Regular Council Meeting
City of West Columbia · Lexington County · meeting of Nov 21, 2014 · Notices
Open the original document More from City of West Columbia
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
City of West Columbia, SC
Regular Council Meeting
April 1, 2014 at 6 p.m.
Members Present: Members Absent:
Joe Owens, Mayor None
Casey Jordan Hallman, Mayor Pro-Tem
Eric L. Fowler
L. Dale Harley
Boyd Jones
Temus C. “Tem” Miles, Jr.
Tommy G. Parler
B.J. Unthank
Teddy Wingard
Others Present:
Jenny Cunningham, City Administrator Dennis Tyndall, Police Chief
Myron Corley, Deputy City Administrator Wyatt Coleman, Fire Chief
Mardi Valentino, City Clerk/PIO Bria n Carter, Assistant City Administrator
Sid Varn, Director of Planning and Engineering Ken Ebener, Municipal Judge
Anna Huffman, IT Administrator Rick Hodge, City Treasurer
Members of the Public and Press
Agenda Item I – Call to Order
Mayor Owens called the meeting to order at 6 p.m. The State, Free Times, Lexington County Chronicle,
Cayce-West Columbia News, The Columbia Star, COLADaily.com and radio and televi sion stations were
notified of the meeting by e-mail on March 28, 2014.
Agenda Item II – Determination of Quorum
Mayor Owens noted a quorum was present to conduct business. Council Member Fowler gave the
invocation followed by the Pledge of Allegiance.
Agenda Item III – Approval of Minutes
A. Mayor Owens entertained a motion to approve the minutes for the regular council meeting held
March 4, 2014. Council Member Unthank so moved and Council Member Parler seconded. The
motion passed unanimously.
B. Mayor Owens stated that the minutes for the special council meeting held March 17, 2014 were not
ready for council to approve and would be placed on the agenda for the May council meeting.
Agenda Item IV – Readings of Communications
A. Mayor Owens recognized Jake More, Esquire, with Moore, Taylor and Thomas, PA to come forward
to speak to council. Mayor Owens stated, “Let me say one thing while Jake’s on his way up here. At
the end of this session I am not going to have anything to say to the media. Everything you say is
usually out of context and is got a slant on it some way or another just to sensationalize the story. So
I’m not fanning the fire. Let these people who want to go ahead, but don’t ask me to talk to you
because I’m not going to.”
Attachment III.B
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
April 1, 2014
Page Two
Agenda Item IV – Readings of Communications (continued)
Mr. Moore stated, “Folks, I don’ t know how I wound up in the middle of whatever we have going on
here. My name is Jake Moore. I practice law over in West Columbia and I did not really mean to get
embroiled in whatever political fighting is going on here. You know, all you folks I consider friends.
I consider the mayor a friend. I consider the ex-mayor a friend. I know most of you folks and y’all
are my friends. The mayor basically came to see me a week or so ago and basically asked me to look
at a proposed ordinance and give my thoughts as to whether or not that could be done. I looked at it.
I looked at the code and gave him an opinion. He asked me to … if I would put that letter in writing
and I did. Then I got Jenny (City Administrator Jenny Cunningham) in trouble by sending the letter
to Jenny with a ‘per your request.’ Well, it actually wasn’t per Jenny’s request. The mayor had come
and basically asked me if I would put it in writing. And I said, ‘Well, Joe, I think that … sure I’d be
happy to put it in writing for you.’ So I did. I sent it to Jenny. And now somebody is apparently
criticizing Jenny for basically asking me for an opinion, which she didn’t do. I met with Joe in my
office and he asked me my opinion. I gave it to him and put it in writing. My understanding is now
that my opinion basically coincides with … I think there was an opi nion from the attorney general’s
office and I think that I looked at the attorney general’s opinion and I happen to think the attorney
general in this case is a genius because he happens to agree with me. So I wrote the letter and the
letter is pretty much self-explanatory. Really and truly I’m sort of embarrassed by being here
because it was made known to me by Jenny this afternoon that well really if an opinion is to be given
to you it probably ought to come from Danny Scott who is the official town attorney. And I would
suggest that if anyone needs any more that maybe you ask Danny Scott because he’s a friend of mine
and a good lawyer as well. And I respect his judgment as well. Has everyone read the letter that I
wrote? Okay. It’s pretty much self-explanatory and I’m happy to answer any questions that
anybody’s got, but I just agree with the attorney general.”
Mayor Owens stated, “Let me say something. I ca lled Nikki (Nikki Setzler, Esq.) today and I told
him that I didn’t expect him to weigh in cause he’s the city lawyer. He would consider it a conflict of
interest I guess, but he said, ‘Joe, the letter that I wrote to you, that Michelle (Michelle Dickerson,
Esq.) wrote you, said the same thing that the AG (attorney general) said.’ So you concur with the
AG? And he said, ‘Yes.’ So that’s where we are on that. So that’s two Lexington County top
lawyers and a bevy of people over at the AG’s office who do nothing but this kind of stuff. People
have said, ‘Ah we don’t agree with it. It’s no good, no good. But I guarantee you if that said the
other they’d be waving it to high heaven.”
Mr. Moore stated, “I would urge you, and again I don’t live in West Columbia, but I’ve practiced law
here for 40 years this October. I would urge you to exercise caution in an action like this. And I
would beg you … we have so much good going on in this town. And we have so much that needs to
be done in this city. And I would simply beg you, whatever differences you have, to see if you can’t
work them out and not take drastic action that would … we just … the infighting sometimes can
detract so seriously from our ability to get the work of the city basically done. I would … you know,
as a taxpayer from the city, but not a voter, I would urge you to exercise restraint and to see if maybe
we can’t get together and put some of our differences aside. With that, I’m here. I’ll answer any
questions anybody’s got about my letter. It’s not really my place to ask you, but I did.”
