RecordWell Data

Regular Meeting Planning and Zoning Documents

City of Memphis · Shelby County · meeting of May 20, 2025 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Memphis

This document is no longer listed on City of Memphis's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF MEMPHIS COUNCIL AGENDA CHECK OFF SHEET ___________________________________________________________________________________ | ONE ORIGINAL | Planning & Development | ONLY STAPLED | DIVISION |TO DOCUMENTS| Planning & Zoning COMMITTEE: 04/22/2025 DATE PUBLIC SESSION: 05/06/2025 DATE ITEM (CHECK ONE) ORDINANCE X RESOLUTION REQUEST FOR PUBLIC HEARING = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = ITEM DESCRIPTION: Close and vacate the public right -of-way of: SAC 2024-007: 196 feet of Mahannah Ave, between Fred St and Minnie St, SAC 2024-008: 302 feet of Minnie St, north of Mahannah Ave CASE NUMBER: SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 LOCATION: 400 Mahannah Avenue COUNCIL DISTRICTS: District 7 and Super District 8 – Positions 1, 2, and 3 OWNER/APPLICANT: Scott Young REPRESENTATIVES: Mark Jobe/Charles Campbell REQUEST: Close and vacate public right-of-way AREA: +/-13,331.09 square feet (SAC 2024-007) and +/- 8,897.90 square feet (SAC 2024-008) RECOMMENDATION: The Division of Planning and Development recommended Approval with conditions The Land Use Control Board Recommended Approval with conditions RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION: Public Hearing Not Required = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = PRIOR ACTION ON ITEM: (1) APPROVAL - (1) APPROVED (2) DENIED 01/09/2025 DATE (1) Land Use Control Board ORGANIZATION - (1) BOARD / COMMISSION (2) GOV’T. ENTITY (3) COUNCIL COMMITTEE = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = FUNDING: (2) REQUIRES CITY EXPENDITURE - (1) YES (2) NO $ AMOUNT OF EXPENDITURE $ REVENUE TO BE RECEIVED SOURCE AND AMOUNT OF FUNDS $ OPERATING BUDGET $ CIP PROJECT #_______________________________ $ FEDERAL/STATE/OTHER = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = ADMINISTRATIVE APPROVAL: DATE POSITION _____________________________________________ ____________ STAFF PLANNER _____________________________________________ ____________ DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR _____________________________________________ ____________ ADMINISTRATOR _____________________________________________ ____________ DIRECTOR (JOINT APPROVAL) _____________________________________________ ____________ COMPTROLLER _____________________________________________ ____________ FINANCE DIRECTOR _____________________________________________ ____________ CITY ATTORNEY = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = _____________________________________________ ____________ CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER _____________________________________________ ____________ COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN Memphis City Council Summary Sheet SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 RESOLUTION APPROVING RESIDENTIAL CORRIDOR DELETION AT 400 MAHANNAH AVENUE, KNOWN AS CASE NUMBER SAC 2024-007 AND SAC 2024-008 • This item is a resolution to allow the above; and • This item may require a new public improvement contract. RESOLUTION RESOLUTION APPROVING THE CLOSURE OF 196 FEET OF MAHANNAH AVE, BETWEEN FRED ST AND MINNIE ST, AND 302 FEET OF MINNIE ST, NORTH OF MAHANNAH AVE , KNOWN AS C ASE NUMBER SAC 2024-007 AND SAC 2024-008 WHEREAS, the City of Memphis is the owner of real property known as 196 feet of Mahannah Ave, between Fred St and Minnie St and 302 feet of Minnie St, north of Mahannah Ave in Memphis, Tennessee and being more particularly described as follows: Closure Description - Mahannah Avenue Part of Mahannah Avenue (68' Wide) between North Second Street and Minnie Street as dedicated in Menzer's North Second Street Subdivision as recorded in Plat Book 14, Page 32 and Road Dedication for Mahannah Street as recorded in Plat Book 81, Page 51, and being further described hereon: Beginning at a point in the south line of Mahannah Avenue (68 feet wide as widened) a distance of 148.91 feet east of the east line of North Second Street (R.O. W. Varies), having Tennessee State Plane Coordinates of North 334471.1128, East 760199.0838 and being in the east line of a 12 foot wide alley as dedicated at Plat Book 14, Page 32 (R.O.S.C.); thence North 01 degrees 53 minutes 46 seconds East a distance of 68.05 feet to the intersection of the north line of Mahannah Avenue with the east line of Fred Street (30' R.O.W.); thence South 85 degrees 53 minutes 30 seconds East along the north line of Mahannah Avenue a distance of 190.00 feet to the intersection of the north line of Mahannah Avenue with the west line of Minnie Street (30' R.O.W.); thence South 15 degrees 12 minutes 12 seconds East along the projection of said west line of Minnie Street a distance of 32. 79 feet to a point in the easterly line of the Industrial Development Board of Memphis and Shelby County property (lnst.11079801); thence South 52 degrees 26 minutes 59 seconds West along said east line a distance of 2.97 feet to a point in the eastern terminus of Mahannah Avenue; thence South 04 degrees 06 minutes 30 seconds West along said western terminus a distance of 35.08 feet to a point; thence North 85 degrees 53 minutes 30 seconds West along the south line of Mahannah Avenue a distance of 196.00 feet to the point of beginning and containing 13,331.09 square feet. The City of Memphis hereby retains an easement for utilities over the above-described area. Closure Description – Minnie Street Real property situated in the City of Memphis, County of Shelby, to wit: Part of Minnie Street (30' Wide) between Luke Street and Mahannah Avenue and being further described hereon: Commencing at a point in the south line of Mahannah Avenue (68 feet wide as widened) a distance of 148.91 feet east of the east line of North Second Street (R.O.W. V aries), having Tennessee State Plane Coordinates of North 334471.1128, East 760199.0838 and being in the east line of a 12 foot wide alley as dedicated at Plat Book 14, Page 32 (R.O.S.C.); thence South 85 degrees 53 minutes 30 seconds East along the south line of Mahannah Avenue a distance of 196.00 feet to the eastern terminus of Mahannah Avenue; thence North 04 degrees 06 minutes 30 seconds East along said line a distance of 35.08 feet; thence North 52 degrees 26 minutes 59 seconds East a distance of 2.97 feet to a point in the southward projection of the west line of Minnie Street and being the True Point of Beginning said point having Tennessee State Plane Coordinates of North 334493.8699, East 760399.4467; thence North 15 degrees 12 minutes 12 seconds West along the west line of Minnie Street a distance of 302.78 feet; thence North 74 degrees 47 minutes 48 seconds East a distance of 30.00 feet to a point in the east line of Minnie Street; thence South 15 degrees 12 minutes 12 seconds East a distance of 290.45 feet to a point in the southern terminus of Minnie Street; thence South 52 degrees 26 minutes 59 seconds West a distance of 32.43 feet to the point of beginning and containing 8,897.90 square feet. The City of Memphis hereby retains an ease ment for utilities over the above-described area. WHEREAS, the City of Memphis has reviewed the recommendation of the Land Use Control Board and the report and recommendation of the Division of Planning and Development and desires to close the hereinabove described public right-of-way and it is deemed to be in the best interest of the City of Memphis that said public right-of-way be vacated, and revert to the abutting property owner(s); and WHEREAS, a public hearing in relation thereto was held before the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board on January 09, 2025, and said Board has submitted its findings and recommendation to the Council of the City of Memphis subject to the following conditions: 1. Provide easements for existing sanitary sewers, drainage facilities, and other utilities or relocate at developer’s expense. 2. The applicant shall provide for the construction of curb, gutter and sidewalk across the closure as required by the City Engineer. If the City Engineer approves access, the applicant shall construct a City Standard curb cut across the closure, all to the s atisfaction of the City Engineer, and at the applicant's expense. The applicant shall enter into a Standard Improvement Contract or obtain a curb cut permit from the City Engineer to cover the above-required construction work. 3. The applicant shall comply with all conditions of the closure within three years of the conditional approval of the closure by the Council of the City of Memphis. 4. Adequate queuing spaces in accordance with section 4.4.8 of the UDC shall be provided between the street right -of-way line and any proposed gate/guardhouse/card reader. Drawings are subject to approval by City Engineering. 5. Adequate maneuvering room shall be provided between the right -of-way and the gate/guardhouse/card reader for vehicles to exit by forward motion. NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED , by the Council of the City of Memphis that the above described public right -of-way be and is hereby closed for public use, subject to the aforementioned conditions. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED , that the Mayor is hereby authorized to execute all Quitclaim Deed(s) to the owners of the properties abutting on the above described public right-of- way, said Deeds not to be delivered until the conditions herein stated have been met by applicant. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED , that a copy of this resolution be sent to the Lawyers Title Insurance Company, the Memphis Title Company, the Chicago Title Company, the Security Title Company and the Shelby County Property Assessor's Office. RIGHT-OF-WAY VACATION PLAT (SAC 2024-007) RIGHT-OF-WAY VACATION PLAT (SAC 2024-008) ATTEST: Cc: Division of Planning and Development – Land Use and Development Services City Engineering – Land Development City Real Estate 1 LAND USE CONTROL BOARD RECOMMENDATION At its regular meeting on Thursday, January 09, 2025, the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board held a public hearing on the following application: CASE NUMBER: SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 LOCATION: 400 Mahannah Avenue COUNCIL DISTRICT(S): District 7, Super District 8 – Positions 1, 2, and 3 OWNER/APPLICANT: Scott Young REPRESENTATIVE: Mark Jobe/Charles Campbell REQUEST: Right-of-way vacation EXISTING ZONING: Employment (EMP) AREA: +/-13,331.09 square feet (SAC 2024 -007) and +/ - 8,897.90 square feet (SAC 2024-008) The following spoke in support of the application: None The following spoke in opposition of the application: None The Land Use Control Bo ard reviewed the application and the staff report . A motion was made and seconded to recommend approval with conditions of the application. The motion passed by a unanimous vote of 8-0-1 on the consent agenda. Respectfully, Cc: Committee Members File 2 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 CONDITIONS 1. Provide easements for existing sanitary sewers, drainage facilities, and other utilities or relocate at developer’s expense. 2. The applicant shall provide for the construction of curb, gutter and sidewalk across the closure as required by the City Engineer. If the City Engineer approves access, the applicant shall construct a City Standard curb cut across the closure, all to the satisfaction of the City Engineer, and at the applicant's expense. The applicant shall enter into a Standard Improvement Contract or obtain a curb cut permit from the City Engineer to cover the above-required construction work. 3. The applicant shall comply with all conditions of the closure within three years of the conditional approval of the closure by the Council of the City of Memphis. 4. Adequate queuing spaces in accordance with section 4.4.8 of the UDC shall be provided between the street right-of-way line and any proposed gate/guardhouse/card reader. Drawings are subject to approval by City Engineering. 5. Adequate maneuvering room shall be provided between the right-of-way and the gate/guardhouse/card reader for vehicles to exit by forward motion. 3 RIGHT-OF-WAY VACATION PLAT (SAC 2024-007) 4 RIGHT-OF-WAY VACATION PLAT (SAC 2024-007) – MAGNIFIED 5 RIGHT-OF-WAY VACATION PLAT (SAC 2024-008) 6 RIGHT-OF-WAY VACATION PLAT (SAC 2024-008) – MAGNIFIED Staff Writer: Mahsan Ostadnia E-mail: mahsan.ostadnia@memphistn.gov AGENDA ITEM: 9 and 10 L.U.C.B. MEETING: January 09, 2025 CASE NUMBER: S AC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 LOCATION: 400 Mahannah Avenue COUNCIL DISTRICT: District 7 and Super District 8 – Positions 1, 2, and 3 OWNER/APPLICANT: Scott Young REPRESENTATIVE: Mark Jobe/Charles Campbell REQUEST: Close and vacate the public right-of-way of: SAC 2024-007: 196 feet of Mahannah Ave, between Fred St and Minnie St, SAC 2024- 008: 302 feet of Minnie St, north of Mahannah Ave EXISTING ZONING: Employment (EMP) CONCLUSIONS 1. The proposed closure of Mahannah Avenue will vacate 13,331.09 square feet (0.31 acres) of public right-of-way between North Second Street and Minnie Street, transitioning it to private use while preserving utility easements for essential services. This closure supports the consolidation and potential redevelopment of adjacent properties, including land owned by the Industrial Development Board, aligning with broader goals to enhance land use and promote redevelopment in the industrial corridor. A detailed survey ensures clear documentation of boundaries and infrastructure, reducing conflicts with neighboring parcels. 2. The Minnie Street closure involves vacating 8,897.90 square feet (0.20 acres) of a 30 -foot-wide right- of-way from Mahannah Avenue to Levee Street. With limited public use, the closure allows adjacent property owners, like KTG USA LP, to incorporate the lan d for expansion or development. Utility easements will be retained to ensure uninterrupted public services, and a detailed survey ensures a smooth transition to private use while addressing all property and infrastructure considerations. 3. The closures of Mahannah Avenue and Minnie Street together would remove approximately 22,229 square feet (0.51 acres) of public right-of-way from the city’s network. 4. The closure of the subject right-of-way will not have any undue or substantial effect upon the existing vehicular and pedestrian traffic flow of the surrounding area. CONSISTENCY WITH MEMPHIS 3.0 This proposal is inapplicable with the Memphis 3.0 General Plan per the land use decision criteria. RECOMMENDATION: Approval with conditions Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 2 2 LOCATION MAP Subject right-of-way located within the pink circle. SUBJECT RIGHT-OF-WAY Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 3 3 PUBLIC NOTICE VICINITY MAP Subject right-of-way highlighted in orange and red. PUBLIC NOTICE DETAILS In accordance with Sub-Section 9.3.4A of the Unified Development Code, a notice of public hearing is required to be mailed and signage posted. A total of 26 notices were mailed on December 17, 2024, see page 19 of this report for a copy of said notice. Additionally, a total of four signs were posted, one at each end of the subject right-of-way, see pages 22-24 of this report for a copy of the sign affidavit. SAC 2024-007 Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 4 4 AERIAL Subject right-of-way outlined in orange and red. SAC 2024-007 Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 5 5 ZONING MAP Subject right-of-way highlighted in orange and red. SAC 2024-007 Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 6 6 LAND USE MAP Subject right-of-way highlighted in orange and red. SAC 2024-007 Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 7 7 SITE PHOTOS View of access point to the subject right-of-way from Mahannah Avenue. View of access point to the subject right-of-way from Mahannah Avenue and Minnie Street. Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 8 8 View of access point to the subject right-of-way from Minnie Street (south). View of access point to the subject right-of-way from Minnie Street (south). Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 9 9 View of access point to the subject right-of-way from above. Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 10 10 RIGHT-OF-WAY VACATION PLAT (SAC 2024-007) Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 11 11 RIGHT-OF-WAY VACATION PLAT (SAC 2024-007) – MAGNIFIED Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 12 12 RIGHT-OF-WAY VACATION PLAT (SAC 2024-008) Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 13 13 RIGHT-OF-WAY VACATION PLAT (SAC 2024-008) – MAGNIFIED Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 14 14 LEGAL DESCRIPTION (SAC 2024-007) Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 15 15 LEGAL DESCRIPTION (SAC 2024-008) Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 16 16 CASE REVIEW Request The request is to close and vacate the public right-of-way of: SAC 2024-007: 196 feet of Mahannah Ave, between Fred St and Minnie St, SAC 2024-008: 302 feet of Minnie St, north of Mahannah Ave Site Details Address: 400 Mahannah Avenue Area: +/-13,331.09 square feet (SAC 2024-007) and +/- 8,897.90 square feet (SAC 2024-008) Description: SAC 2024-007: The subject property right-of-way is located in Memphis, Tennessee, beginning at a point along the south line of Mahannah Avenue, approximately 148.91 feet east of the intersection with North Second Street, based on Tennessee State Plane Coordinates. The boundaries are defined by precise bearings and distances, referencing adjacent streets and rights-of-way, including Fred Street, Minnie Street, and the property of the Industrial Development Board of Memphis and Shelby County. The total area e ncompasses 13,331.09 square feet, with the City of Memphis retaining a utility easement over the described area. SAC 2024-008: The subject property right- of-way is located in Memphis, Tennessee, commencing at a point along the south line of Mahannah Avenue, approximately 148.91 feet east of the intersection with North Second Street, based on Tennessee State Plane Coordinates. The boundaries follow the south line of Mahannah Avenue, proceed to its eastern terminus, and continue along the west and east lines of Minnie Street. The area is defined by specific bearings and distances, with references to adjacent rights -of-way and property lines, and encompasses 8,897.90 square feet. The City of Memphis retains a utility easement over the described area. Analysis Mahannah Avenue Closure Analysis The proposed closure of a portion of Mahannah Avenue focuses on vacating the public right -of-way between North Second Street and Minnie Street in Memphis, covering approximately 13,331.09 square feet (0.31 acres). This section includes infrastructure such as curb cuts, sidewalks, and overhead utilities, all of which are clearly documented in the survey. The request would officially close the eastern terminus of Mahannah Avenue, transitioning it from pu blic to private use, while preserving utility easements for essential services like water, drainage, and power lines. This closure would allow adjacent properties, including land owned by the Industrial Development Board of Memphis and Shelby County, to consolidate and potentially redevelop the area for commercial or industrial purposes. The detailed survey ensures all property boundaries and infrastructure are accounted for, minimizing potential conflicts with neighboring parcels. The closure aligns with the broader goals of improving land use and supporting redevelopment in this industrial corridor while maintaining access to critical utilities. Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 17 17 Minnie Street Closure Analysis The request to close a portion of Minnie Street involves a 30-foot-wide right-of-way stretching from Mahannah Avenue to Levee Street, totaling 8,897.90 square feet (0.20 acres). This section serves as a secondary street with limited public use, making it a strong candidate for closure. Existing features include curb and gutter systems, overhead utilities, and a guard shack near Mahannah Avenue. The City of Memphis will retain utility easements in the area, ensuring no disruption to public services. By vacating this right-of-way, the closure would allow adjacent property owners, such as KTG USA LP and other industrial stakeholders, to incorporate the land into their operations. This could support expansions, improve logistics, or open new opportunities for development. The detailed survey ensures all property lines and infrastructure considerations are addressed, allowing for a smooth transition from public to private use. The closures of Mahannah Avenue and Minnie Street together would remove approximately 22,229 square feet (0.51 acres) of public right-of-way from the city’s network. The closure of the subject right-of-way will not have any undue or substantial effect upon the existing vehicular and pedestrian traffic flow of the surrounding area. RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends approval with conditions. Conditions 1. Provide easements for existing sanitary sewers, drainage facilities, and other utilities or relocate at developer’s expense. 2. The applicant shall provide for the construction of curb, gutter and sidewalk across the closure as required by the City Engineer. If the City Engineer approves access, the applicant shall construct a City Standard curb cut across the closure, all to the s atisfaction of the City Engineer, and at the applicant's expense. The applicant shall enter into a Standard Improvement Contract or obtain a curb cut permit from the City Engineer to cover the above-required construction work. 3. The applicant shall comply with all conditions of the closure within three years of the conditional approval of the closure by the Council of the City of Memphis. 4. Adequate queuing spaces in accordance with section 4.4.8 of the UDC shall be provided between the street right-of-way line and any proposed gate/guardhouse/card reader. Drawings are subject to approval by City Engineering. 5. Adequate maneuvering room shall be provided between the right -of-way and the gate/guardhouse/card reader for vehicles to exit by forward motion. Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 18 18 DEPARTMENTAL COMMENTS The following comments were provided by agencies to which this application was referred: City Engineer: SAC 2024-007 1. Standard Public Improvement Contract or Right -Of-Way Permit as required in Section 5.5.5 of the Unified Development Code. Sewers: 2. See photo below. Dedicate the entire Mahannah Ave as a sewer easement and provide the easement for the rest of the line that is east of the dead- end street. Street Closures: 3. Provide easements for existing sanitary sewers, drainage facilities and other utilities or relocate at developer's expense. 4. City sanitary sewers/drainage facilities are located within the proposed closure area. 5. The applicant shall provide for the construction of curb, gutter and sidewalk across the closure as required by the City Engineer. If the City Engineer approves access, the applicant shall construct a City Standard curb cut across the closure, all to the s atisfaction of the City Engineer, and at the applicant's expense. The applicant shall enter into a Standard Improvement Contract or obtain a Right of Way permit from the City Engineer to cover the above required construction work. 6. The applicant shall comply with all conditions of the closure within 3 years of the conditional approval of the closure by the City Council. 7. Adequate queuing spaces in accordance with section 4.4.8 of the UDC shall be provided between the street right-of-way line and any proposed gate/guardhouse/card reader. Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 19 19 8. Adequate maneuvering room shall be provided between the right -of-way and the gate/guardhouse/card reader for vehicles to exit by forward motion. 9. Required landscaping shall not be placed on sewer or drainage easements. SAC 2024-008: 1. Standard Public Improvement Contract or Right -Of-Way Permit as required in Section 5.5.5 of the Unified Development Code. Sewers: 2. Dedicate the entire Minnie Street as a sewer easement and provide the easement for the rest of the line that is east of the dead-end street. Street Closures: 3. Provide easements for existing sanitary sewers, drainage facilities and other utilities or relocate at developer's expense. 4. City sanitary sewers/drainage facilities are located within the proposed closure area. 5. The applicant shall provide for the construction of curb, gutter and sidewalk across the closure as required by the City Engineer. If the City Engineer approves access, the applicant shall construct a City Standard curb cut across the closure, all to the s atisfaction of the City Engineer, and at the applicant's expense. The applicant shall enter into a Standard Improvement Contract or obtain a Right of Way permit from the City Engineer to cover the above required construction work. 6. The applicant shall comply with all conditions of the closure within 3 years of the conditional approval of the closure by the City Council. 7. Adequate queuing spaces in accordance with section 4.4.8 of the UDC shall be provided between the street right-of-way line and any proposed gate/guardhouse/card reader. 8. Adequate maneuvering room shall be provided between the right -of-way and the gate/guardhouse/card reader for vehicles to exit by forward motion. 9. Required landscaping shall not be placed on sewer or drainage easements. City Fire Division: • The Fire Department does not object to the closure of portions of Minnie St and Mahannah Ave providing all points of Fire Department access to the facility are maintained in compliance with 2021 IFC Section 503. City Real Estate: No comments received. Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 20 20 County Health Department: No comments received. Shelby County Schools: No comments received. Construction Code Enforcement: No comments received. Memphis Light, Gas and Water: No comments received. Office of Sustainability and Resilience: No comments received. Office of Comprehensive Planning: No comments received. Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 21 21 MAILED PUBLIC NOTICE Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 22 22 SIGN AFFIDAVIT Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 23 23 Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 24 24 Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 25 25 APPLICATION Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 26 26 Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 27 27 Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 28 28 Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 29 29 Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 30 30 Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 31 31 Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 32 32 OWNER AFFIDAVIT (SAC 2024-007) Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 33 33 OWNER AFFIDAVIT (SAC 2024-008) Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 34 34 LETTER OF INTENT Staff Report January 09, 2025 SAC 2024-007 and SAC 2024-008 Page 35 35 LETTERS RECEIVED One letter of opposition w as received at the time of completion of this report and have subsequently been attached. East Service Center: 6465 Mullins Station Rd; Memphis, T ennessee 38134 Downtown Service Center: 125 N. Main Street; Memphis, Tennessee 38103 website: www.develop901.com Memphis and Shelby County Division of Planning and Development Record Summary for Street and Alley Closure (Right of Way V acation) Record Detail Information Record Type: Street and Alley Closure (Right of Way Vacation) Record Status: Pending Opened Date: October 31, 2024 Record Number: SAC 2024-007 Record Name: Closure of a Portion of Mahannah Avenue Expiration Date: Description of Work: The Applicant and its affiliate, Community Benefit Partners, LLC, submit this request to close a portion of Mahannah Avenue at the western boundary of the property at 360 Mahannah (039033 00016). Applicant further requests authority to install a guard's shack/controlled entry closer to Fred Street at the point of closure. Parent Record Number: Address: Owner Information Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone N Data Fields PREAPPLICATION MEETING Name of DPD Planner LaT onya Hull Date of Meeting 10/08/2024 Pre-application Meeting Type Phone GENERAL INFORMATION Name of Street where closure will begin Fred Street Name of Street where closure will end Mark Avenue (Private) What is the reason for the street closure? Increased security for the manufacturing facility at 400 Mahannah Street. What is the total area of the right-of-way being 12676.3 Page 1 of 4 SAC 2024-007 GENERAL INFORMATION closed? What is the overall length of the street closure? 