Board Pack for Piedmont Municipal Power Agency – PMPA Board Meeting – May 22, 2025 – v1
City of Westminster · Oconee County · meeting of May 22, 2025 · Notices
Open the original document More from City of Westminster
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Piedmont Municipal Power Agency
BOARD PACK
for
PMPA Board Meeting
Thursday, May 22, 2025
10:00 AM (EDT)
Held at:
PMPA Office
121 Village Drive, Greer, SC 29651
Generated: 2025-05-15 12:41:11
INDEX
Cover Page
Index
Agenda
Attached Documents:
2.1 a Minutes : PMPA Board Meeting - 17 Apr 2025...................................................................... 6
4.1 a April 2025 Financial Board Mailing.pdf................................................................................... 11
5.1 a Piedmont Municipal Power Agency 12 31 2024 Agreed Upon Procedures Report as issued.pdf 18
5.2 a 2025_04_Demand Response Report.pdf............................................................................... 23
5.2 b 2025_04_Energy Report.pdf.................................................................................................. 24
5.3 a Catawba Report May 15, 2025.pdf......................................................................................... 25
5.4 a Exec Comm Minutes - May 7 2025.pdf.................................................................................. 26
Generated on: 2025-05-15 12:41:08
Powered by BoardPro 1
AGENDA
PMPA BOARD MEETING
Name: Piedmont Municipal Power Agency
Date: Thursday, May 22, 2025
Time: 10:00 AM to 2:00 PM (EDT)
Location: PMPA Office, 121 Village Drive, Greer, SC 29651
https://pmpa.zoom.us/j/84854297204?pwd=pUBLRakO7loc7bfk8BdhbmbMO
gZW3E.1
Board Members: Blake Stone, Andy Sevic (Chair), Mayor Randy Randall, Joey Meadors,
Mayor Brian Ramey, David Vehaun, Eric Goodwin, Mayor Foster Senn, Jason
Taylor, Jimmy Bagley, Joe Nichols, John Young, Keith Wood, Kevin Bronson,
Lance Davis, Marc Regier, Mike Richard, Steve Bratton, Tim Hall, David
Dorman
Attendees: Angie Hoover, Brandon Audet, Cindy Frierson, Dedra Howell, Dennis
Cameron, Gary Brunault, Joel Ledbetter, JulieAnne London, Kenny Bradley,
Lynn Price, Mike Frazier, Rion Foley, Robby Townsend, Tom Gressette,
Tracy Quinn, Will Blanton
1. Call to Order
1.1 Identify Virtual Attendees
1.2 Declaration of Quorum
1.3 Invocation
2. Approval of Minutes
2.1 Confirm Minutes
Supporting Documents:
2.1.a Minutes : PMPA Board Meeting - 17 Apr 2025
2.2 Vote to Approve Minutes of April 17, 2025 Board Meeting
3. Action Item
3.1 Catawba and Legislative Committee Members
For Decision
3
6
Agenda : PMPA Board Meeting - May 22, 2025
Powered by BoardPro 2
4. Acceptance of Financial Report
4.1 April 2025
Supporting Documents:
4.1.a April 2025 Financial Board Mailing.pdf
5. Reports
5.1 Finance
Agreed Upon Procedures for Catawba Plant performed by PB Mares.
Supporting Documents:
5.1.a Piedmont Municipal Power Agency 12 31 2024 Agreed Upon Procedures Report as
issued.pdf
5.2 Engineering
Supporting Documents:
5.2.a 2025_04_Demand Response Report.pdf
5.2.b 2025_04_Energy Report.pdf
5.3 Catawba
Supporting Documents:
5.3.a Catawba Report May 15, 2025.pdf
5.4 Report on Meeting of Executive Committee
Supporting Documents:
5.4.a Exec Comm Minutes - May 7 2025.pdf
5.5 Management
6. Executive Session
6.1 Vote to enter into Executive Session
6.2 Discuss matters pertaining to contractual
negotiations
6.3 Vote to return to Regular Session
7. Actions to be taken based on discussions in Executive Session
7.1 Action based on discussion in Executive Session
For Decision
4
11
18
23
24
25
26
Agenda : PMPA Board Meeting - May 22, 2025
Powered by BoardPro 3
8. Participant Discussion
9. Other Business
9.1 Other Business
10. Adjourn
10.1 Adjourn
Next meeting: PMPA Meeting Notice - Jun 19, 2025, 10:00 AM
5
Generated on: 2025-05-15 12:41:08
Powered by BoardPro 1
MINUTES (in Review)
PMPA BOARD MEETING
Name: Piedmont Municipal Power Agency
Date: Thursday, April 17, 2025
Time: 10:00 AM to 12:55 PM (EDT)
Location: PMPA Office, 121 Village Drive, Greer, SC 29651
Board Members: Andy Sevic (Chair), Blake Stone, Mayor Randy Randall, Joey Meadors, Eric
Goodwin, David Dorman, Steve Bratton, Mike Richard, Marc Regier, John
Young, Keith Wood, Mayor Foster Senn, Jason Taylor, Jimmy Bagley, David
Vehaun, Joe Nichols, Lance Davis, Kevin Bronson, Mayor Brian Ramey
Attendees: Joel Ledbetter, JulieAnne London, Mike Frazier, Dennis Cameron, Tracy
Quinn, Lynn Price, Will Blanton, Kenny Bradley, Gary Brunault, Rion Foley,
Tom Gressette
Apologies: Tim Hall, Cindy Frierson, Angie Hoover, Brandon Audet, Dedra Howell, Robby
Townsend
Guests: Tim Baker, Scott Motsinger, Belton Zeigler, Mark White and Andrea Kelley
Notes: Virtual Attendees: David Vehaun, Gary Brunault, Rion Foley, Tom Gressette,
Belton Ziegler, and Andrea Kelley
1. Call to Order
1.1 Identify Virtual Attendees
1.2 Declaration of Quorum
Chairman Sevic declared that a quorum is present and the Board can conduct business.
1.3 Invocation
Mr. Ledbetter gave the invocation.
