TC Minutes 090622
City of Darlington · Darlington County · meeting of Feb 16, 2023 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Darlington
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
CITY OF DARLINGTON
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING HELD IN THE COURTROOM/COUNCIL
CHAMBERS LOCATED AT
400 PEARL STREET, DARLINGTON, SC
TUESDAY SEPTEMBER 6, 2022 - AT 6:00 PM
Present: Mayor Curtis Boyd, City Manager John Payne, Councilpersons Sheila Baccus, John
Segars, Bryant Gardner, John Milling, Howard Nettles, and Elaine Reed. Also present was Mrs.
Lisa Bailey, Police Chief Kelvin Washington, Codes Enforcement Officer Ms. Sheila Jones,
W&S Superintendent Charles Shugart, Vondell Brockington, Ms. Anna DeWitt, Ms. Ernestine
Lyde, Ms. Gloria Hines, Mrs. McDowell, Ms. Jannie Lathan, Dr. William McCall, Mr. Linwood
Epps, Ms. Staci Richey, Mr. John Lewis, Ms. Brook Sylvester, Mr. Ernest Boston, Ms. Susan
Rogers, Ms. Nova Harkless, Mrs. Katrina Ham, Ms. Angela Johnson, Mr. Anthony Hall, Ms.
Jackie L. Jernigan, Mr. Kyle Owens, and other visitors.
INVOCATION & PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Prayer by Mayor Boyd followed by the Pledge of Allegiance
APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM REGULAR MEETING ON AUGUST 2, 2022
Councilman John Milling made a motion to approve the minutes from the regular meeting
on August 2, 2022. Councilwoman Elaine Reed seconded the motion. councilpersons
Nettles, Gardner, Baccus, Segars, and Mayor Boyd voted in favor of the motion.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM SPECIAL MEETING ON AUGUST 17, 2022
Councilwoman Elaine Reed made a motion to approve the minutes of the special meeting
on August 17, 2022. Councilman John Milling seconded the motion. Councilpersons
Nettles, Gardner, Baccus, Segars and Mayor Boyd voted in favor of the motion.
APPROVAL OF MEETING AGENDA
Councilwoman Reed made a motion to approve the meeting agenda for tonight‘s
meeting. Councilman Howard Nettles seconded the motion. Councilpersons Gardner,
Milling, Segars and Mayor Boyd voted in favor of the motion.
REPORT OF STANDING COMMITTEES
a)DARLINGTON DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION ASSOCIATION – LISA BAILEY
Report for Council – August 2, 2022
Darlington Downtown Revitalization Association
Report for Council – September 6, 2022
The DDRA continues the Bringing Downtown Alive! free summer concert series Saturdays on
the Square presented by The City of Darlington this Saturday with chart-topping songwriter
John King from 7 to 10 p.m. Sept. 10 on the Public Square. Enjoy live music, classic cars,
food trucks, and vendors. The featured musician has had a steady climb toward the top of the
country music mainstream. He’s become a No. 1 songwriter, penning Randy Houser's chart-
2
topping “We Went” (which earned him a 2016 ASCAP Songwriter Award) and writing Hootie and
The Blowfish’s “Rollin” (the band’s first song to be released since 2005). He's become a road
warrior, too, playing an average of 150 shows annually while building his audience one gig at a
time. Most importantly, King has begun telling his own story through music, launching his solo
career with “Tonight Tonight” — a Top 40 hit whose anthemic chorus was heard everywhere
from country radio to the weekly NFL recaps on CBS — and releasing his first full-length album
with 2021’s Always Gonna Be You. He says: “Country music is really exciting right now,
because artists are blurring the lines. You don’t have to fit into one category. When I step back
and listen to these songs, I hear southern rock, country, and pop. I hear me. I don’t know what
else to call it. It’s just me.” A variety of food trucks and other vendors will have food, drinks, and
goods available for purchase including Carolina Donut Diva, Dave’s Barnyard BBQ, Diggie
Dawgz, George’s Funnel Cakes, S.C. House of Wings, and Woos & Keems from Cheraw that
offers collard green egg rolls. The Darlington Cruisers, and any other car aficionados, are
welcome to display their rides along Cashua Street. There aren’t any trophies, but it’s a great
way to interact with the community and show off your prized possession. Other sponsors
include Fiber Industries, Wilson Senior Care, Belk Funeral Home, and Pepsi of Florence.
Thank you to the community for supporting our efforts!
b)G
REATER DARLINGTON CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
Ms. Brook Sylvester said they held a ribbon cutting for new chamber member Rush Fit Nutrition,
413 Pearl Street on August 12, 2022. Upcoming events at the Grand Old Post Office: Yoga with
Parker Howle – September 10th at 9:00 am – 10:00 pm. There will be a Buddy Johnson Tribute
Band September 24th at 6:00 pm. Down by the Creek Boutique, which is an online children’s
boutique, will be opening on October 1st with a ribbon cutting at 10:00 am. They are located at
48 Public Square. Ms. Sylvester said their next business After Hours will be September 29th at
Pee Dee Treasurers located at 119 E. Broad Street from 5:30pm – 7pm. Public Square will be
getting a new business-Darington Mercantile & Confectionary. They will be located at 46 Public
Square. The grand opening will be September 15th. A time has not been discussed yet. Ms.
Sylvester said starting on September 16th they will open at 6:30.
CITIZENS WISHING TO APPEAR BEFORE COUNCIL (5 MINUTES PER PERSON 30 TOTAL
MINUTES MAXIMUM)
*Disruptive behavior is not permitted
Ms. Susan Rogers said the first thing she wants to discuss is the city water and sewer. She
said she has county water and city sewer. She said the county has no trouble reading the
meter whether they use satellite or what they use but I got a bill from the city, and I used zero
water for one month. I only used 1200 gallons the next month and then you hit me up for almost
21,000 gallons which would have filled my camper up which you all know I live in. My subject
from there is if we’re going to charge people these fees and this 3% increase give an honest
system of reading meters. Ms. Rogers said I’m on a set income, I have everything drafted out
one account. I don’t worry about it but most people do. And when you get a $178 sewerage bill
drafted out of your account where you knew you were going to have $35 for your medicine this
month, that makes a difference. Ms. Rogers said, “And I’m not denying that I didn’t use the
20,000 gallons of water in a sixty-day period, but I didn’t use it in twenty-four days. Ms. Rogers
3
said, “that is my subject there. I just ask you to find some way, find someone to read these
meters accurately. She said they said they are not read on the same day, I understand that, but
why can’t they just go off the county’s report. It’s accurate, it’s never wrong. Ms. Rogers said, “I
used 80 gallons from one day to the next by the reading that you all read, and the county
system read. She said that’s an average, I don’t deny it. I’m going to water my flowers and do
what I have to do. I’m going to use my water, but I want an accurate monthly statement. Ms.
Rogers said you all have an agreement with some company to lease these apartments on the
Square. She said from what I was told that was set up when the apartments were refurbished
but you have an agreement to pick up the trash per apartment. Do you all have an agreement
with some company at lease these apartments on the Square from what I was told that was set
up in the apartment or refurbished but you have an agreement to pick up the trash per
apartment. Why doesn’t the company that you are leasing to have to supply some form of trash
containers for these people. I’m not going to tell you every color intimate project there is in the
parking lot in the back, but between the homeless and the people buying furniture, leaving
furniture piling it all in the parking lot when they move out that’s….the City streets might look
good but take a back road and see what the parking lot. We advertise it’s a public parking lot.
We send our customers back to look at it just for that purpose she says you need to go check it
out. And it doesn’t just stop at the property line. You might say that’s part of the church’s
parking lot; that doesn’t relieve your responsibility. If the city is going to collect trash and
sanitation from these apartments then that needs to be kept up. She said you were even
charging now we keep our vans in a separate container at the jewelry store Fahrenheit HMES,
the apartment buildings use their curby curbies too but they’re paying you a business rate to
have them and yet these people that are renting are putting their personal supplies. She said I
know you can’t judge.. but it is a problem. I’ve already had Alex meet me there one day …. I
don’t even remember who else met me there. This was months ago. It’s still the same. We
have homeless sleeping in the wooden bins while people are living in apartments. she said
Pam kicked one the other day. She thought it was a dead body, but it moved. She said the city
has got to do something about this backstreet problem that we have because we have to go
through it. We park back there.
Mr. Patel s
aid his property is at 120 S . Main Street. He said he had been getting high water bills
but in December they changed his water meter. Mr. Patel said after changing his water meter
his use for a month was 3,000-4,000 gallons. He said for the last two month they charged him
$100 a month storm fee. Mayor Boyd said that is being corrected. Mr. Patel said he went to the
water department, and he asked them, and they said if he has more than one…that’s they are
going up. Mayor Boyd told Mr. Patel he will contact him tomorrow.
Nova Harkless said she is there t
o speak about her mother’s property at 308 Washington
Street. She said the fence from the cement place is growing over in my mother’s yard and it
looks like a forest. Ms. Harkless said she can’t look down the street because when she comes
out the grass is all over the fence. She said that’s not our grass that’s growing over there. He
said the people at the cement place needs to come put that down. She said I have been
fighting for this a long time. If I’m not fighting for the land I’m fighting for the grass to be cut. Ms.
4
Harkless said I’m not going to talk any longer because you know where it’s located at and I
hope you can get it cut.
Ernestine Lyde said she lives at 108 Flynn Circle. She said my problem is still the water bill.
every month the water bill is increasing and increasing. The value and everything is going up
and the storm fee went up another $3.50 now it’s $10. Now my garbage went up to $35. It
doesn’t make any sense. Ms. Lyde said everything is going higher and higher every month.
When there was four people living in my house before the pandemic my water bills were less
than this and I was using around the same amount, but here it is now in 2022 ever since you
went up on the water bill and you keep going up on this water bill and I don’t understand it. Ms.
Lyde said my problem is if you can give somebody a $30,000 raise and then you gonna keep
going up on the water bill… If we got that kind of money to give somebody that kind of raise why
can’t we take that money and put it toward the water bill. Ms. Lyde said, “Senior citizen…my
mother is a senior citizen. Her water bill, one person; she eighty-eight years old. Her water bill
is close to mine-$100”. Are you kidding me? Something is not right with this. I don’t care how
you look at it I come up here every month and it’s the same thing; the water bill, it keeps going
up. It’s just like what happened? You guys don’t care about us or something. Come on now. It
can’t be that much more about what’s going on than what’s going on with the citizens. We’re
still here. We’re citizens. We matter. We count. This isn’t like something has to be done about
that because if you can give that much money away I’m quite sure that we don’t have to pay
these high-water bills like this over and over again.
Jannie Lathan said my concerns are three-f
old this evening with my comments. First, I support
the council’s approval of the second reading of the ordinance 2022-09 for the rezoning request
of 203 Orange Street. The Board of Directors of this center are requesting their ability to utilize
their property to ensure the center continue to be thriving as an institution. Specifically, to have
the ability to bring online a pediatric speech development program or other such related
businesses on their property of the existing facility they own. Ms. Lathan said, “I use the word
institution very deliberately because under the leadership of former Darlington County
Councilwoman Wilhelmina Johnson, this center has provided programs for several decades that
have greatly enriched our city and the lives of our residents many of whom are here this
evening”. Ms. Lathan said, “In my assessment, this request meets the requirement of the city’s
zoning for residential commercial”. Ms. Lathan said, “I took a few minutes this afternoon and
drove down Orange Street between Main & Pearl Street and here’s what I found. I found there
is an existing mix of residential commercial businesses on this same street, on Orange Street.
