RecordWell Data

03192024 Budget Workshoop Minutes

City of Westminster · Oconee County · meeting of Apr 16, 2024 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Westminster

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 March 19, 2024 MINUTES WESTMINSTER CITY COUNCIL Budget Workshop Meeting Westminster Fire Department Tuesday, March 19, 2024 The City Council of the City of Westminster met in a special called meeting on Tuesday, March 19, 2024 at 4:00 pm with Mayor Brian Ramey presiding. Those in attendance were: Brian Ramey Jimmy Powell Dale Glymph Ruth May Audrey Reese Daby Snipes Adam Dunn City Administrator, Kevin Bronson Assistant to the City Administrator, Reagan Osbon City Clerk, Rebecca Overton Utility Director, Kevin Harbin Fire Chief, Michael Smith Interim Police Chief, Caitlin Pope Members of the public and press Notice of the meeting and the agenda was posted on westminstersc.org twenty-four hours prior to the meeting and all persons, organizations and local media requesting notification and the agenda were notified by email. Call to Order Mayor Ramey called the meeting to order at 4:00 pm. Expenditure Review Part 2 Mr. Bronson presented Council with a PowerPoint presentation reviewing the expenditures for the General Fund, Solid Waste Fund, Youth Recreation Fund, and Hospitality/Accommodation Tax Funds. He stated that the purpose of these workshops was to get Council input and work that into a balanced budget. Attached is the presentation for the record. Adjourn Upon a motion by Mrs. Reese and seconded by Mr. Glymph, the motion to adjourn the meeting at 5:40 pm passed unanimously. (Minutes prepared by Rebecca Overton) _______________________________ ___________________________ Mayor Brian Ramey Date March 19, 2024 Budget Workshop Fiscal Year 2024-2025 (FY2025) Expenditure Review, Part 2 General Fund, et al Westminster, South Carolina FY2024-25 Budget Schedule of events Expenditure Review Part 1 - February 13, 2024 @ 4:00 pm •Utility Fund •(Electric, Water, Water Plant, Sewer) •Capital Projects Fund 13 February Expenditure Review Part 2 – March 19, 2024 @ 4:00 pm •General Fund •Solid Waste Fund •Youth Recreation Fund •Hospitality and Accommodations Tax Fund 19 March 2024 Revenue Review – April 9, 2024 @ 4:00 pm •Hospitality Tax Request Presentations 9 April 2024 City Council Budget Workshop – April 30, 2024 @ 4:00 pm (special called meeting) 30 April 2024 Public Hearing and 1st Reading – May 14, 2024 @ 6:00 pm City Council Meeting 14 May 2024 2nd Reading and Adoption – June 11, 2024 @ 6:00 pm City Council Meeting 11 June 2024 Eight-year History * FY2017-FY2022, final, audited. FY2023 budgeted ** FY2022 Htax fund balance allocation of $266,121 ** FY2023 Htax fund balance allocation of $300,060 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 General Fund 3,337,590$ 2,202,145$ 1,888,300$ 1,848,524$ 1,879,685$ 2,003,438$ 2,326,271$ 2,106,256$ Utility Fund 5,075,204$ 7,477,388$ 7,420,141$ 6,709,141$ 6,829,119$ 7,311,275$ 7,421,903$ 8,301,415$ Solid Waste 340,261$ 320,686$ 415,390$ 323,506$ 500,393$ 338,892$ 714,366$ 915,046$ Youth Recreation Fund 431,195$ 370,137$ 