Council Member Miles asked, “May or, can I ask one question?” Mayor Owens responded, “Sure.”
Council Member Miles asked, “In your research did you look at any previous attorney generals’
opinions?”
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
April 1, 2014
Page Three
Agenda Item IV – Readings of Communications (continued)
Mr. Moore responded, “I did not. What I looked at was the code and I looked at the code basically
dealing with this form of government. And when you basically have got this form of government it,
… basically the code seems to fairly well dictate th at the mayor, the only thing the mayor does is to
work, … act as the presiding officer at the meetings.”
Mr. Miles stated, “Mr. Moore, I have the four sections of state law in front of me that lay out that. I
would challenge you to identify that language in these four sections or in the sections that generally
apply to his powers.”
Mr. Moore responded, “The code section that I’m talking about is, it is by negative implication.
What you basically have is the code section which very plainly says the mayor pro-tem takes over
and presides in the absence of the mayor. By negative implication it is a recognition that the inherent
powers of the presiding officer reside in the mayor. The mayor is the only elected official who is
elected at large and if the mayor isn’t the presiding officer, what is he? The classic definitions of
mayor would always provide inherent power as being the presiding officer. Now does the code
specifically say he is the presiding officer – no. The code does say that the mayor pro-tem acts as the
presiding officer in the absence of the mayor.”
Council Member Miles stated, “Mr. Moore, I look at the section it says … the mayor pro-tem shall
act as the mayor in the absence of the mayor.” Mr. Moore responded, “That’s right.” Council
Member Miles stated, “So if there’s anything in the state law that says the mayor, in our form of
government, that granted it does say it for the strong mayor.” Mr. Moore responded, “Correct.”
Council Member Miles said, “But anything that says it for our form of government I would like to see
it so we can make an informed decision.” Mr. Moore responded, “Here’s the deal, Tem. What it
says that the mayor pro-tem acts in absence of the mayor. By negative implication the statute is
saying that the mayor acts as the presiding officer if he’s there.” Council Member Miles stated, “The
word presiding officer is not in there. And I would just like to point out the reason why I asked you
about previous attorney generals’ opinions, there’s an opinion from May 8, 2009 that was signed by
Bob Goodwin. You know Bob Goodwin, right?” Mr. Miles responded, “Bob’s great.” Council
Member Miles said, “Bob signed the opinion.” Mr. Miles responded, He’s a fine … he’s one of the
best lawyers I’ve ever known.” Council Member Miles stated, “He signed this opinion as well. And
he expressly says the power of (unintelligible) presiding officer are not delegated to the mayor under
state law, under the forms of council-manager or council governments.”
Mr. Moore stated, “You know, Chapin (Town of Chapin) right now …” Council Member Miles said,
“Strong mayor.” Mr. Moore continued, “Strong mayor, but it’s going through some of the exact
same discord that’s going on here. I would, you know, all I can tell you is my reading of the code,
when I read that the … I mean, if we have a code section that says the mayor pro-tem acts in absence
of the mayor, and we pass an city ordinance that says the mayor pro-tem acts in place of the mayor, I
think you’re basically running afoul of the state code. That’s my opinion and you know, it’s my
opinion. My opinion is not worth anything, it’s just my opinion. It happens to be concurred in
apparently by the present attorney general and assuming that my friend Mayor Owens is telling the
truth then apparently Nikki Setzler, the city attorney, agrees. But I don’t know, Nikki’s not here.”
Council Member Miles stated, “(Unintelligible) then absolutely the opinion that his law office issued
to us, he advised against making the mayor pro-tem the presiding officer for the reasons way down
here that was the mayor pro-tem only acts temporarily.
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
April 1, 2014
Page Four
Agenda Item IV – Readings of Communications (continued)
Council Member Miles continued, “But then he goes on to recognize there’s a previous attorney
general’s opinion which, for the sake of clarity, is not binding and this matter will never decided
unless it goes to a court or is issued from a court. But he goes on to specify in his opinion that
whether or not council is free to appoint a presiding officer other than the mayor or the mayor pro-
tem is a different issue and he goes back and he cites this previous attorney general’s opinion where
they say that under our form of government council decides this rule of operating procedures.”
Mr. Moore responded, “You know, I guess … and you’re correct. My opinion, Nikki’s opinion, the
attorney general opinions, they’re all opinions. They mean nothing until and unless you go to court.
Now how do you get to court? You pass the ordinance and you wound up with a lawsuit with y’all
against the mayor or the mayor against y’all. And we’re now spending time, energy, money and
effort on what is probably, in my humble opinion, probably going to be a losing proposition where
somebody’s going to probably wind up embarrassed and everybody ‘s going to leave mad.
Regardless what happens, if you let … the best fight you will ever ha ve is the one you don’t have.
You know, if there is any way on God’s earth to avoid a fight for goodness sake’s, do it. Surely to
goodness we can come to some sort of a resolution where we’ll agree not to fight with each other.
You’ll be spending town money, town time, town energy and by the time it’s over with you will have
had such unmitigated pain and scarring you’ll never work with each other. And that can’t be good
for the people who live in this town. Now again, you guys are the legislature and I hesitate so
horribly to come giving advice. I mean, I was simply asked to write a letter and asked to be here so
here I am. But I think that you’ll be wrong if you go to court, but I could be wrong. I’ve been wrong
plenty of times. But I would ask you, the best fight you’ll ever have is the one you don’t have.
Nobody wins a fight. Surely to goodness we can come and recognize the mayor as the presiding
officer and nothing more. But maybe not, maybe not. That’s for somebody other than me.
