Regular Council Meeting Minutes
City of West Columbia · Lexington County · meeting of May 6, 2015 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of West Columbia
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
City of West Columbia, SC
Regular Council Meeting
Following the Public Meeting on Urban Chicken Farming
April 7, 2015
Members Present: Members Absent:
Joe Owens, Mayor None
Casey Jordan Hallman, Mayor Pro-Tem
Boyd Jones
Eric L. Fowler
L. Dale Harley
Temus C. “Tem” Miles, Jr.
Tommy G. Parler
B.J. Unthank
Teddy Wingard
Others Present:
Jenny Cunningham, City Administrator Wyatt Coleman, Fire Chief
Brian Carter, Assistant City Administrator Anna Huffman, IT Systems Administrator
Stuart Jones, Building Official Dennis Tyndall, Police Chief
Donna Smith, Director of Economic Development Scott Morrison, PIO/West Columbia PD
Sid Varn, Director of Planning and Engineering Justin Black, Treasurer
Mardi Valentino, Director of Human Resources Rick Hodge , Financial Consultant
Jamie Hook, Sanitation/Streets/Parks Superintendent Kelli Brazell, City Clerk
Marquis Solomon, Fire Battalion Chief Kenneth Ebener, Municipal Judge
Members of the Public and Press
Agenda Item I – Call to Order
Chairperson Unthank called the meeting to order at 6:12 p.m. and noted a quorum was present. The State,
Free Times, Lexington County Chronicle, Cayce-West Columbia News, The Columbia Star,
COLADaily.com and radio and television stations were notif ied of the meeting by e-mail on April 2, 2015,
and revised on April 7, 2015.
Agenda Item II – Determination of Quorum
Chairperson Unthank noted a quorum was present to conduct business.
Agenda Item III – Invocation
Council Member Jones gave the invocation.
Agenda Item IV – Pledge of Allegiance
All attendees at the meeting recited the Pledge of Allegiance before the flag of the United States of America.
Agenda Item V – Announcements/Communications by the Mayor
Chairperson Unthank recognized Mayor Owens. Mayor Owens disagreed with Council’s vote to approve the
reimbursement of $5600.00 in legal fees to Council Member Tem Miles for a regulatory commission. The
Mayor stated that the agenda for the March 16, 2015 Special Council meeting was revised and published
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
April 7, 2015
Page Two
Agenda Item V – Announcements/Communications by the Mayor- continued
three hours prior to the meeting. The Mayor stated the vote taken on the reimbursement of legal fees is not
legal, due to the fact, the agenda was revised with less than 24 hour notice. The Mayor stated that he
requested an opinion from the city attorney, Nikki Setzler; and the city attorney agreed that the agenda
should not be amended within 24 hours of a special meeting. The Mayor also asks that the item be placed
back on the agenda and another vote taken, stating the city attorney recommended it. The action item was not
added to the agenda for this meeting as the Mayor requested, due to discussion with the city attorney in
executive session. Mayor Owens was also upset the citizens, that had requested to speak on this matter, had
been left off of the agenda, and all had called more than 24 hours prior to this meeting.
He quoted city ordinance: 1-3-6 Appearance of citizens.
Any citizen who has business with the city shall be entitled to appear before the council at any regular or
special meeting to present any matters pertaining to the city with the exception of personnel matters. Persons
desiring to speak or desiring to make a presentation must notify the clerk to place the subject matter on the
agenda. The Mayor stated there was not a time limit on when they could place it on the agenda.
The Mayor went on to talk about the reimbursement of $5600.00 in legal fees. He is concerned the fees have
no limit placed on them. The Mayor elaborated there is no way to know how much more they will cost. He
feels that the reimbursement of fees is not legal. The Attorney General opinion from July 2, 2013, on the
reimbursement of legal fees states there is a four-part test to determine public purpose:
1) What is the intended ultimate goal or benefit to the public?
2) Are the public parties or private parties the primary beneficiaries?
3) Is the benefit to the public speculative?
4) What is the probability that the public interest will be ultimately served and to what degree?
The Mayor feels the answer to all of the above questions is no. He reiterated the fact that he felt it unjust to
leave the re-vote off of the agenda for this council meeting. Chairperson Unthank stated to reconsider a vote,
according to our city ordinance, the reconsidered vote must take place before the meeting is adjourned.
Chairperson Unthank informed the Mayor the city attorneys would be present in executive session to discuss
the opinion provided; and it would be best to reconsider after council received the Attorney General’s
opinion. Chairperson Unthank also quoted city ordinance:
1-3-7 Agenda.
Matters to be considered by the council at a regular meeting shall be placed on a written agenda prepared by
the clerk-treasurer five (5) days prior to the meeting. Matters not on the agenda may be considered upon
approval of the presiding officer.
After further discussion, Chairperson Unthank moved onto the requests for appearances/citizen comment
period.