611,922$ 267,258$ 342,642$ 450,480$ 441,305$ 579,319$ Fire Department 1% Fund 11,012$ 4,850$ 3,754$ 3,292$ 1,455$ 7,227$ 13,644$ 13,609$ Local Development Corp 23,330$ 3,780$ 40,502$ 33,072$ 9,998$ 18,794$ 47,031$ Hospitality Fund 105,500$ 68,211$ 65,265$ 79,978$ 143,202$ 358,368$ 515,634$ 484,314$ Local Accomodation 3,200$ -$ -$ -$ -$ 2,300$ 30,172$ 12,300$ Total 9,327,292$ 10,443,416$ 10,408,552$ 9,272,201$ 9,729,568$ 10,481,977$ 11,482,089$ 12,459,290$ General Fund, General Government TAX YEAR FISCAL YEAR Property Type Assessed Value Market Value Assessed Value Market Value Assessed Value Market Value Assessed Value Market Value Real Property 4,919,080$ 109,312,889$ 4,898,250$ 108,850,000$ 5,164,540$ 114,767,556$ 5,259,460$ 116,876,889$ Personal Property/ DOR 737,685$ 7,025,571$ 795,284$ 7,574,133$ 841,389$ 8,013,229$ 945,490$ 9,004,667$ Vehicles 731,719$ 12,195,317$ 793,935$ 13,232,250$ 793,067$ 13,217,783$ 866,911$ 14,448,517$ Wa tercra ft -$ -$ 13,660$ 130,095$ 46,160$ 439,619$ Total 6,388,484$ 128,533,777$ 6,487,469$ 129,656,383$ 6,812,656$ 136,128,663$ 7,118,021$ 140,769,691$ Value of a Mill 6,388$ 6,487$ 6,813$ 7,118$ Westminster City Assessed and Market Values Reassessment Year (Delayed) Impl emented Reassessment Year 2021 2022 2023 2019 2020 2021 2022 2020 Vehicle Ratio 6.0 Vehicle Ratio 6.0 Vehicle Ratio 6.0 Vehicle Ratio 6.0 The value of a mil Source: Oconee County Auditor 2023 City millage – 95.8 mills previous City millage – 99.3 mills 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 100 ADMINISTRATION Actual Actual Actual Actual Budgeted 00100 Personal Services 159,313$ 151,945$ 192,136$ 197,864$ 301,237$ 00200 Commodities 13,438$ 16,082$ 19,745$ 20,012$ 23,100$ 00300 Contractual Services 323,668$ 225,751$ 189,904$ (306,428)$ 216,577$ 00600 Capital Outlay -$ -$ -$ -$ Total ADMINISTRATION 496,419$ 393,778$ 401,785$ (88,552)$ 540,914$ Administration Non-Departmental 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 700 NON DEPARTMENTAL Actual Actual Actual Actual Budgeted 00100 Personal Services -$ -$ -$ -$ 12,000$ 00200 Commodities -$ -$ 714$ 357$ -$ 00300 Contractual Services 275,196$ 273,883$ 230,801$ 142,689$ 119,099$ 00600 Capital Outlay -$ -$ -$ 203,269$ 145,045$ 00800 Other -$ -$ -$ -$ 50,659$ Total NON DEPARTMENTAL 275,196$ 273,883$ 231,515$ 346,314.90$ 326,803$ 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 600 PUBLIC WORKS Actual Actual Actual Actual Budgeted 00100 Personal Services -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ 00200 Commodities 11,911$ 14,869$ 23,980$ 24,108$ 19,825$ 00300 Contractual Services 73,846$ 61,993$ 77,146$ 80,184$ 39,400$ 00600 Capital Outlay -$ 18,457$ 19,969$ 236$ 4,800$ 00700 Debt Service -$ -$ -$ -$ Total PUBLIC WORKS 85,757$ 95,319$ 121,094$ 104,527$ 64,025$ Public Works Public Safety Pos ition Clas s ification From To Police Chief Salary 64,673.47$ 84,075.52$ Police Captain/Asst. Chief Salary 51,738.79$ 67,260.39$ Police Lt. Hourly - 2,080/yr 48,871.95$ 63,509.53$ Police Sgt Hourly - 2,080/yr 47,432.19$ 61,643.17$ Police Cpl. Hourly - 2,080/yr 45,992.42$ 59,776.82$ Police Officer - Certified Hourly - 2,080/yr 