Audit Committee — Agenda
City of Clarksville · Montgomery County · Audit Committee · meeting of Feb 3, 2025 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Clarksville
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
AUDIT COMMITTEE
AGENDA
DATE: February 3, 2025
LOCATION: City Hall 4th Floor Conference Room
TIME: 3:00 PM
I. CALL TO ORDER – Director of Internal Audit
II. ANNOUNCE MEMBERS IN ATTENDANCE (VERIFY QUORUM)
III. ELECTION OF CHAIRPERSON AND VICE-CHAIRPERSON
A. Chairperson - Be knowledgeable of Audit Committee functions and responsibilities,
chair meetings, represent the Audit Committee before City Council or any other official
body as necessary, correspond as necessary in regard to Audit Committee issues,
prepare Director’s annual performance evaluation, and coordinate with Human
Resources to hire (or terminate) in regard to the Director’s position.
B. Vice Chairperson - Be knowledgeable of Audit Committee functions and
responsibilities, fill in for or provide assistance to the Chairperson related to any of the
duties listed above.
IV. FINANCIAL STATEMENT AUDIT PRESENTATION BY Crosslin
V. ADOPTION OF MINUTES
A. October 30, 2024 Audit Committee Meeting
VI. DEPARTMENT REPORT
A. Budget Report
B. Update on Internal Audit Activity
VII. NEW BUSINESS
A. None
VIII. COMMITTEE ACTION REQUIRED
A. Crosslin Contract Renewal
B. Review and Approval of Policy Manual Revisions
i. Annual Risk Assessment and Audit Plan Policy
ii. Performing Advisory Services Policy
iii. Communication Policy
IX. CITY COUNCIL ACTION REQUIRED
A. None
X. ADJOURNMENT OF PUBLIC MEETING
XI. PUBLIC COMMENTS (5 minutes each)
XII. NEXT MEETING - April 30, 2025 3:00 PM
XIII. EXECUTIVE SESSION – Vote by the Committee to go into executive session.
During executive session and for the remainder of the meeting, the Audit Committee will be
discussing only matters that are considered confidential under TCA Section 9-3-405 (d). These
items may include:
A. Items deemed not subject to inspection under TCA Section 10-7-503 and 10-7-504
B. Current or pending litigation and pending legal controversies
C. Pending or ongoing audits or audit related investigations
D. Information protected by federal law
E. Matters involving information under TCA Section 9-3-406 where the informant has
requested anonymity.
At this point in the meeting everyone other than Audit Committee members and those asked
to attend by the Audit Committee to address an item related to the categories above will be
asked to leave.
XIV. ADJOURNMENT OF EXECUTIVE SESSION
UNAPPROVED
AUDIT COMMITTEE
MINUTES
DATE: October 30, 2024
LOCATION: CITY HALL FOURTH FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM
TIME: 3:00 PM
I. CALL TO ORDER – Chairperson
The meeting was called to order by Jennifer Thayer at 3:02 pm.
II. ANNOUNCE MEMBERS IN ATTENDANCE (VERIFY QUORUM)
Audit Committee members present: Jennifer Thayer, Patrick Wilkinson, Trey Judd
Audit Committee members absent: Karen Reynolds, Elizabeth Rankin
Quorum verified? Yes
Internal Audit attendees: Stephanie Fox, Jenn Osteen, Becca Darden, Emily Hammer
III. ADOPTION OF MINUTES: July 31, 2024 Audit Committee Meeting
A. Patrick Wilkinson made a motion to adopt the minutes as presented. Trey Judd
seconded. The motion was approved unanimously.
IV. DEPARTMENT REPORT
Stephanie presented the budget report and an update on department activity.
A. Budget Report
B. Update on Internal Audit Activity
C. Discussion of Strategic Plan, Charters, and Revised Policies
Stephanie presented the department’s Strategic Plan, Charter, and Revised Policies.
V. NEW BUSINESS
A. None
VI. COMMITTEE ACTION REQUIRED
A. Audit Committee Candidate Consideration
The committee reviewed qualifications for potential candidates to serve on the
committee from January 2025 - December 2026 . The vote for this item is recorded
under City Council action required.
B. FY 2025 Strategic Plan, Charter, and Internal Audit Policies Approval
Trey Judd made a motion to amend the communication policy extending the time
frame surrounding elections during which internal audit reports may not be issued
from 30 days prior to election day to 30 days prior to the start of early voting for that
election day. Jennifer Thayer seconded. The motion was approved unanimously.
Patrick Wilkinson made a motion to approve the FY 2025 Strategic Plan, Charter, and
Internal Audit Policies as amended. Trey Judd seconded. The motion was approved
unanimously.
