RecordWell Data

Planning Commission Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Jul 15, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON PLANNING COMMISSION PUBLIC COMMENT JULY 15, 2026 A meeting of the Planning Commission will be held on Wednesday, July 15, 2026 at 5:00 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street. The following written comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of the meeting. The comments will also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/pc. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 A. ORDINANCE AMENDMENTS 1. Request approval to amend Sections 54-208 and 54-227 to incorporate minor wording and definition changes to the Short-Term Rental Ordinance intended to clarify and quantify certain terms, limits, submittal and review criteria, and penalties 27 Comment Submitted: • Lee Hewett, 20 Nolen Way Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I am writing to submit a public comment in opposition to Agenda Item #1, the STR Ordinance Amendment, on the Planning Commission agenda for Wednesday, July 15. I understand the online portal deadline was 12:00 PM today; I respectfully ask that this comment be acknowledged into the record or forwarded to the commissioners if at all possible.I am a physician and property owner in the Charleston area with a short-term rental in North Charleston, and a stakeholder in the region's visitor economy. Clear, enforceable STR rules are reasonable, but the amendment as drafted goes further than necessary and does not reflect how these properties have been legally permitted, operated, and relied upon for years. The current draft would harm responsible operators, the local businesses and employees they support, and the visitors who sustain economic activity across the Charleston area.I ask the Commission to oppose the amendment in its current form and pursue a more balanced approach — one that protects neighborhoods while respecting existing legally operating rentals, local investment, and the jobs tied to them. Position: Oppose Agenda Item: #1, STR Ordinance Amendment Meeting: Planning Commission, July 15, 2026 Thank you for your consideration. • Jayda Rabin, 27 Devereaux Avenue Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting The proposed short-term rental ordinance, as currently written, would have far-reaching consequences not only for property owners, but also for the local businesses, employees, Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 2 and visitors who help sustain Charleston’s economy. While we support reasonable regulations and effective enforcement, this proposal imposes restrictions that are unnecessarily burdensome and fail to recognize the long-standing, legally permitted operation of many existing short-term rentals. We encourage you to reject the ordinance in its current form and instead support revisions that preserve neighborhood character while protecting local businesses, private property rights, responsible operators, and the economic benefits that short-term rentals bring to our community. • Cameron Glaws, 95 Line Street Charleston SC 29403 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Re: Proposed STR Ordinance Amendment, ST Overlay Zone (Public Draft, June 24, 2026) To the Charleston Planning Commission, Mayor Cogswell, and Members of City Council: My name is Cameron Glaws. I'm a short-term rental operator and small-business owner in Cannonborough-Elliottborough, where I also run a construction company and employ a local crew. I've invested in this neighborhood for the long haul, and I'm writing in support of responsible STR regulation — and against how this particular amendment is being presented. The agenda calls this a "minor wording and definition change." It isn't. It changes how occupancy may be advertised and imposes a flat eight-guest cap on every unit regardless of size. A restriction on how you're allowed to market a lawful, Fire Marshal-approved property is not housekeeping — it's an economic rule wearing a housekeeping label. Presenting it as minor understates what it actually does to compliant operators across this district. The flat cap is the core problem. It treats a studio and a five-bedroom home exactly the same and ignores the occupancy the Fire Marshal has already approved. The 2+2 standard — two guests per approved bedroom plus two per unit, verified by the Fire Marshal and posted in every unit — is fairer, scales to the actual home, and is easier for the City to enforce, not harder. I'm fully behind it. This isn't only my concern. An independent Tourism Economics study estimates the flat cap would cost Charleston roughly $100.9 million in annual business sales and 480 jobs — lost covers for restaurants, lost accounts for cleaning and maintenance vendors, and lost shifts for local workers like the ones on my own crew. I support real enforcement. I post approved occupancy in every unit and back strong action against parties, noise, overcrowding, trash, and unpermitted units. I'm asking the City to: 1. Adopt the 2+2 occupancy standard, Fire Marshal-verified and posted in each unit. 2. Keep separately permitted same-parcel units clearly allowed to be booked together, each under its own posted limit. 3. Preserve strong, focused enforcement against nuisance behavior and unpermitted units. Regulate the behavior that harms neighborhoods — not the compliant operators who don't. Respectfully, Cameron Glaws Owner, 95 Line Street/ 95 Line LLC/ Old City Builders LLC/ Mount Vernon Partners LLC/ OC Capital Partners LLC • Zachary Viscidi, 59 Cypress Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting The proliferation of AirBNB has caused major disruptions to communities and the rental market in Charleston. While the city has made an effort to limit the operation of these to specific areas, more needs to be done to stop the commercialization of large swaths of neighborhoods. Appropriate limits on the number of reservations as well as the number of individuals able to rent these accommodations is a necessary and important step. When this website began, the city had a dearth of hotel rooms, but that gap has been filled. Please stand up for locals and local neighborhoods! • Peter Larichiuta, 595 Rutledge Ave Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 3 I have lived at my home on Rutledge Avenue for over five years and I’ve counted on the rental income to help support my living expenses, including carrying the cost of my home. It would be devastating if that was no longer an option for me and I’m strongly against any changes to this. At a minimum people that have it should be grandfathered in. • Natalie Hedden, 2 Pagett Street, Daniel Island SC 29492 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Dear Members of the Planning Commission, My name is Natalie Hedden. I am writing to share my perspective on the proposed changes to our city’s short-term rental (STR) occupancy limits. I am not a large, out-of-state corporation or an absent investor. I am a hardworking local citizen, and managing our properties is my full-time job. My husband and I are raising our young family right here in Charleston. We believe deeply in this city, which is why we chose to invest our personal family savings into operating two high- quality, legally permitted STR properties downtown. We deeply understand and respect the city’s desire to maintain the livability and unique charm of our historic neighborhoods; we value this deeply as well. We attend church downtown, make regular charitable donations to benefit our neighbors, and my husband owns a law practice located right here downtown. Because all of our family income is tied entirely to our Charleston-based businesses, we are fully invested in the long-term health and character of this community. A blanket reduction in occupancy limits unfairly penalizes responsible, local owners who are doing things the right way. Our properties actively work against the common friction points associated with STRs. Both of our downtown properties feature ample, dedicated off-street parking and do not contribute to street congestion. Furthermore, we do not "cram" guests in; we have carefully curated spacious accommodations designed to host multiple families with children, groups of friends, and colleagues comfortably and respectfully. To ensure our guests are exemplary neighbors, I partner with YourPad Property Management. This partnership not only supports local jobs but guarantees 24/7 oversight and thorough guest vetting. Because of this rigorous, proactive management, we have never once received a single neighborhood complaint, and our guests have been nothing but respectful of the Charleston community. Additionally, I use my role as a host to actively steer our guests toward our downtown independent businesses, keeping valuable tourism dollars right here in our local economy. Arbitrarily limiting our occupancy will not solve the issues caused by negligent, unpermitted operators. Instead, it will directly damage my primary source of income and reduce the economic support we actively funnel back into downtown businesses and local community causes. I urge the council to consider targeted regulations that enforce penalties against bad actors and actual nuisance properties, rather than cutting the livelihood of local residents who manage their properties with integrity and a flawless record. Thank you for your time, your hard work, and your continued dedication to Charleston. Sincerely, Natalie Hedden • Aaron Rowland, 1240 Winchester Drive, Charleston, SC 29407 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I've worked in luxury hotel management in Charleston for nearly 15 years and now help manage hundreds of short-term rental properties with the same level of hospitality and professionalism we upheld at places like The Dewberry and Charleston Place. The most glaring difference is that, rather than receiving support from the City and its resources, responsible short-term rental operators are often met with resistance that makes it more difficult to operate efficiently, responsibly, and in compliance with the rules. I fully understand the challenges with the existing regulations, and I agree that certain provisions are neither practical nor enforceable. However, I strongly disagree with the Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 4 process being used to consider these changes. Folly Beach is facing many of the same challenges related to short-term rental regulations, yet it has taken a far more thoughtful and transparent approach. The City appointed a committee, conducted public input meetings, commissioned an independent economic study, allocated municipal resources, and created a process that allows for meaningful participation from affected stakeholders. Charleston should follow a similarly deliberate process rather than attempting to move forward with significant changes without sufficient public input, economic analysis, or supporting data. The current proposal appears to be heavily influenced by a small number of individuals whose concerns are based largely on perception and anecdotal claims about large groups and disruptive behavior. Those concerns should be taken seriously, but they should also be supported by actual data, documented violations, and a clear understanding of the consequences of the proposed changes. A decision of this magnitude will affect local businesses, individual property owners, employees, service providers, and responsible operators throughout the community. Before moving forward, the City should conduct the necessary due diligence and establish a transparent, inclusive, and democratic process that gives all stakeholders a meaningful opportunity to participate. I respectfully ask that this matter be deferred until that process can occur. Taking additional time now will lead to a more informed, balanced, and enforceable policy that addresses legitimate concerns without unnecessarily harming responsible businesses and property owners. • Gena Pellechio, 1000 King Street Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Charleston is home to amazing residents, culture, and classic Southern Hospitality! Most everyone here works or have worked in the Hospitality industry and are DIRECTLY effected on what presidents the City Council sets. This maximum 8 guest limit (no matter the size of the house) will effect future guests wanting to experience Charleston and I think you need to take a closer look into the demographics of the people that come to Charleston and why they are here. You seem to have issues with parties and noise complaints...THIS IS ALSO A COLLEGE TOWN and I heard CofC let him more students then they can accommodate! Most of the partying and noise complaints are coming from college students who galavant around the city doing whatever they want. College students live in the same neighborhoods the Short Term Overlay is and have House Parties ALL the time! Maybe you should look into that... rather than cap a guest count that should not cap at 8 guests. 1- I don't know how that would be regulated, are city officials going to be knocking on every short term rental door and asking guests how many people are in their party? That seems a bit stupid 2- 8 People can comfortable fit in a 4 bedroom home- what happens to the homes that are more than 4 bedrooms? If guests can't book a 8 bedroom home (2 person per bedroom, 16 guests) then you are taking away income from the home owners who rent out these homes. These large homes don't always get bachelorette or bachelor trips like you may think! They get blended families, work trips, 60th Birthday celebrations, Wedding anniversaries and you will be taking that experience away from these future guests. Charleston has become more than party central! People come here to experience our culture, the slower way of life, culinary experiences, and the true hospitality of the residents that work in this industry! In my opinion you should have guest count be set on bedroom count- 2 per bedroom so a 1 bedroom house would accommodate 2 guests and a 4 bedroom house would accommodate 8 guests, and a 7 bedroom house would accommodate 14 guests. I think you are going to ruin so many peoples lively hoods, means of income, and more. Charleston is already expensive and most people that want to live and work here can't even afford rent, most businesses can't afford rent. I have seen so many of my favorite places close down over the years due to how expensive this city is and now you want to Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 5 take away from how this city gets its money!!! You should rethink this guest count cap.... coming from an actual resident who has worked in the Hospitality industry for 8 years. • Zack Zollinger, 1 Cool Blow St Charleston SC 29403 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I am a in opposition of the current STR Ordinance Amendment changes. As a downtown Charleston community member as well as an employee of a local management company, I am able to see both sides of these regulations. I believe that having clear and enforceable rules are important and there is certainly a need for a more clear STR ordinance. I do believe that this current draft oversteps bounds as there is mention of IPMC setting occupancy limits, but then the city following up with a hard cap of 8 guests. I believe that if there is an implementation of the IPMC code for occupancy limits, the city should allow this code to set the limits. This gives a much more clear message to owners, managers, and guests that occupancy is based off of square footage rather than an arbitrary number. If this is truly an international code that is referenced across different cities, states, and countries, then we should allow this code to do it's job in our city. Thank you. • Scott Bevers, 182 Dunnemann Ave, Charleston SC 29403 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Dear City Staff, My company has managed hundreds of stays each month for many years, and we have had very few, if any, livability-related violations connected to our guests, including noise complaints. I believe the City should carefully review the actual history of violations and enforcement before moving forward with such a significant change. I am not asking for occupancy to go unregulated. I support applying the stricter, established occupancy standards already used for residential housing under the IPMC. Those standards are substantial, objective, and based on the actual size and layout of a property. What I am asking is that the City avoid layering an arbitrary cap on top of those standards in a way that could undermine years of responsible investment and growth in a neighborhood that many property owners have worked hard to improve. Additionally I am formally requesting that this Planning Commission agenda item be deferred until August, when more residents and property owners are in town and able to participate. This amendment is being advanced during the summer without enough time for meaningful public input, a thorough review of the facts, or a complete analysis of the economic impact. A decision with consequences this significant should not be rushed. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Scott Bevers • Kaitlin Walter, 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting My name is Kaitlin, and I'm a long-term Charleston resident and host who relies on short- term rental income earned in full compliance with the city's existing permitting process. I'm asking Council to reconsider the three provisions under review tonight, because they punish responsible hosts far more than they curb bad behavior. Regarding the proposed STR guest limit: While I run a very small 3 person max B&B, the occupancy caps would be a detriment to hosts with appropriate space for large groups. Weddings are a core part of the Charleston economy, and I know many brides who have used local B&B spaces for their family to stay together, and/or get ready together. A flat number ignores how Charleston actually sells itself - it's built and marketed a real economy around large- group travel. Searching for the data isn't hard: In 2025 alone, the Charleston area hosted roughly 3,737 weddings, with an average guest count of 150 people, and total wedding- Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 6 related spending reaching over $138.6 million. Bachelorette travel follows the same pattern: Charleston is consistently ranked among the top bachelorette destinations in the country, and the average bachelorette group runs about 10 people, spending an average of around $10,800 per trip. Citywide, tourism drove a record $14.35 billion in economic impact in 2025. Eliminating AirBnB housing opportunities will directly impact downtown shops, restaurants, and businesses catering to group events. Regarding the five-year exterior-change penalty: Homeowners already navigate a building permit process for exterior work. Layering a five-year STR penalty on top doesn't add safety or neighborhood protection — it just tells owners that improving, expanding and maintaining their property, could cost them their livelihood for half a decade. That's not regulation; that's a disincentive to invest in your home. As a single female trying to ensure financial success, I completed an overhaul of my property to add a garage, mother-in-law suite and pool. This rule would have eliminated my ability to effectively finance these improvements. Why should a homeowner be penalized for adding value to their property? The interior square-footage comparison. The second proposal would have the city compare the square footage of "residential" space to "short-term rental" space inside a home to judge whether an owner is sharing too much of it with guests. Hosts already disclose the size and layout of their rental space as part of the current permit application — that information is on file. Adding a new, subjective ratio test on top of what's already submitted doesn't close a gap; it duplicates a disclosure the city already has and turns it into a discretionary judgment call about how someone uses their own home. Why this matters beyond these rules? Charleston built its STR permitting system to bring hosts into a transparent, accountable framework — and most of us have stayed in it because it is workable and fair. Rules like these change that calculus. When compliance becomes unpredictable — when adding on a garage or a porch, or being reevaluated on already-disclosed floor plan can retroactively jeopardize a permit — hosts stop investing in their properties and stop trusting the process. That's the opposite of what responsible regulation should do. It doesn't stop bad actors; it makes it harder for the compliant ones to keep going. And it makes it clear that Charleston doesn't want to support its small-business citizens - it wants hotels. • Michael Ulliman, 216 Ashley Avenue Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I am an STR property and business owner in Cannon-Elliotborough. When the City created the STR zone to attract investment to an underdeveloped part of downtown, I invested significant capital to revitalize five properties that had sat untouched for decades — in direct reliance on the framework the City established after in-depth consideration and acknowledgement of the benefits that would come to the City as a result. That investment, alongside my peers', brought millions of guests, Michelin-rated restaurants, small businesses, and substantial tax revenue that has helped support the broader community and elevate Charleston as a top destination. I support evidence- based regulation, but FOIA requests have produced no evidence of elevated violations within the STR zone relative to the rest of the peninsula, and the City hasn't clearly identified a problem that is tied to the properties in the STR zone. In addition, the proposed 8-person cap punishes compliant operators with larger properties regardless of their violation history, discourages the large-group visitors who are a critical driver of Charleston's wedding, hospitality, and small business economy, and — per the City's own Economic Impact Study — will produce negative short- and long-term economic consequences. I support the 2-person-per-bedroom-plus-2 framework used by peer cities as a fair and proportionate alternative. The City could then work with property owners and managers to resolve any issues without changing the regulations so significantly and to the detriment of all who have invested in the City and these communities. Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 7 • Robert Mentzer, 82 Spring Street Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Dear City Staff, Ahead of tomorrow's Planning Commission meeting, I wanted to share some concerns regarding the proposed occupancy cap in our neighborhood. First, I'd ask the Commission to consider the history of the "4 unrelated persons" standard. For years, this has been understood by both the city and the neighborhood as effectively non- enforceable and not grounded in practical logic. That understanding has been consistent and well known, and city permits, approvals, and new builds have all moved forward on that basis. It's concerning to see this history now recast as though property owners have been bad actors all along, when in fact everyone operated under a shared, long-standing understanding. That context matters here because the IPMC alone will already limit occupancy by 25% or more. An arbitrary cap on top of that would jeopardize the livelihoods of hundreds of property owners and isn't grounded in any clear evaluation of square footage or established occupancy code standards. For example, two families traveling together with their children (nine guests total) would no longer be able to visit Charleston as a group, and that kind of group represents a large share of our guests. I'd ask the city to take time to understand why this measure is being pushed so aggressively without fuller diligence, both on the economic impact and on the actual infraction history. On that point: my company handles hundreds of stays a month, and has for many years, with few to zero livability-related infractions tied to our guests (noise included). We respectfully ask staff to recognize that we are willing to apply the stricter, more established occupancy code already used for housing under IPMC (which is significant on its own), rather than undermine decades of growth and investment that have helped build what is now a great neighborhood. Also, I officially request this PC meeting topic on the STR amendment to be deferred to when more people are in town from summer vacations. This amendment is being pushed through in summer months without proper diligence in decision making or getting the facts right. Please defer this topic for more time to be thoughtfully spent and more people to be engaged that are part of the neighborhood. Thank you for your time and consideration. With respect. • Casey Anderson, 71 Bogard St, Charleston, 29403 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Dear Members of Charleston Planning Commission and City Staff, My name is Casey Anderson, and I have owned and lived at 71 Bogard Street in Cannonborough- Elliotborough since 2012. During that time, I have watched our neighborhood evolve while continuing to be a vibrant and desirable place to call home. Throughout my time here, I have lived alongside short-term rentals and have never personally experienced the kinds of problems that are often cited as justification for additional restrictions. From my perspective as a full-time resident, well-managed short-term rentals have coexisted with homeowners without diminishing the quality of life in our neighborhood. I also previously owned and operated a high-end, five-bedroom short-term rental on Spring Street. During my ownership, the property was professionally managed, attracted respectful guests, and never created issues with noise, parties, or disturbances for the surrounding neighbors. That experience reinforced my belief that responsible ownership and management—not arbitrary occupancy limits—are what determine whether a short- term rental is a good neighbor. For that reason, I believe the proposed eight-person occupancy limit is arbitrary and unnecessary. A one-size-fits-all cap fails to consider the size and design of individual homes or the fact that many larger homes are well-suited for extended families or multiple generations traveling together. More importantly, it does not distinguish between responsible operators with a proven track record and those who fail to manage their properties appropriately. I respectfully encourage the Council to Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 8 focus on enforcing regulations that address genuine nuisances and bad actors rather than adopting blanket occupancy limits that unnecessarily burden responsible property owners. My experience—as both a longtime resident of Cannonborough-Elliotborough and a former owner of a successful short-term rental—has shown me that well-managed short-term rentals can exist harmoniously within residential neighborhoods. Thank you for your time, your service, and your thoughtful consideration of this issue. Respectfully, Casey Anderson 71 Bogard Street Charleston, SC • John Robbins, 15 Felix street Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Not necessary! Completely disagree and do not support amendment. Owner at 15 Felix street • McCrea Stern, 13 Johnson road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Oppose • Alexander Nicholson, 128 Columbus Street Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting To the Charleston City Planning Commission, My wife and I own two short-term rental properties—a five-bedroom and a six-bedroom unit. We don't own our own home because we have invested our life savings into building this business and restoring properties in Charleston. We are a small, husband-and-wife operation supported by roughly ten employees, and this business is our family's primary source of income. We support most of the proposed STR Amendment and the adoption of the IPMC Standards. Our primary concern is the proposed expiration of grandfathered occupancy for larger units upon the sale of a property. If larger, legally operating STRs like ours lose their grandfathered occupancy when they are sold, the property' s value will decline substantially because the next owner would be forced to operate at a lower occupancy. For us alone, that loss would exceed one million dollars in value, and thus we would not be able to repay our mortgages after selling. STRs are owned by small retail investors like us - not large companies - and so all of the small "mom-and-pop" owners would be in the same situation, creating financial hardship from which they/we could not recover. I appreciate the discussion about allowing future owners to apply to retain grandfathered occupancy. Unfortunately, that process does not solve the underlying problem. Buyers do not pay full value for rights that are uncertain. A simple analogy is buying a new car. Imagine a dealership tells you the car comes without its two front wheels, but after you buy it (at full price), you can apply at City Hall to receive them. However, the application may or may not be approved. Most buyers would either walk away or insist on paying significantly less. The uncertainty itself reduces the value of the car. Real estate works the same way. The only way to preserve the value of an existing, legally operating STR is to allow it to transfer with the same grandfathered occupancy rights under which it was purchased and operated. If those rights disappear upon sale—or even become subject to an uncertain approval process—the market value of the property (and life savings for folks like us) inevitably declines. I hope the Commission will consider the unintended consequences this would have on small business owners like us. This Amendment has caused great distress to us and thrown our family’s future into jeopardy. Small business owners have invested heavily in Charleston and have played an important role in the revitalization of Spring and Cannon Streets. For us, short-term rentals are not a hobby or Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 9 a side investment—they are our business, our livelihood, and the result of years of hard work and personal financial risk. Thank you again for your consideration and for your service to the City of Charleston. • Jacki Landon, 13299 Escena Ct Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I support IPMC as the occupancy standard, we want the code to set the number with no separate cap on top, and we want enforcement focused on nuisance behavior. IPMC alone will already meaningfully reduce occupancy across the neighborhood. As a mother of 3 young children who frequently travels with other families or extended family members and their children - I feel this restriction is unfair & limits my and families similar to mine ability to travel. • David Betts, 89 Cannon Street, Charleston, SC 29403 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Members of the Planning Commission: My name is David Betts. I have worked in Charleston’s vacation-rental industry for 12 years and have spent much of that time working directly with City zoning, building, and short-term-rental staff. I am submitting these comments in opposition to the proposed amendment, particularly the arbitrary eight-person occupancy and advertising cap. The City has characterized the amendment as increasing permitted occupancy from four unrelated adults to eight occupants. That characterization does not reflect how the current ordinance has actually been interpreted, administered, or enforced over the past eight years. Over the years, City zoning and STR staff repeatedly advised us that the four-unrelated-person provision was not practically enforceable. At the same time, the City continued to review, permit, and approve large homes intended for accommodations use. In several situations, City staff recommended that duplexes be converted into single-family homes that would then operate as short-term rentals. Property owners and developers reasonably relied on that guidance and on the City’s longstanding administration of the ordinance. For example, we have worked closely with the City for approximately four years on the entitlement of 122 Cannon Street, which will include the restoration of a converted triplex back into a proposed single family home, that would be a six-bedroom accommodations project. At The Charlee, we developed large homes specifically designed to accommodate groups comfortably. These projects were not concealed from the City. They were openly reviewed, permitted, and developed with the knowledge that they would be used as accommodations. Substantial investments were made based on that regulatory framework. It is inequitable to permit and encourage the development of large accommodations and then impose a retroactive occupancy cap that prevents those properties from operating as they were designed and underwritten. The proposed eight- person cap is also not a life-safety standard. Under the existing ordinance, the same home may accommodate more than eight people when the guests qualify as a family. The physical safety of a building does not change based on whether the occupants are related to one another. Occupancy should therefore be based on the applicable building, fire, and property-maintenance codes, including bedroom size, means of egress, fire protection, and the safe capacity of the structure. The vast majority of short-term rentals in the neighborhood would still accommodate fewer than eight guests under those standards. However, the limited number of homes designed and approved for larger groups should be allowed to operate at their lawful and safe capacity. The amendment also appears to rely on the assumption that groups larger than eight are primarily disruptive bachelorette parties. That is not an accurate representation of group travel in Charleston. Larger groups include extended families, wedding guests, reunions, golf groups, milestone celebrations, older travelers, and lifelong friends who want to stay Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 10 together. My own 75-year-old mother has traveled to Charleston with a group of high school friends that sometimes exceeds eight people. They choose to share a home because they want to spend time together and make the trip more affordable. Group size alone is not a reliable indicator of guest behavior. A responsible group of ten should not be presumed to create a greater livability concern than an irresponsible group of six. The Cannonborough-Elliottborough Hospitality Alliance has also reviewed City records obtained through the Freedom of Information Act. That review has not demonstrated that Cannonborough-Elliottborough experiences greater short-term-rental-related livability problems than surrounding neighborhoods. We continue to hear generalized claims regarding noise, trash, and neighborhood disruption, but those claims should be supported by documented evidence before the City adopts a broad restriction affecting every property and responsible traveler. We have also received written statements from neighbors surrounding The Charlee, one of our largest developments and a property designed primarily for group travel, stating that they have not experienced noise or other livability problems resulting from the development. Charleston does face legitimate challenges involving late-night activity, public safety, and conditions along King Street. Those challenges deserve serious attention. However, short-term rentals and larger vacation-rental groups should not become a convenient substitute for identifying and addressing the actual sources of those problems. We support reasonable regulation, strong enforcement, responsible property management, and meaningful penalties for operators or guests who create documented problems. We do not support an arbitrary cap that treats every larger group as a nuisance and retroactively undermines investments that the City reviewed, guided, and approved. I respectfully request that the Planning Commission recommend against the proposed eight-person cap and instead require occupancy to be determined under the applicable life-safety and property- maintenance codes. Enforcement should focus on actual misconduct, not assumptions based solely on the number or relationship of the guests. Thank you for your consideration. David Betts YOURPAD • Alyssa Demilio, 2181 parkway drive Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting As the owner of Demilio Design, I oppose the STR ordinance amendment in its current form. Over the last 10 years, I have worked throughout Cannonborough-Elliotborough and the surrounding neighborhoods, helping property owners thoughtfully restore, furnish, and improve homes that serve Charleston visitors. These owners have invested a great deal of money into the neighborhood, not just to create rental properties, but to create well-designed, well-maintained homes that attract respectful guests and groups. From my perspective, the neighborhood has only improved over that time. I have seen homes renovated, streets become more active, local businesses benefit from visitors, and property owners take pride in the way their homes are presented and operated. I have not seen these properties create the types of widespread issues being suggested. Clear and enforceable rules are important, but this amendment goes too far. It risks punishing responsible owners and businesses who have helped improve the neighborhood and who have operated within the rules for years. Please oppose the amendment in its current form and support a more balanced approach that protects neighborhoods while respecting the investment, design work, local businesses, and economic activity that responsible STRs support. • Ham Morrison, 9 gibbes st Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I recently worked with the city for STR approval of my 3200 sq foot 6 bedroom property on 255 Saint Philip (comm STR in the overlay). It’s was a lengthy process of 1 year Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 11 involving the fire department and city planning and building officials. I was asked to add some windows which I did. I borrowed funds to make it happen. I worked extensively on up-fitting and furnishing the historic property to enable the ability to successfully host larger families for their gatherings. This ordinance proposal now limits the homes potential to host and stresses the ability to payback borrowed funds from my approved project. Please reject this amendment and allow at least two per bedroom in houses this size. At the very minimum a grandfathering of this project and others like it will limit the cities potential liability in enacting this restriction. STR’s have been a positive for this neighborhood supporting city tax coffers and local business. I asked the livability department what is driving this and there was no clear answer. In other words this does not appear to be driven by citizen complaints. Why push tax revenue off the peninsula? Thank you for listening and considering • Kyle OKeefe, 38 Riverside Drive, Charleston, SC 29403 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Dear Zoning and Planning Team, My name is Kyle O'Keefe, and I appreciate the opportunity to share my perspective. My primary concern is the proposal to impose a blanket occupancy limit of eight guests on all short-term rental properties, regardless of the number of legally approved bedrooms. While I understand the City's desire to address neighborhood concerns, I believe this approach would have significant unintended consequences for existing property owners, the local economy, and City tax revenue. For owners of larger, legally approved commercial short-term rentals, reducing occupancy to eight guests is effectively a reduction in the property's permitted use after substantial investments have already been made. Many of these properties were specifically designed, renovated, and approved to accommodate larger families, wedding groups, reunions, and multigenerational gatherings. An eight-person limit substantially changes the economic viability of these investments. Had this regulation existed when we renovated our larger properties several years ago, we would have designed them differently. Our investment decisions—including renovation costs, financing, zoning approvals, fire sprinkler systems, fire alarm systems, and life safety improvements—were all made based on the understanding that the approved bedroom count could be utilized as intended. Many owners have invested millions of dollars into these properties over the past several years because the City's zoning framework provided confidence and predictability. Financing was obtained based on projected revenue, which is directly tied to the number of usable bedrooms. A sudden reduction in occupancy could materially reduce cash flow, diminish property values, and potentially create compliance issues with existing loan covenants for many owners. There are also broader implications for the City. Properties with higher income potential have historically sold for higher prices, resulting in increased property tax revenue. If these larger properties lose a significant portion of their earning capacity, their market values will inevitably decline. Owners would effectively be left paying taxes based on purchase prices that reflected income potential that no longer exists. Another point raised during the last in person discussion deserves careful consideration: a universal eight-person cap may unintentionally shift demand toward smaller units while disproportionately harming larger properties that were specifically developed to accommodate larger families. This does not reduce overall tourism demand—it simply redistributes it. Moreover, groups of eight would then try to fit into small one bedroom or two bedroom apartments. A more balanced approach would be to follow the occupancy model used by neighboring jurisdictions such as Mount Pleasant, which generally allows two occupants per bedroom. This standard better reflects the actual size and intended use of a property while still establishing a reasonable occupancy limit. If the City ultimately decides to adopt an eight-person cap, I respectfully request that existing legally approved larger short-term rentals be Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 12 grandfathered under the current occupancy standards. Property owners made significant long-term investments in reliance on the regulations that existed at the time. Applying a new restriction retroactively would unfairly penalize those who acted in good faith under the City's established rules. I respectfully ask the City to carefully consider the financial, legal, and economic consequences of this proposal before adopting a blanket occupancy limit. At a minimum, I encourage consideration of either: • An occupancy standard based on two guests per approved bedroom; or • Grandfathering existing legally approved larger short-term rental properties. Thank you again for your time, your willingness to hear from stakeholders, and your thoughtful consideration of these comments. Sincerely, Kyle O'Keefe • Meagan Okeefe, 9 Legare Street Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting To the Members of Charleston City Council, I am writing to express my strong opposition to the proposed ordinance that would impose a blanket occupancy limit of eight guests for all short-term rental properties, regardless of the number of legally permitted bedrooms. Charleston has spent years developing a comprehensive framework to regulate short-term rentals. Owners have invested under that framework, complying with zoning requirements, overlay districts, annual licensing, life safety inspections, fire code requirements, parking regulations, and numerous other operational standards. Those rules created a predictable regulatory environment that allowed property owners, lenders, and investors to make informed long-term decisions. The proposed occupancy cap fundamentally changes those expectations. A one-size-fits-all limit of eight guests ignores the fact that not all legally permitted short-term rentals are the same. A professionally inspected four-bedroom home designed to safely accommodate larger groups should not be treated the same as a much smaller property. Occupancy should be tied to objective safety standards and the physical characteristics of the home—not an arbitrary number. The stated rationale also appears inconsistent with existing laws. Charleston has long distinguished between unrelated occupants living together and families or other lawful groups occupying a home. The previous occupancy rules addressed residential living arrangements, not the temporary use of legally permitted accommodations. Families gathering for reunions, weddings, graduations, holidays, and other occasions have always been able to occupy homes differently than unrelated long- term residents. Applying an eight-person cap to every short-term rental disregards that distinction without demonstrating a corresponding public safety benefit. Equally important is the financial impact. Many owners invested hundreds of thousands of dollars renovating properties to comply with the City’s requirements, often restoring historic homes and improving neighborhoods. Those investments were made based on the regulations in place at the time. Financial institutions also underwrote loans using projected income that reflected legally permitted occupancy. A significant reduction in allowable occupancy would materially reduce revenue for many properties, diminish property values, and place owners in a position they could not reasonably have anticipated when making these investments. If the City’s concern is life safety or neighborhood impacts, those issues should be addressed through enforceable safety standards, noise enforcement, parking regulations, and existing inspection requirements—not through an arbitrary occupancy cap that bears little relationship to a property’s size, design, or approved bedroom count. Charleston has long been recognized for creating a thoughtful regulatory system that balances neighborhood preservation with responsible tourism. This proposal moves away from that balanced approach and instead penalizes owners who have complied with every rule the City has established. I respectfully ask the Council to reject the proposed blanket occupancy cap and instead preserve an occupancy framework that reflects a property’s legal bedroom Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 13 count, compliance with applicable building and fire codes, and the regulatory structure that owners have relied upon for years. Thank you for your consideration. • Jason Stern, 13 Johnson Rd, Charleston SC 29407 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I oppose this amendment. • Michael Gates, 129 Cannon Street Charleston SC 29403 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting My name is Michael Gates, and I own a home at 129 Cannon Street. The City approved it in 2018 as a six bedroom that sleeps twelve, and I have relied on that approval ever since. I am proud of how it is run. In all those years it has never had a single noise, trash, or parking complaint, and it passes its fire safety inspection every year. The City's own records, released through a Freedom of Information request, show no complaints anywhere about the number of guests staying in a home. There is no problem here to fix. What the eight person cap would really do is turn away the large families and multigenerational groups who need one roof, one kitchen, and one table. Charleston says it wants families, and this is how families visit. I am not asking to expand anything. I am only asking the City to honor the use it already approved. Please grandfather existing, lawfully permitted homes at their approved occupancy. Thank you for considering my perspective. • Tyler Lisk, 101 Blairmore Dr, Charleston, SC 29414 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting The proposed short-term rental ordinance, as written, would unfairly harm Charleston property owners, local businesses, employees, and the city's economy. While thoughtful regulation is appropriate, this amendment goes far beyond that by threatening legally operating businesses that have served Charleston responsibly for years. Please vote against the ordinance in its current form and support a balanced approach that protects neighborhoods without undermining local investment, jobs, and responsible short-term rentals. • Peter Sniderman, 116 Kindred Lane Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting We support IPMC as the occupancy standard, we want the code to set the number with no separate cap on top, and we want enforcement focused on nuisance behavior. IPMC alone will already meaningfully reduce occupancy across the neighborhood. We do expect a negative impact on property values with IPMC; however, an additional cap could significantly reduce the value and livelihoods many of us have spent years building. B. REZONINGS 1. 2298 Mt. Pleasant St. & 1302 Hester St. Peninsula | TMS# 4641300029 & 4641300030 | Council District 4 | Approx. 0.24 ac. Request to rezone from Single Family Residential (SR-1) to General Office (GO). Owner: 2298 Mt. Pleasant Street Adams LLC & Danette Rouse-Grant Applicant: Franklin Adams 1 Comment Submitted: • Franklin Adams, 2322 Sunnyside Ave, Charleston SC Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting We have lived int he neighborhood for over 20 years and fully support this application for re-zoning Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 14 2. DEFERRED|806 Magnolia Rd. West Ashley | TMS# 4180900030 | Council District 9 | Approx. 2.1 ac. Request to rezone from Single-Family Residential (SR-2) to Diverse Residential (DR-9). Owner: Albert J Gobel Jr. Applicant: STYO C. SUBDIVISIONS 1. Riverland Oaks James Island | TMS# 3430000002 | Council District 11 | Approx. 