RecordWell Data

_08192026-11121

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Aug 19, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

A u g u s t 1 9 , 2 0 2 6 | 1 City of Charleston Planning Commission August 19 , 202 6 A meeting of the Planning Commission was held on this date at 5:0 0 p.m. in the public meeting room at 2 George Street. Notice of this meeting was sent to all local news media. PRESENT Commission Members: Chair Charles Karesh, Jimmy Bailey, Steve Hirsch, McKenna Joyce, Sunday Lempesis, Joey Ryan, Erika V. Harrison, and Donna Jacobs. City staff : Christopher Morgan , Amanda Cox, Philip Overcash , Mollie Conner, and Jasmine O ’Neal recording. Link to meeting recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UMG8dU5ywwk&t=310s Chair Karesh explained the rules and procedures of the meeting and introduced the Commissioners, volunteers appointed by Charleston ’s City Council. MINUTES 1. DEFERRED Request Approval of Minutes from the July 15, 2026, Meeting PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT & CONCEPT PLAN 1. DEFERRED | 3294 & 3280 Maybank Highway, 1730 & 1738 Fern Hill Drive Johns Island | TMS# 2790000288, -009, -008, 3130000047, 3130000237, & 2790000006 | Council District 3 | Approx. 13.47 ac. Request to rezone from Commercial Transitional & Rural Residential (CT & RR-1) to Planned Unit Development (PUD). Request Zoning Planned Unit Development (PUD). Zoned Residential (R-4) & Johns Island Maybank Highway Corridor Overlay (JO- MHCO) in Charleston County. Owner: The Charleston Real Estate Company LP, Sherry B. Bailey & Dennis R. Bailey, Rosemary Lynn Knox, & Bight Oak Properties LLC. Applicant: Kimley-Horn REZONINGS A u g u s t 1 9 , 2 0 2 6 | 2 1. 806 Magnolia Road West Ashley | TMS# 4180900030 | Council District 9 | Approx. 2.1 ac. Request to rezone from Single-Family Residential (SR-2) to Diverse Residential (DR-9). Owner: Albert J Gobel Jr. Applicant: STYO Mr. Morgan described the parcel and its surroundings. He said it was an infill site with a 100- year-old house. He showed a map of some historic plats and parks in the neighborhood. In the comprehensive plan, the area had a suburban designation. He said the request was DR-9 because the preservation of the house on the lot would limit the number of units per acre on the site, meaning it would still meet recommendations in the comprehensive plan. The comprehensive plan also called for more missing middle housing like this. Chair Karesh asked Mr. Morgan to describe the process an application went through to get City staff approval. Mr. Morgan said City staff that was familiar with the character area appraisal and the character of the surrounding area reviewed it. He said they looked at the context of the area and the overriding recommendations in the comprehensive plan. Commissioner Jacobs asked how many units were in Concord. Mr. Morgan said around 200 units. A later correction showed t here were 400 units in Concord. Mr. Wofford Stribling was the owner of STYO Development. He said they had been working on developing the lot since 2021. In 2021, they could not move forward with an SR-7 zoning. He said infill opportunities like this needed creative thinking, and this was the largest parcel left in Magnolia available for development. They did plan to preserve the home on the site. He said many builders could not sustain the price of the lot as SR-7. He said even if the land was given for free, houses would have to sell for $800,000 to break even. A DR-9 zoning would allow them to improve the cost. He said flexibility was necessary for high-quality housing projects, and DR- 9 was one step above SR-7. Commissioner Bailey read the names of citizens who submitted public comments in opposition to the application. Public Comment: In Favor: - In Opposition: Thomas Horren:  This was not a response to the desperate need for housing in Charleston; if it was, it would be affordable.  It would irreparably alter this historic community.  It would negatively impact traffic in an area with a lot of children.  The development would increase the risk of flooding.  Zoning was to protect communities, and the community did not want this.  SR-2 zoning would be welcomed. A u g u s t 1 9 , 2 0 2 6 | 3  Zoning exists to prevent economic pressure and permanent burdens on neighborhoods.  DR-9 would allow 10-foot setbacks, which many felt were not enough.  Mr. Stribling offered deed restrictions in response to concerns, which were enforced by neighboring homeowners at their own expense.  