04252023 Budget Workshop Minutes
City of Westminster · Oconee County · meeting of Oct 26, 2023 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Westminster
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
April 25, 2023
MINUTES
WESTMINSTER CITY COUNCIL
Budget Workshop Meeting
Westminster Depot
Tuesday, April 25, 2023
The City Council of the City of Westminster met in a special called meeting on Tuesday, April 25,
2023 at 4:00 pm with Mayor Brian Ramey presiding. Those in attendance were:
Brian Ramey Jimmy Powell Dale Glymph
Audrey Reese Daby Snipes
City Administrator, Kevin Bronson
City Clerk, Rebecca Overton
Utility Director, Kevin Harbin
Fire Chief, Michael Smith
Police Chief, Matt Patterson
Terry Reed, Water/Sewer Supervisor
Members of the public and press
Notice of the meeting and the agenda was posted on westminstersc.org twenty-four hours
prior to the meeting and all persons, organizations and local media requesting notification and
the agenda were notified by email.
Call to Order
Mayor Ramey called the meeting to order at 4:00 pm.
Proposed Balanced FY 2024 Budget – All Funds
Mr. Bronson presented Council with a PowerPoint presentation reviewing the FY
2024 balanced budget. Mr. Bronson pointed out to Council that the FY 2024 budget
did not include any rate increases for electric, water, sewer, or sanitation. He added
that some fees had been increased such as Recreation registration fees, Depot
rental fees, and Anderson Park Shelter rental fees.
Attached is the presentation for the record.
Adjourn
Upon a motion by Mayor Ramey and seconded by Mrs. Reese, the motion to adjourn
the meeting at 6:14 pm passed unanimously.
(Minutes prepared by Rebecca Overton)
_______________________________ ___________________________
Mayor Brian Ramey Date
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
April 25, 2023
Budget Workshop
Fiscal Year 2023-2024
(FY2024)
Proposed FY2024 Budget
Westminster, South Carolina
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
FY2023-24 Budget Schedule of events
• Expenditure Review Part 1 - February 16, 2023 @ 4:00 pm
• Utility Fund (Electric, Water, Water Plant, Sewer)
• Capital Projects Fund
• Expenditure Review Part 2 – March 7, 2023 @ 4:00 pm
• General Fund
• Solid Waste Fund
• Youth Recreation Fund
• Hospitality and Accommodations Tax Fund
• Revenue Review – April 18, 2023 @ 4:00 pm
• Hospitality Tax Request Presentations
• City Council Budget Workshop – April 25, 2023 @ 4:00 pm
(called meeting)
• Public Hearing and 1st Reading – May 9, 2023 @ 6:00 pm City Council Meeting
• 2nd Reading and Adoption – June 13, 2023 @ 6:00 pm City Council Meeting
Summary of Proposed FY2024 Budget
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
General Fund Totals $ 2,914,572
Utility Totals $ 8,301,415
Solid Waste Totals $ 915,046
Fire Department 1% Totals $ 13,609
Youth Recreation Fund $ 579,319
Local Development Corp Totals $ 47,031
Capital Project Fund/State ARP Totals $ 14,530,684
County ARP Totals $ 682,324
Hospitality Fund Totals $ 484,314
State & Local Accom. Totals $ 8,300
All Funds Total $ 28,476,614
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
• Funding Sources (opportunities):
• State of South Carolina
• SC Rural Infrastructure Authority (RIA)
• State Revolving Loan Fund (SFR)
• SCDOT (TAP)
• South Carolina Infrastructure Investment
Program (SCIIP)
• Rural Development (RD) through the USDA
