Budget & Finance Committee — Agenda Packet
Williamson County · Williamson County · Budget & Finance Committee · meeting of Sep 10, 2026 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from Williamson County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
City of Franklin
Meeting Agenda
Budget & Finance Committee
Mailing Address:
109 3rd Ave S
Franklin, TN 37064
(615) 791-3217
Thursday, September 10,
2026
3:00 PM
Eastern Flank Event Facility
City of Franklin Page 1
CALL TO ORDER
SETTING OF THE AGENDA
1. Consideration Of Changes In Agenda And Setting The Agenda
CITIZEN COMMENTS (Open for citizens to be heard on any issue or concern, including those related to
items on the agenda. Please submit a Speaker Card at the beginning of the meeting if you would like to
address the Board/Commission. If you would like to speak on an agenda item, the Chair will hold your
comment until the public comment period associated with the item. As provided by law,
Boards/Commissions shall make no decisions or consideration of action of citizen comments for items not
on the agenda, except to refer the matter to the City Administrator/Staff for administrative consideration,
or to a schedule the matter for consideration at a later date. Those addressing the Board/Commission are
requested to come to the microphone and identify themselves by name and address for the official record.
The Chair may restrict the period for public comment, including the length of the public comment period,
the number of individuals who can speak and the length of time each individual may speak. When time
allows, the standard individual public comment time is two minutes.)
Comments on agenda items may be made in person or by emailing recorder@franklintn.gov before noon
on the day of the meeting. Comments will be submitted for the record.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
2. Consideration Of Approval Of Minutes
May 14, 2026 Budget & Finance Committee
NEW BUSINESS
3. Consideration Of Resolution 2026-66, A Resolution Authorizing The Use Of The Competitive Sealed
Proposals Procurement Method For Choosing The Service Provider For Administrative Services Only For
Group Health, Prescription Drug And Vision Benefits For Employees And Retirees For A Term Of Award
Sponsors: Kristine Brock, Sara Sylvis, Ashley Peery
4. Consideration Of Resolution 2026-67, A Resolution Authorizing The Use Of The Competitive Sealed
Proposals Procurement Method For Choosing The Service Provider For Administrative Services Only For
Group Dental Benefits For Employees And Retirees For A Term Of Award
Sponsors: Kristine Brock, Sara Sylvis, Ashley Peery
Page 1 of 212
Budget & Finance Committee Meeting Agenda September 10, 2026
5. Consideration Of Resolution 2026-70, A Resolution Authorizing The Use Of The Competitive Sealed
Proposals Procurement Method For Choosing The Service Provider For Voluntary Group Term Life And
Short-Term Disability Insurance For Employees And Retirees For A Term of Award
Sponsors: Kristine Brock, Sara Sylvis, Ashley Peery
6. Consideration Of Resolution 2026-71, A Resolution Authorizing The Use Of The Competitive Sealed
Proposals Procurement Method For Choosing The Service Provider For City Life And Accidental Death
and Dismemberment Insurance For Employees And Retirees For A Term of Award
Sponsors: Kristine Brock, Sara Sylvis, Ashley Peery
7. Consideration Of Resolution 2026-72, A Resolution Authorizing The Use Of The Competitive Sealed
Proposals Procurement Method For Choosing The Service Provider For An Employee Assistance
Program (EAP) For Employees And Retirees For A Term Of Award
Sponsors: Kristine Brock, Sara Sylvis, Ashley Peery
8. Consideration Of COF Contract No. 2026-0374, With BlueCross BlueShield Of Tennessee, Inc. For
Administrative Services Only For Group Health, Prescription Drug, And Vision Benefits For Employees
And Retirees For Fiscal Year 2027
Sponsors: Kristine Brock, Sara Sylvis
9. Consideration Of Resolution 2026-74, A Resolution Authorizing The Use Of The Competitive Sealed
Proposals Procurement Method For Choosing The Service Provider For Mowing Services For City Parks
For A Term Of Award
Sponsors: Lisa Clayton
10. Presentation From The City's Advisor For Non-Pension Related Investments
Sponsors: Kristine Brock
11. Consideration Of DRAFT Ordinance 2026-26, An Ordinance To Amend The Budget Of The City Of
Franklin For Fiscal Year 2026-2027
Sponsors: Eric Stuckey, Michael Walters Young
12. Report On State Comptroller's Review, Acceptance and Approval Of The City's FY 2027 Annual
Operating Budget.
Sponsors: Michael Walters Young
13. Financial Report For 4th Quarter Of FY 2026 (UNAUDITED)
Sponsors: Margaret Wilson
14. Monthly Reports For September 2026
Sponsors: Margaret Wilson
OTHER BUSINESS
Page 2 of 212
Budget & Finance Committee Meeting Agenda September 10, 2026
ADJOURN
Anyone needing accommodations due to disabilities please contact the ADA Coordinator at 615-791-3277 at least 24 hours prior to
the meeting.
Page 3 of 212
City of Franklin
Meeting Minutes
Budget & Finance Committee
109 3rd Ave S
Franklin, TN 37064
(615) 791-3217
Thursday, May 14, 2026
3:00 PM
Eastern Flank Event Facility
City of Franklin Page 1
CALL TO ORDER
Chair Clyde Barnhill called the meeting to order at 03:02 PM
Board Members Present: Clyde Barnhill, Ann Petersen, Matt Brown
Board Members Absent: Greg Caesar
Staff Present: Eric Stuckey, Kristine Brock, Michael Walters-Young, Margaret Wilson, Cayce Anderson, Alex
Brown, Alex Bearden
SETTING OF THE AGENDA
1. Consideration Of Changes In Agenda And Setting The Agenda
i. Discussion Of Removal Of Items From Consent/Changes Not Requiring A Vote
ii. Proposed Changes To The Agenda
iii. Approval Of Agenda As Submitted Or Changed
Sponsors:
A motion was made by Alderman Matt Brown, seconded by Vice Chair Ann Petersen to Approve the Agenda
as Submitted. The motion passed 3-0.
CITIZEN COMMENTS (Open for citizens to be heard on any issue or concern, including those related to
items on the agenda. Please submit a Speaker Card at the beginning of the meeting if you would like to
address the Board/Commission. If you would like to speak on an agenda item, the Chair will hold your
comment until the public comment period associated with the item. As provided by law,
Boards/Commissions shall make no decisions or consideration of action of citizen comments for items not
on the agenda, except to refer the matter to the City Administrator/Staff for administrative consideration, or
to a schedule the matter for consideration at a later date. Those addressing the Board/Commission are
requested to come to the microphone and identify themselves by name and address for the official record.
The Chair may restrict the period for public comment, including the length of the public comment period,
the number of individuals who can speak and the length of time each individual may speak. When time
allows, the standard individual public comment time is two minutes.)
Comments on agenda items may be made in person or by emailing recorder@franklintn.gov before noon
on the day of the meeting. Comments will be submitted for the record.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
2. Consideration Of Approval Of Minutes
April 13, 2026 Budget & Finance Committee Meeting
Sponsors:
A motion was made by Alderman Matt Brown, seconded by Vice Chair Ann Petersen to Approve the April 13,
2026 Budget & Finance Minutes. The motion passed 3-0.
Page 4 of 212
Budget & Finance Committee Meeting Agenda May 14, 2026
NEW BUSINESS
3. Consideration Of Procurement Award To Pinnacle Financial Partners Of Nashville, Tennessee For
Comprehensive Banking Services, Including General Banking And Lockbox Processing, In The
Estimated Annual Amounts Of $1,023,044.64 For Interest Earnings On The City’s Average Collected
Balances And $39,782.64 For Fees For The Required Services, For A Term Of Award, For Both The
Finance Department As Well As The Billing And Licensing Department (Purchasing Office Procurement
Solicitation No. 2026-014; Contract No. 2026-0159).
Sponsors: Kristine Brock, Margaret Wilson, Wesley Wright
A motion was made by Vice Chair Ann Petersen, seconded by Alderman Matt Brown to Recommend
the Procurement Award to the Board of Mayor and Aldermen for Approval. The motion passed 3-0.
4. Consideration Of DRAFT Ordinance 2026-09, An Ordinance To Amend The Budget Of The City Of
Franklin For Fiscal Year 2025-2026
Sponsors: Eric Stuckey, Michael Walters Young
A motion was made by Vice Chair Ann Petersen, seconded by Alderman Matt Brown to Recommend the
Ordinance to the Board of Mayor and Aldermen for approval. The motion passed 3-0.
5. Consideration Of DRAFT Ordinance 2026-10, An Ordinance Of The City Of Franklin, Tennessee
Adopting A Budget For The Fiscal Year 2026-2027; Providing An Effective Date
Sponsors: Eric Stuckey, Michael Walters Young
A motion was made by Alderman Matt Brown, seconded by Vice Chair Ann Petersen to Recommend
the Ordinance to the Board of Mayor and Aldermen for approval. The motion passed 3-0.
6. Consideration Of DRAFT Ordinance 2026-11, An Ordinance Of The City Of Franklin, Tennessee,
Establishing The Municipal Property Tax Levy For The Fiscal Year 2026-2027; Providing An Effective
Date
Sponsors: Eric Stuckey, Michael Walters Young
A motion was made by Alderman Matt Brown, seconded by Vice Chair Ann Petersen to Recommend
the Ordinance to the Board of Mayor and Aldermen for approval.The motion passed 3-0.
7. Consideration Of DRAFT Ordinance 2026-08, An Ordinance To Amend Appendix A, Comprehensive
Fees And Penalties, Chapter 17 Refuse And Trash Disposal, To Increase The Fees For Collection Of
Garbage And Refuse.
Sponsors: Mark Hilty, Nate Ridley, Skye Gerhart, Eric Stuckey, Michael Walters Young
A motion was made by Alderman Matt Brown, seconded by Vice Chair Ann Petersen to Recommend
the Ordinance to the Board of Mayor and Aldermen for approval. The motion passed 3-0.
8. Consideration Of DRAFT Resolution 2026-45, A Resolution Adopting A Five-Year Rate Plan For The
Sanitation And Environmental Services Department.
Sponsors: Eric Stuckey, Mark Hilty, Nate Ridley, Michael Walters Young, Skye Gerhart
Page 5 of 212
Budget & Finance Committee Meeting Agenda May 14, 2026
A motion was made by Alderman Matt Brown, seconded by Vice Chair Ann Petersen to Recommend the
Resolution to the Board of Mayor and Aldermen for approval. The motion passed 3-0.
9. Consideration Of DRAFT Ordinance 2026-12, An Ordinance To Amend Appendix A – Comprehensive
Fees And Penalties, Chapter 23 Stormwater Management
Sponsors: Mark Hilty, Skye Gerhart, Eric Stuckey, Michael Walters Young
A motion was made by Alderman Matt Brown, seconded by Vice Chair Ann Petersen to Recommend
the Ordinance to the Board of Mayor and Aldermen for approval. The motion passed 3-0.
10. Consideration Of DRAFT Resolution 2026-46, A Resolution Adopting A Five-Year Rate Plan For The
Stormwater Fund.
Sponsors: Eric Stuckey, Mark Hilty, Michael Walters Young, Skye Gerhart
A motion was made by Vice Chair Ann Petersen, seconded by Alderman Matt Brown to Recommend
the Resolution to the Board of Mayor and Aldermen for approval. The motion passed 3-0.
11. Consideration Of DRAFT Ordinance 2026-13, An Ordinance To Amend The City Of Franklin Municipal
Code, Title 12, Chapter 1 And Appendix A – Comprehensive Fees And Penalties, Chapter 12, Building,
Utility, Etc., Codes To Increase Minimum Nonresidential Plan Review Fees And Establish A Residential
And Fire Protection Plan Review Fee.
Sponsors: Eric Stuckey, Michael Walters Young, Tom Marsh, Glenn Johnson
A motion was made by Vice Chair Ann Petersen, seconded by Alderman Matt Brown to Recommend
the Ordinance to the Board of Mayor and Aldermen for approval. The motion passed 3-0.
12. Consideration Of DRAFT Resolution 2026-41, A Resolution Of The Board Of Mayor And Aldermen For
The City Of Franklin Adopting The Estimate Of Revenues And Expenditures For The Water And
Sanitary Sewer Utility Fund For Fiscal Year 2026-2027; Providing An Effective Date.
Sponsors: Eric Stuckey, Michael Walters Young, Mark Hilty, Michelle Hatcher
A motion was made by Alderman Matt Brown, seconded by Vice Chair Ann Petersen to Recommend the
Resolution to the Board of Mayor and Aldermen for approval. The motion passed 3-0.
13. Monthly Reports For May 2026
Sponsors: Margaret Wilson
The item was acknowledged.
OTHER BUSINESS
ADJOURN
A motion was made by Vice Chair Ann Petersen, seconded by Alderman Matt Brown to Adjourn the Meeting. The
motion passed 3-0.
Meeting Adjourned @ 04:20 PM
Page 6 of 212
Budget & Finance Committee Meeting Agenda May 14, 2026
____________________
Clyde Barnhill, Chair
Minutes Prepared by Sarah Schilling, Sr. Deputy City Recorder - City Recorder's Office - 7/29/26, 9:29AM
The above minutes should be used as a summary of the motions passed and issues discussed at the
meeting. This document shall not be considered a verbatim copy of every word spoken at the meeting.
Page 7 of 212
City of Franklin Page 1 of 2
City of Franklin
109 3rd Ave S.
Franklin, TN 37064
(615) 791-3217
File #: 26-0962
DATE: 9/10/2026
TO: Budget & Finance Committee
FROM: Kristine Brock, Asst. City Administrator/CFO
Sara Sylvis, Benefits Manager
Ashley Peery, Benefits Analyst
SUBJECT:
Consideration Of Resolution 2026-66, A Resolution Authorizing The Use Of The Competitive Sealed
Proposals Procurement Method For Choosing The Service Provider For Administrative Services Only
For Group Health, Prescription Drug And Vision Benefits For Employees And Retirees For A Term Of
Award
PURPOSE:
The purpose of this memorandum is to provide information to the Franklin Board of Mayor and
Aldermen (BOMA) concerning Res. 2026-66, a resolution authorizing the use of the competitive
sealed proposals procurement method for choosing the service provider for administrative services
only for group health, prescription drug and vision benefits for employees and retirees for a term of
award.
BACKGROUND/STAFF COMMENTS:
The procurement of administrative services for group health benefits requires the use of competitive
proposals, as each provider will propose unique and proprietary methods in response to the City's
request for proposals. The City is authorized to use the competitive sealed proposal procurement
method pursuant to the standards set forth in Municipal Code § 5-504 for determining which service
provider to recommend for award of administrative services only for group health, prescription drug
and vision benefits for employees and retirees for a term of award because qualifications,
experience, and competence are more important than price in making the purchase, and because
there is more than one solution to this purchasing issue and the competitive sealed proposal
procurement method will assist in choosing the best solution and service provider.
FINANCIAL IMPACT:
The costs are distributed among various departments and payroll accounts and are approved in the
current budget.
Page 8 of 212
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends that Res. 2026-66 be recommended for approval by the Board of Mayor and
Aldermen.
Page 9 of 212
1
RESOLUTION 2026-66
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE USE OF THE COMPETITIVE SEALED PROPOSALS
PROCUREMENT METHOD FOR CHOOSING THE SERVICE PROVIDER FOR ADMINISTRATIVE
SERVICES ONLY FOR GROUP HEALTH, PRESCRIPTION DRUG AND VISION BENEFITS FOR
EMPLOYEES AND RETIREES FOR A TERM OF AWARD
WHEREAS, pursuant to Tenn. Code Ann. § 12 -3-1207 the City may use competitive sealed
proposals rather than competitive sealed bids when the City adopts a process for the use of competitive
sealed proposals and determines that the use of competitive sealed bidding is either not practicable or
not advantageous to the City; and
WHEREAS, the City passed Ordinance 2019 -24 on August 13, 2019, authorizing the use of the
competitive sealed proposal procurement method; and
WHEREAS, should the City choose to pursue conducting its own competitive process for
establishing the basis of pricing pursuant to sealed submittals and published legal notice, then City staff
requests authority to use the competitive sealed proposal procurement me thod for determining which
service provider to recommend for award of administrative services only for group health, prescription
drug and vision benefits for employees and retirees for a term of award; and
WHEREAS, the Board of Mayor and Aldermen find that the use of the competitive sealed proposal
procurement method is advantageous to the City because qualifications, experience, and competence are
more important than price in making the purchase , and because there is more than one solution to this
purchasing issue and the competitive sealed proposal procurement method will assist in choosing the best
solution and service provider.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF MAYOR AND ALDERMEN OF THE CITY OF
FRANKLIN, TENNESSEE, AS FOLLOWS:
Should the City choose to pursue conducting its own competitive process for establishing the basis
of pricing pursuant to sealed submittals and published legal notice, then the City is authorized to use the
competitive sealed proposal procurement method pursuant to the standards set forth in Municipal Code
§ 5-504 for determining which service provider to recommend for award of administrative services only
for group health, prescription drug and vision benefits for employees and retirees for a term of award
because qualifications, experience, and competence are more important than price in making the
purchase, and because there is more than one solution to this purchasing issue and the competitive sealed
proposal procurement method will assist in choosing the best solution and service provider.
IT IS SO RESOLVED AND DONE on this ____ day of _______________, 2026.
ATTEST: CITY OF FRANKLIN, TENNESSEE:
By: By:
Eric S. Stuckey Dr. Ken Moore
City Administrator Mayor
Law Dept. Approved 08.17.26
Page 10 of 212
2
Approved as to Form:
By:
Ronda D. Webb
Staff Attorney
Law Dept. Approved 08.17.26
Page 11 of 212
City of Franklin Page 1 of 2
City of Franklin
109 3rd Ave S.
Franklin, TN 37064
(615) 791-3217
File #: 26-0963
DATE: 9/10/2026
TO: Budget & Finance Committee
FROM: Kristine Brock, Asst. City Administrator/CFO
Sara Sylvis, Benefits Manager
Ashley Peery, Benefits Analyst
SUBJECT:
Consideration Of Resolution 2026-67, A Resolution Authorizing The Use Of The Competitive Sealed
Proposals Procurement Method For Choosing The Service Provider For Administrative Services Only
For Group Dental Benefits For Employees And Retirees For A Term Of Award
PURPOSE:
The purpose of this memorandum is to provide information to the Franklin Board of Mayor and
Aldermen (BOMA) concerning Res. 2026-67, a resolution authorizing the use of the competitive
sealed proposals procurement method for choosing the service provider for administrative services
only for group dental benefits for employees and retirees for a term of award.
BACKGROUND/STAFF COMMENTS:
The procurement of administrative services for group dental benefits requires the use of competitive
proposals, as each provider will propose unique and proprietary methods in response to the City's
request for proposals. The City is authorized to use the competitive sealed proposal procurement
method pursuant to the standards set forth in Municipal Code § 5-504 for determining which service
provider to recommend for award of administrative services only for group dental benefits for
employees and retirees for a term of award because qualifications, experience, and competence are
more important than price in making the purchase, and because there is more than one solution to
this purchasing issue and the competitive sealed proposal procurement method will assist in
choosing the best solution and service provider.
FINANCIAL IMPACT:
The costs are distributed among various departments and payroll accounts and are approved in the
current budget.
RECOMMENDATION:
Page 12 of 212
Staff recommends that Res. 2026-67 be recommended for approval by the Board of Mayor and
Aldermen.
Page 13 of 212
1
RESOLUTION 2026-67
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE USE OF THE COMPETITIVE SEALED PROPOSALS
PROCUREMENT METHOD FOR CHOOSING THE SERVICE PROVIDER FOR ADMINISTRATIVE
SERVICES ONLY FOR GROUP DENTAL BENEFITS FOR EMPLOYEES AND RETIREES FOR A TERM
OF AWARD
WHEREAS, pursuant to Tenn. Code Ann. § 12 -3-1207 the City may use competitive sealed
proposals rather than competitive sealed bids when the City adopts a process for the use of competitive
sealed proposals and determines that the use of competitive sealed bidding is either not practicable or
not advantageous to the City; and
WHEREAS, the City passed Ordinance 2019 -24 on August 13, 2019, authorizing the use of the
competitive sealed proposal procurement method; and
WHEREAS, should the City choose to pursue conducting its own competitive process for
establishing the basis of pricing pursuant to sealed submittals and published legal notice, then City staff
requests authority to use the competitive sealed proposal procurement me thod for determining which
service provider to recommend for award of administrative services only for group dental benefits for
employees and retirees for a term of award; and
WHEREAS, the Board of Mayor and Aldermen find that the use of the competitive sealed proposal
procurement method is advantageous to the City because qualifications, experience, and competence are
more important than price in making the purchase , and because there is more than one solution to this
purchasing issue and the competitive sealed proposal procurement method will assist in choosing the best
solution and service provider.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF MAYOR AND ALDERMEN OF THE CITY OF
FRANKLIN, TENNESSEE, AS FOLLOWS:
Should the City choose to pursue conducting its own competitive process for establishing the basis
of pricing pursuant to sealed submittals and published legal notice, then the City is authorized to use the
competitive sealed proposal procurement method pursuant to the standards set forth in Municipal Code
§ 5-504 for determining which service provider to recommend for award of administrative services only
for group dental benefits for employees and retirees for a term of award because qualifications,
experience, and competence are more important than price in making the purchase , and because there
is more than one solution to this purchasing issue and the competitive sealed proposal procurement
method will assist in choosing the best solution and service provider.
IT IS SO RESOLVED AND DONE on this ____ day of _______________, 2026.
ATTEST: CITY OF FRANKLIN, TENNESSEE:
By: By:
Eric S. Stuckey Dr. Ken Moore
City Administrator Mayor
Law Dept. Approved 08.17.26
Page 14 of 212
2
Approved as to Form:
By:
Ronda D. Webb
Staff Attorney
Law Dept. Approved 08.17.26
Page 15 of 212
City of Franklin Page 1 of 2
City of Franklin
109 3rd Ave S.
Franklin, TN 37064
(615) 791-3217
File #: 26-0994
DATE: 9/10/2026
TO: Budget & Finance Committee
FROM: Kristine Brock, Asst. City Administrator/CFO
Sara Sylvis, Benefits Manager
Ashley Peery, Benefits Analyst
SUBJECT:
Consideration Of Resolution 2026-70, A Resolution Authorizing The Use Of The Competitive Sealed
Proposals Procurement Method For Choosing The Service Provider For Voluntary Group Term Life
And Short-Term Disability Insurance For Employees And Retirees For A Term of Award
PURPOSE:
The purpose of this memorandum is to provide information to the Franklin Board of Mayor and
Aldermen (BOMA) concerning Res. 2026-70, a resolution authorizing the use of the competitive
sealed proposals procurement method for choosing the service provider for voluntary group term life
and short-term disability insurance for employees and retirees for a term of award.
BACKGROUND/STAFF COMMENTS:
The procurement of voluntary group term life and short-term disability insurance for employees and
retirees requires the use of competitive proposals, as each provider will propose unique and
proprietary methods in response to the City's request for proposals. The City is authorized to use the
competitive sealed proposal procurement method pursuant to the standards set forth in Municipal
Code § 5-504 for determining which service provider to recommend for award of voluntary group
term life and short-term disability insurance for employees and retirees for a term of award because
qualifications,experience, and competence are more important than price in making the purchase,
and because there is more than one solution to this purchasing issue and the competitive sealed
proposal procurement method will assist in choosing the best solution and service provider.
FINANCIAL IMPACT:
As this is a voluntary product, expenses are paid by City of Franklin employees through payroll
deductions.
RECOMMENDATION:
Page 16 of 212
Staff recommends that Res. 2026-70 be recommended for approval by the Board of Mayor and
Aldermen.
Page 17 of 212
1
RESOLUTION 2026-70
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE USE OF THE COMPETITIVE SEALED PROPOSALS
PROCUREMENT METHOD FOR CHOOSING THE SERVICE PROVIDER FOR VOLUNTARY GROUP
TERM LIFE AND SHORT-TERM DISABILITY INSURANCE FOR EMPLOYEES AND RETIREES FOR A
TERM OF AWARD
WHEREAS, pursuant to Tenn. Code Ann. § 12 -3-1207 the City may use competitive sealed
proposals rather than competitive sealed bids when the City adopts a process for the use of competitive
sealed proposals and determines that the use of competitive sealed bidding is either not practicable or
not advantageous to the City; and
WHEREAS, the City passed Ordinance 2019 -24 on August 13, 2019, authorizing the use of the
competitive sealed proposal procurement method; and
WHEREAS, should the City choose to pursue conducting its own competitive process for
establishing the basis of pricing pursuant to sealed submittals and published legal notice, then City staff
requests authority to use the competitive sealed proposal procurement me thod for determining which
service provider to recommend for award of voluntary group term life and short-term disability insurance
for employees and retirees for a term of award; and
WHEREAS, the Board of Mayor and Aldermen find that the use of the competitive sealed proposal
procurement method is advantageous to the City because qualifications, experience, and competence are
more important than price in making the purchase , and because there is more than one solution to this
purchasing issue and the competitive sealed proposal procurement method will assist in choosing the best
solution and service provider.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF MAYOR AND ALDERMEN OF THE CITY OF
FRANKLIN, TENNESSEE, AS FOLLOWS:
Should the City choose to pursue conducting its own competitive process for establishing the basis
of pricing pursuant to sealed submittals and published legal notice, then the City is authorized to use the
competitive sealed proposal procurement method pursuant to the standards set forth in Municipal Code
§ 5-504 for determining which service provider to recommend for award of voluntary group term life and
short-term disability insurance for employees and retirees for a term of award because qualifications,
experience, and competence are more important than price in making the purchase , and because there
is more than one solution to this purchasing issue and the competitive sealed proposal procurement
method will assist in choosing the best solution and service provider.
IT IS SO RESOLVED AND DONE on this ____ day of _______________, 2026.
ATTEST: CITY OF FRANKLIN, TENNESSEE:
By: By:
Eric S. Stuckey Dr. Ken Moore
City Administrator Mayor
Law Dept. Approved 08.17.26
Page 18 of 212
2
Approved as to Form:
By:
Ronda D. Webb
Staff Attorney
Law Dept. Approved 08.17.26
Page 19 of 212
City of Franklin Page 1 of 2
City of Franklin
109 3rd Ave S.
Franklin, TN 37064
(615) 791-3217
File #: 26-0995
DATE: 9/10/2026
TO: Budget & Finance Committee
FROM: Kristine Brock, Asst. City Administrator/CFO
Sara Sylvis, Benefits Manager
Ashley Peery, Benefits Analyst
SUBJECT:
Consideration Of Resolution 2026-71, A Resolution Authorizing The Use Of The Competitive Sealed
Proposals Procurement Method For Choosing The Service Provider For City Life And Accidental
Death and Dismemberment Insurance For Employees And Retirees For A Term of Award
PURPOSE:
The purpose of this memorandum is to provide information to the Franklin Board of Mayor and
Aldermen (BOMA) concerning Res. 2026-71, a resolution authorizing the use of the competitive
sealed proposals procurement method for choosing the service provider for city life and accidental
death and dismemberment insurance for employees and retirees for a term of award
BACKGROUND/STAFF COMMENTS:
The procurement of city life and accidental death and dismemberment insurance for employees and
retirees requires the use of competitive proposals, as each provider will propose unique and
proprietary methods in response to the City's request for proposals. The City is authorized to use the
competitive sealed proposal procurement method pursuant to the standards set forth in Municipal
Code § 5-504 for determining which service provider to recommend for award of life and accidental
death and dismemberment insurance for employees and retirees for a term of award because
qualifications, experience, and competence are more important than price in making the purchase,
and because there is more than one solution to this purchasing issue and the competitive sealed
proposal procurement method will assist in choosing the best solution and service provider.
FINANCIAL IMPACT:
The costs are distributed among various departments and payroll accounts and are approved in the
current budget.
RECOMMENDATION:
Page 20 of 212
Staff recommends that Res. 2026-71 be recommended for approval by the Board of Mayor and
Aldermen.
Page 21 of 212
1
RESOLUTION 2026-71
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE USE OF THE COMPETITIVE SEALED PROPOSALS
PROCUREMENT METHOD FOR CHOOSING THE SERVICE PROVIDER FOR CITY LIFE AND
ACCIDENTAL DEATH AND DISMEMBERMENT INSURANCE FOR EMPLOYEES AND RETIREES FOR
A TERM OF AWARD
WHEREAS, pursuant to Tenn. Code Ann. § 12 -3-1207 the City may use competitive sealed
proposals rather than competitive sealed bids when the City adopts a process for the use of competitive
sealed proposals and determines that the use of competitive sealed bidding is either not practicable or
not advantageous to the City; and
WHEREAS, the City passed Ordinance 2019 -24 on August 13, 2019, authorizing the use of the
competitive sealed proposal procurement method; and
WHEREAS, should the City choose to pursue conducting its own competitive process for
establishing the basis of pricing pursuant to sealed submittals and published legal notice, then City staff
requests authority to use the competitive sealed proposal procurement me thod for determining which
service provider to recommend for award of life and accidental death and dismemberment insurance for
employees and retirees for a term of award; and
WHEREAS, the Board of Mayor and Aldermen find that the use of the competitive sealed proposal
procurement method is advantageous to the City because qualifications, experience, and competence are
more important than price in making the purchase , and because there is more than one solution to this
purchasing issue and the competitive sealed proposal procurement method will assist in choosing the best
solution and service provider.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF MAYOR AND ALDERMEN OF THE CITY OF
FRANKLIN, TENNESSEE, AS FOLLOWS:
Should the City choose to pursue conducting its own competitive process for establishing the basis
of pricing pursuant to sealed submittals and published legal notice, then the City is authorized to use the
competitive sealed proposal procurement method pursuant to the standards set forth in Municipal Code
§ 5-504 for determining which service provider to recommend for award of life and accidental death and
dismemberment insurance for employees and retirees for a term of award because qualifications,
experience, and competence are more important than price in making the purchase , and because there
is more than one solution to this purchasing issue and the competitive sealed proposal procurement
method will assist in choosing the best solution and service provider.
IT IS SO RESOLVED AND DONE on this ____ day of _______________, 2026.
ATTEST: CITY OF FRANKLIN, TENNESSEE:
By: By:
Eric S. Stuckey Dr. Ken Moore
City Administrator Mayor
Law Dept. Approved 08.17.26
Page 22 of 212
2
Approved as to Form:
By:
Ronda D. Webb
Staff Attorney
Law Dept. Approved 08.17.26
Page 23 of 212
City of Franklin Page 1 of 2
City of Franklin
109 3rd Ave S.
Franklin, TN 37064
(615) 791-3217
File #: 26-01011
DATE: 9/10/2026
TO: Budget & Finance Committee
FROM: Kristine Brock, Asst. City Administrator/CFO
Sara Sylvis, Benefits Manager
Ashley Peery, Benefits Analyst
SUBJECT:
Consideration Of Resolution 2026-72, A Resolution Authorizing The Use Of The Competitive Sealed
Proposals Procurement Method For Choosing The Service Provider For An Employee Assistance
Program (EAP) For Employees And Retirees For A Term Of Award
PURPOSE:
The purpose of this memorandum is to provide information to the Franklin Board of Mayor and
Aldermen (BOMA) concerning Res. 2026-72, a resolution authorizing the use of the competitive
sealed proposals procurement method for choosing the service provider for an employee assistance
program (EAP) for employees and retirees for a term of award.
BACKGROUND/STAFF COMMENTS:
The procurement of employee assistance program (EAP) services requires the use of competitive
proposals, as each provider will propose unique and proprietary methods in response to the City's
request for proposals. The City is authorized to use the competitive sealed proposal procurement
method pursuant to the standards set forth in Municipal Code § 5-504 for determining which service
provider to recommend for award of an employee assistance program (EAP) for employees and
retirees for a term of award because qualifications, experience, and competence are more important
than price in making the purchase, and because there is more than one solution to this purchasing
issue and the competitive sealed proposal procurement method will assist in choosing the best
solution and service provider.
