Backup Material
Oconee County · Oconee County · meeting of Jun 8, 2026 · Other
Open the original document More from Oconee County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
OCONEE COUNTY
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
415 S. Pine St. Walhalla, SC 29691
864.638.4218
OconeeSC.com
planninginfo@oconeesc.com
The meeting will be broadcasted live on the County’s YouTube channel, which can be found on the
County’s website at www.oconeesc.com.
Rev. 07/2025
BOARD MEMBERS
John Eagar, Chairman, At-Large Jim Henderson, District 1
Gwen Fowler, District 2 Bill Gilster, District 3
Jason Cox, District 4 Tim Mays, District 5
Wayne McCall, At-Large
AGENDA
Monday, June 8th – 6:00 PM
Oconee County Council Chambers
1. Call to Order
2. Appointment of Board Secretary
3. Approval of Minutes: February 23, 2026 meeting
4. Brief statement about rules and procedures
5. Variance application VA26-000003. TMS 316-00-01-164, with an address of
111 & 113 Shannandoah Dr., Westminster, SC; Mountain Lake Real Property
Holding LLC/EB Investments PA seeks relief from Sec. 38-10.2 regarding the
minimum side setback to split an existing duplex along the firewall.
6. Variance application VA26-000005 TMS 324-00-02-019; with an address of
354 Mill Creek Rd, Westminster, SC; Cathy D Martin seeks relief from Sec.
38-10.2 regarding the required side setback for existing building located
across property line.
7. Adjourn
OCONEE COUNTY
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
415 S. Pine St. Walhalla, SC 29691
864.638.4218
OconeeSC.com
planninginfo@oconeesc.com
The meeting will be broadcasted live on the County’s YouTube channel, which can be found on the
County’s website at www.oconeesc.com.
Rev. 07/2025
BOARD MEMBERS
John Eagar, Chairman, At-Large Jim Henderson, District 1
Gwen Fowler, District 2 Bill Gilster, District 3
Jason Cox, District 4 Chad Overholt, District 5
Wayne McCall, At-Large
STAFF
Elise Dunaway
MINUTES
Monday, February 23, 2026 – 6:00 PM
Oconee County Council Chambers
1. Call to Order – Elise Dunaway Called the meeting to order at 6:00 PM.
2. Election of Officers –
a. Chairman – Motion to nominate John Eagar; seconded. Approved.
b. Vice Chairman – John Eager made a motion to nominate Jim
Henderson; seconded. Approved.
c. Secretary – John Eager made a motion to nominate Elise Dunaway;
seconded. Approved.
3. Motion to approve the minutes from December 17, 2025 – Motion made;
seconded. The motion passed.
4. 2026 Meeting Calendar Revision – Mr. Mays made a motion to accept the
revision to the 2026 Meeting Calendar. Seconded by Mr. Gilster. Approved
Unanimously.
5. Brief statement about rules and procedures – Mr. Eagar outlined the
proceedings of the meeting going forward:
• The applicant will provide a presentation regarding the needs for the
variance for 5-minutes with the Board having the ability to grant more time
if needed.
• The Board will ask questions after each presenter
• The staff will address any additional issues
• Citizen comments will be allowed for period of 3-minutes each with the
Board’s request that the speakers not repeat what others are saying, but
rather concur or state other facts not previously presented
• There will be an applicant rebuttal period if necessary
• The Board will ask any further questions before deliberations
OCONEE COUNTY
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
415 S. Pine St. Walhalla, SC 29691
864.638.4218
OconeeSC.com
planninginfo@oconeesc.com
The meeting will be broadcasted live on the County’s YouTube channel, which can be found on the
County’s website at www.oconeesc.com.
Rev. 07/2025
• Once the Board begins its deliberations, there will be no further input from
the floor. and the Board will begin it’s voting on four questions, and a
negative vote on any one of the four questions will require a denial of the
variance or special exception.
1. Special Exception Application SE25-000003 –
Unmair Ali requests relief from the Fair Play Village Overlay District for a service
station.
TMS 337-00-03-009; Address: 503 East Fair Play Boulevard, Fair Play, SC 29643.
Applicant Comments:
• Unmair Ali presented request to construct a gas station with canopy and three
fueling islands at the subject property.
Staff comments:
• Ms Dunaway clarified that approval of the special exception is required prior
to consideration of any variance.
