RecordWell Data

_08172026-11137

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Aug 17, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Committee on Real Estate August 17, 2026 A meeting of the Committee on Real Estate was held on this date at 3:0 4 p.m. via Zoom . Notice of this meeting was sent to all local news media. PRESENT Committee M embers : Councilmember William Tinkler (Chair), Councilmember Ross Appel (Vice-Chair), Councilmember Waring, Councilmember Polkey, Councilmember Keith Waring, and Mayor William Cogswell C ity Staff and Others : Malena Dinwoodie, Grace Riley, Jeff Vinzani, Julia Copeland, Mollie Conner, Robert Summerfield, Tracy Doran, Melissa Cruthirds, Magalie Creech, Amy Wharton, Christopher Morgan, Hampton Logan, Liz Dieck, Philip Clapper, and Donna Constance Chair Tinkler called the meeting to order. Invocation The meeting was opened with a moment of silence led by Councilmember Tinkler Approval of Minutes On a motion by Councilmember Waring , seconded by Councilmember Gregg , the Committee voted unanimously to approve the July 1 3 , 2026 , Real Estate meeting minutes. a. Authorization for the Mayor, on behalf of the City of Charleston, to accept the donation of fourteen properties located in the City and County of Charleston, located off of Lockwood Drive, and identified as County TMS Nos. 457-06-04-002 through -015. (Lockwood Drive, TMS#s 457-06-04-002, -003, -004, -005, -006, -007, -008, -009, - 010, -011, -012, -013, - 014, and -015). The property is owned by Stuart C. Dawson, Jr. Ms. Dinwoodie said Stuart C. Dawson donated the 14 marsh grid properties . One of those properties was owned by the City. These were located off the west side of Lockwood Drive. The City would use these properties in conjunction with the New Wall Project. The property was appraised at $20,000, but the family agreed to donate it to the City. Councilmember Tinkler asked if the property was not developable. Ms. Dinwoodie said that was correct. Councilmember Waring said they should thank the family for the donation because people would dispute it and try to get money, but donated the property, which would help the project move forward. On a motion by Councilmember Waring, seconded by Mayor Cogswell, the Committee voted unanimously to approve Item A. 2 b. Authorization for Mayor to execute on behalf of the City an electrical easement, approved as to form by the Office of Corporation Counsel, to Dominion Energy South Carolina, Inc., encumbering a portion of the City ’s real property designated as Charleston County TMS No. 343-00-00-003, shown on reference drawings D-085760- 01 and 085844-01, to permit installation of electric service upgrades near and around the Municipal Golf Course. (Municipal Golf Course, TMS# 343-00-00-003). The property is owned by the City of Charleston. [Ordinance] Ms. Copeland said this was for the undergrounding project for the Municipal Golf Course. On a motion by Councilmember Waring, seconded by Mayor Cogswell, the Committee voted unanimously to approve Item B. c. Authorization for the Mayor to execute on behalf of the City of Charleston a lease agreement between Landmarks for Families, Inc. f/k/a Charleston Orphan House, Inc. and Charleston Bilingual Academy, noting its consent to the lease. (5055 Lackawana Blvd., TMS #471-10- 00-001). The property is owned by Charleston Orphan House, Inc. d. Authorizing Mayor to execute on behalf of the City of Charleston an amended deed conveying approximately 16.4 acres on Lackawana Boulevard in the City of North Charleston, South Carolina, to Landmarks for Families, Inc. f/k/a Charleston Orphan House, Inc. (5055 Lackawana Blvd., TMS #471-10-00-001). The property is owned by Charleston Orphan House, Inc. [Ordinance] Ms. Copeland said the Charleston Orphan House, that was donated by the City via a deed with a reverter to a group called Landmarks for Families. The reverter remains in effect as long as the property is used as a site for a residential children ’s treatment center operated by a nonprofit. They were looking to partner with the Charleston Bilingual Academy through a three-year lease and asked whether the City could consent to this, as it falls under the language of the reverter . Councilmember Tinkler asked whether Item D was related to this as well. Ms. Copeland said it was. In 1987, when the City was deeded the property, the deed included the reverter language. The group asked whether they could modify it to allow more flexibility in their use, as the property was intended to serve as a foster home for children. They created wraparound services, including the bilingual academy. They asked the City to amend the deed to change the reverter language to “For so long as the said property is used by a nonprofit corporation for the purpose of serving children and/or families impacted by the Child Welfare System. ” Councilmember