RecordWell Data

Audit Committee — Agenda

City of Clarksville · Montgomery County · Audit Committee · meeting of Oct 30, 2024 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Clarksville

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

AUDIT COMMITTEE AGENDA DATE: October 30, 2024 LOCATION: CITY HALL FOURTH FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM TIME: 3:00 PM I. CALL TO ORDER - Chairperson II. ANNOUNCE MEMBERS IN ATTENDANCE (VERIFY QUORUM) III. ADOPTION OF MINUTES: July 31, 2024 Audit Commiee Meeng IV. DEPARTMENT REPORT A. Budget Report B. Update on Internal Audit Acvity C. Discussion of Strategic Plan, Charters, and Revised Policies V. NEW BUSINESS A. None VI. COMMITTEE ACTION REQUIRED A. Audit Commiee Candidate Consideraon B. Strategic Plan, Charter, and Policy Approval VII. CITY COUNCIL ACTION REQUIRED A. Nominaon of Audit Commiee Members for January 2025 - December 2026 VIII. ADJOURNMENT OF PUBLIC MEETING IX. PUBLIC COMMENTS (5 minutes each) X. NEXT MEETING - January 29, 2025 3:00 PM XI. EXECUTIVE SESSION - Vote by Commiee to go into execuve session. During execuve session and for the remainder of the meeng, the Audit Commiee will be discussing only maers that are considered confidenal under TCA Secon 9-3-405 (d). These items may include: A. Items deemed not subject to inspecon under TCA Secon 10-7-503 and 10-7-504 B. Current or pending ligaon and pending legal controversies C. Pending or ongoing audits or audit related invesgaons D. Informaon protected by federal law E. Maers involving informaon under TCA Secons 9-3-406 where the informant has requested anonymity. At this point in the meeng everyone other than Audit Commiee members and those asked to aend by the Audit Commiee to address an item related to the categories above will be asked to leave. XII. ADJOURNMENT OF EXECUTIVE SESSION UNAPPROVED AUDIT COMMITTEE MINUTES DATE: July 31, 2024 LOCATION: City Hall 4th Floor Conference Room TIME: 3:00 PM I. CALL TO ORDER – Chairperson The meeng was called to order by Jennifer Thayer at 3:01pm. II. ANNOUNCE MEMBERS IN ATTENDANCE (VERIFY QUORUM) Audit Commiee members present: Jennifer Thayer, Elizabeth Rankin, Karen Reynolds, Patrick Wilkinson Audit Commiee members absent: Trey Judd Quorum verified? Yes Internal Audit aendees: Stephanie Fox, Jenn Osteen, Rebecca Darden, Emily Hammer Other Aendees: None III. ADOPTION OF MINUTES: April 24, 2024 Audit Commiee Meeng A. Karen Reynolds made a moon to adopt the minutes for April 24, 2024. Elizabeth Rankin seconded the moon. The moon was approved unanimously. IV. DEPARTMENT REPORT Stephanie presented the following department reports. A. Budget Reports i. FY 2024 ii. FY 2025 B. Update on Internal Audit Acvity C. Quality Assurance and Improvement Program - Annual Review Results Stephanie presented the results of the department’s annual quality review for FY 2024. D. Annual Report Stephanie presented the dra of the department’s annual report. E. Discussion of Internal Audit Charter, Mandatory Guidance, and Organizaonal Independence within Red Book UNAPPROVED Stephanie presented informaon about the following items in accordance with auding standards: ● Audit Commiee charter ● Internal Audit department charter ● Organizaonal independence of the department ● Mandatory guidance components within the Internaonal Professional Pracces Framework V. NEW BUSINESS A. Discussion of Potenal New Commiee Members One new Audit Commiee member will be needed starng in January 2025 to replace Dr. Jennifer Thayer. The Audit Commiee will nominate a candidate to fill that vacancy, and that candidate will be presented to the City Council for confirmaon. VI. COMMITTEE ACTION REQUIRED A. FY 2025 Audit Plan Approval Stephanie presented the dra risk-based audit plan for FY 2025. Elizabeth Rankin made a moon to approve the FY 2025 Audit Plan. Patrick Wilkinson seconded. The moon was approved unanimously. B. Internal Audit Charter Approval Patrick Wilkinson made a moon to approve the Internal Audit Charter. Councilperson Karen Reynolds seconded. The moon was approved unanimously. VII. CITY COUNCIL ACTION REQUIRED A. None VIII. ADJOURNMENT OF PUBLIC MEETING Elizabeth Rankin made a moon to adjourn the public meeng and go into execuve session. Councilperson Karen Reynolds seconded. Public meeng was adjourned at 3:42 pm. IX. PUBLIC COMMENTS (5 minutes each) X. NEXT MEETING - October 30, 2024 at 3:00 PM XI. EXECUTIVE SESSION – Vote by the Commiee to go into execuve session. During execuve session and for the remainder of the meeng, the Audit Commiee will be discussing only maers that are considered confidenal under TCA Secon 9-3-405 (d). These items may include: A. Items deemed not subject to inspecon under TCA Secon 10-7-503 and 10-7-504 B. Current or pending ligaon and pending legal controversies C. Pending or ongoing audits or audit related invesgaons D. Informaon protected by federal law E. Maers involving informaon under TCA Secon 9-3-406 where the informant has requested anonymity. UNAPPROVED At this point in the meeng everyone other than Audit Commiee members and those asked to aend by the Audit Commiee to address an item related to the categories above will be asked to leave. The following topics were discussed: A. Ongoing audits and Invesgaons XII. ADJOURNMENT OF EXECUTIVE SESSION The execuve session was adjourned at 4:09 pm. CITY OF CLARKSVILLE YEAR-TO-DATE BUDGET REPORT Report generated: 10/25/2024 11:05 User: sfox Program ID: glytdbud Page 1 FOR 2025 13 ORIGINAL TRANFRS/ REVISED AVAILABLE PCT APPROP ADJSTMTS BUDGET YTD EXPENDED ENCUMBRANCES BUDGET USED 1100 General Fund 10415211 Salaries and Wages-Inter.Audit 10415211 4111 Full-Time Employe 332,599 0 332,599 88,478.31 .00 244,120.69 26.6% 10415211 4112 Part-Time Employe 2,700 0 2,700 .00 .00 2,700.00 .0% 10415211 4113 Longevity Pay 450 0 450 .00 .00 450.00 .0% 10415211 4211 Health Insurance 60,096 0 60,096 20,032.00 .00 40,064.00 33.3% 10415211 4212 Dental Insurance 1,680 0 1,680 552.00 .00 1,128.00 32.9% 10415211 4213 Life Insurance 212 0 212 69.76 .00 142.24 32.9% 10415211 4214 Disability Insura 1,432 0 1,432 380.44 .00 1,051.56 26.6% 10415211 4221 Social Security C 24,622 0 24,622 6,420.36 .00 18,201.64 26.1% 10415211 4231 TCRS Contribution 41,737 0 41,737 9,979.36 .00 31,757.64 23.9% TOTAL Salaries and Wages-Inter.Audit 465,528 0 465,528 125,912.23 .00 339,615.77 27.0% 10415213 Operating Expenditures-Int.Aud 10415213 4321 Employee Training 14,635 0 14,635 844.88 .00 13,790.12 5.8% 10415213 4322 Memberships & Con 1,940 0 1,940 350.00 .00 1,590.00 18.0% 10415213 4323 Employee Testing 105 0 105 .00 .00 105.00 .0% 10415213 4325 Software Renewals 965 0 965 308.82 .00 656.18 32.0% 10415213 4334 Accounting/Auditi 92,000 0 92,000 .00 .00 92,000.00 .0% 10415213 4442 Rental of Equipme 120 0 120 30.49 60.77 28.74 76.1% 10415213 4521 Property Insuranc 335 0 335 329.00 .00 6.00 98.2% 10415213 4523 General Liability 665 0 665 631.00 .00 34.00 94.9% 10415213 4530 Communications 375 0 375 75.29 .00 299.71 20.1% 10415213 4580 Travel 300 0 300 .00 .00 300.00 .0% 10415213 4610 General Supplies 2,100 0 2,100 .00 .00 2,100.00 .0% 10415213 4640 Books & Periodica 2,100 0 2,100 608.39 .00 1,491.61 29.0% TOTAL Operating Expenditures-Int.Aud 115,640 0 115,640 3,177.87 60.77 112,401.36 2.8% GRAND TOTAL 581,168 0 581,168 129,090.10 60.77 452,017.13 22.2% ** END OF REPORT - Generated by Fox, Stephanie ** 110/25/2024 Internal Audit DepartmentAudit Commiee ReportOctober 2024 Project Stascs Senior ManagementExpense (CY 2021-2022) Building and Codes CG Contract Management CGW Contract Management CG Petty Cash CFR Overtime FY 2025 Ethics Survey 0% 25% 50% 75% 100% Project Status Senior Management Expense (CY 2021-2022) Building and Codes CG Contract Management CGW Contract Management CG Petty Cash CFR Overtime FY 2025 Ethics Survey 100.00 900.00 500.00 500.00 400.00 600.00 300.00 120.00 701.75 171.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 384.00 789.00 171.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 FY 2025 Budgeted HoursFY 2025 Actual HoursTotal Project Hours 112112 158158 229229 229229 149149 137137 7272 7272 Audits & Other Engagements 0 50 100 150 200 250 SeniorManagementExpense (CY2021-2022) Building andCodes CG ContractManagementCGW ContractManagementCG Petty CashCFR Overtime FY 2025 EthicsSurvey PLANNED DAYS ACTUAL DAYS Engagement Duration 210/25/2024 Internal Audit DepartmentAudit Commiee ReportOctober 2024 Hotline Stascs Staff Metrics Percent of Required 40 Hours Completed for CY 2024 Auditor Stephanie Jennifer Emily Rebecca 0% 25% 50% 75% 2024 Continuing Education Hours 0.00% 20.00% 40.00% 60.00% 80.00% JulyAugust SeptemberOctober NovemberDecemberJanuar y Februar y MarchAprilMay June Target UtilizationActual Utilization Audit Utilization Rate - Stephanie 0.00% 20.00% 40.00% 60.00% 80.00% JulyAugust SeptemberOctober NovemberDecemberJanuar y Februar y MarchAprilMay June Target UtilizationActual Utilization Audit Utilization Rate - Jenn 0.00% 20.00% 40.00% 60.00% 80.00% JulyAugust SeptemberOctober NovemberDecemberJanuar y Februar y MarchAprilMay June Target UtilizationActual Utilization Audit Utilization Rate - Emily 0.00% 20.00% 40.00% 60.00% 80.00% JulyAugust SeptemberOctober NovemberDecemberJanuar y Februar y MarchAprilMay June Target UtilizationActual Utilization Audit Utilization Rate - Becca Open Closed Total Reports for FY 2025 0 12 12 Report Status Previously Reported New Reports Department Mandate The City of Clarksville’s Internal Audit department was initially established, along with the Audit Committee, on November 1, 2001. On that date, the City Council established the department as an independent appraisal function within the city government by adopting Ordinance 25-2001-02. The applicable code sections were updated 4 times from 2003 through 2008, and the current version of the code pertaining to internal audit was adopted in 2014. Currently, City Charter Article VI Section 5 and City Code Title 6 Section 6 outline the department’s mandate. Authority - In addition to providing for the existence of an audit committee and department of internal audit, both the City Charter and City Code establish that the department reports directly to the Audit Committee, both administratively and functionally. Additionally, both documents grant the department full unrestricted access to all City records, properties, and personnel relevant to areas under review. This authority and access extends to all city departments, component units, and any other organization or individual that receives city funds. Further, the City Code grants free and unrestricted access to both the Mayor and City Council. Roles - The City Charter and City Code direct the department to conduct financial, performance, and other audit functions and services determined by the Audit Committee. The director’s only roles and responsibilities lie within internal audit. Responsibilities - The City Codes defines the purpose of the department as follows, “To assist all levels of management of the city and its component units in the eective discharge of their responsibilities by furnishing them with analyses, appraisals, recommendations, counsel, and information concerning the activities reviewed by internal audit and promoting eective control at reasonable cost.” We fulfill this purpose by providing both audit and consulting services for City departments, as well as administering the City’s fraud hotline. Scope/Internal Audit Services - Section 6-613 of the City Code describes the scope of internal audit activities as “the examination and evaluation of the adequacy and Strategic Plan 2024 City of Clarksville Internal Audit eectiveness of the city’s system of internal control structure and the quality of performance in carrying out assigned responsibilities to achieve the city's stated goals and objectives.” This section also provides additional details on the types of work that are included in the scope stated above. Our Vision To be a trusted advisor, enhancing organizational value and transparency through insightful and proactive audit and consulting services. Our Mission To ensure public trust and promote transparency, accountability, eciency, and continuous improvement throughout City government. Our Values Integrity - Uphold the highest standards of honesty and ethical behavior in all audit activities. Objectivity - Perform our work in an independent manner, free from bias. Continuous Improvement - Commit to ongoing enhancement of our audit processes and personal professional development to better serve the City and adapt to changing environments. Collaboration - Work together with City leaders and stakeholders to address concerns and achieve shared goals. Transparency - Commit to open and clear communication, ensuring that all stakeholders, including city residents, understand our processes and findings. Excellence - Strive for the highest quality in our audit practices and continuous improvement in our skills and processes. Innovation - Embrace and adapt new methodologies and technologies to enhance the eectiveness and eciency of our audit processes. Alignment with City of Clarksville Our department’s vision, mission, and values align with the City’s goals of transparency and eciency and eectiveness of service for citizens. City of Clarksville Vision “One Clarksville” City of Clarksville Mission Strategic Objectives Strategic Objective 1 - Enhance the knowledge and competencies of auditors and the department to provide audits and consulting engagements of the highest quality. Supporting Initiative #1 Supporting Initiative #2 Supporting Initiative #3 Strategic Objective 2 - Improve eciency and eectiveness of department processes Supporting Initiative #1 Supporting Initiative #2 First choice for residents and industry led by an ecient, eective and transparent City government focused on quality of life. Clarksville city government will provide exceptional services in an innovative and responsible manner to enhance the quality of life for the community. Establish individual development plans for each auditor that identify areas for development of additional skills and competency. Measures: Creation/implementation of a development plan for each auditor, percentage completion of quarterly meetings. Maintaining a minimum level of 40 hours of continuing education for each calendar year. Measures: Conducting four development discussions with each auditor during FY 2025. Provide support for additional certifications and continuing education for auditors. Measures: Implementation of a policy related to equity adjustments for certain additional certifications, Number of auditors pursuing additional certifications. Implementation of a quality assurance and improvement plan that is focused on continuous improvement within the department. Measures: Number of improvements to processes made as a result of quality assurance and improvement program components. Alignment with Global Internal Audit Standards to ensure high quality and eciency in operations. Supporting Initiative #3 Strategic Objective 3 - Leverage technology to enhance risk coverage and provide high quality service to City management Supporting Initiative #1 Supporting Initiative #2 Supporting Initiative #3 Strategic Objective 4 - Enhance communication, collaboration, and trust with all City departments Supporting Initiative #1 Supporting Initiative #2 Supporting Initiative #3 Measures: Implementation of standards and associated processes by January 2025, results of annual quality reviews that indicate conformance with standards, successful completion of a peer review. Enhance eciency in completing engagements Measures: Completion of projects on annual audit plan, percentage of time meeting engagement milestone dates, variance in budgeted and actual engagement hours. Expand use of data analytics in engagements Measures: Percentage of engagements which utilize data analytics, types of data analytics used in engagements Implement audit management software Measures: Evaluating software options, budgeting for implementation cost Incorporate the use of artificial intelligence in engagements, where appropriate Measures: Identifying possible use cases, establishing departmental guidelines Improve frequency and quality of communication with management during engagements Measures: Establishing regular engagement updates to be provided at periodic intervals, improve report format, implement observation rating system Increase management utilization of consulting oerings and technical assistance Measures: Number of requests for technical assistance, number of request for consulting projects Enhance stakeholder engagement and feedback Measures: Increase survey response rate, improve post engagement survey format and questions City of Clarksville Internal Audit Manual Subject Table of Contents 00 - Charter ......................................................................................................... 