VII. CITY COUNCIL ACTION REQUIRED
A. Nomination of Audit Committee Members for January 2025 - December 2026
Trey Judd made a motion to nominate Lynn Stokes and reappoint Elizabeth Rankin to
serve on the Audit Committee from January 2025 through December 2026. Jennifer
Thayer seconded. The motion was approved unanimously.
VIII. ADJOURNMENT
Trey Judd made a motion to adjourn the public meeting and go into executive session. Patrick
Wilkinson seconded. The public meeting was adjourned at 4:14 pm.
IX. PUBLIC COMMENT ( 5 minutes each )
X. NEXT MEETING - February 3, 2025 3:00 PM
January meeting has been rescheduled to February 3, 2025 at 3:00 PM.
XI. EXECUTIVE SESSION - Vote by the committee to go into executive session
During executive session and for the remainder of the meeting, the Audit Committee will be
discussing only matters that are considered confidential under TCA Section 9-3-405 (d). These
items may include:
A. Items deemed not subject to inspection under TCA Section 10-7-503 and 10-7-504
B. Current or pending litigation and pending legal controversies
C. Pending or ongoing audits or audit related investigations
D. Information protected by federal law
E. Matters involving information under TCA Section 9-3-406 where the informant has
requested anonymity.
At this point in the meeting everyone other than Audit Committee members and those asked
to attend by the Audit Committee to address an item related to the categories above will be
asked to leave.
The following topics were discussed:
A. Ongoing audits and investigations
B. Hotline reports
XII. ADJOURNMENT OF EXECUTIVE SESSION
The executive session was adjourned at 4:26 pm.
CITY OF CLARKSVILLE
YEAR-TO-DATE BUDGET REPORT
Report generated: 01/30/2025 10:04
User: rdarden
Program ID: glytdbud
Page 1
FOR 2025 13
ACCOUNTS FOR: ORIGINAL TRANFRS/ REVISED AVAILABLE PCT
1100 General Fund APPROP ADJSTMTS BUDGET YTD EXPENDED ENCUMBRANCES BUDGET USED
10415211 Salaries and Wages-Inter.Audit
10415211 4111 Full-Time Employe 332,599 0 332,599 177,640.64 .00 154,958.36 53.4%
10415211 4112 Part-Time Employe 2,700 0 2,700 .00 .00 2,700.00 .0%
10415211 4113 Longevity Pay 450 0 450 450.00 .00 .00 100.0%
10415211 4211 Health Insurance 60,096 0 60,096 35,056.00 .00 25,040.00 58.3%
10415211 4212 Dental Insurance 1,680 0 1,680 966.00 .00 714.00 57.5%
10415211 4213 Life Insurance 212 0 212 122.08 .00 89.92 57.6%
10415211 4214 Disability Insura 1,432 0 1,432 763.82 .00 668.18 53.3%
10415211 4221 Social Security C 24,622 0 24,622 12,968.76 .00 11,653.24 52.7%
10415211 4231 TCRS Contribution 41,737 0 41,737 21,664.53 .00 20,072.47 51.9%
TOTAL Salaries and Wages-Inter.Audit 465,528 0 465,528 249,631.83 .00 215,896.17 53.6%
10415213 Operating Expenditures-Int.Aud
10415213 4321 Employee Training 14,635 0 14,635 1,970.08 .00 12,664.92 13.5%
10415213 4322 Memberships & Con 1,940 0 1,940 400.00 .00 1,540.00 20.6%
10415213 4323 Employee Testing 105 0 105 102.53 .00 2.47 97.6%
10415213 4325 Software Renewals 965 0 965 308.82 .00 656.18 32.0%
10415213 4334 Accounting/Auditi 92,000 0 92,000 27,297.15 4,127.85 60,575.00 34.2%
10415213 4432 Building Repair & 0 0 0 24.96 .00 -24.96 100.0%
10415213 4442 Rental of Equipme 120 0 120 59.41 37.97 22.62 81.2%
10415213 4521 Property Insuranc 335 0 335 329.00 .00 6.00 98.2%
10415213 4523 General Liability 665 0 665 631.00 .00 34.00 94.9%
10415213 4530 Communications 375 0 375 199.37 .00 175.63 53.2%
10415213 4580 Travel 300 0 300 .00 .00 300.00 .0%
10415213 4610 General Supplies 2,100 0 2,100 425.92 .00 1,674.08 20.3%
10415213 4640 Books & Periodica 2,100 0 2,100 941.69 .00 1,158.31 44.8%
TOTAL Operating Expenditures-Int.Aud 115,640 0 115,640 32,689.93 4,165.82 78,784.25 31.9%
TOTAL General Fund 581,168 0 581,168 282,321.76 4,165.82 294,680.42 49.3%
