Regular Council Meeting Minutes
City of West Columbia · Lexington County · meeting of Nov 21, 2014 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of West Columbia
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
City of West Columbia, SC
Regular Council Meeting
May 6, 2014 at 6 p.m.
Members Present: Members Absent:
Joe Owens, Mayor None
Casey Jordan Hallman, Mayor Pro-Tem
Eric L. Fowler
L. Dale Harley
Boyd Jones
Temus C. “Tem” Miles, Jr.
Tommy G. Parler
B.J. Unthank
Teddy Wingard
Others Present:
Myron Corley, Deputy City Administrator Wyatt Coleman, Fire Chief
Mardi Valentino, City Clerk/PIO Bria n Carter, Assistant City Administrator
Sid Varn, Director of Planning and Engineering Ken Ebener, Municipal Judge
Anna Huffman, IT Administrator Rick Hodge, City Treasurer
Dennis Tyndall, Police Chief Jamie Hook, Sanitation/Streets Superintendent
Marquis Solomon, Fire Battalion Chief Stuart Jones, Building Official
Donna Smith, Director of Economic Development Charles Garren, Public Works Director
Shane Phillips, Police Captain Justin Black, Staff Accountant
Members of the Public and Press
Agenda Item I – Call to Order
Chairperson BJ Unthank called the meeting to order at 6 p.m. The State , Free Times, Lexington County
Chronicle, Cayce-West Columbia News , The Columbia Star, COLADaily.com and radio and television
stations were notified of the meeting by e-mail on May 2, 2014. A revised agenda was published on May 5,
2014.
Agenda Item II – Determination of Quorum
Chairperson Unthank noted a quorum was present to conduct business. Council Member Parler gave the
invocation followed by the Pledge of Allegiance.
Agenda Item III – Approval of Minutes
A. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion to approve the minutes for the special council meeting
held March 17, 2014. Council Member Parler so moved and Council Member Harley seconded. The
motion passed unanimously.
B. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion to approve the minutes for the regular council meeting
held April 1, 2014. Council Member Harley so moved and Council Member Miles seconded. The
motion passed unanimously.
C. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion to approve the special council meeting held April 14,
2014. Council Member Parler so moved and Council Member Harley seconded. The motion passed
unanimously.
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
May 6, 2014
Page Two
Agenda Item IV – Announcements by Mayor
A. Chairperson Unthank recognized Fire Chief Wyatt Coleman who introduced Marquis Solomon, the
newly hired fire battalion chief. Chief Colman said Chief Solomon comes to the city with a lot of
experience and excellent qualifications. Chief Solomon will undertake an administrative role at the
department that will include fire training and evaluation of policies and procedures.
Agenda Item V – Citizens’ Requests for Appearance
A. Chairperson Unthank recognized Mr. Jimmy Brooks, who stated he lives at 3409 Henbet Drive in
West Columbia. Mr. Brooks explained that during the Quail Ridge Homeowners Association
meeting last week a concern arose regarding South Carolina Electric & Gas Company (SCE&G)
constructing a substation along a right of way formerly owned by Southeastern Freight Lines. Mr.
Brooks said about 16 acres of trees have been cut down and the removal of the trees which buffered
road noise from Interstate 20 has negatively impacted the neighborhood.
Chairperson Unthank recognized Deputy City Administrator Myron Corley who said discussions
with SCE&G resulted in construction work not being done on Saturday. He stated he would attempt
to set up a meeting with a neighborhood representative and SCE&G to discuss noise abatement and
replanting trees. He said erecting an eight-foot fence as a barrier would not be sufficient to reduce
the road noise and hopefully further discussions would bring some resolution.
Mr. Brooks also stated that due to the issues between some council members and the mayor, a
petition that calls for changing to the mayor and council form of government is being circulated
among citizens by an organization called West Columbia Voice. Mr. Brooks said that Mayor Owens
should have his presiding officer powers restored to him since by tradition the mayor presides over
council meetings. He said that people are hearing that city employees are being told to not talk to the
mayor.
