Regular Meeting Documents
City of Memphis · Shelby County · meeting of Nov 4, 2025 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Memphis
This document is no longer listed on City of Memphis's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CoM Public
WHEREAS, Captain James Carlos Clark was born on August 8, 1975, in Oktibbeha County,
Mississippi, to the late James Clark and Aretha Jordan, and from an early age, he accepted Christ as his personal
Savior, becoming a devoted member of Beth-el Missionary Baptist Church, where he remained active throughout his
life; and
WHEREAS, Captain James Carlos Clark graduated from Starkville High School in 1994, pursued
further education at Hinds Community College, Davis Marine Training Institution, and The Seamen's Church
Institute Center for Maritime where he built a respected career on the river as a proud Captain for Marquette
Transportation, serving with excellence for 19 years and commanding the M/V Lindsay Ann Erickson with steadfast
leadership and integrity; and
WHEREAS, Captain James Carlos Clark was known not only for his professionalism but also for his
role as a mentor and guide, training young deckhands into skilled pilots, volunteering with youth organizations like
the Boys Club, and modeling the values of discipline, loyalty, and service; and
WHEREAS, beyond his career, Captain James Carlos Clark was a devoted husband, a loving father, and
a proud grandfather whose greatest joy was his family. He led with compassion and strength, providing unwavering
support to his wife, daughters, grandchildren, mother, sisters, cousins, and extended family. He was a man of moral
character and deep integrity who showed up not just when it was easy, but when it mattered most; and
WHEREAS, he was affectionately known as the life of the party, with a radiant smile, infectious laugh,
and a giving spirit. Whether grilling at a family gathering, riding ATVs through the countryside, cheering for his
favorite team, or sharing stories around a fire, Captain James Carlos Clark brought warmth and unity wherever he
went; and
WHEREAS, his love for horses became both a passion and a ministry. As a proud member of the National
Racking Horse Association, Captain James Carlos Clark used horseback riding and trail events to build
community, uplift youth, and inspire pride in culture and tradition. He created space for boys to see strong black
leadership in rural settings and led by example with every ride; and
WHEREAS, Captain James Carlos Clark’s life was grounded in faith, fueled by love, and marked by
service. His influence extended beyond the riverbanks into the hearts and lives of all who knew him. His legacy is
etched in the wisdom he shared, the example he set, and the lives he uplifted .
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Memphis City Council does hereby honor the
extraordinary life, legacy, and service of Captain James Carlos Clark recognizing his distinguished service in the
maritime industry, his unwavering commitment to family and community, and his enduring impact as a leader,
mentor, and friend; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that on this day, the Memphis City Council extends its deepest
condolences and honors Captain James Carlos Clark’s journey and celebrate a life well-lived. May he find eternal
peace, and may his memory continue to guide and inspire generations to come.
Given by my hand and under the
great seal of the City of Memphis
this 21st day of October 2025.
Councilwoman Yolanda Cooper-Sutton
Memphis City Council
1
AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND THE CODE OF ORDINANCES OF MEMP HIS,
TENNESSEE REGARDING THE SMALL BUSINESS ENTERPRISE OPPORTUNITY
PROGRAM
WHEREAS, from time to time it is necessary to amend the Code of Ordinances to meet the current
needs of the citizens of Memphis and ensure our policies comply with local, state, and federal
requirements.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Memphis City Council hereby amends the
Code of Ordinances to add Article XI to Chapter 2 relative to the Small Business Enterprise
Opportunity Program as follows:
Sec. 6-2-407. — Short Title.
This chapter shall be known as the "City of Memphis Small Business Enterprise
Program."
Sec. 6-2-408. — Definitions.
The following words, terms and phrases, when used in this chapter, shall have the meanings
ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning:
Bid means a quotation, proposal, sealed bid or offer to perform or provide labor, materials,
supplies or services to the city for a price on an eligible project, or for an eligible project that
generates revenue for the City.
Bidder means any individual, sole proprietorship, partnership, joint venture, or
corporation that submits a bid to the City.
Certification or recertification means official recognition and approval by the entity
designated by the City of Memphis (“Certifying Entity”) that a business meets the qualification
criteria of a small business enterprise, as set forth in this chapter. Certification or recertification
relates to qualifications regarding ownership, control, and not the quality of the service or product.
City means the City of Memphis.
2
Commercially useful function . To determine whether a business enterprise is
performing a commercially useful function, the Certifying Entity shall consider all the facts in
the record, viewed as a whole, including without limitation the following:
1. A small business enterprise (“SBE”) performs a commercially useful function when it
is responsible for execution of the work of the contract and is carrying out its
responsibilities by performing, managing, and supervising the work involved.
2. To perform a commercially useful function, the SBE must be responsible, with
respect to material and supplies used on the contract, for negotiating price,
determining quality and quantity, ordering the material, and installing (where
applicable) and paying for the material itself.
3. To determine whether an SBE is performing a commercially useful function, the
Certifying Entity will evaluate the amount of work subcontracted by the SBE,
industry practices regarding subcontracting, whether the amount the SBE is to be
paid under the contract is commensurate with the work it is performing , the SBE
credit claimed for its performance of the work, and other relevant factors.
4. An SBE does not perform a commercially useful function if its role is limited to that
of an extra participant in a transaction, contract, or project through which funds are
passed to obtain the appearance of SBE participation. In determining whether an SBE
is such an extra participant, the Certifying Entity will examine similar transactions,
particularly those in which SBEs do not participate.
Contract means and includes any agreement between the City and a person or business
enterprise to provide or procure labor, materials, equipment, supplies and services to, for or on
behalf of the City. The term "contract" shall include an agreement between the City and a person
or business enterprise to perform professional architectural and engineering services, construction
related services or fund the performance of such services, non-professional services and/or goods.
Except as otherwise specifically defined in this section, the term "contract" does not include:
1. Awards made by the City to a nonprofit entity which the City offers assistance,
guidance, or supervision on a project or program and the recipient of the grant
award uses the grant moneys to provide services to the community;
2. Sales transactions where the City sells its personal or real property;
3
3. A loan transaction where the City is acting as a debtor or a creditor;
4. Lease and franchise agreements;
5. Agreements to use City real property; or
6. Gifts of materials, equipment, supplies or services to the City.
Contractor means a prime contractor or vendor on a City contract.
Control or controlled. To determine whether the owner or owners of a potential SBE (as
used in this definition, "SBE owner," which shall denote one or more owners) controls the
potential SBE, the Certifying Entity shall consider all the facts in the record, viewed as a whole,
including without limitation the following:
1. For a SBE owner to be deemed to control, the potential SBE must be
independent. An independent business enterprise is a business whose
viability does not depend on its relationship with another firm.
a. In determining whether a potential SBE is independent, the Certifying Entity
will scrutinize affiliate relationships the SBE has with other firms, in such
areas as personnel, facilities, equipment, financial and/or bonding support,
and other resources.
The Certifying Entity will consider whether present or recent
employer/employee relationships between the SBE owner
and other firms or
persons associated with other firms compromise the independence of the
potential SBE.
b. The Certifying Entity will examine the potential SBE's relationships with
prime contractors to determine whether a pattern of exclusive or primary
dealings with a prime contractor compromises the independence of the
potential SBE.
c. In considering factors related to the independence of a potential SBE, the
Certifying Entity will consider the consistency of relationships between the
potential SBE and other firms with normal industry practice.