Council Member Fowler stated, “I just wanted to say I’ve been elected six times to this seat. Six
times I’ve put my hand on the Bible and said I would uphold the city government, … the city, the
state and the United States, placed my hand on the Bible. I still feel that today. I read the attorney
general’s, that’s his opinion , your opinion. To me that’s state law right now for me. I’ll have to
support this and like I said, I won’t be here for a seventh term. Next year I’m out of here. But let’s
do this right and we’ve come a long way. I know I was the mayor pro-tem twice. One time for one
year and one time for two years. My dear friend and his dear … , all our dear friend Mac Rish got
sick. I was the mayor pro-tem and I tell you I signed some things and some checks back then that
scare me still today. Back then, but I did it. I did what I thought was right with Jenny helping me go
through this. And we got through it. For six terms it has always been the mayor controlling and
took care of the ways doing that and running the meeting. But anyway, like I said, I’m not going to
worry about the (unintelligible).
Mr. Moore stated, “I apologize to Jenny again. I don’t know what we pay here, but it’s not enough.
She’s great. But folks, thank you for allowing me to talk to you and if I can do anything to ever help
you, let me know.” Mayor Owens thanked Mr. Moore for appearing before council.
Agenda Item V – Announcements by Mayor
A. Mayor Owens stated, “We have a Center for Disease Control (CDC) Water Fluoridation Quality
Award. If City Engineer Sidney Varn will approach and give us the good news.
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
April 1, 2014
Page Five
Agenda Item V – Announcements by Mayor (continued)
Mr. Varn stated that the CDC issued a Fluoridation Quality Award for the year 2012 for the Sunset
Water Treatment Plant recognizing the plant provided an optimum level of treatment for fluoride.
Mr. Varn asked Mr. Floyd Wright, Assistant Superintendent and Lead Operator to come forward. He
commended Mr. Wright and the employees at the Sunset Plant for producing quality water for the
citizens of West Columbia. Mayor Owens stated that in his humble opinion that the city has the best
water system in the county. He said that more than 80 percent of Lexington County uses West
Columbia water and he was proud of the operators at the Sunset Plant.
B. Mayor Owens stated that citizens who wish to speak before council should come to the podium and
state their names and addresses because the meeting was being recorded. Mayor Owens recognized
Reverend Leon Blackmon to speak. Rev. Blackmon stated, “Good evening Mr. Mayor and
Councilmen. Most of you know me from a long time back.” The clerk asked Rev. Blackmon to state
his name and address. Rev. Blackmon responded, “Leon Blackmon. 1623 Batchelor Street, West
Columbia. I’m here in support of Councilman Owens and I want everyone here to know that. If you
want to ask me why I’ll tell you. I’ve been knowing Councilman Owens ever since he came on the
scene. For the last thirty-five years, every mayor’s election, I was somewhere in the picture. And
I’m here today to tell all of you we are ashamed of this council. We’re ashamed of this council.
We’ve taken our time. We’ve given our support to the mayor. And the [councilmens] is going to
take it upon [themself] to tell us our vote don’t count. And that’s wrong. Each one of you have your
own districts. You should take care of that district and let the mayor preside over the council where
we voted him. A lot of folks may not like what I’m saying, but I’m here today because Joe Owens
has been a friend of mine ever since he come on the stage. He’s an honest man. He’s an honorable
man and I and him when he first came on the scene we sat, battled it out, but we never lost our
friendship.
I’m here today to say … in order to avoid all this conflict all you have to do is come together. The
citizens of West Columbia voted for the mayor. Why not a referendum? Let the citizens of West
Columbia decide whether they want him to be removed or not. This is the only way that this is going
to turn out right. If you vote today and say he’s not going to be the mayor then I going to feel like
well I don’t have a councilman. And I feel the rest of the citizens are going to say we feel the same
way because what you’re doing is telling us your vote overrides ours and you don’t really have but
one vote. I’m just here today, I feel that it was necessary because I’ve been off the scene for a long
time. I have been retired from (unintelligible) and most of the changes that you see in the city of
West Columbia I played a major part in it. But today, I’m saying again, be careful because you are
about to destroy this community. I’ve been dealing with politics long enough to know what this is all
about. Five yes, four no. Majority votes take over the city. This is as simple as that. You want to
vote yes that five say no you won’t have a voice. Those four that are saying they want Joe to stay in
office, they won’t have a voice because five is going to override that four every time. In my years
out here I’ve seen it happen once before. It is not a pretty picture. I’m not going to stay up here all
day. But I’m going to tell each one of you today, be careful how you vote. Don’t destroy the city
because when you destroy the city what are you going to tell the peoples in your district when you go
back? Word of mouth is out there. Everyone of you that vote to put this man out, we’re going to be
out there telling them, hey, look, put that councilman out. He took your mayor away from you, the
man that we voted for and that’s not right. That’s all I have to say. Thank you.
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
April 1, 2014
Page Six
Agenda Item V – Announcements by Mayor (continued)
Mayor Owens recognized Mrs. Terri Moseley who liv es at 1701 Chimney Swift Lane, to speak. Mrs.
Moseley stated, “I’m Terri Moseley and I’m in Westover Acres. BJ (Unthank) is my district guy who
I have called five times and not called me back. That is very upsetting. I spoke with Christy
(Unthank) and I talked with her about my feelings, exactly how embarrassed and ashamed I was
when I saw the news. I was not here. I see this everyday on Fox News. I don’t want it in my back
yard. Y’all have each been elected to represent your district. I voted for Joe along with 838 other
people. BJ, I pick up the phone and call Joe, I get a tree removed. I pick up the phone and ask Joe a
question about something, he answers his phone. I call you five times to explain to me what has
happened down here, I don’t get an answer. Now y’all are going to vote whether to waste my tax
money on law fees. I mean we’ve got … somebody’ s been in here what four months and we’re
trying to come in and have five chiefs? We’ve got somebody else doing a law suit. This is the town
that I am raising my children in. This is the town that I was raised in. This is ridiculous. Y’all are all
adults. You may not like the way he talks to y’all sometimes, but he’s not ever going to lie to you.
What he feels is what he says. And you can laugh. How long have you been on this council?”
