Planning Commission Public Comments
City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Aug 19, 2026 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Charleston
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITY OF CHARLESTON
PLANNING COMMISSION
PUBLIC COMMENT
AUGUST 19, 2026
A meeting of the Planning Commission will be held on Wednesday, August 19, 2026 at 5:00 p.m.
in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street.
The following written comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of the
meeting. The comments will also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is
encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard.
Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/pc. Please check the website on the
meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items.
For additional information, please contact:
Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781
A. REZONINGS
1. 806 Magnolia Road
West Ashley | TMS# 4180900030 | Council District 9 | Approx. 2.1 ac.
Request to rezone from Single-Family Residential (SR-2) to Diverse Residential (DR-9).
Owner: Albert J Gobel Jr.
Applicant: STYO
9 Comment Submitted:
• Stiles McGowan, 28 Anita Dr
Submitted to Staff for August 19, 2026 Meeting
Neighborhood character: DR-9 zoning would permit substantially denser housing types
than what currently exists along Magnolia Road, out of step with the surrounding single-
family fabric. Traffic and infrastructure: Increased density on this site would add traffic to
local streets that were not designed for higher-volume use, and could strain existing
drainage, water, and sewer infrastructure in the area. Precedent: Approving this rezoning
could open the door to similar requests on adjacent SR-2 parcels, accelerating a
piecemeal shift away from the neighborhood’s established character. Compatibility: A
near-tripling (or greater) of allowable density on a single parcel is a significant jump that
warrants careful scrutiny of its compatibility with the existing SR-2 context, not just the
immediate parcel. I respectfully ask the Commission to deny this rezoning request and to
preserve the current SR-2 designation for this property. Thank you for your
consideration.
• Anne Satterwhite Parks, 1 Jerry Dr
Submitted to Staff for August 19, 2026 Meeting
We noticed the zoning sign on this property does not display the revised meeting
date- we believe this invalidates the meeting for not posting 30 days in advance- is
this true?
Planning Commission
Public Comment | August 19, 2026 Page 2
• Moses and Priscilla Stepter, 4 Anita drive
Submitted to Staff for August 19, 2026 Meeting
Community is over crowded with heavy traffic. We have live in this area over 35
years and to diverse this area would not be a solution , it would add to its
problem. A police sub station would be welcomed
• Jordan Bowe, 56 Anita drive
Submitted to Staff for August 19, 2026 Meeting
I am again opposed to rezoning this property to allow for multifamily housing. My
concern is not with multifamily housing in general, but with whether increased
residential density is appropriate for this particular area given the limitations of the
existing infrastructure. The neighborhood already experiences significant traffic
congestion, and adding a substantially larger number of households and vehicles could
further strain roads that were not designed to accommodate this level of use, potentially
affecting traffic flow, pedestrian safety, and emergency vehicle access. I am also
particularly concerned about flooding and stormwater management. This area already
experiences drainage and flooding issues during periods of heavy rainfall, and additional
development could increase impervious surfaces, reduce natural areas available to
absorb rainfall, and place further demands on an already stressed drainage system.
Increased density may also place additional demands on utilities and other public
infrastructure and could result in the loss of mature trees and green space that currently
assist with stormwater absorption. Before approving a rezoning that permits
substantially greater density, I believe there should be clear evidence that the existing
roadways, drainage systems, utilities, and other infrastructure can adequately support
that development without worsening conditions for current residents. For these reasons,
I respectfully ask that the property retain its current zoning.
• Jessica Patton, 1129 Barrett Rd
Submitted to Staff for August 19, 2026 Meeting
My name is Jessica Patton, and I am a resident of East Oak Forest at 1129 Barrett
Road. I respectfully request that the Planning Commission deny the rezoning request
for 806 Magnolia Road from SR-2 to DR-9. While I understand the need for
thoughtful residential growth throughout Charleston, this particular rezoning is not
appropriate for the location and is inconsistent with the character and planning
framework of the surrounding neighborhood. In addition, the City's planning
framework has long recognized this portion of West Ashley as a suburban
residential area. Residents should be able to rely on adopted plans and existing
zoning regulations when making decisions about where to live and invest.
Approving a substantial increase in density on an interior parcel would set a
precedent for future rezoning requests that could gradually erode the character of
East Oak Forest and similar neighborhoods throughout West Ashley. The property is
located within the interior of an established single-family residential neighborhood.