FINANCIAL IMPACT:
The costs are distributed among various departments and payroll accounts and are approved in the
current budget.
RECOMMENDATION:
Page 24 of 212
Staff recommends that Res. 2026-72 be recommended for approval by the Board of Mayor and
Aldermen.
Page 25 of 212
1
RESOLUTION 2026-72
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE USE OF THE COMPETITIVE SEALED PROPOSALS
PROCUREMENT METHOD FOR CHOOSING THE SERVICE PROVIDER FOR AN EMPLOYEE
ASSISTANCE PROGRAM (EAP) FOR EMPLOYEES AND RETIREES FOR A TERM OF AWARD
WHEREAS, pursuant to Tenn. Code Ann. § 12 -3-1207 the City may use competitive sealed
proposals rather than competitive sealed bids when the City adopts a process for the use of competitive
sealed proposals and determines that the use of competitive sealed bidding is either not practicable or
not advantageous to the City; and
WHEREAS, the City passed Ordinance 2019 -24 on August 13, 2019, authorizing the use of the
competitive sealed proposal procurement method; and
WHEREAS, should the City choose to pursue conducting its own competitive process for
establishing the basis of pricing pursuant to sealed submittals and published legal notice, then City staff
requests authority to use the competitive sealed proposal procurement me thod for determining which
service provider to recommend for award of an employee assistance program ( EAP) for employees and
retirees for a term of award; and
WHEREAS, the Board of Mayor and Aldermen find that the use of the competitive sealed proposal
procurement method is advantageous to the City because qualifications, experience, and competence are
more important than price in making the purchase , and because there is more than one solution to this
purchasing issue and the competitive sealed proposal procurement method will assist in choosing the best
solution and service provider.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF MAYOR AND ALDERMEN OF THE CITY OF
FRANKLIN, TENNESSEE, AS FOLLOWS:
Should the City choose to pursue conducting its own competitive process for establishing the basis
of pricing pursuant to sealed submittals and published legal notice, then the City is authorized to use the
competitive sealed proposal procurement method pursuant to the standards set forth in Municipal Code
§ 5 -504 for determining which service provider to recommend for award of an employee assistance
program (EAP) for employees and retirees for a term of award because qualifications, experience, and
competence are more important than price in making the purchase, and because there is more than one
solution to this purchasing issue and the competitive sealed proposal procurement method will assist in
choosing the best solution and service provider.
IT IS SO RESOLVED AND DONE on this ____ day of _______________, 2026.
ATTEST: CITY OF FRANKLIN, TENNESSEE:
By: By:
Eric S. Stuckey Dr. Ken Moore
City Administrator Mayor
Law Dept. Approved 08.14.26
Page 26 of 212
2
Approved as to Form:
By:
Ronda D. Webb
Staff Attorney
Law Dept. Approved 08.14.26
Page 27 of 212
City of Franklin Page 1 of 1
City of Franklin
109 3rd Ave S.
Franklin, TN 37064
(615) 791-3217
File #: 26-01119
DATE: 9/10/2026
TO: Budget & Finance Committee
FROM: Kristine Brock, Asst. City Administrator/CFO
Sara Sylvis, Benefits Manager
SUBJECT:
Consideration Of COF Contract No. 2026-0374, With BlueCross BlueShield Of Tennessee, Inc. For
Administrative Services Only For Group Health, Prescription Drug, And Vision Benefits For
Employees And Retirees For Fiscal Year 2027
PURPOSE:
The purpose of this memorandum is to provide information to the Franklin Board of Mayor and
Aldermen (BOMA) concerning COF Contract 2026-0374 with BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee,
Inc. to provide administrative services of the city's employee health insurance plan for fiscal year
2027.
BACKGROUND/STAFF COMMENTS:
The current contract for administrative services only for the city's health, prescription drug and vision
insurance is in its final year and is scheduled for re-procurement. This agreement for fiscal year
2027 updates terms and conditions required by BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee, Inc. to keep the
administration of the city's current employee health, prescription drug, and vision insurance plan in
compliance with all federal and state laws.
FINANCIAL IMPACT:
The costs for the administration of the city's employee benefits are incorporated into the current
approved budget as a portion of each department's personnel expenses.
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends that COF Contract 2026-0374 with BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee, Inc. be
recommended for approval by the Board of Mayor and Aldermen.
Page 28 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 9/1/2026
Administrative Services Agreement Page 1
An Independent Licensee of the Blue Cross and Blue Shield Association
ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
BETWEEN
BLUECROSS BLUESHIELD OF TENNESSEE, INC.
AND
CITY OF FRANKLIN, TENNESSEE
CO
F CONTRACT NO. 2026-0374
This Administrative Services Agreement (the “ Agreement”), is by and between City of Franklin,
Tennessee (“ Employer”) and BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee, Inc. (“ BlueCross”), and is
effective as stated in Section 3.1 of this Agreement. Employer and BlueCross may be individually
referred to in this Agreement as a “Party” and are collectively referred to in this Agreement as the
“Parties”.
WHEREAS, Employer has established a self -funded Employee Welfare Benefit Plan; however,
Employer represents that this Employee Welfare Benefit Plan (“Plan”) is not subject to ERISA;
WHEREAS, BlueCross offers to sponsors of self- funded employee welfare benefit plans certain
administrative and related services in connection with such sponsors’ administration of their plans;
and
WHEREAS, Employer seeks for BlueCross to provide, and BlueCross agrees to provide,
administrative services to and on behalf of Employer and the Plan as set forth in this Agreement.
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the promises, covenants, representations, and warranties
set forth herein, and other consideration, the sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, the
Parties each hereby agree as follows:
ARTICLE I – RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE PARTIES
1.1. BlueCross. BlueCross shall provide administrative claims payment services in accordance
with the terms of the Benefit Documents, shall perform other services as set forth in this
Agreement, and shall perform other duties specifically assumed by BlueCross pursuant to
this Agreement. BlueCross does not assume any financial risk or obligation with respect
to Approved Claims or the Plan . BlueCross shall perform its services and duties in
accordance with the terms of this Agreement and applicable law and will administer the
benefits in accordance with BlueCross’s customary administrative standards and practices
and generally accepted standards applicable to claims administration, including other
licensees of the Association. To the extent Employer or the Plan engages a third- party
Employer Service Vendor to administer certain benefits under the Plan, Employer hereby
acknowledges and agrees that (i) BlueCross, BlueCross’ Affiliates, and their
subcontractors or assigns shall have no responsibility for any act, error, or omission of
such Employer Service Vendor or with respect to the performance of such Employer
Service Vendor and (ii) Employer shall remain fully responsible and liable for the acts or
omissions of all Employer Service Vendors.
Law Dept approved 08.31.26
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 29 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 9/1/2026
Administrative Services Agreement Page 2
1.2. Employer. Employer shall perform the obligations set forth in this Agreement, including
maintaining the Plan in accordance with applicable law, providing information to BlueCross
regarding the Plan and Members necessary to administer the Plan, and timely funding and
payment of Approved Claims and ASFs.
1.3. Benefit Documents. Employer shall provide BlueCross with a current, detailed, accurate
copy of the Benefits Documents, which are attached as Exhibit A (“Benefit Documents ”).
Employer shall notify BlueCross of any changes Employer intends to make to the terms
and/or conditions of the Benefit Documents or the Plan. Notification shall be made
sufficiently in advance of any such changes so as to permit BlueCross reasonable time to
review and/or implement such changes. It is Employer’s obligation to ensure all Benefit
Documents, whether or not produced by BlueCross, meet the requirements of applicable
laws. Employer agrees that all Association- mandated language shall be included in its
Benefit Documents. BlueCross shall not be responsible for administering any Benefit
Document that has not been reviewed and accepted by BlueCross. Until Employer has
approved changes to the Benefits Documents, BlueCross will administer the quoted
benefits according to the descriptions contained in Employer’s Benefits Documents last
accepted by BlueCross.
1.4. Stop Loss Coverage. Employer has entered into a stop loss arrangement with a stop loss
vendor. BlueCross’s duties with regard to this stop loss arrangement are set forth in Exhibit
C.
1.5. Fiduciary Responsibility. Employer is solely responsible for the fiduciary responsibilities of
administering its Plan and maintaining adequate funding to support the Plan, determining
eligibility under the Plan, and preparing and providing its covered employees with copies
of Benefit Documents. Although Employer’s Plan is not subject to ERISA, Employer
acknowledges that BlueCross is acting in a ministerial capacity and is not the
“Administrator,” the “Claims Fiduciary,” nor the “Named Fiduciary” of Employer’s Plan, as
those terms are defined in ERISA. The “Plan Administrator” of the Plan, as that term is
defined in ERISA, is Employer.
1.6. Claims Funding. Employer shall timely pay to BlueCross the invoiced amount for Approved
Claims. BlueCross shall notify Employer weekly of the estimated amounts necessary to
fund payment of the Approved Claims. Employer shall then appropriately fund the
Approved Claims in accordance with this Agreement . Nothing in this Agreement shall
obligate or shall be deemed to obligate BlueCross to use its funds to satisfy any of
Employer’s obligations pursuant to this Agreement or Plan benefits. Employer’s assets
and amounts contributed by Members, if applicable, are the only source(s) of funding and
payment of Approved Claims or any other benefit provided under the Plan.
1.7. Administrative Services Fees (“ASF(s)”). Employer shall timely pay ASFs in accordance
with the Agreement. The initial ASF shall be due and payable on the Effective Date of this
Agreement.
Law Dept approved 08.31.26
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 30 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 9/1/2026
Administrative Services Agreement Page 3
ARTICLE II – CONFIDENTIALITY
2.1. Confidential Information.
2.1.1. The parties acknowledge that Employer is subject to the Tennessee Open Records
Act (“TORA”); however, the Parties acknowledge that, to the extent permitted by
applicable law, this Agreement and Confidential Information shall be treated as
confidential, proprietary and trade secret information. Employer further
acknowledges and agrees that BlueCross Confidential Information relating to
provider identifiable information, payment rates and discounts, fee schedules,
allowed amounts, policies and procedures and/or all other information in which
BlueCross has proprietary interest, is proprietary and a valuable trade secret of
BlueCross and that any disclosure or unauthorized use thereof will cause
irreparable harm and loss to BlueCross. Notwithstanding the foregoing, BlueCross
agrees to provide to Employer information reasonably requested by Employer in
BlueCross’ possession to the extent required for Employer to meet its disclosure
obligations with respect to the Plan under applicable law.
2.1.2. The Parties agree that any Protected Health Information that is commingled with
Confidential Information disclosed under this Agreement shall be subject to the
Business Associate Agreement between the Parties.
2.2. Uses and Disclosures of Confidential Information. Neither Party shall use or disclose the
Confidential Information of the other Party, except as permitted herein.
2.2.1. BlueCross’s Release or Disclosure. BlueCross may disclose Employer’s
Confidential Information to providers within BlueCross’s networks, to BlueCross’s
affiliates and other licensees of the Association, and BlueCross’s Representatives
who: (A) need to know such Employer Confidential Information or performance of
responsibilities related to the Plan and/or this Agreement; and (B) are under a duty
or obligation of confidentiality at least as restrictive as those set forth in this
Agreement. BlueCross may also disclose Employer’s Confidential Information
pursuant to a valid subpoena, administrative order or court order.
2.2.2. Employer’s Release or Disclosure of Confidential Information. Employer shall use
BlueCross Confidential Information solely for the purpose of administering
Employer’s Plan. Employer shall not disclose BlueCross’s Confidential Information
to a third party, including an Employer Service Vendor, unless the parties enter
into an executed information sharing agreement with the third party pursuant to
this Section 2.2.2. BlueCross may disclose Confidential Information of Employer
to an Employer Service Vendor for Plan administration as directed by Employer,
provided, however that (A) BlueCross, Employer and such Employer Service
Vendor first must enter into an information sharing agreement approved by
BlueCross authorizing BlueCross to disclose Confidential Information to such
Employer Service Vendor, (B) any such disclosure shall be subject to the
requirements of applicable laws and regulations and their implementing guidance,
the policies and procedures of the Association, this Agreement, and such fully -
executed information sharing agreement, and (C) the Parties acknowledge and
agree that, notwithstanding the foregoing, BlueCross is under no obligation to
release BlueCross Confidential Information at any time. Any information sharing
agreement adopted pursuant to this section shall include:
2.2.2.1. Written authorization by Employer to release the Confidential
Law Dept approved 08.31.26
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 31 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 9/1/2026
Administrative Services Agreement Page 4
Information to the Employer Service Vendor and a statement that
Employer has entered into a business associate agreement with such
Employer Service Vendor as required by HIPAA;
2.2.2.2. A statement that the Employer Service Vendor must have such
information in order to perform their job as it relates to the administration
of the Plan;
2.2.2.3. Protections for the Confidential Information;
2.2.2.4. Prohibitions against use of the data to obtain trade secrets, confidential
business information, personally identifiable information, or otherwise
use in a competitive manner against BlueCross or other licensees of the
Association;
2.2.2.5. A statement by the Employer and Employer Service Vendor that the
disclosure of the Confidential Information is limited to the minimum
necessary to fulfill the purpose for which it will be disclosed;
2.2.2.6. A detailed description of the intended use (and any impermissible uses)
of the Confidential Information;
2.2.2.7. A statement that the Confidential Information will not be resold or
otherwise commercialized by Employer Service Vendor or any other
person;
2.2.2.8. The right for BlueCross to confirm, through an audit, that the Confidential
Information is not being used or disclosed in an impermissible manner;
2.2.2.9. A statement that the Confidential Information will be returned or securely
destroyed by the Employer Service Vendor when it is no longer needed
for the purpose for which it was disclosed;
2.2.2.10. A statement that the Employer Service Vendor will notify BlueCross
when the Employer Service Vendor’s ownership changes;
2.2.2.11. A statement that the Employer Service Vendor will defend or settle
and/or hold harmless and indemnify BlueCross, as well as it officers and
employees, from all claims, losses, or suits resulting from the Employer
Service Vendor’s breach of the information sharing agreement or its
unauthorized use or disclosure of Confidential Information;
2.2.2.12. A statement that the Employer Service Vendor will comply with all laws,
rules and regulations applicable to the sharing of information that
includes Confidential Information contemplated under the information
sharing agreement and that failure to comply with such laws shall be
considered a material breach of such agreement; and
2.2.2.13. Any other requirement BlueCross deems necessary based on the
intended use of the Confidential Information.
2.2.3. Right of Refusal. BlueCross reserves the right to refuse to release: (A) Confidential
Information if BlueCross determines, in its sole discretion, that such release has
the potential to damage BlueCross, including its reputation or competitive position
Law Dept approved 08.31.26
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 32 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 9/1/2026
Administrative Services Agreement Page 5
in the market, or (B) any information BlueCross reasonably believes it cannot
divulge due to applicable state or federal laws, Association provisions, applicable
privileges or judicial or administrative orders. In no instance shall Employer itself,
nor shall Employer allow a third party to, use or disclose BlueCross’s Confidential
Information: (A) to be aggregated with information of other third parties; (B) for the
commercial purposes of any person; or (C) to compete directly or indirectly against
BlueCross.
2.3. Rights in Data. The Parties agree that BlueCross owns claim or payment data (including
any Confidential Information)recorded for or otherwise integrated into BlueCross’s data,
BlueCross claims processing or other systems, or BlueCross Confidential Information.
2.4. Legally Compelled. Employer may disclose Confidential Information if legally compelled
by a valid judicial or administrative order; provided however, that Employer shall make
every attempt to keep BlueCross’s Confidential Information confidential, shall only
disclose the minimum information necessary to comply with the order, shall provide written
notice to BlueCross immediately upon making the determination that BlueCross’s
Confidential Information must be disclosed and shall only disclose the information after
BlueCross has been notified and has the opportunity to consent to or challenge s uch
disclosure.
2.5. Protected Health Information. The Parties have entered into a Business Associate
Agreement, the terms of which control the use and disclosure of Protected Health
Information, as defined by HIPAA.
2.6. Survival. This Article 2 shall survive termination of the Agreement.
ARTICLE III – TERM AND TERMINATION
3.1. Term. This Agreement becomes effective at 12:01 A.M. Eastern Time on July 1, 2026 (the
“Effective Date”) and shall remain in effect until the earliest of the following:
3.1.1. Until June 30, 2027, unless Employer and BlueCross agree in a writing executed
by both Parties to extend the term prior to June 30, 2027;
3.1.2. After the Initial Term of the Agreement, either Party may terminate the Agreement
by giving the other Party no less than sixty (60) days advance written notice of the
terminating Party’s intent to terminate the Agreement as of the date specified in
such notice.
3.1.3. Any other date mutually agreed upon by the Parties; or
3.1.4. The occurrence of any of the events specified in Section 3.2.
3.2. Termination by BlueCross. Notwithstanding the provisions of Section 3.1 above, this
Agreement shall terminate upon the occurrence of any of the following events, as
determined by BlueCross. Such termination shall be effective as of the date identified by
BlueCross in its notice of termination to the Employer, and the Parties acknowledge that
the termination may be retroactively effective.
3.2.1. Employer’s failure to timely provide adequate funds, as set forth in Exhibit B, as
necessary for the payment of Approved Claims;
3.2.2. Employer’s failure to pay any ASFs, late payment penalty or other amounts as set
Law Dept approved 08.31.26
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 33 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 9/1/2026
Administrative Services Agreement Page 6
forth in Exhibit B or otherwise due to BlueCross under this Agreement;
3.2.3. Employer ceases to maintain the Plan;
3.2.4. At any time BlueCross reasonably believes that Employer does not have the
financial ability to adequately and timely fund claims, and Employer has failed to
provide adequate assurances of such ability to BlueCross; or
3.2.5. At any time Employer fails to comply with applicable law or otherwise materially
breaches this Agreement, after the procedures in Section 3.6 have been followed.
3.3. Termination for Invalid Use of BlueCross Confidential Information . If Employer uses or
discloses BlueCross’s Confidential Information in any manner not authorized by this
Agreement, such disclosure shall constitute a material breach that is not subject to cure
or correction, and BlueCross may terminate the Agreement immediately pursuant to
Section 3.6.3.
3.4. BlueCross’s Right to Reinstate. BlueCross has the sole discretion to decide whether to
reinstate this Agreement if it was terminated pursuant to Subsections 3.2 or 3.3. If
BlueCross elects to reinstate this Agreement, Employer shall pay any amounts due and
owing under the Agreement prior to its termination plus a reinstatement fee, which shall
be ten thousand dollars ($10,000.00).
3.5. Termination by Employer. Notwithstanding the provisions of Section 3.1 above, Employer
may terminate this Agreement immediately if the following occurs:
3.5.1. BlueCross has been declared insolvent by the State of Tennessee, and its assets
and obligations have been turned over to a receiver appointed by the State.
3.6. Material Breach.
3.6.1. A material breach is the failure by one Party (the “Breaching Party”) to perform or
carry out a material function or duty required by the terms of this Agreement, where
the failure to perform that function or duty seriously impairs the ability to perform of
the other Party (the “Non-breaching Party”).
3.6.2. If the Non-breaching Party determines that a material breach has occurred, it must
provide the Breaching Party with written notice and no less than thirty (30) days to
cure the breach . If the breach is not cured during such cure period, the Non-
breaching Party may terminate the Agreement effective as of the date set forth in
the notice.
3.6.3. If the Non- breaching Party determines that the breach is not capable of being cured,
the Non-breaching Party may immediately terminate the Agreement upon notice
to the Breaching Party, effective as of the date set forth in such notice.
3.6.4. If either Party disputes a claimed material breach or that a material breach has been
cured or corrected, such Party may immediately request dispute resolution,
pursuant to the terms of Article IV of this Agreement.
3.7. Effect of Termination. The terms and conditions set forth herein shall be of no further force
or effect upon termination of the Agreement, except as follows:
Law Dept approved 08.31.26
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 34 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 9/1/2026
Administrative Services Agreement Page 7
3.7.1. The Parties’ rights and obligations intended to survive termination of this
Agreement shall continue in effect notwithstanding its termination.
3.7.2. Termination of this Agreement, except as provided to the contrary herein, shall not
affect the rights, obligations and liabilities of the Parties arising prior to termination.
3.7.3. The termination of this Agreement does not excuse Employer from paying to
BlueCross any and all fees, amounts, reimbursements or claim payments accrued
through the date of termination. If termination occurs retroactively, any and all fees,
amounts, reimbursements or funding of Approved Claims accrued through the date
of termination of the Agreement, including any Run- Out Period, shall be payable
to BlueCross by Employer no later than ten (10) days after notice of termination is
provided by BlueCross.
3.8. Administration After Termination. Provided that Employer has timely paid all outstanding
amounts needed to fund Approved Claims and ASFs as of the date the Agreement is
terminated and the Agreement has not been terminated by BlueCross pursuant to
Sections 3.2, 3.3 or 3.6 of the Agreement, BlueCross, in its sole discretion which shall not
be unreasonably withheld, may agree to process Run-Out Claims on behalf of Employer’s
Plan. The administration of the processing of Run- Out Claims by BlueCross following
termination of this Agreement will be subject to the terms of this Agreement, as well as
Employer’s current and continued timely and sufficient funding of claims payments.
Employer acknowledges that there is a separate and distinct administrative fee for
BlueCross providing administrative services to pay Run Out Claims, which is set forth in
Exhibit B. Any services performed by BlueCross on Employer’s behalf after termination of
the Agreement will cease no later than 18 months after termination of this Agreement
(“Process Conclusion Date”).
3.9. Final Settlement. BlueCross will complete a final calculation that reconciles any and all
claims payments, fund transfers, recoveries received, and other monies potentially due
under the Agreement up to the Process Conclusion Date to determine the amount
necessary to finalize both Parties’ obligations under this Agreement (the “Final Settlement
Amount”). BlueCross will send Employer an agreement memorializing the final obligations
of the Parties under the Agreement (hereinafter, the “ Final Settlement Agreement ”)
approximately two (2) years after termination of this Agreement. Employer will have thirty
(30) days from the date of the letter attached to the Final Settlement Agreement to dispute
any of the calculations in the Final Settlement Agreement. If Employer has not disputed the
Final Settlement Agreement, or returned a signed Final Settlement Agreement to
BlueCross within the provided time period, Employer shall be deemed to have approved
and executed the Final Settlement Agreement and BlueCross reserves the right to reduce
the Final Settlement Amount to take into account the final amount due BlueCross under
the Agreement. Any amounts recovered beyond the Final Settlement shall be retained by
BlueCross as reasonable compensation for Services under this Agreement.
ARTICLE IV – DISPUTE RESOLUTION
4.1. Non-binding Arbitration. Any dispute related to this Agreement, which the Parties are
unable to resolve through informal discussion within sixty (60) days of the date a Party
notifies the other Party in writing of any such dispute, claim, or controversy, shall be
resolved through non -binding mediation conducted in Chattanooga, Tennessee with a
mutually selected mediator.
4.2. Award. A single arbitrator shall be required to issue a written decision explaining the basis
of the decision and the manner of calculating any award. The arbitrator may not award
Law Dept approved 08.31.26
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 35 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 9/1/2026
Administrative Services Agreement Page 8
any damages excluded under Section 5.3 and must make its decision in accordance with
the terms of this Agreement and applicable laws. The arbitrator’s decision may be entered
and enforced in any State or Federal court.
ARTICLE V – LIABILITY AND INDEMNIFICATION
5.1. BlueCross Indemnification to Employer.
5.1.1. BlueCross neither insures nor underwrites any of Employer’s obligations or
liabilities under the Plan and shall have no obligations to Employer related thereto.
BlueCross is responsible solely for its acts and for the acts of its subcontractors
and employees acting within the scope of their duties under this Agreement.
BlueCross is not responsible for any acts or omissions of Employer or its agents
or any third parties, including Employer Service Vendors, associated with or
contracted by Employer.
5.1.2. BlueCross shall indemnify, defend and hold harmless Employer, its directors,
officers and employees against any and all third party Losses arising out of or in
connection with BlueCross’s gross negligence or willful misconduct in the
performance of its obligations under the Agreement, provided, however , that
BlueCross shall have no obligation to indemnify and hold harmless under this
section if the cause of such Losses was the result of (i) the fault, criminal conduct
or fraudulent acts of Employer or any of its directors, officers, employees or agents;
(ii) direction given by Employer or its directors, officers, employees or agents in the
design or administration of the Plan; (iii) Employer’s breach of its fiduciary duties;
(iv) Employer’s violation of laws; (v) Employer’s infringement of the intellectual
property rights of a third party.
5.1.3. BlueCross’s liability to Employer for Losses pursuant to this Agreement shall be
limited to the value of the ASFs received by BlueCross under the Agreement prior
to the occurrence of the act, action, or failure to act that forms the basis of
BlueCross’s liability.
5.1.4. Notwithstanding the foregoing, BlueCross’s duty to indemnify for Losses and hold
Employer harmless pursuant to Subsection 5.1.2 shall not extend to Losses arising
out of or in connection with acts or omissions of (i) any Network Providers that
provide services to Members , or (ii) any act, error, or omission of any Employer
Service Vendor, or any services such Employer Service Vendor provide(s) to the
Employer and/or Plan.
5.2. Employer Indemnification of BlueCross.
5.2.1. Employer. Employer is responsible for making eligibility and benefit determinations
in connection with the Plan, timely funding and paying all fees and claims for
covered services and paying any other expenses related to or arising in connection
with the Plan. The Parties acknowledge that a governmental entity, as the same is
defined in the Tennessee Code Annotated Section 29- 20-102, may be protected
by the limitation of liability imposed by the Tennessee Governmental Tort Liability
Act, as defined in Tennessee Code Annotated Section 29-20-101 et seq.
5.2.2. To the extent Employer directs BlueCross to administer prescription drug benefits
with a traditional pricing model, Employer shall indemnify and hold BlueCross
harmless to the greatest extent permitted under law for any and all Losses resulting
from or arising out of or in connection Employer’s direction to adopt traditional PBM
Law Dept approved 08.31.26
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 36 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 9/1/2026
Administrative Services Agreement Page 9
pricing and BlueCross’s administration of traditional PBM pricing. The foregoing
indemnification and hold harmless obligation shall be in addition to, and not in lieu
of, any other indemnification provided by Employer to BlueCross under the
Agreement and without regard to any limitation of liability under this Agreement.
Further, Employer understands, agrees and acknowledges that (i) BlueCross may
decline to provide services in connection with the traditional PBM pricing at any
time upon notice to Employer; and (ii) BlueCross assumes no liability for any action
taken pursuant to the Employer’s direction, the traditional PBM pricing, or the
Agreement.
5.3. Limitation on Liability. In no event will the measure of Losses payable by either Party to
the other include, nor will either Party be liable to the other for, any consequential, indirect,
incidental, exemplary, special or punitive damages (including, but not limited to, damages
due to business interruption, trading losses, competitive advantage or goodwill) arising
from or related to this Agreement, whether or not foreseeable, and regardless of the cause
of such damages even if the Party has been advised of the possibility of such damages in
advance.
5.4. Legal Actions.
5.4.1. Legal Actions Brought Against BlueCross. If a third party claim is asserted against
BlueCross (but not Employer) that is based upon actions taken under this
Agreement or the Plan, and litigation, arbitration and/or other legal proceeding
(“Action”) is commenced against BlueCross:
5.4.1.1. BlueCross will provide written notice to Employer as soon as practicable,
but in no event more than one hundred twenty (120) days after
BlueCross determines that the Action involves a Member or the Plan.
Additionally, BlueCross will provide Employer with information with
respect to the status of such Action upon Employer’s reasonable
request. BlueCross shall select and retain counsel as it deems
appropriate in connection with such Action with respect to the interests
of BlueCross.
5.4.1.2. Employer will provide BlueCross with reasonable cooperation in the
defense of such Action, provided however, that BlueCross reserves the
right to select its own counsel and otherwise be involved in the Action.
5.4.1.3. Employer shall remain liable for the full amount of any benefits paid
under the Plan as a result of such Action, in addition to all costs of legal
fees, penalties, interest and other expenses recovered by a Member or
provider in connection with the Action. In no event will BlueCross be
liable for any amount of benefits paid to a Member or provider under the
Plan as a result of any Action, or any legal fees or costs recovered by a
Member or provider in connection therewith.
5.4.2. Legal Actions Brought Against Employer. If an Action is brought against Employer (and not
BlueCross):
5.4.2.1. Employer will select and retain counsel and will assume liability for the
payment of legal fees, costs and disbursements in connection with such
Action.
5.4.2.2. BlueCross will provide Employer with reasonable cooperation in the
Law Dept approved 08.31.26
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 37 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 9/1/2026
Administrative Services Agreement Page 10
defense of such Action, provided however that BlueCross reserves its
right to select its own counsel and otherwise be involved in the Action
as necessary to protect BlueCross’s interests.
5.4.2.3. Employer shall be liable for the full amount of any benefits Losses paid
under the Plan as a result of such Action, as well as any legal fees,
penalties, interest and costs recovered by a Member or provider in
connection therewith. In no event will BlueCross be liable for any amount
of benefits paid to a Member or provider under the Plan as a result of
such Action, or any legal fees or costs recovered by a Member or
provider in connection therewith.
ARTICLE VI – MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS
6.1. Acceptance by Payment of Fees. BlueCross expects that Employer will demonstrate its
acceptance of the terms of this Agreement by executing this Agreement in a reasonable
period of time after receiving it from BlueCross . In the event that Employer has not
executed the Agreement by the Effective Date, this Agreement will be considered
accepted by and binding upon both parties if and when Employer makes a payment to
BlueCross in order to receive the services described in this Agreement.
6.2. Amendment. This Agreement may be modified, amended, renewed or extended only upon
mutual written agreement.
6.3. Assignment. This Agreement may be assigned to a subsidiary or affiliate of Employer upon
ninety (90) days prior written notice to, and with the express written consent of, BlueCross.
BlueCross shall not unreasonably withhold its consent to any such assignment by
Employer.
6.4. Binding Effect of Agreement. The Agreement shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit
of the Parties, their officers, directors, employees, successors, and assigns unless
otherwise set forth herein or agreed to by the Parties hereto.
6.5. Impossibility of Performance. If an act or omission by a third party, including governmental
entities, Network Providers or vendors, renders the performance of this Agreement illegal,
impossible or impractical, the affected Party shall notify the other of the nature of that act
or omission (the “Adverse Event.”) The Parties shall meet and, in good faith, attempt to
negotiate a modification to this Agreement that minimizes the Adverse Event.
Notwithstanding any other provision of this Agreement, if the Parties fail to reach a
negotiated modification concerning the Adverse Event, then the affected Party may
immediately terminate this Agreement upon giving written notice to the other Party.
6.6. Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in any number of counterparts, each of
which shall be deemed an original, and such counterparts shall constitute one and the
same instrument.