2. Administration of Oath of Office to new Board Member
2.1 Oath of Office - David Dorman, Gaffney BPW & Joey
Meadors City of Clinton
Mrs. Quinn, Office Manager/Executive Secretary, who is also a Notary Public, administered the
oath of office to David Dorman, who has been appointed Director from Gaffney, and Joey
Meadors, who has been appointed Alternate Director from Clinton (copies attached).
Confirm Minutes 2.1 a
6
Minutes : PMPA Board Meeting - Apr 17, 2025
Powered by BoardPro 2
3. Approval of Minutes
3.1 Confirm Minutes
PMPA Board Meeting Mar 20, 2025, the minutes were confirmed as presented.
3.2 Vote to Approve Minutes of March 20, 2025 Board
Meeting
Vote to Approve Minutes of March 20, 2025 Board Meeting
10 Supported
0 Opposed
0 Abstained
Decision Date: Apr 17, 2025
Mover: John Young
Seconder: Blake Stone
Outcome: Approved
4. Action Item
4.1 Acceptance of the 2024 Financial Audit
Acceptance of the 2024 Financial Audit
The revised 2024 Financial Audit was included in the Board Pack.
Mr. Regier requested that the phrase "In 2019, PMPA was named a defendant
in a lawsuit by Greer and Rock Hill ..." in Note 16 be change to more accurately
describe what had occurred.
Chairman Sevic acknowledged the concern but stated that the correction didn't
affect the audit's financial accuracy. He suggested that staff note the change in
that wording for the next Financial Audit.
9 Supported
1 Opposed (Greer)
0 Abstained
Decision Date: Apr 17, 2025
Mover: John Young
Seconder: Mayor Foster Senn
Outcome: Approved
5. Acceptance of Financial Report
5.1 March 2025
March 2025
10 Supported
0 Opposed
0 Abstained
Decision Date: Apr 17, 2025
Mover: David Dorman
Confirm Minutes 2.1 a
7
Minutes : PMPA Board Meeting - Apr 17, 2025
Powered by BoardPro 3
Seconder: Kevin Bronson
Outcome: Approved
6. Reports
6.1 Finance
Nothing to report.
6.2 Engineering
Mr. Frazier reviewed the standard engineering reports for March that were included in the Board
Pack.
Mr. Frazier advised the Board that PMPA is hosting an IT Forum on April 24 at the PMPA office.
He asked that anyone wanting to attend to let the staff know.
Mr. Frazier also gave an update on the current status of the Laurens Transmission line.
Mr. Frazier reviewed the process and selection of the combined cycle and combustion turbine
capacities for supplemental power from Santee Cooper for the coming year.
6.3 Catawba
Mr. Cameron reviewed the Catawba and McGuire report included in the Board Pack and any
updates since that report.
6.4 Management
Mr. Ledbetter stated that the Power Conference registration information had been sent to the
Directors and Alternates. The Directors and Alternates are responsible for distributing to their
board or counsel and staff. Registrations are due by Monday, May 12.
Mr. Ledbetter also advised the Board on various legislative issues.
7. Action Item
7.1 Discussion of an Agreement for allocation of G&A
expenses
Allocation of PMPA General and Administrative expenses was identified early as an issue that
needed resolution before a Catawba Project Power Sales Renewal Agreement (CPPSRA) was
adopted. An amendment to the existing CPPSRA that addresses PMPA G&A expenses was
included in the agenda packet along with a Consensus Policy addressing PMPA G&A. After
discussion of these documents it was agreed by the Board that the issue of PMPA G&A could be
addressed after the adoption of a CPPSRA Renewal by the Board. Along with addressing PMPA
G&A, revisions to PMPA's By Laws would also be addressed after adoption of the CPPSRA.
8. Executive Session
8.1 Vote to enter into Executive Session
Vote to enter into Executive Session
A motion to enter Executive Session to discuss:
Confirm Minutes 2.1 a
8
Minutes : PMPA Board Meeting - Apr 17, 2025
Powered by BoardPro 4
1. Matters pertaining to ongoing litigation of Section 5(h) of the Catawba
Power Sales Agreement
2. Matters pertaining to PMPA’s filing of an intervention and protest at the
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
3. Matters pertaining to contractual negotiations to include:
a. Scenario analysis of a supplemental power supply proposal, and
b. Catawba Project Power Sales Renewal Agreement.
10 Supported
0 Opposed
0 Abstained
Decision Date: Apr 17, 2025
Mover: Jimmy Bagley
Seconder: Mayor Randy Randall
Outcome: Approved
8.2 Discuss matters pertaining to ongoing litigation
8.3 Discuss recent filing at FERC
8.4 Discuss matters pertaining to contractual
negotiations
8.5 Vote to return to Regular Session
Vote to return to Regular Session
10 Supported
0 Opposed
0 Abstained
Decision Date: Apr 17, 2025
Mover: Jimmy Bagley
Seconder: Kevin Bronson
Outcome: Approved
9. Actions to be taken based on discussion in Executive Session
9.1 Authorization of Executive Committee Regarding
5(h) Litigation Issues
Executive Committee Authorization Regarding 5H Litigation
A motion authorizing PMPA’s Executive Committee to meet and consider
information that may be received related to the ongoing 5(h) litigation and take all
action deemed necessary to settle and conclude matters received prior to the
regular meeting of the Board on May 22, 2025.
10 Supported
0 Opposed
0 Abstained
Decision Date: Apr 17, 2025
Mover: David Dorman
Seconder: Kevin Bronson
Outcome: Approved
Confirm Minutes 2.1 a
9
Minutes : PMPA Board Meeting - Apr 17, 2025
Powered by BoardPro 5
10. Adjourn
10.1 Adjourn
Next meeting: PMPA Board Meeting - May 22, 2025, 10:00 AM
A motion was made by Mr. Bronson, with a second by Mr. Young to adjourn the meeting. Motion
passed.