TOTAL EXPENSES 581,168 0 581,168 282,321.76 4,165.82 294,680.42
CITY OF CLARKSVILLE
YEAR-TO-DATE BUDGET REPORT
Report generated: 01/30/2025 10:04
User: rdarden
Program ID: glytdbud
Page 2
FOR 2025 13
ORIGINAL TRANFRS/ REVISED AVAILABLE PCT
APPROP ADJSTMTS BUDGET YTD EXPENDED ENCUMBRANCES BUDGET USED
GRAND TOTAL 581,168 0 581,168 282,321.76 4,165.82 294,680.42 49.3%
** END OF REPORT - Generated by Darden, Rebecca **
11/30/2025
Internal Audit DepartmentAudit Committee ReportJanuary 2025
Project Statistics
Senior Management Expense(CY 2021-2022)
Building and Codes
CG Contract Management
CGW Contract Management
CG Petty Cash
CFR Overtime
FY 2025 Ethics Survey
0% 25% 50% 75% 100%
Project Status
Senior Management Expense (CY 2021-2022)
Building and Codes
CG Contract Management
CGW Contract Management
CG Petty Cash
CFR Overtime
FY 2025 Ethics Survey
120.00
1,070.75
299.25
0.00
0.00
0.00
19.75
384.00
1,158.00
299.25
0.00
0.00
0.00
19.75
400.00
1,000.00
500.00
500.00
400.00
600.00
300.00
FY 2025 Actual HoursTotal Project HoursTotal Budgeted Hours
112112
158158
229229 229229
9292
149149
234234
169169 169169
22
Audits & Other Engagements
0
50
100
150
200
250
SeniorManagementExpense (CY2021-2022)
Building andCodes CG ContractManagementCGW ContractManagementCG Petty CashCFR OvertimeFY 2025 EthicsSurvey
PLANNED DAYS ACTUAL DAYS
Engagement Duration
96%96%
116%116%
60%60%
0%0%
0%0%
0%0%
7%7%
0%0%
25%25%
Senior ManagementExpense (CY 2021-2022)
Building and Codes
CG ContractManagementCGW ContractManagement
CG Petty Cash
CFR Overtime
FY 2025 Ethics Survey
Possible ConsultingEngagements
Other Projects
0% 25% 50% 75% 100% 125%
Budgeted Hours Used
21/30/2025
Internal Audit DepartmentAudit Committee ReportJanuary 2025
Hotline Statistics
Staff Metrics
Percent of Required 40 Hours Completed for CY 2025
Auditor
Stephanie
Jennifer
Emily
Rebecca
0% 25% 50% 75%
2025 Continuing Education Hours
0.00%
20.00%
40.00%
60.00%
80.00%
JulyAugustSeptemberOctober
NovemberDecemberJanuar
y
Februar
yMarchAprilMay June
Target UtilizationActual Utilization
Audit Utilization Rate - Stephanie
0.00%
20.00%
40.00%
60.00%
80.00%
JulyAugustSeptemberOctober
NovemberDecemberJanuar
y
Februar
yMarchAprilMay June
Target UtilizationActual Utilization
Audit Utilization Rate - Jenn
0.00%
20.00%
40.00%
60.00%
80.00%
JulyAugustSeptemberOctober
NovemberDecemberJanuar
y
Februar
yMarchAprilMay June
Target UtilizationActual Utilization
Audit Utilization Rate - Emily
0.00%
20.00%
40.00%
60.00%
80.00%
JulyAugustSeptemberOctober
NovemberDecemberJanuar
y
Februar
yMarchAprilMay June
Target UtilizationActual Utilization
Audit Utilization Rate - Becca
Open
Closed
Total Reports for FY 2025
12
12
6
6
Report Status Previously Reported New Reports
42
City of Clarksville, Tennessee
The Astoria • 3803 Bedford Avenue • Suite 103 • Nashville, Tennessee 37215 • Phone: 615.320.5500 • Fax: 615.329.9465 • www.crosslinpc.comThe Astoria • 3803 Bedford Avenue • Suite 201 • Nashville, Tennessee 37215 • Phone: 615.320.5500 • Fax: 615.329.9465 • www.crosslinpc.com
Engagement Fees
At Crosslin, we share with our customers a desire for professional fees to be commensurate
with the value delivered. Through our people, commitment and drive, we strive to ensure that
this equation is always balanced. We seek not to be the lowest-cost provider in the markets we
serve, but rather to provide services that offer compelling value to our customers. We believe
that the fees proposed are competitive for comparable services, but we do not want fees to be
the sole reason on which you base your decision. Should this proposal yield materially different
fee results, and you wish to engage our firm, we would appreciate the opportunity to discuss the
differences with you to ensure that our proposal has considered all of the relevant facts.