In addition to residential there’s a commercial investment business, there’s an AT&T
commercial business, there’s a large commercial hotel, there’s a large commercial bank and
Roses, a very large commercial business whose property also align on Oranges Street”.
Therefore, it should be very clear that the center’s request to utilize their small space for the
noted commercial business is within the approved zoning residential commercial. Secondly,
has this council read the most recent police report filed against the city manager? If so, what
actions are being taken? If not, why not? Ms. Lathan said she is requesting a written response
to these questions as well as what actions the city council has taken to investigate an alleged
involvement of the city manager in the early release from jail of his friend. Lastly, this council
5
with exception of councilwoman Sheila Baccus and Councilman Howard Nettles voted to
increase the water bill of the citizens of Darlington again. Mrs. Lathan said there was no public
hearing on raising these water bills again. Instead, there was an agenda item that read “public
hearing” on a council meeting agenda. An agenda item does not constitute a public hearing.
There was no agenda provided for the public hearing. There was no sign in sheet for residents
to sign up to speak and to express their concerns about this potential increase. Ms. Lathan
said, “We were not informed of existing water rates or the proposed new rates”. Ms.Lathan
said, “Mayor, I am requesting that you and council please take a look into this”. She said and
I’m also requesting that you have the city manager put the new rates on our water bill because
they are not. She said they are not on there like all of our other utility bills and I think they
should be. In fact, I think this is a legal requirement. Ms. Lathan said, “We were told that only
residents who use 5,000 gallons per month would see this increase and that this would only be
20% of the residents of Darlington. She asked, “Where did this 5,000-gallon threshold come
from? Did any of you question this? Ms. Lathan’s time ran out and she asked if someone defer
a minute for her. A gentleman deferred his time. Ms. Lathan asked, “Where did this 5,000
gallon threshold come from? Did any of you ask this question? Were you presented with any
data that showed that only 20% of our residents would be affected? I think not, because this
fake public hearing lasted less than a minute because there was no opportunity for this
information to be presented to you Mayor. There was no opportunity for the citizens to ask any
questions. She asked did you know the average American family uses 30 gallons of water per
day at their homes? The average family size for the nation, for the state of South Carolina, for
the city of Darlington is 2.5 so let’s do the math. That equals 9,000 gallons per month so where
did this 5,000-gallon threshold come from? Here’s a water bill of a one-person, single person
household that’s over 5,000 in the last month. She said in fact, it’s 5,779 gallons. Ms. Lathan
said, “Since this, almost everybody can do a mathematical assessment and realize more than
20% of the residence of the City of Darlington are being assessed at a higher rate for using
more than 5,000 gallons per month. She said Councilwoman Baccus has been requesting of our
city manager for months now to tell us whether our water department is making or losing money
and he refuse to give this answer. In fact, he exasperates everything by saying he can’t come
out with an answer until we get our annual audit. She said this is simple math. Ms. Lathan said
all you have to do is take the amount of money that we are paying.. that you’ve got coming in
and subtract out how much expenses you have, then we’ll know whether we’re making or losing
money in the water department. Ms. Lathan said, “Mayor, I know you said you want to be
transparent, but did you guys know you approved a $30,000 one-time $30,000 increase for the
director of public works?. Councilman Gardner said, “I’m kind of curious how you have that
information. Ms. Lathan said, “It’s called under the Freedom of Information Act, and you know
why we’re going to continue to ask under the Freedom of Information Act because this
Councilwoman who represents me and my ward when I ask her questions she don’t know she
comes to the city manager, and he refuses to answer her so that’s how we got the information.
She said, “In fact Mayor, that information should be published on our website like it is in most
municipalities because this is public funds”. Councilman Gardner asked, “It is or it isn’t”? Ms.
Lathan said, “Go to many municipalities in this state”….Councilman Gardner said, “I understand
that. I thought you said it was published though”. Ms. Lathan said, “It’s not, but it should be”.
Ms. Lathan said, “Other municipalities Councilman, publish this information. This is our money”.
6
Councilman Gardner said, “I’m just curious”. Ms. Lathan said, “I hope I’m allowing time since….
Councilman Gardner said, “You’re at eight minutes right now, but….Mr. Payne said, “You’ve got
ten minutes left in public discussion”. Ms. Lathan said, “I’m trying to answer your question”.
Councilman Gardner said, “It’s not really a question….Ms. Lathan said I don’t think you should
take this time away from us because I’m responding to a Councilman’s question. Councilman
Gardner asked, “Chief Washington could you please come in here Sir”. Chief Washington said,
“That’s the Mayor’s decision Sir”. Councilman Gardner said, “Well, I need to ask a question of
you that you can answer and that’s not trying to”….Chief Washington said, “I understand”.
Councilman Gardner said, “We had a situation that she referenced earlier about our city
manager, and it came up at a previous meeting. It’s my understanding that he recused himself
from the situation and that you were actually in charge of that situation. Is that true”? Chief
Washington asked, “Which situation are you referring to”? Councilman Gardner asked Ms.
Lathan if she would want to clarify the situation. Ms. Lathan said, “No, because I think this is the
inappropriate forum”. Councilman Gardner said, “It’s not ma’am because y’all...here’s the
problem”. Ms. Lathan said, “I think if we need to settle discourse….I think I have asked for a
written response if you want to take this in executive council because I just don’t think this is.
Mayor Boyd said, “Chief Washington the question is, with the incident that involved the arrest
where his name was brought up and all that, did he recuse himself from all that”? Mayor Boyd
asked Chief Washington if he could clarify on that. Chief Washington said, “Because this
involves personnel it’s more appropriate for this to be handled in executive session. Chief
Washington said this should not be handled out in the public. It should be handled in executive
session”. Councilman Gardner said, “The only thing we’re asking is, there’s been a couple of
accusations that our city manager has acted in an inappropriate manner and the very simple
question is, we don’t need anything else about the situation besides did he recuse himself or
not”. Chief Washington said, “And again, I’m going to repeat myself. That is something that
needs to be handled in executive session because it deals with personnel. Personnel that
respond to you all and you’re asking me in public about something to do with my boss….
Councilman Gardner said, “I’ll answer the question for the public. Whenever the situation
happened, our city manager recused himself from the situation. Our Chief took over that
situation and the city manager had nothing to do with it”. Councilwoman Baccus said, “You
don’t even know what you’re talking about. You weren’t there. (Councilwoman Baccus,
Councilman Gardner both talking at the same time). Councilwoman Reed said, “We are
disrespecting Ms. Lathan. She had not finished. Please let her finish. Ms. Lathan said, “On my
bill we’re billed three times for capital. There’s a capital on our water bill and then there’s a
second capital for street capital and those of us that have sprinkler systems we get billed a third
time for capital. Can you at the next meeting let us know why we’re being billed three times.
Mr. John Lewis s
aid, the reason I’m here is our street and road repairs again on Oak Street.
The repair that the new construction made out on the road was excellent. The one that we did
where they cut the road across, once again, it started to crumble. It’s hazardous to the vehicles
and if you take a look at it you can tell the work that was done was extremely poor. Mr. Lewis
said, “North Street at 52 where we’ve got all of the construction work, that drop if you’re coming
down North Street towards Main, if someone hits that hole with their vehicle they are going to
get hurt, they ‘re going to do damage to their vehicles or if somebody is riding a bike or a
7
motorcycle could get seriously injured. Mr. Lewis said the other road repairs are horrible. If you
go through this town we’ve got streets that are in dire need of repair but yet we can spend tons
of money on new trees and everything for the City Square. Mr. Lewis said, “And I’m all for
making the city look good. You do. You go way and beyond because I’ve seen you out there
working on the streets cleaning up and things like that. Mr. Lewis said, “That’s great but that’s
not addressing the problem with our streets and our road. Mr. Lewis said, “Our sidewalks-one
of my neighbors tripped on the sidewalk on Spring Street and tore her….We don’t do anything
to repair those, but we can give money to different organizations that want to do things out here,
but we don’t take money to repair the sidewalks or the roads. He said I know some of the roads
belong to DOT, I know some belong to the county and to be quite honestly I don’t care. You
represent the people of this city. It’s your responsibility to make sure that these roads and these
sidewalks are safe for the public. Mr. Lewis said, “so if that means you have to sue the county
or sue DOT, whatever you have to do, you do it. Otherwise, someone is going to get seriously
hurt and this city is going to pay for it. Mr. Lewis said, “the other concern I have, and I’ve
missed quite a few meetings. But at the last meeting the Mayor Pro-Tem got up and spoke
about civility. He said I’m all for civility. In talking about civility between the city council
members, I want to hear the city council meetings discussing things if they’re concerned about
it. I don’t go for the name calling, but I sure want the city council members to be able to speak
between themselves and express their concerns or say things to the people sitting out here so
we can understand what’s going on. He said, and I want to remind everybody this is our city
council, you represent the citizens of the City of Darlington and that’s exactly what you need to
do is represent the people that have put you in the positions you are in right now. Mr. Lewis
said, I’ve been in the ward that I’ve never received any notification whatsoever of any ward
meetings, any concerns and I couldn’t even tell you who my ward member is, up until tonight
because someone told me. Mr. Lewis said he’s sitting in this room right now and we’ve never
heard from him, but member who belongs to Ms. Baccus ward, she notifies her members. She
sends them emails, notices. Mr. Lewis said, “I’ve lived in my ward for eighteen years and I’ve
never gotten the first piece of information and I can guarantee you that at the next election the
ward member that represents me will not get my vote”.
Gloria Hines s
aid on behalf of the local branch of the NAACP, I am not the president, but I was
called to speak. Ms. Hines passed out copies of a paper. Mayor Boyd said, “Mr. Payne we’re
not supposed to discuss….Mr. Payne said, we’re not Mr. Mayor. Mayor Boyd said, “Mrs. Hines,
as they just said a while ago we’re not supposed to discuss personnel issues. Ms. Hines said, “I
get up here and you’re going to drop me”. Mayor Boyd said, we were just told we’re not
supposed to discuss personnel issues unless it’s in executive session. Ms. Hines said, “Well
this is about the 30% raise. Councilwoman Baccus asked, “Is this personnel or is it budget?''
Ms. Hines said this was in the budget meeting. Councilwoman Baccus said we’re talking about
the budget. Mayor Boyd said you’re pulling a person’s name up, so we need to discuss this in
executive session. Ms. Hines asked, when are you all going to have an executive session so I
can talk. Mayor Boyd said the executive session will have to be after the council meeting at the
next meeting.
Mr. Payne said the 30-m
inute time is up. Mayor Boyd said, we’ve got two more if you all can
make it really quick I’ll let you speak.
8
Katrina Ham said I’m here to address my street which is Jefferson Street and a few more
streets, Washington and W. Broad from my end. Ms. Ham said I think they came last week and
cut the things down. I don’t know who this property belongs to but it’s steady growing up higher.
Ms. Ham said when I saw this the other day, that really got me. She said we don’t have enough
manpower; we can’t get nobody to do it. Clean it up…why don’t we do it? Why should we do it.