2. A potential SBE must not be subject to any formal or informal restrictions which
4
limit the customary discretion of the SBE owner. There can be no restrictions
through corporate charter provisions, bylaw provisions, contracts or any other
formal or informal devices (e.g., cumulative voting rights, voting powers attached
to different classes of stock, employment contracts, requirements for concurrence
by persons other than the SBE owner, conditions precedent or subsequent,
executory agreements, voting trusts, restrictions on or assignments of voting rights)
that prevent the SBE owner, without the cooperation or vote of any other
individual, from making any business decision of the business enterprise. This
subsection does not preclude a spousal co-signature on documents.
3. The SBE owner must possess the power to direct or cause the direction of the
management and policies of the business enterprise and to make day-to-day as well
as long-term decisions on matters of management, policy and operations.
a. An SBE owner must hold the highest officer position in the company (e.g.,
chief executive officer or president).
b. In a corporation, the SBE owner must control the board of directors.
c. In a partnership, the SBE owner must serve as a general partner, with
control over all partnership decisions.
4. Individuals who are not the SBE owner may be involved in an SBE as owners,
managers, employees, stockholders, officers, and/or directors. Such individuals
must not, however, possess or exercise the power to control the business
enterprise, or be disproportionately responsible for the operation of the business
enterprise.
5. The SBE owner may delegate various areas of the management, policymaking, or
daily operations of the business enterprise to other participants in the firm. Such
delegations of authority must be revocable, and the SBE owner must retain the
power to hire and fire any person to whom such authority is delegated. The
managerial role of the SBE owner in the business enterprise's overall affairs must be
such that the Certifying Entity can reasonably conclude that the SBE owner
exercises control over the business enterprise's operations, management, and policy.
6. The SBE owner must have an overall understanding of, and managerial and
5
technical competence and experience directly related to the type of business in which
the business enterprise is engaged and the business enterprise's operations. The SBE
owner is not required to have experience or expertise in every critical area of the
business enterprise's operations, or to have greater experience or expertise in a given
field than managers or key employees. The SBE owner must have the ability to
intelligently and critically evaluate information presented by other participants in
the business enterprise's activities and to use this information to make independent
decisions concerning the business enterprise's daily operations, management, and
policymaking. Generally, expertise limited to office management, administration, or
bookkeeping functions unrelated to the principal business activities of the business
enterprise is insufficient to demonstrate control.
7. If state or local law requires the owner of a particular type of firm to have a
particular license or other credential, then the SBE owner of that type of firm must
possess the required license or credential to be deemed in control. If state or local
law does not require an owner to have such a license or credential, the Certifying
Entity will not deny certification solely on the ground that the SBE owner lacks the
license or credential. However, the Certifying Entity may consider the absence of
the license or credential as one factor in determining whether the SBE owner
controls the firm.
8. The Certifying Entity may consider differences in remuneration between the SBE
owner and other participants in the business enterprise in determining whether the
SBE owner controls the business enterprise. Such consideration shall be in the
context of the duties of the persons involved, normal industry practices, the business
enterprise's policy and practice concerning reinvest ment of income, and any other
explanations for the differences proffered by the business enterprise. The Certifying
Entity may determine that a business enterprise is controlled by its SBE owner
although the SBE owner's remuneration is lower than that of some other participants
in the business enterprise. In a case where someone other than the SBE owner
formerly controlled the business enterprise, and the SBE owner now controls it, the
Certifying Entity may consider a difference between the remuneration of the former
and current owner of the business enterprise as a factor in determining who controls
6
the business enterprise, particularly when the former owner remains involved with
the business enterprise and continues to receive greater compensation than the
current SBE owner.
9. To be viewed as "controlling" a business enterprise, an SBE owner cannot engage
in outside employment or other business interests that conflict with the
management of the business enterprise or prevent the SBE owner from devoting
sufficient time and attention to the affairs of the business enterprise to control its
activities. For example, absentee ownership of a business and part-time work in
a full-time firm are not viewed as constituting control. However, an SBE owner
could be viewed as "controlling" a part-time business that operates only on evenings
and/or weekends, if the SBE owner controls the business enterprise when it is
operating.
10. An SBE owner may control a business enterprise even though one or more of the SBE
owner's immediate family members participate in the business enterprise as a
manager, employee, owner, or in another capacity. Except as otherwise provided in
this subsection, the Certifying Entity must make a judgment about the control the
SBE owner exercises vis-a-vis other persons involved in the business enterprise as
it does in other situations, without regard to whether or not the other persons are
immediate family members. If the Certifying Entity cannot determine that the SBE
owner—as distinct from the family as a whole—controls the business enterprise,
then the SBE owner has failed to carry her/his burden of proof concerning control,
even though he/she may participate significantly in the business enterprise's
activities.
Day or days refers to calendar days.
Eligible project means:
1. Any City contract with a participation goal attached as identified by the Division
of Finance, through its Business Services department (“Business Services”) or
designee thereof
, excluding sole source procurement, emergency procurement, and
contracts governed by 49 CFR 23 and 26.
2. For purposes of this chapter, contract or project "value" shall mean either the
7
expenditure of funds by the City , or the generation of revenue for the City by a
contractor as a direct result of a City contract.
Joint venture means an association of two or more persons, partnerships,
corporations, or any combination of them, established to carry on a single business activity
that is limited in scope and duration. The agreement establishing the joint venture,
partnership or other multi-entity relationship shall be in writing. Further, participation in a
joint venture shall be based on the sharing of real economic interest in the venture and shall
include proportionate control over management, interest in capital acquired by the joint
venture and interest in earnings.
Local business means that the vendor or contractor has a valid domestic type county and
state business license, issued at least one year prior to the bid or proposal opening date, to do
business in said locality that authorizes the business to provide the goods, services, or
construction to be purchased, and the physical principal business address located within the city
limits, in an area zoned for the conduct of such business, from which the vendor operates or
performs the majority of its business on a da y-to-day basis, and also from which the vendor
conducts 100 percent of the necessary functions to maintain or fulfill the contract with the city.
Post office boxes are not verifiable and shall not be used for the purpose of establishing said
address.
Memphis MSA means the geographical area consisting of the following counties: Shelby,
Fayette, Tipton, Desoto, Marshall, Tate, Tunica, and Crittenden.
Business Services means the Business Services Department of the Finance Division of the
City of Memphis. The duties and functions of Business Services shall be defined and amended as
needed by the Director of the City division in which the office operates.
Owned or ownership. In determining whether a potential SBE is owned and operated by
an individual or individuals, the Certifying Entity will consider all of the facts in the record, viewed
as a whole, including, without limitation, the following:
1. The Certifying Entity shall deem the owner of a business enterprise to be whoever
possesses at least 51 percent of the business enterprise. There may be more than
one owner.
a. In the case of a corporation, such an individual must possess at least 51
8
percent of each class of voting stock outstanding and 51 percent of the
aggregate of all stock outstanding.
b. In the case of a partnership, such individual must possess at least 51 percent
of each class of partnership interest. Such ownership must be reflected in the
business enterprise's partnership agreement.
c. In the case of a limited liability company, such individual must possess at
least 51 percent of each class of member interest.
2. The Certifying Entity must find that the individual's ownership is real, substantial,
and continuing, going beyond proforma ownership of the business enterprise as
reflected in ownership documents. The individual must enjoy the customary incidents
of ownership and share in the risks and profits commensurate with their ownership
interests, as demonstrated by the substance, not merely the form, of arrangements.
Purpose and intent. The City shall give a local preference to local businesses within its
geographical limits in awarding City contracts and making purchases whenever the application
of such a preference is reasonable in light of the dollar value of the proposal received in relation
to such expenditures.