Council Member Miles responded, “Long enough for him to lie to me and lie to (unintelligible)
several times.” Mrs. Moseley stated, “He’s never lied to me. And all these people are probably here
… all these people are probably here to support him not you. So that should tell you something. He
is a man of his word. And I can call him at 10 o’clock at night like we had to at a water break. He
stayed in our yard till two o’clock in the morning. He was not mayor yet. But he has been here for
50 years. Would you be at somebody’s house till two o’clock in the morning? Making it sure that
everybody knows your water is going to get back on?” Council Member Miles responded, “If I had a
phone call and I get I (unintelligible).” Mrs. Moseley asked, “Would you be at somebody’s house till
two o’clock in the morning?” Council Member Miles responded, “If that was (unintelligible), I’d be
there.” Mrs. Moseley replied, “Okay. Well, right now I think y’all all need to make your priority
your districts. We all voted and we have a right as a voter. We elected Joe. So let’s stay with Joe. If
y’all want to be productive let’s look, say, at our police department. We need to help get a position
back for a wonderful individual that was let go. Let’s work on that.”
Mayor Owens recognized Mr. Morris Phillips to speak. Mr. Phillips stated, “Gentlemen, everyone, I
tell you, I lived in Greenville for 15 years …” Council Member Miles asked Mr. Morris to identify
himself for the record. Mr. Morris stated, “My name is Morris Phillips, 105 Ashley Court, West
Columbia, 29169-7000. I’ve lived in the city, moved to Greenville, lived there 15 years, came back.
My wife is born and bred in West Columbia and course I had to drive 30 miles to work every day
because she wanted to be in West Columbia. Well, I became a ‘river rat’ myself. I’ve walked across
this river many a time and one thing I like about West Columbia is watch what you say because that
person or that person is kin to that person. And I know every man here. Been praying for that one.
This young lady beat me like a rented mule when I ran against her. This gentleman showed me
around when I was running for office. This gentleman done been most kind to me. Joe, best man I
know. Mr. Unthank, you were the number two in helping me with getting elected and sorry we don’t
do too good, but you sure tried hard, let’s put it that way. And right on down to Teddy, I don’t know
you that well, but I love and respect you. You, sir, (indicating Council Member Miles) look a pious
peacock sitting over there doing you head like that. This place was peaceful till you showed up. And
I don’t like you that much and if you don’t like it that’s fine. I’ll be glad to discuss it with you
anytime.” Council Member Miles responded, “We don’t have to discuss it.” Mr. Morris responded,
“Okay. But I’d like for you to come over to my house about three o’clock in the morning to do it.”
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
April 1, 2014
Page Seven
Agenda Item V – Announcements by Mayor (continued)
Mr. Morris continued, “But this is a wonderful town. You were elected, … you were elected,
everyone of you were. He was elected as mayor. You’re elected to represent your people. And I
will say the lady, when I’m sick I get a card from my representative (Mayor Pro-Tem Hallman). And
Lord, I’ve even had vittles set over to the house when I don’t feel well or she’s had something and I
wasn’t able to be there. But all I’m saying is we are a family. I don’t want to say it. Just want to let
you know we are a family. And I love Chief (Tyndall). I love Matt (Edwards). Hey, we all can have
our opinions, but we must function for the good of the city. And this bull that’s been going on here
lately has got to cease. If we open with a prayer, we hear that sounds like it’s going on hollow
ground, I mean just being wasted because we’ve got to have a Christian attitude. And sir, your
cockiness doesn’t mean doodley to anybody. We had a respected lawyer stand up here and tell us, …
we asked for his opinion. He didn’t have to explain to you why he formed his opinion. He just
merely came and reported what he was requested to do. This is not your court. This is the citizens’
place and each one of you are elected to do a job. If you don’t want to do, get out. Somebody else
will come in. We’ll elect somebody else. And we can put you out if you don’t behave. Thank you.”
Mayor Owens recognized Mrs. Pearl Riley to speak. Mrs. Riley stated, “Good evening. My name is
Pearl Riley. Yes, I’m nervous and I agree with the lady who from, … I’m sorry. I live at 619 Senn
Street, West Columbia. I’ve been there, in that residence for 31 years. I’m a life-long resident of
West Columbia. I’m 70 years old and I agree with the lady from Westover Acres and the other
people. Stop acting like a bunch of children and get some stuff done. In our neighborhood we have
five houses dilapidated. The landlord don’t care about it, but we’re getting things done. Don’t walk
around here, somebody says something you don’t like it. Go to that person. Don’t stir up mess. I am
tired of mess. You were elected to do a job. Why is it where we live the streets are cracked. That’s
in Saluda Park. The streets are cracked. When it rains if I could use my cane I could (unintelligible)
see where there is water. There’s houses there that need to be repaired. There’s drug activity. And
we need to have something done about it. I might get a whiplash now, but you know right at this
time I don’t care. I am just tired of living here like that. In 2000, I think four or five, I gave my dogs
up and people started crossing my fence. I live at the end of Senn Street on Double Branch and they
was coming through my fence , stepping over it with me even putting a No Trespassing sign up.
They went over it anyway. My son took the half a gate from the front and put it to the back. They
stole the gate. I’ve complained and nothing happened. Put it on paper. Didn’t see a thing. Come
January 23 when we had our homeowners meeting, I wasn’t aware of the meeting. I thought just a
little paper whatever. But that time my daughter read it to us and said, ‘Momma, this is about a
homeowners’ meeting.’ I said of course I’ll go. So my niece, LaTonya Matthews, picked me up and
we went there on B Avenue. And we had a wonderful meeting. We had things accomplished. Now
we’ve started every other Saturday picking up trash. But when Mayor Joe Owens was there and
Mayor Pro-Tem (Hallman), Council Member Wingard, I ‘m not sure, and Officer Andrews. We were
talking about the things that was going on in our community. The mayor said this is the meeting I’ve
seen. What else do y’all need? And our chairperson of the neighborhood community, Mrs. Tracy
Sandle, she said, ‘Mrs. Riley is legally blind and people are going through her yard as a shortcut.