Tinkler asked if this was in North Charleston. Ms. Copeland said it was. On a motion by Councilmember Waring, seconded by Mayor Cogswell, the Committee voted unanimously to approve Items C and D together. e. Authorization for Mayor, on behalf of the City, to enter into a First Amendment to Option Agreement with America Street Ventures, LLC ( “ ASV ” ) related to ASV ’s option to purchase those City owned properties known as 76 Aiken Street, 119 America Street, and 121 America Street for a mixed-use development to include up to 52 units of affordable/workforce housing. (76 Aiken, 119 America, 121 America, TMS #s 459-05- 04- 001; -002; -048). The property is owned by the City of Charleston. [Ordinance ] Ms. Dinwoodie said they prepared two versions of the first amendment to the agreement. They had a call with the Humanities Foundation, which had expressed potential additional revisions. 3 Mayor Cogswell said this property was in the Old Cooper River Bridge corridor. The Humanities Foundation had done extensive work in that area. They were undertaking a project on land they had purchased from the City, which was contiguous to this property. They asked whether they could purchase additional property from the City that was not encumbered or had a plan for it. They agreed to enter into a contract because there was urgency to get it under contract so they could submit it for the state low-income housing tax credits. Since the City did not have an appraisal, they said they would sell it to them for $1 million or the appraised value so they could get the tax credits, along with a million dollars in ARPA funding from the county to go toward the acquisition. An appraisal was completed, and it was higher than the contracted price. They asked whether the City would forego the $400,000 that they would receive for the value of the property. The county was not comfortable funding the $1 million if the City was putting in any money, because the developer could not bridge the $400,000. The idea was to deliver 85 units, permanently or deed-restricted . Ms. Dinwoodie said this was for 52 units across the City ’s property and their property as part of this project. Mayor Cogswell asked, of the 52, how many were on the City ’s parcel versus theirs. Ms. Dinwoodie said the site plan showed that the City owned three properties and that the City owned one parcel, and that the Poin sette Apartment Project was on the other side of those parcels, which was a separate project. Mayor Cogswell said what they were getting for the $400,000 was about 25 affordable units. Councilmember Waring asked what the period of affordability was. Ms. Dinwoodie said 30 years. Councilmember Waring said they wanted to move beyond the 30 years and have 50 years of affordability. Ms. Dinwoodie said this was for a period of 30 years from the date of issuance of the certificate of occupancy. Ms. Doran said there were restrictions on Poinsette. They appreciated the support and TIF funding to help close this and hoped to start construction on the 88 units. The small lot on the site plan behind South Carolina State had the same restrictions for 30 years; 75% of the units at 80% AMI below 25% went up to 120. Their option matched the lots they wanted to purchase from the City. They did not receive their tax credits because they realized they needed to do more to increase their point score. The plan was to go back in March to use the Brownville tax credits, leveraging dollars from the county and the City to increase their score and secure project-based vouchers to strengthen their application. Mayor Cogswell asked whether increasing the term from 30 to 50 years would help increase their score. Ms. Doran said no . She asked if they could get more than the units that were in the site plan. Mayor Cogswell said no; 30 years restricted versus 50 years restricted. Ms. Doran said that would not increase the score. What helped the score was if the City donated land that it owned. They would have to give it back to the City and then have the City donate it. This was a convoluted process that some developers were using. But if it was donated and there was a zero-land cost, it would help the score. But it will not help them in this one if they land-leased those lots, because there was already a value on the lot they purchased from the City. Mayor Cogswell asked how much they paid the City for that property. 