27.82 ac. Request Concept Plan approval for a 95-lot townhome development. Owner: Venn James Island, LLC Applicant: Sitecast, LLC 139 Comments Submitted: • Celia Baker, 326 Cheraw Dr Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Hello, thank you for reading my comment. While I have only owned my house on Cheraw Dr for 3 years, my sister lived in Riverland terrace for 20 years now and I am well accustom to how much traffic has changed over the years. The project that is being suggested could bring up to 200 more cars per day for the daily commute. That’s a lot considering we already get caught up in the John’s island traffic. We do not need another subdivision on Maybank. The thing that makes James island so wonderful is how many trees we still have here. Please consider this before approving this application to pass. Thank you so much! • Sara Bell, 1431 Battle Ground Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting We need tracts of land to stay untouched for wildlife habitat and to prevent the flooding that always results from runoff no matter the retention pond built. It is an increasing amount of gridlock traffic around the island even in the middle of the day. It’s not practical to think the island can absorb hundreds of more people. • Jeffrey Denison, 4905 Amberwood ln. N Charleston Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This is all lowland with beautiful trees that they're claiming are defective so that means they want to cut them down. This will make traffic and flooding horrible and it is totally out of character with the neighborhood with those tall Giant buildings. This must be much smaller if at all • Lind Whidfon, 1700 Lotus Lane Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Stop destroying our natural environment. More traffic more pollution over crowded schools. Infrastructure is not substantiated for this development behind the Pour House. Keep James Island livable preserve our ecology • Autumn Fralix, 1243 oxbow drive Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This is absurd! The flooding - the traffic - the roads - cannot handle anymore development ! Stop allowing every inch to be developed!!! I spend a fortune saving wildlife because builders don’t care - humans should care! The ecosystem is trashed because of constantly agreeing to terrible builds - and agreeing to insane amounts of Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 15 added people and traffic! Fix the roads! Fix the issues for those who are native - have lived here our whole lives! Fox it for THE PEOPLE & stop adding more nonsense! • Hillary Sisson, 107 Nassau st Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Please vote NO ON TGE APPROVAL OF THIS SUBDIVISION. Continuing to allow the building on flood plains is only going ruin the beauty, swindle house buyers into buying property that is built on land not meant for building, and making traffic even worse. Please don’t allow what has happened to downtown, John’s island , mt p, and Summerville to happen on James Island. The greed factor is alive and well please don’t contribute tonit • Collin James, 631 Stoneboro court, Charleston SC, 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Good morning, Chairperson and members of the Committee. My name is Collin James, and I live at 631 Stoneboro Ct. I am writing and submitting this statement of opposition on behalf of myself and many concerned neighbors to formally voice our opposition to the proposed 95-lot townhome development. While we understand the need for growth, the sheer scale and location of this project pose severe risks to our community's safety, environment, and quality of life. It is simply too much for this specific area to absorb. The proposed site sits on existing wetlands. Wetlands are not empty space; they are vital, natural infrastructure that absorbs stormwater and prevents environmental disasters. Our local roads are already at a breaking point. A 95-lot townhome development will realistically introduce 150 to 200 additional vehicles to our immediate streets daily. A development of this density requires infrastructure that simply does not exist here. I am asking you, our planning committee, to prioritize the safety and stability of the current community over the profits of this high-density project. Please vote no on this proposal and protect our wetlands, our roads, and our homes. Thank you for your time and your service to our community. • Rebecca Luhrs, 1654 Wading Heron Rd Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This area is too congested already!! Want more flooding, or more traffic?? Heck no! • Laura Chandler, 1039 Secessionville Rd James Island Sc 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Members of Town Council, Enough is enough. For years, residents have watched as too many decisions have favored development with little regard for the people who already live here, and residents like myself are tired of it. Our roads are beyond capacity, our schools are overcrowded, and traffic and flooding across the island continue to worsen with every new project. Yet you continue to consider new developments before addressing the infrastructure that is already failing. This proposed development, Riverland Oaks, is just another example. Where is the stormwater plan that will actually protect the residents on Stefan Drive and Woodland Shores Road? Promises are not enough. We have seen what happens time and time again when trees are cleared, land is filled, and developments move forward without adequate stormwater management. Longtime residents are left paying the price with flooded yards, flooded streets that rarely flooded in the past, and damaged property. James Island is a low-lying community. That is not new information. We have already experienced increasing flooding because of poorly managed runoff from development. Trees are cleared, land is filled, and projects move forward without adequately addressing drainage. Continuing to approve developments without requiring infrastructure that can truly handle the Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 16 increased runoff is irresponsible. Residents are asking for common sense. We need improved drainage and stormwater systems, better roads, and additional schools before any more large-scale development is approved. Infrastructure should come first—not after the damage has already been done. And let's be honest: projects like the Rethink Folly Road median proposal do nothing to address the real issues facing this community. They don't solve flooding. They don't reduce overcrowding. They don't create school capacity. They don't fix failing infrastructure. Your responsibility is to all the people who already call James Island home—not just developers seeking the next project. Before approving even more development, we need to fix the problems we already have. It is time to stop putting developers ahead of residents. Put a pause on new development until our infrastructure can support it. Protect the community you were elected to serve before approving projects that will only make these problems worse. The people of James Island deserve better. It's time for this Council to start putting residents first. • Erin Renner, 2017 Lanneau Lane Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I vote no • Lee Price, 1166 Euclid Drive Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I vote no for the development of the wetlands behind Maybank Highway. • Theresa Ray, 1391 Camp Road Charleston, SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting -Neighborhood Character: While the proposal has been downsized, a 95-unit mixed- density development remains too dense for an area characterized by SR-1 single-family homes in Woodland Shores and Riverland Terrace. The DR-6 zoning of this tract is an isolated "red flag" that disregards the surrounding single-family scale. - Infrastructure Overload: The $1.3 million Hollings Road drainage improvements were intended to provide relief for existing residents, not to subsidize high-density infill. Paving this 28-acre watershed will generate millions of gallons of runoff, likely overwhelming new infrastructure before it is fully operational. - Drainage and Displacement: Filling this 28- acre basin will elevate the water table, pushing water into the crawlspaces and foundations of adjacent properties. - Open Space Misrepresentation: Counting mandatory stormwater retention ponds as "open space" is a disingenuous interpretation of the City's Comprehensive Plan, as these utilities provide no recreational value. - Environmental Policy Gap: Approving this density on a wetland buffer contradicts the City's stated goals for resilience and canopy preservation. We request the Commission require an independent, cumulative watershed impact study rather than a localized review. We request an enforcement of stronger step-down density buffers, increased rear setbacks, and mandatory vegetative screening along shared property • Julie Walters, 331 Pageland rd Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This would increase the flooding along that area. It would even create more problem in the central Park Road area. The congestion is far too much on Maybank Highway as is and I oppose this plan. • Olivia MacDonald, 366 Woodland Shores Rd Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 17 This proposed development does not align with the city of Charleston’s comprehensive plan. 88% of people surveyed for the plan want more green space and areas for recreational use. This proposed subdivision will eliminate the last green belt in the area, directly opposing what current residents want. Does the developer intend to use any of the space for recreational use? For example walking trails or biking paths. Charleston is loosing tree canopy coverage. How will the removal of grand trees be handled? There are many areas throughout the development listed as jurisdictional wetland. How will adding fill dirt to the area change flood water drainage for the surrounding existing houses? The comprehensive plan recommends green infrastructure and wetland buffers for stormwater infrastructure. Eliminating large swaths of trees for tract housing and adding storm water ponds directly opposes the city’s comprehensive plan. Having the main entrance on a neighborhood road also contradicts the city’s traffic goals. Personal vehicle use on Maybank highway will increase while pedestrian and bike traffic will decrease. Many families have voiced they do not feel safe walking with their kids or biking with an increase of through traffic of more than 95 cars on the neighborhood road. As a resident of the direct surrounding area, I am firmly against this proposed development as it has a negative community impact and is not aligned with the city of Charleston’s comprehensive plan. • Payton Messner, 238 Stefan Dr, Apt C Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting To call a subdivision Riverland “Oaks” after cutting down 28 acres of trees is not only appalling, but downright disrespectful. Please do not let this land be torn down and turned into congested townhouses. This ecosystem is essential to the health of James Island. I live on Stefan Dr. and many many animals live in and rely on this wooded space. Maybank traffic is already very dangerous; I witness near-accidents every day with the instillation of the new median in front of Pour House/ Terrace Theater, and adding more housing here will only cause more issues and potential fatalities. The flooding is already an issue on Stefan Dr. with the addition of houses here in the past 10 years. Townhouses and single family units have been flooding with every heavy rain and cause great damage. This geographical area cannot afford more housing, please please do not approve 95 townhouses. • Garrett Beinbrink, 8520 BF Drive Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting NO. NO NO NO. Y’all do see that they’re trying to destroy every piece of Charleston that exists, right? This is an AWFUL and unmitigated DISASTER that will line the pockets of developers at the expense of the people who live here. Please think about the people who already live here instead of everyone else. Please. • Rachel Hawes, 2126 Edisto Ave Charleston, SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Please vote no on subdivision approval for Riverland Oaks. There is no infrastructure to handle that type of addition in the already congested area. Many homes already flood in the area - adding impervious surface to an already flooding area COUPLED with the fact that the subdivision would be filling in some much needed wetlands, is a reckless idea. Please vote no! - a resident of Riverland Terrace • Nathan West, 404 Woodland Shores Rd Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 18 I am writing to respectfully urge the Planning Commission to vote against subdivision approval for the proposed Riverland Oaks development. I live on Woodland Shores Road at the corner where the primary entrance to this development is proposed. My home will be directly affected by this project, and I ask that you carefully consider the long-term impacts on the surrounding neighborhood before approving this subdivision. My greatest concern is stormwater and flooding. This property is located within a Special Flood Protection Zone, yet I remain unconvinced that the proposed stormwater system can adequately manage runoff from a development of this density. The plans include extensive impervious surfaces, numerous roadways and driveways, and significant changes to the existing landscape. As a nearby homeowner, I worry that these changes will increase flooding risks for existing neighborhoods on Woodland Shores Road and Stefan Drive, which already experience drainage challenges during heavy rain events. I am also concerned about the scale of this development. Ninety-five townhomes, buildings reaching up to three stories in height, and a large increase in traffic represent a dramatic change for this established residential area. As someone who lives at the entrance, I will experience the daily impacts of increased vehicle traffic, congestion, noise, and safety concerns. Woodland Shores Road already serves existing residents, pedestrians, cyclists, and school traffic, and adding a development of this size deserves careful scrutiny. Additionally, I ask the Commission to consider the environmental impacts of developing a site that contains wetlands and numerous mature trees. These natural features play an important role in stormwater management, wildlife habitat, and the character of James Island. Once they are altered or removed, they cannot easily be replaced. I recognize that this property is zoned for development, and I understand the need for responsible growth. However, zoning alone should not guarantee approval of a subdivision plan if there are legitimate concerns regarding flooding, infrastructure capacity, compatibility with surrounding neighborhoods, and protection of natural resources. As a homeowner whose property sits at the entrance to this proposed development, I respectfully ask the Planning Commission to deny subdivision approval for Riverland Oaks in its current form and require a plan that better protects neighboring residents, addresses stormwater concerns, and is more compatible with the existing community. Thank you for your time, your service, and your careful consideration of this important decision. Sincerely, Nathan West 404 Woodland Shores Road Charleston, SC 29412 • Carson Seabrook, 1272 Calais Drive Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Please VOTE NO to “Subdivision Approval” for the terrible “Riverland Oaks” 95- townhomes development to be located behind the Charleston Pour House. This is a low- lying, special protection flood zone. There is NO stormwater plan for this property that can manage the run-off that will surely impact residents on Stefan Dr and on Woodland Shores Rd. • Paul Gaskins, 1749 Ashworth Lane Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting The development on James Island and John's Island is out of control and our elected officials need to stop letting the developers buy them out. Having been born and raised on James Island, I never thought I'd see such ridiculous traffic and people selling out to developers in a way that turns a serene island into the mess it has become. It all needs to stop now to keep a little of it's serenity! • Christine Cronin, 290 Stefan Drive Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 19 This proposal to build 95 townhouses will increase traffic on Maybank highway, remove trees that soak up rain, and cause flooding in my back yard. More concrete = more flooding! Stop the building, preserve life. • Susan Morrison, 2173 westrivers road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I live in riverland terrace across Maybank highway from the proposed development. There is already too much traffic on Maybank highway and the property is too low to support the project without trees to absorb the water. Vote no please • Matthew Talamo, 388 Stefan Drive Charleston, SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I own 2 homes on Stefan Drive (both on the side that backs up to this project). One I live in, the other I rent out. These woods are beautiful and very wet. I'm worried about post project drainage, more homes going up where there shouldn't be homes in the first place (like the Peninsula/Daniel Ellis disaster w/ foundation issues), and the destruction of one of the few remaining wooded areas on James Island. My tenant is worried about construction noises and a 3 story townhome towering behind her and looking down into the yard. I hear owls back there every night, tons of bats live back there, so many frogs, I enjoy watching the birds fly into my yard and back to the trees during the day. There are just so many very large trees which I just can't stand to see continuously getting chopped down around the island. This project is unnecessary and inevitably at a 600k+ price tag will continue to price out locals and price out lower income low country residents. Please Deny this project and save one of the few remaining untouched green spaces we have. Thank you. • Heather Roy, 2168 Stonewood dr Charleston SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This is a low-lying, special protection flood zone. There is NO stormwater plan for this property that can manage the run-off that will surely impact residents on Stefan Dr and on Woodland Shores Rd. As a resident of Riverland terrace this is some of the last woodlands in walking distance of our house and we prefer to keep the trees providing oxygen, animal habitats, and stormwater mitigation!!!! VOTE NO!!! • Tangi Thomas, 910 Travers Drive Charleston, SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I am writing as a concerned James Island resident to respectfully ask the Planning Commission to vote against subdivision approval for the proposed Riverland Oaks development. I understand that growth is inevitable, and I support responsible development when it is appropriate for the location. However, I do not believe this proposal is the right project for this site. This property is located within a low-lying Special Flood Protection Zone, in an area that already experiences flooding concerns. Adding 95 townhomes, extensive roadways, driveways, sidewalks, and other impervious surfaces raises serious questions about how additional stormwater will be managed, not only on the property itself, but for the surrounding neighborhoods. Once flooding problems are created, they cannot easily be undone, and it is existing residents who bear the consequences. I am also concerned about the overall intensity of the development. The proposed density, building height, and scale are simply not compatible with the surrounding established neighborhoods. Three-story buildings rising up to 50 feet will dramatically change the character of the area and impact nearby homeowners who have invested in this community for decades. In addition, this project would significantly alter a property that contains wetlands, mature trees, and valuable natural features that help Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 20 define James Island. These environmental resources provide important benefits, including stormwater absorption and wildlife habitat. Once they are lost, they are gone forever. As our region continues to experience heavier rainfall, stronger storms, and increasing flooding challenges, I believe it is more important than ever that development decisions prioritize long-term resilience over short-term density. Approving projects that place additional pressure on environmentally sensitive land puts both current and future residents at risk. I respectfully ask the Commission to consider not only what can be built under current zoning, but whether this proposal truly serves the best interests of the community. I urge you to vote NO on subdivision approval for Riverland Oaks and encourage the applicant to pursue a plan that better protects our neighborhoods, our natural resources, and the long-term future of James Island. Thank you for your time, your service, and your thoughtful consideration. • DeAnn Grayson, 863 Century Place 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Flood and infrastructure issues. Needs more research. • John Glisson, 321 Stefan Drive Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Stefan Drive is one of one a few dead end roads where children can safely play in the streets. We do not want a subdivision built behind us ruining our tranquility just so some millionaire developer can get even more wealthy. Please leave us this space. We don’t need more development. • Kiersten Ahlm, 316 Woodland Shores Rd Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This project will affect our already depleted ecosystem, as well as potentially cause major flooding for the families who have built their lives here • Rachel Huff, 203 Stefan dr. Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This project is poorly planned. This project needs to be redesigned for area and for flooding purposes. • Courtney Farnham, 286 Stefan Dr Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting There a several owls in the wooded area and it would take away their home. This part of maybank highway is already congested enough and not safe with so much traffic. • Jennifer Gibson, 281 Stefan Dr 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Dear Members of the Charleston Planning Commission, I respectfully urge you to vote NO on Agenda Item D.1, the proposed Riverland Oaks subdivision. I am a resident of Stefan Drive, the neighborhood immediately adjacent to the proposed development. My neighbors and I already experience flooding during heavy rain events. I am deeply concerned that adding 95 townhomes, along with the associated roads, driveways, sidewalks, and other impervious surfaces, will increase stormwater runoff and make an existing problem even worse. This property is located within a Special Flood Protection Zone, making thoughtful stormwater management especially critical. While detention Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 21 ponds are proposed, I ask the Commission to carefully consider whether they will adequately protect the surrounding neighborhoods over the long term, particularly as rainfall events become more frequent and more intense. Existing residents should not bear additional flood risk because of new development. I am also concerned about the potential loss of wetlands and mature grand trees that naturally absorb stormwater, provide wildlife habitat, and contribute to the character of James Island. These natural resources are invaluable and cannot easily be replaced once they are removed. I recognize that growth is a part of Charleston's future, but it must occur responsibly and in locations that can support it without placing neighboring communities at greater risk. As someone who lives directly beside this proposed development and already experiences flooding, I ask that you carefully weigh the long-term impacts on the existing community before granting approval. Please vote NO on the Riverland Oaks subdivision as currently proposed. Thank you for your time and consideration. • Paul Langston, 316 Woodland Shores Rd 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Horrible idea for the neighborhood and environment. Way too dense for the space, killing natural wetland habitats with pitcher plants, frogs, lightning bugs, bird nesting areas. Using retention ponds to replace natural wetland areas is basically murdering the plants and animals natural habitat. There is a 20’ buffer zone granted to Woodland Shores neighborhood. We don’t want trees removed from the buffer zone if the project goes through. Drastically increase traffic on an already busy Woddland Shores. • Ben Farnham, 286 Stefan drive Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting The livability of the current residents in the area will be greatly impacted in a negative way. This includes the increased probability of flooding and major traffic concerns on Maybank Hwy. This includes the dangers of hundreds of more cars near pedestrians crossing from one side to the other on Maybank. The exit is right next to the crosswalk. Drivers will only look left to exit and may not notice walkers. The impacts on the environment include the destruction of many nesting barn owls, hawks and many other birds. The destruction of wetlands and thousands of trees. • Joel Harrigan, 345 Woodland Shores Road Charleston SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This is a low lying, special protection flood zone, and how this project can even be considered is INSANE to me. There is NO stormwater plan for this property that can manage the run-off that will impact residentss on both Stefan Drive and Woodland Shores road. Woodland shores already has trouble in certain areas with water when it rains really hard, and removing a ton of trees and adding this site is only going to make things exponentially worse. I moved my family here less than 5 years ago and I love everything about my road now that we have a sidewalk and speed humps that prevent the insane speeding that used to happen on this road. I want to retire here, not to feel like I have no choice but to sell my house after it gets flooded due to this insanity. Please please please vote no. You're making a huge mistake and telling current residents you don't care at all about them, if you do otherwise. • Andrew Brown, 328 stefan drive Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Flooding concern. Cutting down all the trees. • Felicia Brown, 328 Stefan Drive Charleston SC 29412 Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 22 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Please vote no. I have lived on Stefan Drive for 28 years. I do not want my property to have flooding issues because of this development. • Barbara Barriere, 297 Stefan Drive Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting It is too small of an area for 95 homes. The area is already congested and I am fearful of flooding that may occur. I am very opposed to this. • Blaine Gibson, 238 Stefan Dr, Apt C Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Do not approve this plan. The traffic and flooding is already bad and this will cause more issues for James Island residents. • Samantha Eberhardt, 234 Stefan Dr Unit 4-D Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I own my house on Stefan drive. Any major rain already floods our area, I cannot imagine want additional development would do to the area. Our traffic is already terrible and this development will only worsen the situation. I strongly oppose this development. Please consider the people who live in this area instead of the developers trying to make money. • Kelly Rudock, 1594 Westwood Dr Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I am opposed to the development and destruction of dozens of grand oaks