RecordWell Data

Regular Meeting Planning and Zoning Documents

City of Memphis · Shelby County · meeting of Aug 5, 2025 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Memphis

This document is no longer listed on City of Memphis's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF MEMPHIS COUNCIL AGENDA CHECK OFF SHEET ___________________________________________________________________________________ | ONE ORIGINAL | Planning & Development | ONLY STAPLED | DIVISION |TO DOCUMENTS| Planning & Zoning COMMITTEE: 7 /22/2025 DATE PUBLIC SESSION: 8 /19/2025 DATE ITEM (CHECK ONE) ORDINANCE X RESOLUTION REQUEST FOR PUBLIC HEARING = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = ITEM DESCRIPTION: Resolution pursuant to Chapter 9.6 of the Memphis and Shelby County Unified Development Code approving a planned development at the subject property located at 4465 Poplar Avenue, known as case number PD 2025- 006 CASE NUMBER: PD 2025-006 DEVELOPMENT: Oak Court Mall II Planned Development LOCATION: 4465 Poplar Avenue COUNCIL DISTRICTS: District 5 and Super District 9 – Positions 1, 2, and 3 OWNER/APPLICANT: Oak Court Partners LLC REPRESENTATIVE: Brenda Solomito Basar REQUEST: Amendment to PD 87-313 to include additional land and to establish a new set of outline plan conditions for a mixed-use (residential and commercial) development AREA: +/-30.15 acres RECOMMENDATION: The Division of Planning and Development recommended Approval with revisions to the outline plan conditions The Land Use Control Board recommended Approval with revisions to the outline plan conditions RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION: Public Hearing Not Required Hearing – August 19, 2025 = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = PRIOR ACTION ON ITEM: (1) APPROVAL - (1) APPROVED (2) DENIED 07/10/2025 DATE (1) Land Use Control Board ORGANIZATION - (1) BOARD / COMMISSION (2) GOV’T. ENTITY (3) COUNCIL COMMITTEE = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = FUNDING: (2) REQUIRES CITY EXPENDITURE - (1) YES (2) NO $ AMOUNT OF EXPENDITURE $ REVENUE TO BE RECEIVED SOURCE AND AMOUNT OF FUNDS $ OPERATING BUDGET $ CIP PROJECT #_______________________________ $ FEDERAL/STATE/OTHER = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = ADMINISTRATIVE APPROVAL: DATE POSITION _ ____________________________________________ __7/11/25____ PLANNER II _____________________________________________ ____________ DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR _____________________________________________ __7/11/25____ ADMINISTRATOR _____________________________________________ ____________ DIRECTOR (JOINT APPROVAL) _____________________________________________ ____________ COMPTROLLER _____________________________________________ ____________ FINANCE DIRECTOR _____________________________________________ ____________ CITY ATTORNEY = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = _____________________________________________ ____________ CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER _____________________________________________ ____________ COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN Memphis City Council Summary Sheet PD 2025-006 RESOLUTION PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 9.6 OF THE MEMPHIS AND SHELB Y COUNTY UNIFIE D DEVELOPMENT CODE APPROVING A PLANNED D EVELOPMENT AT THE SUBJECT PROPERTY LOCATED AT 4465 POPLAR AVENUE, KNOWN AS CASE NUMBER PD 2025-006 • This item is a resolution with conditions to allow an amendment to PD 87-313 to include additional land and to establish a new set of outline plan conditions for a mixed-use (residential and commercial) development; and • This resolution, if approved with conditions, will supersede the existing zoning for this property; and • The item may require future public improvement contracts. 1 L A N D U S E C O N T R O L B O A R D R E C O M M E N D A T I O N At its regular meeting on T h u rs d ay , J u ly 1 0 , 2 0 2 5 the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board held a public hearing on the following application: CASE NUMBER: PD 2025-006 DEVELOPMENT: Oak Court Mall II Planned Development LOCATION: 4465 Poplar Avenue COUNCIL DISTRICT(S): District 5 and Super District 9 – Positions 1, 2, and 3 OWNER/APPLICANT: Oak Court Partners LLC REPRESENTATIVE: Brenda Solomito-Basar REQ UEST: Amendment to PD 87-313 to include additional land and to establish a new set of outline plan conditions for a mixed-use (residential and commercial) development EXISTING ZONING: Residential Single-Family – 10 (R-10) and Commercial Mixed -Use – 3(CMU-3) underlying PD 87-313 AREA: +/-30.15 acres The following spoke in support: None The following spoke in opposition: None The Land Use Control Board reviewed the application and the staff report. A motion was made and seconded to recommend approval with revisions to the outline plan conditions. The motion passed by a unanimous vote of 8-0 on the consent agenda. Respectfully, Chloe Christion Planner II Land Use and Development Services Division of Planning and Development Cc: Committee Members File 2 PD 2025-006 Outline Plan Conditions – Revisio ns Proposed language is indicated in bold, underline; deletions are indicated in bold strikethrough I. Uses Permitted A. The two free standing buildings located at the intersection of Poplar and the north/south road shall be restricted to office and financial uses. Any use permitted by right in the Commercial Mixed Use – 3 (CMU-3) District. The following additional uses are also permitted by right: 1. Multi-Family in the forms of Large Home, Stacked Townhouse and Apartment. 2. Personal Care Home for the Elderly 4. Neighborhood Arts Center 5. Off-Site Parking for Places of Worship 6. Convention Center 7. Hotel 8. Retail Sales – Outdoor 9. Automotive Sales/Showroom and associated service, including vehicle charging 10. Used goods, secondhand sales 11. Veterinary clinic, and associated uses B. The remaining portion-all uses permitted in the C-P District except: The following uses are prohibited: 1. Adult entertainment establishments 2. Automobile service station, service 3. Gasoline sales 4. Pawn shop 5. Free standing Vehicle wash 6. Sales or Service of Tractor Trailers and Heavy Trucks 7. Sales of Manufactured Housing 8. Palmist, Physic or Medium 9. Smoke/Vape Shop 10. Payday Loan and Flexible Loan Plan Establishments 11. Off Premise Advertising Signs 12. Youth Hostel 13. Bed and Breakfast, Short Term Rental 14. Blood Plasma Donation Center 3 II. Bulk Regulations A. Setbacks shall be consistent with those shown on the concept plan(s) or with the CMU- 3 District regulations. Maximum of 306.000 square feet of retail floor area and related commercial uses. B. Maximum of 132,000 square feet of office floor area and related uses including: 1. A maximum of 37.500 square feet of floor area for the free-standing building located west of the north/south roadway, and 2. A maximum of 6,500 square feet of floor area for the free-standing building located east of the north/south roadway adjacent to Poplar Avenue. C. A maximum of 27,000 square feet of additional floor area is permitted for either office or retail floor area and is to be located east of the north-south parkway. D. Maximum floor area east of the north-south parkway is 427,500. E. Minimum distance between the west curb of the north/south roadway and the west property line-100 feet. F. Maximum building heights: 1. Building heights shall no t exceed 100’ between 300’ and 700’ as measured from the westernmost property line adjoining the Village neighborhood. 2. Building heights shall not exceed 180’ beyond 700’ from the westernmost property line adjoining the Village neighborhood. III. Circulation, Access, and Parking A. The exact location and design of the curb cuts on dedicated streets are subject to the approval of the City Engineer. B. The applicant will dedicate an easement along the south line of Poplar Avenue so that there will be provided a street width of Poplar Avenue forty-six (46) feet from the center line of Poplar Avenue and improved with curb, gutter and sidewalks, the obligation for the improvements conditioned on the improvement by the City of Memphis of the north side of Poplar Avenue within five years of the approval of this P.D.; and if no improvement is made by the City of Memphis within this five year term, the obligation to improve the easement granted shall be terminated. C. The north/south roadway shall be dedicated and improved with a 68-foot right-of-way exclusive of the median width. D. No additional curb cuts other than the two shown on the outline plan shall be permitted on Poplar Avenue. E. No obstructions shall be constructed to prevent access between the proposed development and Goldsmith’s Oak Court unless approved by the Office of Planning and Development. F. Dropped G. All necessary railroad signalizations shall be the applicant’s expense. 4 H. Parking and loading spaces shall generally be in accordance with the Zoning O rdinance Unified Development Code requirements. Shared parking is hereby permitted for all uses and areas within this planned development. IV. Drainage A. Drainage east of the north/south roadway shall be routed along the east side of the roadway or within the roadway toward Southern Avenue. A. Drainage plans shall be submitted to the Division of Public Works City Engineering for review. and improvements shall be in accordance with the Subdivision Regulations. V. Landscaping and Screening A. The Landscape plan for the area west of the north/south roadway shall be recorded with the o utline plan. Detailed Landscaping shall be provided on the Final Plats for each Phase. B. The amount of landscaping and screening shown on the “site plan showing earthen berms and conceptual screening” shall be recorded with the outline plan. C. Light standards west of the north/south roadway shall be a maximum of 10 feet in height. Other light standards shall not exceed 25 feet in height. D. A minimum 15-foot-wide landscaping strip (Plate F) or an equivalent, approved by the Office of Planning and Development shall be provided along all dedicated street frontages. E. There shall be constructed, between the west line of the north/south roadway and the west line of the property, from the south line of the property to the extension of the north line of Lot 2, Barboro Subdivision, earthen berms of the average height of 6 feet. These berms shall be in addition to the landscaping provided herein. The berms and area described herein shall be maintained by the owners of the property. VI. Signage A. Signage shall be in conf ormance with regulations established for Mixed Use Districts as defined in UDC Section 4.9.7D. One ground mounted detached sign not exceeding 100 square feet in area and setback a minimum of 15 feet shall be permitted along the Poplar Avenue frontage, and one along the Southern Avenue frontage. (8-SEE SHEET 3 OF 3 FOR REVISED SIGNAGE NOTE VI.A) B. All signage details shall be illustrated on the final plan. One detached sign for each of the free-standing buildings located near Poplar Avenue shall be permitted. Each sign shall not exceed 35 square feet in area and shall be in accordance with other O-G District sign regulations. C. No other detached signage shall be permitted. Attached signage shall be permitted in accordance with the C-P District regulations. 5 VII. The Land U se Control Board may modify the bulk, access, parking, landscaping, and sign requirements if equivalent alternatives are presented. may make modifications to Condition II through VI but may not increase the maximum quantities approved. The Board may require notification to adjacent property owners prior to approving any modifications. X. Any expansion of this Planned Development is permitted for adjacent parcels subject to Land Use Control Board approval as a Major Modification. XI. A final plan shall be filed within ten (10) years of the date of approval of the Outline Plan by the Legislative Body. The Land Use Control Board may grant extensions at the request of the applicant. XII. Any final plan shall include the following: A. The outline plan conditions. B. The exact location and dimensions, including lots, buildable areas, pedestrian and utility easements, service drives, parking areas, trash receptacles, buildings, loading facilities, and required landscaping and screening areas. C. The location and ownership, whether public or private, of any easement. A. The location and dimensions of building footprints, parking lots, private drives, building elevations, and landscaping and screening. E. A lighting plan detailing the location, height, style, direction, etc. of all outdoor lighting and a photometric plan shall be submitted for administrative review and approval by the Division of Planning and Development. F. A standard improvement contract as defined by Section 5.5.5 of the UDC for any needed public improvements. G. A statement conveying all common facilities and areas, including private drives, common open space and recreation areas, sanitary and storm sewers, or other drainage facilities, and other public facilities dedicated to a property owner’s association or other entity, for ownership and maintenance purposes. H. The 100-year flood elevation. I. The following note shall be placed on the final plat of any development requiring on- site storm water detention facilities: The areas denoted by "Reserved for Storm Water Detention" shall not be used as a building site or filled without first obtaining written permission from the City and/or County Engineer. The storm water detention systems located in these areas, except for those parts located in a public drainage easement, shall be owned, and maintained by the property owner and/or property owners' association. Such maintenance shall be performed so as to ensure that the system operates in accordance with the approved plan on file in the City and/or County Engineer's Office. Such maintenance shall include, but not be limited to removal of sedimentation, fallen objects, debris and trash, mowing, outlet cleaning, and repair of drainage structures. 6 CONCEPT PLAN A 7 CONCEPT PLAN B RESOLUTION PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 9.6 OF THE MEMPHIS AND SHELBY COUNTY UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT C ODE APPROVING A P LANNED DEVELOPMENT AT THE SUBJECT PROPERTY LOCATED AT 4465 POPLAR AVENUE, KNOWN AS CASE NUMBER PD 2025-006 WHEREAS, Chapter 9.6 of the Memphis and Shelby County Unified Development Code, being a section of the Joint Ordinance Resolution No. 5367, dated August 10, 2010, authorizes the Council of the City of Memphis to grant a planned development for certain stated purposes in the various zoning districts; and WHEREAS, the Oak Couty Partners LLC filed an application with the Memphis and Shelby County Division of Planning and Development to allow an amendment to PD 87-313 to include additional land and to establish a new set of outline plan conditions for a mixed- use (residential and commercial) development; and WHEREAS, the Division of Planning and Development has received and reviewed the application in accordance with procedures, objectives and standards for planned developments as set forth in Chapter 9.6 with regard to the proposed development's impacts upon surrounding properties, availability of public facilities, both external and internal circulation, land use compatibility, and that the design and amenities are consistent with the public interest; and has submitted its findings and recommendation subject to outline plan conditions concerning the above considerations to the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board; and WHEREAS, a public hearing in relation thereto was held before the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board on July 10, 2025 and said Board has submitted its findings and recommendation subject to outline plan conditions concerning the above considerations to the Council of the City of Memphis; and WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Memphis has reviewed the aforementioned application pursuant to Tennessee Code Annotated Section 13-4- 202(B)(2)(B)(iii) and has determined that said development is consistent with the Memphis 3.0 General Plan; and WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Memphis has reviewed the recommendation of the Land Use Control Board and the report and recommendation of the Division of Planning and Development and has determined that said development meets the objectives, standards and criteria for a special use permit, and said development is consistent with the public interests. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF MEMPHIS, that, pursuant to Chapter 9.6 of the Memphis and Shelby County Unified Development Code, a planned development is hereby granted in accordance with the attached outline plan conditions. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED , t hat the requirements of said aforementioned clause of the Unified Development Code shall be deemed to have been complied with; that the outline plan shall bind the applicant, owner, mortgagee, if any, and the legislative body with respect to the contents of said plan; and the applicant and/or owner may file a final plan in accordance with said outline plan and the provisions of Section 9.6.11 of the Unified Development Code. OUTLINE PLAN CONDITIONS I. Uses Permitted A. Any use permitted by right in the Commercial Mixed Use – 3 (CMU-3) District. The following additional uses are also permitted by right: 1. Multi-Family in the forms of Large Home, Stacked Townhouse and Apartment. 2. Personal Care Home for the Elderly 4. Neighborhood Arts Center 5. Off-Site Parking for Places of Worship 6. Convention Center 7. Hotel 8. Retail Sales – Outdoor 9. Automotive Sales/Showroom and associated service, including vehicle charging 10. Used goods, secondhand sales 11. Veterinary clinic, and associated uses B. The following uses are prohibited: 1. Adult entertainment establishments 2. Gasoline sales 3. Pawn shop 4. Free standing Vehicle wash 5. Sales or Service of Tractor Trailers and Heavy Trucks 6. Sales of Manufactured Housing 7. Palmist, Physic or Medium 8. Smoke/Vape Shop 9. Payday Loan and Flexible Loan Plan Establishments 10. Off Premise Advertising Signs 11. Youth Hostel 12. Bed and Breakfast, Short Term Rental 13. Blood Plasma Donation Center II. Bulk Regulations A. Setbacks shall be consistent with those shown on the concept plan(s) or with the CMU-3 District regulations. B. Minimum distance between the west curb of the north/south roadway and the west property line-100 feet. C. Maximum building heights: 1. Building heights shall not exceed 100’ between 300’ and 700’ as measured from the westernmost property line adjoining the Village neighborhood. 2. Building heights shall not exceed 180’ beyond 700’ from the westernmost property line adjoining the Village neighborhood. III. Circulation, Access, and Parking A. The exact location and design of the curb cuts on dedicated streets are subject to the approval of the City Engineer. B. All necessary railroad signalizations shall be the applicant’s expense. C. Parking and loading spaces shall generally be in accordance with the Unified Development Code requirements. Shared parking is hereby permitted for all uses and areas within this planned development. IV. Drainage A. Drainage plans shall be submitted to City Engineering for review. V. Landscaping and Screening A. The Landscape plan for the area west of the north/south roadway shall be recorded with the outline plan. Detailed Landscaping shall be provided on the Final Plat for each Phase. B. The amount of landscaping and screening shown on the “site plan showing earthen berms and conceptual screening” shall be recorded with the outline plan. C. Light standards west of the north/south roadway shall be a maximum of 10 feet in height. Other light standards shall not exceed 25 feet in height. D. There shall be constructed, between the west line of the north/south roadway and the west line of the property, from the south line of the property to the extension of the north line of Lot 2, Barboro Subdivision, earthen berms of the average height of 6 feet. These berms shall be in addition to the landscaping provided herein. The berms and area described herein shall be maintained by the owners of the property. VI. Signage A. Signage shall be in conformance with regulations established for Mixed Use Districts as defined in UDC Section 4.9.7D. B. All signage details shall be illustrated on the final plan. VII. The Land Use Control Board may modify the bulk, access, parking, landscaping, and sign requirements if equivalent alternatives are presented. VIII. Any expansion of this Planned Development is permitted for adjacent parcels subject to Land Use Control Board approval as a Major Modification. IX. A final plan shall be filed within ten (10) years of the date of approval of the Outline Plan by the Legislative Body. The Land Use Control Board may grant extensions at the request of the applicant. X. Any final plan shall include the following: A. The outline plan conditions. B. The exact location and dimensions, including lots, buildable areas, pedestrian and utility easements, service drives, parking areas, trash receptacles, buildings, loading facilities, and required landscaping and screening areas. C. The location and ownership, whether public or private, of any easement. D. The location and dimensions of building footprints, parking lots, private drives, building elevations, and landscaping and screening. E. A lighting plan detailing the location, height, style, direction, etc. of all outdoor lighting and a photometric plan shall be submitted for administrative review and approval by the Division of Planning and Development. F. A standard improvement contract as defined by Section 5.5.5 of the UDC for any needed public improvements. G. A statement conveying all common facilities and areas, including private drives, common open space and recreation areas, sanitary and storm sewers, or other drainage facilities, and other public facilities dedicated to a property owner’s association or other entity, for ownership and maintenance purposes. H. The 100-year flood elevation. I. The following note shall be placed on the final plat of any development requiring on- site storm water detention facilities: The areas denoted by "Reserved for Storm Water Detention" shall not be used as a building site or filled without first obtaining written permission from the City and/or County Engineer. The storm water detention systems located in these areas, except for those parts located in a public drainage easement, shall be owned, and maintained by the property owner and/or property owners' association. Such maintenance shall be performed so as to ensure that the system operates in accordance with the approved plan on file in the City and/or County Engineer's Office. Such maintenance shall include, but not be limited to removal of sedimentation, fallen objects, debris and trash, mowing, outlet cleaning, and repair of drainage structures. C O N C E P T P L A NA C O N C E P T P L A N B ATTEST: CC: Division of Planning and Development – Land Use and Development Services – Office of Construction Enforcement Staff Writer: C h loe C h ri s t i on E-mail: c h loe . c h ri s t i on @ m e m ph i s t n . g ov AGENDA ITEM: 5 L.U.C.B. MEETING: July 10, 2025 CASE NUMBER: PD 2025-006 DEVELOPMENT: Oak Court Mall II Planned Development LOCATION: 4465 Poplar Avenue COUNCIL DISTRICT: District 5 and Super District 9 – Positions 1, 2, and 3 OWNER/APPLICANT: Oak Court Partners LLC REPRESENTATIVE: Brenda Solomito Basar REQ UEST: Amendment to PD 87 -313 to include additional land and to establish a new set of outline plan conditions for a mixed use (residential and commercial) development EXISTING ZONING: PD 87-313 CONCLUSIONS 1. The applicant seeks an amendment to the Oak Court Mall Planned Development to include the land of the former Macy’s building, and allow for a variety of uses including apartments, townhomes, retail, and designated open space. See complete list of permitted uses in outline plan conditions on pages 19-22. 