Public comment:
• Alicia Walker – Representing Fair Play Development Corporation; stated
concerns regarding alignment with the Fair Play Strategic Master Plan and
requested application of Appendix A standards.
• Russell Gray – Adjacent property owner representative; expressed concerns
regarding driveway access, safety, traffic, and proximity to residence.
• William Kessler – Raised concerns regarding sewer availability and dumpster
placement.
• Brenda Gray – Expressed concerns regarding traffic, safety, and proximity of
improvements to residence.
• Mike Guy – Raised concerns regarding dumpster placement and site layout.
Applicant Rebuttal: Unmair Ali Provided responses regarding site layout, operations,
utilities, and intended uses of structures.
OCONEE COUNTY
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
415 S. Pine St. Walhalla, SC 29691
864.638.4218
OconeeSC.com
planninginfo@oconeesc.com
The meeting will be broadcasted live on the County’s YouTube channel, which can be found on the
County’s website at www.oconeesc.com.
Rev. 07/2025
Consideration of SE25-000003:
I. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular
piece of property:
1. Motion – Motion made a in the affirmative, seconded. No discussion
2. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
II. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity:
1. Motion – Motion made in the affirmative, seconded. No Discussion
2. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
III. Because of these conditions, the application of this chapter to the particular
piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the
utilization of the property.
1. Motion – Motion made in the affirmative, seconded. No discussion.
2. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
IV. The authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent
uses or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed
by the granting of the variance.
1. Motion – Motion made in the affirmative, seconded. No Discussion.
Opposed
2. Vote
In-favor Opposed
4 2
OCONEE COUNTY
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
415 S. Pine St. Walhalla, SC 29691
864.638.4218
OconeeSC.com
planninginfo@oconeesc.com
The meeting will be broadcasted live on the County’s YouTube channel, which can be found on the
County’s website at www.oconeesc.com.
Rev. 07/2025
V. Mr. Eagar asked – Based on the evidence presented to the Board, do I hear a
motion that the special exception be Approved subject to the following
conditions:
• Fencing along the easement driveway to prevent access from the service
station.
• Fencing along the rear property line with a vegetation buffer to protect
adjacent property.
1. Motion –Motion made in the affirmative; Gwen Fowler seconded.
2. Vote
In-favor Opposed
4 2
Mr. Eagar noted that the variance request was Approved.
2. Variance Application VA 25-000017
Unmair Ali requests relief from setback requirements in Appendix A for a service
station.
TMS 337-00-03-009; Address: 503 East Fair Play Boulevard, Fair Play, SC 29643.
Applicant Comments:
• Unmair Ali Requested reduction of setbacks to allow improved vehicle
maneuverability within the site.
Staff comments:
• None
OCONEE COUNTY
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
415 S. Pine St. Walhalla, SC 29691
864.638.4218
OconeeSC.com
planninginfo@oconeesc.com
The meeting will be broadcasted live on the County’s YouTube channel, which can be found on the
County’s website at www.oconeesc.com.
Rev. 07/2025
Public comment:
• Alicia Walker – Representing Fair Play Development Corporation; stated
concerns regarding alignment with the Fair Play Strategic Master Plan and
requested application of Appendix A standards.
Consideration of VA 25-000017:
VI. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular
piece of property:
1. Motion – Motion made a in the affirmative, seconded. No discussion
2. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
VII. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity:
1. Motion – Motion made in the affirmative, seconded. No Discussion
2. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
VIII. Because of these conditions, the application of this chapter to the particular
piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the
utilization of the property.
1. Motion – Motion made in the affirmative, seconded. No discussion.
2. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
IX. The authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent
uses or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed
by the granting of the variance.
1. Motion – Motion made in the affirmative, seconded. No Discussion.
Opposed
2. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
OCONEE COUNTY
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
415 S. Pine St. Walhalla, SC 29691
864.638.4218
OconeeSC.com
planninginfo@oconeesc.com
The meeting will be broadcasted live on the County’s YouTube channel, which can be found on the
County’s website at www.oconeesc.com.
Rev. 07/2025
X. Mr. Eagar asked – Based on the evidence presented to the Board, do I hear a
motion that the special exception be Approved subject to the following
conditions:
• Fencing along the easement driveway to prevent access from the service
station.
