RecordWell Data

BAR-S Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Jul 23, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL PUBLIC COMMENT JULY 23, 2026 A meeting of the Board of Architectural Review – Small (BAR- S) will be held on Thursday, July 23, 2026 at 4:30 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street. The following written comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of the meeting. The comments will also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston -sc.gov/bar. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 B. APPLICATIONS 1. 32 Dunnemann Avenue BAR2026-002599 | TMS# 463-14-02-017 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6 Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1947 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for the after-the-fact partial demolition of exterior elements visible from the public right-of-way. Owner: 32 DUNN HOLDINGS LLC Applicant: Nicholas Grossman (Stan Dickson, architect) Previous site visit on 6/11/2026. 1 Comment Submitted: • Wagener Terrace Neighborhood Association Submitted to Staff See attached statement. 2. 14 12th Avenue BAR2026-002698 | TMS# 463-15-01-060 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6 Not surveyed | c. pre-1973 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for demolition of structure. Owner: RABIN REAL ESTATE INC Applicant: Neil Stevenson Architects Site visit on 7/23/26 at 8:30 a.m. 1 Comment Submitted: • Wagener Terrace Neighborhood Association Submitted to Staff See attached statement. Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | July 23, 2026 Page 2 3. 15 Francis Street BAR2026-002705 | TMS# 463-15-04-105 | North Central | Council District 4 Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1910| Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for the partial demolition of exterior elements visible from the public right-of-way. Owner: Hunter and Stewart James Applicant: AJ Architects Site visit on 7/23/26 at 8:50 a.m. No Comments Submitted 4. 12 Poinsett Street BAR2026-002715 | TMS# 463-16-02-034 | East Central | Council District 4 Not surveyed | c. 1910| Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for the partial demolition of existing exterior elements visible from the public right-of-way. Owner: W. Gordon Geer Applicant: Rogers American Construction, LLC Site visit on 7/23/26 at 9:10 a.m. No Comments Submitted 5. 84 Sheppard Street BAR2026-002720 | TMS# 460-04-04-079 | Council District 4 Not surveyed | c. 1930| Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for the partial demolition of existing exterior elements visible from the public right-of-way. Owner: Titus Thompson Applicant: Discovery Builders Site visit on 7/23/26 at 9:30 a.m. No Comments Submitted 6. 20 Felix Street BAR2026-002722 | TMS# 460-12-01-030 | Cannonborough / Elliottborough | Council District 6 | Category 4| c. 1852| Old City District Requesting after-the-fact approval for demolition of the house and conceptual approval for new construction. Owner: Billy Estes Applicant: WELCH CUSTOM HOMES, LLC Site visit on 7/23/26 at 9:50 a.m. No Comments Submitted 7. 11 Radcliffe Place BAR2026-002701 | TMS# 460-12-03-099 | Radcliffeborough | Council District 6 Not surveyed | c. 2000| Old City District Requesting conceptual approval for exterior alterations to existing structure. Owner: Thomas Bowen Applicant: AMERICAN VERNACULAR, INC Site visit on 7/23/26 at 10:10 a.m. Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | July 23, 2026 Page 3 No Comments Submitted 8. 3 Murphy Court BAR2026-002665 | TMS# 460-16-03-128 | Radcliffeborough | Council District 6 Category 3| c. 1890| Old and Historic District Requesting approval to add shutters. Owner: Katherine McAfee Applicant: Katherine McAfee No Comments Submitted 9. 16 N Hampstead Square BAR2026-002713 | TMS# 459-05-04-027 | East Side | Council District 4 Category 4 | c. 1872 | Old City District Requesting conceptual approval for porch enclosure and rear second-story addition. Owner: Colin Bumby Applicant: Baker Roddey Previous site visit on 05/28/2026 at 10:30 a.m. No Comments Submitted 10. 102 Ashley Avenue BAR2026-002697 | TMS# 457-03-01-072 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 Not surveyed | c. 1896| Old and Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for removal of infill, fenestration alterations, and new dormers. Owner: Alexander Horan Applicant: Glenn Keyes Architects No Comments Submitted 11. 292 King Street BAR2026-002678 | TMS# 457-04-04-258 | Council District 8 Not surveyed | c. 1838| Old and Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for storefront alterations. Owner: 292 King Street LLC Applicant: Titan Permitting 2 Comments Submitted: • Historic Charleston Foundation Submitted to Staff See attached statement. • Preservation Society of Charleston Submitted to Staff See attached statement. 