and lack of any type of planning for flood mitigation in a flood prone area. • Katherine Skow, 735 Swanson Dr. James Island, SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting The project is severely flawed. The land in question is in a special flood protection zone. No plan submitted for storm run-off. Size and night of development not in keeping with residential neighborhood. • Paula Oakes, 247 Stefan Drive #14 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This is a terrible proposal. This area already floods and putting more homes there and tearing down trees will cause more severe flooding. Please stop this! Thank you. • Elizabeth Geib, 1987 Frampton Avenue, Charleston, SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Please vote no on the subdivision approval for Riverland Oaks! I live nearby and am very opposed to this development. This area cannot support additional development, especially of this size and in this location. It will cause flooding, environmental damage, traffic issues, and more problems. Residents of this area have made it clear over and over that they are opposed to this area being developed. It should be left as is to preserve the wetlands. Thank you for your consideration. • Michael Geib, 1987 Frampton Avenue, Charleston, SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Please vote no on the subdivision approval for Riverland Oaks! I live nearby and am very opposed to this development. This area cannot support additional development, especially of this size and in this location. It will cause flooding, environmental damage, traffic issues, and more problems. Residents of this area have made it clear over and over Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 23 that they are opposed to this area being developed. It should be left as is to preserve the wetlands. Thank you for your consideration. • Summer Crescent, 2991 Blackfish rd. Johns Island SC 29455 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Building housing in this area will create more flooding, even worse traffic, and destroy an ecosystem. Please stop this, the people do not want this. • Haily Vora, 336 woodland shores rd Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I strongly oppose this development due to the detrimental effects on the wetlands and the elevated risk of flood mitigation that affects the back of my property. • Heather Nofsinger, 2186 Parkway Drive Charleston SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This poorly planned townhome project will adversely affect numerous businesses, homes, traffic not to mention the removal of protected oaks. I live nearby and oppose this application! Please deny this project AGAIN! • Lynne Bard, 206 Jedediah Court Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I STRONGLY OPPOSE the construction of these proposed townhomes. I have owned 206 Jedediah Court (at the end of Stefan Drive) for over 7 years. In that time, I have watched trees cut in the land directly behind my home, between Jedediah Court and Woodland Shores. As a result, my yard now holds water even from the quickest of downpours. This proposed project will only exasperate this issue and DECREASE THE VALUE OF MY HOME. A middle school science student learns that trees hold water and eliminating trees means water has nowhere to be absorbed, and therefore floods land. The project has been at issue for a few years now because it is a bad project. The proposed mitigation for the flooding issue is NOT satisfactory. How can a developer possibly justify this development when it will negatively impact so many homes along Woodland Shores and Stefan Drive? What right or authority does this developer have to negatively impact families and their property so that they can make money? Can I compromise the integrity and value of their property for my personal betterment? NO, I CANNOT. Then there is also a MAJOR traffic concern. Adding townhomes means adding more traffic to Maybank Highway (and other streets). The recent installation of an island in the median along the block from Stefan to Woodland Shores on Maybank Highway has been an absolute traffic disaster. By shortening the median for turning, I now take my life into my own hands every time I need to turn left out of Stefan or turn left onto Stefan when traveling west (toward Johns Island). I cannot see oncoming traffic AT ALL when I am turning left onto Stefan from the median and a vehicle in the median trying to turn into Terrace Plaza. I am a sitting duck waiting for the vehicle to turn into Terrace Plaza. Only then can I see the east bound traffic on Maybank and safely turn onto Stefan. I have been one of five or more vehicles trying to turn left or right from this shortened median at the same time at least several times weekly. There is simply not sufficient space in the remaining median. This is a safety hazard. It is a multi-vehicle major accident just waiting to happen and has DECREASED THE VALUE OF ALL HOMES on Stefan Drive as it is now a life-altering decision to turn onto Maybank from Stefan or vice versa. How is adding hundreds of more vehicles to this area going to be safe? It is NOT, plain and simple. Who wants to purchase a home when getting there or leaving is a potential death trap? Who wants to purchase a Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 24 home where the land floods with minimal rainfall? Greater consideration needs to be given to those directly negatively impacted by your decisions. I do not have the right to destroy your property, please refrain from further degrading mine! I IMPLORE YOU to NOT APPROVE this project. Lynne Bard lynnebard29@gmail.com 508 410 9732 206 Jedediah Court Charleston SC 29412 • Annonymous Stefan Resident, na Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I am a Stefan Resident of 10 years and have seen the traffic steadily grow at an outrageous rate over time. The new median offers safe pedestrian crossing which was desperately needed but makes for very unsafe driving in the volume of traffic at the entrance to our street as well as at the 7-way intersection of Maybank and Woodland Shores. At certain times of the day turning left out of Stefan is impossible. Adding another 100-200 vehicles seems unfathomable. How is this development or the city addressing this issue? Also, the proposed ponds are massive and disruptive to wetlands, wildlife and citizens. Outside of how ridiculous it is to replace hundred year old trees in a wooded/swamp area with man made trench-lakes, maintaining them will be a huge task. Who will be paying for this? Will the 'affordable' housing also have HOA fees? What is the budgeted cost for ensuring they are draining, removing alligators, keeping them clean, etc? The majority of James Islanders to not want 95 homes forcefully wedged in between established neighborhoods (and ten feet from transmission lines?!) in one of the last remaining green-space, floodwater-absorbing animal refuges on the island. Do the pleas of the residents who have lived here contributing to the community for 10, 20, 50+ years have any baring on this decision making process at all? Thank you to the public officials for the opportunity to voice concerns and share our deep disapproval of this proposed development. • Lea Melone, 255 Stefan Drive Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This is insane. As it is the area is overpopulated and dangerous with the traffic with multiple accidents and deaths and you want to squish a community in there? Disgusting. • ErinLawhorn, 1500 parklawn drive Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting SUBMITTED ON BEHALF OF THE CHARLESTON COUNTY TREE PRESERVATION ALLIANCE Re: TRC-SUB2024-000286 – Riverland Oaks Concept Plan (TMS #3430000002, James Island, approximately 27.82 acres, 95-lot townhome development) Date: [Insert Submission Date] Dear City of Charleston Technical Review Committee Staff, Planning Commission, and Board of Zoning Appeals Members: The Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance respectfully submits these comments in strong opposition to the proposed Riverland Oaks development concept plan. We urge the Technical Review Committee to recommend denial or significant deferral and redesign, and call upon the Board of Zoning Appeals to apply rigorous scrutiny to any associated variances. This project raises substantial concerns regarding tree preservation, floodplain management, neighborhood character, infrastructure capacity, and consistency with adopted comprehensive plans and corridor management goals. TREE PRESERVATION, CONDITION RATINGS, AND NEED FOR OBJECTIVE RISK ASSESSMENT The City of Charleston's current tree ordinance designates Protected Trees (8" or greater DBH) and Grand Trees (24" or greater DBH, excluding pines and sweetgums). While the ordinance requires permits for Grand Tree removal and emphasizes mitigation, its condition-based letter rating system (e.g., D or F ratings for poor/fair health) is inherently subjective and prone to inconsistent application that can favor development interests over long-term environmental benefits. A rating system Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 25 focused on noting imperfections (e.g., minor defects or structural concerns) fails to capture a tree's longevity, cumulative ecological value, carbon sequestration, stormwater interception, habitat provision, and contribution to the urban forest canopy over decades. Such ratings can portray otherwise viable, mature trees as "defective," facilitating removal by the party with the strongest financial interest in site clearance. This approach undermines the ordinance's preservation intent and erodes public trust. We strongly recommend mandating ISA Tree Risk Assessment Qualification (TRAQ) evaluations for all Grand and Protected Trees on the site. TRAQ provides a standardized, systematic, and quantifiable methodology assessing likelihood of failure, consequences, and overall risk— offering clear, defensible data on immediate hazards rather than vague condition ratings. To eliminate conflicts of interest, these assessments must be conducted or verified by an independent third-party qualified arborist unaffiliated with the applicant, their consultants, or any entity with a development interest. Results should be reviewed and validated by a neutral body, such as Clemson Extension, a local university forestry program, or an established environmental organization with no political or financial ties to City/County development approvals. All trees should carry an assigned replacement value based on standard appraisal methods (e.g., depreciated reproduction cost adjusted for size, species, condition, and location), with full mitigation required for any approved removals. The Alliance further requests full public disclosure of the complete tree survey, including DBH, species, locations, proposed impacts, and assessments, prior to any decision. Any BZA variance for Grand Tree removal must demonstrate strict compliance with hardship criteria and include superior on-site mitigation (e.g., substantial caliper-inch replacements with native canopy species, enhanced buffers, and long-term monitoring). FLOODPLAIN AND STORMWATER CONCERNS IN A KNOWN FLOOD ZONE The site lies in or adjacent to established flood-prone areas on James Island, including historic creek beds. The proposal relies on a large-scale retaining/detention pond in this sensitive context. Adopted plans, including the Charleston City Plan and stormwater design standards, prioritize avoiding exacerbation of flooding, directing growth to higher-elevation areas, and ensuring no adverse impacts to neighboring properties. A pond of this magnitude raises serious risks of overflow, altered hydrology, and worsened flooding during major events—directly conflicting with resiliency goals and public safety. We request independent engineering review under current manuals and full modeling of cumulative impacts. INCONSISTENCY WITH COMPREHENSIVE PLANS, CORRIDOR GOALS, AND NEIGHBORHOOD CHARACTER The Charleston City Plan and supporting corridor management efforts (including Maybank Highway and Riverland Drive area plans) emphasize well-planned growth that maintains suburban/residential character, protects community corridors, manages traffic on local roads like Woodland Shores, and ensures compatibility with existing development patterns. This out-of-context, high-density townhome proposal on a narrow parcel does not align with these principles. It risks fragmenting the landscape, straining infrastructure, and diminishing aesthetic and property values in established neighborhoods. Growth must benefit the broader community—enhancing rather than hindering livability, environmental quality, and long- term resilience. Variances should only be granted where there is no substantial detriment to public welfare or neighborhood character, per statutory criteria. BROADER PUBLIC INTEREST AND RECOMMENDATIONS Approving this project as proposed would prioritize short-term development gains over sustainable, context-sensitive planning. We urge the City to: Defer the concept plan pending independent TRAQ tree assessments, third-party validation, full flood/traffic studies, and revised designs maximizing preservation. Require enhanced buffers, open space, and native replanting consistent with or exceeding ordinance minimums. Ensure all decisions align with the letter and spirit of the Charleston City Plan, corridor overlays, and tree protection goals. The Alliance stands ready to provide additional expertise or participate in discussions. Preserving Charleston's urban Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 26 forest and community character is essential to the health, beauty, and economic vitality of our region. We implore staff and decision-makers to uphold these priorities. Thank you for your careful consideration. Erin Lawhorn Charleston County Tree Preservation Founder. • Amy tamblyn, 472 Woodland Shores Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Dear City of Charleston Technical Review Committee Staff, Planning Commission, and Board of Zoning Appeals Members: The Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance respectfully submits these comments in strong opposition to the proposed Riverland Oaks development concept plan. We urge the Technical Review Committee to recommend denial or significant deferral and redesign, and call upon the Board of Zoning Appeals to apply rigorous scrutiny to any associated variances. This project raises substantial concerns regarding tree preservation, floodplain management, neighborhood character, infrastructure capacity, and consistency with adopted comprehensive plans and corridor management goals. TREE PRESERVATION, CONDITION RATINGS, AND NEED FOR OBJECTIVE RISK ASSESSMENT The City of Charleston's current tree ordinance designates Protected Trees (8" or greater DBH) and Grand Trees (24" or greater DBH, excluding pines and sweetgums). While the ordinance requires permits for Grand Tree removal and emphasizes mitigation, its condition-based letter rating system (e.g., D or F ratings for poor/fair health) is inherently subjective and prone to inconsistent application that can favor development interests over long-term environmental benefits. A rating system focused on noting imperfections (e.g., minor defects or structural concerns) fails to capture a tree's longevity, cumulative ecological value, carbon sequestration, stormwater interception, habitat provision, and contribution to the urban forest canopy over decades. Such ratings can portray otherwise viable, mature trees as "defective," facilitating removal by the party with the strongest financial interest in site clearance. This approach undermines the ordinance's preservation intent and erodes public trust. We strongly recommend mandating ISA Tree Risk Assessment Qualification (TRAQ) evaluations for all Grand and Protected Trees on the site. TRAQ provides a standardized, systematic, and quantifiable methodology assessing likelihood of failure, consequences, and overall risk— offering clear, defensible data on immediate hazards rather than vague condition ratings. To eliminate conflicts of interest, these assessments must be conducted or verified by an independent third-party qualified arborist unaffiliated with the applicant, their consultants, or any entity with a development interest. Results should be reviewed and validated by a neutral body, such as Clemson Extension, a local university forestry program, or an established environmental organization with no political or financial ties to City/County development approvals. All trees should carry an assigned replacement value based on standard appraisal methods (e.g., depreciated reproduction cost adjusted for size, species, condition, and location), with full mitigation required for any approved removals. The Alliance further requests full public disclosure of the complete tree survey, including DBH, species, locations, proposed impacts, and assessments, prior to any decision. Any BZA variance for Grand Tree removal must demonstrate strict compliance with hardship criteria and include superior on-site mitigation (e.g., substantial caliper-inch replacements with native canopy species, enhanced buffers, and long-term monitoring). FLOODPLAIN AND STORMWATER CONCERNS IN A KNOWN FLOOD ZONE The site lies in or adjacent to established flood-prone areas on James Island, including historic creek beds. The proposal relies on a large-scale retaining/detention pond in this sensitive context. Adopted plans, including the Charleston City Plan and stormwater design standards, prioritize avoiding exacerbation of flooding, directing growth to higher-elevation areas, and ensuring no adverse impacts to neighboring properties. A pond of this magnitude raises serious risks of overflow, altered hydrology, and worsened flooding during major events—directly conflicting with resiliency goals and public safety. We request Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 27 independent engineering review under current manuals and full modeling of cumulative impacts. INCONSISTENCY WITH COMPREHENSIVE PLANS, CORRIDOR GOALS, AND NEIGHBORHOOD CHARACTER The Charleston City Plan and supporting corridor management efforts (including Maybank Highway and Riverland Drive area plans) emphasize well-planned growth that maintains suburban/residential character, protects community corridors, manages traffic on local roads like Woodland Shores, and ensures compatibility with existing development patterns. This out-of-context, high-density townhome proposal on a narrow parcel does not align with these principles. It risks fragmenting the landscape, straining infrastructure, and diminishing aesthetic and property values in established neighborhoods. Growth must benefit the broader community—enhancing rather than hindering livability, environmental quality, and long- term resilience. Variances should only be granted where there is no substantial detriment to public welfare or neighborhood character, per statutory criteria. BROADER PUBLIC INTEREST AND RECOMMENDATIONS Approving this project as proposed would prioritize short-term development gains over sustainable, context-sensitive planning. We urge the City to: Defer the concept plan pending independent TRAQ tree assessments, third-party validation, full flood/traffic studies, and revised designs maximizing preservation. Require enhanced buffers, open space, and native replanting consistent with or exceeding ordinance minimums. Ensure all decisions align with the letter and spirit of the Charleston City Plan, corridor overlays, and tree protection goals. The Alliance stands ready to provide additional expertise or participate in discussions. Preserving Charleston's urban forest and community character is essential to the health, beauty, and economic vitality of our region. We implore staff and decision-makers to uphold these priorities. Thank you for your careful consideration. • Susan Milliken, 762 Fort Sumter Dr., Charleston, SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting To Planning Commission Members: Please VOTE NO to Subdivision Approval for the Riverland Oaks 95-unit townhomes plan on James Island. This plan is NOT compatible with the City's Comprehensive Land Use Plan per Section 54-945 of the City's ordinances. The Charleston City Plan (2021) states that Charleston will "restore and preserve natural ecosystems....That ecosystems that provide stormwater benefits and essential wildlife habitats...should be preserved" This 27+ acre wooded sponge forest should be preserved per the "Charleston City Plan". Furthermore, this property is located in a Special Flood Protection Zone. The City must complete their planned large-scale drainage project for the Central Park Drainage Basin area first before a development of this size is constructed. This bad development plan includes: ��(5) ponds for stormwater storage, with the two largest ponds being LAKES, one 158,187 sq ft! And another being 80,815 sq ft. ��Super tall buildings of up to 50 feet or 3 stories. These will tower over neighboring longtime residents on Stefan and Woodland Shores. ��Massive amounts of impervious surface for roadways, sidewalks and driveways. ��There are at least 25 grand trees located on this property, which have been rated grades of “dead”, poor, fair and good. It's hard to believe that so many trees have been rated in “poor” condition. We'd like to see more detailed arborist reports on these trees. ��We have no idea how many grand trees they will request removal for—it will be many. Please vote No on this Subdivision Approval. This plan badly needs more work and study, and it's location is not compatible with the Charleston City Plan. Thank you, Susan Milliken James Island, SC • Claire Witbeck, 2120 Saint Jakes Dr. Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 28 This construction project will strongly negatively impact the area with how densely populated it is. Please consider the negative impacts to already overcrowded roads, flood zones etc. • Jessica Muir, 324 Woodland Shores Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I vote NO! This is a low-lying, special protection flood zone. There is NO stormwater plan for this property that can manage the run-off that will surely impact residents on Stefan Dr and on Woodland Shores Rd. My family is directly impacted by this extremely poor planning. • stefan resident stefan resident, stefan drive Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting vote no. no more traffic. no more flooding. my backyard floods significantly when it rains. can you imagine how much unnecessary money from the city will be needed to mitigate excessive neighborhood flooding between Woodland shores, Stefan, Maybank and Riverland because of this development? and for the traffic, additional improvements will be needed to accommodate these extra 200+ cars, especially as John's Island grows. finally, the ponds they are proposing are enormous!! they will literally generate their own waves in a storm due to their size, which will cause erosion and require more upkeep. are the future residents prepared to pay $1k per month in HOA fees for the millions of dollars in maintenance of the 26 acres will cost? I thought this was affordable housing. If not, will the city eat the cost or will Stefan and Woodland shores just quietly wash away over time? build 20 houses. build 40. 