RecordWell Data

Board of Zoning Appeals — Agenda Packet

Williamson County · Williamson County · Board of Zoning Appeals · meeting of Oct 1, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Williamson County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

City of Franklin Meeting Agenda Board of Zoning Appeals Mailing Address: 109 3rd Ave S Franklin, TN 37064 (615) 791-3217 Thursday, October 1, 2026 6:00 PM Eastern Flank Event Facility City of Franklin Page 1 Notice is hereby given that a meeting of the Board of Zoning Appeals will be held on the date, time, and meeting location listed above. Additional information can be found at www.franklintn.gov/planning. For accommodations due to disabilities or other special arrangements, please contact the Human Resources Department at (615) 791-3216, at least 24 hours prior to the meeting. Accommodations have been made to ensure that the public is able to participate in the meeting. The public may participate in the following ways: • Watch the meeting on FranklinTV or the City of Franklin website. • Watch the live stream through the City of Franklin Facebook and YouTube accounts. • Email comments to planningintake@franklintn.gov to be provided in full to the Commission and included in the minutes, but not read aloud in their entirety during the meeting. Emailed comments are accepted until 12:00 PM (noon) on the day before the meeting. • Comment in-person at Eastern Flank Event Facility. Speakers will be asked to fill out a speaker card prior to the meeting starting. Speakers may sit in the Event Facility. CALL TO ORDER CITIZEN COMMENTS (Open for citizens to be heard on any issue or concern, including those related to items on the agenda. Please submit a Speaker Card at the beginning of the meeting if you would like to address the Commission. If you would like to speak on an agenda item, the Chair will hold your comment until the public comment period associated with the item. As provided by law, the Commission shall make no decisions or consideration of action of citizen comments for items not on the agenda, except to refer the matter to the Planning Director/Staff for administrative consideration, or to a schedule the matter for consideration at a later date. Those addressing the Commission are requested to come to the microphone and identify themselves by name and address for the official record. The Chair may restrict the period for public comment, including the length of the public comment period, the number of individuals who can speak and the length of time each individual may speak. When time allows, the standard individual public comment time is two minutes.) Comments on agenda items may be made in person or by emailing PlanningIntake@FranklinTN.gov before noon on the day of the meeting. Emailed comments will be provided to the Commission and included in the minutes, but not read aloud in their entirety during the meeting. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1. Consideration Of Approval Of The September 3, 2026, BZA Minutes. ANNOUNCEMENTS APPLICATIONS Page 1 of 72 Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Agenda October 1, 2026 2. A Variance Request To Allow One Additional Drive Aisle and Three Additional Rows Of Parking Bays Within The Franklin Road Frontage Area For An Existing Principal Building, and a Variance Request To Allow Two Additional Drive Aisles and Four Additional Rows Of Parking Bays Within The Franklin Road Frontage Area For A Proposed Principal Building For The Property Located At 1213 Country Road (FZO 7.4.) Sponsors: Amy Diaz-Barriga, Ariella Parker 3. A Variance Request To Allow The Front Facades Of 3 Proposed Principal Buildings To Be Oriented Up To 12 Degrees Non-Parallel To The Frontage For The Property Located At Tax Map 089 Parcel 04801 (FZO 6.9.). Sponsors: Amy Diaz-Barriga, Ariella Parker 4. A Variance Request To Allow A Retaining Wall To Be Located A Minimum Of 1.37 Feet From The Side Lot Line For The Property Located At 1316 Buckingham Circle, and a Variance Request To Allow A Retaining Wall To Be Located A Minimum Of 0 Feet From The Rear Lot Line For The Property Located At 1316 Buckingham Circle, and a Variance Request To Allow A Retaining Wall To Be Located A Minimum Of 0 Feet From The Side Lot Line For Parcel 079A-B-01400 (FZO 13.2.2.). Sponsors: Amy Diaz-Barriga, Ariella Parker OTHER BUSINESS ADJOURN Anyone needing accommodations due to disabilities please contact the ADA Coordinator at 615-791-3277 at least 24 hours prior to the meeting. Page 2 of 72 City of Franklin Meeting Minutes Board of Zoning Appeals 109 3rd Ave S Franklin, TN 37064 (615) 791-3217 Thursday, September 3, 2026 6:00 PM Eastern Flank Event Facility City of Franklin Page 1 Notice is hereby given that a meeting of the Board of Zoning Appeals will be held on the date, time, and meeting location listed above. Additional information can be found at www.franklintn.gov/planning. For accommodations due to disabilities or other special arrangements, please contact the Human Resources Department at (615) 791-3216, at least 24 hours prior to the meeting. Accommodations have been made to ensure that the public is able to participate in the meeting. The public may participate in the following ways: • Watch the meeting on FranklinTV or the City of Franklin website. • Watch the live stream through the City of Franklin Facebook and YouTube accounts. • Email comments to planningintake@franklintn.gov to be provided in full to the Commission and included in the minutes, but not read aloud in their entirety during the meeting. Emailed comments are accepted until 12:00 PM (noon) on the day before the meeting. • Comment in-person at Eastern Flank Event Facility. Speakers will be asked to fill out a speaker card prior to the meeting starting. Speakers may sit in the Event Facility. CALL TO ORDER Chair Jonathan Langley called the meeting to order at 6:00 PM. Board Members Present: Jonathan Langley, Dorinda Smith, John Boehms, Jeff Fleishour, William Scales Board Members Absent: None Staff Present: Ariella Parker, Amy Diaz-Barriga, Bill Squires, William Holcomb CITIZEN COMMENTS (Open for citizens to be heard on any issue or concern, including those related to items on the agenda. Please submit a Speaker Card at the beginning of the meeting if you would like to address the Commission. If you would like to speak on an agenda item, the Chair will hold your comment until the public comment period associated with the item. As provided by law, the Commission shall make no decisions or consideration of action of citizen comments for items not on the agenda, except to refer the matter to the Planning Director/Staff for administrative consideration, or to a schedule the matter for consideration at a later date. Those addressing the Commission are requested to come to the microphone and identify themselves by name and address for the official record. The Chair may restrict the period for public comment, including the length of the public comment period, the number of individuals who can speak and the length of time each individual may speak. When time allows, the standard individual public comment time is two minutes.) Chair Langley asked for citizen comments. There were none. Comments on agenda items may be made in person or by emailing PlanningIntake@FranklinTN.gov before noon on the day of the meeting. Emailed comments will be provided to the Commission and included in the minutes, but not read aloud in their entirety during the meeting. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1. Consideration Of Approval Of The August 6, 2026, BZA Minutes. Sponsors: Board Member Smith motioned to approve the August 6, 2026, BZA Meeting Minutes, seconded by Commissioner Scales. The motion carried 5-0. ANNOUNCEMENTS Chair Langley asked if Staff had any announcements. There were none. Page 3 of 72 Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Agenda September 3, 2026 APPLICATIONS 2. A Variance Request To Allow A 9-Foot Encroachment Into The Required 30-Foot Rear Yard Setback For An Addition To An Existing Principal Building For The Property Located At 309 Scottish Court (F.Z.O. 3.6.5.) Sponsors: Amy Diaz-Barriga, Ariella Parker Staff: Ariella Parker. Ms. Parker stated that The subject property is located at 309 Scottish Court and is zoned R-3 Residential 3 District. The applicant is proposing an addition to the rear of the existing house on the property. The R-3 zoning district requires 30-foot rear yard setbacks, and the proposed addition would be 21 feet from the rear property line at its closest point. For this reason, the applicant is requesting a variance to allow a 9-foot encroachment into the 30-foot rear yard setback. Staff Analysis The BZA may authorize a variance only when the request has met all three criteria in accordance with F.Z.O §20.10.6 and State law. Criteria #1. Where, by reason of exceptional narrowness, shallowness, or shape of a specific piece of property at the time of the enactment of the Zoning Ordinance or by reason of exceptional topographic conditions or other extraordinary and exceptional situation or condition, such a piece of property is not able to accommodate development as required under this Ordinance. The shape of the lot combined with the location of the existing house creates a unique situation in this case. The lot is not a typical rectangle shape: it's more narrow at the front of the lot since it's at the end of a cul-de-sac, and the front lot line doesn't parallel the rear lot line, so in order to have the house face the street, it does not parallel the rear lot line. In addition, the existing house was designed to be wider, so it is located further back on the lot to fit within the setbacks, and is located very close to the required minimum rear setback. Due to these unique conditions, this lot would not be able to accommodate an addition to the house as required under this Ordinance. Staff find this criteria is met. Criteria #2. The strict application of any provision enacted under the Zoning Ordinance would result in peculiar and exceptional practical difficulties for or exceptional or undue hardship for the owner of the property. The strict application of any provision enacted under the Zoning Ordinance would result in peculiar and exceptional practical difficulties for or exceptional or undue hardship for the owner of the property. Criteria #3. Such relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without substantially impairing the purpose and intent of the Zoning Ordinance. Staff find that this would not be a detriment to the public good or impair the intent of the Zoning Ordinance. Rear setbacks are intended to be a buffer between houses and the properties behind them. Most of the addition is within the required rear setback, and the proposed encroachment still leaves a significant amount of buffer between this house and the neighboring property behind. In addition, the neighboring lots are not uniform in orientation, and the addition is behind the house, so it will likely not Principal Building Setbacks Minimum Rear Yard 30 feet be visible from the street. For these reasons, the addition would not have a significant effect on the neighboring properties. Staff find this criteria is met. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends the Board of Zoning Appeals move to approve the Variance Request To Allow A 9-Foot Encroachment Into The Required 30-Foot Rear Yard Setback For An Addition To An Existing Principal Building For The Property Located At 309 Scottish Court, because the criteria for granting a variance have been met. Applicant: William Heard. Mr. Heard was present to answer any questions but did not have any new information to add. Citizen Comments: None MOTION Board Member Smith motioned to close the public comment, seconded by Board Member Scales. The motion carried 5-0. MOTION Board Member Smith motioned to approve A Variance Request To Allow A 9-Foot Encroachment Into The Required 30-Foot Rear Yard Setback For An Addition To An Existing Principal Building For The Property Located Page 4 of 72 Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Agenda September 3, 2026 At 309 Scottish Court because the criteria for granting a variance request has been met, seconded by Board Member Boehms. The motion carried by a vote of 5-0. 3. A Variance Request To Allow A 8-Foot Encroachment Into The 38-Foot Landscape And Drainage Easement For A Swimming Pool For The Property Located At 3012 Blossom Trail Lane (F.Z.O. 5.2.7.O.2.) Sponsors: Amy Diaz-Barriga, Ariella Parker Board Member Smith recused herself from this item. Staff: Ariella Parker. Ms. Parker stated that the subject property is located at 3012 Blossom Trail Lane and is zoned PD Planned District, within the Blossom Park Subdivision. There is a 38-foot Landscape and Drainage Easement along the rear lot line. The easement was established at 38 feet because the neighboring lot to the west used to be much larger, and it was required as an incompatible use buffer in the development plan. It was ultimately platted as a Landscape and Drainage Easement, but the same buffer would not be required today, since the neighboring lot to the west has since been developed with residential lots similar in size to this lot. Staff has confirmed with the Engineering department that 20 feet of the easement is still required for drainage, and the plat requires 6 canopy trees to be on the lot. The applicant is proposing a swimming pool in the backyard which would encroach 8 feet into the 38-foot easement. This leaves the required space for drainage, and they are not proposing to remove any canopy trees. Criteria #1 Staff Analysis The exceptional situation in this case is that there is an easement that is larger than would currently be required today, because it was based on conditions that have now changed. The easement takes up the majority of the backyard space, and the space would otherwise be usable for a pool. Since they are still held to the platted easement, they would not be able to put a swimming pool in the backyard. Staff find this criteria is met. Criteria #2 Staff Analysis The strict application of the Zoning Ordinance is preventing the applicant from putting in a swimming pool. The exceptional hardship in this case is that, by today's regulations, the easement would not be required to be as deep, and the swimming pool would likely be allowed. Staff find that this criteria is met. Criteria #3 Staff Analysis Staff find that this request would not be a detriment to the public good or impair the intent of the Zoning Ordinance. The pool does not encroach any closer to the neighbors than would be required by today's standards, and the tree canopy along the rear lot line will remain and provide a buffer between this property and the property behind. The intent of the ordinance in this case is to prevent swimming pools from impairing the intent of easements that have been established for a specific purpose. The purpose of this easement was for drainage, landscape, and as a buffer to the property behind it. This request would not impair the 20 feet needed for drainage, the required trees will remain, and the Zoning Ordinance criteria for requiring an incompatible use buffer have changed. Staff find this criteria is met. Recommendation Staff recommends the Board of Zoning Appeals move to approve the Variance Request To Allow A 8-Foot Encroachment Into The 38-Foot Landscape And Drainage Easement For A Swimming Pool For The Property Located At 3012 Blossom Trail Lane, because the criteria for granting a variance have been met. Applicant: Jenny Lewis. Citizen Comments: None MOTION Board Member Boehms motioned to close the public comment, seconded by Board Member Scales. The motion carried by a vote of 4-0. MOTION Board Member Scales motioned to approve A Variance Request To Allow A 8-Foot Encroachment Into The 38- Foot Landscape And Drainage Easement For A Swimming Pool For The Property Located At 3012 Blossom Trail Page 5 of 72 Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Agenda September 3, 2026 Lane because the criteria for granting a variance request has been met, seconded by Board Member Fleishour. The motion carried by a vote of 4-0. 