Other firms may propose lower fees, but our experience, together with our reasonable fees, make
Crosslin an effective choice.
Our not-to-exceed cost proposal for external auditing services for the City for fiscal year 2024 and
for two-one year renewal options is as follows:
Year Ended Clarksville
City General
Clarksville Gas,
Water, and
Wastewater
CDE
Lightband Total
June 30, 2024 $77,000 $49,500 $47,500 $174,000
Optional Renewal
June 30, 2025 $80,100 $51,500 $49,400 $181,000
June 30, 2026 $83,300 $53,550 $51,400 $188,250
The overall engagement fee has been allocated among City General and the City’s Departments
based on expected hours to be incurred in the performance of the respective engagements,
which is based on our previous history with the City.
The previously mentioned fees are FIXED unless the City’s activities result in changes which
increase the scope of our engagement(s). In those circumstances, we would review the
complexities and scope of the change (e.g., formation of entities, major structure changes,
significant changes in controls processes, significant GASB pronouncements, etc.) and obtain
your approval of the fee increase. The increase would correspond to the hourly rates and fees
quoted previously. At this time, we do not expect any changes from the above fixed fees.
All administrative, online confirmation costs, and technology costs are included in this quotation
as are all out-of-pocket expenses.
City of Clarksville
Internal Audit Manual
Policy Number 03 Review Cycle Annual
Subject Annual Risk Assessment and Audit Plan
Purpose
To define the department’s annual risk assessment and audit plan development process as
required by Global Internal Audit Standards (the Standards). This policy demonstrates
compliance with standard 9.1, 9.4, and 9.5.
Definitions
Risk assessment - The identification and analysis of risks relevant to the achievement of an
organization’s objectives. The significance of risks is typically assessed in terms of impact and
likelihood.
Risk criteria - Categories under which risk will be scored for each audit area.
Policy
The Director will conduct a risk assessment at least annually, and develop an annual audit plan.
The risk assessment will aid Internal Audit in allocating available resources to priorities that
align with the City’s objectives; however, other factors may also be considered in developing the
final audit plan. The resulting risk based audit plan will be presented to the Audit Committee for
review and approval.
The risk assessment process has been designed for simplicity and flexibility to allow alignment
with changing risks. The process utilizes risk criteria and associated weights to determine
whether audit areas in each department should be selected for audit in the upcoming year. The
risk criteria, weighting, and audit areas are based on the professional judgment of the Director
and may be modified from year to year.
The annual risk assessment will be documented, along with the associated audit plans for each
fiscal year.
Procedure
Annual Risk Assessment
Gathering Information
The department collects information to be used in the annual risk assessment throughout the
year. This occurs in a variety of ways, including:
● Standing meetings with various departments
Internal Audit Manual
Page 20 of 52
● Attendance at council committee meetings
● From other audits or advisory engagements
● Annual internal control/risk assessment meetings with Finance and department
management
● Other informal interactions with departments and senior management
● Audit Committee meetings
In addition to the sources listed above, the Director also solicits feedback from select members
of City leadership and senior management. Specifically, the Director will ask the Mayor, Chief of
Staff, CFO, IT Director, and City Attorney about areas of particular concern which may benefit
from an audit or advisory engagement.
To complement the information sources listed above, information from outside sources is
considered to identify emerging risks and other trends. Outside sources may include the
Association of Local Government Auditors, the Institute of Internal Auditors, other continuing
education focused on emerging risks, audit reports from other jurisdictions, and interactions
with other local government internal audit departments.
Process
The formal annual risk assessment process begins with a review of the prior year’s methodology
to determine whether any updates are needed. The Director will review the audit universe for
completeness, risk criteria considered in the prior year, and relative weights previously assigned
to the risk criteria. Changes can be made to these at the Director’s discretion. A summary of
changes, along with finalized risk criteria definitions and weights will be documented within the
risk assessment workbook.
The Director will use information gathered throughout the year to score the risk criteria for each
audit area. The score for each risk criteria will be multiplied by the applicable weight. All
weighted scores will then be totaled to arrive at a cumulative risk score.
Areas with the highest cumulative risk scores are typically selected for the audit plan, subject to
constraints discussed below.
Audit Plan
Development
After the risk assessment is completed, the Director will prepare the annual audit plan. The
audit plan should support the achievement of the City’s objectives.
Available audit hours are calculated for each employee. This calculation considers days worked
per year, along with time allotted for necessary administrative work. The available audit hours
are then allocated among projects selected for inclusion in the audit plan.