216.5 Name of Street/Alley/ROW Mahannah A venue Is this application in response to a citation from Construction Code Enforcement or Zoning Letter? No If yes, please provide additional information - Is this application a time extension? No RELATED CASE INFORMATION Previous Case Numbers BOA 1959-072-CI SAC 1978-007 BOA 1968-100-CI Applicant is submitting a corresponding application to close a portion of Minnie Street contemporaneously herewith. GIS INFORMATION Case Layer - Central Business Improvement District No Class - Downtown Fire District No Historic District - Land Use - Municipality - Overlay/Special Purpose District - Zoning - State Route - Lot - Subdivision - Planned Development District - Wellhead Protection Overlay District No County Commission District - City Council District - City Council Super District - Data Tables Property Owners Property Address : 360 Mahannah Property Owner Name: Community Benefit Partners, LLC Mailing Address (if different than property address): c/o Glankler Brown, 6000 Poplar Avenue, Suite 400, Memphis, TN 38119 Email Address: scott.young@krugerproducts.ca Note: Community Benefit Partners is an entity affiliated with/subsidiary of the Applicant. Property Address: 364 Mahannah Page 2 of 4 SAC 2024-007 Property Owner Name: Community Benefit Partners, LLC Mailing Address (if different than property address): c/o Glankler Brown, 6000 Poplar Ave. Suite 400, Memphis, TN 38119 Email Address: scott.young@krugerproducts.ca Note: Community Benefit Partners, LLC is an entity affiliated with/subsidiary of the Applicant. Property Address: 0 Mahannah Property Owner Name: K.T.G. (USA) L.P. Mailing Address (if different than property address): 400 Mahannah Street, Memphis, TN 38107 Email Address: scott.young@krugerproducts.ca Property Address: 0 Mahannah Street Property Owner Name: K.T.G. (USA) L.P. Mailing Address (if different than property address): 400 Mahannah Street, Memphis, TN 38107 Email Address: scott.young@krugerproducts.ca Property Address: 0 Mahannah Street Property Owner Name: K.T.G. (USA) L.P. Mailing Address (if different than property address): 400 Mahannah Street, Memphis, TN 38107 Email Address: scott.young@krugerproducts.ca Property Address: 0 Minnie Street Property Owner Name: K.T.G. (USA) L.P. Mailing Address (if different than property address): 400 Mahannah Street, Memphis, TN 38107 Email Address: scott.young@krugerproducts.ca Contact Information Page 3 of 4 SAC 2024-007 SCOTT YOUNG (249)288-2592 ADJACENT PROPER TY OWNER OF RECORD Name Address Phone Contact T ype SCOTT YOUNG - APPLICANT Name Address Phone Contact T ype CHARLES CAMPBELL (901)683-9114 ARCHITECT / ENGINEER / SURVEYOR Name Address Phone Contact T ype MARK JOBE (901)857-8324 REPRESENTA TIVE Name Address Phone Contact T ype Fee Information Date AssessedBalanceStatusFeesQuantityFee ItemInvoice # 12/05/20240.00INVOICED400.001Right of W ay Vacation/Closure Fee 1609966 12/05/20240.00INVOICED10.401Credit Card Use Fee (.026 x fee) 1609966 Total Fee Invoiced: $410.40 Total Balance: $0.00 Payment Information Payment Amount Method of Payment Credit Card$410.40 Page 4 of 4 SAC 2024-007 4872-7890-1246, v. 1 December 5, 2024 Memphis & Shelby County Division of Planning & Development 125 North Main Street, 4th Floor Memphis, TN 38103 Re: K.T.G. (USA) LP – Partial Closure of Mahannah Avenue and Minnie Street Ladies & Gentlemen: This firm represents K.T.G. (USA) LP and its affiliate Community Benefit Partners, LLC with respect to the two (2) Street and Alleyway Closure Applications submitted simultaneously for the partial closures of Mahannah Avenue and Minnie Street (the “Applications”). K.T.G. (USA) LP owns large industrial property at 400 Mahannah and its affiliates operate the plant thereon. Over the years, K.T.G. (USA) LP and its affiliate Community Benefit Partners, LLC, have acquired distressed residential properties along Mahannah Avenue and Minnie Street, all of which are now vacant lots adjacent to the portions of Mahannah Avenue and Minnie Street which are subject to these Applications. This request is being made to better control traffic adjacent to the manufacturing facility and to increase security of its parking facilities serving the same. Closing these portions of these streets will not have any negative impact on the citizens of Memphis or specifically the nearby community, but rather will help the K.T.G. (USA) LP deter criminal activity and better secure its manufacturing facility (specifically the parking areas) . As part of these requests, the K.T.G. (USA) LP is requesting approval to move its guard’s shack further west on Mahannah and to install movable concrete barriers at the north end of the closure on Minnie Street to better control access to the manufacturing facility. Thank you for your consideration of the attached Applications. We appreciate the support and if there are any concerns, look forward to finding a mutually agreeable solution to resolve the same. With best regards, GLANKLER BROWN, PLLC Mark T. Jobe, Jr. Mark T. Jobe, Jr. 901.576.1853 mjobe@glankler.com 4863-7830-0158, v. 1 Closure Description - Mahannah Avenue Part of Mahannah Avenue (68' Wide) between North Second Street and Minnie Street as dedicated in Menzer's North Second Street Subdivision as recorded in Plat Book 14, Page 32 and Road Dedication for Mahannah Street as recorded in Plat Book 81, Page 51, and being further described hereon: Beginning at a point in the south line of Mahannah Avenue (68 feet wide as widened) a distance of 148.91 feet east of the east line of North Second Street (R.O. W. Varies), having Tennessee State Plane Coordinates of North 334471.1128, East 760199.0838 and being in the east line of a 12 foot wide alley as dedicated at Plat Book 14, Page 32 (R.O.S.C.); thence North 01 degrees 53 minutes 46 seconds East a distance of 68.05 feet to the intersection of the north line of Mahannah Avenue with the east line of Fred Street (30' R.O.W.); thence South 85 degrees 53 minutes 30 seconds East along the north line of Mahannah Avenue a distance of 190.00 feet to the intersection of the north line of Mahannah Avenue with the west line of Minnie Street (30' R.O.W.); thence South 15 degrees 12 minutes 12 seconds East along the projection of said west line of Minnie Street a distance of 32. 79 feet to a point in the easterly line of the Industrial Development Board of Memphis and Shelby County property (lnst.11079801); thence South 52 degrees 26 minutes 59 seconds West along said east line a distance of 2.97 feet to a point in the eastern terminus of Mahannah Avenue; thence South 04 degrees 06 minutes 30 seconds West along said western terminus a distance of 35.08 feet to a point; thence North 85 degrees 53 minutes 30 seconds West along the south line of Mahannah Avenue a distance of 196.00 feet to the point of beginning and containing 13,331.09 square feet. The City of Memphis hereby retains an easement for utilities over the above-described area. 50,00’ 585°59’30"F Community Benifit Partners Inst. 13104481 S85°53’30"E ee E> S85°53'30"F KTG Inst. 02142899 190. Ov Te erhead_utilities USA LP 00’ 1°53°46"E 8.05’ Concrete Sidewalk Curb cut curb & quits hereon: Beginning at a point in the south line of Mahannah Avenue (68 feet wide as widened) a distance of 148.91 feet east of the east line of North Second Street (R.O.W. Varies), having Tennessee State Plane Coordinates of North 354471.1128, East 760199.0838 and being in the east line of a 12 foot wide alley as dedicated at Plat Book 14, Pgae 32 (R.O.S.C.); thence North 01 degrees 53 minutes 46 seconds East a distance of 68.05 feet to the intersection of the north line of Mahannah Avenue with the east line of Fred Street (30’ R.O.W.); thence South 85 degrees 53 minutes 30 seconds East along the north line of Mahannah Avenue a distance of 190.00 feet to the intersection of the north line of Mahannah Avenue with the west line of Minnie Street (30’ R.O.W.); thence South 15 degrees 12 minutes 12 seconds East along the projection of said west line of Minnie Street a distance of 352.79 feet to a point in the easterly line of the Industrial Development Board of Memphis and Shelby County property (Inst.11079801); thence South 52 degrees 26 minutes 59 seconds West along said east line a distance of 2.97 feet to a point in the eastern terminus of Mahannah Avenue; thence South 04 degrees 06 minutes 30 seconds West along said western terminus a distance of 55.08 feet to a point; thence North 85 degrees 53 minutes 30 seconds West along the south line of Mahannah Avenue a distance of 196.00 feet to the point of beginning and containing 143,431.09 square feet. The City of Memphis \__ hereby retains an easement for utilities over the above described area. yy, Vicinity Map TNSPC/GRID wre Gem NTS _ Symbol Legend © S.M.H. = Sewer Manhole ® D.M.H. = Drain Manhole bg GV = Gas Valve ph WY = Water Valve / | hereby certify that this is a Category | Survey and that the ratio of precision of the un—adjusted survey is 1: 10,000 or greater as shown heregyn and that the survey was done in compliance with curremt\Tennesgee Minimum Standards of Practice. Lawrence E. Astin TN RLS 2113 Existing Oo L.P= Li i .P= Light Pole (Light Standard) Mahannah Avenue Uard Sheck >P.P. = Power Pole }_ » R, [JB] = lelepnone Junction Box MOOS - (68" R.O.w.) | | TJB = Teleph Junction B 88 VT QO. SQFH = Fire Hydrant oe | & m@D.|. = Drain Inlet 148.9 18" ss & KE ig C.1. = Curb Inlet ‘31 to the east jj FY SH/W = Headwall line . Devel of N. Second st. (R.O.W. Varies) curb cut ~ he City of Memphis and Shon’ cor @ WM = Water Meter TY curb & gutter 0O s Inst. 1107980] ¥ vounty © E/M = Electric Meter rs concrete Sidewalk oO oom = Gas Meter / POB 2 N 3344711128 196.00’ M5 SC E 760199.0838 N85°53’ 0” Ww NN AREA a + 15,320.32 Sq Ft a 0.31 acres m : Industri o the City of M Development Board of ~ E€mphis and Shelby C a Inst, 1107980] y County < N GRAPHIC SCALE / Legend > ° i ? 7 6° POB = Point of Beginning IPS = Iron Pin Set (IN FEET ) A portion (or all) of the data used to perform this survey O.E.= Overhead Wires 1 inch = 20 ft. were obtained using GPS/GNSS technology and the following N = North information applies to these measurements: a. Type of S = South a Receiver: Topcon Hyper SR (model#1002399—01), Multi Freq. b. E = East (— Closure Description > Coordinate System: Tennessee State Plane c. Zone: TN 4100 W = West ; Part of Mahannah Avenue (68’ Wide) between North Second Street and d. Datum: NAD 83 ¢. Geoid Model: Geoid 2012A f. Method: CPS = Cotton Picker Spindle Minnie Street as dedicated in Menzer’s North Second Street Subdivision as RIK, g. Precision: Relative Positional Accuracy of 10mm+ippm R.O.W. = Right of Way St t Cl Plat . . . : : - _ t ree osure a recorded in Plat Book 14, Page 32 and Road Dedication for Mahannah horizontal and 15mm-+1ppm vertical. No grid factor was ss = sanitary Sewer pipe Street as recorded in Plat Book 81, Page 51, and being further described applied. rcp = reinforced concrete pipe Mahannoh Avenue Menzer’s North Second Street Subdivision as recorded in Plat Book 14, Page 32 and Road Dedication for Mahannah Street as recorded in Plat Book 81, Page 51 Memphis, Shelby County, TN Area: 13,331.09 SqFt DATE: 10/31/2024 SCALE 1° = 20’ Prepared for: Mark Jobe Campbell Surveying Company t 1023 South Yates Rood Suite 101 Memphis, TN 38119 (901) 683-9114 East Service Center: 6465 Mullins Station Rd; Memphis, T ennessee 38134 Downtown Service Center: 125 N. Main Street; Memphis, Tennessee 38103 website: www.develop901.com Memphis and Shelby County Division of Planning and Development Record Summary for Street and Alley Closure (Right of Way V acation) Record Detail Information Record Type: Street and Alley Closure (Right of Way Vacation) Record Status: Pending Opened Date: November 19, 2024 Record Number: SAC 2024-008 Record Name: Closure of a Portion of Minnie Street Expiration Date: Description of Work: The Applicant submits this request o close a portion of Minnie Street at the northern boundary line of 0 Minnie Street (Tax Parcel 039033 00005) as depicted on the survey attached hereto. The Applicant further requests approval to install a concrete barrier at this point to restrict traffic heading south on Minnie Avenue. Parent Record Number: Address: Owner Information Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone N Data Fields PREAPPLICATION MEETING Name of DPD Planner LaT onya Hull Date of Meeting 10/08/2024 Pre-application Meeting Type Phone GENERAL INFORMATION Name of Street where closure will begin Luke Street (South of) Name of Street where closure will end Mahannah Avenue What is the reason for the street closure? Increased security for the manufacturing facility at 400 Mahannah Street, in particular its parking area. What is the total area of the right-of-way being 9419.29 Page 1 of 4 SAC 2024-008 GENERAL INFORMATION closed? What is the overall length of the street closure? 290.45 Name of Street/Alley/ROW Minnie Street Is this application in response to a citation from Construction Code Enforcement or Zoning Letter? No If yes, please provide additional information - Is this application a time extension? No RELATED CASE INFORMA TION Previous Case Numbers BOA 1959-072-CI SAC 1978-007 BOA 1968-100-CI Applicant is submitting a corresponding application related to the closure of a portion of Mahannah contemporaneously herewith. GIS INFORMATION Case Layer - Central Business Improvement District No Class - Downtown Fire District No Historic District - Land Use - Municipality - Overlay/Special Purpose District - Zoning - State Route - Lot - Subdivision - Planned Development District - Wellhead Protection Overlay District No County Commission District - City Council District - City Council Super District - Data Tables Property Owners Property Address : 0 Minnie Street Property Owner Name: K.T.G. (USA) LP Mailing Address (if different than property address): 400 Mahannah Street, Memphis, TN 38107 Email Address: scott.young@krugerproducts.ca Page 2 of 4 SAC 2024-008 Note: Tax Parcels: 039033 00005 039033 00006 039033 00007 039033 00008 039033 00009 039033 00010 039033 0001 1 Contact Information SCOTT YOUNG (249)288-2592 ADJACENT PROPER TY OWNER OF RECORD Name Address Phone Contact Type SCOTT YOUNG - APPLICANT Name Address Phone Contact Type CHARLES T CAMPBELL (901)683-9114 ARCHITECT / ENGINEER / SURVEYOR Name Address Phone Contact Type MARK JOBE (901)576-1853 REPRESENTA TIVE Name Address Phone Contact Type Fee Information Date AssessedBalanceStatusFeesQuantityFee ItemInvoice # 12/05/20240.00INVOICED400.001Right of W ay Vacation/Closure Fee 1609970 12/05/20240.00INVOICED10.401Credit Card Use Fee (.026 x fee) 1609970 Total Fee Invoiced: $410.40 Total Balance: $0.00 Payment Information Payment Amount Method of Payment Credit Card$410.40 Page 3 of 4 SAC 2024-008 4872-7890-1246, v. 1 December 5, 2024 Memphis & Shelby County Division of Planning & Development 125 North Main Street, 4th Floor Memphis, TN 38103 Re: K.T.G. (USA) LP – Partial Closure of Mahannah Avenue and Minnie Street Ladies & Gentlemen: This firm represents K.T.G. (USA) LP and its affiliate Community Benefit Partners, LLC with respect to the two (2) Street and Alleyway Closure Applications submitted simultaneously for the partial closures of Mahannah Avenue and Minnie Street (the “Applications”). K.T.G. (USA) LP owns large industrial property at 400 Mahannah and its affiliates operate the plant thereon. Over the years, K.T.G. (USA) LP and its affiliate Community Benefit Partners, LLC, have acquired distressed residential properties along Mahannah Avenue and Minnie Street, all of which are now vacant lots adjacent to the portions of Mahannah Avenue and Minnie Street which are subject to these Applications. This request is being made to better control traffic adjacent to the manufacturing facility and to increase security of its parking facilities serving the same. Closing these portions of these streets will not have any negative impact on the citizens of Memphis or specifically the nearby community, but rather will help the K.T.G. (USA) LP deter criminal activity and better secure its manufacturing facility (specifically the parking areas) . As part of these requests, the K.T.G. (USA) LP is requesting approval to move its guard’s shack further west on Mahannah and to install movable concrete barriers at the north end of the closure on Minnie Street to better control access to the manufacturing facility. Thank you for your consideration of the attached Applications. We appreciate the support and if there are any concerns, look forward to finding a mutually agreeable solution to resolve the same. With best regards, GLANKLER BROWN, PLLC Mark T. Jobe, Jr. Mark T. Jobe, Jr. 901.576.1853 mjobe@glankler.com 4865-4581-0430, v. 1 Closure Description – Minnie Street Real property situated in the City of Memphis, County of Shelby, to wit: Part of Minnie Street (30' Wide) between Luke Street and Mahannah Avenue and being further described hereon: Commencing at a point in the south line of Mahannah Avenue (68 feet wide as widened) a distance of 148.91 feet east of the east line of North Second Street (R.O.W. Varies), having Tennessee State Plane Coordinates of North 334471.1128, East 760199.0838 and being in the east line of a 12 foot wide alley as dedicated at Plat Book 14, Page 32 (R.O.S.C.); thence South 85 degrees 53 minutes 30 seconds East along the south line of Mahannah Avenue a distance of 196.00 feet to the eastern terminus of Mahannah Avenue; thence North 04 degrees 06 minutes 30 seconds East along said line a distance of 35.08 feet; thence North 52 degrees 26 minutes 59 seconds East a distance of 2.97 feet to a point in the southward projection of the west line of Minnie Street and being the True Point of Beginning said point having Tennessee State Plane Coordinates of North 334493.8699, East 760399.4467; thence North 15 degrees 12 minutes 12 seconds West along the west line of Minnie Street a distance of 302.78 feet; thence North 74 degrees 47 minutes 48 seconds East a distance of 30.00 feet to a point in the east line of Minnie Street; thence South 15 degrees 12 minutes 12 seconds East a distance of 290.45 feet to a point in the southern terminus of Minnie Street; thence South 52 degrees 26 minutes 59 seconds West a distance of 32.43 feet to the point of beginning and containing 8,897.90 square feet. The City of Memphis hereby retains an easement for utilities over the above-described area. 12’ Alley P.B.14, P32 Community Benifit Partners Inst. 13104481 POC N 334471.1128 E 760199.0838 S85°53'30"E Alan & Brittney Higdon | Inst, 12044198 yse. \ 95.15’ 50.00’ S85°53'30"E KTG USA LP Inst. 02142892 Mahannah Avenue ho (68’ R.O.w.) S85°53’30"E Industrial the City of M N 334493.8699 E 760399.4467 196.00’ ~~ (~ » Symbol Legend Y = - ] Sewer Manhole .H. = Drain Manhole = Gas Valve = Water Valve > Light Pole (Light Standard) > = Power Pole so Telephone Junction Box > = Fire Hydrant RY = Drain Inlet im C.1. = Curb Inlet FSH/W = Headwall @ W/M = Water Meter ©E/M = Electric Meter © G/M = Gas Meter Ne yy <= 6 #XX20@ =oO0 i < ~ 5 UNA UI _ Tc: ll Vicinity Map NTS /— Legend > TNSPC /GRID POB = Point of Beginning IPF = Iron Pin Found IPS = lron Pin Set .= Overhead Wires O m = North South East =mnz ll S WY) Il .W. = Right of Way = Drain Pipe Mag nail set =z0WOa Z GPL II areqd. NS West Part of Minnie Street (30’ Wide) between Luke Street and Mahannah = Cotton Picker Spindle Avenue and being further described hereon: Commencing at a point in the south line of Mahannah Avenue (68 feet wide as widened) a distance of 148.91 feet east of the east line of North Ke wy Second Street (R.O.W. Varies), having Tennessee State Plane Coordinates of North 334471.1128, East 760199.0838 and being in the east line of a 12 foot wide alley as dedicated at Plat Book 14, Pgae 32 (R.O.S.C.); thence South 85 degrees 53 minutes 30 seconds East along the south line of Mahannah Avenue a distance of 196.00 feet to the eastern terminus of Mahannah Avenue; thence North 04 degrees 06 minutes 30 seconds East along said line a distance of 35.08 feet; thence North 52 degrees 26 a AREA minutes 59 seconds East a distance of 2.97 feet to a point in the southward projection of the west line of Minnie Street and being the True Point of Beginning said point having Tennessee State Plane Coordinates of 6,897.90 Sq Ft North 334493.8699, 0.20 acres minutes 12 seconds West along the west line of Minnie Street a distance of 502.78 feet; thence North 74 degrees 47 minutes 48 seconds East a distance of 30.00 feet to a point in the east line of Minnie Street; thence South 15 degrees 12 minutes 12 seconds East a distance of 290.45 feet to a point in the southern terminus of Minnie Street; thence South 52 degrees 26 minutes 59 seconds West a distance of 32.43 feet to the point of beginning and containing 8,897.90 square feet. The City of Memphis hereby retains an easement for utilities over the above described Closure Description > East 760399.4467; thence North 15 degrees 12 yy A portion (or all) of the data used to perform this survey were obtained using GPS/GNSS technology and the following information applies to these measurements: a. Type of Receiver: Topcon Hyper SR (model#1002399-—01), Multi Freq. b. | hereby certify that this is a Category | Survey and that the oW ratio of precision of the un—adjusted survey is 1: 10,000 or greater as shown hereon and that the survey was done in compliance with current Tennessee Minimum Standards of Practice. | Coordinate System: Tennessee State Plane c. Zone: TN 4100 d. Datum: NAD 83 e. Geoid Model: Geoid 2012A f. Method: RTK, g. Precision: Relative Positional Accuracy of 10mm-+1ppm horizontal and 15mm+1ppm vertical. No grid factor was applied. Street Closure Plat Minnie Street Between Luke Street and Mahannah Avenue Greenville Subdivision of Lot 21 Weakley Tract (unrecorded) Memphis, Shelby County, TN Area: 13,331.09 SqFt DATE: 10/31/2024 SCALE 1% = 20’ Prepared for: Mark Joke Lawrence E. Astin TIMI TN BL s 2113 Campbell Surveying Company t 1023 South Yates Road Suite 101 Memphis, TN 38119 (901) 683-9114 Memphis City Council Summary Sheet SUP 2024-039 RESOLUTION PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 9.6 OF THE MEMPHIS AND SHELBY COUNTY UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT CODE APPROVING A SPECIAL USE PERMIT AT THE SUBJECT PROPERTY LOCATED AT THE SOUTHEAST CORN ER OF S MENDENHALL ROAD AND FOX PLAZA DRIVE, KNOWN AS CASE NUMBER SUP 2024-039 • This item is a r esolution with conditions for a special use permit to allow a convenience store with gasoline sales. • This item was heard at the December 2024 meeting of the Land Use Control Board. Between this meeting and the present (March 2025), the applicant has worked with DPD staff to improve the site design. The improved site design is included in the attached resolution. • Nevertheless, DPD staff recommends rejection for three major reasons: o Inconsistency with the intent of the UDC ’s design standards for gas stations. o Ecological concerns related to the site ’s l ocation in an aquifer recharge zone. o Inconsistency with the Memphis 3.0 Comprehensive Plan • The Land Use Control Board also voted to recommend rejection at its December 2024 meeting. • The item may require future public improvement contracts. 1 LAND USE CONTROL BOARD RECOMMENDATION At its regular meeting on Thursday, December 12, 2024, the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board held a public hearing on the following application: CASE NUMBER: SUP 2024-039 LOCATION: 2730 S Mendenhall Rd. COUNCIL DISTRICT(S): District 4 and Super District 8 OWNER/APPLICANT: Beruk Construction REPRESENTATIVE: N/A REQUEST: Special Use Permit to allow a convenience store with gasoline sales. EXISTING ZONING: Commercial Mixed Use – 1 (CMU-1) AREA: +/-1.005 acres The following spoke in support of the application: Aaron Robinson The following spoke in opposition the application: Asad Sojwani The Land Use Control Board reviewed the application and the staff report. A motion was made and seconded to recommend approval with conditions. The motion failed by a vote of 0-9 on the regular agenda. Respectfully, Nicholas Wardroup Planner II Land Use and Development Services Division of Planning and Development Cc: Committee Members File 2 SUP 2024-039 CONDITIONS While the Board recommends rejection, it recommends the following conditions if approved: 1. The applicant shall submit a revised site plan and elevations to the Zoning Administrator for administrative review and approval prior to the granting of any building permits. The granting of this Special Use Permit shall not be construed to waive any requirements of the UDC related to landscaping, bicycle or vehicular parking, or any other standard. 2. At least 3 electric vehicle (EV) charging stations shall be provided. The applicant may eliminate vehicular parking spaces as necessary to meet this requirement. 3. The principal structure shall feature at least 30% transparency on its western façade. The Zoning Administrator may, at their discretion, reduce this requirement after the submission of elevations. No window graphics or window signs shall be permitted on the western façade. 3 SITE PLAN RESOLUTION PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 9.6 OF THE MEMPHIS AND SHELBY COUNTY UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT CODE APPROVING A SPECIAL USE PERMIT AT THE SUBJECT PROPERTY LOCATED AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF S MENDENHALL ROAD AND FOX PLAZA DRIVE, KNOWN AS CASE NUMBER SUP 2024-039 WHEREAS, Chapter 9.6 of the Memphis and Shelby County Unified Development Code, being a section of the Joint Ordinance Resolution No. 5367, dated August 10, 2010, authorizes the Council of the City of Memphis to grant a special use permit for certain stated purposes in the various zoning districts; and WHEREAS, Beruk Construction filed a n application with the Memphis and Shelby County Division of Planning and Development to allow a convenience store with gasoline sales; and WHEREAS, the Division of Planning and Development has received and reviewed the application in accordance with procedures, objectives, and standards for special use permits as set forth in Chapter 9.6 with regard to the proposed development's impacts upon surrounding properties, availability of public facilities, both external and internal circulation, land use compatibility, and that the design and amenities are consistent with the public interest; and has submitted its findings and recommendation concerning the above considerations to the Land Use Control Board; and WHEREAS, a public hearing in relation thereto was held before the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board on December 12, 2024, and said Board has submitted its findings and recommendation concerning the above considerations to the Council of the City of Memphis; and WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Memphis has reviewed the aforementioned application pursuant to Tennessee Code Annotated Section 13-4-202(B)(2)(B)(iii) and has determined that said development is consistent with the Memphis 3.0 General Plan; and WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Memphis has reviewed the recommendation of the Land Use Control Board and the report and recommendation of the Division of Planning and Development and has determined that said development meets the objectives, standards and criteria for a special use permit, and said development is consistent with the public interests. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF MEMPHIS, that, pursuant to Chapter 9.6 of the Memphis and Shelby County Unified Development Code, a special use permit is hereby granted for the request use in accordance with the attached conditions. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED , that this permit merely authorizes the filing of applications to acquire a Certificate of Use and Occupancy, or a Building Permit, and other required permits and approvals, provided that no such Certificate of Use and Occupancy shall be granted until all conditions imposed by the Council of the City of Memphis have been met. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED , that this Resolution take effect from and after the date it shall have been passed by this Council of the City of Memphis, and become effective as otherwise provided by law, and thereafter shall be treated as in full force and effect by virtue of passage thereof by the Council of the City of Memphis, the public welfare requiring same. CONDITIONS 1. The applicant shall submit a revised site plan and elevations to the Zoning Administrator for administrative review and approval prior to the granting of any building permits. The granting of this Special Use Permit shall not be construed to waive any requirements of the UDC related to landscaping, bicycle or vehicular parking, or any other standard. 2. At least 3 electric vehicle (EV) charging stations shall be provided. The applicant may eliminate vehicular parking spaces as necessary to meet this requirement. 3. The principal structure shall feature at least 30% transparency on its western façade. The Zoning Administrator may, at their discretion, reduce this requirement after the submission of elevations. No window graphics or window signs shall be permitted on the western façade. SITE PLAN ATTEST: CC: Division of Planning and Development – Land Use and Development Services – Office of Construction Enforcement Staff Writer: LaTonya Hull and Nicholas Wardroup E-mail: LaTonya.hull@memphistn.gov AGENDA ITEM: 14 L.U.C.B. MEETING: December 12, 2024 , CASE NUMBER: SUP 2024-0039 LOCATION: 2730 S. Mendenhall Road COUNCIL DISTRICT: District 4 and Super District 8 OWNER/APPLICANT: Beruk Construction (Fasil Kabede) REQUEST: Special use permit to allow a convenience store with gas pumps EXISTING ZONING: Commercial Mixed Use 1 – (CMU-1) CONCLUSIONS 1. The applicant proposes to construct a new convenience store and associated 4-pump canopy on a property which served as a parking lot for a Hertz car rental until 2022. 2. Staff recommends rejection of the application for three major reasons: a. Inconsistency with the UDC’s design standards for gas stations, which are intended to encourage more urban and pedestrian -oriented site desi gns, particularly important on sites (such as the subject property) in close proximity to multifamily housing. b. Ecological concerns related to the site’s location in an aquifer rechar ge zone and subsequent inconsistency with the Mid-South Region Resilience Master plan. c. Inconsistency with the Memphis 3.0 Comprehensive Plan. 3. The granting of this special use permit will cause substantial detriment to the public good, it will substantially impair the intent and purpose of an adopted plan or the Unified Development Code (UDC), it will be injurious to the neighborhood and the general welfare, and it will not be in harmony with the purpose and intent of the UDC. CONSISTENCY WITH MEMPHIS 3.0 This proposal is inconsistent with the Memphis 3.0 General Plan per the land use decision criteria. See further analysis on pages 20-23 of this report. RECOMMENDATION: Rejection Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 2 2 LOCATION MAP Subject property located within the pink circle SUBJECT PROPERTY Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 3 3 PUBLIC NOTICE VICINITY MAP Subject property highlighted in yellow PUBLIC NOTICE DETAILS In accordance with Sub-S ection 9.3.4A of the Unified Development Code, a notice of public hearing is required to be mailed and signage posted. A total of 27 notices were mailed on November 19, 2024, see page 24 of this report for a copy of said notice. Additionally, one sign was posted at the subject property, see page 25 of this re port for a copy of the sign affidavit. NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING The meeting was he ld at 5:00 P M on Tues day, November 26, 2024 , at 2734 S Mendenhall Rd, Memphis, T N 38115. Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 4 4 AERIAL Subjec t property outlined in yellow, imagery via Google, 2024 Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 5 5 ZONING MAP Subjec t property indicated by pink star Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 6 6 LAND USE MAP Subject property indicated by a pink star Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 7 7 SITE PHOTOS View of subject property from Fox Plaza looking west View of subject property from S Mendenhall and looking west Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 8 8 View o f subject property from S Mendenhall looking North View o f subject property from S Mendenhall looking Southeast Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 9 9 SITE PLAN Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 10 10 SITE PLAN (MAGNIFIED) Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 11 11 FOX GATE PLAZA SUBDIVISION (2024, Plat Book 306, Pg. 34) Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 12 12 CASE REVIEW Request The request is a special use permit to allow a convenience store with gas sales Approval Criteria Staff disagrees the approval criteria in regard special use permits as set out in Section 9. 6.9 of the Unified Development Code are met. 9.6.9 Approval Criteria No special use permit or planned development shall be approved unless the following findings are made concerning the application: 9.6.9A The project will not have a substantial or undue adverse effect upon adjacent property, the character of the neighborhood, traffic conditions, parking, utility facilities and other matters affecting the public health, safety, and general welfare. 9.6.9B The project will be constructed, arranged and operated so as to be compatible with the immediate vicinity and not interfere with the development and use of adjacent property in accordance with the applicable district regulations. 9.6.9C The project will be served adequately by essential public facilities and services such as streets, parking, drainage, refuse disposal, fire protection and emergency services, water and sewers; or that the applicant will provide adequately for such services. 9.6.9D The project will not result in the destruction, loss or damage of any feature determined by the governing bodies to be of significant natural, scenic or historic importance. 9.6.9E The project complies with all additional standards imposed on it by any particular provisions authorizing such use. 9.6.9F The request will not adversely affect any plans to be considered (see Chapter 1.9), or violate the character of existing standards for development of the adjacent properties. 