RecordWell Data

Pension Committee — Agenda Packet

Williamson County · Williamson County · Pension Committee · meeting of Aug 13, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Williamson County

This document is no longer listed on Williamson County's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

City of Franklin Meeting Agenda Pension Committee Mailing Address: 109 3rd Ave S Franklin, TN 37064 (615) 791-3217 Thursday, August 13, 2026 3:00 PM Eastern Flank Event Facility City of Franklin Page 1 CALL TO ORDER SETTING OF THE AGENDA CITIZEN COMMENTS (Open for citizens to be heard on any issue or concern, including those related to items on the agenda. Please submit a Speaker Card at the beginning of the meeting if you would like to address the Board/Commission. If you would like to speak on an agenda item, the Chair will hold your comment until the public comment period associated with the item. As provided by law, Boards/Commissions shall make no decisions or consideration of action of citizen comments for items not on the agenda, except to refer the matter to the City Administrator/Staff for administrative consideration, or to a schedule the matter for consideration at a later date. Those addressing the Board/Commission are requested to come to the microphone and identify themselves by name and address for the official record. The Chair may restrict the period for public comment, including the length of the public comment period, the number of individuals who can speak and the length of time each individual may speak. When time allows, the standard individual public comment time is two minutes.) Comments on agenda items may be made in person or by emailing recorder@franklintn.gov before noon on the day of the meeting. Comments will be submitted for the record. NEW BUSINESS 1. Consideration Of Chair And Vice Chair, Effective 2026 2. Report From The Human Resources Department Sponsors: Sara Sylvis 3. Report From The Tennessee Consolidated Retirement System ("TCRS") As Investment Administrator For The City's Closed Defined Benefit Pension Plan Sponsors: Daniel Crews, Brenden Fraine 4. Report From Dahab Associates For Performance Review Of The Closed Defined Pension Plan Investments Including Alternative Assets Sponsors: Kevin Condy 5. Report From USI As The Actuary Page 1 of 32 Pension Committee Meeting Agenda August 13, 2026 Sponsors: Kevin Sullivan OTHER BUSINESS ADJOURN Anyone needing accommodations due to disabilities please contact the ADA Coordinator at 615-791-3277 at least 24 hours prior to the meeting. Page 2 of 32 City of Franklin Page 1 of 1 City of Franklin 109 3rd Ave S. Franklin, TN 37064 (615) 791-3217 File #: 26-0946 DATE: 8/13/2026 TO: Pension Committee FROM: Sara Sylvis, Benefits Manager SUBJECT: Report From The Human Resources Department PURPOSE: The purpose of this memorandum is to provide information to the Pension Committee concerning administration of the City's Employee Retirement Program by the Human Resouces Department. BACKGROUND/STAFF COMMENTS: The City's full time employees hired on or before December 31, 2016, are members of the Closed Single Employer Retirement Plan. Full time employees hired on or after January 1, 2017, are members of the State of Tennessee Consolidated Retirement System Defined Benefit Legacy Plan. This presentation is an overview of the number of current employees in both plans as well as the recent history of retirements in the City. FINANCIAL IMPACT: The employer contributions to both retirement plans are appropriated in the FY 2027 annual budget. RECOMMENDATION: For informational purposes. Page 3 of 32 City of Franklin Page 1 of 1 City of Franklin 109 3rd Ave S. Franklin, TN 37064 (615) 791-3217 File #: 26-0947 DATE: 8/13/2026 TO: Pension Committee FROM: Daniel Crews Brenden Fraine SUBJECT: Report From The Tennessee Consolidated Retirement System ("TCRS") As Investment Administrator For The City's Closed Defined Benefit Pension Plan PURPOSE: The purpose of this memorandum is to provide information to the Pension Committee concerning