• Additional federal agency funding
• Capital Market
• Appalachian Regional Commission (ARC)
Current Financial Environment
• 2022-2023 Challenges:
• Threatened lawsuit from Seneca re OJRSA
• 2021 SCDHEC Consent Order
• Staffing
• Rising personnel costs – competitive wages
• Increased supplies and materials cost
• Delivery delays in materials
• Contractor costs
• City financials
• Cost and affordability
• 2023-2024 Challenges:
• Threatened lawsuit from Seneca re OJRSA
• PMPA rate uncertainty, pending litigation
• 2021 SCDHEC Consent Order
• Staffing
• Rising personnel costs – competitive wages
• Increased supplies and materials cost
• Delivery delays in materials
• Contractor costs
• City financials
• Cost and affordability
(source data from the https://www.bls.gov )
Year Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Avera
ge
2023 6.41% 6.04% 4.98%
2022 7.48% 7.87% 8.54% 8.26% 8.58% 9.06% 8.52% 8.26% 8.20% 7.75% 7.11% 6.45% 8.00%
2021 1.40% 1.68% 2.62% 4.16% 4.99% 5.39% 5.37% 5.25% 5.39% 6.22% 6.81% 7.04% 4.70%
2020 2.49% 2.33% 1.54% 0.33% 0.12% 0.65% 0.99% 1.31% 1.37% 1.18% 1.17% 1.36% 1.24%
2019 1.55% 1.52% 1.86% 2.00% 1.79% 1.65% 1.81% 1.75% 1.71% 1.76% 2.05% 2.29% 1.81%
2018 2.07% 2.21% 2.36% 2.46% 2.80% 2.87% 2.95% 2.70% 2.28% 2.52% 2.18% 1.91% 2.44%
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Consumer Price Index (CPI)
City-wide Summary
• Millage (tax) reduction – 3.5 mils
• Recreation Fees - increase ($5/participant)
• Tap Fee increases
• Water Tap Fee (outside city)
• Sewer Tap Fee (outside City)
• Depot Rental fee increase
• Anderson Park fee increase
• Added a Anderson Park (as a department
in GF) $11,500
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Personnel
• 5% COLA
• 3.7% health insurance increase
The Proposed FY2024 Budget is a growth-oriented and reduces expenses to prepare for more future
growth.
Rates
Water Rate – no increase
Electric Rate– no increase
Sewer Rate – no increase
Garbage Collection Fee - no increase
Personnel Benefits (all funds)
• 3.7% health insurance increase(1) Jan 2024 – June 2024 $ 12,037
• 5% cola for all city employees $106,886
• Retirement increase(2)
• Non-Public Safety SCRS $ 12,706
• Public Safety – SCPRS $ 6,805
$138,704
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
(1) 3.7% projected by PEBA (decided by the SC State Legislature). PEBA – Public Employee Benefit Association https://www.peba.sc.gov/
(2) SCRS and SCPRS increases are decided by the SC State Legislature.
Capital Equipment (all funds summary)
2 Police Vehicles $ 90,000
1 Public Works Vehicle $ 44,045
Police Vehicle Up fits $ 11,000
1 Water Pickup $ 46,000
1 Sewer Tractor $ 55,000
1 Leaf Truck $277,000
Total $523,045
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
• $410,096 Utility Fund Transfer to General Fund (5.0% gross revenue transfer)
• $491,148 Utility Fund to Capital Projects Fund (SCIIP match)
• $119,099 General Fund Transfer to Youth Recreation
• $167,576 Solid Waste Fund Balance Transfer to General Fund(1)
• $100,000 Htax Transfer to General Fund
• $117,950 Htax Transfer to Youth Recreation
Proposed Transfers - Summary
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
(1) FY2022 Audit shows a $457,614 Cash and Cash Equivalents, unrestricted fund balance (FY2022 Audit, page 21)
Debt Service
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Footnotes follow on the next slide.