12. 63 Ashley Avenue BAR2026-002693| TMS# 457-03-03-006 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | July 23, 2026 Page 4 Category 4 | c. 1872 | Old and Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for new accessory structure at rear of property. Owner: Cozy Development - 63 Ashley LLC Applicant: Cozy Development 5 Comments Submitted: • James and Sara Ewing, 75 Ashley Ave. Submitted to Innovate Site on July 22, 2026 11:24 AM We strongly discourage the approval of this additional dwelling on massing, scaling, and usage grounds. The current owners have already added what amounts to an accessory dwelling with their back addition, and this would further crowd the lot and the block. At only 4' below the roof line of a recently-elevated main structure, nor much recession from the line of the main houses, it clearly does not meet the guideline for showing a visible step down in function, like all other carriage houses and garages on the block. This house is on one of the highest points on the block, at around 12'. This part of the block did not flood during Hugo. If the new unit were just to be used as an office or pool house, it would not need the further elevation of a full story beneath it. Additionally, the presence of a bathroom in the upper level suggests that future owners could use this as a potential accessory dwelling unit for short-term rentals (assuming the main house is owner-occupied). On a block with substantial parking stress, this would only add more. We do not support this additional unit as designed. • Jack Handegan III, Montagu Street, Charleston, SC Submitted to Innovate Site July 22, 2026 11:34 AM I ask the Board to deny conceptual approval and require substantial restudy of the proposed accessory structure at 63 Ashley Avenue...At nearly the maximum permitted height, the 2 story building reads as a second residence rather than a subordinate accessory structure and appears excessive in its height, massing, fenestration, exterior stair, and relationship to the historic c. 1872 principal house and surrounding properties. Compliance with the zoning does not by itself establish architectural appropriateness. The property is already being marketed as having a separate 700-square-foot accessory dwelling “pending final Board of Architectural Review approval,” but that advance marketing and anticipated resale value should carry no weight in the Board’s decision or create the impression that approval is a formality. I respectfully request a meaningful reduction in height and mass and a redesign that is clearly subordinate and compatible with the historic property and neighborhood. I also want to note that Jamie Ewing who is a direct neighbor of this project was not able to submit his comment as he is in the UK and the website would not work. • Wiley Becker, 44 Rutledge Avenue, Charleston, SC 29401 Submitted to Innovate Site July 22, 2026 11:59 AM Harleston Village Association Charleston, South Carolina Re: Board of Architectural Review - Small July 23, 2026 Meeting 63 Ashley Avenue, TMS 457- 03-03-006 (Agenda Item 12) Dear Chair and Members of the Board, On behalf of the Harleston Village Association, we respectfully oppose conceptual approval for the request at 63 Ashley Avenue. The application proposes a new two-story accessory structure at the rear of a Category 4, c. 1872 residence in the Old and Historic District. Based on the submitted materials, we have concerns regarding zoning compliance (specifically the interaction of the setback and height provisions on which the submittal relies) and the overall scale and massing of the proposed Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | July 23, 2026 Page 5 structure. The request should be denied or deferred unless the applicant can demonstrate full zoning compliance and revise the proposal to be clearly subordinate to the principal historic structure and compatible with the surrounding neighborhood context. 