2 01 - Ethics and Professionalism ........................................................................... 9 02 - Quality Assurance and Improvement Program ........................................... 1 6 03 - Annual Risk Assessment and Audit Plan ..................................................... 2 0 04 - Resource Management .............................................................................. 2 4 05 - Performing Audit Services .......................................................................... 2 6 06 - Performing Consulng Services .................................................................. 3 3 07 - Communicaon .......................................................................................... 3 4 08 - Supervision ................................................................................................ 38 09 - Fraud, Invesgaons, and Hotline Administraon ...................................... 40 10 - Office Administraon ................................................................................. 44 Internal Audit Manual Page 1 of 49 City of Clarksville Internal Audit Manual Policy Number 00 Review Cycle Annual Subject Charter Audit Commiee Purpose The Audit Commiee of the City of Clarksville is established in Arcle VI Secon 5 of the City of Clarksville Charter (the City Charter) and Clarksville City Code (City Code) Secon 6-603 to provide an independent review and oversight of the City’s financial reporng processes and the City’s internal controls. The Audit Commiee also reviews the external auditors’ reports and follows up on management’s correcve acon and compliance with laws, regulaons, and ethics. Addionally, the Audit Commiee also provides oversight of the Internal Audit Department’s independent appraisal funcon. Authority and Responsibilies To establish, maintain, and assure that the City of Clarksville's Internal Audit Department has sufficient authority to fulfill its dues, the Audit Commiee will: ● Discuss the Internal Audit Mandate with the Director, including the appropriate authority, role, and responsibilies of Internal Audit. ● Discuss and approve the Internal Audit Department’s charter annually. ● Champion the department to enable it to fulfill the purpose of internal auding and pursue its strategy and objecves. ● Approve the risk-based internal audit plan as described in City Code Secon 6-615(a). ● Guide and direct the Director of Internal Audit. ● Approve the Internal Audit Department’s budget and resource plan, subject to approval of the overall budget of the City approved by the City Council. ● Receive communicaons from the Director of Internal Audit on the Internal Audit Department’s performance relave to its plan and other maers. ● Approve decisions regarding the appointment and removal of the Director of Internal Audit as described in the City Charter and City Code Secon 6-614(f). ● Review and evaluate the performance of the Director of Internal Audit in accordance with the City Charter and City Code Secon 6-614(e). ● Fix the compensaon of the Director of Internal Audit within the amount appropriated therefore by the City Council as described in the City Charter. ● Make appropriate inquiries of management and the Director of Internal Audit to determine whether there are inappropriate scope or resource limitaons. Internal Audit Manual Page 2 of 49 ● Review and select, pursuant to state law of general applicaon, the external auditors required by the City, to include all City departments and acvies, and blended component units, for financial, performance, internal, or other special audits per City Code Secon 6-609. The awarding of all external audit contracts shall be at the discreon of the Audit Commiee, except that discretely presented component units may select their own external auditor. No member of the Audit Commiee shall be a member of any audit firm that is awarded an audit engagement. ● Review the external auditors' reports and follow up on management's correcve acon and compliance with laws, regulaons, and ethics in accordance with City Code Secon 6-603. ● Adhere to all remaining City Code secons pertaining to the Clarksville Audit Commiee not specifically listed within this Charter. Internal Audit Department Purpose and Mission In accordance with the City of Clarksville’s City Code (City Code) Secon 6-602, the purpose of the Internal Audit Department is to assist all levels of management of the City and its component units in the effecve discharge of their responsibilies by furnishing them with analyses, appraisals, recommendaons, counsel, and informaon concerning the acvies reviewed by Internal Audit and promong effecve control at reasonable cost. In addion to the purpose as defined in City Code, Internal Audit adheres to the purpose statement in Domain I of the Global Internal Audit Standards. In support of the established purpose, the department’s mission statement is to ensure public trust and promote transparency, accountability, efficiency, and connuous improvement throughout City government. To fulfill this purpose and mission, the department will provide audit and consulng services related to City operaons to management and those charged with governance. These services will be provided in an objecve and independent manner. Services may address areas of internal controls, operaonal efficiency and effecveness, compliance with laws and regulaons, or financial integrity. The department provides a risk based, systemac, disciplined approach to evaluate and improve the effecveness of governance, risk management, and control processes throughout the City. This approach helps the City accomplish its objecves and fulfill its responsibility to cizens and the resources they have entrusted to the City. Internaonal Professional Pracces Framework and Global Internal Audit Standards As required by City Code Secon 6-610, the City of Clarksville Internal Audit Department will govern itself by adherence to the mandatory elements of The Instute of Internal Auditors' (IIA) Internaonal Professional Pracces Framework (IPPF), including the Global Internal Audit Internal Audit Manual Page 3 of 49 Standards (the Standards). In addion, Internal Audit will adhere to the policies and procedures contained in the Internal Audit Department's manual, as approved by the Audit Commiee. Mandate Authority The City of Clarksville Charter Arcle VI (the City Charter) establishes the existence of a Department of Internal Audit as an independent agency of the City of Clarksville government, which shall be headed by a Director of Internal Audit. The Director of Internal Audit shall be a cerfied public accountant meeng the requirements of City Code Secon 6-614(b), and will report funconally and administravely to the City Audit Commiee (Audit Commiee) as required by the Charter. Addionally, both the City Charter, Arcle VI Secon 5(e) and the City Code Secon 6-611 state that authority is granted for full, free, and unrestricted access to any and all of the City's records, physical properes, and personnel relevant to any funcon under review. Internal Audit's authority shall extend to all City departments, component units, and any other organizaon or individual that receives City funds. All employees shall assist Internal Audit in fulfilling their staff funcon. Internal Audit shall also have free and unrestricted access to the Mayor and the City Council. The Director of Internal Audit will have unrestricted access to, and communicate and interact directly with, the Audit Commiee, including in meengs without management present in accordance with TCA 9-3-405(d). The Audit Commiee also authorizes the Internal Audit Department to allocate resources, set frequencies, select subjects, determine scopes of work, apply audit techniques required to accomplish audit objecves, and issue reports. Further, the Audit Commiee authorizes the department to obtain assistance or specialized services from within or outside the City of Clarksville where required to complete engagements. This is subject to budgetary constraints. Roles The City Charter and City Code direct the department to conduct financial, performance, and other audit funcons and services determined by the Audit Commiee. The Director has no roles or responsibilies outside of the Internal Audit Department. Responsibilies As noted in the purpose secon of this charter, the department has a responsibility to assist all levels of management of the City and its component units in the effecve discharge of their responsibilies by furnishing them with analyses, appraisals, recommendaons, counsel, and informaon concerning the acvies reviewed by the department and promong effecve control at reasonable cost. Internal Audit Manual Page 4 of 49 The Internal Audit Department fulfills this purpose by providing an array of audit and consulng services for City departments, as well as administering the City’s fraud hotline. Further details on the services provided can be found in the Scope of Work secon of this charter. Independence and Organizaonal Posion Both the Director of Internal Audit and the Internal Audit Department are structured within the City to ensure independence. The City Charter and City Code both support this independence by establishing that the Director reports both funconally and administravely to the Audit Commiee, rather than the Mayor or City Council. The City Charter and City Code also outline the responsibilies of the Audit Commiee to support those reporng relaonships. Further, City Code Secon 6-612 states that all audit acvies shall remain free of influence by any element in the organizaon, including maers of audit scope, procedures, frequency, ming, or report content to permit maintenance of an independent mental atude necessary in rendering objecve reports. Internal auditors shall have no direct operaonal responsibility or authority over any of the acvies they review. Addionally, they shall not develop nor install systems or procedures, prepare records, or engage in any other acvity that would normally be audited. Independence and objecvity in performing internal audit services are the responsibility of every auditor. Auditors must recognize actual, potenal, or perceived impairments to independence or objecvity, and immediately bring those to the Director to be addressed. The Director of Internal Audit will confirm to the Audit Commiee, at least annually, the organizaonal independence of the Internal Audit Department. The Director of Internal Audit will disclose to the Audit Commiee any potenal impairments to independence, including interference and related implicaons in determining the scope of internal auding, performing work, and/or communicang results. Scope of Work As stated in the City Code Secon 6-613, the scope of Internal Audit encompasses (but is not limited to) the examinaon and evaluaon of the adequacy and effecveness of the City's system of internal control structure and the quality of performance in carrying out assigned responsibilies to achieve the City's stated goals and objecves. These acvies, known as assurance or audit services, provide independent assessments to the Audit Commiee, the Mayor, the City Council, management, and outside pares on the adequacy and effecveness of governance, risk management, and control processes for the City of Clarksville. Internal Audit assessments include: ● Evaluang whether risks relang to the achievement of the City of Clarksville’s strategic objecves are appropriately idenfied and managed ● Evaluang whether the acons of the City of Clarkville’s governing body, directors, employees, and contractors are in compliance with the City of Clarksville’s policies, procedures, and applicable laws, regulaons, and governance standards Internal Audit Manual Page 5 of 49 ● Reviewing operaons or programs to ascertain whether results are consistent with established objecves and goals, and whether the operaons or programs are being carried out as planned ● Reviewing and appraising the economy and efficiency with which resources are employed ● Reviewing the systems established to ensure compliance with those policies, plans, procedures, laws, and regulaons, which could have a significant impact on operaons and reports, and whether the organizaon is in compliance ● Reviewing the reliability and integrity of financial and operang informaon and the means used to idenfy, measure, classify, and report such informaon ● Evaluang whether resources and assets are acquired economically, used efficiently, protected adequately, and, as