Actual Budget Projection Projection Projection Projection
2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027
Solid Waste Capital Lease
Garbage Truck1 $32,067 $30,677 $0 $0 -$ -$
Knuckleboom Truck2 $31,202 $29,704 $0 $0 -$ -$
2023 garbage truck3 -$ -$ 46,062.64$ 46,062.64$ 46,062.64$ 46,062.64$
Utility Obligations
principal - revenue bonds $292,489 $0 $0 $0 -$ -$
interest - revenue bonds $10,225 $0 $0 $0 -$ -$
ConserFund4 $0 $0 $40,115 $40,115 $40,115 $40,115
2022 Utility equipment lease5 $0 $79,332 $78,166 $77,001 $75,835 $74,669
Electric line truck6 -$ -$ 39,526.65$ 39,526.65$ 39,526.65$ 39,526.65$
General Fund Obligations
Police/Fire vehicles 7 -$ -$ 50,659.22$ 50,659.22$ 50,659.22$ -$
Fire SCBA's8 -$ 27,960.85$ 27,960.85$ 27,960.85$ 27,960.85$ 27,960.85$
TOTAL $365,983 $167,674 $282,491 $281,325 280,159.20$ 228,334.22$
Debt Service (FOOTNOTES)
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Debt Service is displayed on previous slide.
1Garbage Truck lease - $284,460. 10 yr term @2.24%. May 2013-May 2023
2Knuckleboom Truck lease - $145,000. 5 yr term @2.5%. January 2018-January 2023
3Garbage truck note- $310,000. 7 year term @ 4.01% January 2024-January 2031
4ConserFund Loan - $369,947.23. 10 yr term @ 1.5%. June 2023-June 2032
52022 utility equipment lease - $503,000. Various terms, max 8 yrs @ 1.64%, three (3) pickup trucks,
one (1) brush hog, one (1) bucket truck
6Electric line truck- $272,500. 7 year term @3.43% August 2023-August 2030
7Police/Fire vehicles- $142,500. 3 year term @3.29% August 2023-August 2025
8SCBA's- $174,406. 7 year term September 2022-September 2028
General Fund
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Highlights
• Estimated revenue includes a millage reduction of 3.5 mils
• Transfer from Htax of $100,000
• Transfer from the Solid Waste Fund of $167, 576
• Franchise Fee from Utility fund of $410,021 (a 5% net revenue transfer)
General Fund Totals
Expenditures Revenues
Administration $ 540,914 All Taxes $ 706,525
Fire $ 1,099,588 Intergovernmental Revenue $ 841,000
Police $ 807,882 License, Permits, Fees $ 381,475
Anderson Park $ 11,500 Fines &Forfeitures $ 36,150
Codes $ 63,860 Payment in Lieu of Tax & Franchise Fees $ 466,196
Public Works $ 64,025 Interest income $ 2,005
Non-Departmental $ 326,803 Misc. & Other Income $ 481,221
Total $ 2,914,572 Total $ 2,914,572
Public Safety – Police
Highlights
Police Department continues to modernize to utilize technology to increase
effectiveness
• Two (2) police cruisers ($45,000 each) $ 90,000(1)
• Vehicle up fits $ 11,000
• Police Easy Street Draw $ 3,364
• Two (2) Flock camera systems $ 6,500
• Ballistic vests $ 3,100
• Taser Lease Program $ 8,500
• Unfreeze two (2) Positions $ 110,168(2)
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
(1) Capital Lease/Purchase for two (2) police cruisers. $90,000 financed @ 4.50% for three (3) years. Annual payments of $34,804, budgeted
in Non Departmental.
(2) One position funded to begin October 1st and one position to begin January 1st
Public Safety – Fire
Highlights
• Increase overtime $ 2,600
• Increase part time $ 2,000
• SCBA equipment financing $27,961(1)
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
(1) Twenty (20) SCBA’s with spare cylinders and related equipment. Total cost $164,406.00 financed @3.09% for 7 years. Useful life of 15 years.
