RecordWell Data

_08052026-11101

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Aug 5, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

City of Charleston History Commission August 5 , 2 0 2 6 A meeting of the History Commission was held this date beginning at 4 :0 0 p.m. at City Hall, 80 Broad Street. Notice of this meeting was sent to all local news m e d ia . Present: Harlan Greene, Chair, Elizabeth Chew, Peg Eastman, Brittany Lavelle-Tulla (arrived at 4:03), Angela Mack, and Ken Scarlett. L in k to m eetin g : h ttp s://w w w .yo u tu b e.co m /w atch ? v= n S 6_E R zvJH 0& t= 2807s A. Call to Order Chair Greene called the meeting to order . B. Minutes 1. April 1 , 2026 On a motion of Elizabeth Chew , seconded by Peg Eastman , the Commission on History voted unanimously to approve item B1 , as amended. C. Update on the SC250 Plaque placed at St. Philip ’s Church (Requested by Chair Greene ) Chair Greene said that he had noticed a ‘wonderful plaque ’ about the United States ’ 250 th anniversary of Independence with a lot of information, and he did not remember it coming to the Commission. Commissioner Eastman said that it was overly large. Chair Greene said it was extremely large. It drew attention to itself. He said he had contacted Ms. Katherine Saunders Pemberton at SC250 to see if she knew anything about it. He learned that St. Philip ’s Church did everything within its power to follow protocol. Mr. Edmund Most, interim Section Chief for Facilities & Capital Projects, said that he had spoken with former Section Chief Jason Kronsberg and Clark DeCiantis. He said that on May 1, Mr. Kronsberg and Mr. DeCiantis were asked out to the site to look at relocation of the marker. It was already installed in the cemetery, which was private property. When Mr. Kronsberg and Mr. DeCiantis were asked to look at the location, it was more about spatial context in the right-of-way. The Mayor ’s Design Review Committee (DRC) had purview there. He continued, saying that Mr. Kronsberg could have said at that time that the language should have gone to the History Commission, but Mr. Most said that he thought that Mr. Kronsberg did not feel that that was appropriate because it had already been fabricated, the anniversary was City of Charleston Commission on History A ugust 5 , 202 6 , P age 2 only weeks away, and he was no longer an employee of the City. Mr. Most said that 2 George was not familiar with the History Commission, while the Parks Department was. He personally had done a number of plaques years ago, and they had always brought everything to the Commission. He thought that was where the issue was. Mr. Most continued, saying he had asked Ms. Mandi Herring, Section Chief for Planning, Permitting, & Engineering, if there could be a box that needed to get checked to say that signs need to go through the History Commission during the permitting process. She said they would figure out a way to prevent the issue from happening in the future. He said that originally, the sign would never have needed to come to the Commission because it was being installed on private property. He said they would also add a checkbox to the DRC so that an applicant would see and understand that signs would need to come to the History Commission. Commissioner Eastman said she had seen the sign. She said that she thought there was a size limit for City signs, and the sign was ‘gargantuan ’ and looked oversized to her. She was hoping that St. Philip ’s would choose to put it in a less ‘in your face ’ place. Mr. Most said that when an application historically came to the DRC, they looked at the scale, font size, and such in the context of the space. In this particular context, it had already been fabricated, and so he did not think that Mr. Kronsberg had been in a position to say, ‘this does not work for us. ’ Commissioner Chew asked where the sign exactly was. Chair Greene said that if one were going up Church St., St. Philip ’s was on the right, and the sign stood close to the curb by the portico. It was quite a large sign. Chair Greene passed around an image of the sign on his cell phone to the Commissioners. Chair Greene said he believed the City had only ever worked on State markers or markers the City itself had done. He said the issue was about precedent. He was concerned other people or organizations might want a sign in the same style, and that was something they had to be aware of. He said the explanation was perfectly understandable. Commissioner Lavelle-Tulla asked if the marker still needed to go through the History Commission for approval. Chair Greene said that at first, it was thought that St. Philip ’s or SC250 had brazenly put the marker up on their own, but, after following the trail, they realized that there had been City approvals already, but not the Commission. Ms. Julia Copeland, Corporation Counsel for the City of Charleston, said that if had been brazenly done, as they had thought was the case, they would absolutely tell them to go back to the Commission. However, that was not the case, because the Church and SC250 believed that they had gone through all the proper panels and it had slipped through the cracks, and they did everything they thought they were supposed to do . I t was a weird set of circumstances. Mr. Most said that the lesson was learned and that they would try to minimize it from happening again if the Commission supported the modifications that they would be making to the approvals process. Chair Greene said the Church had worked with SC250 and that they had made their best effort to meet all approvals, which they believed they had. City of Charleston Commission on History A ugust 5 , 202 6 , P age 3 Mr. Most said that because it was being installed on private property, DRC would never have stepped in. It was when it was moved from private property to public property that it did not fit into their regular process. Commissioner Lavelle-Tulla said she thought that they should still go through the approvals process, even if it was only a formality and no changes to the text would be made. For precedence, they still needed to see it. Commissioner Chew said the precedent established could be a problem in the future. Mr. Most asked if the Commission wanted the process of moving a marker from private property to public property to involve the Commission even if that meant having to refabricate the plaque. Commissioner Mack asked why the Church would not just put the marker