4. A Variance Request To Allow The Front Façade Location Of The Proposed Principal Buildings To Be Oriented In A Non-Parallel Manner To The Frontage, And A Variance Request To Allow Parking Area Drive Aisles To Encroach Into The 150-Foot Scenic Corridor Overlay Front Setback Along Ernest Rice Lane, And A Variance Request To Allow A Building To Encroach Into The 150-Foot Scenic Corridor Overlay Front Setback Along Ernest Rice Lane, And A Variance Request To Allow Engineered Grading Within The 150-Foot Scenic Corridor Overlay Front Setback Along Ernest Rice Lane For The Property Located At 336 Ernest Rice Lane (F.Z.O. 6.12., 4.9.4., 4.9.7.). Sponsors: Amy Diaz-Barriga, Ariella Parker Staff: Ariella Parker. Ms. Parker stated The property is located at 336 Ernest Rice Lane, is zoned CI Civic and Institutional District, and has the 150-foot Scenic Corridor Overlay (SCO) along the front lot line of the property. Battle Ground Academy currently has a school campus built on this property, and they are proposing to expand their campus. The expansion of the campus does not meet the Zoning Ordinance in a few ways: 1) The proposed buildings are not parallel to the frontage. The existing campus buildings are not parallel to the frontage, and in order to integrate the new buildings well with the existing buildings, the proposed new buildings are also not parallel to the frontage. 2) There are 2 parking area drive aisles encroaching into the SCO. The applicant has stated that these drive aisles are necessary for campus security, Fire access, and life-safety. 3) The proposed Welcome Center (security checkpoint) is within the SCO. This is to maximize visibility from the street and to be closer to the street than all existing and proposed buildings and campus amenities for campus security. 4) Engineered grading is proposed in the SCO. Due to the location of existing stormwater features, and the topography of the site, grading is proposed within the SCO. The applicant is requesting 4 variances, one for each of the requests outlined above. Request 1: Allow The Front Façade Location Of The Proposed Principal Buildings To Be Oriented In A Non- Parallel Manner To The Frontage. Criteria #1 Staff Analysis The existing campus is a large collection of buildings that have been intentionally designed and coordinated with each other, and this campus grid was originally designed around a building that is listed on the National Register of Historic Places, which is not parallel to the frontage. The new buildings are proposed to fit that same orientation. The exceptional situation in this case is that the property is already developed with a large campus of buildings that are all oriented in the same manner, which is not parallel to the frontage. Staff finds this criteria is met. Criteria #2 Staff Analysis To comply with the Zoning Ordinance, the new buildings would not fit the context of the existing campus. This would affect the view of the campus from the street, and would likely affect the pedestrian circulation and open spaces on the site. The new buildings would not look cohesive with the rest of the buildings on site, which have been intentionally designed to look cohesive thus far. Staff find this criteria is met. Criteria #3 Staff Analysis Staff find that this request is not a detriment to the public good and would not substantially impair the intent of the Zoning Ordinance. Having the new buildings oriented in the same manner as the rest of the campus would improve the view of the campus from the street, which would have a positive effect on the public, not negative. The intent of the Zoning Ordinance in this case is for buildings to be well-designed in a manner that orients buildings towards the street and to have consistency in design. This request meets the intent of the Zoning Ordinance by ensuring the new buildings are well-designed to fit the context of the existing campus and the buildings are not extremely non-parallel to the frontage, so the orientation is still towards the street. In addition, the orientation would be more noticeably inconsistent with the context of the property if they were parallel and didn't fit the existing grid of the campus. Staff find this criteria is met. Request #2. To Allow Parking Area Drive Aisles To Encroach Into The 150-Foot Scenic Corridor Overlay Front Setback Along Ernest Rice Lane. Page 6 of 72 Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Agenda September 3, 2026 Criteria #1 Staff Analysis With the existing buildings and campus amenities, there are limited places on the lot to put new buildings. The front of the lot is the only place with room for the new buildings, but there is no room to also accommodate the parking area drive aisles that are needed for school drop-offs and pick-ups, and fire safety. With the existing buildings on the lot and this being a unique use with specific needs for their entrance, this property cannot accommodate development as required under this ordinance. Staff find this criteria is met. Criteria #2 Staff Analysis For the parking area drive aisle not to encroach into the SCO, the fire requirements and traffic function would be compromised. The applicant worked with the fire department to ensure the proposed design meets their standards for access. The width of the entrance drive loop is the minimum width required for fire lanes, and the increased length of the entrance loop provides the necessary stacking length for cars dropping off and picking up students, which is essential for the school drop-off area. The field house drive provides vehicular circulation around the building. Without these drive aisles, there wouldn't be proper circulation and fire access to the new buildings. Staff find this criteria is met. Criteria #3 Staff Analysis Staff find that this request is not a detriment to the public good and would not substantially impair the intent of the Zoning Ordinance. Ensuring proper circulation and fire access to the new buildings is a benefit to the public. The intent of this ordinance is to protect the city's natural beauty along scenic corridors, by minimizing disturbance in them. The applicant has made an effort to minimize the amount of disturbance, including the drive aisles, being within the SCO. There will also be landscaping that will partially screen the drive aisles from the street. This shows an effort to meet this Zoning Ordinance regulation. Staff find this criteria is met. Request #3. Allow A Building To Encroach Into The 150-Foot Scenic Corridor Overlay Front Setback Along Ernest Rice Lane. Criteria #1 Staff Analysis While the existing buildings and campus amenities limit the places on the lot to put new buildings, it seems to staff that the security checkpoint could be pushed back further to not be within the SCO. Staff believe that this property could possibly accommodate development as required under this ordinance. Staff find this criteria is not met. Criteria #2 Staff Analysis If the security checkpoint were located farther back so that it's outside the SCO, it would be less visible from the street and vehicles may not know to go through the security checkpoint to access the campus. Since this may cause confusion related to campus security, this could be a practical difficulty. Staff find this criteria is met. Criteria #3 Staff Analysis Staff find that this would not be a detriment to the public good but may impair the intent of the Zoning Ordinance. The intent of this ordinance is to protect the city's natural beauty along scenic corridors, by minimizing disturbance in them. The applicant has stated that the building needs to be closer to the street to be visible for security purposes, but also that it will have screening so that it has a minimal visible impact. Based on the importance of the building being visible from the street to serve its purpose, this seems to impair the intent of preserving the natural beauty of the scenic corridor. Staff find this criteria is not met. Request #4. To Allow Engineered Grading Within The 150-Foot Scenic Corridor Overlay Front Setback Along Ernest Rice Lane. Criteria #1 Staff Analysis There are existing stormwater features within the SCO and additional stormwater features are proposed in the SCO due to the topography of the site. The low point of the property is at the front of the lot, so the existing and proposed stormwater features are naturally located there, within the SCO. The existing topography and stream buffers at the low point of the site do not give adequate depth to meet City bio-retention and detention requirements, so grading is being proposed to meet the city requirements. The proposed grading practices mimic the existing flow of the site and the bio-retention and detention depths ensure the stream has improved water quality and downstream structures are unharmed. Since the engineered grading proposed is based on the existing stormwater features and the topography of the site, Staff finds this criteria is met. Criteria #2 Staff Analysis Without the engineered grading in the SCO, the campus would likely not meet the water quality and quantity standards of the city. The site needs additional stormwater features on the site and the topography of the site requires it to be in the SCO. Staff find this criteria is met. Page 7 of 72 Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Agenda September 3, 2026 Criteria #3 Staff Analysis Staff find that this request is not a detriment to the public good and would not substantially impair the intent of the Zoning Ordinance. The proposed grading is minimal, below grade, and will likely not be noticeable from the street. Staff find this criteria is met. Recommendation: Staff recommends the Board of Zoning Appeals move to approve the Variance Request To Allow The Front Façade Location Of The Proposed Principal Buildings To Be Oriented In A Non-Parallel Manner To The Frontage, And approve the Variance Request To Allow Parking Area Drive Aisles To Encroach Into The 150-Foot Scenic Corridor Overlay Front Setback Along Ernest Rice Lane, And disapprove the Variance Request To Allow A Building To Encroach Into The 150-Foot Scenic Corridor Overlay Front Setback Along Ernest Rice Lane, And approve the Variance Request To Allow Engineered Grading Within The 150-Foot Scenic Corridor Overlay Front Setback Along Ernest Rice Lane, because the criteria for granting a variance have been met. Applicant: Gary Vogrin. Mr. Vogrin stated that the team agrees with staff comments other than the variance request for the location of the Welcome Center, which is located within the 150’ scenic corridor overlay. The purpose of the Welcome Center is to provide security for students and staff members. Mr. Vogrin explained that the building would be 15’x15’ resting inside the SCO by 48’. Mr. Vogrin explained that the building would be surrounded by landscaping and, paired with the existing trees, will maintain the scenic corridor and not be a detriment to the SCO. Citizen Comments: Rob Grzech, 1110 Gray Fox Lane. Mr. Grzech stated that he lives within 500 feet of the school campus and has concerns about extra traffic that will be created with the addition of new buildings. Mr. Grzech stated that the architectural drawings are beautiful, and he has no animosity toward the school. Mr. Grzech asked the Board if a traffic study had been completed and if Fire and Police had been consulted regarding traffic safety. Pamela Hand, 1158 Echo Lane. Ms. Hand stated that many of her neighbors did not receive notification of this meeting. Ms. Hand explained that her main concern is the additional traffic that will be created and asked about a traffic plan. Ms. Hand noted that during school dismissal it can take as long as 30-45 minutes to get through traffic. MOTION Board Member Smith motioned to close the public comment, seconded by Board Member Boehms. The motion carried by a vote of 5-0. Chair Langley stated that each variance request will be discussed individually. Board Member Boehms asked if a traffic study had been completed and asked Mr. Vogrin how security will be different from the current security on Echo Lane. Ms. Diaz-Barriga stated that a site plan had not been submitted yet as the applicant chose to begin the process with variance requests. Once a site plan is submitted, a traffic study may be required. Mr. Vogrin stated that Echo Lane does not have a security building but has existing gates that can be closed and opened and are not manned. Mr. Vogrin further stated that all access points to the school would come through the Welcome Center. Board Member Smith asked if all access points will be gated and stated that gates are not shown at the Welcome Center. Mr. Vogrin confirmed that all entry points to the school would be gated including the Welcome Center. The Welcome Center is proposed to be located along the divided boulevard so that cars may easily turn around if they are denied access. Board Member Fleishour asked Mr. Vogrin how the 48’ of encroachment into the scenic corridor overlay benefits the security building and why the building is proposed in that location. Mr. Vogrin stated that the location of the Welcome Center is important for visibility and clarity to drivers that they must stop and check in. Additionally, Mr. Vogrin noted that the location allows for better traffic flow for vehicles entering and exiting the campus. Page 8 of 72 Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Agenda September 3, 2026 MOTION Request 1: Allow The Front Façade Location Of The Proposed Principal Buildings To Be Oriented In A Non- Parallel Manner To The Frontage. Board Member Smith motioned to approve Request #1 a Variance request to Allow The Front Façade Location Of The Proposed Principal Buildings To Be Oriented In A Non-Parallel Manner To The Frontage because the criteria to grant a variance request have been met, seconded by Board Member Boehms. The motion carried by a vote of 5-0. MOTION Request #2. To Allow Parking Area Drive Aisles To Encroach Into The 150-Foot Scenic Corridor Overlay Front Setback Along Ernest Rice Lane. Board Member Boehms motioned to approve a Request #2 a Variance Request To Allow Parking Area Drive Aisles To Encroach Into The 150-Foot Scenic Corridor Overlay Front Setback Along Ernest Rice Lane because the criteria to grant a variance request have been met, seconded by Board Member Smith. The motion carried by a vote of 5-0. MOTION Request #3. To Allow A Building To Encroach Into The 150-Foot Scenic Corridor Overlay Front Setback Along Ernest Rice Lane. Board Member Smith motioned to approve Request #3 a Variance Request To Allow A Building To Encroach Into The 150-Foot Scenic Corridor Overlay Front Setback Along Ernest Rice Lane because the criteria to grant a variance request have been met, seconded by Board Member Scales. Discussion Board Member Smith stated that she appreciates staff comments, but the security of students must be priority number one and by having the Welcome Center closer to the road, it is clearly visible to pedestrian and vehicular traffic. Board Member Boehms stated that he has concerns about the security along Echo Lane and asked if the new parking and new building would also be gated. Mr. Boehms further stated that there are other areas on campus that need to be addressed regarding security. Lastly, Mr. Boehms stated that it appears there is room to move the Welcome Center back so that the building does not encroach the scenic corridor overlay. Ms. Diaz-Barriga stated that the application plan shows a gate at the Welcome Center and a gate at Ernest Rice Lane (loop drive in front of new structure) with the applicant’s intention to gate other entrances, although a gate is not shown by the fieldhouse (without a site plan submittal). Ms. Diaz-Barriga stated that she was not sure about the security measures