She said they have people at the detention center, they’re not doing anything, why not pull them
out and let them clean it. Ms. Ham said there’s always some excuse about it and when I saw
this it was very upsetting to me. Mayor Boyd asked, what street is that. Ms. Ham said, I think
it’s W. Broad. Councilwoman Reed said, “Once you cross Tallulah between Tallulah and
Jefferson there’s this spot that they’ve been dumping it but this time it is horrendous. Ms. Ham
said, and we pay taxes for that. I feel like something needs to be done right away. Councilman
Milling asked Councilwoman Reed if this is going down Broad Street past Tallulah going
towards the highway department? Councilwoman Reed said when you get to the fork just keep
straight across to the right and then just one block. Councilwoman Reed said there are
abandoned houses on both sides. Ms. Ham said and all the lots on Jefferson Street, all the stuff
is growing up on Washington Street. She said we are living in a jungle over here on the west
end. Ms. Harkless asked, don’t we have a city councilperson on that side? Councilwoman Reed
said, “That’s me and I will address it because last Thursday the City came, and they cut the part
that’s growing up that is the city’s part. She said we cannot cut those things growing up on
private property otherwise I would want them to cut mine. Councilwoman Reed said but the city
did come Friday and from Washington Street to Milling Street, the part that you’re talking about
the city came and cut back the city part. Councilwoman Reed said I made them aware on
Wednesday. She said this trash that you’re talking about I walk my dog and it wasn’t there, so
it’s been since that part but each time, our area, that area is being used as a dump site. And
yes, the city can’t keep up with what the residents in those areas are doing. Councilwoman
Reed said, it may not be our residents. It may be all folk coming along because if you go there
this afternoon you’re going to see it. She said we try to do the best, but I have asked those in
the area, please we have to have…I tried to organize cleanup days, but I haven’t gotten a
response from any of those. Councilwoman Reed said, but it is folk in the area that’s doing this,
and I call each time that I see it. She said, and I promise you they have responded very well to
me because that part that you’re talking about that you’re saying growing up, they were there
last Thursday morning and cut that down. Ms. Ham asked, we’ll, who’s supposed to clean it
up? Councilwoman Reed said, the city when they can. They are coming but if they…..I don’t
know how to tell you that if a group comes down this afternoon and we go down on the west end
and it’s all grown up and their scheduled time is to pick up on Thursday or pick up on Monday
that they can keep coming back every time that we have our residents littering up like that. Ms.
Ham said, the people that own the property, all these lots on my street are all grown up. You
can’t cite these people. You can’t go on private property. Something’s got to be done. Ms.
Ham said you’re supposed to get in touch with them, send out a paper and let them know…give
them ten days’ notice or something. If they don’t cut it themselves, you can’t go on the property,
but somebody had to cut it. Ms. Ham said, charge them or we just got to keep looking like
that….(Councilwoman Reed is talking at the same time Ms. Ham is speaking). Councilwoman
Reed said, “Sheila has sent the letters out for each of those lots”. Councilwoman Reed said,
9
“they send the letter over and over and all they can do the way it is right behind where you were
talking about now we have an ordinance when it gets back to the natural state that we don’t do
it. If we do it we’re just going to add on to the taxes. Councilwoman Reed said I do know that
Sheila has sent numbers to each one of those people on there. Mayor Boyd told Ms. Ham to
contact him also when she sees stuff like that.
Ernest Boston l
ives at 121 Allen Street. He said his frustration is 12 times a year once a
month at the corner of Allen Street and Main Street right behind the white house with the fence;
once a month household trash garbage people have been cleaning up houses and they are
taking their trash and dumping it there. Mr. Boston said we would like to suggest to the city
council that they approve the city manager and the street department to buy deer cameras and
put them in the areas where people are using for dump sites. Mr. Boston said we need to do
something. He said he’s getting frustrated. The street is clean, no trash on the street but then
when you come out you see that. He said I want to keep our neighborhood looking good. Mr.
Boston said when people don’t want to do right we need to put something in place so that when
we catch them doing wrong, we fine them and make them pick up trash and clean up. Mr.
Boston asked the council to consider this.
M
ayor Boyd said as an overview for everybody we’re trying hard, but I know sometimes it may
not look like it. He said I know sometimes people want to criticize me for being out there with
the weed eater but at least I’m trying. they won’t give me a key to the backhoe, and they won’t
give me the key to the dump truck or the trash truck, they won’t give me a police car or a ticket
book so I’m limited on what I can or can’t do. It’s the same with the rest of the council, but again
a lot of these issues we’re approaching trying to fix. He said why people want to trash our town
and throw mattresses out and we’re in a predicament you’re not paying the city to pick up your
mattress or your furniture. That’s not even part of the trash and sanitation and then they still go
out and they pick it up and they really should be given a fine. We are trying to deal with all of
these issues, with all the lots that are grown up. Mayor Boyd said we want it cleaned up; we
want it tidied up. We ask for your help. when you see trash out and things like that let us know.
We are trying hard and will continue to try hard and thank you for your comments.
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
a)PUBLIC HEARING ORDINANCE 2022-09 REZONING REQUEST 203 ORANGE STREET
Ms. Angela Johnson said she is a proud citizen of Darlington but she’s living in Columbia now,
but she and her mom are privileged to come back and check on our properties here every other
weekend or so. Ms. Johnson said Darlington County cultural realism complex has put forth this
request (this is their second time) to rezone the parts of the property on Pearl Street campus
that are zoned as residential. I’m aware there are concerns that the residents of the historic
District have not only shared with their council members but also in this venue last year and the
only thing I can say is that we have put forth the effort to talk one on one with them as
councilman Milling recommended we do at the last meeting. We have had one on one zoom
sessions set up so that we could speak with them, and we even had an in-person opportunity
where my sister and her five-year-old went walking through canvassing the neighborhood giving
them the flyer so that we could set aside an hour when we were going to be there so that we
10
could talk one on one. As Mr. Segars said, civil conversation. Ms. Johnson said we had one
resident take advantage of that. Ms. Johnson thanked the city council for availing themselves to
her and her fellow board members. She said they had the opportunity to speak with Mr. Nettles,
Ms. Baccus, Mr. Gardner, and Ms. Reed. She said she had an opportunity to meet one on one
with Mayor Boyd. She said she believes her sister had an opportunity to speak with
Councilman Milling. She thanked the council for giving them an opportunity to completely
communicate to you our goal for keeping CRC alive and progressive within the community. Ms.
Johnson said and then also for sharing with us your concerns and your support for your
constituents. And to that I just want to say I think there is a constituent that you are forgetting
about- CRC. She said CRC is a constituent CRC is a 50-year constituent. She said January 1,
2023, will be 50 years that CRC has been in the Darlington community. Miss Johnson said to
the residence and to the City Council I say the best predictor of future behavior is past behavior
so then where is the concern coming from?'' Is the concern dealing with the fact you have an
entity that has given hundreds of girls opportunities to present they are performing arts and local
state and national competitions is that concerned that the CRC ran the summer food program
partnered with DHEC in the late 70s and early 80s employing over 400 part-time workers during
the summer and ensuring that children were fed when school was closed. Is the concern that
this entity wants to ensure that there is a community that’s going to be able to take advantage of
what else may be out there performing arts, visual arts, historical preservation. Year after year
the Martin Luther King program that the CRC sponsored to bring the community together. She
said there is nothing different about that goal that this current board is pursuing. We have
identified a need in Darlington County that hasn’t been filled yet. A pediatric speech clinic:
clinics like that are being erected in cities up and down the East Coast. We have got interested
parties, educators my sister included, that are interested in fulfilling that need using the property
at 203 Orange St. a property zoned as residential. She said I don’t know how many of you had
a chance to see the property but there is a physical structure on that property and in the front of
that physical structure there is a pretty big space within a fence. She said they have it boarded
off right now to protect Darlington County cultural realism complex from any issues that may
subject us to liability so right now we don’t have it open to the public because we’re not there
daily yet. But how are we going to get to a point where we utilize that facility step one city
council please approve our request to rezone that property that’s misclassified as residential;
rezone it as office/residential please.
Anthony Hall said he’s the community program organizer for the democracy center in Florence.
Mr. Hall said since he’s been here I can’t think about how many times people have told me the
stories of how the CRC and Mrs. Johnson impacted their lives. He said we’re living in a time
now where kids are being lost and the reason that they are lost is because they don’t have
those grounds and roots and nurturing places to go like they used to. He said when you walk
into the CRC it’s like walking into a history book of Darlington-Black Darlington mostly. Mr. Hall
said if you look around you don’t really see a whole lot of things that represent that but if you
want to know what can be and what has been, we’ll she’s got it. She’s probably got more stuff
in the CRC, more history than people can even imagine. Mr. Hall said, it’s my understanding it
used to be a hospital right if it used to be a hospital they couldn’t have been a residence so I
don’t know how they got that misconstrued, but I would hope that you would see the value that
11
the CRC plays in this community. He said not only that property but the Coker Street property.
Mr. Hall said you have to hold onto those type of things it’s not something that you get away
from you need to invest and bring it back up because in a day and a time such as this right here
kids need something, some place that they can go where they know they’re going to find people
there to nurture them and help them get on the right path. So, I would hope that you really and
truly approve this ordinance.
David Longacre s
aid he is a board member with the CRC and also an advisor to the board. He
said we’ve had A number of conversations on this property and I’ve had some concerns with
this over a period of time he said Wilhelmina Johnson was an insurance client of his and that’s
how he got to know her and she decided that I was going to be one of her kids so she adopted
me, brought me in and told me the CRC is yours, you’d better take care of it so we’re following
Wilhelmina’s instructions. Over the period of time this entity has been around almost 50 years
and has provided numerous programs and avenues for the community and not just the city but
also the county and a much larger area that she has run on a continuous basis. The property
section in question on Orange Street was in use for a retail thrift store and a number of other
things she had run out of that building. He said up until the pandemic closed everything down
that was all well and fine because it was grandfathered and able to be used up until that. But
because it was not running longer than a 90 day Everything stopped there, that’s when the
grandfathering no longer was held accountable. Mr. Longacre said that comes to the problem
of this zoning of this property the way it’s chocked up. It was not correct because a section of
the property is actually zoned residential. The other section of it is zoned general commercial
so the argument though that we don’t want to change this portion of the property to office
residential, which makes a lot more sense, we can do pretty much whatever we want on the
other portion of the property because it’s already general commercial and it’s right there. So
why would you not change it? Why would you keep it residential when it does not match what
has always been there. He said that building and property…. the hospital goes back to the
1940s and that building was added on Orange Street 40-50 years old at least it was on
commercial property. It was the hospital property. It does not make sense for it to be
considered residential. It needs to be corrected in the way that it should be. He said with that,
we absolutely understand the concern being a historic district. He said we’re not looking to
change the building structure. we’re not looking to put up apartment complexes. we’re not
looking to build ugly eyesores; we just want this corrected on that section of the property so we
can continue to operate with programs from the CRC the way it’s been done for almost 50
years. That’s what we’re asking.