• Fencing along the rear property line with a vegetation buffer to protect
adjacent property.
1. Motion –Motion made in the affirmative; seconded.
2. Vote
In-favor Opposed
5 1
6. Adjourn- Motion made. Seconded. Approved 6-0
Freedom of Information Act - Variance Application
Permitting Information
Code section from which a
variance is requested
Sec. 38-10.2. - Control free
district (CFD) setbacks
Upload Supporting
Documentation Here
Application is Application is not
APPLICANT RESPONSES TO SECTION 38-7.1
Describe the extraordinary and exceptional condition (such
as size, shape, and topography) that pertains to the subject
property that does not generally apply to other land or
structures in the vicinity.:
This is the only residential home on this portion of the road.
It is a duplex that is located at the beginning of the road and
just behind a commercial property (c-store). The land is
average for the area with uneven areas. There is a large
drop behind the duplex (at least one story of a home).
Are the circumstances affecting the subject property the
result of actions by the applicant/owner? Explain.
The duplex was built on an existing play and the owner
would like to separate the two halves of the duplex for
financial reasons.
Describe the ways in which application of the requirement(s)
of the ordinance effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict
the utilization of the subject property.:
. The setbacks will not allow the duplex to be separated as
shown on proposed survey.
Will the proposed variance result in an activity that will not
be of substantial detriment to adjacent uses or to the public
good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by
the granting of the variance. Explain.:
The proposed changes will not affect any of the neighbors
as the duplex is already in place and this is a division down
the middle of the duplex.
General Contractor
ICC 113.2 Limitations on authority. An application for appeal shall be based on a claim that the true intent of this code of
the rules legally adopted there under have been incorrectly interpreted, the provisions of this code do not fully apply or an
equally good or better form of construction is proposed. The board shall have no authority to waive requirements of this
code.
Comments
OCONEE COUNTYS APPROVAL, PERMITTING, AND/OR INSPECTION(S) OF THIS PROJECT DOES NOT MEAN
THAT THE PROJECT IS IN COMPLIANCE WITH ALL APPLICABLE SUBDIVISION AND/OR HOMEOWNERS
ASSOCIATION, OR SIMILAR ENTITYS, BUILDING AND LAND USE REQUIREMENTS OR RESTRICTIONS, BY
SIGNING BELOW YOU ACKNOWLEDGE THAT COMPLIANCE WITH ANY SUCH STANDARDS IS YOUR
RESPONSIBILITY.
Workflow Reviews Information
Type Creation DateDue DateCompletion DateStatus Description
Planning
and Zoning
Review
03/20/2026 04/28/202601/01/1900 Resubmittal
Required ?DATE SCHEDULED?
6/3/26, 4:08 PM Letter View
file:///C:/Users/dhester/Downloads/FOIA - Variance Application.htm 1/4
Application
Check 03/20/2026 03/21/202603/20/2026 Approved
Review
Complete03/20/2026 01/01/190001/01/1900 Pending
Inspection Information
Activities Information
Type Creation DateDue DateCompletion DateStatus Description
Online
Payment
Received
03/20/2026 03/27/202603/20/2026 Complete
Online
Payment
Received
03/20/2026 03/27/202603/20/2026 Complete
Documents Information
Creation DateFile Name Source
03/20/2026 image.jpg Upload Supporting
Documentation Here
03/20/2026 Your application has been received.htm System Email
03/20/2026 Permit Review.htm Email
03/20/2026 Your citizenserve payment has been received.htmSystem Email
03/20/2026 Receipt.pdf Merge document
03/20/2026 Permit Email.htm Email
03/20/2026 Your citizenserve application status has changed.htmSystem Email
05/08/2026 Permit Review.htm Email
05/18/2026 Permit Review.htm Email
History
Creation DateNote Type Note
03/19/2026 Contact Added Sherri E Howard was added to the case by - Sherri E Howard.
03/19/2026 Property Owner
Added
Contact "MOUNTAIN LAKE REAL PROP HOLDING LLC" was attached
to the case.
03/19/2026 Portal Saved For
Later
Online application for Separate lot with the new common property line
separating a duplex in half thru the firewall This portion is on Shannandoah
Dr on 1437 BLACKJACK RD Saved for Later by - Sherri E Howard and
03/19/2026 10:57 AM
03/20/2026 Document
Attached Document "image.jpg" was attached to the case.