Agenda Item VI– Requests for Appearances/Citizen Comment Period
A. Chairperson Unthank recognized Ms. Martha Wise, President, Ms. Marion Scott, Vice President, and
Mr. Mark Plessinger, Members of the West Vista Guild. The West Vista Guild is a merchant’s
association comprised of business owners from State and Meeting Street area. It has been around
since 1999. Mr. Mark Plessinger, a business owner of Frame of Mind on State Street, introduced
himself to Council. Mr. Plessinger brought his business from Main Street in Columbia. He was
involved in events and revitalization of that area and wants to help revitalize the West Columbia area
as well. Mr. Plessinger reiterated the interest from business owners, in a façade improvement
program. The town of Lexington’s program matches $10.000.00 if the business owner spends
$25,000.00. There is an application process involved. The town of Lexington placed money in their
budget to help get the revitalization process started.
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
April 7, 2015
Page Three
Agenda Item VI– Requests for Appearances/Citizen Comment Period – continued
Chairperson Unthank assured Mr. Plessinger the city is excited to make State and Meeting Streets
look as good as possible. He informed Mr. Plessinger that Council will soon be working on the
budget, and will keep this in mind. He also let Mr. Plessinger know that the city would be in touch
with him as the process moves forward.
B. Chairperson Unthank recognized Mr. Edward Jones of 413 Graham Drive. Mr. Jones would like an
adjustment to a sewer tap fee. He explained when he purchased the home he was told it was on city
sewer and water. He has been paying for sewer on his water bill. Only when sewage was coming up
in his yard, did he realize that he had a septic tank. He has had to pay to have the septic tank pumped,
a line to tap onto city sewer, and now a tap fee of $1000. He requests that the amount of around $800
he previously paid for in sewer, be applied to the tap fee. Chairperson Unthank stated the city is
required by our bond ordinance, not to adjust the tap fees. It is not something the city can legally do
and still abide by our bond requirements. Mayor Owens related that a few months ago, Council
adjusted the tap fee for Fire House Subs by about $15,000.00. Chairperson Unthank recognized
Council Member Miles, who clarified; the city had made an adjustment to the ordinance that sets tap
fees, specifically for restaurants, to bring them in line with the Department of Health and
Environmental Control (DHEC) guidelines. Although sympathetic to Mr. Jones’s plight, the
residential tap fees remain the same. The fees are the same for all of the citizens that live inside the
city limits of West Columbia. Council Member Fowler asked if he had been allowed to make
payments over time. Mr. Jones stated he was given three weeks to pay the bill. He stated the city was
taking a certain percentage of his water and charging him for sewer, and he was not using the sewer
service. City Administrator, Jenny Cunningham, informed Council city ordinance states that if sewer
is available, then an availability charged is assessed to the account. The availability charge is $10.58
every two months. Mrs. Cunningham stated staff would check into Mr. Jones’s account to make sure
he was only charged the minimum and not a percentage. If he was charged incorrectly, staff would
adjust his account, as well as, work with him on paying over time. Chairperson Unthank reassured
Mr. Jones staff would handle the issue. If he was not happy with the results, he could come back
before Council.
C. Chairperson Unthank recognized Mr. Tom Britt of HB Engineering. Mr. Caughman was called away
for a family emergency. Mr. Britt would like to discuss the proposed grading plan for Flow
Townhomes impacting city property and a sewer line located at 136 Sunset Boulevard. Mr.
Caughman has contacted the city staff and requested the ability to do some grading on city property,
at the treatment plant, to make the slopes more consistent and approve the appearance. It is the area
near the security fence at the water plant. They would like to re-grade the area and stop five feet from
the fence. They would also like to put in a swell to make sure the run-off water does not go onto
city’s property. There would be increase in run-off. There is an existing sewer line in that area. The
city staff is concerned about the additional fill being requested to put over the sewer line. Mr.
Caughman and Mr. Britt do acknowledge there will be additional work if the sewer line ever has to
be dug up. Mr. Caughman has proposed to do some additional landscaping on the city property if this
is approved. Council Member Miles asked if the major problem is the sewer line and; how much dirt
would need to be put on top of the sewer line. Mr. Britt stated that there would be four feet of extra
dirt to remove if there was a problem with the line. Chairperson Unthank thanked Mr. Britt. He
informed Mr. Britt the Council would need to consult with the city engineer, and would get back to
him.
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
April 7, 2015
Page Four
Agenda Item VI– Requests for Appearances/Citizen Comment Period – continued
D. Chairperson Unthank recognized Mr. Jimmy Brooks of 3409 Henbet Drive. Mr. Brooks requested to
discuss the payment of legal fees for a Council Member. Mr. Brooks thanked Council for allowing
him to speak. As an aside, Mr. Brooks strongly encouraged Springdale to annex into the city of West
Columbia. The reason Mr. Brooks is here to speak is because of the $5600.00 check that was issued
to Council Member Miles. His concern was about the manner in which the vote was taken. Mr.