And we continued to talk. Mayor Joe Owens said, ‘Mrs. Riley, I’m here with the mayor pro-tem and
another council man and I’m pretty sure we’ll vote and we’ll get your fence put up.’ And yes they
did it in 34 days. I can rest now. I don’t have to worry about people walking behind my house or
coming over the fence because I live alone. And I thank God for everybody that’s helped me. And
you all please grow up. You need to grow up. There’s (unintelligible) that need to be done.”
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
April 1, 2014
Page Eight
Agenda Item V – Announcements by Mayor (continued)
Mrs. Riley continued, “I was just telling this man, you were elected. Take care of your district. If
you don’t know what’s going on in there, find out if you have a home owners’ association. Talk to
the people in your district. Ask them what they needs instead of sitting back there and arguing like a
bunch of kids in kindergarten. Thank you.
Mayor Owens recognized Ms. Tracy Sandle. Ms. Sandle stated, “Good evening, mayor, city council
representatives. My name is Tracy Sandle and I reside at 1357 Gilmore Drive. I came up here to say
two things. It could be more, but I’m going to start out with two, is that the representation that was
presented from my last meeting, it was a disgrace for everyone for the city of West Columbia. Each
one of you were elected, and this has been said more than one time this evening, for your district, to
support your district and work for your district. But the behavior that is displayed to me is working
against the district and against this entire city. Now if you guys feel that you can vote the mayor out
then we as the constituents should be able to vote each and every one of you out. Because if you’re
not here to work with him, with us and for us, then what is your purpose in being up here? I asked
the question at the meeting and it was never answered. Because if there was a problem with how
Mayor Owens presided in the two years, you are all adults, you should have gone to him and talked to
him, man to man. It is clear that that was not done. But once again, we’re not beating you up
Councilman Miles, but as I stated when I asked the question twice, why did it take you to be there
for four months to be their advocate? No one never answered my question and I would like an
answer tonight. If there was not an issue with him before, why is there now?” Mrs. Sandle paused
and waited, then said, “And I’m still not getting any type of response. I know that when we call on
Mayor Owens, he is there. He says he’ll get back with you, that’s what he does. And it needs to stay
as such. No power should be taken from him if you don’t want it taken from yourself. Thank you.”
Mayor Owens recognized Ms. Ann Percy. Ms. Percy stated, “I said I wasn’t going to do this. My
name is Ann Percy, 116 Hammonds Hill Drive, West Columbia, 29169. Everything that the people
have commented before is very true and we all most of us agree. And Tracy, I’m going to answer
your question that you’ve asked three times now. I’m not going to call the name of the council
member, but you know who you are. I had a phone conversation with one of these council members
before the first vote to remove Mayor Owens. I wish you’d look at me when I’m talking to you. And
I asked him, I said, ‘You know, I don’t understand this. Mayor Owens has been nothing but super
and just works for West Columbia, works for all of us. And this person told me with my … I wish I
had a Bible, but I’ll raise my hand to God Almighty, this man said they’re tired of the way the mayor
talks down to them. Listen, Joe is rough as a cob, but he comes straight down the middle of the road
and he tells it like it is. And I don’t understand. It’s a vendetta to get Joe out of that chair. Now,
Tem (Miles) I don’t you, you’re new. Teddy (Wingard), I’ll vote for anything. Mr. Parler, I told you
earlier I have a lot of respect for you. BJ (Unthank), I had a lot of respect for you, but I was very
disappointed with the comment about you not returning calls and I’ve been hearing that on the street.
Joe, I think you are wonderful. You’re doing a great job. Sir (Council Member Fowler), you’ve
always been good. Mr. Jones, I’m not real sure. I don’t know. I don’t understand why council
members sue each other. Why can’t you talk to each other. I don’t know what the situation is, but
it’s an embarrassment to the city and I wish y’all could work things out. Holy Cow! What can I say
about the pretty lady on the council? She, she works so hard for my area, I just can’t believe it. And
I’m just tired of all this bickering and stuff. How are we ever going to get anything done? And I
might get shot at this tonight, but I have a question for you Chief Tyndall, please. Is it Okay that I
ask him a question?” Mayor Owens responded, “Sure.”
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
April 1, 2014
Page Nine
Agenda Item V – Announcements by Mayor (continued)
Ms. Percy continued, “When we had our last, the special council meeting a couple of weeks ago and I
specially talked to you and I said, … I knew there we re going to be some changes made in the police
department, … and I said, ‘I certainly hope that you’re not going to do anything with Matt Edwards
or Shane Phillips. They make you look good. They make the city look good.’ Any kind of meeting
in West Columbia, those two gentlemen are there representing the city and the police department and
I don’t quite understand why we don’t have a major’s position in headquarters. I just don’t
understand. There’s been so many changes, and I just thought, ‘Wow, what is happening to our
city?’ We’ve got such a shakeup in our police department. Our council are embarrassing us on TV.
I have friends in North Carolina that called me and say what in the world, matter of fact, a police
officer that has family in another state, their family called down here. What in the world is going on
in the city of West Columbia? Please for heaven’s sake, let’s all grow up and work together. Please.
And Joe, I will support you to the end. You are my mayor and our mayor. Thank you.
Mayor Owen stated, “I appreciate the kind remarks. And I’m going to tell you now. I’ve got a lot of
things on my plate that I can’t do anything with this stuff hanging over my head. I met with a realtor
Sunday, and I told him things were in flux and I didn’t know exactly what we’re at. I told him I had
an attorney general’s opinion that I think means everything in the world.”