East Oak Forest is characterized by detached single-family homes on larger lots,
mature trees, and open green space. Many residents chose this neighborhood
specifically because of its low-density residential character. The surrounding streets,
including Barrett Road, Magnolia Road, Browning Drive, Anita Drive, Jerry Drive,
and Paula Drive, are overwhelmingly comprised of single-family homes. Rezoning
this property to DR-9 would allow a significantly greater density than what
currently exists in the surrounding area and would introduce a development pattern
that is incompatible with the established character of the neighborhood. East Oak
Forest is more than a collection of homes; it is a true community. Neighbors know
one another, look out for each other, and take pride in maintaining the character of
the neighborhood. Families walk their dogs, ride bikes, and spend time outdoors
Planning Commission
Public Comment | August 19, 2026 Page 3
together. This sense of community is one of the reasons so many residents have
chosen to remain here for years and continue investing in their homes. As Charleston
continues to grow, preserving established neighborhoods like East Oak Forest
becomes increasingly important to maintaining the quality of life that makes West
Ashley such a desirable place to live. In recent years, West Ashley has experienced
significant growth and redevelopment pressure. Residents understand that growth is
inevitable and support responsible development in appropriate locations. However,
not every parcel is suitable for increased density. Established interior
neighborhoods should not bear the burden of continual upzoning when existing
zoning already allows reasonable residential development that is compatible with
surrounding properties. Traffic safety is another significant concern. Residents
already experience ongoing safety issues along Magnolia Road, where speeding is
common and accidents occur regularly. Increasing residential density on this site will
generate additional vehicle trips and place further pressure on roads that already
present safety concerns for residents, pedestrians, cyclists, and families. Before
considering higher-density zoning, the City should carefully evaluate whether the
existing roadway network can safely accommodate the additional traffic
generated by this proposal. Finally, the property is already developable under its
current zoning. Existing SR-2 zoning provides a reasonable opportunity for
residential development while maintaining compatibility with surrounding
properties. A desire to increase development potential should not, by itself, justify a
zoning change that is inconsistent with the established character of the
neighborhood and the expectations of nearby residents. I respectfully ask the
Planning Commission to uphold the existing SR-2 zoning designation and deny the
request to rezone 806 Magnolia Road to DR-9. Thank you for your time and
consideration.
• William Hallman, 20 Anita Dr.
Submitted to Staff for August 19, 2026 Meeting
My main concern is that flooding may increase and I already have severe flooding
in my backyard. When I bought my house 31 years ago the back yard didn't flood
at all. Also there is the concern that the as the amount of space each household
enjoys around their home decreases there would be less children and more adults
and cars. I enjoy walking my dog around the neighborhood jn thr late afternoon
and seeing all of the children on bikes and young families with strollers.
• Bradley Sapper, 23 Anita dr Charleston Sc 29407
Submitted to Staff for August 19, 2026 Meeting
I strongly oppose the proposed rezoning of 806 Magnolia Rd to DR-9. This
rezoning would allow a significantly greater intensity of residential development
than is appropriate for this property and the surrounding neighborhood. Increasing
density in this location could negatively affect traffic, parking, stormwater runoff,
drainage, neighborhood character, and the overall quality of life for existing
residents. Rezoning decisions should consider the cumulative impact on the
surrounding community, not simply the development potential of one parcel. The
existing character and scale of Magnolia Road and the neighboring properties
should be respected, and any future development should be consistent with the
established neighborhood rather than introducing substantially greater density. I
respectfully ask the Planning Commission and decision-makers to deny the request
to rezone 806 Magnolia Rd to DR-9 and preserve zoning that is more compatible
with the surrounding community.
Planning Commission
Public Comment | August 19, 2026 Page 4
• William Hicks, 16 Anita Dr. Charleston, SC 29407
Submitted to Staff for August 19, 2026 Meeting
I live in the Magnolia circle neighbourhood and do not want this property re-zoned.
We currently have a cute and unique neighbourhood, and high density housing in
this 2.1 acre lot would make our area less appealing. We have houses go on the
market throughout the year and they it on the market for months. There are plenty
of options if people want to move to our area. We've had several meetings as a
neighbourhood and not a single person wants to see this property rezoned to fit as
many houses as possible. If the goal is to bring more single family houses to the
West Ashley area, then we should start by focusing on the abandoned lots alllll
around our neighbourhood. Who wins if this property is re-zoned? The people who
live around the property certainly do not win. The developer is the only winner
because he can increase his return on investment. Maybe the city council thinks it's a
win because they can say they brought more houses into West Ashley but our
neighbourhood will actively campaign against anyone who votes in favour of re-
zoning this property. Please don't approve this re-zoning because the local
community and people who will be impacted do not want to see high density
housing squeezed in this lot.
• Jennifer nance, 3 Jerry drive
Submitted to Staff for August 19, 2026 Meeting
I am one of the properties that backs up to this proposed development. Obviously, I
have a personal interest in this, as I will lose a tremendous amount of privacy once
these homes are in my backyard. That being said, I know that it is reality that the
property will likely be developed at some point. However, I feel strongly that it
stays zoned SR2 and that the developer has to work within these restrictions. The
homes in this neighborhood are almost exclusively older one story homes and we all
have lots of privacy. This is the reason I purchased my home over 10 years ago. I
feel it is not the Neighborhoods problem that developer cannot work within the
current constraints of an SR2 Zoning, and he voiced to us that she has already
dumped a lot of money into surveys, etc., and that is one of the reasons he would
hate to walk away from it. Once again, not our problem. He met with many of the
folks in our neighborhood a couple months ago and stated that he had every
intention of only building two-story homes, but this potential change in Zoning would
allow for them on anyone else to come in and put in townhomes or condos. It is
without question that the value of this property will more than double or triple if it is
rezoned, which opens the possibility for the current developer to sell to someone
else and make a large profit simply from doing that. I feel it sets a scary
precedent for the entire city once we start allowing this to happen. This is not an
Nimby issue. Allowing this “neighborhood within a Neighbourhood “ to occur is
going to change the entire fabric of our neighborhood “- Destroying privacy for
many residents, decreasing property values ,increasing traffic, trash and noise. As
our elected officials, I plead to you to vote against the rezoning of this property.