1) Zoning; the submittal relies on two provisions that cannot be combined We ask that staff and the Board closely review whether the proposed accessory structure complies with all applicable zoning requirements. The applicant’s cover sheet (Sheet A000) states that the structure will encroach to within three feet of the interior side and rear property lines in reliance on Sec. 54- 506(f), while simultaneously claiming a two-story / 24-foot maximum accessory- structure height under Sec. 54-306.C (proposed height: 22’-9½”). As we read the Zoning Ordinance, those provisions are mutually exclusive as applied here, as set out below. Conceptual approval should not move forward without confirmation of full zoning compliance given FEMA requirements. Sec. 54-506(f) (Exceptions to setback requirements) permits an accessory building exceeding a 100-square-foot footprint to encroach to within three feet of interior side and rear property lines only where it meets each of the enumerated conditions, including that it “not exceed the height of the principal building on the lot” and be “limited to one and one-half (1½) stories” with “a maximum eave height of eleven (11) feet.” A two- story structure nearly 23 feet tall does not qualify for the exception. Sec. 54- 306.C (Old City Height Districts; Height District 2.5-3) extends the two-story / 24- foot height allowance only to accessory buildings “that satisfy setback requirements of this Chapter”(the standard accessory-structure setbacks of Table 3.1, Sec. 54-301) not to structures placed at the reduced setbacks of the Sec. 54- 506(f) exception. The proposal thus claims the reduced setback of one provision and the increased height of the other, when each is conditioned on forgoing the benefit of the other; as drawn, the structure appears to comply with neither. We note that the Board of Zoning Appeals routinely hears variance requests for precisely this configuration, confirming that zoning relief, not an exception, is the proper vehicle for a two-story accessory building at these setbacks. The site plan references an “encroachment line approved on March 18, 2025” without identifying the approving body or the scope of that approval; we ask that staff confirm on the record whether any BZA variance or special exception covers the height and setbacks of the structure now proposed. Separately, the drawing index (Sheet A000) labels the building sections “ADU Sections,” while the plans label the second floor “Studio/Office.” If an accessory dwelling unit is intended, now or in the future, compliance with Sec. 54-214 and the STR district standards of Table 3.1, Sec. 54-301, including minimum lot area per unit, should be confirmed, and the applicant should be required to state the intended use plainly. 2) Scale and massing A two-story accessory structure at the rear of this property appears excessive given the existing historic residence, lot size, and surrounding residential context. Accessory structures should remain clearly subordinate to the principal structure. As proposed, the height and massing risk creating an intensity of rear- yard development that is not compatible with the property or broader Harleston Village streetscape. These are the criteria the Board applies under Sec. 54-240 and the Charleston Standards, and the Zoning Ordinance itself embodies the same principle: taller accessory buildings are directed to hold full setbacks, and buildings at reduced setbacks are required to remain low. The design should be revised to conform to one of those two patterns: •a lower structure at the reduced setback, or •a two-story structure holding the full Table 3.1 setbacks, with massing, height, and fenestration that defer to the principal residence and the privacy of adjoining rear yards. 3) Neighborhood context and precedent We are concerned about continued pressure to maximize development on historic residential lots in Harleston Village. This type of rear-yard infill, particularly where two stories are Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | July 23, 2026 Page 6 proposed, can create additional density, scale, and mass that are not appropriate for the Old and Historic District. Approval here could set a poor precedent for similar requests elsewhere in the neighborhood. In particular, a precedent for stacking the Sec. 54-506(f) setback exception with the Sec. 54-306.C height allowance, a combination the Ordinance does not authorize. 4) Requested action Respectfully deny conceptual approval as submitted. In the alternative, defer the request and require the applicant to (i) obtain staff confirmation of zoning compliance, including the interaction of Sec. 54-506(f) and Sec. 54-306.C and the scope of any prior BZA relief; (ii) state plainly the intended use of the second floor; and (iii) revise the plans to reduce the height and massing of the accessory structure to a form the Ordinance permits at the proposed setbacks. All citations are to the Zoning Ordinance, Chapter 54 of the Code of the City of Charleston, as currently codified and published at library.municode.com. Thank you for your consideration. Respectfully submitted, Harleston Village Association • Historic Charleston Foundation Submitted to Staff See attached statement. • Preservation Society of Charleston Submitted to Staff See attached statement. 13. 