_05282026-744
Williamson County · Williamson County · meeting of May 28, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Williamson County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Minutes
Williamson County
Board of Zoning Appeals
6:00 P.M. May 28, 2026
Members Present Staff Present
Don Crohan, Chairman John Bledsoe, Codes Compliance Director
Andrew Ring, Vice -Chairman Aaron Holmes, Planning Director
Karen Emerson-McPeak, Secretary Kristi Ransom, County Attorney
Matthew Roberts Jeff McCoy
Kim Waggoner
The Williamson County Board of Zoning Appeals met in regular session on May 28, 2026 in the Executive
Conference Room of the Williamson County Administrative Complex. Chairman Don Crohan began the meeting by
reading a public statement stating that the Board of Zoning Appeals is made up of five citizens nominated as Board
members by the County Mayor and confirmed by the County Commission. One member is a Planning
Commissioner, one member may be a County Commissioner, and the remaining members are not otherwise
connected with County Government. He went on to say the Board will hear from anyone who has anything to say to
the Board relevant to the request at hand. However, the Board will not view or hear anything that does not have a
direct bearing on the item or issue being heard. He requested that all comments be addressed to the Board.
Chairman Crohan asked the members to consider the minutes from the February 26, 2026 meeting. Andrew
Ring made the motion to approve the minutes of the February 26, 2026 meeting as presented and Karen Emerson-
McPeak seconded the motion. The motion was approved by unanimous voice vote.
ITEM 1
A request by Kelsey Magee of T -Square Engineering (Richard Bacon of Cottage Partners LLC, property
owner) for re-approval of a special use of a self-service storage facility located on Shelbyville Highway (Map
140 Parcel 03216). The property is zoned Hamlet (H) and located in the 5th Voting District.
Aaron Holmes gave a presentation on the property, the site plan, and the photos, while explaining the Staff
Report. He reminded the Board of the past BZA hearings on this property and the approvals. He read the
responsibility of the Board on this submittal per the Special Use and Zoning requirements.
Kelsie Magee with T-Square Engineering represented the client.
Chairman Crohan asked Ms. Magee if she had anything to add to the staff report or any corrections.
Ms. Magee replied she did not have any corrections. She explained the reason for this request is that there is
a new potential buyer for this property. The previous site plan was for the purpose of parking RV’s, trailers, etc.
This potential developer is more interested in having enclosed storage facilities to have th e RV’s, trailers, etc.
covered.
Board of Zoning Appeals Minutes May 28, 2026 Page 1
Chairman Crohan asked if the variance for the wooden fence from the last meeting would stay the same.
Ms. Magee replied that they would like to maintain the variance that previously granted.
Chairman Crohan asked if there were any further questions.
Secretary Karen Emerson-McPeak asked how tall the buildings will be?
Mrs. Magee replied, they will be 16 feet tall.
Chairman Crohan asked if there would be office space or an attendant?
Ms. Magee advised that there would not be an attendant.
Chairman Crohan asked if there were any other questions.
Andrew Ring stated that the staff has recommended some stipulations for the storm water maintenance
agreement and operation maintenance for storm water improvements. He asked Ms. Magee if she had any issues
with those and Ms. Magee advised that she did not.
Chairman Crohan opened the public hearing.
Seeing no one to speak, Chairman Crohan closed the public hearing.
Andrew Ring made a motion to approve the request for special use in accordance with Section 5.01 (E) and
Section 11.03 (D) (15) of the Zoning Ordinance and with the additional stipulations of Staff: Execution of a
Stormwater Maintenance Agreement and submission of an Operation and Maintenance Plan for stormwater
improvements, Submittal to and approval by the County Engineer of both the stormwater calculations and the grading
and drainage plan and all signage must be approved per the Ordinance requirements.
Matthew Roberts second the motion. Motion was approved by unanimous voice vote.
ITEM 2
A request by property owner Shane Putty for a variance from the minimum acreage requirement, as outlined
in Article 10 of the Williamson County Zoning Ordinance, for property on Skinner Road (Map 086 parcel
039.05). The property is zoned Rural Development -5 (RD-5) and located in the 5th Voting District.
Jeff McCoy read the staff report. John Bledsoe gave a presentation on the property, the site plan, and the
photos of the property.
Carolyn Brotherton with Brotherton Land Surveying represented the client. Mrs. Brotherton noted that the
site plan on the screen was a previous plan. If approved a new boundary survey will be done. The core hardship for
the property is the acreage, it’s zoned RD-5 which is standard across Williamson County. They are also about 13-14
feet shy of the road frontage requirements. They are requesting the variance based on the lot shape, terrain and
septic placement as the neighboring lot’s septic crosses over onto this parcel. There is a newly identified
Board of Zoning Appeals Minutes May 28, 2026 Page 2
preliminary soils area that Michael Haarbauer has identified for a 2–3-bedroom homesite. If additional acreage
could be obtained around this property, the building site would be the same based on the terrain and topography.