Respectfully Jennifer Nance
The comments below were submitted in June for 806 Magnolia Road prior to item
being deferred:
15 Comment Submitted:
• Ezra Zankel, 47 Anita Drive, Charleston, SC 29407
Submitted to Staff for June 17, 2026 Meeting
Planning Commission
Public Comment | August 19, 2026 Page 5
Dear Members of the Planning Commission: I am a resident of the Magnolia
neighborhood, and I write to ask that the Commission recommend denial of the
request to rezone 806 Magnolia Road from SR-2 (Single-Family Residential) to DR-
9 (Diverse Residential). My opposition is not to the property being used; it is to a
rezoning that exceeds the City’s own adopted plans, contradicts the documented
character of the neighborhood, endangers one of its few genuinely historic
resources, and rewards a hardship the applicants’ predecessors created themselves.
1. DR-9 exceeds the density the City’s own comprehensive plan prescribes for
Magnolia. The Charleston City Plan (2021) designates Magnolia’s residential
interior as “Suburban,” a future land use category with densities of four to eight
dwelling units per acre (2023 Magnolia Area Character Appraisal, p. 48). DR-9
permits nine units per acre, above the top of the City’s own range. The higher-
intensity “Neighborhood Edge” category (6 to 20 units per acre) applies to
peripheries along major roads and transit routes; 806 Magnolia Road is a
landlocked parcel in the neighborhood’s interior, reached only from a residential
street. A rezoning that exceeds the comprehensive plan’s prescribed density is not a
modest adjustment; it is a departure from the plan this Commission is charged with
upholding. 2. DR-9 is incompatible with the neighborhood’s documented character.
The Area Character Appraisal prepared for the City in 2023 quantifies what
Magnolia is: 88% of structures are one to one-and-a-half stories (p. 36); 85% are
Ranch or Minimal Traditional homes (p. 31); 94% of structures are single-family
houses with one unit per parcel (p. 38); the median residential lot is 0.24 acres (p.
56); and 86% of parcels have less than 20% lot coverage (p. 37). Against every
one of those measures, DR-9 is an outlier: multi-family buildings of three or more
units, side setbacks as narrow as three feet, and rear setbacks of ten feet, placing
structures of unprecedented bulk directly against the back fences of existing single-
story homes. The ACA exists precisely so that decisions like this one can be
“referenced and referred to in future projects” (p. 7). I ask the Commission to use it.
3. The rezoning threatens a documented historic resource and its setting. The 1924
Gobel House at 806 Magnolia Road is the only structure of its era in the
neighborhood (ACA, p. 30). The Appraisal documents it as the likely sister structure
of the 1922 King House in Ashleyville: the two houses share their five-window
façades, mirrored chimneys, porticoes, and massing, and, critically, “both structures
were situated on multi-acre lots and had gardens” (p. 39). That pairing of grand
houses on generous grounds is a documented remnant of the area’s pre-subdivision
landscape. The sale of the Paula Drive frontage has already fractured the Gobel
House’s historic setting; rezoning the remaining 2.1 acres for multi-family
construction at three-foot setbacks would extinguish it. Nothing in the rezoning
request protects the house itself: no covenant, no easement, no condition. Once the
land under and around it is entitled for nine units per acre, the economic pressure
on the house becomes one-directional. 4. The hardship is self-created. The parcel is
landlocked because prior owners sold off its Paula Drive road frontage. A
predicament of the owners’ own making is not a planning rationale, and it should
not be cured at the expense of the surrounding neighborhood. Granting upzonings
to relieve self-imposed constraints invites every similarly situated owner to
manufacture the same argument. 5. The site matters to drainage and flooding. The
ACA concludes that “creek systems dating back to the colonial era continue to
influence flooding and drainage challenges in the neighborhood” (p. 56), and
documents the ancient creek bed tied to Old Town Creek (known in the colonial era
as Linning’s Creek) along the neighborhood’s boundary (p. 54). The 2.1 acres at
806 Magnolia Road absorb stormwater today. Development at DR-9 intensity, with
the lot coverage that nine units per acre implies, would push that water into the
yards and crawlspaces of the homes around it, in a neighborhood the City’s own
Planning Commission
Public Comment | August 19, 2026 Page 6
appraisal flags for drainage challenges. 6. The applicant’s assurances are not
enforceable, and the record counsels caution. Zoning runs with the land. A stated
intention to build single-family homes is not part of a DR-9 rezoning, and unless
recorded as a binding condition it binds no one: not this applicant, and not any
future owner, who could build to the DR-9 maximum as of right. The history here
makes that more than hypothetical: the developer sought DR-6 in 2021 and was
rebuffed; committed to SR-2 with 25-foot setbacks and perimeter fencing in 2023
to win neighborhood support; and now, in 2026, requests DR-9, denser than the
original ask. The Commission should evaluate the request on what DR-9 legally
permits, not on what is presently promised. For each of these reasons, I respectfully
ask the Commission to recommend denial of the rezoning of 806 Magnolia Road
and to uphold the SR-2 zoning that matches both the City’s comprehensive plan and
the neighborhood’s documented character. Thank you for your service and your
consideration. Respectfully, Ezra Zankel Magnolia Neighborhood resident
• Patrick Evans, 14 Paula Dr Charleston 29407
Submitted to Staff for June 17, 2026 Meeting
We bought out house in August of last year with the understanding that the
property in question would not be developed. We love our house and
neighborhood and we don't want it to change. Please keep the zoning as is. Thank
you 14 Paula Dr. 29407
• Kimberly Clayton, 1150 Barrett Rd.