appropriate, verifying the existence of such assets ● Reviewing specific operaons at the request of the Audit Commiee, Mayor, or Chief Financial Officer (also referenced as Director of Finance and Revenue), as appropriate ● Reviewing or invesgang maers at the request of the Tennessee Comptroller of the Treasury ● Reviewing the quality of performance of the external auditors and the degree of coordinaon with Internal Audit Director The Director of Internal Audit is established in the City Charter Arcle VI, Secon 5. This secon mandates that the Director shall be appointed by the Mayor upon nominaon by the Audit Commiee, subject to confirmaon by the City Council. It further specifies that the Director shall possess at least one cerficaon indicang proficiency in auding or governmental financial management, and lists acceptable types of experience and knowledge. City Code Secon 6-614 refines these requirements and specifies that the Director shall be a Cerfied Public Accountant. These requirements help ensure that the Director has the appropriate qualificaons and knowledge to carry out the Internal Audit mandate. Human resources maintains a job descripon with more specific requirements. The Director will maintain and enhance qualificaons and competencies necessary to fulfill roles and responsibilies expected by the Audit Commiee. The Director of Internal Audit has the responsibility to: ● Develop and implement a strategy for the internal audit funcon that supports the strategic objecves and success of the City. ● Review the strategy with the Audit Commiee and senior management periodically. ● Establish and evaluate methodologies to guide the department in a systemac and disciplined manner to implement internal audit strategy, develop the internal audit plan, and conform to the Standards. Internal Audit Manual Page 6 of 49 ● Submit, at least annually, to the Audit Commiee a risk-based internal audit plan for review and approval, and communicate the approved plan to senior management. ● Communicate to senior management and the Audit Commiee the impact of resource limitaons on the internal audit plan. ● Review and adjust the internal audit plan in response to changes in the City of Clarksville’s risks, operaons, programs, systems, and controls. ● Communicate to senior management and the Audit Commiee any significant interim changes to the internal audit plan. ● Communicate any changes that potenally affect the mandate or department charter. ● Submit an annual report to the City Council at the end of each fiscal year disclosing all completed audits and invesgaons. ● Ensure each engagement of the internal audit plan is executed, including the establishment of objecves and scope, the assignment of appropriate and adequately supervised resources, the documentaon of work programs and tesng results, and the communicaon of engagement results with applicable conclusions and recommendaons to appropriate pares. ● Distribute the final engagement communicaon to appropriate pares. The Director of Internal Audit is the only person who has the authority to issue an audit report. ● Follow up on engagement findings and correcve acons, and report periodically to senior management and the Audit Commiee any correcve acons not effecvely implemented. ● Ensure the principles of integrity, objecvity, confidenality, and competency are applied and upheld. ● Ensure the Internal Audit Department collecvely possesses or obtains the knowledge, skills, and other competencies needed to meet the requirements of the Internal Audit Charter. ● Ensure trends and emerging issues that could impact the City of Clarksville are considered and communicated to senior management and the Audit Commiee as appropriate. ● Ensure emerging trends and successful pracces in internal auding are considered. ● Establish and ensure adherence to policies and procedures designed to guide the Internal Audit Department. ● Ensure adherence to the City of Clarksville’s Charter, Code, and relevant policies and procedures, unless such policies and procedures conflict with the Internal Audit Charter. Any such conflicts will be resolved or otherwise communicated to senior management and the Audit Commiee. ● Ensure conformance of the Internal Audit Department with the Global Internal Audit Standards , unless the Internal Audit department is prohibited by law or regulaon from conformance with certain parts of the Standards . The Director of Internal Audit will ensure appropriate disclosures are made to senior management and the Audit Commiee and will ensure conformance with all other parts of the Standards . ● Establish a process by which employees, taxpayers, or other cizens may confidenally report suspected illegal, improper, wasteful, or fraudulent acvity in accordance with City Code Secon 6-617. Internal Audit Manual Page 7 of 49 Approval/Acknowledgement Director of Internal Audit Date Audit Commiee Chair Date Mayor of the City of Clarksville Date Internal Audit Manual Page 8 of 49 City of Clarksville Internal Audit Manual Policy Number 01 Review Cycle Annual Subject Ethics and Professionalism Purpose To define the methodologies employed by the Internal Audit Department to demonstrate ethics and professionalism in all acvies. This policy demonstrates conformance with Domain II: Ethics and Professionalism within the Global Internal Audit Standards. Definions Competency - Knowledge, skills, and abilies Independence - Freedom from condions that may impair the ability of the internal audit funcon to carry out internal audit responsibilies in an unbiased manner Objecvity - Unbiased mental atude that allows internal auditors to make professional judgments, fulfill their responsibilies, and achieve the purpose of internal auding Policy Internal Audit Department policy is to conduct themselves and their work with ethics and professionalism. In addion to providing appropriate training and connuing educaon, the department ensures that auditors behave ethically and professionally by properly supervising engagements, mentoring, and feedback in performance reviews. Annually, all staff are required to review the department’s policies and acknowledge that they understand and agree to adhere to these policies. Procedure Integrity Honesty and Professional Courage It is essenal that all auditors perform their work with honesty and professional courage, in accordance with all aspects of Standard 1.1. The standard outlines several principles that exemplify professional courage and honesty, including: ● Being truthful, accurate, clear, open, and respecul in all professional relaonships and communicaons, including those where the auditor is expressing skepcism or an opposing viewpoint ● Not making false, misleading, or decepve statements, nor concealing or oming findings or other pernent informaon from communicaons Internal Audit Manual Page 9 of 49 ● Disclosing all material facts known that, if not disclosed, could affect the City’s ability to make well-informed decisions ● Communicang truthfully and taking appropriate acons, even when confronted by difficult situaons The department supports all auditors in giving legimate, evidence-based engagement results, whether they are favorable or unfavorable. We support performing work with honesty and professional courage not only through providing ethics related training and connuing educaon, but also through proper engagement supervision, mentoring, and performance reviews. Ethical Expectaons The City has adopted a Code of Ethics that all auditors must be familiar with and abide by. In accordance with City policy, all auditors will receive training specific to the City’s Code of Ethics. If auditors idenfy behavior that is contrary to the City’s ethical expectaons, that behavior will be reported to appropriate pares. The department will encourage ethical behavior within the City by conducng ethics specific engagements, like the annual ethics survey, and providing assessments of ethics related risks and controls in individual engagements, where appropriate. In addion to adhering to the City’s ethical expectaons, the Standards require auditors to understand and abide by applicable laws and regulaons. Further, the Standards specify that auditors not engage in or be party to any acvity that is illegal or discreditable to the City or the profession. This includes any acvity that may harm the City or City employees. If auditors idenfy legal or regulatory violaons, the auditor should immediately report this to the Director so that violaons can be reported to appropriate pares. As legal requirements for reporng violaons may vary widely, these are handled based on the specific circumstances of the situaon. Adhering to the ethical and legal expectaons described above is supported by appropriate training and connuing educaon, as well as proper engagement supervision, mentoring, and feedback in performance reviews. Independence and Objecvity City Code Secon 6-612 states that all audit acvies shall remain free of influence by any element in the organizaon, including maers of audit scope, procedures, frequency, ming, or report content to permit maintenance of an independent mental atude necessary in rendering objecve reports. Internal auditors shall have no direct operaonal responsibility or authority over any of the acvies they review. Further, internal audit acvies are not considered to be part of the internal control structure of any other department. The Director of Internal Audit will ensure that the Internal Audit Department remains free from Internal Audit Manual Page 10 of 49 all condions that threaten the ability of internal auditors to carry out their responsibilies in an unbiased manner. If the Director of Internal Audit determines that independence or objecvity may be impaired in fact or appearance, the details of the impairment along with the acons taken will be disclosed to appropriate pares. Should an impairment to independence and objecvity be idenfied aer compleon of an engagement, the Director will discuss the concern with management and the Audit Commiee to determine an appropriate resoluon. Internal auditors will maintain an unbiased mental atude that allows them to perform engagements objecvely and in such a manner that they believe in their work product, that no quality compromises are made, and that they do not subordinate their judgment on audit maers to others. Internal auditors will not implement internal controls, develop procedures, install systems, prepare records, or engage in any other acvity that may impair their judgment, including: ● Assessing specific operaons for which they had responsibility within the previous year ● Performing any operaonal dues for the City of Clarksville or related enes ● Iniang or approving transacons external to the Internal Audit Department ● Direcng the acvies of any City of Clarksville employee not employed by the Internal Audit Department, except to the extent that such employees have been appropriately assigned to auding teams or to otherwise assist internal auditors The Internal Audit Department may perform audits where it had previously performed consulng services, provided the nature of the consulng did not impair objecvity and provided individual objecvity is managed when assigning resources to the engagement. Internal auditors will: ● Timely disclose any impairment of independence or objecvity, in fact or appearance, to the Director and other appropriate pares. ● Exhibit professional objecvity in gathering, evaluang, and communicang informaon about the acvity or process being examined. ● Make balanced assessments of all available and relevant facts and circumstances. ● Avoid conflicts of interest and take necessary precauons to avoid being unduly influenced by their own interests or by the interest of others in forming judgments. ● Not accept any tangible or intangible item that may impair or be presumed to impair independence. To ensure we idenfy and effecvely manage impairments, the department will evaluate auditor objecvity on an annual basis, as well as on an engagement basis. Annually, each auditor will complete an independence and objecvity form and disclose any potenal or known impairments. This annual disclosure will help the Director to appropriately assign engagements and manage resources. As noted above, auditors will nofy the Director of any changes to independence or objecvity in a mely manner. Independence and objecvity is also discussed by the audit team at the beginning of each Internal Audit Manual Page 11 of 49 engagement to ensure that we effecvely manage any potenal impairments. The Director of Internal Audit will confirm to the Audit Commiee, at least annually, the organizaonal independence of the Internal Audit Department. The Director of Internal Audit will disclose to the Audit Commiee any interference and related implicaons in determining the scope of internal auding, performing work, and/or communicang results. Competency Internal auditors must possess and connually develop the proficiency and competency to perform their responsibilies successfully. This includes thorough knowledge of the Standards. Further, auditors should only engage in services for which they have the necessary competencies. A departmental goal is to connually develop auditor competencies and skills by providing appropriate training, mentoring and supervision in alignment with policy 08, and opportunies to expand competency. In support of this goal, we have developed the following requirements for connuing professional educaon. Auditors are also required to track and adhere to requirements of any cerficaons or professional designaons they may hold. The Internal Audit staff is required to complete 40 hours of connuing professional educaon (CPE) annually. The topics should be related to auding, accounng, general government operaons (any service provided by the government), informaon technology, fraud, or any other topic as approved by the Director. The department can ulize the network of various organizaons, including the Instute of Internal Auditors (IIA), the Associaon of Local Government Auditors (ALGA), etc to obtain knowledge, skills, and competencies. Each year the Internal Audit Department budget will include funding for training, pending approval of the City Council. Of the 40 annual hours of required CPE, at least 2 of those hours must be in the field of ethics and 1 hour must be in the field of informaon technology. Auditors will maintain a CPE log in the Internal Audit shared drive. CPE cerficates will also be stored as evidence of CPE compleon. Auditors will also maintain a professional profile to demonstrate competency, which should include educaon, cerficaons, and memberships/involvement in professional organizaons