42,393.02$ 55,137.58$ Police Officer - Noncertified Hourly - 2,080/yr 38,793.60$ 50,445.01$ Pos ition Clas s ification From To Fire Chief Salary 64,686.14$ 84,086.53$ Fire Captain Hourly - 2,912/yr 49,279.74$ 63,429.35$ Fire Marshall Hourly - 2,080/yr 43,709.31$ 56,814.38$ Fire Lt II Hourly - 2,912/yr 45,055.74$ 58,572.47$ Fire Lt. I Hourly - 2,080/yr 43,635.52$ 56,726.16$ Fire Lt. I Hourly - 2,912/yr 43,635.52$ 56,726.16$ Firefighter Hourly - 2,080/yr 40,831.78$ 53,081.28$ Public Safety Pay Scales FY2024 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 300 POLICE Actual Actual Actual Actual Budgeted 00100 Personal Services 418,751$ 487,378$ 539,539$ 538,223$ 677,082$ 00200 Commodities 52,139$ 52,192$ 75,041$ 65,482$ 55,500$ 00300 Contractual Services 77,334$ 90,975$ 104,018$ 137,745$ 75,300$ 00600 Capital Outlay 10,168$ 2,400$ -$ -$ -$ 00700 Debt Service -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ Total POLICE 558,392$ 632,945$ 718,598$ 741,450$ 807,882$ Police Code Enforcement 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 500 CODES Actual Actual Actual Actual Budgeted 00100 Personal Services -$ 402$ 34,391$ 28,806$ 29,810$ 00200 Commodities 975$ 1,710$ 4,490$ 2,481$ 3,050$ 00300 Contractual Services 13,385$ 17,006$ 22,695$ 17,762$ 31,000$ 00600 Capital Outlay -$ -$ -$ -$ Total CODES 14,360$ 19,118$ 61,577$ 49,049$ 63,860$ Police Department, by the numbers 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Police Department FTE's Year Westminster Police Department Calls for Service Oconee County Sheriff’s Office Calls for Service in Westminster City 2017 4,480 903 2018 3,431 1,245 2019 3,497 1,319 2020 3,172 1,395 2021 3,562 1,193 2022 4,068 1,743 2023 5,051 1,877 Police Department Vehicles TAG # YEAR MAKE MODEL MILEAGE PURPOSE UNC925 2011 FORD F-250 167,565 SPARE (MECHANICAL ISSUES) JAR302 2013 CHEV TAHOE 146,308 ROAD PATROL, DRIVEN DAILY JAR301 2013 CHEV TAHOE 152,116 ROAD PATROL, DRIVEN DAILY MG54984 2013 CHEV TAHOE 135,598 ROAD PATROL, DRIVEN DAILY MG54985 2013 CHEV TAHOE 140,224 ROAD PATROL, DRIVEN DAILY MG55453 2016 DODGE CHARGER 94,140 OUT OF SERVICE MG55454 2016 DODGE CHARGER 107,076 ROAD PATROL, DRIVEN DAILY MG66875 2022 CHEV TAHOE 21,723 ROAD PATROL, DRIVEN DAILY MG66876 2022 CHEV TAHOE 23,684 ROAD PATROL, DRIVEN DAILY WXTR494 2023 DODGE CHARGER 5,055 LT, DRIVEN DAILY XDG738 2023 CHEV SILVERADO 8,148 CHIEF, DRIVEN DAILY Condition: New Condition: Fair condition. Mechanical issues Condition: out of service Condition: Good condition minor issues Condition: New Condition: New Condition: New Condition: Needs replaced. Vehicle acquired from Utility Department for a short-term fix. Condition: Fair condition. Mechanical issues Condition: Fair condition. Mechanical issues Condition: Fair condition. Mechanical issues 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 200 FIRE DEPARTMENT Actual Actual Actual Actual Budgeted 00100 Personal Services 337,998$ 287,765$ 359,742$ 463,917$ 934,327$ 00200 Commodities 14,851$ 24,013$ 22,816$ 32,422$ 44,500$ 00300 Contractual Services 57,172$ 89,750$ 78,545$ 64,369$ 92,800$ 00600 Capital Outlay 8,379$ 35,766$ 7,767$ 44,814$ 