back on private property if they were told to refabricate it to meet the Commission ’s standards. Commissioner Chew said that planning an interpretive sign on private property was very different from one on public property. Chair Greene said the Commission may have changed a few words. Commission Chew said the text was important, but the point was more that it was decided that a gigantic sign could be placed in the public right-of-way without the Commission ’s approval. Commissioner Eastman said she felt like she had been slapped in the face when she saw it and felt that it was in the wrong spot. Chair Greene said it was visually arresting. Chair Greene asked Mr. Philip Clapper, the Assistant Clerk of Council, if they could take action on the issue. The Assistant Clerk said that Chair Greene could request that it be on the agenda for the following meeting. Commissioner Chew said that where the City could or could not put a sign was beyond the Commission ’s purview. Chair Greene said that the only reason he had wanted the item on the agenda was to show in the public record how the sign came to be and that it would not be setting a precedent. Commissioner Mack said she was still unsure if she understood why the sign moved from private property to public property. Chair Greene said he was unsure who requested it. Commissioner Mack said that the point was that no one on the Commission had known that that was going to happen. She said that was an issue. She said it could set precedent, and others might ask for the same thing. Chair Greene said that the email he received from St. Philip ’s said that they would be more than willing to talk further about the issue. He said they could speak more at the next meeting. Commissioner Eastman asked for everyone to see the sign. She said it had been ‘shocking ’ to her. Chair Greene said they could put the item on the agenda as an action item at the following meeting. D. Approval of Language for DeCosta House Marker (Requested by the South Carolina Department of Archives and History) City of Charleston Commission on History A ugust 5 , 202 6 , P age 4 Chair Greene introduced the item and said that an additional sign on private property, perhaps sponsored by the Preservation Society of Charleston, could allow for even more information on the topic as an augment to the story. Discussion was held regarding the wording of Side 1. During discussion on Side 1, the Commission requested that "2-story" be removed to make room for "19th-c." to become "19th-century." On a motion of Commissioner Elizabeth Chew, seconded by Commissioner Angela Mack, the Commission voted unanimously to approve Side 1, as amended, as written below. Side 1 In 1935 contractor Herbert A. DeCosta Sr. (1894-1960) and teacher Julia E. Craft DeCosta (1898-1990) moved into this 19th-century. house with their children Herbert Jr. and Bernice. Herbert Sr. renovated the home and initially also used it as an office for the H.A. DeCosta Co., which he formed in 1919. Herbert Jr. joined the firm in 1947. It moved into the building at 93 Spring St. around that time. Herbert Sr. and Julia continued to live here for the rest of their lives. Discussion was held regarding the wording of Side 2. Commissioner Scarlett said he had seen signs such as the one being discussed in other cities and had been impressed by some examples of the buildings that they had done that still existed and with the number of people that they employed over the years. He did not know if they were past the stage of content and were only doing final editing, but he did want to bring up those points. Discussion continued . Ms. Gail DeCosta, granddaughter of Herbert Sr. and Julia DeCosta and daughter of Herbert and Emily DeCosta said that to accommodate for “century, ” they could remove “still ” from the last sentence. Discussion continued. Commissioner Scarlett said that immediately after “One of the most successful African American-owned businesses …” would be an excellent space to place information regarding employment numbers for the firm, though there would be space considerations. Ms. Anna-Catherine Alexander with the Preservation Society of Charleston said that if the property owner were to be willing to work with the Preservation Society, they could add a supplementary marker on private property, still visible from the public right-of-way, they would have much more space to go into further detail. Discussion continued. In l ine 3, "20th-c." became "20th-century ." In line 10, "wide-ranging" became "all ." In line 12, "its" was removed. In line 14, "one" became "One ." In line 16, a comma was added after "S.C." to become "S.C.," and "and was" was deleted. In line 17, "still" was replaced with "it remained ." City of Charleston Commission on History A ugust 5 , 202 6 , P age 5 In line 18, "when" was removed and replaced with "until ." Also in line 18, the Commission suggested that if more room was needed, "it was" could be removed so that it would read "until sold" instead of "until it was sold ." On a motion of Commissioner Elizabeth Chew, seconded by Commissioner Angela Mack, the Commission voted unanimously to approve Side 2 , as amended, as written below. Side 2 H.A. DeCosta Co. was one of the most prominent building firms in 20th-century Charleston. First run by Herbert A. DeCosta Sr. and taken over in 1960 by his son Herbert A. DeCosta Jr. (1923-2008), the company built, designed, or repaired hundreds of buildings of all types and was renowned for restorations of historic architecture. One of the most successful African American-owned businesses in S.C., it remained based at 93 Spring St. until it was sold in 1988. Chair Greene asked Ms. DeCosta about the William and Ellen Craft Foundation. Ms. DeCosta said the Foundation was relatively new, founded in the past year or two, and it sought to live out the goals of William and Ellen Craft. They were passionate about education, and that was one of the things that the Foundation was looking to support, specifically for African Americans. They were looking for funds. She thanked everyone involved with getting the marker done. Chair Greene said they looked forward to its unveiling. E. Adjournment On a motion of Commissioner Peg Eastman, seconded by Commissioner Angela Mack , the Commission voted unanimously to adjourn the meeting. The meeting was adjourned at 5 :47 p .m . Philip E . C la p p e r Assistant Clerk of Council

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.