Regular Council Meeting Minutes
City of West Columbia · Lexington County · meeting of Nov 21, 2014 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of West Columbia
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
City of West Columbia, SC
Regular Council Meeting
June 3, 2014 Following the Public Hearings at 6 p.m.
Members Present: Members Absent:
Joe Owens, Mayor Boyd J. Jones, out of town
Casey Jordan Hallman, Mayor Pro-Tem
Eric L. Fowler
L. Dale Harley
Temus C. Miles, Jr.
Tommy Parler
Teddy Wingard
B.J. Unthank
Others Present:
Myron Corley, Deputy City Administrator Wyatt Coleman, Fire Chief
Mardi Valentino, City Clerk/PIO Bria n Carter, Assistant City Administrator
Rick Hodge, City Treasurer Ch arles Garren, Public Works Director
Sid Varn, Director of Planning and Engineering Stuart Jones, Building Official
Ken Ebener, Municipal Judge Justin Black, Staff Accountant
Jamie Hook, Sanitation/Street/Parks Superintendent Anna Huffm an, IT Systems Administrator
Members of the Public and Press
Agenda Item I – Call to Order
Chairperson Unthank called the meeting to order at 6:19 p.m. and noted a quorum was present. The State,
Free Times, Lexington County Chronicle, Cayce-West Columbia News, The Columbia Star and radio and
television stations were notified of the public hearing by e-mail on May 30, 2014.
Agenda Item II – Determination of Quorum
Chairperson Unthank noted a quorum was present to conduct business. Council Member Parler gave the
invocation followed by the Pledge of Allegiance.
Agenda Item III – Approval of Minutes
A. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion to approve the minutes for the special council meeting
held May 13, 2014. Council Member Harley so moved and Council Member Parler seconded. The
motion passed unanimously.
B. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion to approve the special council meeting held May 28,
2014. Council Member Parler so moved and Council Member Harley seconded. The motion passed
unanimously.
Agenda Item IV – Announcements by Mayor
A. Chairperson Unthank recognized Mayor Owens who stated that council is asking for a 15 percent
water and sewer rate increase and a two percent franchise fee increase. He stated that in good
conscience he could not vote for the increases when five members of the council very casually voted
to give an attorney $10,000.00 for reasons that no one really has given. He said his vote would be in
the negative for increasing any rate.
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
June 3, 2014
Page Two
Agenda Item V – Citizens’ Requests for Appearance
A. Chairperson Unthank recognized Mr. Charles Stuart with Hood Construction. Mr. Stuart said his
company is constructing Gray Collegiate Academy, a charter school on Leaphart Road, and he
wanted to discuss the domestic water tap fee and impact fees. He introduced Mr. Kirby Shealy, an
attorney with Adams & Reese Law Firm who represents Hood Construction. Mr. Shealy explained
that a charter school is a public school chartered either by the state-wide public charter school district
or by local school districts. Schools chartered by the state-wide charter school district do not have
the funding component of local property taxes that local school districts add to the state allocation.
He said that was important because there is an inadequate amount of funding for state-wide charter
schools. The school on Leaphart Road is located where water service can be purchased through
Carolina Water Service, but tap and impact fees have to be paid to both entities. The tap and impact
fees for West Columbia have been calculated to be $110,000.00. There is water service for an
existing building at the location, but a new building is being constructed requiring another tap. Credit
was given for the existing tap, but the tap fee for a new building for 284 high schools students is still
$110,000.00. Hood Construction in the course of budgeting the project for its client estimated
$30,000.00 based on its experience on construction work throughout the Midlands area. The
disparity between what was anticipated and what is the actual amount places a hard burden on the
charter school. Because there is no funding mechanism for facilities like Gray Collegiate, the school
has to figure out how to build its facility and educate children out of the same pot of money. The tap
and impact fees are passed onto the school which will have to make programming adjustments to
absorb that cost. He said that makes the request an unusual situation that is different from a private
taxpayer coming to council seeking a concession because the focus of Gray Collegiate is to better
educate and prepare student athletes who want to compete on a higher level than available at existing
schools. Mr. Shealy said another issue with the location of the school is that water pressure is poor
and the school has to purchase a pump to increase the pressure in order to have adequate water flow.
He said that the school’s unique circumstances make the request worthy of council’s consideration to
vary from the rate schedule for tap fees for out of jurisdiction customers. Mr. Shealy stated council’s
consideration would go a long way toward helping a school that is otherwise underfunded given the
restrictions upon the funding mechanism the general assembly has seen fit to implement to this point.