or associaons (including board or volunteer posions). Knowledge, skills, and competencies are evaluated at various mes throughout the year, including during development of the audit plan and at the beginning of each engagement. The Director performs an assessment of knowledge, skills, and competency during the risk assessment and audit plan development process. This helps the Director ensure the department Internal Audit Manual Page 12 of 49 has sufficient competency to perform planned engagements, and assists with assigning appropriate resources for each engagement. Addionally, knowledge, skills, and competencies of the audit team are assessed at the beginning of each engagement to ensure they are appropriate and sufficient. Due Professional Care The department will plan and perform internal audit services in accordance with the Global Internal Audit Standards. The methodologies established in this manual are wrien specifically for alignment and conformance. The department must also adhere to the City Charter and City Code, as well as applicable secons of Tennessee Code Annotated. In accordance with City Code Secon 6-610, all audit reports will include a conformance statement. If there are circumstances where the department is unable to conform with a requirement in the Standards, the Director will document and communicate the circumstance, alternave acons taken, the impact of those acons, and the raonale. The department will perform all work with due professional care, applying the expected care and skill of a reasonably prudent person and competent internal auditor. Notably, this standard of due professional care does not imply infallibility. Policies and procedures of the department, as well as our standard template workpapers, are designed specifically to adhere to the standards, including due professional care standards. Our planning and tesng workpapers consider the following items from standard 4.2: ● The organizaon’s strategy and objecves ● The interests of those for whom internal audit services are provided and the interests of other stakeholders ● Adequacy and effecveness of governance, risk management, and control processes ● Cost relave to potenal benefits of the internal audit services to be performed ● Extent and meliness of work needed to achieve engagement objecves ● Relave complexity, materiality, or significance of risks to the acvity under review ● Probability of significant errors, fraud, noncompliance, and other risks that might affect objecves, operaons, or resources ● Use of appropriate techniques, tools, and technology In addion to designing our process for adherence to the Standards, Internal Audit staff will sign an annual acknowledgement to adhere to the Standards and the department’s policies and procedures. The department’s quality assurance and improvement program and methodology for engagement supervision assist in ensuring compliance with the Standards and department policies, further evidencing due professional care. Internal Audit Manual Page 13 of 49 Skepcism All Internal Audit staff will exercise professional skepcism in all engagements, and make objecve judgments based on facts. To exercise professional skepcism, all auditors must: ● Maintain an atude that includes inquisiveness ● Crically assess the reliability of informaon ● Be straighorward and honest when raising concerns and asking quesons about inconsistencies ● Seek addional evidence to make a judgment about informaon and statements that might be incomplete, inconsistent, false, or misleading Engagement supervision and feedback during each engagement help ensure that professional skepcism is pracced by all auditors. Confidenality Use of Informaon The City Charter and City Code provide Internal Audit with full, unrestricted access to any and all City records, properes, and personnel relevant to any funcon under review. This authority allows access to all informaon that would otherwise be considered a public record in the State of Tennessee, but also allows access to informaon that is confidenal and not subject to public disclosure. Therefore, it is essenal that we establish expectaons and processes to ensure informaon accessed is both protected and used appropriately. The department will adhere to all relevant policies, procedures, laws, and regulaons when accessing and using informaon. A variety of these may apply, including internal City policies, as well as secons of Tennessee Code Annotated. In accordance with City Code Secon 1-606, informaon accessed may not be used for personal purposes or in any manner detrimental to the City or department. Safeguarding Informaon All informaon and documents, whether physical or electronic, are to be safeguarded in accordance with department and City policies. Auditors must be aware and demonstrate their responsibilies and respect for protecng informaon. This is especially true for informaon that is not a public record, including informaon that is personal in nature. Any documents that contain social security numbers, protected health informaon, or personally idenfiable informaon should be kept in a secure locaon or appropriately electronically safeguarded. To ensure security of electronic informaon, computer passwords should not be shared and computers should be locked when an auditor is away from their desk. Internal Audit Manual Page 14 of 49 When no staff members are present in the office for an extended period of me, the door to the department should be closed. Auditors should maintain the security of their assigned keys. Physical documents within the department should be properly stored during auditor absences such as lunch, outside meengs, overnight, and weekends. All informaon that is no longer needed will be disposed of in accordance with applicable City policies. Workpaper Confidenality and Retenon Unl the final audit report is issued, audit documentaon and audit findings are subject to change. Therefore, audit related materials should not be released to anyone without the express approval of the Director to ensure there is a legal or professional responsibility to do so. Audit work in progress is confidenal and staff should not discuss audit work with others outside the Internal Audit Department except with appropriate individuals. All audit reports are considered a public record, and barring certain provisions described in policy 07, there are no restricons on the release of those reports. However, the workpapers of local government internal audit acvies are considered confidenal and not open to public inspecon per TCA 10-7-504. Workpapers are retained for 10 years from the issuance date of the associated report. Policy Revision History Revision Date N/A Revision Approval N/A Inial Date October 25, 2024 Inial Approval Internal Audit Manual Page 15 of 49 City of Clarksville Internal Audit Manual Policy Number 02 Review Cycle Annual Subject Quality Assurance and Improvement Program Purpose To define the department’s quality assurance and improvement program as required by Global Internal Audit Standards (Standards). This policy demonstrates compliance with standards 8.3, 8.4, 12.1, 12.2, and 12.3. Definions Quality assurance and improvement program - A program established by the chief audit execuve to evaluate and ensure the internal audit funcon conforms with the Global Internal Audit Standards, achieves performance objecves, and pursues connuous improvement. The program includes internal and external assessments. Stakeholder - A party with a direct or indirect interest in an organizaon’s acvies and outcomes. Stakeholders may include board, management, employees, customers, vendors, shareholders, regulatory agencies, financial instuons, external auditors, the public, and others. Policy It is the responsibility of the Director to develop and maintain the quality assurance and improvement program (QAIP) to adhere to requirements in the Standards. The QAIP includes both internal and external assessments, the results of which will be communicated to the Audit Commiee as required. (8.3) The QAIP is intended to assess the adequacy of the department’s conformance with the Standards, the City’s Code of Ethics, and the department’s charter and policies. Procedure External Assessments An external assessment (peer review) shall be performed once every 5 years by an independent, qualified assessment team, which must include at least one acve Cerfied Internal Auditor. In this assessment, the peer review team will assess the adequacy of the department’s QAIP, as well as conformance with the Standards. Compleon of an external assessment is conngent upon approval of funding for the review through the budget process. If in any case funding is not approved for a peer review and the Internal Audit Manual Page 16 of 49 external assessment is not performed within the 5 year me frame, audit reports will include appropriate disclosure unl such me as the external review is completed. Results of each peer review will be communicated to the Audit Commiee and senior management at the next regularly scheduled Audit Commiee meeng. This communicaon will include: ● Scope and frequency of the peer review ● Competencies and independence of the assessment team ● Complete results of the assessment ● Acon plans to address deficiencies and opportunies for improvement, where applicable, along with melines for compleon Acon plans must be approved by the Audit Commiee and agreed to by the Mayor. The final results leer will also be posted to the Internal Audit website. Internal Assessments Periodic Self Assessments A periodic self assessment (annual quality review) will be conducted annually by the Director or their designee. This assessment will mimic an external assessment by using peer review resources from the Associaon of Local Government Auditors as guiding documents. The objecve of this self assessment is to evaluate the following: ● Adequacy of the department’s policies and procedures (methodologies) ● How well the department supports achievement of the City’s objecves ● Quality of internal audit services performed and supervision provided ● Degree to which stakeholder expectaons are met and performance objecves are achieved ● Conformance with the standards In order to accomplish these objecves, the scope of this assessment includes a review of the following: ● Department policies and procedures ● Engagement documentaon for a sample of engagements completed during the review period ● Connuing professional educaon documentaon from the most recent complete calendar year ● Data for performance measures established in the Performance Measurement secon of this policy (12.2) Should this assessment idenfy any deficiencies or opportunies for improvement, the Director will develop acon plans to resolve those deficiencies, along with associated melines for implementaon to correct those deficiencies. Internal Audit Manual Page 17 of 49 Results of the annual quality review will be communicated to the Audit Commiee and senior management directly, and posted to the Internal Audit website. A summary of results will also be included in the annual report issued to the Mayor, City Council, and Audit Commiee. Results will also be provided for use during the department's external assessment. Ongoing Monitoring Ongoing monitoring is performed throughout the year and includes mulple components. Supervision: Each engagement is supervised from planning to communicaon of results by the Director (or their designee). This allows the Director to provide mely feedback to auditors, and ensures that all components of the engagement conform to the Standards. Further details about engagement supervision can be found in policy 08. Templates: Auditors use standard workpaper templates for planning, test work, and reporng in each engagement. Each template is designed to incorporate applicable standards to ensure conformance. These workpaper templates are updated from me to me as process changes occur or as process efficiencies are idenfied and implemented. Engagement Level Quality Review: An engagement level quality review is performed at the end of each engagement to ensure conformance with the Standards and evidence of proper supervision. When possible, this is performed by an auditor who has had no involvement in the engagement. However, the Director may also perform this review. Engagement Debrief: At the end of each engagement, the audit team conducts several discussions to idenfy potenal deficiencies or opportunies for improvement. These include a discussion of resources used to complete the engagement, a discussion of engagement results (to include quality assurance results and impact on future engagements), and an evaluaon of the engagement with a focus on refining and improving processes. Performance Measurement: To fulfill the Internal Audit mandate, it is essenal that we monitor performance and progress. The Director must establish objecves and associated measurements to evaluate performance. These objecves will consider input and expectaons of the Audit Commiee and senior management. The Director will review established performance objecves and measures annually, and present them to the Audit Commiee for approval. The performance objecves are as follows: A. To complete engagements efficiently and effecvely Internal Audit Manual Page 18 of 49 B. To perform invesgaons efficiently and effecvely C. Address appropriate risk areas D. Comply with auding standards To measure our progress toward these objecves, the department has established the set of indicators listed below. These metrics are reported to the Audit Commiee periodically. ● Reported quarterly ○ Progress toward compleon of audit plan, including the status of each planned engagement ○ Actual vs planned days to complete an engagement ○ Actual vs budgeted hours for each engagement ○ Audit me ulizaon rates, which is a rao of me spent on engagement related acvies to working hours ○ Compleon of 40 hours of connuing professional educaon annually in approved topics ● Reported annually ○ Results of annual quality review In addion to the established performance metrics, a post engagement survey will also be sent to management to gather feedback about the audit process and their audit experience. Results of these surveys will be used to idenfy issues and make performance improvements. Policy Revision History Revision Date N/A Revision Approval N/A Inial Date October 25, 2024 Inial Approval Internal Audit Manual Page 19 of 49 City of Clarksville Internal Audit Manual Policy Number 03 Review Cycle Annual Subject Annual Risk Assessment and Audit Plan Purpose To define the department’s annual risk assessment and audit plan development process as required by Global Internal Audit Standards (the