2. In addition toadding the former Macy's land, this proposal amends areas within the existing Oak Court Mall Planned Development and establishes a new planned development preliminarily known as the Oak Court Mall II Planned Development with a revised set of outline plan conditions in accordance with Paragraph 9.6.11E(1) of the Unified Development Code. 3. Overall, staff supports the applicant’s desire to implement an outline plan that will act as a guideline for future mixed-use development at a prime location. 4. The project will not have a substantial or undue adverse effect upon adjacent property, the character of the neighborhood, traffic conditions, parking, utility facilities and other matters affecting the public health, safety, and general welfare. CONSISTENCY WITH MEMPHIS 3.0 This proposal is consistent with the Memphis 3.0 General Plan per the land use decision criteria. See further analysis on page 39-32 of this report. RECOMMENDATION: A pproval w i t h re vi s i on s t o t h e ou t li n e plan c on d i t i on s Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 2 2 LOCATION MAP Subject property located within the pink circle SUBJECT PROPERTY Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 3 3 PUBLIC NOTICE VICINITY MAP Subject property outlined in yellow PUBLIC NOTICE DETAILS In accordance with Sub-Section 9.3.4A of the Unified Development Code, a notice of public hearing is required to be mailed and signage posted. A total of 100 notices were mailed on May 23, 2025, see page 33 of this report for a copy of said notice. Additionally, six signs were posted at the subject property, see page 34 of this report for a copy of the sign affidavit. NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING The meeting was held at 5:00 PM on Tuesday, May 27 , at Wilson Chapel in Christ Methodist Church at 4488 Poplar Avenue. Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 4 4 AERIAL Subject property outlined in yellow, imagery from 2023 Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 5 5 ZONING MAP Subject property highlighted in yellow Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 6 6 LAND USE MAP Subject property indicated by a pink star Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 7 7 SITE PHOTOS View of subject property from existing southernmost parking lot. View of subject property from existing southeast parking lot facing north. Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 8 8 View of mall entrance from the south of Oak Court Drive facing east. View of mall entrance from Poplar Avenue facing south. Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 9 9 View of subject property from Poplar Avenue facing southwest. View of subject property from existing southernmost parking lot. Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 10 10 OUTLINE PLAN Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 11 11 CONCEPT PLAN A Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 12 12 CONCEPT PLAN B Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 13 13 SPIRIT IMAGERY Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 14 14 CASE REVIEW Request The request is an amendment to PD 87-313 to include additional land and to establish a new set of outline plan conditions for a mixed use (residential and commercial) development. Applicability Staff agrees the applicability standards and criteria as set out in Section 4.10.2 of the Unified Development Code are or will be met. 4.10.2 Applicability The governing bodies may, upon proper application, grant a special use permit for a planned development (see Chapter 9.6) for a tract of any size within the City or for tracts of at least three acres in unincorporated Shelby County to facilitate the use of flexible techniques of land development and site design, by providing relief from district requirements designed for conventional developments, and may establish standards and procedures for planned developments in order to obtain one or more of the following objectives: A. Environmental design in the development of land that is of a higher quality than is possible under the regulations otherwise applicable to the property. B. Diversification in the uses permitted and variation in the relationship of uses, structures, open space and height of structures in developments intended as cohesive, unified projects. C. Functional and beneficial uses of open space areas. D. Preservation of natural features of a development site. E. Creation of a safe and desirable living environment for residential areas characterized by a unified building and site development program. F. Rational and economic development in relation to public services. G. Efficient and effective traffic circulation, both within and adjacent to the development site, that supports or enhances the approved transportation network. H. Creation of a variety of housing compatible with surrounding neighborhoods to provide a greater choice of types of environment and living units. I. Revitalization of established commercial centers of integrated design to order to encourage the rehabilitation of such centers in order to meet current market preferences. J. Provision in attractive and appropriate locations for business and manufacturing uses in well -designed buildings and provision of opportunities for employment closer to residence with a reduction in travel time from home to work. K. Consistency with the Memphis 3.0 General Plan. General Provisions Staff agrees the general provisions standards and criteria as set out in Section 4.10.3 of the Unified Development Code are or will be met. 4.10.3 General Provisions The governing bodies may grant a special use permit for a planned development which modifies the applicable district regulations and other regulations of this development code upon written findings and recommendations of the Land Use Control Board and the Zoning Administrator which shall be forwarded pursuant to provisions contained in this Chapter. Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 15 15 A. The proposed development will not unduly injure or damage the use, value and enjoyment of surrounding property nor unduly hinder or prevent the development of surrounding property in accordance with the current development policies and plans of the City and County. B. An approved water supply, community waste water treatment and disposal, and storm water drainage facilities that are adequate to serve the proposed development have been or will be provided concurrent with the development. C. The location and arrangement of the structures, parking areas, walks, lighting and other service facilities shall be compatible with the surrounding land uses, and any part of the proposed development not used for structures, parking and loading areas or access way shall be landscaped or otherwise improved except where natural features are such as to justify preservation. D. Any modification of the district standards that would otherwise be applicable to the site are warranted by the design of the outline plan and the amenities incorporated therein, and are not inconsistent with the public interest. E. Homeowners’ associations or some other responsible party shall be required to maintain any and all common open space and/or common elements. F. Lots of record are created with the recording of a planned development final plan. Residential Criteria Staff agrees the additional planned residential development criteria as set out in Section 4.10.4 of the Unified Development Code are or will be met. 4.10.4 Planned Residential Developments In addition to the standards and criteria set forth in Section 4.10.3, planned residential developments shall comply with the standards and criteria set forth below: A. Formal Open Space A minimum of 0.6% of the total land area of a planned residential development of 15 acres or more shall be subject to the formal open space requirements of Section 6.2.3. No open area may be delineated or accepted as formal open space under the provisions of this Chapter unless it meets the standards of Chapter 6.2, Open Space. B. Accessibility of Site All proposed streets, alleys and driveways shall be adequate to serve the residents, occupants, visitors or other anticipated traffic of the planned residential development. The location of the entrance points of the streets, alleys and driveways upon existing public roadways shall be subject to the approval of the City or County Division of Public Works. C. Off-Street Parking Off-street parking shall be conveniently accessible to all dwelling units and other uses. Where appropriate, common driveways, parking areas, walks and steps may be provided, maintained and lighted for night use. Screening of parking and service areas shall be required through use of trees, shrubs and/or hedges and screening walls. D. Pedestrian Circulation The pedestrian circulation system and its related walkways shall be separated, whenever feasible, from the vehicular street system in order to provide an appropriate degree of separation of pedestrian and vehicular movement. E. Privacy The planned residential development shall provide reasonable visual and acoustical privacy for dwelling units within and adjacent to the planned residential development. Protection and Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 16 16 enhancement of property and the privacy of its occupants may be provided by the screening of objectionable views or uses and reduction of noise through the use of fences, insulation, natural foliage, berms and landscaped barriers. High- rise buildings shall be located within the development in such a way as to minimize any adverse impact on adjoining low rise buildings. F. Distance Requirements Where minimum distance requirements are provided between single family residential zoning districts and certain stipulated uses in this Code, the single -family residential areas of planned developments shall be considered zoned residential. Commercial or Industrial Criteria Staff agrees the additional planned commercial or industrial development criteria as set out in Section 4.10.5 of the Unified Development Code are or will be met. 4.10.5 Planned Commercial or Industrial Developments Approval of a planned commercial or industrial development may be issued by the governing bodies for buildings or premises to be used for the retail sale of merchandise and services, parking areas, office buildings, hotels and motels and similar facilities ordinarily accepted as commercial center uses and those industrial uses which can be reasonably be expected to function in a compatible manner with the other permitted uses in the area. In addition to the applicable standards and criteria set forth in Section 4.10.3, planned commercial or industrial developments shall comply with the following standards: A. Screening When commercial or industrial structures or uses in a planned commercial or industrial development abut a residential district or permitted residential buildings in the same development, screening may be required by the governing bodies. B. Display of Merchandise All business, manufacturing and processing shall be conducted, and all merchandise and materials shall be displayed and stored, within a completely enclosed building or within an open area which is completely screened from the view of adjacent properties and public rights -of-way, provided, however, that when an automobile service station or gasoline sales are permitted in a planned commercial development, gasoline may be sold from pumps outside of a structure. C. Accessibility The site shall be accessible from the proposed street network in the vicinity which will be adequate to carry the anticipated traffic of the proposed development. The streets and driveways on the site of the proposed development shall be adequate to serve the enterprises located in the proposed development. D. Landscaping Landscaping shall be required to provide screening of objectionable views of uses and the reduction of noise. High-rise buildings shall be located within the development in such a way as to minimize any adverse impact on adjoining low-rise buildings. Approval Criteria Staff agrees the approval criteria as set out in Section 9.6.9 of the Unified Development Code are being met. 9.6.9 Approval Criteria No special use permit or planned development shall be approved unless the following findings are made concerning the application: Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 17 17 A. The project will not have a substantial or undue adverse effect upon adjacent property, the character of the neighborhood, traffic conditions, parking, utility facilities and other matters affecting the public health, safety, and general welfare. B. The project will be constructed, arranged and operated so as to be compatible with the immediate vicinity and not interfere with the development and use of adjacent property in accordance with the applicable district regulations. C. The project will be served adequately by essential public facilities and services such as streets, parking, drainage, refuse disposal, fire protection and emergency services, water and sewers; or that the applicant will provide adequately for such services. D. The project will not result in the destruction, loss or damage of any feature determined by the governing bodies to be of significant natural, scenic or historic importance. E. The project complies with all additional standards imposed on it by any particular provisions authorizing such use. F. The request will not adversely affect any plans to be considered (see Chapter 1.9), or violate the character of existing standards for development of the adjacent properties. G. The governing bodies may impose conditions to minimize adverse effects on the neighborhood or on public facilities, and to ensure compatibility of the proposed development with surrounding properties, uses, and the purpose and intent of this development code. H. Any decision to deny a special use permit request to place, construct, or modify personal wireless service facilities shall be in writing and supported by substantial evidence contained in a written record, per the Telecommunications Act of 1996, 47 USC 332(c)(7)(B)(iii). The review body may not take into account any environmental or health concerns. Site Details Address: 4465 Poplar Avenue Parcel ID: 057012 00037, 057012 00038, 057012 00045, 057012 00052, and 057012 00043 Area: +/-30.15 acres Description: The subject properties are known as phases 1 through 6 of Oak Court Mall Planned Development (PD 87 -313) and Lot 2 of Gibbons Subdivision, also known as the site of the former Macy’s department store. The site has previously been used as retail and office space with an associated parking garage. The site has s treet frontages on Oak Court Drive, Poplar Avenue, and Southern Avenue. Surrounding land uses are residential and commercial. Site Zoning History On December 18, 1984, the Council of the City of Memphis approved PD 84 -356 which allowed a planned development for property located on the south side of Poplar Avenue between Cherry Road and Grove Park Road. See pages 36-39 of this report for said resolution. On May 5, 1987, the Council of the City of Memphis approved PD 87-313 which allowed an amendment to the Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 18 18 above mentioned planned development. See pages 40-45 of this report for said resolution. Concept Plan Review and Analysis The applicant is seeking approval for an amendment of the existing Oak Court Mall Planned Development to incorporate additional land and allow for a variety of uses including an automotive showroom, neighborhood arts center, and multi- family uses. While earlier versions of the proposed plans included townhomes in the western 3-acre parcel, revised plans indicate the existing landscaped berm and buffer to be maintained. First Tennessee Bank (Parcel ID 057012 00036) and Dillard’s (Parcel ID 057012 00045) are not to be included in this amendment, thus, if approved, a re-recording of the original Oak Court Mall Planned Development (PD 87- 313) will be required to distinguish the two parcels from the parcels that are included in this amendment. A notable adjustment from the original Oak Court Mall PD are the adjustments to height regulations. The amendment permits that building heights 700 feet away from the west property line may be up to 180 feet. Within 300 to 700 feet of the west property line, heights may not exceed 100 feet. The below graphic illustrates the range that these conditions refer to, with the red highlight representing the range in which the height maximum is 100 feet, and the orange representing the range in which the height maximum is 180 feet. East Memphis hosts three of Memphis’s tallest buildings, including the 22-story, 274-foot I-Bank Tower and the 34-story 365-foot Clark Tower located about 1 ½ miles east of the subject property on Poplar Avenue. The amended conditions are of comparable stature to these structures, and the location restrictions prohibit the proximity of taller building to the adjacent neighborhood on the west. The project will not have a substantial or undue adverse effect upon adjacent property, the character of the Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 19 19 neighborhood, traffic conditions, parking, utility facilities and other matters affecting the public health, safety, and general welfare. RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends approval with revisions to the outline plan conditions. Outline Plan Conditions – Revisions Proposed language is indicated in bold, underline; deletions are indicated in bold strikethrough I. Uses Permitted A. The two free standing buildings located at the intersection of Poplar and the north/south road shall be restricted to office and financial uses. Any use permitted by right in the Commercial Mixed Use – 3 (CMU-3) District. The following additional uses are also permitted by right: 1. Multi-Family in the forms of Large Home, Stacked Townhouse and Apartment. 2. Personal Care Home for the Elderly 4. Neighborhood Arts Center 5. Off-Site Parking for Places of Worship 6. Convention Center 7. Hotel 8. Retail Sales – Outdoor 9. Automotive Sales/Showroom and associated service, including vehicle charging 10. Used goods, secondhand sales 11. Veterinary clinic, and associated uses B. The remaining portion-all uses permitted in the C-P District except: The following uses are prohibited: 1. Adult entertainment establishments 2. Automobile service station, service 3. Gasoline sales 4. Pawn shop 5. Free standing Vehicle wash 6. Sales or Service of Tractor Trailers and Heavy Trucks 7. Sales of Manufactured Housing 8. Palmist, Physic or Medium 9. Smoke/Vape Shop 10. Payday Loan and Flexible Loan Plan Establishments 11. Off Premise Advertising Signs 12. Youth Hostel 13. Bed and Breakfast, Short Term Rental 14. Blood Plasma Donation Center Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 20 20 II. Bulk Regulations A. Setbacks shall be consistent with those shown on the concept plan(s) or with the CMU-3 District regulations. Maximum of 306.000 square feet of retail floor area and related commercial uses. B. Maximum of 132,000 square feet of office floor area and related uses including: 1. A maximum of 37.500 square feet of floor area for the free-standing building located west of the north/south roadway, and 2. A maximum of 6,500 square feet of floor area for the free-standing building located east of the north/south roadway adjacent to Poplar Avenue. C. A maximum of 27,000 square feet of additional floor area is permitted for either office or retail floor area and is to be located east of the north-south parkway. D. Maximum floor area east of the north-south parkway is 427,500. E. Minimum distance between the west curb of the north/south roadway and the west property line-100 feet. F. Maximum building heights: 1. Building heights shall not exceed 100’ between 300’ and 700’ as measured from the westernmost property line adjoining the Village neighborhood. 2. Building heights shall not exceed 180’ beyond 700’ from the westernmost property line adjoining the Village neighborhood. III. Circulation, Access, and Parking A. The exact location and design of the curb cuts on dedicated streets are subject to the approval of the City Engineer. B. The applicant will dedicate an easement along the south line of Poplar Avenue so that there will be provided a street width of Poplar Avenue forty-six (46) feet from the center line of Poplar Avenue and improved with curb, gutter and sidewalks, the obligation for the improvements conditioned on the improvement by the City of Memphis of the north side of Poplar Avenue within five years of the approval of this P.D.; and if no improvement is made by the City of Memphis within this five year term, the obligation to improve the easement granted shall be terminated. C. The north/south roadway shall be dedicated and improved with a 68-foot right-of-way exclusive of the median width. D. No additional curb cuts other than the two shown on the outline plan shall be permitted on Poplar Avenue. E. No obstructions shall be constructed to prevent access between the proposed development and Goldsmith’s Oak Court unless approved by the Office of Planning and Development. F. Dropped G. All necessary railroad signalizations shall be the applicant’s expense. H. Parking and loading spaces shall generally be in accordance with the Zoning Ordinance Unified Development Code requirements. Shared parking is hereby permitted for all uses and areas within this planned development. Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 21 21 IV. Drainage A. Dra inage east of the north/south roadway shall be routed along the east side of the roadway or within the roadway toward Southern Avenue. A. Drainage plans shall be submitted to the Division of Public Works City Engineering for review. and improvements shall be in accordance with the Subdivision Regulations. V. Landscaping and Screening A. The Landscape plan for the area west of the north/south roadway shall be recorded with the outline plan. Detailed Landscaping shall be provided on the Final Plats for each Phase. B. The amount of landscaping and screening shown on the “site plan showing earthen berms a nd conceptual screening” shall be recorded with the outline plan. C. Light standards west of the north/south roadway shall be a maximum of 10 feet in height. Other light standards shall not exceed 25 feet in height. D. A minimum 15-foot-wide l andscaping strip (Plate F) or an equivalent, approved by the Office of Planning and Development shall be provided along all dedicated street frontages. There shall be constructed, between the west line of the north/south roadway and the west line of the property, from the south line of the property to the extension of the north line of Lot 2, Barboro Subdivision, earthen berms of the average height of 6 feet. These berms shall be in addition to the landscaping provided herein. The berms and area described herein shall be maintained by the o wners of the property. VI. Signage A. Signage shall be in conformance with regulations established for Mixed Use Districts as defined in UDC Section 4.9.7D. One ground mounted detached sign not exceeding 100 square feet in area and setback a minimum of 15 feet shall be permitted along the Poplar Avenue frontage, and one along the Southern Avenue frontage. (8-S EE SHEET 3 OF 3 FOR REVISED SIGNAGE NOTE VI.A) B. All signage details shall be illustrated on the final plan. One detached sign for each of the free-standing buildings located near Poplar Avenue shall be permitted. Each sign shall not exceed 35 square feet in area and shall be in accordance with other O-G District sign regulations. C. No other detached signage shall be permitted. Attached signage shall be permitted in accordance with the C-P District regulations. VII. The Land Use Control Board may modify the bulk, access, parking, landscaping, and sign requirements if equivalent alternatives are presented. may make modifications to Condition II through VI but may not increase the maximum quantities approved. The Board may require notification to adjacent property owners prior to approving any modifications. X. Any expansi on of this Planned Development is permitted for adjacent parcels subject to Land Use D. Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 22 22 Control Board approval as a Major Modification. XI. A final plan shall be filed within ten (10) years of the date of approval of the Outline Plan by the Legislative Body. The Land Use Control Board may grant extensions at the request of the applicant. XII. Any final plan shall include the following: A. The outline plan conditions. B. The exact location and dimensions, including lots, buildable areas, pedestrian and utility easements, service drives, parking areas, trash receptacles, buildings, loading facilities, and required landscaping and screening areas. C. The location and ownership, whether public or private, of any easement. A. The location and dimensions of building footprints, parking lots, private drives, building elevations, and landscaping and screening. E. A lighting plan detailing the location, height, style, direction, etc. of all outdoor lighting and a photometric plan shall be submitted for administrative review and approval by the Division of Planning and Development. F. A standard improvement contract as defined by Section 5.5.5 of the UDC for any needed public improvements. G. A statement conveying all common facilities and areas, including private drives, common open space and recreation areas, sanitary and storm sewers, or other drainage facilities, and other public facilities dedicated to a property owner’s association or other entity, for ownership and maintenance purposes. H. The 100-year flood elevation. I. The following note shall be placed on the final plat of any development requiring on-site storm water detention facilities: The areas denoted by "Reserved for Storm Water Detention" shall not be used as a building site or filled without first obtaining written permission from the City and/or County Engineer. The storm water detention systems located in these areas, except for those parts located in a public drainage easement, shall be owned, and maintained by the property owner and/or property owners' association. Such maintenance shall be performed so as to ensure that the system operates in accordance with the approved plan on file in the City and/or County Engineer's Office. Such maintenance shall include, but not be limited to removal of sedimentation, fallen objects, debris and trash, mowing, outlet cleaning, and repair of drainage structures. Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 23 23 DEPARTMENTAL COMMENTS The following comments were provided by agencies to which this application was referred: City Engineer: See below. City Fire Division: See below. City Real Estate: No comments received. County Health Department: No comments received. Shelby County Schools: No comments received. Construction Code Enforcement: No comments received. Memphis Light, Gas and Water: No comments received. Office of Sustainability and Resilience: See below. Office of Comprehensive Planning: See below. Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 24 24 CASE 2: PD 2025-006 NAME: 4465 Poplar Avenue; 057012 00052; OAK COURT PD AMENDED Basin/Lot/CD: 11.971AC/ Black Bayou, 5-C/ 5 1. Standard Public Improvement Contract or Right-Of-Way Permit as required in Section 5.5.5 of the Unified Development Code. Sewers: 2. The availability of City sanitary sewer is unknown at this time. Once the developer has submitted proposed sewer discharge rates to the City’s Sewer Design Dept, a determination can be made as to available sewer capacity. Roads: 3. The Developer shall be responsible for the repair and/or replacement of all existing curb and gutter along the frontage of this site as necessary. 4. All existing sidewalks and curb openings along the frontage of this site shall be inspected for ADA compliance. The developer shall be responsible for any reconstruction or repair necessary to meet City standards. Traffic Control Provisions: 5. The developer shall provide a traffic control plan to the city engineer that shows the phasing for each street frontage during demolition and construction of curb gutter and sidewalk. Upon completion of sidewalk and curb and gutter improvements, a minimum 5 foot wide pedestrian pathway shall be provided throughout the remainder of the project. In the event that the existing right of way width does not allow for a 5 foot clear pedestrian path, an exception may be considered. 6. Any closure of the right of way shall be time limited to the active demolition and construction of sidewalks and curb and gutter. Continuous unwarranted closure of the right of way shall not be allowed for the duration of the project. The developer shall provide on the traffic control plan, the time needed per phase to complete that portion of the work. Time limits will begin on the day of closure and will be monitored by the Engineering construction inspectors on the job. 7. The developer’s engineer shall submit a Trip Generation Report that documents the proposed land use, scope and anticipated traffic demand associated with the proposed development. A detailed Traffic Impact Study will be required when the accepted Trip Generation Report indicates that the number for projected trips meets or exceeds the criteria listed in Section 210-Traffic Impact Policy for Land Development of the City of Memphis Division of Engineering Design and Policy Review Manual. Any required Traffic Impact Study will need to be formally approved by the City of Memphis, Traffic Engineering Department. Curb Cuts/Access: 8. The City Engineer shall approve the design, number, and location of curb cuts. 9. Any existing nonconforming curb cuts shall be modified to meet current City Standards or closed with curb, gutter, and sidewalk. Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 25 25 8. Will require engineering ASPR. Drainage: 10. A grading and drainage plan for the site shall be submitted to the City Engineer for review and approval prior to recording of the final plat. 11. Drainage improvements, including possible on-site detention, shall be provided under a Standard Subdivision contract in accordance with Unified Development Code and the City of Memphis/Shelby County Storm Water Management Manual. 12. Drainage data for assessment of on-site detention requirements shall be submitted to the City Engineer. 13. The following note shall be placed on the final plat of any development requiring on-site storm water detention facilities: The areas denoted by "Reserved for Storm Water Detention" shall not be used as a building site or filled without first obtaining written permission from the City and/or County Engineer. The storm water detention systems located in these areas, except for those parts located in a public drainage easement, shall be owned and maintained by the property owner and/or property owners' association. Such maintenance shall be performed so as to ensure that the system operates in accordance with the approved plan on file in the City and/or County Engineer's Office. Such maintenance shall include, but not be limited to removal of sedimentation, fallen objects, debris and trash, mowing, outlet cleaning, and repair of drainage structures. 14. The developer should be aware of his obligation under 40 CFR 122.26(b)(14) and TCA 69-3-101 et. seq. to submit a Notice of Intent (NOI) to the Tennessee Division of Water Pollution Control to address the discharge of storm water associated with the clearing and grading activity on this site. 15. This project must be evaluated by the Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation regarding their jurisdiction over the watercourses on site, in accordance with the Water Quality Control Act of 1977 as amended (TCA 69-3-101 et seq.). General Notes: 16. Development is greater than 1 acre and is located within a sensitive drainage basin. 17. No other utilities or services may occupy sanitary sewer easements in private drives and yards except for crossings. 18. All connections to the sewer shall be at manholes only. 19. All commons, open areas, lakes, drainage detention facilities, private streets, private sewers and private drainage systems shall be owned and maintained by a Property Owner's Association. A statement to this effect shall appear on the final plat. 20. Required landscaping shall not be placed on sewer or drainage easements. Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 26 26 DIVISION OF FIRE SERVICES  FIRE PREVENTION BUREAU 2668 Avery Avenue ⋅ Memphis ⋅ Tennessee ⋅ 38112 (901) 636-5401 Fax (901) 320-5425 Case Number: PD 2025-006 Date Reviewed: 7/3/25 Reviewed by: J. Stinson Address or Site Reference: 4465 Poplar • All design and construction shall comply with the 2021 edition of the International Fire Code (as locally amended) and referenced standards. • Fire apparatus access shall comply with section 503. • Where security gates are installed that affect required fire apparatus access roads, they shall comply with section 503.6 (as amended). • Fire protection water supplies (including fire hydrants) shall comply with section 507. • Where fire apparatus access roads or a water supply for fire protection are required to be installed, such protection shall be installed and made serviceable prior to and during the time of construction except when approved alternate methods of protection are provided. • IFC 510 In-building two-way emergency responder communication coverage shall be provided in all new and existing buildings. Buildings and structures that cannot support the required level of coverage shall be equipped with systems and components to enhance signals and achieve the required level of communication coverage. • A detailed plans review will be conducted by the Memphis Fire Prevention Bureau upon receipt of complete construction documents. Plans shall be submitted to the Shelby County Office of Code Enforcement. Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 27 27 Robin Richardson Planner II Office of Sustainability and Resilience 125 N. Main St., Memphis, TN 38103 Dorothy.Richardson1@memphistn.gov MEMORANDUM To: Chloe Christion, Planner I From: Robin Richardson, Planner II Date: June 2, 2025 Subject: OSR Comments on PD 2025-006: UNIVERSITY General Comments & Analysis: Located in Zone 1 of the Resilience Zone Framework: Zone 1 areas have the lowest level of development risk and conflict. These areas avoid high risk disaster zones, such as floodplains, and they also do not conflict with sensitive ecological areas. These areas are the most straightforward for development, and development would have the lowest impact on regional resilience. Consider incorporating the protection of ecological assets while balancing the promotion of low -impact site design and compact development typologies in appropriate areas. The applicant is seeking an amended planned development that would allow for the redevelopment of Oak Court Mall. The proposed plan as submitted will increase the number of types of uses for the site. Either of the site plans for the site will increase the amount of pervious surfaces, and both site plans will also increase the amount of tree canopy in the area, particularly along Poplar Avenue. Consistent with the Mid-South Regional Resilience Master Plan best practices: Yes This application is generally consistent with the Mid-South Regional Resilience Master Plan. This site is located in Zone 1, where development is encouraged in Section 4.1 – Resilient Sites due to low risk and low environmental conflict. The proposed development is consistent with Section 4.2 – Smart Growth, as the redesign of the site promotes walkability and adds mixed-use density in an area that could benefit from increased activity. Additionally, the increase in pervious surfaces on the parcel would generally be consistent with the principles of Section 2.3 – Low-Impact Development (though the landscaping as currently proposed does not qualify as Low-Impact Development). Consistent with the Memphis Area Climate Action Plan best practices: Yes By increasing the number of trees on the site, the plan is consistent with Priority Action E.7 – Nurture and Expand the Urban Tree Canopy. Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 28 28 Recommendations: Staff recommends adding a condition requiring the installation of electrical vehicle charging stations, or the installation of electrical wiring necessary to support the future installation of electric vehicle charging stations: 1. At least 5 percent of parking spaces should either have EV charging stations installed or have the electrical wiring necessary to support the future installation of electric vehicle charging stations. 2. All work must be completed according to all applicable building and electrical codes. 3. Parking facilities shall be designed so that at least one of the EV-ready spaces is handicap accessible. When infrastructure is installed on the space, the charging station hardware must be handicap accessible. 4. When calculating the number of required spaces, any fraction of a required parking space shall be rounded up to the nearest whole number. Some other elements that could be added to enhance the sustainability and resilience of the site include: • Incorporate Low-Impact Development (LID) techniques whenever possible in the landscaping of the site. LID uses natural solutions to help address stormwater runoff and other hydrological issues. Some elements that could be beneficial for the site include rain gardens, linear bioretention, or permeable pavement, though other LID techniques would also be welcomed. More information about LID can be found in the Mid-South Regional Resilience Master Plan in Section 2.3 – Low-Impact Development. • Install either green roofs or cool roofs for some of the larger buildings in the proposed development. Both options will help increase the energy efficiency of the buildings and will decrease the heat experienced on the site. For more information about green and cool roofs, please refer to the Mid-South Regional Resilience Master Plan, Section 3.4 – Roof Design. Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 29 29 Comprehensive Planning Review of Memphis 3.0 Consistency This summary is being produced in response to the following application to support the Land Use and Development Services department in their recommendation: PD 2025-006: University Site Address/Location: 4465 Poplar Ave. Overlay District/Historic District/Flood Zone: It is not located in the Overlay District, Historic District or Flood Zone. Future Land Use Designation: Anchor Neighborhood-Mix of Building Types (AN-M), and Anchor Neighborhood Main Street (A-NMS) Street Type: Boulevard & Parkway The applicant is seeking approval for a Planned Development to update the original outline plan conditions and to include additional residential and commercial uses. The following information about the land use designation can be found on pages 76 – 122: 1. Future Land Use Planning Map Red polygon indicates the application site on the Future Land Use Map. Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 30 30 2. Land Use Description/Intent Anchor Neighborhood-Mix of Building Types (AN-M) are walkable neighborhoods within a 5 – 10-minute walk of a Community Anchor. These neighborhoods are made up of a mix of single-unit and multi-unit housing. Graphic portrayal of AN-M is to the right. Anchor Neighborhood Main Street (A-NMS) are walkable, mixed-use centers comprised of house-scale buildings, some of which may be attached, lining two facing blocks, sometimes extending for several adjacent blocks. Graphic portrayal of A-NMS is to the right. “ AN-M” & “ A-NMS” Form & Location Characteristics NURTURE/SUSTAIN - Primarily detached, single -family residences. Attached single -family, duplexes, triplexes and quadplexes permitted on parcels within 100 feet of an anchor and at intersections where the presence of such housing type currently exists; Othe r housing and commercial types along avenues, boulevards and parkways as identified in the Street Types Map where same types exist on two or more adjacent parcels. Height: 1-3 stories. Scale: house-scale. “ AN-M” & “ A-NMS” Zoning Notes AN-M is compatible with the following zone districts: RU-2, RU-3, RU-4, R-SD, R-R, MDR, and CMU-1 when located along avenues, boulevards, and parkways as identified in the Street Types Map, in accordance with Form and characteristics listed above. A-NMS is compatible with the following zone districts: MU, NC, CMU-1, CMU-2 with frontage requirements (MO District) in accordance with Form and characteristics listed above. Existing, Adjacent Land Use and Zoning Existing Land Use and Zoning: Commercial, Office, and Vacant; R-10 and CMU-3 Adjacent Land Use and Zoning: Commercial, Office, Vacant and Residential; R-10, CMU-3, RU-3, and R-15 Overall Compatibility: T h e req u ested u se is compatible w ith th e land u se description and intent, f orm and location ch aracteristics, z oning notes, and th e ex isting and adj acent land u se and z oning, as th e proposed P lanned D evelopment aims to u pdate th e original ou tline plan conditions and inclu de additional residential and commercial u ses. 3. Degree of Change Map Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 31 31 Red polygon denotes the proposed site in Degree of Change area. The Degree of Change is Sustain. 4. Degree of Change Description Sustain areas rely on limited public support and private resources to maintain the existing pattern of a place. 5. Objectives/Actions Consistent with Goal 1, Complete, Cohesive, Communities This Planned Development supports Goal 1.1: Focus future growth and density in and around Community and Citywide Anchors, and aligns with several related actions, including: 1.1.1: Ensuring that zoning designations within anchors and anchor neighborhoods support, maintain, and encourage walkable, mixed-use infill development; 1.1.12: Supporting the creation of new public spaces within and around anchors and anchor neighborhoods; 1.1.29: Encouraging higher-density commercial and residential development in anchors supported by high-frequency transit; and, 1.1.31: Increasing infill and redevelopment that co-locate residential, employment, and retail uses to maximize transit access and active transportation. This Planned Development also supports Goal 1.5: Strengthen neighborhood commercial districts, and aligns with the following actions: 1.5.1: Focus residential infill efforts in anchor neighborhoods to support anchors and neighborhood commercial districts with appropriate population density; 1.5.6: Support the redevelopment and intensification of underutilized commercial properties within Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 32 32 Community Anchors; and, 1.5.9: Improve walkability and multimodal access within and around Community and Citywide Anchors to promote local economies and connect neighborhood residents with local businesses. 