Chairperson Unthank recognized Council Member Dale Harley who asked how many students would
be in the new building. Mr. Shealy responded that students would attend the school for half day
sessions. He explained that 182 students would use both buildings in the morning and the other 182
students would be there in the afternoons. Council Member Miles who asked what the pump system
would cost. Mr. Shealy responded the cost would be $15,000.00. Council Member Miles asked if
the school had a county-wide attendance zone. Mr. Shealy said it was his understanding according to
the school’s charter that the school’s population is drawn from the county. He said there is no money
for transportation to charter schools so typically the students come from the county where the school
is located. Mayor Owens said when the city issues water and sewer bonds the city has a covenant
with the bond purchasers that the taps fees will not be reduced. He said this is required by the bond
ordinance and to reduce taps fees requires the bond ordinance to be changed. He said the city is in a
dilemma because it is not allowed to reduce taps fees even though council may want to help the
school if it could. He said the bonds issued are subject to full payment of taps fees. Mayor Owens
said this is not the first time that the question of reducing tap fees has come before council. Council
Member Miles asked when the project would be completed. Mr. Shealy responded that the school
would open August 2014. Chairperson Unthank said council would take the school’s request under
advisement, but Mayor Owens was correct in that the city could not alter its bond ordinance.
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
June 3, 2014
Page Three
Agenda Item V – Citizens’ Requests for Appearance (continued)
B. Chairperson Unthank recognized Mr. Jimmy Brooks, who stated he lives at 3409 Henbet Drive in
West Columbia. Mr. Brooks stated that over the last couple of months many things have been going
on in the city. He said he was speaking for the West Columbia Voice group about concerns the
members have. He stated that several weeks ago Council Member Miles had a recording he allowed
WIS-TV to play that was about three minutes long. He said he had a couple of questions that
deserved to be answered. He asked who did the recording. Council Member Miles responded that he
had no intentions of answering the question tonight. Mr. Brooks asked Council Miles how did he
came about getting the recording. Chairperson Unthank stated that Mr. Brooks was welcome to make
comments, but this was not the time to interrogate council members. Mr. Brooks said he was asking
a question that the citizens of the city deserve to have an answer. Council Member Miles stated that
as he said he had no intentions of answering the questions. Mr. Brooks asked why there was not
some public input on hiring a special investigator such as a public hearing. He said he did not
understand how council could spend $10,000.00 of citizens’ money then raise water rates to pay for
the attorney. He said those things should not be decided behind closed doors; they needed to be
decided where the public has input and citizens can all hear what is going on. He said a lot of things
have been going on behind closed doors that the public deserves to hear. Mr. Books asked Council
Member Miles how he came to know the individual (Mr. Robert Bolchoz, Esq.) and how is he
qualified to do the job. No one on council responded to Mr. Brooks questions. Mr. Brooks stated
that someone could go on WIS-TV and say whatever he wants to, but it was his understanding that
there were a lot of things WIS refused to air. He said until people start answering the hard questions
that it would not be very believable or reliable. He said citizens should be asking where the tape
came from and what are the qualifications for the gentleman to do the investigation. He asked if
there was anyone who could have done the same work the attorney is doing for $5,000.00. He asked
if the State Law Enforcement Division could have come in and done the same investigation. Mayor
Owens stated that he thought SLED could have done it. Mr. Brooks said in light of some things that
have happened in the last few days maybe some soul searching needs to be done between now and
then. He said some conversations need to be done, not with screaming nor cussing nor leaning across
desks and threatening people, but with serious conversation about how council can come to resolve
this issue. He said the city then can return to what it should be doing like raising its families and
creating new jobs. He said he thought only one or two businesses have applied for business licenses
in the last four months. Mayor Owens stated that prior to the takeover and the loss of his gavel the
city had 41 new businesses in the previous six months and a total on 179 over the past year. He said
since then that the city has issued only 14 business licenses, which is one third of what it has been.
Mr. Brooks said businesses were not going to come into the city as long as the fighting is going on.
He stated there were simple solutions to be able to increase business licenses and get the city back to
being a great community with great people. He said new businesses generate new taxes and new
income that would help the city’s budget. He said council really needs to have some soul searching if
it serious about the investigation. He asked what would happen if something was found on one of the
five council members and would council members be serious enough to stand up against that person.
C. Chairperson Unthank recognized Mr. Kevin Gleaton who stated that he lives at 1909 St. Louis
Avenue and he is also a member of the Columbia Alumni Chapter of Kappa Alpha Psi Fraternity. He
said he was accompanied by the president of the chapter, Mr. James Melvin. Mr. Gleaton said the
fraternity would be holding an event at Stone River on Alexander Road on Saturday, June 14, 2014.