for Echo Lane as a public road. Mr. Vogrin explained that at this stage, as part of the larger plan for expansion, the focus has been on security with the next stage focused on road circulation (public vs. private road), grading and drainage aspects. The top priority and intent of the school is to secure all access points on the campus. Board Member Fleishour asked if Mr. Vogrin could provide any insight regarding traffic relief for the people who live along Echo Lane. Mr. Vogrin stated that the site plan submittal will address traffic, grading, and drainage along with other requirements related to the site plan. Chair Langley asked staff to summarize the requirements of a site plan. Ms. Diaz-Barriga stated that the site plan will include all construction documents including building plans, grading, stormwater management and landscape requirements. The site plan must meet the requirements of the city of Franklin and all design standards. Ms. Diaz-Barriga also stated that traffic is often included and summarized engineering requirements regarding the minimum daily trips that must occur to trigger a requirement for a traffic study. The engineering director may also request a traffic study be completed. Ms. Diaz-Barriga also noted that this site is zoned as CI meaning the site plan will be reviewed by the Planning Commission (FMPC) to specifically address whether the plan meets the design standards required by the city. With no further discussion, the motion for Request #3 carried by a vote of 3–2 with Board Members Boehms and Fleishour voting against. Page 9 of 72 Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Agenda September 3, 2026 MOTION Request #4. To Allow Engineered Grading Within The 150-Foot Scenic Corridor Overlay Front Setback Along Ernest Rice Lane. Board Member Scales motioned to approve Request #4 a Variance Request To Allow Engineered Grading Within The 150-Foot Scenic Corridor Overlay Front Setback Along Ernest Rice Lane because the criteria for granting a variance request have been met, seconded by Board Member Boehms. The motion carried by a vote of 5-0. OTHER BUSINESS Chair Langley asked if there was any further business. There was none. ADJOURN Board Member Smith motioned to adjourn the September 3, 2026, BZA Meeting, seconded by Board Member Fleishour. The motion carried by a vote of 5-0. The meeting adjourned at 6:49 PM. ___________________________ ____________ Chair Date Page 10 of 72 Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Agenda September 3, 2026 Page 11 of 72 City of Franklin Page 1 of 4 City of Franklin 109 3rd Ave S. Franklin, TN 37064 (615) 791-3217 File #: 26-01182 DATE: 10/1/2026 TO: Board of Zoning Appeals FROM: Amy Diaz-Barriga, Asst Director of Planning Development Ariella Parker, Planner SUBJECT: A Variance Request To Allow One Additional Drive Aisle and Three Additional Rows Of Parking Bays Within The Franklin Road Frontage Area For An Existing Principal Building, and a Variance Request To Allow Two Additional Drive Aisles and Four Additional Rows Of Parking Bays Within The Franklin Road Frontage Area For A Proposed Principal Building For The Property Located At 1213 Country Road (FZO 7.4.) PURPOSE: PROJECT INFORMATION COF Project Number: 9230 Applicant: Drew Stokes Owner: Will Tyner, Cross Point Church BACKGROUND/STAFF COMMENTS: Vicinity Zoning/Land Use Site: Civic and Institutional CI District / Civic/Institutional (church) North: Residential R-1 District / Single Family Residential South: Planned PD District, Residential R-1 District / Multifamily Residential (condominium), Estate Residential East: Planned PD District / Multifamily Residential (apartments) West: Civic and Institutional CI District, Planned PD District / Civic/Institutional (church), Single Family Residential Applicable Zoning Ordinance Provisions 20.10 Variance A. The purpose of a variance is to: 1. Provide limited relief from the requirements of this Ordinance in cases where strict application of a particular requirement would create an unnecessary hardship prohibiting the use of land in a manner otherwise allowed under this Ordinance; and 2. Address extraordinary, exceptional, or unique situations that were not caused by the applicant's Page 12 of 72 act or omission. B. Variances are not intended merely to remove inconviences or financial burdens that the requirements of this Ordinance may impose on property owners in general. 7.4 Parking Frontage Parking Placement: A maximum of 2 bays of parking with a single drive aisle shall be permitted between the building and the street. Background The subject property is located at 1213 Country Road, is zoned Civic and Institutional (CI) district, and is within the Scenic Corridor Overlay (SCO), Flood Fringe Overlay (FFO), Hillside/Hillcrest Overlay (HHO), and the 500' Buffer of the Hillside Overlay. The property also has two streams on the property with Riparian Buffers around them. The property has an existing church building with associated parking, and the applicant is proposing a new church building and additional parking. Staff has determined that the property frontage is facing Franklin Road, and CI zoning allows parking frontage. The parking in the frontage area of the existing building is legally nonconforming, since it was built prior to our frontage requirements. Since the existing building has legally nonconforming parking in the frontage area, any expansion of the parking must comply with the regulations of the Zoning Ordinance. Since the applicant is proposing to add additional parking spaces in the frontage area of the existing building, the applicant must request a variance for the parking in front of the existing building. The new building must also comply with the regulations of the Zoning Ordinance. Parking frontage allows a maximum of 2 bays of parking with a single drive aisle, so the applicant is also requesting a variance for the additional parking being requested in the frontage area for the proposed building. Staff Analysis The BZA may authorize a variance only when the request has met all three criteria in accordance with F.Z.O §20.10.6 and State law. The staff has completed an analysis of the request in light of these criteria: Request 1: To Allow One Additional Drive Aisle and Three Additional Rows Of Parking Bays Within The Franklin Road Frontage Area For An Existing Principal Building 1. Where, by reason of exceptional narrowness, shallowness, or shape of a specific piece of property at the time of the enactment of the Zoning Ordinance or by reason of exceptional topographic conditions or other extraordinary and exceptional situation or condition, such a piece of property is not able to accommodate development as required under this Ordinance. This property has the HHO, 500' Buffer of HHO, riparian buffers, FFO, and SCO as unique conditions on the property. Additionally, the property is already developed with an existing church building, parking, and 2 detention ponds. With all these factors, there is very limited space for a new building and the necessary additional parking, and some of the new parking must be located in the frontage area of the existing church building. If it weren't for all the site conditions and the location of the existing building, parking could likely meet the Zoning Ordinance requirements. Staff finds this criteria is met. 2. The strict application of any provision enacted under the Zoning Ordinance would result in peculiar and exceptional practical difficulties for or exceptional or undue hardship for the owner of the property. The strict application of the Zoning Ordinance in this case would likely prevent the new building from being built, or there would not be room for the additional parking that the church has determined is necessary for the use. Staff finds this criteria is met. Page 13 of 72 3. Such relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without substantially impairing the purpose and intent of the Zoning Ordinance. Staff does not find that this request would be a detriment to the public good or impair the intent of the Zoning Ordinance. The additional parking is determined to be necessary for the church, and would ensure that there is sufficient on-site parking for the use. The intent of this regulation is to ensure that nonconforming development can expand, but that it would expand in a way that gets closer to our current development regulations, not further. The way that this additional parking makes the development of this property more nonconforming is that current frontage requirements do not allow the proposed amount of parking to be in the frontage area. The intent is that parking should be secondary to the building and its relationship to the street, and that views from the street should not be of parking lots. The intent of the Zoning Ordinance is to reinforce the principles of Envision Franklin, and in this case it's by only allowing a limited amount of parking in front of principal buildings. Since the existing church and its non-compliant parking in the frontage is almost completely screened from Franklin Road, and the additional parking in the frontage is not closer to the street than the existing parking in the frontage, Staff does not find that this would impair the intent of the Zoning Ordinance. Staff finds this criteria is met. Request 2: To Allow Two Additional Drive Aisles and Four Additional Rows Of Parking Bays Within The Franklin Road Frontage Area For A Proposed Principal Building 1. Where, by reason of exceptional narrowness, shallowness, or shape of a specific piece of property at the time of the enactment of the Zoning Ordinance or by reason of exceptional topographic conditions or other extraordinary and exceptional situation or condition, such a piece of property is not able to accommodate development as required under this Ordinance. This property has the HHO, 500' Buffer of HHO, riparian buffers, FFO, and SCO as unique conditions on the property. Additionally, the property is already developed with an existing church building, parking, and 2 detention ponds. The applicant has also stated that the proposed location of the new building ensures proper pedestrian and vehicular circulation, and fire and emergency access. With all these factors, there is very limited space for a new building and additional parking. This is a large 21 acre lot that would easily be able to accommodate 2 church buildings within the Zoning Ordinance requirements, if it weren't for the existing conditions. Staff finds this criteria is met. 2. The strict application of any provision enacted under the Zoning Ordinance would result in peculiar and exceptional practical difficulties for or exceptional or undue hardship for the owner of the property. The strict application of the Zoning Ordinance in this case would likely prevent the new building from being built and comply with emergency and fire access, given the existing conditions. Staff finds this criteria is met. 3. Such relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without substantially impairing the purpose and intent of the Zoning Ordinance. Staff does not find that this request would be a detriment to the public good or impair the intent of the Zoning Ordinance. The necessary location of the building results in a portion of the existing parking being in front of the new building. This portion of existing parking is fully screened from Franklin Road. The intent of the Zoning Ordinance in this case is that parking should be secondary to the building and its relationship to the street, and that views from the street should not be of parking lots. The intent of the Zoning Ordinance is to reinforce the principles of Envision Franklin, and in this case it's by only allowing a limited amount of parking in front of principal buildings. Since the parking in the Page 14 of 72 frontage area of this new building is existing today and is clearly fully screened front Franklin Road, Staff does not find that this would impair the intent of the Zoning Ordinance. Staff finds this criteria is met. FINANCIAL IMPACT: Unknown. RECOMMENDATION: RECOMMENDED MOTION: Staff recommends the Board of Zoning Appeals move to approve both the Variance Request To Allow One Additional Drive Aisle and Three Additional Rows Of Parking Bays Within The Franklin Road Frontage Area For An Existing Principal Building, and the Variance Request To Allow Two Additional Drive Aisles and Four Additional Rows Of Parking Bays Within The Franklin Road Frontage Area For A Proposed Principal Building For The Property Located At 1213 Country Road, because the criteria for granting a variance have been met. Page 15 of 72 Country Rd Sunrise Cir Century Oak Dr Elk Springs Ct Jackson Lake Dr Elk Hollow Ct £¤31 Brentwood Pointe Sunrise Cir Gateway Ct MooresCt Brentwood Pointe Brentwood Pointe Brentwood Pointe Country Rd Sunrise Cir Century Oak Dr Elk Springs Ct Jackson Lake Dr Elk Hollow Ct £¤31 Brentwood Pointe Sunrise Cir Gateway Ct MooresCt Brentwood Pointe Brentwood Pointe Brentwood Pointe Site Legend 1213 Country Road Hillside/Hillcrest Overlay 500 Ft Buffer of Hillside Floodway Fringe Overlay Scenic Corridor Overlay AG Agricultural District ER Estate Residential District R1 Residential 1 District R2 Residential 2 District R3 Residential 3 District R4 Residential 4 District R6 Residential 6 District MR Mixed Residential District PD Planned District OR Office Residential District CI Civic Institutional District NC Neighborhood Commercial District CC Central Commercial District DD Downtown District 1ST Avenue District 5TH Avenue District RC4 Regional Commerce 4 District RC6 Regional Commerce 6 District RC12 Regional Commerce 12 District GO General Office District LI Light Industrial District HI Heavy Industrial District Ü 0 500 1,000250 Feet This map was created by the Franklin Planning Department. It was compiled from the most authentic information available. The City is not responsible for any errors or omissions contained hereon. All data and materials (c) copyright 2026. All rights reserved. 