investment activities of the City's closed defined benefit pension plan, which are administered by the Tennessee Consolidated Retirement System. BACKGROUND/STAFF COMMENTS: TCRS has served as investment administrator for the City's closed pension plan since January 2017. As of May 31, 2026, the City's closed pension assets under management was $202,721,762. FINANCIAL IMPACT: The City's closed pension plan is funded with employer contributions, investment earnings and a contribution from salary from employees hired between 2010-2016. RECOMMENDATION: For informational purposes. Page 4 of 32 1 STATE OF TENNESSEETreasury DepartmentCity of FranklinAugust 13, 2026 Page 5 of 32 2 2 IntrosDaniel Crews is the Deputy Chief Investment Officer for the Tennessee ConsolidatedRetirement System. He is a senior investment professional with a 27-year track record ofstewarding capital for the State of Tennessee Treasury Department.Crews previously served as the Director of Private Equity. Prior to running the private equityprogram, Crews served as a Senior Portfolio Manager in its public equities group and as anaccount manager for the Tennessee Local Government Investment Pool.He holds both the Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) and the Chartered AlternativeInvestment Analyst (CAIA) designations and earned a BBA and an MA in finance from MiddleTennessee State University, where he subsequently taught as an adjunct professor .Daniel Crews, CFA, CAIADeputy Chief Investment Officer Brenden Fraine joined the Tennessee Consolidated Retirement System in December 2022 asa member on the private equity team. He helps oversee investments across buyout, growthequity, venture capital, and natural resources strategies.Mr . Fraine is a CFA Level II candidate and holds a B.S. in Finance from Tennessee TechUniversity.Brenden FraineInvestment Analyst Page 6 of 32 3 3 TN Treasury Investments Page 7 of 32 4 4 TN Treasury Investments Page 8 of 32 5 5 City of Franklin Pension Investment TransitionNovember 18, 2016:TCRS is approved to be the third-party administrator of the City of Franklin defined benefit plan to be effective January 1, 2017Summer 2018:TCRS staff begins alternative asset transitionDecember 14, 2018:City of Franklin Management Agreement is executed2019-Present: Staff conducts review of City of Franklin alternativesDecember 20, 2016City of Franklin buys TRGT sharesDecember 11, 2018:City of Franklin Board of Mayor and Alderman approve TCRS for the provision of investment management services for the City’s Closed Defined Benefit Pension PlanJanuary 1, 2019: City of Franklin alternatives are transferred to the management oversight of TCRS Page 9 of 32 6 6 City of Franklin – Treasury Managed AccountCity of Franklin- Tennessee Retire Group TrustEnding Market ValueEnding NAVEnding SharesBeginning Market ValueBeginning NAVBeginning SharesAccount$ 3,217,791.75 $ 3,214,239.09 City of Franklin's Alternative Assets Account (TNKM)$ 199,503,970.59 24.7840478,049,693.04$ 198,537,738.87 24.1481278,088,556.92City of Franklin's Participant in TRGT Account (TNMF)$ 202,721,762.34 24.7840478,049,693.04$ 198,537,738.87 24.1481278,088,556.92Total*Statement Date as of 5/31/2026 *Summary: 5/01/2026 to 5/31/2026Account Beginning Shares Beginning NAV Beginning Market Value Ending Shares Ending NAV Ending Market ValueCity of Franklin's Alternative Assets Account (TNKM)3,214,239.09$ 3,217,791.75$ City of Franklin's Participant in TRGT Account (TNMF)8,088,556.92 24.148127 198,537,738.87$ 8,049,693.04 24.784047 199,503,970.59$ Total 8,088,556.92 24.148127 198,537,738.87$ 8,049,693.04 24.784047 202,721,762.34$ City of Franklin- Tennessee Retire Group Trust*Statement Date as of 5/31/2026 *Summary: 5/01/2026 to 5/31/2026 Page 10 of 32 7 7 City of Franklin – Alternative Assets Funds in September 2018: Page 11 of 32 8 8 City of Franklin – Alternative AssetsFunds in March 2026:RMS Growth IIIFIA Timber Growth & Value PartnersFund20112015Vintage Year$1.4 million$1.5 millionCommitment$1.3 million$1.2 millionNAV September 2018$1.26 million$1.93 