6.7. Entire Agreement. This Agreement, including the exhibits and any attachments hereto, all
of which are incorporated herein by reference, contains the entire agreement between
BlueCross and Employer with respect to the specific subject matter hereof. Any prior
agreements, promises, negotiations or representations, either verbal or written, relating to
the subject matter of this Agreement and not expressly set forth in this Agreement are of
no force and effect. The exhibits and attachments to this Agreement include the following:
Law Dept approved 08.31.26
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 38 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 9/1/2026
Administrative Services Agreement Page 11
6.7.1. Exhibit A – Benefit Documents
6.7.2. Exhibit B – Administrative Services Fees
6.7.3. Exhibit C – Duties of and Services Provided by BlueCross
6.7.4. Exhibit D – Medical Management Services Provided by BlueCross
6.7.5. Exhibit E – Duties of Employer
6.7.6. Exhibit F – Automated Clearinghouse (ACH) Authorization Agreement
6.7.7. Exhibit G – Inter-Plan Arrangements
6.7.8. Exhibit H – COBRA Administration Agreement
6.7.9. Exhibit I – Health and Wellness Services
6.7.10. Exhibit J – Reserved
6.7.11. Exhibit K – Reserved
6.7.12. Exhibit L – Reserved
6.7.13. Exhibit M – Online Enrollment Specifications through BlueCross Secured Website
6.7.14. Exhibit N – Grievance Services
6.7.15. Exhibit O – Savings Guarantee
6.7.16. Exhibit P – Pharmacy Services
6.7.17. Exhibit Q – Reserved
6.7.18. Exhibit R – Reserved
6.7.19. Exhibit S – Audits and Records
6.7.20. Exhibit T – Reserved
6.7.21. Exhibit U – Reserved
6.7.22. Exhibit V – Reserved
6.7.23. Exhibit W – Shared Savings
6.7.24. Exhibit X – Addendum
6.8. Governing Law. This Agreement is subject to and shall be governed by the laws of the
United States and State of Tennessee, without regard to conflict of laws provisions.
Law Dept approved 08.31.26
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 39 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 9/1/2026
Administrative Services Agreement Page 12
6.9. Interpretation.
6.9.1. If the provisions of this Agreement are in any way inconsistent with the provisions
of the Benefit Documents, then the provisions of this Agreement shall prevail and
the other provisions shall be deemed modified to the extent necessary to give
effect to such provisions.
6.9.2. If the provisions of this Agreement are in any way inconsistent with the provisions
of the Exhibits and Attachments hereto, then the provisions of Exhibits and
Attachments shall prevail and the inconsistent provisions of this Agreement shall
be deemed modified to the extent necessary to give effect to such provisions.
6.9.3. For purposes of this Agreement, the words “include,” “includes” and “including”
shall be deemed to be followed by the words “without limitation”, and the word “or”
shall not be exclusive.
6.10. Independent Entities.
6.10.1. This Agreement is not intended to create nor deemed or construed to create any
relationship between Employer and BlueCross other than that of independent
entities contracting with each other solely for the purpose of effecting the provisions
of this Agreem ent. Neither the Parties nor their respective directors, officers,
employees or representatives shall be construed to be the partner, joint venturer,
agent, employer, or representatives of the other Party.
6.10.2. On behalf of itself and its Members , Employer hereby acknowledges its
understanding that this Agreement constitutes a contract solely between Employer
and BlueCross which is an independent corporation operating under a license from
the Association permitting BlueCross to use the BlueCross and BlueShield Service
Marks in the State of Tennessee, and that BlueCross is not contracting as the
agent of the Association.
6.10.3. Employer acknowledges that BlueCross is independent from any provider
rendering services to Members, and that BlueCross is not responsible for any acts
or omissions by a provider in rendering care or services to a Member.
6.10.4. Employer acknowledges and agrees that it has not entered into this Agreement
based upon representations by any person other than BlueCross and that no
person, entity, or organization other than BlueCross shall be held accountable or
liable to Employer for any of BlueCross’s obligations created under this
Agreement. This paragraph shall not create any additional obligations whatsoever
on the part of BlueCross other than those obligations created under other
provisions of this Agreement.
6.11. Legal Action. All actions are subject to Article IV, Dispute Resolution.
6.12. Notices. Any notice, request, demand or other communication required to be given
pursuant to this Agreement shall be in writing, sent by certified or registered mail, return
receipt requested, or by Federal Express or other overnight mail delivery for which
evidence of delivery is obtained by the sender, to BlueCross or Employer at the addresses
set forth below. The notice shall be effective on the date the notice was posted.
Law Dept approved 08.31.26
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 40 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 9/1/2026
Administrative Services Agreement Page 13
If to BCBST:
BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee, Inc.
One Cameron Hill Circle
Chattanooga, TN 37402
Attn: Vice President Sales & Account Management
With a copy not constituting notice to:
BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee, Inc.
One Cameron Hill Circle
Chattanooga, TN 37402
Attn: Senior Vice President and General Counsel
If to Employer:
City of Franklin
109 3rd Avenue South
Franklin, TN 37064
6.13. No Third Party Rights. Except as specifically provided herein, none of the provisions of
this Agreement is intended to create third party rights, status or beneficiaries in any person
or entity.
6.14. Reserved.
6.15. Severability. If any provision of this Agreement is declared illegal, void or unenforceable,
the remaining provisions shall remain in force and effect, unless the severance of that
provision substantially deprives a Party of the benefit of its bargain or increases the cost
of performing its duties pursuant to this Agreement.
6.16. Subsidiaries and Affiliates. Any of the functions to be performed by BlueCross under this
Agreement may be performed by BlueCross or any of its subsidiaries, affiliates or
designees.
6.17. Survival. The rights and obligations of the Parties as set forth herein shall survive the
termination of this Agreement to the extent necessary to effectuate the intent of the Parties
as expressed herein.
6.18. Waiver of Breach. Waiver of a breach of any provision of this Agreement shall not be
deemed a waiver of any other breach of the same or a different provision.
6.19. Other Acceptable Forms of this Document. The following shall have the same legal effect
as an original: facsimile copy, imaged copy, scanned copy, and/or an electronic version.
ARTICLE VII - DEFINITIONS
7.1. “ Action” means litigation, arbitration and/or other legal proceeding.
7.2. “ Agreement” means this administrative services agreement entered into by Employer and
BlueCross, including all Exhibits and Attachments hereto.
7.3. “ Approved Claims” means claims processed and approved for payment by BlueCross in
accordance with this Agreement.
Law Dept approved 08.31.26
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 41 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 9/1/2026
Administrative Services Agreement Page 14
7.4. “ ASF(s)” means Administrative Services Fee(s).
7.5. “ Association” means the BlueCross and BlueShield Association.
7.6. “ Benefits Documents” means the benefit documents, which summarize the benefits of the
Employer’s Plan and are attached hereto as Exhibit A.
7.7. “BlueCross” means BlueCross and BlueShield of Tennessee, Inc.
7.8. “BlueCross Confidential Information” means Confidential Information that BlueCross
discloses or authorizes be disclosed to Employer, including BlueCross pricing and
payment data and information, such as payment rates, allowed amounts, fee schedules,
discounts and payment methodologies; claims data (whether at claim level or aggregated),
data and information regarding providers, BlueCross research and technical information;
BlueCross’s processes, procedures or policies, and information obtained from and/or
about the Association and its programs.
7.9. “ Confidential Information” means all information or material (whether tangible or
intangible) that is shared with or disclosed to the other Party pursuant to this Agreement
and the Parties’ relationship, including information identified as proprietary and/or
confidential information, information that is confidential as a matter of law (e.g., personnel
records), and BlueCross Confidential Information disclosed to Employer. The following
shall not constitute Confidential Information for purposes of this Agreement: (a)
Confidential Information that is or becomes generally available to the public other than as
a result of a disclosure by a Party or its Representatives; (b) Confidential Information that
was available to a Party on a non -confidential basis prior to its disclosure by the other
Party or its Representatives; (c) Confidential Information that becomes available to a Party
on a non- confidential basis from a third party (other than BlueCross’s affiliates,
subsidiaries or vendors or the Association or other licensee of the Association), provided
that third party is not known to be subject to any prohibition against transmitting that
information; (d) information that was independently developed by a Party without an use
of or reference to the Confidential Information of the other Party, as shown by documents
and other competent evidence, or (e) Protected Health Information.
7.10. “ Effective Date” means July 1, 2026.
7.11. “ Employee Welfare Benefit Plan” shall have the same meaning as defined in ERISA.
7.12. “ Employer” means City of Franklin.
7.13. “ Employer Service Vendor” means any person providing services to or on behalf of the
Plan or the Employer in connection with the Plan or under the Agreement and any
subcontractor(s) of such Employer Service Vendor.
7.14. “ ERISA” means the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as amended.
7.15. “ HIPAA” means the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996, as
amended, and its implementing regulations, as amended.
7.16. “ Initial Term” means July 1, 2026 through June 30, 2027.
7.17. “ Losses” means any and all liability, actions, claims, lawsuits, settlements, judgments,
costs, interest, penalties , fines, taxes and expenses, including legal costs, fees and
Law Dept approved 08.31.26
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 42 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 9/1/2026
Administrative Services Agreement Page 15
expenses.
7.18. “ Member” means an eligible Employee or eligible Dependent and as that term is further
defined in the Benefit Documents.
7.19. “ Plan” means the self-funded Employee Welfare Benefit Plan established by Employer for
the benefit of its eligible Employees and their eligible Dependents.
7.20. “ Plan Administrator” means the Employer.
7.21. “ Representatives” means a Party’s directors, officers, employees, agents, advisors,
Business Associates (as such term is defined in HIPAA), contractors and other
representatives.
7.22. “ Run- Out Claims” means those claims incurred for Covered Services performed prior to
the termination of this Agreement, but not yet paid and/or not submitted for payment to
BlueCross prior to the termination of this Agreement, where the date a claim is “incurred”
is the date the particular service was rendered or the supply was furnished
7.23. “ Subscriber” means an Eligible Employee enrolled in Employer’s Plan.
7.24. “ Term” means July 1, 2026 through June 30, 2027.
7.25. All non-defined, but capitalized terms included in this Agreement are defined in the Benefit
Documents.
Law Dept approved 08.31.26
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 43 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 9/1/2026
Administrative Services Agreement Page 16
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Parties have caused this Agreement to be executed by their duly
authorized representatives. The undersigned persons hereby warrant that they are duly
authorized to bind each of their represented Parties to the terms of this Agreement.
BLUECROSS BLUESHIELD OF TENNESSEE, INC. CITY OF FRANKLIN
By: By:
Print Name: Print Name:
Title: Title:
Date: Date:
Address: 1 Cameron Hill Circle Address: 109 3rd Avenue South
Chattanooga, TN 37402 Franklin, TN 37064
Employer ID No. 62-6000290
Law Dept approved 08.31.26
Approved as to form:
_________________________
Ronda D. Webb, Assistant City Attorney
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
9/1/2026
SVP & CMO
Robin Young
Page 44 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 9/1/2026
Administrative Services Agreement Page 17
EXHIBIT A TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
BENEFIT DOCUMENTS
Exhibit A consists of the following Benefit Documents
Health Benefit Plan – PPO Option 1
Health Benefit Plan – HDHP Option 2
Health Benefit Plan – Vision
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 45 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit B
Administrative Services Agreement Page 18
EXHIBIT B TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES FEES (ASFS) AND CLAIMS FUNDING METHODOLOGY
1. ASFs. Employer shall pay to BlueCross the following ASFs:
1.1. Medical ASF
Rates effective as of: July 1, 2026
Medical ASF $46.72 per Subscriber per month
Medical Main ASF $46.72 per Subscriber per month
COBRA - Std
w/INL and 1 OSV
$0.91 per Subscriber per month
Musculoskeletal Program $0.98 per Subscriber per month
Teladoc Health Base
Package
$0.50 per Subscriber per month
Medical Guaranteed ASF $49.11 per Subscriber per month
Medical Total ASF $49.11 per Subscriber per month
1. BlueCross provided a 2 month Fee Holiday of the Main Administrative Services Fees in 2026. The Fee Holiday was contingent upon both
medical and pharmacy, on the RX04 network, being administered by BlueCross through 6/30/27 of the multi-year agreement. If pharmacy is carved
out prior to 6/30/27 of the multi-year fee guarantee, the Fee Holiday must be repaid. If medical is terminated prior to 6/30/27 of the multi-year fee
guarantee, the Fee Holiday must be repaid.
1.1.1. The financial offer above is contingent upon both medical and pharmacy
being administered by BlueCross for the duration of the multi -year
agreement.
1.1.2. BlueCross may adjust the above fees at any time, under the following
circumstances:
1.1.2.1. Changes in the Plan, BlueCross’s duties, legislation, regulation
or required assessment or tax that changes BlueCross’ cost in
administering the plan;
1.1.2.2. Termination or addition of a subsidiary, operation or class of
employees covered under the Agreement;
1.1.2.3. Fluctuation of the number of Subscribers by more than 10%
percent by location, state and/or in aggregate. Calculation of the
Medical Total ASF was based on 709 Subscribers; or
1.1.2.4. Fluctuation of the Member to Subscriber ratio by +/ - 0.05. The
Medical Total ASF was based on a Member to Subscriber ratio
of 2.52.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 46 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit B
Administrative Services Agreement Page 19
1.1.2.5. Federal, state, or local government action, change in law or
regulation (or interpretation of a law or regulation) which impacts
the benefit levels or affects BlueCross’ ability to meet its
obligations under this Agreement to Employer, to Employer’s
Covered Members or to BlueCross’ Network Providers, including
but not limited to, legislation, regulation(s) or government
action(s) which impose requirements that affect: (i) BlueCross’
ability to determine or administer Covered Services; (ii)
providers’ delivery of care or the fees p roviders charge; or (iii)
BlueCross’ contracts with Network Providers. Upon the
occurrence of an event described in this Section 1.1.2.5, the
Parties will make a good faith effort to reach a new agreement
that equitably reflects the circumstances as altered by such law,
regulation or government action.
1.2. Allowance
Type of
Allowance Fund
July 1, 2026
Wellness $25,000
BlueCross shall provide an allowance to Employer to fund Plan-related expenses
(“Allowance”). Such Allowance can be used, during the period for which Allowance is
provided, as specified by BlueCross, for BlueCross products or services, or products or
services purchased by Employer from a third -
party related to BlueCross administered
benefit programs. If Employer purchases services from a third party, Employer must provide
BlueCross receipts from such third party in order for the Allowance to be applied toward
such expenses. Expenses for services offered by BlueCross but where Employer has
chosen to carve out to a third party are not eligible for reimbursement. Consultant fees are
not eligible for reimbursement with the Allowance. All requests for reimbursement shall be
made within sixty (60) days of the end of the period, as specified by BlueCross. Any unused
Allowance shall be forfeited if expenses are not incurred by the end of the period for which
the allowance is provided and request for reimbursement is not timely submitted as
addressed above. Unused funds do not rollover or carry-forward into the next or subsequent
year. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the allowance above is contingent upon both medical
and pharmacy being administered by BlueCross for the duration of the multi -year
agreement. Any unused Allowance shall be forfeited at the time BlueCross is notified of
Employer’s termination of coverage for which the Allowance pertains (i.e., medical,
pharmacy).
1.3. Vision ASF
Rates effective as of: July 1, 2026
Vision ASF $1.25 per Vision Subscriber per month
2. Inter-Plan Arrangements (BlueCard) Fees¹. When Members access health care services
outside of Tennessee, claims for those services are received by the licensee of the
Association where the provider is located (the “Host Plan”) and forwarded electronically to
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 47 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit B
Administrative Services Agreement Page 20
BlueCross for adjudication. For claims from providers that participate in the Host Plan’s
provider network, the Member and Plan get the benefit of access to the terms and
conditions of the Host Plan’s contracted arrangement with the provider, including pricing
arrangements. The currently applicable fees for such access to Host Plan’s networks and
arrangements (including administrative processing) are as follows:
Access Fees The Access Fee is charged by the
Host Plan to BlueCross for making the
Host Plan’s network available to
Employer’s Members. The Access
Fee will not apply to nonparticipating
provider claims. The Access Fee is
charged on a per-claim basis and is
charged as a percentage of the
discount/differential BlueCross
receives from the applicable Host Plan
subject to a maximum of $2,000 per
claim. When charged, BlueCross
passes the Access Fee directly on to
Employer.
3.21% of network savings,
capped at $2,000.00 per
claim
Effective January 1, 2027:
3.11% of network savings
capped at $2,000.00 per
claim
Administrative
Expense
Allowance (AEA)
Fee
The AEA Fee is a fixed per-claim
dollar amount charged by the Host
Plan to BlueCross for administrative
services the Host Plan provides in
processing claims for Employer’s
Members. The dollar amount is
normally based on the type of claim
(e.g. institutional, professional,
international, etc.) and can also be
based on the size of your group
enrollment. When charged, BlueCross
passes the AEA Fee directly on to
Employer.
$5.00 per claim
professional and $11.00
per claim institutional
Nonparticipating
Provider Fee
$3.00 per claim
BlueCross
BlueShield
Global
® Core
Fee
$4.35 per claim Member-
submitted, $5.50 per claim
professional, and $18.55
per claim institutional
¹ See Exhibit G for more detail about Inter-Plan Arrangements. Any fees under such arrangements are set by specific
program policies that may change from time to time through a process that the Association administers, and are subject
to change by the Association without notice.
3. Reports. BlueCross shall provide Employer with access to BlueCross’s standard reporting
and interactive reports at no additional charge. Any additional reports requested by
Employer shall be subject to an additional charge determined by BlueCross, such charge
which will be billed separately. Upon termination of this Agreement, Employer shall pay
BlueCross for any and all requested reports, such payment being made in advance of
receiving the requested report.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 48 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit B
Administrative Services Agreement Page 21
4. Timing, Calculation and Funding of Monthly ASFs. Employer shall pay the applicable ASFs
for all Subscribers covered or added during the month. If Employer adds a Subscriber
retroactively, Employer shall pay the applicable ASFs for that Subscriber, calculated from
the Subscriber’s correct enrollment date to the current date. When Employer provides
enrollment data and that data does not match BlueCross’s data, BlueCross’s data will be
used to determine the ASF. BlueCross will work with Employer to resolve the discrepancy.
If no agreement can be reached, BlueCross’s records will control . Until the dispute is
resolved, Employer must pay the ASFs based on BlueCross’s records.
4.1. Monthly Enrollment . The monthly ASF is determined each month based on
enrollment. On the 15th day of each month, Employer shall determine the number
of Subscribers covered under Employer’s Plan, and this shall be the basis for the
ASFs charged by BlueCross for the following month.
4.1.1. Enrollment Changes. Any changes to the initial enrollment will be charged
to Employer in accordance with the following:
4.1.1.1. Subscriber added on or before the 15 th day of the month:
Employer will be charged the monthly ASFs for that Subscriber.
4.1.1.2. Subscriber added after the 15th day of the month: Employer will
not be charged the monthly ASFs for that Subscriber.
4.1.1.3. Subscriber termed on or after the 15th day of the month:
Employer will be charged the monthly ASFs for that Subscriber.
4.1.1.4. Subscriber termed before the 15th day of the month: Employer
will not be charged the monthly ASFs for that Subscriber.
4.2. Funding of ASFs and Adjustments . On the 20th day of each month, BlueCross
shall notify Employer of amounts that BlueCross estimates will be needed to pay
BlueCross’s ASFs for the following calendar month, and funds necessary to
complete any adjustments to Approved Claims, fixed, previously agreed- upon
charges, previous ASFs and any due late fees. Such payments shall be made in
accordance with the Direct Debit Authorization Agreement, which is an Automated
Clearinghouse (ACH) Authorization Agreement, attached to this Agreement as
Exhibit F. Employer will transfer the amount specified by BlueCross into
Employer’s account so such funds shall be available for ACH debit by the first day
of the following month (the “Due Date”).
4.2.1. If the full amount specified by BlueCross to pay ASFs and other fees
pursuant to the Agreement is not received by BlueCross by the Due Date,
BlueCross may immediately suspend or deny payment of all Approved
Claims on behalf of Employer, regardless of the date claims were incurred,
until all amounts due and owing are received by BlueCross. If BlueCross
elects to not suspend claim payments on behalf of Employer, Employer
shall pay a late fee of 1% per month on all amounts that are due and unpaid
to BlueCross, pro- rated for each day that such amounts remain
outstanding. Notwithstanding the foregoing, BlueCross does not otherwise
waive any termination rights it has under the Agreement by electing to
suspend payment of Approved Claims.
4.2.2. If Employer notifies BlueCross of a Member’s termination within ninety (90)
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 49 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit B
Administrative Services Agreement Page 22
days of the Member’s termination, BlueCross will credit Employer with any
ASFs that were paid for that Member for that time period.
4.2.3. If Employer does not notify BlueCross of a Member’s termination within
ninety (90) days of the Member’s termination, BlueCross will only credit
Employer for the most recent ninety (90) day period of ASFs that were paid
by Employer for that Member’s coverage.
5. Additional Administration Charges. The cost of services outlined below may be billed as a
direct cost to Employer.
5.1. Creation, production, and printing non-standard Member material.
5.2. Investigation and litigation of disputed claims, including the amount of the
settlement and any damages (including punitive damages, unless subject to
indemnification pursuant to Article V of the Agreement).
5.3. Development and production of customized or unique reports requested by
Employer, such as management reports, claim reports, reports for stop loss
carriers, and other special reports.
5.4. Customized or unique systems development required by Employer.
5.5. Reprinting materials/ID cards off cycle due to changes or misinformation provided
by or on behalf of Employer to BlueCross.
5.6. Non-standardized Member mailings.
5.7. Training for on-line eligibility in excess of standard training package.
5.8. Diabetes Prevention Program (DPP) enrollment is on a participation -specific
basis, with fees assessed for the first 6 months of participation and on a monthly
basis thereafter*. Employer shall be responsible for any reporting, withholding
and taxes associated with all applicable services.
Diabetes Prevention Program (DPP) Fees
Fee
Per
Participant
Charge
Description
Monthly
Participation
(Months 1-12)
$60 Per
Participant Per
Month
The monthly charge for months
1-12 includes set-up and
implementation, Member
registration, welcome kit containing
a cellular-enabled scale, diabetes
prevention program coaching and
education. Member access to 24/7
on call support, mobile app and web
portal and personal challenges.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 50 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit B
Administrative Services Agreement Page 23
Monthly
Participation
(Months 13 and
beyond)
$30 Per
Participant Per
Month
The monthly charge for months 13
and beyond includes continued
access to the program’s functionality
that was available in months 1-12.
Replacement
Device
$95 per
replacement
Lost or damaged cellular-enabled
scale replacements are the
responsibility of the Employer.
*Each Participant has an initial minimum enrollment term of six (6) consecutive
months. After the 6- month requirement has been fulfilled, participation will be
evaluated monthly and charges for the services will continue monthly or until the
Participant has discontinued Active participation for a consecutive three (3) month
period.
“Active” participation means a Participant is engaging in one or more of the following
activities: live coaching sessions, digital coaching sessions, communication
exchange between a Teladoc Health coach and Participant related to diabetes
prevention, mobile app usage, Participant support call, shared data with care team,
weigh-ins, food logging, or portal logins.
5.9. Diabetes Management Program (DMP) enrollment is on a participation- specific
basis, with fees assessed for the first 6 months of participation and on a monthly
basis thereafter*. Employer shall be responsible for any reporting, withholding
and taxes associated with all applicable services.
Diabetes Management Program (DMP) Fees
* Each Participant has an initial minimum enrollment term of six (6) consecutive
months. After the 6-month requirement has been fulfilled, participation will be
evaluated monthly and charges for the services will continue monthly or until the
Participant has discontinued Active participation for a consecutive three (3) month
period.
“Active” use of the DMP means a Participant is engaging in one or more of the
following activities: blood glucose checks or submission, live coaching sessions,
Fee
Per
Participant
Charge
Description
Monthly
Participation
$67 Per
Participant Per
Month
The monthly charge includes set-up
and implementation, Member
registration, welcome kit containing
FDA-approved data enabled blood
glucose meter, unlimited supply of
test strips and lancets, first line
acute response to alerts generated
from the use of the glucometer
device, diabetes coaching and
education, Member access to 24/7
on call support, mobile app and web
portal with tips of the day.
Replacement
Device
$167 per
replacement
Lost or damaged blood glucose
meter replacements are the
responsibility of the Employer.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 51 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit B
Administrative Services Agreement Page 24
digital coaching sessions, communication exchange between a Teladoc Health
coach and Participant related to diabetes management, mobile app usage,
Member support call, shared data with care team, or portal logins.
5.10. Shared Savings Fees pursuant to Exhibit W.
5.11. Teladoc™ Health Mental Health Complete participation on a participation-specific
basis, with fees assessed for the first 6 months of engagement and on a monthly
basis thereafter. In addition to claim visit costs related to visits with a mental health
Practitioner, program fees will be charged at $14 Per Participant Per Month billed
via claims. Once a Participant is no longer participating in the program for 6
months, the program fees will no longer be charged.
5.12. Independent Dispute Resolution (“IDR”) Fees for Certain Out-of-Network Provider
Claims: Federal administration fees, Certified IDR Entity fees, reasonable legal
costs, if applicable, in connection with the IDR process established by the No
Surprises Act (within the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021) for certain out-of-
network provider claims. These amounts are in addition to the final amount paid to
the provider for the medical claim itself.
5.13. Digital MSK Clinic Program Fees for Digital MSK Clinic Program Services are billed
as claims based on Member utilization.
5.13.1. For the Acute, Chronic, and Pre and Post Surgery Programs, $250 per enrolled
Member will be billed upon completion of the first treatment session per each 365-
day period the Member is receiving Digital MSK Clinic Program Services, and $50
per enrolled Member will be billed for each subsequent treatment session in such
365-day period, up to a maximum of 31 billable treatment sessions per Member, per
365-day period.
5.13.2. The Digital MSK Clinic Program includes two types of Member caps defined below
and will be applied across all programs a Member may qualify for (acute, chronic,
or surgery) as follows:
5.13.2.1 Individual Annual Program Cap (Individual Cap): The Individual Cap per
Member is $1,750 per 365-day period.
5.13.2.2. Aggregate Average Annual Program Cap (Average Cap): The Average
Cap is $995 and is an average based on the aggregate number of enrolled Members
per contract year. The Average Cap is calculated after the end of each run -out
period following the end of the contract year. If an Employer has been charged
more than the Average Cap per contract year, the excess will be refunded back to
the Employer after the end of the run-out period.
5.14. DME Navigator will be billed at a rate of $0.00 Per Member Per Month.
5.15. AdHoc requests for clinical information, including plan of care, for a specific
member or set of members:
5.15.1. Requests for a discussion/consult/review with a BlueCross Medical
Director or Pharmacy Director will incur a charge of $375 per hour
assessed in 15-minute increments.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 52 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit B
Administrative Services Agreement Page 25
5.15.2. Requests for a Care Management Nurse to provide detailed information,
including Case Management Notes, in excess of 2 members per quarter
will incur a charge of $125 per hour assessed in 15-minute increments.
5.16. Audit Support for third-party reviews and audits that fall outside the scope of Exhibit
S.
6. Security Interest. To secure the payment of any amounts due to BlueCross under this
Agreement, Employer hereby grants to BlueCross a first priority security interest and
assigns to BlueCross Employer’s right, title and interest in Employer’s debiting account
and the proceeds thereof. In the event of a default by Employer of any of its obligations to
BlueCross, including the prompt payment when due of any invoice sent to it by BlueCross,
BlueCross shall have the immediate right, upon written notice to Employer, to offset the
proceeds of the debiting account against the amount of any unpaid invoice or other obligation
owed to BlueCross.
7. Claims Funding Methodology. Pursuant to Section 1.6 of the Agreement, the Parties agree
that on a mutually acceptable day of each week, BlueCross shall notify Employer of
amounts that BlueCross estimates will be needed to fund Approved Claims, and BlueCross
shall initiate the debit for Approved Claims to be paid. The debit will clear Employer’s
account the following business day. BlueCross adjudicates claims in accordance with its
internal administrative procedures.
7.1. If the full amount specified by BlueCross to fund Approved Claims is not made
available to BlueCross within the specified time period, BlueCross may
immediately suspend or deny payment of all Approved Claims, regardless of the
date claims were incurred, until all amounts due are received by BlueCross.
7.2. If BlueCross elects not to suspend claim payments on behalf of Employer,
Employer shall pay a late fee of 1% percent per month on all amounts that are due
and unpaid to BlueCross, pro- rated for each day that such amounts remain
outstanding.
7.3. If a partial amount is available, BlueCross may elect (but is not required) to utilize
those funds to pay Approved Claims until full payment is made by Employer.
BlueCross has full discretion to determine which Approved Claims will be paid with
these partial funds, and may or may not exercise that discretion.
7.4. BlueCross shall provide Employer with a list of Approved Claims paid on behalf of
Employer, within 30 calendar days following the end of each month during which
this Agreement remains in effect.
8. Deposit Access. BlueCross has the right to request a cash deposit from Employer at any
time during the Agreement year if, in BlueCross’ sole discretion, BlueCross has reason to
believe that Employer is unable to timely meet its payment obligations under the
Agreement. In connection with the request for a cash deposit, BlueCross shall issue a
notice to Employer, specifying the amount of the deposit which shall be based on a
multiple of an estimate of monthly ASFs and Approved Claims , pursuant to the
requirements established in Exhibit E. Should Employer fail to timely pay ASFs or fund
Approved Claims within the time specified in the Agreement, BlueCross shall have the
right to access funds on deposit without further notice to Employer in order to pay ASFs
and/or fund Approved Claims. Any amount remaining in the deposit account upon
termination of the Agreement will be included in the Final Settlement pursuant to Section
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 53 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit B
Administrative Services Agreement Page 26
3.9.
9. Run Out Claims. Provided that Employer has timely paid all outstanding amounts needed
to fund Approved Claims and ASFs as of the date the Agreement is terminated, BlueCross
will administer run out claims for Employer at the termination of this Agreement for a period
of 180 days from the date this Agreement terminates. The monthly ASFs for performing
this service shall be the same as the ASFs charged Employer at termination of the
Agreement. The monthly ASFs for performing this service shall be based on an average
of the number of Subscribers covered under this Agreement for the 3 months immediately
prior to the termination date of this Agreement. This fee shall be billed for the first 3 months
of the run-out period.
10. Premium Billed Ancillary Products . If Employer has requested that BlueCross provide
additional services through other products (i.e., dental), or has requested that BlueCross
collect premiums or premium equivalents from subscribers or Members to fund other
benefits offered by Employer (i.e., life insurance offered through another carrier, etc.), any
additional funds due from Employer to BlueCross for remittance to other carriers or
providers of services shall be remitted to BlueCross on the same basis as the ASFs.
11. Employer Fails to Pay. Notwithstanding any other term of the Agreement to the contrary,
if Employer fails to pay when due any amount to fund Approved C laims, ASFs or other
fees required to be paid to BlueCross under this Agreement, and such default is not cured
within five (5) days of the Due Date, BlueCross reserves the right to consider the Employer
delinquent and may, at its option:
11.1. Suspend or deny claim payments at any time, in whole or in part; or
11.2. Terminate the Agreement as of the effective date specified in such notice.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 54 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026
Exhibit C
Administrative Services Agreement Page 27
EXHIBIT C TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
DUTIES OF AND SERVICES PROVIDED BY BLUECROSS
1. Generally. It is understood and agreed that BlueCross is empowered and required to act
with respect to the Plan only as expressly stated in this Agreement. Employer and
BlueCross agree that BlueCross’s role under this Agreement is to provide administrative
claims payment and similar administrative services in accordance with the terms of the
Benefit Documents and the Agreement; that BlueCross does not assume any financial risk
or obligation with respect to Approved Claims; and that the services rendered by
BlueCross under this Agreement are merely ministerial, and shall not include the power
to exercise control over the Plan’s assets, if any, or discretionary authority over the Plan.
2. Enrollment: Forms and I.D. Cards . BlueCross shall enroll those individuals who have
completed an enrollment form and are determined by Employer to be eligible for benefits
under the Plan. Employer shall provide BlueCross with enrollment information in a
mutually agreeable format, (i.e., electronically, faxed, paper, etc.) BlueCross is not
responsible for verifying data submitted by Employer. BlueCross shall be entitled to rely
on the information furnished to it by Employer. Employer shall hold BlueCross harmless
for inaccurate information provided by Employer or BlueCross’s inability to perform under
this Agreement as a result of Employer’s failure to provide such information in a timely
manner.
