RecordWell Data

02132024 Budget Workshop Minutes

City of Westminster · Oconee County · meeting of Mar 20, 2024 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Westminster

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 F ebruary 13, 2024 MINUTES WESTMINSTER CITY COUNCIL Budget Workshop Meeting Westminster Fire Department Tuesday, February 13, 2024 The C ity Council of the City of Westminster met in a special called meeting on Tuesday, February 16, 2023 at 4:00 pm with Mayor Brian Ramey presiding. Those in attendance were: B rian Ramey Jimmy Powell Dale Glymph Ruth May Audrey Reese Daby Snipes Adam Dunn C ity Administrator, Kevin Bronson Assistant to the City Administrator, Reagan Osbon City Clerk, Rebecca Overton Utility Director, Kevin Harbin Fire Chief, Michael Smith Electric Supervisor, Taylor Price Water/Sewer Supervisor, Terry Reed Members of the public and press Notice of the meeting and the agenda was posted on westminstersc.org twenty-four hours prior to the meeting and all persons, organizations and local media requesting notification and the agenda were notified by email. C all to Order M ayor Ramey called the meeting to order at 4:00 pm. R eview of Utility Fund Expenditure M r. Bronson presented Council with a PowerPoint presentation reviewing the expenditures for the Utility Fund. He stated that the purpose of these workshops was to get Council input and work that into a balanced budget. A ttached is the presentation for the record. A djourn U pon a motion by Mayor Ramey and seconded by Mr. Dunn, the motion to adjourn the meeting at 5:25 pm passed unanimously. ( Minutes prepared by Rebecca Overton) _______________________________ ___________________________ Mayor Brian Ramey Date February 13, 2024 Budget Workshop Fiscal Year 2024-2025 (FY2025) Expenditure Review, Part 1 Utility Fund Capital Projects Fund Westminster, South Carolina FY2024-25 Budget Schedule of events Expenditure Review Part 1 - February 13, 2024 @ 4:00 pm •Utility Fund •(Electric, Water, Water Plant, Sewer) •Capital Projects Fund 13 February Expenditure Review Part 2 – March 19, 2024 @ 4:00 pm •General Fund •Solid Waste Fund •Youth Recreation Fund •Hospitality and Accommodations Tax Fund 19 March 2024 Revenue Review – April 9, 2024 @ 4:00 pm •Hospitality Tax Request Presentations 9 April 2024 City Council Budget Workshop – April 30, 2024 @ 4:00 pm (special called meeting) 30 April 2024 Public Hearing and 1st Reading – May 14, 2024 @ 6:00 pm City Council Meeting 14 May 2024 2nd Reading and Adoption – June 11, 2024 @ 6:00 pm City Council Meeting 11 June 2024 Utility Administration 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 150 UTILITY ADMINISTRATION Actual Actual Actual Actual Budgeted 00100 Personal Services $ 260,622 $ 218,400 $ 239,989 $ 373,027 $ 489,036 00200 Commodities $ 60,806 $ 54,602 $ 93,660 $ 125,477 $ 72,150 00300 Contractual Services $ 623,858 $ 697,664 $ 677,126 $ 805,322 $ 679,878 00600 Capital Outlay $ - $ 200 $ 50,552 $ (241,161) $ - 00407 Miscellaneous & other $ (5,439) $ - $ - Total UTILITY ADMINISTRATION $ 945,287 $ 970,866 $ 1,055,889 $ 1,062,666 $ 1,241,064 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 250 ELECTRIC Actual Actual Actual Actual Budgeted 00100 Personal Services $ 296,594 $ 283,973 $ 349,045 $ 406,502 $ 375,107 00200 Commodities $ 142,765 $ 191,484 $ 245,919 $ 218,363 $ 278,200 00300 Contractual Services $ 2,329,724 $ 2,463,101 $ 2,479,860 $ 2,629,710 $ 2,768,700 00600 Capital Outlay $ 267,454 $ 494,389 $ 187,030 $ 103,135 $ 57,500 Total ELECTRIC $ 3,036,537 $ 3,432,946 $ 3,261,853 $ 3,357,710 $ 3,479,507 Electric Division 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 350 WATER Actual Actual Actual Actual Budgeted 00100 Personal Services $ 291,002 $ 205,131 $ 200,085 $ 245,894 $ 301,193 00200 Commodities $ 544,170 $ 179,798 $ 281,611 $ 337,348 $ 316,000 00300 Contractual Services $ 206,499 $ 167,507 $ 208,392 $ 225,785 $ 233,800 00600 Capital Outlay $ 111,241 $ 356,910 $ 368,077 $ 360,775 $ - 00700 Debt Service $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 40,115 Total WATER $ 1,152,912 $ 909,345 $ 1,058,165 $ 1,169,802 $ 891,108 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 550 WATER PLANT Actual Actual Actual Actual Budgeted 00100 Personal Services $ 220,109 $ 182,989 $ 183,624 $ 221,805 $ 271,065 00200 Commodities $ 82,570 $ 62,679 $ 105,322 $ 124,251 $ 124,000 00300 Contractual Services $ 379,959 $ 377,981 $ 446,954 $ 687,195 $ 548,250 00600 Capital Outlay - $ 0 $ (1,747) $ 23,051 $ 62,000 Total WATER PLANT $ 682,638 $ 623,649 $ 734,154 $ 1,056,303 $ 1,005,315 Water Division Water Plant Division 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 450 SEWER Actual Actual Actual Actual Budgeted 00100 Personal Services $ 170,270 $ 131,994 $ 110,223 $ 152,332 $ 198,512 00200 Commodities $ 100,547 $ 42,137 $ 69,427 $ 82,243 $ 61,700 00300 Contractual Services $ 600,872 $ 654,105 $ 756,530 $ 872,257 $ 1,124,957 00600 Capital Outlay $ 1,200 $ 53,893 $ 261,788 $ 66,234 $ - Total SEWER $ 872,890 $ 882,130 $ 1,197,968 $ 1,173,066 $ 1,385,169 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 700 NON DEPARTMENTAL Actual Actual Actual Actual Budgeted 00100 Personal Services $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 15,000 00300 Contractual Services $ - $ - $ - $ - 00700 Debt Service $ 18,878 $ 10,182 $ - $ (182,768) $ 117,694 00800 Other $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 65,558 Total NON DEPARTMENTAL $ 18,878 $ 10,182 $ - $ (182,768) $ 198,252 Sewer Division Non-Departmental Division Financial Policies …excerpts… City of Westminster Financial Policies Financial Policies Adopted (May 17, 2022) Revenues (E) All enterprise funds will be self-supporting. The City will establish all user charge fees at a level related to the full costs (operating, direct, indirect and capital) of providing the service. The City will review these fees & charges annually in the budget process and target rates that meet the cost to provide the service. Expenditures The City will provide for a balanced budget, annually, whereby the current operating revenues will be sufficient to support current operating expenditures. An appropriate balance will be maintained between budget dollars provided for direct public services and dollars provided to assure good management and legal compliance… Fund Balance Policy A. Non-spendable and Restricted Fund Balance 1) Unreserved - Assigned Fund Balance a) Assigned Fund Balance-Contingency: To help maintain services during short periods or economic decline and to meet emergency conditions, in addition to any other restricted or committed Fund Balance amounts, the budget shall provide for a contingency designation equivalent to 5% of estimated annual operating revenues in all governmental type funds. Current Financial Environment • 2023-2024 Challenges: • Threatened lawsuit from Seneca re OJRSA • PMPA rate uncertainty, pending litigation • 2021 SCDHEC Consent Order • Staffing • Rising personnel costs – competitive wages • Increased supplies and materials cost • Delivery delays in materials • Contractor costs • City financials • Cost and affordability 2024-2025 Challenges: • PMPA rate uncertainty due to settling litigation – will know more as budget season progresses • OJRSA Regional Planning Study / Central Basin Study: what will these studies reveal/recommend? • 2021 SCDHEC Consent Order – Oak Street Area + various manhole and spot rehabilitations • Rising personnel costs – competitive wages / PEBA increases • Managing the volume of projects scheduled for 2024 • Enhancing water system reliability • Increased supplies and materials cost • Contractor costs • City financials • Cost and affordability of utilities • Unknowns Current Financial Environment, cont’d A financial analysis of the Utility Fund and the City General Fund • What does it show? • What are strengths? • What are weaknesses? Debt Service Coverage-Combined Utility 0.84 1.61 3.88 Days Cash on Hand-Combined Utility 79 71 90 Debt to Equity Ratio-Combined Utility 0.37 0.35 0.30 Debt Ratio-Combined Utility 4.6% 3.97% 6.29% Operating Margin-Combined Utility 6.1% 7.54% 10.59% City Transfer as % of Combined Utility Revenue 6.1% 7.24% 2.95% Range across 10 Participants 0.0 – 6.79 90 - 360 0.02 – 1.14 0.0% - 45.10% -6.34% - 12.76% 0.0% - 5.97% PMPA Benchmarking Report 2023 (portions of) (covers period from 6/30/22 to 3/31/23) 2021 2022 2023 *Some calculations on this slide may contain revenue and expenses for capital leases as well as other factors specific to Westminster. As a result, some of the data may skew the outcome higher or lower. This data is calculated by PMPA. Calculating Days Cash on Hand 1 