While the audit plan normally includes projects with high cumulative risk scores, there are two
other non-risk based engagements that may be included in an audit plan. These are the
Internal Audit Manual
Page 21 of 52
employee ethics survey and the senior management expense audit, which are described in the
Non-Risk Based Engagement section of this policy.
The audit plan contains budgeted hours for specific projects. These include allotments for:
● Employee Ethics Survey
● Senior Management Expense (as appropriate)
● Possible advisory engagements that may arise during the year
● Hotline investigations
● Other technical assistance for departments
● Follow up or monitoring activities on prior audits
● Meeting attendance and completion of the annual risk assessment
In cases where audits have a known area or scope, these will be listed on the audit plan.
However, it is permissible to list a general audit area on the plan, with the specific scope to be
refined during the planning phase of the audit. In these instances, refining the scope during the
engagement will allow us more flexibility to tailor the scheduled audits to current risks in the
selected areas.
Knowledge, Skills, And Competencies Assessment
After a draft audit plan is compiled, the Director will assess whether the department has
adequate knowledge, skills, and competencies to complete the planned engagements. Should a
gap be identified, the Director will document how that gap will be addressed. Gaps may
sometimes require additional training for staff, co-sourcing from another internal audit provider,
or another resource. If gaps are unable to be sufficiently mitigated, this will be communicated to
the Audit Committee and may result in declining the engagement.
Approval
If sufficient knowledge, skills, and competencies exist or any gaps can be appropriately
addressed, the Director will present the draft audit plan to the Audit Committee for approval.
Revisions
It is possible that the audit plan will need to be updated as the year progresses. This may be
due to unforeseen challenges within audits, new priorities, or changing risks. Should a change in
the audit plan be warranted, it will be presented to the Audit Committee for approval.
There may be instances where surprise audits are deemed necessary for successful completion
of the Internal Audit Department’s mission. These are not precluded by this policy, as long as
they are properly communicated to and approved by the Audit Committee.
Non-Risk Based Engagements
Employee Ethics Survey
The department performs an annual ethics survey, which is intended to gauge the awareness of
the City’s Code of Ethics, quality of ethics training, compliance with various laws and City
policies, and the participants’ perception of the City’s ethical environment. Questions may
Internal Audit Manual
Page 22 of 52
change from year to year and may be targeted at different aspects of ethics within the City. The
survey is anonymous, and is sent to all employees, including the Mayor and the City Council.
The results of the survey are intended first and foremost to be used for risk assessment and
audit planning purposes within the Internal Audit Department. As the information may be useful
for management in making improvements to the ethical environment of the City, an
informational report of the results will be provided to the Mayor, Chief of Staff, City Council, and
released publicly. Where appropriate, the report will also contain recommendations for
improving the City’s ethics related processes.
Senior Management Expense
On August 20, 2008, the Audit Committee approved a policy to require an audit of senior
management expenses on a bi-annual basis. This continues to be the policy of the Internal Audit
Department.
For purposes of this audit, senior management is defined as the Mayor, the Chief of Staff,
department heads, and council members. The audit shall include expenses of the Mayor and
Chief of Staff (or the positions that approximate those positions). The included expenses will be
those charged to the Mayor’s budget as well as those that have been charged to other budgets
on behalf of the Mayor or Chief of Staff. The expenses of other department heads and council
members will be included in the audit on a judgmental basis.
Coordination and Reliance on the Work of Other Providers
The Director is required to coordinate with internal and external providers of assurance services
and consider whether to rely upon their work. Coordination of services minimizes duplication of
efforts, enhances coverage of key risks, and improves the value added by providers. If the work
of other providers is relied upon, the Director will document the basis for reliance and retains
responsibility for the conclusions reached by the internal audit function.
Policy Revision History
Revision Date January 30, 2025 Revision Approval
Initial Date October 25, 2024 Initial Approval October 30, 2024
Internal Audit Manual
Page 23 of 52
City of Clarksville
Internal Audit Manual
Policy Number 06 Review Cycle Annual
Subject Performing Advisory Services
Purpose
To define the department’s methodologies related to the performance of advisory engagements.
This policy demonstrates compliance with Global Internal Audit Standards in Domain V:
Performing Internal Audit Services, as well as standards 2.2, 3.1, 5.2, and 9.1.
Definitions
Client - the department or management team requesting the engagement.
Advisory Services - As defined by the Standards, services through which internal auditors provide
advice to an organization’s stakeholders without providing assurance or taking on management
responsibilities. The nature and scope of these services are subject to agreement with
management. (Advisory services may also be known as consulting services.)
Policy
The Internal Audit Department will conduct advisory services in a systematic, disciplined, and
consistent manner, in accordance with the Standards and department methodologies. Standard
template workpapers will be used as a basic structure for all audits to ensure that work adheres
to these requirements.