millionNAV March 20265.84%4.45%Cumulative Net IRR20272026Fund Term Page 12 of 32 9 9 City of Franklin – Investment Performance As of June 30, 2026 Page 13 of 32 10 10 City of Franklin - TRGTTotal US EquityCanada Index FundInternational Developed MarketsInternational Emerging MarketsPrivate EquityReal EstateStrategic Lending AggregateTotal US Fixed IncomeTotal Short TermTRGT Allocation as of:6/30/2026Name Value % of PortTotal US Equity 26,740,199,917 31.7%Canada Index Fund 1,600,069,275 1.9%International Developed Markets 10,415,008,169 12.4%International Emerging Markets 3,384,017,339 4.0%Private Equity 9,161,962,398 10.9%Real Estate 7,845,316,463 9.3%Strategic Lending Aggregate 8,069,843,226 9.6%Total US Fixed Income 16,773,557,983 19.9%Total Short Term 273,861,322 0.3%State of Tennessee - TRGT 84,263,836,091 100.0% Page 14 of 32 11 11 City of Franklin - TRGT Page 15 of 32 City of Franklin Page 1 of 1 City of Franklin 109 3rd Ave S. Franklin, TN 37064 (615) 791-3217 File #: 26-0948 DATE: 8/13/2026 TO: Pension Committee FROM: Kevin Condy SUBJECT: Report From Dahab Associates For Performance Review Of The Closed Defined Pension Plan Investments Including Alternative Assets PURPOSE: The purpose of this memorandum is to provide information to the Pension Committee concerning the most recent quarterly review of the closed pension investments including timber holdings that are managed outside of the TCRS portfolio. BACKGROUND/STAFF COMMENTS: Dahab Associates has served in an investment monitoring capacity for the closed plan for many years. Today's presentation will focus on $3.2 million of alternative assets within the closed pension investment portfolio. FINANCIAL IMPACT: All assets of the closed plan are used for payment of benefits due to retirees of the City hired on or before December 31, 2016. RECOMMENDATION: For informational purposes. Page 16 of 32 City of Franklin Page 1 of 1 City of Franklin 109 3rd Ave S. Franklin, TN 37064 (615) 791-3217 File #: 26-0949 DATE: 8/13/2026 TO: Pension Committee FROM: Kevin Sullivan SUBJECT: Report From USI As The Actuary PURPOSE: The purpose of this memorandum is to provide information to the Pension Committee concerning a summary of the most recent actuarial reports for both the Closed Pension Plan and TCRS Legacy Pension Plan. BACKGROUND/STAFF COMMENTS: Generally Accepted Accounting Principles and the State of Tennessee require public sector pension plans to have an actuarial funding report prepared by a licensed independent actuary on an annual basis. FINANCIAL IMPACT: The actuarially determined employer contribution for both the closed and TCRS plans is appropriated in the FY 2027 Budget. For the closed plan, the employer contribution is $12.3 million. For the TCRS plan, the employer contribution is 7.98% of payroll, or approximately $2.3 million. RECOMMENDATION: For informational purposes. Page 17 of 32 City of Franklin Employees’ Pension Plan 2026 Funding Valuation August 13, 2026 Kevin Sullivan, FSA, MAAA, EA | Principal Page 18 of 32 © 2014-2024 USI Consulting Group. All rights reserved. For Plan Sponsor Use Only. 1 COF Employees’ Pension Plan Agenda • Background on the Plan/Active Populations • Assumption Update • Key Results – 2026 Funding • Key Demographics • TCRS Open Plan Update Page 19 of 32 © 2014-2024 USI Consulting Group. All rights reserved. For Plan Sponsor Use Only. 2 COF Employees’ Pension Plan Background The Pension Plan and Benefit of a City Employee is Determined by Their Hire Date Hired Before January 1, 2017 (City of Franklin Pension Plan – the “Closed Plan”) There are four Tiers within the Plan Hired on or After January 1, 2017 - TCRS Plan Tier 1 (Hired before 7/1/2006) Tier 2 (Hired between 7/1/2006 and 2/15/2010) Tier 3 (Hired after 2/15/2010 and elected to contribute to the Plan) Tier 4 (Hired after 2/15/2010 and did not elect to contribute to the Plan) Page 20 of 32 © 2014-2024 USI Consulting Group. All rights reserved. For Plan Sponsor Use Only. 3 COF Employees’ Pension Plan Background Employee classification – Tier I • Employees hired