Includes $65,558 budgeted in FY2023-24 for contingency. Actual 2021 Acutal 2022 Actual 2023 Budget 2024 Unassigned cash Governmental Funds (p13 2021) (p15 2022) (p14 2023) 978,124$ 1,206,974$ 1,440,021$ 1,440,021$ Solid Waste Fund (p17 2021) (p19 2022) (p18 2023) 128,910$ 255,605$ 319,202$ 319,202$ Utility Fund (p17 2021) (p19 2022) (p18 2023) (448,326)$ 373,326$ (202,628)$ (202,628)$ Unassigned cash 658,708$ 1,835,905$ 1,556,595$ 1,678,567$ 1 Expenses (p12 2021) (p14 2022) (p13 2023) 8,851,741$ 9,636,971$ 13,025,008$ 12,723,960$ Days per year 365 365 365 365 Expenses / days per year = 1 day cash equivalent 24,251$ 26,403$ 35,685$ 34,860$ Days cash on hand 27.162 69.535 43.620 48.151 Revenues net expenses Expenses Revenues Grants Surplus (deficit) Sewer System 1,382,191$ 932,535$ -$ (449,656)$ Water System 1,938,380$ 2,563,850$ -$ 625,470$ Electric System 3,441,700$ 4,043,683$ -$ 601,983$ Solid Waste 341,010$ 417,206$ -$ 76,196$ Total 7,103,281$ 7,957,274$ -$ 853,993$ 20212 20221 (1) Westminster Annual Audit FY2022, p14 (2) Westminster Annual Audit FY2023, p13 Expenses Revenues Grants Surplus (deficit) Sewer System 1,408,416$ 869,412$ -$ (539,004)$ Water System 4,206,454$ 2,898,653$ -$ (1,307,801)$ Electric System 3,761,878$ 4,294,320$ -$ 532,442$ Solid Waste 388,292$ 444,813$ -$ 56,521$ Total 9,765,040$ 8,507,198$ -$ (1,257,842)$ Utility Franchise Fee Transfer Fee Budget Percentage 2019 $336,000 $7,154,678 4.70% (actual) 2020 $426,909 $6,664,432 6.41% (actual) 2021 $495,106 $6,631,532 7.47% (actual) 2022 $496,296 $7,971,746 6.22% (actual) 2023 $377,503 $7,815,065 5.00% (actual) 2024 $410,021 $8,301,414 5.00% (1) (budgeted) (1) Calculated from the total proposed budget of $8,301,414 less $101,000 for equipment capital lease ($8,301,414 x 5% = $410,021) Utility Contingency Planning • Contingency funds 5% of revenue net PMPA/OJRSA • Electric $ 99,674 • Water $122,325 • Sewer $ 16,497 • Total $238,495 • Contingency funds 3% of revenue net PMPA/OJRSA • Electric $ 59,804 • Water $ 73,395 • Sewer $ 9,898 • Total $ 143,097 Calculations based on FY2024 budgeted amounts 2024 each 1% ~$47,669 2023 each 1% ~$40,500 Projects on the Horizon Source of funds Project Grant City Match Total C-Funds street repaving 760,000$ -$ 760,000$ SC Energy Office LED Lights in downtown 9,942$ 1,462$ 11,404$ Oconee County Atax wayfinding signage in downtown 6,500$ -$ 6,500$ CDBG Anderson Park 250,000$ 54,800$ 304,800$ SC EMD backup generators 257,634$ 28,626$ 286,260$ SCIIP sewer system improvements 3,929,180$ 982,295$ 4,911,475$ USDA-RD water system improvements 8,705,000$ -$ 8,705,000$ SC Budget Recreation Complex 5,000,000$ -$ 5,000,000$ SCDPS body-worn Camera 18,246$ -$ 18,246$ SCDPS hand-held radios 15,000$ -$ 15,000$ CDBG Main Street (Retreat to Lucky) 750,000$ 550,000$ 1,300,000$ Federal earmark water plant generator 1,429,000$ 285,800$ 1,714,800$ ARC Grey Street improvements 298,331$ 298,331$ 596,662$ RIA Unity Tank improvements 428,274$ 224,230$ 652,504$ LWCF Pavillion for recreation complex 500,000$ 500,000$ 1,000,000$ SC TAP downtown streetscape 2,000,000$ 400,000$ 2,400,000$ SC PARD Hall Street parking safety rails 16,160$ 4,040$ 20,200$ Federal earmark City Hall rennovation 1,396,851$ 349,213$ 1,746,064$ TOTAL 25,770,118$ 3,678,797$ 29,448,915.00$ Funded - In progress Funded - planning Not funded (source idntified) Capital Projects Fund Oconee County C-Funds Oconee County C-Funds 2021-2023 - Sidewalk Rehabilitation Project $390,315 May 2023 - Approved $760,000 for street repaving Project Includes: portion of W Main (at intersection of W Main and North Ave) / Willow Row / Quick St / Grey St / portion of Highland Ave / Ann Davis St / Oak St / Bermuda St / N. Pew / S. Pew / Maple St Request for Bids is advertised – pre-bid February 20th, bids due March 6th South Carolina Emergency Management – back up generator(s) grant Application $286,260 SCEMD $ 257,634 90% City $ 28,626 10% Project Description: 1. install 60kw generator at City Hall 2. install 60 kw generator at Utility Shop 3. install 80 kW generator at Hwy 76 water pump station 4. install 80 kW generator at North Avenue water storage tank SCEMD = South Carolina Emergency Management Division Award November 2, 2023 Est. completion December 31, 2024 Electric System • On going maintenance, right-of-way maintenance, ongoing system maintenance and