Standards). This policy demonstrates compliance with standard 9.1, 9.4, and 9.5. Definions Risk assessment - The idenficaon and analysis of risks relevant to the achievement of an organizaon’s objecves. The significance of risks is typically assessed in terms of impact and likelihood. Risk criteria - Categories under which risk will be scored for each audit area. Policy The Director will conduct a risk assessment at least annually, and develop an annual audit plan. The risk assessment will aid Internal Audit in allocang available resources to priories that align with the City’s objecves; however, other factors may also be considered in developing the final audit plan. The resulng risk based audit plan will be presented to the Audit Commiee for review and approval. The risk assessment process has been designed for simplicity and flexibility to allow alignment with changing risks. The process ulizes risk criteria and associated weights to determine whether audit areas in each department should be selected for audit in the upcoming year. The risk criteria, weighng, and audit areas are based on the professional judgment of the Director and may be modified from year to year. The annual risk assessment will be documented, along with the associated audit plans for each fiscal year. Procedure Annual Risk Assessment Gathering Informaon The department collects informaon to be used in the annual risk assessment throughout the year. This occurs in a variety of ways, including: ● Standing meengs with various departments Internal Audit Manual Page 20 of 49 ● Aendance at council commiee meengs ● From other audits or consulng engagements ● Annual internal control/risk assessment meengs with Finance and department management ● Other informal interacons with departments and senior management ● Audit Commiee meengs In addion to the sources listed above, the Director also solicits feedback from select members of City leadership and senior management. Specifically, the Director will ask the Mayor, Chief of Staff, CFO, IT Director, and City Aorney about areas of parcular concern which may benefit from an audit or consulng engagement. Process The formal annual risk assessment process begins with a review of the prior year’s methodology to determine whether any updates are needed. The Director will review the audit universe for completeness, risk criteria considered in the prior year, and relave weights previously assigned to the risk criteria. Changes can be made to these at the Director’s discreon. A summary of changes, along with finalized risk criteria definions and weights will be documented within the risk assessment workbook. The Director will use informaon gathered throughout the year to score the risk criteria for each audit area. The score for each risk criteria will be mulplied by the applicable weight. All weighted scores will then be totaled to arrive at a cumulave risk score. Areas with the highest cumulave risk scores are typically selected for the audit plan, subject to constraints discussed below. Audit Plan Development Aer the risk assessment is completed, the Director will prepare the annual audit plan. The audit plan should support the achievement of the City’s objecves. Available audit hours are calculated for each employee. This calculaon considers days worked per year, along with me alloed for necessary administrave work. The available audit hours are then allocated among projects selected for inclusion in the audit plan. While the audit plan normally includes projects with high cumulave risk scores, there are two other non-risk based engagements that may be included in an audit plan. These are the employee ethics survey and the senior management expense audit, which are described in the Non-Risk Based Engagement secon of this policy. The audit plan contains budgeted hours for specific projects. These include allotments for: ● Employee Ethics Survey ● Senior Management Expense (as appropriate) ● Possible consulng engagements that may arise during the year Internal Audit Manual Page 21 of 49 ● Hotline invesgaons ● Other technical assistance for departments ● Follow up or monitoring acvies on prior audits ● Meeng aendance and compleon of the annual risk assessment In cases where audits have a known area or scope, these will be listed on the audit plan. However, it is permissible to list a general audit area on the plan, with the specific scope to be refined during the planning phase of the audit. In these instances, refining the scope during the engagement will allow us more flexibility to tailor the scheduled audits to current risks in the selected areas. Knowledge, Skills, And Competencies Assessment Aer a dra audit plan is compiled, the Director will assess whether the department has adequate knowledge, skills, and competencies to complete the planned engagements. Should a gap be idenfied, the Director will document how that gap will be addressed. Gaps may somemes require addional training for staff, co-sourcing from another internal audit provider, or another resource. If gaps are unable to be sufficiently migated, this will be communicated to the Audit Commiee and may result in declining the engagement. Approval If sufficient knowledge, skills, and competencies exist or any gaps can be appropriately addressed, the Director will present the dra audit plan to the Audit Commiee for approval. Revisions It is possible that the audit plan will need to be updated as the year progresses. This may be due to unforeseen challenges within audits, new priories, or changing risks. Should a change in the audit plan be warranted, it will be presented to the Audit Commiee for approval. There may be instances where surprise audits are deemed necessary for successful compleon of the Internal Audit Department’s mission. These are not precluded by this policy, as long as they are properly communicated to and approved by the Audit Commiee. Non-Risk Based Engagements Employee Ethics Survey The department performs an annual ethics survey, which is intended to gauge the awareness of the City’s Code of Ethics, quality of ethics training, compliance with various laws and City policies, and the parcipants’ percepon of the City’s ethical environment. Quesons may change from year to year and may be targeted at different aspects of ethics within the City. The survey is anonymous, and is sent to all employees, including the Mayor and the City Council. The results of the survey are intended first and foremost to be used for risk assessment and audit planning purposes within the Internal Audit Department. As the informaon may be useful for management in making improvements to the ethical environment of the City, an informaonal report of the results will be provided to the Mayor, Chief of Staff, City Council, and Internal Audit Manual Page 22 of 49 released publicly. Where appropriate, the report will also contain recommendaons for improving the City’s ethics related processes. Senior Management Expense On August 20, 2008, the Audit Commiee approved a policy to require an audit of senior management expenses on a bi-annual basis. This connues to be the policy of the Internal Audit Department. For purposes of this audit, senior management is defined as the Mayor, the Chief of Staff, department heads, and council members. The audit shall include expenses of the Mayor and Chief of Staff (or the posions that approximate those posions). The included expenses will be those charged to the Mayor’s budget as well as those that have been charged to other budgets on behalf of the Mayor or Chief of Staff. The expenses of other department heads and council members will be included in the audit on a judgmental basis. Coordinaon and Reliance on the Work of Other Providers The Director is required to coordinate with internal and external providers of assurance services and consider whether to rely upon their work. Coordinaon of services minimizes duplicaon of efforts, enhances coverage of key risks, and improves the value added by providers. If the work of other providers is relied upon, the Director will document the basis for reliance and retains responsibility for the conclusions reached by the internal audit funcon. Policy Revision History Revision Date N/A Revision Approval N/A Inial Date October 25, 2024 Inial Approval Internal Audit Manual Page 23 of 49 City of Clarksville Internal Audit Manual Policy Number 04 Review Cycle Annual Subject Resource Management Purpose To define resource management responsibilies and processes. This policy demonstrates compliance with Global Internal Audit Standards 8.2, 10.1, 10.2, and 10.3. Policy The Director is responsible for obtaining and managing department resources to ensure fulfillment of the mandate and audit plan. As we operate in a government environment where budget and resources are limited, we must fulfill our mission to the best of our ability with resources available. It is our goal to manage resources as effecvely as possible to maximize the impact of our work. Where possible, we will work with the Audit Commiee and senior management to obtain sufficient resources. If this is not possible, the Director will inform the Audit Commiee about the impact of insufficient resources, as well as how those will be addressed. Procedure Financial Resources The Director is responsible for developing a budget to enable successful compleon of the audit plan. The budget includes salaries and benefits for auditors, funds for training and connuing educaon, technology resources, other supplies, and the City’s financial and compliance audit. Each year, the Director will prepare a budget for consideraon in accordance with City laws and regulaons. The Director will present the proposed budget to the Audit Commiee for their consideraon and approval; however, the department’s budget is part of the larger City budget that is presented by the Mayor for City Council approval. As the Mayor ulmately presents the budget to City Council for approval, the Mayor may make adjustments to the department budget at their discreon. Further, it is possible that the City Council will make adjustments prior to their final approval. The department will operate within the appropriated budget, and the Director will bring any necessary adjustments to the Audit Commiee, Mayor, and Chief Financial Officer. Internal Audit Manual Page 24 of 49 Human Resources The Director is required to effecvely manage the department’s human resources to accomplish the internal audit plan. This includes not only developing an approach to recruit, develop, and retain qualified internal auditors, but also ensuring that those resources are appropriate, sufficient, and effecvely deployed. This is achieved by hiring qualified auditors with varying experience, providing opportunies for connuing educaon, providing budgetary resources to obtain professional designaons relevant to internal auding, assigning auditors a wide variety of engagements/tasks, and providing meaningful feedback and mentoring. This combinaon of acons helps the Director ensure that appropriate resources are available to help accomplish the audit plan. The Director is also responsible for ensuring that sufficient resources are available to accomplish the audit plan. In the government environment, the department must operate with a limited number of posions that have been approved and funded. Requests for new posions can be made when properly jusfied; however, both the Mayor and City Council must approve any new posions. The Director must also effecvely deploy resources to accomplish the audit plan. Resources are monitored on a regular basis throughout engagements and for day to day operaons. The Director may shi assigned responsibilies as necessary to most efficiently accomplish tasks. Each year, the Director considers the appropriateness and sufficiency of human resources in developing the audit plan to ensure that those resources can be effecvely deployed to accomplish the audit plan with available resources. Technological Resources The Director must ensure the department has adequate technology to support the internal audit process. Technology will be regularly evaluated, including during annual budget preparaon to determine whether addional technology is needed to improve efficiency and effecveness of department processes. Requests will be included in the proposed budget as appropriate. The Director will collaborate with the City’s IT department to ensure cohesiveness with exisng systems for all technology requests and implementaon. Auditors will be provided appropriate training when new technology is implemented. Policy Revision History Revision Date N/A Revision Approval N/A Inial Date October 25, 2024 Inial Approval Internal Audit Manual Page 25 of 49 City of Clarksville Internal Audit Manual Policy Number 05 Review Cycle Annual Subject Performing Audit Services Purpose This policy demonstrates compliance with Domain V of the Standards as well as standard 9.3. Definions Methodologies - Policies, processes, and procedures established by the chief audit execuve that guide the internal audit funcon and enhance its effecveness. Workpapers - Documentaon of the internal audit work done when planning and performing engagements. The documentaon provides supporng informaon for engagement findings and conclusions. Policy The Internal Audit Department will conduct audits in a systemac, disciplined, and consistent manner, in accordance with the Standards and department methodologies. Standard template workpapers will be used as a basic structure for all audits to ensure that work adheres to these requirements. Procedure Engagement Documentaon All informaon and evidence to support the audit results will be documented and retained for 10 years. The analysis, evaluaons, and supporng informaon relevant should all be documented where a competent person could repeat the work and derive the same results. In all phases of each audit, documentaon will be reviewed for accuracy, relevance, and completeness and approved by the Director. Workpaper templates are used for consistency between audits and adherence to the Standards and policies. Workpapers as a whole should be a complete collecon of informaon collected, procedures completed, results, and a logical basis for each step. Engagement Resources The types and quanes of resources required to meet the audit objecves will be determined with consideraon of the audit's nature, complexity, and meline. Internal Audit will strategize the most efficient and effecve use of the available financial, human, and technological Internal Audit Manual Page 26 of 49 resources and will assess whether they are sufficient and appropriate for the audit. If there are resource limitaons that impact the ability to