Special Council Meeting
City of West Columbia · Lexington County · meeting of Nov 21, 2014 · Notices
Open the original document More from City of West Columbia
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
City of West Columbia, SC
Special Council Meeting
January 13, 2014 at 6 p.m.
Members Present: Members Absent:
Joe Owens, Mayor None
Casey Jordan Hallman, Mayor Pro-Tem
Eric L. Fowler
L. Dale Harley
Boyd Jones
Temus C. “Tem” Miles, Jr.
Tommy G. Parler
B.J. Unthank
Teddy Wingard
Others Present:
Jenny Cunningham, City Administrator A nna Huffman, IT Systems Administrator
Myron Corley, Deputy City Administrator Wyatt Coleman, Fire Chief
Mardi Valentino, City Clerk/PIO Bria n Carter, Assistant City Administrator
Donna Smith Director of Economic Development Stuart Jones, Building Official
Matt Edwards, Police Major Justin Black, Staff Accountant
Sid Varn, Director of Planning and Engineering Rick Hodge, City Treasurer
Dennis Tyndall, Police Chief Shane Phillips, Police Captain
M e m b e r s o f t h e P r e s s a n d P u b l i c
Agenda Item I – Call to Order
Mayor Owens called the meeting to order at 6 p.m. and noted a quorum was present. The State, Free Times,
Lexington County Chronicle, Cayce-West Columbia News, The Columbia Star, COLADaily.com and radio
and television stations were notified of the meeting by e-mail on January 10, 2014.
Agenda Item II – Invocation and Pledge of Allegiance
Police Captain Shane Phillips gave the invocation followed by the Pledge of Allegiance.
Agenda Item III – New Business
A. Mayor Owens entertained a motion for consideration of a resolution to support the Penny for
Progress Sales Tax Program for infrastructure needs in Lexington County. Council Member Harley
so moved and Council Member Fowler seconded. Mayor Owens recognized Mr. Sid Varn, director
of Planning and Engineering, who presented nine proposed projects to submit to Lexington County
for the Penny for Progress Sales Tax Program and listed as follows:
1. Replace existing 6-inch asbestos cement water main in Decatur Street from Platt Springs
Road to Cayce city limits and make repairs to the existing street.
2. Replace the existing 6-inch asbestos cement water main in Rainbow Drive from Wilton Road
to Dalewood Drive.
3. Replace existing four-inch and two-inch water main in Shampy Street from Rainbow Drive to
the end of the street.
Special Council Meeting Minutes
January 13, 2014
Page Two
Agenda Item III – New Business (continued)
4. Provide a Greenway Capital Repair fund for the existing Three Rivers Greenway.
5. Construct a river walk from Lexington Medical Center to the proposed I-26 Saluda River
Crossing Project.
6. Install a reservoir water mixing system in the Laurel Road Ground Storage Tank.
7. Construct a northwestern river walk connection to the proposed I-26 Saluda River Crossing
Project.
8. Paint the interior and exterior of the Laurel Road Ground Storage Tank.
9. Eliminate the backwash water at the Lake Murray Water Treatment Plant.
Mr. Varn stated the Penny for Progress Sales Tax will be on the ballot as a referendum in the
upcoming November election. He explained that West Columbia must submit its list of proposed
projects to Lexington County by the end of January to be included in the referendum. He said
Council needed to approve a resolution officially supporting the proposed project list.
Mayor Owens recognized Mayor Pro-Tem Hallman who asked if replacing the water meters could be
added to the project list. Mr. Varn responded that he would check to see if replacing the water meters
met the Penny for Progress criteria and if it did he would add it to the project list. Mayor Owens
called for a vote and the motion to approve the resolution passed unanimously.
B. Mayor Owens recognized Ms. Ashley Smith Hunter, Senior Vice President with McKay Public
Affairs. Ms. Hunter gave a presentation on public relations services that she could provide to the city.
C. Mayor Owens recognized Ms. Mardi Valentino, Public Information Officer, who briefed council
members on recent upgrades to the city’s website utilizing Geographical Information Systems (GIS)
technology. Ms. Valentino stated that the city now incorporates a variety of ways to impart official
information such as boil water advisories, Riverwalk Park closings and street and bridge closings as
well as general information about city events and city-supported outreach programs. She said
traditional methods would still be employed, such as news releases and stories to the newsprint,
broadcast and on-line medias, but the city now has the capacity to provide information to citizens
utilizing smart phones, I-Pads and Kindles who access on-line news for their information sources.
D. Ms. Valentino introduced Mrs. Anna Huffman, IT Administrator, who manages the city’s website
and social media. Mrs. Huffman stated that she created a Twitter which now has 301 followers and a
Facebook page with 136 likes, building the city’s social community to nearly 500 people. She tweets
and posts to Facebook at least twice a day, including weekends and holidays with real time updates
on issues and information to residents and businesses. Mrs. Huffman said she created a Constant
Contact database to send out news releases and newsletters via e-mail to citizens who sign up for the
e-mail list through the city’s website. She said the number of people following Twitter and Facebook
and signing up for Constant Contact continues to grow on a daily basis.