6. Pertinent Sections of Memphis 3.0 that Address Land Use Recommendations One of the top district priorities in University District is Revitalize existing distressed commercial centers, which aligns with this Planned Development request. Regarding the community engagement workshop held in the University District on October 22, 2024, the community supported this priority and expressed a desire to provide incentives for the revitalization of distressed commercial centers through targeted investment and strategic development. This Planned Development at Oak Court Mall represents one such revitalization effort. Consistency Analysis Summary The applicant is seeking approval for a Planned Development to update the original outline plan conditions and to include additional residential and commercial uses. The requested use is compatible with the land use description and intent, form and location characteristics, zoning notes, and the existing and adjacent land use and zoning, as the proposed Planned Development aims to update the original outline plan conditions and include additional residential and commercial uses. Sustain areas rely on limited public support and private resources to maintain the existing pattern of a place. This Planned Development supports Goal 1.1: Focus future growth and density in and around Community and Citywide Anchors, and aligns with several related actions, including: 1.1.1: Ensuring that zoning designations within anchors and anchor neighborhoods support, maintain, and encourage walkable, mixed-use infill development; 1.1.12: Supporting the creation of new public spaces within and around anchors and anchor neighborhoods; 1.1.29: Encouraging higher-density commercial and residential development in anchors supported by high-frequency transit; and, 1.1.31: Increasing infill and redevelopment that co-locate residential, employment, and retail uses to maximize transit access and active transportation. This Planned Development also supports Goal 1.5: Strengthen neighborhood commercial districts, and aligns with the following actions: 1.5.1: Focus residential infill efforts in anchor neighborhoods to support anchors and neighborhood commercial districts with appropriate population density; 1.5.6: Support the redevelopment and intensification of underutilized commercial properties within Community Anchors; and, 1.5.9: Improve walkability and multimodal access within and around Community and Citywide Anchors to promote local economies and connect neighborhood residents with local businesses. One of the top district priorities in University District is Revitalize existing distressed commercial centers, which aligns with this Planned Development request. Regarding the community engagement workshop held in the University District on October 22, 2024, the community supported this priority and expressed a desire to provide incentives for the revitalization of distressed commercial centers through targeted investment and strategic development. This Planned Development at Oak Court Mall represents one such revitalization effort. Based on the information provided, the proposal is CONSISTENT with the Memphis 3.0 Comprehensive Plan. Summary Compiled by: Negin Hamidi, Comprehensive Planning. Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 33 33 MAILED PUBLIC NOTICE Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 34 34 SIGN AFFIDAVIT Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 35 35 PD 84-356 APPROVED RESOLUTION Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 36 36 Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 37 37 Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 38 38 Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 39 39 PD 87-313 APPROVED RESOLUTION Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 40 40 Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 41 41 Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 42 42 Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 43 43 Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 44 44 Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 45 45 APPLICATION Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 46 46 Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 47 47 Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 48 48 OWNER AFFIDAVIT Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 49 49 LETTER OF INTENT Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 50 50 Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 51 51 Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 52 52 Staff Report July 10, 2025 PD 2025-006 Page 53 53 LETTERS RECEIVED Seven (7 ) letters of support, two (2) letters o f comment , and thirty -seven (37) letters of opposition were received at the time of completion of this report and have subsequently been attached. Outlook Amending the PUD for Oak Court From McNeal McDonnell <McNeal@sugarservicesllc.com> Date Mon 5/19/2025 4:43 PM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> Cc Josh Poag <jpoag@poagdevelopmentgroup.com>; skern@krndev.com <skern@krndev.com> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Dear Ms. Christion: I am writing in support of Oak Court Partners, LLC proposed amendment to the PUD at Oak Court. Poag Development is leading our partnership and has an impressive history of reimaging commercial properties including Saddle Creek in Germantown. As I understand it, part of the plan includes allowing for townhomes on the vacant three acres south of the First Horizon building. Although having a buffer of vacant land between Oak Court Mall and The Village neighborhood may have seemed like a good idea40 years ago, the lack of structure between the mall and the Village led to a criminal element spilling into the residential areas nearby. I know this to be true because I lived at 479 Cherry Road from 2007 through 2023. As an investor, of course I hope the partnership makes money, but I joined the partnership because I want to see the area flourish. Josh Poad and his team are sure to make this happen. I hope you will support Oak Court Partners proposal for amending the PUD which is scheduled to comebefore the Land Use Control Board at its meeting on June 12th. Sincerely, McNeal McDonnell 901-626-2096 5/19/25, 4:53 PM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAGGrrzRUQ0D5p%2FDiFc… 1/1 Outlook Oak Court Mall Redevelopment Support From John Planchon <john.planchon1@gmail.com> Date Mon 5/19/2025 5:05 PM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> Cc Jade Opper <jade.opper@gmail.com> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Dear Chloe Christion, I am writing to support the proposed redevelopment of Oak Court Mall and the former Macy’s property in East Memphis. As a nearby resident who lives within walking distance of the site, I see this project as a practical opportunity to improve a commercial development that has significantly declined in recent years. My family and I welcome the prospect of a new development that brings valuable services, updated infrastructure, and more activity to the neighborhood. A mixed-use development at this location would better use the space and align with the City’s goals for land use and economic development. It would attract investment, create jobs, and improve residents' access to goods and services. I encourage the Division of Planning and Development to support this project. Please do not hesitate to contact me if I can provide additional input. Sincerely, John Planchon 190 E Cherry Cir Memphis, Tennessee, 38117 5/20/25, 9:14 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAA6VEdhuAUJOhgQgHKxm… 1/1 Outlook Oak Court Mall Redevelopment From Brett Grinder <bgrinder@grindertaber.com> Date Wed 5/21/2025 9:38 AM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> Cc James Webb <mayfordthree@gmail.com>; Jerry Sanders <jsanders@evanspetree.com>; Alexander, Glynn <Glynn.Alexander@pnfp.com>; Allison Gilbert <agilbert@harrisshelton.com>; Cathy Wilson <cmwilson901@gmail.com>; Chad Schaffler <chadschaffler@gmail.com>; Chris Bird <Cbird@dillarddoor.com>; Wright, Andy <Andy.Wright@pnfp.com>; james or jami webb <webbj3@mac.com>; mgrinder@alumni.princeton.edu <mgrinder@alumni.princeton.edu> 1 attachment (463 KB) oak court nhood ltr 5-9-25.pdf; CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Chloe- I’m writing on behalf of a group of neighbors in the Audubon Park neighborhood to voice our vocal support for the Oak Court Mall redevelopment. We are just south of Audubon Park and fully support the demolition of the Oak Court Mall and Macy’s properties to make way for new development. Members of our neighborhood often shop and dine in the Laurelwood area, play golf and tennis at the Audubon and Leftwich facilities, and walk and commute the perimeter of the park, Cherry Road, Oak Court Drive, and the surrounding area ofOak Court Mall. We completely support the modifications to the Planned Development that the developer is seeking to include Macy’s acreage in the Oak Court Development, provide for townhomes as a buffer along Oak Court Drive, and updates to the outline conditions int eh planned development to include additional uses to make this a truly flexible and mixed use property for our area. We are excited about the additional density, dining and retail options that this will bring to our area and the massive improvement this will be over what is currently possible with the Oak Court PD. If you have any questions about our neighbors and our support for the project, please do not hesitate to contact me or any of our group of neighbors copied on this email. Sincerely, Brett Grinder Managing Principal, LEED AP Grinder, Taber & Grinder, Inc. (901) 767.2400 phone (901) 378.9001mobile grindertaber.com web 5/22/25, 8:52 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQANtfvj2rlkGbpe1Dk0q7ENI%… 1/1 Via email: chloe.chrisƟon@memphistn.gov RE: Oak Court Mall – PD Amendment Dear Ms. ChrisƟon, I am wriƟng to share my support of the recently submiƩed Planned Development Amendment for Oak Court Mall. As a 6 th generaƟon Memphian, I believe that the redevelopment of Oak Court Mall is long overdue. The exisƟng PD, adopted in 1987, is outdated and no longer addresses current market condiƟons or prevailing development trends which favor higher density and a mix of commercial uses. The property has been in decline for some Ɵme and has seen a rise in criminal acƟvity that has spilled over to adjacent residenƟal and commercial properƟes. The proposed redevelopment will be a best-in- class desƟnaƟon in Memphis that will create a safer, more vibrant commercial district. By providing the framework for an outdoor mixed-use development, the Oak Court Mall property will be transformed into a 24/7 project that provides retail, dining, office, hotel, and housing opƟons. Memphis’ own future development plan, dubbed Memphis 3.0, encourages new developments to “build up and not out” and this PD Amendment for Oak Court Mall achieves that goal in one of the most robust commercial districts of East Memphis. In addiƟon, quality new housing opƟons are needed within the city, and the inclusion of townhomes along the west side of Oak Court Drive provides addiƟonal housing opƟons for East Memphis residents that seek to “age in place” in their community. The development team has consistently sought neighborhood and stakeholder feedback over the past 7 months as they hosted five (5) informal neighborhood meeƟngs and countless one-on-one meeƟngs. I hope you will support Oak Court Partners’ proposal for amending the PD which is scheduled to come before the Land Use Control Board at its June 12 th meeƟng. Sincerely, Michael Scarbrough May 29, 2025 Chloe Christion Planner II Land Use & Development Services Division of Planning and Development 125 N. Main, Ste. 468 Memphis, TN 38103 Sincerely, Michael Scarbrough Outlook Support for Oak Court Mall Redevelopment From Debbie Thomas <dthomas4201@hotmail.com> Date Tue 6/3/2025 1:47 PM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. To: Land Use & Development Services Division of Planning & Development This note is to send my support to the developers of the Oak Court Mall redevelopment. I am a neighbor that lives in the Village, 2-3 blocks away. I support the group of developers that includes Josh Poag; I believe they will develop the area in a way that supports the historic & current character of this family-oriented East Memphis neighborhood that is important to so many of us. Thank you, Deborah Thomas 4201 Central Lane Memphis, TN. 38117 6/5/25, 11:21 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQALLK4BHtPUlBoOOzuPhN… 1/1 Outlook PD 2025-006 From Coleman Barton <colemanbarton1@gmail.com> Date Tue 6/3/2025 10:33 AM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Good morning, Ms. Christion. I live in the Wynslow HOA which is west of First Horizon. Our gated community consists of 6 houses with a single entry/exit off Poplar. During the holidays in particular, accessing our homes can be challenging. I am concerned with the increase in traffic, we will be challenged to enter our residence. I believe this concern may be alleviated if we could create an entrance through the First Horizon property. I am hoping voicing our concerns early in the process will assist in being proactive and allow time to hopefully address this issue prior to the implementation. I would be happy to assist in any discussions or planning regarding options/solutions. I believe the increased traffic flow will become a significant obstacle in accessing our homes and hope to plan for a solution prior to development. I appreciate your time and look forward to working with the developers to improve memphis as well as our community. Respectfully, Coleman Barton 447 Wynslow Ct (901)-378-0200 colemanbarton1@gmail.com 6/5/25, 11:20 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQABswIIkrdZhHpRWL0Raug… 1/1 Outlook Chloe Christion From JJ Keras <jjkeras@gmail.com> Date Tue 6/3/2025 10:13 AM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Concern regarding Oak Court Redevelopment- 1) no cheap apartment buildings (will ruin city even further) 2) nothing over 8-10 stories please.  2) higher end retail, restaurants requested.  Many thanks, JJ Keras  6/3/25, 10:50 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAIvwRIM1EUdInT4Os3LnQv… 1/1 Outlook . From Jody Brown <jodybrown460@gmail.com> Date Fri 5/16/2025 5:23 PM T o Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Dear Mrs. Christion(.Pardon this impersonal typing but....) Lisa and I bought our house on Cherry Rd 45 years ago.It had some real problems-floor plan,wiring,plumbing ,etc.We have remodeled it 3 times over the years---A little at a time ,we have brought this house up to the standard of this neighborhood.and now have a wonderful,comfortable, maybe even a "fine " home.,worthy of Cherry Rd. We are sure that  the developers are  fine gentlemen and their New York architects are experienced with big projects in the midst of neighborhoods...experience told them -    announce the plan  very shortly before the LUCB hearing(dirty pool). There are several problems I can see in the little info I have . It Is VERY ,very vague,,20Story what and where,shutting down Oak Court Drive;,etc..I did note the three story  townhouses that  were going back up to the houses on Cherry---'''REALLY"that is a stretch. Thank you for reading my ramblings..but we are very serious ... Joel Brown   -460 Cherry Rd 5/19/25, 3:27 PM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAGAYMK6ZiXRPg%2FDn0L… 1/1 Outlook Oak Court Mall Development From Lewis Williamson <lewiscwilliamson3@gmail.com> Date Tue 5/20/2025 12:12 PM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Hi Chloe, I live in the Village on Woodmere Cove and wanted to let you know about some of the concerns I have regarding the planned Oak Court Mall development. The three main concerns I have are: 1. Removing existing buffer and berm on the West side of Oak Court Drive to build town homes against property lines of Cherry Road residents. 2. Apartment/Condo building up to 240 feet 3. The option to close and privative Oak Court Drive I am firmly against these three things and believe they would be detrimental to our neighborhood, particularly with safety and some of the water drainage and flooding issues it could cause. I am for development of the Oak Court Mall property but I believe it needs to be done in a responsible manner and hope you take into consideration the issues outlined above. Thanks, Lewis Williamson 5/20/25, 2:51 PM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAOZsOQrp2o1JkSAbdtS5o… 1/1 Outlook Oak Court Mall Development From Janet Misner <jfmisner@gmail.com> Date Wed 5/28/2025 10:11 AM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. I am adding an email plea to the written one I mailed to you last Friday to review carefully what the proposed Oak Court development group is planning. My greatest concern is for Oak Court Drive to remain as it is and not be privatized.  There is no reason for a private entity to "take over" a public street.  This would prevent any future plans on the developer's side to close the street.  The green space berm along the Western side of Oak Court Drive should remain untouched. It was my understanding that when Oak Court Mall was built, the developers gave Oak Court Drive and that berm as a buffer between residential and commercial.  It is ridiculous to pack in townhouses on that small piece of land.  It would create all kinds of traffic, noise and drainage issues.  I don't know how covenants can be broken...it seems illegal and is definitely just a land grab for the developers.  Memphis needs green spaces and not more concrete and buildings. Another great concern is the multi use piece of this development.  As you know...Poplar at Grove Park and Perkins is already pretty maxed out at different times of the day.  Adding up to 600 more people living there is also unrealistic and impossible to accommodate. I urge the Office of Planning and Development to review with care!  We already feel like we are hanging on by a thread with all the crime and failing infrastructure of MLGW.  Adding a shiny new burden to all of this will not produce a positive outcome for anyone.  It will only push more people to leave.  Please consider and take care in what you approve. Janet Misner 4373 Wynslow Cove   5/28/25, 10:56 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQABY7gMbE1nZCsVvXIjigo3Q%3D 1/1 Outlook Concerning Oak Court Planned Development Amendment - Record Number PD-2025-006, Modification of PD 87-313 - From Lisa Snowden <lisapromenade9@gmail.com> Date Tue 5/27/2025 10:33 PM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Concerning; Record Number PD-2025-006, Modification of PD 87-313 - OAK COURT PLANNED DEVELOPMENT AMENDMENT - 4465 Poplar Ave Memphis, Tn 38117 Dear Members of the Land Use Control Board As a long life long resident of the Belle Meade neighborhood I would like to voice my objection to current Oak Court Planned Development Amendment. The following items are problematic and/or ill conceived. Proposed Townhouses: a) These are described by developers as housing for empty nesters - Height to be 45 feet (roughly 3 stories) - minimal rear and front set backs. This does not conform to the neighborhood height/setback requirements but more importantly a 3 story unit is not the preferred housing for intended market or for retirees, or for residents with young children. b) Also the townhouses would require the removal of the berm and its tree buffer. This berm was codified by city council in 1987 and was crucial in the acceptance of the original Oak Court Mall. It serves as an important noise and privacy buffer for both the residents of Cherry and Poplar. Proposed 240 foot Building Height 20 story building(s) would be totally out of scale and character to the entire neighborhood. Inclusion of an Event/Confernece Center Area Being directly across the street from the Memphis Botanic Garden,Theatre Memphis, and the U of M Tennis Center, the proposed event /conference center is redundant and unnecessary. Inclusion of a Car Dealership and Used Clothing Retailer - unwanted and unneeded and out of character Required Communication with neighbors and neighborhood input. 5/28/25, 10:57 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAM6yK8eU%2BP9HrhV6Etx… 1/2 There was no concerted effort made to include or inform the neighborhood concerning this Development Amendment. Most neighbors were unaware of the plan until an article appeared in the Daily Memphian on May 7, 2025. A well conceived and thoughtful plan could be a positive addition to our neighborhood. But this current amendment is not that.  I urge you to reject PD-2025-006 - Modification of PD 87-313 Sincerely Lisa Snowden set backs nor does it meet the  45 foot Height  Removal of berm and trees 5/28/25, 10:57 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAM6yK8eU%2BP9HrhV6Etx… 2/2 Outlook PD-2025-006, Modification of PD 87-313; Development of Oak Court Mall, 4465 Poplar Ave. From James Lackie <jdl@riverstreetmgt.com> Date Fri 5/30/2025 11:30 AM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> Cc Margie Lackie <mhlackie@mac.com> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Via U.S Mail & Email (Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov) Land Use & Development Services Division of Planning and Development Attention: Chloe Christion 125 N. Main, Suite 468 Memphis, TN 38103 Re: PD-2025-006, Modification of PD 87-313 Development of Oak Court Mall, 4465 Poplar Ave. Dear Ms. Christion: We have recently attended a neighborhood meeting regarding the development of the Oak Court Mall. We are very favorable for the development to occur but would ask that the buffer be maintained on the west side of Oak Court Drive. It has proven through the years to be a great damper between our neighborhood and the mall. The developers are proposing to build a 45-foot group of townhouses directly behind the eastern homes on Cherry Road, which we believe would be invasive to the neighborhood. Our other major concern involves the request to build a 240-foot building on the property. While we are not opposed to a building of half that size, we would strongly request that the building be located as far to the east as possible. The current Plan B would have the building constructed adjacent to Oak Court Drive, which again would be detrimental to the neighborhood. We applaud the efforts of the developers to make the new Oak Court Mall a very vibrant addition to this central location of Memphis. However, maintaining the integrity of The Village and those of us located south of Poplar between the railroad tracks is of vital importance. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, James D. and Margaret H. Lackie 5/30/25, 3:44 PM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAKCDfmA971JEkgTx%2Fa… 1/1 Outlook Second Email Regarding Concerns About Oak Court Mall Redevelopment From Erica Marchbanks <eemarchbanks@gmail.com> Date Tue 6/3/2025 12:50 PM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Hi Chloe, I’m sure you are busy and are getting sick of hearing from me. It’s just impossible not to speak out against injustice in the community. Of course, my family, my neighbors, and I are concerned about the potential high- rise building(s) and lack of specifics on the development plans. However, I want to take one more opportunity today to implore that you understand how important it is for the buffer and berm to the west side of Oak Court Drive not to be removed and for the possibility of it’s removal and replacement by building anything, townhomes or otherwise, in that space to be removed from the plans. Again, I’m sure you’re busy with important work, but please take a moment to think of a place that you love, a place that fills your whole heart with memories of those closest to you and with hope for a beautiful future with those loved ones. Perhaps, your special place is also a parent or grandparent’s home. Maybe, it’s a park, art gallery, or college campus. It’s a place to gather, to laugh, to dream big dreams for the community you hold dear, and you plan on returning to this place as often as possible, enjoying it with friends and family, and safeguarding the meaningful beauty of that place for the continued enjoyment of those you love. Then one day, you learn that the very character of that place, a part of the space vital to what makes it special, is about to be utterly destroyed by someone who does not understand the value of that place, and imagine the hopelessness of feeling like those attempting to upend the everyday lives of those closest to you have indicated through their actions that they do not care about their community at all. My parents’ yard on Cherry Road is that place for me and my extended family and many friends. I have even bought a home near their home to be close to that special place. My parents have lived in their home for my entire life and part of the reason they live there is due to the buffer and berm between their property and Oak Court Drive. My parents and their neighbors worked so hard to find a lasting decision that would be beneficial for their properties and for any development that happened to the east of their properties at any time in the future. They worked as hard as they could to reach the establishment of the green space buffer and the earthen berm. There has never been any reason for anyone living on Cherry Rd or in the Village to believe this agreement would ever be altered, especially without their input. I hope the Land Use & Development Board values a community’s hard work to cooperate with developers and Memphis city planners and that you too see the validity of the understanding that the residents of Cherry Road have been living under for almost 40 years, the understanding that an agreement was reached for a buffer and berm to be established and not removed, especially without the input of Cherry Road residents. Removing the buffer and berm would not just reflect unfavor ably on the developers and any departments associated with the city of Memphis that allow the removal to happen, it would destroy the essence of a community. I have already mentioned in past letters the value of the green setting to the neighborhood. Homes are also built based on where they are located. For instance, homes in zero lots are built in a way that makes that style of living work well, without windows spaced to peer into other people’s homes etc. The homes on Cherry have been built to reflect their location abutting the berm and greenspace. I am horrified to know that townhomes in that area would be looking into my parents’ bathroom and bedroom! All sense of peace and privacy would be obliterated. 6/3/25, 12:54 PM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAMtn%2BLaQx3pFqin5m%2… 1/2 Additionally, I wonder if anyone has told the developers that in addition to destroying the views, property values, and everyday lives of the residents of Cherry Road that the buffer and berm are a valuable wildlife re fuge in Memphis. I wonder because last night the developers showed that they could not even be bothered to lay eyes on the area they are hoping to destroy. They tried to claim in front of Cherry Road residents that everyone on the street has fenced off the backs of their yards and placed barbed wir e at the top of the fences because they do not want to be in contact with the berm. This is not true and clear for anyone to see; my parents’ neighbor to the north doesn’t even have a standing fence across part of the yard. Instead, the buffer and berm work to extend the uninhabited greenspace of the neighboring Audubon Park, Botanic Gardens, and Dixon Gardens. Each year, a group of foxes den at the foot of the berm, and numerous owls and hawks can be seen swooping through the mature trees in the berm area. Rare songbirds nest, and harmless opossums amble through the wooded area, eating mosquitoes and other pests. Box turtles rest in the shade. The developers want to replace that with a retaining wall. As with the lack of understanding regarding how valuable the buffer and berm space are, the developers’ plans as they are now show both ignorance and apathy towards the community in which they want to develop. Just last night, I asked why the developers wanted to replace the buffer and berm with townhomes and a ret aining wall. Why, for instance, would they tell us they want to take advantage of views of the park area across Southern in one meeting and then try to build townhomes with a view of a busy street and the big, white back of Dillard’s? That doesn’t seem like good development. Their response was that they heard (who knows from whom because they have not asked those who live on Cherry) that there was crime on Cherry Road that originated in the existing mall area, so they were using the town homes as a new type of buffer between their development and Cherry. The developers also relayed a fictional tale they had “heard” about someone who had “ died on the berm” due to some sort of violent crime as a reason for removing the berm and replacing it with townhomes. First, this is a fictional tale, so the literal and figurative foundation of their plans is a lie. Secondly, this makes it seem like the developers will not be instituting any plans to make the development safe for visitors and the surrounding Memphis community. Third, this sounds like they are sacrificing the safety of those who would buy the townhomes in order for them to be a buffer. None of this is well thought out positive de velopment. Furthermore, when a neighbor asked about what need Memphis has for the developers to build townhomes in that space, the developers had absolutely no clear answer. The developers w ere completely unable to tell us if or to what degree Memphis would need this large number of townhome dwellings. It sounds like they just wanted to run a bulldozer around and build some buildings and see what happens, which is extremely poor planning. They also told us that the townhomes would present a very fractional net income for their overall plan. So the pros to not outweigh the cons for removing the buffer and berm. For what they admitted was an insubstantial and unclear profit, the developers are willing to ignore a neighborhood’s hard work and longstanding agreement, they are willing to diminish surrounding property values, they are willing to destroy the peace and privacy of the community, they are willing to destroy the character of the neighborhood, and they are willing to destroy a natural refuge. I am taking this one last chance, as the clock ticks, to beg you and the Memphis Land Use and Development Services show that you care about the community and not to allow for the removal of the buffer and berm to the west side of Oak Court Mall. I further want to emphasize that the plans as they stand now are not in a state, both ethically and substantially, to be approved by Land Use and Development Services. Very serious consideration and changes need to be made to the plans at this point. I have been told that once they pass Land Use and Development, the plans are not open to review again and the developers will have carte blanche within what are currently unacceptably undefined parameters t o do what they will, whether it has a positive impact or not. The plans as they are right now must not pass Land Use and Development. My neighborhood and I welcome good development and look forward to finding a path forw ard that is mutually beneficial to our neighborhood and developers. -- Erica Marchbanks EXP Realty 901-355-9552   6/3/25, 12:54 PM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAMtn%2BLaQx3pFqin5m%2… 2/2 Outlook Oak Court Mall Redevelopment Concerns From Olivia Marchbanks <omarchbanks@gmail.com> Date Sun 6/1/2025 8:32 PM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Hello Chloe, I’m writing this email to express my concern and oppose a few key features of the proposed redevelopment at Oak Court Mall. My family has had a home on Cherry Rd for the past 40 years and I'm deeply concerned about numerous potentially negative effects this development will have on my family as well as our friends, neighbors and the surrounding area. Please understand I am in support of redevelopment of Oak Court Mall and hope that in the future, through working together with the neighborhood, developers, and city a great new space will result and be beneficial to all parties involved. Unfortunately at this time, that doesn't seem to be the case.    I would like to highlight a few features that would impact my family and our community negatively. Please also note, during this process we have not only not been contacted regarding the proposed plans, but since learning of a few problematic issues our concerns have been dismissed and we are not being worked with. The initial feature of the development I oppose is the removal of the berm behind the houses that reside on Cherry Rd. To turn a peaceful neighborhood revered for their green space and community into a concrete jungle teaming with townhomes looming into every backyard at almost 70ft tall will not only reduce property values, but completely change the culture and feeling of the neighborhood. This change is in direct violation of an agreement to leave the berm as is ad infinitum which was not only fought for by many of the homeowners that still reside at these properties, but was a pivotal decision for many when selecting their homes. The homeowners will now not only be faced with unexpected loss of privacy in violation of a previous agreement and lower home prices, but there will also be an increase in water runoff into the property owners backyards due to a proposed alleyway. These homes already deal with flooding issues in their yards and this could have dramatic effects on the homes and vegetation. The berm with its trees and hedges has also been a safe haven for owls and falcons, which would lose their homes and most likely relocate, allowing vermin to thrive creating an unwelcome chain of effects for memphis wildlife. The second point I would like to express my contention with is the proposed 20 story building. What could be the purpose of such a large building, almost the size of the Clark Tower in this area? Unfortunately we have no idea and have not received guidance from the developers. Apartments? Who would be filling those? What is the current saturation of apartments in east Memphis? Office space? For whom? My understanding is that there is already a great deal of vacant office space in the 6/2/25, 9:16 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAEjkF02axF1Hi9TKTuUGE0… 1/2 area? How could they even accommodate parking for such a large building?  My belief is that not only will this destroy the character of the area and permanently alter the feeling of the community for what I fear, based on similar size buildings in the area will become a vacant space with no use and potentially just another deterotating shell, not unlike Oak Court Mall. A sad reality is that with vacancy, places loose their allure, they begin to lose funding, not be kept up, and oftentimes result in upticks in crime. I believe this is the exact opposite result the neighborhood as well as the developers would want. More planning needs to be done, statistics analyzed and potentially a much smaller building with clear goals put in its place.   And finally there is no reason to close Oak Court Drive and potentially open Cherry Rd to through traffic. Why would they need this and what would it achieve? We certainly haven’t been told, but we do know it would bring more traffic, more crime, and lower housing prices. Since this is a neighborhood full of young families this increase of traffic through the neighborhood would be much more than a nuisance, but a danger to all the children.  While it seems they just want this as an option, it appears they want the moon as an option with no regard to others. At this stage the developers have no concrete answers, we have not received any advanced notifications, and any concerns have been dismissed. Thank you for taking the time to read this letter. I urge you to please reject this plan and return it to developers. Best, Olivia Marchbanks 6/2/25, 9:16 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAEjkF02axF1Hi9TKTuUGE0… 2/2 To All Interested Parties, The object of this letter is to object most strenuously to elements of the proposed redevelopment of the Oak Court Mall. Let me make this clear. While we oppose some elements of this development, we are not against the redevelopment as a whole. As a neighborhood, what we approve of is a development that is beneficial for the community but respects the integrity of the surrounding residential neighborhoods and has an overall positive effect for everyone. There are four major concerns about this development. The first, and the one of which there is absolutely no compromise or negotiating, is the development of 28 townhomes on the west side of Cherry Road on the existing 100’ wide berm directly behind and on the property lines of the residents of the east side of Cherry Road. The developer is proposing 28, three story town homes that will be 45 to 50 feet in height. The street level is already at least eleven feet above the Cherry Road property owners back yards. Those structures would tower over the residents homes at a height of almost seventy feet. The alley behind these townhomes would run almost to our property lines and the already enormous amount of water run off into our yards would increase exponentially. The developer says their engineer believes it will help our water run off problem but two other independent engineers say it will be a huge contributor of more water runoff. We moved to 520 Cherry Road almost 40 years ago and raised our family in this home. Shortly after we moved in, Belz Development began the development process of what would become the Oak Court Mall on what was the idyllic setting of the then Sienna College. My home is on the east side of Cherry and backs up to Oak Court Drive. All homes on the east side of Cherry had a very clear and distinct view of the development in our backyards. We voiced our concerns to the developer and they listened. The entire neighborhood worked for over a year with the Belz Company, Reeves Engineering and Mike Davis Landscaping Architect to develop a plan that was compatible with everyone. I spoke with Ron Belz just this week and he remembers how we all worked together as a partnership, not in an adversarial position, to produce a good development. As Ron told me last week, “A Good Development makes Good Neighbors.” And he said he would be glad to go on record for that position if asked. Part of that “Good Neighbor Policy” plan consisted of an earthen berm on the west side of Oak Court Drive, at least 6’ high from street level, that would be heavily landscaped. Some of our yards on Cherry sit more than eleven below street level so from our side, in places, some of the berm is 18 to 20 feet tall. A wonderful buffer zone. That berm would run on the west side of Oak Court Drive and ensure a buffer zone for our residents and to guarantee that all future development would occur east of Oak Court Drive. The buffer was clearly intended to afford protection from further development encroachment for all adjacent residential properties to the west of Oak Court Drive. It was clearly established as such and entered into the public record not only by the City Council, the Land Use Control Board but also by two city mayors. As noted by the City Council, “Any such encroachment will promote instability and deterioration of existing residential properties.” To remove that berm after 40 years and build towering townhomes would be a gross breach of faith to all of the neighborhood residents. The understanding was clear in 1984; development ended east of Oak Court Drive. I believe that there can be no doubt in any reasonable person’s mind that the berm and greenbelt area was intended by all parties to end any development west of Oak Court Drive and there has been nothing new that should allow the destruction of that covenant established by the City Council. The second concern is a two hundred- and forty-foot-tall apartment building just south of Dillards on Oak Court Drive. The height alone should be reason to oppose this item. There are a myriad of other problems that go hand and hand with that building. Does the neighborhood need to see something almost as tall as the Clark Tower looming over the tree line? What is the saturation point for apartments in our area, who will they attract, what about the parking? These are just a few of the unthought out or ignored questions the developer needs to address and discuss with the community in an open forum before it is even presented to land use and control. There could be a compromise for this building, reduced height, moved to a far eastern location among some things. The third concern is the option to close and privatize Oak Court Drive. Why? Scott Kern says they probably wont do it and it would be hard to close the street anyway, so why should they have the option? Scott said so they wouldn’t need to go back and ask for it again if they decided they needed it later? What? As are a lot of the items the developer discussed, no substance has been delivered to the neighborhood and almost no real details. We, the neighborhood, found out about the coming development just the way the public did, the news. Not the developers. When I reached out to the developers, I was told they had already had five public meetings but they neglected to notify the entire Village community and not one person that backs up to the berm, the people most impacted by the development. We were told that they did the best they could but somehow just missed us, missed all of the most impacted families, five times. The only public meeting required by the developer was called for the day after Memorial Day, a time when many were out of town and unable to attend. We requested moving that meeting to later in the week but the developer denied us that. We did get the word out to the community and many stayed home to attend the meeting and there was a large turnout at Christ Methodist. Over 90% of the people there were like us and were for a development but not some elements of this one. Yet no one was allowed to speak. The MC gave a slide presentation and took questions written on 3x5 note cards and read the ones he wanted to read. When asked if they would allow anyone else to speak, we were told they only had the room until 7 that evening. No one else was allowed to speak. Like everything else about this project we have been told a lot of nothing. When asked about the details of this project, we were told a lot of, its likely to have, it should have, it probably will, it could have, were not confident but maybe. So that brings up the next point. There is no detail, the buildings have letters but we don’t know what goes where. Everything is vague. Its changing from CMU2 to CMU3 but we weren’t told for what uses or what reasons. We don’t know how many buildings are going to be 240 feet just they want to build some. We don’t know what types of restaurants, fast food, fine dining, used clothing, car lots or anything else that is really going in. We know nothing except that they may put in some bars that will be open until 3:00am. Next to a residential community??? This project is incomplete. At this point it needs to be rejected and sent back to the developers until they can actually sit down with representatives of the community and reach an agreeable compromise. Thank you for your time and consideration. Thomas Marchbanks 901 335 6688 520 Cherry Road Memphis Tn, 38117 Outlook PD 2025-006: Oak Court Planned Development From Peggy McClure <peg.mcclure@gmail.com> Date Sat 5/31/2025 6:02 PM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. It's great to hear that the Oak Court Planned Development has started and backed by local investors. I realize that this first sketch is a placeholder for what will actually be built; that it's being presented to get the zoning changed. I look forward to seeing the final product even if it's years from now. However, after attending the recent neighborhood meeting between KPS Development Partners and neighbors, I have concerns about the project as listed below: * The development of townhouses along the west side where a berm was created years ago when Oak Court Mall was built needs to be eliminated. Why would the developers think that the residents on the other side of the berm would want to have three-story townhomes in their backyards? I recommend that the developers should seriously consider removing this portion of the potential plans because the push back you'll be getting from the Cherry Road neighbors is not worth your time and it's not needed to make the entire project profitable. * The potential 20-story building, no matter where it is located, is far too tall for the area. The height is only four stories fewer than the iBank/White Station Tower. I recommend that you lower your height request because it doesn't fit into the residential area and as neighbors will push back on this as well. * The idea of a hotel in the project is great, but leaving the height in limbo is not acceptable. I recommend that developers consider revising the height to be no higher than the Memphian and state the maximum height because it fits better with the local environment and I think that the neighbors won't push back on this part of the project if the height is lowered. * The "privatization" of Oak Court Drive and what that means is not acceptable. I recommend that the developers state in the plans that it will not be closed, because it shouldn't ever be closed for access to the businesses inside and outside of the project and for traffic flow. Pushing all local traffic to move between Poplar and Southern at only Goodlett, Perkins Extended and Perkins is crazy. The developers surely know that the neighbors aren't buying that it isn't an option some day. There's LOTS of push back on that. * The outdoor green spaces are nice and it will be wonderful to have activities there. However, I recommend that there should be a curfew like the Botanic Garden's "Live at the Garden" concerts; 10:00 pm. There's no need to hassle the neighbors and get complaints. There is a lot of push back on this. 6/2/25, 9:20 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAEW67S7P0OJMlDyjLv3JL… 1/2 * The mixed use plan