meet audit objecves, the Director will be made aware of the issue and then discuss with senior management and the Audit Commiee about the potenal consequences and collaborate on an appropriate course of acon. Inial/Announcement Communicaon Internal Audit should announce the audit to the appropriate management using the audit start noficaon. This announcement will give advance noce to management and relevant staff about the reasoning for the review and general topic of review. This will also be used to request informaon and/or documents needed to begin developing the work program and assessing risks. Entrance Meeng An entrance meeng will be organized and documented as a workpaper. This meeng is for internal audit and the management of the acvity under review. Discussion topics for this meeng include an overview of the audit process, as well as specific quesons related to the engagement. Frequency and preferences of communicaon will be discussed. Ongoing Communicaon Ongoing communicaon is required for transparency and helps idenfy and resolve any misunderstandings or differences. If there are any changes to the audit scope, objecves, or ming it will be promptly communicated to management. Other ongoing communicaon includes: ● Updates about audit progress ● Any issues requiring immediate aenon, such as a GRC issue ● Requests for any necessary informaon and resources to perform the audit Risk Assessment The risk assessment process aims to idenfy, priorize, and manage risks associated with the acvies under review, ensuring alignment with the City’s strategies and risk tolerance. This is documented as the risk matrix and tesng program workpaper. The risk assessment will be updated at various points throughout the audit. Internal Audit will gather detailed informaon and documentaon necessary for a comprehensive understanding of the acvity under review. This includes consideraon of the items listed specifically in standard 13.2. Informaon can also be gathered by conducng interviews, surveys, and process observaons to understand current operaonal procedures. Performing the Risk Assessment Once an understanding is developed, auditors will idenfy risks that may keep the acvity under review from meeng its objecves. Risks from the following categories should be considered: ● Fraud-related risks ● Strategic risks ● Operaonal risks Internal Audit Manual Page 27 of 49 ● Financial risks ● Compliance risks Risks will be evaluated and priorized based on their significance using impact and likelihood. For each risk idenfied, the auditor will determine whether a control exists to migate that risk. Based on that informaon, the auditor should evaluate whether the control is appropriately designed. Considering any controls, the auditor will determine the residual likelihood and impact for each idenfied risk. This evaluaon assists auditors in designing procedures to test for operaonal effecveness. Review and Updates If risks relevant to the audit were previously idenfied, Internal Audit will review and update the risk assessment as necessary based on new informaon or changes to the operaonal environment. At the end of each engagement, the auditor should update the risk matrix based on test procedures conducted to indicate whether the control as designed was operang effecvely. Engagement Objecves and Scope Each audit should have clearly established and documented objecves and scope. Objecves and scope may be adjusted as required by the specifics of the audit engagement and will be approved by the Director. Engagement Objecves Engagement objecves should clearly arculate the audit’s purpose and outline specific goals to be met, including any required by law or regulaon. Objecves should be in alignment with both the specific business objecves of the acvity under review and the overarching objecves of the City. Scope Scope specifies the acvies, locaons, processes, systems, components, me period, and other elements to be reviewed, establishing clear boundaries and focus for the audit. The scope should be defined aer establishing objecves, ensuring it is sufficiently broad to fulfill these objecves. Each engagement objecve should be evaluated independently to ensure it is feasible within the defined scope. Stakeholder requests regarding inclusion or exclusion of certain items, or constraints on engagement duraon, will be evaluated for a limitaon to the scope. Any limitaons that arise should be discussed with management to seek a resoluon. Unresolved issues will be escalated to the Audit Commiee if necessary. Engagement Memo Once the engagement scope and objecves are finalized and approved by the Director, the auditor will send an engagement memo to the appropriate pares. Internal Audit Manual Page 28 of 49 Evaluaon Criteria Idenficaon and Assessment The most relevant criteria should be determined for evaluang the aspects of the acvity under review, as defined in the audit objecves and scope. Auditors must evaluate whether management has established adequate criteria to assess whether the acvity has achieved its intended objecves and goals. If the criteria for the evaluaon is deemed adequate then it should be used. If it is found lacking, the auditor must collaborate with management to define suitable criteria. Work Program Development and Documentaon The work program is a comprehensive program created to meet the audit objecves. This program is created from insights gained in the planning phase and the outcomes of the risk assessment. It will specify the evaluaon criteria for each objecve, outline the tasks required, idenfy the methodologies to be used, list the tools necessary for task execuon, and assign the internal auditors responsible for each task. Approval and Review The work program must be reviewed and approved by the Director prior to implementaon and whenever modificaons are necessary. Work Program Contents Each work program should link idenfied risks and controls from the risk assessment to the tesng approach planned, the audit findings, and conclusions. It should include details such as the name of the internal auditor responsible, the compleon date of tasks, workpaper references, and records of task review and approval. Analyses and Evaluaons Informaon All informaon gathered should be relevant to the audit objecves, fall within the defined scope, and contribute meaningfully to the development of audit findings and conclusions. Informaon must be factual and current to be considered reliable. Reliability can be enhanced when the informaon is directly sourced by Internal Audit, corroborated, or obtained from a system with effecve governance, risk, and compliance measures. Collected informaon should be sufficient enough to perform thorough analyses and evaluaons. Informaon should be comprehensive enough that another competent person could replicate the audit process, using the work program, and arrive at the same conclusions. If relevant informaon is unaainable, this should be noted as a finding. Internal Audit Manual Page 29 of 49 Engagement Findings/Observaons The informaon gathered should be used to idenfy and analyze potenal audit findings. Analyses should be used to idenfy discrepancies between the established evaluaon criteria and the current state (condion) of the acvity under review. Any differences are considered potenal findings that require further evaluaon. If inial analyses do not provide sufficient evidence to substanate a potenal finding, addional analyses should be considered. If there are no significant differences found between the evaluaon criteria and the current condion, the audit conclusion should emphasize sasfactory performance. Evaluaon of Findings Each potenal finding will be evaluated to determine its significance for priorizaon. This evaluaon should be done by considering the likelihood, impact, risk tolerance, and other important factors. Findings should be wrien in plain language to clearly explain the difference between the criteria and the condions observed. Evidence is needed to support the finding and jusfy its significance. Internal Audit will collaborate with management to determine the root cause, potenal effects, and the significance of the issue. Any significant risks will be documented and communicated as a finding/observaon. Internal Audit will determine whether to report other risks as findings based on circumstances. Recommendaons and Acon Plans Internal Audit will develop recommendaons, request management acon plans, and collaborate with management to agree on acons. Internal Audit recommendaons must be discussed with the management of the acvity under review. The recommendaons/acons plans should resolve the differences between the established criteria and the condion, migate the risks, address the root cause, and enhance or improve the acvity under review. A single finding can have mulple recommendaons or correcve acons. Internal Audit should evaluate and discuss the feasibility and reasonableness of the recommendaons/acon plans. If there are any disagreements with the recommendaons or acon plan, both pares should come to a resoluon. It is ulmately management's responsibility to implement acons to address the findings. Internal Audit Manual Page 30 of 49 Engagement Conclusions Internal Audit will develop an audit conclusion that summarizes the audit results relave to the objecves for the audit, as well as the significance of the findings. Audit conclusions will include Internal Audit’s judgment regarding the effecveness of the governance, risk management, and/or control processes or the acvity under review and acknowledgement of effecve processes. Closing Communicaon The exit conference will be used to finalize the engagement results with appropriate pares before issuing a final communicaon. This is an opportunity to discuss any differences or disagreements about the audit results with a goal of reaching agreement. The feasibility of the recommendaons or management acon plans should be discussed including weighing the costs. Management acons plans may not be fully developed for the exit conference, in this case management ideas and Internal Audit recommendaons should be discussed and evaluated. In accordance with City Code Secon 6-616, management has 15 calendar days to provide acon plans, with an extension to 22 calendar days if approved by the Director for good cause. Management acon plans must include expected ming of implementaon and the personnel responsible. Final Communicaon The final communicaon is the last communicaon of an audit. It must be accurate, objecve, clear, concise, construcve, complete, and mely. The final communicaon should have a statement that the audit was conducted in conformance with the Global Internal Audit Standards. If conformance was not achieved, then the final communicaon should disclose the reasons for nonconformance, specific standards not conformed with, and the impact of nonconformity. If management has iniated or completed acons to address a finding before the final communicaon, the acons will be acknowledged in this communicaon. This will be reviewed and distributed by the Director to all appropriate pares. The final communicaon should include: ● Title ● Background (brief synopsis of the acvity under review) ● Recognion (posive aspects of the acvity under review and/or appreciaon of cooperaon) ● Objecves ● Scope ● Recommendaons/Acon Plans ● Conclusions Internal Audit Manual Page 31 of 49 ● Findings with significance and priorizaon ● Scope limitaons with explanaon, if applicable ● Personnel tasked with addressing findings ● Date recommendaons/acon plans should be implemented Confirming the Implementaon of Recommendaons or Acon Plans Internal Audit must confirm that management has implemented the recommendaon or acon plans. Internal Audit should inquire about progress on the implementaon, perform follow-up assessments using a risk-based approach, and update the status of management’s acon in the Internal Audit tracking document. The significance of the findings will determine the extent of the follow up. If management has not completed agreed upon acon plans by the esmated compleon dates, they must provide a wrien update which includes an explanaon of the delay. This will be documented in follow up workpapers. Policy Revision History Revision Date N/A Revision Approval N/A Inial Date October 25, 2024 Inial Approval Internal Audit Manual Page 32 of 49 City of Clarksville Internal Audit Manual Policy Number 06 Review Cycle Annual Subject Performing Consulng Services This policy will be developed for approval in the January Audit Commiee meeng. Policy Revision History Revision Date N/A Revision Approval N/A Inial Date Inial Approval Internal Audit Manual Page 33 of 49 City of Clarksville Internal Audit Manual Policy Number 07 Review Cycle Annual Subject Communicaon Purpose To define the department’s acvies related to communicaon principles. This policy demonstrates compliance with standards 11.1, 11.2, 11.3, 11.4, 11.5, and 15.1. Policy The department strives to communicate effecvely with its stakeholders. We recognize that effecve communicaon is based on a variety of factors, including building relaonships, establishing trust, and ensuring stakeholders and the City benefit from results of internal audit services. The Director will establish both formal and ongoing communicaons that enhance effecveness. Procedure Building Relaonships and Communicang with Stakeholders The Director is responsible for developing a communicaon strategy that builds relaonships and trust with stakeholders. This communicaon strategy includes both formal and informal communicaons. Engagement communicaons are a key part of this strategy, and are discussed in more detail in policy 05. Outside of engagement communicaons, we strive to communicate with stakeholders on a regular basis. The combinaon of all of these communicaons helps enhance our understanding of the City and its risks, processes, and requirements. This is accomplished in the following ways. Audit Commiee Meengs Regularly scheduled Audit Commiee meengs occur quarterly, and special sessions can be called when necessary. At all regularly scheduled meengs, the Director provides updates to the commiee on the department’s budget, progress on the audit plan and associated metrics, and updates on hotline reports. Each meeng also includes a non-public execuve session (provided for in TCA 9-3-405), where the Director and audit staff can provide addional informaon to the commiee about ongoing audits or invesgaons, etc. Management is not present in this poron of the meeng. In addion to the department reports described above, the Director includes other topics on the agenda as appropriate. Depending on the meeng, topics may include: Internal Audit