8 Islington Court BAR2026- 002721| TMS# 460-11-04-072 | Cannonborough / Elliottborough | Council District 6 |Category 4 | c. 1852| Old City District Requesting conceptual approval for alteration to piazza ceiling, new front railing, pier infill, and new roof terrace wall. Owner: Cozy Development – 8 Islington LLC Applicant: Cozy Development No Comments Submitted 14. 95 South Battery Street BAR2026- 002723 | TMS# 457-11-02-047 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Category 3 | c. 1912| Old and Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for fenestration alterations, new side entry, restore parapet, hardscape changes, and change glass enclosure to screened porch. Owner: Michael and Lizzy Pallotta Applicant: Dufford Young Architects No Comments Submitted 15. 19 Broad Street BAR2026- 002724| TMS# 458-09-03-130 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Category 3 | c. 1794| Old and Historic District Requesting removal of historic building name and new building signage. Owner: 19 Broad Street LLC Applicant: Vivid Sign & Design 1 Comment Submitted: Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | July 23, 2026 Page 7 • Julie O’Connor – American Vernacular, Inc., 151 Sheppard St. Submitted to Staff See attached statement. CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL 32 Dunnemann Avenue BAR2026-002599 | TMS# 463-14-02-017 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6 Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1947 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for the after-the-fact partial demolition of exterior elements visible from the public right-of-way. Owner: 32 DUNN HOLDINGS LLC Applicant: Nicholas Grossman (Stan Dickson, architect) Previous site visit on 6/11/2026. Wagener Terrace Neighborhood Association Charleston, SC 29403 July 21, 2026 Frankie Pinto Board of Architectural Review 2 George Street, Suite 3100 Charleston, SC 29401 Re: 32 Dunnemann Avenue, TMS# 463-14-02-017 - Formal Opposition to After-the-Fact Demolition Request Dear Mrs. Pinto, I am writing to you on behalf of the Wagener Terrace Neighborhood Association (WTNA) to formally oppose the after-the-fact demolition request for the property located at 32 Dunnemann Avenue. The WTNA convened on July 20, 2026, and the membership overwhelmingly voted to oppose this request. While the WTNA previously provided a letter of support based on plans for a partial demolition of the rear portion of the property, the current state of the site clearly shows that this scope was drastically exceeded, likely resulting in the total demolition of the historic structure. This blatant disregard for the City's Board of Architectural Review process undermines the Board's authority and threatens the historical integrity of the Wagener Terrace neighborhood. We kindly request that the BAR exercise its full authority to ensure this situation is adequately remedied. Specifically, we reference the recent amendment to the BAR demolition ordinance that allows for reprimanding offenders who exceed their approved demolition scope. Thank you for your time and for your dedication to preserving the character of our city. Sincerely, Jarett Nicholson President, Wagener Terrace Neighborhood Association CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL 14 12th Avenue BAR2026-002698 | TMS# 463-15-01-060 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6 Not surveyed | c. pre-1973 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for demolition of structure. Owner: RABIN REAL ESTATE INC Applicant: Neil Stevenson Architects Site visit on 7/23/26 at 8:30 a.m. Wagener Terrace Neighborhood Association Charleston, SC 29403 July 21, 2026 Frankie Pinto Board of Architectural Review 2 George Street, Suite 3100 Charleston, SC 29401 Re: 14 12th Ave, TMS# 463-15-01-060 - Formal Opposition to Demolition Request Dear Mrs. Pinto, I am writing to you on behalf of the Wagener Terrace Neighborhood Association (WTNA) to formally oppose the demolition request for the property located at 14 12th Ave. The owner of the property failed to meet with the WTNA and communicate their plans for demolition and subsequent construction of a single-family dwelling. While the WTNA supports improving abandoned lots, the association needs to understand what the builder intends to put in its place. There are concerns regarding Electromagnetic field (EMF) readings due to the proximity to the Dominion power lines at the rear of the property. Furthermore, the WTNA is concerned about a single-family dwelling located on such a small piece of property. Ideally, the property would be sold to the city and utilized as a green space for the community. Thank you for your time and consideration regarding this