Special Council Meeting Minutes
January 13, 2014
Page Three
Agenda Item III – New Business (continued)
Mrs. Huffman noted that she made some structural changes to the city’s website due to the
implementation of new servers and domains for the police department. She is in the process of
redesigning the city’s current website to increase the city’s overall online presence, make page
navigation more user friendly and have more eye appealing content with rotating banners and
emergency news tickers. She plans to request money in the next year’s budget to redo the city’s
website. She stated editing and updating the website in house would allow the city to get its
messages out to the public in a cohesive and immediate manner.
Ms. Valentino spoke on how GIS has impacted the way the city disseminates information to the
public. She said the addition of GIS maps allows more information to be imbedded into the website
and visually enhances the city’s messages. She explained she is working with Ms. Emily Pires, GIS
Supervisor, who created an online map of the eight council districts with pop-up information on each
council member. Ms. Valentino stated that boil water advisories are sent out with a map to indicate
the exact location of the area affected by the water line break. She said the GIS map also allows her
to count the number of affected customers and provide that information to the media. Ms. Valentino
concluded that with the explosive growth worldwide in websites and social media the city does not
have a choice of whether or not to engage in the technology, but rather how well the city will use it to
disseminate real time information and the city’s corporate message to the public.
E. Mayor Owens stated that Ms. Karen Hoover requested to speak before council about her progress to
purchase the property at 351 Meeting Street. Even though Ms. Hoover was not on the agenda
Council members agreed to hear her speak. Ms. Hoover stated that she lives at 1027 Rutland Avenue
in West Columbia. She said she spoke to council members in July 2013 about purchasing the
property at 351 Meeting Street to establish an upscale consignment store and received permission
from the city council on October 23, 2013 to purchase the property. She said she was funding the
purchase through a loan from the Small Business Administration (SBA), but the federal government
shutdown in October 2013 put her loan application approval on hold. Ms. Hoover said when the 30-
day deadline to purchase the property neared she called both Mayor Owens and City Administrator
Jenny Cunningham to ask about extending the deadline. She said she was assured there were no
other interested purchasers and that city council knew she wanted to buy the property. Ms. Hoover
said she called again over the holidays about the contract to advise Mrs. Cunningham that she was
pursuing another lender since the SBA seemed to be a slow process. She said she fully intended to
go forward with the contract. She has spent over $14,000 for inventory, building inspections, hiring a
structural engineer, paying a loan fee to the SBA and purchasing supplies and fixtures. She also has
registered the name of her business with the state government, bought a website and built a Facebook
page.
Mayor Owens said the vote to sell the property at 351 Meeting Street was unanimous. He noted that
all the previous renderings from developers interested in the four acres of property at State and
Meeting Streets did not include developing the parcel at 351 Meeting Street. He stated that although
the 30-day contract to purchase the property had expired, Ms. Hoover did receive assurances that the
city was still interested in selling the property to her.
Special Council Meeting Minutes
January 13, 2014
Page Four
Agenda Item III – New Business (continued)
Mayor Owens recognized Council Member Unthank who stated to Ms. Hoover, “I would like to
make a comment. I think it is a little unseemly to be sort of talking about the “he said, she said” in a
public forum. Now we can do that. We were going to discuss it and I certainly have some
information I want to share with Council. I think that it is great that you want to open a business in
West Columbia and I encourage you to do that absolutely. You’ve already got your funds arranged
and so forth, but I am opposed to selling this particular piece of property at a $50,000 loss to the city
that belongs to a larger four-acre plot of land that we cobbled together so that we could put a great
development on it. Now we can discuss it out here in the council chambers. I don’t know you
personally and I want you to know that I would support you in opening a business and in whatever
the city can do to aid you. I know that Donna Smith is our grants writer and there are certain small
business programs that you can look into to aid you in getting a location as well that is right in that
same area. But that small piece of property takes up one third of the State Street frontage of the
overall four-acre piece of property and I’ve got a presentation that is visual for council in a meeting
in executive session that I am going to share with them that really highlights the importance of that
key corner piece of property for a developer that’s going to buy the four million dollar property as
one piece and develop it as a whole. I appreciate your desire to open a business in West Columbia
and that’s great. But I think that it is best if council discusses this in executive session. That’s my
opinion. Does anybody have any comments?”
Council Member Miles stated to Ms. Hoover, “Before we go into executive session, I would like to
say this: This is my district and I will be upfront with you. I would not have supported this had I
been the representative at that time. We were unrepresented and if we are not bound to it I intend to
try to get out of it. But having said that, after we discussed this last it was brought to my attention in
particular that the city has given you some assurances requiring a time. There is legally right and
there is morally right. If we have given you assurances that you relied on I’ll go forth based on that.