9.6.9G The governing bodies may impose conditions to minimize adverse effects on the neighborhood or on public facilities, and to ensure compatibility of the proposed development with surrounding properties, uses, and the purpose and intent of this development code. 9.6.9H Any decision to deny a special use permit request to place, construct, or modify personal wireless service facilities shall be in writing and supported by substantial evidence contained in a written record, per the Telecommunications Act of 1996, 47 USC 332(c)(7)(B)(iii). The review body may not take into account any environmental or health concerns. Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 13 13 Site Details Address: 2730 S. Mendenhall Parcel ID: 074089 E00006 Area: +/1.005 acres Description: The subject property is known as Lot 4A of the 2024 Fox Gate Plaza subdivision and hosts a vacant parking lot. It is a distinct lot from that of the commercial structure to the east (Lot 4B). The site occupies the entire block width between Fox Plaza Dr. and Meadowlake Dr. at their intersection with S Mendenhall Rd. It is served by one curb cut on S Mendenhall at the southern extreme of the property. The recorded plat also grants shared use of the curb cut on lot 4B along Fox Plaza Dr. Site Zoning History A 1993 special use permit (SUP 1993-220) approved vehicle sales at this site, which has hosted a Hertz car rental facility as recently as 2022 (the UDC cons iders vehicle sales and rental to be the same use). Documents from that SUP application indicate that the site had been used as a restaurant prior to the vehicle sales approval. In 2023, the site was subdivided , with the principal structure and the parking lot be ing separated into distinct lots (see plat page 11). The subject property is lot 4A, the former Hertz parking lot. Site Plan Review The applicant propose s to construct a +/- 4 ,988 sq. ft. convenience store along the southern edge of the property, as well as a canopy with fo ur gasoline pumps to the north. The proposed site design does not meet the standards for an SUP waiver under UDC Sub-Item 2.6.3J(2)(d)(ii), necessitating the subject SUP application. Analysis Staff recommends rejection of this application for three major reasons : 1) its inconsistency with the intent of the UDC’s design standards for gas stations, 2) ecologi cal concerns re lated to the site ’s location in an aquifer recharge zone, and 3) its inconsistency with the Memphis 3.0 comprehensive plan. Sub-section 2. 6.3J of the UDC establishes design standards for gas stations intended to encourage more pedestrian-friendly urban design . In short, these standards exempt proposed gas stations from the SUP requirement if they place the pumps to the rear or side of the building and provide an architecturally compatible or physically integrated canopy. Given the site’s pro ximity to a multifamily neighborhood, staff finds it appropriate to strictly enforce these standards in this case. We also note the proposal’s inconsistency with the Mid-South Regional Resilience Master Plan and the Memphis 3.0 Comprehensive Plan. More information regarding these determinations can be found on pages 19-20 and 21-23, respectively. The granting of this special use permit will cause substantial detriment to the public good, it will substantially impair the intent and purpose of an adopted plan or the Unified Development Code (UDC), it will be injurious to the neighborhood and the general welfare, and it will not be in harmony with the purpose and intent of the UDC. Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 14 14 RECOMMENDATI ON Staff r ecommends rejection; however, if approved, staff recommends the following conditions: Conditions 1. The applicant shall submit a revised site plan and elevations to the Zoning Administrator for administrative review and approval prior to the granting of any building permits . The granting of this Special Use Permit shall not be construed to waive any requirements of the UDC related to landscaping, bicycl e or vehicular parking, or any other standard. 2. At least 3 elec tric vehicle (EV) chargin g stations shall be prov ided. The a pplicant may eliminate vehicular parking spaces as necessary to meet this requirement. 3. The principal structure shall feature at least 30% transparency on its western façade. The Zoning Administrator may, at their discretion, reduce this requirement after the sub mission o f elevations. No window graphics or window signs shall be permitted on the western façade. Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 15 15 DEPARTMENTAL COMMENTS The following comments were provided by agencies to which this application was referred: City Engineering: See Next Page City Fire: See page 18. City Real Estate: No comments received. County Health Department: No comments received. Shelby County Schools: No comments received. Construction Code Enforcement: No comments received. Memphis Light, Gas and Water: No comments received. Office of Sustainability and Resilience: See pages 19-20. Office of Comprehensive Planning: See pages 21-23 Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 16 16 CITY ENGINEERING COMMENTS 1. Sta ndard Public Improvement Contract or Right-Of-Way Permit as required in Section 5.5.5 of the Unified Development Code. Sewers: 2. City sanitary sewers are available to serve this development. 3. A sanitary sewer service connection plan is required to be submitted (via 901 portal) to the City Land Development Office for review and approval. 4. All required design plans and potential traffic control plan must be prepared in accordance with the City’s Standard Requirements and must be stamped by a Professional Engineer registered in the State of Tennessee. 5. A Sewer Development fee may be required per the City of Memphis Sewer Use Ordinance. Roads: 6. The Developer shall be responsible for the repair and/or replacement of all existing curb and gutter along the frontage of this site as necessary. 7. All existing sidewalks and curb openings along the frontage of this site shall be inspected for ADA compliance. The developer shall be responsible for any reconstruction or repair necessary to meet City standards. Traffic Control Provisions: 8. The developer shall provide a traffic control plan to the city engineer that shows the phasing for each street frontage during demolition and construction of curb gutter and sidewalk. Upon completion of sidewalk and curb and gutter improvements, a minimum 5 foot wide pedestrian pathway shall be provided throughout the remainder of the project. In the event that the existing right of way width does not allow for a 5 foot clear pedestrian path, an exception may be considered. 9. Any closure of the right of way shall be time limited to the active demolition and construction of sidewalks and curb and gutter. Continuous unwarranted closure of the right of way shall not be allowed for the duration of the project. The developer shall provide on the traffic control plan, the time needed per phase to complete that portion of the work. Time limits will begin on the day of closure and will be monitored by the Engineering construction inspectors on the job. 10. The developer’s engineer shall submit a Trip Generation Report that documents the proposed land use, scope and anticipated traffic demand associated with the proposed development. A detailed Traffic Impact Study will be required when the accepted Trip Generation Report indicates that the number for projected trips meets or exceeds the criteria listed in Section 210-Traffic Impact Policy for Land Development of the City of Memphis Division of Engineering Design and Policy Review Manual. Any required Traffic Impact Study will need to be formally approved by the City of Memphis, Traffic Engineering Department. Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 17 17 Curb Cuts/Access: 11. The City Engineer shall approve the design, number, and location of curb cuts. 12. Any existing nonconforming curb cuts shall be modified to meet current City Standards or closed with curb, gutter, and sidewalk. 13. Will require engineering ASPR. Drainage: 14. A grading and drainage plan for the site shall be submitted to the City Engineer for review and approval prior to recording of the final plat. 15. Drainage improvements, including possible on-site detention, shall be provided under a Standard Subdivision contract in accordance with Unified Development Code and the City of Memphis/Shelby County Storm Water Management Manual. 16. Drainage data for assessment of on-site detention requirements shall be submitted to the City Engineer. 17. The following note shall be placed on the final plat of any development requiring on-site storm water detention facilities: The areas denoted by "Reserved for Storm Water Detention" shall not be used as a building site or filled without first obtaining written permission from the City and/or County Engineer. The storm water detention systems located in these areas, except for those parts located in a public drainage easement, shall be owned and maintained by the property owner and/or property owners' association. Such maintenance shall be performed so as to ensure that the system operates in accordance with the approved plan on file in the City and/or County Engineer's Office. Such maintenance shall include, but not be limited to removal of sedimentation, fallen objects, debris and trash, mowing, outlet cleaning, and repair of drainage structures. 18. The developer should be aware of his obligation under 40 CFR 122.26(b)(14) and TCA 69-3-101 et. seq. to submit a Notice of Intent (NOI) to the Tennessee Division of Water Pollution Control to address the discharge of storm water associated with the clearing and grading activity on this site. Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 18 18 DIVISION OF FIRE SERVICES  FIRE PREVENTION BUREAU 2668 Avery Avenue ⋅ Memphis ⋅ Tennessee ⋅ 38112 (901) 636-5401 Fax (901) 320-5425 Case Number: SUP 2024-039 Date Reviewed: 12/6/24 Reviewed by: J. Stinson Address or Site Reference: 2730 S Mendenhall • All design and construction shall comply with the 2021 edition of the International Fire Code ( as locally amended) and referenced standards. • Fire apparatus access shall comply with section 503. • Where security gates are installed that affect required fire apparatus access roads, they shall comply with section 503.6 (as amended). • Fire protection water supplies (including fire hydrants) shall comply with section 507. • Where fire apparatus access roads or a water supply for fire protection are required to be installed, such protection shall be installed and made serviceable prior to and during the time of construction except when approved alternate methods of protection are provided. • IFC 510 In-building two-way emergency responder communication coverage shall be provided in all new and existing buildings. Buildings and structures that cannot support the required level of coverage shall be equipped with systems and components to enhance signals and achieve the required level of communication coverage. • A detailed plans review will be conducted by the Memphis Fire Prevention Bureau upon receipt of complete construction documents. Plans shall be submitted to the Shelby County Office of Code Enforcement. Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 19 19 OFFICE OF SUSTAINABILITY AND RESILLIE NCE COMMENTS Logan Landry Planner I Office of Sustainability and Resilience 125 N. Main St., Memphis, TN 38103 Logan.Landry@memphistn.gov MEMORANDUM To: Latonya Hull, Planner I From : Logan Landry, Planner I Date : November 4, 2024 Subjec t: OSR Comments on SUP 24-039: PARKWAY VILLAGE General Comments & Analysis: Located in Zones 1 and 3 of the Resilience Zone Framework: Zone 1 a reas have the lowest level of development risk and conflict. These areas avoid high risk disaster zones, such as floodplains, and they also do not conflict with sensitive ecological areas. These areas are the most straightforward for development, and development would have the lowest impact on regional resilience. Consider incorporating the pr otection of ecological assets while balancing the promotion of low -impact site design and compact development typologies in appropriate areas. Zone 3 area s contain resilience assets that could be compromised by certain kinds of development. These assets include wetlands, forests, meadows, and aquifer recharge areas. The loss of these assets makes the entire region less resilient. Context sensitive development could still occur in these areas to minimize its impact. Consider strategic investment in ecological assets through revitalization and preservation as well as the impacts on local and regional hydrology and methods to mitigate drainage impacts. The Zo ne 3 designation is due to the aquifer recharge zone located in the southwest portion of the parcel. The ap plicant is requesting a special use permit to construct a convenience store with gas sales on the subject parcel. Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 20 20 Consistent with the Mid-South Regional Resilience Master Plan best practices: No Section 4.1 – Resilient Sites of the Mid -South Regional Resilience Master Plan discourages development within ecologically sensitive areas, making this application inconsistent with the goals of the Plan. Additionally, the proposed development in the aquifer recharge zone contradicts section 2.2.2 – Aquifer Conservation and Recharge. The nature of the proposed development would increase the hazard of contaminants generated at gas stations to seep into and contaminate the aquifer’s water supply. Consistent with the Memphis Area Climate Action Plan best practices: N/A Recommendations: Staff recommends rejection. Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 21 21 Comprehensive Planning Review of Memphis 3.0 Consistency This summary is being produced in response to the following application to support the Land Use and Development Services department in their recommendation: SUP 2024-039 Site Addre ss/Location: 2730 S Mendenhall Rd, Memphis 38155 Overlay District/Historic District/Flood Zone: Not in an Overlay District, Historic District, or Flood Zone Future Land Use Designation: Low Intensity Commercial and Services (CSL) Stree t Type: Avenue & Parkway The appli cant is requesting a special use permit to create a convenience store with gas sales. The following information about the land use designation can be found on pages 76 – 122: 1. Future Land Use Planning Map Red poly gon indicates the application site on the Future Land Use Map. Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 22 22 2. Land Use Description/Intent Low Intensity Commercial and Service (CSL) areas are typically not associated with anchors. These areas may include neighborhood supporting commercial uses such as retail sales and services, offices, restaurants, funeral services, small-scale recreation, social service institutions, and occasional upper-story residential. Graphic portrayal of CSL is below. “CSL” Form & Location Characteristics Commercial and services uses, 1-4 stories height “CSL” Zoning Notes Generally compatible with the following zone districts: CMU-1 without frontage requirements, OG, SDBP in accordance with Form and characteristics listed above. Existing, Adjacent Land Use and Zoning Existing Land Use and Zoning: Commercial; CMU-1 Adjacent Land Use and Zoning: Commercial, Multi-Family; CMU-1, CMU-3, RU-3 Overall Compatibility: The requested use is not compatible with the land use description/intent, form & location characteristics, and zoning notes. While a convenience store is compatible with land use intent, the expectation of gas pumps will lead to a more intense usage that is more appropriate for CSH. The requested use is not compatible with existing, adjacent land use and zoning. The intended use of gas pumps is too intense for adjacent multi-family homes zoned as RU-3. Degree of Change Map Red polygon denotes the proposed site on the Degree of Change Map. There is no Degree of Change. Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 23 23 3. Degree of Change Description N/A 4. Obj ectives/Actions Consistent with Goal 1, Complete, Cohesive, Communities N/A 5. Pertinent Sections of Memphis 3.0 that Address Land Use Recommendations N/A Consi stency Analysis Summary The applicant is requesting a special use permit to create a convenience store with gas sales. The requested use is not compatible with the land use description/intent, form & location characteristics, and zoning notes. While a convenience store is compatible with land use intent, the expectation of gas pumps will lead to a more intense usage that is more appropriate for CSH. The requested use is not compatible with existing, adjacent land use and zoning. The intended use of gas pumps is too intense for adjacent multi-family homes zoned as RU-3. Based on the information provided, the propo sal is NOT CONSISTENT with the Memphis 3.0 Comprehensive Plan. Summary Co mpiled by: Isaac Bacon, Comprehensive Planning. Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 24 24 MAILED PUBLIC NOTICE Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 25 25 SIGN AFFIDAVIT Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 26 26 APPLICATION Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 27 27 Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 28 28 Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 29 29 Sign Postings Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 30 30 Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 31 31 OWNER AFFIDAVIT Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 32 32 LETTER OF INTENT Staff Report December 12, 2024 SUP 2024-039 Page 33 33 LETTERS RECEIVED No letters received at the time of completion of this report. East Service Center: 6465 Mullins Station Rd; Memphis, T ennessee 38134 Downtown Service Center: 125 N. Main Street; Memphis, Tennessee 38103 website: www.develop901.com Memphis and Shelby County Division of Planning and Development Record Summary for Special Use Permit Record Detail Information Record Type : Special Use Permit Record Status: Pending Opened Date: September 16, 2024 Record Number: SUP 2024-039 Record Name: 2730 S MENDENHALL RD, Memphis 38115 Expiration Date: Description of Work: C-Store with Gas sales Parent Record Number: Address: 2730 S MENDENHALL RD, Memphis 38115 Owner Information Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone Y BERUK PROPER TIES INC 3264 W SARAZENS CIR, MEMPHIS, TN 38125 Parcel Information 074089 E00006 Data Fields PREAPPLICATION MEETING Name of DPD Planner Lucas Skinner Date of Meeting - Pre- application Meeting Type - GENERAL PROJECT INFORMATION Application Type New Special Use Permit (SUP) List any relevant former Docket / Case Number(s) related to previous applications on this site - Is this application in response to a citation, stop work order, or zoning letter No Page 1 of 3 SUP 2024-039 GENERAL PROJECT INFORMATION If yes, please provide a copy of the citation, stop work order, and/or zoning letter along with any other relevant information - APPROVAL CRITERIA A) The project will not have a substantial or undue adverse effect upon adjacent property, the character of the neighborhood, traffic conditions, parking, utility facilities and other matters affecting the public health, safety, and general welfare yes B) The project will be constructed, arranged and operated so as to be compatible with the immediate vicinity and not interfere with the development and use of adjacent property in accordance with the applicable district regulations yes UDC Sub-Section 9.6.9C yes UDC Sub-Section 9.6.9D yes UDC Sub-Section 9.6.9E yes UDC Sub-Section 9.6.9F yes GIS INFORMATION Case Layer - Central Business Improvement District No Class - Downtown Fire District No Historic District - Land Use - Municipality - Overlay/Special Purpose District - Zoning - State Route - Lot - Subdivision - Planned Development District - Wellhead Protection Overlay District No County Commission District - City Council District - City Council Super District - Contact Information FASIL KEBEDE (901)327-5800 APPLICANT Name Address Phone Contact Type Page 2 of 3 SUP 2024-039 Fee Information Date AssessedBalanceStatusFeesQuantityFee ItemInvoice # 09/24/20240.00INVOICED0.001Credit Card Use Fee (.026 x fee) 1594920 T otal Fee Invoiced: $0.00 Total Balance: $0.00 Page 3 of 3 SUP 2024-039 FLOOR PLAN 10'-4" 10'-5" 6'-0" SIDEWALK WIDTH SIDEWALK CHART EXISTING SIDEWALKS SHALL BE REPAIRED AS NECESSARY. 6' STREET NAME FOX PLAZA DR. ADJACENT TO CURB LOCATION FROM BACK OF CURBLINESIDE SOUTH NONEMENDENHALL 1-STORY PROPOSED BUILDING C-STORE 4988 S.F. CONVENIENCE STORE 3'-0" WIDE CONC. SIDE WALK 3'-0" WIDE CONC. SIDE WALK 3'-0" WIDE CONC. SIDE WALK 3'-0" WIDE CONC. SIDE WALK BERMUDA SOD INSTALLED. NOTE: ALL AREAS NOT PAVED OR MULCHED SHALL HAVE SYM COMMON NAME BOTANICAL NAME SIZE Ilex x attentuata 'Fosteri' Foster's Holly PROPOSED PLANTS FH SHAPE QTY 10-12' HT 7 NO. DATE DESCRIPTION REVISIONS PROJECT NAME : CONVENIENCE STORE SHEET TITLE : SITE PLAN DRAWN CHECKED PROJECT NO. HK 01 DATE: 05-21-2024 SHEET NO: SP1-1 141312111098765432 M L K J H G F E D C B A 1 2730 S MENDEN HALL RD, MEMPHIS 38115 ELEVATION 18'-0" T.O. PARAPET ALUM. & GLASS SYSTEM ALUM. & GLASS ENTRY DOORS STL. COL. - REFER TO STRUCTURAL ALUM. COL. COVER BUILDING ADDRESS FINISH FLOOR PREFIN.ALUMINUM COPING SIGNAGE BY OTHERS ELEVATION 0'-0" 36'-5" 21'-10" S3 B2 S3 19'-11" ROOFLINE BEYOND PREFIN.ALUMINUM COPING B1 S2 B3 B2 B2 ELEVATION 20'-4" T.O. PARAPET 3'-6" 0'-3" 5'-3" 1'-4" 6'-1" 1'-8" 18'-0" 20'-4" ALUM. & GLASS SYSTEM B1 ALUM. & GLASS ENTRY DOORS SIGNAGE BY OTHERS S3 S3S3 17'-9" 5'-5" ELEVATION 18'-0" T.O. PARAPET FINISH FLOOR PREFIN.ALUMINUM COPING ELEVATION 0'-0" 49'-10" S2 B2 B2 B1 S2 B3 B2 PREFIN.ALUMINUM COPING ROOFLINE BEYOND BRICK BORDER HEERING BONE PATTERN BRICK BRICK BORDER HEERING BONE PATTERN BRICK B1 3'-6" 0'-3" 5'-3" 1'-4" 6'-1" 1'-8" 18'-0" 20'-4" LEGENDS B1 WHITE BLUFF QSZ SERIAL # 163100 OR APPROVED B2 B3 S2 BRICK SOLDIER BRICK MASONRY SPANISH FORT QUEEN SERIAL # 569000 OR APPROVED BRICK ROWLOCK WOOD TEX. EXT .TILE S3 EIFS WHITE BLUFF QSZ SERIAL # 163100 OR APPROVED NO. DATE DESCRIPTION REVISIONS PROJECT NAME : SHEET TITLE : DRAWN CHECKED PROJECT NO. HK 01 DATE: SHEET NO: A-5 Do not scale drawings. Use given dimensions only. if not shown, verify correct dimensions with the Architect.Contractor shall check and verify all dimensions and conditions at job site 141312111098765432 M L K J H G F E D C B A 1 CONVENIENCE STORE 08-28-2024 38115 ELEVATION 2730 S MENDEN HALL RD MEMPHIS LEGENDS B1 WHITE BLUFF QSZ SERIAL # 163100 OR APPROVED B2 B3 S2 BRICK SOLDIER BRICK MASONRY SPANISH FORT QUEEN SERIAL # 569000 OR APPROVED BRICK ROWLOCK WOOD TEX. EXT .TILE S3 EIFS WHITE BLUFF QSZ SERIAL # 163100 OR APPROVED ELEVATION 18'-0" T.O. PARAPET FINISH FLOOR PREFIN.ALUMINUM COPING ELEVATION 0'-0" 49'-10" S2 B2 B2 B1 S2 B3 B2 PREFIN.ALUMINUM COPINGROOFLINE BEYOND BRICK BORDER HEERING BONE PATTERN BRICK BRICK BORDER HEERING BONE PATTERN BRICK B1 3'-6" 0'-3" 5'-3" 1'-4" 6'-1" 1'-8" 18'-0" 20'-4" ELEVATION 18'-0" T.O. PARAPET FINISH FLOOR PREFIN.ALUMINUM COPING ELEVATION 0'-0" 30'-3" 9'-10" B2 19'-11"ROOFLINE BEYOND PREFIN.ALUMINUM COPING B1 B2 B3 B2 ELEVATION 20'-4" T.O. PARAPET3'-6" 0'-3" 5'-3" 1'-4" 6'-1" 1'-8" 18'-0" 20'-4"B1 S3 17'-9" 5'-5" PAINTED MTL DOOR SHERWIN WILLIAMS ALOOF GRAY (SW 6197) PAINTED MTL DOOR SHERWIN WILLIAMS ALOOF GRAY (SW 6197) SIGNAGE BY OTHERS 17'-9" BRICK BORDER HEERING BONE PATTERN BRICK BRICK BORDER HEERING BONE PATTERN BRICK S3 S3 NO. DATE DESCRIPTION REVISIONS PROJECT NAME : SHEET TITLE : DRAWN CHECKED PROJECT NO. HK 01 DATE: SHEET NO: A-6 Do not scale drawings. Use given dimensions only. if not shown, verify correct dimensions with the Architect.Contractor shall check and verify all dimensions and conditions at job site 141312111098765432 M L K J H G F E D C B A 1 CONVENIENCE STORE 08-28-2024 38115 ELEVATION 2730 S MENDEN HALL RD MEMPHIS CANOPY EAST ELEVATION NTS CANOPY SOUTH ELEVATION NTS BRICK EXISTING COLUMNS (BRICK TO MATCH THE EXISTING BUILDING) BRICK EXISTING COLUMNS (BRICK TO MATCH THE EXISTING BUILDING) BRICK EXISTING COLUMNS (BRICK TO MATCH THE EXISTING BUILDING) 2 SPANISH FORT QUEEN SERIAL # 569000 1 RED BRICK 3 WHITE BLUFF QSZ SERIAL # 163100 NO. DATE DESCRIPTION REVISIONS PROJECT NAME : CONVENIENCE STORE 2730 S MENDENHALL RD, Memphis 38115 SHEET TITLE : DRAWN CHECKED PROJECT NO. HK 23011 DATE: SHEET NO: SP-2 Do not scale drawings. Use given dimensions only. if not shown, verify correct dimensions with the Architect.Contractor shall check and verify all dimensions and conditions at job site CANOPY DESIGN 09-18-2024 Memphis City Council Summary Sheet SAC 2024-010 RESOLUTION APPROVING THE CLOSURE OF AN UNIMPROVED PUBLIC ALLEY APPROXIMATELY 120 FEET IN LENGTH NEAR 610 TM HENDERSON AVE., KNOWN AS CASE NUMBER SAC 2024-010 • This item is a resolution with conditions to abandon the unimproved north-south public alley approximately 120’ in length near 610 TM Henderson Ave. • The conditions recommended by both staff and the Land Use Control Board would require the applicant to close the existing curb cut at their expense. • Both DPD staff and the Land Use Control Board recommend approval with conditions. • This item may require a future public improvement contract. 1 LAND USE CONTROL BOARD RECOMMENDATION At its regular meeting on Thursday, April 10, 2025, the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board held a public hearing on the following application: CASE NUMBER: SAC 2025-010 LOCATION: Near 610 TM Henderson Ave. COUNCIL DISTRICT(S): District 7, Super District 8 OWNER/APPLICANT: James Love REPRESENTATIVE: Smith Building Design, Delinor Smith REQUEST: Abandon an unimproved public alley approx. 120’ in length EXISTING ZONING: Mixed Use (MU) AREA: +/- 1,119 sq. ft. The following spoke in support of the application: None The following spoke in opposition of the application: None The Land Use Control Board reviewed the application and the staff report. A motion was made and seconded to recommend approval with conditions of the application. The motion passed by a unanimous vote of 7-0 on the consent agenda. Respectfully, Nicholas Wardroup Planner II Land Use and Development Services Division of Planning and Development Cc: Committee Members File 2 SAC 2024-010 CONDITIONS 1. The applicant shall provide for the construction of curb, gutter and sidewalk across the closure subject to review and approval by the City Engineer. If the City Engineer approves access, the applicant shall construct a city standard curb cut across the closure, to the satisfaction of the City Engineer. 2. Provide easements for existing sanitary sewers, drainage facilities, and other utilities or relocate at developer’s expense. 3. The applicant shall comply with all conditions of the closure within three years of the conditional approval of the closure by the Council of the City of Memphis. The Land Use Control Board may grant extensions to this date as Major Modifications as outlined in Section 9.8.6 of the UDC. 4. The abutting curb cut shall be closed to City standards at the applicant’s expense. 5. The existing unpermitted fence shall be removed, or permit retroactively obtained, prior to the finalization of the closure. 3 CLOSURE PLAT RESOLUTION R ESOLUTION APPROVING THE CLOSURE OF AN UNIMPROVED PUBLIC ALLEY APPROXIMATELY 120 FEET IN LENGTH NEAR 610 TM HENDERSON AVE., KNOWN AS CASE NUMBER SAC 2024-010 WHEREAS, the City of Memphis is the owner of real property known as the unimproved north-south public alley extending approximately 120’ northward from its intersection with TM Henderson Avenue near 610 TM Henderson Avenue in Memphis, Tennessee and being more particularly described as follows: 10 foot wide alley being a part of Lot 5 of the Probate Court Subdivision of the Rawling Tract as recorded in Probate Court Minute Book 43, Page 466 in Memphis, Shelby County, Tennessee and being further described hereon; Beginning at a point in the north line of T.M. Henderson Avenue (formerly V ollintine Avenue), 30 feet wide, a distance of 373.07 feet east of the east line of North Seventh Street ( 45 feet wide); thence North 04 degrees 38 minutes 57 seconds East along the east line of the Steven Barfoot property (Inst. 15082940) a distance of 119.67 feet to a point in the south line of Lot 4 and being the south line of the James Love Jr. property (Parcel 3, Inst. 24093515); thence South 83 degrees 02 minutes 10 seconds Ea st along the line dividing Lots 4 and 5 of said Rawling Subdivision a distance of 10.01 feet to the northwest corner of the James Love Jr. property ( Parcel 1, Inst. 24093515); thence South 04 degrees 38 minutes 57 seconds West along the west line of said Parcel 1 and the west line of the James Love Jr. property (Inst. 18126843) a distance of 120.14 feet to a point in the north line of T.M. Henderson Avenue; thence North 80 degrees 20 minutes 25 seconds West along said north line a distance of 10.04 feet to the point of beginning and containing 1,199.03 square feet. The City of Memphis hereby retains and easement for utilities over the above described area. WHEREAS, the City of Memphis has reviewed the recommendation of the Land Use Control Board and the report and recommendation of the Division of Planning and Development and desires to close the hereinabove described public right-of-way and it is deemed to be in the best interest of the City of Memphis that said public right-of-way be vacated, and revert to the abutting property owner(s); and WHEREAS, a public hearing in relation thereto was held before the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board on April 10, 2025, and said Board has submitted its findings and recommendation to the Council of the City of Memphis subject to the following conditions: 1. The applicant shall provide for the construction of curb, gutter and sidewalk across the closure subject to review and approval by the City Engineer. If the City Engineer approves access, the applicant shall construct a city standard curb cut across the cl osure, to the satisfaction of the City Engineer. 2. Provide easements for existing sanitary sewers, drainage facilities, and other utilities or relocate at developer’s expense. 3. The applicant shall comply with all conditions of the closure within three years of the conditional approval of the closure by the Council of the City of Memphis. The Land Use Control Board may grant extensions to this date as Major Modifications as outlined in Section 9.8.6 of the UDC. 4. The abutting curb cut shall be closed to City standards at the applicant’s expense. 5. The existing unpermitted fence shall be removed, or permit retroactively obtained, prior to the finalization of the closure. NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED , by the Council of the City of Memphis that the above described public right -of-way be and is hereby closed for public use, subject to the aforementioned conditions. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED , that the Mayor is hereby authorized to execute all Quitclaim Deed(s) to the owners of the properties abutting on the above described public right-of- way, said Deeds not to be delivered until the conditions herein stated have been met by applicant. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED , that a copy of this resolution be sent to the Lawyers Title Insurance Company, the Memphis Title Company, the Chicago Title Company, the Security Title Company and the Shelby County Property Assessor's Office. RIGHT-OF-WAY VACATION PLAT (SAC 2024-010) Staff Writer: Nicholas Wardroup E-mail: nicholas.wardroup@memphistn.gov AGENDA ITEM: 11 L.U.C.B. MEETING: April 10, 2025 CASE NUMBER: S AC 2024-010 LOCATION: Near 610 TM Henderson Ave. COUNCIL DISTRICT: District 7, Super District 8 OWNER/APPLICANT: James Love REPRESENTATIVE: Delinor Smith, Smith Building Design REQUEST: Abandon an unimproved public alley approx. 