Submitted to Staff for June 17, 2026 Meeting
My name is Kimberly Clayton, and I am a resident of East Oak Forest at 1150
Barrett Road. I respectfully request that the Planning Commission deny the rezoning
request for 806 Magnolia Road from SR-2 to DR-9. While I understand the need
for thoughtful residential growth throughout Charleston, this particular rezoning is
not appropriate for the location and is inconsistent with the character and planning
framework of the surrounding neighborhood. In addition, the City's planning
framework has long recognized this portion of West Ashley as a suburban
residential area. Residents should be able to rely on adopted plans and existing
zoning regulations when making decisions about where to live and invest.
Approving a substantial increase in density on an interior parcel would set a
precedent for future rezoning requests that could gradually erode the character of
East Oak Forest and similar neighborhoods throughout West Ashley. The property is
located within the interior of an established single-family residential neighborhood.
East Oak Forest is characterized by detached single-family homes on larger lots,
mature trees, and open green space. Many residents chose this neighborhood
specifically because of its low-density residential character. The surrounding streets,
including Barrett Road, Magnolia Road, Browning Drive, Anita Drive, Jerry Drive,
and Paula Drive, are overwhelmingly comprised of single-family homes. Rezoning
this property to DR-9 would allow a significantly greater density than what
currently exists in the surrounding area and would introduce a development pattern
that is incompatible with the established character of the neighborhood. East Oak
Forest is more than a collection of homes; it is a true community. Neighbors know
one another, look out for each other, and take pride in maintaining the character of
the neighborhood. Families walk their dogs, ride bikes, and spend time outdoors
together. This sense of community is one of the reasons so many residents have
chosen to remain here for years and continue investing in their homes. As Charleston
continues to grow, preserving established neighborhoods like East Oak Forest
becomes increasingly important to maintaining the quality of life that makes West
Planning Commission
Public Comment | August 19, 2026 Page 7
Ashley such a desirable place to live. In recent years, West Ashley has experienced
significant growth and redevelopment pressure. Residents understand that growth is
inevitable and support responsible development in appropriate locations. However,
not every parcel is suitable for increased density. Established interior
neighborhoods should not bear the burden of continual upzoning when existing
zoning already allows reasonable residential development that is compatible with
surrounding properties. Traffic safety is another significant concern. Residents
already experience ongoing safety issues along Magnolia Road, where speeding is
common and accidents occur regularly. Increasing residential density on this site will
generate additional vehicle trips and place further pressure on roads that already
present safety concerns for residents, pedestrians, cyclists, and families. Before
considering higher-density zoning, the City should carefully evaluate whether the
existing roadway network can safely accommodate the additional traffic
generated by this proposal. Finally, the property is already developable under its
current zoning. Existing SR-2 zoning provides a reasonable opportunity for
residential development while maintaining compatibility with surrounding
properties. A desire to increase development potential should not, by itself, justify a
zoning change that is inconsistent with the established character of the
neighborhood and the expectations of nearby residents. I respectfully ask the
Planning Commission to uphold the existing SR-2 zoning designation and deny the
request to rezone 806 Magnolia Road to DR-9. Thank you for your time and
consideration.
• Sea Ken, 1146 Symmes Dr
Submitted to Staff for June 17, 2026 Meeting
This is the solution to the housing crisis! The perfect missing middle, an absolute
golden opportunity to give middle class people a chance to live in a beautiful area.