B. Chairperson Unthank recognized Ms. Karen Hoover who said she lives at 1027 Rutland Avenue in
West Columbia. Ms. Hoover introduced her accountant, Mr. Floyd Harper, who stated he resides at
1801 Saluda River Drive and owns a tax business in Five Points in Columbia. Ms. Hoover stated that
over two months ago she wrote a letter to the city council regarding what had transpired over the
purchase of city property at 351 Meeting Street and how she had entered into an agreement with the
city to buy the property. She explained that unbeknownst to her there was an attempt to take the
property away from her and she had to hire an attorney to defend herself. She said council demanded
that she close on the property in five days and to have the funds within five days she had to take
money out of her IRA account. After council met a third time on the sale of the property she tried to
reinstate her request for a business loan through the Small Business Administration but was turned
down. She was forced to buy the property with her IRA funds. She said Mr. Harper could explain
the tax penalties she incurred and the extra costs associated with purchasing the property due to
deadlines imposed by the city. She said that should never have happened. The purchase of the
property was approved by council with the proper readings. She made the proposal to purchase in
July and got the contract at the end of October. She found out January 7th that Council Member
Unthank was trying to unwind everything that was done. She requested reimbursement of the tax
penalty fees. Chairperson Unthank stated that he did regret the issue which she had incurred, which
certainly was unfortunate.
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
May 6, 2014
Page Three
Agenda Item V – Citizens’ Requests for Appearance (continued)
Chairperson Unthank recognized Council Member Mi les who said when he first got involved with
council, there was a contract between Ms. Hoover and the city to purchase the property at the corner
of Meeting and State Streets. He said when he reviewed the contract it had expired due to a lapse of
time. Council held a council meeting at which time the city made clear that the city administrator had
assured Ms. Hoover that additional time would be given. Council Member Miles said this was
determined during an executive session for a contractual matter. He said he insisted that whether or
not the city had a legal obligation, that the city had a moral obligation because assurances were given
to Ms. Hoover she had additional time to purchase the property and the city should not declare the
contract void. He said in that same meeting council members asked Mayor Owens to contact her to
find out how long she needed to close on the property. Council Member Miles said the mayor left the
room to discuss the issue with Ms. Hoover. When he returned he made representations that Ms.
Hoover was ready to close on the property the next morning. He said based on that information he
asked to extend the contract five days which was more time than Ms. Hoover asked. He said if Ms.
Hoover had asked for more time then he would have lobbied to get her time extended. It was his
understanding that she told the mayor she was ready to close the next morning. Council Member
Miles said he was not party to the conversation between the mayor and Ms. Hoover and he could not
say if it ever occurred. He asked Ms. Hoover to say whether or not she had spoken with the mayor
the night of that meeting and if so had she made any representations that she was ready, willing and
able to close the next morning.
Mayor Owens said everyone on council knew that he was sent out to Ms. Hoover to give her an
ultimatum to close in five days or the contract would be null and void. Mayor Owens said he asked
Ms. Hoover if she could close in five days because that was what council was going to give her. Ms.
Hoover responded that she had asked Mayor Owens if she was going to lose the property and that
Mayor Owens had told her yes. She said she told Mayor Owens she could not get an SBA loan in
five days, which was why she had asked for an extension.
Council Member Miles asked by a s how of hands for council to identify if their recollections were
like his recollection or the mayor’s recollection of the matter. Ms. Hoover asked why was the
contract was back on the table after it had been approved to sell the property to her. Council Member
Miles said she had not closed on the property. Council was notifying her that the contract according
to its terms had expired and council was giving her additional time. Ms. Hoover said she was not
notified that the contract had expired. She had called her council member, Mr. Parler, to find out
what was going on with the contract. She said Mr. Parler told her that Council Member Unthank had
said since she had not bought the property she apparently was no longer interested. Chairperson
Unthank stated the city’s attorney had advised council the city no longer had any obligation to sell the
property because the contract had expired. He noted that Ms. Hoover was getting the property at a
$50,000.00 discount. He said the citizens of West Columbia paid $150,000.00 for the property and
she was purchasing the property for $100,000. He said if Ms. Hoover had bought the property from
the original owner then she would have paid $150,000.00. Ms. Hoover said the original owner paid
$80,000.00 for the property so the city overpaid for the property. Chairperson Unthank said it was
regrettable that Ms. Hoover had incurred a loss, but the city was not under any responsibility as to
how Ms. Hoover financed the purchase. The city did not know what Ms. Hoover was doing to
purchase the property and it was done of her own free will. He said it was the consensus of the city
council to not reimburse Ms. Hoover for any fees or costs associated with financing the purchase of
the property.