120’ in length EXISTING ZONING: Mixed Use (MU) CONCLUSIONS 1. The applicant requests the City abandon an unimproved public alley near the northwest corner of TM Henderson Ave. and Thomas St. 2. The s ubject right-of-way is unimproved and it is difficult to see a scenario in which its elimination would damage the long-term developability of the vicinity. In fact, doing so may eliminate a nonconformity on the abutting property to the west (side setback encroachment). 3. The cl osure of the subject right -of-way will not have any undue or substantial effect upon the existing vehicular and pedestrian traffic flow of the surrounding area. CONSISTENCY WITH MEMPHIS 3.0 This application is not subject to Memphis 3.0 consistency review. RECOMMENDATION: Approval with conditions Staff Report April 10, 2025 SAC 2024-010 Page 2 2 LOCATION MAP Subject right-of-way located within the pink circle SUBJECT RIGHT-OF-WAY Staff Report April 10, 2025 SAC 2024-010 Page 3 3 MAILED NOTICE INFORMATION In accordance with Sub-Section 9.3.4A of the Unified Development Code, staff mailed the below notice on March 29, 2025, to the owners of properties shown in blue (7 notices). Staff Report April 10, 2025 SAC 2024-010 Page 4 4 AERIAL Right-of-way to be closed shown in pink (approximate). Staff Report April 10, 2025 SAC 2024-010 Page 5 5 ZONING MAP (Approximate location of Subject ROW indicated by pink star) Staff Report April 10, 2025 SAC 2024-010 Page 6 6 LAND USE MAP Staff Report April 10, 2025 SAC 2024-010 Page 7 7 SITE PHOTOS Subject ROW looking north from TM Henderson Ave. Alternative angle looking northeast from TM Henderson Ave. Staff Report April 10, 2025 SAC 2024-010 Page 8 8 RIGHT-OF-WAY VACATION PLAT Full resolution version attached to this report. Staff Report April 10, 2025 SAC 2024-010 Page 9 9 CASE REVIEW Request Abandon an unimproved public alley approx. 120’ in length Site Details Location: Near 610 TM Henderson Ave. Area: +/-1,199 sq. ft. Description: The subject right-of-way is an unimproved public alley extending some 120’ northward from TM Henderson Ave. near its intersection with Thomas St. It abuts a vacant property to the east and a single -family residence to the west. It is served by a single curb cut on TM Henderson Ave. Analysis First, staff notes that the alley has already been closed by an unpermitted fence. Our recommended conditions would require the fence to be either removed or permitted prior to the closure’s finalization. They would also require the abutting curb cut be closed. The alley, due to its unimproved nature, is not currently an accessibility benefit to the abutting properties. Additionally, it does not span the full block to Rawlings Pl., making it unlikely that its maintenance as a public alley would improve the vicinity’s future developability. Additionally, it appears the home on the western abutting property may be encroaching into the required side yard setback. Should this be the case, the closure of the alley would have the additional benefit of eliminating a nonconformity. The closure of the subject right-of-way will not have any undue or substantial effect upon the existing vehicular and pedestrian traffic flow of the surrounding area. Staff Report April 10, 2025 SAC 2024-010 Page 10 10 RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends approval with conditions. Conditions 1. The applicant shall provide for the construction of curb, gutter and sidewalk across the closure subject to review and approval by the City Engineer. If the City Engineer approves access, the applicant shall construct a city standard curb cut across the closure, to the satisfaction of the City Engineer. 2. Provide easements for existing sanitary sewers, drainage facilities, and other utilities or relocate at developer’s expense. 3. The applicant shall comply with all conditions of the closure within three years of the conditional approval of the closure by the Council of the City of Memphis. The Land Use Control Board may grant extensions to this date as Major Modifications as outlined in Section 9.8.6 of the UDC. 4. The abutting curb cut shall be closed to City standards at the applicant’s expense. 5. The existing unpermitted fence shall be removed, or permit retroactively obtained, prior to the finalization of the closure. Staff Report April 10, 2025 SAC 2024-010 Page 11 11 DEPARTMENTAL COMMENTS The following comments were provided by agencies to which this application was referred: City/County Engineer: See next page. City/County Fire Division: No comments received. City Real Estate: No comments received. County Health Department: No comments received. Shelby County Schools: No comments received. Construction Code Enforcement: No comments received. Memphis Light, Gas and Water: No comments received. Office of Sustainability and Resilience: No comments received. Office of Comprehensive Planning: No comments received. Staff Report April 10, 2025 SAC 2024-010 Page 12 12 CITY ENGINEERING COMMENTS 1. Standard Public Improvement Contract or Right-Of-Way Permit as required in Section 5.5.5 of the Unified Development Code. Street Closures: 2. Provide easements for existing sanitary sewers, drainage facilities and other utilities or relocate at developer's expense. 3. City sanitary sewers/drainage facilities are located within the proposed closure area. 4. The applicant shall provide for the construction of curb, gutter and sidewalk across the closure as required by the City Engineer. If the City Engineer approves access, the applicant shall construct a City Standard curb cut across the closure, all to the satisfaction of the City Engineer, and at the applicant's expense. The applicant shall enter into a Standard Improvement Contract or obtain a Right of Way permit from the City Engineer to cover the above required construction work. 5. The applicant shall comply with all conditions of the closure within 3 years of the conditional approval of the closure by the City Council. 6. Adequate queuing spaces in accordance with UDC shall be provided between the street right-of-way line and any proposed gate/guardhouse/card reader. 7. Adequate maneuvering room shall be provided between the right-of-way and the gate/guardhouse/card reader for vehicles to exit by forward motion. Staff Report April 10, 2025 SAC 2024-010 Page 13 13 ATTACHMENTS Staff received no letters of support nor opposition prior to the completion of this report. Attached to this document are the applicant’s letter of intent as well as a full-resolution version of the vacation plat. 12/29/2024    Mr. Brett Ragsdale  Zoning Administrator  Division of Planning and Development  125 N. Main St., Ste. 477  Memphis, TN 38103          RE:   0 T.M. HEDERSON A VENUE, Memphis, TN 38107    Parcel Number: ALLEY  Record Numbers:  SAC 2024‐010       Dear Brett:     The three abutting property adjacent to the alley and corresponding owners are as follows:   James Love Jr.; Parcel # 0022034 00038C; 0 T.M. Henderson Ave.   Dessie Love; Parcel # 022037 00035C; 975 Thomas Street   Steven T. Barfoot; Parcel # 022034 00040; 610 T.M. Henderson Ave.  James Love Jr. and Dessie Love shall be responsibility for all fees required to process this application.  Once the legal boundaries are established, each party will be responsible for the proper management of  any green space created. Additionally, at the southwest corner of the existing structure, the drive must  be wide enough to safely accommodate traffic. The extra 5 feet will suffice for this needs. therefore,  approval of this use variance application is being processed.    We are asking that you please review and recommend approval of this use variance application.      Thank you,     Delinor Smith, Smith Building Design and Associates        East Service Center: 6465 Mullins Station Rd; Memphis, T ennessee 38134 Downtown Service Center: 125 N. Main Street; Memphis, Tennessee 38103 website: www.develop901.com Memphis and Shelby County Division of Planning and Development Record Summary for Street and Alley Closure (Right of Way V acation) Record Detail Information Record Type: Street and Alley Closure (Right of Way Vacation) Record Status: Processing Opened Date: December 6, 2024 Record Number: SAC 2024-010 Record Name: O TM HENDERSON AVE. ALLEY CLOSURE Expiration Date: Description of Work: REQUESTING APPROVAL TO CLOSE AN ABANDONDED ALLEY LOCATED 125' WEST OF THE INTERSECTION OF THOMAS STREET AND TM HENDERSON AVE. AND AT THE NORTH PROPERTY LINE. THE ADJACENT NEIGHBOR (ADDRESS 610 TM HENDERSON) MR. STEVEN T. BARFOOT HAS AGREED TO PERTICIPATE IN THIS PROCESS. SUBJECT TRACK IS LOCATED BETWEEN PARCEL #022034 00040 AND PARCEL #022034 00038C. Parent Record Number: Address: 610 TM HENDERSON AVE, MEMPHIS 38107 Owner Information Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone Y BARFOOT STEVEN T 1620 CANADAVILLE LOOP, EADS, TN 38028 Parcel Information 022034 00040 Data Fields PREAPPLICATION MEETING Name of DPD Planner NORMAN SALIBA Date of Meeting 12/02/2024 Pre- application Meeting Type In Person GENERAL INFORMATION Name of Street where closure will begin T. M. HENDERSON AVE. Page 1 of 3 SAC 2024-010 GENERAL INFORMATION Name of Street where closure will end N/A What is the reason for the street closure? APPROVAL OF THE ALLEY CLOSURE WILL CREATE ADDITIONAL SPACE FOR A FRIVABLE PERIMETER AROUND THE EXISTING BUILDING. IT WILL ALSO ALLOW BOTH NEIGHBORS TO ACCESS AND MAINTIAN THE PROPERTY MORE EASILY, INCLUDING CLEANING AND LANDSCAPING. What is the total area of the right-of-way being closed? 1180 What is the overall length of the street closure? 118 Name of Street/Alley/ROW NO NAME Is this application in response to a citation from Construction Code Enforcement or Zoning Letter? No If yes, please provide additional information - Is this application a time extension? No RELATED CASE INFORMATION Previous Case Numbers - GIS INFORMATION Case Layer PD08-301, SUP10-212, Z88-157 Central Business Improvement District Yes Class R Downtown Fire District No Historic District - Land Use SINGLE-FAMILY Municipality MEMPHIS Overlay/Special Purpose District Central Business Improvement District Zoning MDR State Route - Lot E PT 2 Subdivision KAUFMAN Planned Development District - Wellhead Protection Overlay District No County Commission District - City Council District - City Council Super District - Data Tables Property Owners Property Address : 610 T. M. HENDERSON AVE. Property Owner Name: STEVEN BARFOOT Mailing Address (if different than property address): 1620 CANADAVILLE LOOP, EADS TN 38028 Email Address: stb1620@yahoo.com Page 2 of 3 SAC 2024-010 Contact Information JAMES LOVE (901)301-7678 ADJACENT PROPER TY OWNER OF RECORD Name Address Phone Contact T ype JAMES LOVE (901)301-7678 APPLICANT Name Address Phone Contact T ype SMITH BUILDING DESIGN (901)690-3944 REPRESENTA TIVE Name Address Phone Contact T ype Fee Information Date AssessedBalanceStatusFeesQuantityFee ItemInvoice # 12/06/20240.00INVOICED400.001Right of W ay Vacation/Closure Fee 1610383 12/06/20240.00INVOICED10.401Credit Card Use Fee (.026 x fee) 1610383 Total Fee Invoiced: $410.40 Total Balance: $0.00 Payment Information Payment Amount Method of Payment Credit Card$410.40 Page 3 of 3 SAC 2024-010 12/29/2024    Mr. Brett Ragsdale  Zoning Administrator  Division of Planning and Development  125 N. Main St., Ste. 477  Memphis, TN 38103          RE:   0 T.M. HEDERSON A VENUE, Memphis, TN 38107    Parcel Number: ALLEY  Record Numbers:  SAC 2024‐010       Dear Brett:     The three abutting property adjacent to the alley and corresponding owners are as follows:   James Love Jr.; Parcel # 0022034 00038C; 0 T.M. Henderson Ave.   Dessie Love; Parcel # 022037 00035C; 975 Thomas Street   Steven T. Barfoot; Parcel # 022034 00040; 610 T.M. Henderson Ave.  James Love Jr. and Dessie Love shall be responsibility for all fees required to process this application.  Once the legal boundaries are established, each party will be responsible for the proper management of  any green space created. Additionally, at the southwest corner of the existing structure, the drive must  be wide enough to safely accommodate traffic. The extra 5 feet will suffice for this needs. therefore,  approval of this use variance application is being processed.    We are asking that you please review and recommend approval of this use variance application.      Thank you,     Delinor Smith, Smith Building Design and Associates        Memphis City Council Summary Sheet PD 2024-013 RESOLUTION PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 9.6 OF THE MEMPHIS AND SHELBY COUNTY UNIFIE D DEVELOPMENT CODE APPROVING A PLANNED D EVELOPMENT AT THE SUBJECT PROPERTY LOCATED AT EAST SHELBY DRIVE, +/- 700 FEET WEST OF TCHULAHOMA ROAD, KNOWN AS CASE NUMBER PD 2024-013 • This item is a resolution with conditions to allow a drop yard planned development; and • This resolution, if approved with conditions, will supersede the existing zoning for this property; and • The item may require future public improvement contracts. 1 LAND USE CONTROL BOARD RECOMMENDATION At its regular meeting on Thursday, November 14, 2024 , the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board held a public hearing on the following application: CASE NUMBER: PD 2024-013 DEVELOPMENT: Shelby Drive Drop Yard Planned Development LOCATION: East Shelby Drive, +/- 700 feet west of Tchulahoma Road COUNCIL DISTRICT(S): District 3 and Super District 8 – Positions 1, 2, and 3 OWNER/APPLICANT: Stephen Christides, Capital Drop Yard, LLC REPRESENTATIVE: David Bray, The Bray Firm REQUEST: New Planned Development to allow a drop yard EXISTING ZONING: Residential Single-Family – 8 (R-8) AREA: +/-9.18 acres The following spoke in support of the application: None The following spoke in opposition the application: Mary Donald The Land Use Control Board reviewed the application and the staff report . A motion was made and seconded to recommend rejection. The motion failed by a vote of 4-6-0 on the consent agenda. Respectfully, Alexis Longstreet Planner Land Use and Development Services Division of Planning and Development Cc: Committee Members File 2 PD 2024-013 CONDITIONS Outline/General Plan Conditions I. USES PERMITTED: A. AREA A - To be governed by approval conditions of BOA 1990-058 B. AREA B - Truck/tractor drop yard and accessory uses II. BULK REGULATIONS: A. AREA A - To be governed by approval conditions of BOA 1990-058 B. AREA B - The bulk regulations of the EMP zoning district shall apply. III. ACCESS AND CIRCULATION: A. The City / County Engineer shall approve the design, number and location of curb cuts. B. Any existing nonconforming curb cuts shall be modified to meet current City/County Standards or closed with curb, gutter and sidewalk. C. Provide internal circulation between adjacent phases, lots, and sections. Common ingress / egress easements shall be shown on the final plats. IV. LANDSCAPING, SCREENING, AND LIGHTING: A. An NOI as required by the Tree Ordinance shall be filed with the Office of Planning and Development at least 10 days prior to the removal of any tree that is 10 inches or greater in diameter. B. Any dumpster or accessory buildings shall be compatible with the main building. C. Any HVAC equipment or utility meters shall be screened through the use of using fencing or landscaping. If roof mounted, the equipment shall be screened through the use of using an architectural feature such as a parapet. D. The required landscaping shall be exclusive of and in addition to any required easements. E. A detailed landscaping plan shall be submitted with the final plat subject to the approval of the Office of Planning and Development. If the City Engineer's Office requires detention on this property that requires landscape to revised, no use Occupancy Permit shall be issued until a detailed landscaping plan has been approved by the DPD. F. All light poles shall be limited to a maximum of 35 feet in height. G. All lighting shall be designed to direct light straight down and not to trespass onto the adjoining properties. A detailed lighting plan showing the location of the poles and other lighting fixtures and the photometric analysis shall be submitted with the final plat, subject to the review and approval of the DPD. V. Site Plan Review: A site plan shall be submitted for the review, comment and recommendation of the Division of Planning and Development (DPD) and appropriate City Agencies prior to the approval of any plan. However, if there is a disagreement regarding the intention of any of the above conditions, either party may appeal to the Land Use Control Board and if necessary, the Memphis City Council. A. The Site plan shall include: 1. The exact location and dimensions including height of all buildings. 2. The number, location, and dimensions of parking spaces within proposed structures / lots. 3 3. A detailed landscaping plan including the species and diameter of any new plants. 4. A lighting plan showing the location of the freestanding poles, the type of fixtures and if required by DPD, photometric analysis that shows the trespass of light onto adjacent residential properties is no great than 1.0 candle foot at the property line. B. The site plan shall be reviewed based on the following criteria: 1. Conformance with the Outline Plan Conditions. 2. Compatibility with existing properties surrounding the site as well as a compatible internal arrangement of uses. 3. Elements of design such as building orientation, building mass and height, building materials, setback, access, parking and internal circulation, landscaping, and lighting. 4. Adequate access shall be provided to the site as determined by the City Engineer. VI. A final plan shall be filed within five (5) years of the approval of the Outline Plan by the Memphis City Council. The Land Use Control Board may grant extensions at the request of the applicant. VII. Any final plan shall include the following: A. The Outline Plan conditions. B. A standard subdivision contract as defined by the Subdivision Regulations for any needed public improvements. C. The exact location and dimensions including height of all buildings (with elevations) or buildable areas, parking areas, drives, and required landscaping. D. The number of parking spaces E. The location and ownership, whether public or private, of any easement. F. The following note shall be placed on the final plat of any development requiring on-site storm water detention facilities: The areas denoted by “Reserved for Storm Water Detention” shall not be used as a building site or filled without first obtaining written permission from the City Engineer. The storm water detention located in these areas, except for those parts located in a public drainage easement, shall be owned and maintained by the property owner and/or owners' association. Such maintenance shall be performed so as to to ensure the system operates in accordance with the approved plan on file in the City Engineer's Office. Such maintenance shall include, but not be limited to: removal of sedimentation, fallen objects, debris and trash, mowing, outlet cleaning, and repair of drainage structures. 4 CONCEPT PLAN RESOLUTION PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 9.6 OF THE MEMPHIS AND SHELBY COUNTY UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT C ODE APPROVING A PLANNED DEVELOPMENT AT THE SUBJECT PROPERTY LOCATED AT EAST SHELBY DRIVE, +/ - 700 FEET WEST OF TCHULAHOMA ROAD, KNOWN AS CASE NUMBER PD 2024-013 WHEREAS, Chapter 9.6 of the Memphis and Shelby County Unified Development Code, being a section of the Joint Ordinance Resolution No. 5367, dated August 10, 2010, authorizes the Council of the City of Memphis to grant a planned development for certain stated purposes in the various zoning districts; and WHEREAS, the Stephen Christides, Capital Drop Yard, LLC filed an application with the Memphis and Shelby County Division of Planning and Development to allow a drop yard; and WHEREAS, the Division of Planning and Development has received and reviewed the application in accordance with procedures, objectives and standards for planned developments as set forth in Chapter 9.6 with regard to the proposed development's impacts upon surrounding propertie s, availability of public facilities, both external and internal circulation, land use compatibility, and that the design and amenities are consistent with the public interest; and has submitted its findings and recommendation subject to outline plan conditions concerning the above considerations to the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board; and WHEREAS, a public hearing in relation thereto was held before the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board on November 14, 2024 , and said Board has submitted its findings and recommendation subject to outline plan conditions concerning the above considerations to the Council of the City of Memphis; and WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Memphis has reviewed the aforementioned application pursuant to Tennessee Code Annotated Section 13 -4-202(B)(2)(B)(iii) and has determined that said development is consistent with the Memphis 3.0 General Plan; and WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Memphis has reviewed the recommendation of the Land Use Control Board and the report and recommendation of the Division of Planning and Development and has determined that said development meets the objectives, standards and criteria for a special use permit, and said development is consistent with the public interests. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF MEMPHIS, that, pursuant to Chapter 9.6 of the Memphis and Shelby County Unified Development Code, a planned development is hereby granted in accordance with the attached outline plan conditions. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED , that the requirements of said aforementioned clause of the Unified Development Code shall be deemed to have been complied with; that the outline plan shall bind the applicant, owner, mortgagee, if any, and the legislative body with respect to the contents of said plan; and the applicant and/or owner may file a final plan in accordance with said outline plan and the provisions of Section 9.6.11 of the Unified Development Code. OUTLINE PLAN CONDITIONS I. USES PERMITTED: A. AREA A - To be governed by approval conditions of BOA 1990-058 B. AREA B - Truck/tractor drop yard and accessory uses II. BULK REGULATIONS: A. AREA A - To be governed by approval conditions of BOA 1990-058 B. AREA B - The bulk regulations of the EMP zoning district shall apply. III. ACCESS AND CIRCULATION: A. The City / County Engineer shall approve the design, number and location of curb cuts. B. Any existing nonconforming curb cuts shall be modified to meet current City/County Standards or closed with curb, gutter and sidewalk. C. Provide internal circulation between adjacent phases, lots, and sections. Common ingress / egress easements shall be shown on the final plats. IV. LANDSCAPING, SCREENING, AND LIGHTING: A. An NOI as required by the Tree Ordinance shall be filed with the Office of Planning and Development at least 10 days prior to the removal of any tree that is 10 inches or greater in diameter. B. Any dumpster or accessory buildings shall be compatible with the main building. C. Any HVAC equipment or utility meters shall be screened through the use of using fencing or landscaping. If roof mounted, the equipment shall be screened through the use of using an architectural feature such as a parapet. D. The required landscaping shall be exclusive of and in addition to any required easements. E. A detailed landscaping plan shall be submitted with the final plat subject to the approval of the Office of Planning and Development. If the City Engineer's Office requires detention on this property that requires landscape to revised, no use Occupancy Permit shall be issued until a detailed landscaping plan has been approved by the DPD. F. All light poles shall be limited to a maximum of 35 feet in height. G. All lighting shall be designed to direct light straight down and not to trespass onto the adjoining properties. A detailed lighting plan showing the location of the poles and other lighting fixtures and the photometric analysis shall be submitted with the final plat, subject to the review and approval of the DPD. V. SITE PLAN REVIEW: A site plan shall be submitted for the review, comment and recommendation of the Division of Planning and Development (DPD) and appropriate City Agencies prior to the approval of any plan. However, if there is a disagreement regarding the intention of any of the above conditions, either party may appeal to the Land Use Control Board and if necessary, the Memphis City Council. A. The Site plan shall include: 1. The exact location and dimensions including height of all buildings. 2. The number, location, and dimensions of parking spaces within proposed structures / lots. 3. A detailed landscaping plan including the species and diameter of any new plants. 4. A lighting plan showing the location of the freestanding poles, the type of fixtures and if required by DPD, photometric analysis that shows the trespass of light onto adjacent residential properties is no great than 1.0 candle foot at the property line. B. The site plan shall be reviewed based on the following criteria: 1. Conformance with the Outline Plan Conditions. 2. Compatibility with existing properties surrounding the site as well as a compatible internal arrangement of uses. 3. Elements of design such as building orientation, building mass and height, building materials, setback, access, parking and internal circulation, landscaping, and lighting. 4. Adequate access shall be provided to the site as determined by the City Engineer. VI. A final plan shall be filed within five (5) years of the approval of the Outline Plan by the Memphis City Council. The Land Use Control Board may grant extensions at the request of the applicant. VII. ANY FINAL PLAN SHALL INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING: A. The Outline Plan conditions. B. A standard subdivision contract as defined by the Subdivision Regulations for any needed public improvements. C. The exact location and dimensions including height of all buildings (with elevations) or buildable areas, parking areas, drives, and required landscaping. D. The number of parking spaces E. The location and ownership, whether public or private, of any easement. F. The following note shall be placed on the final plat of any development requiring on -site storm water detention facilities: The areas denoted by “Reserved for Storm Water Detention” shall not be used as a building site or filled without first obtaining written permission from the City Engineer. The storm water detention located in these areas, except for those parts located in a public drainage easement, shall be owned and maintained by the property owner and/or owners' association. Such maintenance shal l be performed so as to to ensure the system operates in accordance with the approved plan on file in the City Engineer's Office. Such maintenance shall include, but not be limited to: removal of sedimentation, fallen objects, debris and trash, mowing, out let cleaning, and repair of drainage structures. CONCEPT PLAN ATTEST: CC: Division of Planning and Development – Land Use and Development Services – Office of Construction Enforcement Staff Writer: Alexis Longstreet E-mail: alexis.longstreet@memphistn.gov AGENDA ITEM: 3 L.U.C.B. MEETING: November 14, 2024 CASE NUMBER: PD 2024 – 013 DEVELOPMENT: Shelby Drive Drop Yard Planned Development LOCATION: East Shelby Drive, +/- 700 feet west of Tchulahoma Road (Parcel Tax ID: 060232 00009) COUNCIL DISTRICT: District 3 and Super District 8 – Positions 1, 2, and 3 OWNER/APPLICANT: Stephen Christides, Capital Drop Yard, LLC REPRESENTATIVE: David Bray, The Bray Firm REQUEST: New Planned Development to allow a drop yard EXISTING ZONING: Residential Single – Family – 8 (R-8) CONCLUSIONS 1. On October 16, 1990, City Council approved a Planned Development (PD 1990-349) to allow uses permitted in the Light Industrial zoning district. Staff was unable to locate the original staff report to include further details. 2. On April 11, 2002, Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board recommended approval of Zoning application (Z 2002-102) that proposal rezoning of the subject property to split zone the western portion light industrial and the eastern portion office gen eral. Final disposition from City Council ruling was not found. 3. The applicant is proposing to subdivide the subject property into two areas, ‘Area A’ and ‘Area B’. Proposed area ’B’ will be regulated by Employment (EMP) zoning uses . Area ‘A’ will be governed by BOA 1990 -058 along with the neighboring property located west. 4. The applicant is not proposing fueling services. 5. The proposed drop yard will be located within area ‘B’. 6. The project will have a substantial or undue adverse effect upon adjacent property, the character of the neighborhood, traffic conditions, parking, utility facilities and other matters affecting the public health, safety, and general welfare. CONSISTENCY WITH MEMPHIS 3.0 This proposal is inconsistent with the Memphis 3.0 General Plan per the land use decision criteria. See further analysis on page 21 – 23 of this report. RECOMMENDATION: Rejection; however, if approved, staff recommends outline plan conditions Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 2 2 LOCATION MAP Subject property located within the pink circle SUBJECT PROPERTY Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 3 3 PUBLIC NOTICE VICINITY MAP Subject property highlighted in yellow PUBLIC NOTICE DETAILS In accordance with Sub-Section 9.3.4A of the Unified Development Code, a notice of public hearing is required to be mailed and signage posted . A total of 25 notices were mailed on August 16, 2024 , see page 22 of this report for a copy of said notice. Additionally, one sign was posted at the subject property, see page 23 of this report for a copy of the sign affidavit. NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING The meeting was held on Tuesday, August 27, 2024. Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 4 4 AERIAL Subject property outlined in yellow Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 5 5 ZONING MAP Subject property highlighted in yellow Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 6 6 LAND USE MAP Subject property indicated by a pink star Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 7 7 SITE PHOTOS View of subject property from East Shelby Drive looking north. Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 8 8 View of subject property from East Shelby Drive looking south. Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 9 9 PLOT PLAN Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 10 10 CONCEPT PLAN Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 11 11 CONCEPT PLAN – MAGNIFIED Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 12 12 CASE REVIEW Request The request is a new planned development to allow a drop yard. Applicability Staff agrees the applicability standards and criteria as set out in Section 4.10.2 of the Unified Development Code are or will be met. 4.10.2 Applicability The governing bodies may, upon proper application, grant a special use permit for a planned development (see Chapter 9.6) for a tract of any size within the City or for tracts of at least three acres in unincorporated Shelby County to facilitate the use of fle xible techniques of land development and site design, by providing relief from district requirements designed for conventional developments, and may establish standards and procedures for planned developments in order to obtain one or more of the following objectives: A. Environmental design in the development of land that is of a higher quality than is possible under the regulations otherwise applicable to the property. B. Diversification in the uses permitted and variation in the relationship of uses, structures, open space and height of structures in developments intended as cohesive, unified projects. C. Functional and beneficial uses of open space areas. D. Preservation of natural features of a development site. E. Creation of a safe and desirable living environment for residential areas characterized by a unified building and site development program. F. Rational and economic development in relation to public services. G. Efficient and effective traffic circulation, both within and adjacent to the development site, that supports or enhances the approved transportation network. H. Creation of a variety of housing compatible with surrounding neighborhoods to provide a greater choice of types of environment and living units. I. Revitalization of established commercial centers of integrated design to order to encourage the rehabilitation of such centers in order to meet current market preferences. J. Provision in attractive and appropriate locations for business and manufacturing uses in well -designed buildings and provision of opportunities for employment closer to residence with a reduction in travel time from home to work. K. Consistency with the Memphis 3.0 General Plan. Commercial or Industrial Criteria Staff agrees the additional planned commercial or industrial development criteria as set out in Section 4.10.5 of the Unified Development Code are or will be met. 4.10.5 Planned Commercial or Industrial Developments Approval of a planned commercial or industrial development may be issued by the governing bodies for buildings or premises to be used for the retail sale of merchandise and services, parking areas, office buildings, hotels and motels and similar facilities ordinarily accepted as commercial center uses and those industrial uses which can be reasonably be expected to fu nction in a compatible manner with the other permitted uses in the area. In addition to the applicable standards and criteria set forth in Section 4.10.3, planned commercial or industrial developments shall comply with the following standards: Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 13 13 A. Screening When commercial or industrial structures or uses in a planned commercial or industrial development abut a residential district or permitted residential buildings in the same development, screening may be required by the governing bodies. B. Display of Merchandise All business, manufacturing and processing shall be conducted, and all merchandise and materials shall be displayed and stored, within a completely enclosed building or within an open area which is completely screened from the view of adjacent properties a nd public rights -of-way, provided, however, that when an automobile service station or gasoline sales are permitted in a planned commercial development, gasoline may be sold from pumps outside of a structure. C. Accessibility The site shall be accessible from the proposed street network in the vicinity which will be adequate to carry the anticipated traffic of the proposed development. The streets and driveways on the site of the proposed development shall be adequate to serve the enterprises located in the proposed development. D. Landscaping Landscaping shall be required to provide screening of objectionable views of uses and the reduction of noise. High-rise buildings shall be located within the development in such a way as to minimize any adverse impact on adjoining low-rise buildings. Approval Criteria Staff disagrees the approval criteria as set out in Section 9.6.9 of the Unified Development Code are being met. 9.6.9 Approval Criteria No special use permit or planned development shall be approved unless the following findings are made concerning the application: A. The project will not have a substantial or undue adverse effect upon adjacent property, the character of the neighborhood, traffic conditions, parking, utility facilities and other matters affecting the public health, safety, and general welfare. B. The project will be constructed, arranged and operated so as to be compatible with the immediate vicinity and not interfere with the development and use of adjacent property in accordance with the applicable district regulations. C. The project will be served adequately by essential public facilities and services such as streets, parking, drainage, refuse disposal, fire protection and emergency services, water and sewers; or that the applicant will provide adequately for such services. D. The project will not result in the destruction, loss or damage of any feature determined by the governing bodies to be of significant natural, scenic or historic importance. E. The project complies with all additional standards imposed on it by any particular provisions authorizing such use. F. The request will not adversely affect any plans to be considered (see Chapter 1.9), or violate the character of existing standards for development of the adjacent properties. G. The governing bodies may impose conditions to minimize adverse effects on the neighborhood or on public facilities, and to ensure compatibility of the proposed development with surrounding properties, uses, and the purpose and intent of this development code. H. Any decision to deny a special use permit request to place, construct, or modify personal wireless service facilities shall be in writing and supported by substantial evidence contained in a written record, per the Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 14 14 Telecommunications Act of 1996, 47 USC 332(c)(7)(B)(iii). The review body may not take into account any environmental or health concerns. Site Details Address: East Shelby Drive, +/- 700 feet west of Tchulahoma Road Parcel ID: 060232 00009 Area: +/-9.18 acres Description: The subject property is located on the south side of East Shelby Drive, +/ - 700 feet west of Tchulahoma Road. The property is currently vacant and encompassed with matured landscaping. The lot has +/ - 645.8 feet of frontage along East Shelby Drive. This property is currently zoned Residential Single – Family – 8 with a vacant designated land use. The surrounding properties are a mix of residential (single -family and multi -family), industrial, institutional (place of worship) and vacant designated land uses. Site Zoning History On October 16, 1990, City Council approved a Planned Development (PD 1990 -349) to allow uses permitted in the Light Industrial zoning district. Staff was unable to locate the original staff report to include further details. On April 11, 2002, Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board recommended approval of Zoning application (Z 2002-102) that proposal rezoning of the subject property to split zone the western portion light industrial and the eastern portion office general. On September 03, 2002, City Council rejected approval of Z 2002-102. Concept Plan Review - There will be a total of 200 spaces on the lot. o 6 spaces (12’ x 75’) idle free with A/C and electric connections. (May be expanded based on demand) o 7 spaces will be for automobile parking. o 3 spaces (12’ x 75’) electric charging. (May be expanded based on demand) - There is a proposed curb cut located north east of the lot along East Shelby Drive. o Proposed entrance gate - There is designated 20-foot tree preservation and landscaping buffering along East Shelby Drive. - Class III buffers and tree preservation along the eastern and southern property lines. - Security fencing along the western property line separating proposed Area ‘A’ and Area ‘B’. - Designated detention located at the northwest portion of the proposed boundary of Area ‘B’. - Designated shared detention basin located in the southwest portion of proposed of Area ‘B’ that will encompasses majority of the southern portion of Area ‘A’ stretching from east to west. - Awning provided for trailer repair area along the northeast area of area ‘B’. Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 15 15 Analysis East Shelby Drive is a prominent area for a lot of freight traffic. The applicant is proposing to utilize +/ - 7.00 acres for the idle-free drop yard development in which truckers will be able to park, rest and utilize the driver lounge. The applicant has identified three (3) major infrastructure challenges that the proposed development will address, see page 3 1 – 36 for their findings. The remaining +/ -2.18 acres will be combined with the neighboring property located west and governed by BOA 1990 -058. Unlike the previously proposed and approved planned development, the current plan proposes adequate space to accomplish the goal of alleviating traffic and congestion of the other truck stops within the area. This proposal was deemed inconsistent with Memphis 3.0. The proposed use does not align with the Oakhaven/Parkway Village Planning District priority to “preserve and protect residential neighborhoods from industrial uses with natural barriers. See page 21 – 23 for said analysis. The project will have a substantial or undue adverse effect upon adjacent property, the character of the neighborhood, traffic conditions, parking, utility facilities and other matters affecting the public health, safety, and general welfare. RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends rejection; however, if approved, staff recommends the following outline plan conditions: Outline Plan Conditions – Revisions Proposed language is indicated in bold, underline; deletions are indicated in bold strikethrough I. USES PERMITTED: A. AREA A - To be governed by approval conditions of BOA 1990-058 B. AREA B - Truck/tractor drop yard and accessory uses II. BULK REGULATIONS: A. AREA A - To be governed by approval conditions of BOA 1990-058 B. AREA B - The bulk regulations of the EMP zoning district shall apply. III. ACCESS AND CIRCULATION: A. The City / County Engineer shall approve the design, number and location of curb cuts. B. Any existing nonconforming curb cuts shall be modified to meet current City/County Standards or closed with curb, gutter and sidewalk. C. Provide internal circulation between adjacent phases, lots, and sections. Common ingress / egress easements shall be shown on the final plats. IV. LANDSCAPING, SCREENING, AND LIGHTING: A. An NOI as required by the Tree Ordinance shall be filed with the Office of Planning and Development at least 10 days prior to the removal of any tree that is 10 inches or greater in diameter. B. Any dumpster or accessory buildings shall be compatible with the main building. C. Any HVAC equipment or utility meters shall be screened through the use of using fencing or landscaping. If roof mounted, the equipment shall be screened through the use of using an architectural feature such as a parapet. D. The required landscaping shall be exclusive of and in addition to any required easements. Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 16 16 E. A detailed landscaping plan shall be submitted with the final plat subject to the approval of the Office of Planning and Development. If the City Engineer's Office requires detention on this property that requires landscape to revised, no use Occupancy Permit shall be issued until a detailed landscaping plan has been approved by the DPD. F. All light poles shall be limited to a maximum of 35 feet in height. G. All lighting shall be designed to direct light straight down and not to trespass onto the adjoining properties. A detailed lighting plan showing the location of the poles and other lighting fixtures and the photometric analysis shall be submitted with the final plat, subject to the review and approval of the DPD. V. Site Plan Review: A site plan shall be submitted for the review, comment and recommendation of the Division of Planning and Development (DPD) and appropriate City Agencies prior to the approval of any plan. However, if there is a disagreement regarding the intention of any of the above conditions, either party may appeal to the Land Use Control Board and if necessary, the Memphis City Council. A. The Site plan shall include: 1. The exact location and dimensions including height of all buildings. 2. The number, location, and dimensions of parking spaces within proposed structures / lots. 3. A detailed landscaping plan including the species and diameter of any new plants. 4. A lighting plan showing the location of the freestanding poles, the type of fixtures and if required by DPD, photometric analysis that shows the trespass of light onto adjacent residential properties is no great than 1.0 candle foot at the property line. B. The site plan shall be reviewed based on the following criteria: 1. Conformance with the Outline Plan Conditions. 2. Compatibility with existing properties surrounding the site as well as a compatible internal arrangement of uses. 3. Elements of design such as building orientation, building mass and height, building materials, setback, access, parking and internal circulation, landscaping, and lighting. 4. Adequate access shall be provided to the site as determined by the City Engineer. VI. A final plan shall be filed within five (5) years of the approval of the Outline Plan by the Memphis City Council. The Land Use Control Board may grant extensions at the request of the applicant. VII. Any final plan shall include the following: A. The Outline Plan conditions. B. A standard subdivision contract as defined by the Subdivision Regulations for any needed public improvements. C. The exact location and dimensions including height of all buildings (with elevations) or buildable areas, parking areas, drives, and required landscaping. D. The number of parking spaces E. The location and ownership, whether public or private, of any easement. F. The following note shall be placed on the final plat of any development requiring on-site storm water detention facilities: The areas denoted by “Reserved for Storm Water Detention” shall not be used as a building site or filled without first obtaining written permission from the City Engineer. The storm water detention located in these areas, except for those parts located in a public drainage easement, shall be Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 17 17 owned and maintained by the property owner and/or owners' association. Such maintenance shall be performed so as to to ensure the system operates in accordance with the approved plan on file in the City Engineer's Office. Such maintenance shall include, but not be limited to: removal of sedimentation, fallen objects, debris and trash, mowing, outlet cleaning, and repair of drainage structures. Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 18 18 DEPARTMENTAL COMMENTS The following comments were provided by agencies to which this application was referred: City/County Engineer: 1. Standard Public Improvement Contract or Right-Of-Way Permit as required in Section 5.5.5 of the Unified Development Code. Sewers: 2. The availability of City sanitary sewer is unknown at this time. 3. The developer’s engineer needs to submit a sewer availability request to the Sewer Design Dept. for sewer system capacity. 4. Once the developer has submitted proposed sewer discharge rates to the City’s Sewer Design Dept, a determination can be made as to available sewer capacity. Roads: 5. The Developer shall be responsible for the repair and/or replacement of all existing curb and gutter along the frontage of this site as necessary. 6. All existing sidewalks and curb openings along the frontage of this site shall be inspected for ADA compliance. The developer shall be responsible for any reconstruction or repair necessary to meet City standards. Traffic Control Provisions: 7. The developer shall provide a traffic control plan to the city engineer that shows the phasing for each street frontage during demolition and construction of curb gutter and sidewalk. Upon completion of sidewalk and curb and gutter improvements, a minimum 5-foot-wide pedestrian pathway shall be provided throughout the remainder of the project. In the event that the existing right of way width does not allow for a 5-foot clear pedestrian path, an exception may be considered. 8. Any closure of the right of way shall be time limited to the active demolition and construction of sidewalks and curb and gutter. Continuous unwarranted closure of the right of way shall not be allowed for the duration of the project. The developer shall provide on the traffic control plan, the time needed per phase to complete that portion of the work. Time limits will begin on the day of closure and will be monitored by the Engineering construction inspectors on the job. 9. The developer’s engineer shall submit a Trip Generation Report that documents the proposed land use, scope and anticipated traffic demand associated with the proposed development. A detailed Traffic Impact Study will be required when the accepted Trip Generation Report indicates that the number for projected trips meets or exceeds the criteria listed in Section 210-Traffic Impact Policy for Land Development of the City of Memphis Division of Engineering Design and Policy Review Manual. Any required Traffic Impact Study will need to be formally approved by the City of Memphis, Traffic Engineering Department. Curb Cuts/Access: 10. The City Engineer shall approve the design, number, and location of curb cuts. 11. Any existing nonconforming curb cuts shall be modified to meet current City Standards or closed with curb, gutter, and sidewalk. 12. Will require engineering ASPR. Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 19 19 Drainage: 13. A grading and drainage plan for the site shall be submitted to the City Engineer for review and approval prior to recording of the final plat. 14. Drainage improvements, including possible on-site detention, shall be provided under a Standard Subdivision contract in accordance with Unified Development Code and the City of Memphis/Shelby County Storm Water Management Manual. 15. Drainage data for assessment of on-site detention requirements shall be submitted to the City Engineer. 16. The following note shall be placed on the final plat of any development requiring on-site storm water detention facilities: The areas denoted by "Reserved for Storm Water Detention" shall not be used as a building site or filled without first obtaining written permission from the City and/or County Engineer. The storm water detention systems located in these areas, except for those parts located in a public drainage easement, shall be owned and maintained by the property owner and/or property owners' association. Such maintenance shall be performed so as to ensure that the system operates in accordance with the approved plan on file in the City and/or County Engineer's Office. Such maintenance shall include, but not be limited to removal of sedimentation, fallen objects, debris and trash, mowing, outlet cleaning, and repair of drainage structures. 17. The developer should be aware of his obligation under 40 CFR 122.26(b)(14) and TCA 69-3-101 et. seq. to submit a Notice of Intent (NOI) to the Tennessee Division of Water Pollution Control to address the discharge of storm water associated with the clearing and grading activity on this site. General Notes: 18. Development is greater than 1 acre and requires detention. 19. No other utilities or services may occupy sanitary sewer easements in private drives and yards except for crossings. 20. All connections to the sewer shall be at manholes only. 21. All commons, open areas, lakes, drainage detention facilities, private streets, private sewers and private drainage systems shall be owned and maintained by a Property Owner's Association. A statement to this effect shall appear on the final plat. 22. Required landscaping shall not be placed on sewer or drainage easements. City/County Fire Division: • All design and construction shall comply with the 2021 edition of the International Fire Code (as locally amended) and referenced standards. • Fire apparatus access shall comply with section 503. • Where security gates are installed that affect required fire apparatus access roads, they shall comply with section 503.6 (as amended). • Fire protection water supplies (including fire hydrants) shall comply with section 507. • Where fire apparatus access roads or a water supply for fire protection are required to be installed, such protection shall be installed and made serviceable prior to and during the time of construction except when approved alternate methods of protection are provided. • IFC 510 In-building two-way emergency responder communication coverage shall be provided in all new and existing buildings. Buildings and structures that cannot support the required level of coverage shall be equipped with systems and components to enhance signals and achieve the required level of communication coverage. • A detailed plans review will be conducted by the Memphis Fire Prevention Bureau upon receipt of complete construction documents. Plans shall be submitted to the Shelby County Office of Code Enforcement. Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 20 20 City Real Estate: No comments received. County Health Department: No comments received. Shelby County Schools: No comments received. Construction Code Enforcement: No comments received. Memphis Light, Gas and Water: No comments received. Office of Sustainability and Resilience: No comments received. Office of Comprehensive Planning: Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 21 21 Comprehensive Planning Review of Memphis 3.0 Consistency This summary is being produced in response to the following application to support the Land Use and Development Services department in their recommendation: PD 2024-013 Parkway Village Site Address/Location: 0 Shelby Drive Overlay District/Historic District/Flood Zone: N/A Future Land Use Designation: Anchor Neighborhood-Primarily Single-Unit (AN-S) Street Type: N/A Applicant is seeking a Planned Development to develop an industrial truck drop yard. The following information about the land use designation can be found on pages 76 – 122: 1. Future Land Use Planning Map Red polygon indicates the application site on the Future Land Use Map. 2. Land Use Description/Intent Anchor Neighborhood-Primarily Single-Unit (AN-S) are walkable neighborhoods within a 5 – 10-minute walk of a Community Anchor. These neighborhoods are made up of single-unit and duplex housing. Graphic portrayal of AN-S is to the right. Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 22 22 “AN-S” Form & Location Characteristics NURTURE Primarily detached, single-family residences. Attached single-family residences permitted on parcels within 100 feet of an anchor. Height: 1-2 stories. Scale: house-scale. “AN-S” Zoning Notes Generally compatible with the following zone districts: R-15, R-10, R-8, R-6, R-3, RU-1, MDR in accordance with Form and characteristics listed above. Existing, Adjacent Land Use and Zoning Existing Land Use and Zoning: Vacant, R-8 Adjacent Land Use and Zoning: Single-Family, Multi-Family, Commercial; RU-1, R-MP, CMU-1 Overall Compatibility: This requested use is not compatible with the land use description/intent, form & location characteristics, zoning notes, and existing, adjacent land use and zoning as the proposed use is not compatible with future land use designation. This area is designated Anchor Neighborhood – Primarily Single Unit. 3. Degree of Change Map Red polygon denotes the proposed site in Degree of Change area. The Degree of Change is Nurture. 4. Degree of Change Description Nuture areas rely primarily on public and philanthropic resources to stabilize the existing pattern of a place. The proposed use is a private investment and not compatible with stabilization of existing land use patterns. Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 23 23 5. Objectives/Actions Consistent with Goal 1, Complete, Cohesive, Communities 6. Pertinent Sections of Memphis 3.0 that Address Land Use Recommendations The parcel is located in the Oakhaven/Parkway Village Planning District and the requested use is not consistent with Oakhaven/Parkway Village Planning District Priority – “Preserve and protect residential neighborhoods from industrial uses with natural barriers.” Consistency Analysis Summary Applicant is seeking a Planned Development to develop an industrial truck drop yard. This requested use is not compatible with the land use description/intent, form & location characteristics, zoning notes, and existing, adjacent land use and zoning as the proposed use is not compatible with future land use designation. This area is designated Anchor Neighborhood – Primarily Single Unit. The proposed use is a private investment and not compatible with stabilization of existing land use patterns. The parcel is located in the Oakhaven/Parkway Village Planning District and the requested use is not consistent with Oakhaven/Parkway Village Planning District Priority – “Preserve and protect residential neighborhoods from industrial uses with natural barriers.” Based on the information provided, the proposal is NOT CONSISTENT with the Memphis 3.0 Comprehensive Plan. Summary Compiled by: Nick Wiggins, Comprehensive Planning. Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 24 24 MAILED PUBLIC NOTICE Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 25 25 SIGN AFFIDAVIT Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 26 26 APPLICATION Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 27 27 Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 28 28 Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 29 29 OWNER AFFIDAVIT Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 30 30 LETTER OF INTENT Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 31 31 COMPANY FLYER Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 32 32 Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 33 33 Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 34 34 Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 35 35 Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 36 36 LETTERS RECEIVED Two letters of opposition were received at the time of completion of this report and have subsequently been attached. TCHULAHOMA CORRIDOR COMMENTS Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 37 37 OPPOSITION Staff Report September 12, 2024 PD 2024 - 013 Page 38 38 East Service Center: 6465 Mullins Station Rd; Memphis, T ennessee 38134 Downtown Service Center: 125 N. Main Street; Memphis, Tennessee 38103 website: www.develop901.com Memphis and Shelby County Division of Planning and Development Record Summary for Planned Development Record Detail Information Record Type : Planned Development Record Status: Processing Opened Date: August 9, 2024 Record Number: PD 2024-013 Record Name: Shelby Drive Drop Yard Planned Development Expiration Date: Description of Work: New planned development on the south side of Shelby Drive Parent Record Number: Address: 381 18 Owner Information Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone Y WILLIAMS STEVIE AND NATHANIEL PARTEE 4651 SUNSET RD, NESBITT, MS 38651 Parcel Information 060232 00009 Data Fields PREAPPLICATION MEETING Name of DPD Planner Lucas Skinner Date of Meeting 06/10/2024 Pre- application Meeting Type Email GENERAL PROJECT INFORMATION Planned Development Type New Planned Development (PD) Previous Docket / Case Number n/a Medical Overlay / Uptown No If this development is located in unincorporated Shelby County, is the tract at least three acres? (Note a tract of less than three acres is not n/a Page 1 of 3 PD 2024-013 GENERAL PROJECT INFORMATION eligible for a planned development in unincorporated Shelby County) Is this application in response to a citation, stop work order, or zoning letter No If yes, please provide a copy of the citation, stop work order, and/or zoning letter along with any other relevant information n/a APPROVAL CRITERIA UDC Sub-Section 9.6.9A This project is consistent with development patterns along this portion of Shelby Drive UDC Sub-Section 9.6.9B Type III landscape buffers are included along adjacent residentially zoned property. UDC Sub-Section 9.6.9C All public utilities and services are available to this site. Shelby Drive is fully developed along the subject property. UDC Sub-Section 9.6.9D agreed UDC Sub-Section 9.6.9E agreed UDC Sub-Section 9.6.9F agreed GENERAL PROVISIONS UDC Sub-Section 4.10.3A This project will be compatible with existing uses along this portion of Shelby Drive. B) An approved water supply, community waste water treatment and disposal, and storm water drainage facilities that are adequate to serve the proposed development have been or will be provided concurrent with the development All public utilities are available to this site. Detention will be installed at the southwest corner of the site and along the north property line at the connection to existing storm sewer. C) The location and arrangement of the structures, parking and loading areas, walks, lighting and other service facilities shall be compatible with the surrounding land uses, and any part of the proposed development not used for such facilities shall be landscaped or otherwise improved except where natural features are such as to justify preservation Proposed landscaping meets the UDC standards along street frontage and perimeter property lines. Lighting will be directed inward and will meet the foot candle standards of the UDC. D) Any modification of the district standards that would otherwise be applicable to the site are warranted by the design of the outline plan and the amenities incorporated therein, and are not inconsistent with the public interest agreed E) Homeowners’ associations or some other responsible party shall be required to maintain any and all common open space and/or common elements A property owners association will maintain the common detention basin. F) Lots of record are created with the recording of a planned development final plan Agreed GIS INFORMATION Case Layer Z02-102, Z05-122, Z07-107 Page 2 of 3 PD 2024-013 GIS INFORMA TION Central Business Improvement District No Class R Downtown Fire District No Historic District - Land Use VACANT Municipality - Overlay/Special Purpose District - Zoning R-8 State Route 1 Lot - Subdivision - Planned Development District - Wellhead Protection Overlay District No Contact Information STEPHEN CHRISTIDES - APPLICANT Name Address Phone Contact T ype THE BRA Y FIRM 2950 STAGE PLAZA NORTH, (901)487-2425 ARCHITECT / ENGINEER / SURVEYOR Name Address Phone Contact T ype Fee Information Date AssessedBalanceStatusFeesQuantityFee ItemInvoice # 08/09/20240.00INVOICED500.005Planned Development - each additional or fractional acres above 5 1584854 08/09/20240.00INVOICED52.001Credit Card Use Fee (.026 x fee) 1584854 08/09/20240.00INVOICED1,500.001Planned Development - 5 acres or less 1584854 T otal Fee Invoiced: $2,052.00 Total Balance: $0.00 Payment Information Payment Amount Method of Payment Credit Card$2,052.00 Page 3 of 3 PD 2024-013 OUTLINE PLAN CONDITIONS SH ELBY DRIVE DROP YARD PLANNED DEVELOPMENT I. USES PERMITTED: A. AREA A - To be governed by approval conditions of BOA 1990-058 B. AREA B - Truck/tractor drop yard and accessory uses II. BULK REGULATIONS: A. AREA A - To be governed by approval conditions of BOA 1990-058 B. AREA B - The bulk regulations of the EMP zoning district shall apply. III. ACCESS AND CIRCULATION: A. The City / County Engineer shall approve the design, number and location of curb cuts. B. Any existing nonconforming curb cuts shall be modified to meet current City / County Standards or closed with curb, gutter and sidewalk. C. Provide internal circulation between adjacent phases, lots, and sections. Common ingress / egress easements shall be shown on the final plats. IV. LANDSCAPING, SCREENING, AND LIGHTING: A. An NOI as required by the Tree Ordinance shall be filed with the Office of Planning and Development at least 10 days prior to the removal of any tree that is 10 inches or greater in diameter. B. Any dumpster or accessory buildings shall be compatible with the main building. C. Any HVAC equipment or utility meters shall be screened through the use of fencing or landscaping. If roof mounted, the equipment shall be screened through the use of an architectural feature such as a parapet. D. The required landscaping shall be exclusive of and in addition to any required easements. E. A detailed landscaping plan shall be submitted with the final plat subject to the approval of the Office of Planning and Development. If the City Engineer's Office requires detention on this property that requires landscape to revised, no use Occupancy Permit shall be issued until a detailed landscaping plan has been approved by the DPD. F. All light poles shall be limited to a maximum of 35 feet in height. G. All lighting shall be designed to direct light straight down and not to trespass on to the adjoining properties. A detailed lighting plan showing the location of the poles and other lighting fixtures and the photometric analysis shall be submitted with the final plat, subject to the review and approval of the DPD. V. Site Plan Review: A site plan shall be submitted for the review, comment and recommendation of the Division of Planning and Development (DPD) and appropriate City Agencies prior to the approval of any plan. However, if there is a disagreement regarding the intention of any of the above conditions, either party may appeal to the Land Use Control Board and if necessary, the Memphis City Council. A. The Site plan shall include: 1. The exact location and dimensions including height of all buildings. 