Mayor Owens recognized Mrs. Debbie Owens to speak. Mrs. Owens stated, “My name is Debbie
Owens. I live at 188 Inview Road in West Columbia. As all of you probably know I’m the mayor’s
wife. He’s my husband. I love him. He’s your mayor. The problem that I have is that nothing is
getting done in the city. I don’t know you, Tem (Miles). I got to know you during the campaigning.
Instantly bonded. Just like I did with Abby (Bray). I have a lot of respect for Tommy. Billy Joe, BJ
(Unthank), we go way back. I love your mom and dad. I’ve always thought a lot of you. Eric
(Fowler), it goes without saying. You know, we have history. Mr. Jones, I don’t know what’s going
on, but that’s for another meeting. Casey (Hallman), you’re a godsend and that’s why you were
elected mayor pro-tem, cause you go that extra mile. We’re here today to take another vote. I
happen to know that he’s got the AG’s opinion. I know it’s positive, but I guess that wasn’t good
enough either. The man’s got pneumonia. He’s sitting up here for these people that are sitting out in
the crowd. He’s supposed to go into the hospital and I don’t mind saying that I went against the
doctor and my daughter because it was important for him to sit here and represent the people that
elected him. You guys need to get back to business. We’ve got properties that need to be worked on.
That young lady was talking about the dilapidated houses. There are things that need to be done in
the city. You can’t keep going like this. I know that the vote is being planned again because he (Tem
Miles) called my husband again and told him to step down. You can’t do this, guys. The people
elected him.. I went to 1100 houses. I elected him because I believe he’s a man of compassion. Is he
vocal? Is he strong at times with his words? Yes. Did he embarrass you at a meeting? Yes. And
when he got home, ashamed, and he apologized to everybody. I know things get out of hand, but you
guys are grown people and we’re supposed to be working for the city, not for somebody’s individual
agenda. Joe has never been more than transparent. Is he here all the time? Yes. Big Whoop. He
was here making really good money till he retired to take this job because that’s what he wanted to
do. Bucket list before he died. And I didn’t think that if everybody has a chance to live their dream,
my husband is living his. But this is not exactly what he expected. You guys are better than this.
Take the high road. Listen to the citizens. We want you guys to get back to business. Like Tracy
(Sandle) said so eloquently at the last meeting and again, if there were problems it should have been
in the confines, discussed in the confines, where we didn’t see it all.”
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
April 1, 2014
Page Ten
Agenda Item V – Announcements by Mayor (continued)
Mrs. Owens continued, “This is not good for West Columbia. I’m a nurse. I work in Columbia. I’ve
got people coming to me, asking me questions that I don’t want to discuss with them, because I love
West Columbia. If I didn’t, I wouldn’t have worked so hard to get him elected. I wouldn’t have
watched our bank account go pssssssst. You know, because it meant that much. But that man that I
love, the mayor that you love, to live his dream. Is he brash at times? Yeah. But you know what?
I’ve always known which direction my husband was coming from whether he was my husband or he
was talking to me as a mayor. I pray. I pray that this council will take the right vote tonight. Put this
to bed. Let’s get back to city business. Let’s quit embarrassing our city that all of you say you love
so much. Isn’t that the reason you ran? Because you wanted to do something good? Well you have
a chance to do something tonight. Thank you.”
Mayor Owens recognized Mr. Jimmy Brooks. Mr. Brooks stated, “My name is Jimmy Brooks. I live
at 3409 Henbet Drive. I’m going to be honest with you. We had never been to a council meeting
before the last meeting.” Mayor Owens responded, “Well, I’m sorry you’ve seen what you’ve seen.”
Mr. Brooks stated, “Well, we obviously have some issues. And we came to the last meeting because
we wanted to support Matt Edwards who is a good friend of ours. Went to high school with me and I
would just tell you a couple things, then I want to address you with a couple things. But, we got a
great city. We’ve got a city that we chose to come back to live in after we went and lived in
Lexington for 10 years. A city that we chose, me and my wife have chose to be committed to. Two
weeks ago we bought a lot in our same subdivision to build again on. So it’s a city we want to be in.
I think everybody out here wants to be in this city or we would’ve moved away by now. We
would’ve moved away for a lot of different reasons. It’s a school district we believe in. A school
district my wife teaches in. We believe in this school district. Like I said, I came up through our
schools here. My question to you guys, before I make a statement, is who are we now having in our
schools from our police department? Who are we calling now when we have an issue? I noticed on
the website there is no number for our chief. The number we had was for Matt (Edwards). Who are
we calling now? I would like to know that for the safety of our community. Simple question I hope
somebody can address that.” Mayor Owens said, “(unintelligible) The day after the shooting I was
getting ready to call Matt to get his people, reserve officers in the school, SRO. He already had them
there. I was going to call you and tell you that.” Mr. Brooks stated, “Well, I think he did a great job
and I think, …” Mayor Owens stat ed, “That’s going above and beyond. He’s a great officer, a great
guy.” Mr. Brooks responded, “I think it’s somebody you guys need to step in and I think that‘s
something tomorrow morning you guys need to be here and you’ll need to make that change to put
Matt back in. I think this community deserves him in here. And I think we deserve this
(unintelligible) because he was in our schools. And when you go ask our kids, go, go ask the kids in
our school who they look at when they look at our police department and they’ll say Matt. And if
I’m wrong about that, tell me I’m wrong about that. I have nothing against our police chief at all.
What I do know is Matt is who we look for our police when we moved to West Columbia. And what
ever happened, happened, whatever happened, but I think a lot of this has to do with that. Y’all can
tell me I’m wrong if you want to, but I think all lot of that has to do with that whole situation. My
comment for you, Mr. Miles, is this: Abby Bray (former council member for District 4) was a mentor
to me. Abby Bray was somebody when I was at BC (Brookland-Cayce High School) that came in
when I was either a sophomore or junior and coached me and made me one of the men I am today.
