitated the current building sitting in the parking lot , w ould they be rehabilitating Dash Hall or the caretaker ’s house ? DRAFT Mr. Turner said that City Council empower ed the BAR to make decisions about what was historically valuable. He said when the BAR ma de decisions it was acting on the City ’s policy. He said that even if the building had been heavily altered, that the City could still see it as valuable. Mr. Hellman said Council w as the body that had created the Bar and appointed its members. He said that Council was the best way to resolve these issues because the BAR lacked fairness. He said that Council had the final say in this matter. Chair Appel said that BAR and BZA processes were limited by the facts and ordinances. He said the BAR was limited in its decision so the building would either be preserved or demolished and that this current mediation allowed for creativity. He said that City Council and everyone involved had the flexibility to add educational curriculum or a commemorative plaque which the B oard could not do. He said that blocking the demolition would not solve the issue. Councilmember D ’Allesandro said the story of the Dash family and Dash Hall needed to be told. Mayor Cogswell said that the building was a safety issue for Ashley Hall ’s faculty and students. He said that w h ether or not it was Dash Hall , the building was beyond repair. He said Mr. Anderson made a good point that it was the legacy of the land. He said that Ash le y H all was willing to commemorate Dash Hall. He said a plaque could be built or turned into something that could be owned by Ashley Hall that the preservation Society could help fund and maintain. Chair Appel asked if Ash le y Hall had brought up the issue of two parking spots or whether it was a safety issue. Mr. Hellman said the building was in a state of collapse and had collapsed in two different places. He said Ashley Hall was using the building as a shed and the floor collapsed and when the floor collapsed the ceiling and northern side collapsed. He said the building was too far gone to be repaired. Mayor Cogswell said he was not trying to put the building back together. He said that they could use the treated lumber in a way. Mr. Hellman said Mr. Rosen had said the lumber was not treated and preceded treated lumber . Mayor Cogswell said that there would be a plaque that was new and that used the recycled elements of what was there but it would have been on a new foundation or shed which would have told the story. Mr. Anderson said Ash le y Hall owned the property for 20 years and in those years, they did not repair the building. He said A sh ley Hall should be ashamed of themselves. Chair Appel said that the art community could do something creative with the material. He asked if there was something they could do that did not cost as much to rebuild it but commemorated it more than a plaque. He said the BAR had no authority to do this, and this was the power of the mediated process that they were in and that they could get creative. He said the sign of a good mediation was tha t nobody got absolutely everything that they wanted because if they stayed in the “ zero sum ” mentality then the building was either going to be preserved or destroyed with no plan of what would come next. He said they had the opportunity to create a collaborative, creative, and flexible outcome. He said he needed a recommendation from th e C ommittee. Councilmember Seekings said that what had happened through the mediated process was that they were creating a resolution that went beyond the authority of the BAR. He said it went beyond the authority DRAFT and interests of the Circuit Court and if they did not approve the settlement and there was no resolution it would go to the Circuit Court who had no interest in creating a resolution for the community. He said if it reached the Circuit Court , there would be a bad result. Councilmember Polkey said Chair Appel described an appellant procedure, but he had forgotten to mention that appellant panels did not issue their decision from the bench after the conclusion of the argument. He said they were making a recommendation that City Council would consider. Chair Appel said they were not the appellate body and were in a mediation only. Councilmember Pol k ey said they were an appellate body at the beginning. Chair Appel said they were gathering information and deciding whether or not it was in the City ’s best interest to reach a settlement or resolution. Councilmember D ’Allesandro asked to hear more about the curriculum aspect. Mr. Hellman said the curriculum aspect came from a mediated process a year prior because the majority of the community did not know about Dash Hall. He said the purpose of the curriculum was to work with the school and other organizations, such as the Preservation Society and Avery Institute, to take an 11 th grade American History class project to the Commission on History and to work together to create a plaque. Councilmember D ’Allesandro said he thought this would be part of the school day curriculum. Mr. Hellman said that there was a program at the school where they talked about what building s were and were no longer on the campus and that the building would be included in