1213 COUNTRY ROAD TAX MAP 053, PARCEL 05800 BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OCTOBER 1, 2026 Page 16 of 72 September 4, 2026 Ariella Parker, Planner Planning and Sustainability Department City of Franklin 120 9th Avenue South Franklin, TN 37064 Ms. Parker: Subject: Justification Letter – Variance Application Cross Point Church - Map 53 Parcel 58.00 1213 Country Road Franklin, Tennessee 37069 CEC Project 364-361 Civil & Environmental Consultants Inc. (CEC) is submitting a variance application on behalf of the applicant, Cross Point Church, for consideration to be heard by the Board of Zoning Appeals. The proposed expansion consists of an approximately 34,000- square-foot church building on the existing church campus at the subject address . This application requests a variance from the frontage requirements of the CI (Civic Institutional) District. History and Background The 21.86- acre site currently contains an approximately 14,000- square-foot existing church building, associated parking and drives, stormwater infrastructure, and a 1- story building along Franklin Road. Cross Point Church purchased this previously developed property in 2018. Since that time, the congregation has reached the functional capacity of the existing facilities. The past few years, the c hurch has explored various site plan alternates to expand the campus to serve additional attendees. Cross Point and CEC have worked together to create a conceptual plan that proposes a new building within the existing parking lot of the church. This location was selected to minimize impacts associated with riparian buffers, stormwater features, and existing topographic constraints while still allowing the existing church to remain open during the expansion construction. To View of site existing site and topography. Page 17 of 72 Ms. Parker – City of Franklin CEC Project 364-361 Page 2 September 4, 2026 satisfy parking requirements for the new larger building, additional parking is proposed adjacent to the existing parking and drive aisles. Site Constraints The property fronts Franklin Road where a 1-story structure exists. Dry Creek crosses the property from north to south between the Franklin Road fronting portion of the property and the portion of the campus accessed from Country Road. There is an associated Floodway Fringe Overlay spanning approximately 240 feet wide across the site. No vehicular or pedestrian connection currently exists between the Franklin Road frontage and the existing church building portion of the property. An unnamed stream flows east to west beginning at a headwall through an existing retaining wall near the southwest corner of the existing church building. This stream bisects the existing parking areas and includes an associated 30-foot riparian buffer that is required to remain undisturbed. No vehicular or pedestrian connection currently crosses the stream between the two parking areas. Due to the age of the development, the existing church building and parking encroach the riparian buffer. The existing church building is located near the center of the parcel and is accessed from Country Road. There is no access from the church directly to Franklin Road. Existing parking areas surround the church building on three sides and are not compliant with the frontage requirements. The existing building is to remain in place and occupied during and after the project. The development area on the property is located at the base of a hill that is currently protected by the Hilltop Hillside Overlay and the Hilltop Hillside 500-Foot Buffer. Within the Hilltop Hillside Buffer, naturally occurring slopes that are 14% or greater are required to be protected. This overlay, along with the slopes, limits the opportunity to expand the campus into the wooded portion of the property east of the existing development. The photo below shows the overlay districts currently on the site. Proposed plan of building with overlays shown. Page 18 of 72 Ms. Parker – City of Franklin CEC Project 364-361 Page 3 September 4, 2026 Variance Requests Cross Point Church respectfully requests that the Board of Zoning Appeals grant relie f from the following zoning requirements : 7.4 Parking Frontage – A maximum of two bays of parking with a single drive aisle shall be permitted between the building and the street. Cross Point Church requests: 1. To allow parking within the Franklin Road frontage area for a proposed principal building 2. To allow parking within the Franklin Road frontage area for an existing principal building The existing and proposed use is a place of public assembly. This use is a by-right use in the Civic Institutional Base District. The City of Franklin’s zoning ordinance requires a Yard Frontage, Parking Frontage, or Landscape Frontage. The existing site does not comply with any of these frontage types. Due to the property's unique topographic features, environmental constraints, and existing development pattern, compliance with the required frontage types presents significant practical difficulties. • Site Safety and Accessibility. The proposed building location maintains coordinated fire, vehicular, and pedestrian access within the existing developed campus. Alternative locations or substantial reconfiguration to achieve frontage compliance could disrupt required fire access, increase pedestrian and vehicle conflicts, or require additional improvements within environmentally constrained portions of the property. • Site Functionality and Circulation. The proposed building layout provides a single, clearly identifiable primary entrance serving both the existing and proposed facilities. Compliance with the Parking Frontage requirement would likely necessitate a less functional site layout, resulting in dispersed parking areas and multiple points of building access that diminish efficient circulation and campus cohesion. • Access During Construction. The proposed site layout places the new church building south of the existing facility, allowing access from Country Road to remain open and existing parking areas to the north and east to remain operational during construction. This approach minimizes disruption to ongoing church activities and community services while avoiding the need for temporary access modifications or additional site disturbance elsewhere on the property. Page 19 of 72 Ms. Parker – City of Franklin CEC Project 364-361 Page 4 September 4, 2026 The request is justified by either or both the following: (i ) the property is exceptional due to narrowness, shallowness, or shape of the property; or (ii) the property contains exceptional topographic conditions or other extraordinary or exceptional situations or conditions. As stated in the Site Constraints section, the site has steep slopes within the Hilltop Hillside Overlay Buffer, two streams with their associated riparian buffers crisscross the site, and the existing buildable area has already been previously developed. These conditions are inherent to the property and were not created by the proposed site design. The proposed building location responds directly to these conditions by utilizing an area that has been previously developed as parking lot. It also allows the existing building to remain in place and functional. The property’s unique combination of streams, floodplain, protected slopes, and existing development creates extraordinary and exceptional conditions that substantially limit and fragment the areas reasonably available for expansion. The strict application of the Zoning Ordinance would result in practical difficulties to or undue hardship upon the owner of the property (e.g., Why is your situation-not of personal or financial nature- not general applicable to the other properties throughout the city). Strict application of the Parking Frontage requirement would create practical difficulties due to the property's unique combination of steep slopes, stream corridors, riparian buffers, floodplain constraints, and existing site improvements. These physical conditions significantly limit the locations where a building can be reasonably sited while maintaining safe pedestrian access and minimizing impacts to environmentally sensitive areas. Strict frontage compliance would also either push development into environmentally or topographically constrained areas or materially reduce the area available for expansion, despite the proposed building occupying only approximately 5% of this nearly 22-acre property. As a result, strict compliance would require substantial reconfiguration of the existing developed campus and would materially impair the ability to expand while maintaining required fire and emergency access, safe site circulation, continued operation of the existing church building, and avoidance of environmentally sensitive areas. Strict application of the frontage requirement creates an undue hardship by materially limiting the reasonable expansion of the property despite the relatively modest scale of the proposed development. The relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without substantially impairing the intent and purpose of the Zoning Ordinance. Page 20 of 72 Ms. Parker – City of Franklin CEC Project 364-361 Page 5 September 4, 2026 Granting the requested variances will not be detrimental to the public good nor impair the intent and purpose of the Zoning Ordinance. The proposed building is located within the existing developed campus in a m anner that maintains safe pedestrian, vehicular, and emergency access while avoiding impacts to protected environmental features. It is also significant that the parking creating the requested frontage condition is overwhelmingly existing parking that currently serves the campus. The proposed development is not creating a substantial new parking field between the proposed building and the applicable frontage; rather, placement of the proposed building within the existing developed campus causes the established parking configuration to become subject to the Parking Frontage limitation. Additionally, the proposed building is located approximately 1,200 feet from Franklin Road, therefore, parking areas will remain substantially screened from public roadways due to existing foliage associated with two riparian buffers between Franklin Road and the proposed church which will preserve the visual character of the corridor. See photos below showing viewpoint s from Franklin Road and Country Road. View of Cross Point Church property from Franklin Road. Existing church building is behind the office shown in this photo. Page 21 of 72 Ms. Parker – City of Franklin CEC Project 364-361 Page 6 September 4, 2026 View from County Road south down the entrance drive. The existing church is behind the trees to the left. As a result, the requested variances relate primarily to an internal campus condition and will not create the type of parking-dominated public frontage the Parking Frontage standard is intended to prevent. If you have any additional questions or need anything else, please let me know. Thank you for your review. Sincerely, CIVIL & ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS, INC. Drew Stokes, P.E. Project Manager Page 22 of 72 IP(O)(DISTURBED) BACKFLOWMETERPIT CONC. WOODSHED FFE=726.21 STORYMASONRY GRAVEL ASPHALTPOSTSIGN WOODFENCEWOODDECK CONC.ROCKWALLYLYL LOT 1LURENE COOKP.B. P48, PG. 91MAP 53, PARCEL 60.00MASTER PLANS LLCBOOK 7033, PG. 979 LOT 2COUNTRY ROADS SUBDIVISIONP.B. 5, PG. 43MAP 53, PARCEL 61.00HUGHES FAMILY REVOCABLE TRUSTBOOK 7336, PG. 846 LOT 4COUNTRY ROADS SUBDIVISIONP.B. 5, PG. 43MAP 53, PARCEL 62.00BOB & KITTRA MARY MOOREBOOK 1476, PG. 531 LOT 6COUNTRY ROADS SUBDIVISIONP.B. 5, PG. 43MAP 53, PARCEL 63.00TROY DeMONBREUN & LORI MASSEY-DeMONBREUNBOOK 5974, PG. 164 LOT 19 OPEN SPACEMORNINGSIDE P.U.D. SUBDIVISION, SEC. 8P.B. P40, PG. 104MAP 53, PARCEL 99.16VIEW AT BRENTWOOD POINTE INC.BOOK 7662, PG. 835 MAP 53, PARCEL 57.00JOE LOCKEBOOK 453, PG. 521 20' PUDE PLAT 10' PUDE PLAT 10' PUBLIC UTILITY EASEMENT P.B. 5, PG. 43 10' PUBLIC UTILITY EASEMENT P.B. 5, PG. 43 10' PUBLIC UTILITY EASEMENT P.B. 5, PG. 43 50' LANDSCAPE BUFFER P.B. P51, PG. 45 50' LANDSCAPE BUFFER P.B. P51, PG. 45 PARCEL 58.00 PARCEL 59.00 PARCEL 57.01 PARCEL LINE OHOHOH 10''S10''S10''S10''S10''S10''S6''W OHOHOHOHOHOHOHOH CO CM(O) IP(O) IP(O) IP(O) IP(N) IP(N) IP(O) IP(O) 8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W 6''S6''S6''SUGPUGPUGPUGPUGP UGP IP(O) WELL 1 STORYMASONRY RISERPOLE E GUY WELL ASPHALT ASPHALT ASPHALTASPHALT ASPHALTASPHALT ASPHALTASPHALT HCHCHCHCHCHCHCHCBBBB CO CO CO COCOCOCOELECTRICMETER BOXACACFDCPLUG HANDRAILSFFE=744.2CONCRETEPADS FOR AC CONC.BLOCKWALLLS W.I. FENCEFFE=744.2FFE=743.9 FFE=744.2 BB GUY BACKFLOW TRANS COELECTRICBOX UTILITYLID ASPHALT ASPHALT GRAVEL WELL LOT 8COUNTRY ROADS SUBDIVISIONP.B. 5, PG. 43MAP 53, PARCEL 64.00KEVIN McKEHANBOOK 2659, PG. 917 LOT 5THE LANDINGS SUBDIVISIONP.B. 10, PG. 68MAP 53, PARCEL 77.01STAR BRENTWOOD LLCBOOK 6749, PG. 652 OPEN SPACEBRENTWOOD POINTE SEC 3P.B. P41, PG. 93MAP 53G, GROUP"A", PARCEL 2.03VIEW AT BRENTWOOD POINTE INC.BOOK 7662, PG. 835 LOT 19 OPEN SPACEMORNINGSIDE P.U.D. SUBDIVISION, SEC. 8P.B. P40, PG. 104MAP 53, PARCEL 99.16VIEW AT BRENTWOOD POINTE INC.BOOK 7662, PG. 835PARCEL 59.00PARCEL 57.01 50' LANDSCAPE BUFFER P.B. P51, PG. 45CM(O) IP(O) IP(O)IPIPE(O)IP(O) IP(O)IP(O)IP(O) IP(O) (DISTURBED)(DISTURBED) (DISTURBED) CM(O) PARCEL LINE 50' LANDSCAPE BUFFER P.B. P51, PG. 45 10' PUDE PLAT 10' PUBLIC UTILITY EASEMENT P.B. 5, PG. 43DETENTION POND EASEMENTP.B. P41, PG. 93 50' LANDSCAPE BUFFER P.B. P51, PG. 45 755755760750755 725730735740 720 RESIDENTIAL LAND USE RESIDENTIAL LAND USE RESIDENTIAL LAND USE RESIDENTIAL LAND USE RESIDENTIAL LAND USE RESIDENTIAL LAND USE RESIDENTIAL LAND USE RESIDENTIAL LAND USE RESIDENTIAL LAND USE MAP 53, PARCEL 56.01THERESA DOYLEBOOK 5799, PG. 385RESIDENTIAL LAND USE ZONE"AE" LINESEE NOTE 5 ZONE"AE" LINESEE NOTE 5 ZONE"AE" LINESEE NOTE 3 ZONE"AE" LINESEE NOTE 5 HILLSIDE OVERLAY HILLSIDE OVERLAY BUFFER HILLSIDE OVERLAY BUFFER 1 STORYBRICK/FRAME 6''S 8A B 3 4 5 6 71 2 C D E F G H 83 4 5 6 71 2 A B C D E F G H DESCRIPTIONDATENOREVISION RECORDDATE:DWG SCALE:DRAWN BY:CHECKED BY:APPROVED BY:PROJECT NO:DRAWING NO.: 364-361AS SHOWNSEPTEMBER 2026CATAASRGMCROSS POINT CHURCHCROSS POINT FRANKLIN CAMPUS1213 COUNTRY ROADFRANKLIN, TENNESSEE 37069Civil & EnvironmentalConsultants, Inc.www.cecinc.com117 Seaboard LanePh: 615.333.7797Suite E-100Franklin, TN 37067 NORTH OVERALL EXISTING CONDITIONSEX 1 Page 23 of 72 LOT 2COUNTRY ROADS SUBDIVISIONP.B. 5, PG. 43MAP 53, PARCEL 61.00HUGHES FAMILY REVOCABLE TRUSTBOOK 7336, PG. 846 LOT 4COUNTRY ROADS SUBDIVISIONP.B. 5, PG. 43MAP 53, PARCEL 62.00BOB & KITTRA MARY MOOREBOOK 1476, PG. 531 LOT 6COUNTRY ROADS SUBDIVISIONP.B. 5, PG. 43MAP 53, PARCEL 63.00TROY DeMONBREUN & LORI MASSEY-DeMONBREUNBOOK 5974, PG. 164 LOT 19 OPEN SPACEMORNINGSIDE P.U.D. SUBDIVISION, SEC. 8P.B. P40, PG. 104MAP 53, PARCEL 99.16VIEW AT BRENTWOOD POINTE INC.BOOK 7662, PG. 835 20' PUDE PLAT 10' PUDE PLAT 10' PUBLIC UTILITY EASEMENT P.B. 5, PG. 43 10' PUBLIC UTILITY EASEMENT P.B. 5, PG. 43 50' LANDSCAPE BUFFER P.B. P51, PG. 45 50' LANDSCAPE BUFFER P.B. P51, PG. 45 PARCEL 59.00 PARCEL 57.01 6''W6''W6''W6''W OHOHOHOHOH CO CM(O) IP(O) IP(N) IP(N) IP(O) IP(O) 8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W 8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W 6''S6''S6''S6''S6''S6''S6''S UGPUGPUGPUGPUGPUGPUGPUGPUGPUGPUGPUGPUGPUGP UGPUGPUGPUGP RISERPOLE E GUY WELL ASPHALT ASPHALT ASPHALT ASPHALTASPHALT CO COCOCOCOELECTRICMETER BOXACACFDCPLUG HANDRAILSFFE=744.2CONCRETEPADS FOR AC CONC.BLOCKWALL FFE=744.2FFE=743.9 FFE=744.2 BB GUY BACKFLOW TRANS CO UTILITYLID ASPHALT ASPHALT WELL 755 755760750755 725 730 735 740 RESIDENTIAL LAND USE RESIDENTIAL LAND USE RESIDENTIAL LAND USE RESIDENTIAL LAND USE MAP 53, PARCEL 56.01THERESA DOYLEBOOK 5799, PG. 385RESIDENTIAL LAND USE ZONE"AE" LINESEE NOTE 5 ZONE"AE" LINESEE NOTE 3 HILLSIDE OVERLAY HILLSIDE OVERLAY BUFFER 6''S6''S6''S 8A B 3 4 5 6 71 2 C D E F G H 83 4 5 6 71 2 A B C D E F G H DESCRIPTIONDATENOREVISION RECORDDATE:DWG SCALE:DRAWN BY:CHECKED BY:APPROVED BY:PROJECT NO:DRAWING NO.: 364-361AS SHOWNSEPTEMBER 2026CATAASRGMCROSS POINT CHURCHCROSS POINT FRANKLIN CAMPUS1213 COUNTRY ROADFRANKLIN, TENNESSEE 37069Civil & EnvironmentalConsultants, Inc.www.cecinc.com117 Seaboard LanePh: 615.333.7797Suite E-100Franklin, TN 37067ENLARGED SITE PLAN OVERLAYEX 2 NORTH Page 24 of 72 20' PUDE PLAT 10' PUDE PLAT 10' PUBLIC UTILITY EASEMENT P.B. 5, PG. 43 10' PUBLIC UTILITY EASEMENT P.B. 5, PG. 43 50' LANDSCAPE BUFFER P.B. P51, PG. 45 50' LANDSCAPE BUFFER P.B. P51, PG. 45 PARCEL 59.00 PARCEL 57.01 6''W6''W6''W6''W OHOHOHOHOH CO CM(O) IP(O) IP(N) IP(N) IP(O) IP(O) 8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W 8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W 6''S6''S6''S6''S6''S6''S6''S UGPUGPUGPUGPUGPUGPUGPUGPUGPUGPUGPUGPUGPUGP UGPUGPUGPUGP RISERPOLE E GUY WELL ASPHALT ASPHALT ASPHALT ASPHALTASPHALT CO COCOCOCOELECTRICMETER BOXACACFDCPLUG HANDRAILSFFE=744.2CONCRETEPADS FOR AC CONC.BLOCKWALL FFE=744.2FFE=743.9 FFE=744.2 BB GUY BACKFLOW TRANS CO UTILITYLID ASPHALT ASPHALT WELL ZONE"AE" LINESEE NOTE 5 ZONE"AE" LINESEE NOTE 3 HILLSIDE OVERLAY HILLSIDE OVERLAY BUFFER 6''S6''S6''S 8A B 3 4 5 6 71 2 C D E F G H 83 4 5 6 71 2 A B C D E F G H DESCRIPTIONDATENOREVISION RECORDDATE:DWG SCALE:DRAWN BY:CHECKED BY:APPROVED BY:PROJECT NO:DRAWING NO.: 364-361AS SHOWNSEPTEMBER 2026CATAASRGMCROSS POINT CHURCHCROSS POINT FRANKLIN CAMPUS1213 COUNTRY ROADFRANKLIN, TENNESSEE 37069Civil & EnvironmentalConsultants, Inc.www.cecinc.com117 Seaboard LanePh: 615.333.7797Suite E-100Franklin, TN 37067AERIAL EXHIBITEX 3 NORTH Page 25 of 72 Page 26 of 72 September 8, 2026 City of Franklin Board of Zoning Appeals Planning and Sustainability Department City of Franklin Franklin, Tennessee 37064 Re: Cross Point Church – Supplemental Letter in Support of Variance Request 1213 Country Road, Franklin, Tennessee Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals: On behalf of Cross Point Church, thank you for considering our request for a variance related to the proposed expansion of our Franklin campus. Civil & Environmental Consultants (CEC) has provided a detailed justification describing the unique physical conditions of our property and the basis for our variance request. We wanted to supplement that technical information with some additional context about Cross Point, our Franklin campus, and why this expansion is important to the people and community we serve. Cross Point exists to help people find and follow Jesus. We have been serving the Franklin community since 2012 and from this property for more than 7 years. During that time the campus has become home to a growing congregation of individuals and families from Franklin and the surrounding community. Today, the greatest challenge we face at this campus is simply having enough space to serve the people who are already coming and to continue welcoming others in the future. Our proposed expansion is intended to address that need while allowing us to remain at and responsibly reinvest in our existing Franklin campus. While we have explored the option of relocating we believe our continued presence on this site is a benefit to the Franklin community. An important part of our planning has been finding a way to expand while keeping the existing campus operational. Cross Point is not simply a building that can close for an extended construction project for 24 months. Each week, people gather here for worship, children and students participate in ministry, volunteers serve, and individuals and families find community and support. Maintaining those ministries throughout construction is important to us and to our community. Beyond our weekly gatherings, Cross Point has sought to be an active partner in the Franklin community, serving alongside local organizations including OneGenAway, Path United, Waves, CASA, Healing Housing and others. Our desire is for this campus to continue serving not only our congregation, but the broader Franklin community. The proposed plan allows the existing building to remain operational while the new facility is constructed primarily within an already-developed portion of the property. Once complete, the two buildings can function together as a unified campus. An alternative that required substantial disruption or reconstruction of the Page 27 of 72 existing campus could significantly interfere with our ability to continue serving people during the construction period. We also view this project as a long-term investment in Franklin. Our desire is not simply to construct a larger building, but to continue putting down roots in this community. We want this campus to remain a place where families gather, relationships are formed, people receive care and support, and our church can serve alongside the broader Franklin community for many years to come. We recognize and appreciate the City's responsibility to thoughtfully apply its development standards. We have worked with our design and engineering teams to develop a plan that responds responsibly to the unusual conditions of this property, including its streams, floodplain, topography, protected areas, existing improvements and established circulation. Rather than extending development further into sensitive portions of the site, the proposed plan makes significant use of an area that has already been developed as part of the existing campus. The variance we are requesting is limited, but its approval would allow us to make responsible use of this property, continue operating the campus throughout expansion, and create the additional capacity needed to serve a growing number of people in Franklin. We believe the proposed plan respects both the intent of the City's development standards and the unique realities of this particular property. Most importantly to us, it provides a responsible path to continue investing in a community that Cross Point is grateful to be part of. Thank you for your consideration of our request and for your service to the City of Franklin. Sincerely, Cross Point Church Kevin Queen Duane Higgins Carl VonDemBusshe Justin Johnson Kevin Queen Duane Higgins Carl VonDemBussche Justin Johnson Senior Pastor CFO Elder Board Chair Franklin Campus Pastor Franklin Resident Franklin Resident Franklin Resident Franklin Resident Page 28 of 72 Gregory T. Smith 9-30-26 Dear Board of Zoning Appeals, My name is Greg Smith, and I am writing to express my support for Cross Point Church’s variance request related to its Franklin campus expansion. I have been a resident of the City of Franklin for 15 years. Cross Point has been an important part of the Franklin community, and I am supportive of its plans to continue investing in this property and creating space to serve people and families in our community for years to come. I understand Cross Point has worked with City staff through the review process and that the request before the Board relates to the unique conditions of the existing property and proposed campus plan. I respectfully ask that you consider approving the requested variance so this project can continue moving forward. Thank you for your service to our community and for your consideration of this request. Sincerely, Greg Smith Franklin Resident Page 29 of 72 City of Franklin Page 1 of 3 City of Franklin 109 3rd Ave S. Franklin, TN 37064 (615) 791-3217 File #: 26-01183 DATE: 10/1/2026 TO: Board of Zoning Appeals FROM: Amy Diaz-Barriga, Asst Director of Planning Development Ariella Parker, Planner SUBJECT: A Variance Request To Allow The Front Facades Of 3 Proposed Principal Buildings To Be Oriented Up To 12 Degrees Non-Parallel To The Frontage For The Property Located At Tax Map 089 Parcel 04801 (FZO 6.9.). PURPOSE: PROJECT INFORMATION COF Project Number: 9246 Applicant: Greg Gamble Owner: Carothers Longpoint LLC BACKGROUND/STAFF COMMENTS: Vicinity Zoning/Land Use Site: Neighborhood Commercial District / Vacant North: Planned PD District / Multifamily Residential (apartments) South: Neighborhood Commercial District / Commercial East: Planned PD District / Multifamily Residential West: Planned PD District, Civic and Institutional District / Recreation Applicable Zoning Ordinance Provisions 20.10 Variance A. The purpose of a variance is to: 1. Provide limited relief from the requirements of this Ordinance in cases where strict application of a particular requirement would create an unnecessary hardship prohibiting the use of land in a manner otherwise allowed under this Ordinance; and 2. Address extraordinary, exceptional, or unique situations that were not caused by the applicant's act or omission. B. Variances are not intended merely to remove inconviences or financial burdens that the requirements of this Ordinance may impose on property owners in general. Page 30 of 72 6.9. Building Types, Commercial/Mixed Use Building Facade Location: The building shall parallel the frontage. Background The subject property is currently a vacant parcel, located at the corner of Carothers Parkway, Longpoint Way, and S Carothers Road. There are Flood Fringe Overlay (FFO) and a stream with a Riparian Buffer on the property. The applicant is proposing 5 commercial buildings with associated infrastructure and parking. Staff Analysis The BZA may authorize a variance only when the request has met all three criteria in accordance with F.Z.O §20.10.6 and State law. The staff has completed an analysis of the request in light of these criteria: 1. Where, by reason of exceptional narrowness, shallowness, or shape of a specific piece of property at the time of the enactment of the Zoning Ordinance or by reason of exceptional topographic conditions or other extraordinary and exceptional situation or condition, such a piece of property is not able to accommodate development as required under this Ordinance. This site has a few unique factors. There is a stream with a riparian buffer, FFO on the site, the shape of the lot is unique, and it fronts 3 streets. All of these factors limit where the buildings, parking, infrastructure, and utilities can be placed on the site. None of the 3 streets that this lot fronts are straight lot lines. With this factor, the buildings could not parallel the frontage and also be oriented parallel to each other in a logical, organized manner. Additionally, building 4 specifically would not be able to meet the requirement to be parallel to both Longpoint Way and S Carothers Road, due to the unique lot lines. Staff finds this criteria is met. 2. The strict application of any provision enacted under the Zoning Ordinance would result in peculiar and exceptional practical difficulties for or exceptional or undue hardship for the owner of the property. If the proposed buildings were to comply with the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance, building 1 would likely need to encroach further into the Riparian Buffer and FFO, and buildings 3 and 4 would likely need to be located closer to Longpoint Way and restrict that area needed for utilities, easements, and grading. Staff finds this criteria is met. 3. Such relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without substantially impairing the purpose and intent of the Zoning Ordinance. Staff finds that this request would not be a detriment to the public good and would not impair the intent of the Zoning Ordinance. Being able to orient the buildings in a more parallel manner to each other is a benefit to pedestrians navigating the buildings. The intent of the Zoning Ordinance in this case is for buildings to be well-designed in a manner that orients buildings towards the street and to have consistency in design. This request meets the intent of the Zoning Ordinance by ensuring the buildings are well-designed in relationship to each other and the buildings are not extremely nonparallel to the frontage, so the orientation is still towards the street. Staff finds this criteria is met. FINANCIAL IMPACT: Unknown. Page 31 of 72 RECOMMENDATION: RECOMMENDED MOTION: Staff recommends the Board of Zoning Appeals move to approve the Variance Request To Allow The Front Facades Of 3 Proposed Principal Buildings To Be Oriented Up To 12 Degrees Non-Parallel To The Frontage For The Property Located At Tax Map 089 Parcel 04801, because the criteria for granting a variance have been met. Page 32 of 72 Cobert Ln Alley Archdale Dr Honey Bush Cir Bloom sbury Ln Longpoint Way Flowing Creek Dr Middleton Cir Simmons Ridge Dr Maysbrook Ln Inland Dr Blueberry Ln Society Dr Gracious Dr Cordail St Carothers Pkwy S Carothers Rd Cobert Ln Alley Archdale Dr Honey Bush Cir Bloom sbury Ln Longpoint Way Flowing Creek Dr Middleton Cir Simmons Ridge Dr Maysbrook Ln Inland Dr Blueberry Ln Society Dr Gracious Dr Cordail St Carothers Pkwy S Carothers Rd Site Legend LockwoodCommercial Floodway Fringe Overlay Floodway Overlay AG Agricultural District ER Estate Residential District R1 Residential 1 District R2 Residential 2 District R3 Residential 3 District R4 Residential 4 District R6 Residential 6 District MR Mixed Residential District PD Planned District OR Office Residential District CI Civic Institutional District NC Neighborhood Commercial District CC Central Commercial District DD Downtown District 1ST Avenue District 5TH Avenue District RC4 Regional Commerce 4 District RC6 Regional Commerce 6 District RC12 Regional Commerce 12 District GO General Office District LI Light Industrial District HI Heavy Industrial District Ü 0 500 1,000250 Feet This map was created by the Franklin Planning Department. It was compiled from the most authentic information available. The City is not responsible for any errors or omissions contained hereon. All data and materials (c) copyright 2026. All rights reserved. LOCKWOOD COMMERCIAL TAX MAP 089, PARCEL 04801 BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OCTOBER 1, 2026 Page 33 of 72 kimley-horn.com 4031 Aspen Grove Drive, Suite 200, Franklin, TN 37067 615-315-5659 BZA Submittal | Lockwood Commercial 4408 South Carothers Road, Franklin, Tennessee Map 089 Parcel 04801 September 8, 2026 City of Franklin Board of Zoning Appeals Dear Board of Zoning Appeals, Kimley-Horn, on behalf of Carothers Longpoint LLC, is requesting a variance for the property located at 4408 South Carothers Road , Franklin, Tennessee, identified as Map 089 Parcel 04801 . The subject property contains approximately 8.29 acres and is proposed for Neighborhood Commercial. The applicant is requesting a variance from the bui lding frontage requirements contained within Section 6.9 of the City of Franklin Zoning Ordinanc e , which states: "The front facade shall face the public street, pri vate street, or internal drive, in that priority or der. The building shall parallel the frontage." The proposed development includes Buildings 1, 3, a nd 4. Due to unique environmental features, existing utility infrastructure, site grading limitations, and the curved geometry of the adjacent roadways, the applicant is requesting relief to allow the fro nt facades of Buildings 1, 3, and 4 to be oriented at an angle of up to 12 degrees from parallel to the frontage roads of Longpoint Way and Carothers Parkway . Site Layout Page 34 of 72 September 8, 2026, Page 2 kimley-horn.com 4031 Aspen Grove Drive, Suite 200, Franklin, TN 37067 629-278-4034 Existing Site Constraints The subject property contains multiple environmenta l and man-made constraints that significantly limit the usable and developable area of the site. A stre am and associated riparian buffer extend along the northern property boundary, while existing floodpla in areas further reduce the available building envelope. In addition, the site presents grading an d drainage challenges due to existing topography and the need to accommodate stormwater management r equirements. Several existing utility easements bisect the prope rty and create additional limitations on grading, building placement, circulation, and site accessibi lity. Collectively, these environmental features, u tility constraints, and topographic conditions substantial ly reduce the flexibility available for site design and building orientation. Additionally, both Longpoint Way and Carothers Park way abut the property along curved roadway segments. Because the frontage roads do not maintain a consistent straight alignment across the site, it is impractical to orient the entirety of a build ing façade perfectly parallel to either roadway whi le also accommodating the environmental and utility constraints present on the property. Existing Constraints Page 35 of 72 September 8, 2026, Page 3 kimley-horn.com 4031 Aspen Grove Drive, Suite 200, Franklin, TN 37067 629-278-4034 Variance Request – To Allow Buildings 1, 3, and 4 to be Oriented up to 12 Degrees from Parallel to Longpoint Way and Carothers Parkway: Section 6.9 of the City of Franklin Zoning Ordinance requires that: "The front facade shall face the public street, private street, or internal drive, in that priority order. The building shall parallel the frontage." To accommodate the site's environmental constraints, utility easements, grading requirements, drainage infrastructure, and the curvature of the adjacent roadways, the applicant requests permission for Buildings 1, 3, and 4 to have a front façade orientation that deviates no more than 12 degrees from parallel to the frontage roads of Longpoint Way and Carothe rs Parkway. This relief is necessary to: • Avoid further impacts to existing streams, riparia n buffers, and floodplain areas. • Minimize grading within areas of steep slopes and challenging topography. • Avoid conflicts with existing utility easements an d infrastructure. • Provide efficient internal circulation and site ac cessibility. • Accommodate required drainage and stormwater manag ement facilities. • Allow reasonable development of the property while preserving environmentally sensitive areas. • Address the curved alignment of Longpoint Way and Carothers Parkway, which makes strict parallel