Advisory engagements shall be approved by the Audit Committee as part of the annual plan or
as a special request developing during the fiscal year. Hours will be included in the annual audit
plan for advisory engagements that might develop during the fiscal year. Engagements requiring
less than 80 hours of time do not need the approval of the Audit Committee prior to
commencement; however, the Audit Committee should be informed of this project at the next
Audit Committee meeting. For special requests requiring 80 hours or more, the Director of
Internal Audit will notify the Audit Committee about the request and suggest how the annual
audit plan could be modified to accommodate the request. If the request is not of an urgent
nature, the Director may recommend that it be included in the next audit plan.
Per City Code Section 6-612 Independence, “Internal auditors shall have no direct operational
responsibility or authority over any of the activities they review. Additionally, they shall not
develop nor install systems or procedures, prepare records, or engage in any other activity that
would normally be audited.” This section limits the development, implementation of systems
and procedures, and processing of transactions, but does not preclude the department from
Internal Audit Manual
Page 33 of 52
providing guidance to management on operational improvements, management of risks, or other
value added services as long as management agrees to ownership of the process described in
the advisory engagement documentation.
At times, other departments may ask for Internal Audit’s assistance outside of a formal advisory
engagement. This is frequently in the form of questions related to various topics or part of a
request for input from all City departments. In these situations, the scale of the request is
typically small and management is not requesting a formalized advisory engagement; however,
it is important to provide timely assistance to requesting departments, as Internal Audit’s input
may add value to City operations. Responses to these requests are generally in the form of
possible items for further consideration by the requesting department. These requests are not
considered advisory engagements which are governed by this policy.
Procedure
Advisory engagements allow the Internal Audit Department to add value and provide advice
outside of the audit process, while allowing management to maintain responsibility for
processes and internal controls. Examples of these services may include advising on the design
and implementation of new policies, processes, and systems; providing forensic services;
providing training; and facilitating discussions about risks and controls. Advisory engagements
typically originate by request of the Mayor, CFO, or Department Heads. They may include or
encompass the areas of governance, risk management, and internal control processes as agreed
upon with management requesting the engagements. The department will follow the same
retention guidelines as required for all audits, as well as other requirements in the Internal
Audit reporting policy as they apply (5.2).
Initial Assessment
Each advisory engagement begins with a client meeting to gather more information about the
requested engagement. At this initial meeting, topics of discussion should include:
● Management’s expectations of the work to be performed and how results will be
communicated
● Nature and timing of the engagement
● Management’s objectives and goals related to the engagement, as well as any
associated risks
After this meeting, the Department will meet internally to discuss independence and objectivity
related to the proposed engagement. The Internal Audit Department, and specifically auditors,
may provide advisory engagements relating to operations for which they previously had
responsibility, with appropriate disclosure to the client (2.2). This should be limited based on
the Director of Internal Audit’s judgment. Any other potential impairments to independence or
objectivity must also be disclosed to the party requesting the engagement prior to accepting the
engagement (2.2).
At this time, the Director and engagement team will also perform an analysis to determine
whether the engagement can be accepted. The Director must assess whether the department
has the knowledge, skills, or other competencies needed to perform the engagement. If the
Internal Audit Manual
Page 34 of 52
department does not possess the required skills and competence, the Director may decline or
postpone the engagement, have the team or members of the team attend training to obtain the
necessary skills, or obtain competent advice and assistance from a third party (3.1).
Other considerations in determining whether an engagement should be accepted include:
1. Potential impairments to independence
2. The complexity of work needed to achieve engagement objectives
3. The cost of the engagement in relation to potential benefits
4. Whether the engagement has potential to improve City operations
5. Resources necessary to perform the engagement (13.5)
Planning
If the engagement is accepted, the Department begins the planning phase and prepares a
management agreement related to the engagement.
The objectives, scope, responsibilities, and deliverables of the project must be agreed upon
with the engagement client and this agreement must be in writing for all engagements (Domain
V Intro). The written agreement can be sent via email, provided management provides a reply
indicating their agreement. The agreement must include management’s understanding and
agreement that Internal Audit does not assume any ownership or responsibility for the process
or policy included in the scope of the engagement (Domain V Intro).
Documentation for each of these engagements will vary based on the nature of the
engagement; however, there are a limited number of workpapers that are required for each
engagement, and for which templates are provided.