Manual Page 34 of 49 ● The presentaon of financial and compliance audit results ● Policy updates ● Annual budget approval ● Discussion of standards and the department charter ● Approval of the audit plan ● Discussion of the department’s quality assurance and improvement program results ● Discussion of new commiee members ● Procurement for the City’s financial and compliance audit Other Commiee Meengs Auditors are assigned commiee meengs to aend on a monthly basis. This gives other departments, council members, and senior management an opportunity to see and interact with auditors outside of an audit seng. Addionally, it helps keep up to date with things that are happening in each department, which is essenal for comprehensive assessment of risks. These interacons help develop trust and relaonships, which prove valuable during subsequent engagements for those departments. Standing Meengs The Director has regularly scheduled standing meengs with other departments. The frequency of these meengs is dependent upon the specific department. Topics in these meengs may cover a variety of topics, including current issues and risks facing the department. This provides an opportunity for the Director to keep up with departmental challenges and discuss their governance, risk management, and controls. This also provides a venue for the Director to offer potenal consulng services that may be useful. Strategy and Leadership Sessions Strategy and leadership sessions are another communicaon pathway in which various members of the department parcipate. These typically involve senior management and leadership of all City departments. These are useful for both developing trust with other departments and understanding the City’s strategy for providing services to cizens. Feedback from Stakeholders The department also solicits feedback from departments at the end of each engagement. This helps enhance internal audit processes and further develop trust and support with stakeholders. Effecve Communicaon The department strives to ensure that all communicaons are accurate, objecve, clear, concise, construcve, complete, and mely. These characteriscs are defined in the table below. Accurate Free from errors and distorons, faithful to the underlying facts Objecve Fair, imparal, and unbiased, the result of a fair-minded and balanced assessment of all relevant facts and circumstances Clear Easily understood and logical, avoiding unnecessary technical language, providing all significant and relevant informaon Concise To the point, avoid unnecessary elaboraon, superfluous detail, Internal Audit Manual Page 35 of 49 redundancy, and wordiness Construcve Helpful to management and the organizaon, lead to improvements where needed Complete Lack nothing that is essenal to the target audience, includes all significant and relevant informaon and observaons to support recommendaons and conclusions Timely Opportune and expedient, allow management to take appropriate correcve acon Similar to other standards, supervision and quality assurance methodologies help ensure that communicaon has these characteriscs. These may include coaching or review by the Director or other staff members where appropriate. Formal engagement communicaons go through an extensive review process within the department prior to release to management or publicly. Communicang Results We communicate the results of each engagement in both formal and informal ways. We strive to communicate results to management throughout each engagement. This may include wrien and verbal communicaon methods across meengs, phone calls, and emails. All formal engagement results are communicated to management and senior management, as well as the Audit Commiee. Each formal results communicaons will include conclusions on the engagement, where appropriate. For audits, this includes conclusions on the specific audit objecves. Themes across mulple engagements are communicated to senior management and the Audit Commiee informally in meengs; however, reports are typically not issued to communicate these themes. The department does not issue conclusions at the department or City level. This is not required or typically expected by senior management or City leaders. Special Consideraons The Internal Audit Department recognizes that informaon in our audit reports has the potenal to be miscommunicated, misinterpreted, and taken out of context by the public, media, and policians to gain polical advantage. In order to protect the independence of the Internal Audit Department and to ensure that informaon is accurately communicated during an elecon season, no final internal audit reports shall be issued on a City elecon day for the offices of Mayor, City Council, or City Judge, nor for a period of thirty days prior to the day of the elecon. For other elecons, report release may be restricted at the discreon of the Audit Commiee by majority vote. Audit reports are a public record; however, there are excepons outlined in Tennessee Code Annotated that may require special treatment of reports. TCA Secon 10-7-504 lists various types of informaon which are considered confidenal. If there is a queson about whether the informaon contained in an audit report is confidenal, the Director should consult with the City Internal Audit Manual Page 36 of 49 Aorney to determine whether any poron of the report should be redacted prior to release. Outside of these circumstances, there are no limitaons on the distribuon and use of the results. While audit reports are public records, the workpapers of local government internal audit acvies are considered confidenal and are not open to public inspecon per TCA 10-7-504. Errors and Omissions In the event that errors or omissions are idenfied aer the report is released, the Director must discuss the level of significance with the Audit Commiee. If errors are determined to be significant, the Director must communicate corrected informaon to all pares who received the original communicaon. Since the audit report is a public record, this will involve working with the City’s communicaons department to dra a press release to nofy the public users of the report. Communicang the Acceptance of Risks In the event the Director concludes that management has accepted a level of risk that may be unacceptable to the City, the Director will bring the issue to the aenon of senior management. If the maer is not resolved by senior management, the Director will elevate the issue through the City Council and Audit Commiee. In accordance with this standard, it is not the Director’s responsibility to resolve the risk. Policy Revision History Revision Date N/A Revision Approval N/A Inial Date October 25, 2024 Inial Approval Internal Audit Manual Page 37 of 49 City of Clarksville Internal Audit Manual Policy Number 08 Review Cycle Annual Subject Supervision Purpose To define the acvies required to adequately supervise all engagements performed within the Internal Audit Department, as well as acvies to supervise and develop auditors. This policy demonstrates compliance with standard 12.3. Policy All engagements will be supervised to ensure that engagement objecves are achieved, engagements are performed to the department’s quality standards, auditor development opportunies are idenfied and communicated, and that engagements are performed mely. Engagement supervision will occur throughout the engagement from planning through follow up/monitoring. Procedure Due to the size of the Internal Audit Department, the Director will typically be the engagement supervisor; however, another sufficiently qualified and experienced auditor could act as the engagement supervisor at the Director’s discreon. The engagement process within the Department is highly collaborave between the engagement team and the Director; therefore, engagement supervision occurs on an almost connual basis from the beginning phases of the engagement through compleon and monitoring. The following steps outline how engagements are formally supervised through each engagement, but informal engagement supervision occurs each day in the form of department discussions and meengs. During all phases of the engagement, the Director will be responsible for reviewing all workpapers (required and supporng) evidenced by a sign off and date. This review will be evidenced by comments and review notes made by the Director and their associated responses from the auditor. Review comments are preserved within engagement workpapers as resolved comments or in another form where necessary. Any comments that result from the Director’s review will be addressed by the auditor when received. In addion to the supervision requirements listed above, the Director must also approve the engagement work program that has been developed by the engagement team. When approving the work program, the Director will consider: (1) whether it is designed to achieve engagement Internal Audit Manual Page 38 of 49 objecves and (2) whether it will meet engagement performance standards established by internal policies and the Standards. If changes are made to the work program at any me during the engagement, those changes must be approved by the Director. Prior to the release of the engagement results, an engagement level QA will be performed to ensure quality. Aer the engagement is completed, the Director will conduct a post audit connuous improvement meeng with the engagement team. This meeng will serve as a venue to not only discuss potenal improvements to the engagement process, but also as a venue for discussions promong staff development. In addion to formal engagement supervision, the Director is responsible for supervising and developing auditors to enhance competencies and performance in accordance with standard 3.1. Policy Revision History Revision Date N/A Revision Approval N/A Inial Date October 25, 2024 Inial Approval Internal Audit Manual Page 39 of 49 City of Clarksville Internal Audit Manual Policy Number 09 Review Cycle Annual Subject Fraud, Invesgaons, and Hotline Administraon Purpose To define the Internal Audit Department’s policy and procedures related to fraud and administraon of the City’s Fraud and Audit Hotline. Definions Fraud - An intenonal decepon that violates a law or the public trust for personal benefit or the benefit of others. Policy The Internal Audit Department, along with the City of Clarksville, is commied to conducng business with high ethical standards and in compliance with the law. In accordance with City Code Secon 6-617 and TCA Secon 9-3-406, the Internal Audit Department has established a hotline by which employees, taxpayers, and other cizens may confidenally report suspected illegal, improper, wasteful, or fraudulent acvity. It is the Internal Audit Department’s intent to fully invesgate any suspected acts of illegal, improper, wasteful, or fraudulent acvity. An objecve and imparal invesgaon will be conducted regardless of the party involved. Procedure The Internal Audit Department maintains the City’s Fraud and Audit Hotline. The hotline gives cizens, employees, and elected officials a confidenal method for reporng illegal, improper, wasteful, or fraudulent acvity by City officials or employees. While the hotline is not intended to be used as a method to report improper acvies by private cizens or private businesses, complaints like this are occasionally received. The department categorizes reports according to the method by which they are received. The two main methods for reporng are by phone (voice recording) or by an online reporng form accessible through the City’s website. Both methods allow for confidenal reporng; however, the person making the report can choose to give their contact informaon. Occasionally, the department receives informaon outside of the established hotline that may require invesgaon, including through discussions with employees, assurance or consulng engagements, or other avenues. Internal Audit Manual Page 40 of 49 Reports received by phone or the online reporng form are emailed to all Internal Audit staff members through an automated system. The department maintains hotline report logs by fiscal year, where all reports are logged when received. While each report received is unique and handled based on professional judgment, the department uses the general framework laid out in Chart 1 and Chart 2 on the following pages. Depending on the nature of the report, related invesgave work may take priority over regularly scheduled audit work. Any invesgaon that results from a report will be carried out in a confidenal manner; however, anonymity cannot be guaranteed as an invesgaon progresses. Invesgaons will be fully documented, with appropriate supporng documentaon. The Director (or designee) shall review and approve invesgaon associated workpapers. If informaon available to the department suggests unlawful conduct may have occurred, the Director (or designee) will report that informaon to the State Comptroller within a reasonable amount of me (not to exceed 5 working days) in accordance with TCA 8-4-503. Occasionally aer reporng an incident as noted above, the incident will be returned to the department from the Comptroller or external audit firm for further invesgaon. In these situaons, the department will work with those enes throughout the invesgaon process in handling the issue. Depending on the nature of the incident/report, the department may adjust the audit plan to review internal control or other process related issues that may have allowed the opportunity for the incident to occur. As a general rule, the department does not issue formal invesgave reports; however, issues idenfied may be reported within an audit report, if appropriate. A status summary of the reports received on the City’s Fraud and Audit Hotline will be provided to the Audit Commiee at each regularly scheduled meeng. Policy Revision History Revision Date N/A Revision Approval N/A Inial Date October 25, 2024 Inial Approval Internal Audit Manual Page 41 of 49 Internal Audit Manual Page 42 of 49 Internal Audit Manual Page 43 of 49 City of Clarksville Internal Audit Manual Policy Number 10 Review Cycle Annual Subject Office Administraon Purpose To document an overview of administrave procedures of the Internal Audit Department. Policy All Internal Audit personnel will adhere to the administrave policies described below. Any issues related to these policies should be brought to the Director’s aenon. While many topics are covered, this policy is not meant to be all inclusive of acceptable office pracces. Procedure Service Philosophy and Professionalism It is expected that all audit staff will strive for professional excellence. Accordingly, audit staff are expected to conduct themselves