opposition. Sincerely, Jarett Nicholson President, Wagener Terrace Neighborhood Association CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL 292 King Street BAR2026-002678 | TMS# 457-04-04-258 | Council District 8 Not surveyed | c. 1838| Old and Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for storefront alterations. Owner: 292 King Street LLC Applicant: Titan Permitting 292 King Street BAR2026-002678 | TMS# 457-04-04-258 | Council District 8 Not surveyed | c. 1838| Old and Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for storefront alterations. Owner: 292 King Street LLC Applicant: Titan Permitting Post Office Box 1120 ∙ Charleston, SC 29402 ∙ (843) 723-1623 ∙ Fax (843) 577-2067 ∙ www.historiccharleston.org To: Members of the Board of Architectural Review-Small From: Kate Dutilly, Preservation Planner Date: July 21, 2026 Re: 292 King Historical photographs suggest that this building was modified in the 1950s, at which time the entrance was located on the corner, and the current storefront configuration was established. The existing 1950s-era ground-level features are an important part of the building’s evolution and history. Significantly altering the storefront would diminish this character and eliminate a key period of the building’s development. We respectfully recommend denial of this application. Thank you for your consideration of our position. Position Statement Board of Architectural Review – Small July 23, 2026 292 King Street Dear Board Members, While the existing c. 1950 storefront was the result of a mid-century renovation, historic photographs of 292 King Street available in Historic Charleston Foundation’s Archive serve as a valuable reference for understanding this building’s evolution. If a more traditional storefront is desired, the proposed design should be directly informed by historical documentation. The Preservation Society of Charleston encourages the applicant to reference these photographs (attached) to inform their approach and ensure that historic conditions, like the open, canted corner, are preserved. Thank you for considering our position in this matter. Sincerely, Flannery Antinoro Preservation Specialist https://hub.catalogit.app/search/historic-charleston-foundation/entry/290-292-king-street-(miller-ripley-and-company-buildings)?query=292%20king CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL 63 Ashley Avenue BAR2026-002693| TMS# 457-03-03-006 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 Category 4 | c. 1872 | Old and Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for new accessory structure at rear of property. Owner: Cozy Development - 63 Ashley LLC Applicant: Cozy Development 63 Ashley Avenue BAR2026-002693| TMS# 457-03-03-006 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 Category 4 | c. 1872 | Old and Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for new accessory structure at rear of property. Owner: Cozy Development - 63 Ashley LLC Applicant: Cozy Development Post Office Box 1120 ∙ Charleston, SC 29402 ∙ (843) 723-1623 ∙ Fax (843) 577-2067 ∙ www.historiccharleston.org To: Members of the Board of Architectural Review-Small From: Kate Dutilly, Preservation Planner Date: July 21, 2026 Re: 63 Ashley Although HCF is generally supportive of the proposed architectural direction, we have concerns regarding the height of the structure. We request that the building be reduced in height so that it remains subordinate to the historic structure, and that the first floor be reduced in height to more closely align with the Design Flood Elevation (DFE). Position Statement Board of Architectural Review – Small July 23, 2026 63 Ashley Avenue Dear Board Members, The Preservation Society of Charleston appreciates the applicant reaching out to us about this project and taking our feedback into consideration. While we have no issues with the materiality or architectural direction of this design, the proportions are overly vertical, and we encourage the applicant to reduce the height to the greatest extent possible to achieve a more balanced and contextually appropriate scale. Thank you for considering our position in this matter. Sincerely, Flannery Antinoro Preservation Specialist CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL 19 Broad Street BAR2026- 002724| TMS# 458-09-03-130 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Category 3 | c. 1794| Old and Historic District Requesting removal of historic building name and new building signage. Owner: 19 Broad Street LLC Applicant: Vivid Sign & Design Drawing from 1875, as well as a streetscape and photograph showing that the building has a history of changing signage on the façade.

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.