• Ryan McElhinney, 12 Anita Drive Charleston, SC 29407
Submitted to Staff for June 17, 2026 Meeting
I am a resident/homeowner/property owner in the Magnolia Road area and live
within walking distance from the 806 Magnolia Road property. I am writing to
respectfully ask that the City deny the request to rezone 806 Magnolia Road from
SR-2 to DR-9 (up to 18 living units). My concern is whether this particular rezoning is
appropriate for this specific location. First, the proposed DR-9 designation would
allow a significantly higher residential intensity than what currently exists in the
long-standing surrounding neighborhood. The Magnolia Road neighborhood is
characterized by single-family homes, and the requested zoning would permit
housing types and densities that are not consistent with the established development
pattern of the area. Second, I am concerned about the impact on local
infrastructure. Magnolia Road already experiences traffic congestion as it is a
connector between Hwy 61 and Savannah Hwy. Additional residential density
would increase traffic volumes, traffic noise, turning movements, and safety concerns
for residents, pedestrians, and cyclists. Third, drainage and stormwater
management are critical issues in Charleston. Additional development intensity can
increase impervious surface coverage and place additional demands on stormwater
systems. Given the area's history of flooding concerns, these impacts should be
carefully evaluated before approving a higher-density zoning classification. Finally,
I ask the Commission to consider whether this rezoning is consistent with the City's
adopted planning goals and future land-use policies for the Magnolia Road area.
Zoning decisions should be predictable, transparent, and aligned with the long-term
vision established through the comprehensive planning process, which primarily
should be the same as what the residents want. For these reasons, I respectfully
Planning Commission
Public Comment | August 19, 2026 Page 8
request a denial of the rezoning request for 806 Magnolia Road and request that
it be kept as Single Family Residence, as is all the others in the area.
• Christopher Grimalda, 1103 Byron Rd
Submitted to Staff for June 17, 2026 Meeting
Firstly the proposed DR-9 designation would drastically change the residential
area, and the current infrastructure cannot support. This is a residential
neighborhood, and all though there is a condo development up the road, 18 units, is
too much is absolutely inappropriate for this area. I have very much opposed to
this rezoning request.
• Bob Marshall, 4 Carriage Lane, Charleston, SC 29407
Submitted to Staff for June 17, 2026 Meeting
The rezoning for DR-9 is way out of consistency for the well-established
neighborhood of many years. I noticed that the applicant is SYTO, and not the
owner (Albert Goble). It appears that SYTO is a business that does nothing but
development and construction. So the property owner does not need DR-9 zoning,
the real estate developer SYTO does, in order to cram as many units as possible on
the property in order to maximize financial gain. This is pure corporate greed that
does not take the residents of the neighborhood into consideration at all. This is
100% the wrong reason to rezone. Therefore I respectfully ask that the City deny
the request to rezone 806 Magnolia Road from SR-2 to DR-9.
• Monica Berenguer, 826 Magnolia Rd
Submitted to Staff for June 17, 2026 Meeting
I live at 826 Magnolia Rd and am vehemently against this application. Magnolia
Rd is quickly becoming the new St Andrews Blvd thanks to a recent approval to
allow a church to be rezoned into a commercial/retail business. Cramming multiple
units onto what is a single family home lot will only detract from this historic
community's neighborhood feel and add to the already stressed traffic conditions
on Magnolia Rd. My husband has been working with traffic officers to address the
epidemic of speeding down Magnolia Rd. They have been conducting traffic
studies and the number of citations is alarming. Magnolia Rd is a neighborhood.
Please do not allow it to become an overpopulated thoroughfare. The residents
here deserve better. Thank you for your time in reviewing this message.
• Doug Berenguer, 826 Magnolia Rd
Submitted to Staff for June 17, 2026 Meeting
My wife and I have lived in our home here on Magnolia Rd for 6 years. As we walk
these neighborhood streets, recreationally and daily with our dogs, we have
become alarmed not only by the increase in traffic, but the high speeds of the
commuters traveling down Magnolia Rd, Sycamore, Apollo and other cross streets.
I've begun a campaign with The Charleston Police Dept. & Team 4 - West Ashley
Traffic - to increase speed checks along our neighborhood corridor. The resulting
citations issued in a short period of time puts Magnolia Rd in a critical level of the
excessive speed zones; so much so that a traffic study has begun with trailer speed
check units placed on Magnolia Rd to complete a formal collection of traffic data. I
have the attention and support of Sgt. Fab of the Charleston Police Dept. who,
along with Charleston Team 4 Traffic, are conducting this study. I will be happy to
submit these results to Planning Commission, City Council and SCDOT once the study
and my FOIA request are completed. It should be noted that we (including but not
limited to the residents of the neighborhoods of Avondale, Magnolia, East Oak
Forest, Maryville/Ashleyville) fought very hard to stop the rezoning of the church at
Planning Commission
Public Comment | August 19, 2026 Page 9
Armstrong & Magnolia. This rezoning request was unanimously rejected by
Charleston Planning Commission but surprisingly approved by Charleston City
Council. This alone will increase traffic and create a quality of life disturbance on
an already overloaded neighborhood road (Magnolia Rd.) It also sets precedent
for the addition of commercial property in a neighborhood that is nearly solely
residential. High density and/or multi family property will further destroy the
already critical status of this historic neighborhood. We walk there roads daily.