2.1. BlueCross will not furnish enrollment forms to Employer, since Employer will enroll
Members and maintain eligibility online as described in Exhibit M, Online
Enrollment Specifications through BlueCross Secured Website.
2.2. Once Employer has notified BlueCross in writing that a new Member is eligible for
benefits, BlueCross shall update its systems to reflect that Member’s coverage.
2.3. Once Employer has notified BlueCross in writing that a Member should be
terminated as no longer eligible for coverage, BlueCross shall update its systems
to reflect that change in the Member’s coverage in accordance with Exhibit B.
2.4. BlueCross will conduct certification and verification of incapacitated dependent
information.
3. Claims Processing . BlueCross shall provide claims processing services on behalf of
Employer for all properly submitted claims. BlueCross will follow current industry practices
and its internal claims processing procedures regarding payment of claims, including
timeliness and accuracy of claims payments. For purposes of this paragraph 3, the term
“claim(s)” is defined as a request from a provider of Covered Services and/or a Member
for payment of monies due for the rendering of Covered Services under the Benefit
Documents, and in conformity with any agreements BlueCross enters into with such
providers of Covered Services.
3.1. When necessary, BlueCross shall furnish to Employer, for distribution to Members,
forms to be used for claims submission, and any other forms determined to be
necessary by BlueCross for the administration of the Benefit Documents.
3.2. BlueCross will coordinate with other payors, including Medicare, in adjusting
claims according to the terms and conditions of coverage, including Medicare
Secondary Payor rules. This may delay finalization of the adjudication of a claim,
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 55 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026
Exhibit C
Administrative Services Agreement Page 28
depending on when data is received regarding the claim. If Medicare is primary,
BlueCross will adjudicate benefits based on the Medicare allowed amount.
3.3. BlueCross shall furnish each Member claiming benefits with an explanation of each
claim that is paid, denied or rejected.
3.4. BlueCross shall give Members a reasonable opportunity to appeal a denied claim
or any portion of a claim within the time frames specified by ERISA, according to
the appeals procedure defined in the Benefit Documents; however, Employer shall
retain final discretionary authority and responsibility for claims payment decisions.
3.5. If Employer notifies BlueCross of a Member’s termination from coverage after the
Member’s termination date, and Approved Claims for that Member were paid in
the interim, BlueCross shall request reimbursement from the provider on
Employer’s behalf to the extent possible. However, if Employer does not notify
BlueCross of a Member’s termination from coverage ninety (90) days or more after
the date of Member’s termination of coverage, BlueCross shall not be obligated to
attempt to collect any claim payments which were paid before notice of termination
was received by BlueCross.
3.6. If Employer notifies BlueCross of a Member’s termination from coverage after the
Member’s termination date, and BlueCross made payment of benefits directly to
such Member, BlueCross will attempt recovery unless Employer directs BlueCross
in writing not to attempt recovery from such Member.
3.6.1. If Employer’s Benefit Documents include coverage for pharmacy benefits
that are paid by BlueCross’s pharmacy vendor or Provider -Administered
Specialty Products that are paid by BlueCross, claims paid after a
Member’s termination cannot be recovered from the provider, pharmacy or
any other person or entity, as applicable. However, BlueCross will attempt
recovery from the Member on these claims. If Employer does not wish
BlueCross to attempt recovery from a specific Member, Employer must
direct BlueCross accordingly in writing.
3.6.2. If a claim payment is less than fifty dollars ($50), BlueCross has no
obligation to attempt to collect said claim payment.
3.6.3. If a claim payment was made for services rendered through the BlueCard
program, BlueCross has no obligation to attempt to collect claim payments
that were for less than fifty dollars ($50), or in accordance with stated limits
in effect at the Host Plan location.
3.6.4. If Employer directs BlueCross to use the services of an outside collection
agency to collect a claim payment, the fees charged by such entity shall be
the sole responsibility of Employer.
3.6.5. If benefits are not recoverable from a provider or Member, Employer
remains liable to fund all claims.
3.7. BlueCross will provide Employer with a monthly statement with respect to claims
paid in the prior month.
3.8. At the termination of this Agreement and provided that Employer pays BlueCross
the applicable fees set forth in Exhibit B, BlueCross shall administer the payment
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 56 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026
Exhibit C
Administrative Services Agreement Page 29
of Run Out claims for Employer. These claims shall be administered as any other
claim handled during the term of the Agreement, and shall be subject to the same
restrictions.
3.9. If a catastrophic event (whether weather-related, caused by a natural disaster, or
caused by war, terrorism, pandemic or similar event) occurs that affects Members
in one or more locations, and such catastrophic event prevents or interferes with
BlueCross’s ability to conduct its normal business with respect to such Members
or prevents or interferes with Members’ ability to access their benefits, BlueCross
shall have the right, without first seeking consent from Employer, to take
reasonable and necessary steps to process Claims and provide managed care
services in a manner that may be inconsistent with the Benefits Document but is
undertaken in order to minimi ze the effect such catastrophic event has on
Members, including: ( i) waiving referral, prior authorization or pre- certification
requirements for medical and/or pharmacy services; (ii) waiving administrative
holds and terminations due to nonpayment of premiums; (iii) allowing early refills
on prescription medications; (iv ) offering medical and behavioral health visits
through telehealth; and (v) reducing or waiving cost -sharing obligations for
services. As soon as practicable after a catastrophic event, BlueCross shall report
its actions to Employer. Employer shall reimburse BlueCross for all amounts paid
in good faith, or as required by law, under the circumstances and such amounts
shall constitute Approved Claims for which Employer is responsible for payment,
even if the charges incurred were not for services otherwise covered under the
Benefits Documents.
4. Network Administration. BlueCross shall administer its established cost containment programs
and access and availability benefits management programs, as selected by Employer.
BlueCross’s provider contracts and medical policies control network administration.
4.1. BlueCross shall make available the Blue Network selected by Employer, including
network hospitals and other providers or practitioners with which BlueCross has
contracted, (“ Blue Network ”) to provide Covered Services to Members. All
agreements between providers of services and BlueCross are the sole property of
BlueCross, and BlueCross retains the right to the use and control of these provider
agreements.
4.2. Employer acknowledges that BlueCross does not act either as the agent of or in
any fiduciary capacity with respect to Employer, any of its Plans, or any of its
Members, when BlueCross negotiates its provider and/or vendor arrangements.
4.3. Employer acknowledges that the Blue Network Provider contracts cannot be
modified to meet any specific requirements of Employer, and that BlueCross has
the discretion to change the composition, name, etc. without Employer’s consent
or approval. BlueCross does not guarantee that a specific provider will remai n in
the network, and BlueCross has the right to determine network adequacy, and to
establish and modify billing guidelines and reimbursement arrangements for
Network Providers.
4.4. BlueCross negotiates various payment arrangements with providers, including per
diem, percent of charges, diagnosis related groups (DRGs,) global case rate and
fee schedule arrangements, which vary by provider. Certain facilities may have
multiple or a combination of these arrangements. All of these arrangements
provide payment to the provider, and claims processed using one of these
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 57 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026
Exhibit C
Administrative Services Agreement Page 30
arrangements are considered Approved Claims.
4.4.1. Savings/discounts are not stated herein in actual amounts or percentages,
nor are they guaranteed, since credits can vary by facility, type of service
provided and the specific provider agreement at a given facility.
4.4.2. The provider’s charge to BlueCross will usually be less than the rate
charged for a similar service to the general public. In some cases, however,
the rate negotiated by BlueCross for a particular service may be higher than
the provider’s rate for that service charged to the general public, and
BlueCross will pay the negotiated rate.
4.4.3. BlueCross has certain special arrangements with some providers that may
exempt those providers from certain administrative and medical
management requirements, including, but not limited to, prior authorization,
appropriateness review, notification and written referral requirements.
4.4.4. BlueCross may negotiate a settlement of a reimbursement dispute with a
provider as part of its internal administrative procedures.
5. Reimbursement to Network and Out-of-Network Providers.
5.1. “Network Providers ” are providers that have agreed to participate in the Blue
Network, and to accept BlueCross’s applicable pre-negotiated payment allowance
for certain Covered Services as payment in full, and therefore should not bill the
Members for any amount in excess of the payment allowance for such service(s).
The pre-negotiated payment will be based upon charges for Covered Services or
upon an alternative method of payment, including per diem amounts, percent of
charges, global case rate and fee schedule arrangements, and may be further
reduced by other contractual reductions, adjustments, discounts or offsets based
on BlueCross’s agreements with Network Providers. Network Providers will file
Members’ claims with BlueCross, and BlueCross will make payment directly to
Network Providers.
5.1.1. In the unlikely event of a systems failure at BlueCross (“Outage”) rendering
it temporarily impossible to determine which Network Provider rendered
services during a specific time period while the Agreement is in force,
BlueCross will make estimated payments to Network Providers. This
estimate will be based on past service to BlueCross Members, and will be
proportionately divided among Employer and other Groups which
BlueCross insures or to which BlueCross provides administrative and
claims processing service. When the capability to determine which Network
Providers did provide services during the Outage is restored, BlueCross
will adjudicate the claims submitted on behalf of Members, and notify
Employer of any adjustments necessary to Employer’s claims processing
funding.
5.2. When a Member receives services from a Network Provider, he or she will be
responsible for payment of the applicable Deductible, Coinsurance, Cost-Sharing
and/or Copayment, as well as charges for any non-covered services. A Member’s
Coinsurance for Covered Services received from a Network Provider will be based
on the provisions of the Network Provider’s contract, and the lesser of (i) the
Network Provider’s pre-negotiated payment allowance, or (ii) charges for Covered
Services at the time such Services are provided. BlueCross will not recalculate
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 58 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026
Exhibit C
Administrative Services Agreement Page 31
Coinsurance in the event it recovers a discount or savings with respect to Covered
Services after a claim for such Services is paid. Rather, Employer will receive a
payment or credit for such savings or discounts.
5.3. The Member’s liability for non- covered services, including services that are not
covered because of a benefit maximum or other limitation contained in the Benefit
Documents, will be based on the Network Provider’s actual charges for such
services.
5.4. “Out-of-Network Providers ” are providers that do not participate in the Blue
Network. BlueCross’s payment for Covered Services to any Out -of-Network
Provider will be based on Maximum Allowable Charge for the service performed.
Except as required by applicable law, (including the No Surprises Act enacted as
part of the Consolidated Appropriations Act , 2021), upon receipt of a completed
claim form, and provided adequate funding from Employer is available, BlueCross
shall make payment for Covered Services to the Out-of-Network Provider and not
the Member, unless BlueCross receives proof of payment from the Member before
payment is made to the provider. Except as required by applicable law, when the
Member receives services from an Out -of-Network Provider, he or she will be
responsible for the payment of any difference between BlueCross’s payment and
such provider’s charge(s), and responsible for any applicable Deductible,
Copayment, and Coinsurance, as well as payment of charges for any non-covered
services. The Member’s responsibility for Coinsurance will be based on the
Maximum Allowable Charge for that service. Maximum Allowable Charge shall be
calculated as determined by BlueCross in accordance with the EOC, BlueCross
policies and applicable law.
5.5. When Members obtain Covered Services outside of Tennessee, BlueCross’s Blue
Network reimbursement rules do not apply. Please refer to Exhibit G, Inter -Plan
Arrangements, for a description of how out-of-state providers are reimbursed.
5.6. BlueCross is responsible for reporting and remitting only those abandoned
property funds that were provider payments made with BlueCross funds.
5.7. Employer is required to reimburse the Veteran’s Administration (“ VA”) according
to federal law. BlueCross has an agreement with the VA in which there is an
established fee schedule. Federal law requires payment to the VA, regardless of
the network status, and regardless of the amount of benefits provided for services
by an Out -of-Network Provider. BlueCross will reimburse the VA at the rate set
forth in the agreement between BlueCross and the VA. The Plan will pay the VA
as if it were a Network Provider.
5.8. BlueCross’s contracts with Network Providers may include a variety of payment
methodologies. These payment methodologies may obligate BlueCross to pay an
amount that is in addition to the underlying cost of the service rendered. These
additional costs may include program fees, incentive payments, bonus payments,
or quality payouts. These provider reimbursements will be passed to Employer as
part of the billing process detailed in this Agreement.
5.9. No Member shall have the right to assign, alienate, transfer, sell, hypothecate,
mortgage, encumber, pledge, commute, or anticipate any benefit payment under
the Plan to a third party, and such payment shall not be subject to any legal process
to levy execution upon or attachment or garnishment proceedings against for the
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 59 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026
Exhibit C
Administrative Services Agreement Page 32
payment of any claims. Benefit payments under the Plan may not be assigned,
transferred, or in any way made over to another party by a Member. Nothing
contained in this Agreement or the Plan shall be construed to make the Employer,
Plan or BlueCross liable to any third party to whom a Member may be liable for
medical care, treatment, or services. If a written authorization is provided to
BlueCross by a Covered Person, BlueCross may pay a benefit directly to a provider
of medical care, treatment, or services instead of the Member as a convenience to
the Member; when this is done, all of the Plan's obligation to the Member with
respect to such benefit shall be discharged by such payment. However, BlueCross
reserves the right not to honor any direct payment request to any third party,
including but not limited to, any provider. The foregoing does not preclude any
assignment of payment to Medicaid to the extent required by law. Neither
BlueCross, nor the Plan will honor claims for benefits brought by a third - party;
such third- party shall not have standing to bring any such claim either
independently, as a Member or beneficiary, or derivatively, as an assignee of a
Member or beneficiary.
6. Medical Management Services. BlueCross will provide certain services through its
Medical Management program. These are described in Exhibit D to this Agreement.
7. Claims Payments Adjustments.
7.1. Whenever BlueCross becomes aware that a claims payment to a provider or
Member is less than the amount to which the provider or Member is entitled,
BlueCross shall promptly adjust the underpayment to reflect the proper amount
that should be remitted.
7.2. Whenever BlueCross becomes aware that a claims payment to a provider or
Member is more than the amount to which the provider or Member is entitled,
BlueCross shall make a diligent attempt to recover such overpayment, in
accordance with its customary admini strative procedures , and as permitted by
applicable law. In the event any part of an overpayment is recovered, Employer
will receive a credit from BlueCross. BlueCross shall not be required to institute
any legal proceeding to recover such overpayment. BlueCross will follow its
policies and procedures to settle overpayments.
7.2.1. If a claim payment was made for services rendered through the BlueCard
program, BlueCross has no obligation to attempt to collect claim payments
that were for less than fifty dollars ($50), or in accordance with stated limits
in effect at the Host Plan location.
7.2.2. Subject to the terms in Section 7.2.4, BlueCross will assume liability for an
unrecovered overpayment only if and when it is determined that:
7.2.2.1. the overpayment was caused by an act or omission of BlueCross
subject to indemnification under Article V, Section 5.1;
7.2.2.2. all reasonable means of recovery under the circumstances have
been exhausted; and
7.2.2.3. BlueCross’s acts or omissions were not undertaken at the
express direction of Employer.
7.2.3. BlueCross is not liable for interest on recovered overpayments.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 60 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026
Exhibit C
Administrative Services Agreement Page 33
7.2.4. Employer acknowledges and agrees that, except in cases of fraud
committed by the providerand, subject to applicable law, BlueCross will not
recover overpayments from providers more than 18 months after the date
that BlueCross paid the claim submitted by the provider.
7.2.5. In no event does BlueCross have an obligation to recover on liability for
overpayments of claims that were adjudicated for payment more than three
(3) years before the overpayment is discovered.
7.3. The Parties acknowledge that Employer may not contact Network Providers
directly or indirectly regarding rates or charges for services provided to Members.
All such contact with Network Providers must be by and through BlueCross.
7.4. Overpayment Recoveries: BlueCross, on behalf of Employer has the right to obtain
a refund of an overpayment on any claim(s) paid by BlueCross to a provider or a
Covered Person. Unless otherwise agreed upon between BlueCross and the
provider, when a provider fails to return an overpayment to BlueCross, BlueCross
has the right to utilize the following mechanisms to recover the overpayment: For
purposes of Sections 7.4.1 through 7.4.6 below, “Other Plan(s)” or “Another Plan”
means any health benefit plan other than the Plan, including, but not limited to,
individual and group plans or insurance policies that are administered or insured
by BlueCross.
7.4.1. BlueCross has the right to recover overpayments from future payments due
by BlueCross to a provider in conjunction with BlueCross’s payment of
medical claims for the Plan, or from Other Plans, up to an amount equal to
the overpayment (hereinafter “ Claim Recovery ”). When BlueCross
identifies an overpayment, BlueCross notifies the provider in writing,
identifying the overpayment (including the medical claim(s) at issue), the
provider’s ability to grieve BlueCross’s determination of the overpayment,
and the timeline for submitting payment for the overpayment. If the provider
does not return the requested overpayment as directed, BlueCross may
initiate its Claim Recovery process against future payments consistent with
this section.
7.4.2. BlueCross has the right to reduce payment to a provider by the amount
necessary to recover the overpayment to such provider and to reimburse
BlueCross for the amount BlueCross reimbursed to Employer (net of fees,
if any) in connection with such overpayment.
7.4.3. If BlueCross has made overpayments to a provider for medical claims
relating to members enrolled in more than one (1) Other Plan, BlueCross
may initiate its Claim Recovery process for multiple overpayments
collectively, against future payments owed to such provider on behalf of
Another Plan, as part of a single transaction, resulting in an overpayment
recovery amount which shall be applied in accordance with BlueCross
policies, which prioritize application based on the age of the overpayments,
beginning with the oldest outstanding overpayment or has the right to apply
the Claim Recovery process as otherwise set forth in this Section 7.4.
BlueCross shall not apply recovered amounts in a manner that prioritizes
Overpayments based upon the funding type of any plan (e.g., whether the
plan is fully-insured or self-funded).
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 61 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026
Exhibit C
Administrative Services Agreement Page 34
7.4.4. Employer acknowledges that BlueCross, may from time to time, conduct
Claim Recovery activities with respect to contracted and non -contracted
providers as permitted under the terms of any applicable contract and
applicable law. If BlueCross conducts Claim Recovery, BlueCross shall
record overpayments and returned funds separately and maintain claim
details at the Member account, and group levels.
7.4.5. Subject to the exception(s) set forth in this Section 7.4, Employer agrees
that BlueCross will recover overpayments in accordance with its recovery
process and that Employer has no separate or independent right to recover
any overpayment from BlueCross, provider, or Another Plan.
7.4.6. Employer may, at its option, request on a semi -annual basis, a report on
the status of all outstanding overpayments.
7.5. In the event that BlueCross becomes aware that a claims payment to a provider or
Member was or might have been the result of a fraud, BlueCross shall:
7.5.1. Notify the Plan as soon as possible about the alleged fraudulent claims;
7.5.2. Provide reasonable assistance to the Plan in recovering the alleged
fraudulent claims; and
7.5.3. Report the suspected fraud to the appropriate law enforcement agency.
8. Annual Renewal Claims Analysis.
8.1. BlueCross will provide an annual renewal analysis of Employer’s claims
experience. BlueCross will also provide assistance in benefit design.
8.2. Upon request, but not more often than annually, BlueCross will provide an analysis
of Employer’s claims incurred but not yet reported.
8.3. Upon request, but not more often than annually, BlueCross will provide an analysis
of the suggested funding levels for Employer’s Plan, as administered by
BlueCross.
8.4. Employer acknowledges that these analyses are estimates only, and that the
actual experience may differ from these estimates. These are for Employer’s use
only, and are not prepared for distribution to or reliance by third parties.
9. Mental Health Parity. The parties acknowledge and agree that Employer is solely responsible for
complying with all applicable provisions of ERISA and other laws applicable to Employer’s Plan,
including the Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act and its implementing regulations, as
amended from time to time (“MHPAEA”). BlueCross agrees to cooperate with Employer in
providing information reasonably requested by Employer or its designee in order for Employer to
comply with these obligations.
10. Duties with regard to BlueRe of Tennessee Stop Loss Coverage. Employer has stop loss
coverage with BlueRe of Tennessee (“BlueRe”). BlueCross will perform and provide the following
on behalf of Employer:
10.1. Provide any records needed for the proper administration of stop loss coverage to BlueRe.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 62 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026
Exhibit C
Administrative Services Agreement Page 35
10.2. Provide Employer the following information at renewal:
Census
Age/ Gender Subscriber Count by age/gender
Zip Codes Subscriber Count by LOB, State, Zip
Plan Design Summary/ Plan
Document
Evidence of Coverage
Trigger Reports:
50% of Specific Report 50% Report (Includes Diagnosis Only)
Medical & Rx
10.3. Coordinate payment to brokers, and any other commissions, as may be directed by
Employer.
10.4. Provide to Employer monthly Claimants at 50% of Specific Attachment Point Reports. Any
Employer requests to provide reports to third parties, including Employer Service Vendors,
will be subject to the information sharing agreement process set forth in Section 2.2.2.
11. RESERVED.
12. Section 111 Mandatory Secondary Payor Reporting. Section 111 of the Medicare,
Medicaid, and SCHIP Extension Act of 2007 (MMSEA), titled Medicare Secondary Payor,
(hereinafter “Section 111”) mandates that, effective January 1, 2009, all group health plans
or their representatives submit certain information to CMS. BlueCross is registered as a
medical “Required Reporting Entity” as required under Section 111. BlueCross shall report
the Plan’s medical information required by Section 111. Under no circumstances will
BlueCross be required to report workers’ compensation or liability insurance information
required under Section 111. Employer shall provide all Social Security numbers, tax
identification numbers, and the “total number of employees” (as that is defined in the
MMSEA) information to BlueCross. BlueCross will not be responsible for any deficiency
resulting from Employer’s failure to provide such information to BlueCross.
13. Distribution of Materials.
13.1. Employer shall handle and distribute enrollment materials in a timely manner and
promptly provide to BlueCross the information necessary to administer this
Agreement. Employer’s failure to provide information in a timely manner may
substantially delay and/or jeopardize the enrollment of eligible Members.
13.2. Employer shall distribute notices that Employer and/or BlueCross are legally
required to provide (e.g., special enrollment rights) in a timely manner and in
accordance with all applicable laws. Any off -renewal changes require 60- days
advance notice to Members. Employer shall provide BlueCross with enough
advance notice of any off -renewal changes, not to be less than 90 days, for
BlueCross to meet its obligations under any applicable law and this Agreement.
Employer shall indemnify BlueCross and hold BlueCross harmless from any
damages, loss, action, claim or suit (including court costs and attorney’s fees)
arising from or related to its failure to provide such notices.
13.3. If BlueCross provides its enrollment and/or change forms (“ Forms”) and/or any
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 63 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026
Exhibit C
Administrative Services Agreement Page 36
benefit summaries, and/or comparison sheets (“ Documents”) in an electronic
medium, and Employer delivers Documents electronically to Members or includes
Documents on Employer’s internal intranet or by similar means or for similar
purposes, Employer agrees that:
13.3.1. electronic access shall be limited to Employer’s enrolling employees and
covered employees and be restricted to a “read-only” or similar basis;
13.3.2. they will replace any hard- copy Forms that have been modified by
BlueCross;
13.3.3. the hard-copy documents on file with BlueCross shall control in the event
of any discrepancy; and
13.3.4. Employer remains solely responsible for the content of the Documents and
all other legal requirements pertaining to them (e.g., distribution).
13.4. BlueCross will create a draft Summary of Benefits and Coverage (“ SBC”), based
on services provided by BlueCross, and provide to Employer. Employer shall
review SBC, and revise or supplement as required, prior to distribution. Employer
remains solely responsible for SBC content and all other legal requirements
pertaining to SBC (e.g., distribution). BlueCross shall not charge Employer for draft
SBC. BlueCross may charge Employer for translation of SBC to any language
other than English.
14. Member Outreach. BlueCross or its subcontractor, shall have the right to contact Members
to perform services under this Agreement, or as otherwise required by law, a regulatory
body, or an accrediting agency. Employer warrants that the contact information included
in its enrollment data was obtained directly from the applicable Member and that Members
are aware they may be contacted via that information for non-telemarketing calls, emails,
and/or text messages.
15. Provider Administered Specialty Pharmacy Products. Provider Administered Specialty Pharmacy
Products are those Specialty Pharmacy Products administered to a Member by a health care
provider, whether or not a Network Provider, rather than self-administered by the Member.
Provider Administered Specialty Products can only be dispensed from a specialty pharmacy in
the BlueCross Preferred Specialty Pharmacy Network.
15.1. Provider Administered Specialty Pharmacy Products are those products that meet all three
of the following criteria:
(a) Require in-depth patient teaching, coordination of care, and frequent
monitoring to ensure successful use;
(b) Described by at least one of the following:
i. produced through genetic technology or biopharmaceutical
processes;
ii. target a chronic, rare, genetic, or complex disease; or
iii. require unique handling, distribution, and/or administration; and
(c) Are set forth on the Provider Administered Specialty Pharmacy Product List which is
maintained by BlueCross (available at www.bcbst.com), as may be amended from time
to time for any reason.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 64 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026
Exhibit C
Administrative Services Agreement Page 37
15.2. “Preferred Specialty Pharmacy Network” means BlueCross’s network of p harmacies that
are permitted to dispense Provider -Administered Specialty Pharmacy Products to
providers.
All the medications set forth on the Provider Administered Specialty Pharmacy Product List have
been determined by BlueCross to meet criteria (a) and (b) of Section 15.1 above. However,
some products meeting criteria in (a) and (b) of Section 15.1 above may be excluded from the list.
A Provider Administered Specialty Product may be added or removed from this list at any time for
any reason. Provider Administered Specialty Pharmacy Products can only be dispensed from a
pharmacy in BlueCross’s Preferred Specialty Pharmacy Network. BlueCross will adjudicate
claims for Provider Administered Specialty Pharmacy Products for the Employer.
16. Group Health Plan Federal Requirements.
16.1. Health Plan Transparency Requirements. The Parties acknowledge that Employer’s Plan
is subject to certain requirements under the Affordable Care Act Transparency in
Coverage Final Rule and group health plan requirements in Division BB of the
Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021 and its implementing regulations, as set forth below
(collectively, “Health Plan Transparency Requirements”). BlueCross (i ) agrees to
cooperate with Employer in meeting its obligations under the Health Plan Transparency
Requirements, and (ii) reserves the right to charge a fee for services related to the
implementation and administration of the Group Health Plan Transparency Requirements.
16.1.1. Machine Readable Files. The Parties acknowledge and agree that Employer’s Plan is
required to publicly disclose in-network negotiated rates, billed out-of-network charges,
and prescription drug pricing information to the public through machine readable files
(“MRF’s”). BlueCross agrees (a) to cooperate with Employer in providing information
reasonably requested by Employer or its designee in order for Employer to comply
with these obligations, or (b) at the direction of Employer, to post MRFs on its website
on behalf of the Plan, provided however, that Employer retains liability for any Losses
resulting from Employer’s failure to provide timely to BlueCross any requested
information for BlueCross to perform under this section.
16.1.2. Contract Terms. The Parties acknowledge and agree that, nothing in this Agreement
shall directly or indirectly restrict BlueCross and/or the Plan from (i) providing provider-
specific cost or quality of care information or data to referring providers, Employer,
Members or individuals eligible to become Plan Members; (ii) electronically accessing
de-identified claims and encounter information or data under t he Plan for each Plan
Member, upon request and consistent with applicable law, including but not limited to
HIPAA, GINA, and the ADA, or (iii) sharing such Plan information or data, or directing
such Plan data be shared, with a HIPAA business associate of the Plan consistent with
applicable law and the terms of this Agreement.
16.1.3. Price Comparison Tool. The Parties acknowledge and agree that Employer’s Plan is
subject to requirements under applicable law to provide Members with price
comparison tools. BlueCross agrees to cooperate with Employer in providing
information reasonably requested by Employer or its designee in order for Employer
to comply with the price comparison tool obligations, or (b) at the direction of Employer,
to make available to Plan Members a price comparison tool, provided however, that
Employer retains liability for any Losses resulting from Employer’s failure to provide
timely to BlueCross any requested information for BlueCross to perform under this
section.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 65 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026
Exhibit C
Administrative Services Agreement Page 38
16.2. ID Cards. BlueCross will supply identification cards. BlueCross will supply identification
cards issued at the group’s initial enrollment to Subscriber and identification cards issued
at any other time to Subscriber . Identification cards will be issued in the name of
Subscribers and Dependents.
16.3. Provider Directory Tool. BlueCross will provide Provider Directories through online access
and in accordance with applicable law.
16.4. Continuity of Care. The Parties acknowledge and agree that Employer’s Plan is subject to
continuity of care protections in instances when terminations of certain contractual
relationships result in changes in provider or facility network status. BlueCross agrees to
coordinate impacted Member’s transitions to more appropriate care settings in accordance
with applicable law.
16.5. Health Care and Prescription Drug Reporting. The Parties acknowledge and agree that
the Employer’s Plan is subject to requirements under applicable law to report certain health
care cost information annually to the federal government, such as costs relating to
prescription drugs and air ambulance services. BlueCross agrees (a) to cooperate with
Employer in providing information reasonably requested by Employer or its designee in
order for Employer’s Plan to comply with these reporting obligations, or (b), at the direction
of the Employer, to report on the Plan’s behalf, provided however, that Employer retains
liability for any Losses resulting from Employer’s failure to provide timely to BlueCross any
requested information for BlueCross to perform under this section.
16.6. No Surprises Act. The Parties acknowledge and agree that the Employer’s Plan is subject
to requirements under the No Surprises Act that is part of the Consolidated Appropriations
Act, 2021 (hereinafter, the “NSA”). BlueCross will process those out -of-network claims
subject to the NSA in accordance with the terms of the NSA and its implementing
regulations. BlueCross will also engage in the Independent Dispute Resolution (“IDR”)
process with providers, as required under the NSA. Fees for IDR services are set forth in
Exhibit B.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 66 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026
Exhibit D
Administrative Services Agreement Page 39
EXHIBIT D TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
MEDICAL MANAGEMENT SERVICES PROVIDED BY BlueCross
Employer has selected several of BlueCross’s Medical Management programs for use by
Employer in administering its Plan. All services utilize current medical guidelines and standards.
While these services are described below, the services may be updated from time to time without
prior notice to Employer.
MEDICAL MANAGEMENT – Precision Care Support
1. Inpatient Review.
1.1. Inpatient Precertification . BlueCross will review inpatient admissions (hospital,
subacute facility, skilled nursing facility, inpatient rehabilitation, and 23- hour
observation stays) to evaluate the appropriateness of certain procedures and
Medical Necessity of the requested servi ces. An initial length of stay is assigned
upon admission. Emergency inpatient admissions are reviewed within 24 hours of
admission or the next business day. Employer’s Plan follows BlueCross’s standard
precertification requirements.
1.2. Concurrent Review of per diem admissions . BlueCross will review Members’
inpatient care (hospital, subacute facility, skilled nursing facility, and inpatient
rehabilitation) to ensure Medically Necessary and Medically Appropriate care is
delivered. Concurrent review is performed as services are being rendered.
1.3. Outlier Review of DRG admissions . BlueCross will review any outlier days billed
by a DRG facility on targeted claims after a service is rendered and before payment
is made to ensure cost-effectiveness.
2. Retrospective Review. BlueCross will review targeted claims after a service is rendered
and before payment is made. The purpose of retrospective review is to provide
determinations regarding Medical Necessity, eligibility and benefits.
3. Prospective Review . BlueCross will review targeted, non -emergency related care
procedures, non-routine diagnostics and non-routine pharmacy treatments, as determined
by BlueCross, for medical appropriateness and the necessity of the requested procedure
and setting prior to the procedure being performed.
4. Pre-determination Review . When requested by a provider or Member, BlueCross will
conduct a prospective review to determine whether a procedure will be covered.