03/20/2026
Planning and
Zoning Review -
Activity
A Planning and Zoning Review activity has been assigned to Elise Dunaway
in the Community Development department.
6/3/26, 4:08 PM Letter View
file:///C:/Users/dhester/Downloads/FOIA - Variance Application.htm 2/4
03/20/2026 Application
Check - Activity
A Application Check activity has been assigned to Elise Dunaway in the
Community Development department.
03/20/2026 Review Complete
- Activity
A Review Complete activity has been assigned to Elise Dunaway in the
Community Development department.
03/20/2026 Portal Submitted
Online application for Separate lot with the new common property line
separating a duplex in half thru the firewall This portion is on Shannandoah
Dr on 1437 BLACKJACK RD Submitted by - Sherri E Howard and
03/20/2026 07:01 AM
03/20/2026 Document
Attached
Document "Your application has been received.htm" was attached to the
case.
03/20/2026 Activity UpdateApplication Check assigned to Elise Dunaway was completed by Elise
Dunaway on 03/20/2026
03/20/2026 Activity UpdateApplication Check assigned to Elise Dunaway status changed from Pending
to Approved by Elise Dunaway on 03/20/2026
03/20/2026 Activity UpdatePlanning and Zoning Review assigned to Elise Dunaway status changed
from Pending to Under Review by Elise Dunaway on 03/20/2026
03/20/2026 Permit Status
Updated
Permit# VA26-000003 status was changed from Online Application
Received to Payment Required by Elise Dunaway
03/20/2026 Document
Attached Document "Permit Review.htm" was attached to the case.
03/20/2026 Payment Added Payment of $300.00 added to VA26-000003 receipt #766
03/20/2026
Online Payment
Received -
Activity
A Online Payment Received activity has been assigned to Cynthia Adams in
the Community Development department.
03/20/2026 Document
Attached
Document "Your citizenserve payment has been received.htm" was attached
to the case.
03/20/2026 Document
Attached Document "Receipt.pdf" was attached to the case.
03/20/2026 Document
Attached Document "Permit Email.htm" was attached to the case.
03/20/2026 Activity UpdateOnline Payment Received assigned to Cynthia Adams was completed by
Cynthia Adams on 03/20/2026
03/20/2026 Activity UpdateOnline Payment Received assigned to Cynthia Adams status changed from
to Complete by Cynthia Adams on 03/20/2026
03/20/2026 Permit Status
Updated
Permit# VA26-000003 status was changed from Payment Required to Under
Review by Cynthia Adams
03/20/2026 Document
Attached
Document "Your citizenserve application status has changed.htm" was
attached to the case.
04/01/2026 Activity UpdatePlanning and Zoning Review Due Date Changed from 03/27/2026 to
04/28/2026 by Elise Dunaway.
04/03/2026
Planning and
Zoning Review -
Activity
Activity Planning and Zoning Review has been reassigned from Elise
Dunaway to Casey Neal.
04/03/2026 Review Complete
- Activity
Activity Review Complete has been reassigned from Elise Dunaway to
Casey Neal.
04/03/2026 Activity UpdatePlanning and Zoning Review assigned to Casey Neal status changed from
Under Review to Resubmittal Required by Casey Neal on 04/03/2026
04/14/2026 Planning and
Zoning Review -
Activity Planning and Zoning Review has been reassigned from Casey Neal
to DeAnn Hester.
6/3/26, 4:08 PM Letter View
file:///C:/Users/dhester/Downloads/FOIA - Variance Application.htm 3/4
Activity
04/14/2026 Activity UpdatePlanning and Zoning Review assigned to Casey Neal status changed from
Resubmittal Required to Pending by Cynthia Adams on 04/14/2026
05/08/2026 Activity UpdatePlanning and Zoning Review assigned to DeAnn Hester status changed
from Pending to Resubmittal Required by DeAnn Hester on 05/08/2026
05/08/2026 Document
Attached Document "Permit Review.htm" was attached to the case.
05/18/2026 Document
Attached Document "Permit Review.htm" was attached to the case.