2. The number, location, and dimensions of parking spaces within proposed structures / lots. 3. A detailed landscaping plan including the species and diameter of any new plants. 4. A lighting plan showing the location of the freestanding poles, the type of fixtures and if required by DPD, photometric analysis that shows the trespass of light onto adjacent residential properties is no great than 1.0 candle foot at the property line. B. The site plan shall be reviewed based on the following criteria: 1. Conformance with the Outline Plan Conditions. 2. Compatibility with existing properties surrounding the site as well as a compatible internal arrangement of uses. 3. Elements of design such as building orientation, building mass and height, building materials, setback, access, parking and internal circulation, landscaping, and lighting. 4. Adequate access shall be provided to the site as determined by the City Engineer. VI. A final plan shall be filed within five (5) years of the approval of the Outline Plan by the Memphis City Council. The Land Use Control Board may grant extensions at the request of the applicant. VII. Any final plan shall include the following: A. The Outline Plan conditions. B. A standard subdivision contract as defined by the Subdivision Regulations for any needed public improvements. C. The exact location and dimensions including height of all buildings (with el evations) or buildable areas, parking areas, drives, and required landscaping. D. The number of parking spaces E. The location and ownership, whether public or private, of any easement. F. The following note shall be placed on the final plat of any development requiring on-site storm water detention facilities: The areas denoted by “Reserved for Storm Water Detention” shall not be used as a building site or filled without first obtaining written permission from the City Engineer. The storm water detention located in these areas, except for those parts located in a public drainage easement, shall be owned and maintained by the property owner and/or owners' association. Such maintenance shall be performed so as to ensure the system operates in accordance with the approved plan on file in the City Engineer's Office. Such maintenance shall include, but not be limited to: removal of sedimentation, fallen objects, debris and trash, mowing, outlet cleaning, and repair of drainage structures. Telephone 901-383-8668 29 50 Stage Plaza North Bartlett, Tennessee 38134 August 9, 2024 Brett Ragsdale, Director Memphis and Shelby County Office of Planning and Development 125 North Main Street Memphis, Tennessee 38103 RE: Shelby Drive Drop Yard Planned Development Parcel 060232 00009 Memphis, Tennessee Mr. Ragsdale: Please find attached an application for a new planned development on the south side of Shelby Drive between Airways and Tchulahoma. The site is immediately adjacent to the River City Hydraulics facility located at 3135 E. Shelby Drive. That site operates under a BOA approval from 1990. At this time, RCH is seeking to expand their facilities and will be utilizing the western 2.18 acres (Area A) of the planned development. Expansion of their operations would be governed by the existing BOA conditions of approval. The remaining 7 acres of the parent tract (Area B) would be utilized for a truck/trailer drop yard. As you are aware, truck parking is underserved in our metro area creating an ongoing problem of illegal parking from shopping centers to residential streets to vacant properties. The developers are seeking to bring a high quality drop yard with amenities not found at similar facilities. The site is conveniently located along a major corridor and is less than one mile form the airport and less than 2.5 miles to the interstate. In addition to traditional parking facilities the site will include the following: driver lounge, at least six (6) spaces with air conditioning and electrical connections to allow occupied trucks to not be in idle mode (thus reducing pollution), at least three spaces for EV charging as new electric trucks enter our market, and an area for trailer repair by an independent contractor. Both the non-idle spaces and EV charging stations may be expanded depending on demand. The site will be well lit internally with LED lighting but will be designed to not impact surrounding properties. Security fencing will be installed around the site but will be internal to the landscaping (20 foot landscape plate along Shelby Drive frontage and 15 foot Class III buffer along east and south property lines). Existing trees within the landscape areas will be preserved where possible. Thank you for considering this request. If you have any questions or need any additional information, please contact me. Sincerely, David Gean Bray, P.E. 0 SHELBY DR Pag e 1 of 2 STEVIE WILLIAMS & NATHANIEL PARTEE 4651 SUNSET RD NESBIT, MS 38651 The Bray Firm 2950 Stage Plaza North Bartlett, TN 38134 CAPITAL DROP YARD, LLC. 4646 Poplar Avenue #413 Memphis, TN 38117 OWNER Engineer APPLICANT HAYWOOD & GIORDANO 7731 HWY 301 WALLS, MS 38680 MAPCO PETROLEUM INC 2424 RIDGE RD ROCKWALL, TX 75087 QCSI FOUR LLC 2424 RIDGE RD ROCKWALL, TX 75087 RESIDENT 3271 SHELBY DR MEMPHIS, TN 38118 PEDRO & MAGDELENA RODRIGUEZ 4757 TCHULAHOMA RD MEMPHIS, TN 38118 MEMPHIS REALTY PRO INVESTMENTS LLC 3746 BONNER DR OLIVE BRANH, MS 38654 MFAC CORP 4791 TCHULAHOMA RD MEMPHIS, TN 38118 EASTHAVEN CHURCH OF CHRIST 4833 TCHULAHOMA RD MEMPHIS, TN 38118 MFAC CORP 3767 NEW GETWELL RD MEMPHIS, TN 38118 RESIDENT 4833 TCHULAHOMA RD MEMPHIS, TN 38118 INDEPENDENT POLE BEARERS 4819 TCHULAHOMA RD MEMPHIS, TN 38118 SHELBY COUNTY 160 N. MAIN ST MEMPHIS, TN 38103 RESIDENT 1376 JACKSON PIT RD MEMPHIS, TN 38118 J. TARVER 3021 SHELBY DR MEMPIS, TN 38118 RCHYD TRUST #1 & #2 2025 MADISON LAYNE CT SHERWOOD, AR 72120 RESIDENT 3135 SHELBY DR MEMPHIS, TN 38118 JOHN & KIRK TARVER 2100 WOODCREEK DR GERMANTOWN, TN 38138 RESIDENT 3021 SHELBY DR MEMPHIS, TN 38118 OAKHAVEN MOBILE HOME PARK 3080 SHELBY DR MEMPHIS, TN 38118 KENDALL MEMPHIS PARTNERS 17300 RED HILL AVE STE 280 IRVINE, CA 92614 TRUE VICTORY CHURCH 3150 SHELBY DR MEMPHIS, TN 3818 0 SHELBY DR Pag e 2 of 2 CITY OF MEMPHIS 125 N. MAIN ST MEMPHIS, TN 38103 RESIDENT 3200 SHELBY DR MEMPHIS, TN 38118 ENLIGHTMENT INC 3220 SHELBY DR MEMPHIS, TN 38118 MTNI INC 4505 WASATCH BLVD #350 SALT LAKE CITY, UT 84124 RESIDENT 3250 SHELBY DR MEMPHIS, TN 38118 SHARHAN MUTAHAR 2271 KHUSH BOO CV SOUTHAVEN, MS 38671 RESIDENT 4635 TCHULAHOMA RD MEMPHIS, TN 38118 ASSOC. OF ISLAMIC CHARITABLE PROJECTS 4609 TCHULAHOMA RD MEMPHIS, TN 38118 MELISSA & LORENZO MYRICK 4609 TCHULAHOMA RD MEMPHIS, TN 38118 DARRELL THOMAS 4597 TCHULAHOMA RD MEMPHIS, TN 38118 NEW DEVELOPMENT LLC 3264 W. SARAZENS CIR MEMPHIS, TN 38125 RESIDENT 3292 SHELBY DR MEMPHIS, TN 38118 RONALD & PATRICIA SOLBERG PO BOX 751510 MEMPHIS, TN 38175 RESIDENT 3285 SHELBY DR MEMPHIS, TN 38118 REALTY INCOME PROPERTIES 17 LLC 500 VOLVO PKWY CHESAPEAKE, VA 23320 RESIDENT 3315 SHELBY DR MEMPHIS, TN 38118 TAYLOR’ED GYMNASTICS 4906 STIRRUP DR MEMPHIS, TN 38125 JOSE BOLANOS 3003 SUMMER AVE MEMPHIS, TN 38112 RESIDENT 4730 TCHULAHOMA RD MEMPHIS, TN 38118 MICHAEL WILLIAMS 3300 DAPHNE CV MEMPHIS, TN 38118 SANDRA NESBIT 3301 DAPHNE CV MEMPHIS, TN 38118 STANLEY & SCOTTY BROWNLEE 3305 DAPHNE CV MEMPHIS, TN 38118 PAULA WILSON 3309 DAPHNE CV MEMPHIS, TN 38118 CAROLYN WILLIAMS 4787 DAPHNE RD MEMPHIS, TN 38118 RICHARD & ROBYN BENTON 4793 DAPHNE RD MEMPHIS, TN 38118 City Hall – 125 N. Main Street, Suite 468 – Memphis, Tennessee 38103 – (901) 636-6619 November 14, 2024 Stephen Christides, Capital Drop Yard, LLC Sent via electronic mail to: capitallogisticsgroup@yahoo.com , dgbray@comcast.net Shelby Drive Drop Yard Planned Development Case Number: PD 2024-013 LUCB Recommendation: Rejection Dear applicant, On Thursday, November 14, 2024 , t he Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board recommended rejection of your planned development application for the Shelby Drive Drop Yard Planned Development, subject to the attached outline plan conditions. This application will be forwarded, for final action, to the Council of the City of Memphis. The Council will review your application in a committee meeting prior to voting on it in a public hearing. The applicant or the applicant’s representative(s) shall be in attendance at all meetings and hearings. It is the applicant’s responsibility to contact the City Council Records Office to determine when the application is scheduled to be heard at co mmittee and in public session. The City Council Records Office may be reached at (901) 636-6792. If for some reason you choose to withdraw your application, a letter should be mailed to the Land Use and Development Services Department of the Division of Planning and Development at the address provided above or emailed to the address provided below. If you have questions regarding this matter, please feel free to contact me at (901) 636-6619 or via email at alexis.longstreet@memphistn.gov. Respectfully, Alexis Longstreet Alexis Longstreet Planner II Land Use and Development Services Division of Planning and Development Letter to Applicant PD 2024-013 Page 2 of 4 Cc: David Bray, The Bray Firm File Letter to Applicant PD 2024-013 Page 3 of 4 Outline Plan Conditions I. USES PERMITTED: A. AREA A - To be governed by approval conditions of BOA 1990-058 B. AREA B - Truck/tractor drop yard and accessory uses II. BULK REGULATIONS: A. AREA A - To be governed by approval conditions of BOA 1990-058 B. AREA B - The bulk regulations of the EMP zoning district shall apply. III. ACCESS AND CIRCULATION: A. The City / County Engineer shall approve the design, number and location of curb cuts. B. Any existing nonconforming curb cuts shall be modified to meet current City/County Standards or closed with curb, gutter and sidewalk. C. Provide internal circulation between adjacent phases, lots, and sections. Common ingress / egress easements shall be shown on the final plats. IV. LANDSCAPING, SCREENING, AND LIGHTING: A. An NOI as required by the Tree Ordinance shall be filed with the Office of Planning and Development at least 10 days prior to the removal of any tree that is 10 inches or greater in diameter. B. Any dumpster or accessory buildings shall be compatible with the main building. C. Any HVAC equipment or utility meters shall be screened through the use of using fencing or landscaping. If roof mounted, the equipment shall be screened through the use of using an architectural feature such as a parapet. D. The required landscaping shall be exclusive of and in addition to any required easements. E. A detailed landscaping plan shall be submitted with the final plat subject to the approval of the Office of Planning and Development. If the City Engineer's Office requires detention on this property that requires landscape to revised, no use Occupancy Permit shall be issued until a detailed landscaping plan has been approved by the DPD. F. All light poles shall be limited to a maximum of 35 feet in height. G. All lighting shall be designed to direct light straight down and not to trespass onto the adjoining properties. A detailed lighting plan showing the location of the poles and other lighting fixtures and the photometric analysis shall be submitted with the final plat, subject to the review and approval of the DPD. V. Site Plan Review: A site plan shall be submitted for the review, comment and recommendation of the Division of Planning and Development (DPD) and appropriate City Agencies prior to the approval of any plan. However, if there is a disagreement regarding the intention of any of the above conditions, either party may appeal to the Land Use Control Board and if necessary, the Memphis City Council. A. The Site plan shall include: 1. The exact location and dimensions including height of all buildings. 2. The number, location, and dimensions of parking spaces within proposed structures / lots. 3. A detailed landscaping plan including the species and diameter of any new plants. Letter to Applicant PD 2024-013 Page 4 of 4 4. A lighting plan showing the location of the freestanding poles, the type of fixtures and if required by DPD, photometric analysis that shows the trespass of light onto adjacent residential properties is no great than 1.0 candle foot at the property line. B. The site plan shall be reviewed based on the following criteria: 1. Conformance with the Outline Plan Conditions. 2. Compatibility with existing properties surrounding the site as well as a compatible internal arrangement of uses. 3. Elements of design such as building orientation, building mass and height, building materials, setback, access, parking and internal circulation, landscaping, and lighting. 4. Adequate access shall be provided to the site as determined by the City Engineer. VI. A final plan shall be filed within five (5) years of the approval of the Outline Plan by the Memphis City Council. The Land Use Control Board may grant extensions at the request of the applicant. VII. Any final plan shall include the following: A. The Outline Plan conditions. B. A standard subdivision contract as defined by the Subdivision Regulations for any needed public improvements. C. The exact location and dimensions including height of all buildings (with elevations) or buildable areas, parking areas, drives, and required landscaping. D. The number of parking spaces E. The location and ownership, whether public or private, of any easement. F. The following note shall be placed on the final plat of any development requiring on-site storm water detention facilities: The areas denoted by “Reserved for Storm Water Detention” shall not be used as a building site o r filled without first obtaining written permission from the City Engineer. The storm water detention located in these areas, except for those parts located in a public drainage easement, shall be owned and maintained by the property owner and/or owners' association. Such maintenance shall be performed so as to to ensure the system operates in accordance with the approved plan on file in the City Engineer's Office. Such maintenance shall include, but not be limited to: removal of sedimentation, fallen objects, debris and trash, mowing, outlet cleaning, and repair of drainage structures. CITY OF MEMPHIS COUNCIL AGENDA CHECK OFF SHEET ___________________________________________________________________________________ | ONE ORIGINAL | Planning & Development | ONLY STAPLED | DIVISION |TO DOCUMENTS| Planning & Zoning COMMITTEE: 04/08/2025 DATE PUBLIC SESSION: 04/22/2025 DATE ITEM (CH ECK ONE) ORDINANCE X RESOLUTION X REQUEST FOR PUBLIC HEARING = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = ITEM DESCR IPTION: CASE NUMBER: DEVELOPMENT: LOCATION: COUNCIL DISTRICTS: APPELLANT: REPRESENTATIVE: REQUEST: AREA: RECOMMENDATION: Resolution approving the appeal of Davi d Wade on behalf of Charles B. Dudley, Frank Stallworth, and other resi dents along Grandview Avenue seeking to overturn the action of the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board approving a two-lot residential major subdivision at the subject property located a t 4041 Gra ndview Avenue known as case number S 2024-041 c orrespondence S 2024-041 Correspondence Two -lot residential major subdivision 4014 Grandview Avenue D istr ict 5 and Super District 9 – Posi tions 1, 2, and 3 C harles B. Dudley and Frank Stallworth Davi d Wade Overturn a decision of the Land Use Control Board +/-1.55 acres The Div ision of Planning and Development recommended Approval with cond itions and waivers The Land Use Control Board recommended Approval wit h conditions and waivers RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION: Public Hearing Required Add to consent agenda requesting public hearing – April 8, 2025 Public hearing – April 22, 2025 = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = PRIOR ACTI ON ON ITEM: (1) APPROVAL - (1) APPROVED (2) DENIED 02/13/2025 DATE (1) Land Use Control Board ORGANIZATION - (1) BOARD / COMMISSION (2) GOV’T. ENTITY (3) COUNCIL COMMITTEE = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = FUNDING: (2) REQUIRES CITY EXPENDITURE - (1) YES (2) NO $ AMOUNT OF EXPENDITURE $ REVENUE TO BE RECEIVED SOURCE AND AMOUNT OF FUNDS $ OPERATING BUDGET $ CIP PROJECT #_______________________________ $ FEDERAL/STATE/OTHER = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = ADMINIST RATIVE APPROVAL: DATE POSITION _____________________________________________ ____________ PLANNER II _____________________________________________ ____________ DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR _____________________________________________ ____________ ADMINISTRATOR _____________________________________________ ____________ DIRECTOR (JOINT APPROVAL) _____________________________________________ ____________ COMPTROLLER _____________________________________________ ____________ FINANCE DIRECTOR _____________________________________________ ____________ CITY ATTORNEY = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = _____________________________________________ ____________ CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER _____________________________________________ ____________ COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN 3/31/2025 3/31/2025 Date: March 31, 2025 RE: Case S 2024-041 To: John Zeanah Director, Division of Planning & Development Director Zeanah In advance of case S 2024-041 that will come before the body on April 8th, I would like to recuse myself from all discussions, voting, and deliberations on this item as I have a personal interest in the matter. In service, Chase Carlisle Memphis City Councilman CC: J. Ford Canale – Chairman of the Memphis City Council Attorney Allan Wade – Council Attorney Attorney Brianna Owens – Assistant Council Attorney Brooke Hyman – Chief Administrative Officer Ashleigh Hayes – Deputy Chief Administrative Officer CHASE CARLISLE MEMPHIS CITY COUNCIL SUPER DISTRICT 9-1 Memphis City Council Summary Sheet S 2024-041 Correspondence RESOLUTION APPROVING THE APPEAL OF DAVID WADE ON BEHALF OF CHARLES B. DUDLEY, FRANK STALLWORTH, AND OTHER RESIDENTS ALONG GRANDVIEW AVENUE SEEKING TO OVERTURN THE ACTION OF THE MEMPHIS AND SHELBY COUNTY LAND USE CONTROL BOARD APPROVING A MAJOR SUBDIVISION AT THE SUBJECT PROPERTY LOCATED AT 4014 GRANDVIEW AVENUE, KNOWN AS CASE NUMBER S 2024-0 41 CORRESPONDENCE • This it em is a resolution to appeal the Land Use Control Board’s approval of a 2- lot residential major subdivision; and • The La nd Use Control Board held a public hearing on February 13, 2025, and approved the aformentioned request subject to eight (8) conditions and one (1) waiver; and • David W ade of Martin, Tate, Morrow & Marston, P.C. appeared at the aforementioned public hearing on behalf of the appellant; and • An appea l of the Land Use Control Board decision was filed on February 21, 2025, by David Wade on behalf of Charles B. Dudley, Frank Stallworth and other residents along Grandview Avenue requesting the Memphis City Council overturn the action of the Land Use Control Board; and • No co ntracts are affected by this item; and • No exp enditure of funds/budget amendments are required by this item. 1 LAND USE CONTROL BOARD RECOMMENDATION At its regular meeting on Thursday, February 13, 2025, the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board held a public hearing on the following application: CASE NUMBER: S 2024-041 LOCATION: 4014 Grandview Avenue COUNCIL DISTRICT(S): District 5 and Super District 9 – Positions 1, 2, and 3 OWNER/APPLICANT: Chaseton and Elizabeth Carlisle REPRESENTATIVE: Josh Whitehead REQUEST: Two-lot residential major subdivision EXISTING ZONING: Residential Single-Family – 10 (R-10) AREA: +/-1.55 ac res The following spoke in support of the application: Josh Whitehead The following spoke in regards to the application: David Wade, Chip Dudley, and Frank Stallworth The Land Use Control Board reviewed the application and the staff report. A motion was made and seconded to recommend approval with conditions and waivers of the application. The motion passed by a vote of 5-3 on the regular agenda. Respectfully, Chloe Christion Planner II Land Use and Development Services Division of Planning and Development Cc: Committee Members File 2 S 2024-041 SITE PLAN 3 CONDITIONS & WAIVERS Conditions: 1. The western side yard setback of Lot 2A and the eastern side yard setback for Lot 2B shall be 15 feet. 2. The minimum front yard setback shall be 112 feet; the maximum front setback shall be 122 feet. At least 30 feet of the front facade of the houses shall be placed within this front setback range. 3. The final plat shall be reviewed by the City Engineer to determine the size and location of a stormwater detention area based on a drainage design study that ensures post-construction runoff will be less than pre-construction runoff. 4. Front-loaded garages shall be prohibited. 5. The use of Exterior Insulation Finishing System (EIFS) shall be prohibited on the exterior of the houses. 6. Only single -family detached dwellings shall be permitted on the lots. Any other principal uses permitted by the Memphis and Shelby County Unified Development Code are prohibited. 7. The final plat shall reflect lots of roughly the same size that do not vary more than 1000 square feet from one another. 8. A shared driveway serving both lots is prohibited. Waivers: 1. A waiver to Sub -Sections 5.2.2B and 5.2.21A is granted to relieve the developer and/or building permit holder of the installation of curb, gutter, or sidewalks along the Grandview Avenue frontage. RESOLUTION APPROVING THE APPEAL OF DAVID WADE ON BEHALF OF CHARLES B. DUDLEY, FRANK STALLWORTH, AND OTHER RESIDENTS ALONG GRANDVIEW AVENUE SEEKING TO OVERTURN THE ACTION OF THE MEMPHIS AND SHELBY COUNTY LAND USE CONTROL BOARD APPROVING A TWO-LOT RESIDENTIAL MAJOR SUBDIVISION AT THE SUBJECT PROPERTY LOCATED AT 4014 GRANDVIEW AVENUE , KNOWN AS CASE NUMBER S 2024-041 CORRESPONDENCE WHEREAS, Chaseton and Elizabeth Carlisle filed an application with the Memphis and Shelby County Division of Planning and Development for a two-lot residential major subdivision; and WHEREAS, the Memphis and Shelby County Division of Planning and Development reviewed the application in accordance with the standards and regulations of Memphis and Shelby County Unified Development Code and submitted its findings and recommendation to the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board; and WHEREAS, a public hearing in relation thereto was held before the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board on February 13, 2025, and said Board approved the request of the applicant subject to eight (8) conditions and one (1) waiver. WHEREAS, David Wade, filed an appeal on February 21, 2025, on behalf of Charles B. Dudley, Frank Stallworth, and other residents along Grandview Avenue with the Memphis and Shelby County Division of Planning and Development requesting that the Council of the City of Memphis overturn the action of the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board; and WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Memphis has reviewed the aforementioned appeal pursuant to Tennessee Code Annotated Section 13-4- 202(B)(2)(B)(iii) and has determined that said appeal is consistent with the Memphis 3.0 General Plan; and WHEREAS, upon evidence presented at this p ublic hearing by the appellant, the City Council of the City of Memphis, concludes the appeal herein should be granted. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF MEMPHIS, that the appeal of the appellant, David Wade on behalf of Charles B. Dudley, Frank Stallworth, and other residents along Grandview Avenue, is granted and the action of the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board on February 13, 2025, is hereby overturned. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED , that this r esolution shall take effect from and after the date it shall have been enacted according to due process of law by virtue of the passage thereof by the Council of the City of Memphis. SITE PLAN CONDITIONS: 1. The western side yard setback of Lot 2A and the eastern side yard setback for Lot 2B shall be 15 feet. 2. The minimum front yard setback shall be 112 feet; the maximum front setback shall be 122 feet. At least 30 feet of the front facade of the houses shall be placed within this front setback range. 3. The final plat shall be reviewed by the City Engineer to determine the size and location of a stormwater detention area based on a drainage design study that ensures post-construction runoff will be less than pre-construction runoff. 4. Front-loaded garages shall be prohibited. 5. The use of Exterior Insulation Finishing System (EIFS) shall be prohibited on the exterior of the houses. 6. Only single-family detached dwellings shall be permitted on the lots. Any other principal uses permitted by the Memphis and Shelby County Unified Development Code are prohibited. 7. The final plat shall reflect lots of roughly the same size that do not vary more than 1000 square feet from one another. 8. A shared driveway serving both lots is prohibited. WAIVERS 1. A waiver to Sub-Sections 5.2.2B and 5.2.21A is granted to relieve the developer and/or building permit holder of the installation of curb, gutter, or sidewalks along the Grandview Avenue frontage. ATTEST: CC: Division of Planning and Development – Land Use and Development Services – Office of Construction Enforcement East Service Center: 6465 Mullins Station Rd; Memphis, T ennessee 38134 Downtown Service Center: 125 N. Main Street; Memphis, Tennessee 38103 website: www.develop901.com Memphis and Shelby County Division of Planning and Development Record Summary for Subdivision Record Detail Information Record Type : Subdivision Record Status: Assignment Opened Date: September 26, 2024 Record Number: S 2024-041 Record Name: 4014 Grandview Ave. Expiration Date: Description of Work: Our project objective is to subdivide our 1.55 acre lot into 2 lots (0.78 acres and 0.77 acres). The property is currently in the R-10 zoning district with a minimum lot size of 10,000 s.f. and a minimum lot width of 60'. he proposed lots are a minimum of 112' wide and a minimum of 33,761 s.f. Parent Record Number: Address: 4014 GRANDVIEW AVE, MEMPHIS 38111 Owner Information Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone Y CARLISLE CHASET ON R & ELIZABETH M 4953 Roane Road, MEMPHIS, TN 38117 9013357069 Parcel Information 046047 00030 Data Fields PREAPPLICATION MEETING Name of DPD Planner Norman Saliba Date of Meeting 09/27/2024 Pre- application Meeting Type Email GENERAL INFORMATION Type of Subdivision Major Type of Preliminary Plan Standard Page 1 of 3 S 2024-041 GENERAL INFORMATION Name of Subdivision CRUMP'S ADDITION T O CRUMP'S GRANDVIEW AVENUE SUBDIVISION RECORDED IN P.B. 16, PG. 17 Number of lots 2 Acres 1.55 List any relevant former Docket / Case Number(s) related to previous applications on this site - Access to Public Water Yes Access to Public Sewer Yes Waiver No If yes, please cite the specific Article 5, Chapter 4.3, or Section 3.9.2 waiver(s) requested and provide the justification for the request - Is this application in response to a citation, stop work order, or zoning letter No If yes, please provide a copy of the citation, stop work order, and/or zoning letter along with any other relevant information - GIS INFORMATION Central Business Improvement District No Case Layer - Class R Downtown Fire District No Historic District - Land Use VACANT Municipality MEMPHIS Overlay/Special Purpose District - Zoning R-10 State Route - Lot 2 Subdivision CRUMPS ADDITION TO CRUMPS GRANDVIEW AVE Planned Development District - Wellhead Protection Overlay District Yes County Commission District - City Council District - City Council Super District - Contact Information Page 2 of 3 S 2024-041 CHASET ON R CARLISLE 4303 GWYNNE RD, MEMPHIS, TN, MEMPHIS, TN, 38117 (901)335-7069 APPLICANT Name Address Phone Contact T ype OLLAR SUR VEYING COMPANY, LLC (901)413-8081 ARCHITECT / ENGINEER / SUR VEYOR Name Address Phone Contact T ype CHASET ON R CARLISLE (901)335-7069 REPRESENTA TIVE Name Address Phone Contact T ype Fee Information Date AssessedBalanceStatusFeesQuantityFee ItemInvoice # 10/30/20240.00INVOICED400.001Prelminary Plan Fee1603003 10/30/20240.00INVOICED60.002Per Lot Fee1603003 10/30/20240.00INVOICED1 1.961Credit Card Use Fee (.026 x fee) 1603003 Total Fee Invoiced: $471.96 Total Balance: $0.00 Payment Information Payment Amount Method of Payment Credit Card$471.96 Page 3 of 3 S 2024-041 September 26, 2024 Memphis & Shelby County Office of Planning & Development 125 North Main Street, Suite 468 Memphis, TN 38103 RE: CRUMP'S ADDITION TO CRUMP'S GRANDVIEW AVENUE SUBDIVISION – RESUBDIVISION OF LOT 2 Dear Sir or Madam: Please allow this correspondence to serve as my “Letter of Intent” to subdivide one (1) existing 1.55 acre lot located at 4014 Grandview Avenue, being on the north side of Grandview Avenue and 720’ west of S. Goodlett Road into two (2) residential lots being 0.77 acres and 0.78 acres. The property is currently in the R-10 zoning district with a minimum lot size of 10,000 s.f. and a minimum lot width of 60. The proposed lots are a minimum of 112' wide and a minimum of 33,761 square feet. Sewerage and water will be provided by Memphis, Light, Gas and Water. Thank you in advance for your consideration of this request. Sincerely, Chaseton and Elizabeth Carlisle Staff Writer: Chloe Christion E-mail: chloe.christion@memphistn.gov AGENDA ITEM: 4 L.U.C.B. MEETING: February 13, 2025 CASE NUMBER: S 2024-041 LOCATION: 4014 Grandview Avenue OWNER/APPLICANT: REPRESENTATIVE: REQUEST: EXISTING ZONING: Chaseton and Elizabeth Carlisle Josh Whitehead Two-lot residential major res ubdivision Residential Single-Family – 10 (R-10) CONCLUSIONS 1. This case was held from the December 12, 2024, Land Use Control Board meeting in order for the applicant to satisfy the neighborhood meeting notice requirement per UDC Section 9.3.2. This case was also held at the January 9, 2025 LUCB meeting upon request from the applicant. 