You have embarrassed his seat with what you’ve done the last couple of days. And if he was here,
this would not be going on.” (The cassette tape on Tape One, Side A ran out at this time.)
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
April 1, 2014
Page Eleven
Agenda Item V – Announcements by Mayor (continued)
Mayor Owens recognized Mrs. Johnie Stoney. Mrs. Stoney stated, “My name is Johnie Story and I
live at 106 Garden Trail in Lexington. I am Matt Edwards’ mother-in-law. I am upset about what’s
going on and what’s happened to Matt. I was brought up to say good things about people. So many
people asked me after the last meeting who is the chief of police. While council was in executive
session voting on extending the contract, you told me something that was not true. Matt has to come
to his grievance tomorrow. Why can’t you do some research and get to the bottom of it.” Mayor
Owens said, “I did not know Matt very well when I came on board. Anytime I called up the police
department, he was always there.”
Mayor Owens recognized Matt Edwards. Mr. Edward s stated, “I live at 1020 Riverstone Court. I
have asked for a public hearing at 9:30 a.m. tomorrow. I am here to support the mayor as a citizen.
No matter what happens tomorrow I will support the police department. Those guys at the back of
the room are the best.”
Mayor Owens recognized Mr. Billy Pittman. Mr. Pittman stated, “I am Billy Pittman and I live at
1033 Riverstone Court. Mayor Joe, I voted for you. After seeing the last meeting, I know I voted
correctly. He’s the Mayor and you need to work with him. He needs to work with you.”
Mayor Owens recognized Mrs. Pearl Riley. Mrs. Riley said, “I live on Senn Street. Matt Edwards
played baseball with my sons. Council, you need to pick your battles. His (Matt Edwards) family
has been displaced by all this bickering. Do what’s right. Matt’s always been there for us. You guys
quit with your bickering and move ahead.
Mayor Owens stated, “For two years I tried to keep this city out of the news. I had people call me
about the shooting on Leaphart Street and what’s going on in Chapin (Town of Chapin). If you’re
not passionate about what you’re doing then you’re not worth a darn.”
Mayor Owens recognized Mrs. Kathy Rish. Mrs. Ri sh stated, “I live at 1420 Redwood Drive. Many
of you know me. And this city is near and dear to my heart. I’m proud of the city, but I’m
embarrassed by the last meeting. I’m here to support Matt Edwards who is married to my niece.
He’s been here at the city 15 years and thousands of dollars have been spent on training him. He
needs to come back. I support the city and the police department. I know what it takes to do this job.
My husband (Mac Rish) was mayor for 12 years. Thank you.”
Mayor Owens recognized Mr. Joe Owens. Mr. Owe ns said, “I am Joe’s (Mayor Owens) son and I
drove down from Charlotte to be at the meeting. This is all over Facebook and on the news. No one
is harder on himself than my dad. Not a person here doesn’t know what my dad is like. There are
personal vendettas here. He is an honest, ethical person. I pray you can get beyond this. People are
calling me up about this. This city is getting a bad reputation even in Charlotte.”
Mayor Owens recognized Mr. Gethro Perez. Mr. Pe rez said, “I live at 1518 Holmes Street. All I
want to say is I am 38 years old and this is the future of West Columbia. I’m not planning to go
anywhere. Someone asked the question last night, ‘Why is it that older people are acting like
children?’ As the Bible says when a child act like a child, when a man then act like a man. West
Columbia’s got young people looking at how you behave. If you think this won’t hurt you it will.
Not one business will come here. Someone will ask you why you’re acting like this.”
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
April 1, 2014
Page Twelve
Agenda Item V – Announcements by Mayor (continued)
Mr. Perez continued, “The young people are talking on Facebook and Twitter. People refuse to stand
by and watch this going on. If you thinking you gonna do this and it not come back to hit you, think
again. Can you finally get along? You need to be doing the people’s work. Say a prayer to take
away the malice. If you can do this, then the city can go forward.”
Mayor Owens recognized Mr. Larry Drawdy, who stated, “I’m Larry Drawdy and I live at 2300
Robin Crest Drive. I had an issue many years ago. I had a problem with zoning, but it was taken
care of by the city. I want to talk about Matt Edwards. When I first met Matt I didn’t like him. The
next year my sons played ball with him and I learned that Matt is a team player. His concern is with
kids. If he has a weak player he works with that child. Matt’s been a teacher and a coach. I know
Matt’s character and he is a good officer. I don’t have to worry about my house being safe. I
encourage you to take into consideration the type of guy he is.”
At 7:21 p.m. Mayor Owens gave Council Member Eric Fowler permission to leave the room for
several minutes. He returned at 7:25 p.m.
Mayor Owens recognized Ms. Karen Hoover, who said, “I live at 1027 Rutland Avenue. I‘ve been
before this council many times. Abby Bray was one of my best friends. I went to school with Teddy
(Wingard). Joe (Owens) helped my mother. I’ve watched you vote against each other rather than
what is in front of you. Joe has been a wonderful friend and a wonderful mayor.”
Mayor Owens said, “Mac Rish asked me to come off council to take over the utilities of the city.
Everyone here who knows me knows I have nothing in my heart but love for this city. I have two
lawyers and an attorney general on my side. I’d like for it to die right here. I know all of you support
me.”
Agenda Item VI – Unfinished Business
A. Mayor Owens entertained a motion for second reading consideration of the Planning Commission’s
recommendation to establish the zoning classification of recently annexed property located next to
1138 Brookwood Circle (TMS# 005717-01-014) as R-4 (low-density residential). Council Member
Harley so moved and Mayor Pro-Tem Hallman seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
B. Mayor Owens entertained a motion for first reading consideration of the Planning Commission’s
recommendation to change the zoning classification of 433 Center Street (TMS# 004639-05-014) from
R-1 (high-density residential) to C-2 (general commercial). Council Member Parler so moved and
Council Member Miles seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
C. Mayor Owens recognized Council Member Miles who made a motion to postpone indefinitely
Agenda Item C., the proposed amendment to Section 1-2-5, Mayor Pro-Tem. Council Member
Harley seconded the motion. Council Member Miles stated he did not have any intention to go
forward with the amendment to the city code regarding the term of office for the mayor pro-tem.