Signature:____________________ Date:_________________________
Confirm Minutes 2.1 a
10
LAST MONTH INCREASE DECREASE THIS MONTH
ASSETS
CURRENT UNRESTRICTED ASSETS:
Cash And Markable Debt Securities (W/C) $69,872 $2,942 $0 $72,815
Revenue Fund Valuation (2) 0 0 (2)
Fuel (4,570) 690 0 (3,880)
Participants Accounts Receivable (W/C) 16,699 69 0 16,768
Other Accounts Receivable (W/C) 1,313 0 654 658
Materials & Supplies 19,938 98 0 20,037
TOTAL CURRENT UNRESTRICTED ASSETS 103,251 3,146 0 106,396
CURRENT RESTRICTED ASSETS:
Debt Service 21,788 7,195 0 28,984
Debt Service Reserve 46,187 0 0 46,187
Reserve and Contingency 1,082 1,513 0 2,595
Decommissioning 141,416 582 0 141,998
Supplemental Power Reserve 1,600 0 0 1,600
Restricted Funds Valuation (597) 0 0 (597)
TOTAL CURRENT RESTRICTED ASSETS 211,477 9,290 0 220,768
TOTAL CURRENT ASSETS 314,728 12,436 0 327,164
CAPITAL ASSETS, NET:
Generation 332,961 0 744 332,217
Transmission 4,076 0 11 4,065
LDMS/SCADA 150 301 0 451
General 514 0 9 504
Nuclear Fuel - In Stock And Progress 26,210 482 0 26,692
Nuclear Fuel - In Reactor 22,571 0 1,172 21,399
Construction In Progress 48,869 147 0 49,016
TOTAL CAPITAL ASSETS, NET 435,350 0 1,006 434,344
OTHER NON CURRENT ASSETS:
Net Costs Recoverable From Future Participants Billings 218,838 0 4,093 214,746
Participant Settlement Receivable 45,400 0 0 45,400
TOTAL NON CURRENT ASSETS 699,589 0 5,099 694,490
TOTAL ASSETS $1,014,317 $7,337 $0 $1,021,654
DEFERRED OUTFLOWS:
Asset Retirement Obligation $36,657 $0 $79 $36,578
Redemption Losses, Net 4,063 0 54 4,009
Losses On Advanced Refunding Of Debt, Net 4,463 0 81 4,382
TOTAL DEFERRED OUTFLOWS $45,183 $0 $214 $44,969
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT OF NET POSITION
AS OF APRIL 30, 2025
(DOLLARS IN THOUSANDS)
April 2025 4.1 a
11
LAST MONTH INCREASE DECREASE THIS MONTH
LIABILITIES
CURRENT LIABILITIES:
Accounts Payable - General (WC) $0 $59 $0 $59
Accounts Payable - Duke (WC) 727 115 0 842
Accounts Payable - Other (WC) 277 847 0 1,124
Accrued Expenses - Payroll (W/C) 0 0 0 0
Accrued Expenses - Vacation (W/C) 88 0 0 88
Accrued Expenses - Sick (W/C) 178 0 0 178
Accrued Expenses - Property Taxes (W/C) 2,532 844 0 3,376
TOTAL CURRENT LIABILITIES 3,802 1,865 0 5,667
CURRENT LIABILITIES PAYABLE FROM RESTRICTED ASSETS:
Accrued Interest Payable 183,307 2,776 0 186,083
TOTAL CURRENT LIABILITIES 187,110 4,640 0 191,750
LONG-TERM LIABILITIES:
Bonds - Including Current Installment 340,015 0 0 340,015
Bonds - Settlement 48,330 0 0 48,330
Bond Discounts (29) 0 0 (29)
Bond Premium 35,455 0 553 34,902
CAB 80,330 0 0 80,330
Asset Retirement Obligation 184,151 495 0 184,646
Participant Interest Payable (W/C) 129 8 0 137
Other Postemployment Benefits 1,724 0 0 1,724
TOTAL LONG-TERM LIABILITIES 690,105 0 50 690,055
TOTAL LIABILITIES $877,215 $4,590 $0 $881,805
DEFERRED INFLOWS:
Postemployment Benefits $216 $0 $0 $216
NET POSITION
Net Investments In Capital Assets ($11,894) $0 $589 ($12,483)
Restricted For Other 1,600 0 0 1,600
Unrestricted 192,363 3,121 0 195,485
TOTAL NET POSITION $182,069 $2,532 $0 $184,602
INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES:
Working Capital $83,953 $485 $0 $84,438
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT OF NET POSITION
AS OF APRIL 30, 2025
(DOLLARS IN THOUSANDS)
April 2025 4.1 a
12
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
FINANCIAL SUMMARY
AS OF APRIL 30, 2025
MAJOR DEVIATIONS FROM THE BUDGET WERE:
(In Millions) $ % Comments
Working Capital $1.08 182.4%
Participant Power Sales $0.07 0.4%
Surplus Sales $0.16 41.1% Higher energy sales (40%) than budgeted
Miscellaneous Income/Expense $0.15 22.6% Lower than budgeted Duke fees
Interest Income $0.02 2.6%
Catawba Project Costs $0.55 9.1% Lower than budgeted maintenance and G&A costs & McGuire annual true‐up
Supplemental Power Costs $0.08 2.1%
Catawba Capital Additions $0.89 67.5% Lower than budgeted expenses due to timing of expenses
PMPA Capital Additions $0.35 92.7% Primarily timing of Laurens Transmission line project
Other ($1.19) ‐16.8% McGuire annual true‐up ($0.3M) and lower than budgeted R&C transfer to offset Cap Adds ($0.9M)
(In Millions) $ % Comments
Working Capital $4.18 239.7%
Participant Power Sales $0.78 1.1%
Surplus Sales $1.08 42.9% Higher energy sales (20%) and pricing (15%) received for sales than budgeted
Miscellaneous Income/Expense $0.13 4.7%
Interest Income ($0.11) ‐3.6%
Catawba Project Costs $2.08 7.4% Lower than budgeted O&M costs & year‐end Duke benefits, insurance, and G&A true‐up
Supplemental Power Costs ($0.90) ‐6.7%