orientation impractical across the full length of the building facades. The requested deviation of up to 12 degrees represe nts the minimum relief necessary to allow a functional site layout while maintaining the overall intent of the frontage design standards. Page 36 of 72 September 8, 2026, Page 4 kimley-horn.com 4031 Aspen Grove Drive, Suite 200, Franklin, TN 37067 629-278-4034 Parellel Offset Exhibit The subject property is affected by an unusual combination of environmental, utility, topographic, and roadway-geometry constraints that materially limit development options and building placement. A stream corridor and associated riparian buffer zones, and the 100-year floodplain occupy substantial portions of the site and reduce the area reasonably available for development. Existing utility easements further constrain the property and limit the flexibility available to locate buildings, grading, utilities, and related infrastructure. The site's grading and drainage conditions require the buildings and supporting infrastructure to be positioned as an integrated system. Rotating Building 1 to a parallel orientation with the frontage ro ad would shift grading, utilities, and the limits of disturbance farther into the 100-year floodplain and riparian buffer zones. Although riparian buffer encroachment may be offset through buffer averaging at a 1:1 ratio, the current buffer-averaging calculations are already at the practical Variance Criteria #1: Façade/Frontage Road Orientat ion Where, by reason of exceptional narrowness, shallow ness, or shape of a specific piece of property at the time of the enactment of this Ordinance or by reason of exceptional topographic conditions or other extraordinary and exceptional situation or conditio n, such a piece of property is not able to accommodate development as required under this ordi nance. Page 37 of 72 September 8, 2026, Page 5 kimley-horn.com 4031 Aspen Grove Drive, Suite 200, Franklin, TN 37067 629-278-4034 limit. Additional encroachment would therefore likely require a separate Riparian Buffer Variance Request and would place greater pressure on environmentally sensitive portions of the site. Rotating Buildings 3 and 4 to achieve a parallel orientation would push utilities, easements, and grading toward the public right-of-way, reducing the space available to resolve infrastructure, access , and grading transitions along the frontage. The rotation would also weaken the buildings' relationship to the parking lot, which represents the primary point of interaction and approach for most patrons. Orienting these buildings away from that principal user interface would not reflect sound site-plannin g or building-orientation practices. In addition, because the frontage roads curve, Building 4 cannot be parallel to both Longpoint Way and South Carothers Road simultaneously. Allowing Buildings 1, 3, and 4 to deviate by up to 12 degrees from parallel is therefore the minimum relief necessary to respond to the property's exceptional shape, environmental constraints, utility conditions, grading requirements, and curved roadwa y frontages. The requested orientation preserves a coherent development pattern while avoiding more consequential impacts that strict compliance would create. Building Rotation Conflicts Exhibit Page 38 of 72 September 8, 2026, Page 6 kimley-horn.com 4031 Aspen Grove Drive, Suite 200, Franklin, TN 37067 629-278-4034 Strict application of the ordinance would require Buildings 1, 3, and 4 to maintain a perfectly parallel relationship with frontage roads that follow curved and differing alignments. For Building 1, compliance would move grading, utilities, and limits of disturbance farther into the 100-year floodpla in and riparian buffer zones. Because the existing 1:1 riparian buffer-averaging calculation has little to no remaining flexibility, the additional encroachment would likely trigger a separate Riparian Buffer Variance Request. For Buildings 3 and 4, strict compliance would push utilities, easements, and grading toward the public right-of-way and create avoidable conflicts within an already constrained frontage area. It would also reduce the functional relationship between the buildings and the parking lot, even though the parking lot is the principal point of patron arrival and interaction. That outcome would prioritiz e a rigid geometric relationship to the roadway over practical circulation, intuitive building access, utility coordination, and sound site design. The difficulty is compounded at Building 4 because the curvature and differing alignments of Longpoint Way and South Carothers Road make it impossible for the building to be parallel to both roads at the same time. The requested variance resolves these practical difficulties through a limited adjustment of no more than 12 degrees, while avoidi ng a design alternative that would cause greater environmental disturbance, infrastructure conflicts, and operational inefficiency. Variance Criteria #2: Façade/Frontage Road Orientat ion The strict application of any provision enacted und er this Ordinance would result in peculiar and exceptional practical difficulties to or exceptional or undue hardship upon the owner of such property. Page 39 of 72 September 8, 2026, Page 7 kimley-horn.com 4031 Aspen Grove Drive, Suite 200, Franklin, TN 37067 629-278-4034 Building Alignment Exhibit Granting the variance will not cause substantial detriment to the public good or impair the purpose and intent of the zoning ordinance. Buildings 1, 3, and 4 will continue to address the frontage roads, and the requested deviation is limited to a maximum of 12 degrees. The modest angular adjustment will not materially alter the character of the development or diminish the visual quality of the streetscape. The proposed orientation produces a more appropriate balance among frontage-road relationships, environmental stewardship, infrastructure coordination, and patron access. In particular, retaining the proposed orientation of Building 1 avoids shifting grading, utilities, and disturbance farther into the 100-year floodplain and riparian buffer zones. This is especially important because the available 1:1 Variance Criteria #3: Façade/Frontage Road Orientat ion Such relief may be granted without substantial detr iment to the public good and without substantially impairing the purpose and intent of the zoning map and the Ordinance. Page 40 of 72 September 8, 2026, Page 8 kimley-horn.com 4031 Aspen Grove Drive, Suite 200, Franklin, TN 37067 629-278-4034 buffer averaging is already at its practical limit, and additional impacts would likely necessitate a Riparian Buffer Variance Request with greater consequences for environmentally sensitive areas. Retaining the proposed orientation of Buildings 3 and 4 prevents unnecessary conflicts with existing utilities, easements, and grading along the public right-of-way and preserves a strong relationship between the buildings and parking lot, where most patrons approach and interact with the site. Because Building 4 cannot be parallel to both Longpoint Way and South Carothers Road due to the curvature of the frontage roads, the requested variance is the more reasonable and less impactful form of relief. It supports the ordinance's broader planning objectives by reducing environmental disturbance, maintaining functional circulation and access, and promoting sound engineering and site-design practices. We appreciate your review of these requests and loo k forward to discussing them with you at the July Board of Zoning Appeals hearing. Sincerely, Greg Gamble Landscape Architect Page 41 of 72 FFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFO FFOFFO XXXX XXX FFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFOFFO 567 799 22101089 42108101010101010105 8 5225555 95 4 BUILDING 1±10,800 SF BUILDING 3± 6,000 SFBUILDING 2±12,000 SFBUILDING 4±6,000 SF BUILDING 5±15,000 SF 3 BIO 1 BIO 3 BIO 2 F S EEEE APAPAP APAPAPAP 24.0'18.0'TYP.9.0'TYP.24.0'18.0'TYP. 24.0'24.0'24.0' R5.0'R5.0'R5.0' R5.0'R5.0'R25.0' R5.0'R5.0'R5.0'R5.0'R5.0'R5.0'R5.0'R5.0'R5.0'R5.0'R5.0'R6.0'R30.0' R5.0'R5.0'R5.0'R5.0'R5.0'R5.0' R1.0'R1.0'9.0'TYP. 9.0'TYP.18.0'TYP.18.0'TYP. 18.0'TYP. 22.0'8.0'A A5.0'5.0'7.5' C C E E E I I H R1.0' 24.0'24.0' L L L R5.0'R5.0' AR5.0'R1.0' I 24.0' 22.0'8.0' M G25.0'C CCM M C C C M GN N 15.0' MBSL(TYP.) K Z 9.0'8.0' P11.5' RP Q P P Q Q KS T S S 24.0' R25.0' Y U AREA TO BE DECLARED SURPLUSR.O.W. AND DEDICATED BY THE CITYOF FRANKLIN PER COF CONTRACTNO 2016-0098. R30.0' V R25.0' R25.0'R50.0'S 15.0' MBSL(TYP.) W W V X XFF FXG S SK Z 6.0' 6.0' 12.0'12.0' N NTIE TO EXISTING SIDEWALK5.0' 24.0' 9.0'TYP. TIE TO EXISTING SIDEWALK FLOWING CREEK DR.(LOCAL STREET, 30' R.O.W.)R.O.W. DEDICATION±1147 SQFT POCKET PARKSEE SHEET L2-20 FOR DETAIL LONGPOINT WAY (MAJOR COLLECTOR, 50' R.O.W.) SIMMONS RIDGE DR.(LOCAL STREET, 30' R.O.W.) S. CAROTHERS RD.(MINOR COLLECTOR, 50' R.O.W.) CAROTHERS PKWY.(MAJOR ARTERIAL, R.O.W. VARIES)OFFSITE ROAD IMPROVEMENTS(SEE SHEET 1 THROUGH TS1.2DETAILED PLAN SHEETS)Q N APPROXIMATE 18" WATEREASEMENT PER MUD'S CAPITALIMPROVEMENTS PROJECTINSTALLED BY OTHERS COBERT LANE(LOCAL STREET, 30' R.O.W.) N 33.0' 15.0' MBSL (TYP.) SITE DATA TABLEPROJECT NAME: LOCKWOOD COMMERCIALCOF PROJECT #: #TBDMAP: MAP # 089PARCEL #:04801ADDRESS: 4408 S CAROTHERS RDCITY: FRANKLINCOUNTY: WILLIAMSONSTATE: TENNESSEEEXISTING ZONING: NC, NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIALOVERLAY ZONING DISTRICT:FLOODWAY FRINGE OVERLAYTOTAL ACREAGE OF SITE: ± 8.29 ACRESTOTAL SQUARE FOOTAGE OF SITE:361,112 SFOWNERS:CAROTHERS LONGPOINT, LLCADDRESS:18331 PINES BLVD, SUITE 319PEMBROKE PINES, FL 33029PHONE:954-789-5117EMAIL:MOUTLAW@TRIOUTADVISORY.COMCONTACT NAME:MIKE OUTLAWAPPLICANT:KIMLEY-HORN & ASSOCIATESADDRESS:4031 ASPEN GROVE DRIVE, SUITE 200FRANKLIN, TN 37067PHONE:615-564-2701EMAIL:MARY.McGOWAN@KIMLEY-HORN.COMCONTACT NAME:MARY McGOWAN, P.E.BUILDING SETBACKS:15' FRONT, 10' SIDE AND 15' REARBUILDING SQUARE FOOTAGE:BUILDING 1: 10,800 SFBUILDING 2: 12,000 SFBUILDING 3: 6,000 SFBUILDING 4: 6,000 SFBUILDING 5: 15,000 SFBUILDING USES:60% RETAIL, 20% GROCERY 20% RESTAURANTBUILDING HEIGHT:1 STORYMINIMUM LANDSCAPE SURFACE RATIO:0.15PROVIDED LANDSCAPE SURFACE RATIO:0.15TOTAL REQUIRED PARKING:263 SPACESREQUIRED PARKING RETAIL:102 SPACESREQUIRED PARKING GROCERY:27 SPACESREQUIRED PARKING RESTAURANT:134 SPACESREQUIRED PARKING WITH237 SPACES10% SHARE FACTOR :TOTAL PARKING PROVIDED:245 TOTAL SPACESTOTAL SPACES OVER 120%:0 SPACESBICYCLE PARKING PROVIDED:16 SPACESBICYCLE PARKING REQUIRED:14 SPACESNOTES:1.WITHIN NEW DEVELOPMENTS AND FOR OFF-SITE LINES CONSTRUCTED AS A RESULT OF,OR TO PROVIDE SERVICE TO, THE NEW DEVELOPMENT, ALL UTILITIES, SUCH AS CABLETELEVISION, ELECTRICAL (EXCLUDING TRANSFORMERS), GAS, SEWER, TELEPHONE, ANDWATER LINES SHALL BE PLACED UNDERGROUND.2.THIS SITE PLAN HAS BEEN DESIGNED TO MEET THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE CITY OFFRANKLIN STANDARDS THE INFORMATION SHOWN ON THIS PLAN IS BASED UPON THETENNESSEE STATE PLANE COORDINATE SYSTEM, ZONE 5301, FLIPZONE 4100 AND NAD 83DATUM.3.THE CONSULTANT HAS FOUND NO EVIDENCE OF THE MINERAL RIGHTS OF THIS PROPERTYBEING TRANSFERRED TO ANY PARTY OTHER THAN THE OWNER.4.PROPOSED BUILDINGS IN THIS PROJECT FALL WITHIN THE 100 YEAR FLOODPLAIN, PER THEFEMA FIRM MAP NUMBER 47187C0214H, DATED DECEMBER 20, 2024. NORTH SITE PLAN KEYNOTE LEGENDCONCRETE SIDEWALK (SEE SHEET C2.1, DETAIL RP-8)6" POST CURB (SEE SHEET C2.3, DETAIL 1)4" PARKING STRIPEABCWHITE THERMOPLASTIC STOP BAR (TYP.)DADA PARKINGEADA RAMP (TYP.)FWHEEL STOP (TYP.) (SEE SHEET C2.3, DETAIL 4)GPROPERTY LINE (TYP.)HDUMPSTER PADISTOP SIGNJGREEN INFRASTRUCTURE EASEMENTKLOADING ZONELSTREET LIGHT (TYP.)MCROSSWALK (TYP.) (SEE SHEET C2.3, DETAIL 2)NSTAIRSOM.U.D. EASEMENTPP.U.D.E.QSANITARY SEWER EASEMENTRCURB CUTSBICYCLE PARKING (TYP.)TRETAINING WALL (MAX HEIGHT 10')UROLL OVER CURB (SEE SHEET C2.3, DETAIL RP-SC-1)VCONCRETE DRIVEWAY APRON (SEE SHEET C2.1, DETAIL RP-5)WFLUSH CURBXLANDSCAPE WALL (MAX HEIGHT 1')YBIORETENTION OVERFLOW CHANNELZ MMcBFGALO C2.0SITE PLAN BIORETENTION AREALIGHT DUTY CONCRETEHEAVY DUTY PAVEMENT LIGHT DUTY PAVEMENT SITE LEGEND ALL RADII ARE 3' UNLESS OTHERWISE LABELEDRADII NOTE This document, together with the concepts and designs presented herein, as an instrument of service, is intended only for the specific purpose and client for which it was prepared. Reuse of and improper reliance on this document without written authorization and adaptation by Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. shall be without liability to Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. No.REVISIONSBYDATE DESIGNED BY:CHECKED BY:DRAWN BY:KIMLEY-HORN PROJECT NO.DATE: SHEET NUMBER118711001 4031 Aspen Grove Drive, Suite 200, Franklin, TN 37067Main: 615.564.2701 | www.kimley-horn.com© 2026 Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc.LOCKWOOD COMMERCIALTRIOUT ADVISORY GROUPFRANKLIN, TENNESSEE Drawing name: K:\FRA_LDEV\118711001 - Lockwood Commercial\4-CADD\PlanSheets\C2.0 OVERALL SITE PLAN.dwg C2.0 OVERALL SITE PLAN Aug 10, 2026 3:33pm by: Brayden.Gries 12345678910 12345678908/10/2026 COF #TBD #PERMEABLE PAVERSPARKING COUNT HEAVY DUTY CONCRETE APADA PATHMILL AND OVERLAY CITY OF FRANKLIN STREET CUT NOTES1.ALL CUTS IN PUBLIC STREETS REQUIRE A STREET CROSSING PERMIT AND TRAFFIC CONTROL PLANAPPROVED BY THE STREET DEPARTMENT.2.TRENCH BACKFILL AND STREET REPAIR SHALL BE MADE IN ACCORDANCE WITH CITY OF FRANKLINSTREET STANDARD DRAWING RD-6 (LOCAL) OR RD-7 (COLLECTOR OR ARTERIAL).3.TRENCH EXCAVATIONS SHALL BE MILLED AND OVERLAID A MINIMUM OF 100 FEET CENTERED ON THETRENCH. Page 42 of 72 City of Franklin Page 1 of 4 City of Franklin 109 3rd Ave S. Franklin, TN 37064 (615) 791-3217 File #: 26-01184 DATE: 10/1/2026 TO: Board of Zoning Appeals FROM: Amy Diaz-Barriga, Asst Director of Planning Development Ariella Parker, Planner SUBJECT: A Variance Request To Allow A Retaining Wall To Be Located A Minimum Of 1.37 Feet From The Side Lot Line For The Property Located At 1316 Buckingham Circle, and a Variance Request To Allow A Retaining Wall To Be Located A Minimum Of 0 Feet From The Rear Lot Line For The Property Located At 1316 Buckingham Circle, and a Variance Request To Allow A Retaining Wall To Be Located A Minimum Of 0 Feet From The Side Lot Line For Parcel 079A-B-01400 (FZO 13.2.2.). PURPOSE: PROJECT INFORMATION COF Project Number: 9244 Applicant: Matthew McLure Owner: Michael O'Brian and Save the Franklin Battlefield BACKGROUND/STAFF COMMENTS: Vicinity Zoning/Land Use Site: Residential 3 (R-3) District / Single Family Residential and Recreation North: Residential 3 (R-3) District and Mixed Residential / Single Family Residential and Vacant South: Residential 3 (R-3) District / Single Family Residential East: Residential 3 (R-3) District / Single Family Residential West: Residential 3 (R-3) District / Single Family Residential Applicable Zoning Ordinance Provisions 20.10 Variance A. The purpose of a variance is to: 1. Provide limited relief from the requirements of this Ordinance in cases where strict application of a particular requirement would create an unnecessary hardship prohibiting the use of land in a manner otherwise allowed under this Ordinance; and 2. Address extraordinary, exceptional, or unique situations that were not caused by the applicant's act or omission. B. Variances are not intended merely to remove inconveniences or financial burdens that the Page 43 of 72 requirements of this Ordinance may impose on property owners in general. 