Mayor Owens called for a vote which passed unanimously.
D. Mayor Owens entertained a motion for second reading consideration of proposed changes to Section
1-3-3, Quorum and Rules of Order, of the West Columbia Code of Ordinances. Council Member
Miles asked City Clerk Mardi Valentino to read substituted text for the proposed changes.
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
April 1, 2014
Page Thirteen
Agenda Item VI – Unfinished Business (continued)
City Clerk Valentino read the following text:
(a) A majority of the council memb ers serving shall constitute a quorum for the conduct of
business at any meeting. Except as otherwis e required by state law or ordinance, all
proceedings of council shall be governed by Robert’s Rules of Order. The Chairperson
shall preside, except that in the absence of the Chairperson, the members present shall
elect a temporary presiding member to serve until such absence ends.
(b) The council shall annually, at the first regular council mee ting in December, elect as
provided by the terms herein, one (1) of its members as Chairperson for a term of one
(1) year. Said term of one (1) year shall run from the first regular meeting in December
of each year to the first regular meeting in December one (1) year hence.
(c) Upon second reading of the amended version of this ordinance, whereby the position of
Chairperson is created, a vote of the counc il members for the purpose of electing the
initial Chairperson shall be noticed and sc heduled to occur imme diately prior to the
beginning of the next council meeting, regardle ss of whether such meeting is a regular
or special meeting. The initial term of the first elected Chairperson shall run from the
date of such election until the first regular council meeting in December 2014.
Following completion of the initial term of the first Chairperson, successive elections
and terms of the Chairperson shall be as provided in Subsection (b) above.
Council Member Miles made a motion to amend the proposed changes to the West Columbia City
Code 1-3-3, Quorum and Rules of Order, by striking in its entirety and replacing with the substituted
insert as read by the city clerk. Council Member Harley seconded. Mayor Owens called for a vote.
Council Members Harley, Jones, Unthank, Parler and Miles voted in favor of the motion. Mayor
Owens, Mayor Pro-Tem Hallman and Council Members Fowler and Wingard voted in opposition.
The motion passed five votes to four votes. Council Member Miles stated, “For the record, I make
expressly clear that I will not offer for or accept the position of chairperson.” Mayor Owens stated,
“This is removing me from my duties as mayor.”
Council Member Miles stated that the council must now adopt the main motion for the proposed
changes to the ordinance with the amended text. Council Member Harley seconded the motion.
Council Members Harley, Jones, Unthank, Parler and Miles voted in favor of the motion. Mayor
Owens, Mayor Pro-Tem Hallman and Council Members Fowler and Wingard voted in opposition.
The motion passed five votes to four votes.
E. Mayor Owens entertained a motion for seconded reading consideration of proposed changes to Section
1-3-8, Committees, of the West Columbia Code of Ordinances. Council Member Miles made a motion
to adopt the changes and Council Member Harley seconded. Council Members Harley, Jones, Fowler,
Unthank, Parler and Miles voted in favor of the motion. Mayor Owens, Mayor Pro-Tem Hallman and
Council Member Wingard voted in opposition. The motion passed six votes to three votes.
F. Mayor Owens entertained a motion to for second reading consideration of proposed changes to
Section 1-4-6, City Administrator, of the West Columbia Code of Ordinances. Council Member Miles
so moved and Council Member Parler seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
April 1, 2014
Page Fourteen
Agenda Item VII – New Ordinances and Resolutions
A. Mayor Owens entertained a motion for consideration of an agreement for professional engineering
services for the Rainbow Drive utility relocations. Council Member Unthank so moved and Council
Member Jones seconded. Mayor Owens recognized City Engineer Sid Varn who explained that the
SC Department of Transportation is proposing a new right-of-way at Rainbow Drive which requires
the city to relocate 1,300 linear feet of 12-inch water line and 1,700 linear feet of six-inch of water
line, 200 linear feet of two-inch water line and the adjustment of one sanitary sewer manhole. He
recommended that council approve ICA Engineering, Inc. to provide the engineering services for the
project, which includes survey, construction bidding and documents assistance, design and
construction plan development for the relocation and project management and part-time construction
observation. He said as part of the contract price of $21,600.00, ICA would also provide as-built
drawings from the contractor’s survey. Mayor Owens called for a vote and the motion passed
unanimously.
B. Mayor Owens entertained a motion for consideration of an agreement for professional engineering
services for the Saluda River Drive bridge crossing relocations. Council Member Harley so moved
and Council Member Miles seconded. Mayor Owens recognized City Engineer Sid Varn who
explained that the SC Department of Transportation is proposing to replace the bridge on Saluda River
Drive, which requires the city to relocate approximately 200 linear feet of 6-inch water line attached to
the bridge crossing. The project calls for a temporary water line to provide continuous service to
residents as well as the final waterline. He recommended that council approve ICA Engineering, Inc.
to provide the engineering services for the project, which includes survey, construction bidding and
documents assistance, structural design, design and construction plan development for the relocation,
project permitting and project management and part-time construction observation. He said as part of
the contract price of $12,000.00, ICA would also provide as-built drawings from the contractor’s
survey. Mayor Owens called for a vote and the motion passed unanimously.
Agenda Item VII – Adjourn
Mayor Owens entertained a motion to adjourn. Council Member Unthank so moved and Council Member
Miles seconded. The motion passed unanimously. Council adjourned at 8:14 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Marta M. Valentino, CMC
City Clerk/Public Information Officer
Source: City of West Columbia website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.