is good as we need more quality housing within our city limits; living into the Memphis 3.0 Plan. Our neighborhood is a residential one that has no apartments nearby; there is a reason for that. Owners are more responsible than renters. I recommend that developers make this revision and I think many residents in the nearby area would agree. * The retirement complex doesn't fit within this plan as all of the ones I've seen, in and out of Memphis, have large and enclosed campuses. There isn't enough room for one and Opus is too close to make it profitable. I recommend leaving this part out. * The convention center possibility is not fitting for this area of town. It's one thing to have a large group within a hotel like The Memphian, but not a convention. I recommend eliminating this idea as many in the neighborhood will probably push back. Thanks for reading my long list of thoughts. Good luck to you in working with the developers, the investors and the neighbors to make this a wonderful use of prime real estate. Margaret McClure 387 Roseland Place Memphis, TN   38111 901-409-2313 6/2/25, 9:20 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAEW67S7P0OJMlDyjLv3JL… 2/2 Outlook Reference: PD-2025-0067, Modification of PD 87-313 Development of Oak Court Mall, 4465 Poplar Ave. From Susan Jerkins <susiejerkins@gmail.com> Date Mon 6/2/2025 12:21 PM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Reference: PD-2025-0067, Modification of PD 87-313 Development of Oak Court Mall, 4465 Poplar Ave. June 2, 2025 Dear Ms Christion: As a 40 year resident of Cherry Road, I ask you to consider some of the concerns my family has with the Oak Court Development plans. Let me assure you, we have no issues with a well planned and carefully thought out development of the Oak Court property. However, there are several worrisome issues we have with the development proposal. Firstly, a 20 story rental/ purchase apartment building is not in keeping with the character of an established neighborhood. Secondly, the vagueness of the proposed buildings leaves neighbors with no specific concept of what will actually be built once approval has been granted. Thirdly, water drainage is a huge issue especially for those of us who will experience flooding due to the lower level of our lots if the berm is removed. We are still grateful to the Belz company for building the berm to not only prevent water runoff but to maintain the feel of a longtime established neighborhood apart from the retail and office space We are appreciative and grateful for your consideration of our concerns in an attempt to maintain the well being of families and neighborhoods in our city. Sincerely, Susie Jerkins 6/2/25, 3:23 PM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAC1FZTW7T91Kl7j8gCZmI… 1/1 Outlook Oak court development From Chelsey Lovell <chelsey.lovell@nestmemphis.com> Date Mon 6/2/2025 10:41 AM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Good morning Chloe, I am opposed to the development of Oak Court Mall in its current state especially the removal of the berm/buffer and building townhomes on the west side of Oak Court Drive. Unfortunately I am unable to make it to the meet but here are my major concerns. Review of Primary Concerns: • Removing Buffer Zone ( As detailed in “Concept Plans”) • Building height up to 240 feet (As listed in “Conditions” Paragraph II, D-1) • The right to close Oak Court Drive (As listed in “Conditions” Paragraph III, C) • The vague description of locations and types of proposed business and their intended uses Thank you Chelsey lovell. -- Chelsey Lovell chelsey.lovell@nestmemphis.com 940-595-0744 6/2/25, 3:24 PM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAFvt7wzTYqdFgOnhu9YjxD… 1/1 Outlook Oak Court mall development From Anne Morgan Miller <annemorganmiller@gmail.com> Date Tue 6/3/2025 8:58 AM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. ________________________________ Hi Chloe, I am writing to you in regards to the Oak Court, Mall development plan. I did not attend the meeting last night, but a neighbor of mine did and let me know the plan to build a 20 story apartment building and possibly a car dealership. I live in the Laurelwood neighborhood and my three children attend, Christ Methodist Day school across the street I have strong concerns about this plan. Traffic for one is a concern in this already congested area, but most importantly, I worry about crime and declining property value. I do not think adding apartment buildings in an affluent ZIP Code is the right move. Our area has already seen a rise in crime at Nordstrom rack, Venice, kitchen and other nearby establishments. I worry that adding a car dealership and low cost housing will only attract more crime. This plan will devalue this area of town an d I am strongly against it and other community members I have spoken with are as well. Please consider changing directions for this project. Thank you Anne Morgan Miller Anne Morgan Miller 6/3/25, 9:02 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAEC0raPKW2BIqLVyIevh4s… 1/1 Outlook Oak Court Mall Outline Plan From Snowden, Bayard <Bayard.Snowden@colliers.com> Date Tue 6/3/2025 8:21 AM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> 1 attachment (2 KB) Bayard Snowden.vcf; CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Dear Ms Christion As a neighbor and Memphian I am very concerned about the non-specific outline plan submitted by the applicant. While very much interested in a successful re-development of this property I believe the plan exhibits over reach in several areas. First of these is the request for a 240’ height allowance for two towers. The 240’ height is too tall by at least double. Successful residential buildings of 10 stories are found in multiple locations around Memphis. In addition to the lower height limit thebuildings should be restricted to a maximum number of units. The second main concern is the elimination of the berm and wooded buffer area along the west side of Oak Court Drive and the allowance of multi- story townhomes to be constructed in its place. The buffer is critical to the well being of the Cherry Rd neighbors abutting the buffer. Removing it is not allowed under the current PUD . Removal and placement of townhouses will result in loss of value to the neighborhood. This could be the thread that unravels the tax base of one of the oneof the highest value neighborhoods in Memphis. The new Oak Court plan should increase overall ambience and desirability not weaken the neighborhood. I understand that this application is an outline but the LUCB can impose restrictions. The development planners have not provided specifics of office density, residential density, hotel use, retail box size, or even the specific locations which will affectthe overall look , feel, and ultimate success of the project. This “ idea” should be rejected and the plan should be made specific in many areas such that it will resemble a Site Plan Approval with much detail. Respectfully Submitted, Bayard Snowden 231 West Cherry Circle Memphis 6/3/25, 9:03 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQALl7lqB3oUhzrW0en%2FEA… 1/1 Outlook (No subject) From Jody Brown <jodybrown460@gmail.com> Date Tue 6/3/2025 11:05 AM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. I believe that the investors mean well for the city,but a 10 year opportunity to decide on some very sensitive issues is too much.Our neighborhood could be fighting over the 240' tower and the 45' townhouses until the end of our time on earth .. the destruction of the berm and the erection of 45' high town houses is obviously a stark violation of the agreement with the first developers.The tower height is obviously a threat to the character of this area of east Memphis.at the very least from Highland to Mendenhall-traffic.noise,water control,etc Please consider the negative on our neighborhood. At the minimum, a delay in the LUCD meeting as Tom suggested is warranted. Because we love our city. I  Elizabeth Brown 460 Cherry Rd 6/3/25, 11:10 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAG6umuSbPFtEqVWEuon0… 1/1 Outlook Oak Court Mall Redevelopment From Rebecca Locke <lockerll@yahoo.com> Date Tue 6/3/2025 10:38 AM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Dear Ms. Christion: Last night I attended the Oak Court Mall redevelopment meeting held at Dixon Gardens. I had received notice of the meeting on Monday in my mailbox. We had also received notice of a meeting two weeks ago, but we were traveling for a business meeting and could not attend. I'm writing to share some concerns about the plans as well as the process. We live in a single family home on S. Grove Park Road within sight of Oak Court Mall if you are standing in our front yard. What happens at this site matters to our property value as well as our livability in that neighborhood. My first concern is the process: At last night's meeting where no speaker introduced themselves (with the exception of Josh Poag) nor explained their relationship to the process. We were given to understand that a holiday list was used to reach neighbors which is wholly inadequate and that it was a courtesy to notify us of changes. Why is there not a requirement to give neighbors adequate notice of at least 2-3 months along with multiple opportunities to meet the developers, planners and city leaders? We moved from Atlanta a few years ago, and any change in our neighborhoods required public posting of meeting notications and a series of at least 3 meetings to allow time for public comment and converstion with the developers. What Memphis has (if what I have observed in this process with Oak Court) is a failure to engage the community. My second concern is around the plans which are vague at best. What I heard last night seemed to indicate that they were coming to you for blanket approval which would allow modifications of the current outline without returning for approval of the modificaitons. That could be wonderful for the neighborhoods or terrible, and we will be the beneficiary or the victims without say-so. From what we were given to understand it will be in the hands of the devleopers once they have your approval shortly. I do not wish to leave the future of my neighborhood exclusively in the hands of people whose primary motivation is whether they will they make money from the project. The neighbors whose lives and property values will be affected by the project should also have a voice. As it stands now, and based on the limited information that I have been able to understand, I and my spouse am opposed to approval of this project until and unless we get additional information and clarity to make an informed decision on the scope and the plans. Sincerely, Rebecca Locke 353 S. Grove Park Road 678.612.1864 lockerll@yahoo.com 6/3/25, 11:24 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAM8EecIq96NCmjYdv6FHJ… 1/1 Outlook Oak Court planning From Dan Turley <dturley@turleymaxwell.com> Date Tue 6/3/2025 11:38 AM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. June 3, 2025 My name is Dan Turley Jr. I live at 4369 Tuckahoe. I have developed many successful, premier residential properties in this area over the past 40 years. The plan presented to us is deeply flawed in numerous crucial aspects — not the least of which is the outrageous proposal to construct a 240-foot-tall tower. Such a building would directly conflict with the character of our unique, long-established, and highly desirable community. I strongly urge the Board to send the developers back to work with their planners and come back with a more thoughtful, appropriate plan. The meetings I have attended have produced no meaningful communication — only vague responses and planner jargon. I expect more of the same moving forward if this process continues unchecked. Respectfully, Dan B. Turley Jr. Sent from my iPhone 6/3/25, 11:40 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQACZX%2FlQt3QpGs0864U1… 1/1 Outlook Oak Court Mall Redevelopment From Pat Anderson <pat194@gmail.com> Date Tue 6/3/2025 12:26 PM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. ________________________________ Chloe, Thank you for taking my call and listening to my concerns about this project. To recap, these are my main objections: 1.) A 20 story building will be an eyesore and out of character for the surrounding area. It will negatively affect not just the closest neighbors but the surrounding neighborhoods, too. I am shocked that the developers are even considering it. 2.) All the apartments, condos and townhouses, aside from the businesses, being considered are going to add overwhelmingly to the traffic congestion in this area, which is already bad. It seems to me that the density will be too high for such an already busy area. 3.). The developers at the neighborhood meeting last night were vague about so many parts of their plan. I understand it’s at the beginning stages but it was frustrating to hear them say that they didn’t know the answers to so many questions. I want this development to succeed but not at the expense of the surrounding neighbors. Thank you for your consideration. Pat Anderson 194 Montrose Drive. Sent from my iPhone 6/3/25, 12:28 PM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAFzUfHJeZYhMqOA96b5jrV… 1/1 Outlook Oak court development From Jennie Tucker <jenniemweaver@gmail.com> Date Tue 6/3/2025 9:50 PM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. To Whom It May Concern, I am writing as a long-time resident of the Village neighborhood to share my thoughts on the proposed redevelopment of the former Oak Court Mall site. While I welcome the opportunity to revitalize this valuable area and support responsible growth, I am deeply concerned about several aspects of the current outline plan and its potential impact on the surrounding community. First and foremost, the proposed removal of the existing buffer and berm along the west side of Oak Court Drive is highly troubling. This buffer currently provides essential separation between the Village neighborhood and the Oak Court property. Replacing it with multi-story townhomes built directly along our property lines would significantly alter the character and privacy of our community. Additionally, the prospect of a 240-foot-tall apartment or condominium building—approximately 20 stories —is concerning both for its scale and potential precedent. A structure of this height would be dramatically out of proportion with the existing residential context and would raise numerous questions about traffic, infrastructure, and long-term livability. Equally important is the suggestion that Oak Court Drive may be closed and privatized. This road is not only a critical connector for our neighborhood, but its closure would limit access and divert traffic in ways that could have unforeseen consequences for safety and mobility. Another significant concern is the impact this development may have on an already questionable drainage system. Our neighborhood has long dealt with drainage issues, and adding more impervious surfaces— particularly with the removal of the existing berm—could exacerbate flooding or water runoff problems. This issue was raised at a meeting I attended, but unfortunately, it went unanswered. This confusion only adds to my concern and reflects a broader lack of clarity and responsiveness in the planning process so far. 6/5/25, 9:46 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAEn7F5IGOUhJlxft2S%2FT… 1/2 Finally, I am disappointed in the vagueness of the current plan documents. The outline plan lacks clear labels and specifics, making it difficult for community members to fully understand or engage with what is being proposed. Transparency is essential if we are to build trust and foster collaboration between developers and the neighborhoods that will be most affected. I want to emphasize that I am not opposed to development. I understand that an empty mall benefits no one. But any development should be thoughtfully integrated with the surrounding neighborhoods and should reflect input from the people who live here. I urge the developers and city planners to revisit these concerns and work meaningfully with local residents to achieve a project that is both successful and respectful of its context. Sincerely, Jennie Tucker Resident, Village Neighborhood 6/5/25, 9:46 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAEn7F5IGOUhJlxft2S%2FT… 2/2 Outlook PD-2025-006 4465 Poplar From David Dunlap <dmdlaw@mac.com> Date Tue 6/3/2025 4:56 PM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> Cc Ragsdale, Brett <Brett.Ragsdale@memphistn.gov>; Miller, Breana <Breana.Miller@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Ms. Christion: I am a resident of the Laurelwood subdivision, one of the neighborhoods near to the proposed Macy’s/Oak Court subdivision development referenced above. In a meeting with the developer that was held last night, the developer indicated that part of the proposal is to build a 20 story apartment building on the Macy’s site. It was also stated that the intent is to have 20% subsidized housing in the apartment building. I would appreciate it if you would please note my strenuous objection to both of these proposals. The grounds for my objection are: (1) The current subdivision plat precludes any building in excess of 4 stories. (2) Contrary to the statement in the application, I am not aware of any effort on the part of the developer to “coordinate with surrounding neighborhoods”. Last night’s meeting was the first I have heard from the developer. I would beg to differ with the statement that “previous neighborhood meetings indicated our proposal will be well received and highly anticipated.” I am not sure what they are talking about since I am not aware of any previous meetings, and if there were previous meetings perhaps they were before they decided to propose a 20 story apartment building on the site. No one I have spoken with was previously aware of that proposal and I am not aware of ANYONE  that is in favor of that. (3) The application is too vague and uninformative. I do not see anywhere in the application that would indicate the developer’s intent to build a 20 story apartment building, nor does their plan reflect where and how much other residential use they are proposing, where and how much retail they are proposing, that they are proposing a hotel, and what kind of bars and nightlife they are proposing that could further impact the neighborhoods, nearby church, and schools. There was also discussion at the meeting that they may seek to close Oak Court Drive. Where is this on their application? Closing that road would SIGNIFICANTLY impact traffic in the area and is not acceptable.  (4) Contrary to the statement in the application, the two proposals referenced above would have a substantial and undue adverse impact on adjacent properties and the character of the neighborhood, traffic conditions, and parking. The intersection at Poplar and Perkins Ext. is already overcrowded and difficult, particularly when there is a train running at the intersection of Southern and Perkins Ext. The area is also already overcrowded at 2:30 when White Station High School is dismissed and at 3:00 when Christ Methodist Day School is dismissed. Traffic from a 20 story apartment building and retail would overrun this area. I am concerned about having ANY residential on this development, much less a 20 story apartment building. That is insane to even suggest it. I know it is a delicate subject, but 20% subsidized housing is also not in keeping with the surrounding neighborhoods- it would not “blend with the character of the surrounding neighborhoods” as the application states- and everyone knows it.  6/5/25, 9:46 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQANP2iww4w9VCpagsWDyA… 1/2 (5) Have you considered the impact this would have on White Station High School? Can they handle the additional eligible students this would bring? (6) Given the last minute notice of the deadline for filing an objection to this application, I have not had time to review all of the various easements, covenants and restrictions affecting this property. I would ask that an administrative hold be placed on this this matter, that the developer be required to supplement their application to give more sufficient detail of the their proposed intent regarding this application (particularly given the significant impact this development is going to have on the entire city of Memphis given its central location), that additional meetings be conducted with the surrounding neighborhoods to address these issues, and that the surrounding neighborhoods have adequate time to properly address these proposals.   Sincerely,  David Dunlap     David M. Dunlap, Esq 85 Grove Park Circle Memphis, TN 38117 Cell: (901) 550-7419 Email: dmdlaw@mac.com https://daviddunlaplaw.com 6/5/25, 9:46 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQANP2iww4w9VCpagsWDyA… 2/2 Outlook Record Number PD-2025-006, Modification of PD 87-313 From Katherine Richardson <katherine.richardson@gmail.com> Date Tue 6/3/2025 4:03 PM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. ________________________________ From: Katherine O. Richardson 556 Cherry Road Memphis, TN 38117 901-831-9741 Katherine.Richardson@gmail.com To: Land Use & Development Services, Division of Planning and Development, Attention: Chloe Christion, 125 N. Main, Suite 468, Memphis Tn 38103 Subject: Record Number PD-2025-006, Modification of PD 87-313 Date: June 3, 2025 I want to go on record as opposing several items listed within the Oak Court Planned Development Amendment at 4465 Poplar Avenue, Memphis, TN 38117. Please reference -Record Number PD-2025-006, Modification of PD 87-313. I am opposed to the following: 1. Bulldozing the berm and the mature trees living on the approximate 3 acre, 100 foot deep strip of land abutting the homes on the east side of Cherry Road in the Village neighborhood. 2. Constructing 28 townhomes on the strip of land, which is proposed to be leveled and cleared, on the western edge of the Oak Court property, abutting the eastern border of Cherry Road. 3. Erecting a 240 foot (maximum) tall building “somewhere” along the RR track facing Audubon golf course. (As listed in “Conditions” Paragraph III, C.) 4.The option to close and privatize Oak Court Drive. (As listed in “Conditions” Paragraph III, c). However, in a neighborhood meeting at the Dixon Gallery and Gardens, on Monday, May 2, the developers said the option to privatize Oak court Drive was to be removed fr om their concept plan. The history of the berm and green space along the western most area of the Oak Court property is 6/5/25, 9:48 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAMYWIfLxxQ1AgdF2kmayD… 1/2 instructive and must be considered.  (Reference PD 83-036,PD 84-356) in addition to PD 87-313.  The berm was established as a buffer between the Village residential area and the “concept” of the then to be constructed Oak Court Mall in 1983.  The agreement for the berm /buffer was made between the city council and Belz Development, over the tenure of 2 city mayors. The value of the berm, mature trees and green space is, as they say, priceless.   Memphians benefit from green space, no matter the size. Not only is it a visual aesthetic but it serves to prevent erosion and water run off. Wildlife benefit from green space. The city benefits from increased home values in areas with mature trees and walkable streets. The developers, as outlined in their concept, propose to demolish the berm and  construct 28 townhomes on the approximate 3 acre, 100 foot deep strip.  Along with townhomes, there will be a paved alley and a barrier wall. Consequently, there will be less green earth, less plant life to absorb water and fewer trees for sound absorption.  There is also the issue of light pollution to consider. I am concerned that cleared land with new structures (townhomes and a high rise building) will not only exacerbate drainage problems but will make for parking issues, and increased traffic/congestion along the Poplar corridor. The developers have submitted no traffic plan and no traffic study has been undertaken.  Couldn’t a vehicle estimate for retail units, residential rental and ownership units, plus a  consequent number of  service vehicles and guests vehicles be available for a preliminary traffic study? What increased demands will there be on the city’s utilities? What effects will inhabitants, shoppers and office workers have on surface parking? I am upset that the neighbors most affected, those within the Village neighborhood, were not officially  notified before the meeting held at Christ Church Wilson Chapel on May 27 hosted by Brenda Solomito Bazar. Residents were notified by USPS. Developers stated there were meetings held previously yet no notice was received by USPS or other means by any Village residents with whom I spoke. I am particularly concerned that those living on Cherry Road, had no official notice of any meeting(s) with developers until that sent by Brenda Solomito Basar, postmarked May 15. The letter was dated May 9, 2025. The meeting called by the developers was held on May 27, 2025.  I am to understand that any comment has to be made in writing to LUCB by June 3.  That timeline between letter postmark (May 15) and comment due (close of business June 3) is very short.  Was the delayed notification to residents of nearby neighborhoods intentional? Or, was this simply administrative ineptitude on the part of the developers? The developers do not seem to be acting in good faith. The development process should promote a positive change in the economic, environmental and quality of life of residential communities without damaging the surrounding areas and beyond.  I do not believe the current concept plan promotes overall positive change. Sincerely Yours, Katherine O. Richardson Sent from my iPhone 6/5/25, 9:48 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAMYWIfLxxQ1AgdF2kmayD… 2/2 Outlook Oak Court Development From Mary Anne Gibson <MaryAnneG@thefirmmemphis.com> Date Tue 6/3/2025 4:02 PM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> Cc Thomas Marchbanks <tmarchbanks@marchbanks.com> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. ________________________________ Chloe, please consider this notification of my displeasure of the oak Court development proposal. A giant skyscraper as proposed completely changes the entirety of the neighborhood in a negative way. Please reconsider moving forward. Mary Anne Gibson 6/5/25, 9:48 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAJqg2sWTFOVFknEK7PT5l… 1/1 Outlook Oak Court Mall From Nedra Wick <nedralwick@gmail.com> Date Tue 6/3/2025 3:44 PM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Ms. Christion,       I respectfully request you reject the developers' current application(s) to develop Oak Court Mall; I reside north of the area.  While this development group has no doubt presented a form for LUCB approval, my concern is that there is no specificity, much less a plan.  This is not acceptable in East Memphis, an area of significant residential density.  It is my understanding that LUCB can impose restrictions or outright reject this application; this homeowner requests LUCB do the latter.        As the city and county are well-aware, the area of the current Oak Court Mall is central to one of the highest value neighborhoods in Memphis.  Simply put, the property taxes we pay to choose to live in this area carry the burden for many other parts of the city.  To risk losing the significant East Memphis tax base by approving developments inconsistent with the surrounding area is not in anyone's best interest.  If the current application is  approved by LUCB, this homeowner will begin to look elsewhere before what this developer is suggesting becomes common knowledge and East Memphis loses its desirability.      The developers have not provided specifics about their proposed mixed use, office density, residential density, hotel use, retail use or ratios of each.  They have not identified location or size of spaces other than to provide that two "towers", each 20 floors high, will be located on the property.  It is my understanding there is a 240' height allowance in this area; has the developer made application or already received a variance from the City?   If so, please identify which department(s) and the names of all who were involved.  The developer has provided no explanation of what these massive towers will house.      Other parts of this applicant's  plan include a clear violation of the current PUD.  If you are not aware, this development group intends to significantly alter the established environment.  The plans include cutting down all trees, destroying all greenspace and removing the berm that was created over forty (40) years ago as a buffer for residential neighbors.  Because this area is located over a feed into the Mississippi River I would also suggest that an environmental study by the Army Corps of Engineers may be required prior to beginning construction/destruction on the property to insure what the developer proposes will not negatively impact the water.        Ms. Christion, developing property is an incredible benefit to our community when done responsibly.  The lack of specificity and the lack of attention to the East Memphis neighborhoods by this development group signals just how inappropriate this application is and how very much the City of Memphis will be harmed if LUCB does not exercise its duty to oversee this land's development.  Again, please deny this developer's application and require that if they reapply that they do so with a specific site plan.      My appreciation for your consideration, Nedra L. Wick. 6/5/25, 9:51 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAJYrCE1EqbRCjAejVzyWx… 1/2 Nedra L. Wick Attorney/Arbitrator/GAL Rule 31 Mediator National Association of Counsel for Children 678-612-1031  nedralwick@gmail.com Professional Connection: LinkedIn Scan & Email Documents or Dropbox Please practice charity. NOTICE: This email and all attachments are CONFIDENTIAL and intended SOLELY for the recipients as identified in the "To," "Cc" and "Bcc" lines of this email. If you are not an intended recipient, your receipt of this email and its attachments is the result of an inadvertent disclosure or unauthorized transmittal. Sender reserves and asserts all rights to confidentiality, including all privileges that may apply. Pursuant to those rights and privileges, immediately DELETE and DESTROY all copies of the email and its attachments, in whatever form, and immediately NOTIFY the sender of your receipt of this email. DO NOT review, copy, forward, or rely on the email and its attachments in any way. NO DUTIES ARE ASSUMED, INTENDED, OR CREATED BY THIS COMMUNICATION. If you have not executed a fee contract or an engagement letter, this firm does NOT represent you as your attorney. You are encouraged to retain counsel of your choice if you desire to do so. All rights of the sender for violations of the confidentiality and privileges applicable to this email and any attachments are expressly reserved. 6/5/25, 9:51 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAJYrCE1EqbRCjAejVzyWx… 2/2 Outlook Oak Court Mall Redevelopment From Newton Anderson <nanderson@spicerfirm.com> Date Tue 6/3/2025 3:41 PM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Ms. Christion: I am a resident of the Belle Meade neighborhood (194 Montrose Drive) and am contacting you with regard to the proposed Oak Court Mall Redevelopment. I understand that the hearing before the Land Use Control Board is scheduled next week and that public comments are being collected by you. As you are probably aware, there was a Neighborhood Meeting, open to the public, that took place at Dixon Gallery and Gardens on the evening of June 2, 2025 in which the developer representatives made a presentation and took some questions. I have major concerns about this proposed development. The developer representatives provided almost no specificity about their plans. They produced no studies or other evidence that a project of the proposed size (20 stories) would be feasible. They produced no studies or other evidence of the impact from construction noise nor construction and post- construction traffic on Poplar Avenue and Southern Avenue or on the nearby neighborhoods or small businesses. Nor was there any presentation of a plan of construction (days of the week, times) to fully assess the impact on the nearby residences and businesses as it relates to noise and construction traffic. In the May 5, 2025 letter to Brett Ragsdale, Zoning Administrator for the Division of Planning and Development, which accompanied the Application, in the “Approval Criteria” section of the letter, it was stated without evidence or other support that “The project will not have a substantial or undue adverse effect upon adjacent property, the character of the neighborhood, traffic conditions, parking, utility facilities and other matters affecting the public health, safety, and general welfare”. It was also stated, again without evidence or other support that “surrounding properties outside of the boundary will not be negatively impacted by this application. Previous neighborhood meetings indicated our proposal will be well received and highly anticipated.” It is clear that even though the response at unspecified “previous neighborhood meetings” may have been “well received”, at the meeting that took place at Dixon Gallery and Gardens on the evening of June 2, 2025, and which was attended by the neighbors who stand to be most affected by the project, the reception was anything but favorable. It appears that the developers may even be seeking approval of a project that is likely larger than they actually plan, with virtually no specifics about what will actually be built nor any evidence supporting their vague plans, so that they can claim compromise by agreeing to reduce the size of a building that they never seriously intended to build. Nonetheless, even if the project is scaled down from what they are currently proposing, it lacks justification due to an inability (or refusal) of the developers to show what they intend to build, how large it will actually be and that it will not harm the nearby neighborhoods and small businesses. 6/5/25, 9:53 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQANgBUnGWUEJfpVYyb54ty… 1/2 I understand that the developers are not presenting a final plan at this stage. However, the lack of specificity for this oversized project and the lack of any studies or other evidence showing the extent of what will assuredly be a lasting negative impact on the nearby neighborhoods, small businesses and motorists along Poplar and Southern Avenues is especially disconcerting. I am not opposed to redevelopment of the Oak Court Mall property. Abandoned buildings are in no one’s best interest. And I understand the g oal of Memphis 3.0 is to “build up, not out”. However, “build up” has its limits and I do not believe that the Memphis 3.0 University planning district (withing which this project would be situated) contains any buildings that even approach 20 stories. The Lipscomb and Pitts building (which is actually in the adjoining Core City dis trict) is only 12 stories. A plan for the Oak Court Mall Redev elopment should be far more transparent and should be required to take into account the totality of the impact on the nearby neighborhoods, small businesses and motorists. The developers ha ve not shown that they have given that impact the degree of concern that a project like this requires. I urge the rejection of this plan. Thank you for your attention to my concerns. Newton Anderson 194 Montrose Drive Memphis TN 38117 6/5/25, 9:53 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQANgBUnGWUEJfpVYyb54ty… 2/2 Outlook Oak Court Concerns From Shawn Fussell <sfussup@aol.com> Date Thu 5/22/2025 10:07 AM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Dear Chloe. My name is Shawn Fussell and I am a resident of the Village neighborhood. After seeing some conceptual site plans for the Oak Court Development I have noticed three major concerns: 1. Removing existing buffer and berm on west side of Oak Court Drive to build townhomes against property lines of Cherry Road Residents. 2. Apartment\Condo building up to 240 feet (approx, 20 stories) (As listed in "Conditions" Paragraph II, D-1) 3. The option to close and privatize Oak Court Drive. ("Conditions" Paragraph III, C) I am wholeheartedly in favorfor the development of Oak Court property and frankly the city could use a updated and best in class retail, residential property, however would ask for developers to honor existing berm and placement of high rise for minimal impact to adjacent neighborhood. Thank you for your attention Shawn Fussell 6/9/25, 11:51 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAKacmXgPWCxInCcGR90E0z8%3D 1/1 Outlook Case # PD 2025-006 (Oak Court Mall Development From Ruthie Maupin <laynemaupin@bellsouth.net> Date Mon 6/2/2025 7:52 PM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. ________________________________ I live in the Wynslow community on the western property line of First Horizon Bank. We have only one driveway in and out on Poplar Avenue. It is a few yards west of the exit driveway of the bank. It is difficult now to turn left onto Poplar Avenue or into our community during rush hour. When the mall was thriving we would be completely blocked d uring the Christmas holidays. Adding a thousand or more cars daily would be an impossible challenge. Would you consider buying some land from the bank and make a dedicated right turn lane into Oak Court Drive? It won’t solve the problem completely, but it might help. Thank you, Ruth Maupin Sent from my iPhone 6/3/25, 8:40 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAN%2BkRiCE78NPhhdFPo… 1/1 Outlook I am Totally opposed to the 20 story building proposal for Macy’s redevelopment Macy’s red From Darrelle Miller <darrelle.miller@icloud.com> Date Wed 6/4/2025 8:02 AM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. ________________________________ Sent from my iPhone 6/5/25, 9:44 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAKKxhcSIlhVFs6pTuNRHm… 1/1 Outlook Oak Court Development From Eric Wilson <eric.wilson.au@gmail.com> Date Fri 6/6/2025 3:17 PM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Hello. I'm writing this email is our support of good friends who will be negatively impacted by the removal of the berm and landscaping on the west side of the Oak Court Drive in which 28 townhomes are set to be built. This berm was intended to buffer against future development. This breach would all but ruin a beautiful piece of property I frequent with friends who live there. Thank you kindly for your attention. Eric Wilson 6/9/25, 11:22 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAO%2BXsG4ga6NDhSC9H… 1/1 CITY OF MEMPHIS COUNCIL AGENDA CHECK OFF SHEET ___________________________________________________________________________________ | ONE ORIGINAL | Planning & Development | ONLY STAPLED | DIVISION |TO DOCUMENTS| Planning & Zoning COMMITTEE: 07/22/2025 DATE PUBLIC SESSION: 08/05/2018 DATE ITEM (CHECK ONE) ORDINANCE X RESOLUTION REQUEST FOR PUBLIC HEARING = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = ITEM DESCRIPTION: Resolution pursuant to Chapter 9.6 of the Memphis and Shelby County Unified Development Code approving a special use permit at the subject property located 436 S Front Street., known as case number SUP 2025-011 CASE NUMBER: SUP 2025-011 LOCATION: 436 S Front Street COUNCIL DISTRICTS: District 7 and Super District 8 OWNER/APPLICANT: Stallion Apartments, LLC REPRESENTATIVE: Josh Whitehead, Josh Whitehead Law REQUEST: To convert an existing apartment building to a full-service hotel AREA: +/-0.312 acres RECOMMENDATION: The Division of Planning and Development recommended Approval with conditions The Land Use Control Board recommended Approval with conditions RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION: Public Hearing Not Required = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = PRIOR ACTION ON ITEM: (1) APPROVAL - (1) APPROVED (2) DENIED 09/05/2025 DATE (1) Land Use Control Board ORGANIZATION - (1) BOARD / COMMISSION (2) GOV’T. ENTITY (3) COUNCIL COMMITTEE = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = FUNDING: (2) REQUIRES CITY EXPENDITURE - (1) YES (2) NO $ AMOUNT OF EXPENDITURE $ REVENUE TO BE RECEIVED SOURCE AND AMOUNT OF FUNDS $ OPERATING BUDGET $ CIP PROJECT #_______________________________ $ FEDERAL/STATE/OTHER = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = DATE POSITIONADMINISTRATIVE APPROVAL: ______Travian Smith____________________________ 07/08/2025 PRINCIPAL PLANNER _______________________________________________ ____________ DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR ____________________________________________ ____________ ADMINISTRATOR _____________________________________________ ____________ DIRECTOR (JOINT APPROVAL) _____________________________________________ ____________ COMPTROLLER _____________________________________________ ____________ FINANCE DIRECTOR _____________________________________________ ____________ CITY ATTORNEY = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = _____________________________________________ ____________ CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER _____________________________________________ ____________ COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN Memphis City Council Summary Sheet SUP 2025-011 RESOLUTION PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 9.6 OF THE MEMPHIS AND SHELBY COUNTY UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT CODE APPROVING A SPECIAL USE PERMIT AT THE SUBJECT PROPERTY LOCATED AT 436 S FRONT STREET, KNOWN AS CASE NUMBER SUP 2025-011 • This item is a resolution with conditions for a special use permit to convert an existing apartment building to a full-service hotel; and • The Planning & Development staff is supportive of the Full-Service Hotel, and are recommending approval with the following conditions: o A “no parking” sign shall be erected on the vehicular gate at the adjacent parking lot serving 420 South Main Street to the north of the subject site facing Front Street. o Two spaces along Nettleton Avenue shall be signed in such a way that reserves these spaces for loading during the hours of 9am-5pm. o The trash collection area shall be screened and secured by a fence or wall composed of an opaque matte material compatible with the dominant material of the primary building. Compatibility of material is subject to administrative review and approval by the Zoning Administrator. o A final site plan with landscaping shall be submitted to the Division of Planning and Development for administrative review and approval. • The item may require future public improvement contracts. 1 LAND USE CONTROL BOARD RECOMMENDATION At its regular meeting on Thursday, June 12, 2025, the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board held a public hearing on the following application: CASE NUMBER: SUP 2025-011 LOCATION: 436 S Front Street COUNCIL DISTRICT(S): District 7 and Super District 8 OWNER/APPLICANT: Stallion Apartments, LLC REPRESENTATIVE: Josh Whitehead, Josh Whitehead Law REQUEST: To convert an existing apartment building to a full-service hotel EXISTING ZONING: South Main (SM) AREA: +/-0.312 acres The following spoke in support: None The following spoke in opposition: None The Land Use Control Board reviewed the application and the staff report . A motion was made and seconded to recommend approval with conditions. The motion passed by a vote of 8-0-0 on the consent agenda. Respectfully, Travian Smith Planner I Land Use and Development Services Division of Planning and Development Cc: Committee Members File 2 SUP 2025-011 CONDITIONS 1. A “no parking” sign shall be erected on the vehicular gate at the adjacent parking lot serving 420 South Main Street to the north of the subject site facing Front Street. 2. Two spaces along Nettleton Avenue shall be signed in such a way that reserves these spaces for loading during the hours of 9am-5pm. 3. The trash collection area shall be screened and secured by a fence or wall composed of an opaque matte material compatible with the dominant material of the primary building. Compatibility of material is subject to administrative review and approval by the Zoning Administrator. 4. A final site plan with landscaping shall be submitted to the Division of Planning and Development for administrative review and approval. 