27,961$ 00700 Debt Service -$ -$ -$ -$ Total FIRE DEPARTMENT 418,400$ 437,293$ 468,869$ 605,521$ 1,099,588$ Fire Fire 1% Fund NOTE: Beginning in FY2023, the fund balance was recognized within the budget 040 FIRE DEPARTMENT 1% FUND 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 005 EXPENSE Actual Actual Actual Actual Budgeted 00515 Expense 3,292$ 1,455$ 7,227$ 10,915$ 13,609$ Total EXPENSE 3,292$ 1,455$ 7,227$ 10,915$ 13,609$ Fire Department, by the numbers 1)2018-2023 actual, audited 2)2024 budgeted, as amended with new Oconee County service contract 3) County Funding @ $285,000/year FY2012-FY2023 | @ $550,000/year FY2024 City County Total 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 $119,764 $183,642 $215,848 $152,293 $183,869 $307,504 $287,008 $285,000 $285,000 $285,000 $285,000 $285,000 $285,000 $550,000 $404,764 $468,642 $500,848 $437,293 $468,869 $592,504 $837,008 Westminster Fire Department Year City Calls County Calls Total Calls 2017 297 323 620 2018 192 283 475 2019 221 308 529 2020 280 355 635 2021 359 317 676 2022 265 362 627 2023 256 361 617 With the new Fire Services contract with Oconee County, medical service calls are added for response as of mid-March. Based on call data for medical response, the call volume could go up an additional 800 calls per year. 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Fire Department FTE's 3/11/2024 prepared MKS Fire Department Equipment E-61 Sutphen, 2005 Custom Pumper 31,525 20 Good New light bar in 2022, could not repair due to age E-62 Sutphen, 2009 Custom Pumper 28,000 20 Good New front end due to accident, transmission repaired last year Service Truck - 65 1996 Ford E-350 Box Truck 10,925 Good Spare ladder truck, subject to ISO certification, driven least Brush - 6 2011 Chevrolet 2500 HD 4x4 99,572 Good Purchased used, funtional with low service needs Car - 6 2012 Ford Expedition 4x4 96,210 Poor multiple service needs, now driven by Fire Marshal Chief - 6 2023 Chevrolet Tahoe 4x4 SSV 10,692 New Vehicle purchase in last budget Squad - 6 2011 Ford F-150 P/U Extended Cab 4x4 60,506 Fair Needs driver seat replaced, hopefully this budget year 2022 New Replace 2024/25 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 900 SOLID WASTE Actual Actual Actual Actual Budgeted 00100 Personal Services 138,962$ 344,738$ 175,960$ 178,073$ 276,129$ 00200 Commodities 153,594$ 123,175$ 142,917$ 107,590$ 105,528$ 00300 Contractual Services 25,305$ 28,200$ 22,401$ 18,562$ 42,750$ 00600 Capital Outlay - -$ -$ 309,946$ 277,000$ 00700 Debt Service 5,644$ 4,281$ 2,888$ 2,888$ 213,639$ Total SOLID WASTE 323,506$ 500,393$ 344,166$ 617,060$ 915,046$ Solid Waste Solid Waste (cost-to-serve) 2021 2022 2023 2024 Service Charges 389,477$ 426,472$ 437,108$ 449,250$ Misc 5,784$ -$ 1,417$ 21,220$ Transfer from GF 86,392$ 76,487$ 11,411$ -$ Capital Lease -$ -$ 310,006$ 277,000$ Fund Balance -$ -$ -$ 167,576$ 481,653$ 502,959$ 759,942$ 915,046$ Personal Services 229,948$ 175,960$ 240,423$ 276,129$ Commodities 105,881$ 142,917$ 82,752$ 105,528$ Contractual Services 28,131$ 22,401$ 17,976$ 42,750$ Capital outlay -$ -$ 309,946$ 277,000$ Debt service 63,269$ 