grooming, transformer replacements, pole replacements, etc. • $150,000 substation improvements • $ 80,000 install lightening arrestors across the system, replace fuses as needed • $ 20,000 various line replacements • Cost and scope to be determined – automated meter reading system improvements USDA- RD loan requirements - water $8,705,000 principal loan amount 40 year term 2.65 % annual interest rate Once the loan is closed: • $29,336 monthly payments ($352,032 annual) • Debt Service Reserve (DSR) • $2,934 per month until $352,032 has accumulated, this will take 120 months (10 Years). • Short-lived Asset Reserve (SLAR) (annual allocation for repairs/replacement of system assets) • $94,000 Each year for the 1St 10 years • $352,032 (P&I) + 35,208 (DSR) + $94,000 (SLAR) = $481,240 Years 11-40 • $352,032 (P&I) + $94,000 (SLAR) = $446,032 1 2 3 Lucky Street Water replacement project Water quality issues at First Baptist Church, American Legion/Dots Kitchen, Westminster Senior Outreach. - $253,000 (estimated) - 750 linear feet of new water line - new fire hydrant - 8 service connections Water System improvements • SC RIA Project – Unity Tank • Construction of 120,000-gallon surface water tank and related appurtenances at the existing Unity Tank site to add fire protection storage, redundancy and additional capacity in NW area of the water system • RIA Spring funding cycle (applications due in March) • Construction in calendar years 2024 thru 2025, if awarded • Estimated cost: RIA $428,274 (72% of project costs) City $224,230 (28% of project costs) Total $652,504 Oconee County Approved for Funding – Dedicated to Water Plant and raw water intake Improvements Budget project-to-date actual1 $ 987,420 $ 463,428.46 install (2) VFD’s and upgrade (2) 300 hp pumps $ 155,000 repair plant reservoir (including engineering and permitting) $ 65,000 $ 77,807.88 filter upgrade and maintenance $ 60,000 $106,230.17 repair/improve pipe gallery at the water plant yard $ 32,580 $ 35,037.73 upgrades to the various plant components (valves) $1,300,000 $ 682,324.24 total Capital Projects Fund American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) – Oconee County allocation 1 As of March 27, 2023. The projects continue to progress. Additional draws from the City to Oconee County forthcoming. South Carolina Infrastructure Investment Program (SCIIP) - sewer Application $4,911,475 RIA $3,929,180 80% City $ 982,295 20% Project Description: approximately 980 LF 10" and 7,430 LF 8" SDR38 PVC gravity mains, 39 manholes, 29 service reconnections, and related appurtenances to replace old problematic clay and/or PVC collectors and brick manholes that have exceeded their useful life. RIA = Rural Infrastructure Authority LF = Linear Feet Schedule: Bids advertised Jul 15, 2024 Bids opened Sept 1, 2024 Construction start Nov 1, 2024 Construction complete Nov 1, 2025 $491,147 ARPA funds $491,148 FY2024 Op budget Oak Street area sewer • Est. $4.63 million to make all repairs • Ability to prioritize to do the most important first Sewer system conditions Sewer system conditions Manhole replacements - est. $25,000-$75,000 ea - repairs necessary for: OJRSA CMOM Consent Order - start with the worst 1. Rate increases expected (subject to actions taken by PMPA (for electric) and OJRSA (sewer)) 2. Budget for 5% Franchise Fee 3. Budget contingency (5% or 3%) 4. Prepare financially for USDA-RD Loan requirements for Water System – started in FY2024 5. Prepare financially for SCIIP grant match for Sewer System – match budgeted 6. Prepare for other grant matches (i.e. backup generators, RIA grant(s), downtown infrastructure) 7. Maintain flexibility for additional grant opportunities 8. Electric system improvements - $250,000 9. Operating and personnel budget pressures due to inflation (meter replacement, in phases) 10. Logistics of managing the projects 11. Continue water system improvements 12. Consider projects that could be funded with a borrowing (discussed $5 million) 1. Lucky Street water improvements 2. Oak Street area improvements 3. Sewer system manholes (those that are critical but not a part of SCIIP project) 4. Water and sewer system improvements not covered by streetscape grants Considerations for Council Thank you. You may go home now  The End.

Source: City of Westminster website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.