There is a healthy number of fellow walkers who, along with joggers, bikers,
families with children and/or pets and many elderly residents, must cross the roads
to reach the sidewalks. We've witnessed cars aggressively pass stopped school
buses unloading neighborhood children, cars passing the respectful drivers traveling
the speed limit, drivers creating near-misses with residents using the West Ashely
Bikeway attempting to cross it at Magnolia Rd, drivers running the stop light at
Magnolia and Sycamore and other upsetting vehicular offenses. This 2-lane
neighborhood road was not designed to handle the overload of traffic it is already
experiencing. To purposely add more to this problem is a recipe for disaster for this
community. We respectfully ask that Planning Commission honor the request of the
residents in the neighborhoods along Magnolia Rd and reject this quite outrageous
rezoning request.
• Deborah Sigwald, 1166 Folly Road, Charleston, SC 29412
Submitted to Staff for June 17, 2026 Meeting
I am writing to respectfully ask that the City deny the request to rezone 806
Magnolia Road from SR-2 to DR-9 My concern is this particular rezoning is not
appropriate for this specific location. 1) It appears that the request for expanded
over-development by the Applicant (SYTO) is just for the financial gain of
development, as this is SYTO's business model. 2) The proposed DR-9 designation
would allow a significantly higher residential intensity than what currently exists in
the long-standing surrounding neighborhood. The Magnolia Road neighborhood is
characterized by single-family homes, and the requested zoning would permit
housing types and densities that are not consistent with the established development
pattern of the area. 3) Magnolia Road already experiences traffic congestion as it
is a connector between Hwy 61 and Savannah Hwy. Additional residential density
would increase traffic volumes, and safety concerns for residents, pedestrians,
joggers, and cyclists. 4) Additional development intensity can increase
impenetrable surface coverage and place additional demands on stormwater
systems. Given the area's history of flooding concerns, the DR-9 zoning should make
stormwater drainage worse. 5) I ask the Commission to consider whether this
rezoning is consistent with the City's planning goals and future policies for the
Magnolia neighborhood. Is the City planning to push this area to ultra high dense
Apartment complexes? Zoning decisions should be based on what the residents
want. For these reasons, I respectfully request a denial of the rezoning request for
806 Magnolia Roadand request that it be kept as Single Family Residence, as is all
the others in the area
• Elizabeth Mester, 43 Anita Drive
Submitted to Staff for June 17, 2026 Meeting
As a ten-year resident of the Magnolia neighborhood and owner of 43 Anita Drive,
I oppose the proposed rezoning of 806 Magnolia Road from SR-2 to DR-9. We
must protect our single-family neighborhood — its peace, its character, and the
community we have built together. The scale of this rezoning is alarming. DR-9
density would introduce a level of development wholly incompatible with the
surrounding streets. More units mean more cars, and Magnolia Road is already a
Planning Commission
Public Comment | August 19, 2026 Page 10
narrow, congested corridor with limited parking. Residents and visitors struggle
today; adding dozens of additional households would make that strain
unmanageable and create genuine safety hazards for the children, walkers, and
cyclists who use these streets daily. The old-growth trees on and around this
property are not backdrop — they are habitat. Owls, eagles, and hawks nest and
hunt in the mature canopy that has taken decades to establish. These are not
common urban visitors; they are indicators of a functioning ecosystem that exists
here precisely because of the green space this neighborhood has preserved. Dense
development would clear that canopy entirely, displacing these birds and
permanently eliminating habitat that cannot simply be replanted or replaced.
Flooding is perhaps my most urgent concern. Our neighborhood does not wait for a
major storm to flood — a standard thunderstorm is enough. The drainage ditch at
the corners of Anita and Jerry Streets is already overwhelmed in ordinary rain
events, sending water into the streets on both corners. This is not a worst-case
scenario; it is a routine one. Replacing permeable soil and tree root systems with
impervious surfaces — parking lots, foundations, hardscape — will dramatically
accelerate runoff into an already-failing drainage system. Before any rezoning of
this scale is approved, the city must commission an independent stormwater and
drainage impact study specific to this parcel and the surrounding watershed. The
character of Magnolia is not an abstract sentiment — it is a real and measurable
asset. Tree canopy, green space, setbacks, and the human scale of single-family
homes define why people choose to live here and invest here. DR-9 development
replaces all of that with mass and concrete. Once gone, it cannot be restored. I
urge the board to deny this rezoning application and to work with residents on any
future plans for this property that are proportionate to the neighborhood's existing
fabric. I stand with my long-time neighbors on Anita Drive and Paula Drive in this
opposition — together we represent the families, homes, and community that make
Magnolia worth protecting. The Magnolia community deserves to be heard — and
protected.
• Alex Hanger, 721 Longfellow Road
Submitted to Staff for June 17, 2026 Meeting
I am a resident of East Oak Forest and am writing to formally oppose the request
to rezone 806 Magnolia Road from Single-Family Residential (SR-2) to Diverse
Residential (DR-9). This request is inconsistent with the character of the surrounding
neighborhood. The 806 Magnolia Rd parcel is surrounded by established single-
family homes. DR-9 would permit up to approximately 18-19 dwelling units on this
2.1-acre parcel -- a density completely out of scale with anything adjacent to it.
Approving this request would be spot zoning in the most direct sense: a single
parcel being upzoned to a density level unsupported by anything around it, with no
transition, no planning rationale, and no community input that shaped this request.