2,888$ 63,269$ 46,063$ Transfer out -$ -$ -$ 167,576$ 427,229$ 344,166$ 714,366$ 915,046$ 2021, 2022, 2023 audited | 2024 budgeted Solid Waste Revenue Solid Waste Expense 5% rate increase Youth Recreation Fund Youth Recreation Fund 2022 2023 2024 Major Revenue Sources Actual Actual Budgeted General Fund $111,621 $131,278 119,099$ Hospitality Tax $154,314 $157,310 117,950$ Fees and other 184,545$ 254,413$ 342,270$ Total Budget $450,480 $543,001 579,319$ 050 YOUTH RECREATION FUND 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 400 RECREATION Actual Actual Actual Actual Budgeted 00100 Personal Services 152,170$ 147,616$ 166,610$ 191,835$ 226,269$ 00200 Commodities 31,756$ 34,472$ 51,765$ 67,747$ 64,200$ 00300 Contractual Services 13,500$ 130,037$ 175,902$ 194,864$ 228,850$ 00600 Capital Outlay 69,832$ 30,516$ 56,204$ -$ 60,000$ 00700 Debt Service -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ Total RECREATION 267,258$ 342,642$ 450,480$ 454,445$ 579,319$ Westminster Recreation Participation SPORT AGE GROUP INSIDE OUTSIDE TOTAL Coed Basketball6 & Under 5 23 28 Subtotals 5 23 28 SPORT AGE GROUP INSIDE OUTSIDE TOTAL Boys Basketball 8 & Under 5 27 32 Soccer 6 & Under 7 31 38 10 & Under 3 32 35 8 & Under 4 29 33 12 & Under 7 32 39 10 & Under 5 20 25 14 & Under 3 6 9 12 & Under 17 & Under 1 9 10 15 & Under 2 13 15 Subtotals 19 106 125 Subtotal 18 93 111 Girls Basketball 8 & Under 6 12 18 Football 8 & Under 4 19 23 10 & Under 5 20 25 10 & Under 12 & Under 2 8 10 12 & Under 2 16 18 14 & Under Subtotal 6 35 41 17 & Under Cheerleading 8 &Under 5 11 16 Subtotals 13 40 53 10 & Under Volleyball 9 & Under 7 37 44 12 & Under 3 9 12 12 & Under 8 47 55 Subtotal 8 20 28 14 & Under 1 10 11 Fall Baseball 8 &Under 5 20 25 Subtotals 16 94 110 10 & Under 5 24 29 T-Ball 6 & Under 17 70 87 12 & Under 2 28 30 Subtotal 17 70 87 14 & Under 1 15 16 Spring Baseball 8 & Under 6 39 45 Subtotal 13 87 100 10 & Under 10 33 43 Fall Softball 8 &Under 2 10 12 12 & Under 4 34 38 10 & Under 14 & Under 2 20 22 12 & Under 3 9 12 19 & Under 3 12 15 Subtotal 5 19 24 Subtotal 25 138 163 Fall Volleyball 9 & Under 2 20 22 Spring Softball 8 & Under 7 18 25 12 & Under 5 38 43 10 & Under 2 24 26 14 & Under 2 10 12 12 & Under 2 12 14 Subtotal 9 68 77 15 & Under - - - Subtotal 11 54 65 2022-2023 Westminster Recreation Participation SPORT AGE GROUP INSIDE OUTSIDE TOTAL Coed Basketball6 & Under 3 29 32 All Totaled 98 549 647 Subtotals 3 29 32 SPORT AGE GROUP INSIDE OUTSIDE TOTAL Boys Basketball 8 & Under 4 25 29 Soccer 6 & Under 7 35 42 10 & Under 4 31 35 8 & Under Boys 4 22 26 12 & Under 4 32 36 8 & Under Girls 2 9 11 14 & Under 1 9 10 10 & Under 2 17 19 17 & Under 2 15 17 12 & Under 4 12 16 Subtotals 15 112 127 15 & Under 1 12 13 Girls Basketball 8 & Under 7 8 15 Subtotal 20 107 127 10 & Under 2 19 21 Football 8 & Under 12 & Under 4 13 17 10 & Under 14 & Under 12 & Under 17 & Under Subtotal 0 0 0 Subtotals 13 40 53 Cheerleading 8 &Under Volleyball 10 & Under* 5 42 47 10 & Under 12 & Under 8 41 49 12 & Under 14 & Under Subtotal 0 0 0 17 & Under 2 7 9 Fall Baseball 8 & Under 3 13 16 Subtotals 15 90 105 10 & Under 7 26 33 T-Ball 6 & Under 