05/18/2026 Permit Updated
Permit # VA26-000003 Work Description was changed from Separate lot
with the new common property line separating a duplex in half thru the
firewall This portion is on Shannandoah Dr to Separate lot with the new
common property line separating a duplex in half thru the firewall This
portion is on 111 & 113 Shannandoah Dr by DeAnn Hester
6/3/26, 4:08 PM Letter View
file:///C:/Users/dhester/Downloads/FOIA - Variance Application.htm 4/4
Freedom of Information Act - Variance Application
Permitting Information
Code section from which a
variance is requested Section 38-10.2 Upload Supporting
Documentation Here
Application is Application is not
APPLICANT RESPONSES TO SECTION 38-7.1
Describe the extraordinary and exceptional condition (such
as size, shape, and topography) that pertains to the subject
property that does not generally apply to other land or
structures in the vicinity.:
Are the circumstances affecting the subject property the
result of actions by the applicant/owner? Explain.
The building was placed over/too close to the existing lot
lines in error.
Describe the ways in which application of the requirement(s)
of the ordinance effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict
the utilization of the subject property.:
the required setbacks are violated by the proposed property
lines.
Will the proposed variance result in an activity that will not
be of substantial detriment to adjacent uses or to the public
good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by
the granting of the variance. Explain.:
Proposed property lines have been agreed to by the
adjoining land owners.
General Contractor
ICC 113.2 Limitations on authority. An application for appeal shall be based on a claim that the true intent of this code of
the rules legally adopted there under have been incorrectly interpreted, the provisions of this code do not fully apply or an
equally good or better form of construction is proposed. The board shall have no authority to waive requirements of this
code.
Comments
OCONEE COUNTYS APPROVAL, PERMITTING, AND/OR INSPECTION(S) OF THIS PROJECT DOES NOT MEAN
THAT THE PROJECT IS IN COMPLIANCE WITH ALL APPLICABLE SUBDIVISION AND/OR HOMEOWNERS
ASSOCIATION, OR SIMILAR ENTITYS, BUILDING AND LAND USE REQUIREMENTS OR RESTRICTIONS, BY
SIGNING BELOW YOU ACKNOWLEDGE THAT COMPLIANCE WITH ANY SUCH STANDARDS IS YOUR
RESPONSIBILITY.
Workflow Reviews Information
Type Creation DateDue DateCompletion DateStatus Description
Application
Check 05/06/2026 05/07/202605/07/2026 Approved
Planning
and Zoning
Review
05/06/2026 05/14/202601/01/1900 Under
Review
Review
Complete05/06/2026 01/01/190001/01/1900 Pending
Inspection Information
Activities Information
Documents Information
Creation DateFile NameSource
05/06/2026 DOC001.pdfDocument
6/3/26, 4:11 PM Letter View
file:///C:/Users/dhester/Downloads/FOIA - Variance Application (1).htm 1/2
05/06/2026 Receipt.pdfMerge document
History
Creation DateNote Type Note
05/06/2026 Contact Added GLENN HART was added to the case by Casey Neal.
05/06/2026 Application
Check - Activity
A Application Check activity has been assigned to Casey Neal in the
Community Development department.
05/06/2026
Planning and
Zoning Review -
Activity
A Planning and Zoning Review activity has been assigned to DeAnn Hester
in the Community Development department.
05/06/2026 Review Complete
- Activity
A Review Complete activity has been assigned to Casey Neal in the
Community Development department.
05/06/2026 File Created File created by Casey Neal.
05/06/2026 Document
Attached Document "DOC001.pdf" was attached to the case.
05/06/2026 Payment Added Payment of $300.00 added to VA26-000005 receipt #1224
05/06/2026 Document
Attached Document "Receipt.pdf" was attached to the case.
05/06/2026 Activity UpdateApplication Check assigned to Casey Neal status changed from Pending to
Resubmittal Required by Casey Neal on 05/06/2026
05/07/2026 Activity UpdateApplication Check assigned to Casey Neal was completed by Casey Neal on
05/07/2026
05/07/2026 Activity UpdateApplication Check assigned to Casey Neal status changed from Resubmittal
Required to Approved by Casey Neal on 05/07/2026
05/12/2026 Activity UpdatePlanning and Zoning Review assigned to DeAnn Hester status changed
from Pending to Under Review by DeAnn Hester on 05/12/2026
6/3/26, 4:11 PM Letter View
file:///C:/Users/dhester/Downloads/FOIA - Variance Application (1).htm 2/2
Source: Oconee County website. First collected Oct 23, 2026.