Dr. William McCall s
aid I use to be principal at all the high schools in Darlington County. I
coached at Mayo. Assistant principal at Darlington High School, Hartsville High School, Lamar
High School and was Principal of Timmonsville High School. Mr. McCall said during that time
we had conflict resolution here in Darlington County. He said he did his dissertation on conflict
resolution. Mr. McCall said when you opened up this afternoon you opened with a prayer then
you opened up with the pledge. During my time in school, we started with a pledge, and we
started with a prayer. He said when you look at our town today and we talk about the CRC
Center which I was a part of since 1985. The CRC Center is a much-needed place in this
12
community. It has demonstrated success and it helped a lot of people including me. He said
Mrs. Johnson was his Home Economics teacher. Mr. McCall said Mrs. Johnson taught me
more than just come to class to see the girls, she told me I needed an education. Mr. McCall
said I used to be embarrassed to tell people I didn’t graduate from high school with a high
school diploma Mrs. Johnson is the reason I’m standing before you today. The only thing she
told me when I didn’t get my high school diploma. she said follow your dreams. I want it to be a
soldier and during that time the military was accepting students without a high school diploma.
He said when I went in I was a good soldier and I thought I was going to get promoted.
Everybody got promoted except me. I was a sharp soldier, but I didn’t get promoted and I cried
like a baby. He said he cried so hard his friend took him and enrolled him in school-I only
needed one unit. Mr. McCall said he got his one unit. He said he realized education was not as
hard as I made it, but when I reinvented myself I made it easy because it was something I knew
I needed. He said Mrs. Johnson had a need for Darlington County and she opened up the
doors for a whole bunch of people. She helped a whole lot of people. Mr. McCall said I was
born at Wilson hospital. It was a commercial place then. Why would we make it residential?
How did it become residential? He said I heard a whole bunch of issues talked about but two
issues I didn’t hear about were the killing of our young people and the drug overdose. He said
he used to run his office out of the CRC center, but the building needs some work. I think that
somehow some money should come somewhere to help revitalize Wilson Hospital which is now
the CRC Center. We get money for everything else. Mr. McCall said Mrs. Johnson fought long
and hard for help to get that building up today. Mr. McCall said he wants to come out of
retirement and something for these young folks, especially these young men, from 16-29. He
said I want to deal with all of them. I want to show them that they don’t have to do the things that
they are doing, and I believe I can do that with my conflict resolution program.
Jackie Lynn Jernigan s
aid I live on Sycamore Street which is right across from the cultural
realism building. Ms. Jernigan said I love Mrs. Johnson. I’ve always loved Mrs. Johnson. I was
in high school when she was there teaching. I’m all for the center being built up and having
programs there in the part of the building that is already commercialized. She said as for as Ms.
Iris coming out and speaking to people she did come to my door. I didn’t get to it in time before
she left but she did video my father which I did not appreciate because she never told him that
she was videoing. Ms. Jernigan said so me and Iris did have a discussion and I told her to take
the video down because my father was sharing a lot of private information that did not need to
be on Facebook she was kind and she did take the video down and I appreciate that but I think
when you were telling somebody to get out into the neighborhood and talk to people nobody
wants a video camera in their face. That’s not really getting to know people and talking to them
one on one so that’s probably why a lot of people did not speak with her. Ms. Jernigan said, “As
far as the property that is across the street from me, there was a house on that property on that
lot. This is a little bit about what I’m concerned about. They keep saying it was never residential.
Yes, it was”. Are we talking about all of that being rezoned or just that one little building. She
said that’s what I’m a little bit confused about. Ms. Jernigan said I went back to school and got
my real estate license and that’s what I’m doing now. So therefore, my concern within the
historical district is how it causes the value of the residences that are in the historical district and
also right across the street, the value of our homes if it changes to commercial. She said it’s not
13
about not wanting to help young people. It’s not about not being in support of the cultural
realism center. I’m all for that if they want to start putting programs back in that building I’ll do
what I can to help but as far as rezoning that area, no I don’t wish for it to be rezoned. I hope
that you all will think about the other residents. She says she’s concerned about all of the
residents. What is that doing for us, the ones that are concerned about our property and the
value of our properties. Ms. Jernigan said another thing she is concerned about is that if you do
rezone that then are you going to….what if my mother and father say they want to change theirs
are you going to do it for them? Are you going to do it for everybody else if they want to do it?
She said I’m not against helping young people. That's not what this is about, this is about the
part that used to have a house on it and it is considered historical residential.
Mr. David Longacre said May I ask a question or two. He asked on the portion that you are
speaking of Where at one time there was probably a house prior to the hospital being built. in
the 40s There was a house. the doctor that actually had the hospital built that was his house
where he actually worked out of. Ms. Jernigan said, can I sit down, and you just address….. Mr.
Longacre said, “And I also have a question for you. He asked Ms. Jernigan when did she move
to her property? Mrs. Jernigan said 208 Orange St. which is right across from there is my
mother and father‘s house and I’ve lived there since third grade. She said my son is 23 and I
bought my house when he was four. Ms. Jernigan said and also when I wanted to put a nail sign
in my yard because I wanted to do nails out of that house they told me “No”, I couldn’t put a sign
in my yard. Mr. Longacres said, “So you grew up in that neighborhood; so, the time since 1973
when Wilhelmina Johnson started her program and was in that location you were able to see if
she was using that full property including Orange Street where that building has been”. Ms.
Jernigan said, “No. I saw that she had some programs and the building, I am not so familiar with
anything that she was doing on that property. I know she put picnic tables out there at one time.
As far as utilizing it and seeing a lot of things happening out there, no I didn’t”. Mr. Longacre
said it’s been almost 50 years. I am questioning— nothing has changed in the usage other than
COVID shutting things down and putting a lock down. The property isn’t changing. Ms. Jernigan
said I’m glad you brought that up because that’s my other point I forgot to mention. Once it
changes to commercial then if they sell it, then we don’t know what’s going to happen with it
you’re saying you won’t change the structure, but if somebody else buys it, then we’re not
guaranteed that either. Mr. Longacre said, “We’re not saying commercial, we're saying office
residential so we can get back in that building to use it as it has been used before.
Councilwoman Reed said, “You’re concerned about the effect that it would have on the value of
your home if it’s changed, so from what I’m understanding then I think Ms. Lathan pointed it out
and I heard the number of businesses and offices that’s already in the historic district. I'm trying
to see if all of this exists now”. Are those businesses zoned residential? Councilwoman Reed
asked Ms. Jernigan what she thinks will happen if this property is zoned office residential. Ms.
Jernigan said, “I’ve already stated that up there ma’am”. Councilwoman Reed said, “I didn’t get
a clear understanding there because you were saying it may affect your value and I was saying
what is going to change because we’ve got businesses already in this area in the historical
district”. Ms. Jernigan said, “The one that sits down at the end, if I had known about that one I
would have gone to those meetings and asked for that not to be changed”. Councilwoman
Reed said, “But it is there now. Did it affect the value of your house”? Councilwoman Reed said,
“I truly want to get clear as to why this opposition to what’s already there”. A lady in the
14
audience said when you see a sign….When you are going down Spring Street you see a sign
that says entering the historical district. Where is the sign that says I’m leaving the historical
district. She said it has to end somewhere. She said that’s a pointed question. You can’t tell me
that Roses is in the historical district. She said there’s a starting point and stopping point. Can
somebody explain that before you get into too much discussion about what’s historical.
(Several people are talking at the same time) Mayor Boyd told everybody to keep it one at a
time. Councilwoman Baccus said, if I understand correctly, half of the building is zoned
residential and the other half of the building is zoned office commercial. Ms. Angela Johnson
said the 304 building there is a part of that building that is residential. Mr. Longacre said the
very tail end of 304 building is where the line is supposedly residential. The rest of the building
is general commercial. He said how they ran a line through part of a hospital building and called
that residential it was never consistent when it was zoned to start with. Councilwoman Baccus
said, so it should have never been zoned that from the start. Councilwoman Baccus said, it’s not
like she’s changing anything; she just wants to fix the line. Mr. Longacre said, the 203 Orange
Street building because when we were using that building it was grandfathered in, so we had
the ability to use it, but that 90-day period ran out during the Covid lockdown so that’s when it
reverted back to residential now you can’t even operate out of there the way we’ve been for
almost 50 years. Councilwoman Baccus said, “And so, if we zone it back, we’re not going to
change anything because the building is already being used for 50 years and nothing changed.
Ms. Angela Johnson said Lisa has explained to us the non-impervious space prevents us from
being able to change that space that’s within the fence. Mrs. Lisa Bailey said according to the
zoning ordinance depending on what zoning district you’re in depends on how much impervious
surface (pavement) you can have. Take Walmart for example, they have a lot of pavement
because it general commercial. You have to have a certain number of parking spaces based on
what your use is. Mrs. Bailey said because of the size of this building, there’s only so much of
this property that could even be developed if they were to develop it. She said also this section
(referring to a map) which would be office/residential would serve as a buffer because in office
and residential you can’t build something bigger than 5,000 square feet. She said even if they
tore down that little metal building and built a bigger building for their pediatric services for an
office, there’s only so big it could get. Councilman Nettles asked if they could build multiple
5,000 square feet buildings? Mrs. Bailey said, “Just 5,000 square feet. That’s it”. She said this
parcel has already got part of the hospital on it to count towards that 5,000 square feet. She
said that is the maximum size in office residential that is why it keeps it as a buffer between
commercial and residential because it limits how much building you can do. Mr. Longacres
said, Ms. Lisa correct me if I’m wrong, with the structures that are already there, if it would be
changed to the office/residential where what we call the green space (grass) that’s fenced in
because of the size of the buildings that are already there, we wouldn’t be able to build anything
over there because of how much buildings are already being…..Mrs. Bailey said how much
space is already being taken up by the building. Mr. Longacres said, “So it doesn’t allow us to
go in have it rezoned build a structure there”. Councilman Gardner said, “So if you can’t build
anything on it then why are we rezoning it”? Mr. Longacres said, “So we can use the building
that’s already there because it’s in residential use which does not allow us to run programs and
things that we have been doing there. Councilman Nettles said, I’m confused I thought you were
doing that so you guys could sell the property for the…Mrs. Bailey said, “Well both really”.
15
Councilman Nettles asked, “so which is it”. Mr. Longacres said they have looked at the
possibility of leasing that building and utilizing it. Councilman Gardner said, “Be specific when
you say, “That building”. Mr. Longacres said, “the 203 Orange Street”. Councilman Gardner
said, “The aluminum shed”. Mr. Longacres said, “Yes”. Ms. Angela Johnson said, “No, it is not
a shed. It has never been utilized as such”. Councilman Nettles asked, “So that can be
renovated and utilized as something”. Mr. Longacres said, “Yes. It has had gas heat, running
water, bathroom facility in that building has always been in there. Councilman Nettles said, “It
looks pretty derelict. Mr. Longacres said from the outside it does look…but inside its water tight.
There’s no rot, leaks or things like that. Councilman Milling asked if that was the old laundry
building or am I thinking about….Councilman Gardner asked, “Judge aren’t you recused”.
Councilman Milling said, “I recused myself on the first vote. I have not had any conversation
with these people in a couple of years and so I don’t know that I’m going to recuse myself on
this vote or not. I’m trying to get information to help and understand because I have not talked
with Ms. Johnson. He said principally she was my client and of course you can’t with Ms.