that. Dr. Weston said that there were two efforts. T he first was when they partnered with the Preservation Society to open campus up for a tour where the students did the research. T he second one was an 11 th g rade American Studies Program where they focused on the history of Charleston. The students in that class adopt ed blocks, d id the research, work ed with the Preservation Society, and then g ave the presentation to their peers and visitors. She thought this could be a place where they adopted the block and talked about the significa nce of that block to Charleston. She said that it was difficult to turn it into a tour because they had a responsibility to their young people who went to school there to protect them. Councilmember D ’Allesandro asked for more details about the curriculum and how many years this would happen for. He said he got a book from the library called Charleston Jazz by Jack McCrae that talked about the Dash family, Dash Hall, and local jazz artist s and said it would be great if it was incorporated into the curriculum. Chair Appel said the International African American Museum had information and research that could help Ashley Hall with this important history moving forward. Councilmember Seekings said the objective was to hear from both sides to figure out whether or not th e structure was Dash Hall. He said they should send a recommendation to City Council. He said there should be a procedure on how to go from the BAR to City Council by avoiding the Circuit Court. Mayor Cogswell said he recommended approval for the settlement on the condition that the two parties got together to figure out what the monument or plaque would be that would help tell the story while respecting the Dash family. DRAFT Councilmember D ’Allesandro said he wanted to hear about the curriculum aspect. Councilmember Polkey said he understood that the building could fall down and hoped the parties would conclude on whether the building was Dash Hall. He said he interpreted the settlement as meaning that subject to contingency of the curriculum and the plaque that they would demolish the building that could h ave been Dash Hall. He said on behalf of the African American community, that had a deep cultural and intrinsic connection to the peninsula, he could not approve circumstances that would allow demolition. He said they could not spend more time since the building was a safety issue. He said he had not heard from Charleston ’s African American community on accepting the outcome that the building would be demolished. He said he would like testimonies from people who were alive. He said he could not support the demol ition of the potential remnant of Dash Hall. Chair Appel said he agreed with the Mayor. He said if they could replace the building in the parking lot with something beautiful and compelling that could tell the story of Dash Hall then that would be the best outcome. On a motion of Mayor Cogswell, seconded by Councilmember Seekings, the Committee on Community Development voted to approve D2 . The vote was not unanimous. Councilmember Polkey voted against . iii. Discussion regarding 806 M agnolia Road (Requested by Chair Appel) Chair Appel said this was in West Ash le y and was a proposed rezoning and that it had already gone to the P lanning C ommission, and they had voted to recommend disapproval. He said that spoke to the City ’s policy of promoting missing middle housing, infill redevelopment, and affordable housing. He said Mr. Stribling was going to talk about the financial and economic constraints that went into these projects. He said that this was an opportunity to understand what went into infill because the goal was to accomplish their affordable housing goals and for that to happen, they needed more supply on the market through Project 3500 and by finding creative ways to get more housing all over the City. Mr. Wofford Stribling said he helped run a development firm called STYO Development and before that he was a civil engineer for 15 years . T hey had grow n to the point where they were entitling and permitting 1,000 lots a year. He said they ha d in-house construction, and they had completed site work for 1,000 lots a year and in the upstate they were entitling and permitting 500 lots a year. He said there was an approved site plan for 806 Magnolia. The Technical Review Committee (TRC) approved the set that he had worked on for four years. Behind that site plan, the one he had put together five years ago was never pursued because former Councilmember Shahid advised them to move forward with the existing zoning. He said the preliminary estimates they had looked at on site work costs indicated that they were going to be able to do a successful subdivision by right . He said this was a scrutinized drainage area. He said he had meetings with Mr. Ron Bucci, and they were ready to break ground. He said the existing zoning was SR-7 which was a two-acre site with a large historic home for a price of $ 1 million. He said other houses in the area with larger lots had b een priced at more than $ 1 million. He said once one extrapolated that number across all the homes they had proposed the land would cost $72,000 per lot . The original site infrastructure number was different due to the