5. Specialty Pharmacy Review . If BlueCross administers claims related to Provider
Administered Specialty Pharmacy Products, as described in Exhibit C, then BlueCross will
review specific drugs administered by licensed health care professionals.
6. Home Health, Home Infusion Therapy Review . BlueCross will review prescriptions for
home health care services and home infusion therapy to evaluate the physician’s plan of
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 67 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026
Exhibit D
Administrative Services Agreement Page 40
treatment, appropriateness of setting and Medical Necessity of the prescribed services,
both prospectively and concurrently.
7. Lifestyle/Health Educational Program. BlueCross will send condition-specific educational
materials to low-risk Members identified through the prior authorization process.
8. Care Coordination. BlueCross’s Care Coordination process systematically identifies
opportunities to coordinate and manage Members’ total care.
8.1. Emergency Services Management Program . Nurses will contact Members who
frequently seek emergency room services, identify reasons for the frequent
utilization, and provide assistance in controlling future inappropriate use of
emergency room services.
8.2. Transition of Care. Throughout the different stages of a Member’s treatment,
nurses coordinate the Member’s transitions to more appropriate care settings.
8.3. Condition-specific Care Coordination Program. Through this program, BlueCross
provides assessment and management of low -risk and moderate- risk Members
with specific conditions, such as heart disease, respiratory disease, diabetes,
asthma or hypertension.
9. Catastrophic Medical and Transplant Case Management . BlueCross’s Catastrophic
Medical and Transplant Case Management program utilizes a comprehensive approach
that includes benefit analysis, preauthorization, concurrent review, discharge planning and
cost-effective continuity of care for Members. Members with high- risk conditions such as
terminal illness, severe injury, major trauma, cognitive or physical disability, or transplant
are identified through prior authorization, medical data and claims data. Registered nurses
work with the Member, health care providers and primary caregivers to coordinate the
most appropriate, cost-effective care settings.
Benefits paid through the Catastrophic Medical and Transplant Case Management
program may vary from the benefits described in the Plan. This is done when BlueCross
has determined that the alternative benefits are more Medically Appropriate, cost effective,
and ensure the best outcomes. Employer will fund these benefits, and BlueCross’s
administration of benefits pursuant to the Catastrophic Medical and Transplant Case
Management program shall be within the scope of its duties.
10. RESERVED
11. RESERVED
12. Behavioral Health Management. BlueCross will provide the following services as part of
its Behavioral Health Inpatient Utilization Management program:
12.1. Inpatient Pre- certification. BlueCross will review all facility based level- of-care
admissions (acute care, residential care, partial hospital care, intensive outpatient
care and any other care in lieu of acute care) to evaluate the appropriateness of
treatment applying Medical Necessity criteria. Emergency inpatient admissions are
reviewed within 24 hours of admission or the next business day.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 68 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026
Exhibit D
Administrative Services Agreement Page 41
12.2. Concurrent Review. BlueCross will review the care of Members in facility -based
treatment (acute, residential, partial hospital, intensive outpatient or any other care
in lieu of behavioral health acute care) to ensure Medically Necessary and
Medically Appropriate care is delivered. Lengths of stay are authorized when care
requested meets Medical Necessity criteria.
12.3. Discharge Planning. BlueCross will assess the Member’s behavioral health
condition and monitor the behavioral health program’s discharge planning to
ensure appropriate continuation of care, as necessary, when the Member leaves
that particular level of care.
12.4. Case Management. BlueCross’s Behavioral Health Case management process
identifies high risk Members in facility based levels of care and assesses
opportunities to coordinate and manage the Member’s total behavioral health care
to ensure the best outcomes while the Member remains in facility based levels of
care.
13. DME Navigator is a service that uses integrated clinical criteria to guide appropriate DME
equipment selection for the Member and provides claims and payment integrity with
advanced claims review and data validation.
14. BlueCross shall have the authority, in its discretion, to institute from time to time, utilization
management, case management, disease management or other care- related programs.
These are processes that demonstrate potential improvement in access, quality, efficiency
and Member satisfaction. When BlueCross institutes a care -related program, approved
services provided through such programs are deemed Covered Services even if they are
normally excluded under the Benefits Documents.
MEDICAL MANAGEMENT – Flexible Cost Management Programs
1. Musculoskeletal Procedures. BlueCross will review targeted, non-routine procedures such
as the following: spinal injections, spinal surgery, and hip, knee or shoulder surgery for
medical appropriateness and the necessity of the requested procedure and setting prior
to the procedure being performed.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 69 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit E
Administrative Services Agreement Page 42
EXHIBIT E TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
DUTIES OF EMPLOYER
1. Services. Employer shall:
1.1. Provide BlueCross with a current, detailed description of the Benefit Documents
and any subsequent changes, for acceptance by BlueCross;
1.2. Timely pay and fund all fees and claims as described in this Agreement;
1.3. Provide BlueCross with the necessary Subscriber and Member eligibility
information and timely provide updates to such information;
1.4. Perform other duties and services as described in this Agreement.
2. Notification Regarding Members . Employer shall notify BlueCross of the addition or
deletion of Members as described below:
2.1. When a new Member should be added, Employer shall notify BlueCross within
forty-five (45) days of the effective date of coverage for that Member. If BlueCross
is not notified that a new Member should be added within this time frame,
BlueCross shall have no obligation to adjudicate any claims that were incurred
prior to this time frame.
2.2. When a Member should be terminated from coverage, Employer shall notify
BlueCross within forty -five (45) days of the effective date of that Member’s
termination.
3. Final Authority.
3.1. Except as otherwise specifically stated in this Agreement, Employer retains all final
authority and responsibility for the Plan including the benefit design of the Plan,
funding of claims, claims payment decisions, cost containment program decisions,
eligibility and benefit determinations, compliance with the requirements of the
Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1985, as amended (COBRA),
compliance with HIPAA, compliance with reporting and remitting abandoned
property funds (except as referenced in Exhibit C, Section 5.6) if required by law,
and compliance with any other state and federal laws or regulations applicable to
Employer or the administration of the Plan. The phrase “eligibility and benefit
determinations” means that Employer determines who is eligible to participate,
(i.e., who are employees or dependents) and generally what medical services and
supplies are included or excluded as Covered Services identified in the Benefit
Documents, but does not include the ultimate responsibility for making medical
necessity or other medical management determinations.
3.2. If Employer uses an Employer Service Vendor to provide enrollment data and that
third party’s data does not match BlueCross’s data, BlueCross’s data and records
will be used to determine the ASF unless and until BlueCross and Employer are
able to resolve the discrepancy.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 70 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit E
Administrative Services Agreement Page 43
3.3. Employer shall submit all information to BlueCross in writing. The accuracy of any
changes performed and administered by BlueCross at the instruction of Employer
in benefit design, enrollee status, etc., is the responsibility of Employer. BlueCross
is entitled to rely on Employer’s instructions in performing its duties under this
Agreement.
3.4. A Member has the right to appeal any decision regarding or arising out of this
Agreement, and that appeals process is defined in the Benefits Documents and
the Plan.
4. Eligibility and Enrollment. As of the first day of the Term of this Agreement, Employer will
have delivered enrollment information regarding Members to BlueCross. Employer shall
deliver all employee and dependent eligibility status changes to BlueCross on a monthly
basis, or more frequently as mutually agreed by the Parties.
4.1. Employer shall be responsible for verifying identity of Members to confirm eligibility
and for promptly rescinding coverage of ineligible individuals.
4.2. Employer shall be responsible for providing each Subscriber with a copy of any
required documents.
4.3. If an employee waives his/her (or his/her dependents’) coverage under the Plan at
enrollment or open enrollment, Employer will maintain the original of the waiver,
and if the employee has a qualifying event during the plan year, Employer will
certify to BlueCross that the employee executed a waiver at enrollment or open
enrollment.
5. Financial Obligations.
5.1. Claims Funding. Employer is financially responsible for the timely funding of all
Approved Claims and is the p ayor of benefits for all Members. Employer will
provide BlueCross with such authorizations as are necessary to ensure that
required instruments are valid with respect to funding Approved Claims for
Covered Services.
6. Assessments.
6.1. Employer retains responsibility and liability for all benefits and expenses incident
to the Plan, including any federal, state or local taxes, assessments, or similar
government-imposed fees, other than BlueCross’s income taxes, that are related
to the Plan, the Plan’s Members, enrollees, or participants, or BlueCross’s services
under this Agreement (“Assessments”). For example, Assessments may be based
on: (i) the number of covered lives in the Plan, (ii) the number of covered lives in a
given geographic region, (iii) fees paid or payable to BlueCross for services
provided under this Agreement, including premiums or premium equivalents, (iv)
Approved Claims paid pursuant to this Agreement, or (v) other assessment
methodologies that measure the relative value of benefits or services provided or
delivered under the Plan. If at any time, during or after the term of this Agreement,
BlueCross is required to pay any Assessment on Employer’s behalf, Employer
shall reimburse BlueCross an amount equal to such Assessment(s), which will be
disclosed to Employer via invoice. Additionally, BlueCross pays if any taxes,
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 71 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit E
Administrative Services Agreement Page 44
penalties or interest are imposed, assessed or accrued on any Assessment,
Employer will reimburse BlueCross such additional amounts equal to the tax,
penalty or interest.
6.2. Employer will pay these additional amounts to BlueCross within thirty (30) days
following mailing of invoice. Payments not received within the thirty (30) day period
are subject to the late payment charge described in Exhibit B.
6.3. Employer will pay these additional amounts even if the validity of Assessments has
not been finally determined. If it is finally determined that such Assessments were
not valid, to the extent such Assessments are refunded or otherwise returned to
BlueCross by the appropriate Federal, state or local governmental entity,
BlueCross will refund to Employer an amount equal to those additional amounts
previously paid by Employer plus interest, if any, determined in accordance with
BlueCross’s regular procedures then in effect, less a pro rata share of any
expenses incurred by BlueCross in contesting the validity of such Assessments.
7. Use of Names and Service Marks. Employer agrees to allow BlueCross to use Employer’s
name and service mark on I.D. cards and other forms necessary to implement this
Agreement, for BlueCross’s internal purposes, and to promote Employer’s relationship
with BlueCross to potential or existing providers. BlueCross shall not use Employer’s
name or service mark for any other purpose without the prior written consent of Employer.
Employer agrees that the names, logos, symbols, trademarks, trade names, and service
marks of BlueCross, whether presently existing or hereafter established, are the sole
property of BlueCross and BlueCross retains the right to the use and control thereof.
Employer shall not use BlueCross’s name, logos, symbols, trademarks or service marks
in advertising or promotional materials or otherwise without the prior written consent of
BlueCross and shall cease any such usage immediately upon written notice by BlueCross
or upon termination of this Agreement, whichever is sooner.
Employer agrees that the names, logos, symbols, trademarks, trade names, and service
marks of the Association, whether presently existing or hereafter established, are the sole
property of the Association and the Association retains the right to the use and control
thereof. Employer shall not use the Association’s name, logos, symbols, trademarks or
service marks in advertising or promotional materials or otherwise without the prior written
consent of the Association and shall cease any such usage immediately upon written
notice by the Association or upon termination of this Agreement, whichever is sooner.
8. Claims Incurred and Submitted but not yet Adjudicated. Employer can request reports
regarding claims incurred and submitted but not yet adjudicated through the Account
Manager.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 72 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit F
Administrative Services Agreement Page 45
EXHIBIT F TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
DIRECT DEBIT AUTHORIZATION AGREEMENT
Employer has signed a separate Direct Debit Authorization Agreement, which is hereby
incorporated by reference as part of this Agreement.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 73 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit G
Administrative Services Agreement Page 46
EXHIBIT G TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
INTER-PLAN ARRANGEMENTS
1. Out-of-Area Services.
Overview
BlueCross has a variety of relationships with other Blue Cross and/ or Blue Shield
Licensees referred to generally as “ Inter-Plan Arrangements .” These Inter -Plan
Arrangements operate under rules and procedures issued by the Blue Cross Blue Shield
Association (“Association”). Whenever Members access healthcare services outside the
geographic area BlueCross serves, the claim for those services may be processed through
one of these Inter -Plan Arrangements. The Inter -Plan Arrangements are described
generally below.
Typically, when accessing care outside the geographic area BlueCross serves, Members
obtain care from healthcare providers that have a contractual agreement (“ participating
providers”) with the local Blue Cross and/or Blue Shield Licensee in that other geographic
area (“ Host Blue ”). In some instances , Members may obtain care from healthcare
providers in the Host Blue geographic area that do not have a contractual agreement
(“nonparticipating providers ”) with the Host Blue. BlueCross remains responsible for
fulfilling our obligations to Employer. Our payment practices in both instances are
described below.
This disclosure describes how claims are administered for Inter -Plan Arrangements and
the fees that are charged in connection with Inter -Plan Arrangements. Note that Dental
Care Benefits except when not paid as medical claims/benefits, and those Prescripti on
Drug Benefits or Vision Care Benefits that may be administered by a third party contracted
by Us to provide the specific service or services are not processed through Inter -Plan
Arrangements.
1.1. BlueCard® Program.
The BlueCard® Program is an Inter -Plan Arrangement. Under this Arrangement,
when Members access Covered Services within the geographic area served by a
Host Blue, the Host Blue will be responsible for contracting and handling all
interactions with its participating healthcare providers. The financial terms of the
BlueCard Program are described generally below.
1.1.1. Liability Calculation Method Per Claim – In General.
1.1.1.1. Member Liability Calculation
Unless subject to a fixed dollar copayment, the calculation of the
Member liability on claims for Covered Services will be based on
the lower of the participating provider’s billed charges for
Covered Services or the negotiated price made available to
BlueCross by the Host Blue.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 74 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit G
Administrative Services Agreement Page 47
1.1.1.2. Employer Liability Calculation
The calculation of Employer’s liability on claims for Covered
Services processed through the BlueCard Program will be based
on the negotiated price made available to BlueCross by the Host
Blue under the contract between the Host Blue and the provider.
Sometimes, this negotiated price may be greater for a given
service or services than billed charge in accordance with how the
Host Blue has negotiated with its participating healthcare
provider(s) for specific healthcare services. In cases where the
negotiated price exceeds the billed charge, Employer may be
liable for the excess amount even when the Member’s deductible
has not been satisfied. This excess amount reflects an amount
that may be necessary to secure (a) the provider’s participation
in the network and/or (b) the overall discount negotiated by the
Host Blue. In such a case, the entire contracted pric e is paid to
the provider, even when the contracted price is greater than the
billed charge.
1.1.2. Claims Pricing.
Host Blues determine a negotiated price, which is reflected in the
terms of each Host Blue’s provider contracts. The following are
examples of the negotiated price made available to BlueCross
by the Host Blue, but not an exhaustive list of negotiated prices:
1.1.2.1. An actual price. An actual price is a negotiated rate of payment
in effect at the time a claim is processed without any other
increases or decreases; or
1.1.2.2. An estimated price. An estimated price is a negotiated rate of
payment in effect at the time a claim is processed, reduced or
increased by a percentage to take into account certain payments
negotiated with the provider and other claim - and non- claim-
related transactions. Such transactions may include, but are not
limited to, anti-fraud and abuse recoveries, provider refunds not
applied on a claim-specific basis, retrospective settlements and
performance-related bonuses or incentives; or
1.1.2.3. An average price. An average price is a percentage of billed
charges for Covered Services in effect at the time a claim is
processed representing the aggregate payments negotiated by
the Host Blue with all of its healthcare providers or a similar
classification of its providers and other claim - and non- claim-
related transactions. Such transactions may include the same
ones as noted above for an estimated price.
The Host Blue determines whether it will use an actual, estimated
or average price consistent with its provider contracts. The use of
estimated or average pricing may result in a difference (positive
or negative) between the price Employer pays on a specific claim
and the actual amount the Host Blue pays to the provider.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 75 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit G
Administrative Services Agreement Page 48
However, the BlueCard Program requires that the amount paid by
the Member and Employer is a final price; no future price
adjustment will result in increases or decreases to the pricing of
past claims.
Any positive or negative differences in estimated or average
pricing are accounted for through variance accounts maintained
by the Host Blue and are incorporated into future claim prices. As
a result, the amounts charged to Employer will be adjusted in a
following year, as necessary, to account for over - or
underestimation of the past years’ prices. The Host Blue will not
receive compensation from how the estimated price or average
price methods, described above, are calculated. Because all
amounts paid are final, neither positive variance account amounts
(funds available to be paid in the following year), nor negative
variance amounts (the funds needed to be received in the
following year), are due to or from Employer. If Employer
terminates, Employer will not receive a refund or charge from the
variance account.
Variance account balances are small amounts relative to the
overall paid claims amounts and will be liquidated over time. The
timeframe for their liquidation depends on variables, including, but
not limited to, overall volume/number of claims processed and
variance account balance. Employer has no ownership interest in
any variance account. Variance accounts are notional
bookkeeping accounts maintained by the Host Blue and no
amounts are segregated or held for the benefit of the Employer.
1.1.3. BlueCard Program Fees and Compensation.
Employer understands and agrees to reimburse BlueCross for certain fees
and compensation which BlueCross is obligated under the BlueCard
Program to pay to the Host Blues, to the Association and/or to vendors of
BlueCard Program-related services. The specific BlueCard Program fees
and compensation that are charged to Employer are set forth in Exhibit B.
BlueCard Program Fees and compensation may be revised from time to
time as described in section 1.7 below.
1.2. Special Cases: Value-Based Programs.
1.2.1. Value-Based Programs Overview.
Employer’s Members may access Covered Services from providers that
participate in a Host Blue’s Value-Based Program. Value-Based Programs
may be delivered either through the BlueCard Program or a Negotiated
Arrangement. These Value- Based Programs may include, but are not
limited to, Accountable Care Organizations, Global Payment/Total Cost of
Care arrangements, Patient Centered Medical Homes and Shared Savings
arrangements.
1.2.2. Value-Based Programs under the BlueCard Program.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 76 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit G
Administrative Services Agreement Page 49
1.2.2.1. Value-Based Programs Administration
Under Value-Based Programs, a Host Blue may pay providers
for reaching agreed- upon cost/quality goals in the following
ways: Per member per month, provider incentives, gain share,
risk share, retrospective settlements, prospective settlements,
share of tar get savings, Care Coordination Fees and/or other
allowed amounts.
The Host Blue may pass these provider payments to BlueCross,
which BlueCross will pass directly on to Employer as either an
amount included in the price of the claim or an amount charged
separately in addition to the claim.
When such amounts are included in the price of the claim, the
claim may be billed using one of the following pricing methods,
as determined by the Host Blue:
• Actual Pricing: The charge to accounts for Value-Based
Programs incentives/Shared Savings settlements is
part of the claim. These charges are passed to
Employer via an enhanced provider fee schedule.
• Supplemental Factor: The charge to accounts for Value-
Based Programs incentives/Shared Savings settlements is
a supplemental amount that is included in the claim as an
amount based on a specified supplemental factor (e.g., a
small percentage increase in the claim amount). The
supplemental factor may be adjusted from time to time. This
pricing method may be used only for non -attributed Value-
Based Programs.
When such amounts are billed separately from the price of the
claim, they may be billed as follows:
1.2.2.1.1. Per Member Per Month (PMPM) Billings: Per Member
Per Month billings for Value- Based Programs
incentives/Shared Savings settlements to accounts are
outside of the claim system. BlueCross will pass these
Host Blue charges directly through to Employer as a
separately identified amount on the group billings.
The amounts used to calculate either the supplemental factors for estimated
pricing or PMPM billings are fixed amounts that are estimated to be
necessary to finance the cost of a particular Value- Based Program.
Because amounts are estimates, there may be positive or negative
differences based on actual experience, and such differences will be
accounted for in a variance account maintained by the Host Blue (in the
same manner as described in the BlueCard claim pricing section above)
until the end of the applicable Value- Based Program payment and/or
reconciliation measurement period. The amounts needed to fund a Value -
Based Program may be changed before the end of the measurement period
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 77 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit G
Administrative Services Agreement Page 50
if it is determined that amounts being collected are projected to exceed the
amount necessary to fund the program or if they are projected to be
insufficient to fund the program.
At the end of the Value- Based Program payment and/or reconciliation
measurement period for these arrangements, Host Blues will take one of
the following actions:
1.2.2.1.2. Use any surplus in funds in the variance account to fund
Value-Based Program payments or reconciliation
amounts in the next measurement period.
1.2.2.1.3. Address any deficit in funds in the variance account
through an adjustment to the PMPM billing amount or
the reconciliation billing amount for the next
measurement period.
The Host Blue will not receive compensation resulting from how estimated,
average or PMPM price methods, described above, are calculated. If
Employer terminates, Employer will not receive a refund or charge from the
variance account. This is because any resulting surpluses or deficits would
be eventually exhausted through prospective adjustment to the settlement
billings in the case of Value-Based Programs. The measurement period for
determining these surpluses or deficits may differ from the term of this
Agreement.
Members will not bear any portion of the cost of Value- Based Programs
except when a Host Blue uses either average pricing or actual pricing to
pay providers under Value-Based Programs.
1.2.3. Care Coordinator Fees.
Host Blues may also bill BlueCross for Care Coordinator Fees for provider
services which we will pass on to Employer as follows:
1.2.3.1. PMPM billings; or
1.2.3.2. Individual claim billings through applicable care coordination
codes from the most current editions of either Current Procedural
Terminology (CPT) published by the American Medical
Association (AMA) or Healthcare Common Procedure Coding
System (HCPCS) publ ished by the U.S. Centers for Medicare
and Medicaid Services (CMS).
As part of this Agreement/contract, BlueCross and Employer will not
impose Member cost sharing for Care Coordinator Fees.
1.2.4. Value-Based Programs under Negotiated Arrangements.
If BlueCross has entered into a Negotiated Arrangement with a Host Blue
to provide Value- Based Programs to Members, BlueCross will follow the
same procedures for Value- Based Programs administration and Care
Coordinator Fees as noted in the BlueCard Program section.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 78 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit G
Administrative Services Agreement Page 51
As part of this Agreement, BlueCross and Employer may agree/have
agreed to waive Member cost sharing for care coordinator fees.
1.2.5. Value-Based Programs Definitions.
Accountable Care Organization (ACO): A group of healthcare providers
who agree to deliver coordinated care and meet performance benchmarks
for quality and affordability in order to manage the total cost of care for their
member populations.
Care Coordination: Organized, information- driven patient care activities
intended to facilitate the appropriate responses to a Member’s healthcare
needs across the continuum of care.
Care Coordinator: An individual within a provider organization who
facilitates Care Coordination for patients.
Care Coordination Fee: A fixed amount paid by a Blue Cross and/or Blue
Shield Licensee to providers periodically for Care Coordination under a
Value-Based Program.
Global Payment/Total Cost of Care: A payment methodology that is defined
at the patient level and accounts for either all patient care or for a specific
groups of services delivered to the patient such as outpatient, physician,
ancillary, hospital services and prescription drugs.
Negotiated Arrangement a.k.a., Negotiated National Account
Arrangement: An agreement negotiated between a Control/Home Licensee
and one or more Par/Host Licensees for any National Account that is not
delivered through the BlueCard Program.
Patient-Centered Medical Home (PCMH): A model of care in which each
patient has an ongoing relationship with a primary care physician who
coordinates a team to take collective responsibility for patient care and,
when appropriate, arranges for care with other qualified physicians.
Provider Incentive: An additional amount of compensation paid to a
healthcare provider by a Blue Cross and/or Blue Shield Plan, based on the
provider’s compliance with agreed- upon procedural and/or outcome
measures for a particular group of covered persons.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 79 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit G
Administrative Services Agreement Page 52
Shared Savings: A payment mechanism in which the provider and payer
share cost savings achieved against a target cost budget based upon
agreed upon terms and may include downside risk.
Value-Based Program (VBP): An outcomes -based payment arrangement
and/or a coordinated care model facilitated with one or more local providers
that is evaluated against cost and quality metrics/factors and is reflected in
provider payment.
1.3. Prepayment Review & Return of Overpayments.
If a Host Blue conducts prepayment review activities, including, but not limited to,
data mining, itemized bill reviews, secondary claim code editing, and DRG audits,
the Host Blue may bill BlueCross up to a maximum of sixteen percent (16%) of the
savings identified, unless an alternative reimbursement arrangement is agreed
upon by BlueCross and the Host Blue, and these fees may be charged to
Employer. If a Host Blue engages a third party to perform these activities on its
behalf, the Host Blue may bill BlueCross the lesser of the full amount of the third-
party fees or up to sixteen percent (16%) of the savings identified, unless an
alternative reimbursement arrangement is agreed upon by BlueCross. and the
Host Blue, and these fees may be charged to Employer.
Recoveries of overpayments /from a Host Blue, or its participating and
nonparticipating providers, or from post -payment review activities, can arise in
several ways, including, but not limited to, anti -fraud and abuse recoveries ,
audits/healthcare provider/hospital bill audits, credit balance audits, utilization
review refunds and unsolicited refunds. Recoveries will be applied in general, on
either a claim-by-claim or prospective basis. If recovery amounts are passed on a
claim-by-claim basis from a Host Blue to BlueCross they will be credited to
Employer. When a Host Blue identified and collects these recovery amounts, the
Host Blue may bill BlueCross up to a maximum of sixteen percent (16%) of the
savings identified, unless an alternative reimbursement arrangement is agreed
upon by BlueCross and the Host Blue, and these fees may be charged to
Employer. In some cases, the Host Blue will engage a third party to assist in
identification or collection of recovery amounts. When this occurs, the Host Blue
may bill the lesser of the full amount of the third party fees or up to sixteen percent
(16%) of the savings identified, unless an alternative reimbursement arrangement
is agreed upon by BlueCross and the Host Blue, and these fees may be charged
to Employer.
Unless otherwise agreed to by the Host Blue, for retroactive cancellations of
membership, BlueCross will request the Host Blue to provide full refunds from
participating healthcare providers for a period of only one year after the date of the
Inter-Plan financial settlement process for the original claim. In some cases,
recovery of claim payments associated with a retroactive cancellation may not be
possible if, as an example, the recovery (a) conflicts with the Host Blue’s state law
or healthcare provider contracts, (b) would result from Shared Savings and/or
Provider Incentive arrangements , and Care Coordination Fees or (c) would
jeopardize the Host Blue’s relationship with its participating healthcare providers,
notwithstanding to the contrary any other provision of this Agreement.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 80 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit G
Administrative Services Agreement Page 53
1.4. Inter-Plan Programs: Federal/State Taxes/Surcharges/Fees
In some instances federal or state laws or regulations may impose a surcharge,
tax or other fee that applies to self -funded accounts. If applicable, BlueCross will
disclose any such surcharge, tax or other fee to Employer, which will be Employer’s
liability. See also Exhibit E, paragraph 6.
1.5. Nonparticipating Providers Outside BlueCross’s Service Area.
1.5.1. Member Liability Calculation.
1.5.1.1. In General
When Covered Services are provided outside of BlueCross’s
service area by nonparticipating providers, the amount(s) a
Member pays for such services will be based on either the Host
Blue’s nonparticipating healthcare provider local payment or the
pricing ar rangements required by applicable law. In these
situations, the Member may be responsible for the difference
between the amount that the nonparticipating provider bills and
the payment BlueCross will make for the Covered Services as set
forth in this paragraph. Payments for certain out -of-network
services, including out -of-network emergency services will be
governed by applicable federal and state law.
1.5.1.2. Exceptions
In some exception cases, BlueCross may pay claims from
nonparticipating healthcare providers outside of BlueCross’s
service area based on the provider’s billed charge. This may
occur in situations where a Member did not have reasonable
access to a particip ating provider, as determined by BlueCross
in BlueCross’s sole and absolute discretion or by applicable law.
In other exception cases, BlueCross may pay such claims based
on the payment BlueCross would make if BlueCross were paying
a nonparticipating provider inside of BlueCross’s service area.
This may occur where the Host Blue’s corresponding payment
would be more than BlueCross’s in-service area nonparticipating
provider payment, BlueCross may negotiate a payment.
BlueCross may choose to negotiate a payment with such a
provider on an exception basis.
Unless otherwise stated, in any of these exception situations, the
Member may be responsible for the difference between the
amount that the nonparticipating healthcare provider bills and the
payment BlueCross will make for the Covered Services as set
forth in this paragraph.
1.5.2. Fees and Compensation.
Employer understands and agrees to reimburse BlueCross for certain fees
and compensation which we are obligated under applicable Inter -Plan
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 81 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit G
Administrative Services Agreement Page 54
Arrangement requirements to pay to the Host Blues, to the Association
and/or to vendors of Inter-Plan Arrangement-related services. The specific
fees and compensation that are charged to Employer are set forth in Exhibit
B. Fees and compensation under applicable Inter-Plan Arrangements may
be revised from time to time as provided for in section 1.7 below.
1.6. Blue Cross Blue Shield Global® Core.
1.6.1. General Information.
If Members are outside the United States, the Commonwealth of Puerto
Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands (hereinafter: “BlueCard service area”), they
may be able to take advantage of Blue Cross Blue Shield Global Core when
accessing Covered Services. Blue Cross Blue Shield Global Core is unlike
the BlueCard Program available in the BlueCard service area in certain
ways. For instance, although Blue Cross Blue Shield Global Core assists
Members with accessing a network of inpatient, outpatient and professional
providers, the network is not served by a Host Blue. As such, when
Members receive care from providers outside the BlueCard service area,
the Members will typically have to pay the providers and submit the claims
themselves to obtain reimbursement for these services.
1.6.1.1. Inpatient Services
In most cases, if Members contact the service center for
assistance, hospitals will not require Members to pay for covered
inpatient services, except for their cost -share amounts. In such
cases, the hospital will submit Member claims to the service
center to initiate claims processing. However, if the Member paid
in full at the time of service, the Member must submit a claim to
obtain reimbursement for Covered Services. Members must
contact BlueCross to obtain precertification for non -
emergency inpatient services.
1.6.1.2. Outpatient Services
Physicians, urgent care centers and other outpatient providers
located outside the BlueCard service area will typically require
Members to pay in full at the time of service. Members must
submit a claim to obtain reimbursement for Covered Services.
1.6.1.3. Submitting a Blue Cross Blue Shield Global Core Claim
When Members pay for Covered Services outside the BlueCard
service area, they must submit a claim to obtain reimbursement.
For institutional and professional claims, Members should
complete a Blue Cross Blue Shield Global Core claim form and
send the claim form with the provider’s itemized bill(s) to the
service center address on the form to initiate claims processing.
The claim form is available from BlueCross, the service center,
or online at www.bcbsglobalcore.com. If Members need
assistance with their claim submissions, they should call the
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 82 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit G
Administrative Services Agreement Page 55
service center at 1.800.810.BLUE (2583) or call collect at
1.804.673.1177, 24 hours a day, seven days a week.
1.6.2. Blue Cross Blue Shield Global Core-Related Fees.
Employer understands and agrees to reimburse BlueCross for certain fees
and compensation which we are obligated under applicable Inter -Plan
Arrangement requirements to pay to the Host Blues, to the Association
and/or to vendors of Inter-Plan Arrangement-related services. The specific
fees and compensation that are charged to Employer under Blue Cross
Blue Shield Global Core are set forth in Exhibit B. Fees and compensation
under applicable Inter-Plan Arrangements may be revised from time to time
as provided for in section 1.7 below.
1.7. Modifications or Changes to Inter-Plan Arrangement Fees or Compensation.
Modifications or changes to Inter -Plan arrangement fees are generally made
effective January 1 of the calendar year, but they may occur at any time during the
year. In the case of any such modifications or changes, BlueCross shall provide
Employer with at least thirty (30) days’ advance written notice of any modification
or change to such Inter -Plan arrangement fees or compensation describing the
change and the effective date thereof.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 83 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit H
Administrative Services Agreement Page 56
EXHIBIT H TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
COBRA ADMINISTRATION PROVIDED BY BlueCross
In the event that any Member is entitled to continuation of their benefits under the Benefit
Documents, BlueCross will continue to perform its duties under this Agreement with regard to that
Member as outlined below. That Member shall be charged the amount allowed by law (currently,
102% of the premium equivalent charged to active Subscribers, and 150% if the Member is
disabled). BlueCross’s and Employer’s obligations under this Exhibit shall terminate upon
termination of this Agreement.