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
May 6, 2014
Page Four
Agenda Item VI – Adjourn to Executive Session to Discuss a Legal Matter Regarding a Lawsuit, a Contractual
Matter Concerning City Property, a Personnel Matter Concerning an Employee and a
Personnel Matter Concerning an Appointments to Boards and Commissions
Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion to adjourn to executive session. Council Member Miles so
moved and Council Member Wingard seconded. The motion passed unanimously. Council adjourned to
executive session at 6:25 p.m.
Agenda Item VII – Reconvene to Regular Session
Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion to adjourn executive session and reconvene to regular session.
Council Member Harley so moved and Council Member Miles seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
Council reconvened to regular session at 8:34 p.m. Chairperson Unthank stated that no action was taken in
executive session.
Agenda Item VIII – New Ordinances and Resolutions
A. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for first reading consideration of the Planning
Commission’s recommendation to establish the zoning classification of recently annexed property
located next to 1722 Crapps Avenue (TMS# 004636-04-022) as R-3 (low density residential).
Council Member Miles so moved and Council Member Parler seconded. The motion passed
unanimously.
B. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for first reading consideration of the Planning
Commission’s recommendation to change the zoning classification of 136 Sunset Boulevard (TMS#
004660-02-005) from C-2/GOLD (general commercial/Gateway Overlay District) to C-3 GOLD
(restricted commercial/Gateway Overlay District). Council Member Harley so moved and Council
Member Wingard seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
C. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for consideration of a resolution to recognize the late Mr.
Charlie Dallas Butler, a long-time member of the West Columbia community. Council Member
Fowler so moved and Council Member Parler seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
D. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for consideration of a proclamation to designate the week
of May 18-24, 2014 as National Public Works Week. Council Member Parler so moved and Mayor
Pro-Tem Hallman seconded. Chairperson Unthank recognized Public Works Director Charles
Garren who said the proclamation was an annual national effort to recognize and commend the
outstanding effort of public works employees. The motion passed unanimously.
E. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for consideration of a proclamation to designate May 15,
2014 as Peace Officers’ Memorial Day. Council Member Fowler so moved and Council Member
Parler seconded. Chairperson Unthank recognized Police Chief Dennis Tyndall who explained that
Peace Officers’ Memorial Day was first designated by President John F. Kennedy to honor the
memory of police officers who were slain in the line of duty. He said a memorial service would be
held at the Police Officers’ Memorial on the grounds of the Lexington County Courthouse.
Chairperson Unthank called for the vote which passed unanimously.
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
May 6, 2014
Page Five
Agenda Item VIII – New Ordinances and Resolutions (continued)
F. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for consideration of a an agreement with American
Engineering Consultants, Inc. to provide engineering services for the replacement of the brine tank at
the Lake Murray Water Treatment Plant. Council Member Fowler so moved and Council Member
Jones seconded. Chairperson Unthank recognized Mr. Sid Varn, Director of Planning &
Engineering. Mr. Varn explained that the brine tank at the Lake Murray Water Treatment Plant that
holds the salt used in the Miox disinfectant system needs to be replaced. The projects would consist
of replacing the tank, piping, valves and electrical wiring. The agreement with American
Engineering Consultants, Inc. allows for necessary design services and construction observation in an
amount not to exceed $18,000.00, which is estimated at 12 percent of the final construction cost of
the project. Chairperson Unthank called for the vote with passed unanimously.
G. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for consideration of recommendations by the
Accommodations Tax Committee. Council Member Harley so moved and Council Member Jones
seconded. Chairperson Unthank recognized Ms. Donna Smith, Director of Economic Development.
Ms. Smith stated the West Columbia Accommodations Tax Committee met on Tuesday, April 29,
2014 to consider qualified applications for the distribution of Accommodation Tax Funds. She said
the total amount requested was $60,500; however, the amount of funds available for distribution to
qualified projects was $30,675.
Ms. Smith stated that after re viewing the submitted applications and hearing comments by those
applicants present, the Committee unanimously approved recommending funding the following
applicants in the amounts listed:
West Metro Visitors Center $10,000
Riverbanks Zoo & Garden: $ 8,000
River Alliance/Tartan Day South: $ 5,000
EdVenture Children’s Museum: $ 4,675
Lexington County Recreation & Aging (USTA Championships) $ 3,000
Total: $30,675
Ms. Smith said to the best of the Committee’s knowledge, the recommended projects met all
regulations under Chapter 4 of Title 6 of the South Carolina Code of Laws. She requested that
council approve the recommended funding distribution. Chairperson Unthank called for the vote
which passed unanimously.
H. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for consideration of reappointing the following members
to the West Columbia Planning Commission for four-year terms ending in May 2018: Larry Miller,
William S. “Bill” Mooneyhan, Sr., Harold Prater, and Heyward D. Wessinger. Mayor Owens so
moved and Council Member Fowler seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
I. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for consideration of reappointing the following members
to the West Columbia Zoning Board of Appeals for three-year terms ending in May 2017: Julie
Huffman and Marion Galloway. Mayor Owens so moved and Council Member Fowler seconded.
The motion passed unanimously.
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
May 6, 2014
Page Six
J. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for consideration of appointing Ms. Faye Hutto and Mr.
Ryan Whittaker to the West Columbia Beautification Foundation. Council Member Jones so moved
and Council Member Parler seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
K. Chairperson Unthank recognized Sid Varn, Director of Planning and Engineering, who explained that
he has been working since 2004 to bring water to residents in Big Timber Subdivision, which is
located off Cromer Road by Oak Drive in the Oak Grove Area. He said that the project has been in
development for 10 years. Most people live on large lots with wells and septic tanks. At one point
the city had worked out a design to make water available to the residents, but when it came time to
pay the taps fees to connect to the water line the people backed out of the project. He was contacted
by three residents of the subdivision, George Dubose, Randy Senn and Carl Hawkins, who requested
that the city engage in cost participation to bring water to their properties by accepting one of two
proposals. The first proposal is to reduce the out-of-city tap fee from $2,000 to $1,000 and they pay
in-city water rates. The second proposal would be to waive the tap fee entirely and they pay out-of
city water rates. Mr. Varn said he was presenting the request from five property owners in the
subdivision.
Chairperson Unthank said he was not familiar with council ever reducing taps fees. Mayor Owens
stated that the city’s bond ordinance does not allow reductions in taps fees. He said to reduce the fees
the city would have to pass an ordinance and get the bond underwriters to approve it, which is very
unlikely. Mr. Varn said he did not recommend charging in-city rates to out-of-city water customers
because a precedent would be set by council. He said the tap fees are supposed to go toward paying
for replacing old lines like the current project in Springdale and for capacity in the water plant so the
city could have water available for customers.
Chairperson Unthank recognized Council Member Mi les who made a motion to deny the request.
Mayor Owens seconded the motion, which passed unanimously.
L. Chairperson Unthank recognized Council Member Dale Harley for discussion of forming a council
committee to study the city’s vehicle use policy. Council Member Harley so he wanted to get some
responses from cities that have vehicle use policies in place and asked to postpone the discussion
indefinitely to a future time. Council Member Harley so moved and Council Member Miles
seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
Agenda Item IX. – Adjournment
Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion to adjourn. Council Member Parler so moved and Council
Member Jones seconded. The motion passed unanimously. Council adjourned at 8:52 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Marta M. Valentino, CMC
City Clerk/Public Information Officer
Source: City of West Columbia website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.