SBE Status means whether a firm meets the qualification criteria of a small business
enterprise, as set forth in this chapter.
Small Business Enterprise (SBE) means a firm with its headquarters and/or principal
office located in the City and is an independent and continuing enterprise for profit,
performing a commercially useful function which is owned and controlled by one or more
persons and for which the gross revenues or number of employees averaged over the past three
years, inclusive of any affiliates as defined by 13 CFR 121.103, does not exceed ten million
dollars ($10,000,000) or three hundred (300) employees.
Small Business Owner means a person who owns the business enterprise for which the
owner is seeking SBE certification from the City or approved certifying agencies.
Supplier means a warehouse or manufacturer of materials, supplies or equipment
which contracts directly with a bidder to provide such materials, supplies or equipment on an
eligible project which involves a trade or service. For purposes of measuring the total
contract dollars awarded or paid to suppliers on eligible projects, only amounts paid to
9
suppliers of goods customarily and ordinarily used based upon standard industry or trade
practices shall be counted.
Sec. 6-2-409. — Statement of policy.
It is the purpose of this chapter to promote the economic welfare of the people of the
City, to promote business opportunity for all persons doing business with the City, and to
promote commerce by assisting SBEs to actively participate in the City’s procurement process.
SBEs represent 89 percent of the businesses in the United States and 30 percent of the business
revenue nationwide, according to the United States Bureau of Census. Also, according to the
United States Bureau of Census, in the Memphis metropolitan statistical area, 73 percent of
establishments have less than ten employees and 94 percent of establishments have less than 50
employees.
The City, through Business Services, shall develop a policy and manual to detail the
process, procedure, and methodology for setting SBE goals and utilization of the designated
SBE sheltered market. Business Services shall set annually, at the beginning of each fiscal year,
an aspirational SBE goal for certain designated categories of prime contracts. The annual
aspirational SBE goal may be broken down by Division as outlined in the Business Services
policy and manual. Additionally, Business Services shall set SBE subcontracting goals based
on SBE availability for construction, architecture , engineering, surveying, commodities, and
services in accordance with the Business Services policy and manual.
Sec. 6-2-410. — Duties of Business Services.
Under this chapter, Business Services shall have the following authority and duties for
the implementation of the Small Business Enterprise program under this chapter:
1. Administration and enforcement of this chapter and of the federal disadvantaged
business enterprise program as per 49 CFR parts 23 & 26.
2. Establishment of written policy, manual, procedures, informal guidelines, and forms
as may be necessary to effectuate this chapter.
3. Monitoring compliance with the requirements of this chapter.
10
4. Accept valid and current proof of c ertification of businesses as SBEs from approved
certifying entities in accordance with the standards set forth in this chapter.
5. Development of databases to be maintained as a public record of certified SBEs.
6. Investigation of alleged violations of this chapter, and the issuance of written
statements following any determination of such investigation, stating the
reasons therefor and any penalty to be imposed.
7. Collaborating with the various City divisions to ensure maximum outreach to SBEs.
8. Determination of whether any of the penalties set forth in Section 6-94-17 should
be applied to a business.
9. Attendance at pre-bid, pre-proposal, pre-construction and pre-work conferences.
10. Provision to business entities of all forms, applications, documents and papers
necessary to comply with this chapter.
11. Provision of information to potential bidders, upon request by the potential
bidder, which shall include names and contact information of certified SBEs,
to reinforce and support outreach efforts by potential bidders.
12. Notification by certified mail that a bidder who has bid on and who otherwise
would have been awarded a contract has the right to appeal a determination of
noncompliance with this chapter, with said appeal to be decided by Business
Services within seven calendar days of receipt of the notice of noncompliance.
13. Notification by certified mail that an applicant who has been denied certification
as an SBE has the right to appeal such determination, said appeal to be
determined by Business Services within seven calendar days of receipt of the
notice of such determination.
14. Notification to the purchasing agent of any determination of noncompliance with
this chapter, and of any appeal from any such determination.
15. Monitoring, for data gathering and informational purposes, utilization of SBEs
on eligible projects.
16. Maintenance of documents, forms, records or data regarding this program as provided
11
in this chapter including:
a. Documents, forms, records or data regarding the dollar amounts
subcontracted to or expended for services performed by subcontractors
and suppliers on eligible projects, including the SBE status of each
subcontractor and supplier; and
b. Documents, forms, records or data regarding certified SBEs.
17. Development and implementation of outreach and assistance programs to promote
contracting opportunities for all businesses that wish to do business with the City ,
regardless of SBE status.
18. Establishment of SBE citywide aspirational goals and project specific goals.
19. Identify targeted procurements for SBE -only competition, depended on SBE
availability.
20. The duties of Business Services should include supporting the various City divisions
in achieving their established Small Business Enterprise goals, as well as providing
business development assistance to the local business community. This support should
cover, but not be limited to, the following activities:
(a) Supply comprehensive resources, including informational materials, toolkits,
and training sessions to assist divisions in meeting SBE goals.
(b) Offer expert advice and consulting services to help divisions understand and
navigate SBE objectives effectively.
(c) Collaborate with divisions to develop strategic plans that align with SBE goals,
ensuring a clear path to success.
(d) Facilitate the identification and establishment of partnerships with potential
small businesses, promoting mutual benefits and collaboration.
(e) Organize and conduct training sessions and workshops focused on best
practices for engaging with small businesses and achieving SBE objectives.
(f) Implement monitoring and evaluation processes to assess progress towards
SBE goals and provide feedback for continuous improvement.
12
(g) Create and promote networking events to encourage interaction among
divisions and small business partners, enhancing collaboration and
opportunities.
(h) Maintain open lines of communication with all divisions to ensure they are
informed about available resources and opportunities related to SBE initiatives.
(i) Act as an advocate for small business interests within the organization, ensuring
that their needs and contributions are recognized and valued.
(j) Keep detailed records of activities, partnerships, and progress toward SBE
objectives, providing regular reports to leadership on outcomes and areas for
development.
(k) Conduct research to identify trends, challenges, and opportunities in the small
business landscape to inform strategies and support for divisions.
(l) Establish a system for gathering feedback from divisions and small business
partners to inform ongoing improvements and tailor support services
accordingly.
(m) Establish mentorship opportunities that connect new business owners with
experienced entrepreneurs for guidance and support.
(n) Provide resources and connections to funding sources, such as grants, loans,
and investment opportunities.
(o) Serve as a central resource for local entrepreneurs by offering access to
information and tools that foster business growth.
Sec. 6-2-411. — Small business assistance.
Business Services shall act as a resource for information on small business enterprises and
entrepreneurs.
Business Services
shall also undertake to raise the consciousness of SBEs about City
business opportunities and provide information on taking advantage of the program benefits.
Further, the City shall provide the following assistance to small business enterprises:
1. Access to training; technical assistance. Business Services shall act as a resource for
technical assistance. The office shall collect, organize and disseminate information
13
regarding available technical assistance providers in the Memphis market area.
2. Capital; financing assistance. Business Services shall act as a resource for financial
assistance. The office shall collect, organize and disseminate information regarding
available capital or financing sources in the Memphis market area.
3. Bonding assistance. Business Services shall provide SBEs with information
regarding bonding including, providing a list of qualified service providers that
supply bonding services.
4. Access to markets. Business Services will work to facilitate access to markets for
SBEs, working with the office of planning and development (OPD) and other
development entities to connect eligible businesses to City, state and federal
programs that promote investment and encourage employment, including but not
limited to the various hub zone, enterprise zone, and tax allocation districts.