Presumptive Costs of Six (6) Firefighters
Expenses
• Six (6) new positions $469,227
Revenue
• County Allocation ($500,000 increase from $285,000) $785,000
Six (6) additional firefighters are incorporated into the Fire budget. The revenue to offset these
positions is budgeted. The number of positions funded are designed to match the revenue
received. Negotiations with Oconee County are ongoing.
Utility Fund
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Utility Totals
Expenditures Revenues
Utility Administration $ 1,241,064 Interest Income $ 500
Electric $ 3,479,507 Miscellaneous & Other $ 418,000
Water $ 891,108 Electric $ 4,563,472
Sewer $ 1,385,169 Water $ 2,432,504
Water Plant $ 1,005,315 Sewer $ 884,939
Non-Departmental $ 299,252 Project Operations $ 2,000
Total $ 8,301,415 Total $ 8,301,415
Utility Fund Revenue Highlights
• Water Fund
• Includes 67 tap fees from new residential development $127,300
• Sewer Fund
• Includes 67 tap fees from new residential development $ 65,500
The tap fees are anticipated from the Heirloom Farm subdivision off
Seed Farm Road. The fees represent water and sewer taps from half of
the residential units planned.
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
New Billing Rate Structure (sewer)
RE: New Billing Rate Structure Notification
This is notification that the OJRSA Board of Commissioners voted to approve a new billing rate structure at our
February 6, 2023 board meeting. This new rate structure sets a user base rate plus volumetric rate for
residential and non-residential customers. The new rate structure, which is effective on July 1, 2023
, is as
follows:
Residential:
Base Rate of $10.00 per month + Volumetric Rate of $5.39 per 1,000 Gallons
Non-Residential:
Base Rate of $15.00 per month + Volumetric Rate of $7.37 per 1,000 Gallons
The Member Cities will collect the fees from their customers and submit the payment with the appropriate
usage documentation to the OJRSA by the 15th of each month, with the first payment due in August 2023.
Utility Fund Expenditure Highlights
• Electric
• Increases to cover linemen training $ 15,000
• Water
• New pickup truck $ 46,000
• ConservFund Loan repayment $ 40,115
• Water Plant
• Replace lab cabinets $ 18,000
• HVAC for chemical building $ 11,000
• Backwash pump $ 9,000
• Replace chemical feed pumps $ 24,000
• Sewer
• SCIIP Grant Match $491,148
• New tractor for ROW clearing $ 55,000
• Utility Non-Departmental
• Contingency $ 65,558
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Utility Franchise Fee Transfer
Fee Budget Percentage
2019 $336,000 $7,154,678 4.70% (actual)
2020 $426,909 $6,664,432 6.41% (actual)
2021 $495,106 $6,631,532 7.47% (actual)
2022 $496,296 $7,971,746 6.22% (actual)
2023 $377,503 $7,815,065 5.00% (budgeted)
2024 $410,021 $8,301,415 5.00% (1) (proposed)
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
(1) Calculated from the total proposed budget of $8,301,415 less $101,000 for equipment capital lease ($8,200,415 x 5% = $410,021)
Tap Fee
Comparison
and increase
consideration
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Water Tap Fees
3/4" Inside 3/4" Outside 1" Inside 1" Outside
Walhalla $ 1,800 $ 1,900 $ 2,200 $ 2,200
Seneca $ 2,100 $ 2,800 $ 2,400 $ 3,100
Pioneer $ 2,350 $ 2,650
Westminster $ 1,700 $ 1,900 $ 1,900 $ 2,100
Proposed Westminster $ 1,700 $ 2,000 $ 1,900 $ 2,200
Sewer Tap Fees
4" Inside 4" Outside 6"
Walhalla $ 1,200 $ 1,600 Cost + 30%
Seneca $ 1,050 $ 1,450 Cost + 30%
Westminster $ 1,300 $ 1,500 Cost + 30%
Proposed Westminster $ 1,300 $ 1,600 Cost + 30%
Highlights
• As of the close of FY2022, the Fund is self-sustaining, attaining a true cost-to-serve status.