The applicant previously pursued single-family development on this same property.
City records show that as recently as 2025, this parcel was under Technical Review
for a 7-lot single-family preliminary plat. There was no change in surrounding
conditions between that application and this one. The only thing that changed is the
density being requested. This is a profit-maximization decision, not a planning one.
The infrastructure on Magnolia Road is not designed for this density. Magnolia
Road is a two-lane residential street. Adding up to 18+ units on a single parcel
significantly increases traffic volume, parking demand, and stormwater runoff on a
corridor not sized or configured for it. The City should require a traffic impact
analysis before any rezoning of this scale is approved. DR-9 is inconsistent with the
Plan West Ashley framework. Plan West Ashley, adopted by the City and County,
identifies established single-family neighborhoods as areas to protect rather than
Planning Commission
Public Comment | August 19, 2026 Page 11
upzone. Approving a DR-9 designation on a parcel in a single-family neighborhood
sets a precedent that puts every similar parcel in West Ashley at risk of the same
request. I ask the Planning Commission to recommend denial of this rezoning. If the
applicant wishes to develop this land, the previously proposed 7-lot single-family
subdivision represents an appropriate and compatible use. DR-9 does not.
• Heather Champagne, 14 Tovey Rd Charleston SC
Submitted to Staff for June 17, 2026 Meeting
Failure once again to abide by easement statutes already in place. Would like to
see protection of historic home. Single family homes only on this area
• Sarah Clere, 29 Anita Drive, Charleston, SC 29407
Submitted to Staff for June 17, 2026 Meeting
I am a homeowner in the Magnolia neighborhood writing to express my opposition
to the proposed zoning changes to the 806 Magnolia Road lot. Changing a
neighborhood’s existing zoning law to benefit a developer sets a terrible
precedent. I believe in responsible housing density and well-managed infill, but this
is not a coherent project meant to increase the availability of housing stock in
Charleston and help individuals and families access affordable housing. It is, rather,
an exception meant to benefit one entity at the expense of the entire
neighborhood. I am obviously concerned with the architectural and historical
character of my neighborhood, and flooding is an omnipresent worry. The potential
loss of the Gobel House, an important piece of the history of Maryville and West
Ashley, also saddens me; however, to me as a parent the most pressing issue with
this proposed zoning change is traffic management. The residential streets in the
Magnolia neighborhood lack sidewalks, and drainage ditches make it difficult to
stay a safe distance from the road. Increasing the density in this one small,
awkwardly placed lot will create a stream of vehicular traffic that makes the
neighborhood unsafe for the many children who live and play here. Furthermore,
Magnolia Road itself is the location of bus stops for schools ranging from St.
Andrews Elementary to West Ashley High. Students must cross Magnolia Road when
they get on or off the bus. A concentrated stream of traffic from one point in the
Magnolia neighborhood puts children from all neighborhoods along Magnolia Road
at risk, morning and afternoon. It is unacceptable to put children at risk for real
estate profit. Thank you for considering my thoughts on this issue.
• Thomas Horan, 29 Anita Drive
Submitted to Staff for June 17, 2026 Meeting
A zoning change should not be made for the exclusive benefit of one property
owner at the expense of an entire subdivision. The proposed change would increase
the risk of flooding in Magnolia, put children at risk by increasing traffic,
inconvenience residents throughout the subdivision by increasing commute times,
decrease the value of properties adjacent to 806 Magnolia Rd, and destroy a
historic structure. If this same variance were proposed in the Crescent, Old
Windermere, Byrnes Downes, Avondale, or anywhere downtown, it would be
rejected outright. I think Mayor Cogswell's position on this issue will demonstrate
whether he supports his less affluent constituents, or whether he is merely concerned
with the pecuniary interests of the wealthy. The people of Magnolia, West Ashely,
and the whole of Charleston deserve better. Extant regulations should be upheld!
Ezra Zankel
47 Anita Drive, Charleston, SC 29407
ezankel@gmail.com | (732) 977-5642
August 17, 2026
City of Charleston Planning Commission
2 George Street, Charleston, SC 29401
Re: Agenda Item C.1, August 19, 2026 – Rezoning of 806 Magnolia Road
(TMS# 4180900030) from SR-2 to DR-9 – OPPOSITION
Dear Members of the Planning Commission:
I live at 47 Anita Drive. My property backs directly onto 806 Magnolia Road;
whatever is built there will stand against my back fence, and under DR-9 it could
stand ten feet from it. Few people in this city are more directly affected by this
request than my household and my immediate neighbors. I am unable to attend the
August 19 hearing in person, so I submit this written comment and ask that it be
entered into the record. I renew my June 16, 2026 letter of opposition in full and
again ask the Commission to recommend denial. Since the deferral, I have spoken
with the city planner assigned to this application, and the neighborhood has met
with the developer, Wofford Stribling. What we learned confirms the case against
DR-9. I want to be clear at the outset: I am not opposed to this property being
developed. Homes built under SR-2, the zoning that governs every surrounding
parcel, would be welcome neighbors. What I oppose is the rezoning, because it
shifts the developer’s burden onto the residents next door and removes every
protection we have.