1. When an eligible employee (and/or his or her spouse) first enrolls in Employer’s Plan, and
Employer has notified BlueCross of this enrollment, BlueCross shall:
1.1. Issue an initial COBRA notice to the eligible employee at the home address
supplied by Employer. We will send a single notice to the eligible employee and
spouse if BlueCross’s information is that he or she reside at the same address and
enrolled at the same time;
1.2. Send a separate notice to the spouse, if:
1.2.1. The spouse lives at a separate address from the eligible employee (and
BlueCross is made aware of this by Employer prior to issuing the notice);
or
1.2.2. The spouse becomes enrolled in Employer’s Plan at a different time from
the eligible employee;
1.3. Issue these notices within 14 days of the date Employer notifies BlueCross that
the eligible employee and/or spouse has enrolled.
2. Once notified by Employer that a Subscriber and/or Dependents are eligible for COBRA
continuation (“Eligible COBRA Participant”), BlueCross shall:
2.1. Remove the Member(s) from Employer’s eligible Member record at BlueCross;
2.2. Send a COBRA Qualifying Event Notice to the Eligible COBRA Participant, along
with enrollment forms and rate and benefit information within 14 days of receiving
notice from Employer that a Qualifying Event has occurred;
2.3. Send premium equivalent notices to the Eligible COBRA Participant, either by mail
or other acceptable method;
2.4. Collect all necessary payments and premium equivalents from said Member, in
such amounts as directed by Employer, for all benefits selected to be continued by
the Qualified Beneficiaries. If BlueCross does not receive the necessary payments
from a Qualified Beneficiary, BlueCross will:
2.4.1. Place a stop-pay on the Qualified Beneficiary’s benefits; and
2.4.2. Cancel the Qualified Beneficiary’s coverage at the end of the grace period.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 84 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit H
Administrative Services Agreement Page 57
2.5. Provide claims processing services;
2.6. Provide access to the Blue Network(s);
2.7. Provide all notices and other documentation required under COBRA on Employer’s
behalf once a Member goes on COBRA; and
2.8. Terminate the COBRA continuation coverage at the appropriate time.
2.9. When a notification of termination is generated, (i.e., for failure to submit the
enrollment form and pay the applicable premium during the statutory election
and/or grace period, non- payment of premium charges or expiration of the
applicable eligibility period for COBRA continuation coverage) BlueCross will:
2.9.1. Notify the Qualified Beneficiary of the coverage termination, as well as the
reason and effective date thereof;
2.9.2. Notify Employer of any termination of coverage;
2.9.3. Mail information regarding any available conversion coverage to the
terminated Qualified Beneficiary.
2.10. When a Termination of Coverage letter is sent, it will be sent to the Member’s
current address, as contained in BlueCross’s records.
2.11. If Employer terminates its Plan, BlueCross shall not send out Termination of
Coverage letters.
3. Employer, as the Plan Administrator, shall:
3.1. Provide the eligibility information for all Qualified Beneficiaries to BlueCross with
the monthly eligibility information;
3.2. Notify BlueCross, using BlueCross’s form, that a Subscriber and/or Dependents
are eligible for COBRA within 30 days of the Qualifying Event;
3.3. Provide timely notice of the following information (but in no event more than 30
days) to BlueCross in writing when a Qualifying Event occurs: (a) the name and
address of the Qualified Beneficiaries; (b) type of qualifying event; (c) the date of
the Qualifying Event; (d) the date that Employer-sponsored health coverage would
otherwise terminate; (e) the Qualified Beneficiary’s ID number; (f) the Qualified
Beneficiary’s date of birth; and
3.4. Notify BlueCross of any changes that it becomes aware of that might affect the
Eligible COBRA Participant’s coverage under COBRA.
4. ASF for COBRA-Related Services:
4.1. For Qualified Beneficiaries who have BlueCross-administered health benefits:
4.1.1. Employer shall pay BlueCross the ASF included in Exhibit B;
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 85 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit H
Administrative Services Agreement Page 58
4.1.2. Employer shall pay BlueCross the same ASF for eligible COBRA
Participants as is charged for Subscribers.
4.2. For Qualified Beneficiaries who elect COBRA continuation, but not for BlueCross
administered health benefits, Employer shall pay BlueCross 2% of the premium
equivalent remitted.
4.3. Payment for COBRA administration services is as follows:
4.3.1. For Qualified Beneficiaries who elect COBRA Continuation for BlueCross
administered health benefits:
4.3.1.1. Employer shall pay to BlueCross the currently charged ASF for
all Eligible COBRA Participants;
4.3.2. From each premium equivalent remitted by Eligible COBRA Participants,
BlueCross shall:
4.3.2.1. Retain 2% of the premium equivalent received by BlueCross;
4.3.2.2. Credit Employer with the remainder of the premium equivalent
received by BlueCross.
4.3.3. For Qualified Beneficiaries who do not elect COBRA Continuation for
BlueCross administered health benefits:
4.3.4. From each premium equivalent remitted by Eligible COBRA Participants,
BlueCross shall:
4.3.4.1. Retain 2% of the premium equivalent received by BlueCross;
4.3.4.2. Send a separate check to Employer for the remainder of the
premium equivalent received by BlueCross.
5. BlueCross will provide COBRA administration for all Members covered under Employer’s
Plan.
6. “Qualified Beneficiary ” means each individual person who is eligible for COBRA
continuation coverage, whether formerly covered under the BlueCross administered plan
as a Subscriber or a dependent, or covered under another of Employer’s benefits plans.
7. “Eligible COBRA Participant ” means the group of a Subscriber and/or Dependents,
whether formerly covered under the BlueCross or another of Employer’s benefit plans,
that have elected to be covered together as a family unit and are issued one invoice for
COBRA Continuation Coverage by BlueCross.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 86 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit I
Administrative Services Agreement Page 59
EXHIBIT I TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
HEALTH AND WELLNESS SERVICES
Employer has selected the Health and Wellness Services described below.
1. Services.
1.1. Teladoc™ Health. Teladoc Health provides access to practitioners via telephone,
internet or other telecommunication device, whereby the Practitioner may
diagnose a Member’s ailment, recommend therapy and, where appropriate, write
a non-DEA controlled prescription. Teladoc Health’s Mental Health Complete gives
Members the ability to schedule appointments with mental health Practitioners for
talk therapy and prescription medication management, when appropriate, and also
includes access to certified coaches, digital programs, engagement guidance, and
crisis outreach depending on the Member’s needs. In addition to claim visit costs
related to visits with a mental health Practitioner, program fees will be charged on
a Per Participant Per Month basis as described in Exhibit B.
1.2. Diabetes Prevention Program . The program aims to prevent Members from
developing diabetes. Members at risk for developing type 2 diabetes are identified
through a pre -diabetes screening questionnaire. Once enrolled, Members have
access to the DPP’s standard suite of tools, such as c ellular-enabled scales,
interactive coaching sessions, online classes, etc., that help the Member make
lifestyle changes and decrease their likelihood of developing diabetes. BlueCross’s
DPP utilizes a digitally based platform to administer the program. Pr ogram fees
will be charged on a per-Member basis as described in Exhibit B.
1.3. Diabetes Management Program . The program aims to reduce hemoglobin A1C
levels, emergency room visits and outpatient visits for Members with diabetes who
participate in the program. The DMP gives the Member access to monitoring via
connected meter and real-time insights, unlimited supply of test strips and lancets
shipped direct to Member with automated reordering based on usage, 24/7 support
and access to clinical coaches for diabetes education and support. Real -time
insights help Members share reports with their provider and receive health
notifications and reminders to help keep them on track. The DMP utilizes a digitally-
based platform to administer the program. Program fees will be charged on a Per
Participant Per Month basis as described in Exhibit B.
1.4. The Digital MSK Clinic Program is designed to go beyond digital physical therapy programs
available from other service providers. It includes physical therapy, but adds an Enso non-
addictive, non-invasive wearable pain management device.
1.4.1. The Digital MSK Clinic Program uses online screening to confirm Member eligibility and
appropriateness for the Program. Members may not meet the criteria to participate if
they have comorbidities and have had a recent surgery without adequate post-op care.
If a Member doesn’t meet the Program eligibility criteria, they will be informed in writing
and referred to their primary care physician or a surgeon.
1.4.2. The Digital MSK Clinic Program offers five different care options:
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 87 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit I
Administrative Services Agreement Page 60
1.4.2.1. Preventive care- Job-specific exercises, guided through the Digital MSK Clinic
app, and education on healthy habits and injury prevention.
1.4.2.2. Acute pain care- Customized exercise therapy with access to 1-on-1 physical
therapy video visits.
1.4.2.3. Chronic pain care- An intensive 12- week phase and annual access to
personalized app-guided exercise therapy, Physical Therapist (PT) video
visits, 1 -on-1 health coaching and education. Includes the Enso device,
when clinically needed for pain management. The chronic pain care
program also includes access to the Pelvic Health Program.
1.4.2.4. Pre- and post-op care- One month of pre-surgical care and three months of
post-surgical care that includes personalized exercise therapy, PT video
visits, and 1-on-1 health coaching.
1.4.3. Visits with a PT in the pre- and post-op care program do not count towards a Member’s
medical physical therapy benefit limit.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 88 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit J
Administrative Services Agreement Page 61
EXHIBIT J TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
RESERVED
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 89 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit K
Administrative Services Agreement Page 62
EXHIBIT K TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
RESERVED
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 90 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit L
Administrative Services Agreement Page 63
EXHIBIT L TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
RESERVED
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 91 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit L
Administrative Services Agreement Page 64
EXHIBIT M TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
ONLINE ENROLLMENT SPECIFICATIONS THROUGH BlueCross SECURED WEBSITE
1. BlueCross’s Duties and Responsibilities.
1.1. BlueCross will provide a PIN for website access.
1.2. BlueCross will provide instruction upon Employer’s request. Such instruction may
be done by telephone or personal contact.
1.3. BlueCross will accept data and process enrollment, status change and termination
requests in accordance with the eligibility guidelines.
1.4. BlueCross has the right to audit Employer’s data transmissions for accuracy and
completeness.
2. Employer’s Duties and Responsibilities.
2.1. Employer will submit data only on eligible individuals.
2.2. Employer is responsible for the accuracy and completeness of all data submitted.
2.3. Employer will submit data on a timely basis in accordance with this Agreement.
2.4. Employer assumes responsibility for notifying BlueCross when Employer’s group
administrator or enrollment contact changes, so that BlueCross can revoke that
individual’s website access. BlueCross will revoke access within 5 working days of
being notified. If Employer does not inform BlueCross of any such change, and a
former group administrator or enrollment contact enters fraudulent or incorrect
information through the website, Employer is responsible for these actions.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 92 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit N
Administrative Services Agreement Page 65
EXHIBIT N TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
GRIEVANCE SERVICES
This Exhibit describes duties regarding grievance services:
1. First Level Grievance
1.1 BlueCross shall conduct the first level grievance on Employer’s behalf. For
purposes of handling the first level Grievance, BlueCross is a Limited Fiduciary, as
that term is defined in ERISA.
1.2 BlueCross’ first level grievance committee shall have full discretionary authority to
make eligibility, benefit, claim, or any other applicable benefit determinations.
1.3 A written decision concerning the grievance shall be sent to the Member and to
Employer within the timeframe set forth in the Plan.
1.4 Member shall have the opportunity to submit written testimony and any additional
written information to the committee. Oral testimony will not be permitted at the first
level grievance.
1.5 First level grievance shall be the only mandatory level of grievance.
2. Second Level Grievance
2.1 Employer does not have a Second Level Grievance.
3. External Review.
3.1 Employer does not have External Review.
4. The Plan and BlueCross’ grievance processes shall be subject to and comply with the review
standards applicable to ERISA plans, whether or not the Plan is otherwise governed by
ERISA.
5. BlueCross shall, upon Employer’s request, provide to Employer any grievance information
related to a grievance handled by BlueCross.
6. Nothing in the Plan shall establish a grievance process that contradicts any
statement in this Section.
7. BlueCross shall not be required to perform any grievance services not expressly
stated in this Section.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 93 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit O
Administrative Services Agreement Page 66
EXHIBIT O TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
SAVINGS GUARANTEE BLUE NETWORK
1. Savings Guarantee.
BlueCross guarantees that, of the claims that are approved for Eligible Charges, Employer will see a
savings over the amount charged by Network Providers. The Savings Guarantee will be 63%. This
Savings Guarantee applies only to Eligible Charges received from a Network Provider.
1.1. This Savings Guarantee is valid only for the period July 1, 2026, through June 30, 2027, (the
“SG Effective Period”).
1.2. The measuring period for the Savings Guarantee is the applicable Plan Year, not to exceed
12 months.
1.3. The Savings Guarantee is based on the following facts and assumptions:
1.3.1. An enrollment of 786 lives and 2.56 contract size, and a network penetration of 95%.
1.3.2. No substantial changes (i.e. including but not limited to the addition of a new
participating hospital or the termination of a participating hospital) in the Blue Network
P, or network service area.
1.3.3. The following provider utilization by type: (a) Inpatient, 13.0%; Outpatient, 48.0%; and
Physician 39.0%.
1.4. BlueCross reserves the right to change or nullify the Savings Guarantee if any of the following
occur:
1.4.1. A +/-10% change in overall enrollment or contract size, enrollment by location, state
or addition/closing of a location.
1.4.2. Network penetration falls below 93%.
1.4.3. A substantial change (i.e. including but not limited to the addition of a new participating
hospital or termination of a participating hospital) in BlueCross’ Network area. In such
instance, adjustments will be made accordingly and communicated as soon as
reasonably possible, but not later than 30 days prior to the effective date of the
adjustment.
1.4.4. Provider utilization by type deviates +/-5% from the above percentages.
1.5. Savings Guarantee applies to in-network medical charges only and excludes network access
fees, zero discount claims, behavioral health claims, pharmacy claims, provider administered
specialty pharmacy claims, and claims over $100,000.
1.6. A Network Savings Summary report will be provided on a quarterly basis.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 94 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit O
Administrative Services Agreement Page 67
2. BlueCross will determine the actual Savings Guarantee Percentage and provide Employer with the
amount of any applicable refund, if necessary, no later than three months after the end of the
applicable Plan Year.
2.1. If the achieved savings percentage is 3-4.9 percentage points below the Savings Guarantee,
then BlueCross will return $4.20 Per Contract Per Month (PCPM).
2.2. If the achieved savings percentage is 5 .0 or more percentage points below the Savings
Guarantee, then BlueCross will return an additional $9.82 Per Contract Per Month (PCPM).
2.3. Any amounts owed to Employer by BlueCross will be paid within 30 days of when BlueCross
delivers the Savings Guarantee calculation to Employer. Delivery may be accomplished via
U.S. mail, electronic mail, or fax. Delivery may also be made in person by a representative of
BlueCross.
3. Termination of this Exhibit.
This Savings Guarantee is valid only for the SG Effective Period. Should Employer terminate the
Agreement before the end of the SG Effective Period, this Savings Guarantee will be invalid.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 95 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit P
Administrative Services Agreement Page 68
EXHIBIT P TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
PHARMACY SERVICES
Employer has selected BlueCross to provide pharmacy benefit management services with
respect to Employer’s Plan.
1. DEFINITIONS
The following definitions apply for purposes of this Exhibit only.
“Covered Drug(s)” means those prescription drugs, supplies, and other items that are
covered under the Plan.
“Drug Formulary” means the list of FDA-approved prescription drugs and supplies
developed by BlueCross’ Pharmacy and Therapeutics Committee, or its delegate. The drugs
and supplies included on the Drug Formulary will be modified by BlueCross, or its delegate,
from time to time as a result of factors, including, but not limited to, medical appropriateness,
pharmaceutical manufacturer Pharmacy Rebate arrangements, and patent expirations.
“Home Delivery Network” means BlueCross’ network of Participating Pharmacies where
prescriptions are filled and delivered to Members via mail delivery service. The Home Delivery
Network does not include pharmacies in the Specialty Pharmacy Network.
“Manufacturer Administrative Fees” means those administrative fees paid by
manufacturers to the pharmacy benefit manager pursuant to a contract between the
pharmacy benefit manager and the manufacturer in connection with the pharmacy benefit
manager’s administering, invoicing, allocating, and collecting Pharmacy Rebates.
“Member Submitted Claim” means a Prescription Drug Claim submitted by a Member for
Covered Drugs dispensed by a Pharmacy for which the Member paid cash.
“Over the Counter Drug” or “OTC” means a drug available without a written prescription.
“Participating Pharmacy” means any pharmacy within BlueCross’ Pharmacy network
licensed to provide Covered Drugs to Members.
“Pharmacy Rebate” is revenue received by BlueCross from rebate aggregators or
pharmaceutical manufacturers, which is related to Members’ utilization of Covered Drugs. The
following are specifically excluded from the definition of Pharmacy Rebate and shall be
retained by BlueCross: (a) contractual obligations to BlueCross that require payment of a
penalty or other amount to BlueCross if contractual obligations are not met; and (b) rebates
attributable to any payment BlueCross receives for a Provider Administered Specialty
Pharmacy Product claim as defined in Exhibit C ; and (c) Manufacturer Administrative Fees.
“Prescription Drug Claim” means a Member Submitted Claim or claim for payment
submitted by a Participating Pharmacy as a result of dispensing a Covered Drug to a Member.
“Retail 30 Network” means BlueCross’ network of retail Participating Pharmacies that are
permitted to dispense Covered Drugs to Members typically in a 30-day supply.
“Specialty Pharmacy Network” means BlueCross’ network of Participating Pharmacies that
are permitted to dispense Self-Administered Specialty Pharmacy Products to Members.
“Self- Administered Specialty Pharmacy Product” means those Specialty Pharmacy
Products that a Member administers rather than a provider and that are listed on the
Specialty Drug List . Self-Administered Specialty Pharmacy Products can only be dispensed
from a specialty pharmacy in the Specialty Pharmacy Network and must meet all three of the
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 96 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit P
Administrative Services Agreement Page 69
following criteria:
a) Require in-depth patient teaching, coordination of care, and frequent
monitoring to ensure successful use;
b) Described by at least one of the following:
i. produced through genetic technology or biopharmaceutical
processes;
ii. target a chronic, rare, genetic, or complex disease; or
iii. require unique handling, distribution, and/or administration; and
c) Are set forth in the Drug Formulary which is maintained by BlueCross, or
its delegate, (available at www.bcbst.com), as may be amended from
time to time for any reason.
All the medications set forth in the Drug Formulary have been determined by BlueCross, or its
delegate, to meet criteria (a) and (b) above. However, some products meeting criteria in (a)
and (b) above may be excluded from the Drug Formulary. A Self-Administered Specialty
Pharmacy Product may be added or removed from the Drug Formulary at any time for any
reason.
2. PHARMACY SERVICES
BlueCross will provide the following pharmacy benefit management services:
Employer and Member Services
Toll-free consumer advisor number for Members Designated account team
Coordinated eligibility submission Benefit plan setup
Member Submitted Claim processing Electronic claims processing
Network Pharmacy Services
Pharmacy help desk Pharmacy reimbursement
Pharmacy network management ePrescribing
Home Delivery Services
Customer service for Members Benefit education
Installment Payment Program Prescription delivery – standard
Manage Automatic Refills and Renewals Bridge supply
Specialty Pharmacy Network Services
Benefit education Prescription delivery – standard
Reporting Services
Web-based client reporting Billing reports
Website Services
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 97 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit P
Administrative Services Agreement Page 70
BlueAccess - access to benefit, drug, health and
wellness information; prescription ordering
capability; My RX Choices and customer service
Email a Pharmacist – 24/7 access to specialized
pharmacists to answer non-urgent questions via email
about medications.
Cost Containment and Trend Management
Solutions1
Solution Description Fee
Formulary
Management
Drug Formulary program based on evidence-based medicine,
integrated utilization management leveraging best practice guidelines
and physician expertise to comparatively review and assess new and
existing drugs for safety, efficacy and cost control.
No
Additional
Fee
POS Safety
Messaging
A concurrent drug utilization program design to assist with
preventing drug-related adverse events. Online, real-time drug
utilization analysis is performed at the point of prescription
dispensing, whether the dispensing occurs at the retail Pharmacy or
at the home delivery Pharmacy.
No
Additional
Fee
Utilization
Management
Represents a wide variety of rules-driven programs such as prior
authorization, quantity limits, and step therapy to manage trends in
patient drug utilization and client drug spend.
• Prior Authorization - Monitors the dispensing of high-cost
medications and those with the potential for misuse by
requiring special approval (authorization) for certain drugs.
• Step Therapy - Manages drug costs by ensuring that patients try
first-line (first step), clinically effective, lower-cost medications
before they “step up” to higher-cost medication.
• Quantity Management - Sets dispensing limits for
certain drugs based on FDA approved dosing
guidelines.
No
Additional
Fee
Drug Coverage
Determinations
Includes initial determinations and reconsideration processes and
criteria for benefit design related requests, plan exclusion reviews
(clinical or administrative reviews of non-Covered Drugs), copay
reviews, plan limit reviews (e.g. age, gender, days’ supply limits),
administrative reviews, clinical benefit reviews and direct claim reject
reviews. The initial determinations and reconsideration processes
are in addition to and occur before the Grievance Procedure.
Members may submit Grievances in accordance with the Grievance
Procedure outlined in their EOC.
No
Additional
Fee
Integrated
Benefit
Management
Integrated solution that provides real-time shared deductible and out-
of-pocket accumulations between the medical and pharmacy benefit.
No
Additional
Fee
Specialty
Pharmacy
Management
Program encourages the adherence to safe and effective use of
specialty pharmacy drugs according to prescribed regimens. The
program achieves savings by establishing benefits for specialty
prescriptions, limiting distribution to preferred vendors, establishing
prior authorization criteria to assure appropriate utilization, and
renegotiating of drug prices annually.
No
Additional
Fee
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 98 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit P
Administrative Services Agreement Page 71
Comprehens
ive Fraud,
Waste and
Abuse
Comprehensive Fraud Waste and Abuse (FWA) reviews claims on
the provider, pharmacy, and member level to identify any abnormal
filling practices. Once an entity has been identified as filling
potentially fraudulent prescriptions, our criminal investigations team
will review and implement mitigation strategies.
No
Additional
Fee
High Cost
Claimant
Review
An integrated management program targeting cost stratification and
focused interventions for high dollar pharmacy claimants as part of a
comprehensive Member population health solution.
No
Additional
Fee
Retail
Vaccine
Program
This preventive services program broadens the reach of flu and other
vaccines while reducing costs by providing a convenient and less
expensive alternative through the Retail 30 Network.
No
Additional
Fee
Drug Savings
Review
Program to communicate with providers to suggest missing or
alternate drug therapies for members taking certain medications.
This program consists of algorithmic and clinician reviews that
examine members’ diagnoses and drug dosages, and when
appropriate, recommends changes in therapy. When the algorithm
identifies a potentially harmful prescription, specialty trained
pharmacists notify the prescribing physician and vending pharmacist
before the drug is dispensed.
No
Additional
Fee
Core Medication
Management
Program for members with chronic conditions to ensure they are
taking medications properly by addressing potential adherence
issues and closing gaps in care. This program analyzes pharmacy
claims data and notifies members and providers with refill and late to
fill notifications per member’s preferred method of communication.
No
Additional
Fee
Cost Saver
Cost Saver utilizes a third-party contracted Participating Pharmacy
network to enable Plan Members to take advantage of lower discount
card prices, when available, while retaining the benefit of the drug
utilization and clinical programs provided under the Plan. The
program, which is eligible for non-specialty medications, is fully
automated so it ensures members receive the lowest possible price
without any additional discount cards.
No
Additional
Fee
1. State legislation may impact program availability
2.1 Participating Pharmacies . The amount paid to the Participating Pharmacy for
Prescription Drug Claims may or may not be equal to the amount charged to Employer,
and BlueCross will absorb any negative margin or retain any positive margin. Subject to
applicable law, BlueCross may co mmunicate with Members regarding benefit design,
cost savings, availability and use of the selected networks, as well as provide supporting
services.
A list of Participating Pharmacies is available to Members on-line. BlueCross does not
direct or exercise any control over the professional judgment exercised by any
pharmacist providing pharmaceutical related services.
2.2 Any reports requested upon termination will incur an ad hoc fee. BlueCross shall not be
obligated to release such report until the fee has been paid.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 99 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit Q
Administrative Services Agreement Page 72
EXHIBIT Q TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
RESERVED
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 100 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit R
Administrative Services Agreement Page 73
EXHIBIT R TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
RESERVED
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 101 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit S
Administrative Services Agreement Page 74
EXHIBIT S TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
AUDITS and RECORDS
1. Audit of BlueCross.
1.1. Audits Generally . During the term of this Agreement, Employer may audit
BlueCross, at Employer’s own expense, in accordance with the following
requirements:
1.1.1. Employer shall provide a written audit request to BlueCross at least 45 days
in advance of the requested audit date. Such request shall include the
requested audit date, the requested auditor, the manner of compensation
for the auditor, and information about the nature, purpose, scope and
objectives of the audit.
1.1.2. Employer and BlueCross will agree on an independent, third party auditor
to conduct the audit (“Auditor”).
1.1.3. The audit shall be conducted in accordance with the terms of BlueCross’s
standard audit agreement and this Agreement. The audit agreement shall
be finalized and executed by BlueCross, the Auditor, and Employer prior to
the commencement of the audit.
1.1.4. The audit shall be limited in scope to claims paid within the 12 months prior
to the date the Audit Agreement is executed by the final signatory (“ Audit
Time Period”).
1.1.5. Employer agrees that its audit rights are limited to BlueCross and do not
extend to BlueCross’s vendors or subcontractors. Any BlueCross audit
shall be performed based on the information in BlueCross’s records.
1.1.6. With respect to any audit, claims adjustments will be based on actual claims
reviewed and not upon sampling, statistical projections or extrapolations.
1.1.7. The Parties agree that claims adjudicated following BlueCross’s claims
processing guidelines shall be deemed to have been properly adjudicated,
including, but not limited to, the claims processed through the BlueCard
program.
1.1.8. BlueCross shall be required to supply only such information which is in its
possession and which is reasonably necessary for Employer to administer
the Plan or for the auditor to perform its duties provided in the mutually
agreed upon agreement, provided that such disclosure is not prohibited by
any third party contracts to which BlueCross is a signatory or any
requirements of the law. Employer hereby represents that, to the extent any
disclosed information contains personally identifiable or health information
about a Member, the Member has authorized disclosur e to Employer or
Employer otherwise has the legal authority to have access to such
information.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 102 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit S
Administrative Services Agreement Page 75
1.1.9. Employer shall not hire a third party to conduct a contingent fee audit,
where the third party’s compensation, in whole or in part, is based on a
percentage of errors (or savings, or uncovered recoveries, etc.), which may
be found by the third party in its audit. BlueCross may request, and
Employer will provide, the proposal for compensation of any requested
auditor.
1.2. Medical Claims Audits.
1.2.1. While this Agreement is in effect, Employer may perform one medical
claims audit during each calendar year.
1.2.2. After the termination of this Agreement by either Party and any applicable
run-out period, Employer may perform one medical claims audit during the
15 months after the effective date of termination. With respect to medical
claims audits, medical claims include claims for Provider Administered
Specialty Pharmacy Products when BlueCross has agreed to administer
those claims.
1.2.3. The only claims subject to audit are those claims paid during the Audit Time
Period. Any claims paid prior to the Audit Time Period shall not be subject
to audit.
1.2.4. For each Audit Time Period, no more than 250 claims shall be selected for
review.
1.2.5. Claims audits will be conducted using the Benefit Plan approved by and in
the possession of BlueCross and that was in effect at the time the claims
being audited were adjudicated. Submitting the Benefit Plan to BlueCross
later than six (6) months after the start of the applicable Benefit Period will
cause Employer to lose its right to audit that Benefit Period.
1.3. Pharmacy Claims Audits.
1.3.1. While this Agreement is in effect, Employer may perform one pharmacy
claims audit during each calendar year.
1.3.2. After the termination of this Agreement by either Party and any applicable
run-out period, Employer may perform one pharmacy claims audit during
the 15 months after the effective date of termination.
1.3.3. The only claims subject to audit are those claims paid during the Audit Time
Period. Any claims paid prior to the Audit Time Period shall not be subject
to audit.
1.3.4. For each Audit Time Period, no more than 250 claims shall be selected for
review.
1.3.5. Claims audits will be conducted using the Benefit Plan approved by and in
the possession of BlueCross and that was in effect at the time the claims
being audited were adjudicated. Submitting the Benefit Plan to BlueCross
later than six (6) months after the start of the applicable Benefit Period will
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 103 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit S
Administrative Services Agreement Page 76
cause Employer to lose its right to audit that Benefit Period.
1.4. Clinical Process Audits.
1.4.1. In lieu of an audit identified above, Employer may perform one clinical
process audit during each calendar year that this Agreement is in effect.
1.4.2. Employer shall have no right to conduct a clinical process audit upon
termination of this Agreement.
1.4.3. The only processes subject to audit are those processes that were
performed by BlueCross during the Audit Time Period. Any process
performed by BlueCross prior to the Audit Time Period shall not be subject
to audit.
1.4.4. With respect to a clinical process audit, the audit, scope and methodology
will be consistent with generally acceptable auditing standards.
1.4.5. For each Audit Time Period, no more than 25, randomly selected case files
shall be reviewed as part of a clinical process audit.
2. Reports. BlueCross will provide to Employer reports as specified in Exhibit B.
3. Books and Records . BlueCross shall maintain books and records directly related to its
payment of claims on behalf of Employer pursuant to this Agreement, in accordance with
its customary business practices. Upon execution of an applicable agreement relating to
use and conf identiality, BlueCross shall make such books and records available for
inspection by authorized representatives of Employer at BlueCross’s home office, during
normal business hours, upon reasonable advance written request, at Employer’s expense,
during the term of this Agreement and for 6 years from the date of the Final Settlement.
The required agreement shall be determined by BlueCross based on the intended use of
the information.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 104 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit T
Administrative Services Agreement Page 77
EXHIBIT T TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
RESERVED
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 105 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit U
Administrative Services Agreement Page 78
EXHIBIT U TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
RESERVED
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 106 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit V
Administrative Services Agreement Page 79
EXHIBIT V TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
RESERVED
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 107 of 212
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
Exhibit W
Administrative Services Agreement Page 80
EXHIBIT W TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
SHARED SAVINGS
BlueCross will perform recovery services in the identified areas and, as compensation for these
services, BlueCross will retain a percentage of any recovery (“ Shared Savings”) as identified
below. Shared Savings will be taken in accordance with BlueCross’s administrative processes.
Shared Savings will be reconciled via reporting updated on a weekly basis.
1. Legal Recoveries . BlueCross may represent the interest of Employer in any litigation
against a third party where the claims are related to subrogation or overpayments for
pharmaceutical products, medical devices, durable medical equipment/supplies, and/or
other such claims resulting in causes of action described below. This representation grants
BlueCross the ability to identify, pursue, negotiate settlements of, and/or recover direct
legal or equitable claims related to the services performed pursuant to this Agreement.
Employer grants to BlueCross the specific authority and discretion to opt Employer in or
out of any class or direct settlement in which both BlueCross and/or Employer may be
considered class members or settling parties, and the authority to pursue any recoveries
for claims paid as a result of fraud, abuse or other inappropri ate action by a third party.