Business Services may monitor in conjunction with OPD SBE involvement in
procurement opportunities generated by OPD.
Sec. 6-2-412. — City-maintained records and reports.
The effectiveness of the SBE Program will be measured by a review of data indicating
prime, subcontractor and supplier awards to SBEs. Program effectiveness measurements will
also include efforts by City staff to provide prime contracting opportunities for SBEs. In order
to ensure the effective tracking of these efforts, the following shall be done:
1. Each contractor shall continuously maintain, compile, and provide to Business
Services, monthly, information relating to its use of SBEs on the City project. This
information shall include without limitation the following information for each of the
SBE subcontractors and suppliers utilized by the contractor on the City project: a
description of the categories of contracts awarded to SBEs; the dollar value of
contracts awarded to SBEs; and contact information for the SBEs. Additionally, the
contractor shall provide information regarding its progress toward attaining the
SBE goal on the city project.
2. Within 30 days after the end of a contract in which there was an SBE goal, each
contractor shall provide Business Services with a report that summarizes the
14
outcome of the project information, including without limitation: the identity of
and contract information for each SBE to whom the contractor has awarded a
subcontract or supplier agreement; the type of work performed or supplies
provided by each subcontractor/supplier; the dollar value of each of the
subcontracts/supplier agreements; and the total percentage of the value of the City
contract subcontracted to SBE subcontractors and/or suppliers.
3. The purchasing department shall provide Business Services with information
regarding every City contract on which the prime contractor is an SBE or on which
an SBE is part of a joint venture or mentor protege team serving as the prime
contractor. The information shall include the name and contact information of the
SBE, the type of contract, and the dollar value of the contract.
4. Business Services shall prepare a consolidated report based on a compilation and
analysis of the reports submitted by each contractor and information from the
purchasing department regarding the City’s use of SBEs as prime contractors. The
consolidated report will identify and assess the awards to SBEs of City contracts,
prime contractors' use of SBE subcontractors and suppliers, prime contractors'
progress in achieving SBE subcontract goals, and other SBE development and
contracting efforts. Specifically, Business Services will maintain records and prepare
reports showing:
(a) Awards to SBE subcontractors and suppliers, including names of
contractors and subcontractors, nature of the work/services performed,
and the percentage of SBE participation per contract. The City will
obtain regular reports from prime contractors on their progress in
meeting contractual SBE commitments;
(b) Specific efforts by contractors to identify and award contracts to SBEs;
(c) Copies of direct mailings by contractors to SBEs;
(d) City contracts awarded to SBEs or prime contractors in which an SBE was
a joint venture partner or part of a mentor protege team. This
information shall include without limitation the name and contact
information of the SBEs, the type of contract, and the dollar value of
15
the contract;
(e) Pre-bid conference information as it relates to the SBE program;
(f) Requests for assistance from SBEs interested in bidding/proposing on city
contracts and subcontracts;
(g) Workshops, seminars and training programs conducted for SBEs; and
(h) Efforts to assist SBEs in acquiring bonding and insurance.
5. Business Services will submit annual SBE participation reports to the Council. These reports
shall include a summary of the information described in this section, plus an analysis of the total
dollar value of City contracts/subcontracts awarded to SBEs during the preceding year,
categorized by prime contracting dollars, subcontracting dollars, and supplier dollars. The
percentage of the total dollar value of these contracts that was awarded to SBEs during the
preceding year shall also be provided.
Sec. 6-2-413. — Small business enterprise program goals and counting procedures.
A. The Business Services Manager or appropriate designee in conjunction with the purchasing
agent will set an SBE subcontracting goal based on the established goal -setting
methodology in the Business Services policy and manual for each specific prime
contract with subcontracting and/or supplier possibilities, but shall have the authority to
reduce or eliminate such SBE goal on a contract-by-contract basis based upon the type
of contract, the type of subcontracting work that will be required, and the availability of
SBEs therefor. Every bidder on an eligible project shall be required to submit, with its
bid submission, the names, address, certification numbers, if applicable, of certified
SBEs or firms that have applied for SBE certification at the time of the bid submission,
and any other information required by Business Services as set forth in the project's
solicitation documents.
B. SBE participation is counted as follows:
1. The City will only give bidders credit toward the SBE goal(s) for those SBEs that
16
are certified as of the bid or proposal due date.
2. Once a firm is certified as a n SBE, the total dollar value of the subcontractor or
supplier contract awarded to the SBE by the contractor is counted toward the
applicable SBE goal. However, if a firm who is listed on the contract as having its
SBE certification pending has its certification denied, or if an SBE fails to be
recertified during the term of the contract, or if an SBE is decertified during the
term of the contract, the dollar value of the contract awarded to that SBE cannot be
counted toward the applicable SBE goal.
3. The City will count toward its SBE goal a portion of the total dollar value of a
contract with a joint venture equal to the percentage of the ownership and
contractual commitment to the SBE partner in the joint venture.
4. The City will count toward the SBE goal a portion of the total dollar value of a
contract with a mentor protege team equal to the percentage of the project self -
performed by the SBE member of the team.
5. The City will count toward its SBE goal only expenditures to SBEs that perform a
commercially useful function in the work of the contract.
6. The City will count toward its SBE goals the following expenditures to SBE
firms that are not suppliers:
a. The fees or commissions charged for providing a bona fide service, such
as professional, technical, consultant or managerial services and assistance
in the procurement of essential personnel, facilities, equipment, materials
or supplies required for performance of the contract, provided that the fee
or commission is determined by the City to be reasonable and not
excessive as compared with fees customarily allowed for similar services.
b. The fees charged for delivery of materials and supplies required on a job
site (but not the cost of the materials and supplies themselves) when the
hauler, trucker, or delivery service is not also the manufacturer of, or a
regular dealer in, the materials and supplies, provided that the fee is
determined by the City to be reasonable and not excessive as compared
with fees customarily allowed for similar services. The fees or
17
commissions charged for providing any bonds or insurance specifically
required for the performance of the contract, provided that the fee or
commission is determined by the City to be reasonable and not excessive
as compared with fees customarily allowed for similar services.
C. Goal Setting Committee:
Each Goal Setting Committee or series of Goal Setting Committees is to be appointed and
chaired by the Business Services Manager or designee. The committee shall include, at a
minimum, the Purchasing Agent or designee, the Business Services Manager or designee, the
Chief Financial Officer or designee, the Director or designee of the originating department.
The committee will determine which goals will be applied to specific contracts based on
various criteria.
D. Sheltered market.
1. Business Services, in consultation with the purchasing department will designate
certain procurements as sheltered market procurement opportunities, which will
only be open for competition by and between SBEs.
a. Contracts of $2,500.00 to $100,000.00. Under the sheltered market program,
every acquisition of goods or services that has an anticipated dollar value
between $2,500.00 and $100,000.00 is automatically reserved exclusively for
small businesses, except for those contracts pertaining to street projects, as
described in the CIP budget. The Business Services designee and the
purchasing agent may agree to exclude any procurement in this category from
the sheltered market at their joint discretion. The sheltered market
procurement requirement will only apply when there is a reasonable
expectation that offers will be obtained from three or more SBEs that are
competitive in terms of market prices, quality, and delivery. If only one
acceptable offer is received from a responsible SBE, the sheltered market
procurement will be withdrawn and the product or service, if still needed,
will be solicited on an unrestricted basis.
b. Contracts over $100,000.00. In addition, the Business Services designee and
purchasing agent may agree to designate any contract over $100,000.00 for
18
SBEs, except for those contracts pertaining to street projects, pertaining to
public works construction, or other projects for which a sheltered market
would conflict with state law. The sheltered market designation shall be
made only when there is a reasonable expectation that bids will be obtained
from at least three responsible SBEs and that the award will be made at a fair
market price.