They feel that the request is reasonable based on the low impact and that it meets the rural character of Skinner Road
Chairman Crohan opened the public hearing on this item.
Andrew Lux lives at 2270 Skinner Road. Mr. Lux started by saying he was the previous owner of the entire
15 acres before he built his home in 1981. It was down to 12 acres when they built their addition. They could not
locate a secondary septic area near the original septic area, and they tried for 4 years to find a backup area for his
septic. The property is very steep and rocky. Section 10.2 (E) of the Williamson County Zoning Ordinance says
appropriate infrastructure is needed, including the availability of sewage or septic services. Skinner Road does not
have municipal sewer available, and every house is on septic and zoned RD-5. His property is located at a very steep
and rocky knoll. The previous owner sold the approximate 12-acre lot and Mr. Putty’s future 3-acre lot, with the
total being a 15-acre lot. In order for the previous owner to build his house the septic system had to be installed
southward to what would become the Putty’s property. The previous owner sold him the approximately 12-acre lot
and deeded the Putty’s the 3 acres. By the time of taking ownership of the property the Putty’s were aware that his
septic was on that property. They also knew the entire area was zoned RD-5, as they lived next door for many years.
They also knew this newly acquired 3-acre parcel was not large enough to build a residence. They sold their 5 acres
and home instead of the 8 acres thus creating a self-imposed hardship. Lastly, he and his neighbors are concerned
about this change. Our state, county and city zoning commissions have established many guidelines to maintain the
purpose and intent of zoning regulations in this area. This requirement does not meet any of them in or have any
merit to stand on for changing the standard regulations. He asked the Board to deny this variance, to remain RD-5
for current and future property owners.
Chairman Crohan asked to clarify that his septic field goes through that property now and he had to maintain
the system?
Mr. Lux replied, yes sir.
Lynda Artemov lives at 1804 Warren Hollow Road. She said that several of her neighbors have expressed
their dislike for this because it is an ongoing issue for people wanting to build. We do not have the infrastructure to
support traffic and so forth. If you allow 3 acres instead of 5 acres it will set a terrible precedent. She agreed with
Mr. Lux’s statement.
Annamarie Donaldson lives at 2268 Skinner Rd . adjacent to these properties. She describe d where the
Putty’s lived at one time on the map. She said many of the neighbors that I do not know have told her that they do
not want this variance. She stated they moved here several years ago to be close to family , to be part of a great
community, a community known to protect its people and investments. She asked the Board to look at the beautiful
property and protect their investment.
Board of Zoning Appeals Minutes May 28, 2026 Page 3
Seeing no one else wishing to speak, Chairman Crohan closed the public hearing.
Chairman Crohan asked if the staff or the applicant had anything else to say.
Mrs. Brotherton noted that when they did their research, they did not find an easement recorded for the
septic system. The Putty’s have already acknowledged they would be happy to provide the easement if this variance
were approved. Secondly, they do have a preliminary soil report identifying a secondary area as of February 9th that
does not conflict with the existing Lux system. It was mentioned in the staff report that the Putty’s did buy th e
property in 2015 and it is their investment as well. She said she has worked with her husband and their survey
business for 4 years and done extensive work within the Williamson County planning, building , and septic
departments. This challenge is not uncommon; this property is unique and will keep its rural character.
Shane Putty said he didn’t realize there was such negativity toward them building. He believes that they can
build a conservative home on this large 3-acre lot that does fit into the neighborhood. There is a buffer of trees and
the Lux’s may not be able to see the home from theirs. They are willing to make considerations to be good
neighbors. They have a large lot that they thought we would be buildable. The septic had been an issue until recently
when there was acceptable preliminary soil areas located on the property. They would like to build a home back on
Skinner Road where they want to be.
Mrs. Brotherton added that the Putty’s have approached adjoining neighbors to buy property to get the
needed acreage, but all were unwilling to sell.
Kelly Putty explained they did live at 2268 Skinner Rd. and raised seven children on that property. When
they bought the home, the homeowner , Michael Peterson, at the time offered them the other lot a lso. They did
purchase the lots under two different purchases. They did not go together according to him. They had no idea where
that originated from, the Lux property or the old Peterson property. When they looked at the deed, they realized it
was the Lux property, and assumed that’s why the septic is on it. They made an investment in this land thinking
when they sold their house that we could build back. They raised their kids on this beautiful road and would like to
be able to do that with their grandkids. They had asked Mr Lux if he would like to sell some land to help reach the
5-acre requirement and he said no, he would be happy if they just donated their portion to him. Another neighbor
contacted them when the soil scientist was out there wanting to know if they would sell the lot to her. They were
excited to find possible acceptable soils on the land and are willing to do whatever they can to build on the land.