4 Ms. Doran said this was a swap because they purchased one of the lots; they were buying back from the City and had the option on the other. Everything had been appraised by the City, and they paid the difference at that time for the Pointset parcel. The lot behind South Carolina State was $1.385 million. There was a carrying cost, so what was left on the small lot was $486,000 in a loan with the CLIMB fund, which was prorated . They put the rest of that on the Pointset, which would be paid back to the CLIMB fund at closing. Mayor Cogswell asked whether they did not receive the tax credits, so the urgency was to allow the county to spend its ARPA funds. Ms. Doran said yes. They would need to determine whether they could proceed as a workforce housing development, with the City bringing in equity and using other conventional property. The restrictions would be the same: 75% to 80. Mayor Cogswell said there were three parcels that they would sell at a discount because that was the ask. They wanted to promote affordable housing, but they had to be judicious with taxpayers' money. There was urgency because they had $1 million that could go toward land, and they did not need all three parcels. They could reduce the business plan and use the county funds. The City could maintain the other two parcels or sell them as single-family with permanent deed restrictions in fee simple. Ms. Doran said they could not do anything unless they had 40 units. If they could not accommodate 40 units because that was the minimum for tax credits, they would be zoned five stories for that property, and the stormwater drainage would be a major lift there. They were not sure whether that would be the best use for those lots for single-family homes next to them. It would also eliminate their access to America Street. Mayor Cogswell said they were not trying to overcomplicate it. Ms. Doran said they would not have to close immediately, but there was an urgency to use the $1 million from the county. They understood that if the City ’s appraisal was $1.6 million without the extra affordability, they would have more affordable units. Mayor Cogswell said the appraisal was $1.6 million as is, with no affordability restrictions. If affordability restrictions were added, the appraisal dropped to $1.4 million. He asked whether they were asking the City to sell it for no more than $1 million. Ms. Dinwoodie said that was correct. It was appraised two different ways because they completed the rezoning to match their zoning with the additional mixed-use and a five-story height. It was appraised with zero affordable units, then with 52 units on it, with restrictions in place. It was done this way because the ordinance or code itself did not require a specific number of residential units to be built. Ms. Doran said that the 52 units included their lot. Councilmember Polkey said he appreciated the Mayor ’s approach to ensuring they were maximizing value for the taxpayer, as well as Councilmember Waring ’s mention of the limitations of the time frame for affordability. With respect to the appraisal and the option they agreed to earlier, he asked for more information about the expectations that informed the initial land trade and the $1 million. Because the Humanities Foundation ’s expectations changed as this was being pieced together, he thought it would be helpful to put that history on the table. Ms. Doran said that when they did the trade with the City, they purchased one and had the other two under option, which appraised for $425,000 each at that time. They said they would purchase those back and combine them with their lot so they could have a viable tax credit development there. They rezoned their lot to add one more story, and the City rezoned their lot, which increased the value. 5 Councilmember Polkey said he considered the tracks' relationship to the Poinsette Development, as well as their proximity to the Archer Project, which was regarded as a well-executed effort on behalf of the Humanities Foundation. The tracks were also near the James Lewis Apartments and the Grace Homes affordable housing corridor, which was in the final phases of completion for that area. He asked because this project was part of a series of projects that had high expectations and a certain understanding over a significant period of time , and at some point, dramatic adjustments could undermine the whole effort. Councilmember Waring said that when the property was returned from the federal highway, they wanted to create affordability. Grace Homes was built first , and that property was given to the housing authority and made permanent. The James Lewis was a 60-year affordability program, and the land was reverted to the City. James Lewis had 63 units, Grace Homes had 55 units, and he supported Project 3500. He did not know about Project 3500, which had an affordability period of 30 years , and about the population forecast predicting that in 25 years they would have many more people on the peninsula than they have today. That meant affordability 30 years from now would be at a premium with an increased population . When they gave up land permanently through a sale, the ability to extend affordability would be lost at the end of the 30 years. He understood they wanted to take advantage of the money from the county or the subdividing