2. Partial sheltered market procurements. A sheltered market procurement of a
single acquisition or a class of acquisitions may be total or partial. The Business
Services designee and the purchasing agent may designate a portion of an
acquisition as sheltered market procurement, except for construction.
3. To obtain sheltered market procurement, an SBE must perform at least a given
percentage of the contract. This provision limits the amount of subcontracting an
SBE may enter into with other firms when performing these types of contracts. The
provisions are as follows:
a. Construction. For general and heavy construction contractors, at least 15
percent of the cost of the contract, not including the cost of materials, must
be performed by the SBE prime contractor with its own employees. For
special trade construction, such as plumbing, electrical, or tile work, this
requirement is 25 percent.
b. Manufacturing. At least 50 percent of the cost of manufacturing, not
including the cost of materials, must be performed by the SBE prime
contractor.
c. Services. At least 50 percent of the contract cost for personnel must be
performed by the SBE prime contractor's own employees.
Sec. 6-2-414. — Certification as a Small Business Enterprise.
A. A business seeking certification or recognition of certification from the City as
an SBE must submit documentation as designated by the City on the prescribed form,
affirming under penalty of perjury that the business qualifies as an SBE. In order to qualify
as an SBE, the potential SBE owner must meet the following requirements:
19
1. Demonstrate that the firm's gross revenues or number of employees averaged over
the past three years, inclusive of any affiliates as defined by 13 CFR 121.103 do
not exceed ten million dollars ($10,000,000) or three hundred (300) employees;
2. Demonstrate that the SBE owners listed on the certification application own and
control the business;
3. Demonstrate that it is or will be performing a commercially useful function;
4. Demonstrate that it is located in the City; and
5. Demonstrate that the principal owner maintains a residence in the Memphis MSA.
B. Business Services or the Certifying Entity may also, if it deems it necessary, perform an
on-site review of the potential SBE owner's business prior to approving an application for
certification.
C. A firm that is denied certification may not reapply for certification for a period of 12
months from the date of the denial.
D. Firms certified by other government agencies will be required to be certified under this
chapter regardless of previous certification.
E. When a firm which has previously been designated an SBE exceeds either the gross revenue
or the number of employees provision, it will be deemed to have graduated from the SBE
Program with no right of reentry.
1. Graduation procedures. Any interested party may request an evaluation of an
SBE firm. That evaluation will be performed at the time of the recertification
for the SBE. Upon recertification, a firm will be evaluated for graduation from
the program. Once Business Services has been notified by the certifying agency
that the firm has exceeded the size standards established by the NAICS, the
following steps will be followed:
a. Notification. Business Services shall issue a letter of notification to the
firm detailing its intent to graduate the firm from the program. The
letter of notification shall set forth findings, based on the facts and in
accordance with law and regulations, for every material issue relating to
the basis of the program graduation with specific reasons for each
20
finding.
b. Appeal. The firm will be allowed 45 days from the date of the letter to
appeal the decision. To appeal the decision, the firm must submit in
writing to Business Services, information which would explain why the
proposed basis of graduation is not warranted. Upon receipt of the
appeal, Business Services will notify the firm in writing of the receipt
of the appeal.
c. Review. If the firm appeals its graduation from the program within the
requisite 45 days, the appeal will be reviewed by a committee composed
of the director of finance, purchasing agent, and city engineer. Within 15
days of receipt of the appeal, a written decision will be issued to the firm
by the committee via Business Services.
2. Post graduation. After the effective date of firm's graduation from the program
as provided for herein, a firm is no longer eligible to participate in or receive
assistance from the SBE program. However, such firm is obligated to complete
previously awarded contracts and/or subcontracts, including any priced bids that
may be exercised. Upon graduation there will be no right of reentry.
Sec. 6-2-415. — Recertification.
Once certified as an SBE by the City or approved certifying entities, the certification
is valid for a period of one year from the date the City or approved certifying entity certified the
applicant as an SBE. Prior to the expiration of the one-year period, a business that desires to
be recertified by the City or approved certifying entity shall:
1. File an application to renew with the City or approved certification entity as
designated by the City; and
2. Meet the requirements specified in this chapter for certification
as an SBE.
21
Sec. 6-2-417. — Decertification of Small Business Enterprise.
A. The City or approved certifying entities may decertify the SBE for any of the following
reasons:
1. Changes in the firm’s circumstances since the certification of the firm that
render the firm unable to meet the eligibility standards;
2. Information or evidence that was not available to the City at the time the firm
was certified that, if available, would have resulted in a denial of certification;
3. Information that was concealed or misrepresented by the firm in
connection with the certification application or review conducted by the
City;
4. A change in the certification standard or requirements of the City since the
certification of the firm;
5. Prior to taking formal action, Business Services staff shall provide the business with
written notice of the proposed revocation. During the pendency of the proceeding,
the SBE firm's certification shall remain valid. Business Services staff shall then
prepare a recommendation regarding the proposed revocation for review and
approval by the chief operating officer. If approved by the chief operating officer,
Business Services shall issue an initial notice of decertification to the SBE owner by
certified mail. The SBE may appeal the initial notice of decertification within seven
days of the receipt of the initial notice of decertification. If the SBE owner fails to
appeal the initial notice of decertification within the period set forth in this section,
the decertification shall be final and take effect immediately.
6. If Business Services decertifies an SBE proposed to work, or currently working, on
a contract, the decertified SBE's participation on the contract may no longer be
counted toward fulfillment of the City’s SBE goals. If the contractor no longer meets
the City’s SBE goals after the decertification of the former SBE, the contractor shall
be required, within 30 days after notification by Business Services, to demonstrate
good faith efforts to substitute the decertified SBE. Failure to demonstrate good
faith efforts to substitute a decertified SBE will result in the bidder being declared
22
nonresponsive, if done prior to the award of the contract, or the contractor being held
in default of the contact, if done after the award of the contract.
Sec. 6-2-418. — Certification reviews.
In addition to reviewing firms for cause, Business Services will conduct random
certification reviews of certified SBEs by auditing them to verify that the information
submitted by a business is accurate, and that the business remains eligible after certification has
been granted. Certification is subject to revocation if it is determined that a business no longer
qualifies as an SBE under the terms of this chapter. Certification reviews may be conducted for
any business for which Business Services determines a certification review is warranted.
Businesses subject to certification reviews must provide Business Services with any information
requested to verify the certification eligibility of the business.
Sec. 6-2-419. — Appeals.
A. Determination of noncompliance . A responsible bidder that is determined to be
nonresponsive to the requirements of this chapter, and that otherwise would have been
awarded a contract, as determined in consultation with the purchasing agent, shall receive a
written determination by the Business Services designee , via certified mail, setting forth the
reasons for the determination of nonresponsiveness.
B. Denial of certification as an SBE. Upon a denial of certification as an SBE, Business Services
shall notify the affected party in writing, via certified mail, setting forth the reasons for the
denial of certification.
C. Time for filing notice of appeal. Any business that has been denied certification as an SBE,
or against whom a final determination of nonresponsiveness to the requirements of this
chapter has been made by Business Services , may appeal the final determination of
nonresponsiveness or denial of SBE certification by filing a notice of appeal with Business
Services in writing within seven (7) calendar days of receipt of the notice of the final
determination of noncompliance or denial of certification.