If the owner couldn ’t develop the land profitably under the SR-2 zoning, they should sell for conservation value. Constance Halligan:  Previous plans the developer submitted had a contractor assess the site for flood mitigation for a maximum of 8 units under the current zoning.  The development would negatively impact the property value of the surrounding homes.  If this w ere to be developed, it should become affordable housing.  It wouldn ’t fit into the character of the neighborhood. Anne Parks:  The developer mentioned a need for multifamily homes, but there were new neighborhoods nearby that added hundreds of new homes to the area.  Her next-door neighbor ’s house was just sold for $750,000.  The development would negatively impact neighbors ’ property values. William Hicks:  Numerous houses in the area were sold for reasonable prices recently.  There were plenty of vacant lots where houses have been torn down that could be redeveloped to address the need for more housing. Craig Nelson:  Kids are often running and playing on the street, and he worried about how traffic changes would affect that.  The neighborhood already had issues with flooding.  The City should buy the property and turn it into a community center. Will McAlister:  There was more drainage needed in the area to mitigate flooding.  He was concerned that after purchase, the developers would choose a cheaper drainage option if allowed to do so.  It would change the character of the community. Dana Handevins:  Purchased her home last year for $730,000.  She was concerned about having more than 8 houses built on the site.  The 10-foot buffer wasn ’t enough.  The flooding in the area was already terrible. Sierra Atkins:  They bought their house because the neighborhood was the perfect fit for their family. A u g u s t 1 9 , 2 0 2 6 | 4  She wasn ’t against having more people in the community but was concerned about the number of houses they would try to fit on the site.  There was a lot of foot traffic in the area.  There are other, better-fitting communities for transitional and younger family housing in the area. Stiles McGallen:  When Mr. Stribling met with neighbors and was asked to name one benefit this development would have to the community, he couldn ’t name one. Jennifer Nance:  The rezoning would allow multi-family homes, and even if Mr. Stribling didn ’t plan to do that with this development, it could happen in the future. Marshal Stort:  The current zoning allows the neighborhood's layout to remain the same.  The surrounding houses deserve private backyards.  The property values of the surrounding houses would decrease  There were protected trees on the property, and they should do an independent arborist evaluation on them. Unidentified Public Commenter:  Last year, it was rezoned to allow 9 houses; he asked why they would need to rezone it again for multi-family housing. Chair Karesh asked what the rest of the process for this application would look like if it was approved tonight. Mr. Morgan said it would have to go through the City ’s Technical Review Committee (TRC). Chair Karesh asked what TRC would analyze. Mr. Morgan said they would ensure it met the City ’s stringent stormwater standards, such as requiring properties to hold water and not let it drain to surrounding areas. TRC also evaluated possible traffic changes. Mr. Morgan anticipated that traffic wouldn ’t be an issue because an extra 10 cars in a neighborhood with hundreds wouldn ’t make much of a difference. Commissioner Hirsch asked what the difference between SR-2 and DR-9 was. Mr. Morgan said SR-2 required a 25-foot front and rear yard, while DR-9 required a 10-foot front and rear yard. DR-9 required 6-foot total setbacks, while SR-2 required 9-foot total setbacks. Commissioner Harrison asked if Accessory Dwelling Units (ADU s ) were allowed in SR-2. Mr. Morgan said yes, they were. Mr. Stribling said housing looked different than it did in 1953 when the neighborhood was built; good housing won ’t always look the same. He and the City ’s Head of Stormwater analyzed the site for years and created a comprehensive watershed plan. He said he was willing to do that again to create a successful project. Before development, he had a career as a stormwater A u g u s t 1 9 , 2 0 2 6 | 5 resource civil engineer and never had development or design problems with a project after it was built. He has been working with the community to try to address their concerns. Mr. Stribling said they submitted an arborist report to the City