These claims include, but are not limited to, all legal claims Employer can assert whether
based on common law or statute, such as RICO, antitrust, deceptive trade practices,
consumer fraud, insurance fraud, unjust enrichment, breach of fiduciary duty, breach of
contract, breach of covenant of good faith and fair dealing, torts (including fraud,
negligence and product liability), breach of warranty, medical monitoring, false claims and
kickbacks. If BlueCross obtains a recovery from any of these efforts, BlueCross will
reimburse Employer’s pro rata share of the recovery. This share is calculated from the
Employer’s claims history of Covered Members at the time of such recovery, less the
Employer’s pro rata share of the costs, if any, fees paid to outside counsel and any other
costs incurred in obtaining a recovery. BlueCross will not charge the Employer for any
costs if BlueCross does not obtain a recovery that exceeds those costs. The authority
granted herein survives the termination of this Agreement.
1.1 Subrogation Recoveries.
1.1.1 BlueCross will enforce Employer’s subrogation rights. For all subrogation
recoveries received on or after July 1, 2022, BlueCross will retain a fee of
39% of the gross subrogation recovery. Employer is responsible for
payment of: (a) any outside attorneys’ fees incurred in enforcing
Employer’s subrogation rights; and (b) any other expenses arising in
connection with litigation to enforce its subrogation interest, including, but
not limited to, court costs and discovery expenses.
1.1.2 For any recoveries received before the Process Conclusion Date,
BlueCross will deduct its fee, and any expenses associated with the
litigation. The remaining amount is the net recovery, and the amount that
Employer will receive as a credit.
1.2 Mass Tort Recoveries.
1.2.1 BlueCross will perform mass tort recoveries on behalf of Employer.
BlueCross will retain a fee of 39 % of all mass tort recoveries received on
or after July 1, 2022.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 108 of 212
Exhibit W
Administrative Services Agreement Page 81
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
1.2.2 For any recoveries received before the Process Conclusion Date,
BlueCross will deduct its fee, the attorneys’ fee (if any) and any other
litigation expenses from each recovery amount received. This net recovery
is the amount that Employer will receive as a credit.
1.3 Class Action Recoveries.
1.3.1 BlueCross will perform class action recoveries on behalf of Employer.
BlueCross will retain a fee of 39% of all class action recoveries received on
or after July 1, 2022.
1.3.2 For any recoveries received before the Process Conclusion Date,
BlueCross will deduct its fee, the attorneys’ fee (if any) and any other
litigation expenses from each recovery amount received. This net recovery
is the amount that Employer will receive as a credit.
2. Audit Services. BlueCross will conduct audits in varying manners and forms, including but
not limited to, pre-payment claims audits, post -payment claims audits, eligibility
overpayment audits, and provider audits. BlueCross, in its sole discretion, will determine
when and how to conduct such activities and nothing in this Agreement shall limit
BlueCross’ righ t or authority to conduct such activities. When BlueCross identifies an
overpayment or prevents an overpayment from occurring as a result of these activities,
BlueCross will retain 39% of any such overpayment recoveries or overpayment prevention
savings. Savings are determined at the time of the initial audit finding. BlueCross will credit
Employer for any savings, less the BlueCross retention amount, as appropriate.
3. Enhanced Payment Integrity Services . BlueCross, or its delegate, may conduct pre-
payment and post payment enhanced payment integrity reviews. BlueCross, or its
delegate, will determine whether and in what manner to conduct such activities, and
notwithstanding any provision of this Agreement to the contrary, Employer authorizes
BlueCross to conduct such activities. When the enhanced pre-payment or post payment
integrity review identifies an overpayment or prevents an overpayment from occurring,
BlueCross will retain 39% of any such recoveries or prevention savings. Savings are
determined at the time of the initial audit finding.
4. Coordination of Benefit Services. BlueCross will conduct coordination of benefits activities.
BlueCross, in its sole discretion, will determine when and how to conduct such activities
and nothing in this Agreement shall limit BlueCross’ right or authority to conduct such
activities. When BlueCross identifies an overpayment or prevents an overpayment from
occurring as a result of these activities, BlueCross will retain 39% of any such
overpayment recoveries or overpayment prevention savings. Savings are determined at
the time of the initial finding. BlueCross will credit Employer for any savings, less the
BlueCross retention amount, as appropriate.
5. Provider Administered Specialty Pharmacy Product Rebates . BlueCross may receive
rebates and other consideration related to claims for Provider Administered Specialty
Pharmacy Products (“ Provider Administered Specialty Pharmacy Product Rebates ”).
BlueCross retains 100% of Provider Administered Specialty Product Rebates. Contractual
obligations to BlueCross that require payment of a penalty or other amount to BlueCross
if contractual obligations are not met are specifically excluded from the definition of
Provider Administered Specialty Pharmacy Product Rebates and shall b e retained by
BlueCross.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 109 of 212
Exhibit W
Administrative Services Agreement Page 82
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
6. Pharmacy Rebates.
6.1 For Pharmacy Rebates based on service dates occurring on or after July 1, 2017,
Employer will receive 100% of Pharmacy Rebates (as defined in Pharmacy
Services Exhibit).
7. Out-of-Network Claim Management Program. When permitted by Association rules and
guidelines, BlueCross will calculate a reduction in billed charges for Members’ claims for
Covered Services received from Out -of-Network Providers (as defined in Exhibit C,
Section 5.4). Claims eligible for this s ervice must meet BlueCross’s established criteria.
As consideration for this service, BlueCross shall receive a fee of fifteen percent (15%) of
the reduction of billed charges. This program excludes claims subject to the No Surprises
Act.
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 110 of 212
Exhibit X
Administrative Services Agreement Page 83
111164 – City of Franklin – 7/1/2026 CONFIDENTIAL
EXHIBIT X TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AGREEMENT
RESERVED
Docusign Envelope ID: D2F059D1-959C-84F5-817A-7F03F4186748
Page 111 of 212
City of Franklin Page 1 of 2
City of Franklin
109 3rd Ave S.
Franklin, TN 37064
(615) 791-3217
File #: 26-01026
DATE: 9/10/2026
TO: Budget & Finance Committee
FROM: Lisa Clayton, Director of Parks & Recreation
SUBJECT:
Consideration Of Resolution 2026-74, A Resolution Authorizing The Use Of The Competitive Sealed
Proposals Procurement Method For Choosing The Service Provider For Mowing Services For City
Parks For A Term Of Award
PURPOSE:
The purpose of this memorandum is to provide information to the Franklin Board of Mayor and
Aldermen (BOMA) concerning Res. 2026-74, a resolution authorizing the use of the competitive
sealed proposals procurement method for choosing the service provider for mowing services for city
parks for a term of award.
BACKGROUND/STAFF COMMENTS:
The Parks Department's current contract for mowing services ends December 31, 2026. In order to
select a new contractor for a term of award, the Parks Department wishes to utilize the competitive
proposal procurement method. This will allow for service providers to propose innovative and unique
ways to provide the required mowing services, while implementing cost-saving practices unique to
each provider. The City is authorized to use the competitive sealed proposal procurement method
pursuant to the standards set forth in Municipal Code § 5-504 for determining which service provider
to recommend for award of mowing services for city parks for a term of award because qualifications,
experience, and competence are more important than price in making the purchase, and because
there is more than one solution to this purchasing issue and the competitive sealed proposal
procurement method will assist in choosing the best solution and service provider.
FINANCIAL IMPACT:
The costs are budgeted for within account 110-82654-44700 in the current approved budget.
RECOMMENDATION:
Page 112 of 212
Staff recommends that Res. 2026-74 be recommended for approval by the Board of Mayor and
Aldermen.
Page 113 of 212
1
RESOLUTION 2026-74
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE USE OF THE COMPETITIVE SEALED PROPOSALS
PROCUREMENT METHOD FOR CHOOSING THE SERVICE PROVIDER FOR MOWING SERVICES
FOR CITY PARKS FOR A TERM OF AWARD
WHEREAS, pursuant to Tenn. Code Ann. § 12 -3-1207 the City may use competitive sealed
proposals rather than competitive sealed bids when the City adopts a process for the use of competitive
sealed proposals and determines that the use of competitive sealed bidding is either not practicable or
not advantageous to the City; and
WHEREAS, the City passed Ordinance 2019 -24 on August 13, 2019, authorizing the use of the
competitive sealed proposal procurement method; and
WHEREAS, should the City choose to pursue conducting its own competitive process for
establishing the basis of pricing pursuant to sealed submittals and published legal notice, then City staff
requests authority to use the competitive sealed proposal procurement me thod for determining which
service provider to recommend for award of mowing services for city parks for a term of award; and
WHEREAS, the Board of Mayor and Aldermen find that the use of the competitive sealed proposal
procurement method is advantageous to the City because qualifications, experience, and competence are
more important than price in making the purchase , and because there is more than one solution to this
purchasing issue and the competitive sealed proposal procurement method will assist in choosing the best
solution and service provider.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF MAYOR AND ALDERMEN OF THE CITY OF
FRANKLIN, TENNESSEE, AS FOLLOWS:
Should the City choose to pursue conducting its own competitive process for establishing the basis
of pricing pursuant to sealed submittals and published legal notice, then the City is authorized to use the
competitive sealed proposal procurement method pursuant to the standards set forth in Municipal Code
§ 5-504 for determining which service provider to recommend for award of mowing services for city parks
for a term of award because qualifications, experience, and competence are more important than price
in making the purchase , and because there is more than one solution to this purchasing issue and the
competitive sealed proposal procurement method will assist in choosing the best solution and service
provider.
IT IS SO RESOLVED AND DONE on this ____ day of _______________, 2026.
ATTEST: CITY OF FRANKLIN, TENNESSEE:
By: By:
Eric S. Stuckey Dr. Ken Moore
City Administrator Mayor
Law Dept. Approved 08.17.26
Page 114 of 212
2
Approved as to Form:
By:
Ronda D. Webb
Staff Attorney
Law Dept. Approved 08.17.26
Page 115 of 212
City of Franklin Page 1 of 1
City of Franklin
109 3rd Ave S.
Franklin, TN 37064
(615) 791-3217
File #: 26-01084
DATE: 9/10/2026
TO: Budget & Finance Committee
FROM: Kristine Brock, Asst. City Administrator/CFO
SUBJECT:
Presentation From The City's Advisor For Non-Pension Related Investments
PURPOSE:
The purpose of this memorandum is to provide information to the Franklin Board of Mayor and
Aldermen (BOMA) concerning an update of non-pension related investments.
BACKGROUND/STAFF COMMENTS:
As of June 30, 2026, the City had a market value of non-pension related investments of
$328,191,516, of which $98,784,498 was bond proceeds designated for identified capital
projects. This is an increase from the June 30, 2025, market value of $263,906,120. The primary
change between fiscal year end 2025 and 2026 was the issuance of the $104,305,000 Series 2026
General Obligation Bonds on March 12, 2026.
FINANCIAL IMPACT:
The earned income from non-pension related investments in FY 2026 was $9,074,321, an increase
of $109,938 from FY 2025. The FY 2026 book yield on the portfolio was 4.09% versus 4.29% in FY
2025.
RECOMMENDATION:
For informational purposes.
Page 116 of 212
June 30, 2026
Year End Investment Report City of Franklin
Page 117 of 212
2
Market Overview
Interest Rates & The Yield Curve
• Yields are significantly higher across every tenor
versus June 2019, with the 2-year at 4.18% (up
from 1.76%) and the 5-year at 4.23% (up from
1.77%).
• By June 2026, the yield curve returned to the
normal shape after being invert after COVID
cause long term inversion.
• Oil prices have almost fallen to pre-war levels
yet yields remain elevated on an FOMC
perceived as becoming more hawkish.
3.00%
3.20%
3.40%
3.60%
3.80%
4.00%
4.20%
4.40%
$50
$60
$70
$80
$90
$100
$110
$120
$130
Jun '25 Jul '25 Aug '25 Sep '25 Oct '25 Nov '25 Dec '25 Jan '26 Feb '26 Mar '26 Apr '26 May '26 Jun '26
Oil Fell While Yields Remain Elevated
Brent Crude (Left Axis) 2yr Treasury Yield (Right Axis)
2.09%
1.76% 1.77%
2.01%
3.82%
4.18% 4.23%
4.47%
1.50%
1.75%
2.00%
2.25%
2.50%
2.75%
3.00%
3.25%
3.50%
3.75%
4.00%
4.25%
4.50%
4.75%
5.00%
3 Month Bill 2 Year Note 5 Year Note 10 Year Note
Source: Bloomberg
Yield Curve Shift from 2019 to 2026
Jun-19 Jun-26
Page 118 of 212
3
June 30, 2026
3
Market Overview
GDP and Inflation
• Price growth accelerated over Q2 with headline CPI
decreased to 3.37% in May while core CPI lowered to 2.48%.
• Energy prices have been a main contributor however -
service prices have accelerated for three consecutive
months, and inflation remains well above the Fed’s 2%
target.
• The initial estimate of Q2 GDP growth came in at 1.5% and
was supported by a nice rebound in consumption.
• Nonresidential fixed investment added another solid quarter
and broadened out relative to Q1.
• Economic forecasts call for GDP growth to continue running
at a trend level, but forecasters do not expect inflation to fall
to the Fed’s target until 2028.
2.90% 2.50%
4.70%
3.40%
0.80%
3.60% 3.30%
1.90%
-0.60%
3.8% 4.4%
0.5%
2.1% 1.5%
-6.0%
-5.0%
-4.0%
-3.0%
-2.0%
-1.0%
0.0%
1.0%
2.0%
3.0%
4.0%
5.0%
6.0%
7.0%
8.0%
Q1 2023 Q2 2023 Q3 2023 Q4 2023 Q1 2024 Q2 2024 Q3 2024 Q4 2024 Q1 2025 Q2 2025 Q3 2025 Q4 2025 Q1 2026 Q2 2026
GDP Growth and Composition
Personal Consumption Expenditures Fixed investment
Government consumption expenditures and gross investment Change in Private Inventories
Net Exports Gross Domestic Product
Source: U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis
0.0%
2.0%
4.0%
6.0%
8.0%
10.0%
Inflation YOY Over Five Years
Fed Target CPI YoY Core CPI YoY
Page 119 of 212
Compliance Report
Compliance Report
City of Franklin | Total Aggregate Portfolio June 30, 2026
Category
Policy Diversification Constraint Policy Limit Actual Value* Status
US Treasury Obligations Maximum % of Holdings 100.000 73.208 Compliant
US Agency Callable Securities Maximum % of Total Portfolio 25.000 1.552 Compliant
US Agency FFCB Issuer Concentration 35.000 4.294 Compliant
US Agency FHLB Issuer Concentration 35.000 0.000 Compliant
US Agency FHLMC Issuer Concentration 35.000 0.000 Compliant
US Agency FNMA Issuer Concentration 35.000 0.000 Compliant
US Agency Obligations - All Other Issuers Combined 35.000 0.000 Compliant
US Agency Obligations Issuer Concentration 35.000 4.294 Compliant
US Agency Obligations Maximum % of Holdings 100.000 4.294 Compliant
Municipal Issue Directly Internally or Interfund Loans Maximum % of Holdings 10.000 0.000 Compliant
Certificates of Deposits and Federally Insured Obligations Issuer Concentration 10.000 0.000 Compliant
Certificates of Deposits and Federally Insured Obligations % of Holdings 25.000 0.000 Compliant
Money Market Govt Only 0.000 0.000 Compliant
Money Market Maximum % of Holdings 10.000 2.287 Compliant
LGIP Maximum % of Holdings 30.000 5.065 Compliant
Bank Time Deposits/Savings Accounts Maximum % of Holdings 50.000 15.146 Compliant
RepurchaseAgreements Maximum % of Holdings 10.000 0.000 Compliant
1) Actual values are based on market value.
2) The compliance report allows for resolutions to be documented if an actual value exceeds a limit. The specific resolution can be found on the client portal site.
GPA Investment Report 4
Policy Maturity Structure Constraint Policy Limit Actual % Status
Maturity Constraints Under 30 days Minimum % of Total Portfolio 10.000 24.233 Compliant
Maturity Constraints Under 2 years Minimum % of Total Portfolio 50.000 84.846 Compliant
Maturity Constraints Under 4 years Minimum % of Total Portfolio 100.000 100.000 Compliant
Policy Maturity Constraint Policy Limit Actual Term Status
US Treasury Maximum Maturity At Time of Purchase (years) 4.000 3.138 Compliant
US Agency Maximum Maturity At Time of Purchase (years) 4.000 2.912 Compliant
Certificates of Deposit Maximum Maturity At Time of Purchase (years) 4.000 0.000 Compliant
Weighted Average Maturity (years) 2.000 0.918 Compliant
Policy Credit Constraint Status
US Agency Obligations Minimum Ratings AA-/Aa3/AA- (Rated by 2 NRSRO) Compliant
Money Market Ratings Minimum AAA/Aaa/AAA (Rated by 1 NRSRO) Compliant
Page 120 of 212
City of Franklin | Total Portfolio
June 30, 2026
GPA Investment Report 5
Strategic Quarterly Update
Metric Previous Current
Book Yield 06/30/2025 06/30/2026
Ending Book Yield
BP2026 Investments --- 3.67%
BP2026 Liquidity --- 3.67%
BP2025 Investments 4.13% 3.27%
BP2025 Liquidity 4.66% 3.67%
Investment Core 4.23% 4.14%
Liquidity 4.57% 3.86%
Total Book Yield 4.27% 3.95%
Values 06/30/2025 06/30/2026
Market Value + Accrued
BP2026 Investments --- 66,155,682
BP2026 Liquidity --- 19,018,952
BP2025 Investments 28,135,584 5,892,599
BP2025 Liquidity 3,978,893 7,717,265
Investment Core 195,240,057 182,655,644
Liquidity 36,551,586 46,751,375
Total MV + Accrued 263,906,120 328,191,516
Net Unrealized Gain/Loss
Total Net Unrealized Gain/Loss 1,065,357 -600,180
Metric Previous Current
Strategy 06/30/2025 06/30/2026
Effective Duration
Investment Core 1.34 1.28
Benchmark Duration 1.43 1.41
Total Effective Duration 1.13 1.02
Total Return (Net of Fees %)*
Investment Core 5.40 3.32
Benchmark Return 5.41 3.24
Total Portfolio Performance 5.28 3.44
*Changes in Market Value include net unrealized and
realized gains/losses.
Maturity Total Portfolio
Average Maturity Total Holdings 1.20 1.08
Page 121 of 212
Asset Allocation Change
Asset Allocation Change
City of Franklin | General Fund Portfolio June 30, 2026
06/30/2025 06/30/2026 Change
Security Type Market Value +
Accrued % of Portfolio Market Value +
Accrued % of Portfolio Market Value +
Accrued % of Portfolio
US Treasury 153,078,327 66.04% 168,164,461 73.30% 15,086,134 7.26%
US Agency 41,385,818 17.85% 13,730,580 5.99% (27,655,238) (11.87%)
Money Market Fund 774,384 0.33% 759,296 0.33% (15,089) (0.00%)
Bank Deposit 28,398,773 12.25% 30,678,560 13.37% 2,279,786 1.12%
Pooled Funds 8,154,340 3.52% 16,074,121 7.01% 7,919,782 3.49%
Total 231,791,643 100.00% 229,407,018 100.00% (2,384,624)
If negative cash balance is showing, it is due to a pending trade payable at the end of period.
GPA Investment Report 6
Page 122 of 212
Historical Balances
Historical Balances
City of Franklin | General Fund Portfolio June 30, 2026
Market Value
Market Value and Return
Period Market Value + Accrued Earned Income Book Yield Effective Duration Maturity in Years
FY 2020 153,250,485 3,150,219 1.88 0.87 0.96
FY 2021 180,892,683 2,129,123 0.87 0.93 0.94
FY 2022 213,622,845 1,554,714 1.22 1.24 1.28
FY 2023 226,186,801 4,482,602 2.83 1.18 1.25
FY 2024 233,562,589 7,604,601 3.74 1.17 1.24
FY 2025 231,791,643 8,964,383 4.29 1.13 1.20
FY 2026 229,407,018 9,074,321 4.09 1.02 1.08
GPA Investment Report 7
$153.3M
$180.9M
$213.6M $226.2M $233.6M $231.8M $229.4M
$0.0M
$50.0M
$100.0M
$150.0M
$200.0M
$250.0M
FY 2020 FY 2021 FY 2022 FY 2023 FY 2024 FY 2025 FY 2026
Page 123 of 212
Summary Overview
Summary Overview
City of Franklin | General Fund Portfolio June 30, 2026
Portfolio Characteristics Allocation by Asset Class
Metric Value
Cash and Cash Equivalents 47,511,977
Investments 181,895,042
Book Yield 4.09%
Market Yield 4.02%
Effective Duration 1.02
Years to Maturity 1.08
Avg Credit Rating AA+
Strategic Structure
Account Par Amount Book Value Market Value
Net
Unrealized
Gain (Loss)
Book
Yield Maturity* Effective
Duration
Benchmark
Duration Benchmark
Investment
Core 181,410,602 181,360,683 180,910,797 (449,886) 4.14% 1.35 1.28 1.41 ICE BofA 0-3 Year US
Treasury Index
Liquidity 46,751,375 46,751,375 46,751,375 0 3.86% 0.01 0.01 0.09 ICE BofA US 1-Month
Treasury Bill Index
Total 228,161,977 228,112,058 227,662,172 (449,886) 4.09% 1.08 1.02 1.14
GPA Investment Report 8
Page 124 of 212
Portfolio Activity
Portfolio Activity
City of Franklin | General Fund Portfolio June 30, 2026
Accrual Activity Summary
Month to Date Fiscal Year to
Date
(07/01/2025)
Beginning Book Value 228,804,772.93 228,916,721.99
Maturities/Calls (5,000,000.00) (58,000,000.00)
Purchases 4,907,150.00 54,376,652.39
Sales 0.00 (7,507,725.00)
Change in Cash, Payables, Receivables (604,790.00) 10,184,479.23
Amortization/Accretion 4,924.87 128,445.68
Realized Gain (Loss) 0.00 13,483.51
Ending Book Value 228,112,057.81 228,112,057.81
Fair Market Activity Summary
Month to Date Fiscal Year to
Date
(07/01/2025)
Beginning Market Value 228,733,691.11 229,964,565.88
Maturities/Calls (5,000,000.00) (58,000,000.00)
Purchases 4,907,150.00 54,376,652.39
Sales 0.00 (7,507,725.00)
Change in Cash, Payables, Receivables (604,790.00) 10,184,479.23
Amortization/Accretion 4,924.87 128,445.68
Change in Net Unrealized Gain (Loss) (378,804.37) (1,497,730.08)
Net Realized Gain (Loss) 0.00 13,483.51
Ending Market Value 227,662,171.61 227,662,171.61
Maturities/Calls Market Value
Month to Date (5,000,000.00)
Fiscal Year to Date (58,000,000.00)
Purchases Market Value
Month to Date 4,907,150.00
Fiscal Year to Date 54,376,652.39
Sales Market Value
Month to Date 0.00
Fiscal Year to Date (7,507,725.00)
GPA Investment Report 9
Page 125 of 212
Return Management-Income Detail
Return Management-Income Detail
City of Franklin | General Fund Portfolio June 30, 2026
Accrued Book Return Return Comparisons
Periodic for performanceless than one year.Annualized for performance greater than one year.
Fiscal Year Ending
06/30/2025
Fiscal Year Ending
06/30/2026
Amortization/Accretion 198,935.07 128,445.68
Interest Earned 8,765,448.34 8,932,391.30
Realized Gain (Loss) 0.00 13,483.51
Book Income 8,964,383.42 9,074,320.50
Average Portfolio Balance 220,887,554.78 218,867,017.66
Book Return for Period 4.07% 4.21%
Fair Market Return Interest Income
Fiscal Year Ending
06/30/2025
Fiscal Year Ending
06/30/2026
Fair Value Change 2,559,260.71 (1,626,175.77)
Amortization/Accretion 198,935.07 128,445.68
Interest Earned 8,765,448.34 8,932,391.30
Fair Market Earned Income 11,523,644.12 7,434,661.22
Average Portfolio Balance 222,908,091.91 218,867,017.66
Fair Market Return for Period 5.32% 3.47%
Fiscal Year Ending
06/30/2025
Fiscal Year Ending
06/30/2026
BeginningAccrued Interest 1,455,318.33 1,827,076.71
Coupon Income 8,866,914.74 9,448,764.89
PurchasedAccrued Interest 473,224.78 471,955.95
Sold Accrued Interest 0.00 (37,812.50)
Ending Accrued Interest 1,827,076.71 1,744,846.57
Interest Earned 8,765,448.34 8,932,391.30
GPA Investment Report 10
Page 126 of 212
Return Management-Performance
Return Management-Performance
City of Franklin | Investment Core June 30, 2026
Performance Returns Net of Fees
Periodic for performance less than one year.Annualized for performance greater than one year.
Historical Returns
Period Month to Date Quarter to Date Fiscal Year to
Date
(07/01/2025)
Trailing Year Trailing 3 Years Trailing 5 Years Since Inception
(01/01/2014)
Return (Net of Fees) 0.124% 0.558% 3.319% 3.319% 4.524% 2.440% 1.803%
Return (Gross of Fees) 0.127% 0.566% 3.350% 3.350% 4.555% 2.469% 1.860%
ICE BofA 0-3 Year US
Treasury Index
0.115% 0.529% 3.244% 3.244% 4.478% 2.404% 1.727%
GPA Investment Report 11
Page 127 of 212
Risk Management - Maturity/Duration
Risk Management - Maturity/Duration
City of Franklin | General Fund Portfolio June 30, 2026
Effective Duration
1.02 Yrs
Years to Maturity
1.08 Yrs
Days to Maturity
394
Distribution by Effective Duration
GPA Investment Report 12
Page 128 of 212
Appendix
Page 129 of 212
Summary Overview
Summary Overview
City of Franklin | BP2026 Portfolio June 30, 2026
Portfolio Characteristics Allocation by Asset Class
Metric Value
Cash and Cash Equivalents 19,621,395.29
Investments (Market Value + Accrued) 65,553,238.89
Book Yield 3.67%
Market Yield 3.89%
Effective Duration 0.67
Years to Maturity 0.54
Avg Credit Rating AA+
Strategic Structure
Account Par Amount Book Value Market Value Net Unrealized
Gain (Loss)
Yield at Cost Effective
Duration
Benchmark
Duration
Benchmark
BP2026 Investments 65,602,442.86 65,836,986.50 65,686,692.86 (150,293.64) 3.67% 0.67 0.50
ICE BofA 0-1 Year US
Treasury Notes & Bonds
BP2026 Liquidity 19,018,952.43 19,018,952.43 19,018,952.43 0.00 3.67% 0.09 ICE BofA US 1-Month
Treasury Bill Index
Total 84,621,395.29 84,855,938.93 84,705,645.29 (150,293.64) 3.67% 0.67
GPA Investment Report 14
Page 130 of 212
Return Management-Income Detail
Return Management-Income Detail
City of Franklin | BP2026 Portfolio June 30, 2026
Accrued Book Return Return Comparisons
Periodic for performance less than one year.Annualized for performance greater than one year.
Since Inception
Amortization/Accretion (7,582.72)
Interest Earned 1,019,357.82
Realized Gain (Loss) 0.00
Book Income 1,011,775.09
Average Portfolio Balance 89,036,793.93
Book Return for Period 1.13
Fair Market Return Interest Income
Since Inception
Fair Value Change (142,710.91)
Amortization/Accretion (7,582.72)
Interest Earned 1,019,357.82
Fair Market Earned Income 869,064.18
Average Portfolio Balance 89,036,793.93
Fair Market Return for Period 0.96
Since Inception
BeginningAccrued Interest 0.00
Coupon Income 912,724.57
PurchasedAccrued Interest 362,355.64
Sold Accrued Interest 0.00
Ending Accrued Interest 468,988.89
Interest Earned 1,019,357.82
Notation: Book and Fair Market Returns are not annualized
GPA Investment Report 15
Page 131 of 212
Summary Overview
Summary Overview
City of Franklin | BP2025 Portfolio June 30, 2026
Portfolio Characteristics Allocation by Asset Class
Metric Value
Cash and Cash Equivalents 13,609,863.90
Book Yield 3.50%
Market Yield 3.50%
Effective Duration 0.00
Years to Maturity 0.00
Avg Credit Rating AAA
Strategic Structure
Account Par Amount Book Value Market Value Net Unrealized
Gain (Loss)
Yield at
Cost
Effective
Duration
Benchmark
Duration
Benchmark
BP2025 Investments 5,892,599.22 5,892,599.22 5,892,599.22 0.00 3.27% 0.00 0.50 ICE BofA 0-1 Year US
Treasury Notes & Bonds
BP2025 Liquidity 7,717,264.68 7,717,264.68 7,717,264.68 0.00 3.67% 0.09 ICE BofA US 1-Month
Treasury Bill Index
Total 13,609,863.90 13,609,863.90 13,609,863.90 0.00 3.50% 0.00
GPA Investment Report 16
Page 132 of 212
Return Management-Income Detail
Return Management-Income Detail
City of Franklin | BP2025 Portfolio June 30, 2026
Accrued Book Return Return Comparisons
Periodic for performance less than one year.Annualized for performance greater than one year.