Higher purchases in January due to colder temperatures, offset by fewer energy and backstand purchases than budgeted
and Santee Cooper 2024 year‐end adjustment
Catawba Capital Additions ($1.06) ‐12.2% Higher than budgeted expenses related to inventory reclass and timing of year‐end expenses
PMPA Capital Additions $0.75 60.7% Primarily timing of Laurens Transmission line project
Other $1.43 5.8%
Duke reclass of spare Reactor Coolant pump motor from inventory to capital ($.7M) and additional R&C transfer to offset
Cap Adds ($1.0M), partially offset by the McGuire annual true‐up ($0.3M)
Favorable >5%
Near Budget +/‐ 5%
Unfavorable < 5%
YEAR‐TO‐DATE VARIANCES
APRIL VARIANCES
April 2025 4.1 a
13
CURRENT MONTH
ACTUAL BUDGET OVER(UNDER)
YEAR TO DATE
ACTUAL BUDGET OVER(UNDER) %
CATAWBA PROJECT:
CATAWBA POWER SALES
Participant $14,053 $13,569 $484 $57,876 $57,318 $558 1.0%
Duke-Exchange Energy 737 950 (213) 3,729 3,910 (181) (4.6%)
Other-Surplus 549 389 160 3,606 2,523 1,083 42.9%
TOTAL 15,338 14,908 430 65,210 63,751 1,459 2.3%
CATAWBA POWER COSTS
Operations & Maintenance 1,931 2,081 (150) 9,758 10,899 (1,141) (10.5%)
Fuel Amort(Fuel Acct Deposit) 1,172 1,191 (19) 4,626 4,765 (139) (2.9%)
Purch Power-Duke-McGuire Cap 20 20 0 80 81 (1) (0.7%)
-McGuire Energy 389 684 (295) 3,499 3,681 (182) (5.0%)
Customer Acct and G&A-Duke 776 759 17 2,751 3,034 (283) (9.3%)
Customer Acct and G&A-Agency 335 428 (93) 1,443 1,753 (310) (17.7%)
Property Tax Equivalent 835 835 0 3,341 3,340 1 0.0%
Tax Other-Duke 93 106 (13) 397 422 (25) (5.9%)
TOTAL 5,552 6,104 (552) 25,895 27,975 (2,080) (7.4%)
FUNDS AVAILABLE FROM OPERATIONS 9,787 8,804 983 39,315 35,776 3,539 9.9%
INTEREST INCOME 836 815 21 2,904 3,014 (110) (3.6%)
MISCELLANEOUS INCOME(EXPENSE) (523) (676) 153 (2,578) (2,706) 128 (4.7%)
FUNDS AVAILABLE FOR CAPITAL NEEDS 10,099 8,943 1,156 39,641 36,084 3,557 9.9%
OTHER AVAILABLE FUNDS
Debt Service-Principal 0 0 0 66,565 66,565 0 0.0%
-Interest 0 0 0 10,952 10,946 6 0.1%
Reserve & Contingency - Capital Additions 427 1,314 (887) 9,784 8,722 1,062 12.2%
Fuel 482 827 (345) 4,498 7,775 (3,277) (42.1%)
DEPOSITS
Debt Service-Principal 2,255 2,256 (1) 9,021 9,021 0 0.0%
-Interest 4,738 4,738 0 18,953 18,953 0 0.0%
Reserve & Contingency 1,940 1,940 0 7,760 7,760 0 0.0%
Decommissioning 582 560 22 2,188 2,203 (15) (0.7%)
Inventory 98 40 58 (715) (111) (604) 544.1%
PAYMENTS
Debt Service-Principal 0 0 0 66,565 66,565 0 0.0%
-Interest 0 0 0 10,952 10,946 6 0.1%
Capital Additions 427 1,314 (887) 9,784 8,722 1,062 12.2%
Fuel 482 827 (345) 4,498 7,775 (3,277) (42.1%)
TRANSFERS (TO) FROM
Reserve & Contingency 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0%
DSR Release/Special Transfers 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0%
Catawba Working Capital 485 (591) 1,076 2,433 (1,742) 4,175 (239.7%)
Supplemental Working Capital 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0%
WORKING CAP INCREASE(DECREASE) $485 ($591) $1,076 $2,433 ($1,742) $4,175 (239.7%)
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
STATEMENT OF REVENUE & EXPENSE PER THE BOND RESOLUTION
As of April 30, 2025
(DOLLARS IN THOUSANDS)
April 2025 4.1 a
14
CURRENT MONTH
ACTUAL BUDGET OVER(UNDER)
YEAR TO DATE
ACTUAL BUDGET OVER(UNDER) %
SUPPLEMENTAL:
SUPPLEMENTAL POWER SALES
Participants-Supplemental Power 3,375 3,787 (412) 14,427 14,210 217 1.5%
-Leased Facilities 26 28 (2) 105 112 (7) (5.8%)
-Other 100 116 (16) 399 454 (55) (12.0%)
TOTAL 3,502 3,931 (429) 14,932 14,776 156 1.1%
SUPPLEMENTAL POWER COSTS
Purch Power-Supp Capacity 848 878 (30) 3,393 3,512 (119) (3.4%)
-Supp Energy 425 534 (109) 1,825 1,070 755 70.6%
Purch Power-Participants 991 1,035 (44) 4,131 4,281 (150) (3.5%)
Purch Power-Other 219 171 48 1,052 796 256 32.2%
Transmission 852 764 88 3,384 3,126 258 8.3%
Transmission-Agency 0 4 (4) 0 16 (16) (100.0%)
Leased Facilities-Duke 36 37 (1) 144 150 (6) (4.2%)
Meter-Agency 2 0 2 94 77 17 22.1%
Customer Acct and G&A-Duke 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0%
Customer Acct and G&A-Agency 89 115 (26) 383 471 (88) (18.6%)
Property Tax Equivalent 9 9 0 35 36 (1) (3.6%)
TOTAL 3,471 3,547 (76) 14,441 13,535 906 6.7%
FUNDS AVAILABLE FROM OPERATIONS 31 384 (353) 491 1,241 (750) (60.5%)
MISCELLANEOUS INCOME(EXPENSE) 199 200 (1) 800 800 0 0.0%
FUNDS AVAILABLE FOR CAPITAL NEEDS 230 584 (354) 1,291 2,041 (750) (36.8%)
PAYMENTS
Debt Service-Interest 202 202 0 807 808 (1) (0.1%)
Capital Additions-Transmission 7 211 (204) 185 842 (657) (78.0%)
-LDMSS/SCADA 21 125 (104) 299 341 (42) (12.4%)
-General 0 46 (46) 0 50 (50) (100.0%)
WORKING CAP INCREASE(DECREASE) $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0.0%