He said proceeds from the event would support the fraternity’s student scholarships program.
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
June 3, 2014
Page Four
Agenda Item V – Citizens’ Requests for Appearance (continued)
Mr. Gleaton stated that proceeds from last year’s event raised over $25,000 in scholarship funds. He
said the event at Stone River is from 8 p.m. to 1 p.m. and over 300 guests were expected. He noted
that he has been in touch with Lt. John Norman with the West Columbia Police Department and
several police officers will assist with the valet parking. Mr. Gleaton said his fraternity was
requesting a variance from the noise ordinance because normally the noise ordinance goes into effect
at 9 p.m. and event would be ending at 1 p.m. He said it was the intent of the fraternity to not cause
any problems for the residents in the nearby neighborhood.
Mr. Melvin said the people in the fraternity are from about 25 to 80 years old and would not be
making any disturbance, but they wanted to be sure the event was in compliance with city ordinances.
Chairperson Unthank said he had spoken with Mr. Brian Carter, Assistant City Administrator about
the event and with Lt. Norman who would most likely ne at the event. He said it was evident that the
event would be populated with responsible people and the music would be inside the building.
Chairperson Unthank said that council welcomed the Kappa Alpha Psi Fraternity members and was
glad they chose to hold their event in West Columbia. Chairperson Unthank recognized Mayor
Owens who made a motion to sanction the fraternity’s event at Stone River on June 14, 2014 and
Council Member Fowler seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
D. Chairperson Unthank received a request from Mr. Morris K. Phillips to speak before council even
though he was not on the agenda. Chairperson Unthank polled the council members who gave
consensus for Mr. Morris to speak. Chairperson Unthank recognized Mr. Phillips who stated that he
lives at 105 Ashley Court in West Columbia. Mr. Phillips said he wanted to compliment the
Sanitation Department for the excellent job the workers did on the recent West Columbia Clean Up
Day in April.
Agenda Item VI – Adjourn to Executive Session to Discuss a Contractual Matter Concerning Commercial
Property and a Contractual Matter Concerning a Professional Services Agreement
Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion to adjourn to executive session. Council Member Parler so
moved and Council Member Miles seconded. The motion passed unanimously. Council adjourned to
executive session at 6:59 p.m.
Agenda Item VII – Reconvene to Regular Session
Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion to adjourn executive session and reconvene to regular session.
Council Member Harley so moved and Council Member Wingard seconded. The motion passed
unanimously. Council reconvened to regular session at 7:50 p.m. Chairperson Unthank stated that no action
was taken in executive session.
Agenda Item VIII – New Ordinances and Resolutions
A. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for first reading consideration of an ordinance adopting a
budget for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2014 and levying a tax to meet such budget for the fiscal
year, with General Fund $12, 878,000 and Water and Sewer Fund $12,122,00. Council Member
Harley so moved and Council Member Wingard seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
June 3, 2014
Page Five
Agenda Item VIII – New Ordinances and Resolutions (continued)
B. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for first reading consideration of an ordinance establishing
amended water and sewer service charges for the city of West Columbia. Council Member Harley so
moved and Council Member Miles seconded. Council Members Harley, Fowler, Unthank, Parler and
Miles voted in favor of the motion. Mayor Owens, Mayor Pro-Tem Hallman and Council Member
Wingard voted in opposition. The motion passed five votes to three votes.
C. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for first reading consideration of an ordinance establishing
amended hydrant fees for out-of-city water customers. Council Member Parler so moved and
Council Member Harley seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
D. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for first reading consideration of a ordinance to adopt
Section 1-3-9 of the city of West Columbia Code of Ordinances relating to the inclusion of public
invocations at council meetings. Mayor Owens made a motion and Council Member Fowler
seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
E. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for first reading consideration of an ordinance to amend
Section 1-3-2 of the city of West Columbia Code of Ordinances relating to the order of proceedings
for regular council meetings. Council Member so moved and Council Member Wingard seconded.
Mayor Pro-Tem Hallman stated there should be a place for Mayor’s Announcements. Council
Member Miles made a motion to amend the main motion in order to include a section for Mayor’s
Announcements in the order of proceedings for council meeting. Mayor Owens seconded the motion
to amend, which passed unanimously. Chairperson Unthank then restated the main motion as
amended. Council Member Miles so moved to accept the amended main motion and Mayor Pro-Tem
Hallman seconded. The motion as amended passed unanimously.
F. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for first reading consideration of the Planning
Commission’s recommendation to change the zoning classification of property located at 706 12th
Street (TMS# 004633-02-006) as C-1 (intensive commercial) to C-2 (general commercial). Council
Member Harley so moved and Mayor Owens seconded. Chairperson Unthank recognized Mr. Brian
Carter, Assistant City Administrator who stated the property was the former Good Year Auto Center,
a non-conforming, grandfathered use as an auto repair business in Triangle City where most
properties carry a C-1 zoning classification. He explained that if a property sits vacant for quite a
while it will eventually lose its grandfathered use and only uses allowed in its zoning classification
would be approved. Mr. Carter said the grandfathered use of auto repair was no longer allowed for
the property and the owner wanted to change the zoning classification to C-2 which allows auto
repair uses and auto sales. He noted that no one spoke in opposition at the Planning Commission
meeting, but there have been concerns about the appearance of automotive sales lots in the city.
Chairperson Unthank called for the vote. Mayor Owens, Mayor Pro-Tem Hallman and Council
Members Harley, Fowler, Unthank, Parler and Wingard voted in favor of the motion. Council
Member Miles voted in opposition. The motion passed seven votes to one vote.
G. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for consideration to approve a contract to purchase .1265
acres of commercially zoned property located at 115 State Street (TMS# 004647-31-003). Mayor
Owens so moved and Council Member Fowler seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
June 3, 2014
Page Six
Agenda Item VIII – New Ordinances and Resolutions (continued)
H. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for consideration of an additional agreement with the
County of Lexington outlining the implementation of the Stormwater Management Program (SWMP)
in support of the NPDES General Permit for SMS4. Mayor Owens so moved and Council Member
Fowler seconded. Chairperson Unthank recognized Mr. Sid Varn, Director of Planning &
Engineering who explained that West Columbia is part of a consortium of eight municipalities and
Lexington County working together to develop, implement and annually revise the SWMP to address
water quality issues in the county. He referred to page 1 of the proposed agreement and noted that
Lexington County would be handling the last four items on the page, which includes: establishing
compliance with minimum control measures, developing programs for public education/outreach and
public involvement/participation, developing and implementing an illicit detection and elimination
program, and developing and implementing a construction site runoff control program. He said the
intergovernmental agreement between the city and the county documents to the Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA) that the city is sharing its responsibility with the other members of the
consortium to management storm water issues. Unthank called for the vote and the motion passed
unanimously.
I. Chairperson Unthank recognized Mr. Sid Varn, Director of Planning and Engineering, who stated
that the city opened 12 bids for chemicals at 2 p.m. on June 2, 2014. He recommended approval of
the low bids as indicated on the bid sheet distributed to council and as follows:
Chemical Company Low Bid
Aluminum Sulfate Chemtrade Chemicals $ 194.00 per dry ton
Hydrofluosilicic Acid 25% Key Chemi cal, Inc. $ 0.193 per wet pound
Lime Bulk Greer Industries $ 0.091 per pound
Sodium Silicoflouride Univar USA, Inc. $ 0.52 per pound
Sodium Hydroxide 25% JCL Jones Chemical Co. $ 0.0742 per wet pound
Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for consideration to approve chemical bids for the Saluda
River and Lake Murray Water Treatment Plants. Council Member Harley made a motion to approve
the low bids as presented by Mr. Varn and Council Member Fowler seconded. The motion passed
unanimously.
J. Chairperson Unthank stated the item on the agenda for consideration of an agreement for professional
consulting services with Johnson & Associates, Insurance, Inc. would be delayed until a further time.
He said that council members discussed the agreement and wanted to defer action until Mr. Carter
had an opportunity to look into the matter and report back to council. He said council would make a
decision based upon the Mr. Carter’s report of the efficiency of the present services now in place.
K. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion to accept the 2014 Edward Byrne Memorial Justice
Assistance Grant for Law Enforcement Programs. Council Member Fowler so moved and Council
Member Harley seconded. The motion passed unanimously. Chairperson Unthank stated that the
West Columbia Police Department would be applying to the U.S. Department of Justice for a grant of
$12,380.00 to purchase in-car video systems.
Regular Council Meeting Minutes
June 3, 2014
Page Seven
L. Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion for consideration of to appoint Ms. Wilhelmenia Frazier,
Deputy Clerk of Court, to the Employee Grievance Committee to fill an unexpired term ending
January 2017. Mayor Owens so moved and Council Member Fowler seconded. The motion passed
unanimously.
Agenda Item IX. – Adjournment
Chairperson Unthank entertained a motion to adjourn. Mayor Owens so moved and Council Member Miles
seconded. The motion passed unanimously. Council adjourned at 8:26 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Marta M. Valentino, CMC
City Clerk/Public Information Officer
Source: City of West Columbia website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.