part that was adjacent to them, and keeping the other two lots had some potential legs to it. He thought they needed more time to work it out. If they looked at the property that had been parceled out, which took a lot of allies to come together to make this happen, with Humanities being one. He hoped their goal, objective, and efforts would be for a lot of affordability for more than 30 years. Ms. Doran said they discussed this when they did the Poinsette and the whole trade to begin with to make council happy at that time had a right of first refusal , which meant that if they decided to sell , if they had an offer, the City could buy it for 10% below that market value. Mayor Cogswell said there was a flaw in the appraisal in the valuation. They asked the appraiser to appraise it assuming 52 units, which was not just on their parcels where the appraisal was based , but on the City ’s parcels plus their parcel. If they valued the City ’s parcel, then arguably the number might come down a bit, but the valuation would be at $1 million. They had reservations about a 30-year time limit, and if they were going to commit to a longer term, they needed to commit. T here was an urgency with the county to decide in the next several weeks whether they would use this for ARPA funding or not. He suggested that they move forward with a motion with the purchase price of $1 million, with contingencies that it be twofold. One that at least 50 units would be built on the combined properties and that the affordability period be extended from 30 years to 50 years. Chair Tinkler asked if they suggested that the appraisal would not be $1.4 million. Mayor Cogswell said their property was appraised assuming 52 units would be built on the property. Ms. Dinwoodie said on their property, not the combination of their property. Mayor Cogswell said there was a typo in the description because Ms. Doran stated that 52 units would be built on the combined properties, the City ’s and those owned by Humanities. Chair Tinkler asked if they were suggesting the 50 units and 50 years. Mayor Cogswell said if it helped Humanities to give it to them as a contribution for their tax credit score, that would be fine and that this would be a forgivable loan. Ms. Dinwoodie said she would amend this to state 50 units across all project properties, including the City's and their own properties that they already own, with a purchase price of $1 million. The restrictions would run for 50 years at the AMIs discussed. 6 Councilmember Polkey asked, given the addition of 20 years, for their initial impressions on how that would affect their ability to finance this project. He supported the value and spirit of this when they began th e conversation, with the $400,000 as was understood at the time, across the broader scope of the number of units. So, with the adjustments they were discussing, there would be a meaningful effect on financing the project across the board, which made him uncomfortable, bumping up to 50 without understanding the impact on the project's capacity to be financed. He asked if they had any insights from their experience on what that adjustment meant in broader strokes. Ms. Doran said they had never implemented 50-year restrictions because they felt properties with 30-year restrictions would need to be recapitalized and would run down over time . There would be no reserves, and depending on what happens with interest rates, this could become problematic. For all of the units they had developed in the City of Charleston, they sold the properties, and some were redone. They never converted any to market rate, and the only ones taken out of the tax credit program were still at 80%, so they did not know what the ramifications would be at this time. Councilmember Polkey asked for more information specifically about the timing challenge with the county. He asked whether they knew when the deadline would be for them to have their ducks in a row, so they would not forgo the opportunity with the ARPA money. Ms. Doran said they were told they would have to close in September, but they were going for an end-of-year closing because they would have to deploy it so they would not lose it. Councilmember Polkey said he understood the importance of the long arc of affordability and did not dispute its value. But there could be a difference between 40 and 45 years, and the specifics could put them in a better place than where they were, though not as far as where they could be. He wanted to make sure they were balancing the need to move forward with the need to be fully informed. His concern was the 50 because they did not know what that would do to the deal, and they were not objecting to the value of getting as much affordability as possible. Mayor Cogswell said he was not sure how much impact this would have on the value. As stewards of the City, they