I would ask that you put together some time line and documentation regarding who you spoke with,
when you spoke with them and also when you incurred the expenses for $14,000 that you laid out,
just so I can see the time of when those assurance were given and when you occurred the expenses,
and exactly where we are in our obligation to you.”
Ms. Hoover responded, “I’ve got all that. I’ve got everything on a spreadsheet. I can give you most
of that information tonight. I talked with [City Administrator] Jenny [Cunningham] two days before
the contract expired.”
Council Member Miles stated, “I was unaware of that in our previous discussions and I would just
like to have all the information.”
Ms. Hoover stated, “I’m ready to go at this point. I’ve brought my contractor with me. We’ve
already done the renderings. I’m going to make it a great, great location. It is not going to look like
the same building. It is going to be such an enhancement to the area. You won’t even recognize it. I
plan on doing it. We’ll make the city proud when you come across the river and see that [building].”
Mayor Owens stated, “I want to remind people that the vote on that was unanimous. So that people
who have reservations now, I wish they’d had those reservations then. We have never had a
rendering from [developers] that included that piece in the process.”
Special Council Meeting Minutes
January 13, 2014
Page Five
Agenda Item III – New Business (continued)
Ms. Hoover stated, “I couldn’t do what I needed to do on the back end until I got approval from city
council that I would have a contract on that property. Now there was no sense in me paying a
structural engineer for talking with my contractor and going over the plans, and talking with Stuart
[Jones, Building Official] from the city to see what it would cost and if it were possible for a second
story without doing all my homework before I even knew that it would be approved. That once it
was approved that’s when I put everything into motion and I was given 30 days to close this deal.
That’s when I said I need a little bit more time than 30 days. The SBA just can’t move that fast. I’m
getting it. I have everything in order. I’m ready. I’m really disappointed. I had my heart set on this
location. I have looked at locations all over West Columbia. I have met with three business owners
on Meeting Street on different properties. I love this location. This is where I want to be.”
Council Member Unthank stated, “I just wanted to point out, Mayor, that I think anyone who was in
that meeting, the initial meeting, I was opposed to this. So the vote shows unanimous, but I want to
go on record as pointing out that in the executive session I was opposed to it and you invited Ms.
Hoover into the executive session. Then I had to speak in front of her, saying that this is not in
keeping with our vision to develop the property as a whole. It occupies the entire corner of State and
Meeting, which is a key visual part of that whole property and I opposed it. We came out and voted
on it. I was so breathless that we have done what we had done that I just didn’t say anything. But I
do want to go on public record here tonight that I opposed it and I oppose it still. And I’ve got some
very interesting information to share with you all.” Mayor Owens stated, “Yet you voted for it.”
Council Member Unthank responded, “I voted for it because I couldn’t believe we would do it. I
didn’t vote for it verbally, but I know it counted as a vote. Last week we had agreed in principle and
we had potentials to terminate the contract.”
Agenda Item IV – Adjourn to Executive Session to Discuss a Contractual Matter
Mayor Owens entertained a motion to adjourn to executive session. Council Member Unthank so moved and
Council Member Parler seconded. Council adjourned to executive session at 7 p.m.
Agenda Item V – Reconvene to Regular Session
Mayor Owens entertained a motion to adjourn executive session and reconvene to regular session. Council
Member Unthank so moved and Council Member Wingard seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
Council reconvened to regular session at 7:40 p.m. Mayor Owens stated that no action was taken in
executive session.
Mayors Owens stated to Ms. Hoover, “Previously we voted unanimously at eight [council members] since
Council Member Miles was not elected yet, to sell Ms. Hoover the property on Meeting Street. It went past
the expired time. However, she was given assurances that things were okay. Based on that, after a very civil
and orderly meeting, we believe that the time having run out, is going to be waived because you did talk to
the chief administrative officer of the city and as well as the mayor. We’re going to give you five working
days to close. Are you good with that?”
Ms. Hoover responded, “Yes.”
Special Council Meeting Minutes
January 13, 2014
Page Six
Agenda Item V – Reconvene to Regular Session (continued)
Mayor Owens asked if anyone else had anything [to say]. Council Member Unthank stated, “I still insist on
going on record as opposing this sale. I think it’s a mistake. So I just want that known to my constituents
that I oppose this sale because it’s not good for the city. It’s not good for the value of the development of
that property. And I deeply regret that we’re for this. It’s not because I didn’t try to convince council
otherwise, but the mayor is in your corner and very much so. So you owe a debt of gratitude to the mayor
because I did everything I could to convince my fellow council members and I stand defeated on that. So I
yield the floor.”
Mayor Owens stated, “I don’t count this as a victory. I count this as good and what we said we would do. If
you’re not good to your word then you’re no good. The only thing you have in politics is your word. You
break that you’ve got nothing.”
Agenda Item VI – Adjourn
Mayor Owens entertained a motion to adjourn. Council Member Jones so moved and Council Member
Miles seconded. The motion passed unanimously. Council adjourned at 7:45 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Marta M. Valentino, CMC
City Clerk/Public Information Officer
Source: City of West Columbia website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.