and there were no trees that required BZA or special exceptions to be removed. He said the development would have minimal effect on traffic in a neighborhood this large. They wanted to bring a slight increase in density to the area and do it tastefully. He had offered the City the opportunity to buy it, but staff said it would be a more complicated process. He said the development would not be detrimental to the neighborhood. Commissioner Jacobs asked if the development met stormwater standards according to TRC. Mr. Stribling said it did. She said that the City has seen new subdivisions built that didn ’t flood due to the City ’s stringent stormwater standards. Commissioner Jacobs asked what the lot coverage was. Mr. Stribling said because the parcel was next to a public right-of-way, they had limited options for design and stormwater treatment. Therefore, they had to fill more of the lot and decided to use a private system that wouldn ’t burden taxpayers. He said the system would be easier to maintain for long-term durability. He said there would likely be more rooftop coverage, but they would have to continue working with the Stormwater Department to see how much. Commissioner Lempesis asked what size the road would be. Mr. Stribling said it would mirror surrounding roads, so 22-24 feet. Commissioner Lempesis asked if it would be under a Horizontal Property Regime (HPR) or an HOA. Mr. Stribling said it would be under HPR. Commissioner Harrison asked how many of the surrounding lots could fit inside of the parcel. Mr. Stribling said around 7. Commissioner Joyce asked how many units could fit on the site if the house there was preserved and it was zoned DR-9. She said there was a risk of a new buyer coming in, demolishing the home, and building denser housing than they should. Mr. Morgan said theoretically under DR-9 they could fit 18 units on the site. However, it would be difficult to fit that many and still meet City requirements. Meeting City requirements, the lot could fit 12 units, including the house already there. Commissioner Lempesis said they were going from 7 units per acre to 9 units by changing the zoning and expressed concern about not having conditions for the zone. Mr. Morgan said State law did not allow them to put conditions on the zone. Commissioner Lempesis asked why one home had such a big parcel. Mr. Stribling said it was large so they could preserve the house and some big trees on the site. Commissioner Jacobs asked if the house would be allowed to turn into apartments under DR-9 zoning. Mr. Morgan said it would be. Commissioner Jacobs said they could look into creating some affordable housing there. A u g u s t 1 9 , 2 0 2 6 | 6 Commissioner Hirsch asked what assurance the City has that the 25-foot landscape buffers would be maintained if they changed the zoning. Mr. Morgan said if they were building multifamily homes, there would be a buffer requirement. Commissioner Ryan asked how the plan changed since it was denied last year. He said it seemed like they were proposing more density than what the map could show. Commissioner Bailey said it didn ’t seem like the current zoning and inability to improve the property was a detriment to the surrounding neighborhood. He said concerns expressed tonight, like traffic and flooding, were to be addressed in a separate process that didn ’t involve the Planning Commission. He thought the property was appropriate for the 7 houses. On a motion of Commissioner Bailey, seconded by Commissioner Ryan, the Planning Commission voted to deny the request to rezone 806 Magnolia Road to Diverse Residential (DR-9) from Single-Family Residential (SR-2). The vote was not unanimous; Commissioner Jacobs and Commissioner Lempesis opposed. Chair Karesh said the application would go before City Council to be denied or approved. ZONINGS 1. 2038 Ironstone Alley West Ashley | TMS# 3531200044| Council District 2 | Approx. 0.17 ac. Request zoning Single Family Residential (SR-2). Zoned Residential (R-4) in Charleston County. Owner: David and Nancy Heronemus 2. 1036 Teracotta Drive West Ashley | TMS# 3531200062 | Council District 2 | Approx. 0.17 ac. Request zoning Single Family Residential (SR-2). Zoned Residential (R-4) in Charleston County. Owner: Therese Marie Melton 3. 1028 Teracotta Drive West Ashley | TMS# 3531200064| Council District 2 | Approx. 0.18 ac. Request zoning Single Family Residential (SR-2). Zoned Residential (R-4) in Charleston County. Owner: Curtis and Jennifer Jackson 4. 