Johnson without talking a little bit about CRC so I had recused myself the first time around. I
have not decided whether I’ll recuse myself this time around or not. Councilman Gardner said,
“So you recuse yourself on one vote and then vote on the next one”? Councilman Milling said,
“I have a chance and an opportunity to rethink just as you voted the first time to approve it and
you have a right to vote the second time to not approve it”. Councilman Gardner said, “I just
didn’t know if we legally could recuse ourselves”. Councilman Milling said, “So back to the
question, was this the old laundry or was this a different building that you are talking about is
water-tight”? Mr. Longacres said, “I believe it was at one time what was considered the laundry
building for the hospital”.
Kyle Owens…I live at Sycamore & Orange Street as Jackie Lynn referenced earlier I did
recently purchase my home in May. He said with that being said, I was not a part of the prior
rezoning request so I’m just coming in on this office/residential zoning request. Mr. Owens said
I moved here 12 years ago and I.ve always wanted a historic home so when this one became
available that’s when I purchased that property. Mr. Owens said, “I’m not in favor of changing
the zoning because it would change the zoning for the entire property. He said he was able to
attend the city planning meeting and was able to meet with Dr. Arnold. That day we had two
hours of discussions, and we suggested many different options that may be able to correct the
zoning issue for the building that’s in question. We were told every time that the way to do it
was rezoning the entire property. He said also during that time Ms. Arnold did pass out a flyer
which in that flyer it states they plan to sell the building and the plat to an entity that provides
related health care services. He said, our concern as residents was that property being sold is
going to change hands. She said it was going to be sold to another nonprofit and so that plot
has to be split up. Mr. Owens said our concern is If that happens, you’ve got one plot of land
that the building is on and then the other plot of land, what happens to later down the road. Ms.
Johnson asked if Kyle could read that full paragraph. (Mr. Kyle read the full paragraph) Ms.
Johnson said I wanted you to read it in its entirety because not only did we show in there that
we had other options prior to ultimately selling it, but it very clearly conveyed to the community
who we would consider transferring it to if we did. She said you don’t want to glaze over that
because the short statement that you read would justify peoples concern of who they are going
to pass it to. Mr. Owens said, “Our concern is what happens in two years down the road”. Ms.
16
Johnson asked, “What happened when you bought your house. The people around you, were
they concerned about you buying your house. Mr. Owens said when you change it to office
residential that opens up the option for doctors’ offices, banks, apartments, duplexes, triplexes,
quadruplexes etc. Our concern is if that happens, and the property does change hands again
then what happens to the landscape of the historic district on Orange Street. Councilwoman
Baccus said, I don’t think it’s big enough for duplexes and quadruplexes and all of that”.
Councilwoman Reed said, “I’m not sure where your home is but the businesses that’s been
there like the bank and the and the phone are they near your home. You don’t wonder what they
might do in two years”. Councilwoman Reed said, “All I’m trying to get at….it appears to
be..right now these folk want to be able to get it correct and the zoning the people that did it did
them an injustice. She said all of the opposition that I’m hearing is simply it’s still like they don’t
want to correct this but it’s just all personal when the same situation exists. She said when you
purchased your home offices were there….are there and that’s all they are zoning it to just
cover how it is now. Why is that a problem”? Councilman Gardner said, “Offices….this isn’t a
discussion this is a public hearing. You’re not required to debate with us, you are here to speak
a comment to make your will be heard and you’re not here to go back and forth if you don’t want
to”. Councilman Gardner said, “So, we’re talking about commercial properties are already here.
Already here is being defined as right beside this property but if you go on every side of this
property….Councilwoman Reed said, “That statement is wrong”. Councilman Gardner said,
“Your statement was wrong too but I didn’t interrupt you. Mayor Boyd told Councilwoman Reed
to let him finish but she kept talking. Mayor Boyd had to hit the gavel. He told Councilwoman
Reed to let Councilman Gardner finish talking and then she can speak. Councilman Gardner
said, “If you look at (Councilwoman Reed started talking again) Councilwoman Reed said, “ I
cannot understand if you’re comfortable with the offices already there, what is your fear”? Mr.
Owens said, “This property is right beside my house, right across the street”. He said my
concern is once it’s been cut and sold….the concern is there’s an opportunity for other
businesses. He said it changes the historical landscape of the St. John’s Historic District.
Councilwoman Reed said, “From what I’m looking at those businesses are in the historic district.
Mr. Owens said, “And I wasn’t here whenever those got changed”. Councilwoman Reed said,
“But you brought your home in this because you wanted the historical home inside a historical
district that have businesses. She said that’s all I’m saying. She said in two years we don’t
know what the landscape is going to be. Councilwoman Reed said, “You purchased it knowing
businesses were there in this historical district because that’s what you wanted. She said you
can’t even perceive that no businesses will not come. She said somebody else may buy a
home and do business out of theirs. Mr. Owens said they would have to rezone it.
Councilwoman Reed said and that’s what would happen so why is it such…. Mr. Owens said I
would be here too if another home was trying to be rezoned. He said the historic district needs
to stay the historic district as a single-family residential. Councilwoman Reed said, “But you
know it’s not that because it’s not that now”. Mr. Owens said we’re trying to prevent all of the
homes in the historical district from changing to that if you change this then in the future you
open up opportunities for a home around the corner in the historic district to come and have it
rezoned and then have an office residential or that type of change to different types of uses for
the property. Councilwoman Reed said, “In that area there are going to be changes and I
promise you it is going to happen within these two years whether you support this or not there
17
are going to be changes because it’s downtown Darlington”. Councilwoman Reed said, “It may
stay historical, but it’s not going to stay like it is now”. Councilman Gardner said, “When you
turn off the Square there are commercial properties. When you get down to the property in
question you are in a plainly historic district”. Councilman Gardner said, “I have been reached
out to from people off of Orange Street, off of St. John’s, everyone in the historic district”. He
said, we’re not talking about the CRC being able to not operate. That’s not our interest. Our
interest is protecting our historic district just like we did on Oak Street when Ms. Jannie Lathan
came up a few months back and asked us to rezone and put some …..into historic districts to
protect those from the encroachment of Genesis. Councilman Gardner said, “And that’s what
happened in one historic district because the town cares about their historic districts. He said if
we’re going to go and chop up our historic districts with zoning. Councilman Gardner said, “The
CRC building has a slither on the back of it and it’s residential, but the rest of that building is
commercial as it should be. He said they can go in there and operate tomorrow and nobody
from the city is stopping them. The question is whether we should rezone the piece of property
so that they can have the ability to sell it for a future use that we are unsure about. He said at
the end of the day we don’t know the future use the potential uses but we don’t know any of the
future use, so the question is whether the city wants to rezone a property under the assumption
that the future use is going to be this or this. He said the fear in my mind is that we start cutting
up the historic districts and then what’s the point of them. He said I have no issue with us going
and looking at a variance for a business that you potentially want to run, and we can approve
with no problem for the back area, but to go and rezone the property from my perspective is
blatant disregard for historic district and what we’re trying to build in our town in the historic
area. Mr. Owens said, “You were asking about variances we did talk about that type of situation
in the planning meeting that lasted almost 2 hours and had those discussions with Dr. Arnold
and the city planning commission, but we were told that that type of thing won’t happen. He
said they even suggested variances and that sort of thing. Councilwoman Baccus said, “So
Lisa, before Covid kicked in, that portion of the building was grandfathered in as office
commercial. Was it grandfathered in”? Mrs. Bailey said, “The use, that business, and this
building was all grandfathered in because it was continuously operating. She said Covid
stopped all of that”. She said now while we say a small sliver the majority of this property is
residential 10 (low density residential). Mrs. Bailey said, “This big portion (looking at the map) is
the portion we’re talking about. The front portion is commercial. She said the hospital is divided
in half. The hospital was there when the zoning was done and clearly not done correctly”. Mrs.
Bailey said, “A couple of blocks over not too long-ago Ms. Jones handed out some maps that
show a block or two over where we just rezoned a whole section where right now there’s Sassy
Girl Vintique which is where the Park Florist was located, that block, to commercial use because
that’s what it is”. Councilwoman Baccus said, “So technically, at the end of the day, all they are
asking us to do is fix a problem that Covid created. Councilwoman Baccus said they had it
office commercial for the last whatever years”. Mrs. Bailey said it probably should not have
been zoned R-10 to start with. Councilwoman Baccus said, “And they didn’t do anything crazy
with it in the last 50 years before Covid and if covid would have never happened they would still
be operating the same as office commercial, so I don’t understand what the issue is and I don’t
understand what the residents’ issue is”. She said, simply because I don’t want you to do it. It
makes no sense”. Councilwoman Baccus said, “If they wanted to, they could put up a 50-foot
18
fluorescent light on that half of the building. Mrs. Bailey said they can put whatever is allowed in
general commercial on that part of the building. She said, for example on Oak Street, the
building of Genesis, there is a portion that is built all the way to the sidewalk. Councilwoman
Baccus said, “And if you open the door you will kill somebody”. Mrs. Bailey said, “Now that
section of the building is zoned core commercial and that is why that is allowed there, and you
can tell exactly where further down Oak Street it stops being core commercial because the
building is setback. Mrs. Bailey said, “Why are we going to make them go through two vastly
different residential 10 and general commercial when they’re using it for office residential. Mrs.
Bailey said, “If they have to build, for the front half of the building use one set of rules and for the
back half of the building use a different set of rules”. Councilman Gardner said, “Just to be
clear, you’re saying back half. You’re saying half of the building….the previous picture that you
showed us…..Mrs. Bailey showed Councilman Gardner the area on the map. Councilman
Gardner said, “When you gave this to us last year (he referred to the map saying somewhere
around this mark) that was left out of core commercial. He asked where is that picture? It
showed the actual zoning. Mrs. Bailey showed him on the map. Councilman Gardner said, “I’m
not trying to divide what half and half is I’m just…Mrs. Bailey said, “It’s not exactly half, but it’s a
considerable portion of the property”. Councilman Gardner asked, “How can we change the
zoning on this back half and be different on this front half”? He said why can’t we change the
zoning from this point of view (looking on the map). Mrs. Bailey said because that is not a
separate parcel. Councilman Gardner said, “This isn’t a separate parcel either, correct? So
how are we going to change the zoning”….Mrs. Bailey said, “They can’t get a plat done and
approved without having it separated and they can’t separate it as R-10 into that small of a
section. She said in R-10 you can separate it, but it has to be 100 feet width and it’s got to be
so large”. Councilman Gardner said, “I’m not asking to put it in R-10. He said you’re splitting up
the property from GC to office residential in the back, right”? Mrs. Bailey said, “Yes. That’s what
it would be, but it’s currently R-10”. Councilman Gardner said, “If we pass this tonight the back
half would be office residential and the front half would be commercial”. Mrs. Bailey said,
“Correct”. Councilman Gardner said, “So then I don’t understand why we could not do office
residential down the sideline to go directly in line with this like you mentioned with the Dairy Bar
(a perpendicular line ) and then they will be able to operate their business just like they want,
and everybody is happy”. Mrs. Bailey said, “If they are potentially going to sell the property do
you want to have this argument again because if you don’t do the whole thing as office and
residential they’ll just come here in two years when they have established a business in that
property and say I need this split because I’m trying to sell this piece of property. Councilman
Gardner said, I don’t like the idea of rezoning for the potential use anyway, obviously I’ve said
that already but if you’re telling me I’m splitting the property on one access from GC and office
residential I’m just curious why I couldn’t split on another access. Mrs. Bailey said we’re saying
that we don’t want to split….Councilman Gardner said, you’re already doing it. Mrs. Bailey said,
yeah, we’re already doing it and that was a mistake. That’s what we’re saying. It doesn’t need
to be split”. Councilman Gardner said, That’s two mistakes though. The first mistake and then
you’ll want to do it again. Councilwoman Baccus said, we’re trying to fix what Covid created.