Fiscal Year to Date
(07/01/2025)
Amortization/Accretion 913.50
Interest Earned 691,405.40
Realized Gain (Loss) 16,028.68
Book Income 708,347.58
Average Portfolio Balance 16,663,247.12
Book Return for Period 4.35%
Fair Market Return Interest Income
Fiscal Year to Date
(07/01/2025)
Fair Value Change (18,426.78)
Amortization/Accretion 913.50
Interest Earned 691,405.40
Fair Market Earned Income 673,892.12
Average Portfolio Balance 16,663,247.12
Fair Market Return for Period 4.20%
Fiscal Year to Date
(07/01/2025)
BeginningAccrued Interest 139,525.14
Coupon Income 672,210.25
PurchasedAccrued Interest 0.00
Sold Accrued Interest (158,720.29)
Ending Accrued Interest 0.00
Interest Earned 691,405.40
Notation: Book and Fair Market Returns are not annualized
GPA Investment Report 17
Page 133 of 212
Portfolio Holding & Transactions
Page 134 of 212
Holdings
Holdings
City of Franklin | General Fund Portfolio June 30, 2026
Account Par Value Detailed Description Book
Yield
Net Unrealized
Gain/Loss
Effective
Duration
S&P
Rating
Fitch
Rating
Moody's
Rating
Cash
Investment Core 1,306 US Dollar 0 AAA AAA Aaa
Cash Total 1,306 0 AAA AAA Aaa
Fixed Income
Investment Core 5,500,000 US TREASURY 4.500 07/15/26 4.73% 2,045 0.04 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 10,500,000 US TREASURY 4.375 08/15/26 4.52% 7,210 0.13 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 5,000,000 US TREASURY 4.625 09/15/26 4.78% 10,083 0.21 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 6,000,000 US TREASURY 4.625 10/15/26 4.64% 14,190 0.29 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 8,400,000 US TREASURY 4.625 11/15/26 4.35% 13,460 0.37 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 10,000,000 US TREASURY 4.375 12/15/26 4.12% 11,932 0.45 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 7,000,000 US TREASURY 4.125 02/15/27 4.36% 13,860 0.6 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 6,700,000 US TREASURY 4.500 04/15/27 4.71% 34,442 0.77 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 9,300,000 US TREASURY 4.500 05/15/27 4.49% 30,670 0.85 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 10,500,000 US TREASURY 4.625 06/15/27 4.59% 47,493 0.93 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 11,750,000 US TREASURY 3.750 08/15/27 4.16% 248 1.08 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 10,500,000 US TREASURY 4.125 10/31/27 3.86% (40,386) 1.28 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 8,000,000 US TREASURY 3.500 01/31/28 3.85% (40,968) 1.5 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 11,250,000 US TREASURY 3.625 03/31/28 3.93% (47,052) 1.66 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 12,000,000 US TREASURY 3.500 04/30/28 3.93% (52,794) 1.75 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 7,500,000 US TREASURY 4.625 09/30/28 3.71% (72,491) 2.1 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 3,500,000 US TREASURY 3.125 11/15/28 3.53% (50,037) 2.25 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 5,000,000 US TREASURY 3.500 11/15/28 3.48% (76,914) 2.24 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 5,000,000 US TREASURY 4.000 01/31/29 3.62% (66,918) 2.39 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 7,500,000 US TREASURY 4.250 02/28/29 3.72% (83,190) 2.47 AA+ AA+ Aa1
GPA Investment Report 19
Page 135 of 212
Holdings
Holdings
City of Franklin | General Fund Portfolio June 30, 2026
Account Par Value Detailed Description Book
Yield
Net Unrealized
Gain/Loss
Effective
Duration
S&P
Rating
Fitch
Rating
Moody's
Rating
Investment Core 5,000,000 FED FARM CR BNKS 3.520 03/06/29
'28 4.24% 932 2.36 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 8,750,000 FED FARM CR BNKS 3.875 03/27/29 3.83% (84,222) 2.55 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Investment Core 6,000,000 US TREASURY 3.875 05/15/29 4.03% (21,480) 2.68 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Fixed Income Total 180,650,000 4.15% (449,886) 1.28 AA+ AA+ Aa1
Money Market Funds
Liquidity 16,074,121 TennesseeLocal Government
Investment Pool 3.65% 0 0.01 NA NA NA
Liquidity 30,677,253 PINNACLE BANK DEPOSIT 3.97% 0 0.01 NA NA NA
Investment Core 759,296 FIRST AMER:GVT OBLG;Y 3.27% 0 0 AAAm AAA Aaa
Money Market Funds
Total 47,510,670 3.85% 0 0.01 AAA AAA Aaa
Total 228,161,977 4.09% (449,886) 1.02 AA+ AA+ Aa1
GPA Investment Report 20
Page 136 of 212
Transactions
Transactions
City of Franklin | General Fund Portfolio June 30, 2026
Identifier Detailed Description Trade Date Settle Date Total Amount Units Principal Amount Accrued
Interest
Buy
31846V203 FIRST AMER:GVT
OBLG;Y (44,903,936) 44,903,936 44,903,936 0
PIN_DEP (23,916,955) 23,916,955 23,916,955 0
TN_LGIP (15,757,602) 15,757,602 15,757,602 0
91282CHA2 US TREASURY 3.500
04/30/28 07/29/2025 07/31/2025 (5,997,656) 6,000,000 5,945,156 52,500
9128285M8 US TREASURY 3.125
11/15/28 10/15/2025 10/16/2025 (3,504,619) 3,500,000 3,458,848 45,771
91282CJW2 US TREASURY 4.000
01/31/29 12/10/2025 12/12/2025 (5,127,904) 5,000,000 5,055,078 72,826
91282CPK1 US TREASURY 3.500
11/15/28 02/25/2026 03/02/2026 (5,053,680) 5,000,000 5,001,953 51,727
91282CJA0 US TREASURY 4.625
09/30/28 03/12/2026 03/16/2026 (7,823,206) 7,500,000 7,664,063 159,143
91282CKD2 US TREASURY 4.250
02/28/29 03/12/2026 03/16/2026 (7,623,429) 7,500,000 7,609,570 13,859
3133EWKC3 FED FARM CR BNKS
3.875 03/27/29 04/24/2026 04/28/2026 (8,790,047) 8,750,000 8,760,850 29,197
91282CQR5 US TREASURY 3.875
05/15/29 05/12/2026 05/15/2026 (5,973,984) 6,000,000 5,973,984 0
3133EWFV7 FED FARM CR BNKS
3.520 03/06/29 '28 06/09/2026 06/12/2026 (4,954,083) 5,000,000 4,907,150 46,933
Total (139,427,102) 138,828,493 138,955,146 471,956
Maturity
912828Y79 US TREASURY 2.875
07/31/25 MATD 07/31/2025 07/31/2025 5,000,000 (5,000,000) (5,000,000) 0
91282CFE6 US TREASURY 3.125
08/15/25 MATD 08/15/2025 08/15/2025 5,000,000 (5,000,000) (5,000,000) 0
GPA Investment Report 21
Page 137 of 212
Transactions
Transactions
City of Franklin | General Fund Portfolio June 30, 2026
Identifier Detailed Description Trade Date Settle Date Total Amount Units Principal Amount Accrued
Interest
91282CJB8 US TREASURY 5.000
09/30/25 MATD 09/30/2025 09/30/2025 5,000,000 (5,000,000) (5,000,000) 0
3133ENP95 FED FARM CR BNKS
4.250 09/30/25 MATD 09/30/2025 09/30/2025 2,500,000 (2,500,000) (2,500,000) 0
91282CFP1 US TREASURY 4.250
10/15/25 MATD 10/15/2025 10/15/2025 3,500,000 (3,500,000) (3,500,000) 0
3130ATUC9 FHLBANKS 4.500
12/12/25 MATD 12/12/2025 12/12/2025 7,500,000 (7,500,000) (7,500,000) 0
3133EPBJ3 FED FARM CR BNKS
4.375 02/23/26 MATD 02/23/2026 02/23/2026 5,500,000 (5,500,000) (5,500,000) 0
3133EPCF0 FED FARM CR BNKS
4.500 03/02/26 MATD 03/02/2026 03/02/2026 5,000,000 (5,000,000) (5,000,000) 0
3133EPHH1 FED FARM CR BNKS
4.000 04/28/26 MATD 04/28/2026 04/28/2026 8,000,000 (8,000,000) (8,000,000) 0
91282CHB0 US TREASURY 3.625
05/15/26 MATD 05/15/2026 05/15/2026 6,000,000 (6,000,000) (6,000,000) 0
3130AWGR5 FHLBANKS 4.375
06/12/26 MATD 06/12/2026 06/12/2026 5,000,000 (5,000,000) (5,000,000) 0
Total 58,000,000 (58,000,000) (58,000,000) 0
Sell
1ST_DEP 4,859 (4,859) (4,859) 0
PIN_DEP 21,632,089 (21,632,089) (21,632,089) 0
31846V203 FIRST AMER:GVT
OBLG;Y 44,919,025 (44,919,025) (44,919,025) 0
TN_LGIP 7,837,820 (7,837,820) (7,837,820) 0
3130AUU36 FHLBANKS 4.125
03/13/26 10/24/2025 10/27/2025 7,545,538 (7,500,000) (7,507,725) (37,813)
Total 81,939,331 (81,893,793) (81,901,518) (37,813)
GPA Investment Report 22
Page 138 of 212
COPYRIGHT © 2019 by Government Portfolio Advisors, LLC. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced in
any form or by any means—graphic, electronic, or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, taping, and information storage
and retrieval systems—without the express written permission of Government Portfolio Advisors. Contents are based on information
from sources believed to be reliable, but accuracy and completeness cannot be guaranteed. Nothing herein should be construed
as any past, current or future recommendation to buy or sell any security or an offer to sell, or a solicitation of an offer to buy any
security. This material does not purport to contain all of the information that a prospective investor may wish to consider and is not
to be relied upon as such or used in substitution for the exercise of independent judgment.
Government Portfolio Advisors
503-248-9973
www.gpafixedincome.com
Page 139 of 212
City of Franklin Page 1 of 3
City of Franklin
109 3rd Ave S.
Franklin, TN 37064
(615) 791-3217
File #: 26-01129
DATE: 9/10/2026
TO: Budget & Finance Committee
FROM: Eric Stuckey, City Administrator
Michael Walters Young, Chief Budget & Performance Officer
SUBJECT:
Consideration Of DRAFT Ordinance 2026-26, An Ordinance To Amend The Budget Of The City Of
Franklin For Fiscal Year 2026-2027
PURPOSE:
The purpose of this memorandum is to provide information to the Franklin Board of Mayor and
Aldermen (BOMA) concerning Consideration Of DRAFT Ordinance 2026-26, An Ordinance To
Amend The Budget Of The City Of Franklin For Fiscal Year 2026-2027
BACKGROUND/STAFF COMMENTS:
Purpose
The purpose of this item is to amend the Fiscal Year 2027 Budget to comply with State budgeting
guidance regarding:
1. Ensuring authorizations in place to balance each fund’s budget on a cash basis on June 30,
2027.
Background
The State Comptroller has provided guidance that budget amendments are to be on the cash basis
and must occur prior to fiscal year end (June 30) to ensure no fund has a deficit fund balance or
deficit cash balance at year end.
In order to stay ahead of this responsibility, staff is proposing three budget amendments. They are
split across various funds, but include:
1) Distribution of Annual Wage Increases
2) Carry-over/Minor Expense Items
3) New Purchases
By Fund the impacts of these amendments are:
Page 140 of 212
A. General Fund:
i. Revenues: Increase of $101,046. This increase is attributable to one item:
1. Use of Fund Balance: Increase of $101,046. This increase will be used several “carry-over”
items in the operations budgets of certain general fund departments. These items include funding for
the search for a new HR Director and a replacement leaf vacuum budgeted in FY 2026 but not
received until FY 2027.
ii. Expenses: Increase of $101,046. This increase is attributable to two amendments as follows:
1. Distribution of Annual Wage Increases/Wage Adjustments: Redistribution of $3,002,921 to all
General Fund departments to fund the annual Cost of Living (COLA) and merit-based pay
adjustments effective July 1, 2026. As a reminder, the FY 2027 Annual Operating and Capital Budget
included a 2.5% COLA for all employees and between a 0.5% to 2.5% merit adjustment for City
employee’s dependent upon their annual evaluation scores.
In addition, of that total amount of $3,002,921, $193,296 is attributable to funding increases in
starting pay for personnel in the Franklin Police Department as discussed at the Board of Mayor and
Alderman meeting on August 11, 2026.
2. Carry-over/Minor Expense Items: $94,296 in multiple departments. This accounts for several
increases/decreases, but the major categories are: $79,296 for a replacement leaf vacuum, $25,000
for increase in cost of a billing software and $21,750 for the continued recruitment of a new Human
Resources Director, and smaller misc. expense appropriations.
B. Sanitation & Environmental Services Fund:
i. Revenues: Increase of $49,500 from use of fund balance.
ii. Expenses: Increase of $367,307. This increase is attributable to two amendments as follows:
1. Distribution of Annual Wage Increases: Redistribution of $217,807 between the three divisions.
2. Carry-over/Minor Expense Items: Increase of $129,500 for a commercial fleet vehicle budgeted
in FY 2026 not received until FY 2027 and the reallocation of $80,000 of e-commerce fees from
Water Management to Sanitation.
C. City Facilities Tax Fund:
i. Expenses:
2. Carry-over/Minor Expense Items: Increase of $659,350 for three Police Cruisers and a
materials handler for the Sanitation and Environmental Services Fund originally budgeted in FY 2026
and not received until FY 2027.
D. Stormwater Fund:
i. Expenses: Increase of $111,669. This increase is attributable to two amendments as follows:
1. Distribution of Annual Wage Increases: Redistribution of $91,669 between the two divisions.
2. Carry-over/Minor Expense Items: Increase of $20,000 for the reallocation of $20,000 of e-
commerce fees from Water Management to Stormwater.
E. Hotel Motel Fund:
i. Revenues: Increase of $231,988 from American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) Grant funds.
ii. Expenses: Increase of $231,988 attributable to one amendment:
2. Carry-over/Minor Expense Items: Increase of $231,988 for the reappropriation of remaining ARPA
funds for Conference Center renovations.
F. Water Management Fund:
i. Expenses: The expense changes are divided between three amendments as follows:
1. Distribution of Annual Wage Increases: Increase of $369,640 between
the six operational divisions of the Water Management fund.
2. Carry-over/Minor Expense Items: Increase of $2,812,834 for three main sets of expenses:
Page 141 of 212
$1,686,049 for Water Management costs related to ongoing approved CIP projects $806,785
attributable to vehicles and equipment budgeted and ordered in FY 2026 but not received until FY
2027 and $320,000 due to cost increases for necessary chemicals for plant operations.
3. New Projects: Increase of $1,251,794 for work on HOBAS pipe repairs ($325,794 for completion
of Ewingville HOBAS repairs and $926,000 for engineering services with Alliance for review,
assessment and design recommendations for replacement of remaining HOBAS pipe throughout the
system.)
This is the first budget amendment during this Fiscal Year to the budget. We envision at least two
more during the Fiscal Year.
FINANCIAL IMPACT:
The amendments, as proposed, would result in:
1. General Fund: No Change.
2. Sanitation & Environmental Services Fund: Decrease of Fund Balance of $317,807.
3. City Facilities Tax Fund: Decrease of Fund Balance of $659,350.
4. Stormwater Fund: Decrease of Fund Balance of $20,000.
5. Hotel/Motel Fund: No Change.
6. Water & Wastewater Funds: Decrease of Fund Balance of $4,071,373.
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends that DRAFT Ordinance 2026-26 be recommended for approval by the Board of
Mayor and Aldermen.
Page 142 of 212
Ordinance 2026-26
Amending the FY 2027 Budget
September 10, 2026
Budget & Finance Committee
City of Franklin, Tennessee
FY 2027 Operating Budget
Page 143 of 212
Ordinance 2026-26
Amendments
1) Distribution of Annual Wage Increases
2) Carry-over/Minor Expense Items
3) New Purchases
City of Franklin, Tennessee
FY 2027 Operating Budget
Presentation to Budget & Finance Committee September 10, 2026
Slide 2
Page 144 of 212
Ordinance 2026-26
Amendments By Fund
- General Fund:
Expenses: Net change of zero dollars. The change in total
budgeted activity, however, is an increase of $101,046. That
change is attributable to the first three amendments as follows:
1. Distribution of Annual Wage Increases: Redistribution of
$3,002,921 to all General Fund departments to fund the annual
Cost of Living (COLA) and merit-based pay adjustments effective
July 1, 2026. As a reminder, the FY 2027 Annual Operating and
Capital Budget included:
- 2.5% COLA for all employees
- 0.5% to 2.5% merit adjustment
City of Franklin, Tennessee
FY 2027 Operating Budget
Presentation to Budget & Finance Committee September 10, 2026
Slide 3
Page 145 of 212
Ordinance 2026-26
Amendments By Fund
- General Fund:
2. Carry-over/Minor Expense Items: Increase of $101,046 in
multiple departments. This accounts for several increases
/decreases, but the major categories are:
- $79,296 for a replacement leaf vacuum (funded by Use of
Fund Balance)
- $25,000 for increase in cost of a billing software (offset
by expense decreases in General Expenses)
- $21,750 for the continued recruitment of a new Human
Resources Director (funded by Use of Fund Balance)
City of Franklin, Tennessee
FY 2027 Operating Budget
Presentation to Budget & Finance Committee September 10, 2026
Slide 4
Page 146 of 212
Ordinance 2026-26
Amendments By Fund
- Sanitation & Environmental Services Fund:
Revenues: Increase of $49,500 from use of fund balance
Expenses: The expense changes but are divided between two
amendments as follows:
1. Distribution of Annual Wage Increases: Redistribution of
$217,807 between the three divisions
2. Carry-over/ Minor Expense Items: Increase of $129,500 for
a commercial fleet vehicle budgeted in FY 2026 not received until
FY 2027 and the reallocation of $80,000 of e-commerce fees from
Water Management to Sanitation.
City of Franklin, Tennessee
FY 2027 Operating Budget
Presentation to Budget & Finance Committee September 10, 2026
Slide 5
Page 147 of 212
Ordinance 2026-26
Amendments By Fund
- City Facilities Tax Fund:
Expenses:
2. Carry-over/Minor Expense Items: Increase of
$659,350 for three Police Cruisers and a materials handler
for the Sanitation and Environmental Services Fund
originally budgeted in FY 2026 and not received until FY
2027.
City of Franklin, Tennessee
FY 2027 Operating Budget
Presentation to Budget & Finance Committee September 10, 2026
Slide 6
Page 148 of 212
Ordinance 2026-26
Amendments By Fund
- Stormwater Fund
Expenses:
Increase of $111,669.
1. Distribution of Annual Wage Increases: Redistribution of
$91,669 between the two divisions.
2. Carry-over/Minor Expense Items: Increase of $20,000
for the reallocation of $20,000 of e-commerce fees from
Water Management to Stormwater.
City of Franklin, Tennessee
FY 2027 Operating Budget
Presentation to Budget & Finance Committee September 10, 2026
Slide 7
Page 149 of 212
Ordinance 2026-26
Amendments By Fund
- Hotel/Motel Fund
Net change of zero dollars.
Revenues: Increase of $231,988 from American Rescue Plan Act
(ARPA) Grant funds.
Expenses: Increase of $231,988 attributable to one amendment:
2. Carry-over/Minor Expense Items: Increase of $231,988 for the
reappropriation of remaining ARPA funds for Conference Center
renovations.
City of Franklin, Tennessee
FY 2027 Operating Budget
Presentation to Budget & Finance Committee September 10, 2026
Slide 8
Page 150 of 212
Ordinance 2026-26
Amendments By Fund
- Water Management Fund
Expenses: The expense changes are divided among three amendments
as follows:
1. Distribution of Annual Wage Increases: Increase of $369,640
between the six operational divisions of the Water Management fund.
2. Carry-over/Minor Expense Items: Increase of $2,812,834 for three
main sets of expenses: $1,686,049 for Water Management costs related
to ongoing approved CIP projects, $806,785 attributable to vehicles and
equipment budgeted and ordered in FY 2026 but not received until FY
2027, and $320,000 due to cost increases for necessary chemicals for
plant operations.
City of Franklin, Tennessee
FY 2027 Operating Budget
Presentation to Budget & Finance Committee September 10, 2026
Slide 9
Page 151 of 212
Ordinance 2026-26
Amendments By Fund
- Water Management Fund
Expenses: The expense changes are divided between three
amendments as follows:
3. New Projects: Increase of $1,251,794 for work on HOBAS
pipe repairs ($325,794 for completion of Ewingville HOBAS repairs
and $926,000 for engineering services with Alliance for review,
assessment and design recommendations for replacement of
remaining HOBAS pipe throughout the system.)
City of Franklin, Tennessee
FY 2027 Operating Budget
Presentation to Budget & Finance Committee September 10, 2026
Slide 10
Page 152 of 212
Ordinance 2026-26
Fund Balance Changes
1. General Fund: No Change.
2. Sanitation & Environmental Services Fund: Decrease of Fund
Balance of $317,807.
3. City Facilities Tax Fund: Decrease of Fund Balance of $659,350.
4. Stormwater Fund: Decrease of Fund Balance of $20,000.
5. Hotel/Motel Fund: No Change.
6. Water & Wastewater Funds: Decrease of Fund Balance of
$4,071,373.
City of Franklin, Tennessee
FY 2027 Operating Budget
Presentation to Budget & Finance Committee September 10, 2026
Slide 11
Page 153 of 212
Questions
City of Franklin, Tennessee
FY 2027 Operating Budget
Presentation to Budget & Finance Committee September 10, 2026
Slide 12
Page 154 of 212
ORDINANCE NO. 2026-26
TO BE ENTITLED: “AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND THE BUDGET OF THE CITY OF FRANKLIN FOR
FISCAL YEAR 2026-2027”
WHEREAS, the City Charter, Article VIII, provides for adoption of an annual budget
for departments of the City of Franklin; and
WHEREAS, an annual budget process appropriating funds to the various
departments and divisions of the City government for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2026
has been completed in accordance with state law and local ordinances; and
WHEREAS, the Board of Mayor and Aldermen find it is in the best interests of the
citizens of the City of Franklin to modify the annual budget from time to time.
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED, by the Board of Mayor and Aldermen of
the City of Franklin, Tennessee:
SECTION I: That the annual budget for the City of F ranklin for the Fiscal Year
2026-2027 shall be amended and does allocate and appropriate additional funding as
follows:
GENERAL FUND [Amendments 1, 2]
REVENUE
Use of Fund Balance Increase $ 101,046
EXPENDITURES
Court Personnel Increase $ 5,068
Administration Personnel Increase $ 80,935
Billing & Licensing Personnel Increase $ 51,680
Project & Facilities Personnel Increase $ 40,666
Communications Personnel Increase $ 21,232
Information Technology Personnel Increase $ 208,660
Emergency Management Personnel Increase $ 9,334
Budget & Performance Personnel Increase $ 17,051
Law Personnel Increase $ 37,162
Finance Personnel Increase $ 58,818
Engineering Personnel Increase $ 88,290
Human Resources Personnel Increase $ 187,160
Human Resources Operations Increase $ 21,750
Planning & Sustainability Personnel Increase $ 74,901
Building & Neighborhood Services Personnel Increase $ 203,552
Police - Admin Personnel Increase $ 185,299
Police - Admin Operations Increase $ 25,000
Police - CID Personnel Increase $ 42,334
Police - Patrol Personnel Increase $ 548,533
Police - Support Services Personnel Increase $ 55,242
Fire Personnel Increase $ 592,892
Streets - Maintenance Personnel Increase $ 174,826
Streets - Maintenance Capital Increase $ 79,296
Streets - Traffic Personnel Increase $ 38,520
Streets - Fleet Personnel Increase $ 42,289
Parks Personnel Increase $ 247,413
General Expenses Personnel Decrease $(3,002,921)
General Expenses Operations Increase $ (20,000)
Economic Development Decrease $ 1,850
-------------
Page 155 of 212
Net Increase (Decrease) to Total General Fund Balance $ -
SANITATION & ENVIRONMENTAL [Amendment 1, 2]
SERVICES FUND
REVENUE
Use of Fund Balance Increase $ 49,500
EXPENDITURES
SES Administration Personnel Increase $ 38,438
SES Collection Personnel Increase $ 127,038
SES Disposal Personnel Increase $ 52,331
SES Disposal Operations Increase $ 49,500
SES General Personnel Decrease $ (180,000)
SES General Operations Decrease $ 80,000
SES General Capital Decrease $ 200,000
---------------
Net Increase (Decrease) to Sanitation $ (317,807)
- & Environmental Services Fund Balance
CITY FACILITIES TAX FUND [Amendment 2]
REVENUE
EXPENDITURES
Police - Cruisers Increase $ 146,524
SES - Materials Handler Increase $ 455,000
--------------
Net Increase (Decrease) to City $ (659,350)
Facilities Tax Fund Balance
STORMWATER FUND [Amendment 1]
REVENUE
EXPENDITURES
Stormwater - Streets Personnel Increase $ 61,933
Stormwater - Engineering Personnel Increase $ 29,737
Stormwater - General Personnel Decrease $ (91,669)
Stormwater - General Operations Increase $ 20,000
---------------
Net Increase (Decrease) to Stormwater $ (20,000)
Fund Balance
HOTEL/MOTEL FUND [Amendment 2]
REVENUE
American Rescue Plan Act Grant Increase $ 231,988
EXPENDITURES
Conference Center Renovations Increase $ 231,988
---------------
Net Increase (Decrease) to Hotel/Motel Tax $ -
Fund Balance
Page 156 of 212
WATER & WASTEWATER FUND [Amendments 1, 2, 3]
REVENUE
EXPENDITURES
Utility Billing Personnel Increase $ 10,127
Water Distribution Personnel Increase $ 69,074
Water Distribution Operations Increase $ 136,066
Water Distribution Capital Increase $ 61,944
Water Plant Personnel Increase $ 62,544
Water Plant Operations Increase $ 100,000
Water General Personnel Decrease $ (135,000)
Water General Capital Increase $ 690,000
Utility Administration Personnel Increase $ 87,407
WasteWater Collection Personnel Increase $ 53,161
WasteWater Collection Operations Increase $ 1,034,775
WasteWater Collection Capital Increase $ 325,794
WasteWater Plant Personnel Increase $ 87,327
WasteWater Plant Operations Increase $ 720,000
WasteWater General Personnel Decrease $ (227,895)
WasteWater General Capital Increase $ 996,049
---------------
Net Increase (Decrease) to Total Water & Sewer Fund Balance $(4,071,373)
SECTION II: That each department of the City shall limit its expenditures to the
amount appropriated; that any changes or amendments to the appropriations set forth in
the budget shall be made in accordance with the City Code, Article VIII.
SECTION III: That this Ordinance shall take effect on after the passage of the
Third and Final Reading; the health, safety and welfare of the citizens of the City of
Franklin requiring it.
ATTEST: CITY OF FRANKLIN, TENNESSEE
By: ___________________________ By: ________________________
ERIC S. STUCKEY DR. KEN MOORE
City Administrator Mayor
Approved as to form:
_______________________________
Shauna R. Billingsley, City Attorney
PASSED FIRST READING: ______________________
PUBLIC HEARING: ______________________
PASSED SECOND READING: ______________________
PASSED THIRD READING: ______________________
Page 157 of 212
September 3, 2026
TO: Board of Mayor and Aldermen
FROM: Eric Stuckey, City Administrator
Michael Walters Young, Chief Budget & Performance Officer
RE: Consideration of Ordinance 2026-26, 1st Quarter FY 2027 Budget Amendments
Purpose
The purpose of this item is to amend the Fiscal Year 2027 Budget for compliance with State budgeting
guidance regarding:
1. Ensuring authorizations in place to balance each fund’s budget on a cash basis on June 30,
2027.
Background
The State Comptroller has provided guidance that budget amendments are to be on the cash basis and
must occur prior to fiscal year end (June 30) to ensure no fund has a deficit fund balance or deficit cash
balance at year end.
In order to stay ahead of this responsibility, staff is proposing three budget amendments. They are
split across various funds, but include:
1) Distribution of Annual Wage Increases
2) Carry-over/Minor Expense Items
3) New Purchases
By Fund the impacts of these amendments are:
A. General Fund:
i. Revenues: Increase of $101,046. This increase is attributable to one item:
1. Use of Fund Balance: Increase of $101,046. This increase will be used
several “carry-over” items in the operations budgets of certain general
fund departments. These items include funding for the search for a new
HR Director and a replacement leaf vacuum budgeted in FY 2026 but not
received until FY 2027.
ii. Expenses: Increase of $101,046. This increase is attributable to two amendments
as follows:
1. Distribution of Annual Wage Increases/Wage Adjustments:
Redistribution of $3,002,921 to all General Fund departments to fund the
annual Cost of Living (COLA) and merit-based pay adjustments effective
July 1, 2026. As a reminder, the FY 2027 Annual Operating and Capital
Budget included a 2.5% COLA for all employees and between a 0.5% to
Page 158 of 212
2.5% merit adjustment for City employee’s dependent upon their annual
evaluation scores.
In addition, of that total amount of $3,002,921, $193,296 is attributable to
funding increases in starting pay for personnel in the Franklin Police
Department as discussed at the Board of Mayor and Alderman meeting
on August 11, 2026.
2. Carry-over/Minor Expense Items: $94,296 in multiple departments. This
accounts for several increases/decreases, but the major categories are:
$79,296 for a replacement leaf vacuum, $25,000 for increase in cost of a
billing software and $21,750 for the continued recruitment of a new
Human Resources Director, and smaller misc. expense appropriations.
B. Sanitation & Environmental Services Fund:
i. Revenues: Increase of $49,500 from use of fund balance.
ii. Expenses: Increase of $367,307. This increase is attributable to two amendments
as follows:
1. Distribution of Annual Wage Increases: Redistribution of $217,807
between the three divisions.
2. Carry-over/Minor Expense Items: Increase of $129,500 for a commercial
fleet vehicle budgeted in FY 2026 not received until FY 2027 and the
reallocation of $80,000 of e-commerce fees from Water Management to
Sanitation.
C. City Facilities Tax Fund:
i. Expenses:
2. Carry-over/Minor Expense Items: Increase of $659,350 for three Police
Cruisers and a materials handler for the Sanitation and Environmental
Services Fund originally budgeted in FY 2026 and not received until FY
2027.
D. Stormwater Fund:
i. Expenses: Increase of $111,669. This increase is attributable to two amendments
as follows:
1. Distribution of Annual Wage Increases: Redistribution of $91,669 between
the two divisions.
2. Carry-over/Minor Expense Items: Increase of $20,000 for the reallocation
of $20,000 of e-commerce fees from Water Management to Stormwater.
E. Hotel Motel Fund:
i. Revenues: Increase of $231,988 from American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) Grant
funds.
ii. Expenses: Increase of $231,988 attributable to one amendment:
2. Carry-over/Minor Expense Items: Increase of $231,988 for the
reappropriation of remaining ARPA funds for Conference Center
renovations.
F. Water Management Fund:
i. Expenses: The expense changes are divided between three amendments as
follows:
1. Distribution of Annual Wage Increases: Increase of $369,640 between
Page 159 of 212
the six operational divisions of the Water Management fund.
2. Carry-over/Minor Expense Items: Increase of $2,812,834 for three main
sets of expenses: $1,686,049 for Water Management costs related to
ongoing approved CIP projects $806,785 attributable to vehicles and
equipment budgeted and ordered in FY 2026 but not received until FY
2027 and $320,000 due to cost increases for necessary chemicals for plant
operations.
3. New Projects: Increase of $1,251,794 for work on HOBAS pipe repairs
($325,794 for completion of Ewingville HOBAS repairs and $926,000 for
engineering services with Alliance for review, assessment and design
recommendations for replacement of remaining HOBAS pipe throughout
the system.)
This is the first budget amendment during this Fiscal Year to the budget. We envision at least two more
during the Fiscal Year.
Financial Impact
The amendments, as proposed, would result in:
1. General Fund: No Change.
2. Sanitation & Environmental Services Fund: Decrease of Fund Balance of $317,807.
3. City Facilities Tax Fund: Decrease of Fund Balance of $659,350.
4. Stormwater Fund: Decrease of Fund Balance of $20,000.
5. Hotel/Motel Fund: No Change.
6. Water & Wastewater Funds: Decrease of Fund Balance of $4,071,373.
Options
1. Approve amendment(s) as proposed.
2. Make changes to the amendment(s) where desired.
Recommendation
Staff recommends approval of the amendments.
Page 160 of 212
City of Franklin Page 1 of 2
City of Franklin
109 3rd Ave S.
Franklin, TN 37064
(615) 791-3217
File #: 26-01010
DATE: 9/10/2026
TO: Budget & Finance Committee
FROM: Michael Walters Young, Chief Budget & Performance Officer
SUBJECT:
Report On State Comptroller's Review, Acceptance and Approval Of The City's FY 2027 Annual
Operating Budget.
PURPOSE:
The purpose of this memorandum is to provide information to the Franklin Board of Mayor and
Aldermen (BOMA) concerning receipt, acknowledgment and approval of the FY 2027 Operating
Budget
BACKGROUND/STAFF COMMENTS:
The City of Franklin, Tennessee is required annually to submit the approved operating budget within
15 days of the third and final reading by the Board of Mayor and Alderman. The State of Tennessee's
Office of the Comptroller confirmed the receipt of Franklin's budget and provided unconditional
approval of it on August 6, 2026. The approval letter is attached herein.
Of note, the approval letter pointed out two items for consideration:
Expenditures Not Appropriated
From the letter: "During our review of the budget, we noted that your most recent audit reflected
actual expenditures exceeding budget appropriations within General Fund and City Facilities Tax
Fund. All should be authorized in original an amendment to or a supplemental appropriation. The
governing body closely monitor throughout year ensure remain appropriations. Future audits reflect
this issue has been corrected.exceeding budget appropriations within the General Fund and the City
Facilities Tax Fund. All expenditures should be authorized in the original budget, an amendment to
the b
Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.
Source: Williamson County website. First collected Oct 27, 2026.