need to put their money where their mouth was and push for more affordability longer term. Councilmember Polkey said he would not vote on this because of the change in position based on the time allotted. His vote against this should not be construed as an objection to the fundamentals of ensuring they were appropriate stewards of the taxpayer ’s dollars, as is the Mayor ’s position and continues to be the Mayor ’s position, as well as Councilmember Waring ’s position of maximizing the affordability period. He did not think the affordability period in this conversation was sufficient for him to provide his support. Ms. Dorian asked whether this would be problematic, since all the other properties they were working on were over 30 years old and had the same restrictions, and whether they had an option to purchase the land at that time. Mayor Cogswell said they could make an offer. Councilmember Waring said they could learn from what was already done. For Grace Homes, the City gave land to the housing authority and created permanent affordable housing. That property, at the end of 60 years, would revert to the City. The longer period of affordability on the same site where the bridge came down was given back to the City, the Council, and the Mayor at that time, as well as Riley and Tecklenburg, who ensured affordability. To say it could not be done was to ignore that it already had been. Numbers and appraisals change, and the question was not about valuation because the City got the property for free to help create affordability, which is why the housing authority did not pay for its land. They got CPW to bring infrastructure in at CPW ’s cost; 7 that included the water and sewer lines. They got Dominion to bring in electrification there at reduced cost so it could be right at the property line. Many allies helped bring affordability to the corridor so it could be done for longer than 30 years. They spoke of other people creating longer affordability in this quarter, and that it had been done before. Instead of listening to the diet tribe, maybe pull out the documents that helped make it happen to make it a reality and learn from it. Ms. Doran said the difference was that they purchased and paid for land, whereas the others were either donated or leased and were no longer there. So, they were trying to combine that with another piece of property that already had restrictions on it and had worked through. Councilmember Polkey said he did not dispute what Councilmember Waring said, but the earlier conversation and the experience they had on the phone did not make him comfortable with the timing of the action from a procedural standpoint, because the county was driving the timing. On a motion by Mayor Cogswell, seconded by Councilmember Waring, the Committee voted to approve the $1 million purchase price, subject to contingencies that at least 50 units be built on the combined properties and that the affordability period be extended from 30 to 50 years. The vote was not unanimous. Councilmember Polkey voted Nay. f. Authorization for Mayor, on behalf of the City, to enter into a Fourth Amendment to Commercial Lease Agreement with the owners of property located at 102 Wappoo Creek Drive, Unit B-5 to extend the current lease for an additional three years. This property is used by CPD ’s Team 3 offices. (102 Wappoo Drive, Unit B-5, TMS# 424- 01-00-010). The property is owned by Ann H. O ’Brien as Trustee of Trust B u/w Paul H. O ’Brien, LLC. Ms. Dinwoodie said this was a three-year renewal with two single-year options and a 3% escalation rate. This was used by CPD Team 3 on James Island off Wappoo Drive. They are currently in discussions with the owner to make some upgrades due to wear and tear. On a motion by Councilmember Waring, seconded by Councilmember Gregg, the Committee voted unanimously to approve Item F. g. Please consider the following annexations: (i) 1610 Sam Rittenberg Boulevard (2.25 acre) (TMS# 351-08-00-002), West Ashley, ( District 9 ). The property is owned by C Level Investments LLC. (ii) 1657 Ashley Hall Road (1.61 acre) (TMS# 351-08-00-027), West Ashley, Charleston County, (District 9). The property is owned by C Level Investments LLC. (iii) 106 San Juan Avenue (0.22 acre) (TMS# 418-06-00-035), West Ashley, Charleston County, to the City of Charleston, (District 9). The property is owned by Joe Costo. (iv) 1631 Means Street (Approximately 0.25 acre) (TMS# 424-05-00-082), James Island, Charleston County, (District 11). The property is owned by Kenneth Strange . On a motion by Councilmember Waring, seconded by Mayor Cogswell, the Committee voted unanimously to take all four annexations together for approval. With there being no further business, the Committee adjourned the meeting at 3:54 p.m. Clerk of Council ’s Office Donna Constance 8

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.