Chairman Crohan said, the main thing that the board had to decide is why they would allow a home to
be built on 3 acres on a 5-acre area (RD-5). He asked the applicant if there was a reason why they should let
them build in a zone that requires 5 acres?
Mrs. Brotherton noted the terrain had been mentioned several times concerning the rock and incline. It’s the
same incline as the 2268 property which has a steep driveway but is doable. Once it is all cleared, it will be a great
building site.
Matthew Roberts asked if the property was zoned RD-5 when the property was purchased in 2015.
Mr. Bledsoe responded, yes.
Board of Zoning Appeals Minutes May 28, 2026 Page 4
Mr. Roberts said so they knowingly bought two lots. One with the house on it with 5 acres and one that they
also purchased that didn’t meet the 5-acre requirement. That would have been known at the time.
Mr Bledsoe responded yes, the situation would have been the same in 2015. The current zoning ordinance
became effective in January 2013.
Mrs. Putty said they were never informed it was not a buildable lot.
Mr. Roberts made a motion to deny the request for the variance due to the fact that the property does not
meet the minimum road requirement and does not meet the required 5 acres for RD-5, which is the current zoning of
said property.
Andrew Ring seconded the motion. Motion was approved by unanimous voice vote.
ITEM 3
A request by Robert Russell for an appeal of staff’s determination the property
referenced by tax Map 159, Parcel 01104, and located on Bo Lane is an illegal lot of record
and the determination that the review of a large lot easement subdivision is required, a
variance from the access and platting requirements, and other variances, if needed. The
property is zoned Rural Development -5 (RD-5) and located in the 5th Voting District.
John Bledsoe gave a presentation on the property, the site plan, and the photos of the property with
descriptions, and read the staff report.
Robert Paul Russell (Paul) and wife Nichole were present. Mr. Russell had a prepared statement that he read
to the Board. They are asking for a variance in the width of the driveway on Bo Lane that would allow them to build
on their land. Existing homes have been constructed on the road accessed by Bo Lane without being asked to widen,
improve or modify the road. They feel they have done everything asked of them by the Planning Department and
replied in a timely manner. The staff memo takes the position of the minor subdivision classification question is
outside this Board’s jurisdiction. They respectfully disagree. Prior to filing they asked the Planning Director if the
Board of Zoning Appeals was the correct department to hear these issues. The Planning Department’s response was,
you must make the appeal of the administrative decision to the Board of Zoning Appeals and the Board must
overturn his decision in order for the application to be reviewed as a minor subdivision. The staff has recommended
this matter to be deferred to give the staff more time to analysis the potential Agricultural Exemption. They
respectfully opposed that request and asked the Board to act that evening to avoid any further delays.
Chairman Crohan opened the public hearing.
Barry Burris with the Williamson County Emergency Management for fire and rescue was present to answer
any questions.
Seeing no one else wishing to speak, Chairman Crohan closed the public hearing.
Chairman Crohan asked if they had checked with the county before purchasing the land to see if it would
need a large lot subdivision plat or what they would need before purchasing the land.
Board of Zoning Appeals Minutes May 28, 2026 Page 5
Mr. Russell replied that before they purchased the land they spoke with the County. They understood there
was a large lot process. Chapdelaine Surveying was working on it and did not anticipate any issues. They were
surprised that the County was insisting on a sixteen-foot width for the driveway when they had agreed to have
sprinklers installed in the new home. They did not measure the road before they bought the property,and did not
realize it would be an issue.
Chairman Crohan said, you do realize requests one and two can go before the Board, but the third does not
because it is not in their jurisdiction. That belongs to the Planning Commission.
Mr. Russell responded, they were directed to the Board of Zoning Appeals.
Chairman Crohan continued to say he was clarifying that for him.
Secretary Karen Emerson-McPeak asked if they are talking about one house?
Mr. Russell replied, yes.
Secretary McPeak then asked, and you purchased the land in August of last year.
Mr. Russell replied, yes.
Secretary McPeak asked if all of Bo Lane was in Williamson County?
Mr. Russell replied no.
Mr. Bledsoe referring to the map on Power Point, pointed out the county boundaries were represented by the
red lines, the back portion of their property is in Rutherford County.
Secretary McPeak asked how many total houses are on Bo Lane?