public right of ways having minimal Best Management Practices (BMP) as to how to handle stormwater. He said that rather than having to get rid of three lots and doing a four-lot subdivision what he and his engineer Mr. Chip decided was the solution was to price out pervious paver s and an under ground drain system. He said the project was started in 2021 and now five years later site work had gone up in the L owcountry so $1.6 million dollars was a fair market construction price and the lot price would come to $228,000. He said the impact fees through Charleston Water System would be $15,000 . He said no one was valuing the lots at $315,000 per lot and they had overpaid for the land. He said if it was rezoned to SR-7 it would cost $243,000 per lot . He said that the numbers were for cost not for profit and that the Carolinas had a standard that if one completes a project, DRAFT they make 20% return on the lot. He said by adding 20% a finished lot of $315,000 would be valued at $380,000 and if one did the same thing with a finished lot of $240,000 would be valued at $290,000. He said that even if the land was free there was a fundamental problem with the zone , and this had to do with the cost of water and sewer main extensions and stormwater. He said he appreciate d that the City of Charleston had high stand ard s for stormwater, but it came at a cost of development for infill projects. He had a meeting with Mr. Pullman, Mr. Morgan, and Councilmember Tinkler and they asked to come up with a Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) solution . He said they went to the stormwater P lanning staff and the recommendation they came up with was that a DR-9 rezone was the best solution. He said that when one did an infill project that it would not align with the base zoning or the existing zoning of a project. He said he met with the P lanning D epartment and the neighbors and knew that the rezon ing would work. He said that there was concern from the community about putting townhomes in , but it was not his intention to put townhomes there. With that change one could use the $500,000 land cost and divide it between 11. With DR-9 it would allow for a horizontal property regime and in a detached scenario lending would work the same but if he put in townhomes it would change to a condo lending mechanism which would exclude buyers. He said because of this there would no longer be a public road and he would have the ability to make the space fall under HOA maintenance and that would allow underground retention through chambered systems. He said Mr. Morgan had said that that neighborhood was built and finished in 1953 and now 75 years later housing and development look ed different. He said that because of that the zoning needed to look different and he could demonstrate what good infill looked like. Chair Appel said this was important if they wanted to meet the missing middle housing affordability goal because the zoning needed to align with the economic realities and costs that the developers were fac ed with . He said that missing middle affordable housing was not going to come from nowhere and if they wanted to achieve their affordably goals, they were going to have to act like P roject 3500. Mayor Cogswell said with rezoning they could deliver houses with the same quality and location with 40% lower cost. Adjourn There being no further business to discuss, the meeting adjourned at 5:15p.m. Calista Bowen Clerk of Council ’s Office CITIZEN COMMENTS RECEIVED FOR COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT – AUGUST 20, 2026 1. Please incorporate my comments from the May 26, 2026 City Council meeting regarding the same topic. Deny this demolition request for Dash Hall. by Emily Pigott, 21 Father Grants Court 08/18/26 3:54:22 PM 2. I urge the Committee to recommend that Council reject the agreement in its current form. The proposed agreement relies on an unsupported assumption that no original portion of Dash Hall remains. Available research directly refutes this claim, and City Council should give significant weight to the unanimous decision of BAR-S, which found that demolition would be a loss to Charleston and that the building is not beyond repair. At a minimum, all reasonable preservation alternatives should be evaluated before the this historic community landmark is permanently lost. by Kenneth Hirsch, 77 Bull Street 08/18/26 4:29:20 PM DRAFT 3. Dash Hall- please reject or table this until later. Dash Hall deserves to have a chance at history and preservation. by Jennie Culkin, 128 Columbus Street 08/18/26 4:38:20 PM 4. The BAR at first denied demolition of this site important to Charleston's history. The arbitration that went forward and the decision made was highly unusual: it opens the door for any person or corporation or owner to disregard the opinion of experts regarding demolition of ANY structure. We stand to lose scores and scores of vernacular and endangered buildings if this precedent is allowed. But even worse, there is NO reason for this precedent in the first place. The owner of the building had erroneous information regarding the building. A source has been discovered that proves the owner's claim about the building was incomplete and ultimately FALSE. (And the presentation