D. Posting of appeal security . Any bidder that files an appeal to a final determination of
23
nonresponsiveness by Business Services must, at the time of filing, post security in the
amount of one percent of the financial offer of the appellant. If the Business Services
hearing officer upholds the determination of the office of contract compliance, he or she
shall assess against the appellant reasonable attorneys' fees and other administrative costs
incurred by the City in reviewing and responding to the appeal. If the City is represented
by its law department, such fees and costs will be calculated at the hourly rate of each
attorney participating in the review and response to the appeal set forth in each attorney's
most recent City paycheck times the number of hours worked by such participating
attorneys on the appeal. If the City is represented by outside counsel, such fees and costs
will be calculated at the billing rates of the firm's attorneys, plus all out-of-pocket costs
of the firm concerning the appeal. Within 15 days of ruling against the appellant, the
Business Services hearing officer, in consultation with the City’s law department and
outside counsel, if any, will calculate the City’s cost in reviewing and responding to the
appeal and will apply the appellant's bond or certified check to the costs. Any remaining
balance of the bond or certified check will be returned to the appellant.
E. Notice of hearing date and hearing. Within three (3) calendar days of receipt of a notice
of appeal from an aggrieved party, excluding official holidays, the Business Services
designee shall forward the notice to the Business Services hearing officer.
F. Exhaustion of administrative remedies. A protester shall be required to exhaust its
administrative remedies before filing suit in any state or federal court based on a
determination of nonresponsiveness or denial of certification by Business Services
rendered pursuant to this chapter.
G. Duties of office of business services hearing officer . The duties of the Business
Services hearing officer shall be as follows::
1. The Business Services hearing officer shall have exclusive jurisdiction to
determine all appeals arising under this chapter.
2. The Business Services hearing officer shall set a hearing date not more than seven (7)
calendar days from the date of receipt of the notice of appeal from the Business Services
designee, excluding official holidays. The hearing officer shall cause notice of the hearing
to be served upon all parties by certified U.S. mail. Such notice shall set forth with
particularity the decision being appealed by the aggrieved business and shall include the
24
hearing date, time and place.
3. At the hearing, all parties shall be provided a fair and impartial hearing and shall
be allowed to produce any and all evidence in either party's possession
concerning the final determination of nonresponsiveness with the requirements
of this chapter, or the denial of certification as an SBE.
H. Decision. Within seven (7) calendar days after conclusion of the hearing, excluding
official holidays, the Business Services hearing officer shall make a written decision on
the appeal, which decision shall affirm, alter or reverse the final determination of
nonresponsiveness or the denial of certification by Business Services. The hearing officer
shall decide whether the final determination of nonresponsiveness or the denial of
certification being appealed was in accordance with the law in existence at the time that
the bidder was found to be nonresponsive, at the time that certification was denied, or at
the time the penalties were imposed.
I. Notice of decision. Within seven calendar days after conclusion of the hearing, excluding
official holidays, the Business Services hearing officer shall issue written notice of the
decision on the appeal to all parties. The notice of the decision shall be sent to all parties
by certified U.S. mail and shall set forth the reasons for the decision.
J. Appeal. The decision of the hearing officer shall be binding on all parties,
subject to the right of appeal to the chief operating officer or its designee.
Sec. 6-2-420. — Small business enterprise directory.
The City will create an S BE directory that lists S BEs categorized by types of firms to
facilitate identifying businesses with capabilities relevant to a particular specification. Each
business listing will contain the business name, contact person, address, phone number, legal
structure of the business, and details concerning the company's business specialties. North
American Industrial Classification System (NAICS) codes will be identified for each company.
Business Services will develop and continuously maintain a database as a public record of certified
SBE firms.. In compiling this directory, Business Services will identify and certify as many SBEs
as possible that perform the types of work or provide the types of supplies needed by the City. The
City will maintain and have available an updated SBE directory and source lists for each
bid/proposal solicitation to facilitate identifying SBEs working in areas relevant to general
25
contracting requirements and to particular solicitations.
Sec. 6-2-421. — Procedures to ensure that SBEs have an equitable opportunity to
compete for contracts and subcontracts.
A. Procedures to ensure opportunities. The City shall utilize the following measures
to ensure maximum practicable opportunities for SBE participation on city
contracts:
1. Assist SBE in obtaining insurance and surety bonds where necessary in the
performance of contracts, including but not limited to:
a. Encouraging prime contractors t o assist SBE subcontractors in obtaining
bonding;
b. Encouraging staged bonding where feasible, when bonding is carried
over from one project stage to the next; and
c. Relaxing bonding requirements for projects less than $100,000.00.
2. Encourage the formation of joint ventures between SBEs. Business Services
will also assist prime contractors in identifying interested SBEs for
subcontracts;
3. Provide information on the City’s organization and contractual needs and offer
instructions on bid specifications, procurement policy, procedures, and general
bidding requirements;
4. Provide specifications and requests for proposals to the SBE community in a timely
manner to allow SBEs adequate time to develop responsible and responsive bids. In
instances where the cost of obtaining specifications or requests for proposal is
prohibitive, copies of the material will be made available at no charge to SBE
development agencies;
5. Establish prorated payment and delivery schedules where feasible, to minimize
cash flow problems faced by small firms. The City will provide guidance to SBE
contractors regarding maintenance of positive flow in order that current
obligations can be met;
26
6. Hold pre-bid conferences to explain SBE requirements as well as forms that
must be submitted with a bid;
7. Permit bidders to review and evaluate successful bid documents of similar
procurements and use debriefing sessions to explain why certain bids were
unsuccessful;
8. Provide projected procurement information and contracting schedules through
the office of contract compliance and other outreach efforts;
9. Conduct internal information workshops to inform and acquaint City staff with
the goals and objectives of the City’s small business enterprise program, and to
sensitize them to the challenges faced by SBEs;
10. Maintain records showing specific efforts to identify and award contracts to
SBEs and establish a monitoring system to ensure that all contractors,
subcontractors, consultants, and vendors comply with contracts specifications
related to SBE utilization; and
11. Inform SBEs of bid notices and specifications related to their capability by placing
bid notices in major local newspapers and other periodicals. Bid notices will also be
sent to local trade associations, technical assistance agencies, economic development
groups, and SBEs with capabilities that may be relevant to the bid notice as identified
by the City’s SBE database . Bid specifications will be made available to SBE
contractor associations and technical assistance agencies. Lists of potential firms
bidding as primes will also be made available to SBEs.
B. Direct assistance to SBEs. In addition to the procedures set forth in subsection A of this
section, Business Services shall also undertake special measures to assist SBEs in
overcoming barriers to participation on City contracts. This assistance will be offered
directly by the City , as well as by City referral to other assistance agencies with
established, comprehensive, and continuous SBE development programs. Businesses
requiring management and technical assistance will be identified through a questionnaire,
through personal experience with these businesses, and through requests for assistance.
Business Services will offer the following direct assistance to SBEs:
1. Provide counseling and training sessions for SBEs. City staff will be available to
27
interested business representatives to explain (in detail) instructions for
preparation of bid specifications, the City’s procurement policies, procedures and
general bid requirements. The Business Services designee will coordinate and
follow up on all requests for assistance to ensure that all necessary information was
provided.
2. Provide coordination and referral to existing business development organizations.
3. Sponsor intensive workshops and training sessions on identified SBE problem
areas (i.e., pricing and estimating, joint venture formation, accounting
principles, marketing, etc.).
Sec. 6-2-422. — Methods by which the city will require contractors and subcontractors to
comply with applicable SBE requirements.