13.2.2. Retaining Walls, Location A. Retaining walls shall be set back from a lot line a minimum of five feet or the distance equal to the height of the wall, whichever is greater. Background The subject properties are located at 1316 Buckingham Circle and Tax Map 079A Parcel 01400. There is an existing retaining wall that was built without a permit along the south and west (side and rear) property lines of 1316 Buckingham Circle. The retaining wall is a maximum of 3.8 feet tall along the rear and side lot lines. The retaining wall is located on top of the rear property line, and is 1.37 feet from the side lot line at its closest point. The Zoning Ordinance requires that this wall be at least 5 feet from any lot line. The applicant is requesting 3 variances:1) For the retaining wall to be located a minimum of 1.37 feet from the side lot line, 2) For the retaining wall to be 0 feet from the rear lot line for 1316 Buckingham Circle (because it is located on top of the property line), and 3) For the retaining wall to be located 0 feet from the lot line for the property behind 1316 Buckingham Circle (tax map 079A parcel 01400), since the wall encroaches over the property line. Staff Analysis The BZA may authorize a variance only when the request has met all three criteria in accordance with F.Z.O §20.10.6 and State law. The staff has completed an analysis of the request in light of these criteria: Request 1: To Allow A Retaining Wall To Be Located A Minimum Of 1.37 Feet From The Side Lot Line 1. Where, by reason of exceptional narrowness, shallowness, or shape of a specific piece of property at the time of the enactment of the Zoning Ordinance or by reason of exceptional topographic conditions or other extraordinary and exceptional situation or condition, such a piece of property is not able to accommodate development as required under this Ordinance. This property had steep slopes on the entirety of the backyard, prior to the building of the wall. The wall was placed close to the side property line so that the stairs could be accessed at the relatively level side yard. In order to do this, the stairs have to be oriented perpendicular to the side lot line and between the side of the house and the side lot line. Because the existing house is about 6.8 feet from that side lot line, the retaining wall and stairs leading up to the backyard area encroach into the setback required for the retaining wall. Due to the uniquely sloped backyard, and the house being located close to the side setback, this lot could not accommodate the retaining wall and stairs that allow easy access to the backyard from the side. Staff finds this criteria is met. 2. The strict application of any provision enacted under the Zoning Ordinance would result in peculiar and exceptional practical difficulties for or exceptional or undue hardship for the owner of the property. If the retaining wall were built to meet the setback requirements, the stairs would be harder to access since they would have to be accessed from the steep slope. If the stairs were not built with the retaining wall, the backyard could not be accessed from this side yard. The backyard is not easily accessed from the front yard because the steep slope condition exists in the front yard as well, so the backyard would not be easily accessed from the front yard. Staff finds this criteria is met. 3. Such relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without substantially impairing the purpose and intent of the Zoning Ordinance. Page 44 of 72 Staff finds that this request could be a detriment to the neighboring properties and does not meet the intent of the Zoning Ordinance. Part of the intent of this Zoning Ordinance regulation is to ensure that if the wall were to crumble or fall it wouldn’t have a negative impact on the neighboring property. The Zoning Ordinance regulation implements this intent by ensuring that the distance between a retaining wall and a side or rear property line is at least equal to the height of the wall. While the unique design of the retaining wall makes the backyard more easily accessed from the front yard, it is still a 3.8-foot tall retaining wall proposed to be a minimum of 1.37 feet from the side property line. If the wall were to crumble or fall, it would all crumble and fall onto the neighboring property. Staff finds this criteria is not met. Request 2: To Allow A Retaining Wall To Be Located A Minimum Of 0 Feet From The Rear Lot Line For The Property Located At 1316 Buckingham Circle 1. Where, by reason of exceptional narrowness, shallowness, or shape of a specific piece of property at the time of the enactment of the Zoning Ordinance or by reason of exceptional topographic conditions or other extraordinary and exceptional situation or condition, such a piece of property is not able to accommodate development as required under this Ordinance. Staff does not find any unique condition of the lot that would have prevented the retaining wall from being at least 5 feet from the rear lot line. Staff finds this criteria is not met. 2. The strict application of any provision enacted under the Zoning Ordinance would result in peculiar and exceptional practical difficulties for or exceptional or undue hardship for the owner of the property. Staff does not find that locating the wall at least 5 feet from the rear property line would result in an undue hardship for the owner of the property. Staff finds this criteria is not met. 3. Such relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without substantially impairing the purpose and intent of the Zoning Ordinance. Staff finds that this request would not be a detriment to the public good or impair the intent of the Zoning Ordinance. Part of the intent of this Zoning Ordinance regulation is to ensure that if the wall were to crumble or fall it wouldn’t have a negative impact on the neighboring property. Seeing as the property owner that would be affected is also requesting a variance to allow this wall to remain, staff does not find that this request would be a detriment to that property. Additionally, that property to the rear is owned by Save the Franklin Battlefield, and will not be developed. Staff finds that this criteria is met. Request 3: To Allow A Retaining Wall To Be Located A Minimum Of 0 Feet From The Lot Line For Parcel 079A-B-01400 1. Where, by reason of exceptional narrowness, shallowness, or shape of a specific piece of property at the time of the enactment of the Zoning Ordinance or by reason of exceptional topographic conditions or other extraordinary and exceptional situation or condition, such a piece of property is not able to accommodate development as required under this Ordinance. Staff does not find any unique condition of the lot that would have prevented the retaining wall from being at least 5 feet from the rear lot line. Staff finds this criteria is not met. 2. The strict application of any provision enacted under the Zoning Ordinance would result in peculiar and exceptional practical difficulties for or exceptional or undue hardship for the owner of the property. Page 45 of 72 Staff does not find that locating the wall at least 5 feet from the rear property line would result in an undue hardship for the owner of the property. Staff finds this criteria is not met. 3. Such relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without substantially impairing the purpose and intent of the Zoning Ordinance. Staff finds that this request would not be a detriment to the public good or impair the intent of the Zoning Ordinance. Part of the intent of this Zoning Ordinance regulation is to ensure that if the wall were to crumble or fall it wouldn’t have a negative impact on the neighboring property. Seeing as the wall would fall onto this property if it were to fall, staff finds that it meets the intent of the Zoning Ordinance. Staff finds that this criteria is met. FINANCIAL IMPACT: Unknown. RECOMMENDATION: RECOMMENDED MOTION: Staff recommends the Board of Zoning Appeals move to deny the Variance Request To Allow A Retaining Wall To Be Located A Minimum Of 1.37 Feet From The Side Lot Line For The Property Located At 1316 Buckingham Circle, and the Variance Request To Allow A Retaining Wall To Be Located A Minimum Of 0 Feet From The Rear Lot Line For The Property Located At 1316 Buckingham Circle, and the Variance Request To Allow A Retaining Wall To Be Located A Minimum Of 0 Feet From The Lot Line For Parcel 079A-B-01400, because the criteria for granting a variance have not all been met. Page 46 of 72 Buckingham Cir Granger View Cir Buckingham Cir Granger View Cir Site Legend 1316 Buckingham Circle and Parcel 079A-B-01400 AG Agricultural District ER Estate Residential District R1 Residential 1 District R2 Residential 2 District R3 Residential 3 District R4 Residential 4 District R6 Residential 6 District MR Mixed Residential District PD Planned District OR Office Residential District CI Civic Institutional District NC Neighborhood Commercial District CC Central Commercial District DD Downtown District 1ST Avenue District 5TH Avenue District RC4 Regional Commerce 4 District RC6 Regional Commerce 6 District RC12 Regional Commerce 12 District GO General Office District LI Light Industrial District HI Heavy Industrial District Ü 0 500 1,000250 Feet This map was created by the Franklin Planning Department. It was compiled from the most authentic information available. The City is not responsible for any errors or omissions contained hereon. All data and materials (c) copyright 2026. All rights reserved. 1316 BUCKINGHAM CIRCLE, TAX MAP 079A PARCEL 01400 TAX MAP 079A, GROUP C, PARCEL 01000 TAX MAP 079A, GROUP B, PARCEL 01400 BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OCTOBER 1, 2026 Site Page 47 of 72 1316 Buckingham Cir BZA SUBMITTAL Studio 16 Outdoor Design · Page 1 of 7 September 8, 2026 City of Franklin Board of Zoning Appeals Dear Board of Zoning Appeals, Studio 16, on behalf of the Michael O’Brian Living Trust, is requesting two variances for the property located at 1316 Buckingham Circle, Franklin, Tennessee. The property is Lot 115 of Buckingham Park, Section 3, as recorded in Plat Book 18, Page 85, Williamson County, Tennessee, and is approximately 0.21 acres. The requested variances are related to the existing retaining wall located along the rear and side property lines. The retaining wall was constructed without a permit and is non-conforming. It was constructed within the P.U.D.E. along the property line on the southern side yard and extends approximately 1 inch to 6.5 inches onto the adjacent property along the rear property line. The encroachment onto the adjacent property is acknowledged by the property owner, SAVE THE FRANKLIN BATTLEFIELD INC., who is aware of the condition and will be providing a letter of consent and no objection. There is a fence located on top of the wall. This fence will be moved off the wall to comply with wall ht requirements. The enclosed application and supporting documentation provide additional information regarding the existing site conditions and the basis for the requested variances. Thank you for your consideration of this request. Sincerely, Matt McLure, P.E. Civil Engineer Studio 16 Outdoor Design. Page 48 of 72 1316 Buckingham Cir BZA SUBMITTAL Studio 16 Outdoor Design · Page 2 of 7 1. Where, by reason of exceptional narrowness, shallowness, or shape of a specific piece of property … or by reason of exceptional topographic conditions or other extraordinary and exceptional situation or condition, such piece of property is not able to accommodate development as required under this Ordinance. The property previously contained an exceptionally steep slope along the side and rear yard that made the area difficult to stabilize and maintain. Prior to construction of the retaining wall, the steep grade made establishing and maintaining grass difficult, leaving areas of exposed soil susceptible to erosion and rapid stormwater runoff. The retaining wall was placed along the property line on both the south and west side along an existing fence. See Site Plan Exhibit A. The location also provided an area for steps to reach a relatively level area at the bottom. If the wall was moved back to meet the required setback, the steps would end on a steep slope. This would make the transition from the stairs to the rear yard impractical and potentially unsafe. 2. The strict application of any provision enacted under this Ordinance would result in peculiar and exceptional practical difficulties to or exceptional hardship upon the owner of such property; and Strict application of the required setback would create practical difficulty for the property owner because of the steep grades and limited width of the southern side yard. Moving the retaining wall into the required setback on the southern side yard would reduce the available level area at the bottom of the steps. The stairs would then terminate on a steep slope, making access to the rear yard impractical and potentially unsafe. The wall currently provides a stable transition between the different elevations and has allowed grass and other vegetation to be established in an area where the steep slope previously made it difficult for grass to grow. The vegetation and grading also help slow stormwater and allow more water to soak into the ground instead of running off the steep, bare soil toward the neighboring property. The stormwater calculations can be seen in Exhibit “B” Hydrographs. 3. Such relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without substantially impairing the purpose and intent of the zoning map and this Ordinance. Granting the requested variances would not create a substantial detriment to the public good. The request is limited to allowing the existing retaining wall to remain in its current location. The wall provides a stable transition between the different elevations and allows the stairs to provide practical access to the rear yard. The wall and grading have also helped stabilize the steep slope and Page 49 of 72 1316 Buckingham Cir BZA SUBMITTAL Studio 16 Outdoor Design · Page 3 of 7 allow vegetation to grow. This helps slow stormwater runoff and allows more water to soak into the ground rather than running off the property at a higher velocity. See again Exhibit “B” Hydrographs. The encroachment onto the adjacent property is approximately 1 inch to 6.5 inches along the rear property line. The adjacent property owner, SAVE THE FRANKLIN BATTLEFIELD INC., is aware of the condition and will be providing a letter of consent and no objection. Allowing the wall to remain will maintain the current access, grading, and stabilized condition of the property without substantially affecting the surrounding properties or the purpose of the zoning requirements. We appreciate the boards consideration Matt McLure, PE Civil Engineer C: 423.883.6021 E: mmclure@s16design.com Page 50 of 72 1316 Buckingham Cir BZA SUBMITTAL Studio 16 Outdoor Design · Page 4 of 7 PREVIOUSLY EXISTING FENCE Page 51 of 72 1316 Buckingham Cir BZA SUBMITTAL Studio 16 Outdoor Design · Page 5 of 7 PREVIOUSLY EXISTING FENCE CURRENT CONDITIONS Page 52 of 72 XX EXISTING RESIDENCEFFE: 777.41'GFE: 767.50' LOT 114MAP: 79A GRP: C PAR: 11.00REV LIV TRUST OF DOCTOR RARAYPB: 18 PG: 85 OPEN SPACEMAP: 79A GRP: C PAR: 9.00BUCKINGHAM PARKHOMEOWNERS ASSOC INCPB: 18 PG: 85 LOT 47MAP: 79A GRP: C PAR: 9.00SAVE THE FRANKLINBATTLEFIELDPB: 16 PG: 115 PATIODECK A/CEXISTINGDRIVEWAY N8°43'22"E 63.00' N81°18'44"W 124.54' N81°59'29"E 68.79' S67°08'49"E 50.76' C1C2S8°41'16"W 26.63' BUCKINGHAM CIRCLE(40' R.O.W.) 775 XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX RETAININGWALL 8" SA8" SA8" SA8" SA8" SA8" SA 8" SA 8" SA 8" SA 8" SA 8" SA 8" SA8" SA8" SA8" SA8" SA8" W8" W8" W8" W8" W 8" W 8" W 8" W 8" W 8" W8" W8" W8" W8" W 765 760 770 0.53' WALLENCROCHMENT XXXXXXXXXXXX 0.09' WALLENCROCHMENT WALL ENCROACHMENTALONG REAR PROPERTYLINE, WIDTH VARIES 10' PUDE 30' MBSL5' MBSL 5' MBSL30'MBSL 10'PUDE5' PUDE& MBSL 6" WALL TW 775.60BW 772.80 TW 772.30BW 768.50 TW 775.50BW 772.61 TW 772.10BW 768.701.37' WALLTO PROPERTY LINE6.85' FENCE TO BEMOVED OFF WALL 1' BRICK WALL WITHPRIVACY FENCE(ENCROACHMENTINTO PUDE) MBSL ARE BASED ONRECORDED PLAT. VERIFYWITH CITY OF FRANKLIN770 770 777 777 776773772 ENCROACHMENT ONTONEIGHBORING PROPERTY 1.43' WALL TOPROPERTY LINENo. Date & Description9/10/26 Dim to Wall1 O'BrianResidence1316 Buckingham CrFranklin, TN 37064 00.000BABA00.00.0000Approved By :Drawn By :Plan No :IFC Date :L1.0PROPOSED SITEPLAN Project Address: 1229 Lakeview DriveFranklin, TN 37067o. 615.415.9903www.studio16design.com STUDIO16O U T D O O R D E S I G N General Notes: Plan Description: Revisions: ExistingConditions 0'15'20' Scale:1" = 10' - 0"5'10'© Copyright Studio 16 Outdoor Design 2022 EXISTING CONDITIONS / BZA NOTES1.EXISTING CONDITIONS INFORMATION SHOWN ON THISPLAN IS BASED ON THE TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEYPREPARED BY BROTHERTON LAND SURVEYING DATED06-18-26.2.PROPERTY BOUNDARIES AND BOUNDARY DIMENSIONSSHOWN ARE BASED ON AVAILABLE SURVEY INFORMATION.BOUNDARY DIMENSIONS ARE SHOWN TO THE NEARESTFOOT.3.EXISTING BUILDINGS AND STRUCTURES ARE SHOWN WITHLOCATIONS, EXTERIOR DIMENSIONS, AND APPROXIMATESQUARE FOOTAGES, AS APPLICABLE. EXTERIORDIMENSIONS ARE MEASURED FROM OUTSIDE WALL TOOUTSIDE WALL.4.PROPOSED BUILDINGS AND STRUCTURES ARE SHOWNWITH LOCATIONS, EXTERIOR DIMENSIONS, AND SQUAREFOOTAGES, AS APPLICABLE.5.ALL EXISTING SITE FEATURES SHOWN ON THIS PLAN AREBASED ON AVAILABLE SURVEY INFORMATION AND/ORFIELD OBSERVATION AND SHOULD BE VERIFIED IN THEFIELD PRIOR TO CONSTRUCTION.6.PROPERTY LINES AND EASEMENTS SHOWN ARE FORREFERENCE AND PLANNING PURPOSES.7.ANY DISCREPANCIES BETWEEN THE CONDITIONS SHOWNON THIS PLAN AND ACTUAL FIELD CONDITIONS SHALL BEBROUGHT TO THE ATTENTION OF THE ENGINEER. Page 53 of 72 1316 Buckingham Cir BZA SUBMITTAL Studio 16 Outdoor Design · Page 7 of 7 EXHIBIT B HYDROGRAPHS STORMWATER CACLULATIONS Page 54 of 72 Hydraflow Table of ContentsFLow Calcs Obrian.gpwHydraflow Hydrographs Extension for Autodesk® Civil 3D® by Autodesk, Inc. v2026 Monday, 09 / 14 / 2026Hydrograph Return Period Recap............................................................................. 