Performing the Engagement
Work programs must be documented for each engagement; however, this documentation may
vary based on the nature and complexity of the engagement (13.6). The program must be
sufficient to address the agreed upon objectives and must address the risks and controls
consistent with the objectives (13.3). Due to the nature of advisory services, a formal,
documented risk assessment and evaluation of criteria may not be necessary depending on the
engagement (13.2, 13.4). Throughout the engagement, auditors should be alert to any
significant risks or control issues that are present. The auditor should keep the management
team requesting the engagement and the Director of Internal Audit informed of the progress of
the engagement (13.1). If auditors encounter any issues related to the scope of the
engagement, they will notify the Director of Internal Audit. The department requesting the
engagement and the audit team will then meet to determine if the engagement should continue.
This may include a discussion of whether an audit of the area is more appropriate.
Reporting the Results of the Engagement
The Director of Internal Audit is responsible for communicating the results of the advisory
engagement to the engagement client and to those in management identified for distribution of
the report. The final communication must include the objectives, scope, recommendations
and/or action plans (if applicable), and conclusions (15.1). The conclusion must summarize the
Internal Audit Manual
Page 35 of 52
results relative to the engagement objectives and management objectives. The conclusion must
also summarize the internal auditors’ professional judgement about the overall significance of
the findings (14.5). This should occur in the method specified in the management agreement.
If any issues are identified outside the scope of the engagement, these issues must be
communicated to the management team. These issues can be reported in writing as part of the
advisory engagement report, verbally, or written separately.
Advisory engagement reports will be distributed as agreed with management. The Audit
Committee will always be included in report distributions and aware of the results of advisory
engagements. Advisory engagement reports will not be posted to the City website, unless
agreed upon by management in the written agreement at the beginning of the engagement. The
Director will assess whether posting the results of the engagement will be beneficial for the
City.
Prior to releasing any agreed upon deliverables, an engagement level quality assessment will be
performed in accordance with the Department’s Quality Assurance and Improvement Program
Policy.
Monitoring Disposition of Results
Due to the nature of these services, the results are not monitored.
Post Engagement Risk and Future Audit Planning Considerations
Information obtained during advisory engagements, specifically those related to risk and risk
management, should be incorporated into the evaluation of risk for the organization and the
organization’s management of risk. Information related to internal control functionality or lack of
internal control within a process should be incorporated into the risk assessment process and
considered for future audits (9.1 considerations).
Future consideration must also be given to potential impairments. The Internal Audit
Department may provide assurance services where it had previously performed advisory
services, provided the nature of the engagement did not impair objectivity of the department or
individual auditors. The Director should take precautions to address any impairments including
limiting the assurance engagement to those auditors not performing the advisory engagement
and allowing for more than a year to pass between the advisory engagement and the assurance
engagement (2.2).
Policy Revision History
Revision Date N/A Revision Approval N/A
Initial Date January 30, 2025 Initial Approval
Internal Audit Manual
Page 36 of 52
City of Clarksville
Internal Audit Manual
Policy Number 07 Review Cycle Annual
Subject Communication
Purpose
To define the department’s activities related to communication principles. This policy
demonstrates compliance with standards 11.1, 11.2, 11.3, 11.4, 11.5, and 15.1.
Policy
The department strives to communicate effectively with its stakeholders. We recognize that
effective communication is based on a variety of factors, including building relationships,
establishing trust, and ensuring stakeholders and the City benefit from results of internal audit
services. The Director will establish both formal and ongoing communications that enhance
effectiveness.
Procedure
Building Relationships and Communicating with Stakeholders
The Director is responsible for developing a communication strategy that builds relationships
and trust with stakeholders. This communication strategy includes both formal and informal
communications.
Engagement communications are a key part of this strategy, and are discussed in more detail in
policy 05. Outside of engagement communications, we strive to communicate with stakeholders
on a regular basis. The combination of all of these communications helps enhance our
understanding of the City and its risks, processes, and requirements. This is accomplished in the
following ways.
Audit Committee Meetings
Regularly scheduled Audit Committee meetings occur quarterly, and special sessions can be
called when necessary. At all regularly scheduled meetings, the Director provides updates to the
committee on the department’s budget, progress on the audit plan and associated metrics, and
updates on hotline reports. Each meeting also includes a non-public executive session (provided
for in TCA 9-3-405), where the Director and audit staff can provide additional information to the
committee about ongoing audits or investigations, etc. Management is not present in this
portion of the meeting.
In addition to the department reports described above, the Director includes other topics on the
agenda as appropriate. Depending on the meeting, topics may include:
Internal Audit Manual
Page 37 of 52
● The presentation of financial and compliance audit results
● Policy updates
● Annual budget approval
● Discussion of standards and the department charter
● Approval of the audit plan
● Discussion of the department’s quality assurance and improvement program results
● Discussion of new committee members
● Procurement for the City’s financial and compliance audit
Other Committee Meetings
Auditors are assigned committee meetings to attend on a monthly basis. This gives other
departments, council members, and senior management an opportunity to see and interact with
auditors outside of an audit setting. Additionally, it helps keep up to date with things that are
happening in each department, which is essential for comprehensive assessment of risks. These
interactions help develop trust and relationships, which prove valuable during subsequent
engagements for those departments.