95 is beyond unreasonable and is a clear attempt to maximize profits, not safety or long term success. • Jody Leverknightt, 1209 Cecil Cir Charleston 29412 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I live on James Island and I would like to come eat at the James or visit the movie theater or go to Miller’s all day. Guess what I don’t do on a daily basis because the traffic is so atrocious on that side of town. I only go to areas where I can take the back road to get to Riverland Drive. I don’t know who would ever conceive that this would be a good idea to add 95 townhomes with multiple cars per townhome that would only add to the traffic. In all honesty, I think all construction needs to be stopped until you can fix the traffic issues. We really should be able to enjoy the island that we pay taxes and live on. • DeAnna Hohn, 759 Cartwright Dr. Charleston, SC 29414 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This plan is NOT compatible with the City's Comprehensive Land Use Plan per Section 54- 945 of the City's ordinances. The Charleston City Plan (2021) states that Charleston will "restore and preserve natural ecosystems....That ecosystems that provide stormwater benefits and essential wildlife habitats...should be preserved" This 27+ acre wooded sponge forest should be preserved per the "Charleston City Plan". This property is located in a Special Flood Protection Zone! STOP OVER DEVELOPING OUR COUNTY!! • Andrew Tweel, 2167 COKER AVE 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting City of Charleston resident. I got an error message on my initial submission so am resubmitting. This area cannot handle any more development-- flooding, tree canopy, and Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 29 traffic are already strained. Taxpayers and residents should not have to shoulder the burden for private profits. • Charles Carper, 2186 Parkway Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Boiler plate message created . If you could find a way to blast this Susan, I messed up the everyone feature on our page and couldn’t get it out the way I wished ! SUBMITTED ON BEHALF OF THE CHARLESTON COUNTY TREE PRESERVATION ALLIANCE Re: TRC-SUB2024- 000286 – Riverland Oaks Concept Plan (TMS #3430000002, James Island, approximately 27.82 acres, 95-lot townhome development) Date: [Insert Submission Date] Dear City of Charleston Technical Review Committee Staff, Planning Commission, and Board of Zoning Appeals Members: The Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance respectfully submits these comments in strong opposition to the proposed Riverland Oaks development concept plan. We urge the Technical Review Committee to recommend denial or significant deferral and redesign, and call upon the Board of Zoning Appeals to apply rigorous scrutiny to any associated variances. This project raises substantial concerns regarding tree preservation, floodplain management, neighborhood character, infrastructure capacity, and consistency with adopted comprehensive plans and corridor management goals. TREE PRESERVATION, CONDITION RATINGS, AND NEED FOR OBJECTIVE RISK ASSESSMENT The City of Charleston's current tree ordinance designates Protected Trees (8" or greater DBH) and Grand Trees (24" or greater DBH, excluding pines and sweetgums). While the ordinance requires permits for Grand Tree removal and emphasizes mitigation, its condition-based letter rating system (e.g., D or F ratings for poor/fair health) is inherently subjective and prone to inconsistent application that can favor development interests over long-term environmental benefits. A rating system focused on noting imperfections (e.g., minor defects or structural concerns) fails to capture a tree's longevity, cumulative ecological value, carbon sequestration, stormwater interception, habitat provision, and contribution to the urban forest canopy over decades. Such ratings can portray otherwise viable, mature trees as "defective," facilitating removal by the party with the strongest financial interest in site clearance. This approach undermines the ordinance's preservation intent and erodes public trust. We strongly recommend mandating ISA Tree Risk Assessment Qualification (TRAQ) evaluations for all Grand and Protected Trees on the site. TRAQ provides a standardized, systematic, and quantifiable methodology assessing likelihood of failure, consequences, and overall risk— offering clear, defensible data on immediate hazards rather than vague condition ratings. To eliminate conflicts of interest, these assessments must be conducted or verified by an independent third-party qualified arborist unaffiliated with the applicant, their consultants, or any entity with a development interest. Results should be reviewed and validated by a neutral body, such as Clemson Extension, a local university forestry program, or an established environmental organization with no political or financial ties to City/County development approvals. All trees should carry an assigned replacement value based on standard appraisal methods (e.g., depreciated reproduction cost adjusted for size, species, condition, and location), with full mitigation required for any approved removals. The Alliance further requests full public disclosure of the complete tree survey, including DBH, species, locations, proposed impacts, and assessments, prior to any decision. Any BZA variance for Grand Tree removal must demonstrate strict compliance with hardship criteria and include superior on-site mitigation (e.g., substantial caliper-inch replacements with native canopy species, enhanced buffers, and long-term monitoring). FLOODPLAIN AND STORMWATER CONCERNS IN A KNOWN FLOOD ZONE The site lies in or adjacent to established flood-prone areas on James Island, including historic creek beds. The proposal relies on a large-scale retaining/detention pond in this sensitive context. Adopted plans, including the Charleston City Plan and stormwater design standards, Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 30 prioritize avoiding exacerbation of flooding, directing growth to higher-elevation areas, and ensuring no adverse impacts to neighboring properties. A pond of this magnitude raises serious risks of overflow, altered hydrology, and worsened flooding during major events—directly conflicting with resiliency goals and public safety. We request independent engineering review under current manuals and full modeling of cumulative impacts. INCONSISTENCY WITH COMPREHENSIVE PLANS, CORRIDOR GOALS, AND NEIGHBORHOOD CHARACTER The Charleston City Plan and supporting corridor management efforts (including Maybank Highway and Riverland Drive area plans) emphasize well-planned growth that maintains suburban/residential character, protects community corridors, manages traffic on local roads like Woodland Shores, and ensures compatibility with existing development patterns. This out-of-context, high-density townhome proposal on a narrow parcel does not align with these principles. It risks fragmenting the landscape, straining infrastructure, and diminishing aesthetic and property values in established neighborhoods. Growth must benefit the broader community—enhancing rather than hindering livability, environmental quality, and long- term resilience. Variances should only be granted where there is no substantial detriment to public welfare or neighborhood character, per statutory criteria. BROADER PUBLIC INTEREST AND RECOMMENDATIONS Approving this project as proposed would prioritize short-term development gains over sustainable, context-sensitive planning. We urge the City to: Defer the concept plan pending independent TRAQ tree assessments, third-party validation, full flood/traffic studies, and revised designs maximizing preservation. Require enhanced buffers, open space, and native replanting consistent with or exceeding ordinance minimums. Ensure all decisions align with the letter and spirit of the Charleston City Plan, corridor overlays, and tree protection goals. The Alliance stands ready to provide additional expertise or participate in discussions. Preserving Charleston's urban forest and community character is essential to the health, beauty, and economic vitality of our region. We implore staff and decision-makers to uphold these priorities. Thank you for your careful consideration. • Melissa Conover, 1353 White House Blvd 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting We don’t have the infrastructure to support this amount of townhomes. Traffic is already horrible along this stretch of Maybank and you made it worse by putting the median in so adding townhomes which means more people and more cars is going to make it unbearable. Until you can figure out how to properly fix our infrastructure for long term growth instead of using short term quick fixes, we can’t support more people and cars in this area. • Cassandra Bartolf, 7180 Tanglewood Dr North Charleston SC 29418 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Vote no! • Diane Staubs, 1430 Folly Rd Charleston SC 29412 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting It is time for Home Development to pause. Developers are infringing on the beauty, resources, residents, wildlife and JI daily life by destroying our land; building in clearly uninhabitable areas; congesting roadways and literally killing the Goose that lays the Golden Egg. The remaining irreplaceable green land areas should not be covered in cement. No more concrete. One of our Charleston "Leaders" was questioned last year Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 31 about the over development of our beautiful area. His ignorant response was "Well you can't stop growth...". As Leaders in our communities you can certainly put forth an effort to MANAGE GROWTH. This would be your job. PLEASE...MANAGE CHARLESTON'S GROWTH for all of our sakes! • Kevin Nofsinger, 2186 Parkway Dr 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I oppose Riverland Oaks Townhomes project vigorously • Marian Hoffman, 2041 Terrabrook Lane 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This will cause too much traffic on Maybank, Woodland Shores and Central. The creek will overflow on the streets due to overflow rain when trees are gone. Stop 95 townhouses! • Ben Farnham, 286 Stefan Drive 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This development will flood my back yard due to rain and lack of ptoper drainage to overflow from the concrete. Too much traffic will cause delays on Maybank highway • Kathy Swittenberg, 1391 D Camp Road 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This area cannot handle that type of development especially when traffic is already miserable. The height is too much and please stop filling in wetlands. • Elyse Kriegshaber, 2148 Edisto Avenue 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Dear City of Charleston Technical Review Committee Staff, Planning Commission, and Board of Zoning Appeals Members: The Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance respectfully submits these comments in strong opposition to the proposed Riverland Oaks development concept plan. We urge the Technical Review Committee to recommend denial or significant deferral and redesign, and call upon the Board of Zoning Appeals to apply rigorous scrutiny to any associated variances. This project raises substantial concerns regarding tree preservation, floodplain management, neighborhood character, infrastructure capacity, and consistency with adopted comprehensive plans and corridor management goals. TREE PRESERVATION, CONDITION RATINGS, AND NEED FOR OBJECTIVE RISK ASSESSMENT The City of Charleston's current tree ordinance designates Protected Trees (8" or greater DBH) and Grand Trees (24" or greater DBH, excluding pines and sweetgums). While the ordinance requires permits for Grand Tree removal and emphasizes mitigation, its condition-based letter rating system (e.g., D or F ratings for poor/fair health) is inherently subjective and prone to inconsistent application that can favor development interests over long-term environmental benefits. A rating system focused on noting imperfections (e.g., minor defects or structural concerns) fails to capture a tree's longevity, cumulative ecological value, carbon sequestration, stormwater interception, habitat provision, and contribution to the urban forest canopy over decades. Such ratings can portray otherwise viable, mature trees as "defective," facilitating removal by the party with the strongest financial interest in site clearance. This approach undermines the ordinance's preservation intent and erodes public trust. We strongly Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 32 recommend mandating ISA Tree Risk Assessment Qualification (TRAQ) evaluations for all Grand and Protected Trees on the site. TRAQ provides a standardized, systematic, and quantifiable methodology assessing likelihood of failure, consequences, and overall risk— offering clear, defensible data on immediate hazards rather than vague condition ratings. To eliminate conflicts of interest, these assessments must be conducted or verified by an independent third-party qualified arborist unaffiliated with the applicant, their consultants, or any entity with a development interest. Results should be reviewed and validated by a neutral body, such as Clemson Extension, a local university forestry program, or an established environmental organization with no political or financial ties to City/County development approvals. All trees should carry an assigned replacement value based on standard appraisal methods (e.g., depreciated reproduction cost adjusted for size, species, condition, and location), with full mitigation required for any approved removals. The Alliance further requests full public disclosure of the complete tree survey, including DBH, species, locations, proposed impacts, and assessments, prior to any decision. Any BZA variance for Grand Tree removal must demonstrate strict compliance with hardship criteria and include superior on-site mitigation (e.g., substantial caliper-inch replacements with native canopy species, enhanced buffers, and long-term monitoring). FLOODPLAIN AND STORMWATER CONCERNS IN A KNOWN FLOOD ZONE The site lies in or adjacent to established flood-prone areas on James Island, including historic creek beds. The proposal relies on a large-scale retaining/detention pond in this sensitive context. Adopted plans, including the Charleston City Plan and stormwater design standards, prioritize avoiding exacerbation of flooding, directing growth to higher-elevation areas, and ensuring no adverse impacts to neighboring properties. A pond of this magnitude raises serious risks of overflow, altered hydrology, and worsened flooding during major events—directly conflicting with resiliency goals and public safety. We request independent engineering review under current manuals and full modeling of cumulative impacts. INCONSISTENCY WITH COMPREHENSIVE PLANS, CORRIDOR GOALS, AND NEIGHBORHOOD CHARACTER The Charleston City Plan and supporting corridor management efforts (including Maybank Highway and Riverland Drive area plans) emphasize well-planned growth that maintains suburban/residential character, protects community corridors, manages traffic on local roads like Woodland Shores, and ensures compatibility with existing development patterns. This out-of-context, high-density townhome proposal on a narrow parcel does not align with these principles. It risks fragmenting the landscape, straining infrastructure, and diminishing aesthetic and property values in established neighborhoods. Growth must benefit the broader community—enhancing rather than hindering livability, environmental quality, and long- term resilience. Variances should only be granted where there is no substantial detriment to public welfare or neighborhood character, per statutory criteria. BROADER PUBLIC INTEREST AND RECOMMENDATIONS Approving this project as proposed would prioritize short-term development gains over sustainable, context-sensitive planning. We urge the City to: Defer the concept plan pending independent TRAQ tree assessments, third-party validation, full flood/traffic studies, and revised designs maximizing preservation. Require enhanced buffers, open space, and native replanting consistent with or exceeding ordinance minimums. Ensure all decisions align with the letter and spirit of the Charleston City Plan, corridor overlays, and tree protection goals. The Alliance stands ready to provide additional expertise or participate in discussions. Preserving Charleston's urban forest and community character is essential to the health, beauty, and economic vitality of our region. We implore staff and decision-makers to uphold these priorities. Thank you for your careful consideration. • Cindy Wynne, 1440 Battleground Rd 24 Apollo Road Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 33 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Oppose • Melanie Lovell, 1168 Wyndham road charleston sc 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I oppose the request for the Riverland Oaks subdivision concept plan approval (submitted under owner Venn James Island, LLC / applicant Sitecast, LLC for a 27.82-acre, 95-lot townhome development). We absolutely need more housing but we do not need to remove almost every tree from a beautiful wooded lot to create new homes. Let’s work with abandoned commercial buildings and other ways to create housing without sacrificing our beautiful tree canopy. • Pam Bingham, 2174 Golfview Dr 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Please vote NO to this project • Charles Lingenfelter, 2060 Medway Road 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Good Day, I have lived on James Island for over 40 years and the majority of that has been in Riverland Terrace. This proposed development is not needed or wanted for the following reasons: 1. Traffic is already bad in this area. The influx of more people and cars will do nothing but make this problem worse. There are traffic chokepoints right in this area that have not or will not be addressed (Riverland Drive/Woodland Shores Road, Riverland Dr/Maybank Highway, Riverland Dr/Central Park Road, Maybank Highway/Fleming Rd, etc.). It took one of our neighbors being hit and almost killed (with her quality of life changed forever, mind you) and then a public outcry and neighborhood rallying cry to get speed humps and sidewalks in that area. 2. There is a long standing farmers market that operates right where your proposed road will come through at. This market is operated by local vendors and brings in hundreds of people a month to visit this part of James Island. This proposed development will cut this local established market in half, if not more. 3. The Woodland Shores area just completed an upgraded drainage system, to help fix the long-standing flooding issues. Any new development will destroy the natural water drainage and make the new drainage measures obsolete. 4. Just because there is an area with trees and plants without housing on it, does not mean that it has to be developed. Have the courage to reflect and see that this island has become oversaturated with houses and development. It is not about "it is not the way it was back then" rather, it is "this way of living is becoming unsustainable" Please stop this development. We do not want it, our neighbors do not want it, and the island can not support it. If the only party supporting this is the one making a profit from this, then the people will know where the City of Charleston stands. • Mary Allison Kelly, 759 Cartwright Dr. 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Not compatible with citys comprehensive land use plan per section 54-945 of the city's ordinances. This is not what will preserve Charleston • Corie Hipp, PO Box 12376 Charleston, SC 29422. 24 Apollo Road Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 34 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Please VOTE NO to Subdivision Approval on the Riverland Oaks concept. This plan is NOT compatible with the City's Comprehensive Land Use Plan. • Donna Cheseborough, 2024 Coker Ave Charleston South Carolina 29412 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting There is already too much density of housing in that area. There will be no place for water to go and flooding will happen, even more than it's flooding now. Trees will be removed and wild life will be displaced – the very reasons we love James Island. Traffic is already extreme between Woodland Shores and Folly Road on Maybank. It can take 20 minutes to traverse. This will make it much, much worse. • stefanie snead, Timberland drive 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting PLEASE VOTE NO to Subdivision Approval. This plan is NOT compatible with the City's Comprehensive Land Use Plan per Section 54-945 of the City's ordinances. The Charleston City Plan (2021) states that Charleston will "restore and preserve natural ecosystems....That ecosystems that provide stormwater benefits and essential wildlife habitats...should be preserved" This 27+ acre wooded sponge forest should be preserved per the "Charleston City Plan". • Erin Lingle, 598 SALTGRASS POINTE DR CHS 29412 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting The proposal has been downsized, but a 95-unit mixed-density development remains too dense for an area characterized by SR-1 single-family homes in Woodland Shores, Riverland Terrace and surrounding areas. The DR-6 zoning of this tract is an isolated "red flag" that disregards the surrounding single-family scale. The $1.3 million Hollings Road drainage improvements were intended to provide relief for existing residents, not to subsidize high-density infill. Paving this 28-acre watershed will generate millions of gallons of runoff, likely overwhelming new infrastructure before it is fully operational. The traffic along Riverland Drive and Woodland Shores has only increased with people frequently speeding and traffic backing up from Maybank Highway. Riverland Drive is not ready for another subdivision without a solution to the traffic issues. We shouldn't have to wait for another person to be nearly fatally injured to have traffic calming measures addressed. • Alicia Avnayim, 335 Stefan Drive 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Hello, I have lived in Charleston since 2004 and in 2018 bought a house on Stefan Drive so I've witnessed the rapid growth in the area, the problems it has caused, and rarely a successful solution implemented. This area cannot take a build of the magnitude. Areas change, landscapes change and what this area is zoned for just doesn't work anymore. Please consider all the problems that will arise with no solutions- flooding, traffic, quality of life, killing of nature.. I also don't trust the builders as they have shown to be dishonest and shady practices. On one of the renderings I remember seeing they were going to connect to Stefan Drive and I know that's not possible as someone on our street bought that but of land so something like that would never happen. The following are points a neighbor shared that I agree with in opposition of this development -Neighborhood character: The proposal has been downsized, but a 95-unit mixed-density development Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 35 remains too dense for an area characterized by SR-1 single-family homes in Woodland Shores, Riverland Terrace and surrounding areas. The DR-6 zoning of this tract is an isolated "red flag" that disregards the surrounding single-family scale. - Infrastructure Overload: The $1.3 million Hollings Road drainage improvements were intended to provide relief for existing residents, not to subsidize high-density infill. Paving this 28-acre watershed will generate millions of gallons of runoff, likely overwhelming new infrastructure before it is fully operational. - Drainage and Displacement: Filling this 28- acre basin will elevate the water table, pushing water into the crawlspaces and foundations of adjacent properties. - Open Space Misrepresentation: Counting mandatory stormwater retention ponds as "open space" is a disingenuous interpretation of the City’s Comprehensive Plan, as these utilities provide no recreational value. - Environmental Policy Gap: Approving this density on a wetland buffer contradicts the City’s stated goals for resilience and canopy preservation. -We request the Commission require an independent, cumulative watershed impact study rather than a localized review. -We ask the Commission to enforce stronger step-down density buffers, increased rear setbacks, and mandatory vegetative screening along shared property boundaries. • Jessica Wise, 253 Stefan Drive 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Please do not approve these townhomes. It is so congested and unsafe at that area on maybank as it is. I worry for my kids safety every time they leave Stefan Dr and this will only make it worse. • Wilfred Barriere, 297 Stefan Drive 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This area of James island has been inundated with new homes. The roads have become congested with traffic. Flooding conditions have not been addressed. Now more homes more cars have been added to the mix. I say enough is enough to individual contractors changing the quality of life. • Danielle Kilcullen, 388 Stefan Drive Charleston SC 29412 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting 95 townhomes is way too high of a density for this area of James Island. Us residents (I live on Stefan Drive) already deal with the crazy amount of Johns Island traffic onto our sections of Maybank Hwy. Adding 95 households worth of cars to are road is an overload no one wants and one that should not be aligned with the city's vision for planning. Additionally, I am concerned with paving over these wet areas and increasing drainage issues which we already deal with during heavy rains. • Curtis Rodriguez, 320 Woodland Shores Rd Charleston, SC 29412 24 Apollo Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Dear Members of the Planning Commission, I am writing as a concerned Charleston resident and community member to urge the Commission to vote NO on subdivision approval for the Riverland Oaks development — the proposed 95-townhome project on approximately 27.82 acres behind the Charleston Pour House on James Island. I have reviewed the submitted plans and supporting materials carefully, and I believe this project poses unacceptable risks to the surrounding neighborhood, its residents, and the natural environment of this site. I also write to respectfully but directly challenge the staff Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 36 recommendation of approval. The Staff Recommendation Conflicts with the City's Own Plan The Charleston City Plan's Future Land Use Map designates this parcel as Suburban — a classification that contemplates lower-density, single-family-oriented development consistent with the established neighborhoods surrounding it. A 95-unit townhome development does not reflect that designation. Approving Riverland Oaks would put this Commission at odds with the city's own comprehensive planning guidance. Staff's recommendation of approval does not reconcile this conflict, and the Commission should not accept it without pressing for that explanation. An Isolated Density Spike in a Single- Family Neighborhood The zoning map tells a clear story. The Riverland Oaks parcel is zoned DR-6 — but it sits as an isolated island surrounded on virtually every side by SR-1 and R-4 single-family residential zoning. The neighborhoods along Stefan Drive to the east and Woodland Shores Road to the south and west are single-family communities. There is no transitional buffer, no gradual step-down in density. The DR-6 designation on this parcel is the product of a prior upzoning, and Riverland Oaks is the direct consequence of that decision. The Commission should weigh whether building out that upzoning to its maximum density — 95 townhomes at up to 50 feet and three stories tall — genuinely serves the surrounding community, or whether it simply exploits what the zoning change made permissible. Aerial photographs make the physical reality plain. This is a narrow, elongated parcel squeezed between residential streets. Future residents on Stefan Drive and Woodland Shores Road will have three-story townhome buildings on or near their property lines, with no meaningful separation. Traffic Safety on an Already Dangerous Corridor The Commission must consider what 95 additional townhome units will mean for traffic on Maybank Highway — a corridor that has already claimed lives and is actively under remediation for safety failures. Maybank Highway