12 & Under 3 26 29 Subtotal 14 & Under 2 18 20 Spring Baseball 8 & Under Subtotal 15 83 98 10 & Under Fall Softball 8 & Under 1 9 10 12 & Under 10 & Under 1 16 17 14 & Under 12 & Under 19 & Under Subtotal 2 25 27 Subtotal Fall Volleyball 9 & Under 6 16 22 Spring Softball 8 & Under 12 & Under 6 38 44 10 & Under 14 & Under 2 9 11 12 & Under 17 & Under 1 0 1 15 & Under Subtotal 15 63 78 Subtotal 2023-2024 Local Development Corporation Local Development Corporation 060 LOCAL DEVELOPMENT CORP 700 NON DEPARTMENTAL 00300 Contractual Services 40,502$ 33,072$ 9,998$ -$ -$ 00800 Other 18,794$ 47031 Total NON DEPARTMENTAL 40,502$ 33,072$ 9,998$ 18,793.50$ 47,031.00$ Hospitality and Accommodations Tax Hospitality Fund FY2022 fund balance allocation of $266,121 | FY2023 fund balance allocation of $300,060 | FY2024 fund balance allocation of $284,314 080 HOSPITALITY FUND 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 700 NON DEPARTMENTAL Actual Actual Actual Actual Budgeted 00200 Commodities (1)$ 85$ -$ 00300 Contractual Services 38,227$ 121,325$ 202,943$ 181,221$ 352,314$ 00600 Capital Outlay 11,450$ 3,278$ 41,858$ 217,027$ 92,000$ 00800 Other 30,300$ 18,600$ 38,132$ 41,450$ 40,000$ Total NON DEPARTMENTAL 79,978$ 143,203$ 282,933$ 439,784$ 484,314$ 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 090 LOCAL ACCOMMODATION Actual Actual Actual Actual Budgeted 00200 Commodities -$ 22$ 800$ 00300 Contractual Services -$ -$ -$ 47,256$ 11,500$ 00800 Other -$ -$ 2,300$ -$ -$ Total NON DEPARTMENTAL -$ -$ 2,300$ 47,278$ 12,300$ Local Accommodation Fund Hospitality Tax- community grants 2019 $ 43,500 2020 $ 28,600 2021 $ 49,800 2022 $ 40,000 2023 $ 42,500 2024 $ 40,000 Policy Considerations Utility Franchise Fee Transfer Fee Budget Percentage 2019 $336,000 $7,154,678 4.70% (actual) 2020 $426,909 $6,664,432 6.41% (actual) 2021 $495,106 $6,631,532 7.47% (actual) 2022 $496,296 $7,971,746 6.22% (actual) 2023 $377,503 $7,815,065 5.00% (actual) 2024 $410,021 $8,301,414 5.00% (1) (budgeted) (1) Calculated from the total proposed budget of $8,301,414 less $101,000 for equipment capital lease ($8,301,414 x 5% = $410,021) Calculating Days Cash on Hand 1 Includes $65,558 budgeted in FY2023-24 for contingency. Actual 2021 Acutal 2022 Actual 2023 Budget 2024 Unassigned cash Governmental Funds (p13 2021) (p15 2022) (p14 2023) 978,124$ 1,206,974$ 1,440,021$ 1,440,021$ Solid Waste Fund (p17 2021) (p19 2022) (p18 2023) 128,910$ 255,605$ 319,202$ 319,202$ Utility Fund (p17 2021) (p19 2022) (p18 2023) (448,326)$ 373,326$ (202,628)$ (202,628)$ Unassigned cash 658,708$ 1,835,905$ 1,556,595$ 1,678,567$ 1 Expenses (p12 2021) (p14 2022) (p13 2023) 8,851,741$ 9,636,971$ 13,025,008$ 12,723,960$ Days per year 365 365 365 365 Expenses / days per year = 1 day cash equivalent 24,251$ 26,403$ 35,685$ 34,860$ Days cash on hand 27.162 69.535 43.620 48.151 Current Financial Environment, cont’d A financial analysis of the Utility Fund and the City General Fund • What does it show? • What are strengths? • What are weaknesses? Debt Service Coverage-Combined Utility 0.84 1.61 3.88 Days Cash on Hand-Combined Utility 79 71 90 Debt to Equity