• FY2022 Audit shows a $457,614 Cash and Cash Equivalents, unrestricted fund balance (FY2022 Audit, page 21)
• $167,576 Fund Balance appropriation to the General Fund
• FY2021 transfer from the GF = $86,392
• FY2022 transfer from the GF = $76,487
• FY2023 transfer from the GF = $11,411
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Solid Waste
Solid Waste Totals
Expenditures Revenues
Personel Services $ 276,129 Fees $ 449,250
Commodities $ 105,528 Proceeds from Borrowing $ -
Contractual Services 42,750 Other, Interest Income $ 465,796
Debt Service $ 213,639 Transfer from General Fund $ -
Capital Outlay $ 277,000 Total $ 915,046
Total $ 915,046
$174, 290
Solid Waste (cost-to-serve)
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Solid Waste Revenue
2021 2022 2023 2024
Service Charges $ 389,477 $ 426,472 $ 441,750 $ 449,250
Misc $ 5,784 $ - $ 1,000 $ 21,220
Transfer from GF $ 86,392 $ 76,487 $ 11,411 $ -
Capital Lease $ - $ - $ - $ 277,000
Fund Balance $ - $ - $ - $ 167,576
$ 481,653 $ 502,959 $ 454,161 $ 915,046
Solid Waste Expense
Personal Services $ 229,948 $ 175,960 $ 250,141 $ 276,129
Commodities $ 105,881 $ 142,917 $ 102,900 $ 105,528
Contractual Services $ 28,131 $ 22,401 $ 39,850 $ 42,750
Capital outlay $ - $ - $ - $ 277,000
Debt service $ 63,269 $ 2,888 $ 63,269 $ 46,063
Transfer out $ - $ - $ - $ 167,576
$ 427,229 $ 344,166 $ 456,160 $ 915,046
2021, 2022 audited | 2023 budgeted | 2024 proposed
Fire Department 1%
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Fire Department 1% Totals
Expenditures Revenues
Fire Dept. 1% $ 13,609 Misc. & Other $ 13,609
Total $ 13,609 Total $ 13,609
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Youth Recreation
Highlights
• Intergovernmental review (Oconee County) increased from $30,000 to $50,000
• Proposed fee increases to cover inflationary cost increases
Youth Recreation Fund
Expenditures Revenues
Personal Services $ 226,269 Intergovernmental Revenue $ 50,000
Commodities $ 64,200 License, Permits, & Fees $ 257,050
Contractual Services $ 228,850 Grant Income $ 10,000
Capital Outlay $ 60,000 Misc. & Other $ 262,269
Total $ 579,319 Total $ 579,319
Youth Recreation
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Westminster $35/$60
Seneca $35/$60
Walhalla $30/$70
Pickens $45/$55
Easley $70/$70
Pendleton $75/$75
Six Mile $75/$75
Liberty $60/$85
Clemson/Central $60/$90
Salem $60/$60
Anderson $40/$60
Recreation registration fees proposed
Current:
inside $35 outside $60 late fee $15
Proposed:
inside $40 outside $65 late fee $20
inside/outside
For 2022 approximately 85% of participants live outside the city limits
Local Development Corporation
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Local Development Corp
Totals
Expenditures Revenues
Other $ 47,031 Misc. & Other $ 47,031
Total $ 47,031 Total $ 47,031
Capital Projects Fund/State ARP Funds
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Highlights
$ 8,705,000 USDA-RD water system improvements
$ 760,000 C-Funds for road repaving
$ 4,911,475 SCIIP Grant and grant match ($3,929,180 RIA | $982,295 City)
$ 94,000 Water system short-lived assets (USDA-RD requirement)
Capital Project Fund/State ARP Totals
Expenditures Revenues
Administration $ 760,400 Intergovernmental Revenue $ 760,400
Water $ 8,799,000 Grant Income $ 644,956
Sewer $ 4,971,284 Misc. & Other $ 8,705,000