near this site has seen a disturbing pattern of fatal collisions and pedestrian deaths in recent years, with incidents concentrated near the Charleston Pour House and Terrace Plaza — directly adjacent to the Riverland Oaks access point. A pedestrian was killed on the corridor in December 2025. In response, the city and county accelerated the Maybank Highway and Woodland Shores Complete Streets project, installing raised concrete medians, center islands, and mid-block pedestrian crossings specifically to slow traffic and reduce crash rates along this stretch. Those safety improvements are now generating their own community crisis. Because the new raised medians block direct left turns, drivers are executing hazardous U- turns at Woodland Shores Road to access local businesses. Residents have raised urgent concerns about the dangerous turning movements this has created, and a community petition is currently circulating calling for enforcement, new signage, or a protected green arrow to address the problem. The intersection at Woodland Shores Road and Maybank Highway is, at this moment, a documented safety flashpoint. Now the Commission is being asked to approve a 95-unit residential development that will funnel additional vehicle trips onto this same corridor — through the same intersection where U-turns are already causing hazards — without any traffic impact analysis that accounts for these changed conditions. The medians that were installed to save lives have simultaneously constrained traffic flow in ways the neighborhood is still struggling to manage. Adding the vehicle load of a 95-townhome development into this environment, without a serious and current traffic study, would be irresponsible. The Commission should require one before any approval moves forward. A Site Poorly Suited for Dense Development The property sits within a Special Flood Protection Zone. The site contains at least four distinct wetland areas totaling approximately 0.86 acres (0.200, 0.069, 0.141, and 0.450 acres respectively). The presence of wetlands at this scale is not an incidental detail — it is a clear signal that the land itself is ecologically unsuitable for the density of development being proposed. The applicant's stormwater management plan does not resolve this problem; it reframes it. The plan relies on five retention ponds, two of which are effectively small lakes: one measuring 158,187 square feet and another at 80,815 square Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 37 feet. Taken together, these water features do not represent a managed solution — they represent a conversion of the site's interior into standing water. The Commission should also be clear-eyed about what is being counted as "open space" in this application. A review of the Open Space Plan (Sheet C4.5) shows that the green-shaded areas designated as passive open space are, in large part, the retention pond footprints themselves. This is stormwater infrastructure, not usable parkland. Future buyers and neighboring residents deserve to understand that distinction. Without a rigorous, independent stormwater impact analysis, the Commission has no credible basis to conclude that downstream flooding on Stefan Drive and Woodland Shores Road will not worsen. The current plan provides no such assurance. The Hollings Road Drainage Improvements Will Not Protect These Neighborhoods Some may assume that the recently completed Hollings Road drainage improvements — which included upgraded box culverts and canal enhancements — will offset the flooding risk this development creates for Stefan Drive and Woodland Shores Road. That assumption should not go unchallenged. Those improvements were designed and engineered to address existing drainage deficiencies in the system as it stood when the project was scoped. They were not designed to absorb the additional stormwater burden that 95 new townhomes — with their associated roads, driveways, parking areas, and rooftops — will introduce into this already-stressed watershed. The scope, sizing, and capacity of those improvements reflect the drainage demands of the neighborhood as it existed, not the neighborhood as it would exist with a dense new development added upstream of the system. Completed public infrastructure cannot be retroactively credited as mitigation for a private development that postdates it. If the Commission intends to rely on the Hollings Road improvements as any part of its rationale for approval, it should first require the applicant to demonstrate, with engineering analysis, that the upgraded system has sufficient remaining capacity to handle the runoff load Riverland Oaks will generate — above and beyond the existing deficiencies those improvements were built to correct. That analysis has not been provided. Until it is, the Hollings Road project offers no meaningful assurance to the residents of Stefan Drive and Woodland Shores Road. Impervious Surface and Runoff Ninety-five townhomes, with their associated roads, driveways, parking areas, and sidewalks, will blanket a flood-prone site with impervious surface. On a parcel already carrying a Special Flood Protection Zone designation and documented wetlands, that coverage will dramatically increase stormwater runoff. The flooding consequences for adjacent residential streets are predictable — and preventable, but only if this project is stopped or fundamentally redesigned. Tree Canopy Loss The site hosts at least 25 grand trees. The tree survey submitted with the application notes that many are rated in poor or dead condition — yet even compromised grand trees provide canopy cover, stormwater absorption, and ecological function. Development at this density makes it nearly inevitable that the majority of these trees will be removed. James Island has absorbed significant canopy loss over the past two decades of development pressure. This Commission has an opportunity to apply a higher standard here. Conclusion The city's own Future Land Use Map calls this area Suburban. The surrounding zoning is almost entirely single-family. The site sits in a flood zone with nearly an acre of documented wetlands. The stormwater plan replaces those wetlands with retention lakes and calls them open space. The Hollings Road drainage improvements were never designed to handle the runoff this development will generate. Three-story buildings will rise directly adjacent to single-family homes with no buffer. At least 25 grand trees stand to be lost. And the primary access corridor — Maybank Highway — is an active safety crisis that this development would make measurably worse. Every one of these facts argues against approval. Taken together, they make a compelling case that this site is the wrong location for this project at this density. I respectfully ask that each member of this Commission vote NO on subdivision approval for Riverland Oaks. The residents of Stefan Drive, Woodland Shores Road, and the broader Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 38 James Island community are counting on this body to apply rigorous scrutiny where the facts demand it. Wednesday's vote is one of those moments. Respectfully submitted, Curtis Rodriguez 320 Woodland Shores Rd Charleston, SC 29412 • Paul Chirles, 2005 FRAMPTON AVE, CHARLESTON, SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I am writing to urge the members of the City of Charleston Planning Commission to enthusiastically OPPOSE the Riverland Oaks (TMS# 3430000002) request to clear the parcel, fill in wetlands, remove countless grand oaks, and build 95 townhomes behind the Pour House on James Island. The overdevelopment of James Island and the Low Country needs to stop. Developers are destroying the natural beauty and protection of James Island and surrounding areas. The infrastructure cannot handle the current volume of residents, let alone Maybank Highway and the ridiculous median recently installed, Woodland Shores, and Riverland Drive. Approving this request will NEGATIVELY impact a large portion of northern James Island residents and negatively impact natural flood protections. Reasons to oppose: 1. This property is located in a Special Flood Protection Zone. Ignoring the Special Flood Protection Zone is guaranteed to risk the lives and property of James Island residents 2. The development with fill in almost 3 acres of wetlands and replace it with massive amounts of impervious surface for roadways, sidewalks and driveways. Wetlands that help reduce flooding during heavy rainstorms and HURRICANES and support countless type of wildlife. 3. An unknown amount of grand trees that would have to be removed. Grand Trees, like the wetlands, assist with flooding and erosion management. 4. The plan calls for super tall buildings of up to 50 feet or 3 stories which will ruin the aesthetics of the Low Country look, vibe, and classic lifestyle. In addition, these proposed structures will tower over neighboring longtime residents on Stefan and Woodland Shores. I urge the members of the City of Charleston Planning Commission to enthusiastically OPPOSE the Riverland Oaks (TMS# 3430000002) request to clear the parcel, fill in wetlands, remove countless grand oaks, and build 95 townhomes behind the Pour House on James Island. • DeAnn Grayson, 863 Century place Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting No to the 95 unit complex • Melba Hawkins, 394 Stefan Drive, Charleston, SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting There is a major concern in my community of Stefan Drive for water runoff which is a direct result of destruction of trees prior to building. Some homes already have water buildup in their yards after a rainfall. So yes, I am in opposition to building behind our homes. In addition the building of these townhouses will be the direct cause of more traffic on Maybank Highway. The traffic is already a major problem and the median just placed there is a monumental disaster for people wanting to make a left turn out of Stefan onto Maybank. It is impossible to see the traffic heading towards John’s Island and quite honestly, I’m afraid there will soon be an accident and a lawsuit against the city for this median which inhibits everyone’s vision when making a left turn onto Maybank Highway. The only way you can truly understand this is to visit Stefan Drive and try to make a left hand turn onto Maybank. Thank you for your attention and listening to my concerns. • Kristen Nichols, 2020 Sea Water Drive Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Please vote no on this. The area already floods. More development doesn’t help. Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 39 • Jayme Jarrett, 3077 Vincent Astor Drive Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Please VOTE NO to Subdivision Approval for Riverland Oaks 95-townhome development plan: • Dee Johnson, Grimball rd charleston sc Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Ya'll please protect james island and its natural oak trees stop approving all of these development projects the infrastructure is already fragile enough. Have any of yall not seen the lorax • Heather Bobbitt, 935 Julia Street Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting No more development especially in flood lands • William Smith, 1352 Bresee St Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Dear City of Charleston Technical Review Committee Staff, Planning Commission, and Board of Zoning Appeals Members: The James Island community is in strong opposition to the proposed Riverland Oaks development concept plan. We urge the Technical Review Committee to recommend denial or significant deferral and redesign, and call upon the Board of Zoning Appeals to apply rigorous scrutiny to any associated variances. This project raises substantial concerns regarding tree preservation, floodplain management, neighborhood character, infrastructure capacity, and consistency with adopted comprehensive plans and corridor management goals. TREE PRESERVATION, CONDITION RATINGS, AND NEED FOR OBJECTIVE RISK ASSESSMENT The City of Charleston's current tree ordinance designates Protected Trees (8" or greater DBH) and Grand Trees (24" or greater DBH, excluding pines and sweetgums). While the ordinance requires permits for Grand Tree removal and emphasizes mitigation, its condition-based letter rating system (e.g., D or F ratings for poor/fair health) is inherently subjective and prone to inconsistent application that can favor development interests over long-term environmental benefits. A rating system focused on noting imperfections (e.g., minor defects or structural concerns) fails to capture a tree's longevity, cumulative ecological value, carbon sequestration, stormwater interception, habitat provision, and contribution to the urban forest canopy over decades. Such ratings can portray otherwise viable, mature trees as "defective," facilitating removal by the party with the strongest financial interest in site clearance. This approach undermines the ordinance's preservation intent and erodes public trust. We strongly recommend mandating ISA Tree Risk Assessment Qualification (TRAQ) evaluations for all Grand and Protected Trees on the site. TRAQ provides a standardized, systematic, and quantifiable methodology assessing likelihood of failure, consequences, and overall risk—offering clear, defensible data on immediate hazards rather than vague condition ratings. To eliminate conflicts of interest, these assessments must be conducted or verified by an independent third-party qualified arborist unaffiliated with the applicant, their consultants, or any entity with a development interest. Results should be reviewed and validated by a neutral body, such as Clemson Extension, a local university forestry program, or an established environmental organization with no political or financial ties to City/County development approvals. All trees should carry an assigned replacement value based on standard appraisal methods (e.g., depreciated reproduction cost adjusted for size, species, condition, and location), with full mitigation required for any approved removals. We further request full public disclosure of the complete tree survey, including DBH, species, locations, proposed impacts, and assessments, prior to any decision. Any BZA variance Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 40 for Grand Tree removal must demonstrate strict compliance with hardship criteria and include superior on-site mitigation (e.g., substantial caliper-inch replacements with native canopy species, enhanced buffers, and long-term monitoring). FLOODPLAIN AND STORMWATER CONCERNS IN A KNOWN FLOOD ZONE The site lies in or adjacent to established flood-prone areas on James Island, including historic creek beds. The proposal relies on a large-scale retaining/detention pond in this sensitive context. Adopted plans, including the Charleston City Plan and stormwater design standards, prioritize avoiding exacerbation of flooding, directing growth to higher-elevation areas, and ensuring no adverse impacts to neighboring properties. A pond of this magnitude raises serious risks of overflow, altered hydrology, and worsened flooding during major events—directly conflicting with resiliency goals and public safety. We request independent engineering review under current manuals and full modeling of cumulative impacts. INCONSISTENCY WITH COMPREHENSIVE PLANS, CORRIDOR GOALS, AND NEIGHBORHOOD CHARACTER The Charleston City Plan and supporting corridor management efforts (including Maybank Highway and Riverland Drive area plans) emphasize well-planned growth that maintains suburban/residential character, protects community corridors, manages traffic on local roads like Woodland Shores, and ensures compatibility with existing development patterns. This out-of-context, high-density townhome proposal on a narrow parcel does not align with these principles. It risks fragmenting the landscape, straining infrastructure, and diminishing aesthetic and property values in established neighborhoods. Growth must benefit the broader community—enhancing rather than hindering livability, environmental quality, and long- term resilience. Variances should only be granted where there is no substantial detriment to public welfare or neighborhood character, per statutory criteria. BROADER PUBLIC INTEREST AND RECOMMENDATIONS Approving this project as proposed would prioritize short-term development gains over sustainable, context-sensitive planning. We urge the City to: Defer the concept plan pending independent TRAQ tree assessments, third-party validation, full flood/traffic studies, and revised designs maximizing preservation. Require enhanced buffers, open space, and native replanting consistent with or exceeding ordinance minimums. Ensure all decisions align with the letter and spirit of the Charleston City Plan, corridor overlays, and tree protection goals. Preserving Charleston's urban forest and community character is essential to the health, beauty, and economic vitality of our region. We implore staff and decision-makers to uphold these priorities. Thank you for your time and consideration. • britt travis, 274 woodland shores road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting We live on woodland shores and are disturbed that this development could move forward as designed. The trees being removed were designated by the developer not the county. The wetlands would be destroyed. 200+ cars daily in an area that is already over populated and cannot handle the current traffic. The animals that live in this natural habitat will be displaced and destroyed. Our property will flood now due to the impervious surfaces and raised dirt elevation from this development. Our peace and quiet will be destroyed by all of the construction and the noise of 200+ residents where we once listened to the birds enjoying their natural habitat. Our privacy will be violated by third floor people peering down into our private back yard. In sum, this is the worst designed development in the history of James island. Please do not let this move forward as designed! • Erin Passow, 274 Woodland Shores Rd Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I am writing as a James Island resident to respectfully urge you to oppose the proposed Riverland Oaks development. While I understand that growth is inevitable, I believe this Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 41 project is simply too intensive for this property and will have lasting consequences for our community. My concerns include: * The loss of valuable green space and the removal of numerous mature trees that provide critical wildlife habitat and help absorb stormwater. * Increased flooding risks. James Island already experiences flooding challenges, and replacing natural land with extensive roads, driveways, sidewalks, and other impervious surfaces will only worsen those problems despite engineered stormwater systems. * Significant traffic increases on roads that are already heavily traveled. Our neighborhood has worked hard to improve pedestrian safety through sidewalks and speed-calming measures. Adding a high-density development will create more congestion and make walking and biking less safe for children, families, annimals, and residents. * The scale of the project is incompatible with the surrounding neighborhoods. Three-story buildings and high-density development will permanently change the character of this area. On a personal level, what saddens me most is watching one of the remaining natural spaces on James Island disappear. Green space is becoming increasingly scarce, yet it is essential for wildlife, the health of our community, and the quality of life that has made James Island such a special place to live. Development should be thoughtful and balanced. I respectfully ask you to prioritize the long-term health, safety, and resilience of our community over short-term development interests. Once these trees and green spaces are gone, they cannot be replaced. Please vote against this proposal and encourage a development plan that better protects James Island’s natural environment, addresses flooding concerns, and preserves the character of our neighborhoods. Thank you for your time, your service, and your consideration. • Brad Tamblyn, 472 Woodland Shores rd. Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I'm very concerned for my House and property. My family has lived here since April of 2020. I'm a 4th generation Charlestonian and love my city. I fully understand why people want to move here and support a majority of it's growth. However, my yard has flooded with as much as 2 feet of water by the so called back drainage ditch that runs parallel along the Riverland Oaks proposed development. Note, this ditch is filled with debris and muck from previous flooding and can't hold water. It takes 3 to 4 days for the flood waters to receed. My garage has taken on 1ft. of water on a couple of occasions. I have excellent videos and pictures documenting every one of these flood occurrences and so does my prominent flood mitigation attorney. We are ready to proceed with a suit against the developer and planning commission for negligence, nuisance and trespassing if approved. I will NEVER stop fighting this cause. I have also walked thru the existing property proposed for the Riverland Oaks development. It is a swamp in many locations. The developer will have to fill and build hence destroying this Habitat. I've witnessed several Owls, Redtail Hawks, Woodpeckers and many other forms of wildlife on this proposed development. I just don't understand how any planning commisioner with common sense would approve any development on a 2 acre wide strip of land at its widest point. It's literally not more than an acre wide for much of the property. Only logical reason I can think of is that each Planning Commissioner that is sitting before you today, has been promised a free condo or a compensation package to an anonymous family member of their choice. This includes the newly elected Town Council member who has mysteriously dissapeared from this fight. You know who you are. He was spearheading this movement and has now ghosted this cause. Very strange considering he lives adjacent to this property. Then you want to build a 3 story structure underneath High Voltage Power lines. Also the intersection at Woodland Shores and Maybank is already deemed one of the most dangerous intersections in Charleston County. This will further endanger everybody. Bye Bye to the wonderful Farmers Market at The Pour House. Bye Bye to any parking at The Pour House for Events. Bye Bye to our wonderful Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 42 sidewalk community. When does this ridiculous development STOP IN CHARLESTON. I ask of each Planning Commissioner TODAY to VOTE NO AND STOP THIS MADNESS! Do the job we elected you to do! Stand up for our rights and VOTE NO! Thank you for allowing my words and consideration. God Bless all of You to make the right decision! • Patrick Duncan, 2082 Maybank Highway unit A Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting As a long time James Island/Riverland terrace resident, I strongly oppose this project being developed. It would desecrate a beautiful community that supports its neighbors. Parking and infrastructure is already a current problem in the area. • Brad Tamblyn, 472 Woodland Shores Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting If the planning commission approves this development then you have no choice but to approve my future dock permit! Thats how illogical this proposed development is! Stand up fot the people who elected you to your position! VOTE NO! • Ester Peterson, 370, Woodland Shores Rd Charleston, SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I have serious concerns about the suitability of this project for the proposed site. The property is in a low-lying area within a Special Flood Hazard zone, and approving a development of this scale raises important questions about flood risk, stormwater management, and the long-term safety and resilience of the community. Not only my house but the surrounding homes of my neighbors have flooded in the past and this will only get worse as the subdivision would be located right behind all of these homes. I ask that you all please vote No for this subdivision, thank you for your time. • Jeff Chausse, 370, Woodland Shores Rd Charleston, SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Dear Members of the Planning Commission, I am writing to formally express my opposition to the proposed development “Riverland Oaks” subdivision, which would involve building on land identified as wetlands. As a property owner in James Island/Charleston County, I urge the Commission to deny this proposal or require a full environmental review before any permits are issued. My concerns are as follows: 1. Flood Control and Stormwater Management. Wetlands act as natural sponges, absorbing excess rainfall and reducing the risk of flooding for surrounding properties. Filling or building on this land could increase runoff and flood risk to nearby homes and infrastructure. 2. Water Quality. Wetlands filter pollutants and sediment before they reach groundwater and nearby waterways. Development in this area threatens the quality of our local water supply. 3. Habitat and Biodiversity. Wetlands provide essential habitat for local wildlife, including migratory birds, amphibians, and other species. Destroying this habitat would have lasting ecological consequences. 4. Regulatory Compliance. I ask that the Commission confirm this proposal has undergone a full wetlands delineation and environmental impact assessment in accordance with [state wetlands protection act / local ordinance / Clean Water Act Section 404, as applicable], and that this documentation be made available for public review. 