1. The City’s own planner concedes the request does not fit the plan.
Christopher Morgan told me this rezoning is “basically in line with what the
comprehensive plan states” and that “1 to 9 units per acre is in line with suburban
zoning.” The City Plan defines Suburban as 4 to 8 units per acre. Nine is not eight,
and “basically in line” is an admission that it is not in line. Mr. Morgan also told me
staff sometimes “have to encourage a zoning district that on the surface seems that
it won’t be the most perfect” because the code has “older zoning standards... not
great for encouraging infill.” If the zoning code needs modernizing, the remedy is a
code amendment debated citywide, not handing one interior parcel an entitlement
the plan does not allow. Staff’s assurance that “we don’t think that we’ll end up
with more than what the comprehensive plan says” is not enforceable. DR-9 is. The
Commission’s vote approves what DR-9 permits, not what staff predicts.
2. Every stated reason for this rezoning is financial.
Mr. Morgan confirmed the developer “couldn’t make them work financially” under
SR-2, and Mr. Stribling has told neighbors the same. That is the entire case:
regulation and profit. Zoning exists precisely to prevent economic pressure on a
single owner from being converted into permanent burdens on a neighborhood. If
financial infeasibility justified upzoning, every parcel in Charleston would be one
hard-luck story away from rezoning. It is not the job of existing residents to absorb
a developer’s costs, and it is not the Commission’s job to underwrite a land deal.
3. There are no enforceable protections on offer, and the proposed
substitute shifts the burden onto us.
The City has stated it will not attach conditions to a rezoning. That means approval
is not “a few single-family homes”; it is the full DR-9 envelope, permanently, for
any future owner: multi-family buildings of three or more units, 3-foot side
setbacks, 10-foot rear setbacks. Mr. Morgan confirmed no development plans have
been submitted; his understanding that the developer is “talking about doing
single family units” rests on nothing in the record.
The neighborhood engaged with Mr. Stribling in good faith. Because the City will
not entertain conditions, the only protection he could offer was potential deed
restrictions. Deed restrictions are enforced by neighboring homeowners, at their
own expense, through private litigation, and in practice would force us to form an
HOA just to afford enforcement. Even a cooperative process produced nothing the
City can enforce. That transfers the cost of policing this development from the City
onto the residents the current zoning already protects.
An upzoning is also a transfer of value. The day DR-9 is approved, this parcel is
worth more with nothing built on it, and STYO is free to sell the entitlement at a
profit. Every assurance Mr. Stribling has made, however sincerely, ends at the
closing table: a future owner buys the zoning, not the promises. SR-2 is the only
protection that survives a sale. We have it. We ask to keep it.
4. In the developer’s own words, this is “the last plot of land of this size in
the area that hasn’t been developed.”
That is an argument for care, not for maximum density. A 2.1-acre interior parcel
on the bed of historic Linning’s Creek, holding the neighborhood’s only 1924-era
house, in a basin the City’s own appraisal flags as flood-vulnerable, is exactly the
kind of land the City should be working to preserve. Real alternatives exist:
development under existing SR-2, with any needed relief handled case by case
through the Board of Zoning Appeals; a conservation easement in partnership with
a land trust; acquisition through the Charleston County Greenbelt program; or
purchase for a neighborhood park and stormwater green space, serving both flood
mitigation and a part of West Ashley short on public green space. If the owner
cannot develop profitably under lawful zoning, selling for conservation value is a
legitimate exit. Rezoning is not the only door out.
5. The June record still stands, and the request fails the Commission’s own
criteria.
Nothing material has changed since June except the level of opposition. DR-9
remains spot zoning, with no comparable district anywhere near this parcel. It
remains incompatible with a neighborhood the City’s 2023 Area Character
Appraisal documents as 94% single-family. The application still contains no
protection for the 1924 Gobel House. The hardship remains self-created. The
flooding concerns remain unanswered, and so do traffic concerns: because the
parcel is landlocked, every trip generated by up to nine units per acre on 2.1 acres
would funnel through the same narrow interior residential streets, and no traffic
analysis of any kind is in the record. Under Section 54-944, the Commission
reviews a rezoning for its effect on the character of the district and neighborhood
and its relationship to the overall zoning program and future land use plans. This
request fails each of those tests, by staff’s own numbers. The petition opposing this
rezoning now has 253 verified signatures, up from 114 in June, with signers
identifying their streets so the City can see that Magnolia neighbors are speaking.
For these reasons I ask the Commission to find the request inconsistent with the
comprehensive plan and recommend denial. If the Commission is not prepared to
deny, I ask that it defer pending (1) a written staff analysis explaining how nine
units per acre is consistent with a plan that caps Suburban at eight; and (2)
submission of actual development plans, so the Commission and the public can
evaluate what is proposed rather than what is predicted.
Thank you for your service and your consideration.
Respectfully,
Ezra Zankel
47 Anita Drive, Magnolia Neighborhood (abutting property owner)
(732) 977-5642 | ezankel@gmail.com
Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.