Mrs. Bailey said this is not removing the historic nature of the property. This is not eliminating
their requirements to meet the Secretary of the Interior standard for historic district. It is still
classified as a historic district. Mrs. Bailey said we have five historic districts in this town. One
19
of those is an Industrial Historic District. The zoning is a separate issue from the historic nature
of the property. She said there are historic properties that are industrial, there are historic
properties that are commercial and there are historic properties that are residential. Councilman
Gardner said, “Well explain this one to me, why are we arguing? Why is the city's perspective,
has you in that position arguing from a different perspective than you were on Oak Street?
What’s the difference because I see these as the same”. Mrs. Bailey said, “Last year they
asked, they petitioned, and the Planning Commission approved and recommended you change
the whole parcel to general commercial”. Councilman Gardner asked, “On Oak Street”? Mrs.
Bailey said, “No on this piece of property right here". Councilman Gardner said, “I asked you
about Oak Street”. Mrs. Bailey said I wanted that whole parcel to be the same thing too. She
said they asked to be all general commercial and the planning commission approved that
recommendation. Mrs. Bailey said, “This council shot it down and suggested a compromise.
This is the compromise. There is no other option for them to do it”. Councilman Gardner said,
“No offense, but this has nothing to do with my question I asked you. I asked you very
specifically whenever you came before us about the Oak Street area and expanding the historic
district, the city's perspective was one way. It's my opinion that it’s different in this situation.
Help me understand what the difference is. Mrs. Bailey said, “Here is the difference: a historic
district has nothing to do with zoning; these are completely different books; they have nothing to
do with each other”. Councilman Gardner asked why we protected one and we want
to…Councilwoman Baccus said, “I don’t think we’re protecting nothing because that’s a
humongous building going on Oak Street. Genesis is building; they are building in the middle of
a historic district”. Mrs. Bailey said the property that was protected is the houses that are along
Oak Street where Ms. Lathan lives at North Street and those houses on the right side between
Oak Street and Genesis. That is what was protected”. Councilman Gardner asked, “From
what”? Mrs. Bailey said, to become in the historic district so that those residents have access to
tax credits for when they want to improve their homes and maintain that historic character that
we all love. Councilwoman Reed said, “It was my understanding that it was the historical district
situation on Oak Street, but Orange Street is codes. Councilwoman Reed said, “It is not about
historic she said you didn’t understand her answer. She was answering you that her position for
Oak Street was about the historical district. Her position now is about zoning. that’s the
difference. Mayor Boyd asked, “Is the piece of property they’re asking at the back of Orange
Street classified as historic”? Mrs. Bailey said it is. She said it’s in the historic district and they
will have to meet with codes and have those…Whatever they decide to build or add on, or
change will have to meet the Secretary of Interior’s standards just like the house across the
street. Mayor Boyd said, “I do ask this of everybody sitting in the room; we as a council have to
make a decision and we are trying to make the best decision so I’m going to ask everybody to
please pull your emotions out of it and let’s make the right decision. He said that’s what I’m
trying to do”. Mayor Boyd said my question is, so that is historical. Is the front building also
historical? Is the whole block historical? Mrs. Bailey said, “No Sir. It follows that line right here
(she showed him on a map). Mrs. Bailey said the residential part is historic. The general
commercial part is not. Mayor Boyd said, “Like on Oak Street for those homes to get into the
historical park somebody had to agree on or disagree on….did they automatically get put into a
historical park”? Mrs. Bailey said that is a completely different situation. She said those property
owners came to a historic landmark commission meeting and asked to be in the historic district.
20
Mrs. Bailey said, “And here we have the CRC property owners asking”. Boyd asked if the
property owners of the CRC asked to be in the historic district”? Mrs. Bailey said, “No. The
historic district was created in the late 80s”. Mayor Boyd said, “So if the house beside it or
around it asked to be put into it how did the CRC building”….. Mrs. Bailey said the city created
it. Mayor Boyd said, “So they just put it in the historical park”. Mrs. Bailey said, “But that
doesn’t affect the use. Zoning affects the use; the historic district is talking about how it looks”.
Mayor Boyd, Mrs. Bailey and Sheila Jones continued to discuss zoning and the property in
question. Councilman Segars said, “I’d like to question the gentleman here. He just brought the
piece of property on Sycamore Street. Councilman Segars asked would he have bought that
piece of property knowing the property in question is going to be rezoned to something other
than residential which leads to the people across Orange Street next to the Dana property and
those houses along there”. He asked Mr. Owens would they have moved there and bought that
piece of property knowing that this green space may change into a somewhat commercial type
of application. Mr. Owens said, “I probably wouldn’t have brought the house thinking it was in a
residential street which is what those properties are (referencing the map). Council continued to
discuss the issue. Councilman Gardner said, “If Covid is the issue and loss of the previous use
is the issue I don’t know where she’s getting her legal advice from, but I always thought we
could make variances. And if Covid caused that business to close and you’ve lost your use
ability, I don’t understand why we couldn’t give a variance for that business to still run there. He
said that would be my suggestion. Councilman Gardner said, “And I think it could be easily
done. It may take us a month and we can have our lawyer work out the paperwork and we could
have it done probably without even council’s vote.
Ms. Jannie Lathan said, Mayor I think you are absolutely correct when you say we should
really take the emotions out of this because when we look at our existing zoning, codes, and
requirements for this rezoning classification if clearly meets that. She said I sympathize with the
residence about being concerned about property value but the center for all directors has been
so forthcoming with their intentions that it’s only going to increase property value because what
they are proposing is going to look much better than what some thought was a shed. Ms.
Lathan said, “I think doing the right thing, correcting errors that the city has made on the one
hand and following the existing requirements for zoning the City has and taking emotions out of
this it’s the proper way for us to proceed”. Mayor Boyd asked Ms. Sheila Jones if they were to
tear down the building in front on general commercial, nothing changed tonight and they built a
funeral home, bank, whatever. Sheila Jones said, “If they tore the front down, that’s general
commercial and there's a list of things they can do on the front”. Mayor Boyd said, “Let’s say
they tore that down and they built a building across the front with a drive-through out to the front
and the back was all paved and when I drive by it still could look like it’s all one unit, but it still
would be R-10 but it would just be a parking lot. Would they be allowed to have that as….Mayor
Boyd said, “They’re not asking for that I’m just saying….Ms. Jones said, “I understand what
you’re saying, but what I’m saying is if you look on here parking lots are not permitted in R-10;
they are permitted in OR (office residential). Councilman Gardner asked, “Could a psychiatrist
operate an office out of a residence. Sheila Jones said, yes. It’s called a home occupation and
they would have to live within the parameters of home occupation which means it could never
look from the exterior that there is a business on the inside”. Councilman Gardner said, “So a
speech therapist could run their business out of there”. Ms. Jones said we have a speech
21
therapist that’s running out of a home at this time. Ms. Johnson said just to make sure that I’m
clear, we don’t have any plans of pursuing a home occupation because we don’t have any plans
of anyone ever residing at 203 Orange Street. Mayor Boyd asked council if they want to make a
suggestion to table it and work on it until next month or do you want to make a vote. Mr. Payne
said if you’re going to move on you need to close the public hearing first. Councilman Gardner
made a motion to close the public hearing at 8:10 pm. Councilman Nettles seconded the
motion. Councilpersons Milling, Baccus, Reed, Segars and Mayor Boyd voted in favor of
the motion.
b)SECOND READING – O
RDINACNE 2022-09 – REZONING REQUEST 203 ORANGE
STREET, LISA BAILEY. PLANNING DIRECTOR
Councilman Gardner made a motion to table second reading on ordinance 2022-09
Rezoning Request 203 Orange Street until our next council meeting. Councilman Nettles
seconded the motion. Councilpersons Milling, Segars and Mayor Boyd voted in favor to
table second reading until next month. Councilwomen Baccus and Reed voted against
the motion to table.
NEW BUSINESS
a)SE DARLINGTON ARCHITECTURAL SURVEY FINAL REPORT- STACI RICHEY
Ms. Richey thanked the council for hiring her to do this project for the City of Darlington. She
said this is the southeast Darlington historic resource survey. Ms. Richey said she is an
architectural historian and historic preservationist. She said there are several components to
this project. There is the historic context statement in the beginning where I research the
development of Darlington particularly the southeast section to help explain why the buildings
that are there, are there. The second component was the survey itself, so there are 317
resources that I survey in this section. Ms. Richey said out of the southeast section of Darlington
there are three main components. There’s a historic avenues district which has A through H
avenues, and it also has First through Third Streets. Ms. Richey said there’s an industrial
section on the Northeast corner and on the south section down at Joe Lewis Boulevard from H
Ave. She said this has historically been an African American residential / industrial area. She
said in looking at the southeast section of Darlington there’s clearly some rhyme and reason to
that Avenue section in the first street. There was a group of white investors who created the
Darlington Land Improvement company in 1888 and they had this area platted in 1890 to open
this section up to residential development and to make money. They sold properties in some
areas and became rental properties, and it became African American residential. I don’t know if
they specifically marketed to that demographic or if it’s because Edmond Deas came in 1890
and he was an African American and he kind of established that it would be that. Ms. Richey
said originally as you can see on the cover that’s the plat of the north half of this area. It was
supposed to go all the way to Seventh Street, but the railroad that came in 1911 slashed
through Fourth Street so that disrupted the concept of this whole residential area going all the
way to Seventh Street. She said it grew very slowly. When Darlington Veneer company came
in 1918 it probably helped with growth. When Dixie Cup came in the 1930s that helped with
residential growth. Ms. Richey said she made a recommendation for a National Registry District
of the Avenues area which is the grid pattern you see on the cover for its association with land
22
planning and private development in the 1890s which is kind of a popular trend at that time and
also for association with African American history in Darlington. She said the State Preservation
office has concurred with that recommendation so that doesn’t list anything on the register it’s
just a recommendation. If someone down the road wanted to make a district then they have
that foundation. She said nothing has changed for anyone’s property, there's no new rules for
anyone’s property, it’s just a recommendation. Ms. Richey said at least now you have a record
of what’s in this section of town, why it is there and what may be historically important. Mrs.