Mr. Bledsoe replied he thought there were three and this would be the fourth.
Mr. Russell said this deed division was originally seventy acres. The property to the west was part of th e
original property.
Secretary McPeak asked if there was city water available?
Mr. Russell replied no. They are digging a well. On the southern edge of Bo Lane there are three private
water lines. All three of those other neighbors that have the water meter are at Taliaferro Rd.
Secretary McPeak asked if they could connect eventually?
Mr. Russell replied yes, they could but it would be expensive to run to their property.
Mr. Burris asked if they had received the letter from coordinator Bonson on this project dated April 15th?
Mr. Bledsoe spoke up and said no, this was not included in the packet.
Board of Zoning Appeals Minutes May 28, 2026 Page 6
Mr. Burris said it may be inappropriate to mention the letter, but he would disagree with one statement that
was made previously as to the fitness of Bo Lane for the demands for fire and rescue. It’s not meeting what it needs.
You all have to decide about what type of subdivision review is required.
Mrs. Russell spoke to say she has a great respect for what he does and it’s not taken lightly. She stated that
she worked at Vanderbilt in the trauma and burn unit so she understands the importance of fire and safety. They are
talking about regulations and to her it’s a commonsense thing. She grew up on a gravel road, and they are meeting
the fire safety regulations with a sprinkler system.
Secretary McPeak asked who owns Bo Lane?
Mr. Russell said his assumption would be the people to the north but he wasn’t sure.
Chairman Crohan asked Mr. Russell if he had an objection to deferring until it could be studied more.
Mr. Russell replied yes, he did not want the decision to be deferred.
Chairman Crohan asked what’s incorrect about the County position?
Mr. Russell said that the subdivision regulations have four different subdivision procedures. The way the
county interprets the minor subdivision procedure and s aying it requires a large lot easement is essentially
eliminating that minor subdivision option for lots that are off of a access easement, which he believes is contrary to
the express language in the subdivision regulations. The deed division that created this property is exempt under the
subdivision regulations. They are not required to plat under the subdivision regulations. The way this gets pulled
into zoning is Section 17.03(A). It doesn’t say shall, it says may. In his opinion that’s a permissive option, it’s not a
mandatory requirement. Even if that was intended, a permissive option is what he believes 17.03(A) in the Zoning
Ordinance is. It should not override an express exemption that’s in the Subdivision Regulations.
Chairman Crohan responded saying a small lot subdivision, you can do that with one or two lots according to
the regulations.
Mr. Russell replied yes.
Chairman Crohan responded saying it’s not that you can’t do it, you have to meet the criteria.
Mr. Russell continues in saying that the rules for the minor subdivision must be two properties, they have to
be five lots or more and you can’t need a variance. So, under the rules for minor subdivisions, we do not need a
variance. We only need a variance when they say that you have to qualify with all the requirements for a large lot
easement subdivision. Which is a different process.
Chairman Crohan replies if it could be a minor subdivision, we would not be here.
Mr. Russell replied yes, that was the reason for request three.
Board of Zoning Appeals Minutes May 28, 2026 Page 7
Andrew Ring spoke and said he had a question for the staff. If we were to grant a variance to only section
3.02 of the Subdivision Regulations , the sixteen foot width requirement on just this parcel for the purpose of
permitting a single-family residence. Does that make the problems go away?
Mr. Bledsoe responded that the sixteen-foot requirement comes from the Subdivision Regulations.
Mr. Ring said, so they could not do that.
Chairman Crohan said no they could not do that.
Mr. Bledsoe said that could be something that could be forwarded to the Planning Commission with the
submission of the plat. The Planning Commission could grant a variance for that ordinance. The Board of Zoning
appeals can’t grant variances for the Subdivision Regulations.
Attorney Kristi Ransom said they have three options they can take up, and the staff has asked them to defer
them to review additional information. The applicants are asking to go ahead and take up the variance request that
they have listed in number two in their document.
Mr. Ring said based on the questions from staff, they did not have enough information to figure out how to
put a motion together.
Chairman Crohan said his statement was that they are being asked to work through this and see if the County
has made an error or if they had followed regulations.
Chairman Crohan asked if everyone understood that. The replies were yes. We need to rule or make a
decision on what we have the authority to do in this situation.
Mrs. McPeak made a motion that we follow the staff’s request and defer this until the June meeting.
Mr. Ring second the motion. Motion was approved for deferral by unanimous voice vote.
ITEM 4
General Public Comment-No citizens were present to speak.
With no other business to come before the Board, the meeting was adjourned at approximately 7:40 P.M.
__________________________
Secretary’s Signature
___________________________
Date
Source: Williamson County website. First collected Nov 4, 2026.