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
STATEMENT OF REVENUE & EXPENSE PER THE BOND RESOLUTION
As of April 30, 2025
(DOLLARS IN THOUSANDS)
April 2025 4.1 a
15
CURRENT MONTH
ACTUAL BUDGET OVER(UNDER) %
YEAR TO DATE
ACTUAL BUDGET OVER(UNDER) %
% ANNUAL
BUDGET
G&A-OFFICE EXPENSE
$133,320 $138,200 ($4,880) (3.5) Payroll $531,359 $568,200 ($36,841) (6.5) 29.6
9,962 10,800 (838) (7.8) Employer's FICA 44,633 48,600 (3,967) (8.2) 38.8
19,465 19,100 365 1.9 Medical/Life Insurance 78,248 76,700 1,548 2.0 34.0
12,751 12,700 51 0.4 401A Plan 57,346 57,100 246 0.4 34.8
41 0 41 0.0 Subscriptions 705 400 305 76.3 35.3
0 3,100 (3,100) (100.0) Dues & Memberships 266,689 271,200 (4,511) (1.7) 70.4
1,479 2,100 (621) (29.6) Utilities 7,377 8,400 (1,023) (12.2) 29.5
1,333 1,400 (67) (4.8) Telephone 5,275 5,600 (325) (5.8) 31.0
146 2,100 (1,954) (93.0) Office Supplies 2,059 8,400 (6,341) (75.5) 8.2
47 200 (153) (76.5) Postage 559 700 (141) (20.1) 28.0
0 100 (100) (100.0) Printing 49 400 (351) (87.8) 2.5
1,043 2,600 (1,557) (59.9) Board & Staff Expenses 4,062 6,300 (2,238) (35.5) 7.1
0 200 (200) (100.0) Miscellaneous 2,397 1,000 1,397 139.7 79.9
576 600 (24) (4.0) Equipment Rental 2,754 2,400 354 14.8 39.3
2,422 11,200 (8,778) (78.4) Maintenance-Building 9,533 74,700 (65,167) (87.2) 9.3
21,462 23,700 (2,238) (9.4) Travel-Conf/Meetings 52,785 106,900 (54,115) (50.6) 17.6
50 1,800 (1,750) (97.2) Travel-Training 2,885 16,000 (13,115) (82.0) 9.6
1,872 3,000 (1,128) (37.6) Travel-Agency 8,107 12,200 (4,093) (33.5) 22.5
0 0 0 0.0 Worker's Comp Insurance 4,998 5,000 (2) 0.0 100.0
0 0 0 0.0 Property Insurance 11,277 13,000 (1,723) (13.3) 86.7
0 0 0 0.0 Liability Insurance 10,126 11,000 (874) (7.9) 9.1
7,968 9,100 (1,132) (12.4) Bank & Rating Agency Fees 8,049 9,400 (1,351) (14.4) 7.3
0 0 0 0.0 Annual Report 0 0 0 0.0 0.0
(120) 40,100 (40,220) (100.3) Economic Development 96,275 161,000 (64,725) (40.2) 19.1
9,176 9,400 (224) (2.4) Telecommunications 35,382 37,600 (2,218) (5.9) 31.3
0 500 (500) (100.0) Maintenance-Telecom 0 2,000 (2,000) (100.0) 0.0
28,919 79,800 (50,881) (63.8) Computer Hardware/Software 190,682 172,800 17,882 10.3 47.3
251,912 371,800 (119,888) (32.2) TOTAL G&A OFFICE EXPENSE 1,433,611 1,677,000 (243,389) (14.5) 31.4
G&A-OUTSIDE SERVICES
78,590 76,200 2,390 3.1 Legal 205,515 305,000 (99,485) (32.6) 22.5
43,282 27,500 15,782 57.4 Engineering 70,365 110,000 (39,635) (36.0) 21.3
0 0 0 0.0 Accounting 55,040 54,000 1,040 1.9 78.6
49,989 59,800 (9,811) (16.4) Financial 60,478 63,100 (2,622) (4.2) 24.4
0 5,000 (5,000) (100.0) Administrative 0 5,000 (5,000) (100.0) 0.0
349 2,400 (2,051) (85.5) Technology 1,050 9,600 (8,550) (89.1) 3.6
172,210 170,900 1,310 0.8 TOTAL G&A OUTSIDE SERVICES 392,448 546,700 (154,252) (28.2) 24.6
$424,122 $542,700 ($118,578) (21.8) TOTAL OPERATING EXPENSE $1,826,059 $2,223,700 ($397,641) (17.9) 29.6
TRANSMISSION EXPENSE-AGENCY
$0 $4,000 ($4,000) (100.0) Transmission Line Maintenance $0 $16,000 ($16,000) (100.0) 0.0
1,730 0 1,730 0.0 Energy Efficiency/DSM 94,021 77,000 17,021 22.1 69.1
$1,730 $4,000 ($2,270) (56.8) TOTAL XMSN EXPENSE $94,021 $93,000 $1,021 1.1 50.5
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
STATEMENT OF G&A EXPENSE
AS OF APRIL 30, 2025
April 2025 4.1 a
16
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
AS OF APRIL 30, 2025
After this month’s operations, PMPA had $84.4 million in working capital, which was $4.2 million better than the YTD budget.
April 2025 4.1 a
17
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
AGREED-UPON PROCEDURES
DECEMBER 31, 2024
ASSURANCE, TAX & ADVISORY SERVICES
Finance 5.1 a
18
INDEPENDENT ACCOUNTANT'S REPORT ON APPLYING
AGREED-UPON PROCEDURES
To the Management of
Piedmont Municipal Power Agency
Greer, South Carolina
We have performed the procedures enumerated below on the accounting for costs specific to the Catawba
Nuclear Facility. Duke Energy Carolinas (Duke) is res ponsible for the accounting for costs specific to the
Catawba Nuclear Facility.
Piedmont Municipal Power Agency (PMPA) has ag reed to and acknowledged that the procedures
performed are appropriate to meet the intended purpose of verifying th e validity and accuracy of costs
specific to the Catawba Nuclear Facility. This re port may not be suitable for any other purpose. The
procedures performed may not address all the items of in terest to a user of this report and may not meet
the needs of all users of this report and, as such , users are responsible for determining whether the
procedures performed are appropriate for their purposes.