Standing Meetings
The Director has regularly scheduled standing meetings with other departments. The frequency
of these meetings is dependent upon the specific department. Topics in these meetings may
cover a variety of topics, including current issues and risks facing the department. This provides
an opportunity for the Director to keep up with departmental challenges and discuss their
governance, risk management, and controls. This also provides a venue for the Director to offer
potential advisory services that may be useful.
Strategy and Leadership Sessions
Strategy and leadership sessions are another communication pathway in which various
members of the department participate. These typically involve senior management and
leadership of all City departments. These are useful for both developing trust with other
departments and understanding the City’s strategy for providing services to citizens.
Feedback from Stakeholders
The department also solicits feedback from departments at the end of each engagement. This
helps enhance internal audit processes and further develop trust and support with stakeholders.
Effective Communication
The department strives to ensure that all communications are accurate, objective, clear,
concise, constructive, complete, and timely. These characteristics are defined in the table below.
Accurate Free from errors and distortions, faithful to the underlying facts
Objective Fair, impartial, and unbiased, the result of a fair-minded and
balanced assessment of all relevant facts and circumstances
Clear Easily understood and logical, avoiding unnecessary technical
language, providing all significant and relevant information
Concise To the point, avoid unnecessary elaboration, superfluous detail,
Internal Audit Manual
Page 38 of 52
redundancy, and wordiness
Constructive Helpful to management and the organization, lead to
improvements where needed
Complete Lack nothing that is essential to the target audience, includes all
significant and relevant information and observations to support
recommendations and conclusions
Timely Opportune and expedient, allow management to take appropriate
corrective action
Similar to other standards, supervision and quality assurance methodologies help ensure that
communication has these characteristics. These may include coaching or review by the Director
or other staff members where appropriate. Formal engagement communications go through an
extensive review process within the department prior to release to management or publicly.
Communicating Results
We communicate the results of each engagement in both formal and informal ways. We strive to
communicate results to management throughout each engagement. This may include written
and verbal communication methods across meetings, phone calls, and emails.
All formal engagement results are communicated to management and senior management, as
well as the Audit Committee. Each formal results communications will include conclusions on
the engagement, where appropriate. For audits, this includes conclusions on the specific audit
objectives.
Themes across multiple engagements are communicated to senior management and the Audit
Committee informally in meetings; however, reports are typically not issued to communicate
these themes.
The department does not issue conclusions at the department or City level. This is not required
or typically expected by senior management or City leaders.
Special Considerations
The Internal Audit Department recognizes that information in our audit reports has the potential
to be miscommunicated, misinterpreted, and taken out of context by the public, media, and
politicians to gain political advantage. In order to protect the independence of the Internal Audit
Department and to ensure that information is accurately communicated during an election
season, no final internal audit reports shall be issued on a City election day for the offices of
Mayor, City Council, or City Judge, nor for a period of thirty days prior to the start of early voting
through the day of the election. For other elections, report release may be restricted at the
discretion of the Audit Committee by majority vote.
Audit reports are a public record; however, there are exceptions outlined in Tennessee Code
Annotated that may require special treatment of reports. TCA Section 10-7-504 lists various
types of information which are considered confidential. If there is a question about whether the
information contained in an audit report is confidential, the Director should consult with the City
Internal Audit Manual
Page 39 of 52
Attorney to determine whether any portion of the report should be redacted prior to release.
Outside of these circumstances, there are no limitations on the distribution and use of the
results.
While audit reports are public records, the workpapers of local government internal audit
activities are considered confidential and are not open to public inspection per TCA 10-7-504.
Errors and Omissions
In the event that errors or omissions are identified after the report is released, the Director must
discuss the level of significance with the Audit Committee. If errors are determined to be
significant, the Director must communicate corrected information to all parties who received the
original communication. Since the audit report is a public record, this will involve working with
the City’s communications department to draft a press release to notify the public users of the
report.
Communicating the Acceptance of Risks
In the event the Director concludes that management has accepted a level of risk that may be
unacceptable to the City, the Director will bring the issue to the attention of senior
management. If the matter is not resolved by senior management, the Director will elevate the
issue through the City Council and Audit Committee. In accordance with this standard, it is not
the Director’s responsibility to resolve the risk.
Policy Revision History
Revision Date January 30,2025 Revision Approval
Initial Date October 25, 2024 Initial Approval October 30, 2024
Internal Audit Manual
Page 40 of 52
Source: City of Clarksville website. First collected Nov 22, 2026.