15 - YearSummary Report......................................................................................................................... 2Hydrograph Reports................................................................................................................... 3Hydrograph No. 1, SCS Runoff, Pre Wall Condition................................................................ 3TR-55 Tc Worksheet............................................................................................................ 4Hydrograph No. 2, SCS Runoff, With Walls Condition............................................................. 5TR-55 Tc Worksheet............................................................................................................ 610 - YearSummary Report......................................................................................................................... 7Hydrograph Reports................................................................................................................... 8Hydrograph No. 1, SCS Runoff, Pre Wall Condition................................................................ 8Hydrograph No. 2, SCS Runoff, With Walls Condition............................................................. 950 - YearSummary Report.......................................................................................................................10Hydrograph Reports.................................................................................................................11Hydrograph No. 1, SCS Runoff, Pre Wall Condition..............................................................11Hydrograph No. 2, SCS Runoff, With Walls Condition...........................................................12100 - YearSummary Report.......................................................................................................................13Hydrograph Reports.................................................................................................................14Hydrograph No. 1, SCS Runoff, Pre Wall Condition..............................................................14Hydrograph No. 2, SCS Runoff, With Walls Condition...........................................................15 Page 55 of 72 Hydrograph Return Period Recap1Hyd. Hydrograph Inflow Peak Outflow (cfs) HydrographNo. type hyd(s) Description(origin) 1-yr 2-yr 3-yr 5-yr 10-yr 25-yr 50-yr 100-yr1SCS Runoff ------ ------- ------- ------- 0.102 0.159 ------- 0.329 0.408 Pre Wall Condition2SCS Runoff ------ ------- ------- ------- 0.087 0.141 ------- 0.306 0.384 With Walls Condition Proj. file: FLow Calcs Obrian.gpw Monday, 09 / 14 / 2026 Hydraflow Hydrographs Extension for Autodesk® Civil 3D® by Autodesk, Inc. v2026 Page 56 of 72 Hydrograph Summary Report2Hyd. Hydrograph Peak Time Time to Hyd. Inflow Maximum Total HydrographNo. type flow interval Peak volume hyd(s) elevation strge used Description(origin) (cfs) (min) (min) (cuft) (ft) (cuft)1SCS Runoff 0.1022720 233 ------ ------ ------ Pre Wall Condition2SCS Runoff 0.0872720 200 ------ ------ ------ With Walls Condition FLow Calcs Obrian.gpw Return Period: 5 Year Monday, 09 / 14 / 2026 Hydraflow Hydrographs Extension for Autodesk® Civil 3D® by Autodesk, Inc. v2026 Page 57 of 72 Hydrograph Report3Hydraflow Hydrographs Extension for Autodesk® Civil 3D® by Autodesk, Inc. v2026 Monday, 09 / 14 / 2026Hyd. No. 1Pre Wall ConditionHydrograph type = SCS Runoff Peak discharge = 0.102 cfsStorm frequency = 5 yrs Time to peak = 720 minTime interval = 2 min Hyd. volume = 233 cuftDrainage area = 0.050 ac Curve number = 77.000Basin Slope = 0.0 % Hydraulic length = 0 ftTc method = TR55 Time of conc. (Tc) = 7.3 minTotal precip. = 3.30 in Distribution = Type IIStorm duration = 24 hrs Shape factor = 484Hydrograph Discharge Table( Printed values >= 80.00% of Qp.)Time -- Outflow(min cfs)716 0.087718 0.101720 0.102<<722 0.090...End Page 58 of 72 TR55 Tc Worksheet4Hydraflow Hydrographs Extension for Autodesk® Civil 3D® by Autodesk, Inc. v2026Hyd. No. 1Pre Wall ConditionDescriptionABCTotalsSheet FlowManning's n-value = 0.400 0.011 0.011Flow length (ft) = 63.0 0.0 0.0Two-year 24-hr precip. (in) = 2.20 0.00 0.00Land slope (%) = 18.80 0.00 0.00Travel Time (min)=7.30+0.00+0.00=7.30Shallow Concentrated FlowFlow length (ft) = 0.00 0.00 0.00Watercourse slope (%) = 0.00 0.00 0.00Surface description = Paved Paved PavedAverage velocity (ft/s)=0.00 0.00 0.00Travel Time (min)=0.00+0.00+0.00=0.00Channel FlowX sectional flow area (sqft) = 0.00 0.00 0.00Wetted perimeter (ft) = 0.00 0.00 0.00Channel slope (%) = 0.00 0.00 0.00Manning's n-value = 0.015 0.015 0.015Velocity (ft/s)=0.000.000.00Flow length (ft) ({0})0.0 0.0 0.0Travel Time (min)=0.00+0.00+0.00=0.00Total Travel Time, Tc .............................................................................. 7.30 min Page 59 of 72 Hydrograph Report5Hydraflow Hydrographs Extension for Autodesk® Civil 3D® by Autodesk, Inc. v2026 Monday, 09 / 14 / 2026Hyd. No. 2With Walls ConditionHydrograph type = SCS Runoff Peak discharge = 0.087 cfsStorm frequency = 5 yrs Time to peak = 720 minTime interval = 2 min Hyd. volume = 200 cuftDrainage area = 0.050 ac Curve number = 74.000Basin Slope = 0.0 % Hydraulic length = 0 ftTc method = TR55 Time of conc. (Tc) = 9.0 minTotal precip. = 3.30 in Distribution = Type IIStorm duration = 24 hrs Shape factor = 484Hydrograph Discharge Table( Printed values >= 80.00% of Qp.)Time -- Outflow(min cfs)716 0.073718 0.085720 0.087<<722 0.077...End Page 60 of 72 TR55 Tc Worksheet6Hydraflow Hydrographs Extension for Autodesk® Civil 3D® by Autodesk, Inc. v2026Hyd. No. 2With Walls ConditionDescriptionABCTotalsSheet FlowManning's n-value = 0.240 0.011 0.011Flow length (ft) = 63.0 0.0 0.0Two-year 24-hr precip. (in) = 2.20 0.00 0.00Land slope (%) = 4.00 0.00 0.00Travel Time (min)=9.01+0.00+0.00=9.01Shallow Concentrated FlowFlow length (ft) = 0.00 0.00 0.00Watercourse slope (%) = 0.00 0.00 0.00Surface description = Paved Paved PavedAverage velocity (ft/s)=0.00 0.00 0.00Travel Time (min)=0.00+0.00+0.00=0.00Channel FlowX sectional flow area (sqft) = 0.00 0.00 0.00Wetted perimeter (ft) = 0.00 0.00 0.00Channel slope (%) = 0.00 0.00 0.00Manning's n-value = 0.015 0.015 0.015Velocity (ft/s)=0.000.000.00Flow length (ft) ({0})0.0 0.0 0.0Travel Time (min)=0.00+0.00+0.00=0.00Total Travel Time, Tc .............................................................................. 9.00 min Page 61 of 72 Hydrograph Summary Report7Hyd. Hydrograph Peak Time Time to Hyd. Inflow Maximum Total HydrographNo. type flow interval Peak volume hyd(s) elevation strge used Description(origin) (cfs) (min) (min) (cuft) (ft) (cuft)1SCS Runoff 0.1592718 365 ------ ------ ------ Pre Wall Condition2SCS Runoff 0.1412720 323 ------ ------ ------ With Walls Condition FLow Calcs Obrian.gpw Return Period: 10 Year Monday, 09 / 14 / 2026 Hydraflow Hydrographs Extension for Autodesk® Civil 3D® by Autodesk, Inc. v2026 Page 62 of 72 Hydrograph Report8Hydraflow Hydrographs Extension for Autodesk® Civil 3D® by Autodesk, Inc. v2026 Monday, 09 / 14 / 2026Hyd. No. 1Pre Wall ConditionHydrograph type = SCS Runoff Peak discharge = 0.159 cfsStorm frequency = 10 yrs Time to peak = 718 minTime interval = 2 min Hyd. volume = 365 cuftDrainage area = 0.050 ac Curve number = 77.000Basin Slope = 0.0 % Hydraulic length = 0 ftTc method = TR55 Time of conc. (Tc) = 7.3 minTotal precip. = 4.25 in Distribution = Type IIStorm duration = 24 hrs Shape factor = 484Hydrograph Discharge Table( Printed values >= 80.00% of Qp.)Time -- Outflow(min cfs)716 0.141718 0.159<<720 0.159722 0.139...End Page 63 of 72 Hydrograph Report9Hydraflow Hydrographs Extension for Autodesk® Civil 3D® by Autodesk, Inc. v2026 Monday, 09 / 14 / 2026Hyd. No. 2With Walls ConditionHydrograph type = SCS Runoff Peak discharge = 0.141 cfsStorm frequency = 10 yrs Time to peak = 720 minTime interval = 2 min Hyd. volume = 323 cuftDrainage area = 0.050 ac Curve number = 74.000Basin Slope = 0.0 % Hydraulic length = 0 ftTc method = TR55 Time of conc. (Tc) = 9.0 minTotal precip. = 4.25 in Distribution = Type IIStorm duration = 24 hrs Shape factor = 484Hydrograph Discharge Table( Printed values >= 80.00% of Qp.)Time -- Outflow(min cfs)716 0.123718 0.140720 0.141<<722 0.124...End Page 64 of 72 Hydrograph Summary Report10Hyd. Hydrograph Peak Time Time to Hyd. Inflow Maximum Total HydrographNo. type flow interval Peak volume hyd(s) elevation strge used Description(origin) (cfs) (min) (min) (cuft) (ft) (cuft)1SCS Runoff 0.3292718 760 ------ ------ ------ Pre Wall Condition2SCS Runoff 0.3062718 702 ------ ------ ------ With Walls Condition FLow Calcs Obrian.gpw Return Period: 50 Year Monday, 09 / 14 / 2026 Hydraflow Hydrographs Extension for Autodesk® Civil 3D® by Autodesk, Inc. v2026 Page 65 of 72 Hydrograph Report11Hydraflow Hydrographs Extension for Autodesk® Civil 3D® by Autodesk, Inc. v2026 Monday, 09 / 14 / 2026Hyd. No. 1Pre Wall ConditionHydrograph type = SCS Runoff Peak discharge = 0.329 cfsStorm frequency = 50 yrs Time to peak = 718 minTime interval = 2 min Hyd. volume = 760 cuftDrainage area = 0.050 ac Curve number = 77.000Basin Slope = 0.0 % Hydraulic length = 0 ftTc method = TR55 Time of conc. (Tc) = 7.3 minTotal precip. = 6.80 in Distribution = Type IIStorm duration = 24 hrs Shape factor = 484Hydrograph Discharge Table( Printed values >= 80.00% of Qp.)Time -- Outflow(min cfs)716 0.297718 0.329<<720 0.324722 0.279...End Page 66 of 72 Hydrograph Report12Hydraflow Hydrographs Extension for Autodesk® Civil 3D® by Autodesk, Inc. v2026 Monday, 09 / 14 / 2026Hyd. No. 2With Walls ConditionHydrograph type = SCS Runoff Peak discharge = 0.306 cfsStorm frequency = 50 yrs Time to peak = 718 minTime interval = 2 min Hyd. volume = 702 cuftDrainage area = 0.050 ac Curve number = 74.000Basin Slope = 0.0 % Hydraulic length = 0 ftTc method = TR55 Time of conc. (Tc) = 9.0 minTotal precip. = 6.80 in Distribution = Type IIStorm duration = 24 hrs Shape factor = 484Hydrograph Discharge Table( Printed values >= 80.00% of Qp.)Time -- Outflow(min cfs)716 0.274718 0.306<<720 0.302722 0.261...End Page 67 of 72 Hydrograph Summary Report13Hyd. Hydrograph Peak Time Time to Hyd. Inflow Maximum Total HydrographNo. type flow interval Peak volume hyd(s) elevation strge used Description(origin) (cfs) (min) (min) (cuft) (ft) (cuft)1SCS Runoff 0.4082718 949 ------ ------ ------ Pre Wall Condition2SCS Runoff 0.3842718 886 ------ ------ ------ With Walls Condition FLow Calcs Obrian.gpw Return Period: 100 Year Monday, 09 / 14 / 2026 Hydraflow Hydrographs Extension for Autodesk® Civil 3D® by Autodesk, Inc. v2026 Page 68 of 72 Hydrograph Report14Hydraflow Hydrographs Extension for Autodesk® Civil 3D® by Autodesk, Inc. v2026 Monday, 09 / 14 / 2026Hyd. No. 1Pre Wall ConditionHydrograph type = SCS Runoff Peak discharge = 0.408 cfsStorm frequency = 100 yrs Time to peak = 718 minTime interval = 2 min Hyd. volume = 949 cuftDrainage area = 0.050 ac Curve number = 77.000Basin Slope = 0.0 % Hydraulic length = 0 ftTc method = TR55 Time of conc. (Tc) = 7.3 minTotal precip. = 7.95 in Distribution = Type IIStorm duration = 24 hrs Shape factor = 484Hydrograph Discharge Table( Printed values >= 80.00% of Qp.)Time -- Outflow(min cfs)716 0.370718 0.408<<720 0.400722 0.343...End Page 69 of 72 Hydrograph Report15Hydraflow Hydrographs Extension for Autodesk® Civil 3D® by Autodesk, Inc. v2026 Monday, 09 / 14 / 2026Hyd. No. 2With Walls ConditionHydrograph type = SCS Runoff Peak discharge = 0.384 cfsStorm frequency = 100 yrs Time to peak = 718 minTime interval = 2 min Hyd. volume = 886 cuftDrainage area = 0.050 ac Curve number = 74.000Basin Slope = 0.0 % Hydraulic length = 0 ftTc method = TR55 Time of conc. (Tc) = 9.0 minTotal precip. = 7.95 in Distribution = Type IIStorm duration = 24 hrs Shape factor = 484Hydrograph Discharge Table( Printed values >= 80.00% of Qp.)Time -- Outflow(min cfs)716 0.346718 0.384<<720 0.377722 0.325...End Page 70 of 72 SAVE THE FRANKLIN BATTLEFIELD, INC. Franklin, TN 9/02/2026 City of Franklin Board of Zoning Appeals Franklin, Tennessee RE: 1316 Buckingham Circle – Retaining Wall Variance Dear Members of the Board: Save the Franklin Battlefield, Inc. is the owner of property adjacent to 1316 Buckingham Circle, Franklin, Tennessee. We understand that an existing retaining wall located at 1316 Buckingham Circle extends beyond the property line and encroaches onto property owned by Save the Franklin Battlefield, Inc. Save the Franklin Battlefield, Inc. has reviewed the location of the existing retaining wall and is aware of the encroachment. We have no objection to the retaining wall remaining in its existing location and do not object to the property owner’s request for a variance from the applicable zoning requirements. We understand that the City of Franklin’s approval of a zoning variance is a separate matter from any private property rights between the adjoining property owners. This letter is provided to confirm our position regarding the existing retaining wall and our non- objection to the variance request. We respectfully request that the Board of Zoning Appeals consider this letter as part of its review of the variance request. Sincerely, Chip Huffman President Board of Directors Save the Franklin Battlefield, Inc. Page 71 of 72 From: Tim Crowe <timcrowe01@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, September 29, 2026 4:33 PM To: Planning Intake <planningintake@franklintn.gov> Subject: Variance Request for 1316 Buckingham Cicle ATTENTION COF staff: This email originated from outside the City of Franklin. Please use discretion when clicking on attachments & links from unknown senders or suspicious emails. Recently, I received a notice of the BZA hearing on 10/01/2029, since I am a homeowner within 500 feet of the property at 1316 Buckingham Circle. I do not plan to attend the hearing. As I have discussed with the city previously, my concern regarding the improvements at 1316 Buckingham Circle have to do with the apparent change in storm water runoff resulting in erosion of my property. My solution, at my expense, is to install a drain on my property to redirect the water flow. I certainly plan to request any necessary city permits before before I contract for the work to be done. Thank you.. . -- Tim Crowe c 630-518-8776 Page 72 of 72

Source: Williamson County website. First collected Oct 27, 2026.