Brooks stated that there was not enough notice given to allow citizens to be there when the vote was
taken. It is his opinion; every effort has been made to deter citizens from voicing their opinion. He
would like to see it re-voted on with ample notice, and in front of people that care about the
community. He would also like to see a cap put on the amount that to be reimbursed. Mr. Brooks
urged Council to come to a compromise even if a mediator is needed. Chairman Unthank recognized
Council Member Miles. Council Member Miles stated for the record, he has recused himself from the
discussion of reimbursement fees. Mr. Miles asked Mr. Brooks for clarification of his reason for
having issues with vote. Mr. Brooks stated his concerns: the short period of time before the meeting
the agenda was amended, and the short notice to the community. Mr. Miles related to Mr. Brooks the
reason the agenda was originally amended was because of the proposed Memorandum of
Understanding (MOU) for the sale of the property at State Street and Meeting Street. That item was
an action item and was voted on that night without issue. Council Member Miles stated this is
selective outrage. Mayor Pro-Tem Hallman related that she would like the matter of the MOU re-
visited, as well as, the reimbursement of legal fees. Chairperson Unthank stated Council was going
into executive session to discuss all of these issues. He moved the approval of the minutes until after
reconvening from executive session.
Agenda Item VIII – Adjourn to Executive Session for Discussion of a City Property Contractual Matter, a
Water/Sewer Contractual Matter, and a Legal Matter
Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion to adjourn to executive session. Council Member Jones so moved
and Mayor Owens seconded with discussion. Mayor Owens stated there was nothing on the agenda that
stated Council was going into executive session to discuss the vote on Tem Miles reimbursement of legal
fees. He stated if that topic came up in executive session he would leave the room. Chairperson Unthank
asked for all in favor of adjourning to executive session. Mayor Pro-Tem Hallman, Council Members
Harley, Jones, Fowler, Unthank, Parler, Wingard, Miles voted in favor of adjourning to executive session.
Mayor Owens was opposed. The motion passed eight votes to one vote. Council adjourned to executive
session at 7:01 p.m.
Agenda Item IX – Reconvene to Regular Session
Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion to adjourn executive session and reconvene to regular session.
Council Member Jones so moved and Council Member Parler seconded. Mayor Pro-Tem Hallman, Council
Members Harley, Jones, Fowler, Unthank, Parler, Wingard, Miles voted in favor of reconvening to regular
session. Mayor Owens stated he would not vote. The motion passed unanimously. Council reconvened to
regular session at 8:33 p.m. Chairperson Unthank stated that no action was taken in executive session.
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
April 7, 2015
Page Five
Agenda Item X – New Business
A. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for first reading consideration of an ordinance to approve
the sale of city property at State and Meeting Streets to Estates Properties, LLC. Chairperson Unthank
stated Council would table the motion until a future meeting. There was no vote taken.
B. Chairperson Unthank entertained consideration reappoint Paul Rex Adkins, Water/Sewer
Superintendent, and Stephan P. Metro, Park Ranger, for three year terms to the West Columbia
Grievance Committee. The terms would end in January 2018. Council Member Miles so moved and
Mayor Pro-Tem Hallman seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
C. Chairperson Unthank entertained consideration to appoint Carol Y. Ostendorff, Water Plant Operator
A, for a three year term, to the West Columbia Grievance Committee. The term would end in January
2018. Council Member Parler so moved and Council Member Miles seconded. The motion passed
unanimously.
D. Chairperson Unthank entertained consideration to appoint Dr. Liz Holmes to the West Columbia
Beautification Foundation Board. Council Member Boyd Jones made the nomination. Council
Member Jones so moved and Council Member Fowler seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
E. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for consideration of bids for a new phone system by Anna
Huffman. The city phone system is failing. It is over ten years old and we can no longer get parts for
it. AT&T had to come to the city twice in the last week to repair it. If the system fails totally, it will
take days to get it back up and running. Out of three bids, the lowest was AT&T. The city will be
able to reuse all but 35 handsets. The handsets are $300.00 each. The total bid is $31, 811.78. She is
asking for a budget amendment for the current year’s budget. Mayor Owens so moved and Council
Member Fowler seconded. Council Member Miles asked if that cost included the handsets needed.
Mrs. Huffman stated the price included everything, even installation. The motion passed
unanimously.
Agenda Item VII – Approval of Minutes for Previous Meetings
Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion to approve the minutes for the Special Council meeting held
March 16, 2015 and the Special Council Meeting on March 24, 2015. Chairperson Unthank asked for
corrections or deletions on either set of minutes. Mayor Pro-Tem Hallman requested that the March 16,
2015 minutes be amended. She is concerned about the way that the adjournment was marked, so she asked
the clerk to amend the minutes. Mayor Pro-Tem Hallman stated the vote was marked unanimous and she
never voted. The nays were not called for, and she still had questions. City Clerk, Kelli Brazell indicated she
made the corrections Mayor Pro-Tem Hallman requested. Chairperson Unthank called for a vote to approve
the minutes as amended. The motion passed unanimously with changes.
Agenda Item XI – Adjournment
Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion to adjourn. Council Member Harley so moved and Council
Member Parler seconded. Mayor Pro-Tem Hallman, Council Members Harley, Jones, Fowler, Unthank,
Parler, Wingard, Miles voted in favor of adjourning the meeting. Mayor Owens was stated he would not
vote. The motion passed unanimously. Council adjourned at 8:40 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Kelli Brazell
City Clerk
Source: City of West Columbia website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.