in a courteous manner that focuses on problem resoluon, not conflict. Audit staff are expected to dress in a professional manner that is appropriate for the circumstances. Business are will vary depending upon daily acvies. For instance, formal meengs with public leaders may warrant more formal business are than conducng interviews with auditees which may jusfy business casual are. Occasionally, field work may require much more casual are, such as jeans, boots, or shorts. In these cases the overlying theme should be that the clothing is neat, clean, and in good condion. For daily office work, clothing that would be worn on the weekend generally is inappropriate for the office. The one roune excepon to this is that the City has established Friday as a casual day. On these days jeans and appropriate shirts are acceptable provided that they are neat, clean, and in good condion. T-shirts with slogans or sayings on them are generally not considered appropriate. Rules of Conduct Audit staff must be parcularly careful that private interests and acvies do not adversely affect or conflict with their public posion dues. Audit staff should avoid any acon that might result in, or create the appearance of using their public posion for private gain. Internal Audit Manual Page 44 of 49 Audit staff should be familiar with the City Code of Ethics, and will complete ethics training annually. Material noncompliance with the ethics policy is subject to appropriate disciplinary acon. Work Environment The Internal Audit Department strives for a professional, high-performance workplace environment. Auditors should use headphones or play music at a low level that cannot be heard beyond their office. In addion, children should not be brought to the office for extended periods of me during normal work hours. Work Hours Under the City’s pay plan all auditors are considered exempt, salaried professionals and as such they are not entled to paid overme and they generally receive no compensaon of any kind for extra hours worked. It is expected that persons holding exempt management posions will remain on duty for whatever me is necessary to carry out the responsibilies of their posions. City policy allows the Director to occasionally grant excused me off for extra hours of required work. Excused me will only be granted for job performance that exceeds the basic requirements of the job and not solely on extra hours worked to accomplish the basic job. This determinaon will be made by the Director. Although exempt salaried professionals are not required under the Fair Labor Standards Act to have “normal” work hours, it is City’s pracce to have a standard work schedule for management employees. The most common work schedule for a full-me auditor is a seven and a half hour day, with every weekend off. City policy allows a flexible scheduling arrangement where an addional hour is worked 8 out of 10 business days in a two week period, and the 10th business day is off. This arrangement can be approved by the Director based on availability and seniority. Time off requests are done electronically through ExecuTime and approved by the Director. Time sheets are to be submied for Director approval at the end of each two week pay period in ExecuTime. The following general rules apply to work hours: ● The Internal Audit Department strives to be open to customers from 8:00 AM to 4:30 PM, Monday through Friday. ● If circumstances prevent keeping the office open, and no one will be in the office for an extended period of me, a sign should be placed on the door. ● Lunch hours generally should be no more than one hour per work day for an eight hour day. ● Breaks, while not required under the Fair Labor Standards Act, are permied but should be reasonable in length. ● Once a work schedule is established, the Director should be nofied of any unexpected late arrivals or absences as soon as possible. ● Vacaon requests should be made as far in advance as reasonably possible. ● Vacaon and personal leave requests will be approved subject to the ability to Internal Audit Manual Page 45 of 49 provide adequate office coverage. ● If there are conflicts in leave and/or alternave work schedule requests, the most senior employee’s request generally will have priority over the least senior employee’s request. Time Reporng The Internal Audit Department uses a consolidated mesheet where each employee has a different tab to report their hours worked. To allow most efficient me reporng, the mesheet should be updated on a weekly basis. Time worked is separated between direct me and admin me. Direct me includes work on specific audits, consulng engagements, technical help for departments, or other projects. Admin me includes non-project me such as training, meengs, and leave me. The smallest increment necessary for reporng is one quarter hour. In reporng work hours, staff normally account for 37.5 hours per week. If addional hours are worked those should also be reported on the me sheet. It is important to accurately report me because it is used for a variety of crical purposes, including in department metrics and future audit planning. The department metrics are used to evaluate the efficiency and producvity of work performed by individual auditors as well as the Internal Audit Department as a whole. “Checking-Out” When auditors plan to be gone for an extended period of me (greater than an hour), they communicate to the Director their desnaon and when they expect to return. If audit staff plan to be out of the office on assignment for more than a day, during their absence they should communicate with the Director by email or phone at least once daily. Building and Office Access Audit staff will be provided with an office key for which they are held accountable. If the office will be empty for an extended period of me, the door should be locked. Audit staff are not to obtain duplicate keys without the permission of the Director. Security badges are issued for building access. Audit staff are responsible for being knowledgeable of and complying with regulaons regarding the proper use of security badges as required by Human Resources. Facility and Office Use City office space, equipment, supplies, and services are not for personal use unless they are allowed for by City policy. This includes the use of the internet, e-mail, computers, digital devices, phones and cellular phones, and other similar items. Computer Security, Soware Compliance, and Access to Informaon The objecve of computer system security is to ensure that only authorized persons have access Internal Audit Manual Page 46 of 49 to informaon and operaons. Passwords should be developed in accordance with guidelines recommended by the Informaon Technology department. Audit staff are responsible for operang their own City issued computer. The Director should be nofied of problems that arise with hardware or soware which cannot readily be resolved. IT work orders can be submied to the IT staff for assistance with issues described above. The City adheres to certain soware pracces to ensure that employees and the organizaon obey the law and do not commit copyright infringement. In addion, the use or installaon of any soware that has not been approved by Informaon Technology is prohibited. Disclosing your password, making unauthorized copies of soware, or accessing applicaons or informaon (including electronic informaon) for inappropriate reasons are subject to disciplinary acon up to and including terminaon. Auditors are expected to be knowledgeable of and compliant with IT’s Computer Usage policy which is available on Internal Audit’s shared drive. Laptops and Other Digital Devices- Security and Use Audit staff should protect the security of laptops and other digital devices at all mes. Portable storage such as USB drives should be encrypted if sensive informaon will be temporarily or permanently stored on such devices. Personal USB drives should not be used in City computers for any reason. Telephone Use – Calls, Voicemail, and Text Messages Phones should be answered in a courteous manner. In general the employee will tell the caller they have reached the Internal Audit Department along with their name. Personal local calls either using the City’s phone system or a personal cell phone are to be kept to a minimum. Personal long distance calls are not acceptable on the City’s landline phone except for an emergency of limited duraon. Text messaging on personal cell phones should be kept to a minimum and should not cause connuous interrupons throughout the day. Email and Internet Infrequent personal use of the City’s email system is authorized. Remember that emails are subject to open records requests. Limited personal use of the internet is allowed; however, personal use must not interfere with the performance of normal work dues. In addion, personal use should be done during the employee’s personal me (such as lunch or before and aer normal work hours) and should be of reasonable duraon. No inappropriate use of the Internet is allowed. Inappropriate use includes photographs, screensavers, or text that could be offensive to members of the public or other staff; posng to nonbusiness chat rooms and discussion forums; private commercial acvies such as operang a private business using City owned equipment; and other uses incompable with public service. Internal Audit Manual Page 47 of 49 Social Media Audit staff should use discreon in the types of informaon posted to personal social media sites that can be accessed by the public. Posng items to public forums that might damage the credibility of the auditor or the Internal Audit Department is discouraged and may be grounds for discipline. Recycling and Discarding of Documents Audit staff are to conserve and recycle discarded paper documents. Sensive or confidenal items must be shredded. Procurement All purchases must be approved by the Director before the purchase is made. For large purchases the approval process is accomplished through the Munis PO system. For smaller P-card purchases, email permission should be received before the purchase is made. The Director reviews and approves the P-card transacons as they appear on the monthly P-card statement. Employees are expected to be familiar and comply with the City’s P-card policy. External Audit Procurement In accordance with City Code secon 6-609, the Audit Commiee shall select the external audit firm for the City. The commiee will select the external audit firm through the City’s established request for proposals (RFP) process. Each contract for the external audit will be for one year, renewable annually by the Audit Commiee. To encourage compeon and auditor rotaon when possible, a new RFP will be issued at least every 3 years. Staff Meengs The department will have staff meengs on a regular basis. The format and frequency of these meengs may change depending on the needs of the department. Compensaon and Employee Benefits Internal Audit staff will be compensated and receive employee benefits in accordance with City policy. Performance Reviews Formal performance reviews are conducted once per fiscal year prior to June 30th. This process is intended to evaluate job performance, working relaonships, and professional growth. The Director prepares an evaluaon of the employee’s performance in accordance with the City’s adopted evaluaon methodology, and meets with the employee to discuss the results. In addion to the annual formal evaluaon, performance issues are discussed throughout the year. Review comments provided as part of engagement supervision are also indicators of employee performance. Internal Audit Manual Page 48 of 49 Resignaon and Terminaon Any employee intending to resign his or her posion should, out of professional courtesy, give the Director at least two weeks wrien noce. Delegaon of Authority in Director’s Absence When the Director is absent for extended periods of me, the most senior auditor is authorized to handle day to day audit issues that may occur during this me. For non-roune issues that may arise, the most senior auditor should consult with the Audit Commiee Chair for determinaon of acon. Emergencies Audit staff should be familiar with evacuaon procedures in case of fire or other emergencies. In addion, staff should know how to nofy building security and other appropriate City personnel in case of emergency. If audit staff feel they are being threatened, they should call building security or 911. Travel All City related travel must be done in accordance with the City’s Travel Policy and associated procedures. Polical Acvies Engaging in polical acvies while on the job is prohibited. Employees may not spend me on the job promong candidates, ballot measures, or polical commiees. Employees may express personal views, as appropriate; however, when expressing those views to other employees they should clearly indicate that they are not the views of the Internal Audit Department. City Policies and Procedures The City of Clarksville has developed policies and procedures that apply to all City employees. Audit staff are to be familiar with these policies and procedures. Policy Revision History Revision Date N/A Revision Approval N/A Inial Date October 25, 2024 Inial Approval Internal Audit Manual Page 49 of 49 Lynn Stokes – Professional BioI have lived in Clarksville for 39 years. Accounting/Auditing Experience and CredentialsPassed the CPA exam in 1991Worked as an auditor and tax professional with a local CPA firm for 14 years. This work involved conducting financial audits of area local governments and non-profit organizations. The work also involved tax preparation for individuals, non-profits, partnerships and LLCs.Worked as Director of Internal Audit for the City of Clarksville for 9 years conducting internal audits of various City departments and other processes within City government. The worked involved developing risk assessments and understanding the internal controls surrounding the area being audited. An audit report was issued for each audit conducted.Worked part time for another local CPA firm for three years conducting the financial audit of Montgomery County E911.Attended 80 hours of training every two years to maintain CPA credential through 2018.Applicable Volunteer ExperienceHabitat for Humanity of Montgomery County – Treasurer for three years, Board president for two years.Fort Campbell Historical Foundation – Financial reporting oversight of $22M grant funds for the Tennessee Wings of Liberty Museum – 2022 – current.Treasurer for local church for 17 years.Tax preparer for Volunteer Income Tax Assistance (VITA) program of the IRS – three years.

Source: City of Clarksville website. First collected Nov 22, 2026.