before July 1, 2006 (Voluntary contribution - pre/post tax) • Normal retirement as early as 25 years of Credited Service – Tier II • Employees hired between July 1, 2006 and February 15, 2010 • Normal retirement at 65/5 years of service – Tier III • Employees hired after February 15, 2010 who elected to contribute to the Plan. – Tier IV • Employees hired after February 15, 2010 who elected to contribute to a defined contribution plan. This valuation holds no liability for this group. • Effective January 1, 2017, the Plan was closed to new Participants. Census data for those employees was not provided. Page 21 of 32 © 2014-2024 USI Consulting Group. All rights reserved. For Plan Sponsor Use Only. 4 COF Employees’ Pension Plan Assumption/Method Updates • For the 2026 valuation, we have continued to use the discount rate of 6.75%. – Based on Resolution 2025-18 – Matches current investment earnings assumption for TCRS • TCRS did not lower their assumption with their recent experience study • For the 2026 valuation, we have continued to use the mortality assumption that includes projected mortality improvement in accordance with TCA §9-3-501 – 105% RP-2014 Healthy Annuitants/Non-Annuitants (Blue Collar) – Ten Years of Mortality Improvements with Scale MP-2021 Page 22 of 32 © 2014-2024 USI Consulting Group. All rights reserved. For Plan Sponsor Use Only. 5 COF Employees’ Pension Plan Experience Study Results • Assumptions Already Reviewed and Updated – Discount Rate • Maintain at 6.75% – Mortality and Mortality Projection • 105% RP 2014 Blue Collar Mortality with MP21 Projection for 10 Years – COLA • Maintain at 2.0% – Additional Assumptions • No changes to Salary Increase Assumption, Rates of Retirement, and Rates of Termination ̶ Since 2017, the active population is down 44% while the retiree population is up 100% ̶ Mortality will becoming an increasingly important assumption while active assumptions (salary increase, retirement and termination) will become less significant Page 23 of 32 © 2014-2024 USI Consulting Group. All rights reserved. For Plan Sponsor Use Only. 6 COF Employees’ Pension Plan Actuarial Value of Assets Determination of Valuation Assets Market Assets, January 1, 2025 $173,765,612 Weighted Prior Year Contributions 3,130,147 Weighted Prior Year Distributions (5,474,130) Subtotal 171,421,629 Expected Interest 11,570,960 Total Contributions 12,082,010 Total Distributions (11,303,005) Expected Asset Value, January 1, 2026 $186,115,577 Market Asset Value, January 1, 2026 198,121,556 Variance from Expected Asset Value $12,005,979 2025 $(12,005,979) 2024 (2,486,907) 2023 (6,355,153) 2022 27,798,593 Market Asset Value for January 1, 2026 $198,121,556 -80% of 2025 Variance (9,604,783) -60% of 2024 Variance (1,492,144) -40% of 2023 Variance (2,542,061) -20% of 2022 Variance 5,559,719 Actuarial Valuation Assets Before Limits $190,042,287 Limits of Actuarial Value of assets a. 90% of Market Value including accruals $178,309,400 b. 110% of Market Value including accruals 217,933,712 Actuarial Value of Assets after limits 190,042,287 Page 24 of 32 © 2014-2024 USI Consulting Group. All rights reserved. For Plan Sponsor Use Only. 7 COF Employees’ Pension Plan How Well Funded is the Plan? All measures using 6.75% Discount Rate Liability Measure Liability Asset Value (Actuarial Value) 2026 Funded Ratio 2025 Funded Ratio Comments Present Value of Benefits – Value of all benefits expected to be earned by all current participants $299.9MM $190.0MM 63.4% 63.7% Not a useful measure of the funded status Entry Age Normal Accrued Liability – Liability to date under the required funding method $284.5MM $190.0MM 66.8% 67.8% The best measure of funded status. Generally considered “well funded” to be above 80% Accumulated Benefit Obligation – Liability if everyone terminated on the valuation date $247.4MM $190.0MM 76.8% 82.2% Includes nonvested benefits Page 25 of 32 © 2014-2024 USI Consulting Group. All rights reserved. For Plan Sponsor Use Only. 8 COF Employees’ Pension Plan Key Results - Funding 2026 2025 2024 