3 SITE PLAN RESOLUTION PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 9.6 OF THE MEMPHIS AND SHELBY COUNTY UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT CODE APPROVING A SPECIAL USE PERMIT AT THE SUBJECT PROPERTY LOCATED 436 S FRONT STREET, KNOWN AS CASE NUMBER SUP 2025-011 WHEREAS, Chapter 9.6 of the Memphis and Shelby County Unified Development Code, being a section of the Joint Ordinance Resolution No. 5367, dated August 10, 2010, authorizes the Council of the City of Memphis to grant a special use permit for certain stated purpos es in the various zoning districts; and WHEREAS, Stallion Apartments, LLC filed an application with the Memphis and Shelby County Division of Planning and Development to convert an existing apartment building to a full -service hotel; and WHEREAS, the Division of Planning and Development has received and reviewed the application in accordance with procedures, objectives, and standards for special use permits as set forth in Chapter 9.6 with regard to the proposed development's impacts upon surrounding propertie s, availability of public facilities, both external and internal circulation, land use compatibility, and that the design and amenities are consistent with the public interest; and has submitted its findings and recommendation concerning the above considerations to the Land Use Control Board; and WHEREAS, a public hearing in relation thereto was held before the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board on June 12, 2025, and said Board has submitted its findings and recommendation concerning the above considerations to the Council of the City of Memphis; and WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Memphis has reviewed the aforementioned application pursuant to Tennessee Code Annotated Section 13 -4-202(B)(2)(B)(iii) and has determined that said development is consistent with the Memphis 3.0 General Plan; and WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Memphis has reviewed the recommendation of the Land Use Control Board and the report and recommendation of the Division of Planning and Development and has determined that said development meets the objectives, standards and criteria for a special use permit, and said development is consistent with the public interests. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF MEMPHIS, that, pursuant to Chapter 9.6 of the Memphis and Shelby County Unified Development Code, a special use permit is hereby granted for the request use in accordance with the attached conditions. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED , that this permit merely authorizes the filing of applications to acquire a Certificate of Use and Occupancy, or a Building Permit, and other required permits and approvals, provided that no such Certificate of Use and Occupancy shall be granted until all conditions imposed by the Council of the City of Memphis have been met. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED , that this Resolution take effect from and after the date it shall have been passed by this Council of the City of Memphis, and become effective as otherwise provided by law, and thereafter shall be treated as in full force and effect by virtue of passage thereof by the Council of the City of Memphis, the public welfare requiring same. CONDITIONS 1. A “no parking” sign shall be erected on the vehicular gate at the adjacent parking lot serving 420 South Main Street to the north of the subject site facing Front Street. 2. Two spaces along Nettleton Avenue shall be signed in such a way that reserves these spaces for loading during the hours of 9am-5pm. 3. The trash collection area shall be screened and secured by a fence or wall composed of an opaque matte material compatible with the dominant material of the primary building. Compatibility of material is subject to administrative review and approval by the Zoning Administrator. 4. A final site plan with landscaping shall be submitted to the Division of Planning and Development for administrative review and approval. SITE PLAN ATTEST: CC: Division of Planning and Development – Land Use and Development Services – Office of Construction Enforcement Staff Writer: Travian Smith E-mail: Travian.Smith@memphistn.gov AGENDA ITEM: 8 L.U.C.B. MEETING: June 12, 2025 CASE NUMBER: SUP 2025-011 LOCATION: 436 S Front St. COUNCIL DISTRICT: District 7 and Super District 8 OWNER/APPLICANT: Stallion Apartments, LLC REPRESENTATIVE: Josh Whitehead, Josh Whitehead Law REQUEST: To convert an existing apartment building to a full-service hotel EXISTING ZONING: South Main (SM) CONCLUSIONS 1. The request is for converting an apartment building into a full-service hotel. 2. According to the applicant, the reasoning is due to increased demand in the market for a boutique hotel. The neighborhood demonstrates a strong market due to the prior use of a few units as Airbnb’s. Additionally, the National Civil Rights Museum, which is located within walking distance from the site, is currently undergoing a multi -million-dollar expansion that will attract an increased number of visitors to the historic site over time. 3. Staff agrees the approval criteria in regard special use permits as set out in Section 9.6.9 of the Unified Development Code are met. 4. The granting of this special use permit will not cause substantial detriment to the public good, nor will it substantially impair the intent and purpose of an adopted plan or the Unified Development Code (UDC), nor will It be injurious to the neighborhood or the general welfare, and it will be in harmony with the purpose and intent of the UDC. CONSISTENCY WITH MEMPHIS 3.0 This proposal is consistent with the Memphis 3.0 General Plan per the land use decision criteria. See further analysis on page 21 of this report. RECOMMENDATION: Approval with conditions Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 2 2 LOCATION MAP Subject property located within the pink circle SUBJECT PROPERTY Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 3 3 PUBLIC NOTICE VICINITY MAP Subject property highlighted in yellow PUBLIC NOTICE DETAILS In accordance with Sub-Section 9.3.4A of the Unified Development Code, a notice of public hearing is required to be mailed and signage posted. A total of 425 notices were mailed on May 22, 2025, see page 25 of this report for a copy of said notice . Additionally, one sign was posted at the subject property, see page 26 of this report for a copy of the sign affidavit. NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING The meeting was held at 5:00 PM on Monday, June 2, 2025, at The Stallion Apartments at 436 South Front Street. Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 4 4 The Metropolitan (2011) (PLAT BOOK 251 PAGE 002) Subject property highlighted in yellow Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 5 5 AERIAL Subject property outlined in yellow, imagery from 2024 Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 6 6 ZONING MAP Subject property highlighted in yellow Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 7 7 LAND USE MAP Subject property indicated by a pink star Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 8 8 SITE PHOTOS View of subject property from Front Street looking Northeast. View of subject property from Front Street looking North. Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 9 9 View of subject property from Front Street looking Southeast. View of subject property from Front Street looking Southeast. Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 10 10 Site Photos per the Applicant Photo 1: Top-down view of site (north is to the right). Photo 2: View looking north; the stallion is the center foreground. Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 11 11 Photo 3: View looking east; note the proximity of the National Civil Rights Museum, located in the center background. Photo 4: View south along Front Street. Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 12 12 Photo 5: View looking northeast; Front Street is on the left and Nettleton Avenue is on the right. Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 13 13 SURVEY Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 14 14 SITE PLAN Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 15 15 SITE PLAN – MAGNIFIED Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 16 16 CASE REVIEW Request The request is to convert an existing apartment building to a full-service hotel. Approval Criteria Staff agrees the approval criteria in regard special use permits as set out in Section 9. 6.9 of the Unified Development Code are met. 9.6.9 Approval Criteria No special use permit or planned development shall be approved unless the following findings are made concerning the application: 9.6.9A The project will not have a substantial or undue adverse effect upon adjacent property, the character of the neighborhood, traffic conditions, parking, utility facilities and other matters affecting the public health, safety, and general welfare. 9.6.9B The project will be constructed, arranged and operated so as to be compatible with the immediate vicinity and not interfere with the development and use of adjacent property in accordance with the applicable district regulations. 9.6.9C The project will be served adequately by essential public facilities and services such as streets, parking, drainage, refuse disposal, fire protection and emergency services, water and sewers; or that the applicant will provide adequately for such services. 9.6.9D The project will not result in the destruction, loss or damage of any feature determined by the governing bodies to be of significant natural, scenic or historic importance. 9.6.9E The project complies with all additional standards imposed on it by any particular provisions authorizing such use. 9.6.9F The request will not adversely affect any plans to be considered (see Chapter 1.9), or violate the character of existing standards for development of the adjacent properties. 9.6.9G The governing bodies may impose conditions to minimize adverse effects on the neighborhood or on public facilities, and to ensure compatibility of the proposed development with surrounding properties, uses, and the purpose and intent of this development code. 9.6.9H Any decision to deny a special use permit request to place, construct, or modify personal wireless service facilities shall be in writing and supported by substantial evidence contained in a written record, per the Telecommunications Act of 1996, 4 7 USC 332(c)(7)(B)(iii). The review body may not take into account any environmental or health concerns. Site Details Address: 436 S. Front Street Parcel ID: 002105 00010 Area: +/- 13,590.72 (.312 acres) Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 17 17 Description: The subject property is known as The Stallion, located at 436 S. Front Street in the South Main district of Downtown Memphis. The building currently houses 28 units, 22 of which are 1 -bedroom units and six (6) of which are 2 -bedroom units. Ten (10) of the units are currently utilized as short -term rentals through Airbnb. According to the Shelby County Assessor of Property’s website, the property was developed in 2013. According to the Shelby County Register of Deeds, the property is within The Metropolitan subdivision which is in the South Main zoning district. The subject property is currently classified as multifamily in use as an apartment complex. Site Zoning History On July 28, 2010, the Board of Adjustment approved BOA 2010 -019 for a variance from the required parking aisle width of 22 feet to 18th feet to accommodate basement parking; and a variance from the current permitted maximum density of 18 residential dwelling units to permit a total of 25 residential dwelling units. See page 19 of this report for said resolution. Note that after the adoption of ZTA 24-1 in May of 2024 the South Main District no longer has a maximum residential dwelling unit density per acre. Relevant Unified Development Code Clauses Paragraph 7.2.2C(3) - Special Use Permit The following uses are subject to the approval of a Special Use Permit: Gas Stations Hotel, Bed and Breakfast Retail Sales, Outdoors Self-Storage Facilities Tavern, Cocktail Lounge or Night Club with greater than 125 seats Any restaurant, tavern, cocktail or night club with outdoor entertainment or with outdoor space, such as a patio or deck, that exceeds 25% of the area of the site. For sites with multiple uses, only the portion of the site that contains the restaurant, tavern, cocktail or night club and its accessory uses shall be used to calculate this 25%. Paragraph 7.2.2D(3) Façades greater than 100 feet in length along a street frontage, as measured horizontally, shall be articulated to provide visual interest and a human scale by incorporating any combination of the following features: columns, pilasters, balconies, piers, v ariation of material building and setback variations of at least 3 feet. No uninterrupted length of any façade shall exceed 100 horizontal feet. Site Plan Review The site plan provided is from the approved BOA 2010-019 case. However, the site plan was not followed as the garage doors along Nettle Avenue are not in the outlined location. Additionally, the streetscape and landscaping were not constructed correctly. Because of this, the final site plan with landscaping will need to be submitted in efforts to correct this issue. The site plan demonstrates the area of the building which makes up 0.31 acres of the lot. There is a proposed 30ft setback from South Front Str eet and Nettleton Avenue. Each street frontage has a curb and gutter alongside a handicap ramp for accessibility measures. The subject property propose d a basement parking under the building making up 25 spaces . Adjacent to the subject property is a bank, condominiums, and a railroad track. The subject property is proposed to be mixed use, making up commercial and guest rooms. The building is 3 stories tall, excluding the basement. The lodging area is made up of 25,280 sq. feet, whereas the commercial area will make up 2,432 sq. feet. Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 18 18 Analysis • The request is for converting an apartment building into a full-service hotel. • According to the applicant, the reasoning is due to increased demand in the market for a boutique hotel. The neighborhood demonstrates a strong market due to the prior use of a few units as Airbnb’s. Additionally, the National Civil Rights Museum, which is located within walking distance from the site, is currently undergoing a multi-million-dollar expansion that will attract an increased number of visitors to the historic site over time. • Staff agrees the approval criteria in regard special use permits as set out in Section 9.6.9 of the Unified Development Code are met. • The granting of this special use permit will not cause substantial detriment to the public good, nor will it substantially impair the intent and purpose of an adopted plan or the Unified Development Code (UDC), nor will It be injurious to the neighborhood or the general welfare, and it will be in harmony with the purpose and intent of the UDC. RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends approval with conditions. Conditions 1. A “no parking” sign shall be erected on the vehicular gate at the adjacent parking lot serving 420 South Main Street to the north of the subject site facing Front Street. 2. Two spaces along Nettleton Avenue shall be signed in such a way that reserves these spaces for loading during the hours of 9am-5pm. 3. The trash collection area shall be screened and secured by a fence or wall composed of an opaque matte material compatible with the dominant material of the primary building. Compatibility of material is subject to administrative review and approval by the Zoning Administrator. 4. A final site plan with landscaping shall be submitted to the Division of Planning and Development for administrative review and approval. Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 19 19 Notice of Disposition Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 20 20 DEPARTMENTAL COMMENTS The following comments were provided by agencies to which this application was referred: City/County Engineer: No comments received. City/County Fire Division: No comments received. City Real Estate: No comments received. County Health Department: No comments received. Shelby County Schools: No comments received. Construction Code Enforcement: No comments received. Memphis Light, Gas and Water: No comments received. Office of Sustainability and Resilience: No comments received. Office of Comprehensive Planning: See Comments Below. Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 21 21 Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 22 22 Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 23 23 Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 24 24 Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 25 25 MAILED PUBLIC NOTICE Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 26 26 SIGN AFFIDAVIT Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 27 27 APPLICATION Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 28 28 Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 29 29 OWNER AFFIDAVIT Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 30 30 LETTER OF INTENT Staff Report June 12, 2025 SUP 2025-0011 Page 31 31 LETTERS RECEIVED No letters received at the time of completion of this report. East Service Center: 6465 Mullins Station Rd; Memphis, T ennessee 38134 Downtown Service Center: 125 N. Main Street; Memphis, Tennessee 38103 website: www.develop901.com Memphis and Shelby County Division of Planning and Development Record Summary for Special Use Permit Record Detail Information Record Type : Special Use Permit Record Status: Pending Opened Date: May 2, 2025 Record Number: SUP 2025-011 Record Name: The Stallion Hotel Expiration Date: Description of Work: Conversion of apartment building to full-service hotel. Parent Record Number: Address: 436 S FRONT ST, MEMPHIS 38103 Owner Information Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone Y STALLION AP ARTMENTS LLC 101 SILVERSTONE LN, SHENANDOAH, TX 77384 Parcel Information 002105 00010 Data Fields PREAPPLICATION MEETING Name of DPD Planner Brett Ragsdale Date of Meeting 04/22/2025 Pre- application Meeting T ype Email GENERAL PROJECT INFORMATION Application Type New Special Use Permit (SUP) List any relevant former Docket / Case Number(s) related to previous applications on this site BOA 2010-19 Is this application in response to a citation, stop work order, or zoning letter No Page 1 of 3 SUP 2025-011 GENERAL PROJECT INFORMATION If yes, please provide a copy of the citation, stop work order, and/or zoning letter along with any other relevant information - APPROVAL CRITERIA A) The project will not have a substantial or undue adverse effect upon adjacent property , the character of the neighborhood, traffic conditions, parking, utility facilities and other matters affecting the public health, safety, and general welfare Correct. B) The project will be constructed, arranged and operated so as to be compatible with the immediate vicinity and not interfere with the development and use of adjacent property in accordance with the applicable district regulations Correct. UDC Sub-Section 9.6.9C Correct. UDC Sub-Section 9.6.9D Correct. UDC Sub-Section 9.6.9E Correct. UDC Sub-Section 9.6.9F Correct. GIS INFORMATION Case Layer - Central Business Improvement District No Class - Downtown Fire District No Historic District - Land Use - Municipality - Overlay/Special Purpose District - Zoning - State Route - Lot - Subdivision - Planned Development District - Wellhead Protection Overlay District No County Commission District - City Council District - City Council Super District - Contact Information JOSH WHITEHEAD (901)810-5789 APPLICANT Name Address Phone Contact Type Page 2 of 3 SUP 2025-011 Fee Information Date AssessedBalanceStatusFeesQuantityFee ItemInvoice # 05/02/20250.00INVOICED500.001Special Use Permit Fee - 5 acres or less (Base Fee) 1646202 05/02/20250.00INVOICED13.001Credit Card Use Fee (.026 x fee) 1646202 Total Fee Invoiced: $513.00 Total Balance: $0.00 Payment Information Payment Amount Method of Payment Credit Card$513.00 Page 3 of 3 SUP 2025-011 April 29, 2025 Bre. Ragsdale, AIA Mary W. Sharp Zoning Administrator Chair, and Members Memphis and Shelby County Memphis and Shelby County Division of Planning and Development Land Use Control Board RE: Conversion of The Stallion Apartments into The Stallion Hotel Mr. Ragsdale, Chair Sharp and Members of the Board: Please find the a.ached applicaOon for a Special Use Permit that would allow the conversion of The Stallion Apartments located at 436 South Front into a hotel. We believe the market for an addiOonal bouOque hotel in the neighborhood is very strong, given our experience with uOlizing some of the units in the building as AirBnB’s and the mulO-million dollar expansion that is currently underway at the NaOonal Civil Rights Museum. The museum, which is a half-block to the Stallion’s east, is set to open its new exhibit space and renovated Legacy Building and boarding house wing this year. The museum is set to increase its square footage by about 50%, which will likely result in a proporOonal increase in the number of visitors to the historic site. The Stallion Hotel will be focused on families; each unit will contain a crib. The building currently houses 28 units, 22 of which are 1-bedroom units and six (6) of which are 2-bedroom units. Ten (10) of the units are currently uOlized as short-term rentals through AirBnB; it is our desire to idenOfy the building as a facility with full hotel ameniOes. A front desk will be staffed 24 hours a day, seven (7) days a week, which will provide on-site personnel for the hotel. In addiOon, a fitness center will be provided on the first floor. The basement garage contains 16 parking spaces. In addiOon, there are eight (8) parking spaces along Ne.leton. Pick-up and drop-off lanes will be provided in both the basement garage and along Ne.leton. Please see the a.ached plans for exterior modificaOons that were the subject of a façade grant from the Downtown Memphis Commission. These modificaOons include new paint, new façade and sidewalk lighOng, new brick planters, new signage and even a new sculpture. We look forward in reposiOoning the Stallion in the marketplace in a way that will further cement the viability of the South Main neighborhood. Recent aerial photographs of the site are a.ached to this le.er. Thank you for your consideraOon, Josh Whitehead Photo 1: Top-down view of site (north is to the right). Photo 2: View looking north; the Stallion is in the center foreground. Photo 3: View looking east; note the proximity of the NaFonal Civil Rights Museum, located in the center background. Photo 4: View south along Front Street. Photo 5: View looking northeast; Front Street is on the leO and NePleton Avenue is on the right. 436 S FRONT ST GRANT DESIGN PROPOSAL AMIT AGGARWAL STALLION APARTMENTS LLC Overall 1. New Main multicolored LED Lights 2. Brick wall with planters 3. Sidewalk lights 4. New Paint throughout 5. Sculpture on the side 1. New Main lights New colored remote-controlled LED lights throughout the front and side of the building 2. New brick wall for planter on the front side 3. New Sidewalk lights 4. New paint throughout Note: Colors NOT final yet 5. Sculpture on the side of the building Note: Sculpture may change, not a final one

Source: City of Memphis website. First collected Oct 27, 2026.