Electric $ - Sewer 4,420,328
Non-Departmental $ - Non-Departmental -
Total $ 14,530,684 Total $ 14,530,684
County ARP
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Approved for Funding
$ 524,172 complete raw water improvements
$ 93,504 repair plant reservoir (including engineering and permitting)
$ 64,648 repairs and upgrades to water plant
$ 682,324 Total
County ARP Totals
Expenditures Revenues
Water $ - Grant Income $ 682,324
Water Plant $ 682,324
Total $ 682,324 Total $ 682,324
Highlights
• Transfer to GF (1) $100,000
• Transfer to Youth Recreation (1) $117,950
• Special Events Committee $ 8,000
• Christmas Decorations $ 25,000
• Downtown improvements $ 62,290
• Simpson Road fields $ 37,000
• Hall Road Recreation Complex $ 50,000
• Local Agency Grants $ 40,000
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Hospitality Tax
(1) tied to eligible activities
Hospitality Fund Totals
Expenditures Revenues
Contractual Services $ 352,314 Misc. & Other $ 484,314
Capital Outlay $ 92,000 Total $ 484,314
Other (Grants) $ 40,000
Total $ 484,314
Highlights
• Income stream $200,000
• Fund balance appropriation $284,314
State & Local Accommodations Tax
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Highlights
Visit Oconee $5,000
Oconee Chamber of Commerce $2,500
State & Local Accom. Totals
Expenditures Revenues
Commodities 800 Intergovernmental Revenue $ 5,500
Contractual Services $ 7,500 Misc. & Other $ 2,800
Total $ 8,300 Total $ 8,300
Calculating a tax bill
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Step 1: appraised value X assessment rate = assessed value
Step 2: assessed value X millage rate / 1,000 = $ tax bill
Example:
Step 1: $150,000 house X .04 = 6,000
Step 2: 6,000 X 99.3 / 1,000 = $595.80
Step 1: appraised value X assessment rate = assessed value
Step 2: assessed value X millage rate / 1,000 = $ tax bill
Calculating a tax bill
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Scenario 1 (owner occupied house):
$150,000 house X .04 = 6,000
6,000 X 99.3 / 1,000 = $595.80
6,000 X 95.8 / 1,000 = $574.80 ($21 savings)
Scenario 2 (commercial business):
$420,000 building X .06 = 25,200
25,200 X 99.3 / 1,000 = $2,502.36
25,200 X 95.8 / 1,000 = $2,414.16 ($88.20 savings)
Summary of proposed changes
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Millage (tax) reduction
Current 99.3 mills
Proposed 95.8 mills
Water Tap Fees
3/4" Inside 3/4" Outside 1" Inside 1" Outside
Current $ 1,700 $ 1,900 $ 1,900 $ 2,100
Proposed $ 1,700 $ 2,000 $ 1,900 $ 2,200
Sewer Tap Fees
4" Inside 4" Outside 6"
Current $ 1,300 $ 1,500 Cost + 30%
Proposed $ 1,300 $ 1,600 Cost + 30%
Recreation registration fees proposed
Current:
inside $35 outside $60 late fee $15
Proposed:
inside $40 outside $65 late fee $20
Current
Depot 1st hour per hour
Rental $ 50 $ 25 (4 hr min)
Deposit $ 100
Anderson Park
Pavilion $ 35 3 hours
Small gazebo $ 25 3 hours
additional hours $ 5 per hour
Proposed
Depot 1st hour per hour
Rental $ 75 $ 50 (4 hr min)
Deposit $ 150
Anderson Park
Pavilion $ 50 3 hours
Small gazebo $ 35 3 hours
additional hours $ 20 per hour
1
2
3
4
Questions…discussion
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
Thank you.
The End.
Gateway to the Mountain Lakes Region
You may go home now
Source: City of Westminster website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.