2023 Number of Participants Active 308 347 370 397 Deferred Vested 162 165 189 183 Retired and Disabled 378 341 312 292 Annual Covered Payroll $ 35,269,224 $ 37,641,024 $ 37,030,890 $ 30,238,979 Average Annual Earnings $ 114,510 $ 108,476 $ 100,083 $ 76,169 Present Value of Benefits $ 299,913,391 $ 276,455,124 $ 254,505,653 $ 209,723,952 Entry Age Normal Past Service Liability $284,544,103 $ 259,552,351 $ 237,729,906 $ 195,578,819 Actuarial Value of Assets $190,042,287 $176,008,231 $ 163,626,923 $ 152,073,912 Unfunded Supplemental Liability $ 94,501,816 $ 83,544,120 $ 74,102,983 $ 43,504,907 Annual Funding Levels Normal Cost $ 2,655,107 $ 2,944,036 $ 2,818,765 $ 2,354,516 Normal Cost Rate 7.53% 7.82% 7.61% 7.79% Expected Employee Contribution $ (399,342) $ (381,366) $ (379,119) $ (324,394) Net Normal Cost $ 2,255,765 $ 2,562,670 $ 2,439,646 $ 2,030,122 Net Normal Cost % of Payroll 6.40% 6.81% 6.59% 6.71% Recommended Contribution $ 12,364,690 $ 11,378,088 $ 10,159,294 $ 7,019,361 % of Payroll 35.06% 30.23% 27.43% 23.21% Present Value of Accrued Benefits $247,433,890 $214,133,869 $195,216,337 $164,765,127 Security Ratio 76.81% 82.20% 83.82% 92.30% Page 26 of 32 © 2014-2024 USI Consulting Group. All rights reserved. For Plan Sponsor Use Only. 9 COF Employees’ Pension Plan Funded Status (in millions) • The funded status decreased from 2025 to 2026. Key Factors • Payroll increases higher than expected increased the past service liability 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 Liability $177.4 $195.6 $237.7 $259.6 $284.5 Asset Value $160.8 $152.1 $163.6 $176.0 $190.0 Funded Ratio 90.7% 77.8% 68.8% 67.8% 66.8% Interest Rate 7.00% 6.90% 6.80% 6.75% 6.75% $0 $50 $100 $150 $200 $250 $300 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 Page 27 of 32 © 2014-2024 USI Consulting Group. All rights reserved. For Plan Sponsor Use Only. 10 COF Employees’ Pension Plan Recommended Cash Contribution (in millions) • The Total contribution is [Normal cost - Expected Employee contribution + Amortization of Unfunded Liabilities] $0.00 $2.00 $4.00 $6.00 $8.00 $10.00 $12.00 $14.00 Year 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 Contribution $5.70 $4.11 $7.02 $10.16 $11.38 $12.36 Page 28 of 32 © 2014-2024 USI Consulting Group. All rights reserved. For Plan Sponsor Use Only. 11 COF Employees’ Pension Plan Demographics • No new entrants beginning on January 1, 2017 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 Active DV Ret Page 29 of 32 © 2014-2024 USI Consulting Group. All rights reserved. For Plan Sponsor Use Only. 12 COF Employees’ Pension Plan Gain/Loss Summary for 2026 Gain/(Loss) Investment (AVA basis) 1,532,714 Retirement Decrement (8,622,684) Termination Decrement (3,490,521) Disability (128,110) Retiree Mortality 24,867 Compensation & COLA Increase (4,990,200) Other Mortality (270,193) Data Corrections 473,337 Other Asset due to AVA smoothing 1,256,304 Total Gain/(Loss) (14,214,486) Page 30 of 32 © 2014-2024 USI Consulting Group. All rights reserved. For Plan Sponsor Use Only. 13 TCRS Open Plan Summary 2025 2024 2023 Valuation Date June 30, 2025 June 30, 2024 June 30, 2023 Contribution Period 7/1/2026 – 6/30/2027 7/1/2025 – 6/30/2026 7/1/2024 – 6/30/2025 Active Members 384 352 319 Annualized Salary $28,317,272 $24,353,698 $21,398,286 Inactive Members 187 161 132 Discount Rate 6.75% 6.75% 6.75% Present Value of Benefits $56,167,241 $43,679,203 $36,582,562 Employee Contribution Rate 5.00% 5.00% 5.00% Employer ADC Rate 7.98% 7.44% 7.62% Actuarial Accrued Liability $17,061,481 $12,098,051 $8,936,700 Actuarial Value of Assets $15,295,499 $10,861,279 $7,503,134 Funded Ratio 89.6% 89.8% 84.0% Page 31 of 32 © 2014-2024 USI Consulting Group. All rights reserved. For Plan Sponsor Use Only. 14 Questions/Discussion • ______________________________________ • ______________________________________ • ______________________________________ • ______________________________________ • ______________________________________ Page 32 of 32

Source: Williamson County website. First collected Oct 27, 2026.