The procedures and the associated findings are as follows:
1. Capital Expenses Tie-Out
We compiled the monthly capital expenditure de tail reports for the FERC 107 and 108 accounts and
agreed the total of the expenditures to the Y ear-to-date Full Expenditures Report Reconciliation
(“YTD Reconciliation”). The total per the comp iled detail and the YTD Reconciliation agreed
without exception.
2. Capital Additions Testing
We selected 139 capital addition expenditures and inspected the supporting documentation. We
agreed that the capital costs were re lated to the Catawba Plant, were incurred during the fiscal year
January 1, 2024 to December 31, 2024, and were charged to th e proper FERC account. Additionally,
we inspected the supporting documentation and conf irmed selected items were approved for payment
and recorded as capital additions to the plant. This procedure resulted in one capital addition
expenditure for which the accrued amount in 2023 was $45,050 more than the revised invoice for
2024.
Finance 5.1 a
19
Piedmont Municipal Power Agency
April 23, 2025
Page 2
3. Fuel Testing
We inspected all fuel costs applied to the uran ium pool and uranium and conversion sub-pools and
compared them to the monthly rollforwards. We examined the supporting documentation for each
charge to the pool to confirm proper additio n to the pools. We inspected the supporting
documentation for all direct charges to the Catawba Plant for enrichment and agreed the information
to the “Catawba Reload Fuel by Month” reports. This procedure resulted in no deviations.
4. O&M Expense Testing
We selected 120 O&M expenses and inspected th e supporting documentation. We agreed the
expenses were related to the Catawba Plant, were incurred during the fiscal year January 1, 2024 to
December 31, 2024, and were charged to the proper FERC account. We inspected the supporting
documentation and confirmed selected items were approved for payment and recorded as O&M
expenses for the Catawba Plant. On e of the selected payroll items resulted in $4.92 less than the
amount expensed when recalculated, the variance be ing due to the Workday system not rounding for
FLSA rate. No other deviations noted.
5. Administrative & General Expense Analysis
We obtained the “Annual Operating Estimate” workbook/support document and bifurcated the FERC
accounts between portions of the account that ar e directly charged based on actual expenses and
charged based on 1/12
th of the estimated annual amounts per month. We recalculated the amounts
seen on the YTD Reconciliation from the amounts c ontained in the “Annual Operating Estimate”
workbook. This procedure resulted in no deviations.
6. Administrative & General True-up
We obtained the totals for the A&G FERC accoun ts for Duke Energy Carolinas as a whole and
recalculated the A&G true-up related to the Catawba Plant. These procedures resulted in no
deviations.
7. Duke Service Fee Testing
We obtained the monthly bills sent to PMPA from D uke. Based on direct labor, indirect costs, and
accounting fees, we recalculated the 11.45% servi ce fee charged by Duke to PMPA. We agreed the
recalculated fees to the YTD Reconciliation. This procedure resulted in no deviations.
Finance 5.1 a
20
Piedmont Municipal Power Agency
April 23, 2025
Page 3
8. Analytical Review
We compared the current year O&M and Capital costs to their budgeted estimated amounts by FERC.
The O&M expenditures were $27,073, 592 or 10.76% less than the es timated amounts. We inquired
with Duke Energy Carolinas personnel as to th e reasoning for the over-estimate. Duke Energy
Carolinas personnel have informed us that the main causes were as follows:
i. During the fiscal year 2024, there were labor vacancies which reduced overall labor costs in
comparison to the estimated amount.
ii. During the fiscal year 2024, there were Departme nt of Energy reimbursements of $1.2 million,
which were used to offset expenses.
iii. During the fiscal year 2024, there was a significant Benefits rate decrease based on actual claims
throughout the year.
iv. During the fiscal year 2024, there were projects budgeted for that were not finalized.
v. During the fiscal year 2024, there were $5.8M of Reactor Coolant Pump internals reclassified
from inventory to Capital Spare and $2.4M less in emergent facility repair projects.
vi. During the fiscal year 2024, Capital Department of Energy Reimbursement of $0.6M of
settlement costs received from the Department of Energy for CNS-incurred dry fuel
loading/storage costs due to a federal repository for nuclear waste not yet approved.
vii. In addition to the items noted above, there we re costs budgeted to O&M accounts that ended up
recorded in other FERC accounts during the year.
The Capital expenditures were 10,268,957 or 5.83% lower than the estimated amount.
9. Inventory Observation
We selected 15 items which had changes in quan tities from the prior year from the Duke-provided
inventory listing. We physically counted the qua ntity of these items on hand. There were no
deviations identified.
We selected 15 items at random from the warehouse floor and physically counted the quantity on
hand and compared the counted quantity to the quantity listed on the Duke-provided inventory listing.
There were no deviations identified.
Additionally, we observed the eight main diesel fuel tanks and compared to the engineering
conversion amount for the amount in each tank. Th e total gallons per the count and recalculation
using the engineering reports was 850 gallons less, or $2,201.50, than the amount recorded in the
inventory listing.
10. Inventory Valuation Testing
We selected 30 purchases and issuances of inventor y and agreed the inventory recording to the
supporting documentation. This procedure resulted in no deviations.
Finance 5.1 a
21
Piedmont Municipal Power Agency
April 23, 2025
Page 4
We were engaged by PMPA to perform this ag reed-upon procedures engage ment, and conducted our
engagement in accordance with attestation standard s established by the American Institute of Certified
Public Accountants. We were not engaged to and did not conduct an ex amination or review, the objective
of which would be the expression of an opinion or conclusion, respectively, on Duke Energy Carolinas
accounting for costs specific to the Catawba Nuclear Facility. Accordi ngly, we do not express such an
opinion or conclusion. Had we performed additional procedures, other matters might have come to our
attention that would have been reported to you.
We are required to be independent of PMPA and to meet our other ethical responsibilities, in accordance
with the relevant ethical requirements related to our agreed-upon procedures engagement.
This report is intended solely for the information and use of Piedmont Municipal Power Agency and
Duke Energy Carolinas governing boar d and management, and is not inte nded to be, and should not be,
used by anyone other than these specified parties.