The City’s staff is available to assist contractors and subcontractors in implementing this
program. As a standard procedure, such assistance includes:
1. Clearly set forth the City’s SBE Program goals in all City solicitations.
2. Attend pre-proposal/bid conferences to explain the City’s SBE Program.
3. Identify certified SBEs in the City’s database and providing a list of available,
certified SBEs upon request.
4. Provide plan holder lists and pre -bid sign- in sheets made available to interested
SBEs upon request.
5. Assist bidders with developing their SBE Programs.
6. Monitor SBE participation levels on projects throughout the duration of a
contract. Contractors violating contract provisions regarding SBE
participation are subject to the sanctions set forth in Section 6-94-17.
Sec. 6-2-423. — Means to ensure that bidders make good faith efforts to meet SBE contract
goals.
A. For all contracts for which SBE contract goals have been established, the bidder shall be
required to submit SBE participation information to the City and any other information
28
required by Business Services as set forth in the project's solicitation documents. The award
of the contract will be conditioned upon satisfaction of the requirements established by
the City. The bidder shall submit, with its bid submission, the following information:
1. The name, address and certification number, if applicable, of the SBE
firms that will participate in the contract;
2. The description of the work each named SBE will perform; and
3. The dollar amount of participation by each named SBE firm.
B. If the SBE participation submitted by the bidder does not meet the SBE contract goals,
the bidder must submit with its bid submission evidence demonstrating that good faith
efforts were made to meet the goals. The City will review documents submitted at the
time of the bid and make its determination of good faith efforts based on those submitted
documents. Additional submissions will not be permitted. To determine sufficient good
faith efforts to meet the SBE contract goal, a bidder/proposer shall document the steps
it has taken to obtain SBE participation, including but not limited to the following:
1. Attendance at a pre- bid meeting, if any, scheduled by the City to
inform SBEs of subcontracting opportunities under a given
solicitation.
2. Provide copies of a dvertisements in general circulation media, trade association
publications, and other media for at least 15 days before bids or proposals are due.
3. Copies of written notification sent to all City certified SBEs that perform the
type of work to be subcontracted, in sufficient time to allow said SBEs to
participate effectively, soliciting said SBEs' interest in working on the project
and advising the SBEs:
a. Of the specific work the bidder intends to subcontract;
b. That their interest in the project is being solicited; and
c. How to obtain information for the review and inspection of the plans,
specifications and requirements of the bid.
29
4. A written statement that economically feasible portions of work were selected
to be performed by SBEs, including, where appropriate, segmenting elements
of work or combining elements of work into economically feasible units. The
ability of the bidder to perform the work with its own work force will not in
itself excuse the bidder from making good faith efforts to meet participation
goals.
5. A statement of the good faith efforts to negotiate with SBEs for specific subcontracts,
including at a minimum:
a. The names, addresses, and telephone numbers of SBEs that were contacted.
b. A description of the information provided to SBEs regarding the plans and
specifications for portions of the work to be performed.
c. A statement of why additional agreements with SBE were not reached.
d. Concerning each SBE, the SBE contacted but rejected as unqualified, and the
reasons for the bidder's conclusion.
e. Efforts made to assist the SBEs contacted that needed assistance in obtaining
bonding or insurance required by the competitor or the City.
6. Outreach efforts documentation. A statement describing the bidder's outreach
efforts to identify, contact, contract with, or utilize businesses, including certified
SBEs, as subcontractors or suppliers on the eligible project. Business Services shall
set forth in the solicitation document the documents that a bidder may submit to
demonstrate its outreach efforts, and such documentation may include, without
limitation, evidence of the following:
a. The bidder contacted Business Services to identify available businesses to
work on the eligible project, including certified SBEs, regardless of race,
gender or ethnicity. Business Services will supply a letter to be included in
the bid of the efforts rendered by the bidder as it relates Business Services
recommendations.
b. The bidder placed notices of opportunities for qualified businesses to
perform subcontracting work on the eligible project in newspapers, trade
journals, and other relevant publications, including publications specifically
30
targeted to SBEs, or communicated such notices of opportunities via the
Internet or by other available media or means.
c. The bidder submitted invitations to bid for work on the eligible project to
qualified businesses, including certified SBEs.
d. The bidder included in such notices and invitations a full disclosure of the
criteria upon which bids, proposals or quotes would be evaluated, and also
included contact information for inquiries, submissions, or requests to
review any necessary bid documents.
e. The bidder promptly responded to inquiries, provided necessary physical
access and time for interested businesses to fully review all necessary bid
documents, and otherwise provided information, access and time necessary
to allow all interested businesses to prepare bids and quotes.
f. For each business which contacted or was contacted by the bidder regarding
subcontracting or other services on the eligible project but was not
contracted with or otherwise utilized on the eligible project, the bidder shall
provide a written statement setting forth the dates of such contacts, the
nature of such contacts, and the reasons why an agreement was not reached
regarding work to be performed on the project. The bidder shall maintain
all written documents reflecting such contacts, including bids, quotes and
proposals.
7. To determine whether a bidder that has failed to meet SBE goals may be awarded
the contract, the Business Services Manager, the director of finance and the purchasing
agent, prior to the award of the project, will determine whether the efforts the bidder
made to obtain SBE participation were good faith efforts. Efforts that are merely
pro forma are not good faith efforts to meet the goals. In order to award a contract
to a bidder that has failed to meet SBE contract goals, the Business Services
Manager, the director of finance and the purchasing agent will determine whether the
bidder actively and aggressively made efforts to meet the City’s SBE goals. A bidder
making a good faith effort would consider a number of factors in negotiating with
subcontractors, including SBE subcontractors, and would take a firm's price and
capabilities as well as contract goals into consideration. However, the fact that
31
there may be some additional costs involved in finding and using SBEs is not in
itself sufficient reason for a bidder's failure to meet the contract SBE goal, as long
as such costs are reasonable. Also, the ability or desire of a prime contractor to
perform the work of a contract with its own organization does not relieve the
bidder of the responsibility to make good faith efforts. Prime contractors are not,
however, required to accept higher quotes from SBEs if the price difference is
excessive or unreasonable. In determining whether a bidder has made good faith
efforts, the Office of Business Services will take into account the performance of
other bidders in meeting the contract. For example, when the apparent successful
bidder fails to meet the contract goal, but others meet it, the Office of Business
Services may reasonably raise the question of whether, with additional reasonable
efforts, the apparent successful bidder could have met the goal. If the apparent
successful bidder fails to meet the goal but meets or exceeds the average SBE
participation obtained by other bidders, the City may view this, in conjunction with
other factors, as evidence of the apparent successful bidder having made good faith
efforts. Businesses that fail to meet SBE goals and fail to demonstrate good faith
efforts shall be deemed nonresponsive to the City’s SBE requirements and shall
not be eligible to be awarded the contract.
8. To ensure that all obligations under contracts awarded to SBEs are met, the City
shall review the contractor's SBE involvement efforts during the performance of
the contract. The contractor shall bring to the attention of the City any situation
in which regularly scheduled progress payments are not made to SBE
subcontractors.
C. Bidders shall not terminate, replace, or reduce the work of the SBE that the bidder has
counted toward meeting the committed SBE goal unless:
1. The SBE refuses to enter into a contract consistent with the Letter of Intent.
2. The SBE’s certification expires.
3. The SBE materially breaches its contract with the bidder.
In addition to post -award terminations, the provisions of this section apply to pre -award
deletions of or substitutions for SBE firms put forward by bidders.
32
Sec. 6-2-424. — Penalties for noncompliance.