Ratio-Combined Utility 0.37 0.35 0.30 Debt Ratio-Combined Utility 4.6% 3.97% 6.29% Operating Margin-Combined Utility 6.1% 7.54% 10.59% City Transfer as % of Combined Utility Revenue 6.1% 7.24% 2.95% Range across 10 Participants 0.0 – 6.79 90 - 360 0.02 – 1.14 0.0% - 45.10% -6.34% - 12.76% 0.0% - 5.97% PMPA Benchmarking Report 2023 (portions of) (covers period from 6/30/22 to 3/31/23) 2021 2022 2023 *Some calculations on this slide may contain revenue and expenses for capital leases as well as other factors specific to Westminster. As a result, some of the data may skew the outcome higher or lower. This data is calculated by PMPA. Debt Service Footnotes follow on the next slide. Actual Budget Projection Projection Projection Projection 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 Solid Waste Capital Lease Garbage Truck1 $30,677 $0 $0 -$ -$ -$ Knuckleboom Truck2 $29,704 $0 $0 -$ -$ -$ 2023 garbage truck3 -$ 46,063$ 46,063$ 46,063$ 46,063$ 46,063$ Utility Obligations principal - revenue bonds $0 $0 $0 -$ -$ -$ interest - revenue bonds $0 $0 $0 -$ -$ -$ ConserFund4 $0 $40,115 $40,115 $40,115 $40,115 $40,115 2022 Utility equipment lease5 $79,332 $78,166 $77,001 $75,835 $74,669 $73,503 Electric line truck6 -$ 39,527$ 39,527$ 39,527$ 39,527$ 39,527$ General Fund Obligations Police/Fire vehicles 7 -$ 50,659$ 50,659$ 50,659$ -$ -$ Fire SCBA's8 27,961$ 27,961$ 27,961$ 27,961$ 27,961$ 27,961$ Combined Obligations 2023 Vehicle/Equipment Lease9 121,801$ 121,801$ 121,801$ 121,801$ TOTAL 167,674$ 282,491$ 281,325$ 280,159$ 228,334$ 227,168$ Debt Service (FOOTNOTES) Debt Service is displayed on previous slide. 1 Garbage Truck lease - $284,460. 10 yr term @2.24%. May 2013-May 2023 2 Knuckleboom Truck lease - $145,000. 5 yr term @2.5%. January 2018-January 2023 3 Garbage truck note- $310,000. 7 year term @ 4.01% January 2024-January 2031 4 ConservFund Loan - $369,947.23. 10 yr term @ 1.5%. June 2023-June 2032 5 2022 utility equipment lease - $503,000. Various terms, max 8 yrs @ 1.64%. Three (3) pickup trucks, one (1) brush hog, one (1) bucket truck. 6 Electric line truck- $272,500. 7 year term @3.43% August 2023-August 2030 7 Police/Fire vehicles- $142,500. 2 year term @3.29% August 2023-August 2025 8 SCBA's- $174,406. 7 year term September 2022-September 2028 9 2023 Vehicle/Equipment lease- $535,000. 5 year term @4.48% - September 2024- September 2028- (2) police vehicles @ $90,000 total, (1) public works vehicle @ $44,045, (1) water pickup @ $46,000, (1) sewer pickup @ $55,000, (1) leaf truck @ $277,000 Questions, for City Council… 1. Did you see anything today that you wish to change in the upcoming budget? 2. Do you support a 5% franchise fee from the Utility Fund to the General Fund? 3. Do you support a millage reduction? 4. Do you support continued vehicle replacements for Police and Fire with capital lease purchases? 5. Do you support a 2% COLA for all employees? 6. How would you like to allocate Htax revenues? Last year’s slide for Hospitality Tax expenditures Thank you. You may take a break now  The End.

Source: City of Westminster website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.