2. The proposed preliminary plan subdivides the parcel into two lots of 33,541 and 33,976 square feet . Each lot is +/ - 20,000 square feet over the required minimum for residential lots in the R -10 district. Each lot has a width of +/- 112 feet and the building setback line is 112 feet per the original recorded subdivision. The existing asphalt drive is proposed to remain. 3. The proposed lots are consistent with the rhythm of other residential lots within a 500 -foot radius of the subject property. See pages 13-14 for lot size analysis. 4. The proposed preliminary plan is compatible with and in keeping with the character of development in the neighborhood and conforms with all applicable provision and requirements of the Unified Development Code. CONSISTENCY WITH MEMPHIS 3.0 This proposal is consisten t with the Memphis 3.0 General Plan per the land use decision criteria. See further analysis on pages 20-22 of this report. RECOMMENDATION: Approval with conditions and waivers Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 2 2 LOCATION MAP Subject property located within the pink circle SUBJECT PROPERTY Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 3 3 PUBLIC NOTICE VICINITY MAP Subject property outlined in red. PUBLIC NOTICE DETAILS In accordance with Sub-Section 9.3.4A of the Unified Development Code, a notice of public hearing is required to be mailed. A total of 73 notices were mailed on November 23, 2024, see page 23 of this report for a copy of said notice. NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING The meeting was held at 3:00 PM on Friday, December 20, 2024, at 4014 Grandview Avenue. Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 4 4 CRUMP’S ADDITION TO GRANDVIEW AVENUE SUBDIVISION (1951) (PLAT BOOK 16 PAGE 17) Subject property outlined in red, Lot 2 Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 5 5 AERIAL Subject property outlined in yellow, imagery from 2023 Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 6 6 ZONING MAP Subject property highlighted in yellow Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 7 7 LAND USE MAP Subject property indicated by a pink star Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 8 8 SITE PHOTOS View of subject property from Grandview Avenue. Additional view of subject property from Grandview Avenue. Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 9 9 PRELIMINARY PLAN Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 10 10 PRELIMINARY PLAN – MAGNIFIED Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 11 11 CASE REVIEW Request The request is a two-lot residential major resubdivision. Review Criteria Staff agrees the major preliminary plan review approval criteria as set out in Sub -Section 9.7.7H of the Unified Development Code are met. 9.7.7H Approval Criteria 1. A major preliminary plan shall be approved by the Land Use Control Board if it meets the following criteria: a. Conforms with all the provisions and requirements of any plans to be considered (see Chapter 1.9); b. There are adequate public facilities available, to be provided by the applicant or programmed within the five-year capital improvements program of the governing bodies to accommodate the proposed development; c. Conforms with all the applicable provisions and requirements of this development code; and d. Conforms with all the provisions and requirements of other applicable codes and ordinances relating to land development not included in this development code. 2. The LUCB or governing body(s) may reject a preliminary plan if it is determined that the proposed subdivision is not in keeping with the character of development in the neighborhood. The LUCB or governing body(s) shall consider the following in the determination of the character of the development in the neighborhood. a. Building setback lines of all principal structures that lie within 500 feet of the proposed subdivision. b. Size and width of all lots within 500 feet of the proposed subdivision. c. Proximity of arterial and connector streets within 500 feet of the proposed subdivision. d. Diversity of land uses within 500 feet of the proposed subdivision. Site Details Address: 4014 Grandview Avenue Parcel ID: 046047 00030 Area: +/-1.55 acres Description: The subject property is known as Lot 2 of Crump’s Addition to Grandview Avenue Subdivision with a zoning of Residential Single-Family – 10. Subject property is currently vacant and surrounded by single -family residential uses. The lot has one street frontage on Grandview Avenue. Subject property is located within the Black Bayou Sensitive Drainage Basin (5-C). Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 12 12 Relevant Unified Development Code Clauses Sub-Section 3.6.1A – Regulations for Permitted Housing Types Preliminary Pla n Review The proposed preliminary plan subdivides the parcel into two lots of 0.77 and 0.78 acres. Each lot has a width of 112 feet and the building setback line is 112 feet per the original recorded subdivision. The existing asphalt drive is proposed to remain with access to lot 12B. Lot 2A will obtain its own curb cut and driveway for access. Analysis Regarding the lot size, the lots created with this proposed subdivision are 33,541 and 33,976 square feet in the R-10 District in which the lot area minimum 10,000 square feet is required. The proposed lots are also consistent with the size of lots in the surrounding area. See below for an analysis of lots within a 500 -foot radius of the subject property. Both east and west side setbacks for the proposed lots should be marked as 5’ and the rear setback should be marked as 20’ . The front setback provided is 112’ which is in keeping with the rhythm of the surrounding properties. Setbacks of the residences abutting the east and west property lines of the subject lot are +/ - 113 feet and +/- 117 feet respectively. The proposed preliminary plan is compatible with and in keeping with the character of development in the neighborhood and conforms with all applicable provision and requirements of the Unified Development Code. RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends approval with conditions and waivers. Conditions: Changes from the previous report are indicated in bold, underline ; deletions are indicated in bold strikethrough. 1. The western side yard setback of Lot 2A and the eastern side yard setback for Lot 2B shall be 15 feet. 2. The minimum front yard setback shall be 112 feet; the maximum front setback shall be 122 feet. At least 30 Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 13 13 feet of the front facade of the houses shall be placed within this front setback range. 3. The final plat shall be reviewed by the City Engineer to determine the need, size and location of stormwater detention area. A non-buildable area of 20 feet in depth (north to south) by 30 feet in width (east to west) shall apply to the northwest corner of Lot 2A for stormwater detention. 4. Front-loaded garages shall be prohibited. 5. The use of Exterior Insulation Finishing System (EIFS) shall be prohibited on the exterior of the houses. 6. Only single-family detached dwellings shall be permitted on the lots. Any other principal uses permitted by the Memphis and Shelby County Unified Development Code are prohibited. Waivers: 1. A waiver to Sub-Sections 5.2.2B and 5.2.21A is granted to relieve the developer and/or building permit holder of the installation of curb, gutter, or sidewalks along the Grandview Avenue frontage. LOT ANALYSIS MAP Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 14 14 Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 15 15 Average lot width: 142 feet (133 feet not inlcuding parking lot and athletic fields) Average lot size: 1.08 acres Average front setback: 71 feet Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 16 16 DEPARTMENTAL COMMENTS The following comments were provided by agencies to which this application was referred: City Engineer: 1. Standard Public Improvement Contract or Right-Of-Way Permit as required in Section 5.5.5 of the Unified Development Code. Sewers: 2. City sanitary sewers are available to serve this development. 3. If the lot will be subdivided into two or more additional lots, each of the additional lots must have their own service connection. 4. A sanitary sewer service connection plan is required to be submitted (via 901 portal) to the City Land Development Office for review and approval. 5. All required design plans and potential traffic control plan must be prepared in accordance with the City’s Standard Requirements and must be stamped by a Professional Engineer registered in the State of Tennessee. 6. A Sewer Development fee may be required per the City of Memphis Sewer Use Ordinance. 7. Payment of applicable sewer development fees per the City of Memphis Sewer Use Ordinance should be paid to the Land Development Office. Roads: 8. The Developer shall be responsible for the repair and/or replacement of all existing curb and gutter along the frontage of this site as necessary. 9. All existing sidewalks and curb openings along the frontage of this site shall be inspected for ADA compliance. The developer shall be responsible for any reconstruction or repair necessary to meet City standards. Traffic Control Provisions: 10. The developer shall provide a traffic control plan to the city engineer that shows the phasing for each street frontage during demolition and construction of curb gutter and sidewalk. Upon completion of sidewalk and curb and gutter improvements, a minimum 5-foot-wide pedestrian pathway shall be provided throughout the remainder of the project. In the event that the existing right of way width does not allow for a 5-foot clear pedestrian path, an exception may be considered. 11. Any closure of the right of way shall be time limited to the active demolition and construction of sidewalks and curb and gutter. Continuous unwarranted closure of the right of way shall not be allowed for the duration of the project. The developer shall provide on the traffic control plan, the time needed per phase to complete that portion of the work. Time limits will begin on the day of closure and will be monitored by Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 17 17 the Engineering construction inspectors on the job. 12. The developer’s engineer shall submit a Trip Generation Report that do cuments the proposed land use, scope and anticipated traffic demand associated with the proposed development. A detailed Traffic Impact Study will be required when the accepted Trip Generation Report indicates that the number for projected trips meets or exceeds the criteria listed in Section 210-Traffic Impact Policy for Land Development of the City of Memphis Division of Engineering Design and Policy Review Manual. Any required Traffic Impact Study will need to be formally approved by the City of Memphis, Traffic Engineering Department. Curb Cuts/Access: 13. The City Engineer shall approve the design, number, and location of curb cuts. 14. Any existing nonconforming curb cuts shall be modified to meet current City Standards or closed with curb, gutter, and sidewalk. Drainage: 15. A grading and drainage plan for the site shall be submitted to the City Engineer for review and approval prior to recording of the final plat. 16. Drainage improvements, including possible on-site detention, shall be provided under a Standard Subdivision contract in accordance with Unified Development Code and the City of Memphis/Shelby County Storm Water Management Manual. 17. Drainage data for assessment of on-site detention requirements shall be submitted to the City Engineer. 18. The following note shall be placed on the final plat of any development requiring on-site storm water detention facilities: The areas denoted by "Reserved for Storm Water Detention" shall not be used as a building site or filled without first obtaining written permission from the City and/or County Engineer. The storm water detention systems located in these areas, except for those parts located in a public drainage easement, shall be owned and maintained by the property owner and/or property owners' association. Such maintenance shall be performed so as to ensure that the system operates in accordance with the approved plan on file in the City and/or County Engineer's Office. Such maintenance shall include, but not be limited to removal of sedimentation, fallen objects, debris and trash, mowing, outlet cleaning, and repair of drainage structures. 19. The developer should be aware of his obligation under 40 CFR 122.26(b)(14) and TCA 69-3-101 et. seq. to submit a Notice of Intent (NOI) to the Tennessee Division of Water Pollution Control to address the discharge of storm water associated with the clearing and grading activity on this site. General Notes: 20. The width of all existing off-street sewer easements shall be widened to meet current city standards. 21. Development is greater than 1 acre and is located within a sensitive drainage basin. Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 18 18 22. No other utilities or services may occupy sanitary sewer easements in private drives and yards except for crossings. 23. All commons, open areas, lakes, drainage detention facilities, private streets, private sewers and private drainage systems shall be owned and maintained by a Property Owner's Association. A statement to this effect shall appear on the final plat. 24. Required landscaping shall not be placed on sewer or drainage easements. Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 19 19 City Fire Division: No comments received. City Real Estate: No comments received. County Health Department: No comments received. Shelby County Schools: No comments received. Construction Code Enforcement: No comments received. Memphis Light, Gas and Water: No comments received. Office of Sustainability and Resilience: No comments received. Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 20 20 Office of Comprehensive Planning: Comprehensive Planning Review of Memphis 3.0 Consistency This summary is being produced in response to the following application to support the Land Use and Development Services department in their recommendation: S 2024-041 University Site Address/Location: 4041 Grandview Avenue Overlay District/Historic District/Flood Zone: Future Land Use Designation: Anchor Neighborhood-Primarily Single-Unit (AN-S) Street Type: The applicant is seeking approval to subdivide one parcel into two. The following information about the land use designation can be found on pages 76 – 122: 1. Future Land Use Planning Map Red polygon indicates the application site on the Future Land Use Map. 2. Land Use Description/Intent Anchor Neighborhood-Primarily Single-Unit (AN-S) are walkable neighborhoods within a 5 – 10-minute walk of a Community Anchor. These neighborhoods are made up of single-unit and duplex housing. Graphic portrayal of AN-S is to the right. “AN-S” Form & Location Characteristics ACCELERATE Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 21 21 Primarily detached, single-family residences. Attached single-family, duplexes, triplexes and quadplexes permitted on parcels within 100 feet of an anchor; at intersections where the presence of such housing type currently exists at the intersection and along avenues, boulevards and parkways as identified in the Street Types Map. Height: 1-3 stories. Scale: house-scale “AN-S” Zoning Notes Generally compatible with the following zone districts: R-15, R-10, R-8, R-6, R-3, RU-1, MDR in accordance with Form and characteristics listed above. Existing, Adjacent Land Use and Zoning Existing Land Use and Zoning: Single-Family, R-10 Adjacent Land Use and Zoning: Single-Family, RU-1, R-10 Overall Compatibility: This requested use is compatible with the land use description/intent, form & location characteristics, zoning notes, and existing, adjacent land use and zoning. 3. Degree of Change Map Red polygon denotes the proposed site in Degree of Change area. The Degree of Change is Accelerate 4. Degree of Change Description Accelerate areas rely on a mix of primarily private and philanthropic resources along with some public resources to intensify the existing pattern of a place. Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 22 22 The proposed building is a private investment and infill development contextually compatible with the anchor neighborhood. 5. Objectives/Actions Consistent with Goal 1, Complete, Cohesive, Communities The requested use is consistent with Objective 1.5.1 – Focus residential infill efforts in anchor neighborhoods to support anchors and neighborhood commercial districts with appropriate population density. 6. Pertinent Sections of Memphis 3.0 that Address Land Use Recommendations NA Consistency Analysis Summary The applicant is seeking approval to subdivide one parcel into two. This requested use is compatible with the land use description/intent, form & location characteristics, zoning notes, and existing, adjacent land use and zoning. The proposed building is a private investment and infill development contextually compatible with the anchor neighborhood. The requested use is consistent with Objective 1.5.1 – Focus residential infill efforts in anchor neighborhoods to support anchors and neighborhood commercial districts with appropriate population density. Based on the information provided, the proposal is CONS ISTENT with the Memphis 3.0 Comprehensive Plan. Summary Compiled by: Christina Edingbourgh, Comprehensive Planning. Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 23 23 MAILED PUBLIC NOTICE Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 24 24 APPLICATION Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 25 25 Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 26 26 Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 27 27 OWNER AFFIDAVIT Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 28 28 LETTER OF INTENT Staff Report February 13, 2025 S 2024-041 Page 29 29 LETTERS RECEIVED One letter has been received at the time of completion of this report and has subsequently been attached. City Hall – 125 N. Main Street, Suite 468 – Memphis, Tennessee 38103 – (901) 636-6619 February 14, 2025 Whitehead Law PLLC 275 Jefferson Avenue Memphis, TN 38103 Sent via electronic mail to: josh@joshwhiteheadlaw.com Crump’s Addition to Grandview Avenue Subdivision – Resubdivision of Lot 2 Case Number: S 2024-041 LUCB Decision: Approval with conditions Dear applicant, On Thursday, February 13, 2025, the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board approved your major subdivision application requesting a two-lot resubdivision of Lot 2 of Crump’s Addition to Grandview Avenue Subdivision located at 4041 Grandview Avenue , subject to the following conditions and waivers: Conditions: 1. The western side yard setback of Lot 2A and the eastern side yard setback for Lot 2B shall be 15 feet. 2. The minimum front yard setback shall be 112 feet; the maximum front setback shall be 122 feet. At least 30 feet of the front facade of the houses shall be placed within this front setback range. 3. The final plat shall be reviewed by the City Engineer to determine the size and location of a stormwater detention area based on a drainage design study that ensures post- construction runoff will be less than pre-construction runoff. 4. Front-loaded garages shall be prohibited. 5. The use of Exterior Insulation Finishing System (EIFS) shall be prohibited on the exterior of the houses. 6. Only single-family detached dwellings shall be permitted on the lots. Any other principal uses permitted by the Memphis and Shelby County Unified Development Code are prohibited. 7. The final plat shall reflect lots of roughly the same size that do not vary more than 1000 square feet from one another. 8. A shared driveway serving both lots is prohibited. Letter to Applicant S 2024-041 Page 2 of 3 Waivers: 1. A waiver to Sub-Sections 5.2.2B and 5.2.21A is granted to relieve the developer and/or building permit holder of the installation of curb, gutter, or sidewalks along the Grandview Avenue frontage. Next Step: To initiate the final plat review process, a final plat review record must be submitted via the Develop 901 Citizen portal. If you have questions regarding this matter, please feel free to contact me at (901) 636-6619 or via email at chloe.christion@memphistn.gov. Respectfully, Chloe Christion Planner I Land Use and Development Services Division of Planning and Development Cc: Milos Mikic, Whitehead Law File Letter to Applicant S 2024-041 Page 3 of 3 PRELIMINARY PLAN NOTICE TO INTERESTED OWNERS OF PROPERTY (APPEAL OF LAND USE CONTROL BOARD ACTION) You will take notice that a public hearing will be held by the City Council of the City of Memphis, Tennessee, meeting in session in the Council Chambers, First Floor, City Hall, 125 North Main Street, Memphis, Tennessee, 38103, on Tuesday, ___________________ at 3:30 P.M., in the matter of granting an application for an appeal of decision made by the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board, as follows: CASE NUMBER: S 2024-041 CORRESPONDENCE LOCATION: 4014 Grandview Avenue COUNCIL DISTRICTS: District 5 and Super District 9 – Positions 1, 2, and 3 APPEALANT: Charles B. Dudley and Frank Stallworth REPRESENTATIVE: David Wade EXISTING ZONING: Residential Single-Family – 10 (R-10) REQUEST: Overturn a decision of the Land Use Control Board (LUCB) (The LUCB approved a two-lot residential major subdivision) AREA: +/-1.55 acres RECOMMENDATIONS: Memphis and Shelby County Division of Planning and Development: Approval with conditions and waivers Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board: Approval with conditions waivers NOW, THEREFORE, you will take notice that on Tuesday, , at 3:30 P.M. the City Council of the City of Memphis, Tennessee will be in session at the City Hall, Council Chambers, 125 North Main Street, Memphis, Tennessee 38103 to hear remonstrance’s or protests against the making of such changes; such remonstrance’s or protests must be by personal appearances, or by attorneys, or by petition, and then and there you will be present if you wish to remonstrate or protest against the same. THIS THE ____________________, ____________ FORD CANALE _ CHAIRMAN OF COUNCIL ATTEST: _KAMETRIS WYATT_ CITY COMPTROLLER TO BE PUBLISHED: Shelby County ITS / ReGIS 160 North Main, Suite 1000, Memphis, TN 38103 email: ReGIS@shelbycountytn.gov | www.gis.shelbycountytn.gov Legend Roads Shelby County Zoning Arlington Zoning Bartlett Zoning Collierville Zoning Germantown Zoning Lakeland Zoning Millington Zoning Parcels 0 340 680 1,020 1,360 ft Map prepared through Shelby County Government's online mapping Portal on 12/5/2024 ¯ CITY OF MEMPHIS COUNCIL AGENDA CHECK OFF SHEET ___________________________________________________________________________________ | ONE ORIGINAL | Planning & Development | ONLY STAPLED | DIVISION |TO DOCUMENTS| Planning & Zoning COMMITTEE: 0 3/25/25 DATE PUBLIC SESSION: 0 4/08/25 DATE ITEM (CHECK ONE) X ORDINANCE RESOLUTION X REQUEST FOR PUBLIC HEARING = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = ITEM CA PTION: Z oning ordinance amending Ordinance No. 5367 of Code of Ordinance, City of Memphis, Tennessee, adopted on August 10, 2010, as amended, known as the Memphis and Shelby County Unified Development code, to authorize a zoning use district reclassification for land located on 0 Mt. Moriah Ext, north of Kirby Terrace Drive B y taking the land out of the Residential Single -Family – 8 (R -8), Residential Urban – 2 (RU -2), Conservation Agriculture (CA) and Residential Single-Family – 15 (R-15) Use Districts and including it in the Commercial Mixed-Use – 3 (CMU-3) Use District, known as case number Z 2024-009 CASE NUMBER: Z 2024-009 LOCATION: 0 Mt. Moriah Ext, north of Kirby Terrace Drive COUNCIL DISTRICTS: District 2 and Super District 9 – Positions 1, 2, and 3 OWNER/APPLICANT: Prentiss Mitchell REPRESENTATIVES: N/A REQUEST: Rezoning of +/-22.96 acres from Residential Single -Family – 8 (R -8), Residential Urban – 2 (RU -2), Conservation Agriculture (CA) and Residential Single -Family – 15 (R -15) to Commercial Mixed-Use – 3 (CMU-3) RECOMMENDATION: The Division of Planning and Development recommended Rejection The Land Use Control Board recommended Rejection RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION: Public Hearing Required Set date for first reading – March 18, 2025 Second reading – March 25, 2025 Third reading – April 8, 2025 = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = PRIOR ACT ION ON ITEM: (1) APPROVAL - (1) APPROVED (2) DENIED 02/13/2025 DATE (1) Land Use Control Board ORGANIZATION - (1) BOARD / COMMISSION (2) GOV’T. ENTITY (3) COUNCIL COMMITTEE = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = FUNDING: (2 ) REQUIRES CITY EXPENDITURE - (1) YES (2) NO $ AMOUNT OF EXPENDITURE $ REVENUE TO BE RECEIVED SOURCE AND AMOUNT OF FUNDS $ OPERATING BUDGET $ CIP PROJECT #_______________________________ $ FEDERAL/STATE/OTHER = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = ADMINIS TRATIVE APPROVAL: DATE POSITION _____________________________________________ __3/10/2025__ PLANNER II _____________________________________________ ____________ DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR _____________________________________________ __3/10/2025__ ADMINISTRATOR _____________________________________________ ____________ DIRECTOR (JOINT APPROVAL) _____________________________________________ ____________ COMPTROLLER _____________________________________________ ____________ FINANCE DIRECTOR _____________________________________________ ____________ CITY ATTORNEY = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = _____________________________________________ ____________ CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER _____________________________________________ ____________ COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN Memphis City Council Summary Sheet Z 2024-009 ZONING ORDINANCE AMENDING ORDINANCE NO. 5367 OF CODE OF ORDINANCE, CITY OF MEMPHIS, TENNESSEE, ADOPTED ON AUGUST 10, 2010, AS AMENDED, KNOWN AS THE MEMPHIS AND SHELBY COUNTY UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT CODE, TO AUTHORIZE A ZONING USE DISTRICT RECLASSIFICATION FOR LAND LOCATED ON 0 MT. MORIAH EXT, NORTH OF KIRBY TERRACE DRIVE. BY TAKING THE LAND OUT OF THE RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY – 8 (R-8), RESIDENTIAL URBAN – 2 (RU-2), CONSERVATION AGRICULTURE (CA) AND RESIDENTIAL SINGLE- FAMILY – 15 (R-15) USE DISTRICTS AND INCLUDING IT IN THE COMMERCIAL MIXED- USE – 3 (CMU -3) USE DISTRICT, KNOWN AS CASE NUMBER Z 2024-009 • Approval of this zoning district reclassification will be reflected on the Memphis and Shelby County Zoning Atlas; and • No contracts are affected by this item; and • No expenditure of funds/budget amendments are required by this item. 1 LAND USE CONTROL BOARD RECOMMENDATION At its regular meeting on Thursday, February 13, 2025 the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board held a public hearing on the following application: CASE NUMBER: Z 2024-009 LOCATION: 0 Mt. Moriah Ext, north of Kirby Terrace Drive COUNCIL DISTRICT(S): District 2, Super District 9 – Positions 1, 2, and 3 OWNER/APPLICANT: Prentiss Mitchell REPRESENTATIVE: N/A REQUEST: Rezoning of +/-22.96 acres from Residential Single -Family – 8 (R-8), Residential Urban – 2 (RU -2), Conservation Agriculture (CA) and Residential Single-Family – 15 (R-15) to Commercial Mixed -Use – 3 (CMU-3) The following spoke in support of the application: Prentiss Mitchell The following spoke in opposition of the application: None The Land Use Control Board reviewed the application and the staff report. A motion was made and seconded to recommend approval of the application. The motion failed by a unanimous vote of 0-9. Respectfully, Chloe Christion Planner II Land Use and Development Services Division of Planning and Development Cc: Committee Members File 2 PLOT PLAN ORDINANCE NO: ____________ ZONING ORDINANCE AMENDING ORDINANCE NO. 5367 OF CODE OF ORDINANCE, CITY OF MEMPHIS, TENNESSEE, ADOPTED ON AUGUST 10, 2010, AS AMENDED, KNOWN AS THE MEMPHIS AND SHELBY COUNTY UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT CODE, TO AUTHORIZE A ZONING USE DISTRICT RECLASSIFICATION FOR LAND LOCATED AT 0 MT. MORIAH EXT, NORTH OF KIRBY TERRACE DRIVE BY TAKING THE LAND OUT OF THE RESIDENTIAL SINGLE- FAMILY – 8 (R -8), RESIDENTIAL URBAN – 2 (RU -2), CONSERVATION AGRICULTURE (CA) AND RESIDENTIAL SINGLE -FAMILY – 15 (R -15) USE DISTRICTS AND INCLUDING IT IN THE COMMERCIAL MIXED-USE – 3 (CMU-3) USE DISTRICT, KNOWN AS CASE NUMBER Z 2024-009. WHEREAS, a proposed amendment to the Memphis and Shelby County Unified Development Code, being Ordinance No. 5367 of the Code of Ordinances, City of Memphis, Tennessee, as amended, has been submitted to the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board for its recommendation, designated as Case Number: Z 2024-009; and WHEREAS, t he Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board has filed its recommendation and the Division of Planning and Development has filed its report and recommendation with the Council of the City of Memphis; and WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Memphis has reviewed the aforementioned amendment pursuant to Tennessee Code Annotated Section 13-4- 202(B)(2)(B)(iii) and has determined that said amendment is consistent with the Memphis 3.0 General Plan; and WHEREAS, the provisions of the Code of Ordinances, City of Memphis, Tennessee, as amended, relating to the proposed amendment, have been complied with. NOW THERE FORE, BE IT ORDAINED, BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF MEMPHIS: SECTION 1: THAT, the Memphis and Shelby County Unified Development Code, Ordinance No. 5367 of the Code of Ordinances, City of Memphis, as amended, be and the same hereby is amended with respect to Use Districts, as follows: BY TAKING THE FOLLOWING PROPERTY OUT OF THE RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY – 8 (R -8), RESIDENTIAL URBAN – 2 (RU -2), CONSERVATION AGRICULTURE (CA) AND RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY – 15 (R-15) USE DISTRICTS AND INCLUDING IT IN THE COMMERCIAL MIXED-USE – 3 (CMU-3) USE DISTRICT. The following property located in the City of Memphis, Tennessee being more particularly described as follows: BEGINNING AT A FOUND ½” IRON PIPE, SAID PIPE BEING THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF THE KIRBY MEADOWS SECTION D (77-46) SUBDIVISION, SAID POINT ALSO BEING IN THE EAST LINE OF THE KIRBY MEADOWS SECTION C (66-23) SUBDIVISION, ALSO HAVING TN STATE PLANE COORDINATES (NAD83) OF N:285302.74, E:820189.16, SAID POINT ALSO BEING 145.0 FEET NORTH OF THE CENTERLINE OF VALLEY PARK DR. (50’ R.O.W.); THENCE, N 03°57'07" E ALONG THE EAST LINE OF THE KIRBY MEADOWS SECTION C (66-23) SUBDIVISION FOR A DISTANCE OF 430.41 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF THE LENOX LAND PARK MEMPHIS LAND LP (20011299) TRACT THE FOLLOWING THREE (3) CALLS; THENCE, N 61°51'19" E PASSING A SET ½” IRON PIN WITH CAP AT A DISTANCE OF 2.0 FEET AND CONTINUING ON FOR A TOTAL DISTANCE OF 881.58 FEET TO A SET 1/2” IRON PIN WITH CAP; THENCE IN A SOUTHERLY DIRECTION WITH A NON-TANGENT CURVE TURNING TO THE RIGHT WITH A RADIUS OF 25.00 FEET, AN ARC LENGTH OF 34.71 FEET, AND HAVING A CHORD BEARING OF S 01°00'38" W AND A CHORD DISTANCE OF 31.99 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE IN A EASTERLY DIRECTION WITH A REVERSE NON-TANGENT CURVE TURNING TO THE LEFT WITH A RADIUS OF 75.00 FEET, AN ARC LENGTH OF 339.86 FEET, AND HAVING A CHORD BEARING OF S 89°05'16" E AND A CHORD DISTANCE OF 115.21 FEET TO A POINT, SAID POINT BEING IN THE SOUTH LINE OF THE STATE HIGHWAY 385 ; THENCE ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF THE STATE HIGHWAY 385 THE FOLLOWING FOUR (4) CALLS; THENCE, S 41°46'42" E FOR A DISTANCE OF 281.61 FEET TO A SET 1/2” IRON PIN WITH CAP; THENCE, S 44°26'59" E PASSING A SET 1/2” IRON PIN WITH CAP AT A DISTANCE OF 476.98 FEET AND CONTINUING ON FOR A TOTAL DISTANCE OF 506.98 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE, S 55°29'22" E FOR A DISTANCE OF 150.75 FEET TO A SET 1/2” IRON PIN WITH CAP; THENCE, S 49°58'12" E FOR A DISTANCE OF 130.41 FEET TO A FOUND IRON PIN WITH A HOSHALL CAP; THENCE, S 03°43'47" W ALONG A WEST LINE OF THE SPIRIT MASTER FUNDING LLC (270- 16) TRACT FOR A DISTANCE OF 197.07 FEET TO A FOUND IRON PIN WITH A HOSHALL CAP; THENCE, N 87°16'22" W ALONG A NORTH LINE OF THE SPIRIT MASTER FUNDING LLC (270-16) TRACT FOR A DISTANCE OF 240.34 FEET TO A FOUND IRON PIN WITH A HOSHALL CAP; THENCE ALONG THE NORTH LINE OF THE KIRBY MEADOWS SECTION D (77-46) SUBDIVISION THE FOLLOWING THREE (3) CALLS; THENCE, N 86°55'57" W FOR A DISTANCE OF 125.62 FEET TO A SET 1/2” IRON PIN WITH CAP; THENCE, N 69°40'46" W FOR A DISTANCE OF 62.98 FEET TO A SET 1/2” IRON PIN WITH CAP; THENCE, N 86°02'53" W FOR A DISTANCE OF 1253.97 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING CONTAINING 1000109.02 SQUARE FEET OR 22.96 ACRES MORE OR LESS. SECTION 2: THAT, the Zoning Administrator of the Division of Planning and Development be, and is hereby directed to make the necessary changes in the Official Use District Maps to conform to the changes herein made; that all official maps and records of the Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board and the City of Memphis be, and they hereby are, amended and changed so as to show the aforementioned amendment of the said Zoning Ordinance. SECTION 3: THAT, this ordinance take effect from and after the date it shall have been passed by the Council, signed by the Chairman of the Council, certified and delivered to the Office of the Mayor in writing by the comptroller, and become effective as otherwise provided by law. PLOT PLAN ATTEST: CC: Division of Planning and Development – Land Use and Development Services – Office of Construction Enforcement Shelby County Assessor City Hall – 125 N. Main Street, Suite 468 – Memphis, Tennessee 38103 – (901) 636-6619 February 14, 2025 Prentiss Mitchell, Delta Area Holdings LLC Horn Lake, Mississippi 38637 Sent via electronic mail to: mimllcmemphis@gmail.com Case Number: Z 2024-009 LUCB Recommendation: Rejection Dear applicant, On Thursday, February 13, 2025 , t he Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board recommended rejection of your rezoning application located southeast of Mount Moriah Road Extension to be included in the Commercial Mixed-Use - 3 (CMU-3) Zoning District. This application will be forwarded, for final action, to the Council of the City of Memphis. Ordinances appear on three consecutive Council Agendas with the third one being the Public Hearing. The Council will review your application in a committee meeting prior to voting on it in a public hearing. The applicant or the applicant’s representative(s) shall be in attendance at all meetings and hearings. It is the applicant’s responsibility to contact the City Council Records Office to determine when the application is scheduled to be heard at committee and in public session. The City Council Records Office may be reached at (901) 636-6792. If for some reason you choose to withdraw your application, a letter should be mailed to the Land Use and Development Services Department of the Division of Planning and Development at the address provided above or emailed to the address provided below. If you have questions regarding this matter, please feel free to contact me at (901) 636-6619 or via email at chloe.christion@memphistn.gov. Respectfully, Chloe Christion Planner II Land Use and Development Services Division of Planning and Development Cc: File Staff Writer: Chloe Christion E-mail: chloe.christion@memphistn.gov AGENDA ITEM: 6 L.U.C.B. MEETING: February 13, 2025 CASE NUMBER: Z 2024-009 LOCATION: 0 Mt. Moriah Ext, north of Kirby Terrace Drive COUNCIL DISTRICT: District 2 and Super District 9 – Positions 1, 2, and 3 OWNER/APPLICANT: Prentiss Mitchell REPRESENTATIVE: N/A REQUEST: Rezoning of +/-15.6 acres from Residential Single-Family – 8 (R-8), +/- 6.97 acres from Residential Urban – 2 (RU-2), +/- 0.44 acres from Conservation Agriculture (CA) and +/- 0.27 acres from Residential Single -Family – 15 (R-15) to Commercial Mixed-use – 1 (CMU-1) CONCLUSIONS 1. The request is a rezoning from multiple residentially-oriented zoning districts to Commercial Mixed-se – 3 (CMU-3). 