Bailey said, we started this project given the major investment by Dixie Cup and for working with
the county and economic development looking at that area and the amount of vacant properties
and knowing that because of that investment more investment is likely to come so we wanted to
survey this area to gather as much information and as much history as we could because
development will wipe out stuff. Mrs. Bailey said we wanted to capture that history before it’s
gone. Councilman Milling asked where would you anticipate that additional commercial growth
or industrial growth would occur somewhere within this district because of what Dixie Cup has
done? Mrs. Bailey said with Dixie cup investing $145 million that’s going to make people take
notice she said this property that’s available that has access to the railroad…that property being
available is obviously property that we would be pitching to different industries and commercial
uses. Councilman Milling asked, “do we have a block of property that is where people would
like to sell it if we could get an industry…. Mrs. Bailey said this is to start that process. She said
working with the county they developed a plan for the area (the starts of a plan) which was
presented to council several years ago when Mr. Frank Willis was still alive. Ms. Richey said
the proposed boundary, if there were to be a historic district, stops on Third Street and the
railroad is essentially on Fourth Street.
b)S
CMA CIVILITY RESOLUTION - JOHN PAYNE, CITY MANAGER
Mr. Payne said he wanted to follow up on Councilman Segars comments from last month in
September. All of us except for Ms. Elaine went to the SCMA Conference in Charleston and
their theme was Civility in Government. It doesn’t matter if it’s Darlington or the Pee dee or
South Carolina, it’s just a national issue. He said that they have asked Municipalities and towns
to pass a civility resolution if you will and that’s what I’m going to present to you. Mr. Payne
said, “From their website they’ve got nine pillars of civility and I’ll read them to you quickly:
23
Mr. Payne said that he gave them a copy of the resolution. He said he would read it very briefly
assuming that you will pass it, there is a signature section for each one of you at the bottom.
A RESOLUTION
PLEDGING TO PRACTICE AND PROMOTE CIVILITY IN THE
CITY OF DARLINGTON
24
WHEREAS a recent national survey found that 93% of Americans believe that incivility is a problem, with 68%
considering it a "major" problem and 74% believing that incivility is increasing in America;
WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Darlington (the "Council"), the governing body of the City of Darlington,
South Carolina {the "Municipality"), recognizes that robust debate and the right to self-expression, as protected by
the First Amendment to the United Stat s Constitution, are fundamental rights and essential components of
democratic self-governance.
WHEREAS, the Council further recognizes that the public exchange of diverse ideas and viewpoints is necessary
to the health of the community and the quality of governance in the Municipality;
WHEREAS, the Members of Council, as elected representatives of the community and stewards of the public
trust, recognize their special role in modeling open, free and vigorous debate while maintaining the highest
standards of civility, honesty and mutual respect; and
WHEREAS, in order to publicly declare its commitment to civil discourse and to express its concern for the
common good and well- bei
ng of all of its residents, the Council has determined to adopt this resolution,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED AS FOLLOWS:
The City of Darlington pledges to practice and promote civility within the governing body.
The elected officials of the Council enact this civility pledge to build a stronger and more prosperous community
by advocating for civil engagement, respecting others, and their viewpoints, and finding solutions for the
betterment of the City of Darlington.
This pledge ensures all communication - both spoken and written - to be open, honest and transparent as this is
vital for cultivating trust and relationships.
This pledge ensures mutual respect to achieve municipal goals, recognizing that patience, tolerance and civility
are imperative to success.
This pledge ensures opportunities for finding common ground and engaging in civil discussion to seek solutions
while actively listening and thoughtfully participating.
ADOPTED IN REGULAR MEETING this 6th day of September 2022.
Civility Makes the Difference
Councilman Gardner made a motion to approve the Civility Resolution to practice and promote
stability in the City of Darlington. Councilman Nettles seconded the motion. Councilpersons
Milling, Baccus, Reed, Segars and Mayor Boyd voted in favor of the motion. Mr. Payne said
after the meeting he will ask each of them to sign the resolution.
c)UP
DATE OF THE PAST YEAR - JOHN PAYNE, CITY MANAGER
• Mr. Payne said Mr. Mayor it has kind of flown by. I have been here a little over a year
and I remember when I interviewed I knew I was coming into a town that needed some
special attention and I felt that I am proud to stand here today and give you this
information. Now this is not everything that we have done. These are what I call the
ten-thousand-foot level items. Mr. Payne said that he just wants to go over it. I will tell
you what I have done. This is the list:
• Personnel policies on sexual harassment, Covid, random alcohol and drug testing and
creation of an employee grievance committee.
• H-Tax -- $23,000 from two businesses that had not paid in over 2 years - random audits and
now have Enforcement
25
• New monthly H-Tax form with verification requirement ST- 3 form
• Business license income verification requirement with tax return or income statement
• Recouped nearly $19,000 from one big-box retailer that had never paid a business
license
• State Treasurer LGIP investment of $3.9M has in one month brought in over $7,000 vs
previous $4,200/year (paying 2.24% now) ~$85,000/year in interest income.
• GP conveying parking lot for stormwater drainage; working with railroad for
easement
• Rewired City Hall and installing new telephone system
• Creation of Grants Committee to streamline process
• Mavis Tire, Mod Wash, Convenience Store - GP, Genesis, Courthouse, Historic
Museum expansions, 47 new apartments. Three new stores around the Public Square -
hairdresser, ice cream/confectionary, children's clothing stores. New physical therapy
business is coming to the old KFC in October and the Southern Charm restaurant
opened.
About to apply for ~$8M in grants to address water/sewer/stormwater.
Terrance Carraway Police Memorial is almost finished
Repairing W/S infrastructure - 9,208 work orders, 5662 sewer pump station daily checks
24/7/365; repaired/replaced 266 items at the City's 14 pump stations; completed 188
sewer service line cleanouts - do not flush "disposable wipes." Repaired 345 water line
leaks.
d)GR ANTS COMMITTEE UPDATE – JOHN PAYNE,CITY MANAGER
Mr. Payne said you created a grants committee several months ago. They met for the first time
on August 15th. Applications have been posted on the website and in the paper. Applications
are due by 5 o’clock on September 23rd. The committee will meet on September 29, 2022, to
interview the applicants and make their funding decisions. Mr. Payne said the committee will
make the recommendations to you at the October 4th meeting. Mr. Payne said what I’m
requesting is they are going to need to know a dollar amount that you are willing to take out of
H-tax to disperse to these entities. Councilman Gardner said, “We might have to cancel that
because Council requested to get an update as far as what we spent last year so we can have
an idea”…Mr. Payne read the names of the entities that the city gave money to last year.
Councilman Gardner said, “I don’t care. Names are irrelevant; we need a dollar amount”. Mr.
Payne said $77,000. Councilman Gardner said, “In my opinion DDRA and downtown Alive
should not be incorporated in this community fund because that’s something the city does. Mr.
Payne said if you would like to theoretically remove it, that’s fine. Mr. Payne said if you want to
take out DDRA that’s $29,500. Councilman Nettles said don’t we have an outstanding request
for something. Mr. Payne said the Pilot Club and the Southern 500. He said they are going to
make an application. Mr. Payne said without DDRA, it’s $30,000. Mr. Payne said to keep in
mind there’s no requirement that you give a penny of this. You could use it all to fund your own
projects. Mayor Boyd asked if we are going to pull ….Councilman Gardner said, we all know we
26
have to fund a recreation complex next in the next coming calendar year and you all are taking
from that fund, which right now has $266,000 a year in it. He said we only have $266,000 right
now and you all are wanting to potentially take out $75,000 and do it as community relations for
nonprofits? Councilman Gardner said, “I have no problem with nonprofits. I support nonprofits,
but it’s not the government’s job. The government‘s job is to give resources to the community
that we collect taxes from”. He said the resource that we’re supposed to give out of that
hospitality fund is tourism related stuff; it’s not community related. It’s supposed to be for stuff
that comes and brings tourism money into the city. Councilman Gardner said $266,000 minus
$75,000, I don’t know how we’re going to pay for ballfields in a couple of months.
Councilwoman Reed said, “We’re not going to be able to pay for football fields with that 200 and
something thousand anyway. Councilwoman Reed said, “The thought that you have how come
you haven’t used it in the past”. Councilwoman Reed said, “All we’re saying is what we have
done in the past and we have voted to do these things and it’s going to be expected that we
continue. She said we have set up a grants committee so these folks can come and request.
Councilwoman Reed said, all we’re saying now is that we will cap it. Do you want to lower it?
Councilman Gardner said, “Yes”. Councilwoman Reed said, “We are going to do it. We cannot
not do it because of what we have put out there and its public knowledge. Let's just cap this,
give us an amount that the committee can work with and move on”. Councilwoman Reed said,
“I’m just saying because we have spent $77,000 I do not see giving anything less”. Councilman
Gardner said, “First off, we didn’t spend $77,000 we spent $54,000. He said second of all, just
because we’ve done something in the past is not a good enough reason to do it in future. Right
now, we have to be conservative with our dollars”. Councilman Gardner said, “Y’all tore us up
and down for raising the water and stormwater fee and the sewer and you want to spend all the
money in the hospitality fund and then wonder why we can’t buy a ballfield”? (Councilman
Gardner, Councilwoman Baccus & Reed are talking at the same time). Mayor Boyd said if we
pull out $25,000 for DDRA to fund the events downtown; and you can pull out the Pilot Club and
the Chamber which are the main three that pull our events. He said that totals all together
about $47,000. Mayor Boyd made a suggestion of $60,000. Councilman Milling made a
motion to set aside $60,000 out of the hospitality tax fund that we give the grants
committee $35,000 to operate with and that out of the $60,000 that we set aside, we
earmark $25,000 of it to go to DDRA. Councilman Gardner seconded the motion.
Councilpersons Nettles, Baccus, Reed, Segars and Mayor Boyd voted in favor of the
motion.
e)CA
RNEGIE LIBRARY LEASE TO COUNTY - JOHN PAYNE, CITY MANAGER
Mr. Payne said, “The County Administrator approached me, and they are asking the city to allow
them to enter a lease with us for the Carnegie library for a term of up to five years for the sole
purpose of storing artifacts and documents from the historical museum. Councilman Gardner
said, “I’m fine with that as long as we take out in section #3 where it says “automatically renew
for up to two successive sixty-month periods. Councilman Gardner asked when the county
takes over the lease are we still in charge of the maintenance? Mr. Payne said, “Yes. We will
take care of our normal maintenance”. Councilman Gardner asked how much we are charging.
Mr. Payne said, “five dollars”. Councilman Gardner said, “If we are in charge of the maintenance
and with their wear and tear is five dollars appropriate”? Mayor Boyd said there is no wear and
27
tear. He said as the owner of the building the only thing we’re responsible for is the outside
structure of it and the roof. Mr. Payne asked Lisa to remind him for the streetscape grant what
did the county do for us for the library. Mrs. Bailey said the county is paving the parking lot as
part of their bigger project and they’re giving us that money to match the grant to do the awnings
and paint the back of the building. Mrs. Bailey said when we discussed previously changing
using the Carnegie Library as the museum before they got their $4 million grant, that was one of
the original plans. She said it does need to have a new HVAC system to be temperature and
moisture controlled if they are going to put the museum quality items in it. Mayor Boyd said that
could be hundreds of thousands of dollars. He said I wouldn’t think they are expecting us to
drop hundreds of thousands of dollars. Councilman Nettles said, “Can you ask that question”?
Councilman Gardner said, “I guess we could ask them if we have to replace the A/C if they will
meet us 50-50 on the cost of it”. Mr. Payne said, “I can ask”. Councilman Milling said in item #4
he has concerns about the language because it indicates that we’ve got something we’ve got to
take care of. He said under item 5-B ii it says the premises will be used exclusively by lessee,
so we don’t actually have any right to use the premises with them as this lease is written at this
time. If they are using a portion and we want to use a portion, there is nothing in here that
guarantees that we have access to the building because they are getting exclusive. Mr. Payne
said he can present any changes they may have. Mayor Boyd said, “I wouldn’t think that the
city would want to have any access to all of that stuff. Mayor Boyd said my suggestion would be
to take that out because we don’t want access to it”. Councilman Milling said, “Item #7 talks
about repairs and it says we’ve got no duty to make any repairs. And it says we have no duty to
make any repairs or improvements to the premises except structural repairs necessary for
safety and tenantability purposes and such other repairs as are specifically provided for herein.