1259 Wisteria Road West Ashley | TMS# 3511200108| Council District 7 | Approx. 0.21 ac. Request zoning Single Family Residential (SR-2). Zoned Residential (R-4) in Charleston County. Owner: Rebecca Hopkins and Joseph Redding The Planning Commissioner took Zoning Items 1-4 together. A u g u s t 1 9 , 2 0 2 6 | 7 Mr. Morgan described the parcels. On a motion of Commissioner Jacobs, seconded by Commissioner Lempesis, the Planning Commission voted unanimously to approve the Single Family Residential (SR-2) zoning requests for 2038 Ironstone Alley, 1036 Teracotta Drive, 1028 Teracotta Drive, and 1259 Wisteria Road. 5. 1704 Walpole Way Johns Island | TMS# 2791400008| Council District 3 | Approx. 0.48 ac. Request zoning Single Family Residential (SR-1). Zoned Johns Island Maybank Highway Corridor Overlay (JO-MHC-O) in Charleston County. Owner: Shateque Hacker 6. 1805 Huntington Drive West Ashley | TMS# 3520900095| Council District 9 | Approx. 0.30 ac. Request zoning Single Family Residential (SR-1). Zoned Residential (R-4) in Charleston County. Owner: Nicholas D'Allesandro 7. 1631 Means Street James Island | TMS# 4240500082| Council District 11 | Approx. 0.22 ac. Request zoning Single Family Residential (SR-1). Zoned Residential (R-4) in Charleston County. Owner: Kenneth Strange Mr. Morgan described the parcels. On a motion of Commissioner Ryan, seconded by Commissioner Jacobs, the Planning Commission voted unanimously to approve the Single Family Residential (SR-1) zoning requests for 1704 Walpole Way, 1805 Huntington Drive, and 1631 Means Street. P&P STAFF UPDATES (as needed) Commissioner Lempesis said they should discuss zoning preferences and capping the number of units allowed on a site when they discussed rezoning rebates again. There being no further business to discuss, the meeting was adjourned at 6:27 p.m. Jasmine O ’Neal Clerk of Council ’s Office A u g u s t 1 9 , 2 0 2 6 | 8 CITY OF CHARLESTON PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING REPORT AUGUST19, 2026 MINUTES 1. DEFERRED TO NEXT MEETING | Request Approval of Minutes from the July Planning CommissionMeeting REZONINGS 1. 806 MagnoliaRoad WestAshley| TMS#4180900030| CouncilDistrict9 | Approx.2.1 ac. Requestto rezonefromSingle-FamilyResidential(SR-2) to DiverseResidential(DR-9). Owner: Albert J Gobel Jr. Applicant: STYO Motion:Disapproval(6-2) 1st: Bailey 2nd: Ryan JimmyBailey Favor McKennaJoyce Favor JoeyRyan Favor CharlesKaresh Favor ErikaV. Harrison Favor SundayLempesis Oppose BartJackson Absent HarryLesesne Absent SteveHirsch Favor DonnaJacobs (alternate) Oppose ZONINGS 1. 2038IronstoneAlley WestAshley| TMS#3531200044|CouncilDistrict2 | Approx.0.17ac. RequestzoningSingleFamilyResidential(SR-2).ZonedResidential(R-4) in CharlestonCounty. Owner:DavidandNancyHeronemus 2. 1036TeracottaDrive WestAshley| TMS#3531200062| CouncilDistrict2 | Approx.0.17ac. RequestzoningSingleFamilyResidential(SR-2).ZonedResidential(R-4) in CharlestonCounty. Owner:ThereseMarieMelton 3. 1028TeracottaDrive WestAshley| TMS#3531200064|CouncilDistrict2 | Approx.0.18ac. RequestzoningSingleFamilyResidential(SR-2).ZonedResidential(R-4) in CharlestonCounty. Owner:CurtisandJenniferJackson 4. 1259WisteriaRoad WestAshley| TMS#3511200108|CouncilDistrict7 | Approx.0.21ac. RequestzoningSingleFamilyResidential(SR-2).ZonedResidential(R-4) in CharlestonCounty. Owner:RebeccaHopkinsandJosephRedding A u g u s t 1 9 , 2 0 2 6 | 9 Motion:Approval(8-0) 1st: Jacobs 2nd: Lempesis JimmyBailey Favor McKennaJoyce Favor JoeyRyan Favor CharlesKaresh Favor ErikaV. Harrison Favor SundayLempesis Favor BartJackson Absent HarryLesesne Absent SteveHirsch Favor DonnaJacobs (alternate) Favor 1. 1704WalpoleWay JohnsIsland| TMS#2791400008|CouncilDistrict3 | Approx.0.48ac. RequestzoningSingle FamilyResidential(SR-1).ZonedJohns IslandMaybankHighwayCorridor Overlay(JO-MHC-O) in Charleston County. Owner:ShatequeHacker 2. 1805HuntingtonDrive WestAshley| TMS#3520900095|CouncilDistrict9 | Approx.0.30ac. RequestzoningSingleFamilyResidential(SR-1).ZonedResidential(R-4) in CharlestonCounty. Owner:NicholasD'Allesandro 3. 1631MeansStreet JamesIsland| TMS#4240500082|CouncilDistrict11 | Approx.0.22ac. RequestzoningSingleFamilyResidential(SR-1).ZonedResidential(R-4) in CharlestonCounty. Owner:KennethStrange Motion:Approval(8-0) 1st: Ryan 2nd: Jacobs JimmyBailey Favor McKennaJoyce Favor JoeyRyan Favor CharlesKaresh Favor ErikaV. Harrison Favor SundayLempesis Favor BartJackson Absent HarryLesesne Absent SteveHirsch Favor DonnaJacobs (alternate) Favor

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.