2. When asked what the purpose of this rezoning was, the applicant responded that he does not know what intended uses would occur if the rezoning were to be approved. With no direction as to what development may take place at the subject property, this rezoning to high-intensity commercial would permit a variety of undesirable uses such as a nightclub, tavern, or used tire shop. 3. The subject property is located within a floodplain in which development of any kind, especially large - scale commercial development, is strongly discouraged. 4. The proposed rezoning to Commercial Mixed- Use – 3 is not in keeping with the nature of the surrounding residential and office land uses of the subject property. Therefore, staff is recommending rejection of the rezoning. CONSISTENCY WITH MEMPHIS 3.0 This proposal is inconsistent with the Memphis 3.0 General Plan per the land use decision criteria. See further analysis on pages 14-16 of this report. RECOMMENDATION: Rejection Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 2 2 LOCATION MAP Subject property located within the pink circle SUBJECT PROPERTY Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 3 3 PUBLIC NOTICE VICINITY MAP Subject property outlined in red. PUBLIC NOTICE DETAILS In accordance with Sub-Section 9.3.4A of the Unified Development Code, a notice of public hearing is required to be mailed and signage posted. A total of 190 notices were mailed on December 17, 2024, see page 17 of this report for a copy of said notice. Additionally, one sign was posted at the subject property, see page 18 of this report for a copy of the sign affidavit. NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING The meeting was held at 8:05 AM on Saturday December 21, 2024, at the Home Depot at 3469 Riverdale Road. Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 4 4 AERIAL Subject property outlined in yellow, imagery from 2023 Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 5 5 ZONING MAP Subject property highlighted in yellow Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 6 6 FEMA MAP Subject property outlined in yellow Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 7 7 LAND USE MAP Subject property indicated by a pink star Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 8 8 SITE PHOTOS View of subject property from Kirby Terrace Drive looking north. View of subject property from State Route 385 looking west. Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 9 9 PLOT PLAN Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 10 10 LEGAL DESCRIPTION INST: CY9742 BEGINNING AT A FOUND ½” IRON PIPE, SAID PIPE BEING THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF THE KIRBY MEADOWS SECTION D (77-46) SUBDIVISION, SAID POINT ALSO BEING IN THE EAST LINE OF THE KIRBY MEADOWS SECTION C (66-23) SUBDIVISION, ALSO HAVING TN STATE PLANE COORDINATES (NAD83) OF N:285302.74, E:820189.16, SAID POINT ALSO BEING 145.0 FEET NORTH OF THE CENTERLINE OF VALLEY PARK DR. (50’ R.O.W.); THENCE, N 03°57'07" E ALONG THE EAST LINE OF THE KIRBY MEADOWS SECTION C (66-23) SUBDIVISION FOR A DISTANCE OF 430.41 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF THE LENOX LAND PARK MEMPHIS LAND LP (20011299) TRACT THE FOLLOWING THREE (3) CALLS; THENCE, N 61°51'19" E PASSING A SET ½” IRON PIN WITH CAP AT A DISTANCE OF 2.0 FEET AND CONTINUING ON FOR A TOTAL DISTANCE OF 881.58 FEET TO A SET 1/2” IRON PIN WITH CAP; THENCE IN A SOUTHERLY DIRECTION WITH A NON-TANGENT CURVE TURNING TO THE RIGHT WITH A RADIUS OF 25.00 FEET, AN ARC LENGTH OF 34.71 FEET, AND HAVING A CHORD BEARING OF S 01°00'38" W AND A CHORD DISTANCE OF 31.99 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE IN A EASTERLY DIRECTION WITH A REVERSE NON-TANGENT CURVE TURNING TO THE LEFT WITH A RADIUS OF 75.00 FEET, AN ARC LENGTH OF 339.86 FEET, AND HAVING A CHORD BEARING OF S 89°05'16" E AND A CHORD DISTANCE OF 115.21 FEET TO A POINT, SAID POINT BEING IN THE SOUTH LINE OF THE STATE HIGHWAY 385; THENCE ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF THE STATE HIGHWAY 385 THE FOLLOWING FOUR (4) CALLS; THENCE, S 41°46'42" E FOR A DISTANCE OF 281.61 FEET TO A SET 1/2” IRON PIN WITH CAP; THENCE, S 44°26'59" E PASSING A SET 1/2” IRON PIN WITH CAP AT A DISTANCE OF 476.98 FEET AND CONTINUING ON FOR A TOTAL DISTANCE OF 506.98 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE, S 55°29'22" E FOR A DISTANCE OF 150.75 FEET TO A SET 1/2” IRON PIN WITH CAP; THENCE, S 49°58'12" E FOR A DISTANCE OF 130.41 FEET TO A FOUND IRON PIN WITH A HOSHALL CAP; THENCE, S 03°43'47" W ALONG A WEST LINE OF THE SPIRIT MASTER FUNDING LLC (270-16) TRACT FOR A DISTANCE OF 197.07 FEET TO A FOUND IRON PIN WITH A HOSHALL CAP; THENCE, N 87°16'22" W ALONG A NORTH LINE OF THE SPIRIT MASTER FUNDING LLC (270-16) TRACT FOR A DISTANCE OF 240.34 FEET TO A FOUND IRON PIN WITH A HOSHALL CAP; THENCE ALONG THE NORTH LINE OF THE KIRBY MEADOWS SECTION D (77-46) SUBDIVISION THE FOLLOWING THREE (3) CALLS; THENCE, N 86°55'57" W FOR A DISTANCE OF 125.62 FEET TO A SET 1/2” IRON PIN WITH CAP; THENCE, N 69°40'46" W FOR A DISTANCE OF 62.98 FEET TO A SET 1/2” IRON PIN WITH CAP; THENCE, N 86°02'53" W FOR A DISTANCE OF 1253.97 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING CONTAINING 1000109.02 SQUARE FEET OR 22.96 ACRES MORE OR LESS. Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 11 11 CASE REVIEW Request The request is a Rezoning of +/ -15.6 acres from Residential Single -Family – 8 (R -8), +/ - 6.97 acres from Residential Urban – 2 (RU -2), +/ - 0.44 acres from Conservation Agriculture (CA) and +/ - 0.27 acres from Residential Single-Family – 15 (R-15) to Commercial Mixed-use – 1 (CMU-1) Review Criteria Staff agrees the review criteria as set out in Sub-Section 9.5.7B of the Unified Development Code are met. 9.5.7B Review Criteria In making recommendations, the Land Use Control Board shall consider the following matters: 9.5.7B(1) Consistency with any plans to be considered (see Chapter 1.9); 9.5.7B(2) Compatibility with the present zoning (including any residential corridor overlay district) and conforming uses of nearby property and with the character of the neighborhood; 9.5.7B(3) Suitability of the subject property for uses permitted by the current versus the proposed district; 9.5.7B(4) Whether the proposed change tends to improve the balance of uses, or meets a specific demand in the City or County; and 9.5.7B(5) The availability of adequate police services, fire services, school, road, park, wastewater treatment, water supply and stormwater drainage facilities for the proposed zoning. Site Details Address: 0 Mt. Moriah Ext. Parcel ID: 093500 00627 Area: +/-22.96 acres Description: The subject property is a vacant lot with a zoning of Residential Single -Family – 8 (R-8), Urban Residential – 2 (RU-2), Conservation Agriculture (CA) and Residential Single-Family – 15 (R-15). The lot has one street frontage along State Route 385. The surrounding land uses are a mixture of single-family, commercial and office lots. Analysis When asked what the purpose of this rezoning was, the applicant responded that he does not know what intended uses would occur if the rezoning were to be approved. With no direction as to what development may take place at the subject property, this rezoning from predominately residential classification to high-intensity commercial would permit a variety of undesirable uses such as a nightclub, tavern, or used tire shop. The subject property is located within a floodplain in which development of any kind, especially large -scale commercial development, is str ongly discouraged. The Future Land Use Planning Goals of the Office of Comprehensive Planning’s Memphis 3.0 plan also discourage development on the subject property as it is designated Open Spaces & Natural Features (OSN). Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 12 12 The site may also have a history of being used, at least in part, as a construction debris landfill. As of the release of this staff report, research to confirm this in ongoing. If confirmed, development of this site may be compromised if unstable soils are found. See below aerial photograph from 1996 which shows that this site was previously used as a borrow pit for fill dirt in the construction of Nonconnah Parkway and is believed to have been filled, in part, by construction debris. It should also be mentioned that the site appears to be subject to development limitations in accordance with the Tennessee Scenic Highway System Act (TN Code 54-17-114(a)(l)(J) and 54-17-115(a)(I)(2)). These limitations restrict the height of a building to 35 feet. CMU -3 Zoning permits a maximum building height of 75 feet. This adds further validity that the subject property is not meant to be developed with the mass, height, and scale CMU-3 encourages. Finally, the District Intent Statement for CMU -3 Zoning found in UDC Paragraph 2.2.3D(3) states the following: “The CMU-3 District is intended to accommodate a very broad range of high intensity commercial, office, and employment uses that require highly visible and highly accessible locations with direct access to arterials.” The site has no direct access to an arterial street. The proposed rezoning to Commercial Mixed- Use – 3 is not in keeping with the nature of the surrounding residential and office land uses of the subject property. Therefore, staff is recommending rejection of the rezoning. RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends rejection. Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 13 13 DEPARTMENTAL COMMENTS The following comments were provided by agencies to which this application was referred: City Engineer: Basin/Lot/CD: Kirby, 18-A/23.5ac/2 1. Standard Public Improvement Contract or Right- Of-Way Permit as required in Section 5.5.5 of the Unified Development Code. Sewers: 2. The availability of City sanitary sewer is unknown at this time. Once the developer has submitted proposed sewer discharge rates to the City’s Sewer Design Dept, a determination can be made as to available sewer capacity. General Notes: 3. Development is greater than 1 acre and will require detention when developed. City Fire Division: No comments received. City Real Estate: No comments received. County Health Department: No comments received. Shelby County Schools: No comments received. Construction Code Enforcement: No comments received. Memphis Light, Gas and Water: No comments received. Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 14 14 Office of Sustainability and Resilience: Logan Landry Planner I Office of Sustainability and Resilience 125 N. Main St., Memphis, TN 38103 Logan.Landry@memphistn.gov MEMORANDUM To: Chloe Christion, Planner I From: Logan Landry, Planner I Date: December 31, 2024 Subject: OSR Comments on Z 24-09: SOUTHEAST General Comments & Analysis: Located in Zone 1 and Zone 4 of the Resilience Zone Framework: Zone 1 areas have the lowest level of development risk and conflict. These areas avoid high risk disaster zones, such as floodplains, and they also do not conflict with sensitive ecological areas. These areas are the most straightforward for development, and development would have the lowest impact on regional resilience. Consider incorporating the protection of ecological assets while balancing the promotion of low -impact site design and compact development typologies in appropriate areas. Zone 4 areas are high risk locations, namely riparian corridors, floodplains, and especially high vulnerability to earthquakes. Development in these locations is often directly at risk for flooding. Although these risks could be mitigated through the const ruction of major flood control infrastructure and higher seismic construction standards, it is generally advisable to avoid these areas for future development whenever possible. Efforts should be made to protect and further prevent development within Zone 4 for the purposes of mitigating the risk exposure to health and safety. Nearly the entirety of the parcel is located in Zone 4 which is due to its location in both the 100 -year floodplain (1% annual chance of flooding) and the 500-year floodplain (.2% annual chance of flooding) for nearby Nonconnah Creek. The parcel is currently zoned Residential (R-8) and the Applicant would like to rezone to Commercial Mixed Use (CMU- 3). The land is currently vacant and undeveloped. Consistent with the Mid-South Regional Resilience Master Plan best practices: No This rezoning request is generally not consistent with the Mid -South Regional Resilience Master Plan. The Plan designates the floodplain as an area where development should be restricted due to exposure to environmental hazards like flooding (Section 4.1 -- Resilient Sites). Additionally, Section 4.3 – Flood Smart Development encourages preserving vacant parcels that are in the floodplain and avoiding development. Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 15 15 Consistent with the Memphis Area Climate Action Plan best practices: N/A Recommendations: Staff does not recommend approval of this rezoning request. Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 16 16 Office of Comprehensive Planning: Comprehensive Planning Review of Memphis 3.0 Consistency This summary is being produced in response to the following application to support the Land Use and Development Services department in their recommendation: Z 2024-009 Southeast Site Address/Location: 0 Mount Moriah (Parcel Number 093500 00627) Overlay District/Historic District/Flood Zone: In a Flood Zone but not in an Overlay Zone or Historic District Future Land Use Designation: Open Spaces & Natural Features (OSN) Street Type: NA The applicant is seeking a Rezoning from R-8 to CMU-3 The following information about the land use designation can be found on pages 76 – 122: 1. Future Land Use Planning Map Red polygon indicates the application site on the Future Land Use Map. 2. Land Use Description/Intent Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 17 17 Wildlands, waterways, and natural features with a focus on preservation and occasional opportunities for passive recreation. Conservation Agriculture. Graphic portrayal of OSN to the right. “OSN” Form & Location Characteristics Conservation and recreational uses. “OSN” Zoning Notes Generally compatible with the following zone districts: OS, FW, CA in accordance with Form and characteristics listed below. Consult zoning map and applicable overlays for current and effective regulations. Changes unlikely; may consider rezonings, as appropriate, at the time of a small area plan. Analysis to understand how uses like wind farms, solar farms, stormwater facilities, community gardens/CSAs, apiaries, timber harvesting, or other similar uses are integrated into these zones. Existing, Adjacent Land Use and Zoning Existing Land Use and Zoning: Vacant, R-8 Adjacent Land Use and Zoning: Single-family Residential, Office, Commercial and Vacant, R-8, CA and FW Overall Compatibility: This requested land use is not compatible with these adjacent land uses and zoning districts because there is no other CMU-3 district adjacent, and the creek serves as a natural barrier from the other commercial uses. 3. Degree of Change Map Red polygon denotes the proposed site in Degree of Change area. There is no Degree of Change. 4. Degree of Change Description N/A 5. Objectives/Actions Inconsistent with Goal 1, Complete, Cohesive, Communities Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 18 18 The requested use is not consistent with Action 1.3.13. “Apply nature lots and flood lots as transitonal uses at community edges, particularly where communities border envioronmental hazards.” This lot currently serves as a buffer lot in a large flood zone, the request if granted would be inconsistent with the Goal 1 Action. The requested use is also not consistent with Action 1.3.14. “Identify opportunities to apply flood lots throughout communities to address persistent stormwater issues.” Activating what is functioning as a floodlot for commercial use is inconsistent with the action. 6. Pertinent Sections of Memphis 3.0 that Address Land Use Recommendations The parcel is in the Open Space and Natural Features Future Land Use Category. The intent of this category is for areas that have been identified as wildlands, waterways, and natureal features with a focus on preservation. This requested rezoning is not consistent with the goals of this Future Land use Category cheifly the goal of flood control. Consistency Analysis Summary The applicant is seeking a Rezoning from R-8 to CMU-3 This requested land use is not compatible with these adjacent land uses and zoning districts because there is no other CMU-3 district adjacent, and the creek serves as a natural barrier from the other commercial uses. The requested use is not consistent with Action 1.3.13. “Apply nature lots and flood lots as transitonal uses at community edges, particularly where communities border envioronmental hazards.” This lot currently serves as a buffer lot in a large flood zone, the request if granted would be inconsistent with the Goal 1 Action. The requested use is also not consistent with Action 1.3.14. “Identify opportunities to apply flood lots throughout communities to address persistent stormwater issues.” Activating what is functioning as a floodlot for commercial use is inconsistent with the action. The parcel is in the Open Space and Natural Features Future Land Use Category. The intent of this category is for areas that have been identified as wildlands, waterways, and natureal features with a focus on preservation. This requested rezoning is not consistent with the goals of this Future Land use Category cheifly the goal of flood control. This proposed rezoning is also not consistent with Memphis 3.0 Goal 3: Sustainable and Resilient Communities Objective 3.3 Expand use and protection of natural landscapes and green infrastructure or Objective 3.5 Protect life, Property, infrastructure and environment from disaster events. Based on the information provided, the proposal is NOT CONSISTENT with the Memphis 3.0 Comprehensive Plan. Summary Compiled by: Christina Edingbourgh, Comprehensive Planning. Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 19 19 MAILED PUBLIC NOTICE Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 20 20 SIGN AFFIDAVIT Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 21 21 APPLICATION Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 22 22 Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 23 23 OWNER AFFIDAVIT Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 24 24 LETTER OF INTENT Staff Report February 13, 2025 Z 2024-009 Page 25 25 LETTERS RECEIVED Two (2) letters of opposition have been received at the time of completion of this report and have subsequently been attached. Outlook Case number Z 2024-009 From Sharon Robinson <sharonrobinson047@gmail.com> Date Wed 1/22/2025 7:17 PM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> Cc Sharonrobinson047@gmail.com <sharonrobinson047@gmail.com> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Good evening Mrs Chloe Christion I contacting you because I received a notice in the mail concerning a request to rezoning I am AGAINST IT. I do not want this and I need for the city council to know it. Please keep me informed on what I need to do to keep this from happening or taking place. Thank you for your time I can be contacted at (901)493-6311 if I’m not in leave a message and I will return your call. 1/23/25, 8:50 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAJHwEe65sltMid%2BVkmU… 1/1 Outlook Case Z 2024-009 rezoning RU-2 and R-6 to CMU From keresia jones <keresiajns@yahoo.com> Date Sat 1/25/2025 2:11 PM To Christion, Chloe <Chloe.Christion@memphistn.gov> CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Memphis organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. I don't agree with rezoning. The gas line runs through my back yard and I don't want additional connections to raise concerns. I feel it will bring unwanted traffic to an already crowded area and crime increase. The rezoning would not benefit us in anyway! Keresia Jones 6780 kiby arms drive 1/27/25, 9:19 AM Mail - Christion, Chloe - Outlook https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADM3YmYxNzI4LWY1NjUtNDlmNy1hYWE1LTZjNjAzMWRkYzBmOQAQAAQUiUPbY9VJjV4FIkxl%2… 1/1 East Service Center: 6465 Mullins Station Rd; Memphis, T ennessee 38134 Downtown Service Center: 125 N. Main Street; Memphis, Tennessee 38103 website: www.develop901.com Memphis and Shelby County Division of Planning and Development Record Summary for Rezoning Record Detail Information Record Type : Rezoning Record Status: Processing Opened Date: September 12, 2024 Record Number: Z 2024-009 Record Name: Riverdale & HWY 385 Expiration Date: Description of Work: REZONING Parent Record Number: Address: 381 15 Owner Information Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone Y F ARRELL PROPERTIES (PSO) 2174 E PERSON AVE, MEMPHIS, TN 38114 Parcel Information 093500 00627 Data Fields PREAPPLICATION MEETING Name of DPD Planner Chloe Christion Date of Meeting 10/07/2024 Pre- application Meeting Type Phone GENERAL INFORMATION Have you held a neighborhood meeting? No Is this application in response to a citation from Construction Code Enforcement or Zoning Letter? No If yes, please provide additional information - GIS INFORMATION Page 1 of 3 Z 2024-009 GIS INFORMATION Case Layer - Central Business Improvement District No Class R Downtown Fire District No Historic District - Land Use VACANT Municipality - Overlay/Special Purpose District - Zoning R-8 State Route 1 Lot - Subdivision - Planned Development District - Wellhead Protection Overlay District Y es County Commission District - City Council District - City Council Super District - Data T ables ADDRESS AND P ARCEL LIST Property Parcel Number: 093500 00627 Property Address: 0 Mount Moriah Contact Information PRENTISS MITCHELL (901)305-5000 APPLICANT Name Address Phone Contact T ype Fee Information Date AssessedBalanceStatusFeesQuantityFee ItemInvoice # 10/07/20240.00INVOICED750.001Residential Rezoning - 5 acres or less 1597845 10/07/20240.00INVOICED19.501Credit Card Use Fee (.026 x fee) 1597845 T otal Fee Invoiced: $769.50 Total Balance: $0.00 Payment Information Payment Amount Method of Payment Credit Card$769.50 Page 2 of 3 Z 2024-009 LEGAL DESCRIPTION INST: CY9742 BEGINNING AT A FOUND ½” IRON PIPE, SAID PIPE BEING THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF THE KIRBY MEADOWS SECTION D (77-46) SUBDIVISION, SAID POINT ALSO BEING IN THE EAST LINE OF THE KIRBY MEADOWS SECTION C (66-23) SUBDIVISION, ALSO HAVING TN STATE PLANE COORDINATES (NAD83) OF N:285302.74, E:820189.16, SAID POINT ALSO BEING 145.0 FEET NORTH OF THE CENTERLINE OF VALLEY PARK DR. (50’ R.O.W.); THENCE, N 03°57'07" E ALONG THE EAST LINE OF THE KIRBY MEADOWS SECTION C (66-23) SUBDIVISION FOR A DISTANCE OF 430.41 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF THE LENOX LAND PARK MEMPHIS LAND LP (20011299) TRACT THE FOLLOWING THREE (3) CALLS; THENCE, N 61°51'19" E PASSING A SET ½” IRON PIN WITH CAP AT A DISTANCE OF 2.0 FEET AND CONTINUING ON FOR A TOTAL DISTANCE OF 881.58 FEET TO A SET 1/2” IRON PIN WITH CAP; THENCE IN A SOUTHERLY DIRECTION WITH A NON-TANGENT CURVE TURNING TO THE RIGHT WITH A RADIUS OF 25.00 FEET, AN ARC LENGTH OF 34.71 FEET, AND HAVING A CHORD BEARING OF S 01°00'38" W AND A CHORD DISTANCE OF 31.99 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE IN A EASTERLY DIRECTION WITH A REVERSE NON-TANGENT CURVE TURNING TO THE LEFT WITH A RADIUS OF 75.00 FEET, AN ARC LENGTH OF 339.86 FEET, AND HAVING A CHORD BEARING OF S 89°05'16" E AND A CHORD DISTANCE OF 115.21 FEET TO A POINT, SAID POINT BEING IN THE SOUTH LINE OF THE STATE HIGHWAY 385; THENCE ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF THE STATE HIGHWAY 385 THE FOLLOWING FOUR (4) CALLS; THENCE, S 41°46'42" E FOR A DISTANCE OF 281.61 FEET TO A SET 1/2” IRON PIN WITH CAP; THENCE, S 44°26'59" E PASSING A SET 1/2” IRON PIN WITH CAP AT A DISTANCE OF 476.98 FEET AND CONTINUING ON FOR A TOTAL DISTANCE OF 506.98 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE, S 55°29'22" E FOR A DISTANCE OF 150.75 FEET TO A SET 1/2” IRON PIN WITH CAP; THENCE, S 49°58'12" E FOR A DISTANCE OF 130.41 FEET TO A FOUND IRON PIN WITH A HOSHALL CAP; THENCE, S 03°43'47" W ALONG A WEST LINE OF THE SPIRIT MASTER FUNDING LLC (270-16) TRACT FOR A DISTANCE OF 197.07 FEET TO A FOUND IRON PIN WITH A HOSHALL CAP; THENCE, N 87°16'22" W ALONG A NORTH LINE OF THE SPIRIT MASTER FUNDING LLC (270-16) TRACT FOR A DISTANCE OF 240.34 FEET TO A FOUND IRON PIN WITH A HOSHALL CAP; THENCE ALONG THE NORTH LINE OF THE KIRBY MEADOWS SECTION D (77-46) SUBDIVISION THE FOLLOWING THREE (3) CALLS; THENCE, N 86°55'57" W FOR A DISTANCE OF 125.62 FEET TO A SET 1/2” IRON PIN WITH CAP; THENCE, N 69°40'46" W FOR A DISTANCE OF 62.98 FEET TO A SET 1/2” IRON PIN WITH CAP; THENCE, N 86°02'53" W FOR A DISTANCE OF 1253.97 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING CONTAINING 1000109.02 SQUARE FEET OR 22.96 ACRES MORE OR LESS. Page 3 of 3 Z 2024-009 Municipal Planner Land Use and Development Services Division of Planning and Development 125 N. Main, Ste. 477 Memphis, TN 38103 Delta Area Holdings LLC P.O. Box 488 Horn Lake, MS 38637 LETTER OF INTENT RE: 0 Mt Moriah, Memphis TN 38125 Department of Planning and Development, Delta Area Holdings LLC is applying for Rezoning at 0 Mt Moriah, Memphis TN 38125 (parcel # 093500 00627). Best Regards, Delta Area Holdings LLC NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING ON PROPOSED AMENDMENT TO THE ZONING MAP OF THE CITY OF MEMPHIS Notice is hereby given that a Public Hearing will be held by the City Council of the City of Memphis in the Council Chambers, First Floor, City Hall, 125 North Main Street, Memphis, Tennessee 38103 on Tuesday, __April 8, 2025__ at 4:00 P.M., in the matter of amending the Zoning Map of the City of Memphis, being Chapter 28, Article IV of the Code of Ordinances, City of Memphis, Tennessee, as amended, as follows: CASE NUMBER: Z 2024-009 LOCATION: 0 Mt. Moriah Ext., north of Kirby Terrace Drive COUNCIL DISTRICTS: District 2 and Super District 9 – Positions 1, 2, and 3 OWNER/APPLICANT: Prentiss Mitchell REPRESENTATIVE: N/A REQUEST: Rezoning of +/ -22.96 acres from Residential Single -Family – 8 (R -8), Residential Urban – 2 (RU-2), Conservation Agriculture (CA) and Residential Single-Family – 15 (R-15) to Commercial Mixed-Use – 3 (CMU-3) RECOMMENDATIONS: Memphis and Shelby County Division of Planning and Development: Rejection Memphis and Shelby County Land Use Control Board: Rejection NOW, THEREFORE, you will take notice that on Tuesday, April 8, 2025 , at 4:00 P.M. the City Council of the City of Memphis, Tennessee will be in session at the City Hall, Council Chambers, 125 North Main Street, Memphis, Tennessee 38103 to hear remonstrance’s or protests against the making of such changes; such remonstrance’s or protests must be by personal appearances, or by attorneys, or by petition, and then and there you will be present if you wish to remonstrate or protest against the same. THIS THE ____________________, ____________ FORD CANALE _ CHAIRMAN OF COUNCIL ATTEST: _KAMETRIS WYATT_ CITY COMPTROLLER TO BE PUBLISHED: Legend polygonLayer Override 1 Override 2 polygonLayer Override 1 Roads Parcels 0 0.08 0.16 0.24 0.32 mi Map prepared through Shelby County Government's online mapping Portal on 3/7/2025 ¯

Source: City of Memphis website. First collected Oct 27, 2026.