of the information stopped any further action, till now.) The historic record proves that the building IS historic and IS a relic of Dash Hall; so not only will this be a dangerous precedent, it is based on incomplete and erroneous information. The building exists; no sign or teaching about its history can ever replace it. The decision was made on erroneous information. Correct information, now in hand, should reverse it. by Harlan Greene, 32 Chapel Street 08/18/26 5:21:56 PM 5. Charleston Community Development Committee Agenda Item: d II As a long-time resident of this wonderful city and having spent most of my professional career working to preserve the Historic (Cultural) heritage of the city, I am compelled to write to encourage you to carefully consider the important preservation issues raised by the pressure to demolish the Dash Hall structure and recognize the importance of protecting it. I served for many years on the BAR-S and was one of the Board Members who voted to deny this demolition request. I am sure much will be made of the fact that this small building does not retain much of the historic material of the original structure and thus lacks significant grounds for preservation. It will likely be argued that the extant structure is only a fragment of the original. These arguments may hold some truth, but the existing structure retains enough original material and form to be an important representation of the original. These conditions aside, there are even more essential reasons to preserve this small structure. Preservation of historic materials is important, but in today ’s understanding of preservation, original material is not the only important element in an historic structure ’s value. For many years preservationists and conservators have understood that the Eurocentric concept (emphasized in the Venice Charter of 1964) that Cultural Authenticity resides principally in structures, materials, and workmanship is only one way to view preservation. In more recent years, as the value of preservation has spread out of Europe and the United States and into the rest of the world, the adoption of documents such as the Nara Document (1994) and the Burra Charter (2013) have emphasized that Cultural Heritage embodies Authenticity when it reinforces and cultivates shared values. The preservation of Authentic Cultural Heritage includes not just monumental structures, but settings, landscapes, modest structures, neighborhoods, and community practices. These elements can be as important as the history represented by monuments and their materials. Dash Hall is a perfect example of this concept. A concept in preservation widely practiced and supported around the world and embraced by UNESCO in evaluating World Heritage Sites. (UNESCO ’s 1972 Convention focused on physical properties; 2003 expanded to include intangible cultural heritage.) The Dash Hall structure represents an important element of the Heritage of a large group of Charleston ’s citizens. It not only represents the artistic contributions of Charleston ’s citizens, but DRAFT many of those Citizens made major contributions at a national level to the music of an important period in the country ’s history. The casual destruction of one of the last physical representations of the contributions Charlestonians made to the Cultural Heritage of this period is a significant disservice to the city ’s history and its current citizens, and an action contrary to preservation philosophy and practice. It is important to understand that focusing on narrow heritage perceptions, which focus solely on physical heritage and elite conservation approaches can marginalize local communities. There are many avenues available to preserve the Dash Hall structure and still appropriately develop the site on which it currently sits. Destruction of this historic structure should not be one of those avenues. Located on the Ashley Hall School campus, this portion of the original Dash Hall, preserved and restored, would be an important tool in representing and teaching Charleston ’s unique history. Thank you, Fillmore Wilson Charleston, SC 29412 843-452-4717 fillmore@meadorsinc.com by Fillmore Wilson, 756 Harborview Road 08/19/26 2:48:39 PM 6. Ashley Hall - do the right thing! Allow Dash Hall to remain and be restored... please do not erase this important piece of African American history in Charleston, SC. by Dr. Louester Robinson, 4871 Durant Avenue, North Charleston, SC 29405 08/19/26 3:03:44 PM 7. How joyful would it be to see distinct value in the Dash Hall property, with preservation as an outcome! Charleston's history should continue to celebrate its music, and there is opportunity to interpret a jazz club in Dash Hall. Locals and tourists alike will benefit from caring for this structure. by Colleen Rizzo, 2620 Wye Lane 29405 08/19/26 4:14:21 PM 8. I submitted a recommendation at the initial Community Development meeting to preserve Dash Hall (148 Smith Street) and today, I submit this second request. I strongly encourage the Committee to recommend that City Council reject the proposed settlement agreement between the City of Charleston and Ashley Hall School in its current form. I oppose overturning BAR-S ’ unanimous denial of demolition of Dash Hall, one