5. Long-Term Community Impact. Once wetlands are destroyed, they cannot be easily replaced. I encourage the Commission to weigh the short-term benefits of this development against the permanent, irreversible loss of this natural resource. I respectfully request that the Commission deny this application, or at minimum delay approval until an independent environmental review is completed and shared with the public. I would also welcome the opportunity to speak on this matter at any upcoming public hearing. Thank you for your Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 43 time and consideration. Please feel free to contact me with any questions. Sincerely, Jeff Chausse 370 Woodland Shores Rd Charleston, SC 29412 (843) 460-4534 • Carmen Mercer, 1626 Donnie Lane Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I request that you vote no to subdivision approval for the Riverland Oaks development. This is a flood prone area and will cause further issues. • Joshua Neal, 336 Woodland Shores Rd. Charleston, SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting To: City of Charleston Planning Commission Re: Request to Vote NO on Subdivision Approval — "Riverland Oaks" (95-unit townhome development), Planning Commission Meeting, July 15, 2026 From: Dr. Joshua A. Neal, 336 Woodland Shores Rd., Charleston, SC 29412 Dear Members of the Planning Commission, I am a resident of Woodland Shores Road whose property directly adjoins the proposed Riverland Oaks development. I am writing to respectfully urge the Commission to vote NO on subdivision approval, and to ask that the following technical deficiencies be entered into the record and resolved before any approval is considered. 1. Stormwater management and flood impact on adjoining property. The site sits in a low-lying, specially protected flood zone, and the plan proposes a road and a stormwater retention pond directly behind my property. The back portion of my lot already experiences recurrent flooding under existing conditions, which indicates that the site's pre-development drainage capacity is already exceeded. Before approval, I ask the Commission to confirm that the applicant's stormwater management plan demonstrates, with supporting engineering calculations, that post- development runoff will produce no net increase in the rate or volume of stormwater discharged toward Woodland Shores Road and adjacent lots, in full compliance with the City of Charleston stormwater design standards and applicable SCDES requirements. Placing a retention pond and additional impervious surface at the low point adjacent to properties that already flood raises a substantial question as to whether this standard can be met. If it cannot be demonstrated on the record, the plan does not satisfy the City's technical criteria and should not be approved. 2. Required buffer from adjoining residential property. It is my understanding that a 20-foot buffer is required along the rear boundary separating this development from existing residential lots. Based on the site plan, it does not appear that this buffer has been correctly accounted for where the proposed road and retention pond are located near my property line. I ask the Commission to verify that the required buffer is accurately shown, is free of encroachment by the road, pond, or associated grading, and complies with the applicable DR-6 and subdivision regulations. If the buffer has not been properly applied, the plat does not meet the City's requirements and approval would be premature. 3. Wetland impacts and federal review. The meeting packet identifies multiple areas of wetlands on the site. Wetland impacts of this kind ordinarily require a Clean Water Act Section 404 permit from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, which can carry associated federal environmental-review and agency-consultation obligations. I ask the Commission to confirm that any required federal wetlands permitting and associated review have been completed — or, if not, to condition its consideration on that being resolved first, so the City does not approve a plat whose wetland impacts remain federally unpermitted. I would also note for the record that the site supports active native wildlife habitat, including the Great Horned Owl (Bubo virginianus), which I have documented on video and can provide. Great Horned Owls and their active nests are protected under the federal Migratory Bird Treaty Act, and I ask that the presence of protected species on site be considered in the review of clearing and permitting. For these reasons — unresolved stormwater and flood-mitigation concerns, an apparent buffer deficiency, and Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 44 outstanding wetland permitting and environmental-review questions — I respectfully request that the Commission vote NO, or at minimum defer action until these technical requirements are fully documented and satisfied. Thank you for your time and for entering these comments into the record. Respectfully, Dr. Joshua A. Neal 336 Woodland Shores Rd., Charleston, SC 29412 joshua.anderson.neal@gmail.com • Samantha Duncan, 250 Stefan Dr. Unit A Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting As a resident/property owner on Stefan Dr., this land development project is widely concerning. There are multiple factors that raise concern, including flooding and water runoff issues already present on Stefan Dr., increased infrastructure concerns on an already crowded corridor of Maybank Hwy including normal traffic congestion and drawbridge gridlock backups, and destruction of thousands of trees and wildlife disruptions. I strongly urge the community to reassess the impact that this development will bring. There is not an available housing crisis in this area. There is however a potential crisis to existing housing and current residents should this plan be approved. I appreciate your consideration that this development plan should be denied. • Simaya van Dooren, 739 Schaffer Street Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Please vote NO on this. This development would be in a low-lying, special protection flood zone. Please respect these protections. There is NO stormwater plan for this property that can manage the run-off that will impact residents on Stefan Dr and on Woodland Shores Rd. Thank you • Brandon Muir, 324 Woodland Shores Rd Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Impermeable surface size concerns, traffic routing on Maybank, insufficient flood protections in place given the ongoing misalignment of City’s planning tables related to frequency/size of storms • DIANE & JOHN MOLNAR, 289 Stefan Dr Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Please vote NO to the plan. We are in strong opposition to the proposed Riverland Oaks development concept plan. We urge the Technical Review Committee to recommend denial or significant deferral and redesign, and call upon the Board of Zoning Appeals to apply rigorous scrutiny to any associated variances. This project raises substantial concerns regarding tree preservation, floodplain management, neighborhood character, infrastructure capacity, and consistency with adopted comprehensive plans and corridor management goals. Thank you. • Sarah Bourne, 1229 Creek Stone Way Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I URGE you to vote NO on this project! The area is much better served as a buffer zone between neighborhoods and businesses, for wildlife, and for proper water/storm drainage. The parking area at the Pour House already floods, and filling in the area behind it with pavement and townhomes will make that significantly worse. Plus, the development will negatively impact a local, family-owned, business that has been operating there for 20+ years. The Charleston Pour House is a staple of art, connection, and tourism in the local community and for artists and fans across the country. The people who move into the townhomes would likely complain about the noise from the business that came first. Finally, the infrastructure of the roads there was made worse by Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 45 the recent addition of the median. Traffic is already congested and poorly managed in that area. To add more homes in this area would be foolish, and I am begging you to vote NO to developing behind the Charleston Pour House!! • Kathleen Ate, 404 Stefan drive Charleston sc 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This would have a heavily negative impact on the existing neighborhoods and residents. As well as negative impacts on wildlife. Please stop this development. • Edie Hering, 1022 Mt. Vernon Drive 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Please vote NO on the Riverland Oaks Subdivision with 95 proposed townhomes. Not only is it in a flood zone, James Island cannot accommodate that many additional homes. • Caroline deGolian, 700 Daniel Ellis Drive Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I strongly urge the Planning Commission to VOTE NO on the Riverland Oaks subdivision approval. This poorly planned development would exacerbate flooding on Stefan Dr and Woodland Shores Rd, which already have serious flooding problems. The area for the proposed development is a protected flood zone. Per the 2021 City of Charleston's Comprehensive Land Use Plan Section 54-945, the City of Charleston will "restore and preserve natural ecosystems....That ecosystems that provide stormwater benefits and essential wildlife habitats...should be preserved". Please, vote NO on the Riverland Oaks subdivision which will only cause serious flooding and traffic issues on James Island. • Johanna Lingenfelter, 2060 Medway Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This high density complex will absorb valuable sponge forest that will be vital as floods continue to worsen, and continue to complicate traffic on a congested highway. Furthermore, NONE of the recent housing additions on the James Island Maybank corridor have been "affordable." Please look into repurposing spaces that have already been disturbed, such as the old strip mall next to the Roper facilities on Folly Road. • Sommer Pendergraft, 860 B Mellichamp.Dr. Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This area is already plagued with traffic issues and flooding. Adding 95 more residences on top of this natural wetland will cause both of these issues to become exponentially worse for those with existing houses. This is a terrible plan by a builder known for subpar construction quality and will do nothing to improve the area. We need housing, yes. This plan is not the answer. • MARCOS VARGAS, 2117 Grove. Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This is an already congested and dangerous area. Several people have already died crossing that street in that same spot The area floods and more homes without infrastructure is damaging the soul of the city. You cannot keep building without building infrastructure first. Voting for this project goes against everything this historic city stands for • Lindsey Killeen, 210 Collingwoood Ave Charleston, SC 29407 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Almost an entire acre of wetlands will be destroyed for this project, which will have a massive negative impact on both the local ecosystem and flooding. This is a low-lying, Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 46 special protection flood zone and there is no stormwater plan for this property that can manage the runoff that will impact residents on Stefan Dr. and on Woodland Shores Rd. There are at least 25 grand trees on this property and tearing any of them down will also have a negative lasting impact on the ecosystem and flooding. The location for this project is also terrible - the Riverland/Maybank intersection, Woodland Shore/Maybank intersection, and Folly/Maybank intersection are already highly congested and DANGEROUS, meaning the danger and congestion will only get worse with the addition of this project. In summary, this project not only poses a serious threat to the local ecosystems, flooding potential and congestion issues, but it also poses a threat to the character that makes James Island special. Please, do NOT approve this project and protect this special area. • Dr. Gracja Rodriguez, 320 Woodland Shores Rd. Charleston, SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Dear Planning Commission, For years, Charleston has faced growing public criticism for behaving like a 'fill-and-build' city, clearing natural forested sponges, filling low-lying pockets, and replacing them with high-density asphalt footprints, only to deal with the downstream flooding consequences later. The Riverland Oaks proposal is a textbook example of this outdated behavior. By voting 'no' or demanding a significant down- zoning of this 28-acre tract, this Commission has a powerful opportunity to prove that Charleston is moving past the fill-and-build era. I am not opposed to all development, but I am against high density development in a natural area crucial for existing homes. While the proposal has been downsized from the original, a 95-unit mixed-density development remains too dense for an area characterized by SR-1 single-family homes in Woodland Shores, Riverland Terrace and surrounding area. The DR-6 zoning of this tract is an isolated "red flag" that disregards the surrounding single-family scale. You can show the community that our planning guidelines are living documents designed to protect established neighborhoods. Frustratingly, counting stormwater retention basins (retention ponds) toward the project's open space requirements is a disingenuous interpretation of the City’s Comprehensive Plan. These ponds are mandatory utility infrastructure designed for runoff management; they are completely unusable for human recreation and should not be used to justify such a high-density footprint. Regarding the Hollings Road drainage improvements, the Hollings Road drainage improvements are a long-overdue correction for existing residential issues, not an open invitation to overload the system with a new 95-unit development. This will be complete infrastructure overload. Paving over 28 acres of natural watershed will generate millions of gallons of net-new runoff. If you approve Riverland Oaks, the new infrastructure will be overwhelmed before it is even fully broken in, effectively wasting $1.3 million in public funds. Taxpayers paid $1.3 million to give our neighborhoods a breathing room from chronic flooding. When the developer dumps tons of dirt fill onto this 28-acre basin to elevate 95 townhomes, the underground water table will immediately rise and push outward into our existing single-family yards. Giving that hard-won drainage capacity away to a private developer's high-density project completely defeats the purpose of the public project. We ask the Commission to defer or deny until a cumulative, independent watershed impact study is completed—not just a localized site review. The City of Charleston frequently publishes goals regarding resilience, water management, and preserving the canopy. I would like to hold the city to this. James Island's canopy is disappearing. If the city shouts resilience but approves a 95-unit high-density complex on a known wetland buffer, the actions don't match the policy. If this Commission denies or defers this high-density request due to its incompatibility with our neighborhood, it opens the door for a better solution. This 28-acre tract is the perfect candidate for the Lowcountry Land Trust or the City’s Greenbelt program. Ideally, we urge the City to Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 47 pause this development to explore a conservation buyout via the Lowcountry Land Trust or Greenbelt program, preserving this land as a natural "community sponge." I understand the city cannot force a developer to give their land to a land trust but we can bring them back to the negotiation table. Our neighborhoods votes, out-of-state developers don't. This is our number one priority in this very important year. We will be watching carefully if the city's leadership actually practices the resilience they preach, or if they are going to rubber-stamp another fill-and-build project. Prove to the public that we are not a fill and build city. The City of Charleston, THIS is YOUR chance. The Commission has the authority to ensure Charleston's growth is smart and resilient. Please show the community that our planning guidelines are protective documents, not rubber stamps for maximum-density infill. Don't tell us, SHOW us. It is NOT too late to vote NO. • Liz Crowley, 2395 Folly Rd Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Enough already! Take some control to save our future. Please. • Martin Padgett, 727 Creekside Dr. Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Riverland Oaks James Island | TMS# 3430000002 | Council District 11 | Approx. 27.82 ac. Request Concept Plan approval for a 95-lot townhome development. Owner: Venn James Island, LLC Applicant: Sitecast, LLC The over-development of James Island and surrounding communities in Charleston has gotten out of hand. We don’t have the infrastructure in place to support the growth we’ve had as things exist now. This planned development is the last thing James Island needs right now. This will only add to the already horrible traffic situation that exists there during most hours of the day. • Scott McLaughlin, 51 Held Circle, Charleston, SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I am a lifelong resident of James Island and have seen immense growth in the area. This high density development, if approved, will contribute to already miserable traffic on Maybank Highway. Further, drainage in these areas is already suspect, and demolishing the current biomass and installing impervious surfaces will no doubt lead to more issues. Members of the planning commission, please vote no. • Heather Piazza, 2856 Claybrook St., Johns Is., Sc 29455 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Riverland Oaks James Island | TMS# 3430000002 | Council District 11 | Approx. 27.82 ac. Request Concept Plan approval for a 95-lot townhome development. Owner: Venn James Island, LLC Applicant: Sitecast, LLC Key concerns regarding the current proposal include: - Neighborhood Character: While the proposal has been downsized, a 95-unit mixed- density development remains too dense for an area characterized by SR-1 single-family homes in Woodland Shores and Riverland Terrace. The DR-6 zoning of this tract is an isolated "red flag" that disregards the surrounding single-family scale. - Infrastructure Overload: The $1.3 million Hollings Road drainage improvements were intended to provide relief for existing residents, not to subsidize high-density infill. Paving this 28-acre watershed will generate millions of gallons of runoff, likely overwhelming new infrastructure before it is fully operational. - Drainage and Displacement: Filling this 28- acre basin will elevate the water table, pushing water into the crawlspaces and foundations of adjacent properties. - Open Space Misrepresentation: Counting mandatory stormwater retention ponds as "open space" is a disingenuous interpretation of the City’s Comprehensive Plan, as these utilities provide no recreational value. - Environmental Policy Gap: Approving this density on a wetland buffer contradicts the Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 48 City’s stated goals for resilience and canopy preservation. We request the Commission require an independent, cumulative watershed impact study rather than a localized review. We request an enforcement of stronger step-down density buffers, increased rear setbacks, and mandatory vegetative screening along shared property boundaries. • Ignatius Dauchot, 2038 Cheraw Dr Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Please VOTE NO to “Subdivision Approval”. This is one of the few remaining green spaces in the area--home to countless owls, hawks, etc. As a local resident, the added congestion along Woodland Shores is also of great concern. • William Jarrett, 3077 Vincent Astor Drive, Johns Island, SC 29455 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Please Vote no to this development. The culture of James Island will be negatively impacted by this development. This will also negatively impact the natural landscape of James Island. • Kimberly Biederman, 1041 Harbortowne Road 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting We don’t need to destroy anymore wetlands and green space for someone to benefit from. The flooding is already a problem. This will Only make it worse. Not to mention taking away animals homes. • Jennifer Griswell, 1027 Kingswood Drive Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting No more building. The island can not support the development. Leave it be! • Allie Colgan, 1333 sea aire drive, Charleston sc 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting No!!! There is too much building on JI- it’s like a parking lot now. We need to save as much green space as we can. We don’t need anymore traffic or congestion- especially in that area! • Magdalen Abarta, Folly Road Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I am opposed to this subdivision being built for multiple reasons, to include ecological and quality of life issues. Thank you. • Will Davis, East and West Rd Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Being born and raised in James Island, I have watched massive development of the surrounding sea islands. They all continue to destroy wetland environments and native tree species that have been around for hundreds of years. It is wreaking havoc on the environment of James Island and worsening the flood problem. This is what happens when you destroy wetland environments, fill them, and divert all the water into stormwater retention ponds. There is no where for the water to go, it creates sterile environments. This is a new age of engineered issues that seem to be the copout for destroying wetlands. People move here and try to make a quick buck by buying land and pushing the absolute limits for how big and how many homes they can build on the smallest plots. This is not James Island and I pray the town makes the right call by rejecting this. Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 49 • Whitnei Smith, 1220 Oakcrest Dr. Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting As a concerned citizen, the approval of this project will damage the ecosystem that is already there which will result in more flooding issues. Removing trees will cause more flooding and even more traffic in that area. • Anonymous Anonymous, Anonymous Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting This plan is NOT compatible with the City's Comprehensive Land Use Plan per Section 54- 945 of the City's ordinances. The Charleston City Plan (2021) states that Charleston will "restore and preserve natural ecosystems....That ecosystems that provide stormwater benefits and essential wildlife habitats...should be preserved" This 27+ acre wooded sponge forest should be preserved per the "Charleston City Plan". • Christine Cronin, 290 Stefan Drive Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I live at 290 Stefan Dr. Building 95 townhouses behind my backyard will cut down all the trees that help absorb rain water. My backyard floods now when the current ditch overflows, when the trees are gone, it will be worst and flood my crawl. Do not build and pour concrete on this proposed land for townhouses. • Luis Rodriguez, 515 Woodland Shores, Charleston SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Proposed project affects the neighborhood character. A sizable effort was made to make Woodland Shores a safer road after an unfortunate hit and run. Increasing the traffic flow will undo all current successful efforts. Adding a possible traffic flow of an additional + 95 cars again makes Woodland Shore a thoroughfare instead of the desired neighborhood street. • Loretta Nagel Rodriguez, 513 Woodland Shores, Charleston, SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting After having just completed a much needed sewer infrastructure update on , Woodland Shores Rd, speed bumps to slow and deter additional traffic on Woodland Shores and sidewalks ..the proposed 95 lot development adjacent will have a direct affect on re- flooding neighbors and moving backwards... As a new homeowner we made sure to consider our neighbors in how we built our homes' water flow and retention. Lets move forward and preserve this land and NOT build RIVERLAND OAKS. • Kim Corbett, 2003 Covey Lane Charleston SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Boiler plate message created . If you could find a way to blast this Susan, I messed up the everyone feature on our page and couldn’t get it out the way I wished ! SUBMITTED ON BEHALF OF THE CHARLESTON COUNTY TREE PRESERVATION ALLIANCE Re: TRC-SUB2024- 000286 – Riverland Oaks Concept Plan (TMS #3430000002, James Island, approximately 27.82 acres, 95-lot townhome development) Date: [Insert Submission Date] Dear City of Charleston Technical Review Committee Staff, Planning Commission, and Board of Zoning Appeals Members: The Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance respectfully submits these comments in strong opposition to the proposed Riverland Oaks development concept plan. We urge the Technical Review Committee to recommend denial or significant deferral and redesign, and call upon the Board of Zoning Appeals to apply rigorous scrutiny to any associated variances. This project raises substantial concerns regarding tree preservation, floodplain management, neighborhood character, Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 50 infrastructure capacity, and consistency with adopted comprehensive plans and corridor management goals. TREE PRESERVATION, CONDITION RATINGS, AND NEED FOR OBJECTIVE RISK ASSESSMENT The City of Charleston's current tree ordinance designates Protected Trees (8" or greater DBH) and Grand Trees (24" or greater DBH, excluding pines and sweetgums). While the ordinance requires permits for Grand Tree removal and emphasizes mitigation, its condition-based letter rating system (e.g., D or F ratings for poor/fair health) is inherently subjective and prone to inconsistent