Morehead City, North Carolina
April 23, 2025
Finance 5.1 a
22
2025_04_Demand Response Report.docx
To: Board of Directors and Alternates
From: Mike Frazier
Date: May 14, 2025
PMPA did not call for any Demand Response events during April.
PMPA Monthly Peak1: 395.4 MW @ Hour Ending 5:00 p.m. on Apr 30th
Does NOT coincide with the Duke Energy Transmission Peak on
Apr 30th @ Hour Ending 6:00 p.m.
Monthly Maximum GSP Airport Temperature – 88° F on Apr 5th
PMPA Total Participant Load
3: 422.1 MW @ Hour Ending 5:00 p.m. on Apr 30th
PMPA Ratchet Quantity: 507.9 MW – based on Jul. 15, 2024 @ HE 5:00 p.m.
All loads are reflected at the transmission level, which includes 2.12% losses as of June 1, 2024.
1 PMPA Monthly Peak – Used by Santee Cooper to determine PMPA’s capacity charge. This peak
includes the load served by nine Participants (does not include Union) and generation (added back to
the load) produced by the load-side generators. It also does not include Greer CPW’s load served from
the leased Laurens EMC delivery points.
2 April temperatures were slightly warmer than normal and similar to April, 2024. There were several
days that temperatures rose into the mid-eighties. While the warmest temperatures occurred earlier in
the month, the PMPA system peaked on the last day of the month. This is due primarily to many of the
earlier warmer days occurring on weekends.
3 PMPA Total Participant Load – includes load served by all ten Participants including the Greer CPW’s
load served from leased Laurens EMC delivery points and generation produced by the load-side
generators.
PMPA
Demand Response System
Report
Month CDD % of Normal
Apr 2025 92 219
Normal 42
Apr 2024 70 167
Engineering 5.2 a
23
ENERGY REPORT *
Piedmont Municipal Power Agency
APRIL, 2025
The Energy Authority (Surplus Energy Sold and Gross Revenue)
2,533 61,444 $ 24.26 $ / MWh
14,462 530,899 $ - YTD 36.71 $ / MWh - YTD
Duke Energy (Surplus Energy Sold and Gross Revenue)
10,094 304,902 $ 30.21 $ / MWh
54,824 1,898,265 $-YTD 34.62 $ / MWh - YTD
Santee Cooper (Surplus Energy Sold and Gross Revenue)
7,598 196,428 $ 25.85 $ / MWh
42,048 1,226,885 $-YTD 29.18 $ / MWh - YTD
Total Surplus Sales Revenue 562,774 $
3,656,049 $ - YTD 111,334 MWh-YTD
Generation Imbalance Charge ………………………………… (11,990) $
148,826 $ - YTD
($22,576)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Energy Imbalance Charge …………………………………… 55,106 $
88,782 $ - YTD
$24,432
Supplemental Energy Purchased ………………………………...………………..……
Santee Cooper TEA Backstand &
Total
2,250 6,011 8,261 MWh
21,627 7,969 29,596 MWh - YTD
70,794 313,192 383,986 $
1,320,846 405,088 1,725,934 $ - YTD
31.46 52.10 46.48 $ / MWh
61.07 50.83 58.32 $ / MWh - YTD
* All MWh are measured at the bus bar (generation level)
($20,388)
$12,481 $18,193
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
& Includes energy and transmission costs
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MWh - YTD
MWh
MWh
MWh-YTD
MWh
MWh-YTD
$30,974
Deviation Band 1 - +/- 1.5% Deviation Band 2 - Between +/-1.5% & 7.5% Deviation Band 3 - Greater than +/- 7.5%
Deviation Band 1 - +/- 1.5% Deviation Band 2 - Between +/-1.5% & 7.5% Deviation Band 3 - Greater than +/- 7.5%
Engineering 5.2 b
24
Catawba 5.3 a
25
Executive Committee Meeting
Piedmont Municipal Power Agency
May 7, 2025
Via Teams
Voting Andy Sevic, Chairman Easley
Members Blake Stone Abbeville
Present Jimmy Bagley Rock Hill
John Young Laurens
Kevin Bronson Westminster
Others Joel Ledbetter PMPA
Julieanne London PMPA
Mike Frazier PMPA
Dennis Cameron PMPA
Tracy Quinn PMPA
Marc Regier Greer
Steve Bratton Gaffney
Lance Davis Union
Joey Meadors Clinton
Keith Woods Laurens
Foster Senn Newberry
Rion Foley Burr & Forman
Trenholm Walker Walker, Gressette, Linton, LLC
Andrea Kelly Seneca Journal
Call to Order Chairman Sevic called the meeting of the Executive Committee to
order at 10:00 am.
Approval of Minutes Blake Stone made a motion to approve the minutes of the
Executive Committee meeting of January 29, 2024 with a second
by Jimmy Bagley. The motion passed unanimously.
Jimmy Bagley made a motion to approve the minutes of the
Executive Committee meeting of August 15, 2024 with a second
by Blake Stone. The motion passed unanimously.
Consent Judgement on
Declaratory Judgement
Kevin Bronson made a motion to approve the Consent Judgement
on Declaratory Judgement for Civil Action No.: 2023- CP-23-
03809, and give the General Manager the authority to execute.
This action will resolve the litigation brought by Greer CPW and
the City of Union against PMPA. The motion passed unanimously.
The Consent Judgement is attached to these minutes.
Adjourn
With no other business to discuss a motion was made by Kevin
Bronson, seconded by John Young, to adjourn the meeting. The
Report on Meeting o... 5.4 a
26
motion passed unanimously. The meeting was adjourned at 10:10
am.
Respectfully submitted,
Joel D. Ledbetter
Board Secretary
Report on Meeting o... 5.4 a
27
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA
COUNTY OF GREENVILLE
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
THIRTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
CIVIL ACTION NO: 2023-CP-23-03809
CITY OF GREER and CITY OF UNION,
Plaintiffs,
vs.
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER
AGENCY,
Defendant.