of this country ’s few remaining Jazz and dance hall landmarks. Demolition of this site would not only permanently erase the physical identity of Charleston ’s pioneering role in the development of jazz in America but it would also be a loss to our nation ’s arts and cultural legacy. Karen Chandler, Ph.D., Co-Founder Charleston Jazz Initiative Associate Professor Emerita College of Charleston by Karen Chandler, 2525 Shreeve Lane, Nashville, TN 37207 08/19/26 7:35:48 PM 9. I am against its demolition. It is part of Dash Hall which is a historic building where Black people enjoyed themselves during Jim Crow days. Demolishing the structure eradicates the memory . by Stephen C. Ziff, 8 Legare Street, Charlestonarleston 08/19/26 10:37:18 PM 10. As a proud "purple" Ashley Hall girl, having attended for 8 years, I please urge the Committee to recommend that Council reject the agreement in its current form. My Ashley Hall friends are still my lifelong best friends and our core girl group consists of well-educated, strong women who advocate for such things as preserving the last remains of Dash Hall. The proposed agreement relies on an unsupported assumption that no original portion of Dash Hall remains. In fact, available research directly refutes this claim. As a born-and-bred Charlestonian, I appreciate the deteriorated state of many downtown structures. I fondly remember shopping for stereo DRAFT equipment with my parents in the lower level of Read Brothers. Please, I beg you to consider preserving the history of Dash Hall. We owe more to the history of Jim Crowe than a parking lot. A parking lot. Consider those two words. I understand that change arrived in my hometown many years ago and that is is often a wonderful improvement. However, this proposed change is not wonderful. A placcard , an inscribed bench for quiet reflection, or any other such homage would be a grave disservice to the history of Dash Hall. Mrs. McDonald, Mrs. Jollow , Mrs. Ruggiero, and many others at Ashley Hall taught us to be strong and respectful women. I respectfully urge you to please reject the agreement in its current form and, instead, consider the unanimous decision of BAR-S. by Jennifer Bracey, 81 Chadwick Drive Charleston, SC 29407 08/19/26 12:28:47 AM 11. Dear Community Development Committee, I am asking the City Council not to approve the destruction of the remaining Dash Hall structure at 148 Smith Street. This is about more than one small building. It is about what kind of Charleston we choose to preserve — and whose history we believe deserves to remain visible. The record before the City indicates that this structure is a remnant of historic Dash Hall, and that the area has experienced significant loss of buildings associated with African American heritage. The Preservation Society has also noted that protecting African American history is a core priority identified in the Charleston City Plan. Dash Hall represents a time in Charleston when Black people were restricted to certain places and excluded from spaces reserved for white people. Those places were not incidental — they were part of the lived history of Charlestonians. Please don ’t make it easier for future generations to forget that history ever happened. Preservation gives us the opportunity to acknowledge the past honestly so that we can move forward together. If we want reconciliation, inclusion, and a shared future, we must first be willing to recognize and preserve the places that tell the whole story. The BAR determined that the building was not beyond repair and that its loss would be a loss to the city. There are also less drastic preservation alternatives available, including partial retention, relocation, or delaying demolition to explore other options. Moreover, overturning the BAR decision would set quite a precedent of lack of respect for this organization ’s professional standing and collaboration with the city. Please do not make demolition the final chapter. We cannot move forward together by continuing to erase more of what came before us. We move forward together by acknowledging it, preserving it, learning from it, and making room for every story in Charleston's history. Sincerely, Grace Wingfield by Grace Wingfield, 81 Nunan St.Charleston , SC 29403 08/20/26 10:27:19 AM 12. As an Ashley Hall alumna and a Board member of BAR-S, I am not only opposed to but I am appalled at Ashley Hall's request to demolish Dash Hall. The school has an opportunity to celebrate preservation and African American history in the city of Charleston - the city that they are a part of and that supports them. In doing so, they could set an example for other institutions and, more importantly, for their students - that architectural and cultural assets should be cherished as a text of the history they are part of. Ashley Hall's request to demolish the building should not only be denied but they should be required to preserve and restore it in a way that gives back to the community. When we reviewed this project at BAR-S, we considered it thoroughly and deeply and the Board's decision to deny the demolition should be honored. Thank you. by Rebecca Patton, 6 Gibbes Street, Charleston, SC 29401 08/20/26 11:26:40 AM

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.