Councilman Milling said, “And I just don’t know whether or not there are any structural repairs
that they think are necessary for safety and tenantability. Mr. Payne said, I don’t think that they
know. They haven’t indicated anything to me. Councilman Milling said I want us to know
whether we’re going to have some structural, what they consider to be necessary , for us to
repair before they take possession. Councilman Milling said if they’re not thinking there are any,
then if they can let us take that out, it will be nice to take it out. Councilman Milling said, “In item
#7 take out the language where it starts at “except structural repairs necessary for safety and
tenantability purposes and such other repairs as are specifically provided for herein”. Mayor
Boyd said the county would maintain the a/c at the current capacity. Councilman Milling said on
Item #16 where its talking about our rights. He said I’m just wondering sometime entities put
mediation and/or arbitration provisions in case disputes arise instead of going into court. I don’t
know whether those would be desirable or applicable for both sides. This is something we
could discuss with them. Councilman Gardner said we can come back to this next month but in
the meantime we can empower our City Manager to tell the County Administrator that we’re
going change some of the language in certain sections. Councilman Milling said there is some
language in Item #18 but I haven’t found it elsewhere, but it talks about successors and assigns.
Councilman Milling said, “I don’t whether there is a provision in here that allows them to assign
this lease to anybody else, but I don’t think we want to give them the authority to assign it to
anybody. We just want to be sure it’s a non-assignable lease. Councilwoman Reed said, “It
seems like there is a lot of discussion about this for us to be able to go on. John you need it and
give him a chance to really examine this thing and come back to us….Councilman Milling said,
28
“I have given John Payne all of my concerns”. (Councilwoman continued keep talking while
Councilman Milling was talking) Councilman Milling said. “Looks like this is going to be draft #1.
He said I think Bryant said let’s give Mr. Payne the authority to continue to negotiate to be sure
that he comes back to council at the next meeting with something that will be the final draft.
Councilwoman Reed said, “I want your input since you have examined it.” Councilman Milling
said, “I will be glad to look at it but it’s the City Attorney who needs to pass final muster on it.
Mr. Payne said, “If you give me that authority I will take care of it.
f)EMPLOYEE COMPENSATION AND CLASSIFICATION STUDY BIDS – J
OHN PAYNE,
CITY MANAGER
Mr. Payne said when he interviewed one of the points that he made and a concern of his was
the city needs a compensation and classification study for our employees. He said our payroll is
roughly 60-63% of our budget. Mr. Payne said, “I have found that what’s called “wage
compression”. That’s when someone who has been here for ten years is making $16 an hour
and then you’ve got someone that comes in new, and because of inflation, and maybe they’ve
got a little more qualifications, but basically doing the same job, they may be making $18 an
hour. So, the people that’s been here working for years and years, get left behind. Mr. Payne
said we have to compete with every other municipality and a lot of times, private businesses. In
order to do that we need to know what market rates are for each job that we have, and right now
we don’t have that. He said except for a few people here, a lot of our employees don’t have
titles and it’s important to have a classification system. Mr. Payne said, “And what my goal is in
doing this, and this has been budgeted, is to have a pay scale and we don’t have that right
now”. He said we have for whatever reason; their pay is disconcerting, and it makes it hard to
keep good employees. He said his biggest concern is we’re not competitive. Mr. Payne said I
contacted five entities and I only got two responses. Mr. Payne said, “The one I recommend is
from the Archer Company and their bid is $16,350. He said the other group out of Florida
submitted a bid for $28,500. Both estimate it will take about 3 ½ months to do this. They will
also give us a better way to evaluate employees. Mr. Payne asked Council to approve the
Archer Company bid for $16,350 to complete a compensation and classification study for the
City of Darlington. Councilwoman Reed asked if the Municipal Association offers this type of
resource. Mr. Payne said, “They have ranges of each municipality that participates, but they
don’t do this per se. Mr. Payne said the company is not going to tell you what each employee
should be making exactly. Councilman Nettles said, “There’s a quantitative series of questions
that they ask and that they look for. He said they look at national averages and things like that.
They’re looking at comparable entities like we’re a city government at this size in this region.
Councilman Nettles said there’s a whole bunch of things they are going to look at to determine
whether or not we are meeting some standards. It ‘s giving you a guideline so you can say, now
we’re being consistent. He said it’s another way to take the guess work off some people (maybe
hiring managers, the city manager or whomever) making sure things are consistent. He said it’s
also a good way to make sure all of your employees are treated the same way based on the
same provided criteria. Councilwoman Baccus said, “I understand what you’re saying, and I
understand how it should work, but based two things that happened in the last year we just
giving raises on whims. We gave a $10,000 and now we gave another person a $30,000 raise a
month after the budget, which should have been a 2% raise. Councilman Gardner said, “I think
29
this is a great idea why we would fund this”. Councilwoman Baccus said, “I don’t see no point in
doing this because we’re giving raises on whims”. Councilwoman Reed said, “Because you
made these assessments to see that these things needed to be done….some of the folk is
asking about these raises is simply when you knew this needed to be done why take the action
that would cause this kind of question….making us look at…that’s what I’m saying. And John
you have to be able to respond to that, to the citizens because this is rampart in the community
about certain people get raises without….and the same thing that you’re saying, I’ve been here
a long time. When you saw that these things…and you wanted to straighten this out.
Councilman Gardner said, “But in the meantime I would like to motion to approve Archer
Company bid for $16,350. Councilman Milling asked Mr. Payne if we would end up with a
document we can utilize once the study is done. Is there going to be a document prepared that
the city could operate on”? Mr. Payne said, “I’ll have a document”. Councilman Nettles
seconded the motion. Councilpersons Baccus, Reed, Milling, Segars and Mayor Boyd
voted in favor of the motion.
g)CO
URTHOUSE WATERLINE REPAIRS – CHARLES SHUGART, WATER & SEWER
DIRECTOR
Mr. Payne said the county has asked that we table this until next time.
h)UP DATE DEMO LIST – SHEILA JONES, CODES ENFORCEMENT
Ms. Sheila Jones said in updating the demo list there are three residential properties and two
commercial properties that are being carried over from last year. We are going to add seven
properties to the demo list and one of which is a commercial property. Councilman Milling
wanted to know if that property was more likely to be utilized with the front staying as it is or is it
more likely to be marketable if you tear the front off? Ms. Jones said, “Likely on the front for
structural…If you can…she said I believe that’s an engineering question. Councilman Milling
said, “the reason I asked that question is I was talking to a person who has an interest in it and
said that they had the agreement worked out with the current owner if they could just get the
current owner to move their junk out. He said if the perspective would like to have that front I
wouldn’t want to tear it down. Ms. Jones said it’s not on the top of the list. Ms. Jones said this
could prod the current owner to go ahead and make a decision one way or the other, but it can’t
continue stay as it is. Councilman Milling said I don’t have a problem with it, but I would like to
have that one not run first to get done. Ms. Jones said with that one specifically if we decided to
do it as a city, we would have to get a structural engineer to go in there to make sure the front
and sides are ok. She said there’s a lot of other things that are going to be involved in that one
so that one is not at the top of the list. Councilman Milling made a motion to approve the
updated demo list for fiscal year 2022-2023. Councilwoman Elaine Reed seconded the
motion. Councilpersons Nettles, Baccus, Gardner, Segars and Mayor Boyd voted in
favor of the motion.
i)A
DA COMPLIANCE PLAN – SHEILA JONES, CODES ENFORCEMENT
Ms. Sheila Jones said the State is requiring for all municipalities to update their ADA
Compliance and their ADA Transition Plan. Ms. Jones said together with the COG they have
updated the ADA Plan. She said they had to appoint an ADA committee to go over what is
30
reasonable and accommodating to people. She said they have some aid facilities for the
hearing impaired if they were to come to our council meeting or any meeting that we have. Ms.
Jones said they had to come up with a grievance committee so if somebody did not like our
decision to not be able to do something that’s accommodating to them they can go in front of
the grievance committee that’s made up of several different people that are employees of the
city to include one person who is connected to somebody who has a disability. They had to post
our grievance procedure on the board outside and also on the website. She said they are also
requiring for every city employee to go through ADA Sensitivity training which has to be done by
the end of the year. Ms. Jones said everything is done so far except the sensitivity training.
She will meet with them next week to figure out the best way to get all of our employees through
the training before the end of the year. They said go on to internet, but I told them some of our
employees don’t have that kind of technology so we’re trying to figure out a way to best suit our
employees. Ms. Jones said, “I just need Council to approve the plan so that we can get it to the
State so we can continue to apply for grants. Councilwoman Reed made a motion to
approve the ADA Compliance Plan submitted by Ms. Sheila Jones apparently the ADA
Coordinator. Councilwoman Baccus seconded the motion. Councilpersons Nettles,
Gardner, Milling, Segars and Mayor Boyd voted the approve the ADA Compliance Plan.
j)P
URCHASE OF LAW ENFORCEMENT E QUIPMENT – KELVIN WASHINGTON, CHIEF OF
POLICE
Police Chief Washington said he is almost sure we approved this last year, but Mr. Payne didn’t
want to take any chances. Chief Washington said we received a grant from the SC Department
of Public Safety. He said it’s a reimbursement grant for laptops. Mr. Payne asked that he bring
it before them because it’s over $5,000. Chief Washington said it’s $39,000 and we have the
funds on hand, and I just need you all to approve the transaction. Councilman Bryant
Gardner made a motion to approve the purchase of law enforcement equipment (laptops
for patrol cars) in the amount of $39,083.30. Councilman Howard Nettles seconded the
motion. Councilpersons Baccus, Reed, Millings, Segars and Mayor Boyd voted in favor
of purchasing law enforcement equipment (laptops) in the amount of $39,083.30.
EXECUTIVE SESSION –
Pursuant to SC Code 30-4-40( E ), disclosure of law enforcement
techniques. Council may or may not act following Executive Session.
Councilwoman Elaine Reed made a motion to go into executive session at 9:52 PM.
C
ouncilman Howard Nettles seconded the motion. Councilpersons Gardner, Baccus,
Milling, Segars and Mayor Ward voted in favor of the motion.
Councilman Howard Nettles made a motion to end executive session at 9:56 PM.
Councilman Bryant Gardner seconded the motion. Councilpersons Reed, Baccus,
Milling, Segars and Mayor Boyd approved the motion.
Councilwoman Elaine Reed made a motion to approve the purchase of law enforcement
equipment in the amount of $8,979.40. Councilman Howard Nettles seconded the
motion. Councilpersons Gardner, Baccus, Milling, Segars and Mayor Boyd voted to
approve the purchase of law enforcement.
31
REMINDER
Tuesday October 4, 2022, at 6:00 PM – Regular Monthly Meeting of Darlington City Council.
ADJOURN
Upon motion of Councilman Gardner, seconded by Councilman Nettles, to adjourn the
meeting at 9:58 PM. Councilpersons Reed, Baccus, Milling, Segars and Mayor Boyd
approved the motion.
Mayor
ATTEST:
Clerk & Treasurer
Source: City of Darlington website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.