A contractor who fails to comply with any portion of this chapter, and whose failure
to comply continues for a period of 30 calendar days after the contractor receives written notice
of such noncompliance from the director of Business Services, shall be subject to any or all
of the following penalties:
1. Withholding of ten percent of all future payments for the eligible project until
Business Services determines that the contractor is in compliance with this
chapter.
2. Withholding of all future payments under the eligible project until it is
determined that the contractor is in compliance with this chapter.
3. Cancellation of the eligible project.
4. Refusal of all future contracts or subcontracts with the City for a minimum of one
year and a maximum of five years from the date upon which this penalty is
imposed.
Sec. 6-2-425. — Outreach to SBEs.
The City considers information dissemination and communication with SBEs as an
integral part of the city's SBE Program. As a part of its outreach program, Business Services
will solicit input from representatives of SBEs, trade associations and community organizations.
This input will serve several important functions, including:
1. Providing information to identify additional SBE firms;
2. Assisting in refining SBE Program goals and procedures; and
3. Providing an independent assessment of the effectiveness of the City’s SBE
program.
33
Sec. 6-2-426. — Procedures to require that participating SBEs are identified by name by
competitors for contracts.
A. The City shall indicate, in solicitations for contracts that provide opportunities for SBE
participation, goals for the use of SBE firms. Solicitations shall require all bidders to
submit a written assurance of meeting the goals in their bids or proposals. Bids must
also include a proposed schedule of SBE participation that lists the names of SBE
subcontractors, a description of the work each is to perform, and the dollar value of each
proposed SBE subcontract. If the SBE participation does not meet the SBE contract
goals, the bidders must submit sufficient information and evidence demonstrating that
the bidder made good faith efforts to meet the goals.
B. Bidders are required to submit this information with their bids and bidders are so
informed at the time of solicitation. Agreements between a bidder and an SBE in which
the SBE promises not to provide subcontracting quotations to other bidders shall be
prohibited.
34
Sec. 6-2-427. — Local preference for award of city contracts.
Purpose and intent. The City shall give a local preference to local businesses in the city limits in
awarding City contracts and making purchases whenever the application of such a preference is
reasonable in light of the dollar value of the proposal received in relation to such expenditure.
1. Local preference.
a. In order to be eligible for the local preference, the vendor must provide a copy
of the domestic county and state business license and shall also provide proof
that county personal property taxes and all other necessary local business
operational taxes inherent to businesses whose principal base of operations is
located within the city limits were appropriately paid and/or authorize the
governing bodies of each agency to release such information to the city.
b. In the bidding of, or letting contracts for procurement of supplies, materials,
equipment and services, with a total price of $10,000.00 or more, local
preference shall mean that if the lowest responsive bidder is a regional or non-
local business, then all bids received from responsive local businesses are
decreased by five percent. The original bid is not changed; the five percent
decrease is calculated only for the purposes of determining the local preference.
The local preference cost differential is not to exceed $100,000.00.
c. In the case of a request for proposal, letters of interest, best evaluated bids,
qualifications or other solicitations and competitive negotiation and selection in
which objective factors are used to evaluate the responses, local businesses are
assigned five percent of the total points of the total evaluation points up to a
maximum of five points.
d. In the event of a tie between a local business and one or more non-local business
meeting specifications, the ties shall be broken in favor of the local business.
2. Local presence.
a. In the event there is no local business preference designation, either due to non-
participation or non- eligibility after the five percent differential or five -point
35
assignment, then local presence will be considered for the procurement of goods
and services over the amount of $2,000,000.00.
b. Local presence will be demonstrated by the total number of individuals a
business employs within the county. For procurements, a five percent
differential, which is not to exceed $200,000.00, shall be granted for the
business that demonstrates the highest number of total employees located
within the county at the time of the bid response. For request for proposals or
matters for which factors are evaluated, local presence at the time of the
response will be a weighted criterion. In no event shall the local presence
designation be allowed for a business with less than 25 local employees at the
time of the bid response.
3. Exceptions.
a. The local business preference or presence criteria shall not apply to purchases
or contracts which are funded, in whole or in part, by a governmental entity and
the laws, regulations, or policies governing such funding prohibit application of
the local preference, nor shall the local preference apply to purchases made or
contacts let under emergency or noncompetitive situations.
b. Application of the local preference or local presence criteria to a particular
purchase, contract or category of contracts for which the city is the awarding
authority may be waived upon written justification and recommendation of the
city to compare qualification, character, responsibility and fitness of all persons,
firms, or corporations submitting bids or proposals. Further, the preference or
presence criteria established herein in no way prohibit the right of the city from
giving any other preference permitted by law in addition to the preference
authorized herein.
Section 2. — Severability.
BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED, That if any provision of this chapter or any application
thereof to any person or circumstance is held invalid, such invalidity shall not affect other
provisions or applications of this chapter which can be given effect without the invalid
36
provisions or applications and are to this end declared to be severable.
Section 3. — Codification.
BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED, That this ordinance amends Chapter 2 of the Official City
Code. The City has authorized the Municipal Code Corporation to provide a republication of
the City's Ordinances in the Official City Code, as amended from time to time, for the
convenience of the public. The Official City Code and the official version of all new, amending,
repealing and clarifying ordinances adopted by the City Council are maintained by the City's
Comptroller in the Office of Council Records.
Section 4. –Effective Date.
BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED, That this Ordinance shall take effect after having been passed
by City Council, signed by the Chair of Council, certified and delivered to the office of the
Mayor in writing by the comptroller, and becomes effective as otherwise provided by law and
shall remain effective and operative unless and until the City Council alters, amends clarifies or
repeals it by a superseding, amending, clarifying or codifying ordinance.
Sponsor(s):
J. Ford Canale
CHAIRMAN
COM Revised 04.30.25
Memphis City Council Summary Sheet 1.Description of the Item (Resolution, Ordinance, etc.)Resolution to accept grant funds from TN Dept of Disability and Aging in the amount of hirty housand ollars ($30,000) to support Senior Center operations and programming at Josephine Lewis Sr. Center. 2.Initiating Party (e.g. Public Works, at request of City Council, etc.)City of Memphis Parks 3.State whether this is a change to an existing ordinance orresolution, if applicable.N/A 4.State withered this will impact specific council districts or superdistricts.District-7 Super- 8 5.State whether this requires a new contract, or amends an existingcontract, if applicable.N/A 6.State whether this requires an expenditure of funds/requires abudget amendment.City of Memphis must approve revenue of hirty housand dollars ($30,000).
Resolution accepting grant funds of hty housand ollars ($30,000.00) from Tennessee Department of Disability and Aging for Josephine Lewis Senior Center. WHEREAS, Tennessee Department of Disability and Aging and is a division of the State of Tennessee; and WHEREAS, the City of Memphis, through Memphis Parks, owns and operates six senior centers; and WHEREAS, Memphis Parks has been awarded grant funds to support senior center operations and programming; and WHEREAS, Lewis senior center has been awarded grant funds in the amount of hirty housand ollars ($30,000.00); and WHEREAS, it is necessary to accept these funds and amend the Fiscal Year 2026 operating budget grant account PK90146 and; WHEREAS, it is necessary to appropriate these funds in the amount of hirty housand ollars ($30,000.00) for supplies; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Memphis that the Fiscal Year 2026 operating budget be hereby amended by accepting the grant of hirty housand ollars ($30,000.00) for supplies into PK90146; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that funding of $30,000.00) be allocated and appropriated to PK90146.
G138
P062
Source: City of Memphis website. First collected Oct 27, 2026.