application that can favor development interests over long-term environmental benefits. A rating system focused on noting imperfections (e.g., minor defects or structural concerns) fails to capture a tree's longevity, cumulative ecological value, carbon sequestration, stormwater interception, habitat provision, and contribution to the urban forest canopy over decades. Such ratings can portray otherwise viable, mature trees as "defective," facilitating removal by the party with the strongest financial interest in site clearance. This approach undermines the ordinance's preservation intent and erodes public trust. We strongly recommend mandating ISA Tree Risk Assessment Qualification (TRAQ) evaluations for all Grand and Protected Trees on the site. TRAQ provides a standardized, systematic, and quantifiable methodology assessing likelihood of failure, consequences, and overall risk—offering clear, defensible data on immediate hazards rather than vague condition ratings. To eliminate conflicts of interest, these assessments must be conducted or verified by an independent third-party qualified arborist unaffiliated with the applicant, their consultants, or any entity with a development interest. Results should be reviewed and validated by a neutral body, such as Clemson Extension, a local university forestry program, or an established environmental organization with no political or financial ties to City/County development approvals. All trees should carry an assigned replacement value based on standard appraisal methods (e.g., depreciated reproduction cost adjusted for size, species, condition, and location), with full mitigation required for any approved removals. The Alliance further requests full public disclosure of the complete tree survey, including DBH, species, locations, proposed impacts, and assessments, prior to any decision. Any BZA variance for Grand Tree removal must demonstrate strict compliance with hardship criteria and include superior on-site mitigation (e.g., substantial caliper-inch replacements with native canopy species, enhanced buffers, and long-term monitoring). FLOODPLAIN AND STORMWATER CONCERNS IN A KNOWN FLOOD ZONE The site lies in or adjacent to established flood- prone areas on James Island, including historic creek beds. The proposal relies on a large- scale retaining/detention pond in this sensitive context. Adopted plans, including the Charleston City Plan and stormwater design standards, prioritize avoiding exacerbation of flooding, directing growth to higher-elevation areas, and ensuring no adverse impacts to neighboring properties. A pond of this magnitude raises serious risks of overflow, altered hydrology, and worsened flooding during major events—directly conflicting with resiliency goals and public safety. We request independent engineering review under current manuals and full modeling of cumulative impacts. INCONSISTENCY WITH COMPREHENSIVE PLANS, CORRIDOR GOALS, AND NEIGHBORHOOD CHARACTER The Charleston City Plan and supporting corridor management efforts (including Maybank Highway and Riverland Drive area plans) emphasize well-planned growth that maintains suburban/residential character, protects community corridors, manages traffic on local roads like Woodland Shores, and ensures compatibility with existing development patterns. This out-of-context, high-density townhome proposal on a narrow parcel does not align with these principles. It risks fragmenting the landscape, straining infrastructure, and diminishing aesthetic and property values in established neighborhoods. Growth must benefit the broader community—enhancing rather than hindering livability, environmental quality, and long-term resilience. Variances should only be granted where there is no substantial detriment to public welfare or Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 51 neighborhood character, per statutory criteria. BROADER PUBLIC INTEREST AND RECOMMENDATIONS Approving this project as proposed would prioritize short-term development gains over sustainable, context-sensitive planning. We urge the City to: Defer the concept plan pending independent TRAQ tree assessments, third-party validation, full flood/traffic studies, and revised designs maximizing preservation. Require enhanced buffers, open space, and native replanting consistent with or exceeding ordinance minimums. Ensure all decisions align with the letter and spirit of the Charleston City Plan, corridor overlays, and tree protection goals. The Alliance stands ready to provide additional expertise or participate in discussions. Preserving Charleston's urban forest and community character is essential to the health, beauty, and economic vitality of our region. We implore staff and decision-makers to uphold these priorities. Thank you for your careful consideration. • Kim Murphy, 1660 Dexter Lane, Charleston, SC, 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Re: TRC-SUB2024-000286 – Riverland Oaks Concept Plan (TMS #3430000002), James Island, approximately 27.82 acres, 95-lot townhome development) Dear City of Charleston Technical Review Committee Staff, Planning Commission, and Board of Zoning Appeals Members: I oppose the proposed Riverland Oaks development concept plan. We urge the Technical Review Committee to recommend denial or significant deferral and redesign, and call upon the Board of Zoning Appeals to apply rigorous scrutiny to any associated variances. This project raises substantial concerns regarding tree preservation, floodplain management, neighborhood character, infrastructure capacity, and consistency with adopted comprehensive plans and corridor management goals. FLOODPLAIN AND STORMWATER CONCERNS IN A KNOWN FLOOD ZONE The site lies in or adjacent to established flood-prone areas on James Island, including historic creek beds. The proposal relies on a large-scale retaining/detention pond in this sensitive context. Adopted plans, including the Charleston City Plan and stormwater design standards, prioritize avoiding exacerbation of flooding, directing growth to higher-elevation areas, and ensuring no adverse impacts to neighboring properties. A pond of this magnitude raises serious risks of overflow, altered hydrology, and worsened flooding during major events—directly conflicting with resiliency goals and public safety. We request independent engineering review under current manuals and full modeling of cumulative impacts. INCONSISTENCY WITH COMPREHENSIVE PLANS, CORRIDOR GOALS, AND NEIGHBORHOOD CHARACTER The Charleston City Plan and supporting corridor management efforts (including Maybank Highway and Riverland Drive area plans) emphasize well-planned growth that maintains suburban/residential character, protects community corridors, manages traffic on local roads like Woodland Shores, and ensures compatibility with existing development patterns. This out-of-context, high-density townhome proposal on a narrow parcel does not align with these principles. It risks fragmenting the landscape, straining infrastructure, and diminishing aesthetic and property values in established neighborhoods. Growth must benefit the broader community—enhancing rather than hindering livability, environmental quality, and long- term resilience. Variances should only be granted where there is no substantial detriment to public welfare or neighborhood character, per statutory criteria. BROADER PUBLIC INTEREST AND RECOMMENDATIONS Approving this project as proposed would prioritize short-term development gains over sustainable, context-sensitive planning. We urge the City to: Defer the concept plan pending independent TRAQ tree assessments, third-party validation, full flood/traffic studies, and revised designs maximizing preservation. Require enhanced buffers, open space, and native replanting consistent with or exceeding ordinance minimums. Ensure all decisions align with the letter and spirit of the Charleston City Plan, corridor overlays, and tree protection goals. The Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 52 Alliance stands ready to provide additional expertise or participate in discussions. Preserving Charleston's urban forest and community character is essential to the health, beauty, and economic vitality of our region. We implore staff and decision-makers to uphold these priorities. James Island is already overdeveloped. The traffic is overwhelming. Especially in the Maybank Highway area. We do not need more high density developments. James Island is already well on the road to being an unpleasant place to live. Your role is to help our community …….so please don’t add to the overdevelopment problem. Thank you for your careful consideration. Sincerely, Kim Murphy • stefanie snead, Timberline drive Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting VOTE NO to Subdivision Approval. This plan is NOT compatible with the City's Comprehensive Land Use Plan per Section 54-945 of the City's ordinances. The Charleston City Plan (2021) states that Charleston will "restore and preserve natural ecosystems....That ecosystems that provide stormwater benefits and essential wildlife habitats...should be preserved" This 27+ acre wooded sponge forest should be preserved per the "Charleston City Plan”. • Jessica Wilson, 356 Woodland Shores Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Dear Mr. Schultz and Members of the Technical Rview Committee, Please VOTE NO Nto Riverland Oaks subdivision! My house is at 356 Woodland Shores and backs up to the proposed Riverland Oaks property. Before I owned this house, I rented next door for many years. There is always standing water on this property that has served as a drainage area for Woodland Shores and Stefan Drive -- both areas prone to regular flooding and known to have many houses that have flooded many times in the two decades that I have lived here.When the electric lines were installed over 10 years ago, my flooding greatly increased. I can't even fathom developing this property. These photos are from October 2015. Ten years ago this property was covered in water almost all the time, all the way across from Woodland Shores to Stefan lines. It's way worse now!This is the property that you are talking about putting a major development. In the 10 years since these photos have taken, my property has seen a major increase in flooding. In October 2015, the water was just starting to creep into the back yard (across the fence) from the proposed Riverland Oaks development. Now, ten years later, when it floods, it has gotten so much worse, filling my huge backyard (half acre) and even touching my house multiple times. I have spent at least $25k in moisture damage, dehumidifier installation, encapsulation and mold removal due to this flooding. It is inconceivable that you would consider building there. The whole are acts as drainage pond for multiple James Island areas that already majorly flood. Many houses on my road have flooded multiples times in the 20 years that I have lived on Woodland Shores. Think about all the water being absorbed by those trees and overgrowth. There are true wetlands with fish on that property. You are going to flood me out of my home! We all know the traffic issues and traffic-related accidents and deaths in this area. Please also take that into consideration with any developing plans in this area. Please say NO to the proposed Riverland Oaks development. I apologize that I cannot be there in person to say this, but I will be in Virginia for a Hero's Walk tomorrow (7/15). If you have any other questions, please let me know. I am sure I have more recent photos of the regular flooding, but I did not have time to pull them today. Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 53 • Michael Thomas, 2106 Maybank hwy 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting We own property and live in this area and we are against this development because of the adverse affects this development will produce. This area should be left undeveloped because of it's purpose of drainage for this area. If you fill it and build it then the water will go elsewhere onto others property causing flooding and property damage. Leave this land as a drainage basin • Mary Johnson, 436 Howle Ave Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I live close to the area being discussed for development. I must tell you that this area floods and it will cause congestion of epic proportions. The intersections before the site and after the site are already backed up. It has taking almost an act of god to get a flashing turning light on Maybank and woodland shore and even with that addition I watched 3 cars while at the light at Wappoo and Maybank just today make a u turn when they reached the intersection so they could get to the Sunday market behind the poor house. The problem will became dangerous when you have a new road coming out along side of the poor house. This is so wrong and yet lm sure it will go forward and in 3-5 years with additional people on the road driving, walking, waiting on school buses and so on people will be hurt and lives will be lost. The area on maybank can not handle this much traffic and placing a new development with people attempting to get out of their street or in is just not going to work primarily because of what has now been done to Maybank and Woodland shore. There will be a serious issue if this is allowed to take place starting with development and continuing with construction and people living in the proposed area. • Elizabeth Winsor, 2111 St James Drive Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting No to apartment complex • Lewis Nelson, 2056 Cheraw Drive Charleston SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 54 Subdivision Riverland Oaks TMS# 3550800065 Please deny this development plan. This land is currently one of the few remaining green spaces that remain on the island. It was wrongly rezoned. Development of this density would contribute to significant destruction of habitat and increase flooding issues for existing neighborhoods. Only a lower density plan should be considered. • Alison Paquette, 46 Crosscreek dr charleston sc 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting I am born and raised on James Island. This is an awful awful idea no one on James island wants this. The traffic in the area is already dense and now the new updates have made it less accessible to enjoy the things in the area. The people of James island deserve to enjoy their home and our environment without 200 additional people and cars to deal with. James island needs things for children and shopping, not any more car washes or more neighborhood. The pour house and the terrace is an enjoyable area and this will further diminish the accessibility of this area. • Joyce Weir, 2210 Aubrey Drive Charleston SC 29412 Submitted to Staff for July 15, 2026 Meeting Stop the construction planned off the Maybank Hwy on James Island. It will destroy a vital area of our ecosystem. D. ZONINGS 1. 2788 Garden Creek Road West Ashley | TMS# 3550800065 | Council District 2 | Approx. 0.34 ac. Request zoning Canterbury Woods-Planned Unit Development (CW-PUD). Zoned Planned Development (PD) in Charleston County. Owner: Vincent Ferrante 2. 2792 Garden Creek Road West Ashley | TMS# 3550800066 | Council District 2 | Approx. 0.33 ac. Request zoning Canterbury Woods-Planned Unit Development (CW-PUD). Zoned Planned Development (PD) in Charleston County. Owner: Christine Murakami 3. 1627 Wappoo Drive James Island | TMS# 3511200106 | Council District 7 | Approx. 0.20 ac. Request zoning Single Family Residential (SR-1). Zoned Residential (R-4) in Charleston County. Owner: Terrence Rank 4. 2153 Saint James Dr. West Ashley | TMS# 3430100147 | Council District 11 | Approx. 0.29 ac. Request zoning Single Family Residential (SR-1). Zoned Residential (R-4) in Charleston County. Owner: Michael Creasy E. PP&S STAFF UPDATES PUBLIC MEETING ACCOMMODATIONS: Planning Commission Public Comment | July 15, 2026 Page 55 In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, people who need alternative formats, ASL (American Sign Language) Interpretation, or other accommodation, should please contact Janet Schumacher at 843-577-1389 or schumacherj@charleston-sc.gov three business days prior to the meeting. Position Statement Planning Commission July 15, 2026 Ordinance Amendment B.1. Dear Board Members: The Preservation Society of Charleston (PSC) supports the proposed amendments to Sections 54-208 and 54-227 of the City of Charleston Zoning Ordinance. These changes will help ensure that the city’s Short Term Rental (STR) Ordinance is implemented and enforced in a manner consistent with its original intent and recognized best practices. PSC particularly supports the amendments clarifying that square footage may be considered when determining whether an STR is subordinate to the principal residential use. This provision provides clearer guidance for administration and enforcement and reinforces the ordinance’s intent that STRs remain accessory uses on residential properties. By strengthening the city’s ability to maintain the residential character of neighborhoods, protect existing housing stock, and uphold the balance between visitor accommodations and community preservation, these amendments advance the core goals of the STR Ordinance. Thank you for considering our position in this matter. Sincerely, Anna-Catherine Alexander Director of Advocacy Initiatives July 14, 2026 VIA EMAIL Julia Copeland, Esq. Magalie Creech, Esq. City of Charleston Office of Corporation Counsel copelandj@charleston-sc.gov creechm@charleston-sc.gov Re: Proposed Short-Term Rental Ordinance Amendment Dear Julia and Magalie: As you know, I represent CKC Properties, LLC (“CKC”) in various matters. CKC, through its affiliates, owns and operates multiple short-term rental (“STR”) units in the City’s STR Overlay Zone. Also, CKC is currently in the process of constructing or obtaining building permits for several other units that will be used as STR units, as CKC has conspicuously disclosed on all applicable permit and Technical Review Committee applications.1 It is our understanding that the City of Charleston’s staff is sponsoring various amendments to the ordinance that governs STR units, including imposing a maximum occupancy limit of the lesser of the occupancy allowed under the International Property Maintenance Code (IPMC) or eight persons. For the reasons discussed below, we are requesting that the City revise the proposed ordinance amendment to eliminate the eight-person maximum occupancy limit or, alternatively, provide grandfathered status to STR units that are already operating, in construction, or in the permitting process to exempt them from the eight-person maximum. To begin, we challenge the legitimacy of the eight-person occupancy limit as it is not connected to the City’s interest in protecting the life or safety of STR guests. The IPMC, through its occupancy limits, establishes that properties with four or more bedrooms of adequate size under the IPMC can safely accommodate more than eight guests. Furthermore, we are unaware of any studies the City has conducted to establish the eight-person maximum or what specific objective such limit is attempting to accomplish. While it has been suggested that occupancy limits may be intended to discourage noisy and disruptive parties in residential neighborhoods, the City’s existing noise ordinance, found at Sec. 21-16, already provides the City with ample authority to penalize those guests who disrupt neighboring residents. As a result, the eight-person maximum is an arbitrarily determined limitation that neither advances a legitimate governmental purpose of protecting life and safety nor is it narrowly tailored to achieve the goal of reducing loud parties. These fundamental flaws with the eight-person maximum occupancy limit raise serious Equal Protection concerns because it imposes on STR units an occupancy limit that is stricter than 1 CKC’s STR units are identified on Attachment A, which is attached. July 14, 2026 Page 2 building-safety code requirements, while exempting other residential units from that limit. See Hignell-Stark v. City of New Orleans, 154 F.4th 345 (5th Cir. 2025) (ruling that ban on businesses from owning STRs violated the Equal Protection Clause). The City cannot treat similarly situated property owners differently without a rational basis, and none exists here. To avoid this potential constitutional violation, the City should eliminate the eight-person maximum occupancy limit. With respect to this request, it is important to note that many STR units with four or more bedrooms are currently accommodating families of more than eight persons. During the engagement process associated with this STR amendment, it has become clear that many are under the mistaken belief that the current STR ordinance limits occupancy to only four individuals of the same family, thereby creating the impression that the proposed eight-person limit will actually increase occupancy limits. That impression is, however, false because it is routine for larger extended families of more than eight persons to rent a single unit consisting of four or more bedrooms. This reality needs to be recognized and taken into account to ensure that consideration of the STR ordinance amendment is based on accurate and truthful information. If the occupancy limit is not eliminated, we urge the City to alternatively grandfather STR units that are currently permitted, under construction, or in the permitting process and expressly exempt them from the eight-person limit. This exemption is essential to protect the reasonable investment- backed expectations of those owners, such as CKC, who have expended significant sums to purchase property and build or modify STR units with more than four bedrooms. These existing and prospective STR owners reasonably relied in good faith on the lack of a fixed occupancy limit for STR units when they chose to invest in their properties. It would be fundamentally unjust— and legally indefensible—for the City to unilaterally change the rules now, particularly when the eight-person occupancy limit serves no legitimate public safety purpose, as demonstrated above. While we are aware that the current version of the proposed STR ordinance amendment provides limited grandfathered status to units with an existing STR operating permit, we believe that it does not go far enough to protect the investments of all property owners that would be affected by the eight-person cap. First, the exemption only applies to STR units with existing operating permits, which means that prospective STR units currently in the construction or permitting pipeline will have no protection. Second, the existing version of the proposed ordinance mandates that grandfathered status will be lost upon certain occurrences, such as a transfer of interest, change in membership composition of a corporate entity, and upon permit expiration. As such, the current version of the proposed amendment provides only temporary protection that will eventually result in loss of significant value and investment when the grandfathered status is lost. To ensure that the investments of all STR owners are adequately protected, it is necessary that the exemption from the eight-person cap be expanded to properties that are currently in the construction or permitting process and be continued for as long as the unit has an STR operating permit. If grandfathered status is not provided or expanded, the City will most assuredly face legal challenges to the eight-person limit. We are confident that the approvals and permits obtained to build, modify, and/or operate STR units with more than four bedrooms protect such units under the Vested Rights Act and related City ordinances from subsequent amendments that would affect the intensity of their permitted uses, which the eight-person maximum unlawfully attempts to do. July 14, 2026 Page 3 In addition, the time of application rule under Pure Oil Div. v. Columbia , 254 S.C. 28 (1970), provides clear protections to those owners, like CKC, who are currently in the permitting process. In conclusion, we appreciate the City’s and its staff’s engagement with property owners and residents in the STR Overlay Zone. While we understand that differing and sometimes inconsistent interests can make obtaining consensus on zoning and land uses difficult, we believe that our proposals set forth above strike a reasonable compromise that will allow the City to achieve its goal of providing clarity to the STR ordinance without unconstitutionally and unfairly interfering with owners’ property rights. We remain willing to continue to engage in good faith with the City on this subject, and please do not hesitate to contact me if you have any questions. Sincerely, E. Brandon Gaskins July 14, 2026 Page 4 ATTACHMENT A 1. Properties with current STR Operating Permit: a. 122 Spring Street – Units 201, 202, 301, and 302 b. 124 Spring Street – Units 201, 202, 301, and 302 c. 158 Spring Street d. 186 Saint Philip Street – Units 201 and 202 e. 259 Saint Philip Street 2. Properties under construction or in permitting process: a. 10 Arbor Spring Court – Under Construction – Permit #SF2025-26286 b. 16 Arbor Spring Court – Under Construction – Permit #SF2025-26287 c. 70 Line Street – Permit Application Under Review – Permit #SF2026-27887 d. 111 Trebloc Court Unit A– Permit Application Under Review – Permit #SF2026-27888 e. 111 Trebloc Court Unit B – Permit Application Under Review – Permit #SF2026-27888 f. 112 Trebloc Court Unit A – Permit Application Under Review – Permit #SF2026-27889 g. 112 Trebloc Court Unit B – Permit Application Under Review – Permit #SF2026-27889 h. 115 Trebloc Court Unit A – Permit Application Under Review – Permit #SF2026-27890 i. 115 Trebloc Court Unit B – Permit Application Under Review – Permit #SF2026-27890 j. 116 Trebloc Court Unit A – Permit Application Under Review – Permit #SF2026-27891 k. 116 Trebloc Court Unit B – Permit Application Under Review – Permit #SF2026-27891

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.