CONSENT JUDGMENT ON
DECLARATORY JUDGMENT
THIS MATTER is before the Court on the request of Plaintiffs City of Greer (“Greer”) and
City of Union (“Union”) (Greer and Union are collectively “Plaintiffs”), and Defendant Piedmont
Municipal Power Agency’s (“PMPA”). Plaintiffs and PMPA (collectively the “Parties”) jointly
seek entry of this Consent J udgment on Declaratory Judgment Action (the “Consent Judgment”)
and dismissal of this action pursuant to Rule 41 of the South Carolina Rules of Civil Procedure.
In support of this Consent Judgment, the Parties show and the Court finds as follows:
1. Greer and Union are members and participants of PMPA, as that term is defined in
the CPPSA defined below.
2. Plaintiffs and PMPA executed certai n contracts in August 1980, known as the
Catawba Project Power Sales Agreement (“ CPPSA”) and the Supplemental Power Sales
Agreement (“SPSA”).
3. The SPSA between Greer and PMPA will expire on December 31, 2028.
4. The SPSA between Union and PMPA will expire on December 31, 2029.
5. The CPPSAs between Plaintiffs and PMPA are scheduled to expire and terminate
on July 31, 2035.
Report on Meeting o... 5.4 a
28
2
6. Section 2 of the CPPSAs provides that “Ne ither termination nor expiration of this
Agreement shall affect any accrued liability or obligation hereunder, including, but not limited to,
the cost of decommissioning the Catawba Project.”1
7. Section 5(h) of the CPPSAs provides that:
At the earliest reasonable time after the termination of this Agreement,
PMPA shall prepare, date and on such date mail to the Participant a final
accounting statement showing the remain ing obligations and liabilities for
which PMPA is responsible with re spect to the Bonds and the Catawba
Project under the Bond Resolution and the Project Agreements and the costs
to PMPA of discharging and satis fying the same. The final accounting
statement shall credit to the Participants, and deduct from any amount
otherwise chargeable to them, the fair market value of any assets related to
the Catawba Project then retained by PMPA. If the final accounting
statement shows that such obligations and liabilities exceed such credits
after application by PMPA of all other funds available for such purpose, the
Participant shall pay PMPA a sum determined by multiplying the amount
shown to be due in such accounting statement by the Participant’s Catawba
Share. If the final accounting statemen t shows that such obligations and
liabilities are less than su ch credits after application by PMPA of all other
funds available for such purpose, PM PA shall pay the Participant a sum
determined by multiply ing the amount of the excess credit by the
Participant’s Catawba Share, unless otherwise directed by the Participant
with respect to the application thereof. The final accounting statement shall
be mailed, and amounts due thereunder shall be paid, in the same manner
and under the same terms and conditions as is provided with respect to
Billing Statements.
8. The Parties dispute when the date or existence of a condition that constitutes “at the
earliest reasonable time after th e termination of the CPPSA” will occur such that PMPA must
prepare the “final accounting statement” as set forth Section 5(h) of the CPPSAs.
9. The Parties wish to resolve this Decl aratory Judgment acti on by entering this
Consent Judgment, while also reserving their rights and claims as to when the date or existence of
a condition that constitutes “at th e earliest reasonable time afte r the termination of the CPPSA”
1 As the term “Catawba Project” is defined in the CPPSA.
Report on Meeting o... 5.4 a
29
3
will occur such that PMPA must prepare the “final accounting statement” as set forth in Section
5(h) of the CPPSAs.
NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED BY CONSENT
OF THE PARTIES as follows:
1. The Parties agree and affirm they shall comply with the terms of the CPPSAs,
including but not limited to Section 5(h) of the same.
2. Section 5(h) obligates PMPA at the earliest reasonable time after the termination of
the CPPSA on July 31, 2035, to prepare, date and on such date mail to each of the Plaintiffs a final
accounting statement containing the information described above in Paragraph 7.
3. The Parties reserve their rights and claims as to when the date or existence of a
condition that constitutes “at the earliest reasonable time after the termination of the CPPSA” will
occur such that PMPA must prep are the “final accounting statement” as set forth in Section 5(h)
of the CPPSAs.
4. This Consent Judgment does not establish a specific date or existence of a condition
that constitutes “at the earliest reasonable time after the termination of the CPPSA” will occur such
that PMPA must prepare the “fin al accounting statement” as set forth in Section 5(h) of the
CPPSAs.
5. The entry of this Consent Judgment does not preclude th e Parties from asserting
any position regarding when the date or existen ce of a condition that constitutes “at the earliest
reasonable time after the termination of the CPPSA” will occur such that PMPA must prepare the
“final accounting statement” as set forth in Section 5(h) of the CPPSAs.
Report on Meeting o... 5.4 a
30
4
6. Nothing in this Consent Judgment alters or amends the CPPSAs between Plaintiffs
and PMPA.
7. Pursuant to Rule 41 of the South Carolin a Rules of Civil Procedure, the Parties
stipulate to dismissal of this action with prejudice and with each party bearing its own costs and
attorneys’ fees.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
__________________________________________
CIRCUIT JUDGE
______________, 2025
Greenville, South Carolina
CONSENTED TO BY:
/s/Sarah L. DiFranco
Sarah L. DiFranco
POYNER SPRUILL
S.C. State Bar No.: 79830
301 S. College Street, Suite 2900
Charlotte, North Carolina 28202
Telephone: (704) 342-5250
Email: sdifranco@poynerspruill.com
/s/ J. Nicholas Ellis
J. Nicholas Ellis
POYNER SPRUILL
P.O. Box 353
Rocky Mount, NC 27802
Telephone: (252) 446-2341
Email: Jnellis@poynerspruill.com
Admitted Pro Hac Vice
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
Report on Meeting o... 5.4 a
31
5
/s/Marc Regier
Marc Regier
General Manager
Greer Commission of Public Works
Plaintiff
/s/ Joe Nichols
Joe Nichols
City Administrator
City of Union
Plaintiff
/s/Thomas P. Gressette, Jr.
Thomas P. Gressette, Jr.
Walker Gressette & Linton, LLC
66 Hasell Street
Charleston, South Carolina 29401
Telephone: (843) 727-2249
Email: gressette@wglfirm.com
Attorneys for Defendant
/s/Joel D. Ledbetter
Joel Ledbetter
General Manager
Piedmont Municipal Power Agency
Defendant
Report on Meeting o... 5.4 a
32
Source: City of Westminster website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.